Latest / My Playful Wife — A Tender Literary Love Story / My Playful Wife — Season 1, Episode 63: A Face

Transcript

My Playful Wife — Season 1, Episode 63: A Face · My Playful Wife — A Tender Literary Love Story

0:00
My playful wife. Not this one. This one gets
0:06
chosen. And I understood that for Celonie there
0:09
was, already, no longer a decision to be made.
0:13
She had looked at the face, and the looking had
0:16
done in her instantly what it would take me longer
0:18
and more. The call came on an unremarkable Wednesday
0:25
in the middle of the afternoon while I was failing
0:28
to concentrate on the accounts and the woman
0:30
from the agency said there was a child she thought
0:33
we should see and that she would send the file.
0:36
And just like that... After all the weeks of
0:39
waiting for an abstraction, the abstraction acquired
0:42
a face, an age, a name, and a history and stopped
0:46
being an idea we were waiting for and became
0:48
a particular person already alive in the world,
0:51
who had been alive the whole time we were waiting,
0:54
in a building across the city, being a child
0:56
while we were busy imagining one. The file arrived
1:01
that evening. It was thinner than I had expected.
1:04
A few printed pages, some official language,
1:07
a summary of a short life in the flattened vocabulary
1:11
of administration, and clipped to the inside
1:13
of it, when I opened it at the kitchen table
1:16
with Saloni standing very still behind my chair,
1:19
was a photograph. And I, who have spent six years
1:23
and six notebooks training myself to look at
1:26
exactly one human face, found myself looking,
1:29
for the first time, at the face of the child
1:32
who might become ours, and discovered that nothing
1:35
in all that training had prepared me for the
1:37
particular vertigo of it. I had thought, foolishly,
1:41
that being good at looking at faces would help
1:43
me here, that my long practice on Saloni's face
1:47
had made me some kind of expert. It had not.
1:50
A photograph gives you almost nothing. That was
1:53
the first thing the vertigo taught me. A face
1:56
you have lived beside for years is a thing you
1:59
read fluently, every small shift legible from
2:02
decades of context. A child's photograph is the
2:05
opposite, a single frozen instant of a stranger,
2:09
stripped of all the context that makes a face
2:12
mean anything, and you bring to it nothing but
2:15
your own projections and fears. I could read
2:18
Saloni's face like my mother tongue. This face
2:22
I could not read at all, and the not being able
2:25
to, after six years of fluency, was its own particular
2:28
helplessness. His name was Kabir. He was seven
2:35
years old, and the photograph was the ordinary
2:38
kind. the kind a school or an institution takes,
2:42
a plain head and shoulders against a neutral
2:44
wall, and in it he was not smiling. That was
2:49
the first thing I saw, that he was not smiling,
2:52
and that he was not smiling in a very particular
2:55
way that I recognized instantly and from the
2:58
inside because I had worn it myself at his age.
3:01
It was not sulking, and it was not sadness, exactly.
3:05
It was guardedness. It was the carefully neutral
3:08
face of a child who has learned that there is
3:10
no percentage in showing what you feel, who has
3:13
been looked at before by adults deciding whether
3:16
to want him, and has learned not to perform hope
3:19
for them, because hope performed and then disappointed
3:22
is worse than no hope at all. I knew that face.
3:26
I had made that face at a different table. In
3:29
a different decade, the unwatched second son
3:32
arranging his features into something that would
3:34
not need anything from anyone. And here it was
3:38
again, looking up at me out of a cheap photograph
3:41
clipped to a thin file, on a seven -year -old
3:44
who had arranged his small face into exactly
3:47
the armor I had once arranged mine into, for
3:50
exactly the same reason. The file told the rest
3:56
in its flat administrative way, and I will not
3:59
set down here the particulars of how a small
4:01
boy comes to be in a children's home, because
4:03
they were his to keep and not mine to broadcast,
4:06
and because the specifics, dignified and sad,
4:09
are less the point than the shape they made,
4:12
which was a shape I already knew. The shape was
4:16
this. Kabir had been, his whole short life, a
4:20
child no one had quite chosen. There had been
4:23
reasons, none of them his fault, that the adults
4:26
who should have kept him could not. And then
4:29
there had been the home. And then, the file noted
4:32
in its bloodless way, he had been viewed more
4:35
than once by prospective families and not taken
4:38
forward. Which is to say, in the human language
4:41
the file declined to use, that he had been looked
4:43
at repeatedly by people deciding whether to want
4:47
him, and repeatedly not chosen. He was seven,
4:50
and he had already been passed over. He was getting,
4:54
the agency woman had said gently, to the age
4:57
where it becomes harder. People want babies,
5:00
blank slates, and a boy of seven with a guarded
5:04
face and a thin sad file is not what most people
5:07
picture when they picture a child. He had been
5:10
unwanted not once, but as a recurring condition.
