Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Nuts and Bolts of Arbitration: Mastering Mediation
Transcript
- 0:03Hello everyone, and welcome to today's program,
- 0:07Nuts and Bolts of Arbitration, Mastering Mediation.
- 0:11I am Alla Poli Castro, Director of Education
- 0:14and Professional Development here at Beverly
- 0:16Hills Bar Association. And today it's my pleasure
- 0:18to introduce our speakers, Tracy Frisch and Marcus
- 0:22Quintanilla. Tracy is the division vice president
- 0:26of mediation for the American Arbitration Association
- 0:29and the executive director of the AAA and ICDR
- 0:33foundation. With more than 17 years at AAA, she
- 0:36leads initiatives to expand access to mediation
- 0:39and advance innovative dispute resolution practices
- 0:42globally. Tracy also teaches commercial arbitration
- 0:45laws as an adjunct professor at Pace University
- 0:48Law School and has extensive experience as a
- 0:51mediator, educator, and speaker on ADR topics
- 0:54across New York's courts and community mediation
- 0:56programs. Marcus is an international arbitrator,
- 1:01mediator, and counsel with more than two decades
- 1:03of experience resolving complex commercial, energy,
- 1:07technology, and cross -border disputes. A fellow
- 1:10of the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators, he
- 1:12has served as neutral in cases under major arbitral
- 1:16institutions, including AAA, ICDR, SIAC, and
- 1:21SCIA. Council in High -Stakes International Arbitrations
- 1:26Across the Americas, Europe, and Asia. He also
- 1:29teaches international arbitration and mediation
- 1:31at the University of California Davis School
- 1:34of Law. We can't wait to hear what they have
- 1:36to share with us today, so I'm going to turn
- 1:37it over to them. Great. Thank you so much. Thank
- 1:41you to the Bar Association for having us. And
- 1:44Marcus, thank you for joining me in this conversation
- 1:46about mediation. Oh, gosh. Yeah, it's really
- 1:49my pleasure. And by the way, I do want to say
- 1:52all of that. You know, in addition to all those
- 1:55other hats that I wear with all those initials
- 1:57that you had to rattle off, I'm on the ADR committee
- 2:01of the California State Bar or the California
- 2:05Lawyers Association. And we actually use the
- 2:08Beverly Hills Bar Association as one of our role
- 2:12models on putting together CLE programs. So you
- 2:17have a very tight knit group and you just do
- 2:19great programming. So I was really honored to
- 2:21get the chance to join. Thank you so much, Marcus.
- 2:25Thank you. So, Marcus, I'm going to start the
- 2:30conversation today by really setting the stage.
- 2:34And you've practiced as a big firm lawyer, and
- 2:37now you serve as a mediator across various types
- 2:40of matters. How has that transition shaped the
- 2:44way that you think about mediation as a tool
- 2:47for resolving disputes? Yeah, it's a great question
- 2:52Tracy and you know a lot i hear it sometimes
- 2:54people talk like i'm a. Recovering big law partner
- 2:59or whatever i don't really view it that way i
- 3:02loved my time as a partner in big law and i still
- 3:07like my work doing council work now which i still
- 3:10do a little bit in addition to my work is a neutral
- 3:13and i think the two really in force each other.
- 3:18I mean, certainly it's not this really wasn't
- 3:20your question, but being an arbitrator and being
- 3:24a mediator definitely, I think, makes me more
- 3:27effective as an advocate. And I think being in
- 3:30the advocacy seat is super valuable to knowing
- 3:36how to really be successful in those different
- 3:42formats. So here's. What I would say I think
- 3:46my experience in advocacy which is quite recent
- 3:50and ongoing. It gives me a really concrete sense
- 3:55of what lawyers want to get out of this right
- 3:59for their clients and by extension what the clients
- 4:02themselves want right and that and for me. It's
- 4:06really it can kind of be reduced to two things
- 4:09they want the best deal possible. If there's
- 4:14gonna be a deal at all, they just want a mediator
- 4:18who's gonna help them get the best deal possible.
- 4:23And secondly, they want, if a deal can't happen,
- 4:30they really want this whole process of mediation
- 4:33to prepare them for battle, right? They wanna
- 4:37get some value out of it. So if it can't be a
- 4:40settlement on terms that they like, They at least
- 4:44want to get sort of unofficial discovery out
- 4:48of the process or get some assessment that helps
- 4:51them be more effective in the remainder of the
- 4:54case. And so those are the two things that I
- 4:59kind of built into my approach as a mediator.
- 5:03I want to deliver one or the other of those things
- 5:08so that the parties and their lawyers are getting
- 5:11real value for it. Yeah, I think that makes a
- 5:14lot of sense and I think Coming from an advocate's
- 5:18perspective You understand like you said look
- 5:22what what the advocates are maybe looking to
- 5:24get out of mediation right for for their clients
- 5:27I hear a lot of times folks who are interested
- 5:30in transitioning from being an advocate to being
- 5:33a mediator. Oh I can be a mediator. I've sat
- 5:36as an advocate, you know in hundreds and hundreds
- 5:38of cases and I always try to press upon them
- 5:40that Yes, and that gives you a wonderful perspective,
- 5:43but you need to have experience sitting in the
- 5:46mediator seat before I think you can really understand
- 5:49what it takes and what's involved in being a
- 5:52mediator. I always encourage folks who are looking
- 5:56to do this transition to get cases under their
- 5:59belt, whether it's through court -connected cases
- 6:02or whatever it is. to have that experience sitting
- 6:05in the mediator seat, because I think it feels
- 6:07very different from that perspective than it
- 6:10does from the advocate's point of view. For sure.
- 6:13And you know what I would add to that is because
- 6:17my work as an advocate is quite recent and ongoing,
- 6:23I also have a really good sense of what lawyers
- 6:26are doing wrong and what their mindset is That
- 6:34it shouldn't be okay, and it's that that's not
- 6:37me condemning them. That's me reflecting back
- 6:39on past Marcus right before I'd actually sat
- 6:44in this role either as an arbitrator or as a
- 6:46mediator. I think the. You know if you're let's
- 6:52face it most of us are litigators who are involved
- 6:55in this process of dispute resolution including
- 6:58alternative dispute resolution and. we are not
- 7:04fundamentally deal lawyers, most of us, right?
- 7:07If we were, we'd be business people or we'd be
- 7:10at least corporate lawyers or something, right?
