Latest / Star Wars Alliance / Ahsoka Ep. 3 Review & FACPOV Returns Interview Star Wars Alliance CXXXVIII
Transcript
- 0:00The Force will be with you always. Hello, everyone looks back to another
- 0:19episode of Star Wars Alias your home. I'm Geek ultimately his podcast network for
- 0:25any and all things Star Wars. I'm your host as always Katie and with
- 0:29me like I always. I mean, it's a typical day of the week.
- 0:32It's Clay, Clay, how are you doing today? I am doing
- 0:36fairly well. Had a little bit of a late night. Of course,
- 0:43we have a very special episode today, but you know, talking about the
- 0:48book from a certain point of view, Return the Jedi. But I did
- 0:52in fact edit the podcast that we that we recorded this weekend, which is
- 0:58the actual review of this book. This is actually dropping for any of those
- 1:03who are listening to this the next day. Of course, we record on
- 1:07Wednesdays. If you're listening to this on Thursday, you should already have the
- 1:12review already in your feet as well, so you can listen to this interview,
- 1:18yes, interview, and then you can go listen to the actual review
- 1:23of the book. Remember this is a hefty book. We have a lot
- 1:29to talk about in that review, but we decided to go with Katie.
- 1:33We kind of cheated, but it was top five favorite stories and then honorable
- 1:37mentions, and then we threw some more out there. There was just so
- 1:40much that we enjoyed that we couldn't let just slip by. But of course
- 1:44it's not just me that is with us in this recording today, in this
- 1:49episode, of course, we are here with Tom of course, the editor
- 1:55of Any and All Star Wars Books, basically del Ray Books. Am I
- 2:00right? Tom? That's right, all right? And of course he is.
- 2:05Uh. I can never pronounce this right when I look at your Twitter
- 2:08account, pronounce it for me, Darth Darth in turn us in turn us
- 2:14Okay, okay, Darth in turn us over at Twitter. And I know
- 2:17you recently had a blue Sky account, so go check that as well.
- 2:23But you have also been doing some amazing work over on your sub stack,
- 2:28so if you guys can please subscribe to that as well. Very very informative
- 2:34and a hefty task that you have been putting out since your campaign to do
- 2:40all of that. I know you were kind of lofting the idea of making
- 2:45a substack, but I think it's very very cool that you've been doing that.
- 2:49Thank you. I'm glad, you're glad you're enjoying. Yeah, it's
- 2:52definitely one that went immediately on my list to read because I always like hearing
- 2:55like the behind the scenes stuff. So but yes, Clay is going to
- 3:02get us started with our first question. We are going to be basically talking
- 3:06about the from a certain point of view, return of the Jedi books,
- 3:09but not just the recent book that came out Returning the Jedi. We're gonna
- 3:14just kind of be talking about the full process because this is a trilogy that's
- 3:19completed and it's been uh six years, uh top to bottom? Five years?
- 3:25Okay, wait is it six? No, yeah, you're right,
- 3:28it's six. Sorry, twenty seventeen. Okay, yeah, I could do
- 3:31math. I wanted to make sure so, but yeah, it's an impressive
- 3:38feat considering. I mean, I've got the stack right here. It's a
- 3:43Paul stack, and they just got a little bit bigger each time they did
- 3:46they did, they got bigger and longer each time. So of course,
- 3:52uh, the first question that we have for you today is what are your
- 4:00favorite memories from completing this trilogy overall, of from a certain point of view
- 4:14of one general and then two specific ones. The general one is just getting
- 4:18to work with so many different creators on helping them craft and write and find
- 4:29their Star Wars story. I mean, across all three anthologies there are one
- 4:32hundred and eight unique contributors, because of course we had some folks who've written
- 4:38across multiple anthologies, but of the one twenty stories with a one hundred and
- 4:43eight unique contributors, and of that one hundred and eight number, so many
- 4:47of them are people who were making their first contribution to Star Wars in this
- 4:53series, and so getting to sit down, it's like, it's my favorite
- 4:56thing about being a book editor overall is working with folks on developing books and
- 5:00stories. So to get to do that so many times over with so many
- 5:04different people who have such who all have the same passion for Star Wars,
- 5:10but all come to it from a different place. I'll come to it with
- 5:12a different connection and a different experience, and getting to guide and help each
- 5:16one of them develop their story. It's just like the kind of larger enduring
- 5:20memory. The two specific memories that I have is for the first book,
- 5:29around New York Comic Con, we did a New York Comic Con panel and
- 5:32we were able to have I think like fourteen of the authors or something like
- 5:39that who were at that panel and it was a ninety minute panel, and
- 5:42we actually like rotated people on and off the stage. We had a bunch
- 5:46of people on the stage and they chat for a while and then rotate them
- 5:48off and get the next group. And we did that couple of times.
- 5:50And we also paired that with like a special edition of the book that all
- 5:55those authors had signed. And while that panel was really great, it's wonderful.
- 5:58It's on YouTube. It was modern rated by Pablo Hidago, who was
- 6:00just like masterful wrangling that many people into a coherent and entertaining panel. But
- 6:06the best part about that is, in order to get all those books signed,
- 6:11we had to have all the authors come to this room in a building
- 6:15near where New York Comic comm was being held earlier in the day and sign
- 6:18all the books. And it ended up being this really small room and it
- 6:23was like a really hot, humid day in New York and like this almost
- 6:28awful experience. I mean, it was actually totally fine, but like the
- 6:30other authors are like, what are you doing, like throwing us into this
- 6:32like sweaty, like hot room and everyone's having a really good time, but
- 6:36like it just stands out just kind of the kind of a little bit of
- 6:40hilarity that that was built around that particular event, but it was really cool
- 6:45and it was a fun celebration. The second other memory that I have is
- 6:48oddly enough, another convention memory, which is twenty nineteen Star Wars celebration in
- 6:55Chicago. We have our booth there and we had decided, Now, remember
- 7:00it's twenty nineteen, so only the first book exists because fact puv ESP was
- 7:06twenty twenty. We had decided, like, oh, we know that a
- 7:10couple of the authors from the first book are going to be in celebration at
- 7:14Chicago. It's a Star Wars convention. Why don't we have like a little
- 7:16three author signing at our booth, you know, And well, we'll have
- 7:18a couple of people, and so we planned to do that, and then
- 7:23as the show got closer, we heard, oh, well, this other
- 7:26person's coming, Okay, we'll add them. And then this other person's coming,
- 7:29all right, we'll add them. And it kept going and it kept
- 7:31going, and by the time we got to the show, we had eight
- 7:34people. But when we get to the show, we heard the two more
- 7:39people were coming, and we just like we didn't want to say not to
- 7:41anybody. We didn't want to turn in the author's away. We thought it
- 7:44would just be weirdest, like, yeah, but what if what if like
- 7:46everybody but that one author who's here gets to print. This is weird.