5:14
He had learned. At seven, what I had taken until
5:18
fifty to begin unlearning, that the beam of attention
5:21
was something that passed over him on its way
5:24
to someone more deserving, and that the safest
5:27
thing was to stop expecting it to stop. There
5:30
is a cruelty in the system that means well, one
5:33
I had not understood until I held its paperwork.
5:36
Every viewing that came to nothing, every family
5:39
that looked and declined, was logged in that
5:41
file as a neutral event, a fact of process. And
5:45
each one, I understood, had been for Kabir an
5:48
entire small apocalypse, a door opening and closing,
5:52
a hope he was surely told not to form and surely
5:55
formed anyway, quietly extinguished. The file
5:59
recorded the procedure and was blind to the boy's
6:02
experience of it. To the agency, it was a placement
6:06
that did not proceed. To a seven -year -old,
6:09
it was, they came, they looked at me, they did
6:12
not want me again. He had survived that more
6:15
than once. No wonder the small face had learned
6:19
to give nothing away. It had tried giving things
6:22
away and had them handed back. And I sat at the
6:28
kitchen table with his guarded little face in
6:30
my hand and felt the whole thing change under
6:33
me from an idea into a person and understood
6:37
for the first time what we had actually been
6:39
doing. Because waiting for a child had been,
6:43
I saw now, safe, in a way I had not admitted.
6:47
An abstraction asks nothing of you. You can want
6:51
it in the warm, adjust it to fit your hopes,
6:54
keep it conveniently faceless. But this was not
6:57
an abstraction. This was Kabir, seven, who did
7:01
not smile, who had been passed over. who was
7:04
at this moment alive in a building across the
7:07
city, not knowing that two people were sitting
7:09
at a kitchen table looking at his photograph.
7:12
And a face cannot be unseen. That was the vertigo,
7:16
that the moment I looked at the actual photograph,
7:19
the safe abstract child vanished forever and
7:22
was replaced by a particular boy I could now
7:25
never unknow, so that to say no... which we were
7:28
still entirely free to do, which the agency had
7:31
been careful to say we were free to do, would
7:34
no longer be declining an idea. It would be looking
7:37
at Kabir's guarded face, the face that had already
7:40
been looked at and set aside by others, and being
7:43
one more set of adults who looked at him and
7:46
chose, for our own reasons, not to take him forward.
7:50
One more passing over. I did not know if I had
7:53
it in me to do that, now that I had seen him.
7:56
And I understood that this was precisely why
7:59
they show you the face, because the face is the
8:02
end of the safe abstraction and the beginning
8:04
of the actual moral weight. I have come to believe
8:08
this is true far beyond the question of a child,
8:11
that it is one of the central mechanics of being
8:13
a person, that we keep ourselves comfortable
8:16
mostly by keeping things abstract and that all
8:19
real moral weight enters through the particular.
8:22
It is easy to have opinions about the poor, the
8:25
displaced, the unchosen, and the aggregate. The
8:28
aggregate has no face and asks nothing of you
8:31
but an opinion. It is another thing entirely
8:34
to sit at your own kitchen table with one thin
8:37
file and one guarded photograph and a single
8:40
name, Kabir 7. The particular is where the abstract
8:44
finally comes to collect its debt. Everyone is
8:48
generous toward the faceless many. The question
8:51
that actually measures a person is what they
8:53
do about the one face they have been shown, the
8:56
one they can no longer pretend not to have seen.
9:02
Saloni had not said a word. I turned to look
9:05
at her and found that she had gone very still,
9:08
one hand pressed to her mouth, and that she was
9:11
looking at the photograph over my shoulder with
9:14
an expression I had not seen on her before. Oh.
