Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Conversion Therapy at the Supreme Court
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Conversion Therapy at the Supreme
- 0:05Court. I'm Anthony Ross, Chair of BHBA's Constitutional
- 0:08Law Section. I am delighted to introduce our
- 0:11speakers, Scott Skinner -Thompson and Pelikanos.
- 0:14Scott Skinner -Thompson is a professor and Dean
- 0:16Scholar at the University of Colorado Law School,
- 0:18where his research and teaching focus on constitutional
- 0:20law, civil rights, and privacy law, with particular
- 0:23emphasis on LGBTQ plus and HIV issues. His book,
- 0:27Privacy at the Margins, examines privacy as an
- 0:30anti -subordination tool of resistance to surveillance.
- 0:33And his article, Identity by Committee Exploring
- 0:35the Legal Construction of Gender and Protections
- 0:37for Transgender People, received the 2024 Duke
- 0:41Dominion Award for Best LGBTQ Law Review article.
- 0:44His broader scholarship has appeared in leading
- 0:46journals, including Georgetown Law Journal, Michigan
- 0:49Law Review, and Yale Law Forum. Prior to joining
- 0:52Colorado Law in 2017, he practiced alongside
- 0:55organizations including the ACLU, LGBT, and HIV
- 0:59Project, and the Transgender Law Center, and
- 1:01his contributions to LGBTQ plus rights had been
- 1:04recognized by both the National and Colorado
- 1:06LGBTQ plus bar associations. Pelicanos is a staff
- 1:11attorney at Lambda Legal specializing in constitutional
- 1:13and civil rights law, where they have worked
- 1:15since 2023. They earned their JD from the University
- 1:19of Denver Sturm College of Law with a constitutional
- 1:21rights and remedies certificate and previously
- 1:23interned with the ACLU of Colorado and the Civil
- 1:26Rights Division of the U .S. Department of Justice.
- 1:29A co -author of a published law review article
- 1:31tracing the U .S. legal history of transgender
- 1:33discrimination, Pelikanos is also an active board
- 1:36member of the National Trans Bar Association.
- 1:39Welcome to you both and let's get started. Great.
- 1:43Well, thanks so much, Tony, and thanks to the
- 1:46Beverly Hills Bar Association for organizing
- 1:49this CLE on the important case of Childs v. Salazar
- 1:55and the court's analysis of whether or not state
- 2:01laws banning so -called conversion therapy are
- 2:07permissible under the First Amendment when applied
- 2:11to talk therapy. And thanks as well to Pelikanos
- 2:17for joining me and helping to explain this case.
- 2:24Childs versus Salazar handed down earlier this
- 2:29year involved an as applied challenge to Colorado's
- 2:35ban on conversion practices, which It can involve
- 2:43attempts to forcibly change people's sexual orientation
- 2:48or gender identity. Colorado is one of about
- 2:55half of all the states that have chosen to regulate
- 2:59this practice. And the reason why states like
- 3:03Colorado, states like California and indeed California
- 3:07was the first state to ban conversion therapy
- 3:13for minors do so is because an overwhelming amount
- 3:18of medical evidence suggests that this practice
- 3:23is not in fact therapeutic. And therefore, many
- 3:28people believe that calling it conversion therapy
- 3:31is a misnomer because there's nothing therapeutic
- 3:34about it. And the reason why the medical community
- 3:39believes that this practice is not therapeutic
- 3:45is really twofold. First, it doesn't work. That
- 3:51is, people's gender identity and sexual orientation
- 3:56is not susceptible to... forced change, even
- 4:03through, you know, coercive methods that historically
- 4:08have involved, you know, aversive methods like
- 4:12electroshock therapy, but continue to involve
- 4:19efforts through so -called TAC therapy, again,
- 4:24therapy misnomer. efforts to sort of convince
- 4:30or change people's identity through oral discussion
- 4:36in the context of a professional relationship.
- 4:40So it doesn't work and it also causes great harm.
- 4:47And this is true really regardless of the type
- 4:50of conversion effort or conversion practice,
- 4:54again, whether it's physical interventions or
- 4:57oral interventions. Part of the reason why conversion
- 5:02practices or change efforts cause harm is because
- 5:06they inherently involve discrediting the person's
- 5:11identity, telling them that there's something
- 5:13wrong with it, there's something needing to be
- 5:17changed when in fact the evidence is clear from
- 5:23queer people's lived experiences and scientific
- 5:28studies. well that sexual and gender diversity
- 5:32is a normal part of our world and is a normal
- 5:37part of the human experience and not something
- 5:40that needs to be changed, but something that
- 5:43ought to be celebrated. So California, Colorado,
- 5:48you know, recognizing these realities have sought
- 5:52to protect vulnerable youth from these practices.
- 5:58and passed laws banning them. And in Colorado's
- 6:03case, they did so through a statute about six
- 6:09years ago that through their license, their licensing
- 6:15law. So to... As is the case for many professionals,
- 6:22many of the viewers, if not all, will be lawyers.
- 6:25You understand that you are a professional, right?
- 6:28And so to practice law in. the state of California,
- 6:35you have to be licensed by the state of California.
- 6:38So too, with medical professionals like doctors
- 6:42and therapy, you have to get a stamp of approval
- 6:46and a premature from the state in which you wish
- 6:49to work. And in this way, states exercise a degree
- 6:54of control or regulation over people who hold
- 6:57themselves out as being professionals, as bearing
- 7:01the impermature of the state. And the states
- 7:04naturally want to regulate that and say, okay,
- 7:07this person is actually legitimate. They've passed
- 7:09the California bar exam and they went to law
- 7:12school. They meet these basic requirements. In
- 7:20addition, states put limits on what you can do
- 7:23and what you can't do pursuant to that state
- 7:26approval. And one thing that Colorado has done
- 7:28is said, well, engaging in sexual orientation
- 7:32or gender identity change efforts is not permitted.
