Latest / Reformed Thinking / “Shall Not the Judge of All the Earth Do Right?”: Abraham’s Intercession and the Harmony of Divine Justice and Mercy (Genesis 18:22–33)
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to reformed thinking. I'm so glad you're with us
- 0:02today. Glad to be here.
- 0:03We have a massive text to get into.
- 0:06We are cracking open Genesis chapter 18.
- 0:09A very familiar one. It is.
- 0:11I mean, if you've spent anytime in church, you know the first
- 0:13half of this chapter. It's that classic scene by the
- 0:16irks of memory. Right with the three visitors.
- 0:18Exactly. Abraham sitting there in the
- 0:20heat of the day, these three men show up and there's this, you
- 0:24know, this rush of hospitality. Sarah's making cakes.
- 0:27Abraham is running to the herd to get a calf.
- 0:29It feels very domestic, very intimate.
- 0:33It's the scene where Sarah laughs at the promise of a son.
- 0:37It's a stunning picture of Grace.
- 0:38It really is. You have the Lord appearing to
- 0:40Abraham, eating with him, renewing all these covenant
- 0:42promises. It feels like everything is
- 0:44right with the world. But then.
- 0:46But then the scene shifts, the camera angle moves.
- 0:49You could say the meal's over, the sun is setting and the men
- 0:52get up to leave and all of a sudden we're not talking about
- 0:55birth and laughter anymore. No, we're staring down the
- 0:58barrel of total destruction. The whole text just pivots.
- 1:01It pivots hard. The visitors who we know are
- 1:04angels with the Lord in a temporary physical form, they
- 1:08look down towards Sodom and this sets the stage for what I think
- 1:12is one of the most misunderstood conversations in the entire
- 1:15Bible. I would agree.
- 1:17I have heard so many sermons that portray Abraham's
- 1:21intercession here as a kind of negotiation.
- 1:23The haggling metaphor. The haggling metaphor gets
- 1:26framed like a flea market transaction.
- 1:28I'll give you 50. No.
- 1:30How about 40, you know? That's the standard Sunday
- 1:32school take, isn't it? That this is a story about being
- 1:35bold enough to bargain with God, right?
- 1:37But when you actually study this, especially to the lens of
- 1:40Reformed theology, that reading just falls apart.
- 1:43It really does. This is not a marketplace, this
- 1:46is a courtroom. It's a high stakes legal drama.
- 1:49Abraham isn't haggling over the price of a rug.
- 1:51He's acting as legal counsel in a capital case.
- 1:54And the judge? And the judge he's addressing is
- 1:56the judge of all the earth. Wow, that framing changes the
- 2:00entire mood of the passage. We're moving from the Oaks of
- 2:03Mamre, which stands for Life and Covenant Intimacy, to this
- 2:07overlook facing Sodom, which is all about death and judgment.
- 2:12It's a jarring shift, yeah. And the mission for our
- 2:15discussion today is to really analyze what Abraham is actually
- 2:18doing here. We want to look at this
- 2:20intercession as a forensic appeal.
- 2:22A. Forensic appeal.
- 2:24Yeah, an appeal based entirely on God's character.
- 2:27And in doing that, we need to see how this text harmonizes
- 2:29justice and mercy. How it exposes the total
- 2:33depravity of the human heart and why it proves that we need a
- 2:37better mediator than Abraham. So let's get into the text
- 2:39itself. The setup here is so crucial.
- 2:41In verse 22 you see the spatial separation happening.
- 2:44The men, the 2 angels, they turn and walk toward Sodom.
- 2:47But the text says Abraham still stood before the Lord.
- 2:51That phrase stood before is doing a lot of heavy lifting in
- 2:53the original Hebrew. Tell us about that.
- 2:55It's a mad lift me. This isn't just, you know,
- 2:57loitering or waiting around in the ancient Near East.
- 3:00This is technical language. It describes the posture of a
- 3:02servant waiting for a command from his master, or more
- 3:06specifically, an official standing in a Royal Court.
- 3:09Abraham is taking a formal stance.
- 3:12So he's assuming a position. He is a position of service and
- 3:16attention, and then the text says he drew near.
