Latest / In God We Trusted / Why Do Good People Still Defend Communism?
Transcript
- 0:02[music]
- 0:11Welcome to God We Trusted. I'm your
- 0:13host, Will. I'm here alongside Sam. Sam,
- 0:15what are we talking about today? Today,
- 0:16we're going to be talking about
- 0:17communism and how this has been an idea
- 0:20that for the last century and a half or
- 0:22so has really appealed to people and
- 0:24everybody comes to it and they're like,
- 0:25"Oh, that sounds really great." But in
- 0:27practice, every single time that it's
- 0:29tried, it has been atrocious. It's a
- 0:32blight on humanity. It causes
- 0:34unbelievable suffering and death
- 0:35everywhere it's tried. And so we want to
- 0:37talk about it just to kind of teach and
- 0:39and from a biblical perspective why this
- 0:41is such a bad idea. Yeah. It's one of
- 0:43those theories that should have died
- 0:44when every time it happens it's awful,
- 0:46but all of a sudden every college course
- 0:48is like, "Hey, what about this?" And all
- 0:50the young people are like, "Maybe."
- 0:52Yeah. And I mean you can you can
- 0:54understand how this appeals to like a
- 0:56workingclass people. You know, for
- 0:58example, today we live in a generation
- 1:00where younger people are coming up,
- 1:02housing seems unaffordable. People are
- 1:05looking at life and they're like, man, a
- 1:0640-hour work week and you just slave
- 1:08away for a company and you know, you
- 1:10have no life of your own. And you feel
- 1:12the oppression of having to go to work
- 1:14and make a living in a world that feels
- 1:16set up against you. And so you can
- 1:18imagine a revolutionary who comes along
- 1:20and says, "You know what? Let's just get
- 1:21rid of all that." You know, communism
- 1:23will take all the money from the wealthy
- 1:25and will distribute it around and nobody
- 1:27will own anything anymore. There will be
- 1:29no more businesses to oppress you. The
- 1:32oligarchs will wipe them out. Everybody
- 1:34will just share and it'll be wonderful
- 1:36and everybody will have enough food and
- 1:38everybody will, you know, participate in
- 1:40the success of the country. And
- 1:42everybody's like, "Yeah, that sounds
- 1:44really, really good."
- 1:47until it's in practice and you find out
- 1:50that communism does not take the poor
- 1:52and lift them up. It takes everybody and
- 1:54tears them down. So where did communism
- 1:56really start? Where did it come from?
- 1:57Who who came up with this idea? So Karl
- 1:59Marx who wrote the communist manifesto
- 2:02in 1848's the first guy who comes along
- 2:04and he is hitting at all of these kinds
- 2:07of sentiments. Right? So in the 1800s
- 2:10you've got the industrial revolution,
- 2:12you've got labor laws and all that stuff
- 2:13that start coming out and Marx is coming
- 2:15in Europe. He's in Germany and he's
- 2:17like, "The working class is being
- 2:19treated like garbage. Let's start a
- 2:22revolution. We'll and we'll build them
- 2:24up and we'll take over." And and he had
- 2:26this idea of communism, which he defines
- 2:29as the abolition of private property,
- 2:32which means you don't have your money,
- 2:34he doesn't have his money, she doesn't
- 2:36have her money, no private businesses,
- 2:38everything is owned together, right? And
- 2:41he's like, "That'll work great. We'll
- 2:43have a temporary period where, you know,
- 2:45the government has to, of course, take
- 2:47from everybody to distribute it out,
- 2:49make sure that everything's okay. And
- 2:50that's of course it that's going to be
- 2:52pretty oppressive and it's going to be a
- 2:54revolution that's violent. And he owned
- 2:56all that. But he said, "The abolition of
- 2:58private property is therefore the
- 3:00complete emancipation of all human
- 3:02senses and qualities. You're no longer
- 3:04going to be enslaved to materialism.
- 3:06we'll be able to have a brotherhood
- 3:08where we just exist together and work in
- 3:10harmony and and like you hear that and
- 3:13you're like man that that sounds okay.
