Latest / Bloomberg Law / Supreme Court Likely to Reject Effort to Kick Trump Off Ballot
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 2: What about the idea that we should think about democracy,
- 0:14Speaker 2: think about the right of the people to elect candidates
- 0:18Speaker 2: of their choice of letting the people decide, because your
- 0:22Speaker 2: position has the effect of disenfranchising voters to a significant degree.
- 0:29Speaker 3: At the Supreme Court today, Justice Brett Cavanaugh expressed a
- 0:33Speaker 3: concern that seemed to underlie the oral arguments over Colorado's
- 0:37Speaker 3: effort to disqualify Donald Trump from this year's presidential election
- 0:41Speaker 3: ballot for engaging in an insurrection. Liberal and conservative justice
- 0:45Speaker 3: is alike question whether the Colorado Supreme Court has the
- 0:49Speaker 3: power to kick Trump off the ballot. Chief Justice John
- 0:52Speaker 3: Roberts and Justice Elaina Kagan voice doubts that a single
- 0:55Speaker 3: state should have the power to make a decision with
- 0:58Speaker 3: such national implications.
- 1:01Speaker 4: I think that the question that you have to confront
- 1:03Speaker 4: is why a single state should decide who gets to
- 1:06Speaker 4: be president of the United States. In other words, you know,
- 1:09Speaker 4: this question of whether a former president is disqualified for
- 1:13Speaker 4: insurrection to be president again is just say it. It
- 1:18Speaker 4: sounds awfully national to me in very.
- 1:22Speaker 5: Quick order, I would expect, although my predictions have never
- 1:26Speaker 5: been correct, I would expect that a goodly number of
- 1:31Speaker 5: states will say, whoever the Democratic candidate is, you're off
- 1:35Speaker 5: the ballot, and others for the Republican candidate, you're off
- 1:39Speaker 5: the ballot, and it'll come down to just a handful
- 1:41Speaker 5: of states that are going to decide the presidential election.
- 1:44Speaker 5: That's a pretty daunting consequence.
- 1:47Speaker 3: As to the question of whether Donald Trump had engaged
- 1:50Speaker 3: in an insurrection, in two hours of oral arguments, only
- 1:55Speaker 3: one Justice, Katanji Brown Jackson posed that question to Trump's
- 1:59Speaker 3: attorney Jonathan Mitchell.
- 2:01Speaker 1: For an insurrection, there needs to be an organized, concerted
- 2:03Speaker 1: effort to overthrow the government of the United States through violence.
- 2:07Speaker 3: And this point is that a chaotic effort to overthrow
- 2:10Speaker 3: the government is not an insurrection.
- 2:12Speaker 1: Well, we didn't con see that it's an effort to
- 2:13Speaker 1: overthrow the government either. Justice Jackson right. None of these
- 2:16Speaker 1: criteria were met. This was a riot, It was not
- 2:19Speaker 1: an insurrection. The events were shameful, criminal, violent, all of
- 2:21Speaker 1: those things, but did not qualify as insurrection as that
- 2:24Speaker 1: term is used in section three.
- 2:26Speaker 3: My guest is election law expert Derek Muller, a professor
- 2:29Speaker 3: at Notre Dame Law School. Broad question First, does it
- 2:33Speaker 3: appear that the justices are going to rule that Colorado
- 2:37Speaker 3: can't disqualify Trump from the ballot, perhaps even unanimously.
- 2:42Speaker 6: Yeah, I think it's going to be an unanimous or
- 2:44Speaker 6: near unanimous decision reversed in the Colorado Supreme Court. Here,
- 2:48Speaker 6: the justices across the ideological spectrum seemed concerned about the
- 2:52Speaker 6: notion that one state could have such an outsized influence
- 2:55Speaker 6: and the presidential election, to have such an influence on
- 2:58Speaker 6: the rest of the process, and to do so without
- 3:01Speaker 6: any guidance from Congress. The presidency's unique office. It's not
- 3:06Speaker 6: just an office out of one state, but an office
- 3:08Speaker 6: that comes from the choices of many states making the decision.
- 3:12Speaker 6: I think the notion that the Supreme Court would be
- 3:14Speaker 6: expected to clean up those messes if different states reached
- 3:17Speaker 6: different resolutions, so that every time there was a challenge
- 3:20Speaker 6: it would end up at the Supreme Court store was
- 3:22Speaker 6: certainly unattractive to them. So I think there's a lot
- 3:24Speaker 6: of consensus that Trump's name will appear on the ballot.
- 3:27Speaker 3: Let's discuss some of the arguments that Trump raised. He'd
- 3:31Speaker 3: argue that the president isn't covered by the insurrection clause
- 3:35Speaker 3: because the president is not an officer of the United
- 3:38Speaker 3: States as defined in that clause, And there was a
- 3:41Speaker 3: lot of discussion of what is an officer does a
- 3:44Speaker 3: president qualify? And Justice Neil Gorsich basically gave a history
- 3:48Speaker 3: lesson at one point, don the term officer versus office.
- 3:51Speaker 6: So tell us about that, Yeah, I mean, I think
- 3:54Speaker 6: Justice Corsich was worried about some of what I describe
- 3:56Speaker 6: as pedantic originalism. We're worried about parsing these terms of
- 4:00Speaker 6: such fine precision. So I think that argument was the
- 4:03Speaker 6: lead argument from Trump's attorneys, but they didn't end up
- 4:07Speaker 6: relying on it too heavily. To oral argument. Now that's said,
- 4:09Speaker 6: Justice Jackson spent a significant amount of time at argument
- 4:12Speaker 6: suggests that the history at the time shows that the
- 4:17Speaker 6: Reconstruction Congress was really worried about state offices and about
- 4:21Speaker 6: state factions of ex Confederates gathering together and retaking parts
- 4:26Speaker 6: of the government. And if that's the case, the fact
- 4:29Speaker 6: that the word president is not listed among those offices
- 4:32Speaker 6: suggest that the Framers were not terribly worried about the
- 4:37Speaker 6: presidency at all. And if that's the case, the inference
- 4:39Speaker 6: should be the presidency was just not of their concern
- 4:41Speaker 6: and therefore not one of those offices covered. So while
- 4:44Speaker 6: she spoke up about that proposition, it's not clear how
- 4:46Speaker 6: many other justices would agree with her, and it didn't
- 4:48Speaker 6: get as much attention as some of the other issues
- 4:50Speaker 6: at argument.