- 7:48So what we ended up doing is we had ten authors and we destroyed our
- 7:56booth in order to make it work. We actually had to like basically take
- 8:00every book off of every table and every inch of space and cram all the
- 8:03authors together. And then we went to line people up. And anyone who's
- 8:07been to any convention, but particularly Star Wars Celebration or come to if you've
- 8:11come specifically to Star Wars, the del Ray Star Wars, the Star Wars
- 8:15Books booth, you know we line folks up for book signings, and you
- 8:18know, you wait in line, you walk up gate book sign and we
- 8:20started to line people up and it was an hour before the signing was going
- 8:24to start. We already had two hundred people in line and we only have
- 8:28an hour long signing. And to give you a little bit of behind the
- 8:33scenes knowledge, generally speaking, kind of you feel like if you're doing an
- 8:37hour long signing with just one author, usually budget that you could do like
- 8:41between eighty and one hundred people, depending on how fast an author is.
- 8:46Some authors are much slower in terms of signings, some are much longer.
- 8:48Soe you can try to budget in that like seventy eight and ninety range,
- 8:54but that's just kind of a number you have in your head. So we
- 8:56already have two hundred people in line and it's an hour foot show. So
- 9:00we capped the line because we're like, okay, but all these people just
- 9:03were like, we know you capped the line, but we want to wait
- 9:05in line anyway, because we'd love to participate because this is this is kind
- 9:07of a once, you know, a once in a once, you know,
- 9:11a one time opportunity. So what we did was we were like,
- 9:13okay, cool, anybody who wants to can stand in this extra line.
- 9:18Two things. One, you have to know that we can't guarantee that you're
- 9:22going to get a book. Sung you may stand here for an hour,
- 9:24and then I might just tell you sorry, actually you may stand for over
- 9:28an hour, then I said. But then the second thing we told him
- 9:31is, look, we have this arranged. We're not blocking anything, but
- 9:35if the security folks for the show come over and say, hey, guys,
- 9:37this line is too long. It's getting out of hand, you would
- 9:39have to leave. Is that okay? And everyone in line in that overflow
- 9:43area everyone understood that. And this funny thing started having that as more people
- 9:46got into the overflow line, everybody in the line would like give them the
- 9:50spiel and everybody was just like holding hands and we ended up actually signed,
- 9:56having four hundred and fifty books signed in an hour, and we were able
- 10:03to accommodate every single person who had stood in line and every single overflow person.
- 10:07And the way that we did this, I apologize, is a very
- 10:11long story, but it's all good. It's good. The way that we
- 10:13were able to do this is a couple of the staff members, a couple
- 10:16of us were standing around and are like, well, we we we've got
- 10:18to keep this line phishing. And one thing that you can do with a
- 10:22book line to be a fishing is have everyone have their book ready to whatever
- 10:26page that a books can be signed on, so you know, put a
- 10:28bookmark, you know, if you got the flap, put the flap in
- 10:31at the title page that when you open the book, nobody's got to like
- 10:33fish through looking for it, right, even if you save five seconds of
- 10:37person when you start talking about two hundred four hundred people. Five seconds of
- 10:39person you know, adds up. So we're like, okay, we'll have
- 10:41everybody flap the book to the title page, put the book on the table,
- 10:45and we'll just slide it down the table and every author will just sign
- 10:48and we'll tell every author, hey, try to sign in the same spot.
- 10:50So we're you don't have to move the books or anything, just do
- 10:52and we'll be able to go. Then we had this other thought. We're
- 10:56like, wow, you know these books each chapter header, you know,
- 11:01each author gets their little chapter header, and we're like, well, some
- 11:03people might want the authors to sign on the chapter headers. What if they
- 11:05want to do that? Like well, so we decided to accommodate everybody,
- 11:11and we made this decision. We said, okay, we're gonna give every
- 11:13person a line of choice either the title page or the first page of each
- 11:18story. If you choose title page, we just went through and said,
- 11:20hey, if you want title page, just flap your book to the title
- 11:22page so it opens on the table. You open, you go for everybody
- 11:26else. What we did was we actually created piles of sticky note little slips,
- 11:31ten sets of them, and handed them out to every single person who
- 11:35wanted them, and me and a couple other staff people memorized the ten first
- 11:41pages. So it was like, so we would stand in front of a
- 11:45group of people in the line, like I'd go to a group of ten
- 11:46people, I'd say, all right, everybody, who's doing first page of
- 11:48the chapter, pay attention please, everyone look at and say, okay,
- 11:52take these stickies. I'd say, okay, well you're gonna do is You're
- 11:54gonna You're gonna put a little sticky on each one so that when we have
- 11:58all these tabs right, so then each author can just turn to the next
- 12:01tab right it's it's it's full pirth. So I said, okay, you're
- 12:05ready. Here we go page ten, page seventeen point seven, thirty four,
- 12:11page sixty three, and we would just go all the way down the
- 12:13list and then I'd go to sane and because we had people waiting, this
- 12:16was one of the benefits. Because we had people waiting in line so long,
- 12:20because people showed up so early, we had all this time to like
- 12:22do all this stuff so that when the signing started, it was just just
- 12:26clockwork and everything just moved. And then I went to the authors, and
- 12:31I was like, oh, there's pay attention to me. Here's how this
- 12:33works. I need you all. Because the authors were chatting and having a
- 12:37good time. I was like, I need you all. Pay attention.
