Latest / Chatter that Matters / Zita Cobb - The Miracle of Fogo Island
Transcript
- 0:04I tried something different last week, and I'm gonna continue with it.
- 0:07And that is to record the opening after I've recorded my
- 0:11interview with my guest. And the reason being is it gives
- 0:15me time to reflect and hopefully present why I
- 0:18think their story and lessons in life matter to you
- 0:22and to me and hopefully to a lot of people. My guest today is
- 0:26Zita Cobb. We need lots of miracles, but miracles are actually quite easy.
- 0:30A miracle is when someone has a slight shift in how they
- 0:33see the same thing. I didn't know what to expect. I mean, I've heard
- 0:37such incredible things about this beautiful force of
- 0:41nature. Her intellect, her emotional capacity,
- 0:45and her ability to do is unlike anything I've ever seen.
- 0:49Our entrepreneurs are all in places. They need to be fed and loved and supported.
- 0:52I think what we're missing and if if there's one thing, if I had a
- 0:54magic wand, is to build an architecture for
- 0:58collaboration in each place and across the pillars.
- 1:03And why this story is so important is that she's applied
- 1:06all of this to where she was born and in doing
- 1:10so, has been part of creating a gift not only to the
- 1:14community that lives there, the world, especially
- 1:18the part of the world where humans still wanna be
- 1:21human beings. We know how to make things. If it's made out of wood, we
- 1:24can make it. We know how to make furniture. We know how to make quilts.
- 1:27We know how to grow things. We know how to fish. All of those things
- 1:30we would need to bring to bear to welcome guests and take care of
- 1:34them. And And so it's like a way through practice of keeping our
- 1:37skills and our knowledge and building a platform to practice
- 1:41hospitality. I hope you enjoy
- 1:45getting to know Zita Cobb as much as I did.
- 1:51Hi. It's Tony Chapman. Thank you for listening to Chatter That Matters presented
- 1:55by RBC. If you can, please subscribe to the podcast. And
- 1:59ratings and reviews, well, they're always welcome, and they're always appreciated.
- 2:05Zita Cobb, welcome to Chatter That Matters. Thank you, Tony. Great to be
- 2:09here. Now my audience is all over the world, and I'm sure
- 2:13most of them have heard of Newfoundland. Some might even even gone to a
- 2:16play. But I just love you to just take a moment and
- 2:20describe what I personally consider one of the most beautiful parts
- 2:24of Canada. Honestly, one of the most beautiful parts of, the world. Well, the
- 2:27province is called Newfoundland and Labrador. We must never forget about Labrador.
- 2:32And it is it holds up the Northeast Part of
- 2:35Canada. And it's, it gives new meaning to the word
- 2:39rugged in terms of its landscapes. It's a very, very old
- 2:42landscape. The part that I'm from is the Northeast
- 2:47Coast, and that's rougher than rough in terms of
- 2:50landscape. And the rocks that I grew up on are 400,000,000
- 2:54years old. There's something about the soul of
- 2:58Newfoundlanders and Labradorians that comes out of those rocks and
- 3:02comes out of that North Atlantic and that kind of epic
- 3:06and difficult and noble set of relationships.
- 3:09So let's talk about epic, noble, and in
- 3:13some ways, how challenging it was to grow up there. I was because as a
- 3:17young girl on Fogo Island, you grew up with this
- 3:20incredible community, but not with the luxuries that most people take
- 3:24for granted, running water and electricity. Yeah. I think I had the real luxuries.
- 3:28The island of Fogo Island is about just under four times the size of
- 3:31Manhattan, so quite a large island with 10 different communities. I grew up in
- 3:35one called Joe Batt's Arm, which when I was growing up had about
- 3:39900 people. I grew up with this deep intimate
- 3:42relationship with place and with rocks
- 3:46and with the ocean, and we had this
- 3:50confidence from competence. And we always
- 3:54knew we could make a living. We fed ourselves. We as you say,
- 3:57we didn't have electricity, and we didn't have running water, and we had very little
- 4:01health care. So it wasn't fun when someone had a
- 4:04toothache. I also, spent one year of my
- 4:08childhood life in a sanatorium because I had TB when I was
- 4:12five and six. I understood what it
- 4:16means to be in an active everyday
- 4:19relationship with people and place. You also mentioned in
- 4:23several interviews a defining moment in your life as when your
- 4:26your father burnt his boat. I'm an eighth generation Fogo
- 4:30Islander. People started to arrive from Europe,
- 4:34to Fogo Island in the mid sixteen hundreds. Generation after generation
- 4:38after generation of us have made a living on the North Atlantic fishing
- 4:41in little boats that we built ourselves, like my father who built
- 4:45his boat. When the industrialization of the
- 4:49fishery arrived, and it took no time at
- 4:52all to take just about every last fish out of the water because we humans
- 4:56are very effective when we get focused on something, He
- 5:00couldn't see a future. You know, he came home on that
- 5:03that exact day with one fish. Threw it on the kitchen
- 5:07floor, and we all kinda stood there looking at this one fish on the kitchen
- 5:10floor, and he just simply said, it's over. When I talked earlier about, you know,
- 5:14we're confident people, that confidence comes
- 5:18from the knowledge of the place. Nature knows everything. And every
- 5:22once in a while, we pay attention to it and we learn. Nature knows the
- 5:25cure for cancer. And people who have kept
- 5:29a steady, uninterrupted relationship with nature know stuff.
