Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Manage a Team Member Who Always Says I Can Do It Myself
Transcript
- Lucas: You know that team member who says 'I can do it myself' — genuinely, not passive-aggressively — but ends up working late, missing deadlines, and eventually burning out? Luna: Oh, absolutely. I had a direct report like that once. Smart, capable, but would rather drown than ask for help. Lucas: Exactly. And as a manager, you're caught between respecting their autonomy and watching the train go off the rails. So today we're going to dig into that specific personality — the employee who insists on going solo. Lucas: I want to start with a real case. A marketing coordinator named Priya at a mid-sized tech firm in Austin. Her manager, David, noticed she was taking on more and more work without delegating. When he offered to reassign some tasks, she said, 'No, I've got it. I work better alone.' Luna: Classic. And then what happened? Lucas: Over six months, her output quality slipped, she started missing internal deadlines, and she became irritable in meetings. David tried to intervene again, but Priya interpreted it as a lack of trust. Eventually she quit citing 'burnout.' The company spent about fifteen thousand dollars on recruitment and ramp-up for her replacement. Luna: Ouch. And that's the hidden cost of the 'I can do it myself' mindset. It's not just about workload — it's about retention. Lucas: Right. So what drives this behavior? It's rarely laziness. Often it's a fear of being seen as incompetent, or a past experience where delegation led to poor results. Priya once told David that a previous manager had given her a task and then micromanaged it so badly she resolved to never share work again. Luna: So it's a trust wound. The employee doesn't trust that help will actually be helpful. Lucas: Exactly. And the manager's instinct — to back off and give space — can actually reinforce the problem. The employee hears 'my manager trusts me to handle it alone' when what they need is 'my manager will help me grow by collaborating.' Luna: So what do you do differently? Because just ordering them to delegate won't work. Lucas: There's a three-step framework I've seen work. Step one: reframe help as a growth opportunity, not a rescue. Instead of saying 'Let me take some work off your plate,' say 'I want you to partner with someone on this project so you can learn their approach to client presentations.' Luna: Nice — you're repositioning it as skill-building, not hand-holding. Lucas: Exactly. Step two: assign a structured peer buddy for specific collaborative tasks. Not just 'work with Sarah,' but 'You and Sarah will co-lead the Q3 campaign. You own the creative, she owns the analytics, and you'll review each other's work before the Friday sync.' Luna: That makes it concrete. It's not vague 'collaboration' — it's a defined partnership with clear ownership. Lucas: Right. And step three: use what I call 'forced delegation' exercises in your 1-on-1s. Once per month, ask the employee to identify one task they currently own that someone else could do at 80% quality or better. Then together, you script the handoff conversation. Luna: That's clever because it builds the muscle gradually. They're not delegating a huge project — just one task. And you're coaching them through it. Lucas: Exactly. Over time, they start to see that delegating doesn't mean losing control. It means building a team that can scale beyond them. Luna: And speaking of scaling — if today's framework was useful to you, the way this show stays ad-free is listener support. You can buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small way to keep these episodes free for everyone. Lucas: Yeah, we really appreciate that. And honestly, it's because of listeners like you that we can drill into topics like this without interruption. So thank you. Lucas: Let's go back to the peer buddy concept for a second, because I think it's the most practical tool here. A study from Gallup in 2023 found that managers who normalize asking for help see twenty-seven percent higher team retention. Luna: Twenty-seven percent — that's huge. And it makes sense. When help-seeking is modeled from the top, it becomes safe to say 'I need support.' Lucas: Exactly. So as a manager, you have to be the first one to ask for help in front of your team. Say 'Hey, I'm stuck on this budget model. Can you two take a look?' Luna: That's vulnerable. But it sends a powerful signal: no one here is expected to have all the answers. Lucas: And that's especially important for the 'I can do it myself' employee. They need to see that competence isn't about solo performance — it's about knowing when to leverage the team. Luna: So let's talk about what happens when the employee still resists, even after you've tried the reframing and the buddy system. Lucas: That's a tougher scenario. At that point, you need to make the business case explicit. You say, 'Priya, I respect your desire to own this work. But our team's success depends on knowledge sharing. If you leave tomorrow, we'd lose everything you've built. That's a risk I can't accept.' Luna: Wow — that's direct. It frames it as a risk to the organization, not a personal failing. Lucas: Exactly. And then you offer a specific, low-stakes collaboration: 'For the next two weeks, I want you to spend thirty minutes a day pairing with Jamie on the reporting dashboard. You can still own the final output, but the process is joint.' Luna: So you're meeting them halfway. They keep ownership, but the process becomes collaborative. Lucas: Right. And if they still refuse? That's a performance issue. At that point, you document the conversation, set clear expectations, and escalate if necessary. But in my experience, most employees come around when they see the structure is designed to make them — and the team — more successful. Luna: And if they do come around, what's the long-term payoff? Lucas: You build a team member who becomes a multiplier. Someone who used to hoard work now actively mentors others. I've seen it happen. Priya, if David had caught this earlier, could have become his best team lead. Luna: Instead of costing fifteen grand to replace. Lucas: Exactly. So the takeaway: don't let 'I can do it myself' go unchecked. It's not a sign of strength — it's a symptom of a trust issue that needs gentle, structured intervention. Luna: And if you're a first-time manager hearing this, start with the reframe. Then the buddy system. Then the forced delegation. And model help-seeking yourself. Lucas: Great advice. That's it for this week's Manager Monday. Good luck with your 1-on-1s this week. Luna: See you next time.