9:19
She said very quietly behind her hand, just that
9:24
at first. And then she took the photograph for
9:27
me gently and held it in both hands and looked
9:30
at it the way she looks at things she has decided
9:32
to love. And she said, look at him. He's decided
9:36
not to want anything. Seven years old and he's
9:40
already given up on being chosen. Look at his
9:43
little face deciding not to hope. And her voice
9:47
broke on it, and I realized that she was reading
9:50
the exact thing in the photograph that I was.
9:52
The guardedness, the armor, the small face arranged
9:56
against disappointment, but that where I was
9:59
reading my own childhood in it, she was reading
10:01
something simpler and more immediate. A child
10:05
in front of her who had stopped expecting to
10:07
be seen, which is the one thing in the world
10:09
she cannot bear. The thing her whole life is
10:13
organized against. No, she said, to the photograph,
10:18
to the boy who could not hear her, to the years
10:21
he had spent being passed over. Not this one.
10:24
This one gets chosen. And I understood that for
10:28
Saloni there was, already, no longer a decision
10:32
to be made. She had looked at the face, and the
10:35
looking had done in her instantly what it would
10:37
take me longer and more fearfully to arrive at.
10:40
She was already his. I have watched Celonie decide
10:44
to love several times now, across the years,
10:48
and it is always the same and always astonishing.
10:52
She does not weigh. She does not protect herself,
10:56
or audit the risk, or wait to see whether the
10:59
love will be returned or convenient or safe.
11:02
She simply sees a thing that needs looking at
11:05
and looks, and the looking is already the love,
11:08
with no gap between the two at all. I am built
11:11
the other way. I weigh everything. My love comes
11:15
slowly behind a long convoy of consideration
11:19
and fear. Watching her go instantly and wholly
11:23
toward a guarded boy in a photograph, I felt
11:26
the old familiar mix of awe and inadequacy that
11:30
she could do in a heartbeat. Freely, the thing
11:33
it had taken me six years and a near divorce
11:35
to learn to do it all, and even now could manage
11:39
only slowly, with effort, one careful face at
11:43
a time. That night I lay awake and turned over
11:49
the question the photograph had forced, which
11:51
was whether you can love a face before you know
11:53
the person behind it, and I think I arrived,
11:56
finally, at the series' own answer. the one the
11:59
whole of my six notebooks had been circling for
12:02
years. You cannot. That is the honest truth,
12:06
and I distrust people who claim otherwise, who
12:10
say they fell in love with a photograph. You
12:13
cannot love Kabir yet, because I do not know
12:15
Kabir. I know a name, an age, a guarded face,
12:19
a thin file. the actual boy, the real and surely
12:23
difficult and particular child, I have not met
12:27
and do not yet love, because love is not a thing
12:30
you feel at a photograph. But here is the other
12:33
half of it, the half the notebooks taught me,
12:35
love was never the spark you feel. Love is the
12:39
looking you commit to. And while I could not
12:42
love the boy in the photograph, I could do the
12:44
thing that is actually love's beginning, which
12:46
is to commit in advance of all feeling to the
12:49
looking to decide to go and meet him and learn
12:52
his actual face and keep learning it day after
12:55
day until the stranger in the photograph became,
12:58
through nothing more than sustained and faithful
13:01
attention, a person I knew and then a person
13:04
I loved. That is not loving a face. That is promising
13:08
to do the love. It is the only honest way anyone
13:12
ever begins, with a child or with anyone, and
13:15
it was, I realized, exactly what Saloni had done
13:18
across the kitchen in a single instant and what
13:21
would take me a little longer. Not to feel love
13:24
at a photograph, but to promise it. We told the
13:29
agency the next morning that we wanted to meet
13:32
him. It was not a yes to Kabir. It was not that
13:36
simple, and they were careful. Again, to slow
13:40
us down, to explain the steps, the introductions,
13:43
the gradual building of contact, the hundred
13:46
ways it could still not work for his sake as
13:49
much as ours. But it was a yes to the meeting,
13:52
which was a yes to letting the abstraction stay
13:54
dead and the particular boy stay real, a yes
13:58
to the irreversible business of having seen a
14:00
face and choosing to go toward it rather than
14:03
away. And when I had made the call, I went and
14:07
stood in the doorway of the room with the bed
14:09
in it, the bed Saloni had bought on faith, against
14:12
my caution, weeks ago, and I looked at it differently
14:16
now, because it was no longer a bed for an abstraction.
