Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Self-Efficacy, Locus of Control & the Big Five: Personality at Work
Transcript
- 0:00So picture this. It is a freezing January morning
- 0:03in Washington, D .C. Oh, I can already feel the
- 0:05cold. Right. And commuters are just pouring into
- 0:08the metro station, heads down, rushing to work.
- 0:11Just a standard chaotic rush hour. Exactly. And
- 0:14there is this young guy in jeans and a baseball
- 0:17cap standing against a wall. He pulls out a violin
- 0:20and he just starts playing these incredibly intricate
- 0:24classical pieces. When people just walk by, I'm
- 0:27assuming. Thousands of people walk right past
- 0:29him. I mean, a few toss in some loose change,
- 0:32sure, but after 45 minutes he packs up. He's
- 0:35made like $32. Which is just wild considering
- 0:38who it actually was. Yeah because what those
- 0:40commuters didn't realize was that the young guy
- 0:42was Joshua Bell. Like one of the greatest violin
- 0:45virtuosos alive right now. Exactly and he was
- 0:48playing a Stradivarius worth three and a half
- 0:50million dollars. I mean two days earlier he had
- 0:52sold out a theater in Boston where the absolute
- 0:55cheapest seats were a hundred bucks. That is
- 0:58just such a perfect example of what we are getting
- 1:00into today. It really is. So welcome to the Psychology
- 1:03Undergrad. I'm your host and I'm here with our
- 1:06resident expert. Hey everyone. We are so excited
- 1:08you're joining us for this session. Think of
- 1:10us as your study buddies as we unpack a massive
- 1:13stack of notes today. Yes. Today we are doing
- 1:15a deep dive into the underlying mechanics of
- 1:18organizational behavior, individual differences,
- 1:23and well the staggering flaws in human perception.
- 1:26Basically we're looking at what makes people
- 1:28tick in the workplace. Right. And that Joshua
- 1:30Bell experiment is the perfect distillation of
- 1:33selective perception. Because they just didn't
- 1:36expect to hear world -class music in a subway.
- 1:38Exactly. The commuter's brains literally filtered
- 1:41out world -class genius because they didn't expect
- 1:44to find it next to a turnstile. And what's really
- 1:47fascinating here is that this exact same cognitive
- 1:49filtering dictates everything that happens in
- 1:51the modern workplace. Right, because we all just
- 1:54assume we are objective evaluators of talent.
- 1:56Oh, totally. We think we can perfectly judge
- 1:58character and performance. But in reality, our
- 2:01brains are just constantly constructing these
- 2:03convenient fictions. Okay, let's unpack this.
- 2:06Because if you are listening and you think this
- 2:08is just some abstract theory, you need to know
- 2:11about... Guy Kawasaki. Oh yeah, the legendary
- 2:14Silicon Valley venture capitalist. Right. He
- 2:17has publicly stated that his biggest college
- 2:19regret was not taking organizational behavior
- 2:21and social psychology. Wow. Not finance, not
- 2:25engineering. Nope. He realized far too late that
- 2:28the math and the financial modeling, that was
- 2:30actually the easy part. Yeah, the real existential
- 2:32threat to any business is misunderstanding the
- 2:35people running it. Exactly. So by joining this
- 2:38deep dive, you are literally already one step
- 2:40ahead of a billionaire. I love that. And to avoid
- 2:43that trap Kawasaki fell into, we really have
- 2:46to start at the foundational building blocks
- 2:48of human motivation, which are our values. And
- 2:51looking at the source material, it points directly
- 2:53to the Rokeach value survey as the ultimate framework
- 2:56here. Yeah, Milton Rokeach developed this brilliant
- 2:59methodology. He broke human priorities into two
- 3:02distinct categories based on 36 core values.
- 3:04Right, the terminal values and the instrumental
- 3:06values. Exactly. So terminal values are basically
- 3:10the ultimate endpoints you are striving for in
- 3:13your life. Like achieving a world at peace or
- 3:17social recognition, right? Yeah, or inner harmony,
- 3:20true friendship. Those are your final destinations.
