Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Crime and Disorder: Addiction, Mental Illness and Drug Policy vs Bail?
Transcript
- 0:00Robert Buffam: legally speaking with Michael Mulligan.
- 0:02Robert Buffam: Mike, can you hear me If you can, welcome to the show.
- 0:05Michael Mulligan: I sure can.
- 0:06Michael Mulligan: It's always great to be here, and you are in the Big Apple, I believe.
- 0:09Michael Mulligan: Are you?
- 0:09Michael Mulligan: Indeed?
- 0:10Michael Mulligan: I am, through the miracle of the telephone, never too far away, though.
- 0:15Robert Buffam: That's great.
- 0:15Robert Buffam: Well, listen, thanks for taking the time to join us.
- 0:17Robert Buffam: There's a variety of topics that you've dug into and we can talk about those.
- 0:23Robert Buffam: I also wanted to ask you, if I could it's not something that we planned, but you're an expert on this.
- 0:28Robert Buffam: I wanted to ask you about bail reform, because it's something you and I have spoken a fair bit about and it's become very political.
- 0:33Robert Buffam: Of course, it's a federal thing, but it's also something that has attracted a lot of provincial attention, and there's been a lot of outrage about repeat offenders being released into the community, pressure on the provincial government to do something about it and, at times, what appears perhaps to be grandstanding, by politicians, including the Premier, saying that they're pushing hard for changes.
- 0:53Robert Buffam: They may be pushing hard for changes.
- 0:54Robert Buffam: There's also a limit as to what people can do.
- 0:56Robert Buffam: What is your take on this issue?
- 1:00Michael Mulligan: That's a very good question.
- 1:01Michael Mulligan: It's certainly understandable why the current government of British Columbia would like to blame the wording of the bail sections in the criminal code as the cause of the just clear social disorder that anyone could see.
- 1:18Michael Mulligan: Who, for example, walks down Pandora in Victoria, walks down Pandora in Victoria, and I have a bit of a different perspective on that as somebody who has been worked in the criminal justice system for many years.
- 1:31Michael Mulligan: In my view, that is to a large extent a misdiagnosis of the problem.
- 1:38Michael Mulligan: Whether that is a intentional misdiagnosis because it allows the provincial government to cast blame on the federal government, or whether that's simply a misunderstanding is hard to know.
- 1:50Michael Mulligan: I should say that the root causes of the serious and obvious social disorder are to a large extent provincial responsibilities, to a large extent provincial responsibilities, and the root of many of them is in the approach that's been taken provincially to drug policy and mental health.
- 2:14Michael Mulligan: And essentially what's happened is that we moved from a system which dealt with drugs as a criminal justice matter and that was clearly not a complete solution to the problem.
- 2:27Michael Mulligan: Right?
- 2:27Michael Mulligan: If you have somebody who's addicted to drugs, likely the threat of jail is not going to deter you, if the threat of death hasn't deterred you from using drugs.
- 2:36Michael Mulligan: But what was clearly missing in that effort, which no doubt was well-intentioned at the time, is anywhere near what is required in terms of treatment to ensure that people can stop using those things.
- 2:51Michael Mulligan: And so we have a circumstance where you have literally thousands of people who are profoundly addicted to often fentanyl, often combined with mental illness, who have no treatment option, and so they wind up living on Pandora in tents, and then the reality is that they would be committing petty crime morning, noon and night in order to get the money to purchase the drugs, and so that is the core cause of the social disorder, which is absolutely real.
- 3:23Michael Mulligan: The changes to the bail system some of which were made has, in my judgment, no hope of addressing that problem in any meaningful way.
- 3:34Michael Mulligan: Now, that isn't to say that additional resources, for example with Crown or judicial resources, can't have some effect around the margins.
- 3:44Michael Mulligan: Clearly there are some people who do need to be in custody, and if there's additional resources, that might be done more effectively.
- 3:54Michael Mulligan: But it has no hope of curing that underlying problem, and so my take on it is that, while it may be well-intentioned, that is a misdiagnosis of what the root of the problem is, and the changes that have been made have had virtually no effect on the underlying problem.
- 4:14Michael Mulligan: So it's a serious problem.
- 4:16Michael Mulligan: It's real.
- 4:16Michael Mulligan: There are things that could be done about it.
- 4:18Michael Mulligan: It's just that what's been pointed to is not the root cause of it, and so that's why it has been unsuccessful.