- 7:36You cannot hold yourself out as a licensed professional
- 7:40and do this towards youth and say that this is
- 7:43licensed and that Colorado thinks that this is
- 7:46effective practice. So the plaintiff petitioner
- 7:55in this case, Charles, hadn't yet provided this
- 8:01therapy, but brought a pre -enforcement challenge
- 8:05as this is becoming pretty frequent with First
- 8:08Amendment challenges to anti -discrimination
- 8:11law, which is to say that Colorado had enforced
- 8:14the law against her, but she brought a pre -enforcement
- 8:17challenge saying she wanted to do so. And she
- 8:22was worried that if she did, Colorado would regulate
- 8:25her. And she believed that as applied to her
- 8:29and her provision of quote unquote talk therapy
- 8:32to people, that it would violate her first amendment
- 8:40rights. You know, one thing before delving into
- 8:45it in more detail just that I want to underscore
- 8:49about the significance of a lot of these cases,
- 8:52whether it's Childs or 303 Creative, other First
- 8:56Amendment challenges to LGBT anti -discrimination
- 8:59laws, it really offers the plaintiffs in these
- 9:07instances You know, folks who want to use the
- 9:10First Amendment as a deregulatory tool to undermine
- 9:13anti -discrimination tools, the ability to really
- 9:16tell the story, they get to be, to paint themselves
- 9:19as the sympathetic party, and that there are
- 9:22no... LGBTQ people front and center in these
- 9:27cases. And so I think these pre -enforcement
- 9:29challenges are significant in terms of the narrative
- 9:34and storytelling capacity of these Supreme Court
- 9:37cases because we're not actually seeing how queer
- 9:40lives are directly affected. And this is in contrast
- 9:44to, for example, the wedding, the marriage cases
- 9:48where LGBTQ lives were often front and center.
- 9:55Everybody remembers Edie Windsor, right? Everybody
- 9:58remembers Jim Bergefell. So in this pre -enforcement
- 10:04challenge, Chiles argued that her therapy was
- 10:11in bold words and therefore that by preventing
- 10:16her pursuant to this licensing regulation from
- 10:19expressing those words in this context, you know,
- 10:24in a power relationship with a youth, someone
- 10:27under 18 years of old, that it targeted her speech
- 10:31on the basis of viewpoint and therefore should
- 10:33be subject to strict scrutiny. And the Supreme
- 10:38Court agreed in an 8 to 1 decision. Um, importantly,
- 10:46and this has been a little bit, uh, misunderstood
- 10:49and there's been some misreporting about, about
- 10:51this. The Supreme court did not rule even in
- 10:56this as applied challenge, Colorado's law unconstitutional.
- 11:01Okay. And that's true in a couple of respects.
- 11:04First, this wasn't a facial challenge. All right.
- 11:06And as the Supreme court recognized at the outset,
- 11:10to the extent that the opinion prevents conversion
- 11:14practices that involve more than talk, such as
- 11:18these aversive methods, the physical interventions.
- 11:22The court says nothing controversial about them
- 11:25under the First Amendment. So in many respects,
- 11:29the laws are still valid. But even with regard
- 11:35to as applied challenges that involve speech
- 11:39or communication, the court did not rule, okay,
- 11:44that the First Amendment was necessarily violated
- 11:47here. They ruled that strict scrutiny applied
- 11:50and they remanded it back to the lower courts
- 11:53for determination of whether or not Colorado
- 11:57can survive strict scrutiny. That is whether
- 12:00or not they can justify this burden on childless
- 12:04speech. based on the existence of a compelling
- 12:08government interest and that it's narrowly tailored
- 12:11to achieve that interest. And we're going to
- 12:13see how that ongoing litigation plays out. And
- 12:17I think Colorado is not without arguments that
- 12:22it can't survive strict scrutiny. And that's
- 12:24because of a lot of the medical evidence that
- 12:26I mentioned at the outset, which suggests that
- 12:30this causes harm, right? subjecting people to
- 12:35psychological distress and stigma. Combating
- 12:41that is a compelling government interest. And
- 12:44attorney, or excuse me, therapy licensing laws
- 12:46are a narrow targeted way of doing that. But
- 12:53why did the court conclude that this was targeted
- 12:57at speech? So I'll explain that a little bit
- 13:00and then I'll... uh, take a breath and let Pelicanus
- 13:04explain, um, why, uh, Justice Jackson, uh, felt,
- 13:08um, felt differently. So the court, uh, basically,
- 13:11uh, concluded, uh, you know, its analysis was,
- 13:15uh, pretty formalistic. Um, and it basically
- 13:19concluded, well, a therapist uses words. Okay.
- 13:24And those are words are historically sort of
- 13:28bread and butter speech. And so since the law
- 13:31burdens what words they can, the therapist can
- 13:35say in the context of their counseling sessions,
- 13:39it's targeting their speech. And they said it
- 13:41was a viewpoint discrimination because it says
- 13:43they can't say words that are discrediting of
- 13:47someone's sexual orientation or gender or identity,
- 13:49but they can say words that are affirming of
- 13:54that. I think that that formalistic analysis
- 14:01brushes over a lot of important precedent, but
- 14:09Justice Jackson gets to a lot of that. And so
- 14:12I'll let Pelikanis take it from there and then
- 14:16we'll discuss some of the implications of the
- 14:20decision. Absolutely. Thank you, Professor Skinner
- 14:23-Thompson and the HBA and Tony for having us
- 14:27here and being a part of this discussion. Yeah,
- 14:30as you point out, it was an 8 -1 decision. And
- 14:35for a lot of people, that felt a little surprising
- 14:37before they got into some of the details that
- 14:40you just mentioned. What the eight found is that
- 14:44there was viewpoint discrimination. Justice Jackson
- 14:48came in and said, I can't get on board with what
- 14:50everyone else is saying because conduct and the
- 14:54question of whether this was conduct or speech
- 14:57became so relevant and important to her and what
- 14:59she wrote about at the forefront of her dissent.
