Latest / Bloomberg Law / Supreme Court Weighs Title VII Case, Judges Facing Security Threats
Transcript
- 0:02Speaker 1: You're listening to the Bloomberg Lawn Podcast. Catch us weekdays
- 0:05Speaker 1: at ten pm Easter on Bloomberg dot Com, the iHeartRadio app,
- 0:09Speaker 1: and the Bloomberg Business App, or listen on demand wherever
- 0:12Speaker 1: you get your podcasts.
- 0:15Speaker 2: Welcome to the Bloomberg Law Show. I'm Kimberly Robinson alongside
- 0:19Speaker 2: Greg Storr. June Grosso is out this week ahead. In
- 0:22Speaker 2: this hour, we'll talk about the growing threats against the
- 0:24Speaker 2: judiciary and the inadequacies in the tracking system meant to
- 0:27Speaker 2: keep federal judges safe.
- 0:29Speaker 3: But first, the Supreme Court heard its last argument of
- 0:32Speaker 3: the year this week in a case about workplace bias protections.
- 0:36Speaker 4: I want to give you a chance to just flesh
- 0:39Speaker 4: out your position, which I understand has been subject to
- 0:43Speaker 4: some questioning this morning, that in adopting the Civil Rights
- 0:49Speaker 4: Act of nineteen sixty four, Congress sought to root out discrimination,
- 0:55Speaker 4: root and branch, and that all of it is impermissible,
- 1:00Speaker 4: presumptively injurious.
- 1:02Speaker 2: That was Justice Neil Gorstch, shuming up the employees' argument
- 1:06Speaker 2: about the sweeping nature of federal anti discrimination laws. Joining
- 1:10Speaker 2: us now to explain is robert Iafula, who covers labor
- 1:13Speaker 2: Law at Bloomberg Law. Thanks for joining.
- 1:15Speaker 5: Us, Thanks for having me.
- 1:17Speaker 2: So, Bobby, tell us about the former Saint Louis police
- 1:20Speaker 2: sergeant at the heart of this case.
- 1:21Speaker 6: What is she claiming happened to her?
- 1:23Speaker 5: Well, yeah, so, Jaitania Muldrow was a veteran's sergeant in
- 1:28Speaker 5: the Saint Louis Police Department and she was assigned to
- 1:32Speaker 5: the Intelligence unit, which allowed her to work on investigations
- 1:36Speaker 5: and wear playing clothes and driving on my car, and
- 1:41Speaker 5: then she was transferred. This is not something she wanted.
- 1:44Speaker 5: She was transferred to sort of a normal beat cop position,
- 1:47Speaker 5: so she had to go back to driving a squad car,
- 1:51Speaker 5: wearing uniform, dealing with the changing shifts of a beat
- 1:57Speaker 5: coop and that was not something that she wanted or
- 2:01Speaker 5: led to this suit.
- 2:04Speaker 3: Okay, So this case is about the employment protections in
- 2:07Speaker 3: something called Title seven. Tell our listeners, what are those
- 2:11Speaker 3: protections generally meant to do?
- 2:14Speaker 5: Yeah, generally, they're meant to prevent discrimination in the workplace.
- 2:19Speaker 5: Title seven spells out some certain protected traits, sex, religion, race,
- 2:26Speaker 5: so on, and so forth, that workers are not to
- 2:30Speaker 5: be discriminated against on the basis of those protected traits
- 2:34Speaker 5: as they affect the terms, conditions and privileges of employment.
- 2:38Speaker 5: So here the former police sergeant, she claimed that this
- 2:42Speaker 5: transfer was based on her gender.
- 2:45Speaker 2: So really at the heart of this case is whether
- 2:48Speaker 2: these sort of adverse job transfers, as opposed to something
- 2:51Speaker 2: like an outright firing, are sufficient to trigger Title seven's
- 2:56Speaker 2: employment protections, even if there's not a showing a specific harm.
- 3:02Speaker 6: Is that right?
- 3:02Speaker 2: And if so, how did that play out in Muldro's case.
- 3:06Speaker 5: Well, yes, so with her case, the trial court and
- 3:10Speaker 5: then the appellate court that viewed the trial court's decision
- 3:14Speaker 5: both looked at the facts of the case and they said,
- 3:17Speaker 5: you know, while she didn't want this transfer to happen,
- 3:21Speaker 5: she retained the same rank, it didn't affect her pay,
- 3:26Speaker 5: her salary, you know, and that basically it didn't materially
- 3:31Speaker 5: disadvantage her, even though it was a preference to work
- 3:35Speaker 5: on the intelligence team that instead of the beat And
- 3:39Speaker 5: because of that lack of a material harm, that's why
- 3:44Speaker 5: the court threw up her claim. Like she never got
- 3:46Speaker 5: to the point of proving whether the transfer was based
- 3:50Speaker 5: on gender, which would be violet of Title seven. It
- 3:54Speaker 5: got thrown up because she couldn't show she suffered a
- 3:56Speaker 5: material harm.
- 3:59Speaker 3: So before we talk about what happened at the Supreme Court,
- 4:02Speaker 3: the other lower federal courts have they all agreed with
- 4:06Speaker 3: the analysis of the Eighth Circuit in saying that you
- 4:09Speaker 3: need to show that sort of material harm.
- 4:12Speaker 5: So there's a split on that issue. Most of the
- 4:15Speaker 5: Court's appellate courts that have weighed in on this issue
- 4:19Speaker 5: have agreed with the position that the Eighth Circuit took.