- 7:13So most of us are just much more comfortable
- 7:17fighting than we are negotiating. And I speak
- 7:21even for myself in my role really as a trial
- 7:26lawyer and an arbitration counsel, there is a
- 7:31tendency To just think of the mediation as an
- 7:37another parallel arena of battle Okay, and in
- 7:44some ways that is true and I will I think as
- 7:46our conversation develops We'll get around to
- 7:49that in some ways. It's true. But in some ways
- 7:51it is profoundly not true And I think you'll
- 7:55have some more questions for me down the road
- 7:57where we'll get into that but it as a mediator
- 8:00it's helpful for me to know that the lawyers
- 8:04that I'm working with, at least at the very beginning
- 8:06of our relationship, are not necessarily thinking
- 8:10about this process the way that they should.
- 8:14And therefore, and that's no dig on them, that's
- 8:16just kind of the beast, you know, that's in human
- 8:19nature. So that is kind of my first signal that
- 8:26I need to Talk with them and work with them a
- 8:30lot in the background before we're even ready
- 8:33to make the mediation happen Yeah, and from from
- 8:39your vantage point would you do you think mediation
- 8:43is underutilized and If so What what how could
- 8:50it add real value? So what do you think mediation
- 8:53like why does remain underutilized if you think
- 8:55so? in some cases where it could add real value.
- 8:59Yeah, I think it is underutilized. Although,
- 9:04you know, if you think about it, most cases settle,
- 9:08right? I mean, if cases are being tried, Like,
- 9:13what is it? I think you probably, as an institutional
- 9:16representative, have stats right at your fingertips,
- 9:19but it's like 90 % of cases that get filed get
- 9:22settled. Is that right? Something like that?
- 9:24Yeah, absolutely. I would say even probably less
- 9:25than 1 % actually go to trial. Right. And even
- 9:29then, if you're in that 1%, you're going to be
- 9:32waiting for a very long time to get your day
- 9:33in court. How what percentage of those settlements
- 9:40are preceded by mediation? I don't really know.
- 9:43I don't know if you have a statistical view into
- 9:47that Do you have a statistical view into that?
- 9:49I don't I don't have a statistical view But I
- 9:51think that you know oftentimes and it's also
- 9:54when in the process, you know And I think oftentimes
- 9:56the settlement comes eve of trial versus the
- 9:59value add by having an earlier conversation and
- 10:03an earlier really engaged mediation. Exactly.
- 10:08So actually, that's exactly where I was going
- 10:10to go. And for those of you in our viewing audience,
- 10:13Tracy and I didn't really work this out in advance.
- 10:15But that's a perfect segue because as I see it,
- 10:19you're right. A lot of these, the vast majority
- 10:22of the cases are going to settle. But a lot of
- 10:24times, They're going to settle at very close
- 10:28to the last minute after just a huge expenditure
- 10:31has happened and maybe someone blinks or someone,
- 10:36you know, it's only you know, nothing focuses
- 10:38the mind quite like a hanging right? And so when
- 10:42you're right at that moment and then you have
- 10:43all the evidence in front of you. Boom, the settlement
- 10:47happens, but if a good mediator had been brought
- 10:53in. much earlier in the process, I think a lot
- 10:58of those cases that are gonna settle anyway could
- 11:01have settled a lot sooner, and could have settled
- 11:04without as much expense, and candidly, the sort
- 11:08of human distraction and heartache that goes
- 11:11in with seeing a case all the way through, okay?
- 11:16So why do I think mediation is underused? For
- 11:22me, I think there are a few factors. One is kind
- 11:27of what I said before. The people who are involved
- 11:31in the process are, the lawyers at least, are
- 11:35usually litigators, right? And litigators, very
- 11:39candidly, we profit by fighting. We don't profit
- 11:43by settling quickly, all right? So that doesn't
- 11:47mean that lawyers are Misrepresenting their clients
- 11:51or or engaging in bad faith or turning or anything
- 11:55like that, but All of us the judgments that we
- 12:00make are influenced subconsciously by our Motivations
- 12:05and our economic rewards, right? That's anyone
- 12:08who would deny that I think is just not being
- 12:10truthful So that's in the background and then
- 12:14when you add to it That there's just not a total
- 12:18comfort level with engaging in negotiations,
- 12:23as opposed to just, you know, running through
- 12:26the steps of litigation and fighting, fighting,
- 12:29fighting at each of the points. That sort of
- 12:33lack of comfort also means that the lawyers are
- 12:37not necessarily recommending mediation, at least
- 12:41not recommending it early in the process. And
- 12:45then there's a third element, which I think is
- 12:47very important and that we need to explore in
- 12:49more depth as our conversation goes on. And that
- 12:53is, you know, it is a commonplace that you don't
- 12:56want to be the one to show weakness, right? You
- 12:59don't want to be the first one to say, hey, should
- 13:01we mediate this? Because A, are you going to
- 13:04lose credibility with your client? And B, are
- 13:08you going to show weakness to the other side,
- 13:11which can only hurt your leverage? right? If
- 13:14they perceive you as being weak, it's only going
- 13:17to strengthen their, the, harden their negotiation
- 13:20position, right? So I think all of those thoughts
- 13:23are going on. And net -net that results in mediation
- 13:29not being activated as soon as in the process
- 13:32as it really could. And if those issues were
- 13:37addressed and the mediation process started earlier,
- 13:40I think it could produce measurable, economically
- 13:43measurable benefits for other parties. Yeah,
- 13:47and I wonder as you think about a case, particularly
- 13:51a litigated case, are there signals that you
- 13:58see in a case, legal, business, human, that tell
- 14:03you that mediation might be especially effective?
- 14:07Yeah, you know, that question sort of goes more
- 14:11to the perspective of counsel than it does for
- 14:17the mediator, right? Because as a mediator, I'm
- 14:20just living my life waiting for someone to call
- 14:22me and say, hey, we want you to mediate. So once
- 14:25they call me, they've already decided that. Now,
- 14:28however, if I put myself wearing my hat as attorney
- 14:33for the parties, when do I think mediation makes
- 14:37sense? Well, personally, I think mediation makes
- 14:46sense as soon as you have enough information
- 14:53about your case and about the other side's case
- 14:56to meaningfully begin making cost -benefit analysis
- 15:03of your own case behind the scenes. Okay, and
- 15:11Again, I think although you know clients are
- 15:15becoming More and more demanding in my experience
- 15:19and more and more sophisticated in a lot of ways.