- 3:21The verb for that is nagash. Nagash I I feel like I've seen
- 3:25that word before in the Joseph narrative maybe.
- 3:28You did. That's a great catch.
- 3:29It's used when Judah approaches Joseph, who he thinks is this
- 3:33powerful Egyptian ruler, to plead for his brother Benjamin.
- 3:37It's also used in priestly context for approaching the
- 3:40altar. So it signifies stepping forward
- 3:42for advocacy, the bold, deliberate movement into the
- 3:44inner circle. So Abraham is not a bystander
- 3:47just watching the world burn. Not at all.
- 3:49He has been admitted into the divine counsel.
- 3:51He's a friend of God. Which is just mind blowing when
- 3:54you think about it. God actually pauses his plan to
- 3:57reveal it to a human being. It is in verse 17 God asked this
- 4:01rhetorical question, Shall I hide from Abraham what I'm about
- 4:04to do? It implies God debated it, or at
- 4:06least he wanted us to see the question.
- 4:07I mean, God is about to wipe a city state off the map.
- 4:10He's sovereign. He doesn't need a permission
- 4:12slip. So why tell Abraham?
- 4:14It's certainly not because God needs advice, right?
- 4:17The text gives us the reason God has chosen Abraham so that he
- 4:22might command his children and his household after him to keep
- 4:25the way of the Lord by doing righteousness and justice.
- 4:28Ah. So that's the key.
- 4:30That is the key. God reviews the judgment because
- 4:34He is training Abraham. He needs Abraham, and through
- 4:37him all of us, to understand what divine justice actually
- 4:40looks like. So the destruction of Sodom
- 4:42isn't some outburst of divine rave.
- 4:45No, it's not God losing his temper.
- 4:47It's a wholly calculated and necessary reaction to pervasive
- 4:51sin. By bringing Abraham into the
- 4:53loop, God is vindicating his own character before the gavel
- 4:56drops. He wants Abraham to know that
- 4:57the judge is just. But this brings up a huge
- 5:00theological hurdle that I think a lot of people trip over.
- 5:03The sovereignty question. The sovereignty question If God
- 5:06is sovereign and if the outcry against Sodom has already
- 5:09reached him, the verdict seems set.
- 5:12So why pray? Isn't it just fatalism to say,
- 5:15well God decreed it so my prayer is pointless?
- 5:18That's a really lazy view of sovereignty, though.
- 5:20Well, Vaidalism says the blueprint is drawn, so I'm just
- 5:23going to take a nap. Biblical faith says God is the
- 5:27architect, and he has graciously invited me to work on the site
- 5:30with him. That's a great way to put it.
- 5:32Abraham standing before the Lord completely contradicts fatalism.
- 5:37He prays with the conviction that God actually hears and
- 5:39responds, but it also contradicts presumption.
- 5:42Meaning he doesn't just charge in.
- 5:44Exactly. He doesn't storm into the throne
- 5:46room demanding his rights. He waits.
- 5:48He asks. He is active, but he's
- 5:51incredibly reverent. He knows he's duffing in ashes,
- 5:54yet he still steps into the legal chamber to present a
- 5:56defense. And that defense, It begins with
- 5:59a question that echoes through the rest of the Bible, verse 23.
- 6:02Will you indeed sweep away the righteous with the wicked?
- 6:05This is the absolute heart of his forensic appeal and we need
- 6:09to be really precise with our terms here.
- 6:11OK. When Abraham says righteous, the
- 6:13Hebrew was Sadiq, he's referring to someone in right standing
- 6:15with the law, someone innocent of the capital charges brought
- 6:18against the city, and the wicked.
- 6:19The wicked Rasha means the guilty, those characterized by
- 6:22impiety and criminal looseness. And that verb sweep away Safa.
- 6:29It implies indiscriminate destruction.
- 6:31Like wiping a table clean without sorting the good from
- 6:34the bad. Precisely.
- 6:35So Abraham is not asking for amnesty.
- 6:38He isn't saying God. Please ignore the fact that
- 6:41these people are wool monsters. Not at all, and that's a vital
- 6:45distinction. He isn't asking God to overlook
- 6:48sin, He is asking God to distinguish between categories.