- 4:51Speaker 3: What about kicking this over to Congress and saying that
- 4:55Speaker 3: Congress has to enforce Section three?
- 4:58Speaker 6: Yeah, there were versions of the congressional enforcement question that
- 5:01Speaker 6: came up, and there's Justice Kavanaugh seemed to lean most
- 5:04Speaker 6: strongly into an eighteen sixty nine decision called Griffin's Case,
- 5:08Speaker 6: which involved then Chief Justice Chase, who was riding circuit
- 5:13Speaker 6: at the lower court, issuing a decision effectively saying Congress
- 5:17Speaker 6: needs to do this, and nobody else can do this
- 5:19Speaker 6: without congressional involvement. It's not clear there was a lot
- 5:21Speaker 6: of support for that. Justicet of my own particular pushed
- 5:24Speaker 6: back on that argument, but there was broad consensus on
- 5:27Speaker 6: a different dimension, and several justices expressed concern that one
- 5:31Speaker 6: state could enforce this in a presidential election without some
- 5:35Speaker 6: kind of federal guidance or federal oversight. That's not necessarily
- 5:38Speaker 6: clear what that would look like, but I think the
- 5:40Speaker 6: concern that states could go about this on their own
- 5:42Speaker 6: in a presidential election, to keep a candidate off and
- 5:45Speaker 6: again have an effective exclusion that could carry over to
- 5:48Speaker 6: other states was problematic and a reason why the uniquely
- 5:52Speaker 6: national office the presidency required perhaps unique congressional legislation to
- 5:57Speaker 6: implement it in such a case.
- 5:58Speaker 3: Just as Kavanaugh gave of what I'll call a little
- 6:01Speaker 3: speech about democracy and the importance of not disenfranchising voters,
- 6:08Speaker 3: do you think that underlies all this and it's really
- 6:11Speaker 3: more a political consideration that the Court doesn't want to
- 6:15Speaker 3: be the one to say, no, this person can't be
- 6:19Speaker 3: on the ballot.
- 6:20Speaker 6: Yeah, I mean, there are some radiations of this to
- 6:23Speaker 6: think about. There's one level, which is, in the case
- 6:26Speaker 6: of ambiguity or uncertainty, how confident do we have to
- 6:29Speaker 6: be about this result before we're going to exclude somebody,
- 6:32Speaker 6: And I think somebody like Justice Jackson was leaning into
- 6:34Speaker 6: that argument with this office at the United States point.
- 6:37Speaker 6: If the concerns were about state offices, the presidency is
- 6:40Speaker 6: not listed in that way in favor of allowing the
- 6:42Speaker 6: candidate's name on the ballot. Sousa's course, such and some others. Yeah,
- 6:45Speaker 6: tod question a little bit more broadly about the consequences
- 6:49Speaker 6: of this decision, And I think the consequences could be
- 6:52Speaker 6: viewed in those terms of the people making a decision
- 6:55Speaker 6: that people voting, but also in terms of the very
- 6:57Speaker 6: real concerns about the Court's involvement in the case. And
- 7:01Speaker 6: while it wasn't as overt in these terms, I think
- 7:04Speaker 6: there is a concern from the Court that if it's
- 7:06Speaker 6: asked on a regular basis to adjudicate the qualifications and
- 7:10Speaker 6: candidacies of presidential candidates, it puts itself in a very
- 7:13Speaker 6: difficult spot and it finds its healthy arbiter of decisions
- 7:16Speaker 6: that we typically think are left to the political process.
- 7:18Speaker 6: So there was an undercurrent of allowing the political process
- 7:22Speaker 6: to play out. But I think part of that was
- 7:24Speaker 6: more skepticism that these states had done the right thing
- 7:28Speaker 6: or that the Supreme Court was the right place to
- 7:30Speaker 6: do it, rather than maybe just some affirmation that states
- 7:33Speaker 6: should be able to do.
- 7:33Speaker 7: What they want.
- 7:34Speaker 3: Do you think there's a fear sort of like echoes
- 7:37Speaker 3: of Bush v. Gore, we don't want to be in
- 7:39Speaker 3: that position.
- 7:40Speaker 6: Yeah, I think there are echoes of that. I think,
- 7:42Speaker 6: to be sure, I think the Court, since Bush Versus
- 7:45Speaker 6: was certainly acutely aware of the consequences of being involved
- 7:49Speaker 6: in decisions like this now Prolroda Supreme Court's decision puts
- 7:53Speaker 6: the United States Supreme Court in a difficult place, right
- 7:56Speaker 6: if it acts or if it doesn't act, it finds
- 7:59Speaker 6: it so on one side of a political question or another.
- 8:02Speaker 6: So that's why I think I was somewhat heartened to
- 8:04Speaker 6: see the Supreme Court justices coalescing around arguments with one
- 8:07Speaker 6: another and supporting a sort of singular output. So I
- 8:11Speaker 6: think there's going to be a lot of effort to
- 8:13Speaker 6: coalesce around a clear decision from the Court the percurium,
- 8:17Speaker 6: ideally unanimous decision that resolves the issue at least for
- 8:21Speaker 6: presidential candidates or some set of federal candidates, and moves
- 8:25Speaker 6: on to say that the political process needs to resolve it.
- 8:27Speaker 6: And that might be unsatisfying to some, but I think
- 8:30Speaker 6: at the top level, I think the Court is aware
- 8:32Speaker 6: that it doesn't want to be viewed as overtly partisan,
- 8:35Speaker 6: and whatever it can do to mitigate that, it will
- 8:37Speaker 6: definitely try to do.
- 8:38Speaker 3: So do you have any idea what path they'll choose
- 8:41Speaker 3: to get there?