- 15:22I think gone are the days when You have clients
- 15:27even clients with pretty big checkbooks that
- 15:29just say Just go do scorched earth and come back
- 15:33to us a few million dollars later and we'll check
- 15:35in right there. They're being very careful with
- 15:39their litigation spins. So, nevertheless, we
- 15:50really have to make a special effort from the
- 15:53very beginning of the case to start thinking
- 15:55about it, not just as what's our budget as lawyers
- 16:00to bring this case to point A, B, C, and then
- 16:04after trial, right? But thinking about it, always
- 16:07in terms of what is the value proposition for
- 16:10the client? And what is their cost benefit analysis
- 16:15for this case? And although this is not a little
- 16:21seminar on how to be a good lawyer for your client
- 16:24exactly, that's just. A really important piece
- 16:29of advice I would give, especially to our younger
- 16:31practitioners who are just kind of coming up
- 16:34into the practice. It's very natural that you're
- 16:37just focused on, you know, be the best lawyer
- 16:40I can possibly be. Learn how to take the best
- 16:43deposition I can possibly take right motions,
- 16:46etc, etc, but. All of us at the from as early
- 16:51as possible in our practice and in our involvement
- 16:54in a case. So start thinking about. What's the
- 16:57business proposition for the client and what's
- 17:00the value of this for them? And are they gonna
- 17:03spend more than this case really should be worth,
- 17:06right? So once you have enough information to
- 17:11be able to say, here's how much I think we're
- 17:13gonna spend on this case. And I have some sense
- 17:18of what our likelihood of success might be based
- 17:22on. the discovery that's been developed thus
- 17:26far, and you're not just purely pulling stuff
- 17:30out of the air, then I think it's already time
- 17:33to start talking about mediation. And to that
- 17:39end, I don't know, this is, I may be stepping
- 17:41over a question that you're gonna get to later,
- 17:43but in my own practice, I think it's important
- 17:49to start getting clients ready for that concept
- 17:55of mediation and kind of a structured settlement
- 17:58process very early, i .e. at the beginning of
- 18:03your relationship with them. Let me just pause
- 18:06there because I know I've been rambling on for
- 18:08a long time here and you might have follow up.
- 18:10Yeah, no, this is perfect because I really just
- 18:12next wanted to segue into how do you advise lawyers
- 18:16to raise the idea of mediation, you know, not
- 18:19only with their own clients but also with opposing
- 18:22counsel and maybe a skeptical client who says,
- 18:25you know what, you think we're going to lose?
- 18:26Why would you suggest mediation? Right. Right.
- 18:28And that's, you know, as I kind of hinted at
- 18:31earlier, that's one of counsel's biggest concerns,
- 18:35right? That that two -pronged concern of is my
- 18:38own client going to think I'm chickening out?
- 18:41No one wants to give that message. And is the
- 18:44other side going to think, ah, you know, we now
- 18:47smell blood because the other side wants to settle?
- 18:51So how to overcome those things. That's a very,
- 18:56you know, let's take them one at a time. And
- 18:58by the way, I really, I kind of want to get your
- 19:02perspective on this because I think you have
- 19:04been mediating for a very long time and quite
- 19:07successfully. And so you can give me some tips
- 19:10right here on this call, right? Which I'll incorporate
- 19:12into my practice. But I think as a lawyer for
- 19:17the, on the client side, What I like to do is
- 19:23kind of use that old Klauschwitz comment, right?
- 19:29That war is diplomacy by other means, right?
- 19:34It's never going and blowing up cities and people
- 19:37and so forth, tragic, is never an end in itself.
- 19:40It's always a tool to political objectives. Well,
- 19:44similarly, A lawsuit is never an end in itself,
- 19:49right? It is a tool in achieving usually, and
- 19:53when we're dealing with civil litigation, business
- 19:56objectives. And so I think it's very important
- 20:03to sit down with the client at the very beginning
- 20:06of the case, whether it's plaintiff or defendant,
- 20:09and put that fact out on the table. And almost
- 20:16have built into their mind that the idea of a
- 20:22settlement opportunity, whether it's mediation
- 20:25or whether it's something else, is kind of an
- 20:29intrinsic part of the battle plan. It's not just
- 20:34something, it's not like your whole focus is
- 20:37on trial. And then somewhere along the way, as
- 20:40everyone gets war weary, and the client starts
- 20:43looking at their bills, then we raise the issue
- 20:46of mediation. No. From the very, very beginning,
- 20:49we say, look, this is all that's gonna happen
- 20:50in a case. Discovery's gonna happen here, then
- 20:53there's gonna be motion practice, and if we get
- 20:56through that, then there's gonna be this trial
- 20:58here. But we think it's really important to understand
- 21:01that most cases do settle. This case is probably
- 21:04gonna be one of them. So we actually... Want
- 21:08to think about at what time in the process might
- 21:12we want? to go for mediation Okay And we can
- 21:20talk about why mediation as opposed to just pick
- 21:22up the phone and call opposing counsel and try
- 21:24to negotiate Okay, that's to me. That's an important
- 21:28fork in the road But in a way having mediation
- 21:34as a special event that is presided over by a
- 21:39third party, makes it, I think, psychologically
- 21:43kind of a good little self -standing landmark
- 21:48in the process of each litigation. So I like
- 21:53to put it out there as something we're thinking
- 21:55of from the very beginning. And therefore, when
- 21:58I raise it, my client's not like, oh, wow, you're
- 22:01chickening out. No, this was part of the battle
- 22:04plan from the beginning. Now, what about how
- 22:12you raise it with the other side without losing
- 22:16credibility or et cetera? You know, I'm really
- 22:22interested in your take on this, but I'll just
- 22:25give you my personal view. There are all kinds
- 22:29of lawyers in this world, okay? And there are
- 22:32all kinds of different ways of being highly affected.
- 22:35as a lawyer in this world. And some people are
- 22:39highly effective by just being workaholic, extremist,
- 22:48mean, scorched earth, backbiting lawyers. I teach
- 22:55at law school and I like to encourage them to
- 22:58be really upstanding, noble lawyers. I cannot
- 23:03lie to them and say that bad behavior doesn't
- 23:06sometimes pay. Sometimes it does pay. But life
- 23:10is too short in my view. So that's just not my
- 23:13approach. And I've been fortunate enough in my
- 23:17own practice to, you know, I can count many friends
- 23:21that I have acquired over the years who started
- 23:24off as opposing counsel. Okay. So let me put
- 23:28it this way. This does not mean you have to be
- 23:31chummy with your opposing counsel. and it certainly
- 23:36doesn't mean that you shouldn't really bite hard,
- 23:40okay? But I think there is something to be said
- 23:43for picking up the phone early in a case and
- 23:48just introducing yourself in a way that is not
- 23:52through a firmly written letter, right? But rather,
- 23:56you know, here I am, and, you know, I bet we're
- 23:58gonna have a lot of fights over the next year
- 24:00or two, but... You know, I'm going to do my best
- 24:06to just be as nothing personal about it as possible
- 24:11and to be as straight a shooter about it as possible.