- 3:16And so what marks except for the
- 3:18bloodshed and all of that that part but
- 3:21he says you know the government will
- 3:22take over the government will educate
- 3:24the children collectively the government
- 3:26will be the one that drives everything.
- 3:30And Marx who is is not a believer. In
- 3:33fact, he says communism begins where
- 3:36atheism begins. He he recognized you
- 3:39have to get rid of religion for
- 3:40communism to work. Which makes sense.
- 3:42Why? Because God gives us all individual
- 3:45value and freedom. And that communism
- 3:47just takes it away.
- 3:47>> That's right. Religion and especially
- 3:50the Bible comes along and it gives you
- 3:52property rights and it gives you the imo
- 3:54day and it says that God is the highest
- 3:57authority and that you owe your
- 3:58allegiance to him. Well, for communism
- 4:00to work, guess who has to be the highest
- 4:02authority? The government. The state.
- 4:04And so, anytime you see a dictator, one
- 4:06of the first things they always do is to
- 4:08come in and try to wipe out religion.
- 4:10You see that in every single communist
- 4:12regime that's ever been tried, they come
- 4:14and they they stamp out religion. And
- 4:17the reason for that is they they can't
- 4:18have a competitor that's higher than the
- 4:20government's authority. And then before
- 4:22you know it, in every single communist
- 4:25experiment that's tried, they say, "You
- 4:27know what? This is going to be great.
- 4:28we're going to tear down from the the
- 4:30people who are the oppressors, right?
- 4:32So, communism comes and says, "Oh,
- 4:34there's a victim and a villain class.
- 4:36There's there's those people who are
- 4:37trying to hold from you and then there's
- 4:39this underclass that's being exploited
- 4:42and the exploited need to overthrow the
- 4:44oppressors and it's like after that
- 4:47everything will just be rosy and
- 4:49wonderful." You know, it's the same
- 4:50sentiment that drove the French
- 4:52Revolution that ended in crazy bloodshed
- 4:54and political instability. Well, every
- 4:56time that kind of thing is tried, the
- 4:58same thing happens again and again. And
- 5:00so
- 5:02>> in 1917, you find the first communist
- 5:04revolution in Russia, which is the
- 5:06Bolevik revolution, where they come in
- 5:09and you have Vladimir Lenon and his
- 5:10underlings, Joseph Stalin and others,
- 5:12and they're like, you know, workers of
- 5:14the world, you know, bring them
- 5:15together. What happens? Lenon goes on a
- 5:18red terror campaign where six million
- 5:20people die. his p his his successor
- 5:23Stalin comes and kills 20 million people
- 5:26and it's all with a utopian vision right
- 5:28that's so appealing like we'll get rid
- 5:30of suffering we'll get rid of all the
- 5:32slavery we'll get rid of all the
- 5:33exploitation
- 5:35>> and then they just become the ones who
- 5:37choose the winners and losers and so
- 5:39when Stalin comes in and he's killing 20
- 5:41million people and he's like well you
- 5:42know Ukraine has a lot of food over
- 5:44there uh we'll just take from them and
- 5:46then he starves the Ukraine and millions
- 5:48of them die under his leadership in the
- 5:5140s when China's like, "Oh, communism
- 5:53seems like a great idea."
- 5:56And you have Mao who comes along. Guess
- 5:57what the death toll is under Mao
- 5:59bringing this utopian vision to the
- 6:02world.
- 6:02>> I mean, dozens of millions, right?
- 6:04>> Yeah. 60 million people die. And so like
- 6:08and you go and you look at Pulpot and
- 6:10Cambodia and all the places where
- 6:12communism is tried, Cuba, other you see
- 6:15massive massive suffering where whoever
- 6:18has the power drives everyone into the
- 6:22dirt. Anyone who stands against them,
- 6:23anyone who speaks up against suffering
- 6:26or exploitation or government abuses,
- 6:28they just disappear. They're gone. They
- 6:30go to the goologs. They they're put in
- 6:32camps or they're just straight up
- 6:34murdered. You find this in every single
- 6:36communist regime that's ever been tried.