- 8:42Speaker 6: Yeah, I think the goal will probably be something along
- 8:45Speaker 6: the lines of this notion that the presidency is a
- 8:49Speaker 6: unique national office. The Court has its precedence saying that
- 8:53Speaker 6: states have less of an interest in patrolling the ballot
- 8:56Speaker 6: for those kinds of candidacies because it is a unique
- 8:59Speaker 6: national office. That there are concerns about how states administer
- 9:04Speaker 6: this inconsistently, or that if there's one state that moves first,
- 9:08Speaker 6: how does that affect other states? And those practical consequences
- 9:12Speaker 6: are significant enough to suggest that Congress needs to be
- 9:15Speaker 6: the one to provide guidance and rules in this context.
- 9:18Speaker 6: At least it comes to Section three at the fourteenth Amendment.
- 9:21Speaker 6: So it will be I think something that is a
- 9:23Speaker 6: little bit more election law heavy than Section three heavy,
- 9:27Speaker 6: as the case has been mostly litigated, but something that
- 9:30Speaker 6: reflects these concerns that presidential elections are unique and require
- 9:34Speaker 6: some kind of federal guidance before they can be regulated
- 9:36Speaker 6: in the way that Colorado tried to do here.
- 9:39Speaker 3: I think there was only one question about what's at
- 9:43Speaker 3: the heart of this Colorado case. Did Donald Trump engage
- 9:47Speaker 3: in an insurrection? And after an hour, Justice Katanji Brown
- 9:51Speaker 3: Jackson pose that question, and then it sort of disappeared,
- 9:55Speaker 3: never more to be heard.
- 9:57Speaker 6: Yes, I think there was very little appetite on the
- 10:00Speaker 6: court today to be talking about engaging in insurrection about
- 10:03Speaker 6: the First Amendment issues. There was almost no discussion about
- 10:07Speaker 6: those topics. There was some brief discussions about what insurrection was.
- 10:11Speaker 6: Trump's attorney did mention that, you know, it was enous
- 10:14Speaker 6: acts from an ale acts committed that day. So some
- 10:16Speaker 6: condemnation there about whether it was an insurrection, and they
- 10:20Speaker 6: kind of stipulated admitted that they were willing to say
- 10:22Speaker 6: that at least for purposes of argument today. And so
- 10:25Speaker 6: the court did avoid some of those really thorny in
- 10:28Speaker 6: the weeds fact intensive or disputed questions, focusing instead on
- 10:33Speaker 6: a variety of other topics that they could coalesce around.
- 10:35Speaker 6: And so while it might have surprised people that they
- 10:38Speaker 6: think a lot more attention, it was not terribly surprising
- 10:40Speaker 6: to me. I think that was the issue that they
- 10:42Speaker 6: wanted to avoid the most of all messy facts with
- 10:44Speaker 6: deep political consequences. If they can decide on pure law,
- 10:48Speaker 6: all the better for them.
- 10:49Speaker 3: There was a sort of a warning from the attorney
- 10:52Speaker 3: for the Colorado voters. He said, if Colorado loses this case,
- 10:56Speaker 3: the issue could come back with a vengeance. If Trump
- 10:59Speaker 3: was a left president and then members of Congress have
- 11:03Speaker 3: to decide whether to let him take office. Did the
- 11:05Speaker 3: Supreme Court is it going to leave that open that question?
- 11:10Speaker 6: It seems like they might. You know, the question of
- 11:12Speaker 6: whether or not Congress on January sixth, twenty twenty five
- 11:15Speaker 6: will count electoral votes or try to object to them
- 11:17Speaker 6: and refuse to count them is certainly an open one.
- 11:20Speaker 6: And then there's the separate question about what happens after
- 11:22Speaker 6: Trump takes office. Will there be lawsuits to challenge his
- 11:25Speaker 6: official action? And if so, what did those challenges look like? So,
- 11:29Speaker 6: if the court moves in the direction that we anticipate
- 11:32Speaker 6: it's moving, it seems that it's more a valid access
- 11:35Speaker 6: issue and less an issue of disqualification Intersection three. But
- 11:40Speaker 6: it does leave the door open for another day the
- 11:42Speaker 6: resolve these questions. Now that said, there are significant challenges
- 11:47Speaker 6: in the future. For one, Trump has to win the
- 11:49Speaker 6: election and that might not happen. And if he does,
- 11:52Speaker 6: you know, are there other vehicles or means to challenge
- 11:54Speaker 6: this issue and set it up? Then, depending on how
- 11:56Speaker 6: the Supreme Court writes the opinion, if it puts the
- 11:59Speaker 6: ball much more more clearly in Congress's court, there might
- 12:02Speaker 6: not be other avenues to do it without some affirmative
- 12:05Speaker 6: Congressional action. And of course, if he is the president,
- 12:07Speaker 6: I doubt he would sign a new legislation that would
- 12:10Speaker 6: authorize additional investigation or inquiry into his conduct. So there
- 12:14Speaker 6: are some open questions that arise, and I think we'll
- 12:17Speaker 6: see how much risk the Supreme Court is willing to
- 12:20Speaker 6: tolerate in this case after.
- 12:21Speaker 3: This argument, and how the justices seem to be fleeing
- 12:26Speaker 3: for the exits. In my opinion, do you think that
- 12:30Speaker 3: when Trump makes a request for sirchiai from the DC
- 12:34Speaker 3: Circuit Court decision rejecting his claims of presidential immunity, do
- 12:38Speaker 3: you think that they'll refuse to take that case or
- 12:41Speaker 3: they'll be four hardy souls who want to address that issue.
- 12:45Speaker 6: Yeah, I don't know, you know if I'm thinking what
- 12:48Speaker 6: the court might do here, and maybe I'm wrong, But
- 12:51Speaker 6: you issue a decision in a couple of weeks on
- 12:53Speaker 6: this case saying Trump can appear on the ballot, and
- 12:55Speaker 6: the same day you deny sircerari in the community case
- 12:58Speaker 6: and essentially say the Circuit opinion stands and he can
- 13:02Speaker 6: be subject to criminal prosecution. So in both cases, the
- 13:05Speaker 6: court would be letting the political and legal process play
- 13:08Speaker 6: out without needing to step in. Now, I don't know
- 13:11Speaker 6: if they're going to do that. There might be some
- 13:13Speaker 6: interest in addressing the immunity issues at some level from
- 13:16Speaker 6: some justices in the court, but that is kind of
- 13:19Speaker 6: a wait and see approach. We don't quite know how
- 13:21Speaker 6: these two cases might relate to one another, but there
- 13:23Speaker 6: definitely seem to be linked to some degree, and at.