- 4:22Speaker 5: So I think it's something in the order of five
- 4:26Speaker 5: appellate courts have said, yeah, there's some sort of They
- 4:30Speaker 5: kind of formulate it different ways, whether the material, tangible harm,
- 4:35Speaker 5: or a significant disadvantage. It's just some way of saying, hey,
- 4:39Speaker 5: what's the material harm? Why didn't this hurt you? But
- 4:43Speaker 5: there are two circuits that have gone the other way,
- 4:45Speaker 5: the DC Circuit and I think it's a sixth Circuit
- 4:48Speaker 5: have said no, that's not a requirement to making a
- 4:53Speaker 5: claim of discrimination under Title seven when it comes to transfers.
- 4:57Speaker 2: And so during the oral arguments in the Supreme Court court,
- 5:02Speaker 2: what were some of the concerns from the justices regarding
- 5:04Speaker 2: these different tests? And I guess let's start with a
- 5:07Speaker 2: lack of a harm requirement. What's the concern there?
- 5:13Speaker 5: The concern there is cheaply around what is a limiting principle?
- 5:18Speaker 5: You know, if the justice is posed all sorts of
- 5:22Speaker 5: different hypothetical questions. You know, what if an employer transfers
- 5:27Speaker 5: all the women workers into rooms offices that have one
- 5:33Speaker 5: color of paint and another all the men in a
- 5:36Speaker 5: different color of paint. Or what if an employer, you know,
- 5:40Speaker 5: a supervisor asks all the employees, how is your weekend?
- 5:45Speaker 5: Except for one employee? And they allegedly done that. Do
- 5:49Speaker 5: that on the basis of of race or sex or
- 5:52Speaker 5: other protected trait? You know? So, is it connected with
- 5:56Speaker 5: this sort of policy concern about federal courts being inundated
- 6:00Speaker 5: with frivolous lawsuits, that they can't just get rid of
- 6:04Speaker 5: it an early stage, that they have to go through
- 6:08Speaker 5: stages of litigation before it could be thrown out.
- 6:11Speaker 3: And was there an answer to those concerns? What did
- 6:14Speaker 3: the lawyer for the police sergeant say when, for example,
- 6:18Speaker 3: presented with the hypothetical about workers of different genders being
- 6:22Speaker 3: assigned to offices with different colors.
- 6:26Speaker 5: Yes, so his position was that discrimination is the harm itself,
- 6:33Speaker 5: and he kind of resisted the premise of the question
- 6:36Speaker 5: that they were supposed to be absurd. For example, he
- 6:39Speaker 5: talked about if you distribute pink pens to some employees
- 6:44Speaker 5: and bluepens to others at a random basis, that's that's
- 6:48Speaker 5: clearly not a problem. But if you do it on
- 6:50Speaker 5: the basis of race, that is a problem. But during
- 6:54Speaker 5: arguments they did talk about other sort of natural limiting
- 6:57Speaker 5: principles that might emerge. You know, the fact that an
- 7:02Speaker 5: employee could prove that there was discrimination. In order to
- 7:05Speaker 5: win damages, they'd have to show that they suffered an
- 7:07Speaker 5: injury that needed to be compensated. So if it's the
- 7:11Speaker 5: pen hypothetical, sure you might get a jury to say
- 7:15Speaker 5: that that was discrimination, but you're not going to win
- 7:17Speaker 5: any money. If you're not going to win any money,
- 7:19Speaker 5: you're not going to get a lawyer. You know, this
- 7:21Speaker 5: sort of comes out that way.
- 7:24Speaker 6: So what about going the other way.
- 7:26Speaker 2: Let's say the Supreme Court say is that there's some
- 7:29Speaker 2: kind of heightened arm requirement. What concerns do critics of
- 7:33Speaker 2: that side have.
- 7:35Speaker 5: Yeah, I mean argument is that it basically would allow
- 7:40Speaker 5: for segregation in the workplace based on gender or race
- 7:45Speaker 5: or other protected traits. You know, which they argue that
- 7:50Speaker 5: Title seventh clearly does not allow.
- 7:53Speaker 3: Did you get a sense in the courtroom of which
- 7:57Speaker 3: way the justices were leaning on this question.
- 8:01Speaker 5: Yeah, it did seem like there was a small minority
- 8:05Speaker 5: of justices that were extremely concerned about this question about
- 8:11Speaker 5: trivial differences creating frivolous lawsuits and the negative consequences of that,
- 8:19Speaker 5: But that was only maybe two or three justices seemed
- 8:22Speaker 5: to focus on that. The other justices seemed to really
- 8:26Speaker 5: embrace the workers argument that the harm of discrimination is
- 8:31Speaker 5: the discrimination itself.
- 8:33Speaker 2: And so, you know, there's been a lot of talk
- 8:35Speaker 2: over the years that the Roberts Court is friendly to businesses,
- 8:39Speaker 2: that it's a business friendly court, So this sort of
- 8:42Speaker 2: suggests the opposite in this case.
- 8:45Speaker 1: Yeah.