14:20
It was, possibly, a bed for Kabir, seven, who
14:24
did not smile, and the room rearranged itself
14:27
around that possibility into something almost
14:30
unbearably specific. A bed is an abstraction
14:34
until you can name the head that will lie on
14:36
it. We had bought it, weeks before, as an act
14:40
of faith aimed at no one in particular, a gesture
14:43
toward a hoped -for child with no face. Now it
14:48
had a candidate. Now, standing in the doorway,
14:51
I could not look at the small maid bed without
14:54
seeing a specific seven -year -old who did not
14:57
smile lying in it, his guarded face on the pillow
15:00
Saloni had chosen, in the room we had readied,
15:03
in the home of two people who had, at last, looked
15:08
at him. The image undid me a little standing
15:11
there. It was the first time the future had arrived
15:14
with a face attached, and a future with a face
15:17
is a far more dangerous and a far more real thing
15:21
than a future that is still only a hope. I wrote
15:27
it that night in the sixth notebook, his photograph
15:30
now propped against the lamp on the desk where
15:33
I could see it while I wrote. That an idea and
15:37
a face are not the same thing, and that the whole
15:40
distance between waiting and committing is the
15:42
distance between the two. For weeks we had waited
15:45
for an idea, a child -shaped space, safe precisely
15:49
because it had no face to reproach us. And then
15:53
a thin file had put a face into the space, and
15:56
the face had ended the safety, because you cannot
15:59
weigh a face the way you weigh an idea. A face
16:02
makes a claim an idea never can. A face, once
16:06
seen, converts every subsequent no from a decision
16:09
into a rejection. They show you the photograph,
16:12
I understood, exactly when they want to end your
16:15
abstraction and begin your responsibility. And
16:18
the awake response, the only one consistent with
16:21
six years of notebooks. was not to retreat back
16:24
into the safe idea, but to let the particular
16:26
boy stay particular, to keep looking at the actual
16:30
guarded face instead of the convenient blank,
16:32
and to go and meet the real child the photograph
16:35
could only point at. Saloni had done it in a
16:38
second. I would do it in my slower way. But we
16:42
would both do it because we had seen his face
16:44
now, and you cannot unsee a face, and a man who
16:48
has trained for six years to look does not get
16:50
to look away from the one face that most needs
16:52
looking at. Then the working line, the sixth
16:58
notebook open, the photograph against the lamp,
17:02
a seven -year -old's guarded eyes watching me
17:05
write. Beware how safe an abstraction is and
17:09
how much a face will ask of you. It is easy to
17:12
want a child, a cause, a stranger in the abstract.
17:16
The abstraction is faceless and therefore weightless,
17:19
and you can hold it in the warm without cost.
17:22
But sooner or later, if you are serious, someone
17:25
will show you a face, a real and particular one,
17:29
and the face will end the abstraction and begin
17:32
the responsibility. Because a face cannot be
17:35
weighed and set down the way an idea can, a face,
17:38
once truly seen, makes every turning away a rejection
17:42
of someone and not merely a declining of something.
17:46
Do not flee back into the safe idea when the
17:49
face arrives. Let the face stay particular. Go
17:52
toward it. You cannot love a stranger's face
17:56
on sight. Love is not the spark but the looking
17:59
you commit to, but you can promise the looking
18:02
and the promise. made before all feeling, is
18:05
where every real love that ever lasted actually
18:08
began. I kept the pen and left his photograph
18:13
propped against the lamp, because I did not want
18:16
to put it back in the file, because putting it
18:18
back in the file felt like putting him back in
18:21
the dark, and I went to bed beside Celonie, who
18:24
was already asleep, who had been as since the
18:27
first instant she saw the guarded little face
18:29
deciding not to hope. I was not yet his, not
18:33
the way she was. I am slower at these things.
18:36
I would have to meet him and learn him and do
18:40
the long looking before the feeling came. But
18:43
I had promised the looking. We were going to
18:45
meet him. And somewhere across the city, a seven
18:48
-year -old who had been passed over slept in
18:50
a building not knowing that tonight, for the
18:53
first time in his short, unchosen life. Two people
18:56
had looked at his face and decided not to look
18:59
away. To be continued in episode 64, The Meeting.
19:16
Playful Wife. If this story is staying with you,
19:20
the next episode is already waiting. Subscribe
19:23
so you don't miss it. The complete book is on
19:26
Amazon and early episodes plus bonus chapters
19:29
are on my Patreon. Links are in the description.
19:33
I'm Mia. Thank you for listening.