- 5:32That's where innovation is from. So now you take someone, my
- 5:36father, who couldn't read. His whole life was fishing, and now there are no more
- 5:40fish. For him, I think the burning of the
- 5:43boat was not willing to
- 5:47suffer the indignity of watching it fall apart
- 5:51and to pull it up on the shore and watch it decay. It was a
- 5:54protest, anger. I think he meant it to be symbolic
- 5:58for us kids to say, stop dreaming. And did
- 6:02you have a chance later in life to talk to him
- 6:05about that moment? Because he, you know, he takes the family to Ontario.
- 6:09I can't imagine what it would be like to walk in his shoes at that
- 6:12point. It would be like, to me, a refugee
- 6:15leaving everything they know and coming to another part of the world and knowing nothing.
- 6:19There's a beautiful song about that time of when the Newfoundlanders had to
- 6:23go. And some of them were part of the kind of forced
- 6:26resettlement, and some of them, like my father, just decided it was
- 6:30done. And the song there's a line in the song called The Outpour People, and
- 6:33it is this. They moved without leaving and
- 6:37never arrived. And you could certainly say that about
- 6:41my father. And he went from being the most dignified
- 6:44person you'd ever know to someone who struggled for dignity. They I went to
- 6:48Ottawa to go to university to study business because that's what he said
- 6:52I had to do to figure out how this money thing works before it eats
- 6:55everything we love. And they went and my parents and
- 6:59my youngest brother went to Scarborough where, of course, Scarborough had a lot of
- 7:02Newfoundlanders. And many of my brothers were in Scarborough. So that's why
- 7:06they landed there. First time in his life, he had to have a bank account
- 7:09because they had to pay the rent. He really hated having to go over to
- 7:13the bank and make an x in front of these young people
- 7:17who were working at the bank. I can imagine. So he wanted to
- 7:20learn to write his name. I tried to teach him, and so,
- 7:24yeah, I started with the alphabet like you would, did not go well.
- 7:28And so finally he said to me, which was brilliant, of course, he said,
- 7:32I don't need to know all of that. It's just a shape. So he
- 7:36used to go and draw. It was as if it was a drawing, his signature.
- 7:39I have to believe not only his mental health, but your physical health would
- 7:43suffer when you go from being someone that had stature and
- 7:46someone that was the head of the family and and now going into
- 7:50a world where, as you said, he was embarrassed because he couldn't even sign his
- 7:54name. It has to be difficult as a child to see confidence
- 7:58disappear in somebody that you've entrusted your life to for so many
- 8:02years? It was I mean, in some ways, it was funny because they couldn't they
- 8:05would go to the grocery store and not be able to navigate. You know, they
- 8:08spent weeks trying to find cabbage, and they thought iceberg lettuce was
- 8:12cabbage. They'd never seen such a thing. So it was always these very funny stories.
- 8:16I was younger because, of course, in Newfoundland, we only had grade 11. So when
- 8:19I started at Carleton, I was 17. I had just turned 17.
- 8:23But, you know, my father is was a tough cookie
- 8:26mentally and physically. He was able to kinda zoom
- 8:30out and understand what was happening to him. And, you know, it didn't
- 8:34deteriorate into manifestations of despair you see when people lose
- 8:38their dignity. I think he just found he he just found other
- 8:41outlets. And I think he looked at the whole society that he'd been
- 8:45now cast into with kind of humor. We're gonna
- 8:48fast forward a little bit. But before we get back to what you're doing in
- 8:52the sense of place, the next move on the chessboard for you is
- 8:55you had a very successful career in high-tech, and you did
- 8:59extraordinarily well. So for someone that came out and was sent to learn
- 9:03business and figure out this money thing, you figured it out pretty well.
- 9:07You know, it's kind of a funny thing. I went, to university to study
- 9:11this money thing with, probably a a bit
- 9:14of anger about the money thing. Like, I have to stop this
- 9:18money thing. You know? And in the studying of business, I
- 9:21actually fell in love with what it could do. In that time, I don't know
- 9:25if you remember the book Small is Beautiful, it came out when I was in
- 9:28university. Business is about how the
- 9:32part belongs to the whole. And this kind of cauliflower thinking and thinking about
- 9:36fractals and thinking about that Fogo Island is just one little
- 9:39floret in a big cauliflower. What matters is the
- 9:43stem that holds us all together. How do we get all the
- 9:46flows, the economies, like the flows of things to this
- 9:50all the florets so that they have nutrition, so that the
- 9:54cauliflower is well? So that really changed how I thought about business
- 9:57and and economy and the link between business and
- 10:01economy. Tell me how the whole high-tech world came on because
- 10:05you're starting having this interesting philosophy. And I guess technology in many ways
- 10:08is the the lifeblood of the cauliflower, if it's done right. Yes.