- 6:40And here's the deal, like if you were to
- 6:41step back and you were to say, "Man, but
- 6:44but doesn't the ethic of communism sound
- 6:46good?" I mean, apart from the atheism
- 6:47thing, right, which they require atheism
- 6:49because they're
- 6:50>> they're trying to exploit power, but
- 6:53doesn't it sound good? Like, you know,
- 6:55C, we're all going to share, you know, a
- 6:57lot of people who are will try to say,
- 6:59"Oh, Christianity is pro-communism. Look
- 7:01at Acts two. They shared everything in
- 7:03common. Well, in Acts two, they're doing
- 7:06it voluntarily out of a out of an ethic
- 7:08of love that's like, "Hey, if you have a
- 7:09need, I want to meet it."
- 7:10>> Yeah. I'm going to fill it personally
- 7:12with my private choice.
- 7:13>> That's right. That's right. I'm going to
- 7:15sell it and I'm going to give from the
- 7:17heart, not because of guns pointed at
- 7:19me. Right. Well, what happens with
- 7:20communism is it comes with this ethic
- 7:22that says, "Hey, you can trust the
- 7:24benevolent government to institute this
- 7:26idea of sharing that's going to go
- 7:28across, you know, class lines and and
- 7:30bring everybody together." What's the
- 7:32problem with that? Communism
- 7:36runs under the assumption that humanity
- 7:38is good. Yeah.
- 7:40>> And can be trusted and that when you
- 7:42give them power that they will use it
- 7:44for good. And if there's anything that
- 7:46political history can show you over
- 7:48thousands of years is what happens when
- 7:51you give humanity unchecked power. Only
- 7:54bad.
- 7:55>> They will abuse it. They will absolutely
- 7:57abuse it. Like even and when you go to
- 7:59the Bible, the most trusted figure, the
- 8:02man after God's own heart, right? Here's
- 8:03King David. What does he do when he gets
- 8:06power? All of a sudden, he becomes
- 8:07corrupted. He starts exploiting people.
- 8:09He puts Uriah to death. He takes
- 8:11advantage of Ba Sheba. You look at
- 8:13Solomon and his writings. And when he
- 8:16becomes more and more powerful, he
- 8:18begins to exploit people to where when
- 8:20he leaves as king, when he dies, the
- 8:22people are like, "Oh, we feel so
- 8:24oppressed. Please give us rest." So like
- 8:27every single king, no matter even if
- 8:30they're the righteous ones, every single
- 8:32king that gets power struggles with
- 8:35corrupting power and the brilliance of
- 8:37where America comes from and and the
- 8:39ideas of free markets. America wasn't
- 8:42started by saying, "Oh yeah, we're
- 8:44capitalism. Just, you know, go run and
- 8:45do whatever you want to each other." It
- 8:47was founded under the idea that humanity
- 8:50is pretty corrupt. Like that's why we
- 8:52have separation of powers because you
- 8:54don't want one person to have much
- 8:55power. And that's why we have checks and
- 8:57balances. And it's why we have term
- 8:59limits for people in office. And it's
- 9:00why we put boundaries around those that
- 9:03are in authority because every time
- 9:05someone's given authority that's
- 9:07unchecked, they'll abuse it. And so with
- 9:10the system of a free market in a
- 9:12constitutional republic, there were
- 9:15boundaries set on it. And capitalism
- 9:17without moral restraint is just as
- 9:20gross. you will exploit other people.
- 9:22You'll drive them into the dirt. It's
- 9:24usually what creates the the impulse to
- 9:26run toward communism is to look at the
- 9:29exploited and to be like, "Hey, that's
- 9:30not fair. That's not good."
- 9:33But the instinct to then be like, "So,
- 9:35we need to take this has always been a
- 9:37crazy thing to me." So, the impulse of
- 9:39communism is, hey, look at how these
- 9:42exploited people are being abused by the
- 9:44power powerful. We need to give more
- 9:47power to the powerful to help them. And
- 9:50it's like what? Like that's the absolute
- 9:53wrong instinct. It's going to result in
- 9:55more misery for the exploited. And it
- 9:58does every time. Communism is a fool's
- 10:01mission. Yeah. The communist equation
- 10:03only works if there's no sin. That's
- 10:05right. Like when you look at the utopian
- 10:06vision, you're like, "Oh man, this would
- 10:07be awesome." But then when you look at
- 10:09our own hearts, it's like, "Man, you
- 10:10give me that kind of power, I don't know
- 10:12what I'm going to do." And that's the
- 10:14same with every human that takes
- 10:16>> regard that. So you mentioned kind of
- 10:17the big two, Russia and China being
- 10:19communist parties, but like are there
- 10:20more?