- 15:03That being, as Professor Skinner -Thompson mentioned,
- 15:07we are regulated as attorneys. We're familiar
- 15:10with the fact in our regulations for licensing
- 15:13that that there are limits on what we can say
- 15:17and what context. We cannot advertise, for example,
- 15:21in particular ways. We cannot be dishonest in
- 15:27certain ways, even though our whole profession
- 15:29is based around speech and writing. I mean, no
- 15:33one can argue that being a lawyer and the work
- 15:35that we do is so grounded in free speech. But
- 15:41we can still be regulated within a professional
- 15:43context. And so Justice Jackson similarly says,
- 15:48listen, when it comes to whether therapeutic
- 15:54or not, but talk -based practices aimed at providing
- 15:58therapy to particularly youth, when those When
- 16:05the whole practice, the whole medical practice
- 16:08is based around speech, yes, speech is a part
- 16:11of it, but more importantly, this is a medical
- 16:14practice and therefore can and should be regulated
- 16:17by licensing authorities. And so at the forefront
- 16:20of her dissent, she points this out, right? And
- 16:24she uses a discussion around some of the precedent
- 16:28around NIFLA and around Planned Parenthood to
- 16:31say, Listen, there are other contexts, even medical
- 16:35context, which is Planned Parenthood, where there's
- 16:38a deep discussion from this court about when
- 16:41medical professions, when speech within a medical
- 16:46context can and should be regulated. And so Justice
- 16:50Jackson in her dissent really, really leans into
- 16:53both the conduct aspect, kind of redefining and
- 16:58separating her. her dissent from the rest from
- 17:03the majority of the court saying describing what
- 17:08incidental meant in this case, right? Really
- 17:11describing when speech is incidental and not
- 17:17just redefining, but explaining why that's so
- 17:19relevant in this context that when you're dealing
- 17:22with a profession where speech is a part of the
- 17:26practice, that's when we can regulate. One of
- 17:31the other things Justice Jackson does so elegantly
- 17:35is really stands up for the youth and re -centers
- 17:38their voices in this discussion. Professor Skinner
- 17:42-Thompson mentioned earlier when we have these
- 17:44First Amendment cases that come before any event,
- 17:49right? It's just at the forefront, this pre -enforcement
- 17:52stage. It's hard to get those stories in. One
- 17:55way that we do that is through, you know, briefing
- 17:58from other from friends of the court who come
- 18:01in and and explain the people who are affected
- 18:06by these laws in this case LGBTQ people and more
- 18:09specifically youth and there's really a deep
- 18:14discussion from Justice Jackson about why that
- 18:16matters really pulling to the forefront all of
- 18:20the medical evidence that says that this practice
- 18:23is harmful. pulling in particular stories and
- 18:29quotes from the people who have been affected
- 18:32and how devastating it was in their lives to
- 18:36face this level of reinforced narrative around
- 18:42shame, around how wrong their gender expression
- 18:48or presentation or identity or sexual orientation
- 18:51was and the long -term effects that had. why
- 18:55it's particularly potent for youth is that their
- 19:00brains really are in this developmental stage
- 19:02where they're taking in the adults that are around
- 19:06them, the messaging that they're getting and
- 19:10they're integrating that. And when it's in conflict
- 19:14with who they are fundamentally as a person,
- 19:17that becomes extraordinarily problematic. and
- 19:21harmful. And so Justice Jackson centers that
- 19:24harm in addition to the reframing around conduct
- 19:29versus pure speech and what can be regulated.
- 19:34I think she elegantly navigates it all, but I
- 19:39think many were surprised that it was an 8 -1
- 19:42decision and she was the lone dissenter. I will
- 19:45point out that the typical people the typical
- 19:49justices that you might see in or expect to be
- 19:53in this descent, what they did instead is is
- 19:57concurring opinions in which they said, listen,
- 20:00we think that this law is viewpoint base, but
- 20:06if it were viewpoint neutral, if you could write
- 20:10this law in a way that generally applied to all
- 20:15viewpoints on whether LGBTQ people should be
- 20:21either affirmed, treated neutrally, or with aversion,
- 20:27trying to convert them back into a cisgender
- 20:32or heteronormative landscape. If you treated
- 20:36all of those equally, then perhaps this law wouldn't
- 20:44stand up to this level of scrutiny. And so they
- 20:48left open possibilities for the half of the states,
- 20:55right? 25 states who wanted to outlaw conversion
- 21:00therapy because of its harms. They left open
- 21:03a pathway to do so. And they said, OK, maybe
- 21:06as next steps, this is this is the blinking red
- 21:08light of here's how you could move forward. You
- 21:12could try and rewrite a law. Um, that could withstand
- 21:16the scrutiny. So I think that's a good segue
- 21:20probably professor to turn it back into the,
- 21:23what are the long term effects and consequences
- 21:25of this decision. Yeah, and I think, I mean,
- 21:31just. Professor, it looks like your microphone
- 21:39is out. Can you try to reset it real quick? I
- 21:46can hear you now. Can you hear me? Yes. Okay.
- 21:53So, you know, in terms of the concurrence by
- 22:01Justices Kagan and Sotomayor, I mean, this is
- 22:07reading tea leaves a little bit, but I think
- 22:10as Pelikan has rightly explained, right? They
- 22:14try to gesture to the idea that it might be possible
- 22:17to enact a content -based regulation that prohibits
- 22:23these kind of change efforts that. isn't viewpoint
- 22:28one and they seem to be sort of nudging the regulators
- 22:32in that direction. I think that's absolutely
- 22:36correct. I think they're also doing something
- 22:40else, which is their concurrent starts by talking
- 22:47about attacks on ideology. and how those are
- 22:54inherently suspect under the First Amendment.