- 6:51His argument is a moral 1. It's strictly moral, he is
- 6:54saying in effect, God. If you drop fire on the the
- 6:57whole city and kill the innocent along with the guilty, you will
- 7:00look like the Pagan gods. The gods of the Canaanites or
- 7:02the Babylonians? Exactly.
- 7:03The gods of the surrounding nations were capricious.
- 7:06They were unpredictable. I mean in the Epic of Gilgamesh
- 7:08the gods fled the whole earth just because humans were being
- 7:11too noisy and kept them awake. So Abraham is challenging
- 7:15Yahweh, saying you are not like them.
- 7:17Yes, and he uses incredibly strong language to do it.
- 7:21In verse 25 he says far be it from you.
- 7:24It sounds so intense in English. It's even more so in Hebrew.
- 7:27The word is chalilah. It's an exclamation of horror,
- 7:31essentially means profane. He's saying it would be a
- 7:33profanity for you to act this way.
- 7:36Abraham is acting as a theologian here.
- 7:37He's arguing that for God to be unjust is a theological
- 7:41impossibility. He's appealing to God's very
- 7:44nature. Shall not the judge of all the
- 7:45earth do what is just, or more literally do mish pat?
- 7:50This connects to a classic philosophical problem, doesn't
- 7:52it? The Euthyphra dilemma?
- 7:53It does. Is something right because God
- 7:55wills it, or does God will it because it's right?
- 7:57And that's the battle between what's called volunteerism and
- 8:00essentialism. Volunteerism is the idea that
- 8:03good is just whatever God decided in the moment.
- 8:06So if God decided tomorrow that hating your neighbor was good,
- 8:10then hate would become. Good.
- 8:12Under a strict volunteerist view, yes.
- 8:14It suggests God's will is arbitrary, that is untethered to
- 8:17any fixed nature or standard. Which is terrifying.
- 8:21It makes God a tyrant who just makes up the rules as he goes.
- 8:24It's a nightmare scenario, really.
- 8:26It removes all stability from the universe, but this text
- 8:30flatly refutes that view. How so?
- 8:33Abraham is arguing from essentialism or realism.
- 8:36He's saying that God wills what is right because He is, in his
- 8:39very essence, eternally righteous.
- 8:42So God is bound by his own perfection.
- 8:44He is. He cannot act against his own
- 8:46nature any more than he can cease to exist.
- 8:49Abraham isn't holding God to some standard outside of God.
- 8:52He's asking God to be consistent with himself.
- 8:55He's asking the judge to be the rule.
- 8:57Shall not the judge of all the earth do what is just?
- 8:59It's a rhetorical question, but the answer has to be yes.
- 9:02It must be yes. If the answer is no, then
- 9:04gravity falls apart. Moral law falls apart.
- 9:07Everything collapses. So he appeals to the standard of
- 9:09the law that flows from God's nature.
- 9:11Right. He isn't asking for a favor.
- 9:13He's asking for Mishpat for justice.
- 9:16And here's where the brilliance of the text really shines.
- 9:19Because by asking God to apply strict justice to distinguish
- 9:22the righteous from the wicked, Abraham is actually setting up a
- 9:25devastating discovery. And this leads us to the
- 9:28countdown. The countdown We start at 50.
- 9:31Suppose there are 50 righteous within the city.
- 9:34And God replies, If I find 50, I will spare the whole place for
- 9:38their sake. Then Abraham goes to 45403020
- 9:42and finally 10. This is the part everyone calls
- 9:45haggling, right? But if we drop that metaphor,
- 9:47what is actually happening here? OK.
- 9:49Think of Abraham as a defense attorney.
- 9:51He's probing the evidence during a deposition.
- 9:53OK, I like that. He's testing the mercy of the
- 9:56court, yes, but he's also testing the moral state of his
- 9:59client, the city. He's trying to find the floor of
- 10:02its depravity. He starts high with 50. 50
- 10:06That's a respectable number. If there are 50 decent man in
- 10:08the city, surely that city has a future.
- 10:12And God agrees. But then Abraham pauses.
- 10:16You can almost see him doing the math in his head.
- 10:19He looks at what he knows of Sodom, and he realizes 50 might
- 10:23be a stretch. It feels like a slow dawning
- 10:24horror for him. He isn't negotiating the price
- 10:26down. He's realizing the inventory
- 10:28simply isn't there. That is it exactly.