- 24:14And you know, you may not like what I tell you,
- 24:17but I'm going to do what I say and say what I
- 24:20mean. And I hope as this process develops, you
- 24:24know, we can. Work in a business like way because
- 24:29I'm certainly going to do that right a kind of
- 24:31icebreaker conversation like that sometimes It
- 24:36gets totally rebuffed. Okay. All right. So what
- 24:39do you have? What have you lost not much, right?
- 24:42Sometimes it begins a dialogue that allows you
- 24:46To plant the idea of mediation really early in
- 24:49the process like, you know, I think we're hey
- 24:52I don't think we're anywhere near being able
- 24:55to mediate this case, because I don't know what
- 24:57kind of ammo you have. But we will be finding
- 25:00out. And when that happens, we'll both know what
- 25:04our reasonable negotiating positions are. And
- 25:07maybe we could think about mediation then. What
- 25:10do you think about that? And so I've planted
- 25:14the seed that I don't even want to mediate now,
- 25:18but I'm an economically rational human. who might
- 25:22want to mediate in the future. So I think that
- 25:25lessens the edge of broaching the subject of
- 25:31mediation at a later date. But what do you think,
- 25:35Tracy? I also view mediation not necessarily,
- 25:39and I know we've talked about this, you do too,
- 25:41as sort of like a one -day event, right? So it's
- 25:44a process, and it can be part of the process
- 25:47that goes along with the preparing the discovery
- 25:50and, you know, doing all the things that you
- 25:52would do as if you were going to, you know, full
- 25:53blown go to trial. So I think also framing it
- 25:56both to your client and to opposing party of
- 25:59like, do you want to get a mediator on board,
- 26:01you know, to sort of start discussion, see where
- 26:03it goes, you know, maybe we have some discovery
- 26:06disputes, maybe we could just get those settled,
- 26:08you know, sort of, you know, kind of take it
- 26:10in pieces and not feel the pressure of like,
- 26:13this is like all or nothing. We're either gonna
- 26:15settle this, you know, at the all -end -all mediation
- 26:19session or that's forever lost on us. But, you
- 26:22know, really seeing it as part of the process
- 26:25and something that can kind of go along with
- 26:27as you're doing other things, you know, to litigate
- 26:32your case. I also, from the AAA's perspective,
- 26:35we... push very hard on having a good ADR clause.
- 26:39So to all those transactional attorneys out there,
- 26:42if you might have this wonderful clause about
- 26:45arbitration, but I very much encourage you to
- 26:48have a clause of have mediation as a condition
- 26:51precedent to arbitration or litigation. And in
- 26:54that case, you're following what the contract
- 26:56says. No one's losing faith. The contract says,
- 27:00you gotta try mediation. Okay. Correct. And you
- 27:04know what? So Tracy, as was indicated earlier
- 27:08in our meeting today, I teach international arbitration
- 27:12at UC Davis Law School, and I also teach international
- 27:15mediation and negotiation. And it just so happens
- 27:19that yesterday I was teaching about arbitration
- 27:23clauses and what we called tiered dispute resolution
- 27:28clauses, which is this idea of having some kind
- 27:32of condition precedent to arbitration. Now, since
- 27:38we're giving advice on how to be a corporate
- 27:40lawyer in this program, okay? If you do that
- 27:45in your arbitration clause, it can be a very
- 27:47good thing, but be careful as how you structure
- 27:51it so that it can't be used for gamesmanship
- 27:54when you get to the time of a dispute, right?
- 27:57What I teach my students is, You know, there
- 28:01needs to be a very clear triggering event. There
- 28:03needs to be a very clear period of time for the
- 28:06mediation to happen in. And then if for whatever
- 28:10reason it doesn't resolve the case, then the
- 28:16parties get to arbitrate. So you don't leave
- 28:18it kind of murky and open -ended so that one
- 28:22party can delay the process by saying, we haven't
- 28:24mediated enough, right? So that's one thing I
- 28:28would counsel. The other thing is the problem
- 28:32with those, I actually do like arbitration clauses
- 28:38that build in a mediation requirement, or at
- 28:44least a soft requirement. But I do think that
- 28:49the traditional model where the mediation is
- 28:52put as a condition precedent to even beginning
- 28:56the arbitration, say, or beginning the lawsuit,
- 29:00so you could have it that way as well, is not
- 29:04optimal, okay? And it's because right at the
- 29:09beginning of the dispute, most parties, or at
- 29:11least most outside lawyers, right, don't think
- 29:14they have enough information to make the mediation
- 29:17meaningful. So you'll go through the the motions,
- 29:22if you will, of mediating, but you're not really
- 29:25ready to resolve the case. And so you're still
- 29:28gonna go through another half a year or a year
- 29:31of disputes before there's maybe the real mediation,
- 29:34you know? So I haven't thought this through and
- 29:39viewing public, I have not cleared this with
- 29:42Tracy, all right? So, but I think we need some
- 29:45thought leadership on how we can... further improve
- 29:50our ARB clauses that maybe say something like,
- 29:54at some time prior to the arbitration, or the
- 30:00merits hearing, the parties shall schedule a
- 30:05mediation. Now, what I like about a clause like
- 30:09that, which I'll be honest with you, I've never
- 30:11seen a clause like that. It allows the parties
- 30:16to dispense with the premature mediation, but
- 30:21it gives them a really good anchor where neither
- 30:26of them loses face to have the arbitrator schedule
- 30:32in like a pause in the procedural timetable to
- 30:37conduct the mediation. Yeah, and we also have
- 30:41clauses that I have seen that say the mediation
- 30:44shall happen concurrently, you know, with the
- 30:48arbitration, sort of have it as a, like I was
- 30:50saying before, like a tag along a process that's
- 30:52happening at the same time as you are moving
- 30:54forward, you know, with whatever other dispute
- 30:57resolution process you're involved in. So yeah,
- 31:00I could absolutely see that. And the good thing
- 31:03about this is, remember, I'm thinking of it from
- 31:06the arbitration, vantage point, but this could
- 31:10also apply if you're in a litigation, right?