- 13:26Speaker 3: Least we'll find out pretty quickly in Supreme Court time.
- 13:29Speaker 3: That is Thanks so much for your insights, Derek. That's
- 13:32Speaker 3: Professor Derek Muller of Notre Dame Law School. Coming up next,
- 13:35Speaker 3: more analysis of the arguments. This is Bloomberg. This is
- 13:42Speaker 3: Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio. The Supreme
- 13:47Speaker 3: Court seems poised to reject attempts to kick former President
- 13:51Speaker 3: Donald Trump off the twenty twenty four presidential ballot, with
- 13:55Speaker 3: conservative and liberal justices in a parent agreement in a
- 13:59Speaker 3: case it puts them at the heart of a presidential election.
- 14:03Speaker 3: Joining me to discuss the oral arguments today is Professor
- 14:06Speaker 3: Harold Krant of the Chicago Kent College of Law. After
- 14:09Speaker 3: hearing the oral arguments, do you have any doubt that
- 14:11Speaker 3: the justices are going to rule against Colorado? Here?
- 14:15Speaker 8: The Justices will rule against Colorado. The only question is
- 14:18Speaker 8: on which ground. And obviously the two and a half
- 14:21Speaker 8: hour argument covered a great deal of territory. But I
- 14:24Speaker 8: think at the end of the day, justices on both
- 14:27Speaker 8: sides of the I convinced that they wanted no part
- 14:31Speaker 8: of this case in terms of trying to figure out
- 14:33Speaker 8: what Section three of the Fourteenth Amendment means through its
- 14:37Speaker 8: disqualification for insurrection, and they will definitely find a way
- 14:41Speaker 8: so as to keep Trump on the ballot for now.
- 14:45Speaker 3: Do you think they want no part of it? Because
- 14:48Speaker 3: there's been a lot of controversy around the court, and
- 14:51Speaker 3: with the Bush vy Gore decision, people are still criticizing
- 14:54Speaker 3: the Court about that. I mean, do you think that
- 14:56Speaker 3: they just want to stay away from this even if
- 14:58Speaker 3: it is a decision that O when the Supreme Court
- 15:00Speaker 3: can make.
- 15:01Speaker 8: It may be a little bit of the residual concern
- 15:05Speaker 8: of the court reputation that foundered in the wake of
- 15:07Speaker 8: bushbersus Core, But I think there's a different concern here,
- 15:10Speaker 8: and that is Section three to fourteenth amendment doesn't really
- 15:14Speaker 8: clarify what's supposed to happen, what is the process that's
- 15:17Speaker 8: supposed to take place? And justices kept hammering Colorado's attorneys
- 15:22Speaker 8: by saying, you know, how much process is due. Shouldn't
- 15:26Speaker 8: be the voters who get to decide who remains on
- 15:29Speaker 8: the ballot. What if there's a retaliation and people try
- 15:34Speaker 8: to throw up Democrats off the ballots as well, And
- 15:38Speaker 8: at the end of the day, one state could have
- 15:41Speaker 8: the power to wreck the mechanism for a fair vote
- 15:45Speaker 8: amongst the entire nation. So at the end of the day,
- 15:48Speaker 8: the court was saying, look, maybe Congress needs to suggest
- 15:52Speaker 8: what the procedure is, but we don't want one or
- 15:55Speaker 8: two or three states to take away a vote from
- 15:59Speaker 8: the entire country. For a national office, state office, that's different,
- 16:03Speaker 8: But for a national office, we need some kind of
- 16:05Speaker 8: orally mechanism to determine who remains on the ballot.
- 16:10Speaker 3: I mean that seems not like a legal argument. That
- 16:13Speaker 3: seems like a political argument. You know, we don't want
- 16:16Speaker 3: to take this away from the people. We don't want
- 16:18Speaker 3: chaos at the ballot. I mean, that's what it sounds like.
- 16:22Speaker 8: It is partially a policy slash political argument, but it's
- 16:27Speaker 8: also grounded in what they called the kind of implicit
- 16:31Speaker 8: preclusion of the Section three of fourteenth, meaning that Congress
- 16:36Speaker 8: really has to set the ground rules. And the one
- 16:40Speaker 8: way to sort of see this more legally is that
- 16:43Speaker 8: in Section three, Congress has the power to reinstate someone
- 16:50Speaker 8: who's disqualified by a two thirds vote. How could they
- 16:53Speaker 8: exercise this power if a state would bar the individual
- 16:59Speaker 8: from the ballot first, because then the issue would never
- 17:01Speaker 8: arise and Congress wouldn't have this power to in fact
- 17:05Speaker 8: give a pardon or to allow someone who committed insurrections.
- 17:09Speaker 7: To still be seated.
- 17:11Speaker 8: So it's in their view section three years about giving
- 17:15Speaker 8: Congress the ultimate authority. And so I didn't want a
- 17:18Speaker 8: particular state, or two states or four states to take
- 17:21Speaker 8: actions that would deprive Congress of this ultimate power of
- 17:25Speaker 8: seating somebody who otherwise would be excluded because of the
- 17:28Speaker 8: participation in the insurrection.
- 17:31Speaker 3: We know that the Special Councils is not trying him
- 17:34Speaker 3: for insurrection.
- 17:35Speaker 8: No he's not, and which suggests under the theory of
- 17:39Speaker 8: the court that this case should not ever ridden because
- 17:45Speaker 8: the only mechanism currently in place for disqualifying a candidate
- 17:51Speaker 8: other than age and residency and so forth is being
- 17:57Speaker 8: tried and convicted for insurrection, and that's not going to happen.
- 18:01Speaker 2: I know.
- 18:01Speaker 3: This is the first time they're interpreting this provision. They
- 18:05Speaker 3: refer to a case from eighteen sixty nine, Griffin's case,
- 18:09Speaker 3: and that was from a federal court in Virginia, not
- 18:12Speaker 3: even the Supreme Court. Is that the best they could.
