Latest / Hotdish and Hot Takes / Hot Takes on Pumpkin Spice Season
Transcript
- Kali: You know fall is here when you walk into a store for paper towels and somehow leave with a pumpkin spice candle, a pumpkin spice coffee, and the strong urge to buy decorative gourds. today we're unpacking that the pumpkin spice takeover, our hot takes, and what we actually want to eat or drink when the weather turns. I am so excited about this conversation and probably for the wrong reasons and this this is like this is my version of your hot dish and casserole right like you had strong opinions Jen: Yep, absolutely. Kali: I feel like this is a hot topic for me or a hot take for me because where did it come from? Like I did a little research because I wanted to know like when did this come about? Where did it come from? And why are we at where we're at? Like I love fall. I love pumpkin stuff like cookies and pumpkin bread and different things like that. I'm not a big pumpkin pie person, but I'll eat it. But I just in general I like pumpkin stuff. Can't necessarily say that I like pumpkin spice. And so with doing my research, what I found was in 2003. So what 23 years ago? Starbucks came out with their first pumpkin spiced latte. And it took off. And so really the pumpkin spice thing came about or the craze came about because of marketing. It's literally a marketing thing. So people went crazy over the pumpkin spice latte from Starbucks, and everybody after that just took the craze and went wild with it and jumped on board with it. I don't know about you, but for me, like I've bought pumpkin spice stuff, like cookies or whatever, thinking it would be similar to my homemade ones, and they're awful. They're absolutely awful. And so I'm curious, what are your thoughts around pumpkin spice stuff? Jen: Well, I actually don't drink a lot of pumpkin spice. The only pumpkin things I like are pumpkin bars. Kali: Mmm, yeah. Again, like I think in baked goods are really good. The problem I see with a lot of it is they're just taking the spice component and adding it into things and not taking into relation the pumpkin piece of it. Again, doing a little research, Starbucks pumpkin spice latte actually has some pumpkin puree in it. I honestly don't know if I've ever tasted the pumpkin spice latte from Starbucks, which people are probably like, well then why can you have an opinion? Because I've tasted a lot of other stuff and it's not good. It's just not good. And the pumpkin spice piece of it can be an array of different spices. why are we not focusing more on like the fall piece of it? Why is it solely around the pumpkin spice piece of it? Like why is there candles? Why is there like literally they have body wash and everything else that is pumpkin spice? Jen: Became a cra it's definitely a craze. Yeah. Kali: Wa why did you go outside of food? Jen: That's a very good question, and probably just because of some really good marketing would be my guess, but I just think people get on a bandwagon and they can't get off the bandwagon. So much to that point, it just keeps coming up earlier and earlier every year, right? You know. I don't think it'll fall until s September, October. But pumpkin spice came out in August, I think, right? Comes out as a flavor in August for everyone to get excited about. Kali: And they and they initially started pumpkin spice season after Labor Day and now it's end Jen: Yeah. Kali: of August, sometime in August that's coming out. And it used to end right as Halloween happened. And now it's running into November. we're just expanding it further and further. It's like the stores, right? The retail stores. Like pretty soon we're already gonna see Christmas stuff and we haven't even had Halloween yet. Jen: Right. Well, it's the same thing at Christmas. Valentine's Day comes out before Christmas even happens. Kali: Right. But why? Jen: This might be a good market research question to ask like our audience because I just think like I said, people get on this bandwagon and they can't get off this bandwagon. Then next thing you know, you have to have everything. Everything has to be pumpkin something. Kali: But why? Like I'm I am all for decorating for Fall. Like I never really decorated for Halloween. I have a child that absolutely loves Halloween and like the Halloween houses and stuff versus like the Christmas houses, And I think it's great for those that enjoy it. I I just personally love fall. Like I love the fall colors, the coziness of fall. this time of year, I back when I canned, I would do all my canning. I make soups, I make broths, I make all of that stuff in preparation for winter. And I think of all that stuff. probably because my childhood growing up, that's what my mom did, right? Like it was canning season and she would make soup broths and she would like beef and vegetable and chicken stalks. And you know, it was constantly something happening in the kitchen from end of August, beginning of September all the way through hunting season in November. there was bars being made and cookies and that you know she was freezing them because hunting season and there's always this array of people at my mom's house. And so that coziness that comes with fall, I absolutely love. I just don't get why I have to walk in and see everything pumpkin spice. Jen: But I think you just nailed it. Maybe it's associated with feeling cozy. The orange color, Kali: Yeah. Jen: orange and creams, curl up to a good pumpkin. Kali: I mean, I'm all about apple crisp. I'll probably make apple crisp three or four times over the next two months. And I'll make pumpkin Jen: Yeah. Kali: bread and that type of thing. But like I don't want to walk into a retail store and have it like thrown in my face everywhere. and you are starting to see more candles are like apple scented and stuff like that, but it's just this pumpkin spice body wash and hair stuff and like it's just freaking everywhere. Jen: It's a thing. It's just a thing. Like during Kali: So I Jen: the Christmas months when you walk in and you smell the pine cones everywhere. Yeah. Kali: And I I love a good fresh cut tree, I just I don't