- 31:14It's all consensual. It's by contract, right?
- 31:17So if, let's just suppose we're in an arbitration,
- 31:21and we're six months into this arbitration, and
- 31:24now we had in our calendar, our procedural timetable,
- 31:29that the parties are gonna mediate, or this is
- 31:32their 30 -day period in which they're supposed
- 31:34to mediate. If the parties have decided Look,
- 31:37we're just at total loggerheads. We hate each
- 31:41other. We're never going to settle. We have a
- 31:43totally different assessment of the evidence.
- 31:45Fine. You can just agree mutually that you're
- 31:50going to waive the mediation. Okay, fine. You
- 31:52haven't lost anything, right? But having it there
- 31:56is really good because it gives both sides the
- 32:00ability to say, look, we got to do this. This
- 32:02is what we agreed to as part of our program.
- 32:06and then it frees them up to not feel like they're
- 32:10showing weakness. Yeah, that's great. So let's
- 32:13fast forward, right? Everyone's agreed to attempt
- 32:15mediation. I think an important, probably the
- 32:21most important part of mediation is preparation.
- 32:25So what would you say good preparation looks
- 32:29like? from your perspective, like not the mediator's
- 32:32preparation, but the client, the attorney with
- 32:34their client. What does their preparation, good
- 32:36preparation look like for a mediation? Right,
- 32:39well, okay, so it's interesting. We should talk
- 32:42about mediator preparation as well as party and
- 32:46advocate preparation, because they go together,
- 32:48right? The first thing you have to do is pick
- 32:51the right mediator. It's going to run the thing
- 32:55the way that really makes sense. Now, But either
- 33:03way, in a moment, I'd like to talk about two
- 33:05different approaches to running the mediation.
- 33:09But whichever way is picked, for me, the key
- 33:15thing is you should try and not, it's almost
- 33:21inevitable that you put a trial lawyer in any
- 33:24setting and he thinks it's a trial. Okay, that's
- 33:27it. It's very hard to resist treating your mediation
- 33:34statement as a little trial brief and just showing
- 33:38how strong your case is because the perception
- 33:44is, look, I've got to convince the mediator.
- 33:49Everybody knows the mediator's gonna beat on
- 33:51them and he's gonna beat on the other side. That's
- 33:53what mediators are supposed to do. So we wanna
- 33:56give the mediator as much ammo to beat on the
- 33:59other side as possible. And then we'll usually
- 34:02conclude with some little perfunctory paragraph
- 34:05that says, but of course we're willing to settle
- 34:08on reasonable terms, but terms that must take
- 34:10account of all of this great argumentation that
- 34:13I've just given you for 10 pages. I don't think
- 34:17that's a super useful exercise, okay? So far
- 34:23more important, and now how you exactly package
- 34:25it into your mediation statement, part of that
- 34:27depends on how, if the mediation statements are
- 34:30gonna be confidential versus whether they're
- 34:32gonna be exchanged, et cetera, et cetera. But
- 34:36I think the fundamental thought process has got
- 34:40to be developing a settlement analysis with your
- 34:44client, okay? And here's what I mean by that.
- 34:50And it sort of goes back to the days when I first
- 34:53started in practice, like the first three or
- 34:56four years of practice as a young lawyer, I was
- 35:00in charge of defending large insurance companies
- 35:06who were being sued for bad faith denial of coverage.
- 35:12Which I've got to tell you, that's a great place
- 35:13to cut your teeth as a lawyer. Because if you
- 35:16can defend an insurance company in a jury trial,
- 35:19you can defend anybody. But the great thing about
- 35:24insurance clients, insurance company clients,
- 35:27is they're in the business of being sued. So
- 35:29they are not strangers to the courthouse. And
- 35:34they always made us do these memos that were
- 35:39Here are the facts of the case and here's the
- 35:42key law of the case and here's what our exposure
- 35:46is in principle, but here's what our percentage
- 35:49of winning looks like. So you discount it and
- 35:53then here's how much it's going to take to act
- 35:55the budget to actually get us to trial, right?
- 35:58So it. As a young lawyer, I thought these percentages
- 36:02are kind of like BS. We're just like pulling
- 36:06them out of our minds. 65 % chance of prevailing
- 36:10on this motion, right? Yes, that's true. They
- 36:14are a little bit artificial, but it's a good
- 36:17exercise to already get you and the client thinking
- 36:22in an economically rational way, to come up with
- 36:27actual numbers. This is what we think at this
- 36:31moment in time would be a rational settlement
- 36:34range. I think that's the exercise you should
- 36:39do with your clients. And depending on how your
- 36:44mediator runs the mediation, that may be actually
- 36:48also what you want to share with the mediator.
- 36:50Maybe you pad it, but you know it's going to
- 36:53be irresistible for you to, you know, overstate
- 36:56your chances of success to the mediator. That's
- 36:59fine. He or she will whittle you down, right?
- 37:02But the point is. Putting that as your framework
- 37:07from the get go. I think is super useful. It's
- 37:11useful for you. It's useful for your client and
- 37:14it's useful for the mediator. Much more so than
- 37:18just this brief about how great your case is.
- 37:21And the other side has another brief that says
- 37:23how great their case is. Yeah, no, I think that
- 37:26that's a great point. And doing that sort of
- 37:28risk adjusted analysis, you know, I think is
- 37:32crucial, you know, in any case, and particularly
- 37:34when you're entering into mediation. And like
- 37:37you said, so you can talk about it with your
- 37:39client in a rational sort of objective way and
- 37:44look at the economics of of the case. So I think
- 37:48that that's very good advice. What would you
- 37:51say, and maybe you feel like you've already done
- 37:53this, but what are some other common mistakes
- 37:56that lawyers might make when preparing clients
- 37:59for mediation? So other than just the brief and
- 38:02sort of being, you know, sort of just putting
- 38:03your litigation brief into a mediation brief,
- 38:06what are other sort of common mistakes that they
- 38:09could be avoided? Well, sort of I think you could
- 38:15do two things that I frequently see that are
- 38:18done wrong, right? One is you're treating your
- 38:22client like you're preparing them for a deposition,
- 38:24or you're preparing them for being on the witness
- 38:27stand. Because again, that's just transposing
- 38:33into the mediation setting really a different
- 38:38animal, which is trial, okay? So that's not helpful.