- 18:14Speaker 8: Do so that case was by Chase would become the
- 18:20Speaker 8: Chief Justice. And it was right in the aftermath of
- 18:24Speaker 8: the fourteenth Amendment. And so the idea being that this
- 18:28Speaker 8: is the contemporary original meaning of the fourteenth Amendment somehow
- 18:33Speaker 8: flowed into that case. Of course, it's even more ironic
- 18:36Speaker 8: because then the Chief Justice changed his mind later in
- 18:39Speaker 8: the subsequent decision. I don't think at the end of
- 18:41Speaker 8: the day that's going to be dispositive, though there was
- 18:44Speaker 8: clearly a lot of discussion of the case, because it
- 18:47Speaker 8: gives the tone of the assumption that Congress will set
- 18:51Speaker 8: the rules, and Congress did for years. Congress had a
- 18:53Speaker 8: provision that an Enforcement Acts that was in place from
- 18:57Speaker 8: eighteen seventy to nineteen forty eight, which did provide mechanism
- 19:00Speaker 8: for challenging the legitimacy of someone who was elected but
- 19:04Speaker 8: get an insurrectionist. No one knew and no one suggested
- 19:08Speaker 8: that or a argument why that was repealed in nineteen
- 19:10Speaker 8: forty eight, So it remains a mystery. But again I
- 19:14Speaker 8: think that that's the mechanism that the Court was searching for.
- 19:18Speaker 8: That is, it's too dangerous to allow fifty states to
- 19:22Speaker 8: come up with different views, and what's the Court supposed
- 19:25Speaker 8: to do with that? Rather, instead there should be an
- 19:28Speaker 8: orderly determination. Some people think there there already was an
- 19:31Speaker 8: orderly determination if Congress did that through the January sixth hearings,
- 19:36Speaker 8: but to the Court that it was not a determination
- 19:39Speaker 8: per se that President Trump engation insurrection and therefore should
- 19:44Speaker 8: be disqualified.
- 19:45Speaker 3: Do you have any idea what likely route they'll take
- 19:48Speaker 3: to get to their decision.
- 19:49Speaker 8: From listening from the case, there are some justices who
- 19:52Speaker 8: were concerned about whether the president was even covered under
- 19:57Speaker 8: the Section three or fourteenth Mendment. I think the strong
- 19:59Speaker 8: argument is that he is covered, but there was discussion
- 20:02Speaker 8: of that.
- 20:02Speaker 7: I think more than justices.
- 20:04Speaker 8: Seem to agree, however, that it's up to Congress. You
- 20:08Speaker 8: can call it a implicit preemption. You can call it
- 20:11Speaker 8: a kind of decision that the amendment is not self executing,
- 20:16Speaker 8: at least not by the states, and some kind of
- 20:19Speaker 8: theory along those lines will, I think, attract a majority
- 20:22Speaker 8: in the case.
- 20:23Speaker 3: Do you think that a majority is what the chief
- 20:26Speaker 3: wants or the chief wants unanimity.
- 20:30Speaker 8: Certainly the chief wants unanimity. It's possible that there will
- 20:34Speaker 8: be unanimity, not on whether the president is covered. I
- 20:38Speaker 8: think there certainly is going to be a split on
- 20:40Speaker 8: that issue, but there may be unanimity on the idea
- 20:42Speaker 8: that the states are not the place in which this
- 20:47Speaker 8: qualification should start. Rather, it has to be a different
- 20:50Speaker 8: kind of process, one that is only so far been
- 20:54Speaker 8: delineated by the criminal statute that still remains, which punishes insurrection.
- 20:59Speaker 3: So what do you think about a more than two
- 21:01Speaker 3: hour argument about Donald Trump being an insurrectionist at least
- 21:06Speaker 3: under Colorado's Supreme Court, and yet only one question on
- 21:11Speaker 3: whether he was an insurrectionist.
- 21:13Speaker 8: I didn't think the court wanted to touch the question
- 21:16Speaker 8: of whether exident Trump was an insurrectionist or not, and
- 21:19Speaker 8: they certainly steered clear from that throughout almost the entire argument.
- 21:24Speaker 2: You know, that.
- 21:24Speaker 8: Obviously has been the issue that has attracted tension nationally.
- 21:28Speaker 8: But I think the really the more important determination here
- 21:32Speaker 8: is what about that process?
- 21:35Speaker 7: You know, how is.
- 21:36Speaker 8: It that one state confines he's an insurrectionist, another state
- 21:39Speaker 8: confined that he's not. And then even more so, we
- 21:42Speaker 8: do have at least a definition of what insurrection is,
- 21:45Speaker 8: but we have no definition of what giving aid and
- 21:48Speaker 8: comfort to the enemy is, which is also in Section
- 21:51Speaker 8: three of the fourteenth Amendment. And so how would the
- 21:53Speaker 8: court had the tools to figure out whether someone has
- 21:56Speaker 8: given aid or comfort to the enemies? It truly is,
- 22:00Speaker 8: And I think the recognition is the Amendments just not
- 22:03Speaker 8: very well written. And what do you do to try
- 22:07Speaker 8: to have a functioning government when you have part of
- 22:10Speaker 8: the fourteenth Amendment which is cryptic and probably not thought
- 22:14Speaker 8: out very well. We know everybody needed it to get
- 22:17Speaker 8: rid of those Confederates who remained in state offices, but
- 22:21Speaker 8: beyond that, it's a little difficult to know what the
- 22:24Speaker 8: entire picture was or design, and maybe it was just
- 22:26Speaker 8: a faulty designed, you know, at the get go, And
- 22:29Speaker 8: then put that puts the court in the difficult situation
- 22:32Speaker 8: of either trying to salvage it section three or putting
- 22:36Speaker 8: it in Congress's lap, and it seems that what they're
- 22:39Speaker 8: going to do is put the issue in Congress's lap
- 22:41Speaker 8: as opposed to trying to create an interpretation of the
- 22:45Speaker 8: amendment that is workable.
- 22:48Speaker 3: There's a theory that the court may try to balance
- 22:51Speaker 3: things out by really against Colorado here, but then not
- 22:56Speaker 3: taking on the case on President Trump's claims of presidential immunity,
- 23:03Speaker 3: sort of balancing it out.
- 23:05Speaker 8: I don't know if the Court's going to take that will.