- 10:12And I grew up in a place that was deeply, and still is,
- 10:16deeply innovative. I mean, this is a sounds like a bit of a crude thing,
- 10:20but, you know, this joke about Newfoundlanders is, Newfoundlanders can put the arse in a
- 10:23cat. And it's true. We can figure anything out. And because we
- 10:27we approach it with the belief that we can, and the reason we feel we
- 10:31can is because we've had to. I love working with
- 10:34people who love figuring stuff out. I actually started my career because, you know,
- 10:38I'm a Newfoundlander. I I worked in the oil patch for a while. I worked
- 10:41for Shell Texaco first and then Shell. I was responsible for a gas field in
- 10:45Southern Alberta. And I met this
- 10:48contractor that was doing cold regions research, left the oil
- 10:52companies, and I joined this little company that, at the time I joined
- 10:56them in Calgary, had 80 people in
- 10:59Canada. And some were in Calgary and and focused on the Beaufort. And
- 11:03some were in Ottawa, focused on cold regions technology and icebreakers and all
- 11:07of that. And it was owned by a
- 11:10US company that had been started by two guys who came out of the US
- 11:13Coast Guard. I loved those people. Like, I still do. They
- 11:17were mostly engineers,
- 11:21scientists that were doing numerical modeling and things like that. And
- 11:24my career really was do everything that they shouldn't be doing. So, of
- 11:28course, you know, I was a controller and human resources and
- 11:32purchasing every single thing. I saw my career as create the
- 11:35enabling conditions so that these people can innovate.
- 11:39You're a microcosm of the of the cauliflower even within that business.
- 11:43You are the stem. I never thought of it that way. I really didn't. But
- 11:47that is how and that's what what I'm good at and what gives me joy.
- 11:50What does the floret need, and what do these, inventors need? So
- 11:53then I when I left then I joined a company called what was
- 11:57that I joined at JDS Optics, based in
- 12:01Ottawa and founded by four people who came out of Bell
- 12:04Northern Research. It was the most beautiful company. It
- 12:08was privately held. And I joined in
- 12:121989 and right at the time that and it was involved in wave
- 12:15division multiple I mean, in fiber optics. Wave division multiplexing
- 12:19was really just becoming a big thing. And so I was with that company until
- 12:2302/2001, and it grew to 40,000 people. And in my last
- 12:27two years with the company was a time of integration. I bought
- 12:3040 companies around the world. It was crazy. When we return, things get really,
- 12:34crazy. When we return, things get really, I don't
- 12:38know, powerful for me. We go beyond Newfoundland
- 12:41and Labrador and talk about what happened and is
- 12:45happening on Fogo Island. This incredible
- 12:48connection with culture and humanity and nature. People from
- 12:52all over the world wanna make it their place to be. It's also a
- 12:56place for locals to be purposeful, to give and receive
- 12:59gratitude, and to really bring to life the power of
- 13:03humanity when it's working together within a circular
- 13:07economy. I'll build on that after my chat with Zita.
- 13:13Hi. It's Tony Chapman, host of Chatter That Matters, presented by
- 13:16RBC. Ideas matter. Ideas are the oxygen of human
- 13:20endeavor. They breathe life into how we work, live, and play. Ideas
- 13:23let us create and innovate and overcome complex and often
- 13:27challenging circumstances. Big or small, revolutionary or evolutionary,
- 13:31almost every positive step forward begins with a good idea. So bring
- 13:35your ideas to RBC because they matter, and they'll bring theirs because
- 13:38you matter. Ideas happen at RBC.
- 13:42I used to work for a man who come to work as a technology company
- 13:45every day, and he'd say, the most most important thing is to keep the most
- 13:48important thing the most important thing. I think the most important thing
- 13:52was said by Schumacher in the seventies, nature and culture are the
- 13:56two great garments of human life. And business and technology are
- 14:00the two great tools that can and should serve them. My guest today is
- 14:04Zita Cobb. She came from a small fishing village,
- 14:07built an extraordinary career in finance before returning back
- 14:11to that village, and working with everyone there to create
- 14:15the Fogle Island Inn. And the lessons learned are
- 14:18lessons could benefit all of Canada.
- 14:23You could have just spent the rest of your life enjoying life. I mean, you
- 14:27did very well intellectually, emotionally, financially. It was a great
- 14:30run. But you chose to come back to Fogo Island.
- 14:34I mean, this is somebody that's traveling all over the world, buying businesses all over
- 14:37the world, and that that that's part of the story I was fascinated
- 14:41with. That was this always a calling for you or did it get to a
- 14:44certain part of your life where you said it's now or never? I'm just curious
- 14:48what was the magnetic qualities that would bring it back. You know, I never
- 14:51lost my relationship with place, with Fogo Island ever. I mean,
- 14:55I was always going back and forth. I always had this idea I wasn't gonna
- 14:58live very long because in my family people tip tend not to live all that
- 15:02long because we have heart disease. We're, like, half Irish bat you know,
- 15:05bad hearts. As a child, it was always my plan
- 15:09that I am going to sail back across the ocean. I wanna
- 15:13go and see where these ancestors came from, and I want to have that experience
- 15:17of sailing. And so the first thing I did, and and I
- 15:20actually bought the boat before I left JDS, is I went
- 15:24sailing. So I lived on the boat on sale for five years. The first thing
- 15:27I did at home that was specific to what's mine to do
- 15:31was I started a scholarship program for kids leaving the high school there to go
- 15:35to university. And I was at home
- 15:39for a review of the scholarship as a public review of the program,
- 15:43and a woman set up and said, you're just
- 15:47paying our kids to leave. Can't you do something to make
- 15:51work? Her question set off a whole
- 15:54bunch of thinking. The answer kind of presented itself. I
- 15:58was sailing, and I stopped one day in Mystic Seaport, which
- 16:02is America's, you know, museum of its relationship with the sea.
