Latest / Dark Murder: True Crime Cases / Episode 90
Transcript
- 0:06Dark murder True crime cases five, four, three, two, one one
- 0:21one. Welcome back. I'm your host, Jordan Lee. I'm sure you
- 0:31are all ready to dive into some dark, creepy stories, so let's get
- 0:34started. They had the killer, but what was his name? In eighteen
- 0:44fifty four, the tiny town of Nell's Corners, Ontario, was rocked by
- 0:50a crime that would lead to a trial that left those who bore witness to
- 0:54it with more questions than answers. It all started on the night of October
- 0:59eighteenth, when John Niles, his wife, her sister, and his brother
- 1:04Augustus had just finished dinner when a group of five men broke through the front
- 1:10door. John was alone at this time, and when he saw the stranger's
- 1:14faces as darkened with a black substance, he knew what their intentions were.
- 1:21The sound of their gunfire echoed through the house, and John Nells was lying
- 1:26badly wounded on the floor. A slight twitch brought a second bullet. The
- 1:30commotion brought his wife and her sister to his aid, who were subsequently ignored
- 1:36as the suspects tore off the dying man's watch before searching the rest of the
- 1:40house for valuables. Augustus, having been woken from the first shot, and
- 1:46upon hearing the second, chose not to move from his bed. After the
- 1:49five men left, they disappeared into the night, only to reappear a few
- 1:53miles down the road, where they held up a couple of farmers for the
- 1:57few dollars in their pockets. Afterward, they all boarded a train headed to
- 2:01Buffalo, and upon arrival they went their separate ways. Their disguises proved inadequate,
- 2:07however, since the women and the two farmers were able to give an
- 2:10accurate description of the men to authorities, three of the men, men by
- 2:16the name of King, Blois and Bryson, were quickly found and arrested.
- 2:23Afterward, all three of them were found guilty and sentenced to death by hanging.
- 2:28King and Blowis would eventually face this punishment, but Bryson would have his
- 2:32sentence commuted to life in prison. The one thing that they did not agree
- 2:38on was none of them had been the one to fire the bullet that eventually
- 2:40killed John Nels. That had been one William Townsend. A month would pass
- 2:47until police would get a tip about Townsend. It came when two men walked
- 2:52into a hotel in Port Robinson and saw him or who they believed was William
- 2:58Townsend. The police were immediately called. Several people ran to the location hoping
- 3:04to see the arrest of their wanted criminal, including Constable Charles Richard, who
- 3:09confronted the stranger. For his efforts, the man believed to be Townsend pulled
- 3:15out a gun and fired. The constable would die a few hours later,
- 3:19and the man who was suspected to be Townsend fled from the scene. It
- 3:23would be another two years before Townshend would reappear once more, this time in
- 3:29Cleveland, Ohio. He was arrested without a fight and eventually extradited to Canada
- 3:36in May eighteen fifty seven to stand trial for the murder of John Nelt.
- 3:40From the very beginning, the man people thought of as William Townsend was a
- 3:46problem. Not only was he hostile towards the police, but the high profile
- 3:50case had drawn the attention of some very powerful people. The primary argument he
- 3:55made centered on his claim that he wasn't in fact William town but Robert McHenry,
- 4:01a Scott and Mariner who was stationed out of Cleveland. He also told
- 4:05authorities he'd been in California during the time john Nels was killed. When the
- 4:12trial began, the only question that seemed the matter was, this is this
- 4:17man William Townsend or Robert McHenry. If you were to believe Lucy Humphreys,
- 4:25john Nell's sister in law, he was the man who shot and killed him.
- 4:30Even Bryson was brought in from prison to testify to the man's identity,
- 4:33who claimed he was Townsend. Even a number of former neighbors also claimed him
- 4:39to be the man in question. Despite this list of witnesses, however,
- 4:44the defense placed one person after another, including Townsend's own brother in law,
- 4:48on the stand, all of which told the jury they didn't know the accused.
- 4:54The parade of witnesses worked in the defense's favor, and after six hours
- 4:59of deliberation, the jury came back and told the judge they were deadlocked.
- 5:02After their dismissal, the defendant was preparing to be returned to jail when he
- 5:08was read a warrant for his arrest for the murder of Constable Charles Richards.
- 5:14Townsend or McHenry was transferred to another location to stand trial for that murder.
- 5:19His defense was identical to the one he'd incorporated in his previous trial. This
- 5:26time, the jury came back with a verdict that all of them were happy
- 5:29with. They announced to the court room they believed him to be McHenry and
- 5:34thus he was not guilty. With the acquittal, the taverns around the city
- 5:39that night were full of those celebrating with the defense's victory. Despite the setback,
- 5:46he was still under arrest for the murder of John Nells and had to
- 5:49be returned for a possible retrial. Three days after getting back, however,
- 5:55he was told that the government didn't desire to go forward with another trial.
- 6:00After posting bond, he was released after promising to return if he was ever
- 6:05required the second trial, though it would never happen. After his release,
- 6:12there was a period of time when McHenry was highly sought after to speak in
- 6:15public, but he eventually disappeared from public view. The question that remains to
- 6:21this day is whether this man was William Townsend, murderer and thief, or
- 6:27whether he was Robert McHenry, mariner from Cleveland. The answer may never be known.