- 23:07Speaker 8: I assume there'll be a certain petition filed within a
- 23:09Speaker 8: matter of days, as the DC Circuit indicated in the
- 23:12Speaker 8: roadmap that it gave to President Trump's lawyers. But I
- 23:16Speaker 8: do predict that if they do grant Sir serai, they
- 23:19Speaker 8: would rule against the president. Presidential immunity should exist from
- 23:24Speaker 8: some crimes, but not for the charges, at least of
- 23:28Speaker 8: sedition conspiring to overthrow the government. There needs to be
- 23:32Speaker 8: a balance there between where the president should maintain his
- 23:37Speaker 8: freedom from judicial second guessing. But I think the court
- 23:41Speaker 8: perhaps didn't reason it adequately, but clearly stated that any
- 23:45Speaker 8: kind of balancing tests would suggest it's more important to
- 23:48Speaker 8: have criminal process here than to claim immunity. And I
- 23:53Speaker 8: think the court would agree with that. They'll probably slightly
- 23:56Speaker 8: different reasoning.
- 23:57Speaker 3: So before I let you go, I have to mention
- 23:59Speaker 3: one thing. Justice Clarence Thomas did not recuse himself even
- 24:04Speaker 3: though his wife has been connected in many ways to January.
- 24:08Speaker 8: Sixth, and he was actually very active in the questioning
- 24:12Speaker 8: today as well. He's maintained and fantastically that whatever his
- 24:17Speaker 8: wife did is not a reflection of his views and
- 24:20Speaker 8: that he can maintain an unbiased perspective despite the fact
- 24:24Speaker 8: that she participated in events that led to January sixth,
- 24:29Speaker 8: and his presence says a testamitude the firmness of his belief.
- 24:33Speaker 3: Thanks so much for being on the show. Hal that's
- 24:35Speaker 3: Professor Harold Krent of a Chicago Kent College of Law.
- 24:38Speaker 3: Coming up next on the Bloomberg Law Show, we'll take
- 24:41Speaker 3: a close look at the historic verdict in Michigan, the
- 24:44Speaker 3: first time a mother has been found guilty of a
- 24:46Speaker 3: mass school shooting committed by her son. Will that verdict
- 24:50Speaker 3: open the floodgates to other parents being prosecuted for the
- 24:54Speaker 3: criminal acts their children commit. I'm June Grosso and you're
- 24:57Speaker 3: listening to Bloomberg. It was an unpreced dented verdict in Michigan.
- 25:02Speaker 3: For the first time, a mother was found guilty of
- 25:04Speaker 3: the maschool shooting committed by her son. A jury convicted
- 25:08Speaker 3: Jennifer Crumbley of four counts of involuntary manslaughter for each
- 25:12Speaker 3: of the students her teenage son murdered in a shooting
- 25:15Speaker 3: rampage at Oxford High School in twenty twenty one. The
- 25:20Speaker 3: question now is does this case provide a blueprint for
- 25:23Speaker 3: other prosecutors to bring criminal charges against parents for the
- 25:28Speaker 3: crimes their children commit. Joining me is Echo Yanka, a
- 25:31Speaker 3: professor at the University of Michigan Law School. In a
- 25:34Speaker 3: real sense, was it Jennifer Crumbley's parenting that was on
- 25:39Speaker 3: trial here?
- 25:40Speaker 7: I think the prosecution painted a picture of her as
- 25:42Speaker 7: an indifferent, callous parent, one who is more interested in
- 25:47Speaker 7: her courses and hobbies, her extramarital affairs than getting her
- 25:52Speaker 7: child to help that he explicitly seemed to be seeking.
- 25:56Speaker 7: But of course the prosecution knew that being a bad
- 25:58Speaker 7: parent is not by itself illegal, and having that be
- 26:02Speaker 7: the only line of argument would be not just legally insufficient,
- 26:06Speaker 7: but probably unpalatable, And so they really made a point
- 26:10Speaker 7: that it's not just that she is a bad parent.
- 26:12Speaker 7: It's that she had opportunity after opportunity to do something
- 26:16Speaker 7: to avoid these killings, and that even given a million
- 26:19Speaker 7: little moments where she could have saved those lives, she
- 26:22Speaker 7: did nothing.
- 26:24Speaker 3: The prosecution had so much evidence against Crumbly, from her
- 26:28Speaker 3: son's text that she didn't answer, to journal entries, to
- 26:31Speaker 3: videos of her at the shooting range with her son.
- 26:35Speaker 3: What was the best evidence in your mind?
- 26:38Speaker 7: I think you put your finger exactly on it that.
- 26:40Speaker 7: As the prosecution tried to hammer home, it just seems
- 26:43Speaker 7: like there were a million moments where she could have
- 26:45Speaker 7: done something given him the help he needs. There's a moment,
- 26:48Speaker 7: for example, when he is caught searching online about ammunition
- 26:53Speaker 7: and she texts back, you know, I don't care if
- 26:55Speaker 7: you do this, just don't get caught laugh out loud,
- 26:57Speaker 7: you know, Lol. But if you ask me the single moment,
- 27:01Speaker 7: the single moment that was the most powerful, when I
- 27:04Speaker 7: talked to friends, when I debate with legal colleagues, and
- 27:07Speaker 7: frankly just around the dinner table, I would say the
- 27:10Speaker 7: fact that the school called her in that very day
- 27:13Speaker 7: when Ethan is drawing pictures of violence and death, and
- 27:17Speaker 7: they asked the Crumbleys to take even home, and depending
- 27:21Speaker 7: on who you believe, they either refuse or together they
- 27:24Speaker 7: decide not to do it, but in any case they
- 27:26Speaker 7: walk out of their knowing that he had a weapon.
- 27:29Speaker 3: The four person told NBC that she was swayed by
- 27:33Speaker 3: the belief that Crumbley was the last person who had
- 27:36Speaker 3: custody of the gun and that therefore she was responsible
- 27:41Speaker 3: for it. And she said the picture of her handling
- 27:43Speaker 3: the gun last was pretty damning for me. And I'm
- 27:46Speaker 3: wondering if that is faulty reasoning. I mean, can you
- 27:50Speaker 3: really draw a conclusion of guilt from the last information
- 27:53Speaker 3: that the prosecution has?