- 12:39If you see no tabs, just sign on the title page. You keep
- 12:41it moving. If you see tabs, just take the next tab and go.
- 12:45And it worked beautifully, and it was such a wonderful communal moment.
- 12:48It was a logistical triumph, but there was so much joy in that line.
- 12:52There was so much joy in that signing, and it ultimately, you
- 12:56know, one of the things about these books, it's just like how much
- 13:00joy is inherent, and not just their creation, but the reaction to them,
- 13:03the way that people celebrate them, and that experience, as hectic and
- 13:07really ultimately ridiculous as it was, when I think back on it was so
- 13:11emblematic of that joy that I always think of when I think about these books.
- 13:16The Star Wars book community is so awesome. Like I can never get
- 13:22past how like some of my interactions have gone on Twitter and you were talking
- 13:26about twenty seventeen New York Comic Con and I just remember seeing those pictures.
- 13:31I think you were posting them and some of the authors were posting them on
- 13:33my Twitter feed and just kind of talking about how insane that day was.
- 13:39That's totally awesome. I love it. The next question, kind of talking
- 13:46about the trilogy overall, is did anything change between the books and if so,
- 13:50how, And I had a couple of examples here, like bringing in
- 13:54the new creators, because obviously one hundred eight individual creators choosing part particular characters
- 14:01for the books, And obviously I think this is probably my favorite example seeing
- 14:05some of the character pitches get wilder. Yeah, So as far as like
- 14:11the process of making these that hasn't really changed from book to book. The
- 14:16overall process that we went through, the kind of way we managed the project
- 14:22hasn't really traged. We gotten a little We've definitely gotten better at it as
- 14:26each book has gone, gotten a little more efficient, done a few different
- 14:28things in terms of just like the organization, the way we set up our
- 14:31spreadsheets or files or whatever, you know, like very mechanical stuff, But
- 14:35almost everything else about how the books were made has been exactly the same from
- 14:41book one to book three. So you know, in terms of creators,
- 14:45we always wanted each time to bring in a reals as exciting a group of
- 14:52creators as we could, and while we love having folks come back to do
- 14:56multiple stories, we really always looked at the series as a way to one
- 15:01be able to celebrate with creators beyond just authors, so folks who are journalists,
- 15:07who are working in other parts of entertainment or pop culture, so expanding
- 15:09the voices outside of just book or comic authors, but also to always be
- 15:16intentional about trying to bring more new voices into Star Wars, because that's one
- 15:20of the things that we celebrate about Star Wars overall. That's one of the
- 15:22legacies of Star Wars is the fact that it you know, it brings new
- 15:26voices into it and they contribute it to it, and those new voices become
- 15:30part of the overall tapestry. But they also affect and change and drive Star
- 15:35war Wars forward because they are new, because they are different, because they
- 15:37bring an element that Star Wars hasn't had before. So we did try to
- 15:41bring as many new authors as we could each time through as far as like
- 15:46how characters got chosen, again, that remained exactly the same, which was
- 15:50that it was really author driven, you know, as long as it was
- 15:54a character who could fit within the bounds of one of the films and had
- 15:56a connection to a scene or some element of the film. You know,
- 16:00a character was pretty much fair game. And the other rules about choosing characters
- 16:04never really wavered. You know, nobody, you know, we can't have
- 16:07two of the same character in the book. There's not going to be two
- 16:08wedge until the stories. And you know, people can't tell a story from
- 16:12the pov of han luke Lea or Darth Vader or really the Droids because like
- 16:18those characters are already the main characters. You know, those those kinds of
- 16:21things were consistent throughout and I think that that helped not only us stay consistent
- 16:25in making these books, but it gave all the contributors a consistent sense of
- 16:29consistency about what the possibility space was. And I think that gets to the
- 16:33last thing, which is you are totally right the character pitches and the storytelling
- 16:37styles and the the kind of audacity of the storytelling choices that the authors were
- 16:44making. I think god grander as the books went on. And I don't
- 16:49want anyone to misinterpret misinterpret and think that means that I somehow think the like
- 16:55the first set of stories are lesser. No. In fact, it's because
- 16:57of that first set of story stories that I think that that happened, because
- 17:00I think with each anthology, the creators who were coming to whatever entry they
- 17:06were writing for looked at the previous one, or looked at the previous two
- 17:08and said, oh my gosh, I could do that. Oh my god,
- 17:11Okay, I'm gonna try. You know, oh I can go I
- 17:14can be that bold, I can be that audacious in my storytelling forms,
- 17:18what characters? I wait a minute, you can write a story about the
- 17:22cave? Okay? Like? And I think it gave permission and gave a
- 17:26model for each group of creators who was coming after to just go bigger and
- 17:32to go wider and to try something more and more. I think that's actually
- 17:36a gift that each book gives to its next, gives to its you know,
- 17:40it's subsequent book. You're totally right, And that was super exciting,
- 17:45And that was actually probably something that did change on our end, which was
- 17:48that because we had that experience, because we saw the possibility space of the
- 17:52kinds of stories that people were telling with each new entry, we could be
- 17:56even bolder in talking to the authors as we're developing those stories and saying,
- 17:59hey, you can push this even more, Hey we can we can actually
- 18:03like dial this up from where it already is because we already knew it would
- 18:06work. Yeah, I know, like a lot of people and I'm just
- 18:11saying this, but like a lot of people when they saw like a Dexter
- 18:14Jester story in Return of the Jedi, We're like, where the heck is
- 18:18he in the movie? Like that makes no sense, but like reading the
- 18:21story like it makes total sense and putting it in that place like it's such
- 18:25an awesome connection, and like, while it's wild, it totally works,
- 18:29and I'm super glad it does. Yeah, I think it's great. I
- 18:32think the stories like that or choices like that bring that sense of surprise to
- 18:37the anthology that you know, you're like, oh, I'm just this is
- 18:40an anthology about a movie I've seen, you know, five, ten,
- 18:42a, you know a dozen? Think you know a movie I know so
- 18:45well? What could be new or surprising about it? And that is one
- 18:48of those things that a lot of the authors are really great about discovering those
- 18:52spaces, in those moments where the story could still really be surprising, even
- 18:56if you know, you know these films like the back of your hand.