- 10:31And this brings us face to face with the doctrine of total
- 10:34depravity. From the Westminster Confession,
- 10:36yes. The confession describes
- 10:38unregenerate humanity as wholly defiled in all the parts and
- 10:42faculties. Now, we often think depravity
- 10:45means every person is as bad as they could possibly be.
- 10:49You know that every neighbor is a serial killer.
- 10:51Right, but that's not what it means.
- 10:53No, Technically it means that sins corruption has infected
- 10:57every part of us. Our mind, our will, our
- 10:59emotions. And in Sodom, that corruption is
- 11:02total. This was a major city state.
- 11:04It wasn't a tiny village. And yet Abraham realizes he
- 11:08might not even find 10 men who aren't participants in its
- 11:11wickedness. And 10 is a significant number
- 11:14in Jewish tradition. Isn't it the minion?
- 11:16It is. The term comes later, but the
- 11:18concept is rooted right here. 10 is a quorum.
- 11:21It's the smallest number needed to constitute a community.
- 11:24If you have 10, you have a congregation.
- 11:26If you have fewer than 10, you just have a few isolated
- 11:29individuals. So he's looking for a remnant
- 11:31that can preserve the corporate identity of the city.
- 11:33He is, and this shows us what you could call the mathematics
- 11:36of mercy. God is willing to spare the
- 11:38whole place for the sake of just a few.
- 11:40That's a staggering display of grace right there.
- 11:43God was willing to let thousands of wicked people continue living
- 11:47just so that 50 or even 10 righteous people wouldn't be
- 11:50swept away. It is the remnant principle.
- 11:53The righteous act as a preservative.
- 11:55They're the salt holding back the decay.
- 11:57But the terrifying part of this whole dialogue is what happens
- 12:00at 10. And at the countdown.
- 12:02Abraham asks. Suppose 10 are found there, and
- 12:05God says I will not destroy it if I find 10.
- 12:07Yeah. And then silence.
- 12:09Abraham stops asking. He stops.
- 12:11Why? Why not ask for five?
- 12:13Why not just ask for Lot and his family specifically?
- 12:16Because I think Abraham realizes he's hit the absolute floor.
- 12:20If there aren't even 10 righteous men, the argument for
- 12:23corporate preservation becomes legally invalid.
- 12:25You can't ask a judge to save an entire city state for the sake
- 12:29of two or three people who probably want to leave anyway.
- 12:31At that point, the corruption is absolute.
- 12:33It's absolute. The city is essentially dead
- 12:35already. The fire is just the cremation,
- 12:37so the. Silence that follows.
- 12:38That's the verdict. That is the verdict, and this is
- 12:41so crucial. Sodom is destroyed not because
- 12:45God like mercy he agreed to spare it for just 10, but
- 12:49because the 10 did not exist. It's the death knell for
- 12:52Pelagianism. It is.
- 12:54The idea that humans are inherently good or can fix
- 12:57themselves if you just give them enough time.
- 13:00Abraham probes the city for righteousness and the result is
- 13:03zero. Well, nearly zero.
- 13:05There's a lot, there is a lot, but as we see in chapter 19, Lot
- 13:08has to be dragged out by his collar.
- 13:11He isn't saving the city. He barely gets saved himself as
- 13:14through fire, as the apostle would say.
- 13:17It really refutes that modern notion that if we just educate
- 13:19people enough or fix the economic structures, society
- 13:22will perfect itself. Genesis 18 says no.
- 13:25A culture can reach a point of moral 0 Wholly defiled.
- 13:29It exposes the spiritual bankruptcy of man.
- 13:31Abraham stops asking because he knows the defense has rested.
- 13:34There's no more evidence to present.
- 13:36This paints a pretty bleak picture of humanity.
- 13:39We have a righteous holy judge and a city with 0 righteousness
- 13:42to its name. If the story ends there, we're
- 13:44all in serious trouble. We are, But as Reformed
- 13:47thinkers, we know the Old Testament is always pointing
- 13:49forward. So how do we connect this to
- 13:51Christ? We have to view Abraham here as
- 13:54a type, a shadow of the great high priest.