- 16:06In Mystic is a is a banking schooner, was a Newfoundland
- 16:10banking schooner called the the Dunton, Leonard Dunton. And the
- 16:14day I was there, there were a bunch of Newfoundlanders there doing a demonstration for
- 16:17the making of fish. At that very moment, I
- 16:21was in touch with my good friend Pete from the island, and
- 16:25he said, oh, you had a terrible letter from the mayor that your house my
- 16:29uncle had passed away and left me a little house, like a little salt box
- 16:32700 square foot house. Your house is an eyesore, and you either have
- 16:35to fix it up or tear it down. Tell them we're gonna tear it down.
- 16:38What am I I mean, what am I gonna do with a falling down house?
- 16:41Then later that afternoon, I'm standing at Mystic Seaport looking around the
- 16:45Leonard S. Dunton, a Newfoundland banking schooner was saved.
- 16:49Somebody thought that was worth saving. And I thought, what am I doing?
- 16:53I have the means to save this house.
- 16:57I have the means to do a lot of things.
- 17:01If I'm not going to do something on Fogo Island, do I expect you to
- 17:04come do it or someone else to come do it? These things, like,
- 17:08place holds the things that have inherent value to my
- 17:12ability to make meaning and I think everybody's ability to make meaning.
- 17:16Here I was standing in this place that I was so grateful existed
- 17:20because it really gave us access to the past. It it gave us
- 17:24access to the relationships from the past and the knowledge from the past.
- 17:27And and I was gonna just tear down my own. Ed, did you, at
- 17:31that point, consider it a calling or
- 17:35something I should do as part of my portfolio
- 17:39of interest and activities? Because it truly became a calling. I
- 17:42think it it grew. I think it did start with a, like, a little
- 17:46miracle. We need lots of miracles, but miracles are actually quite easy.
- 17:50The miracle is when someone has a slight shift in how they
- 17:53see the same thing. If I had been standing anywhere
- 17:57but Mystic Seaport, I'm not sure the little miracle would have set off in
- 18:01my head. But it was a little bit like pulling a thread on
- 18:05a sweater that you just you thought you were just pulling that little thread, and
- 18:08then you realize this is connected to the whole sweater. And before you realize that,
- 18:10you gotta knit a whole new sweater. And so I I think it,
- 18:14was a series of little miracles that started with that. So let's
- 18:18talk about place based economics because
- 18:22you've framed your TED Talks, you've framed a lot of your
- 18:25conversations around this sense of place.
- 18:29And I think other people have talked about it as the circle economy. The
- 18:32indigenous certainly talk about it within their world. Just how do
- 18:36you define it, and why aren't we not all
- 18:40embracing it? I think we're suffering from a kind of place
- 18:43blindness. Place is a funny thing because,
- 18:47like, everything is bound up with its opposite. So if you were in a place,
- 18:51and I know a lot of people and a lot of my friends who were
- 18:55born and raised in small, faraway places, they
- 18:58would feel imprisoned to think that they they couldn't leave.
- 19:02You know, they didn't see it as, like, a gift to be a part of
- 19:06the place, and they wanted to get away from it. So the possibility
- 19:09of moving and being in motion is so appealing
- 19:13to all of us that when the idea of a global
- 19:17village, oh my god, there's all these systems that support you can live where you
- 19:20like and all of this, we just forgot that we
- 19:23are embodied creatures, that we are
- 19:27social creatures, and that we are meaning seeking creatures.
- 19:31And when you think about place, place holds nature. And
- 19:35culture is a human response to a place, it's the sum of what we have
- 19:39learned and shared in this place. And those things are integral to meaning
- 19:43making. So I think we rushed away from place a bit too soon, and then
- 19:46we woke up and realized, oh, hang on a second. There isn't a global village
- 19:49at all. There's just a whole bunch of villages. We
- 19:53allowed an economy to develop, a global economy,
- 19:57globalized economy to develop, that forgot to knit
- 20:01the places into it. So the really, the global economy
- 20:04became, you know, a whole bunch of institutions and organizations
- 20:08loosely organized by governments that place wasn't even a
- 20:12consideration, let alone a design element in the economy.
- 20:16So that's what I think we're trying to solve for now. Because, you know, I
- 20:19think ultimately humans are lazy. We are lazy. And so it's
- 20:23like, oh, jeez, we have to go back and clean up and take care of
- 20:25the place. Yeah, yeah, we do. We're not going to solve a housing crisis by,
- 20:29you know, talking about it or wishing it so. We're going to, like, figure out
- 20:32how to make this work. And so I think the economy should be the
- 20:36sum of its parts. I mean, I could do a whole talk now, which is
- 20:39Canada, much less than the sum of its parts. And
- 20:43it is. We have 4,500 amazing communities that are incorporated,
- 20:47and God knows how many more that are too small and not yet incorporated
- 20:51and maybe never will be. Maybe that's fine. But if you think
- 20:54about the economy as think about it as plumbing.