- 22:58And so I think what they may be doing a little
- 23:02bit is actually thinking a little bit to the
- 23:04future in terms of all the attacks on supposed
- 23:09gender ideology that are being made by the Trump
- 23:13administration and many states and localities.
- 23:18And so trying to do a little sort of um anticipatory
- 23:22defense and say okay if you don't like laws that
- 23:26target speech because you disagree with it like
- 23:31fine but like let's let's keep an eye to the
- 23:35future and be sure that we um fairly apply this
- 23:38rule when supposed efforts to advance gender
- 23:41ideology, which is the right sort of boogeyman
- 23:45for transgender rights are attacking. And Keegan
- 23:50invokes ideology right out of the gate. And I
- 23:54think that that's part of maybe what's going
- 23:57on. Again, this is tea leaf reading. In terms
- 24:02of the consequences, I think It's going to be
- 24:06difficult for the court to cabin them, right?
- 24:09Colorado did an admirable job with this statute.
- 24:17And if you look at the text of it, they define
- 24:21what they're regulating in a very specific way.
- 24:31Pursuant to the law, licensed counselors are
- 24:34forbidden from engaging, quote, in any practice
- 24:36or treatment, dot, dot, dot, that attempts, dot,
- 24:39dot, dot, to change any individual's sexual orientation
- 24:42or gender identity. So it is targeted at practice,
- 24:46treatment, right? And at conduct. And as Pellekonis
- 24:53explained, right, much medical practice or treatment
- 24:58involves words. just because words are involved
- 25:03doesn't necessarily um right like we're just
- 25:06characterizing something in speech ought not
- 25:09right be a magical on -off switch in terms of
- 25:14the first amendment uh regulation if you can
- 25:17just say oh words are involved words are involved
- 25:19words are involved to get first amendment regulation
- 25:21then everything is subject to first amendment
- 25:25structuring because almost everything we do involves
- 25:29words. And certainly that's the case for professional
- 25:34regulation. So, you know, when, what is this
- 25:39going to mean for malpractice law, legal malpractice
- 25:43law or medical malpractice law? I really, I really
- 25:45don't know. I mean, we, it is the state of California
- 25:50and Colorado, they say things like you can't,
- 25:53you know, lie to your or misstate, egregiously
- 25:57misstate, commit negligence about what the law
- 26:02says. It's words, all we do, we traffic in words.
- 26:07Is that now going to be subject to strict scrutiny?
- 26:11Perhaps. I think we don't know. Financial advisors,
- 26:17right? Same thing. traffic and words. Is that
- 26:19going to be subject to their regulation, going
- 26:23to be subject to scrutiny? Potentially. So I
- 26:30think that the consequences of this are going
- 26:35to be a little bit difficult to have it. And
- 26:40I think, you know, here it's important to put
- 26:43this case in a broader context, which is particularly
- 26:46when it has come to efforts to protect queer
- 26:49people. OK, the court has increasingly used been
- 26:55finding speech everywhere. Right. And and and
- 26:58been using the First Amendment to strike down
- 27:01those regulations, whether it's a. business that
- 27:06runs a website or a therapist who's engaged in
- 27:11a practice of medicine at the court's finding
- 27:14speech and allowing them to avoid anti -discrimination
- 27:20structures. So I think that this has implications
- 27:23for regulation of professionals, but I think
- 27:25it's also part of a broader movement on the court
- 27:29that has implications for for, for all sorts
- 27:33of anti -discrimination, uh, regulation and of
- 27:37course, not limited to, to, uh, queer people.
- 27:43Yeah. To follow up, I think, um, advocates within
- 27:48the kind of LGBTQ space, many of them after the
- 27:53oral arguments and trials. imagined what was
- 27:58coming down the road, given the court's composition
- 28:00and the questions that were asked and a variety
- 28:03of things. They kind of read the situation. And
- 28:07even though this opinion came out fairly early
- 28:11in the 2026 opinion distribution, they were prepared
- 28:20so that while all of the states were still in
- 28:23their legislative sessions, They kind of brainstormed
- 28:27what could be our response? What can we bring
- 28:30if that doesn't work? If our original kind of
- 28:34model bill and what was replicated across many
- 28:36states didn't work, how do we continue bringing
- 28:40the message forward that conversion therapy is
- 28:42not safe? And how do we try and protect more
- 28:46people who could be exposed to this harmful practice?
- 28:50And so what they did is they brought kind of
- 28:56a new, in a couple of places, Colorado, one of
- 28:59them, California currently debating about this
- 29:02as well, a new bill that instead of being a law
- 29:08that quote unquote has viewpoint discrimination
- 29:13regulation of these practices, instead They're
- 29:17just working on increasing the statutory limitation
- 29:20of when you can bring some of these malpractice
- 29:24lawsuits against providers because of the harm
- 29:27they're causing. So exactly as Professor Skinner
- 29:30-Thompson said, what are the long -term implications
- 29:33in malpractice is really an interesting question
- 29:36given that seems to be the next arena that this
- 29:40discussion is moving into. like the threat that
- 29:47maybe the concurrence of Justice Sotomayor and
- 29:50Kagan saw around well, if we regulate this professional
- 29:56speech when it comes to this viewpoint, what's
- 29:59going to happen with, you know, other viewpoints
- 30:03such as that gender identity and sexual orientation
- 30:08should be affirmed. So that was their concern.
- 30:10So what we're seeing in the malpractice arena,
- 30:14is a lot of what we call de -transitioner lawsuits,
- 30:19folks who have regrets or feel maybe their doctor
- 30:27actually committed malpractice. And there are
- 30:32ongoing questions within the LGBTQ rights movement
- 30:37amongst activists, amongst providers themselves.