- 38:45Instead, you really want, and that's why I said
- 38:47the settlement analysis is important, you want
- 38:50to get their buy -in to how you've presented
- 38:54your settlement analysis to the mediator. It
- 38:58is still important that they be consistent with
- 39:02you, right? And so your telling of the story
- 39:06and your assessment, you called it a discounted
- 39:10risk. assessment, you got to have their buy -in
- 39:15with that, right? And so then related to that
- 39:20point is how do you prepare? I think you do have
- 39:23to have a discussion about what the mediation
- 39:26is going to look like. You need to talk with
- 39:28the client about what things the client is going
- 39:31to say versus what you're going to say. I generally
- 39:38think it is best for clients not to just go off
- 39:41script and start interfacing directly with the
- 39:46mediator, unless we have really mapped that all
- 39:50out in advance. Usually a mediator will not want
- 39:57to step on counsel's toes, right? After all,
- 40:01counsel are the ones who. recommend mediators
- 40:04for the most part, right? So I don't know mediators
- 40:06who really want to make counsel look bad in front
- 40:14of their clients. I think that is a highly disadvantageous
- 40:17thing to do from a business standpoint as a mediator.
- 40:21But in working with your client, you just want
- 40:25to have a good sense of what are the rules of
- 40:28engagement? When are we going to ask for breaks?
- 40:32What kind of things are we gonna discuss between
- 40:34us before we front them to the mediator? Those
- 40:39are for me the key preparation elements. Do you
- 40:42think there are some biggies that I've missed?
- 40:44Yeah, the only other thing I think is talking
- 40:47to your clients in terms of like, what are their
- 40:50interests in this case and settling this case,
- 40:54right? So part of it is definitely financial
- 40:56and that's what the risk analysis is gonna get
- 40:58you at. maybe time, right? Time commitment, financial
- 41:01commitment, right? That's a big part of it. But
- 41:04also, is there sort of reputational risks they're
- 41:06concerned about? Is there a relationship, you
- 41:08know, that my, you know, my favorite, one of
- 41:11my favorite things about mediation is we're not
- 41:14just talking dollars and cents, you know, that
- 41:15you can really get into sort of more of the other
- 41:20aspects of a dispute than you would, you know,
- 41:24in an arbitration or in court. So I think, you
- 41:26know, it may be that, no, it's just financial.
- 41:28you know, that that's really all there is. OK,
- 41:30OK. You know, but but there may be sort of other
- 41:33things that are important to the client that
- 41:35they could get from the mediation. Absolutely.
- 41:38And I'm really glad you mentioned it, because
- 41:41for me, that settlement analysis should also
- 41:47include those kinds of factors. And that's probably
- 41:51where we fall the shortest, usually as as lawyers,
- 41:56is we don't really probe Whether they're you
- 41:59know, what are the real business interests? As
- 42:03opposed to just our positions that we're taking
- 42:06about on this legal issue Here's how likely we
- 42:09are to win etc. Etc. Maybe the thing that's really
- 42:12important is not Is the damage is X or is it
- 42:165x but it's this has to get decided within six
- 42:19months Or we're gonna have this other really
- 42:21big problem, right? So focusing on interests.
- 42:25I agree totally key And then you alluded to this
- 42:30before and I want to make sure we get to it.
- 42:31So the role of the mediator, right? So clients
- 42:36often ask, I think, you know, what exactly is
- 42:39this mediator going to do? Like, what is mediation?
- 42:41So I'm wondering from your perspective, how do
- 42:43you describe your role to the parties? You know,
- 42:46that's that obviously some parties may be very
- 42:47familiar with mediation, some parties may not.
- 42:50So particularly for someone who is not, how do
- 42:53you describe what your role is as the mediator?
- 42:56Yeah, I mean, the simple version is I'm here
- 42:58to help you broker a deal. Right. And I'm I sort
- 43:03of make that pitch. Usually what I do is I, of
- 43:07course, will have an initial meeting with both
- 43:09sides. So we're all on the same page. But then
- 43:13individually, right, I like to communicate to
- 43:16them very firmly that I see my goal as helping
- 43:22them package Their message in a way to get them
- 43:28the best deal possible now. It just so happens
- 43:31and I make this very clear I'm also a double
- 43:33agent because I'm doing that for the other side,
- 43:36too So here's what I'm never gonna do. I'm never
- 43:38gonna lie to either side I'm never gonna misrepresent
- 43:41to either side for me. I mean, I think for me
- 43:44having the party's trust That they feel that
- 43:48I'm a straight shooter Is very important Okay,
- 43:53so I maintain that religiously. But within that
- 43:57framework, every volley that goes back and forth,
- 44:02I'm there. Yes, I press on the parties to say,
- 44:07you know what, you think 75 % chance on this
- 44:10argument? Let's look at why. Maybe that's not
- 44:14so, right? So I will do that. But I'm also, at
- 44:17the end of the day, always there to help them
- 44:20package their next communication to the other
- 44:23side in a way that I think is gonna help move
- 44:27the needle with the other side. And you talked
- 44:30a moment ago about a lot of mediators and a lot
- 44:34of the, I think the classic concept of mediation
- 44:39is this one and done event, right? Where here
- 44:43we've been slogging through this litigation or
- 44:46this arbitration for a year or more. And now
- 44:49we're gonna have, there's gonna be this mediation
- 44:53and we're gonna prepare for the mediation and
- 44:56we're gonna sit in the mediation and maybe we,
- 44:58you know, there are some mediators out there
- 45:00who are like 20 and $30 ,000 a day mediators.
- 45:03I'm not one of those. And then you're gonna go
- 45:06into this mediation and then it's either gonna
- 45:10be a flop after two hours or it's gonna grind
- 45:14into the night. and it's still going to flop
- 45:17or maybe it's actually going to settle everything.
- 45:20In some cases, that is good. Some parties need
- 45:27that kind of event to psychologically bring them
- 45:32together, okay? And one of your tasks as lawyers
- 45:36is to figure out if that's the case, right? But
- 45:39it's not always the case, especially if you have
- 45:43already programmed your Client to know that a
- 45:47mediation phase is going to be is a natural part
- 45:51of the proceeding because another way of doing
- 45:54a mediation and it's more my approach is. Yes,
- 45:59there's an initial meeting with the parties,
- 46:02but a lot of there and yes, there should be a
- 46:05day on the calendar, which is. The official mediation
- 46:10day, but really. a whole lot of the negotiation.