- 10:21>> Yeah, I mean you go back to, you know,
- 10:231917 and then the 1940s that triggered
- 10:26the Red Scare. Like if you go back and
- 10:28study US history in the late 1940s after
- 10:31World War II, 1950s, you have the Red
- 10:33Scare where the US is looking at
- 10:34communism spreading all over the globe,
- 10:36which is this godless, oppressive
- 10:40scourge on humanity. And today we're
- 10:42like, oh, communism, no big deal. But
- 10:44communism nearly dominated the world and
- 10:47it would have made the world a really
- 10:48dark place. But I want to just let me
- 10:50read to you the number of nations that
- 10:52dabbled in communism and felt the misery
- 10:55of it. Ready? Afghanistan, Albania,
- 10:58Angola, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Bellarus,
- 11:01Benin, Bosnia, Bulgaria, Burma,
- 11:03Cambodia, Cape Verde, Colombia, Congo,
- 11:07Croatia, Cuba, Czech Republic, Estonia.
- 11:09If you notice, I'm going in alphabetical
- 11:10order and we're on E. Ethiopia, Finland,
- 11:13Georgia, East Germany, Granada, Greece,
- 11:16Guinea, Hungary, Capuchia, Kazakhstan,
- 11:20Kyrgystan, Laos, Latvia, Lithuania,
- 11:23Macedonia, Madagascar, Muldova,
- 11:25Mongolia, Montenegro, Mosambique, Nepal,
- 11:27Nicaragua, North Korea, North Vietnam,
- 11:30Peru, Poland, Romania, Slovenia,
- 11:32Somalia, South Vietnam, Spain, Sudan,
- 11:34Tajikiststan, Tibet, Turkmanistan,
- 11:36Ukraine, Usbekiststan, Yemen and
- 11:38Yugoslavia.
- 11:40So, communism was like it was spreading
- 11:44and it was just swallowing up the earth.
- 11:46And you know what it left behind in the
- 11:4720th century? A death toll that exceeds
- 11:50100 million dead.
- 11:53>> Wow.
- 11:54>> Of regimes that killed their own people.
- 11:57>> Of regimes that starved intentionally
- 11:59their own people. Of regimes that
- 12:01outlawed religion everywhere that it was
- 12:03tried. Imprisoning priests and
- 12:05ministers. Outlawing the gospel.
- 12:07Outlawing other religions as well. it
- 12:10was one of the most oppressive systems
- 12:12that's ever been tried. And the fact
- 12:14that this modern generation is like, hm,
- 12:18[clears throat] seems like a good idea
- 12:19is because our history classes are not
- 12:21teaching what communism actually imposed
- 12:24on the world. And we need to get that
- 12:26message out there that this is not this
- 12:28is radioactive. This is not a canister
- 12:31that we want to open again because it
- 12:33unleashes unbelievable suffering. If you
- 12:36care for the poor, communism is what you
- 12:40want to run away from because it
- 12:42unleashes hell on the lower classes.
- 12:45Yeah. When you put it like that, it's
- 12:46crazy that in modern times that we see
- 12:48any popular like cuz how popular is it
- 12:50right now?
- 12:50>> So, there have been a couple of polls
- 12:52and usually what the polls do is they'll
- 12:53mix in communism with socialism which
- 12:56there there is a difference but usually
- 12:57socialism is it's always leading you on.
- 13:01It's an on-ramp toward communism. But
- 13:03there was an article in 2019 published
- 13:06in the Independent and the UK about
- 13:08Americans and it says more than a third
- 13:09of millennials approve of communism.