- 20:58Well, if the plumbing works, it includes all the little toes
- 21:01and fingers of a place, like a country. That's
- 21:05a beautiful economy. Lifts up, serves, it underpins
- 21:09places. And if it underpins a place and places, then it
- 21:12underpins lives. Well, let's go back to your cauliflower analogy because I I love
- 21:16what you're presenting to me. But I would argue that in Canada,
- 21:20I would argue in many places around the world, we've cut off the stem. It's
- 21:24to other people's advantage, whether it's social media to herd you in their
- 21:27places with like minded people who like like minded content or
- 21:31politicians who see divide to conquer as their
- 21:35means to an end, we've lost that sense of
- 21:38identity. So even if we had 4,500 of these little
- 21:42florists out there starting to realize that this connected, we're better
- 21:46and stronger, there's a lot of people that are wanting to build a
- 21:50mode around each one of those communities because it serves to their advantage
- 21:54versus what you talk about, which I also love, was the sense that
- 21:58this culture is a manifestation of the place you're in. Yeah. I I think when
- 22:01we lose our places and I lose our relationship with
- 22:05places, culture is local. And when
- 22:09those relationships get stretched or broken, I
- 22:12think we're we get lost. I spend a lot of time thinking about where do
- 22:16values come from and how do values shift? Because obviously they do.
- 22:20There's a connection to actions. Right? Actions shape norms.
- 22:24Norms shape beliefs. Beliefs shape values. If
- 22:28you are connected in a place and and an active member of
- 22:32a community that has I mean, that's the beautiful thing about community
- 22:36is a place. There's all kinds of people there. And whoever you know, all kinds
- 22:39of ages and just all kinds of points of view that you kind of you
- 22:42would need a kind of social literacy to live with people. Because
- 22:46sometimes, like, I grew up next to my father's brother. Those two men did not
- 22:50like each other. And we knew it. But it never was sort of
- 22:53open animosity. It was just you're living next to people
- 22:57that, in their case, they didn't really like each other. But they needed each other.
- 23:01And so we mucked along together. And out of that came
- 23:04a set of values around how we treat each other. So if you
- 23:08take people away from place and take away the necessity to actually
- 23:12get along with other people, how do we orient? Where are the North
- 23:15Stars? We all have very vibrant virtual lives
- 23:19now that in some cases have almost supplanted our physical
- 23:23lives. And we have retreated from the physical lives because in our
- 23:27physical lives, oh, my God, people are a pain and your hip hurts and everything
- 23:30online is so much easier. We don't like that friction of the physical world.
- 23:34And if we are unrooted from past and
- 23:38relatives and history and all of that, it's easy to believe the stuff
- 23:42you see and read. We're very vulnerable. So you're countering,
- 23:46and we're gonna talk about the Fogo Island Inn and how that
- 23:50has become a place that is world renowned. So that lady that
- 23:53said, why are you creating scholarships for people to leave?
- 23:57You've created an entity where people believe people from all over the
- 24:01world have come in. And I understand part of it is what you call this
- 24:04thing about, I guess, a, b, c, d, this asset based
- 24:08community development or Shorefast. So for the people that
- 24:11haven't experienced Fogo Island, what would they experience
- 24:15coming there? And then let's get to the STEM, which is the sense of a,
- 24:19b, c, d. It it is, as we jokingly say, far away from
- 24:22far away, its own rhythms and rituals
- 24:27and is intact. It hasn't been flattened
- 24:31by the commercialization of every single thing. You're not gonna
- 24:35find the stuff you see chain after chain after global
- 24:39chain. You just don't see that. And its landscape is so
- 24:43shocking, I think, to most people that the minute you get off the ferry,
- 24:46your imagination wakes up because it's a step out of time in a
- 24:50way, but it's actually not behind time. I think it might be ahead of time.
- 24:55People who grow up on a small island like we
- 24:58did, who are confident, then the key is confidence. Like, if we
- 25:02break the confidence of a people, we have broken the people.
- 25:06Fogo Islanders have their confidence. And when they're confident, they
- 25:10are super open to visitors, like, super
- 25:13open. I think people are shocked that everybody talks to
- 25:17you. And And Mary Walsh, she says, people think that Newfoundlanders
- 25:21are friendly. Mary Walsh says, no, no, we're just nosy. Very nosy.
- 25:24So, like, who are you? And what's your story? And what's your home? And
- 25:28what can we learn from each other? It's a very natural
- 25:32part. So when you go through ABCD, I mean, you
- 25:36could look at Fogo Island and say, my gosh, it's a bald rock in the
- 25:39North Atlantic and the cod collapsed. Like, what's the point? There's no electricity, no running
- 25:42water. We gotta get the people out of there. Some government officials thought that.
- 25:46And into that breach arrived the National Film Board of Canada
- 25:50with this beautiful project called Challenge for Change. It was an anti
- 25:53poverty, program project trying to understand the root
- 25:57causes of poverty, urban and rural. And a filmmaker named Colin Lowe
- 26:01arrived with the University from St. John's Memorial. And they didn't have any
- 26:05answers. They just had questions. And this is the beautiful thing. And basically
- 26:08what they were asking people is, well, what do you know? What do you have?
- 26:12What do you think you have? And what do you think could be done? And
- 26:16of course, local people know stuff. Deep cultural
- 26:19knowledge. But nobody ever asked them questions. And out of that came,
- 26:24this is back when I was 10, building a slightly bigger boat so we could
- 26:27go to the Midshore. That's how we held on. Those people of my parents'
- 26:30generation made a co op, so we held on. In our case,
- 26:35going through a similar process, you realize, we're
- 26:39deeply hospitable people. We should have we should have a world class inn.