- 8:45Speaker 5: Well, you know, each case is going to be a
- 8:48Speaker 5: separate issue, and with this issue in particular. For example,
- 8:53Speaker 5: when Brett Kavanaugh was DC Circuit judge before he assented
- 8:59Speaker 5: to the bend, which he was in a case that
- 9:02Speaker 5: dealt with this issue, and at that time there was
- 9:05Speaker 5: binding precedent that had to be applied that required a
- 9:09Speaker 5: material harm. But he said in a concurring opinion that
- 9:11Speaker 5: DC Circuit should change their case law and get rid
- 9:15Speaker 5: of this requirement, and which is something that the circuit
- 9:19Speaker 5: did a few years later. Or also take you know
- 9:22Speaker 5: Gorsich for example. You know, in some respects a rock
- 9:26Speaker 5: conservative justice you appointed by former President Trump. But at
- 9:31Speaker 5: the same time he wrote the case that expanded Title
- 9:37Speaker 5: seven's protection to cover gender identity and sexual orientation, which
- 9:44Speaker 5: would be it was something that businesses did not want
- 9:46Speaker 5: at the time, but he grounded that decision in the
- 9:50Speaker 5: text of Title seven. You know today he asked a
- 9:54Speaker 5: lot of questions that indicated that he was firmly ground
- 10:00Speaker 5: in the text of Title seven when he talked about
- 10:04Speaker 5: they're not needing to be an additional requirement.
- 10:07Speaker 2: Well, coming up on the program, we'll get more on
- 10:09Speaker 2: the Title seven case in front of the Justices with
- 10:11Speaker 2: Robert Iafola. Remember you can always get the latest legal
- 10:15Speaker 2: news by listening to our Bloomberg Law podcast on Apple,
- 10:18Speaker 2: Spotify or anywhere where you get your podcasts.
- 10:21Speaker 6: I'm Kimberly Robinson and I'm Greg Store.
- 10:24Speaker 3: This is Bloomberg.
- 10:32Speaker 1: You're listening to the Bloomberg Law Podcast. Cat's the program
- 10:36Speaker 1: weekdays at ten pm Eastern on Bloomberg Radio. Tune in
- 10:39Speaker 1: app Bloomberg dot Com and the Bloomberg Business App. You
- 10:42Speaker 1: can also listen live on Amazon Alexa from our flagship
- 10:46Speaker 1: New York station. Just say Alexa play Bloomberg eleven thirty.
- 10:51Speaker 3: I'm Kimberly Robinson and I'm Greg Store worrying for June Grosso.
- 10:56Speaker 7: But are you saying that if the employer wants to
- 10:59Speaker 7: increase in the workplace and so promotes, say some black employees,
- 11:04Speaker 7: and they get better jobs, then that's discrimination.
- 11:09Speaker 3: That was Justice Amy Coney Barrett, wondering how a broad
- 11:11Speaker 3: view of employment discrimination protections might play out in future cases.
- 11:15Speaker 3: We've been speaking with robert Iofola about employee bias protections
- 11:19Speaker 3: being considered by the US Supreme Court. Bobby, We're going
- 11:22Speaker 3: to get to Justice Barrett's question in a second, but
- 11:26Speaker 3: first let me ask you. This case had kind of
- 11:29Speaker 3: a coirk to it in that the question that the
- 11:33Speaker 3: Saint Louis police sergeant asked the Supreme Court to consider
- 11:37Speaker 3: is not the exact question they're actually considering. Can you
- 11:40Speaker 3: explain what happened and how that might be affecting what
- 11:43Speaker 3: the Court does?
- 11:45Speaker 5: Yes, yeah, that's right, Greg. So Originally, when Muldro petitioned
- 11:50Speaker 5: the court to review the Eighth Circuit decision and revive
- 11:54Speaker 5: her gender bias lawsuit. She asked a much broader leader
- 11:59Speaker 5: question about the need for a showing of material harm
- 12:05Speaker 5: for any workplace decision that affects terms, conditions, and privileges
- 12:10Speaker 5: of employment. You know, so you could imagine that could
- 12:13Speaker 5: cover things like work assignments. You know, where you're assigned
- 12:18Speaker 5: to work you have to work outside? And the heat
- 12:20Speaker 5: can you work inside? And the air conditioning? You know
- 12:22Speaker 5: what job functions you have to perform, all sorts of
- 12:25Speaker 5: different things. But the court, when they accepted her request
- 12:29Speaker 5: to take this case, they narrowed it down and to
- 12:35Speaker 5: just job transfers, just the material harm requirement for job transfers,
- 12:41Speaker 5: not for a whole myriad of employment decisions that could
- 12:46Speaker 5: potentially be illegally motivated by race or another biased decisions.
- 12:53Speaker 2: Okay, but we've already on this program talked about things
- 12:57Speaker 2: that go well beyond transfer, right. We talked about the colors,
- 13:00Speaker 2: We talked about the color of offices. So this is
- 13:03Speaker 2: something that confused me about the argument was there was
- 13:06Speaker 2: discussion on this broader point, right, and whether there's some
- 13:10Speaker 2: sort of deminimous discrimination that sort of is permissible by
- 13:15Speaker 2: Title seven?
- 13:16Speaker 6: Is that right?