- 19:00One of the one of the things that I have been saying, particularly about
- 19:03returning the Jedi from a certain point of view, and I've said it in
- 19:07our book club that we have at the end of every single episode, and
- 19:11especially in our review that we did this weekend, is that it blows my
- 19:15mind how you take a character that literally, while you're watching the movie,
- 19:19you blink and you missed that character, and they have this overarching, beautiful
- 19:26background and like this huge story behind them, but it's just this minuscule character
- 19:33and they've made it so big in this one books. It's one of my
- 19:37favorite things about about this one in particular, because I've fallen in love with
- 19:41a lot of the stories in this book. That's awesome, that's amazing.
- 19:47The third question is, when creating from a certain point of view, how
- 19:52did the timeline of each movie affect the creation of the actual book series.
- 20:00This is a really great question, and there's there's really two reasons. And
- 20:04what's kind of interesting is that if you look at the three films, I
- 20:08put Empire and Jedi, I pair them together over here, and then I
- 20:14have a new hope sitting by itself. For this reason is that the very
- 20:18first thing we would do when creating any of these is the team would sit
- 20:21down and we'd be we'd watch the movie and we say that we were working,
- 20:25which is a funny thing to say, we watched the movie, and
- 20:27we would do kind of an initial survey of the film. We would write
- 20:32down, oh, you know, yeah, you could have a story about
- 20:34this character, you could have a story in this scene. Oh, these
- 20:37five people appear any of you know, And we'd break down kind of the
- 20:40scenes a little bit and just lay the film out just to give us a
- 20:42scope of like what does this look like. And one of the things that
- 20:47we found is that, like if you look at a New Hope, it's
- 20:49so really kind of balanced movie. There are set pieces or scenes with lots
- 20:56of characters all throughout the film. Like you rarely go more than a few
- 21:00minutes without having a bunch of characters, you know, whether you go from
- 21:04the blockade runner and then there's a little bit with not that much, but
- 21:07then you've got a big imperial meeting, and then there's the cantina and then
- 21:11not that much and then the death Star escape and then not that much and
- 21:15then you know, rebel briefings and then the big attack. Like there's this
- 21:18weird, this interesting kind of balance. And even in the moments when the
- 21:21movie gets isn't quite the right word, but like when it gets quieter,
- 21:25when there's only a few characters, there's usually still a couple of characters that
- 21:27you could so easily be like, oh, you could tell it a stir
- 21:30about that character whatever. The other two movies are not balanced in that same
- 21:36way. They are both very heavy at the very beginning and sort of the
- 21:40very end. You know, ESB is like the howth scene has a bunch
- 21:44of characters, and then in the middle of the movie there's not that many
- 21:48characters. There's tons of scenes where it's like it's just Luke, Luke and
- 21:52Yoda, or it's just Han and La there's no one else, or you
- 21:56have like scenes that are all cutting into each other constant, so you don't
- 22:00get these longer scenes. You've got like these people are running from the asteroid
- 22:03and Luke's training and these Imperials are talking and these people are doing it's just
- 22:07you know, everything is overlapping. We're turning to the Jedi is interestingly the
- 22:10same way, because it opens obviously with you know, Joba is palacing the
- 22:14Battle of Endor at the end, and in the between, we've got all
- 22:17this inner cutting and all these kind of shorter things. So it's funny that
- 22:21you have this balanced one and these two. They're not unbalanced, but you
- 22:25know, they're just balanced in a different way, or they're structured in one.
- 22:27And that affected things because we always wanted each book to celebrate the whole
- 22:33movie. So when you have something like a New Hope, it was actually
- 22:37relatively easy to make sure that we were representing basically every scene in the film
- 22:41in some way, and we didn't have like forty stories in the Cantina.
- 22:45There are a bunch of stories in the Cantina because there's a lot of characters
- 22:48there, right, But that one was pretty easy to lay out and pretty
- 22:52easy to see those opportunities. For the other two books, there was a
- 22:56real we had to be a little more concerted and being like, we can
- 23:00not have three scenes set on Haf. You know, Haf is very important
- 23:03to the Empire strikes back, but like, we cannot have thirty stories set
- 23:07there. So on the latter two books, we actually had to do this
- 23:10thing where after a certain amount of time, we'd almost close off a part
- 23:12of the film. So once we got to a certain number of hot stories
- 23:17or endoor stories, as more authors came on, because you know, the
- 23:19different the authors would come on board at you know, different moments as we
- 23:22were recruiting folks talking to folks, and we would sort of say, you
- 23:26know, we kind of have a lot of stories set in job As Palace.
- 23:30So if you'd be cool at maybe looking at a character or seen somewhere
- 23:33else in the movie, that would be great. And we'd left ourselves all
- 23:37the grace of Like if someone came up with an amazing idea for a story
- 23:41in one of those denser sections, we told we would let them do it.
- 23:44But we tried to, you know, be like, okay, we've
- 23:47got enough of these stories now, and we had to be a little more.