- 13:12>> So we're north of a third of the
- 13:14millennial generation that approves of
- 13:16communism. In 2017 there was a study
- 13:19done by the Frasier Institute and this
- 13:21one found that more millennials prefer
- 13:23to live in a quote socialist communist
- 13:26or fascist nation than a capitalist one.
- 13:30Wow. In 2018, Gallup for found that more
- 13:33millennials preferred socialism to
- 13:35capitalism. That's terrifying to me. The
- 13:38Economist magazine even ran a headline
- 13:41that was called the rise in socialism.
- 13:43Um, and a 2019 Axio poll found that 61%
- 13:46of younger Gen Z adults have a positive
- 13:50view of socialism. So, when they're
- 13:51asked like, "Hey, do you think that the
- 13:53government should begin taking roles and
- 13:55and regulating or owning businesses or
- 13:57controlling things?" more and more
- 13:59people are like, "Hey, that sounds like
- 14:00a good idea. We should empower the
- 14:02powerful with more power to help the
- 14:05exploited and and the weak and the
- 14:06poor." And it's like, like, learn from
- 14:08history. This doesn't work. It ends
- 14:11badly. It really does every time that
- 14:14you go in that direction, it doesn't end
- 14:15well. And the trouble is, like I'm a
- 14:17millennial. It turns out I just wasn't
- 14:19taught all of those numbers. I wasn't
- 14:21talk about Lenin or Stalin and what they
- 14:23did. It took me until I was 30 and I
- 14:24listen to a real dictator's podcast to
- 14:26figure out what any of these guys even
- 14:28did and all of a sudden you do you see
- 14:29how all that progresses every single
- 14:31time. You're like, "Wait, wait, that's
- 14:32not what I was sold."
- 14:33>> Yeah.
- 14:33>> Like, so in that podcast series, Real
- 14:36Dictators, which you've listened to,
- 14:37right?
- 14:37>> Yeah.
- 14:38>> Isn't it predictable? Like every time
- 14:40the story is like,
- 14:42>> it's the same story again and again as
- 14:43you have a guy who comes along and
- 14:45what's it what what's his selling what's
- 14:46his selling scheme? He comes along and
- 14:48says, "I'll help you.
- 14:50>> I'm I'm going to bring us out of the
- 14:51ashes. bad guys. I can help you get what
- 14:55you want. That's right. And how do how
- 14:56does the story go? Give me the playbook.
- 14:58I mean, here comes the power. All of a
- 15:00sudden, a bunch of people die. Like you
- 15:01said, like even
- 15:02>> every time,
- 15:03>> even Carl Mark's like, "Hey, it's going
- 15:04to be bad for a while." And all of a
- 15:06sudden, everybody who has a voice to
- 15:07stop this is dead. And all of a sudden,
- 15:09people look around now. This guy is
- 15:10absolute power. We can't stop him now.
- 15:12He gets too big. Then eventually war
- 15:14happens and then everything crumbles.
- 15:15>> And what's weird is the wealth doesn't
- 15:17go to the poor. The wealth goes to all
- 15:19of his friends.
- 15:20>> Yeah. Now all of a sudden there's just
- 15:22oligarchs around the communist leader
- 15:23and everybody else is starving. Like
- 15:25look at everywhere. I mean even in
- 15:27modern headlines, look at what's
- 15:28happened to Venezuela that's gone from
- 15:29being one of the wealthiest nations in
- 15:31the Western Hemisphere once they
- 15:33embraced radical socialism. Look at what
- 15:36look at what's happened to them under
- 15:37Hugo Chavez and Maduro. You've got
- 15:39massive oppression, massive starvation.
- 15:41Their nation has fallen into shambles.
- 15:44Look at what happened to Cuba in in the
- 15:461950s. goes from one of the wealthiest
- 15:48nations that was a a tourist spot for
- 15:50everybody. Everybody wanted to go there.
- 15:51Look at what it is now. Look at what's
- 15:53happened to religious freedom in these
- 15:54countries. Like, who would say, "Yes,
- 15:57let's import that into America. It's a
- 15:59great idea." It does not help the poor.