- 3:22I always like to visualize this as a GPS system.
- 3:26The terminal value is the destination you actually
- 3:28type in before you put the car in drive. That
- 3:31is a great way to think about it. And then the
- 3:33instrumental values are the specific routes you
- 3:36choose, the speed limits you obey, and the driving
- 3:40etiquette you follow to actually get there. Right,
- 3:42because instrumental values are your acceptable
- 3:44modes of conduct. Things like being inherently
- 3:47honest or relentlessly ambitious may be strictly
- 3:50obedient. Yeah, you really cannot understand
- 3:53a person's behavior until you understand the
- 3:55route they believe is necessary to reach their
- 3:57destination. And our notes show this causes huge
- 4:00problems at work. Oh, absolutely. If we connect
- 4:02this to the bigger picture, it explains why deep
- 4:05-seated conflicts arise even when two people
- 4:07share the exact same goal. Like two founders
- 4:10wanting to build a legacy company. Yes. They
- 4:13both share that terminal value. But if founder
- 4:16A's instrumental value is cutthroat ambition
- 4:18and founder B's is compassionate collaboration,
- 4:22I mean, that company will just tear itself apart
- 4:24from the inside. It's so true. And where do these
- 4:28values even come from? Well, the sources highlight
- 4:30how these frameworks are heavily inherited from
- 4:32early family dynamics. But crucially, they come
- 4:36from religious and moral teachings, too. That
- 4:38makes sense, like a specific faith dictating
- 4:40the rules. Exactly. A religion might dictate
- 4:43that forgiveness and absolute obedience are the
- 4:46non -negotiable instrumental values you need
- 4:48to achieve a terminal value, like eternal salvation.
- 4:51Or spiritual peace. And you see these frameworks
- 4:54shift on a macro level across generations, too.
- 4:56Oh, the generational divide is huge here. Yeah,
- 4:59the data shows baby boomers often organize their
- 5:01instrumental values around loyalty to the organization.
- 5:04They view their career as central to their identity.
- 5:07Right. Whereas GenXers watched all that corporate
- 5:09downsizing happen. Exactly. So they shifted their
- 5:12instrumental values toward individualism and
- 5:15pragmatism. They prioritize quick promotions
- 5:17and work -life balance over blind company loyalty.
- 5:21So values establish our direction, but personality
- 5:24dictates how we travel. And when we analyze workplace
- 5:28behavior, the gold standard is the big five personality
- 5:32traits. Ocean acronym, right? Yes. So for anyone
- 5:35listening, a great memory trick is to use the
- 5:37acronym OCEAN. That stands for openness, conscientiousness,
- 5:41extroversion, agreeableness, and neuroticism.
- 5:45And we aren't just looking at this as a simple
- 5:47categorization. No. We're looking at the cognitive
- 5:50and emotional mechanics behind each of those
- 5:52traits. And the most crucial finding in the literature
- 5:54here is about conscientiousness. It is basically
- 5:56the single trait that uniformly predicts high
- 5:58performance across almost all occupations. Which
- 6:01makes perfect sense when you think about it.
- 6:03Yeah. It's essentially the ability to delay gratification,
- 6:06maintain focus, and honor commitments even when
- 6:09your motivation drops. It's the grit factor.
- 6:11Right. But I want to push back on how we culturally
- 6:15value some of these other traits, specifically
- 6:18agreeableness. OK, let's hear it. Well, the assumption
- 6:21is always that you want a highly agreeable workforce.
- 6:24I mean, who wants to work with a jerk, right?
- 6:26Right. It feels like the ultimate green flag
- 6:28in a job interview. Exactly. So is agreeableness
- 6:31always a good thing? It seems intuitive that
- 6:34it would be, but high agreeableness actually
- 6:37masks a massive organizational vulnerability.