- 23:51We had to be a little more organized like that for the latter two
- 23:53books, just because the other thing though, that it really affected was the
- 24:00order, the final order of the stories within the books, because again,
- 24:03a new hook's a pretty balanced thing, and it's like each scene just flows
- 24:07into the next. There's definitely a sense that a few scenes here and there
- 24:10are overlapping or happening at the same time. But there's not a lot of
- 24:14cross cutting. It's like a lot of scenes end and then we wipe and
- 24:17go to the next scene, and then the next scene ends and we go
- 24:18to the next see or we jump forward in time. There's not a lot
- 24:22of inner cutting, and so ordering those stories was actually pretty easy. I
- 24:26think we came up with the initial order and then I think we moved like
- 24:32five stories around and was mostly just like a flip flop these two that kind
- 24:36of those little small tweaks. For the other two films, we had to
- 24:41order and reorder those stories a bunch of times. I actually was looking at
- 24:45this the other day because someone else was asking about it. For The Empire
- 24:48Strikes Back, we re ordered all of the stories five times, and for
- 24:55Return of the Jedi we did it three times one because I think we got
- 24:57a little bit better at ordering the stories. So the Return of the generated
- 25:00leverage experience. But we had to reorder them because you would just look at
- 25:04a bunch of those scenes and you're just like, these two scenes are happening
- 25:07on top of each other, and this one starts, and then if we
- 25:10go wait for a minute we go this one, we come back to it.
- 25:12There's a lot of that, and so that that created some more challenge
- 25:17in ordering the stories. It made things a little more different. We couldn't
- 25:21just rely on, oh, well, where does the story start, because
- 25:23that often wouldn't be enough to figure out where should it go in the tapestry.
- 25:30So we had to come up with a whole bunch of new rules about
- 25:33how we order the stories for that really came into play in the second and
- 25:36the third book. So those are the two things obviously none of the movies
- 25:41have a problem with like, oh man, are we going to be able
- 25:44to get forty characters out of this? That was never a question, never
- 25:47once. No one was ever worried about that because Star Wars movies have you
- 25:52know, teen numbers of characters that you could feasibly write stories about. It
- 25:56really was just a matter of like, oh, no, are we going
- 25:59to get Ewok stories? And we didn't. I will say they are some
- 26:04of my favorite By the way, listen, letting people know fact pop Oops,
- 26:10oops, all e Walks is out there. Very very good, Katie,
- 26:18you have the next one, all right, y'all, we're going to
- 26:22hit our first ad break and we will be right back in three two one.
- 26:27Yes, So Boba Fett is one of a few characters that have a
- 26:33story in all three From a certain point of view books, were there any
- 26:37special considerations made to connect or disconnect the three stories together for any character?
- 26:44This is not a really great question, because I love getting to talk about
- 26:48the ways in which the stories in these anthologies connect and interconnect. So specifically
- 26:53for Boba Fet not really, because there wasn't a whole lot specifically done,
- 27:02because his stories really take place at like these very three, very distinct moments
- 27:07in his life, and so you know this story that Paul Deni wrote for
- 27:11the first one, when you're going to write the story about him in Job's
- 27:15Palace in Return of the Jedi, there's not really a whole lot you need
- 27:18to leverage from that first story, because again, it's not necessarily a follow
- 27:22on, even though it's in the same character. In all the cases where
- 27:25we would have an author taking on a character who already had a fact POV
- 27:27story from a previous entury, in like ninety nine point nine nine nine percent
- 27:33of those cases, the author already knew that, and they were like,
- 27:34yeah, I was actually already. You know. Part of the reason I
- 27:37chose this character is like I was influenced by this story, you know,
- 27:41like I know, yeah, Like fran Wilde and I for Return of the
- 27:44Jedi talked about Alexander Fried's mon Mathma story in a New Hope. And one
- 27:48of the reasons why if you look at the title of Alexander Fried's story the
- 27:52Last Contingency and the title of fran wild story, no contingency was entirely wanting
- 27:57to nod to those things. And I love Friend's story. Friend's story was
- 28:03awesome, like it was. I'm gonna say it was badass. It's great.
- 28:08It was great. So so in pretty much all the cases, the
- 28:11authors were like so aware of the other stories of their character, and we're
- 28:18keen themselves on either teasing or pulling something out from those previous stories to spin
- 28:22forward, or at least to keep the character consistent as far as the characters
- 28:29concerned, not necessarily in terms of the tone of the style of their story,
- 28:32because you know, the tone of Paul Denis Bubafet story and the tone
- 28:36of Sorita Krodovia's story and the tone of Tera sim stories are all like a
- 28:38little different but still consistent as far as that character. It's just them leaning
- 28:42on their own individuality as as you know authors and writings. So there wasn't
- 28:52a whole lot and there was certainly never a moment we were like, hey,
- 28:55don't do a connection. It was very much in the hands of the
- 28:56authors of how much wanted to to pull forward previous stories of those characters.
- 29:07So Boba Fett is a good example of that, you know, and Boba
- 29:08Fett just got chosen because you know, so many people love bothfet But of
- 29:12course that's exactly why if we hadn't you know, if you had asked me
- 29:17back in twenty seventeen one, if you had been like, hey, you're
- 29:19going to do three of these, I would wow. But then if you
- 29:22were like can you would you you know, bet on a character having a
- 29:26story in all three? I mean, Boba Fett probably would have been number
- 29:27one, just because you know, it's both. So that was the kind
- 29:33of consideration we did, character by character, which was really just you know,
- 29:37when folks wanted to have the other stories and pull things from them.
- 29:41We we did some connections, but again it was all kind of guided by
- 29:45the author's choices. But In a lot of cases, authors wanted to build
- 29:48off of previous stories, and that that's one of the real joys I have,
- 29:53particularly of this third anthology, Return of the Jedi, is so many
- 29:59of the story came out of authors telling us how much they enjoyed the previous
- 30:03anthologies and saying, I want to build a story that is in conversation with
- 30:08this story from fact pub one, or I want to build off of what
- 30:11this author did in the second story with this character, and that was like
- 30:15really exciting and heartwarming to see. If you want a really good example of
- 30:21that, read any of the pilots stories in the Return of the Jedi anthology.