- 16:01And by the way, this isn't speculative
- 16:03anymore. So, listen to this. In 1991,
- 16:07when the Soviet Union and the United
- 16:09States were raging in a cold war, right?
- 16:11And it was the free west, the capitalist
- 16:14west up against the Soviet Union which
- 16:16was the birthplace of communism and the
- 16:18one who was exporting this all over the
- 16:20world. Well, the Soviet Union broke in
- 16:231991
- 16:25and all of a sudden a flurry of nations
- 16:27start abandoning communism to adopt free
- 16:30market principles. The Soviet Union
- 16:32starts breaking off all of its satellite
- 16:34countries. And listen to what happens.
- 16:36So, as soon as these countries walk away
- 16:38from communism, and by the way, you know
- 16:39that huge list that I read earlier,
- 16:42>> how many communist countries are there
- 16:43today? Five. Just five. There's only
- 16:46five left. Everyone else has walked away
- 16:48from it. And even China, which is one of
- 16:50those countries, is beginning to embrace
- 16:51free market stuff because they recognize
- 16:54communism is a train wreck. So, listen
- 16:56to this. Between 1990 and 2011, all
- 17:00these nations walk away from communism.
- 17:02Oh, the poor must have suffered. They
- 17:05got rid of communism. The poor must be
- 17:06really hurting in those countries.
- 17:08Listen to this. The global poverty rate
- 17:10in the two decades after communism was
- 17:13abandoned fell from 43% to 21%.
- 17:16>> Wow.
- 17:17>> So the poverty rate when you get rid of
- 17:19communism falls by more than half.
- 17:23>> So who cares for the poor?
- 17:26>> Capitalism has done more to elevate the
- 17:28poor than any communism or socialism
- 17:31that has ever been tried. A billion
- 17:33people came out of poverty when the
- 17:35world abandoned communism.
- 17:37>> That's different. Yeah,
- 17:38>> that's amazing. In 1960, communist
- 17:41China, this is hard. This is crazy to
- 17:43think about. Communist China was poorer
- 17:46than most African nations at the time.
- 17:49>> Wow. Now they're considered a dominant
- 17:51superpower now that they're gaining all
- 17:53the economic freedoms and they're
- 17:54beginning to build businesses and
- 17:55everything else. Not the same story.
- 17:58They were poorer than most African
- 17:59nations. But after economic reforms that
- 18:02came after the collapse of Soviet Union
- 18:04where they said, "Hey, we want to allow
- 18:06freedom in our markets and we
- 18:07decollectivized farming like we're going
- 18:09to allow businesses to own farmland
- 18:11again and entrepreneurship and
- 18:13businesses and things like that."
- 18:15They'll start allowing Chinese citizens
- 18:17enjoyed a 13 hear this 13fold increase
- 18:21in their real income between 1990 and
- 18:232014. Wow.
- 18:25>> So in 24 years their average income
- 18:29multiplied 13 times. 24 years. Imagine
- 18:33your income multiplying.
- 18:34>> I'm in correct.
- 18:36>> Wh why why did it do that? Because they
- 18:39abandoned the stupid principles of
- 18:41communism.
- 18:42>> And what little bit of daylight of free
- 18:44markets they allowed into their country.
- 18:46Their nation exploded in it. It brought
- 18:48the poor radically lifted the poor. And
- 18:52nothing in history has done more to
- 18:54elevate people out of poverty than
- 18:56abandoning the ideals of communism. Free
- 19:00markets elevate the poor. And so this is
- 19:03another study that I think is just like
- 19:04what do you do with this? If you're if
- 19:06you're pro-communism, right? You care
- 19:08about the poor. Listen to this.
- 19:11>> There's a study done by the foundation
- 19:13for that for economic education and they
- 19:16studied, you know, all the different
- 19:17countries based on economic freedoms.
- 19:19like are you a free market country or
- 19:21are you a planned economy you know
- 19:23centralized planning
- 19:25>> communists and they found that the
- 19:26income earned by the poorest 10% and the
- 19:29most economically free countries so
- 19:32let's list the capitalist one let's take
- 19:34the bottom 10% of the capitalist
- 19:36countries okay and then we'll compare
- 19:39them to the the least economically free
- 19:42countries what would be the difference
- 19:45the poorest of the capitalist countries
- 19:48bottom 10% % earn eight times more than
- 19:52those living in the least economically
- 19:55free countries. So eight times more.