- 30:41If we extend the statute of limitations, in these
- 30:45bills that are viewpoint, that aim to be viewpoint
- 30:48neutral, that don't specifically say for conversion
- 30:52therapy, what are the consequences also of these
- 30:58bills on all aspects of this discussion, meaning
- 31:01both for these harmful conversion practices and
- 31:05for the ability of. therapists and medical providers
- 31:10more broadly to provide gender affirming care
- 31:13and affirming therapy. And so the entanglements
- 31:18of these multiple viewpoints continue to move
- 31:21forward. And in child's when the court asks basically
- 31:27the bills not to target specifically conversion
- 31:33practices that really highlights how careful
- 31:41we have to be because of the intertwined nature
- 31:44of all these practices and then you have primarily
- 31:48blue states trying to support LGBTQ people and
- 31:53primarily red states actively harming LGBTQ people
- 32:00and whatever happens in one arena if you truly
- 32:03are writing laws to be neutral must then also
- 32:06be true in this other. And it's such a difficult
- 32:08balancing act that it's presenting a challenge
- 32:13of how to move forward with the implicit goals
- 32:16of protecting LGBTQ people, particularly youth
- 32:20who are exposed to these practices. Yeah, absolutely.
- 32:25And just I think to Just to embellish that, because
- 32:32I think it's sort of a critical point, Pelikanis,
- 32:35right? Justice Gorsuch, okay, even in the majority
- 32:38opinion, seems to suggest that malpractice suits,
- 32:43okay, the tort law is different than a state
- 32:49using it, okay, malpractice common law, right,
- 32:53is different than states using... their licensing
- 32:59regulation. Now, part of his reasoning for believing
- 33:04that's different is historical, is basically
- 33:09an originalist movie. He says, well, historically,
- 33:11malpractice has existed. But the First Amendment
- 33:15still applies to tort law, and sometimes the
- 33:21substance of it. That's why there are first amendment
- 33:29limits on defamation towards, right? You need
- 33:32actual analysis in certain contexts, for example.
- 33:37But he seems to suggest that malpractice would
- 33:40withstand first amendment scrutiny toward law,
- 33:45would withstand amendment scrutiny for two reasons.
- 33:47One, historical, like an originalist perspective.
- 33:50And two, he's like, well, these standards of
- 33:54proof in a lawsuit make it more narrowly tailored,
- 34:00right? Because a plaintiff would have to show,
- 34:03bring a lawsuit, satisfy a jury, and demonstrate
- 34:08that this went against the standards of care.
- 34:13To me, this is some empty formalism because what
- 34:18states like Colorado and California and others
- 34:23are effectively doing when they ban sexual orientation
- 34:29and gender identity efforts is basically saying
- 34:32incorporating the standard of care. As Pelikanis
- 34:36is suggesting, right, Kagan and Gorsuch sort
- 34:41of seem to think that that might be viewpoint
- 34:44neutral. Okay, just if you don't comply with
- 34:49the standards of care, you can be sued. But the
- 34:53standards of care themselves... take into consideration
- 34:58the words that you're being being said right
- 35:02like if you use words that delegitimize someone's
- 35:08identity right like the standards of care would
- 35:10say that that's not good not not permissible
- 35:14so so i think that the part of this i mean i
- 35:19i think it's good that they've left open this
- 35:22potential means of regulation, but I think it
- 35:26is a little bit overly formalistic and in terms
- 35:31of its logic, it doesn't really hold for me.
- 35:36And then I think another thing that gets difficult,
- 35:41right, as Pelikanis is underscoring is, okay,
- 35:45what if states just say standards of care? Well,
- 35:51a lot of the medical evidence, you know, discredits
- 35:56this and a lot of the medical evidence supports
- 35:59gender affirming care, but the Supreme Court
- 36:06has also particularly, you know, certain justices
- 36:09on the Supreme Court have also shown that they
- 36:12actually don't believe in science and in doctors
- 36:16and are not going to, um, uh, trust them. And
- 36:21this is, you know, several justices in Scrimetti,
- 36:25um, and we're pretty explicit in that, that they
- 36:28don't, they don't think that medicine is, um,
- 36:33uh, right, and that they believe they're two
- 36:38sexes and that's it. And, you know, facts, facts
- 36:43be damned, right? And then, oh, Justice Thomas
- 36:46this morning in his concurrence in the BPJ transgender
- 36:51case reiterated that. I mean, just gratuitously
- 36:54just writing a concurrence to basically say trans
- 36:59people don't exist. And so I think that lawyers
- 37:08should try to exploit this malpractice opportunity.
- 37:14to try to use tort law. I'll be interested to
- 37:18see how, whether Justice Gorsuch, for example,
- 37:24remains true to his word and believes that basically
- 37:26incorporating the standard of care is content,
- 37:31is viewpoint neutral. I mean, I have my doubts,
- 37:37but I'm, you know, we'll hold out hope. I want
- 37:43to address one of the questions in the Q &A real
- 37:46quickly on standing, and then I want to turn
- 37:48back to this morning's BPJ Hecox decision and
- 37:53think a little bit more about as applied challenges
- 37:56here in just a second. But to answer the question
- 37:59in the chat, which is basically like, is there
- 38:01even standing in this case? A question that was
- 38:05also raised in 303 Creative, for example. But
- 38:09in Childs V. Salazar, as many people understand
- 38:14it and was discussed in the opinion, um, Childs
- 38:22the therapist, there's, there's a question of
- 38:26whether her practice would even be regulated
- 38:28under Colorado's law, right? And in the sense
- 38:32that the way that she has described her practice,
- 38:40um, may be that she isn't practicing conversion
- 38:46therapy or conversion practices in the way that
- 38:51this law would regulate, right? In the sense
- 38:56that if she truly is just being with her patients
- 39:01and talking, wants the ability to talk through
- 39:03whatever comes up for them and what they're bringing
- 39:05up and what they're bringing forward, then there
- 39:09is a question of whether she is according to
- 39:13the statute would even be regulated. However,
- 39:18that was not at the forefront. I think many people
- 39:20before Charles V. Salazar opinion came out, they
- 39:23thought, well, maybe there would be kind of a
- 39:26group dissent and or potentially, although unlikely,
- 39:31a majority opinion based on the lack of standing.