- 30:27So many of them are connected to and are building off of Jason fries
- 30:33rendezvous point story in Empire Strikes Deack, just because that story encompasses so many
- 30:37of the rebellion pilots who then go on to feature in Return of the Jedi,
- 30:41and so many of the stories in Return of the jedire authors just being
- 30:47like, oh, right, I'm building, you know, nodding to Jason's
- 30:48story, or take pulling their character from that and spinning them forward to what
- 30:52are they now, like, you know, a year later? In terms
- 30:55of the story, So there was there was a lot of fun with that,
- 30:59and they're all so authors who took it upon themselves to be like,
- 31:02hey, I'm writing this pilot and this other author I know who's writing this
- 31:04other pilot. We're going to build some interconnectivity in right from the jump.
- 31:10So yeah, but there was it was a lot of fun to connect the
- 31:14stories together and to connect the characters together, but also to give space to
- 31:18the authors to tell their own story with this character that still feel unique.
- 31:25You mentioned Boba Fett. Another great one who's got a story in all three
- 31:27is Palpatine. And if you go read Ian Doger's Palpatine story, which you
- 31:32know, because Ian is just this amazing writer in terms of his ability to
- 31:37you know, turn anything into Shakespeare quite literally, including start. I was
- 31:41going back the other day and relistening to a New Hope, and that threw
- 31:45me off so much because I did not remember that like the Shakespeare being in
- 31:51that story, but like it was like, oh and like just listening to
- 31:55it again it was awesome. But then you read, you know, in
- 31:57book two in Empire Strikes Back anthology, Mike Chen picks up the Palpatine baton
- 32:02and like, we didn't tell Mike Chen he needed to write like Shakespeare because
- 32:07it needed to you know, matching in story. But you read those two
- 32:08stories and oh my gosh, you can just see how how much they are
- 32:13in conversation with one. I learned how much they compliment any together. And
- 32:15then when you come and pick up Return of the Jedi and Olive Blake now
- 32:20has taken on the Impi the baton of the Emperor and is writing a story
- 32:23that feels so much like Ian's but also feels so much like Mike's. And
- 32:29those three stories all stand apart as their own amazing interpretations of this character.
- 32:35But the authors just created this. There's this this thing about them that ties
- 32:38them all together and that makes them, you know, feel feel like a
- 32:44you know, a matched you know, a trio. It's really cool.
- 32:46There's a little bit of this almost like will of the force, just this
- 32:51almost unintended thing that kind of happened between you know, the Bavavord stories,
- 32:55the Palpatine stories, the Wedge stories, the you know, there's any number
- 32:59of characters who have multiple appearances that you could point to that had this happen,
- 33:04which is so cool. It's so much fun. Is so exciting to
- 33:07see. Wedge's stories are carefully some of my favorite because it's just one of
- 33:10those characters that's always been a lot to me, especially going back to the
- 33:14Rome Squadron books and legends, so like seeing his growth especially and knowing how
- 33:21it connects to the aftermath books like Perfect Stories and Wedge two. I'm so
- 33:25I'm glad you mentioned that because which two is kind of prototypical I think as
- 33:30far as what the from a certain point of view, books are trying to
- 33:32do for characters. You know, you were mentioning. I started, like,
- 33:36we see these movies, it's often a character who's on like the screen
- 33:38for literally half a second, and then we give them a story, you
- 33:40know, and you tease out this whole life they lived. And Wedge is
- 33:44one of those characters. In the original trilogy, were like, you know,
- 33:46he's got like a couple of minutes of screen time in each movie.
- 33:49He kind of you know, he says one or two things, you know,
- 33:52particularly an empire and returned. He's got like a couple of lines,
- 33:55and you remember him, but like not enough that you really learn a ton
- 34:00about who he is underneath. And then that is what the story can do
- 34:02is give you the rest of the character who is underneath that person that you
- 34:07see flying the X Wing or carrying the boxes through Hawf or working on the
- 34:13you know, the the x wings in the back of the hangar like that.
- 34:15He's almost like the prototy typical character for that sort of thing. So,
- 34:21yeah, it's it's cool that he appears in all of them and that
- 34:22he has these tethers to all these other stories. Yeah. Uh. The
- 34:30next two questions are music centric. We know that you had a playlist while
- 34:37you were editing Return of the Jedi, and uh. The second question is
- 34:45more inspired by a video that has been going around lately from a Soca.
- 34:51There was a scene in one of the first two episodes of Asoka and somebody
- 34:54put a modern song to it, and so we're going to ask you something
- 34:58about that. But the first question, what were your top two songs on
- 35:04that playlist when editing from a certain point of view Return of the Jedi.
- 35:09I have to break your heart a little bit. There is no There is
- 35:14no editors playlists for from a certain point of view, Chick. There is
- 35:17no editors playlist for any of the from a certain point of view books,
- 35:21and this is the reason. It's just that there are so many stories,
- 35:24and it's just like the sort of shifts in perspective, in tone and characters
- 35:29and parts of the film. It's like everything is so different that I was
- 35:32listening to music at times. I was reading stories because it's just one of
- 35:36the things that I do. But I was not building I was not building
- 35:39playlists. Okay, okay, because I jumped between this so now, but
- 35:43if you asked me think about what songs would be on the fact playlist,
- 35:47I'm now, we're going to try to invent one in my head, like
- 35:51on the spot here. Uh. I think Closing Time by Semisonic probably would
- 35:59have been near the end of it, said like made it through a trilogy,
- 36:01finally done a closing Time, go get some rest? Uh might have
- 36:06been on it. Uh. There's the Teddy Bear picnic song. Are you
- 36:14guys, are you familiar with the Teddy Bear picnic picnic? It doesn't sound
- 36:17familiar. You go down the woods today, You're in for a big surprise.