- 19:57>> That's a huge number.
- 19:58>> Huge number. I mean, so imagine eight
- 20:01times more than you make just based on
- 20:03what kind of economy.
- 20:04>> It's 80,000 versus 10,000.
- 20:06>> Correct.
- 20:06>> That's a huge number.
- 20:07>> Correct. So when you're talking about
- 20:09like and I understand it like the
- 20:11idealized version of communism, oh we'll
- 20:13all share and it'll be wonderful and you
- 20:14know we'll go la.
- 20:17Humanity doesn't allow that. And so what
- 20:20happens is is when you give somebody the
- 20:22incentive to go out and make money for
- 20:24their family and to care for their own
- 20:25and to make their own stuff, turns out
- 20:27they care a lot more about it. Whereas
- 20:29when you collectivize it, it's like
- 20:31everybody goes, "Why? Why bother? I'm
- 20:33going to get the same no matter what I
- 20:35do." And so it's like everybody just
- 20:37sinks together because there's no
- 20:38incentive to create and to sell and I'm
- 20:41making goods that you don't want, but I
- 20:42don't care because I'm getting the same
- 20:44check anyway. Turns out that when you
- 20:46innovate and when your efforts actually
- 20:48contribute to how you and your family
- 20:50are going to live, you make better
- 20:52goods, you make better decisions, you
- 20:55work harder to benefit your neighbors
- 20:56and your society and you innovate and
- 20:59you bring technology that helps your
- 21:01people live in better medical care. By
- 21:03the way, you look at medical care,
- 21:05[laughter] just just to bring this up,
- 21:07medical care differences, just as an
- 21:10aside, like in those years where half of
- 21:13the world lost their mind and embraced
- 21:15communism and the world became a really
- 21:17dark place in the 20th century, in all
- 21:19the nations where you saw communism as a
- 21:22whole, guess what happened to life
- 21:24expectancy? Even as technology
- 21:26throughout the world was growing and
- 21:27growing and medical care and everything
- 21:28else was improving, life expectancy in
- 21:31those countries did this while life
- 21:33expectancy in the capitalist countries
- 21:35did this. In the west it was climbing.
- 21:37Infant mortality went down. Not in the
- 21:40communist countries. And all of these
- 21:42places like every measurable outcome of
- 21:44prosperity, of health, of general
- 21:47happiness plummeted. Liberty gone. Like
- 21:51everything about communism is just dumb.
- 21:55[laughter] I mean, it it breeds
- 21:56destruction and really yucky times. So
- 21:59for anybody who thinks that communism is
- 22:03this this really appealing, you know,
- 22:04we'll just all get along and share, it
- 22:06never works out that way and it always
- 22:09decimates the very people that it's
- 22:11promising to help the most. Yeah. The
- 22:13crazy part about communism is it
- 22:14promises life, but only brings death in
- 22:16all facets of life. like real physical
- 22:18death or a death of livelihoods or or
- 22:21whatever it is, it just offers a promise
- 22:23that I can't fulfill cuz it's
- 22:24impossible. And even kind of in a funny
- 22:26way, not to make this less serious than
- 22:28it is, but if you look at the five
- 22:29countries that are practicing communist
- 22:30right now, would you want to live in
- 22:32them? Like North Korea,
- 22:34>> Laos, never heard of it, but never want
- 22:36to go there. [laughter]
- 22:37>> Cuba, I know a lot of Cubans in South
- 22:40Florida, they're not going back, even if
- 22:42you want to, right? Vietnam, North
- 22:43Vietnam, don't want to go there. China.
- 22:45Maybe if you're part of the ruling
- 22:46party, but if you're just have any
- 22:48religious beliefs or you have any
- 22:49feeling that's against that party, you
- 22:51don't want to live there. So, it's like
- 22:52take your chances, guys.