- 39:33And that just really didn't come to the forefront
- 39:36of the discussion. And I think in part the kind
- 39:41of critical legal analysis is because the court
- 39:44wanted to talk about all of the issues in this
- 39:47case and didn't want standing to get in their
- 39:48way. They didn't want to be limited by not having
- 39:52not having all of the details fleshed out of
- 39:58like who is actually harmed by this and also
- 40:00not having details fleshed out about whether
- 40:02the state would even come in and you know, hold
- 40:08a hearing or try and regulate your license or
- 40:10that there'd be any kind of legal consequences
- 40:13to this therapist in particular. And because
- 40:18it was an as applied challenge, like there are
- 40:21questions of whether this case should have even
- 40:24made it to the Supreme Court or been at the forefront
- 40:27of this. I hope Joshua Clip that that kind of
- 40:32hones in and answers your question, but. I would
- 40:35love to turn more now. Yeah, can I just add one
- 40:38thing? I mean, I think everything is right. One
- 40:40thing I'd add is that the backdrop here that
- 40:44a lot of the litigants are using, it's no mistake
- 40:49or no coincidence that Colorado is involved in...
- 40:53All of these First Amendment cases, right, Mashpee's
- 40:56Cake Shop, 303, Childs, St. Mary's coming to
- 41:03the court, right, they're all coming out of Colorado.
- 41:07And part of that is the litigants are, one, Colorado
- 41:10has a state government that protects queer people.
- 41:15So they have a lot of these laws, so that's true
- 41:17of half of the states. But they've used... the
- 41:23fact that Colorado has enforced its anti -discrimination
- 41:26law in the past, right? To say that there's like
- 41:31credible threat, right? So that, for example,
- 41:33in 303 Creative, again, no action, no going concern.
- 41:40The litigants said, well, you enforce the statute
- 41:43against Jack Phillips, you'll enforce it against
- 41:46me. And so the court, in many respects, when
- 41:52it comes to the First Amendment, taken a very
- 41:58broad approach to determining standing and actual
- 42:04injury. And there's some precedent for that because
- 42:07the court in the First Amendment context is very
- 42:09worried about chilling. But to the question,
- 42:12I think there's an argument that they've really
- 42:17taken it quite far. Yeah, thank you for for bringing
- 42:23that in that's that is yeah, we've developed
- 42:25quite a history in Colorado at this point that
- 42:27they're relying on For pre -enforcement reasons
- 42:30and and First Amendment as we I'm sure everyone
- 42:33heard in law school is special And for good reason
- 42:36and in some cases, but I wanted to turn now if
- 42:40we could to as applied Challenges, which in child's
- 42:44we Salazar that that's what we have here, right?
- 42:46We have an as applied challenge this one therapist
- 42:49saying, you know, you can't apply this law to
- 42:52me or be unconstitutional. And then today in
- 42:56BPJ and HECOX, the court very much being critical
- 43:01of as applied challenges in constitutional law
- 43:04settings and saying, actually, you know, just
- 43:10because some people are harmed, and maybe it's
- 43:13unconstitutional when applied to some small group
- 43:15of people, If the state's interest is to protect
- 43:20this larger group of people, then maybe it's
- 43:22still okay. And it seems to be discrediting or
- 43:28tearing down or doing a disservice to the history
- 43:32of as applied challenges. And it feels paradoxical
- 43:37or unfair that in child's that question, the
- 43:43same court, the same composition of court. justices,
- 43:47you know, the same time period is like, no, no,
- 43:49that's totally fine in this setting. Even if
- 43:52just one person might be harmed by this, and
- 43:54it's not broadly problematic or broadly, it fulfills
- 43:59the state's stated interest. That's fine. But
- 44:03in this other context, with trans youth and sports,
- 44:08where for example, Pepe, Becky Pepper Jackson,
- 44:13the athlete, in West Virginia that just because
- 44:17one person who maybe didn't who didn't go through
- 44:21endogenous puberty who has been on puberty blockers
- 44:24and hormones maybe this one youth that it would
- 44:31be unconstitutional for her that doesn't mean
- 44:34we should throw out the law writ large and that
- 44:39level of hypocrisy feels difficult to swallow
- 44:41and I'm wondering if you have any thoughts on
- 44:43that professor. Well, I think it's an important
- 44:49point, and I'm still digesting this morning's
- 44:55opinion. As I read the majority opinion, so part
- 45:00of the argument raised by Becky Pepper Jackson's
- 45:04lawyer was that even if bans on trans female
- 45:12participation in sports are generally okay under
- 45:20sex discrimination law as applied to someone
- 45:24who had had puberty blockers and hormonal interventions
- 45:28who didn't and therefore may not have had any
- 45:35physical advantages that a prototypical males,
- 45:46assigned male at birth might have, the law negatively
- 45:51impacts her. And they said that basically, as
- 45:56Paula Thomas explained, that that would, diving
- 46:00down into that level of detail would transform
- 46:03equal protection sex discrimination law from
- 46:06intermediate scrutiny into strict scrutiny because
- 46:10it would require the government to show, um,
- 46:15you know, that the law wasn't narrowly tailored,
- 46:18right? No broader than necessary. Okay. Which
- 46:21is not what intermediate scrutiny generally requires.