- 13:18Speaker 5: Yeah? So, on the one hand, I think that some
- 13:21Speaker 5: of the justices were using those examples kind of to
- 13:26Speaker 5: deployment the weapon of absurdity to point out why you
- 13:30Speaker 5: need a limitation. So some of these situations are not real,
- 13:33Speaker 5: like the assignment of colors of pens and whatnot. But
- 13:36Speaker 5: also they had some concerns about these situations. But at
- 13:39Speaker 5: one point Justice Jackson brought it back to the narrow
- 13:43Speaker 5: question presented and she said, quite directly, Hey, look, I
- 13:47Speaker 5: thought we narrowed this question to just transfers so that
- 13:50Speaker 5: we didn't have to worry about this sort of issue
- 13:53Speaker 5: about what is trivial and all sorts of random and
- 13:59Speaker 5: potentially discriminatory workplace's actions.
- 14:02Speaker 3: So the case before the Supreme Court is being pressed
- 14:05Speaker 3: by a woman claiming discrimination, but there's also the specter
- 14:09Speaker 3: that whatever rule the Court comes out with could be
- 14:12Speaker 3: used by people pressing so called reverse discrimination cases, namely
- 14:17Speaker 3: and say a white person saying an employer's diversity policy
- 14:22Speaker 3: discriminates against them. We heard that question from Justice Barrett
- 14:27Speaker 3: asking about that subject. Was there any more from the
- 14:30Speaker 3: court on that Do we have any kind of indication
- 14:33Speaker 3: as to whether corporate diversity policies might be affected by
- 14:37Speaker 3: this case.
- 14:39Speaker 1: Well.
- 14:39Speaker 5: Justice Thomas also asked whether the worker's definition of discrimination
- 14:45Speaker 5: here in the need for no material harm, could run
- 14:50Speaker 5: headlong into efforts to diversify the workplace. So it's clearly
- 14:54Speaker 5: on the court's mind. It seems like with this narrow
- 15:00Speaker 5: question presented, the ruling will most likely deal just with transfers.
- 15:06Speaker 5: But you could imagine that there'll be all sorts of
- 15:09Speaker 5: commentary in the opinion that down the road litigans My
- 15:13Speaker 5: point to whether they be folks worried about discriminatory employment
- 15:20Speaker 5: actions that aren't transfers, or you know, whether they're raised
- 15:24Speaker 5: by the sort of people that you're mentioning, folks who
- 15:27Speaker 5: are against quote unquote reverse racism.
- 15:31Speaker 2: And then surprisingly, bathrooms have been a topic at the
- 15:35Speaker 2: US Supreme Court over recent terms, and sort of wondering
- 15:39Speaker 2: that came up in the argument too, is that going
- 15:41Speaker 2: to be one of the areas where you know, this
- 15:44Speaker 2: case could potentially have a broader impact the idea of
- 15:48Speaker 2: access to bathrooms for transgender students or transgender workers.
- 15:54Speaker 5: Yeah, I was sort of surprised when that came up
- 15:57Speaker 5: in the arguments myself. When the parties were discussing, you know,
- 16:02Speaker 5: possible exceptions to this idea that discrimination is by definition
- 16:08Speaker 5: a harm the people suffer. You know, that attacked your
- 16:11Speaker 5: dignity and statement attaching these sort of things. But when
- 16:14Speaker 5: discussing this, I believe it was the lawyer for the
- 16:18Speaker 5: Solicator General's office that the Biden administration lawyer had brought
- 16:22Speaker 5: up bathrooms as one of the examples of an area
- 16:25Speaker 5: that traditionally we just viewed it's essentially sex discrimination. Right
- 16:33Speaker 5: to say that women go to the bathroom in that
- 16:36Speaker 5: room and then go to the bathroom in that room.
- 16:38Speaker 5: But if that's an example of an accepted discrimination on
- 16:43Speaker 5: the basis of sex, that nobody were the questions. But
- 16:46Speaker 5: of course it is coming up in cases a bathroom
- 16:48Speaker 5: access for transgendered individuals. Again, I think it's similar to
- 16:53Speaker 5: the issue with the diversity programs that I do not
- 16:57Speaker 5: believe that there'll be any like holding directly on point
- 17:01Speaker 5: about the bathroom issue, but there may be stray discussion
- 17:05Speaker 5: in the majority opinion or an assenting opinion that litigans
- 17:10Speaker 5: down the road might seize on lit on either side
- 17:13Speaker 5: of the debate.
- 17:14Speaker 3: Bobby stepping back just a little bit, so this Court,
- 17:17Speaker 3: in many ways, is a very conservative court. I think
- 17:21Speaker 3: a lot of people listening might be a little bit
- 17:24Speaker 3: surprised that this court, even though this may end up
- 17:27Speaker 3: being a narrow decision, might be ruling in favor of
- 17:32Speaker 3: employment discrimination suits. And it wouldn't be the first time
- 17:35Speaker 3: they've done that. You mentioned the case involving suits by
- 17:39Speaker 3: transgender people on suits alleging sexual orientation discrimination. What's going
- 17:46Speaker 3: on here? Can you excurve encapsulate why the court is
- 17:50Speaker 3: doing something that many people might be counterintuitive?