- 4:25Robert Buffam: What's been pointed to is not the root cause of it, and so that's why it has been unsuccessful.
- 4:29Robert Buffam: Okay, so to be clear, you're saying reforms to the federal bail provisions or laws that have been trumpeted as being a step in the right direction actually are not going to make much of a difference, if any.
- 4:41Michael Mulligan: It'll be on the absolute margin.
- 4:42Michael Mulligan: The underlying problem is not, or the underlying solution to the fact that we have thousands of people who are profoundly addicted to drugs living on the streets and committing crime is not to, for example and we've got to remember what bail is right the origin of the reason we have a bail system at all is we presume people to be innocent, and if you don't have a bail system, the presumption of innocence is essentially meaningless.
- 5:08Michael Mulligan: Right If somebody's arrested for it.
- 5:10Michael Mulligan: Many of the people who are on the street and in that position, the crimes they are committing are usually not serious violent crimes which may well dictate detention, but they are usually things like shoplifting.
- 5:23Michael Mulligan: And so the solution to the problem of somebody who is profoundly mentally ill, seriously addicted to drugs, living on the street, is not to wait until they are caught shoplifting and then hold the person in custody prior to their trial.
- 5:40Michael Mulligan: That will simply produce a person who's been in custody for a period of time who is then released still as a mentally ill person who's addicted to drugs, and so that is just not the solution to the problem.
- 5:55Michael Mulligan: We shouldn't, frankly, be waiting until somebody goes and commits some crime to buy drugs and then deal with it as if the underlying root of the problem is a desire to shoplift cheese.
- 6:08Michael Mulligan: That is not the underlying problem.
- 6:10Michael Mulligan: The underlying problem is the profound drug addiction and mental illness which is untreated and which we have not provided resources to treat.
- 6:18Michael Mulligan: We've legalized the possession and use of the drugs.
- 6:20Michael Mulligan: That remain legal in many circumstances.
- 6:23Michael Mulligan: Frankly, the latest batch of amendments to those permit somebody who is sheltering, homeless, to continue to possess and use drugs as I read it anywhere and so, without treatment facilities, what we see on the street now is simply going to continue, and no tinkering with the wording around bail is going to solve that, and there are discussions about whether we should have mandatory treatment, for example, and that may have merit.
- 6:54Michael Mulligan: Frankly, the legislation we already have in place, which permits somebody to be detained under the Mental Health Act if they're a danger to themselves or others, would likely have application to somebody who's profoundly addicted to drugs, using them and unable to stop.
- 7:09Michael Mulligan: They're clearly a danger to themselves.
- 7:10Michael Mulligan: They have a real chance of dying if they continue doing that.
- 7:14Michael Mulligan: The trouble is there is nowhere for the person to go and unless you have adequate treatment facilities, the debate about should we have mandatory treatment for people who are in that position is meaningless, because even if you are somebody now who desperately wants help, sticks up your hand, makes your way past the drug paraphernalia vending machines that have been installed at hospitals, stumbles in and says I want help, I need to stop.
- 7:38Michael Mulligan: I realize I'm going to die.
- 7:40Michael Mulligan: There's nowhere for them to go.
- 7:41Michael Mulligan: What is your view?
- 7:43Robert Buffam: on sorry to interrupt you on this topic of bail reform.
- 7:48Robert Buffam: One of the stories that is a tragic one that has attracted a fair bit of attention is the story of the woman in Surrey who was killed, and it's alleged that the man who murdered her is somebody who was out on bail at the time.
- 8:01Robert Buffam: It's a person who has a history of many violent offenses and crimes and the public is outraged, understandably, by that set of facts and wondering how on earth the court had released him on bail.
- 8:15Robert Buffam: The premier had weighed in.
- 8:16Robert Buffam: It became a political issue and he said that he would get to the bottom of what the judge's decision was at the bail hearing.
- 8:22Robert Buffam: As we both know, bail hearings are generally subject to a publication ban and the government has indicated they're going to try and have that ban lifted, moved in a way that would allow the public at large, not only the family to find out the details of what happened, but also general public.
- 8:40Robert Buffam: Is that likely to succeed as something to happen, or is that maybe more responding to the public outcry in what might be a political way?
- 8:48Michael Mulligan: It's responding to a public outcry in a political way, and that is why that has not occurred.
- 8:52Michael Mulligan: It has not occurred because there's no mechanism to do that.