- 46:23It requires, right? Um, a substantial relationship,
- 46:26right? Some, some, it tolerates some overbreath.
- 46:30Okay. Um, not a lot, but some. And so they're
- 46:33saying, but if you have an as applied sex equality
- 46:37argument that requires one person, not to be
- 46:42treated differently, then it would basically
- 46:44be transforming the standard into strict scrutiny.
- 46:49I do think that that juxtaposed to child seems
- 46:54deeply unfair. One thing I will say is, and this
- 47:03is just more gesturing to the real complexity
- 47:07and difficult litigation posture that LGBTQ rights
- 47:14advocates are in is, and which is not to second
- 47:20guess the litigation strategy at all, but I think
- 47:23the as applied rhetoric itself was arguably,
- 47:37not inclusive, which is to say, right? The result
- 47:43of, if the Supreme Court agreed with that, that
- 47:45as applied to certain trans people who went under,
- 47:49you know, went under these certain medical interventions
- 47:52at the appropriate time, they can play, but other
- 47:54trans people who didn't can't play, I think that
- 47:58that's a result that I think it's deeply uncomfortable
- 48:06for many people in the queer community. Which
- 48:12isn't to say it shouldn't have pursued, but I
- 48:16think that it's gesturing to how under this court,
- 48:24even the most conservative and narrower approaches
- 48:30to recognizing the existence of queer people
- 48:33are being met with really dismissive responses.
- 48:43And again, I don't quote me on this because I
- 48:47think maybe at the end of the opinion, Cavanaugh
- 48:50refers to Becky Pepper Jackson as transgender,
- 48:54but for the first 13 pages, He refers to Becky
- 49:01Pepper Jackson as a biological male who identifies
- 49:05as female, which is to say that, you know, the
- 49:09court doesn't, in its rhetoric, much even, the
- 49:17outcomes are there, but even in its rhetoric,
- 49:20a lot of times is quite racist queer identities.
- 49:30with alacrity, which in and of itself imposes
- 49:33an injury, right? See the opening point we talked
- 49:37about, right? Stigmatizing queer people and not
- 49:39recognizing that they exist is a harm in and
- 49:43of itself. Yeah, I think you point out something
- 49:49so vital to bring to the forefront, which is
- 49:52regardless of the legal arguments, decisions,
- 49:55outcomes in these cases, so much of the media
- 50:01responses, the public discussions really seem
- 50:07to lead to a lot of stigmatization, to a lot
- 50:11of just generalized harm against the LGBTQ community
- 50:16when in Supreme Court cases, the way that they
- 50:24write about our community isn't careful and thoughtful.
- 50:29Even if we have different opinions on what the
- 50:32legal outcome should be, it would be really nice
- 50:37to see opinions written with a level of respect
- 50:42that we see for other groups of people. Absolutely.
- 50:48And again, the posture of these cases is queer
- 50:53people are a threat to people's First Amendment
- 50:55rights. Queer people are a threat to cis women's
- 51:01opportunities. And as justice, as the dissent
- 51:11in BBJ, the concurrence dissent notes, it's unfortunate
- 51:21that the majority in that case really positions
- 51:27itself as the champion of women's rights and
- 51:32says, look at how important these opportunities
- 51:34are for people and how critical they are, but
- 51:38then ignores. It's like, yeah, no. No shit, Sherlock,
- 51:43that's why trans people want to participate because
- 51:50it's really important and their involvement isn't.
- 51:55And as Kevin also notes, right, like you're not
- 51:58the value of sports is not just from victory.
- 52:03OK. But it's also from learning how to deal with
- 52:06defeat. And yet. they hold up that defeat as
- 52:11like the um, an existential crisis if it were
- 52:16the case that a trans woman happened to be a
- 52:19cis woman. Should we turn to questions? Yeah,
- 52:27I think that would be great. Okay. Um, you all
- 52:33have both the option of writing questions in
- 52:36the Q &A and or I think there's, is there a possibility
- 52:41for asking them aloud or we can repeat them aloud
- 52:45if you put them in the Q &A. Whether that be
- 52:51legal questions, practical questions of what
- 52:53we might see down the road for trials and conversion
- 52:57practices. How the BPJ case today might impact
- 53:03LGBTQ rights more generally. So it doesn't look
- 53:10like we have questions just yet. Perhaps there
- 53:13are some other things or other, you know, I guess
- 53:16the points that you just mentioned that you can
- 53:18discuss while we wait for submissions. Absolutely.
- 53:23Yeah, I would be interested in continuing the
- 53:26discussion on kind of what the court did today
- 53:30around equal protection. I think that's. that's
- 53:33interesting that they at least acknowledged intermediate
- 53:36scrutiny, although not using all of the same
- 53:38words and framing that I would, that they could
- 53:42at least recognize that a ban on trans youth
- 53:49in schools deserves intermediate scrutiny and
- 53:52at least applied that, which is different than
- 53:55some of the circuit precedent in other cases
- 54:02against laws that restrict LGBTQ people in some
- 54:06capacity, especially trans people, where courts
- 54:10have tried to only apply rational basis scrutiny.
- 54:14Yeah, I think it's an important point. I also
- 54:16think, you know, because they believed, you know,
- 54:21one critical consequence is the one you noted
- 54:24and others that they did not decide whether transgender
- 54:27identity ought to be to characterize as a quasi
- 54:31suspect classification because they didn't need
- 54:34to because they were already applying intermediate
- 54:37scrutiny because there was a sex -based classification.