- 13:57He's an intercessor. He stands between the wrath of
- 14:00God and the objects of that wrath.
- 14:03But he is an imperfect intercessor.
- 14:05He is, as he admits, just dust and ashes.
- 14:08So what's the primary contrast between Abraham's intercession
- 14:12and Christ's? It's the basis of the plea.
- 14:15Look at Abraham's logic. It's all conditional.
- 14:18If I find 50. If I find 40, he is trying to
- 14:21leverage human merit. He's trying to find something
- 14:23good in the people. He is, he's saying God, there's
- 14:25something good down there, so please hold back your hand.
- 14:28He's looking for a reason in the Sinner to save the Sinner.
- 14:31And he runs out of reasons. Precisely.
- 14:33The countdown is 0. But Christ, Christ please, not
- 14:36based on our merit at all. It's based on his own finished
- 14:40work. He doesn't say Father forgive
- 14:42them because there are 10 good guys among them.
- 14:44He says Father forgive them, and he bases that petition on his
- 14:49own perfect sacrifice. So Abraham counts down to 10 and
- 14:52stops. He goes back to his place and
- 14:55the fire falls. But Christ counts down to 0 to
- 14:58the absolute moral zero of the human heart, and he doesn't walk
- 15:03away. He steps in.
- 15:05That is the shift Abraham seeks preservation.
- 15:07Spare the wicked for the sake of the righteous, but Christ offers
- 15:10substitution. That is the gospel logic in a
- 15:13nutshell. Abraham asked, will you sweep
- 15:15away the righteous with the wicked?
- 15:17And the answer we get at the cross is no, I will sweep away
- 15:20the righteous 1 instead of the wicked.
- 15:21The judge of all the Earth did do right.
- 15:23He did, he satisfied justice, but he did it by taking the
- 15:26penalty upon himself and the person of the Son.
- 15:29So in Genesis 18, Abraham hoped that Lot's righteousness,
- 15:32whatever small amount there was, would shield Sodom.
- 15:36But in the New Testament we talk about imputation.
- 15:38Right. Lot's righteousness was barely
- 15:40enough to shield Lot himself. It certainly couldn't cover the
- 15:42city. But Christ's perfect
- 15:45righteousness is imputed to the ungodly.
- 15:47As Romans 4.5 tells us, it's a shield that actually works.
- 15:50And it's permanent. It's permanent, unlike Abraham,
- 15:53who is dust and ashes and eventually died.
- 15:55Hebrews 7 tells us that Jesus holds his priesthood
- 15:58permanently. He always lived to make
- 16:00intercession. He never has to stop at 10.
- 16:02He never has to return to his place in defeat.
- 16:05He sits at the right hand of the Father, having secured the
- 16:07verdict. The gospel answers the question
- 16:10that Genesis 18 leaves hanging in the air.
- 16:13Where is the righteousness? It isn't in US.
- 16:15It's in Christ. That is it.
- 16:17And that changes everything about how we view judgement.
- 16:20The judge judge the mediator so that the defendants could go
- 16:23free. So let's bring this home.
- 16:25What does this mean for us today?
- 16:26We have the theology. We have the typology.
- 16:28How do we apply this? We usually talk about head,
- 16:31heart and hands. Let's start with the head, then
- 16:33the doctrine. This text must vindicate God's
- 16:36justice in our minds. What?
- 16:38Do you mean by that? We live in an age of theological
- 16:42liberalism that wants a God of pure affirmation with no wrath
- 16:47or open theism, which claims God doesn't know the future and is
- 16:50just sort of negotiating as he goes, surprised by the outcome.
- 16:54Genesis 18 completely shuts that down.
- 16:56Completely. God knows the outcome.
- 16:58He is the judge of all the earth.
- 16:59We have to affirm the reality of hell and divine retribution.
- 17:03If we don't believe God is just, we won't value the cross.
- 17:07That's a strong connection. If Sodom didn't deserve to burn,
- 17:10then Jesus didn't need to die. Exactly.
- 17:12We have to have the theological backbone to say God's judgement
- 17:15is measured and it is right. That's a hard truth, but a
- 17:18necessary one. OK, So what about the heart?