- 36:22If you go out in the woods today, you better go into spise.
- 36:24For every bear there ever was there ever there is there ever there was
- 36:29you know today's the day that Teddy Bears have their picnic. It's this very
- 36:31old like children's song thing, and for whatever reason when I was it did
- 36:36come up when I was thinking about some of the Ewoks stories. The so
- 36:40that's that song, that childish song would have definitely been on there because it
- 36:45was thinking about the e Walks. And also in this by Henry Hall.
- 36:51Yeah, it's this very old sort of jingle thing. I'm gonna I'm gonna
- 36:55set that aside and almost totally discover it. It's it's absent too. It's
- 37:01absolutely ridiculous, this little jingle, and I think related to the Ewok stories
- 37:07and in a very strange way, specifically the wolf Trap story by Alissa Alone.
- 37:15So uh yeah, the Teddy very pigmrick semi sonic closing time. Maybe
- 37:23it's the end of the world as we know it, you know, And
- 37:25I feel fine a little r m uh, but yeah there. It's just
- 37:30the nature of those projects were so different from the normal books that it really
- 37:37didn't lend itself. It also so happens that because the way that these books
- 37:40are made, which is, you know, story concepts and outlines and the
- 37:45manuscripts they all come in at these wild at these different moments because they're all
- 37:47shorter. It's not like I just get we get one delivery of a manuscript,
- 37:51right, and so these stories all get developed and made around like everything
- 37:58else. So like I, you know, we were working on some of
- 38:00these stories while we're working on Cataclysm, while we're working on Battle Scars,
- 38:02while we're working on Rise of the Red Blade, while I'm you know,
- 38:06looking at early material around Phase three of the High Republic, like with around
- 38:10all those things, like, oh, you know, I got a few
- 38:13hours here, I'm going to dive into these two stories. Oh you know,
- 38:15tonight, I'm gonna you know, read these five and so also because
- 38:19of that, because I am reading and working on them around all these other
- 38:22projects, many of which do end up having playlists because of the nature of
- 38:24their development, it just didn't ever come together to make a playlist specifically for
- 38:30from a certain point of view. But I'm glad you asked. I'm glad
- 38:32you asked about anyway, because now I got to think about it. We
- 38:37asked that in the first interview, I think it was about the Thrown What
- 38:42was your song for the first Thrown Ascendency book? So I was like,
- 38:45we got to ask it again. Now, a little bit of background before
- 38:52Katie asked the second question. Recently, in the I guess minor spoilers for
- 38:59one of the first two episodes of Asoka, we see Sabine writing a speeder,
- 39:07and in the actual show there is actual composed Star Wars related music to
- 39:15that scene. But somebody uh put on top of that the Beastie Boys and
- 39:22it sounded great with that song with her just driving with the wind blowing her
- 39:28hair, and it just looked really really cool. So Katie go ahead and
- 39:31ask this second to last question. If there was one needle drop you could
- 39:37put in Return of the Jedi, what would it be? And I guess
- 39:42where? Man, jeez, this is really hard, you know, I
- 39:54think I think there's something to like you could put a needle drop when Luke
- 40:00and Leah and then jump on the speeders on end Or to chase the Stormtroopers
- 40:05and that fight engages, mostly because that is not a very dialogue heavy part
- 40:08of the film, So you could have a needle drop in and as the
- 40:12score already does, you could let the music like really play into the sense
- 40:15of action there. I think that would be a really good place uh,
- 40:23oh man, I And I don't know what the song is. You know,
- 40:28it's not sabotage, but like, I don't know what the song is
- 40:30that I think obviously you could put a more modern needle drop on top of
- 40:37like the montage of celebrating across the galaxy, like especially when we see like
- 40:43Chorisson, and you could even liked because we jump around to a couple days,
- 40:45you could put a couple of quicker, sort of needle droppy things,
- 40:49which might be kind of cool. But I actually think, and I again,
- 40:52I don't know what the song is, but like this is the challenge
- 40:54that I would put to someone, is can you put a short needle drop,
- 41:00but a really affecting one right at the moment where Luke raises his lightsaber
- 41:06and tries to strike down Palpatine, invader blocks him and we get Palpatine's laughter
- 41:10as the you know, we know now the duel between the father and the
- 41:14son is about to start, and in that moment where you can see Palpatine's
- 41:17face with you know on the other side of the cross blades, is there
- 41:22a needle drop that you could have put right there? See Tom, now
- 41:25you have invented a challenge for me, and I will post this specifically,
- 41:31this small segment of our interview out there and see if anybody else could could
- 41:37possibly enter this challenge, because that I think that would be a lot of
- 41:42fun. We overhear at the g U A H. We talk movies tv
- 41:49shows all the time, and one of our biggest talking points usually is whenever
- 41:54a composer is attached to a movie or TV show and then we go see
- 42:00said movie in theaters and we're like, man, that needle drop just didn't
- 42:04fit, or like all this needle drop was awesome. Maybe it kind of
- 42:07took you out of the movie, but it's of course Star Wars is just
- 42:12something that would sound really odd if it had a needle drop nowadays, even
- 42:16back then in the seventies, it just wouldn't make sense for the sci fi
- 42:21fantasy of it. And you know, after seeing that video earlier this week,
- 42:27I was like, you know, maybe it could work, Maybe it
- 42:30could work. So I just wanted to ask you that question. Well,
- 42:32that's the extra challenge though. If someone's going to try to figure it out,
- 42:36it's got to be a song that would have existed in nineteen eighty two
- 42:38or nineteen eighty two. You can't put You can't put a two thousand song
- 42:44because they wouldn't have had that. You know, you can challenge by being
- 42:46like, it's only music that would have been available in okay, early eighties,
- 42:52and that would have Well what about special edition, because well, but
- 42:55okay, special edition. You can get yourself into the nineties. But you
- 42:59still you can only go so far. So yeah, we'll say you can
- 43:02either you can go into the nineties if you want to do we're dropping a
- 43:05needle drop into the special edition. You can go into the mid nineties,
- 43:09so you know, you can get some like you know, if you want
- 43:13to make the needle drop smells like teen Spirit by Nirvana, you can you
- 43:17know. All right, Well, I'm actually I'm legit writing this down and
- 43:24I will do some research, try it on my own and then post it
- 43:28on Twitter, on threads on Blue Sky and see if anybody else would like
- 43:32to join in on that challenge. But we do have one other question,
- 43:37Katie. You have it written down, right, We wrote down the last
- 43:42question. All right, guys, this is our second ad break. Remember
- 43:46we don't choose these ads. If you don't like them, I'm sorry,
- 43:51it's not on me, but we'll be right back, Tom laugh. But
- 43:54like I forget stuff all the time, like in the Blake. If you
- 43:58can see all the post it notes, I'm staring at it right now.