- 54:40They said, well, you know, no need to decide
- 54:43that issue because the result would be the same
- 54:50level of scrutiny. You know, one thing I think
- 54:56and probably should have understood at the outset,
- 55:04is that the court is obviously in a period of
- 55:16retrenchment when it comes to queer lives, which
- 55:23is, you know, if you're a queer person, if you're
- 55:26a trans person, difficult. Each one of these
- 55:29opinions is a gut punch. I don't want to speak
- 55:37for Pelicanus, but speaking for myself, you know,
- 55:41this morning, getting up, doing this on this
- 55:45day is difficult. Which is to say, like, there's
- 55:53this, you know, repeated trauma that comes down
- 55:59with these decisions. And, you know, which is
- 56:04particularly acute for trans -yous. But I guess,
- 56:11like, and so I think people should take time
- 56:15to digest, take time to engage in self -care
- 56:18to the extent that they... are feeling harmed
- 56:24by these decisions. But where I turn to next
- 56:31is that these are ongoing legal and social battles.
- 56:41And in much the same way that the court's views
- 56:47I've swung to the right on a myriad of issues
- 56:50with continued advocacy. The court of today will
- 57:01not always be the court. And even if it does
- 57:04stay to the right, no court gets to decide. whether
- 57:09or not queer people and trans people are real,
- 57:13only trans and queer people know that, and we
- 57:16don't need external recognition to know that,
- 57:23and we don't need to look to these people to
- 57:27find meaning in our lives. Important as the legal
- 57:31protections are, they're not what create identity
- 57:35or give us meaning. Yeah, super important to
- 57:42highlight that. We're here. Poor queer. Exactly.
- 57:45We shall continue to be so. Yeah. I found something
- 57:50to kind of backtrack to conversion practices
- 57:54for just a moment that I found really interesting
- 57:57when I was researching my recent... law review
- 58:03article and really digging into the history of
- 58:05discrimination against trans folks, something
- 58:08that I learned from the GLBT Historical Society,
- 58:12which is in San Francisco. They have beautiful
- 58:15digital archives for those not familiar, which
- 58:18include these really amazing archives by a trans
- 58:23woman who has been fighting against conversion
- 58:26practices. I think the material is from the 80s
- 58:33or 90s and she writes about her experience in
- 58:36the 70s and prior you know experiences with conversion
- 58:40therapy and practices going back before that
- 58:43um and just the long history that we stand on
- 58:47sometimes you know in one sense it's a little
- 58:50dark that we've been fighting against these harms
- 58:53for so long but also somewhat reassuring to me
- 58:57that We have existed and people have cared and
- 59:01people have been pushing back against harmful
- 59:03practices for so long because we have this incredible
- 59:06vibrant community and That absolutely and Colorado
- 59:10is like a great example of that because I mean
- 59:12we were the hates the Colorado was the hate state
- 59:14Okay, and now you know it's got every LGBTQ protection
- 59:21on the book and And that's because where people
- 59:29have been persuasive and people have opened their
- 59:34hearts to them in many communities. 20 years
- 59:42ago, states were still outlawing gay sex. History
- 59:51is really important. There's another question.
- 59:57Given that Skirmety landed on rational basis
- 1:00:00to permit Tennessee's ban on gender -affirming
- 1:00:03care to stay in place, can other states trying
- 1:00:05to protect its LGBTQ assert that there's a rational
- 1:00:08basis for their protective laws? I think the
- 1:00:12short answer is yes, absolutely. I mean, I think
- 1:00:14that there's more than a rational basis for those
- 1:00:17laws. And, you know, in cases like 303, right?
- 1:00:26The court, even though it said as applied to
- 1:00:31the website designer, while it was unconstitutional,
- 1:00:36they recognized the critical importance of public
- 1:00:41accommodation laws, including as they pertain
- 1:00:44to queer people, sort of not explicitly saying,
- 1:00:47but sort of suggesting that there's at least
- 1:00:51for anti -discrimination laws. I also just wanna
- 1:00:56engage with the premise of that question real
- 1:00:58quickly. I don't think it's the case that a rational
- 1:01:03basis is going to be applied to every anti -trans
- 1:01:07law. The Skirmetti decision went out of its way
- 1:01:10to note that like it really, that case, the reason
- 1:01:14they applied, Rational basis review was because
- 1:01:20it dealt with the provision of a particular medical
- 1:01:23practice and the wording of that statute to target
- 1:01:26the practice and the law didn't use gender or
- 1:01:31sex in its view. In contrast, as we saw today,
- 1:01:36the court said, oh, this is a sex -based law.
- 1:01:38we are going to apply, um, intermediate, uh,
- 1:01:42scrutiny. So I do, I do not think that every
- 1:01:44anti -trans law is going to be subject to, um,
- 1:01:47rational basis, uh, uh, view going forward. Yeah,
- 1:01:51agree. And in fact, like what I've seen in practice
- 1:01:54and most of the courts that I've dealt with since
- 1:01:58Skrimeti came out is that really Skrimeti applies
- 1:02:00when, when the classification is for gender dysphoria,
- 1:02:04um, and not trans people more broadly or even
- 1:02:08today's decision based on quote unquote, biological
- 1:02:11sex, right? Like that's where you get your intermediate
- 1:02:14scrutiny. So I think odd as it is to say today's
- 1:02:21BPJ Hecox decision is helping cabin scrimmety
- 1:02:25in some ways. That's true. All right. I think
- 1:02:33we are slightly over time, but really appreciate,
- 1:02:36um, the audience, and thank you Pelicanos for
- 1:02:41joining me and helping to unpack both conversion
- 1:02:45therapy trials and today's decision. Thank you.
- 1:02:50It was a blast to have this conversation. Looking
- 1:02:51forward to our next. This concludes today's presentation.
- 1:02:56Thank you so much, Professor Skinner -Thompson
- 1:02:58and Pelicanos for joining us today, and thank
- 1:03:00you so much to our audience. Have a great day,
- 1:03:02everybody.