- 17:54Speaker 5: Yeah, I mean, from my perspective, I think it comes
- 17:57Speaker 5: down to judicial philosophy. Essentially, judges that tend to hail
- 18:04Speaker 5: from the right side of the political spectrum also claim
- 18:08Speaker 5: allegiance to a way of interpreting law known as textualism,
- 18:13Speaker 5: where they're not interested in the legislative history that might
- 18:18Speaker 5: have gone on that led up to the writing of
- 18:21Speaker 5: the law. They're only interested in what the words on
- 18:25Speaker 5: the paper say and what those words meant at the
- 18:28Speaker 5: time that they were written. So in this case, give
- 18:32Speaker 5: the workers attorney really leaned into this, It's really about
- 18:36Speaker 5: what does Title seven say. Title seven does not explicitly
- 18:40Speaker 5: create any separate harm requirement. It just says it's unlawful
- 18:44Speaker 5: for an employer to discriminate against any individual concerning terms, conditions,
- 18:48Speaker 5: and privileges of employment because of their sex, or race
- 18:53Speaker 5: or other protected traits. So in that respect, it kind
- 18:58Speaker 5: of fits right in with some of the justices on
- 19:02Speaker 5: the Court that are conservative justices, but their textualers well.
- 19:06Speaker 2: Our thanks to Bloomberg Law is robert Iafola. Coming up
- 19:09Speaker 2: next on the Bloomberg Law Show, we'll take a look
- 19:11Speaker 2: at threats against federal judges and what the government is
- 19:14Speaker 2: doing to try to stop them.
- 19:15Speaker 6: I'm Kimberly Robinson.
- 19:17Speaker 3: And I'm Greg Store. This is Bloomberg.
- 19:26Speaker 1: You're listening to the Bloomberg Law Podcast. Catch us weekdays
- 19:30Speaker 1: at ten pm Easter on Bloomberg dot Com, the iHeartRadio app,
- 19:34Speaker 1: and the Bloomberg Business App, or listen on demand wherever
- 19:37Speaker 1: you get your podcasts.
- 19:40Speaker 2: I'm Greg Store and I'm Kimberly Robinson. In for June
- 19:43Speaker 2: Grosso Up now. The number of credible threats against federal
- 19:46Speaker 2: judges climbed in recent years, with more than one hundred
- 19:49Speaker 2: and eighty substantiated threats against federal judges from January to
- 19:53Speaker 2: March of twenty twenty three.
- 19:55Speaker 8: Two weeks ago. My life as I knew it changed
- 19:58Speaker 8: in an instant, and my family will never be the same.
- 20:02Speaker 8: A madman who I believe was targeting me because of
- 20:06Speaker 8: my position as a federal judge came to my house.
- 20:10Speaker 2: That was Federal Judge Esther Salas in twenty twenty, after
- 20:12Speaker 2: a gunman open fire at her home, killing her twenty
- 20:15Speaker 2: year old son and severely injuring her husband.
- 20:17Speaker 3: Here to talk to us about threats against judges and
- 20:20Speaker 3: the government's efforts to thwart them. As a familiar voice,
- 20:23Speaker 3: Bloomberg laws Lydia Wheeler, who when she's not filling in
- 20:26Speaker 3: as a host on this show, covers the Supreme Court
- 20:29Speaker 3: and the federal judiciary. So, Lydia, you recently wrote a
- 20:32Speaker 3: story about judicial security and threats against judges. What did
- 20:36Speaker 3: you uncover?
- 20:37Speaker 9: That's right. So, I actually learned in my reporting that
- 20:40Speaker 9: the United States Marshal Service can't fully assess the security
- 20:44Speaker 9: risks that federal judges face because its system for tracking
- 20:48Speaker 9: threats doesn't allow marshalls to cross reference behavioral information and
- 20:52Speaker 9: spot suspicious activity that could actually help them connect cases. So,
- 20:57Speaker 9: former marshals told me that the system that there use
- 21:00Speaker 9: now was actually built to keep tabs on prisoners and
- 21:03Speaker 9: futuitism investigations, not actually track threats and inappropriate communications against
- 21:08Speaker 9: the judiciary. You know, one former marshal you know put
- 21:11Speaker 9: it to me this way. He said, think about if
- 21:14Speaker 9: there's a little red corvette seen circling the federal courthouse
- 21:16Speaker 9: in Omaha, Nebrassa on Wednesday, and then a red corvette
- 21:20Speaker 9: is spotted circling a federal courthouse in Little Rock, Arkansas
- 21:23Speaker 9: on Friday. Intelligence analysts really need to be able to
- 21:26Speaker 9: connect those dots pretty quickly, and that's something that they
- 21:29Speaker 9: can't do right now.
- 21:31Speaker 2: Well, is the Marshal Service working on a fix for
- 21:34Speaker 2: this problem?
- 21:35Speaker 9: Yeah, they are, so. The Martial Service has been working
- 21:37Speaker 9: on this for some time. They've been working to transition
- 21:40Speaker 9: the entire agency over to a new system called capture.
- 21:44Speaker 9: That former marshals I talked to told me that it
- 21:46Speaker 9: would let the Judicial Security Division actually break data down
- 21:50Speaker 9: into more detail, you know, track threats by district, by drudge,
- 21:54Speaker 9: by you know, person who made the thread and how
- 21:56Speaker 9: the threat was communicated. But funding issues and competing prayer
- 22:00Speaker 9: already have really contributed to the projects away.
- 22:04Speaker 3: So what sorts of threats are judges getting.
- 22:07Speaker 9: For this story, I actually looked at cases of people
- 22:09Speaker 9: who have been federally prosecuted for threatening a judge, just
- 22:12Speaker 9: to get an idea of the type of threats that
- 22:15Speaker 9: you know judges are getting, and I can tell you
- 22:18Speaker 9: they're often very explicit and some are actually pretty scary.
- 22:22Speaker 9: So you know, the threats are most often communicated by email.