- 6:40Wait, really? How so? Well. Highly agreeable
- 6:44individuals possess a deep psychological need
- 6:46for social harmony. They are terrified of conflict.
- 6:49Oh, so they just avoid arguing at all costs.
- 6:52Yes. So when a process is broken or a manager
- 6:55is making a disastrous decision, the highly agreeable
- 6:58employee will simply nod along to preserve the
- 7:00peace. They actively suppress constructive change
- 7:03oriented communication. Exactly. Because innovation
- 7:06requires friction and agreeable people avoid
- 7:09friction like the plague. They will politely
- 7:11organize the deck chairs while the Titanic goes
- 7:13down. That is a brutally accurate way to put
- 7:15it. And it also comes down to the specific demands
- 7:18of the role. Like if you are hiring a defense
- 7:20attorney or a union negotiator, high agreeableness
- 7:23is a total liability. You don't want a nice person.
- 7:26You want a pit bull. Exactly. You need someone
- 7:28who is energized by conflict, not paralyzed by
- 7:31it. And this brings up a concept known as person
- 7:34-job fit. It operates right alongside person
- 7:36organization fit. So matching the company culture
- 7:39versus matching the actual skills of the role?
- 7:42Precisely. You need your traits to match the
- 7:44daily demands of the work and your values to
- 7:47match the culture of the company. But wait, a
- 7:49lot of companies don't even use the big five,
- 7:51right? They use the Myers -Briggs. Oh, the MBTI.
- 7:54Yes, Fortune 100 companies spend millions deploying
- 7:57the MBTI for team building retreats. Which our
- 7:59sources flag as a major issue if it crosses over
- 8:03into actual hiring. It is a massive red flag.
- 8:05Yeah. The MBTI forces people into one of 16 rigid
- 8:09types, like you are either an ESTJ or an INFP.
- 8:13It completely ignores the reality that human
- 8:15traits exist on a fluid bell curve. Right. It
- 8:18measures types instead of traits on a spectrum.
- 8:21Well, it's fine for generating conversations
- 8:23about communication styles. Using it for hiring
- 8:26is essentially corporate astrology. Corporate
- 8:28astrology. I love that. It just lacks the predictive
- 8:31validity required for high stakes decisions.
- 8:34And the danger of relying on static personality
- 8:36types is that it ignores the interactionist perspective
- 8:39too. Yes. Because human behavior is not a fixed
- 8:43output. It is a dynamic equation. Right. Behavior
- 8:46is a function of the person interacting with
- 8:48the situation. Exactly. Like a notoriously introverted
- 8:52software engineer might sit silently through
- 8:55every single staff meeting. But if you place
- 8:57them in a small group, debugging a critical system
- 9:01failure that they are deeply passionate about.
- 9:03Right. They might suddenly take aggressive command
- 9:05of the room. The situation unlocks latent aspects
- 9:09of their personality. And this ties right back
- 9:11into Guy Kawasaki's hiring strategy. He argues
- 9:14that a resilient organization must be an ecosystem
- 9:16of contrasting strengths. Yeah. He warns that
- 9:19mediocre managers hire less talented people just
- 9:22to protect their own fragile egos. Or they hire
- 9:24people who just mirror their own personalities.
- 9:27Exactly. A truly secure leader audits their own
- 9:30psychological blind spots and intentionally hires
- 9:32people who are better than themselves to complement
- 9:35those weaknesses. They engineer a situation where
- 9:38diverse traits can actually interact. And that
- 9:41level of self -awareness is intimately tied to
- 9:44how we perceive our own agency. This is a concept
- 9:47known as locus of control. Right, the degree
- 9:49to which an individual believes they are the
- 9:51master of their own fate. Right, so an internal
- 9:53locus of control means you believe your choices,
- 9:57your effort, and your competence dictate your
- 9:59outcomes. Which typically makes for very successful
- 10:02entrepreneurs. Yes, but the flip side is the
- 10:06external locus of control. That's where you believe
- 10:09your life is dictated by luck, systemic forces,
- 10:12or a higher power. And this is where the research
- 10:14uncovers a rather dark behavioral link. It really
- 10:17does. The sources reveal a strong correlation
- 10:20between an external locus of control and a higher
- 10:23propensity for unethical behavior in the workplace.