- 27:55Speaker 7: So I feel torn about that. I'll say why. On
- 27:58Speaker 7: the one hand, part of the background of because part
- 28:03Speaker 7: of the overall theory of her involunteer manslaughter rest on
- 28:06Speaker 7: her negligence, and that rests on the idea that an
- 28:10Speaker 7: ordinary person would have known that it was going to
- 28:12Speaker 7: do this, An ordinary person should have seen that this
- 28:15Speaker 7: danger existed. And so the fact that the parents knew
- 28:19Speaker 7: that there was a weapon, that the parents didn't tell
- 28:21Speaker 7: the school, that the parents, as you say, in some sense,
- 28:24Speaker 7: could have for example, locked up the guns. All those
- 28:27Speaker 7: things are in the mix, But I do worry about
- 28:30Speaker 7: a jury foreman. You know, if I were a defense
- 28:33Speaker 7: were on appeal, you might think such reasoning assumes evidence
- 28:38Speaker 7: not in fact, and it's not clear that it is
- 28:40Speaker 7: the legally relevant standard. So I think I understand the
- 28:45Speaker 7: feeling behind it, but I worry that if that sentence
- 28:49Speaker 7: is literally true, you know, it's going to give the
- 28:51Speaker 7: defense something to hold on.
- 28:53Speaker 3: Crumbly took the stand in her own defense. As you know,
- 28:56Speaker 3: often when that happens, the whole focus of the jury
- 28:59Speaker 3: is on the credibility of the defendant, and she didn't
- 29:03Speaker 3: come across well on the stand. The jury for person said,
- 29:07Speaker 3: once we went into deliberation, it became clear that she
- 29:09Speaker 3: was not a super reliable witness in this case.
- 29:13Speaker 7: Look, her testimony was not great. I thought the worst
- 29:17Speaker 7: moment was when she was asked what she would do
- 29:20Speaker 7: differently today, and her answer was nothing right. I understand
- 29:24Speaker 7: the impulse for her answers, I just didn't do anything wrong,
- 29:26Speaker 7: But when you're staring at a day where four children
- 29:30Speaker 7: were killed and seven more were injured, that answer just
- 29:34Speaker 7: feels callous. So I definitely worried about that. That being said, look,
- 29:39Speaker 7: the defense had a great legal principle on which they
- 29:41Speaker 7: were lying, but they had a really tough task because
- 29:44Speaker 7: the prosecution had really painted her is callous, bordering on monstrous,
- 29:48Speaker 7: and I think the defense felt a lot of pressure
- 29:51Speaker 7: to humanize her. The only image that the jurors had
- 29:55Speaker 7: in their minds was of a parent who just didn't
- 29:57Speaker 7: care about her son and her son's danger to others,
- 30:00Speaker 7: and so I understand why they felt strategically like they
- 30:03Speaker 7: had to do something to claw back an image of
- 30:06Speaker 7: a human mother who is doing her best.
- 30:08Speaker 3: He said, the defense had a good theory. Tell me
- 30:11Speaker 3: what the theory is.
- 30:13Speaker 7: Well, the defense I think had two prongs. The second
- 30:16Speaker 7: wave just talked about that look, I mean, there's a
- 30:18Speaker 7: kind of human instinct. This is a mother doing our best.
- 30:21Speaker 7: And moreover, you're saying a reasonable person could have foreseen this.
- 30:24Speaker 7: You're asking a mother to foresee something that mothers might
- 30:28Speaker 7: think is bordering on unthinkable. You're asking a mom to
- 30:31Speaker 7: foresee that her son will be monstrous, will be a
- 30:34Speaker 7: mass shooter. And so that has a kind of I
- 30:37Speaker 7: wouldn't say it's the very point of the legal theory,
- 30:39Speaker 7: but it has a kind of diffuse tug on a
- 30:41Speaker 7: juror's heart that suly requiring a mother to see that
- 30:45Speaker 7: is a strain. But the core of the defense theory
- 30:48Speaker 7: really is the first year legal principle, the one that
- 30:52Speaker 7: you learn when you're starting law school that you are
- 30:55Speaker 7: just not responsible for the actions of another that when
- 30:58Speaker 7: somebody who's a responsible acts it severs the causal change.
- 31:02Speaker 7: And I think the defense really thought at the end
- 31:04Speaker 7: of the day that not only as a legal matter,
- 31:08Speaker 7: but as a social and moral matter that has a
- 31:10Speaker 7: lot of weight in people's minds.
- 31:12Speaker 3: Do you think that this case provides a blueprint to
- 31:15Speaker 3: other prosecutors and we'll see more parents being charged for
- 31:20Speaker 3: the criminal acts of their children.
- 31:23Speaker 7: Yeah, this is a question I've been asked a lot,
- 31:24Speaker 7: and I, you know, I struggle to answer it well.
- 31:28Speaker 7: On the one hand, as we've discussed, this case has
- 31:30Speaker 7: such degregious facts, such heartrending facts where moment after moment,
- 31:36Speaker 7: things were going wrong, and to be honest, you know,
- 31:40Speaker 7: perhaps perhaps it's just an extraordinary case of extraordinary facts,
- 31:44Speaker 7: you know, as lawyers say, the kind of case that
- 31:46Speaker 7: should be confined to its facts. On the other hand,
- 31:49Speaker 7: you know the life of the law's precedent, lawyers argue
- 31:52Speaker 7: by analogy, and prosecutors certainly do too. And once a
- 31:56Speaker 7: prosecutor has this precedent in the world, it's impossible to
- 31:59Speaker 7: imagine that they won't use it. And further, as I've said,
- 32:02Speaker 7: as I've said before, and I think is really important,
- 32:04Speaker 7: prosecutors can use these things in ways that are much
- 32:07Speaker 7: less spectacular and visible than a Crumbley case. Right, So
- 32:11Speaker 7: in the Crumbley case, the whole nation, indeed the whole
- 32:14Speaker 7: world is interesting because the facts are so visceral, but
- 32:17Speaker 7: we won't see the case. Or the prosecutor has a
- 32:19Speaker 7: parent who thinks they have a legal defense and says, look,
- 32:23Speaker 7: I'm going to offer you three years, but if you
- 32:25Speaker 7: don't accept this flea bargain, I'm going to prosecute you
- 32:28Speaker 7: for fifteen or twenty. And if that person pleads out,
- 32:31Speaker 7: they may be giving up on their legal defenses. They
- 32:35Speaker 7: may serve many years in jail, and it will be
- 32:38Speaker 7: quite invisible, it will be quite under the radar. And
- 32:40Speaker 7: I worry about those cases.