- 8:55Michael Mulligan: And my comments about the bail system and the wording of the Act and so on is not to say that every decision is perfect.
- 9:03Michael Mulligan: It isn't.
- 9:04Michael Mulligan: Act and so on is not to say that every decision is perfect.
- 9:08Michael Mulligan: It isn't.
- 9:08Michael Mulligan: It is a human process.
- 9:09Michael Mulligan: And the fundamental challenge with bail decisions is you are you, not you the judge is trying to predict whether this person is going to be the person who behaves in some way that causes serious harm while the person's out on bail.
- 9:23Michael Mulligan: That is hard to predict.
- 9:24Michael Mulligan: I mean, part of the problem with people who are in the category that I've described we've been talking about the people who are, you know, living on Pandora, who are suffering from profound mental illness and drug addiction is that ultimately, the behavior of somebody in that circumstance is going to be unpredictable.
- 9:39Michael Mulligan: And there is a problem that from time to time and we know that, we've seen that in Victoria and we've seen it elsewhere in the province somebody who is seriously mentally ill, addicted to drugs, will from time to time behave in a random, violent way and seriously hurt or kill someone.
- 9:55Michael Mulligan: That is just the truth.
- 9:57Michael Mulligan: But when you are charged with the task of which of these thousands of people who, for example, somebody's arrested for, you're the constable.
- 10:06Michael Mulligan: You're called down to the shoplifting case at the food store and you've managed to.
- 10:09Michael Mulligan: You know somebody's been caught stealing cheese that would be a common thing.
- 10:13Michael Mulligan: So you've got the cheese thief there.
- 10:16Michael Mulligan: You, the police officer constable, need to decide is this cheese thief going to be the person who would randomly choose to commit some violent act under the influence of drugs tomorrow or the next day?
- 10:27Michael Mulligan: That's a hard call.
- 10:28Michael Mulligan: Now there are cases which, ultimately, the wrong call is made, and the one you're talking about may or may not be one of those.
- 10:37Michael Mulligan: We don't know because we don't have the information that was provided at the bail hearing and not every bail decision that turns out to be wrong, and I should say many of those and most of those decisions are made by the police themselves.
- 10:48Michael Mulligan: Only in a small percentage of cases do the police actually take the person and ask that they have a bail hearing.
- 10:54Michael Mulligan: Most of the time when the police show up and arrest somebody for cheese theft, the police themselves decide to release the person.
- 11:01Michael Mulligan: There is no bail hearing, no judges involved at all, and most of those decisions turn out to be correct, but not all of them.
- 11:14Michael Mulligan: And it is not a possible solution to say we will hold every cheese thief in custody.
- 11:16Michael Mulligan: The jails would be full in one week.
- 11:18Michael Mulligan: We are speaking.
- 11:20Robert Buffam: I keep cutting you off.
- 11:21Robert Buffam: I finish your thoughts, sorry.
- 11:23Michael Mulligan: Yeah, that's not a possible option, so nothing is perfect.
- 11:26Michael Mulligan: There are cases like the one you described that may be a serious error.
- 11:29Michael Mulligan: We don't know because we don't have the information about that particular one in good time.
- 11:33Michael Mulligan: We will find out those bans on publication and once the case is concluded.
- 11:38Robert Buffam: And your view, having been somebody who's in the courts very frequently, is it's unlikely that a publication ban on that bail hearing and the reasons for the release would be lifted.
- 11:49Michael Mulligan: There's no mechanism for that in the criminal code at all.
- 11:52Robert Buffam: Okay, well, there we have it.
- 11:54Robert Buffam: Our guest is Michael Mulligan.
- 11:55Robert Buffam: We've got Legally Speaking.
- 11:57Robert Buffam: We're going to take a quick break and then we'll come back to talk to Michael about some interesting cases he's dug into.
- 12:02Robert Buffam: Here's a commercial.
- 12:02Robert Buffam: Welcome back to the program.
- 12:04Robert Buffam: I'm Rob Buffam filling in for Adam Sterling.
- 12:07Robert Buffam: We're speaking right now with Michael Mulligan, a criminal defense lawyer who has his weekly segment Legally Speaking.
- 12:12Robert Buffam: Michael, thanks for joining us from New York.
- 12:16Michael Mulligan: Oh, I should say, always a real pleasure to be here.
- 12:18Michael Mulligan: I look forward to doing this every week.