- 26:42The things and knowledge that we have that we can put into that inn is
- 26:46rare. It's not broken. What was the tipping
- 26:50point that had you going from, wow, we've got
- 26:53hospitality, we know how to do things, we should create a world
- 26:57class into actually putting a shovel in the ground. I think
- 27:01it's when you do it with others. So I worked very closely with two of
- 27:04my many brothers. I think if it had just been us in
- 27:08our close conversation, there's always the option to
- 27:12back away from it. It's like, Yeah, you know, I don't feel like doing it.
- 27:15I want to go back. I mean, the hardest thing for me was to give
- 27:17up sailing. That was really hard. But because this became a
- 27:20community wide, island wide conversation, you're hardly gonna
- 27:24say, well, I changed my mind. I think I wanna go sailing. Like, I think
- 27:27it's about the commitments we make to each other. I don't remember there
- 27:31being a moment that we weren't gonna move. Because once you start,
- 27:35once you start the conversations, if they're open conversations, then
- 27:39it it doesn't even belong to me. It belongs to us. Am I
- 27:43going to let you down? No. This co op,
- 27:46this collective of consciousness and energy and
- 27:50heart, It also seems to be manifested in even how
- 27:54you run your business because it's very transparent. People
- 27:57really understand how it all works.
- 28:01That counters the principles of a lot of people that feel control
- 28:05comes from knowledge. Knowledge gives me power. And
- 28:09you're saying the opposite that by surrendering that knowledge, it gives
- 28:12us collective power. Yes. Exactly. And it certainly gives us more pleasure. And the
- 28:16other thing about the inn, of course, we didn't start, I don't own the inn.
- 28:19Like, I don't own anything on Fogo Island except my car and that
- 28:23little house that I did fix up and I now live in. The inn belongs
- 28:27to the community because it's owned in this model. It's owned actually by the charity
- 28:30called Shorefast, owns it. It's operated by a separate
- 28:35board that's called Shorefast Social Enterprises. But the beneficial owners
- 28:38are people of Fobo. I didn't I mean, I'm I'm on this planet a bit
- 28:42longer than I ever thought I would be. But when the time comes to go,
- 28:45nothing needs to be done. Arrangements don't have to be made. And so I think
- 28:49the focus on transparency around the business model is maybe it's a
- 28:53little bit back to my father saying, you gotta go and figure out how this
- 28:56money thing works. Otherwise, it's gonna eat everything we love. Well, I
- 29:00am very excited about how money can work. I'm horrified by
- 29:03how it does work when it doesn't have a relationship with place.
- 29:08Helping make that visible and helping more people understand that. Like, I think the
- 29:12most important form of literacy we need in this world now
- 29:15is place literacy and economic literacy. And I don't mean
- 29:19by economic literacy financial literacy. I mean more people that
- 29:23understand how the economy works. Like, what are these flows? It's like a
- 29:27big plumbing system. And I think one of the greatest risks we
- 29:31have is that people feel, and many do, utterly
- 29:34powerless. People would rather have a conversation about their sex life than the
- 29:38economy. Because to most people, it's something that happens to them.
- 29:41And they're frustrated by it and they're just trying to survive it. But we are
- 29:45all economic actors, and we can all be
- 29:49economic stewards. How do we take what all of you
- 29:53have created and bottle it in a way that some of the
- 29:56other 4,500 communities in Canada are struggling for
- 30:00a sense of place, who they are, why they matter, the questions you
- 30:04ask time and time again, the questions that was answered by the National
- 30:07Film Board. How do we bring that so that we can start
- 30:11making our destiny more a matter of choice than leaving it to
- 30:15the chance of a world that I don't
- 30:19necessarily have to even connect to? We're building a
- 30:22National Institute for Community Economies, which will have a
- 30:26network associated with it and a digital platform, but it's a it's a way
- 30:30of gathering the good and best practices for community
- 30:33economic development. I mean, we can build a country where
- 30:37all investment is development, and that is such
- 30:40beautiful work. And that is where money
- 30:44meets place. Money making and meaning making are not
- 30:48opposites. They can come together. The more of us
- 30:52that are engaged in this and aware of that, the more we're gonna get this
- 30:55right. Like, we can do cultural and social and local development
- 30:59at the same time as we're doing investment. Investors
- 31:03growing a capacity to understand place will help. I mean,
- 31:07I think the work really is how do we reconcile the
- 31:10management of institutions with the management of place and
- 31:14places. That's the work and that's the magic. I mean, and if you
- 31:18think about Canada and these 4,500
- 31:21incorporated communities, we have very little horizontal
- 31:26musculature as a country. We're like, it's all these kind of vertical
- 31:29silos that are either political or private.
- 31:33So at every turn, you realize that the
- 31:37regional economy or the provincial economy or the national economy is not
- 31:40organized to intersect with place. I can't get
- 31:44ferry schedule to line up with a plane schedule to come together. They just don't
- 31:47connect because they're optimized in two different systems.
- 31:51The Department of Education doesn't optimize for local. It optimizes for
- 31:55the effectiveness or efficiency, not even effectiveness
- 31:59of itself, not the kids that you're trying to educate.