- 32:42Speaker 3: As far as appellate issues, you mentioned one, do you
- 32:45Speaker 3: see any you know, obvious appellet issues.
- 32:48Speaker 7: There are going to be some, right, I mean, I
- 32:50Speaker 7: do think the format of the jury speaking. You know,
- 32:54Speaker 7: there's a reason injuries deliberate in secret, so you know
- 32:58Speaker 7: that that statement that she thought Jennifer Tumbling was last
- 33:01Speaker 7: to handle the gun might be worrying. They're always going
- 33:05Speaker 7: to be issues on which the judge ruled, in particular
- 33:08Speaker 7: some of the evidence the judge let in, some of
- 33:10Speaker 7: the really really gut wrenching photographic evidence. Truly, some part
- 33:14Speaker 7: of the appeal will be that bad evidence was more
- 33:16Speaker 7: prejudicial than broken. You know, the argument will be something like,
- 33:19Speaker 7: everybody knows that Ethan committed this horrible act. There was
- 33:23Speaker 7: no need to see the result of it, right, There
- 33:26Speaker 7: was no there's no real addition by seeing the pictures.
- 33:30Speaker 7: It just emotionally, it's like the jurors. But I think
- 33:33Speaker 7: ultimately the thing on which you appeal is the legal principle.
- 33:37Speaker 7: I mean, if this goes all the way up to
- 33:39Speaker 7: the Michigan Supreme Court, what you're going to be doing
- 33:41Speaker 7: is asking the Supreme Court to reinforce the legal norm
- 33:45Speaker 7: that one just can't be responsible for another person's act.
- 33:49Speaker 7: That parents who are you know, the hypothetic will be
- 33:52Speaker 7: parents who are doing their best but are afraid that
- 33:54Speaker 7: their children are tempted to violence. At some point they
- 33:58Speaker 7: get to say I've done what I can. His actions
- 34:01Speaker 7: are his.
- 34:02Speaker 3: Now, what about the judge let in a broad range
- 34:05Speaker 3: of evidence, from the time she spent with her horses
- 34:09Speaker 3: to an extramarital affair.
- 34:11Speaker 7: Yeah, I mean some of that I do think will
- 34:14Speaker 7: be taken up on appeal, in particular, as I said,
- 34:16Speaker 7: the photos of the killing will be taken up on appeal,
- 34:19Speaker 7: maybe the horses, although that stuff doesn't seem you know,
- 34:23Speaker 7: the question is there is It's sort of just a
- 34:25Speaker 7: diffuse character assassination. The extra manal affair is an interesting one.
- 34:29Speaker 7: The judge actually initially ruled that it could not come in,
- 34:32Speaker 7: but it was the defense counsel that eventually decided they
- 34:35Speaker 7: wanted to push the questioning. And even though perhaps that
- 34:39Speaker 7: conversation should have been had outside of the earshot of
- 34:41Speaker 7: the jury, the defense council ultimately invited that evidence in.
- 34:45Speaker 7: So I don't see any real problematic issue there. The
- 34:49Speaker 7: defense council waived the ejection.
- 34:51Speaker 3: The father's trial is coming up. Will he learn from
- 34:54Speaker 3: what happened here? Can he use different strategies, you know,
- 34:59Speaker 3: change things up or his trial, or maybe even try
- 35:02Speaker 3: to plead out.
- 35:03Speaker 7: Yeah, it's a great question, and I'm you know, my
- 35:06Speaker 7: mind is spinning about that too. Obviously, the parents are
- 35:09Speaker 7: the ones in the most pain, and Jennifer Crumley was convicted,
- 35:13Speaker 7: but other than those people, nobody had a worse day
- 35:16Speaker 7: than James Crumley. Right now, I would say every case
- 35:19Speaker 7: is different. You know, this case was supposed to be
- 35:21Speaker 7: tried together until really almost the last minute where they
- 35:25Speaker 7: decided to separate the cases. And presumably that's because each
- 35:29Speaker 7: of them thinks that or at least one of them
- 35:32Speaker 7: thought that there were more damning facts towards the other. Right,
- 35:34Speaker 7: So you saw Jennifer argue that it was the father, James,
- 35:38Speaker 7: who bought the god and he is the one in
- 35:39Speaker 7: charge of blocking it up. And presumably his team will
- 35:42Speaker 7: have arguments about why she's more culpable, and most importantly,
- 35:45Speaker 7: every jury is different. Right, So, but it seems to
- 35:48Speaker 7: me the most obviously that will happened given a conviction
- 35:50Speaker 7: is that his team will move or change up venue.
- 35:53Speaker 7: They'll just think this poisons It was already such an
- 35:56Speaker 7: emotional and difficult case, so visible that the conviction is
- 36:01Speaker 7: just too poisonous for them. And then a part of
- 36:03Speaker 7: me really does wonder if, at this late hour, if
- 36:06Speaker 7: they really would reach out for a plea bargain, and
- 36:09Speaker 7: if Franklin's the prosecution would think there's anything to gain
- 36:11Speaker 7: after they've already done all the work to take the
- 36:13Speaker 7: case to trial.
- 36:14Speaker 3: Once thanks so much for being on the show. That's echo, Yanka,
- 36:18Speaker 3: a professor at the University of Michigan School of Law.
- 36:21Speaker 3: Jennifer Crombley will be sentenced in April. Her husband will
- 36:25Speaker 3: go on trial later this month. Ethan Cromblee is serving
- 36:28Speaker 3: a sentence of life in prison after pleading guilty in
- 36:32Speaker 3: the case. And that's it for this edition of the
- 36:35Speaker 3: Bloomberg Law Podcast. Remember you can always get the latest
- 36:38Speaker 3: legal news by subscribing and listening to the show on
- 36:41Speaker 3: Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast,
- 36:45Speaker 3: slash Law. I'm June Grosso and this is Bloomberg