- 12:19Michael Mulligan: I also just wanted to say, before I move on to the cases to talk about this week, that I didn't want to leave people with the impression that the current state of affairs, with serious social disorder, high rates of crime and people dying every day, is a hopeless problem.
- 12:37Michael Mulligan: There are policy prescriptions that are likely to make a difference.
- 12:41Michael Mulligan: I mean the current model.
- 12:43Michael Mulligan: I don't think it was ill-intended.
- 12:45Michael Mulligan: The idea was that if you destigmatized drug use, people would seek out treatment, and that's sort of at the heart of things, like vending machines handing out crack pipes.
- 12:54Michael Mulligan: But if you don't have the treatment facility available in anywhere near what is required numbers, given how profound and serious and large the scope of that problem is, that approach and it should have been obvious would fail, and there just doesn't seem to have been the willingness to come to grips with that, and so we now seem to have a continue to have a policy position that appears to be the worst of all possible worlds right.
- 13:23Michael Mulligan: What used to sort of not adequately but to some extent bed down the problem, dealing with it as a criminal justice matter, is largely gone and so we're left with what we've got, which has produced the disorder that we have.
- 13:35Michael Mulligan: There is a solution to it dealing with it as an addictions problem rather than, in my view, waiting for the person to go and steal something and then try to deal with it as a criminal justice issue, and that approach would be both less expensive and get to the heart of it.
- 13:51Michael Mulligan: Our core problem is not a whole bunch of people that really want cheese and batteries from local stores.
- 13:57Michael Mulligan: The heart of the problem is you've got people that have profound, serious drug addictions that don't have any capacity to get treatment.
- 14:03Michael Mulligan: So we can deal with it.
- 14:05Michael Mulligan: It's not hopeless.
- 14:06Michael Mulligan: It's just diagnosing it as a problem with the bail wording for people CFAX, victoria, an iHeartRadio station, if it's.
- 14:18Robert Buffam: Yeah, sorry, we were no problem.
- 14:20Michael Mulligan: Finish off your thoughts on that, because that was some really interesting insight on that, just the distinctions that need to be made so so just saying there is, there are policy changes that could be effective if we deal with the underlying, if we provide a mechanism to deal with the underlying drug addiction.
- 14:34Michael Mulligan: Rather than waiting for people who are profoundly drug addicted and often also mentally ill to commit a minor crime or multiple minor crimes and then try to deal with it as a bail and criminal justice issue, we should get ahead of it and deal with the underlying problem.
- 14:49Michael Mulligan: That's what we haven't done and no amount of destigmatization is going to solve the problem.
- 14:55Michael Mulligan: If there's just nowhere somebody can go to get help.
- 14:57Michael Mulligan: And that's what we've done and that's why we see the result that we've seen.
- 15:01Michael Mulligan: So I didn't want to leave people with the impression that there isn't something that can be done, and I also don't leave people with the impression there aren't any improvements in the criminal justice system.
- 15:10Michael Mulligan: Clearly there are.
- 15:10Michael Mulligan: It's not perfect, but that's not the heart of this problem.
- 15:13Michael Mulligan: And tinkering around with it or blaming the federal government's wording of the bail provisions is just to completely miss what the underlying cause is.
- 15:22Michael Mulligan: And if we don't diagnose the problem correctly, we won't come to a solution.
- 15:26Michael Mulligan: And that seems to be where we're currently at.
- 15:28Michael Mulligan: So maybe there'll be a change after October.
- 15:30Michael Mulligan: I guess we'll have to wait and see what people want to do with that.
- 15:33Robert Buffam: Well, thank you for articulating your thoughts on that and insight on that so clearly.
- 15:36Robert Buffam: We've got about five minutes left.
- 15:37Michael Mulligan: I'm sort of taking so much of it talking about bail but it's a case that deals with the issue of sometimes courts refer to it as testamentary autonomy Like what can you actually do in your will in terms of leaving your estate to somebody, what is permitted and not permitted in British Columbia?
- 16:07Michael Mulligan: And one of the constraints on that what somebody is permitted to do, what your actual degree of autonomy is, are provisions of what's now Section 60 in the Wills Estates and Succession Act.
- 16:18Michael Mulligan: These used to be in an act called the Wills Variation Act, but a number of years it was sort of modernized and put into that different stature, and what that really provides is that if in somebody's estate they don't provide what is referred to as sort of adequate proper maintenance and support for a spouse or child, a court can just modify the will to achieve that outcome.