- 10:25Wait, really? Believing in luck makes you more
- 10:27unethical. Well, the underlying psychology is
- 10:30basically a form of moral disengagement. If you
- 10:33fundamentally believe that external forces are
- 10:36driving the bus, your sense of personal accountability
- 10:39diminishes. So an employee who thinks the system
- 10:41is rigged against them anyway feels less cognitive
- 10:45dissonance when cutting corners. Exactly. They
- 10:47offshore the moral responsibility to the environment.
- 10:50Okay, here's where it gets really interesting.
- 10:52We've been talking about the traits that make
- 10:54up who we are, but perception is the study of
- 10:57how we actively construct and often completely
- 11:01botch our understanding of everyone else. Yes,
- 11:05our brains are not objective cameras. They are
- 11:08highly subjective filters. I always think of
- 11:11human perception as like an Instagram filter.
- 11:14You aren't seeing the raw image. You are seeing
- 11:16it filtered through your background, your expectations,
- 11:19and your emotions. That's a great analogy. Yeah.
- 11:21And that filtering is deeply rooted in our visual
- 11:24processing. I mean, consider that classic contrast
- 11:26illusion from the text. Oh, the one with the
- 11:28circles. Yeah. If you draw a circle on a page
- 11:30and surround it with tiny circles, your brain
- 11:33processes the center circle as being massive.
- 11:35But if you take that exact same center circle
- 11:37and surround it with gigantic circles, it suddenly
- 11:40appears tiny. Exactly. The objective reality
- 11:44of the ink on the page hasn't changed at all.
- 11:47But our brains rely entirely on contextual contrast
- 11:50to assign meaning. We even hallucinate data that
- 11:53isn't there, right? Like seeing a white triangle
- 11:56that isn't actually drawn just because the angles
- 11:58are hinted at. We extrapolate to create order
- 12:01out of chaos. And we do the exact same thing
- 12:04to people. Which brings us right back to Joshua
- 12:06Bell on the subway. Selective perception. We
- 12:09only see what we expect to see. Commuters expect
- 12:13subway busters to use struggling amateurs. So
- 12:16they literally couldn't hear the brilliance.
- 12:18And in a corporate environment, this selective
- 12:20filtering breeds devastating self -fulfilling
- 12:22prophecies. Oh, completely. For instance, a senior
- 12:25executive might harbor a stereotype that young
- 12:28employees are just entitled and lazy. So because
- 12:30of that biased perception, the executive unconsciously
- 12:34assigns the young employee menial, boring tasks.
- 12:37Right. They withhold all the complex, interesting
- 12:39projects. And naturally, the young employee becomes
- 12:41bored, disengaged, and starts goofing off on
- 12:44their phone. Proving the executive right. The
- 12:46executive observes this and says, aha, I knew
- 12:50it. This generation is utterly lazy. But the
- 12:54executive's initial prejudice actually manufactured
- 12:56the exact behavior they were complaining about.
- 12:58It's a vicious cycle. But what happens when reality
- 13:01aggressively confronts us? Like, what happens
- 13:04when that executive meets a young professional
- 13:06who is just a relentless, undeniable workaholic
- 13:10and totally shatters the stereotype? You would
- 13:13assume the brain updates the software, right?
- 13:14Yeah, that they abandon the prejudice. But the
- 13:17human ego refuses to admit a core processing
- 13:20error. Instead, we use a psychological defense
- 13:23mechanism called subcategorizing. Subcategorizing?
- 13:27How does that work? Well, let's say someone holds
- 13:29a deep bias that women are naturally accommodating
- 13:31and submissive. Then they get hired by a female
- 13:33CEO who is fierce, commanding, and ruthless.