- 32:03Bringing place into all these systems makes those systems
- 32:07stronger. I I think that's the answer to resilience. I mean, resilience is
- 32:10ultimately local. If you had a magic wand and you're going in these communities,
- 32:14where's the biggest barriers that if you could just take that
- 32:18friction away, such great common sense? We organize
- 32:21ourselves around a poem. And the poem is the art of walking
- 32:25upright, is the art of using both feet. One is for
- 32:28holding on and one is for reaching out. And you gotta do them both
- 32:32or you're just gonna fall down. And every community is a bit different, but
- 32:36there's a lot in common. First of all, it's understanding yourself in the
- 32:39world. Understand how you fit into the
- 32:43regional and the provincial and the national and the global. That
- 32:46takes skill sets and experience sets that many local
- 32:50people don't have. That can be solved. I think the thing
- 32:54that is sometimes the hardest, and I see it in big and small
- 32:57communities, is there are very few architectures for
- 33:01collaboration within the place. So I could name so many
- 33:05communities across the country where you've got the city councils that are doing what they
- 33:08think, you know, my favorite question to ask in any place, who's
- 33:12responsible for the economy here? Must be the mayor.
- 33:16The mayor will be like, no, that he's if it's a he, responsible for
- 33:20the barking dogs and collecting taxes and how do we keep the water running here.
- 33:23I mean, I think what, Hazel McCallian said about Canada
- 33:27I see this a lot, which is, you know, the federal government has all the
- 33:31money, the provincial governments have all the power, and the municipalities have all the
- 33:34problems. What she didn't say is, all of our assets,
- 33:38all of our assets as a country are in a place somewhere.
- 33:42Our entrepreneurs are all in places. They need to be fed and loved and
- 33:45supported. So I think what we're missing, and if there's one thing, if I had
- 33:49a magic wand, is to build an architecture for
- 33:52collaboration in each place and across the
- 33:56pillars. So where the mayors or the councils come together with the
- 34:00business community, come together with the not for profits, come together with the educators,
- 34:04because it really actually takes all of us. And to all see
- 34:07ourselves as stewards of our place and the best way to steward your
- 34:11place is steward your economy and that we can do together.
- 34:15What about the what I call the invisible bars of status quo? Because
- 34:19I come to a meeting. I oh, yeah. Let's do it. But then I walk
- 34:22back and the last thing I wanna give up is what I feel I'm entitled
- 34:25to. I wanna preserve my status quo,
- 34:29whether that's power, that's influence, whether that's a level
- 34:32of entitlement because I've I've done this job for so many years.
- 34:36How do you break that apart? Because when you're talking about collaboration,
- 34:40when I see a silo, I see a moat, and I don't see a lot
- 34:43of drawbridges. And in fact, the middle ground is getting completely
- 34:47disappeared by a bigger and bigger moat. There is a process. There are many
- 34:50processes for that, but you're I couldn't agree with you more, Tony. Like, that
- 34:54people get very rigid around what they need to believe for whatever
- 34:58reason they need to believe that we can't touch this. There's a fellow, and he's
- 35:01from Alberta, named Doug Griffiths. He's he heads the Chamber of Commerce
- 35:05in Edmonton now. He was on MHA, and he wrote a
- 35:09book called 13 ways to kill your community, which
- 35:13is well worth reading. There is a a case study about our
- 35:16work that gets at some of this. They developed something called the
- 35:20PLACE model. It's an acronym. It's the l. It's about linking
- 35:24outsiders and insiders. And a part of our process and what we
- 35:28want to build into the institute's knowledge that we wanna get out in the
- 35:32world and add to is this holding on and reaching out. I think
- 35:36about it as hospitality. Someone has to set the table. So if if you're a
- 35:39family that fights with each other a lot, nothing like someone coming over
- 35:43from dinner, you know, for your dinner tonight to say, okay, stop fighting. Can we
- 35:46please set the table? Just stop fighting and act nice. And by the time the
- 35:49visitors have left, you're actually talking to each other differently. So I I think that
- 35:53is an important part of the flow of energy in a place that
- 35:57helps lessen the moat. How far do we have to
- 36:00get to precarious before we have that
- 36:04willingness to act? Very good friend of mine is from,
- 36:07Africa. And he said, you know, we we used to be happy with one meal
- 36:11a day and we fought hard for a second. And if we ever got three
- 36:14meals, it was an extraordinary day. So we were always hungry.
- 36:18We weren't entitled. He said his biggest surprise when he came to
- 36:22Canada was it wasn't about working for that second meal
- 36:26or being consumed about finding that second meal. It was expecting
- 36:29that second meal. And I'm wondering if part of our society,
- 36:33we've gotten to this point because as much as we want
- 36:37that future, we're not standing on enough shifting sand to say
- 36:41we gotta make a leap for it. We have difficulty also making a relationship
- 36:45with the future. One of my favorite books is The Leopard,
- 36:49which is set in Sicily. It's written in
- 36:521958 at the time of the reformation when all of the institutions had outlived
- 36:56their usefulness. And society they were struggling to figure out the
- 36:59path. And the great line from that book is, if you want
- 37:03things to stay the same, things have to change.
- 37:07Can you figure out that your two meals are not gonna be
- 37:10guaranteed? It's a twofold thing. It's because we do want we tend to
- 37:14want to defend what we have or think think we have and fail
- 37:18to see the future and fail to see that it's precarious unless we can figure
- 37:22out a world that works for more people. But the first thing
- 37:26is, which is I think where place I I see the place as the answer
- 37:29to everything, obviously, is if you see the world as a zero sum
- 37:33game and you're at the center of it, then you're never
- 37:37going to be open to anything. I tell you,
- 37:40if you actually show up in a community and start to
- 37:44muck along with people, you will not see your the more or less is
- 37:48there a song game, and you will not see yourself at the center. And the
- 37:51minute that little miracle happens, everything changes
- 37:55because in your life arrives this powerful
- 37:58thing called us. My guess, my last question for you,
- 38:02because I've I've taken so much of your time today, have you found your place?