- 16:46Michael Mulligan: And so that naturally raises the question what does proper maintenance and support mean?
- 16:51Michael Mulligan: And at one point there's a view well, does that just mean like if somebody is destitute, you can't just leave them destitute, you have to provide some means of support for them?
- 16:59Michael Mulligan: And the Supreme Court of Canada a number of years ago now, many years ago now, answered that, saying no, that's not what that terminology means.
- 17:09Michael Mulligan: And so the case I'm going to talk about that just came out.
- 17:13Michael Mulligan: It involved a case where there were two siblings, brother and sister, both described by the court.
- 17:18Michael Mulligan: As you know.
- 17:19Michael Mulligan: They didn't have any disabilities, they were married, had children, they both lived what's described as comfortable middle class lives, so it wasn't a circumstance where somebody is impoverished and they haven't been provided for.
- 17:31Michael Mulligan: And so the particular case involved, the fact pattern involved there was a mother and father of these two siblings who were fighting over the will.
- 17:43Michael Mulligan: The father won the lottery a number of years ago.
- 17:47Michael Mulligan: He won a million dollars in the BC 49 and bought some rental houses and various other things.
- 17:54Michael Mulligan: He sadly passed away a few years after he won the lottery and, as is common, his wife inherited the proceeds of that and other investments proceeds of that and other investments and then over a number of years the two children, brother and sister, were both described as sort of very caring and committed children, helping their mother through all sorts of things.
- 18:21Michael Mulligan: There's no issue about either of them being sort of the black sheep of the family.
- 18:24Michael Mulligan: But over the years the mother provided various gifts to her son and the explanation or the complaint by the daughter was that those things were done.
- 18:39Michael Mulligan: As a result of what she described as traditional Chinese values, and her argument was that she had favored her son because he was her son, son in preference to her.
- 18:52Michael Mulligan: And the case involves sort of what often occurs in these cases.
- 18:57Michael Mulligan: Sort of this is virtually embarrassing to read it.
- 19:01Michael Mulligan: You go through and it's sort of a litany of complaints about how you know mom would do the dishes at his house but not at my house when she came over and you know how she spoke about having a son would be a good thing, things of this sort.
- 19:15Michael Mulligan: And ultimately the argument made to the judge was that the son, because he received many benefits and financial assistance from the mother over the years, from the mother over the years, the will wasn't fair and that the daughter should get a larger percentage of the money left in the estate at the time the mom passed away.
- 19:37Michael Mulligan: And the judge very interestingly went through all of this history about sort of alleged statements the mother had made and the gifts provided, sort of traditional values and so on, and then put that into that matrix of what amounts to sort of adequate maintenance and support.
- 19:56Michael Mulligan: And in that regard the judge adopted sort of an approach that you know what has to happen here and this is consistent with the law, has to be consistent with sort of a prudent parent acting in their role to make judicious decisions in their parenting duty.
- 20:13Michael Mulligan: And ultimately the judge concluded that because of what she found the judge found to be an unequal treatment based on gender grounds over the years providing more support for the son than the daughter over the years providing more support for the son than the daughter the judge concluded that the division of property in the will was not adequate or fair and increased the amount of money that the daughter received in the will.
- 20:40Michael Mulligan: And so it's a very interesting case because it shows sort of how those values are now part of the law in the province and what it means in terms of what somebody's actual autonomy is, in terms of leaving differential amounts in their will.
- 20:54Michael Mulligan: And while there's reference to the fact there's autonomy, it is constrained.
- 20:59Michael Mulligan: What isn't constrained people should know about is when people are alive.
- 21:02Michael Mulligan: Of course, they can give money to whomever they want in whatever quantity they want, but in terms of your will, if there's an alleged unfairness on grounds like this, a court has authority to vary it to achieve what the judge concludes would be adequate support for the parties and that's the outcome of the case, and I thought it's an important thing for people to know just when they're planning their affairs and thinking about what they do and gifts they give and hopefully we don't wind up in a reported court decision at the end of the day and people can think about that when planning their affairs if they have a particular wish for an outcome.
- 21:41Robert Buffam: Okay, well, listen.
- 21:42Robert Buffam: Thank you, Michael.
- 21:42Robert Buffam: That is a fascinating case and one that will affect all families that have two children of different genders.
- 21:48Robert Buffam: In any event, Thank you for sharing your time with us.