- 13:37Okay, so their stereotype is busted. Not to them.
- 13:39Instead of dismantling their sexist worldview,
- 13:43their brain build a tiny conceptual fence around
- 13:45this one individual. They label her a career
- 13:48woman or an exception to the rule. Leaving the
- 13:51overarching prejudice completely intact. Exactly.
- 13:54We perform incredible mental gymnastics to protect
- 13:57our initial assessments, which is why first impressions
- 14:00are so dangerously permanent. Because they act
- 14:02almost independently of subsequent evidence,
- 14:04right? Yeah. Imagine meeting a project manager
- 14:07named Anne. And during that first meeting, she
- 14:10is dismissive, cuts you off, and rushes out of
- 14:13the room. Your brain instantly labels Anne as
- 14:15a rude, toxic person. Right. Now let's say a
- 14:18week later, HR mentions that on the exact day
- 14:21you met Anne, she had just found out her mother
- 14:24was rushed to the hospital. Logically, you now
- 14:26have the context. You should wipe the slate clean.
- 14:29But psychologically, the anchor refuses to budge.
- 14:31You don't think, oh, Anne was just stressed.
- 14:34You think Anne is a toxic person and her mother
- 14:36is sick. It just adds to the label instead of
- 14:38erasing it. That is wild. And that stubborn anchoring
- 14:41effect heavily influences attribution theory.
- 14:44OK, so attributions are the causal explanations
- 14:46we give for behavior, right? Exactly. We're always
- 14:49acting as amateur detectives, trying to decide
- 14:52if a behavior is due to an internal cause, like
- 14:55their personality, or an external cause, like
- 14:58the situation. And it depends on clues like consensus,
- 15:02distinctiveness, and consistency. But we are
- 15:04terrible hypocritical detectives because of the
- 15:07self -serving bias. Oh, the self -serving bias
- 15:10is everywhere. If I fail a finance exam, it's
- 15:12because the test was unfair. That's an external
- 15:15attribution. But if I pass, it's because I'm
- 15:18a genius, which is internal. We weaponize these
- 15:21attributions to shield our self -esteem. And
- 15:24the stakes escalate dramatically when we apply
- 15:26them to others. Right. Our sources detail a really
- 15:29profound study on workplace harassment here.
- 15:31Yes. It highlights the incredibly dark side of
- 15:34our internal biases. Researchers found that when
- 15:37observers evaluated a harassment claim, if they
- 15:40attributed responsibility to the victim, basically
- 15:42making an internal attribution, they were significantly
- 15:45less likely to punish the harasser. The way we
- 15:48psychologically frame cause and effect literally
- 15:50alters our moral compass. If we default to blaming
- 15:53the individual, we systematically excuse the
- 15:56toxic environment. And these default settings
- 15:58are actually deeply ingrained cultural operating
- 16:01systems. Right. Taking this global, Geert Hofstede's
- 16:04landmark research shows how entire nations navigate
- 16:07individualism, power distance, and uncertainty
- 16:11avoidance. Yeah. But the truly revolutionary
- 16:13insight is uncovering the evolutionary drivers
- 16:16behind these cultural traits. Like, why are some
- 16:19cultures naturally more introverted? Well, the
- 16:22data points to the historical prevalence of infectious
- 16:24diseases and pathogens. This blew my mind when
- 16:27I read it. If your ancestors lived in a region
- 16:30constantly ravaged by deadly pathogens, engaging
- 16:33with strangers or being highly extroverted was
- 16:36basically a death sentence. Exactly. The societies
- 16:39that survived were the ones that developed a
- 16:41behavioral immune system. So they enforced introversion
- 16:44and strict hygiene norms to literally stay alive.
- 16:47Culture is just a collective survival strategy
- 16:49echoing through centuries. And that strategy
- 16:52fundamentally alters how the human eye scans
- 16:54the world. Wait, visual perception changes too.