- 22:53>> If you're an evangelical in China,
- 22:55there's a healthy chance you could
- 22:56disappear. Or if you're a weaguer or
- 22:58religious minority, you're going to end
- 22:59up in a train going to a camp somewhere.
- 23:02And the Chinese are like, we we're not
- 23:04losing sleep over this.
- 23:05>> And that's the reality, man. Like,
- 23:07there's there was a brilliant guy who
- 23:09was was a survivor of a Soviet goolog.
- 23:11His name is Alexander Solenich. He gave
- 23:13an address to Harvard, very famous. And
- 23:16after he got out of the goologs, where
- 23:18he was sent for just having common
- 23:20sense, he wrote this series of books
- 23:23called the Gulog Archipelago. And it was
- 23:26about all the different goologs that the
- 23:28Russians had established where they just
- 23:29sent dissident like if you disagree with
- 23:31us, you lose your freedom and we send
- 23:33you to the goolog to work in hard labor
- 23:35camps. and he went and collected stories
- 23:37and wrote the Gulog Archipelago, which
- 23:39is a really really interesting read for
- 23:41anybody who wants to know how communism
- 23:43takes root and what it looks like when
- 23:45it's starting in the initial stages of
- 23:47taking everyone's liberty away. And he
- 23:50talks about the suffering of the people
- 23:52under communism. But I love this quote
- 23:54that he gives because it's really
- 23:55simple. And at the root of communism,
- 23:58like I said, Mark says communism begins
- 24:00where atheism begins. And Solenich
- 24:03basically says that's exactly right.
- 24:05Listen to what he says and we'll I'll
- 24:07just we'll close with this. He says,
- 24:08"Over a half a century ago, while I was
- 24:11still a child, I recall a number of old
- 24:13people offering the following
- 24:14explanation for the great disasters that
- 24:16had befallen Russia. Men have forgotten
- 24:19God. That's why all this has happened."
- 24:22Well, since then, I've spent 50 years
- 24:24working on the history of our
- 24:25revolution. In the process, I've read
- 24:28hundreds of books, collected hundreds of
- 24:30personal testimonies, and have already
- 24:32contributed eight volumes of my own
- 24:34toward the effort of clearing away the
- 24:36rubble left by the upheaval. But if I
- 24:39were asked today to formulate as
- 24:41concisely as possible the main cause of
- 24:43the ruinous revolution that swallowed up
- 24:46some 60 million of our own people, I
- 24:49could not put it more accurately than to
- 24:51repeat. Men have forgotten God. That's
- 24:55why all this has happened. Powerful.
- 24:59That's what happens. What is what is
- 25:00communism? But to say I mean in a weird
- 25:03way, it's saying materialism is more
- 25:05important than men. Ironically, because
- 25:07it's supposed to be the antidote to
- 25:09that, right? It's supposed to be like,
- 25:10oh no, men are more precious than their
- 25:12income. But inevitably, what it says is
- 25:15it's envy. It's, hey, look what they
- 25:16have. We need to take it from them and
- 25:18give over here. And then it reduces men
- 25:20to just widgets that are treated with no
- 25:23care to where 60 million and how many in
- 25:27the goologs and how many that starved
- 25:29and all the suffering that it unleashes
- 25:31all for the sake of a revolution in
- 25:33power that's centralized at the top so
- 25:36they can abuse it. It never has a
- 25:38different outcome. And so I love the
- 25:41fact that right now there's a trend in
- 25:43America all over the place where states
- 25:45are saying we are going to bring this in
- 25:47and codify it to where this needs to be
- 25:49taught to the coming generations because
- 25:52there should not be generations coming
- 25:54out of America that say hm communism
- 25:57sounds like a good idea. No, it is a
- 25:59philosophy of death. It is hostile to
- 26:02the scriptures and no Christian should
- 26:04be flirting with this ideology. It's
- 26:07devastating. Don't become a commie.
- 26:09That's correct. And so we'll leave it
- 26:11there. I want to thank you so much for
- 26:13watching. Join us next time as we take a
- 26:15look at another issue and examine what
- 26:17the Bible has to [music] say about it
- 26:19here on In God We Trust.
- 26:27[music]