- 22:27Speaker 9: They come to the judges chambers by phone and are
- 22:30Speaker 9: left in a voicemail message, and oftentimes they come in
- 22:34Speaker 9: handwritten letters. So I actually came across one case from
- 22:37Speaker 9: twenty seventeen that was against a man in Connecticut who's
- 22:42Speaker 9: threatened to harm a federal bankruptcy judge in a handwritten
- 22:46Speaker 9: letter that he put in in her mailbox at her home,
- 22:49Speaker 9: so he actually knew where she lived, and you know,
- 22:52Speaker 9: it was basically telling her like, don't go too far
- 22:55Speaker 9: in this hearing. You know, back off, I'm warning you.
- 22:59Speaker 9: And you know, oftentimes the threat goes beyond not only
- 23:03Speaker 9: the judge, but also targets the people who are closest
- 23:06Speaker 9: to them, so it will say that they know the
- 23:09Speaker 9: threatener often threatens a spouse or the judges children as well.
- 23:14Speaker 2: So in looking at the people who have been prosecuted
- 23:17Speaker 2: for threatening a federal judge. Are there any similarities among
- 23:20Speaker 2: those people?
- 23:22Speaker 9: There definitely are. So we teamed up with Peter Simmy,
- 23:26Speaker 9: who is a sociologist at Chapman University. He's actually been
- 23:29Speaker 9: studying threats against public officials at the National counter Terrorism Innovation,
- 23:35Speaker 9: Technology and Education Center at the University of Nebraska, Omaha,
- 23:39Speaker 9: and so with his data, we were able to look
- 23:42Speaker 9: at cases from the last ten years, and you know,
- 23:45Speaker 9: looking at this wealth of information, we found that most often,
- 23:49Speaker 9: you know, threateners have some sort of a connection to
- 23:51Speaker 9: the judge that they're threatening, or at least a connection
- 23:54Speaker 9: to the case that that judge is hearing. So meaning
- 23:57Speaker 9: they've either had a case before the judge in the
- 23:59Speaker 9: past or they know someone who has. Sometimes so the
- 24:03Speaker 9: person is just really upset about the case that the
- 24:06Speaker 9: judge is presiding over, so thinks back. You know, we've
- 24:09Speaker 9: reported in recent months that Judge Tanya Chutkin has gotten
- 24:14Speaker 9: death threats. You know, she's the judge that's overseeing that
- 24:16Speaker 9: criminal case right now in DC that's accusing President Donald
- 24:20Speaker 9: Trump of conspiring to overturn the twenty twenty election results.
- 24:25Speaker 9: We also found that people who threaten judges often have
- 24:29Speaker 9: a criminal history already, lots of them have mental health issues,
- 24:34Speaker 9: and several of them are motivated by ideology. So, you know,
- 24:39Speaker 9: Peter Sime at Chapman University, you know, found that in
- 24:41Speaker 9: his research that actually right wing extremism ideologies tend to
- 24:46Speaker 9: be the most prominently presented here. And so you know,
- 24:51Speaker 9: but threats are also coming in, you know, from people
- 24:53Speaker 9: on the other side of the political line too. If
- 24:56Speaker 9: you'll think back Judge Matthew kes Merrick, who's the federal
- 24:59Speaker 9: district judg in Texas. You know, he got a barrage
- 25:02Speaker 9: of death threats and harassing phone calls in March when
- 25:05Speaker 9: he was hearing a big case over a key abortion
- 25:09Speaker 9: drug known as mis apristone. And I'm sure you both
- 25:12Speaker 9: remember the man who was found, you know, outside of
- 25:16Speaker 9: Justice Brett Kavanaugh's home. You know, he was armed with
- 25:18Speaker 9: a pistol and he told investigators that he was there
- 25:22Speaker 9: to kill the justice because he was upset about the
- 25:25Speaker 9: court's leak of the draft abortion decision.
- 25:28Speaker 3: Lydia, in your story, you distinguish among different types of
- 25:32Speaker 3: people who make threats. You said that there are hunters
- 25:36Speaker 3: and there are howlers. Can you describe what those are?
- 25:40Speaker 5: That's right?
- 25:40Speaker 9: So the marshals refer to people who threatened judges repeatedly
- 25:43Speaker 9: at howlers, you know those, and then they those are
- 25:47Speaker 9: people who repeatedly send messaging or threatening messages, but they
- 25:52Speaker 9: don't ever act on them. And then there are people
- 25:55Speaker 9: who actually go out and seek out the judge and
- 25:58Speaker 9: attack them, and those are known as hunters. And I'm
- 26:01Speaker 9: told that they're rarely one and the same, so meaning
- 26:04Speaker 9: howlers don't often turn into hunters, but marshals, you know,
- 26:09Speaker 9: former marshals told me that it's impossible to know kind
- 26:12Speaker 9: of which threats are credible and if a hunter or
- 26:16Speaker 9: if a howler is going to become a hunter eventually
- 26:19Speaker 9: unless they actually investigate and look into the threat itself.
- 26:22Speaker 4: You know.
- 26:23Speaker 9: I will say that the judges and the former marshals
- 26:26Speaker 9: that I spoke with all praised the work of the
- 26:29Speaker 9: Marshals Service and spoke about how judicial security is just
- 26:33Speaker 9: a really difficult job, even with the best analytical tools.