- 46:14Sometimes all of the negotiation happens before
- 46:18the mediation day. The mediation day gets taken
- 46:20off calendar because we've already reached a
- 46:22settlement. And I've done that through just kind
- 46:25of shovel diplomacy over a period of weeks or
- 46:28months. Sometimes that can be, I think, very
- 46:33successful. Yeah. And I've also had the experience
- 46:36where after the mediation day, you know, there's
- 46:40still a few loose ends that the parties, you
- 46:42know, might want to do some homework on. And
- 46:45then you don't need to have another, you know,
- 46:47convening, you just have conversations, you know,
- 46:50after the session, official session. And that's,
- 46:54you know, how it ends up, you know, being really,
- 46:56there are, it's a neck and a tail that often
- 46:59do wag the dog, right? So Yeah, you need that
- 47:03mediation event, but really very important work
- 47:06can be done both before and your right, Tracy,
- 47:08afterwards. And just being prepared for that
- 47:11is a good idea. Yeah, yeah. So I want to move
- 47:17to integrating mediation into legal practice.
- 47:22And I think we've covered most of this. But what
- 47:26would you say for lawyers looking to integrate
- 47:28and you gave some tips, you know, sort of giving
- 47:30the the conversation to your client saying this
- 47:34is going to be part of our game plan. But, you
- 47:37know, is there anything else you think for lawyers
- 47:39looking to integrate mediations or more more
- 47:41systematically into their practice? Is there
- 47:44advice that you would offer them? Well, everything
- 47:46that we just said, plus the one thing that I
- 47:50never did as before I became a neutral. that
- 47:54I think would be a great idea is if you have
- 47:57the time, take a mediation course. They have
- 48:02short ones and they have longer ones. If you
- 48:05actually were ever interested in becoming a mediator,
- 48:10most jurisdictions have this requirement of a
- 48:1440 -hour mediation program that usually lasts
- 48:17a week and different law schools offer them at
- 48:20different price points. But wow. You learn a
- 48:24lot. And I think it can help you as, I mean,
- 48:30if you're actually interested one day in being
- 48:32a neutral, it's a great way to get started. But
- 48:38even if you're just, if you want to be a counsel
- 48:41and for clients as an advocate, right? I think
- 48:46that kind of training could be really good, especially
- 48:49for litigators who, as I said, aren't necessarily
- 48:52always just naturally at home in negotiation.
- 48:57Yeah. And I've seen more law schools, which I'm
- 49:00excited about, and organizations, you know, the
- 49:02AAAs offers, and I think other organizations
- 49:04do too. I've seen training for advocates in mediation,
- 49:10you know, representation in mediation. I've seen
- 49:13law school competitions about representation
- 49:15in mediation. So, you know, I think that that's
- 49:18so important that it's not necessarily sort of
- 49:21a natural skill set. And it's not something that
- 49:24they're traditionally teaching in law schools,
- 49:26right? They're teaching you how to become a transactional
- 49:29attorney or litigator. I don't know, you know,
- 49:30whatever theoretical, whatever they're teaching
- 49:32in law schools, but it's not necessarily to be
- 49:36an advocate in mediation. So I think that that's,
- 49:40you know, another, another avenue to look at
- 49:41is trainings on, on being an advocate in mediation
- 49:45as well. Hey Tracy, before I see that our time
- 49:48is running here, we're down to 10 minutes. Okay.
- 49:52I gotta hear about the AAA. Okay. The AAA's offerings,
- 49:57I mean, you've got a pretty nifty suite of services
- 50:00that can really help this. So can you tell us
- 50:03about that? Sure. So the AAA, despite our name
- 50:07being the American Arbitration Association, we
- 50:10offer a robust mediation panel of highly qualified
- 50:16panel mediators like Marcus with deep substantive
- 50:20and ADR experience. across industry, dispute
- 50:23types. We offer mediation for everything from
- 50:25commercial, construction, employment, consumer.
- 50:28We just launched family to do divorce, custody,
- 50:31free naps, post naps, and all that. And we also
- 50:34have international mediation. So we sort of do
- 50:38it all. And you can find our panel of mediators
- 50:42on our website, adr .org backslash mediation.
- 50:45where you can search our mediators by practice
- 50:48area, location, compensation, and you can also
- 50:53file a mediation easily through that website.
- 50:57I think something that sets the AAA apart is
- 51:01really our focus on industry expertise. Someone
- 51:05like Marcus happens to have many different industry
- 51:08expertises from international to IP and trademark
- 51:11and construction. A lot of our panelists, focus
- 51:15on different industries, but many of them are
- 51:18focused on an industry. They have an employment
- 51:20background. They have a construction background.
- 51:22They have a tech background. And our panelists
- 51:26include seasoned attorneys, former judges, subject
- 51:29matter specialists. And our mediators are vetted
- 51:34for professional reputation, ADR experience.
- 51:38That's part of my role is to make sure that we
- 51:41are sort of displaying the best panelists for
- 51:45our clients. And we also offer continual ongoing
- 51:51training for our mediators. We want to keep our
- 51:54panel current with best practices, emerging issues,
- 51:58not only industry specific areas, which we focus
- 52:01on, but also areas like cybersecurity advances
- 52:03in AI and how AI can play a positive role in
- 52:06ADR. So we sort of are trying to... boost our
- 52:11panel in all different ways. We also offer case
- 52:15management support, so that's a big part of what
- 52:18the AAA provides, so it's helping you find the
- 52:21right mediator for your case and then helping
- 52:24to manage that case. We have case management
- 52:29specialists at the AAA who are focused just on
- 52:32mediation, so just supporting the mediation process.
- 52:36And they'll do everything from coordinating the
- 52:38filing to getting the best mediator appointed,
- 52:41scheduling, procedural logistics, really just
- 52:44reducing that administrative friction for councils,
- 52:47the mediator, and the parties. And we also have
- 52:52systems we accommodate, obviously, in -person,
- 52:55virtual, hybrid mediations, whatever you're looking
- 52:58for. And I'm obviously a big proponent of mediation.
- 53:03I think that it's a very cost -effective way
- 53:06to settle a dispute. It's confidential. I think
- 53:13that it's worthwhile to engage in. We said it
- 53:17may be at the beginning of the process, the middle
- 53:19of the process, close to the end of a process.