- 38:06My place has never changed, you know. I mean, I I am made
- 38:09of Fogo Island and, you know, that's how I orient in this
- 38:13world. Ottawa is absolutely my second
- 38:17home, and my work is about
- 38:21how we put place in the economy. We have to get accounting
- 38:25to change. As long as the balance sheet doesn't show any of
- 38:28our actual assets, we're not gonna change what we do.
- 38:32I think about fish. You know, I jokingly say my
- 38:36father, you say, well, who in their right mind would catch all the fish? And
- 38:39he said, well, you could blame the policy makers. You could blame the the corporations
- 38:42that own the boats, but I don't. I blame the accountants
- 38:46because we were busy counting the fish we took out of the water and not
- 38:49the fish that were left in the water. I always end my podcast with my
- 38:53my three takeaways, and I don't even know where to begin because I've just been
- 38:56so moved by listening to your, you know, the world according
- 39:00to Cita Cobb. I guess the first word is the sense of how
- 39:04important place is. Realize that our past, present, and
- 39:08future are connected. And having a constant conversation,
- 39:12not being afraid to plant roots. And then the second thing is just building on
- 39:15that, the florets and this cauliflower and that we're all connected,
- 39:19but I really see this energy force. Your place in
- 39:23many ways is is that connective tissue. I think everything you've
- 39:27done in your life has been about connecting things, you know. And when I look
- 39:30at that business that you had, it was always about connecting the moving pieces,
- 39:34and we bought and we sold and we brought this back together, but always
- 39:38trying to make something. But I think the most important thing is, I'm
- 39:41not saying it was a throwaway, but it was a simple sentence. It was a
- 39:44whole concept of confidence. How important it is that we
- 39:48have confidence. If we don't have confidence, we are
- 39:52vulnerable. We're vulnerable to social media. We're vulnerable to being divided by our
- 39:55politicians. We're vulnerable in so many different ways, but we have
- 39:59confidence in in our place and our place within that
- 40:02place. I think it's one of the most powerful lessons I've heard on chatter that
- 40:06matters, and I thank you for that. And I just thank you for spending so
- 40:09much time with me today because you're just a beautiful human being.
- 40:13I'm so happy your place is in Canada. It's our
- 40:16place together, Tony, and we'll have more conversations. Many
- 40:20more. I've got the greatest
- 40:24job in the world. I get to share stories of people like Zeta
- 40:27Cobb, beautiful human beings, human beings
- 40:31in a constant conversation mother nature
- 40:35and human nature, creativity, and collaborative,
- 40:39circular economy, sharing the wealth of so much to learn from
- 40:43stories like hers. And it wouldn't be possible, Chad, if it
- 40:47matters, without RBC. So just for the RBCers out there listening, thank you. You should
- 40:48be so for the RBCers out there listening, thank you.
- 40:52You should be so proud what your organization does as an entity or through
- 40:55its foundation to make such a positive impact on Canada.
- 40:59Today, I wanna talk to you about Canada's new economy.
- 41:03What are we gonna create that creates positive
- 41:07energy and purpose, profit, taxes,
- 41:11where wealth is shared evenly versus put in the hands of a few,
- 41:15where investments are made with intent. I started thinking of our
- 41:19legacy industries and wondering, could they ever change to do
- 41:23that? Private sector, public sector,
- 41:27unions, special interest groups, would they ever trust each other? Would all
- 41:31they all feel that one was trying to win over the other. I'm not
- 41:34sure. I've never really met a person that's willing to give up anything
- 41:38that they feel they work for or deserved. So I thinking, well,
- 41:42what else can we do? And one of the areas that came to mind and
- 41:45why I did back to back shows, first with Ben Cowan Durr,
- 41:49with his golf courses in Cape Breton, world renowned. And today with Zita
- 41:52Cobb, is tourism. Tourism
- 41:56brings so much magic. Happy people
- 42:00today all armed with camera, video player,
- 42:03and a social media empire. Time in life where we
- 42:07are so thirsty for human nature, mother
- 42:11nature, the nature of things versus the reality of
- 42:14today. And an industry that when you think of your nature
- 42:18as a stage and what happens around it is the
- 42:22experiences that you create, authentic and real,
- 42:25not synthetic like you might find in Vegas, but
- 42:29real. It's what people want nowadays. And where else but
- 42:33Canada? Our landmass, our beauty. I mean, I see
- 42:37a longevity center near our hot springs, And
- 42:40everything is about living longer and better.
- 42:44I see what we can do with culinary, multicultural,
- 42:48ecotourism, adventure tourism. Send me your place in the
- 42:52world, and I promise you I'll send back an
- 42:56idea that nothing less will give you a point of discussion.
- 43:01Tourism means the world to each of us, to all of us.
- 43:05And tourism can be one of the pillars that ignites
- 43:09Canada's new economy. And next week,
- 43:13we're gonna talk about farm to fork, and why food means the world
- 43:16to all of us, and why Canada can become a superpower
- 43:20in food. It's
- 43:24Tony Chapman. Thanks for listening to my rant. Thank you RBC,
- 43:28and let's chow down.