- 16:57Yes. Western cultures, which are highly individualistic,
- 17:00process visual data in isolation. If a Westerner
- 17:03wants to determine someone's emotion, they look
- 17:06exclusively at that one person's face. But in
- 17:08collectivistic Asian cultures, they focus on
- 17:11context. They will actually scan the emotions
- 17:14of the surrounding group to understand how the
- 17:16individual is feeling. It's a completely different
- 17:19neurological pathway for establishing reality.
- 17:22If we connect this to the bigger picture, it
- 17:24is a pretty bleak view of human judgment. We
- 17:27are biased, selective, and culturally constrained.
- 17:31So how can companies ever hire the right people?
- 17:34The corporate answer is to remove the human brain
- 17:36entirely using data and automation. But early
- 17:40attempts were disastrous. Oh yeah, pre -employment
- 17:43personality testing is super controversial. Mostly
- 17:45because they only explain like 10 to 15 percent
- 17:48of the variance in job performance. Cognitive
- 17:51ability is actually a way stronger predictor.
- 17:53Plus there is massive legal exposure. The textbook
- 17:56mentions how Renta Center got in huge trouble
- 17:59with the ADA for using the MMPI to screen employees.
- 18:02That's a clinical psychiatric tool, right? Yes,
- 18:05designed to diagnose severe mental illness. You
- 18:07cannot use that for retail screening. And can't
- 18:09people just fake the answers anyway to look good?
- 18:12They absolutely do. Which is why companies like
- 18:14Kronos, who acquired the Unicrew platform, took
- 18:17a different approach. Right. They use automated
- 18:20software for companies like Burger King and Costco.
- 18:22Yeah. They screen hourly workers based on massive
- 18:25databases of past employees. Applicants just
- 18:28get a color code, right? Red for no, yellow for
- 18:31caution, and green for hire immediately. Exactly.
- 18:34And to answer your question about faking, It's
- 18:37actually really hard to game this system because
- 18:39the ideal profile is counterintuitive. Oh, because
- 18:43human intuition about what makes a good employee
- 18:45is statistically wrong. Yes. For example, a candidate
- 18:49applying for a sales role might try to fake extreme
- 18:53extroversion. assuming that's what the company
- 18:55wants. Because our stereotype is that salespeople
- 18:58are loud and gregarious. But the algorithm's
- 19:00historical data showed the most successful salespeople
- 19:03weren't highly extroverted. They just had a high
- 19:05passion for the product. So by trying to fake
- 19:07it, the candidate actually flags themselves as
- 19:10a bad fit. Exactly. The machine bypasses our
- 19:13perceptual blind spots. So what does this all
- 19:16mean? We have surfed the ocean of personality,
- 19:19we've learned how situations alter behavior,
- 19:22and we exposed how our brains selectively filter
- 19:25reality. And we looked at how software is trying
- 19:27to fix all of this. Right. So as a listener,
- 19:30remember to be mindful of your own self -serving
- 19:32biases at work, and remember the sheer power
- 19:35of a first impression in your next interview.
- 19:37Definitely. But I want to leave you with one
- 19:40final thought to mull over, building on that
- 19:43Kronos case. Okay, let's hear it. If human perception
- 19:45is inherently flawed, and we are relying on historical
- 19:49data to train this hiring software to find the
- 19:52ideal candidate, well, aren't we just hard -coding
- 19:55our past human biases into these machines? If
- 19:58an algorithm only hires the type of person we
- 20:00historically deemed successful, will we ever
- 20:03truly overcome our blind spots, or are we just
- 20:05automating them? Oh, wow. That is a terrifying
- 20:08paradox to end on. As we build systems to escape
- 20:11our flawed psychology, we might just be locking
- 20:13ourselves inside it. Well, thank you so much
- 20:16for joining us for this deep dive. I'm your host,
- 20:19alongside our resident expert, and we will see
- 20:20you next time on The Psychology Undergrad.