- 53:23But I always think that it brings a value add
- 53:26to wherever you are. And AAA itself is a non
- 53:31-for -profit organization. And so we really are
- 53:33focused on the experience of our end users, the
- 53:36parties and council involved in the mediation.
- 53:39So that's my. So Tracy, let's be real concrete
- 53:42about this. I'm a lawyer in our audience and
- 53:46I've got a case that just is a dog and I want
- 53:50to settle this thing. So what do I do? Do I just
- 53:53I go on the website and I is there a number I
- 53:57call? How do I? get access to a list of AAA mediators
- 54:04so that I can get this ball rolling. Yeah, so
- 54:07two ways. One, you can go on our website, ADR
- 54:10.org backslash mediation and file a mediation.
- 54:12We have an easy to use online filing system.
- 54:15Or you can email us at mediation services at
- 54:19ADR .org if you're looking for additional information.
- 54:23You know, you have any questions about how to
- 54:25file a case. So we try and make it very simple.
- 54:29how to file it. And then do you get do they get
- 54:32a if they file a mediation do they then get in
- 54:36due course a a list of proposed mediators just
- 54:40like in arbitration? So what we start what we
- 54:42start with is our search tool because we have
- 54:44everyone you know public facing so we'll say
- 54:46to the parties you know meet and confer you know
- 54:48we've got a panel of a thousand mediators you
- 54:52know so we have various expertise various locations
- 54:55see if you can you know, solve your first negotiation
- 54:58and decide upon someone. I actually heard from
- 55:02someone the other day, it was a good nugget,
- 55:04and they said, I like to agree with who the other
- 55:06side wants as their mediator, because that means
- 55:10that they're going to listen to them. You know,
- 55:12they're going to sort of take what they have
- 55:14to say seriously. So I think that's a good little
- 55:16tidbit. And, and yeah, if council has trouble
- 55:21selecting, you know, sort of meeting and conferring
- 55:23and deciding amongst themselves who to select,
- 55:26then yes, we will send a list, you know, that
- 55:28we will have curated that we think, you know,
- 55:31we'll fit the bill there and we'll do sort of
- 55:33a strike and rank and appoint somebody. But we
- 55:35do like to encourage parties to select a neutral
- 55:38from our panel. Makes sense. Yeah. So I know
- 55:47we have just about five minutes left. So I want
- 55:49to ask, you know, if you could leave the participants,
- 55:54Marcus, with some key takeaways about using mediation
- 55:57more effectively in their practice, what do you
- 55:59think it would be? How can people use it? Well,
- 56:03you know, I doubt we're going to say at this
- 56:07point we've covered so much territory. I don't
- 56:09think we're going to say anything totally new.
- 56:11I think the key, the most important thing I would
- 56:14want to emphasize is View the mediation not as
- 56:23something that just arises after you've done
- 56:28enough bloodletting, okay? Think of it as an
- 56:31intrinsic part of your litigation plan. And start
- 56:38having those conversations early and often. That
- 56:42would be, I guess, my single biggest takeaway.
- 56:46Yeah, and you know, I'm sorry. Go ahead Tracy.
- 56:50I don't know please with the Why you know we
- 56:57talked earlier about Most cases settle but maybe
- 57:01a lot of them settle really late in the process
- 57:04instead of early in the process And could mediation
- 57:07help that and the reason the answer is clearly.
- 57:10Yes is this? Not to get overly Like nerdy about
- 57:16this right but this is actually based on neuroscience
- 57:19okay. Our brains are wired. To not be able to
- 57:28see objectively. In a situation of conflict okay
- 57:33that is like literally they they've stuck wires
- 57:38in people's brains and yeah trust me it shows
- 57:41that the different parts of your brain light
- 57:43up. when you're looking at your own position
- 57:47versus the other side's position, right? And
- 57:52so that's why, you know, if that weren't the
- 57:55case, every dispute would settle, right? The
- 57:59parties would be like, oh, okay, do, do, do,
- 58:01do, do. Objectively, here's what the right settlement
- 58:03is. That doesn't happen. Because, not because
- 58:08we're dumb, not because we're greedy, right?
- 58:11But just because we can't. And so getting a neutral
- 58:18party in there who's going to help you and help
- 58:21the other side overcome some of this innate cognitive
- 58:26bias, I think is really helpful. That doesn't
- 58:31mean that they have to be kind of singing kumbaya
- 58:34and things like that, right? I find, at least
- 58:37in most business disputes, that's not all that
- 58:40productive. But what is productive is getting
- 58:43a mediator who you can kind of bond with and
- 58:46trust and will just help you get over that inability,
- 58:51that natural inability to see the other side's
- 58:55case and your case in a truly objective way.
- 58:59Yeah. And I think you hit on something earlier
- 59:01in our discussion, too, that lawyers are not
- 59:04necessarily taught or conditioned to participate
- 59:08in this kind of process. You mentioned newer
- 59:13lawyers or folks who maybe weren't as familiar
- 59:15with mediation doing a training as a neutral,
- 59:19maybe doing some trainings to be an advocate
- 59:21in mediation. But I'm wondering if you have any
- 59:24other advice for lawyers who are newer to mediation
- 59:26to build confidence and competence in this area
- 59:31to feel like, okay, I'm comfortable recommending
- 59:34this to my client and representing them in this
- 59:37type of process. Well, you know, it's interesting
- 59:41if one goes to one of those training programs
- 59:45Like the 40 hour programs that we talked about
- 59:48there are a lot of opportunities to do volunteer
- 59:54mediation and with like small claims court and
- 59:59and things of that nature and I've done some
- 1:00:02of that stuff and I think that kind of practice
- 1:00:04can be Really helpful and actually can also be
- 1:00:07really fun Yeah, and I say that to folks who
- 1:00:11come to me and say I'm interested in becoming
- 1:00:12a mediator I say find a training find a training
- 1:00:15that's connected to a caseload You know so that
- 1:00:18when you're taking a community mediation training
- 1:00:21connected to a caseload, so you do get the experience
- 1:00:24of marrying the theory with with the practice
- 1:00:28I think that is important Well, we've reached
- 1:00:31our time. I thank you for joining us Thank you
- 1:00:34all for joining us for this conversation about
- 1:00:36the nuts and bolts of mediation and hope you
- 1:00:39will check out the AAA's website, ADR .org backslash
- 1:00:43mediation, if you have any other questions, and
- 1:00:46hope you will all sort of pursue this area for
- 1:00:49your clients. Thank you so much for the opportunity
- 1:00:53to visit with you today, Tracy, and to the BHBA.