- 17:23Our affections? It's so easy to look at the
- 17:25sodoms of our own culture and just get angry or disgusted.
- 17:28It is. It's easy to slide into self
- 17:30righteousness. Look at those terrible sinners
- 17:32over there. But look at Abraham.
- 17:35He stood there and he pleaded. He didn't celebrate the coming
- 17:37destruction and Lot and Lot. Second, Peter 2.7 says he was
- 17:41tormented in his righteous soul. He wasn't indifferent, but he
- 17:45wasn't gleeful either. He was in agony.
- 17:46Compassionate agony. We should be tormented by the
- 17:49sin we see, not just annoyed by it.
- 17:51We should fear the judgement enough to flee it ourselves and
- 17:54love our neighbors enough to warn them.
- 17:57If we truly believe what we said about the head, that judgement
- 18:01is real and just, that our heart should break for the lost.
- 18:06We shouldn't just be culture warriors destroying enemies.
- 18:09We should be intercessors pleading for their souls.
- 18:12Which leads us to the hands, the practice.
- 18:15What do we actually do? Well, first, intercessory
- 18:18prayer. We need to recover the art of
- 18:20drawing near. We need to pray for the
- 18:22restraint of evil in our cities. We need to pray for the
- 18:24salvation of the elect. And we need to use Abraham's
- 18:27arguments. Pray based on God's character.
- 18:30Lord, for the sake of your great name, show mercy.
- 18:32And we also need to confront idols.
- 18:34The commentaries we looked at mentioned specific things,
- 18:37materialism, sexual anarchy. We can't be afraid to name the
- 18:40sins of the time. Sodom had specific sins.
- 18:43Our culture has specific sins. We need them not to condemn
- 18:47people to hell, but to offer the only remedy, which is Christ.
- 18:50But we have to be distinct. We must be distinct.
- 18:52You cannot intercede for Sodom if you're pitching your tent
- 18:55toward Sodom. That refers to Lot again,
- 18:57doesn't it? He got too close.
- 18:59He did. He hesitated when the angels
- 19:01told him to run. We cannot be indistinguishable
- 19:05from the world if we're just like the culture.
- 19:08We have no platform from which to warn the culture.
- 19:11We need to live as sojourners, just as Abraham did.
- 19:14And finally, that leaves evangelism.
- 19:16The countdown stopped. That's the haunting reality of
- 19:19this chapter. There is no safety in Numbers.
- 19:22People think, well, everyone else is doing it.
- 19:24Surely God won't judge us all. Genesis 18 says yes, he will.
- 19:28So we have to preach Christ before the clock runs out.
- 19:30We have to, we have to tell people that the only safety is
- 19:33not in the crowd but in the mediator.
- 19:35It's a heavy message, but in the end, it's a hopeful one because
- 19:38of Christ. That is the only hope.
- 19:40As we wrap up, let's look at how the narrative ends.
- 19:43Verse 33 And the Lord went his way, and Abraham returned to his
- 19:48place. It's so quiet, the session is
- 19:51over. The next morning the smoke rose.
- 19:54Abraham looked out and he saw the destruction.
- 19:57Very somber ending to the chapter.
- 19:58It does leave us with a final thought to chew on, though.
- 20:01It does. Genesis 18 leaves us with this
- 20:04haunting question. Where is the righteousness that
- 20:07can save a city? It wasn't in.
- 20:09Sodom. It wasn't in Sodom, and it
- 20:11wasn't even in Abraham. He was just a man of dust.
- 20:13The silence at the end of that chapter is deafening, and it's
- 20:16only broken centuries later by the voice of the Son of God.
- 20:21We survive the judgement not because we're one of the 50.
- 20:24And not because we're lucky. We survive because we're hidden
- 20:28in the one righteous man. That's the only place to stand.
- 20:30Thank you for walking us through this.
- 20:32It really transforms a familiar story into something so solid
- 20:36for our faith. It has been my pleasure.
- 20:38And to our listener, thank you for joining us on Reformed
- 20:41Thinking. We encourage you to go read
- 20:42Genesis 18 again with these fresh eyes.
- 20:45Rest in the Judge who is also your Savior.
- 20:47We'll see you next time.