- 26:36Speaker 9: You know, several of the judges I spoke with just
- 26:39Speaker 9: you know, wanted to make that clear, you know that
- 26:41Speaker 9: they have a really hard job, you know, even if
- 26:43Speaker 9: they have the best tools.
- 26:46Speaker 2: So you said you spoke with some federal judges, how
- 26:48Speaker 2: do they feel about these threats and sort of what's
- 26:50Speaker 2: going on with the Marshall's office.
- 26:52Speaker 9: Yeah, that's right. So I spoke with Judge Timothy Corrigan.
- 26:55Speaker 9: You know, he now serves as chief judge of the U. S.
- 26:58Speaker 9: District Court for the Middle District of four. You know,
- 27:01Speaker 9: he said that threats are just part of the job
- 27:04Speaker 9: and that he has to deal with them. But that's
- 27:06Speaker 9: actually really hard on his family. And that's the hardest
- 27:10Speaker 9: part to think about that because of what he chose
- 27:12Speaker 9: to do for a living, he's now putting you know,
- 27:14Speaker 9: those that he loves the most at risk. And Judge
- 27:17Speaker 9: Corgan is interesting because actually in twenty thirteen he was
- 27:22Speaker 9: nearly as fascinated at his home when a gunman took
- 27:25Speaker 9: aim outside his window. You know, he was just relaxing
- 27:29Speaker 9: in his recliner watching TV and you know, all of
- 27:32Speaker 9: a sudden, there was this big explosion and you know,
- 27:35Speaker 9: in the investigation afterwards, they found out that the bullet
- 27:38Speaker 9: had missed his head by one point six inches. You know,
- 27:43Speaker 9: in that attack, the attacker was actually able to sneak
- 27:46Speaker 9: away from the scene and he ended up on the
- 27:48Speaker 9: list of possible suspects because he had a warrant out
- 27:51Speaker 9: for his arrest. He had violated I guess the terms
- 27:54Speaker 9: of his supervised release and was actually few backs before
- 27:57Speaker 9: Judge Corgan. But Judge Corgan told me that he didn't
- 28:01Speaker 9: even remember him very well, and like the only reason
- 28:03Speaker 9: he made that list of potential suspects was because you know,
- 28:06Speaker 9: he had he had that warrant out for his arrest.
- 28:09Speaker 9: But so, you know, Judge Corgan has gotten threats since
- 28:13Speaker 9: then from other people, and you know, like I said,
- 28:16Speaker 9: he said, they're just a feature of the job, and
- 28:17Speaker 9: he said that they don't try to affect him that
- 28:19Speaker 9: much on the bench or you know that they aren't
- 28:21Speaker 9: really having an impact. But you know, the sociologists I
- 28:24Speaker 9: spoke with said, you know, judges are human and these
- 28:27Speaker 9: threats could impact you know, how they they you know,
- 28:31Speaker 9: form their decisions and how they rule on the bench.
- 28:33Speaker 3: Lydia, you said they are increasing. Now, is there a
- 28:37Speaker 3: broader effect on the federal judiciary.
- 28:39Speaker 9: Yeah, So my sources are telling me that, you know,
- 28:42Speaker 9: a threat against a member of the judiciary is really
- 28:44Speaker 9: a threat against democracy and that it's not tenable for
- 28:48Speaker 9: democracy to have people expressing their grievances and leasing that
- 28:52Speaker 9: discontent with threats of violence, you know, at this volume,
- 28:55Speaker 9: so you know, the sociologists I spoke with that it
- 28:59Speaker 9: suggests that a certain lawlessness is acceptable and actually becoming normalized.
- 29:03Speaker 9: So yeah, this is you know, the broader impacts are
- 29:06Speaker 9: pretty great here, So.
- 29:07Speaker 2: Lydia, we heard previously from Judge Esther Sallas, who was
- 29:12Speaker 2: involved in an attack in twenty twenty by a gunman
- 29:14Speaker 2: that killed her son and injured her husband. Can you
- 29:16Speaker 2: tell us what happened with that case. There was some
- 29:20Speaker 2: legislation that came as a result of that, right.
- 29:24Speaker 9: Yeah, that's right. So you know, Judge Sallas actually lobbied
- 29:27Speaker 9: Congress after that horrible tragedy to pass the Daniel anderl
- 29:32Speaker 9: Judicial Security and Privacy Act in twenty twenty two, and
- 29:36Speaker 9: that law aims to make judges personal identifiable information harder
- 29:40Speaker 9: to find online. And so actually I reached out to
- 29:45Speaker 9: the Administrative Office of the US Courts and they told
- 29:48Speaker 9: me that since that law passed, about three million individual
- 29:53Speaker 9: pieces of judges information have been removed from the Internet
- 29:56Speaker 9: since then, So we know that the law is having
- 30:00Speaker 9: an impact and Judge Ballas told me that she also
- 30:03Speaker 9: got a similar legislation passed at the state level in
- 30:06Speaker 9: New Jersey, and she's working for other states to pass
- 30:10Speaker 9: a similar legislation as well. She's really made it her
- 30:13Speaker 9: life's mission now without her only son, so living, you know,
- 30:18Speaker 9: to have some sort of impact on judicial security and
- 30:23Speaker 9: make judges safe so no one else has to go
- 30:25Speaker 9: through this a horrible tragedy Lydia.
- 30:27Speaker 3: Is there reason the thing that the removal of all
- 30:30Speaker 3: that information has indeed made judges in their families safer.