know. To me it's just gotten so out of control. And yeah, I mean you're a chapstick person. Do you want pumpkin spice chapstick? Jen: no. I do not. Kali: See what I mean? Like, but people buy it. Jen: It's just not my thing, right? So it's just definitely not my flavor. Kali: I mean and part of the marketing piece of it with Starbucks is they do a limited time. So anytime you do anything for a limited time, people are going to buy it, And Jen: exactly. Kali: and I'm guessing that other competitors seen this or other marketing places seen it. And thought, wow, they did really good. Like they probably went back and looked at the profit margins or whatever it was and thought, okay, next year we're gonna do the same thing. And so it totally is a marketing piece when it comes to the pumpkin spice thing. But I mean, even like McDonald's and some of the fast food chains and other places are now having pumpkin spice stuff. And I don't know, I just think like why why has it blown up and become this craze? And I guess it's just a marketing piece of it. And I'm not all about a marketing, like buying something because it's a craze or buying something or selling something because it's a marketing ploy. Jen: Yeah. Well, McDonald's does the shamlock shake only in March. Definite limited time. You know, I think the the other piece to that is it's limited. Limited time. You only have a couple months to do it. Or people think and perceive. I can only get this for a couple of months, you know. Alani does that with a particular flavor. The witch's brew only comes out this time and it's only out for a couple months. So you get super excited Kali: Right. Jen: about it, then you stock up and Next thing you know you have boxes and boxes of which is Brulani if you like it, right? So Kali: Are you talking from personal experience? Jen: I am not, but my son's girlfriend loves it, so of course we stacked up at Sam's Club for her. Kali: Ha ha ha And maybe that's that's a piece of it, right? Like part of my business is around helping people buy and align and be authentically who they are and true to themselves. And when we create FOMO, FOMO's buying from a spot that isn't truly what we want. Right? Like I Jen: Right. But if you really like the flavor, then you're like, my god, I gotta get this right now. Like, I only have Kali: Right, 'cause I'm not gonna have it for another year. Like you said the shamrock shake. Every year I shake my head 'cause all I can see at the shamrock shake in McDonald's is green and die. Jen: We don't even get it, so I just know it only comes out during like March Madness. Yeah. Kali: I and when I think about things I can't say that there's anything that I buy into that's a limited time thing. I'm t Jen: Yeah. But it gets everyone in exactly what you just said, FOMO. Fear of missing them. Kali: FOMO's a bad place to be though. We're buying from FOMO. We're we're buying from a spot that's not truly aligned with what we want. Right? Jen: Yeah. Kali: Like, we know that. Jen: I think people do know it, but it's just not this it's like when you're inundated with all that marketing stuff, that's what you fall trap fall into that trap. Kali: It's like Black Friday phrase. I don't even like Black Friday anymore. Jen: Hmm. I don't anymore because the ads are gone and I thoroughly Kali: I know. Jen: enjoyed missing the ads. I I absolutely loved the the spirit of going through and with your family and circling and Kali: Press. Jen: making a game plan and now it's not fun because you literally can shop weeks in advance and have all your stuff done that you would have done on the Black Friday before Thanksgiving even starts. And so that just Kali: Right. Right. Jen: takes the fun away from that. Experience. Kali: Right getting up at seven thirty in the morning and going out and buying a paper that's like, you know, two inches thick with all the ads in it and sitting around the table and going through it with my kids. Like that I do, right? I literally Jen: I miss those data. Yes. Yeah. Kali: my youngest who's seventeen, was it y yeah, yesterday, he's seen it at Sam's Club, like a little pamphlet thing we got for their September specials and he's like, Hey, is any of the Christmas ones come yet? it's freaking September, but he's right. they're gonna start coming in the mail, or they used to. And that's the that piece of it, I guess, you're hitting something on the head for me, is that I am more about creating traditional memories with my family, with my friends, that type of thing. And when we get into these crazes or these things that create more FOMO, that isn't a good sensation or feeling for me. with it, like you said, Black Friday. Like I literally can remember my kids going through and circling things and then me like figuring out what they were getting for Christmas and coming up with as a game plan of how I was gonna walk around Target or what stores Jen: Mm-hmm. Kali: I was going to first. Right. Like I stood outside Jen: Yeah. Kali: one year for an hour and it was blizzarding out and I had all my stuff on and my then husband bringing me a hot cocoa to keep me warm. Like right? Like it was it was Jen: Yeah, those are the best days, yes. Kali: it was the thrill and the fun of it where To me, pumpkin spice season is is just there's no memory with that. There's no thrill with that. There's no piece of it that I'm wanting to buy into, I guess. Jen: Yeah. I'm a hundred a hundred percent with you there. Yeah. Kali: But you know, carving pumpkins and making memories, all for that. Jen: Yeah, and I think if you want to weigh in on it, jump into our DMs about it because I'd love to know what our listeners think about Pumpkin's place. Kali: Absolutely. I think too, put it the comments. if you're on Apple, Spotify, wherever you are, we'd love to hear more from you on your thoughts around pumpkin spice. Are you in the same boat as us where you don't want to jump on crazes? Or are you in a spot of where you love to jump on crazes, you have the FOMO piece of it? And FOMO, I mean, to some isn't bad, but to me, I just it's not an energy I want to be in. Until next time, you guys, stay curious.