- 30:35Speaker 9: It has in some respects, but you know, judges and
- 30:40Speaker 9: former commercials that I spoke to said that there's no
- 30:42Speaker 9: way to remove all of the information from the Internet.
- 30:46Speaker 9: You know, it's hard to keep track of all of it,
- 30:48Speaker 9: and it's hard to find it all, and there's always
- 30:51Speaker 9: going to be information on the dark web, and so
- 30:54Speaker 9: that's going to continuously be a risk. That this is
- 30:56Speaker 9: a step in the right direction. You know, I actually
- 31:00Speaker 9: chatted with a former marshal who trains judges on security,
- 31:04Speaker 9: and you know, he said that they needed to be
- 31:06Speaker 9: proactive and be a participant in their own survival. So
- 31:11Speaker 9: he basically advises them to get a home security system,
- 31:14Speaker 9: you know, be really mindful of their social media posts.
- 31:18Speaker 9: He said that they should protect their private information the
- 31:21Speaker 9: best way that they can. You know, it starts with them,
- 31:23Speaker 9: and that they when they are out of the office
- 31:26Speaker 9: and you know, outside of the federal courthouse, that they
- 31:29Speaker 9: should pay attention to their surroundings and if they see
- 31:32Speaker 9: something suspicious to report it. You know. Judge Dallas told
- 31:35Speaker 9: me that she, you know, prior to this attack, she
- 31:37Speaker 9: had actually seen the attacker on her street and had
- 31:42Speaker 9: had seen him ahead of time. And former marshals say
- 31:44Speaker 9: that they hear this kind of thing, you know, all
- 31:46Speaker 9: the time from some judges that you know, they'll get
- 31:49Speaker 9: that kind of intuition of like oh that doesn't feel right,
- 31:52Speaker 9: and they don't report it, and you know, or they
- 31:55Speaker 9: don't know that they should report it. And so this
- 31:57Speaker 9: former marshal was saying, definitely, if something rubbed you the
- 32:00Speaker 9: wrong way, like, you know, it's better to err on
- 32:02Speaker 9: the side of caution. So really to trust your intuition
- 32:06Speaker 9: and to take all the threats that you're getting seriously.
- 32:08Speaker 2: So Lydia wondering is there any other advice that's given
- 32:12Speaker 2: to judges on how they can protect themselves and keep
- 32:14Speaker 2: themselves safe well on the bench.
- 32:17Speaker 9: Yeah, so you know, marshals are basically just saying that,
- 32:20Speaker 9: you know, pay attention to the threats that are coming through.
- 32:24Speaker 9: You know, it's easy to disregard them that you think
- 32:27Speaker 9: are just like completely you know, outlandish. I mean some
- 32:31Speaker 9: of the threats that I read. Yeah, you know, you
- 32:33Speaker 9: can tell that a person that is writing them is
- 32:37Speaker 9: suffering from some mental health crisis, but that doesn't necessarily
- 32:41Speaker 9: mean that that person won't act on that threat. So
- 32:43Speaker 9: it's important to make sure that you're reporting them and
- 32:47Speaker 9: then also that you know, Marshalls told me that it's important,
- 32:50Speaker 9: or former marshals, I should say, told me that it's
- 32:52Speaker 9: important that judges kind of follow up and say like,
- 32:54Speaker 9: you know, hey, where are we with that, and kind
- 32:56Speaker 9: of you know, like I said, be an active participant
- 32:59Speaker 9: in their own security.
- 33:00Speaker 3: LYDIA. We haven't talked about state court judges. Are they
- 33:04Speaker 3: getting similar types of threats?
- 33:06Speaker 9: Definitely, they're one hundred percent facing the same kind of
- 33:10Speaker 9: threats that federal judges are facing, and some of them
- 33:13Speaker 9: have had really horrible tragedies like some federal judges have.
- 33:16Speaker 9: Just recently in October, there was a Maryland state court
- 33:20Speaker 9: judge who was shot to death in the driveway of
- 33:22Speaker 9: his home. You know, the prime suspect was actually a
- 33:26Speaker 9: man that had lost a custody of his children in
- 33:30Speaker 9: a divorce hearing earlier that day in front of the
- 33:33Speaker 9: judge that he shot. And you know, police actually found
- 33:36Speaker 9: that man about a week later deceased. So while marshals
- 33:41Speaker 9: are tracking threats against federal judges, there, I've been told
- 33:44Speaker 9: there is no national repository for threats against state court judges.
- 33:49Speaker 9: And there's way more of them. I mean, we're talking
- 33:52Speaker 9: about like over thirty thousand state court judges across the country,
- 33:57Speaker 9: and you know, states either aren't collecting this data, or
- 34:02Speaker 9: they're not collecting it consistently across states, or they're not
- 34:06Speaker 9: reporting it publicly. So it's really hard to tell what
- 34:09Speaker 9: state court judges are facing. And they don't have the
- 34:11Speaker 9: protection of the Marshall Service, so actually those people are
- 34:14Speaker 9: less protected.
- 34:16Speaker 2: Sounds like a lot of work to do, but thank
- 34:17Speaker 2: you to Lydia Wheeler that's going to do it. For
- 34:20Speaker 2: this edition of The Bloomberg Law Show, I'm Kimberly Robinson and.
- 34:24Speaker 3: I'm Greg Storr. Stay with us top stories and global
- 34:27Speaker 3: business headlines are coming up right now.