- 44:01Here's my stack of them right here. Okay, So the last question,
- 44:07is there a character that didn't get cho chosen for a story that you were
- 44:10surprised about? There's actually a bunch of them. You know, as we
- 44:15talked about when we when we would start each project, we'd do that survey
- 44:20of the film, and like I said, we'd make an initial list that
- 44:22wasn't meant to be prescriptive. It wasn't We wouldn't hand that to authors and
- 44:25say you can only pick from this list. It was just to one get
- 44:30a scope of the density of the characterism and movies. But also you know,
- 44:34some folks would would jump onto the project and they say, hey,
- 44:36I already know I absolutely want to write this character. You know, Charlie
- 44:38Jane Anders for Return of the Jedi was like, I want to write the
- 44:42Starlac story. Okay, cool off we go, you know, and other
- 44:45authors would jump in and say I have ideas for these two characters, and
- 44:49we know we were workshop them and figure out. But some authors would say,
- 44:53you know, do you have a list, Like they would just want
- 44:55something as a starting point, because you know, when you give someone the
- 44:59entire handy store of Star Wars characters in a film to go through, it
- 45:02could be overwhelming. So I feel like, all right, what if we
- 45:05just you know, we look in just this area to start, We'll just
- 45:07look at the chocolates to pull this analogy for you know, we'll go over
- 45:10to hard candy later. We'd also use that so that if as we got
- 45:15further along, if parts, if a lot of characters start to get chosen,
- 45:19you when you get down to the last couple of story slots, a
- 45:22lot of characters have been chosen to be able to go to folks and say,
- 45:24okay, here are the characters who haven't been chosen. If you want
- 45:28to look at a list that we know is already good, or you have
- 45:31other ideas, so we'd use it for all that. But that meant that
- 45:34I would make a list, and the team would make a list of characters
- 45:37we kind of guessed would be chosen, and so like for the first story,
- 45:44Jet Porkins, the pilot from the Death Star Battle, I was just
- 45:49so surprised that he didn't get chosen. I was really surprised. In the
- 45:54Empire strikes Back, I will say that I just assumed that, like General
- 46:00Views, would be one of the first characters off the board. He did
- 46:04get a story, of course, Christy Golden wrote this amazing story, but
- 46:07he was one of the later characters chosen, and like we were getting down,
- 46:09I was like, wow, someone, no one's going to choose Veers.
- 46:13That's really surprising, and that's just like it's interesting because I think part
- 46:15of part of this, part of this is probably says something about like the
- 46:21characters that maybe I am really interested in, or the characters who just jump
- 46:23out to me in these movies, and so when they do or don't get
- 46:27chosen or they're not like first off the board. You know, he also
- 46:31got chosen. But Will row Hood in Empire strikes Back with the you know,
- 46:36Camtono, we also assume, like Will row Hood, there will be
- 46:38like a fistfight to write the world row Hoods. And there were a couple
- 46:43of people who inquired, but like it wasn't the first character. And then
- 46:46Rob Hart came on board and said I would love to write it, and
- 46:49we got like one other question about it. But I thought originally we might
- 46:52have to have some sort of decafalon to figure out who's going to write the
- 46:54wild row Hood story for Return of the Jedi. I'm trying to think if
- 47:00there is a character, there's not a character. But there is a scene
- 47:06that I was a little surprised more characters were not pulled from, which is
- 47:10the briefing scene where mon Mathma and Akbar sort of lay out that we're going
- 47:15to attack the Death Star and the Emperor's on board, and just as Luke
- 47:20walks in, there are so many you know, it's like the original briefing
- 47:23scene. It's a little bit like a hawthor a cantina scene where there are
- 47:28so many characters. There's the dresslians in the background, there's all these random
- 47:32rebels in outfits that we've never seen really anywhere else, you know, There's
- 47:37all these other people, and so I was a little surprised that we didn't
- 47:40get one or two more characters pulled out of that scene, just because there
- 47:45are so many blank slate characters there that you could have, you know,
- 47:49pulled from. But that was probably that. That's really probably it. It's
- 47:55probably like that group of characters, and then you know you brought it up
- 48:01earlier, Katie, So I think it makes sense to mention, which is,
- 48:05you know, Adam lands Garcia's writing Dexter Jetster for Return of the Jedi,
- 48:09and you had said, like, you know, when you first hear
- 48:10that, you're like, well, he's not, like, where the heck
- 48:13is he in the movie? And then when you see where he is in
- 48:15the book, and I don't it's not a spoiler to say this, because
- 48:20you know we would share this is that he is one of the POV characters
- 48:22when we see the celebrations across the galaxy, right, and he's obviously on
- 48:27Corresson. It was once Adam chose dex And and said that's that's what you're
- 48:32doing. I was like, oh my gosh, that's such a great idea.
- 48:36That is that almost gives you a slate to add not any character,
- 48:40but like, there are so many characters who are not in Return of the
- 48:43Jedi that you probably could have chosen because they would be on Naboo or they
- 48:47would be on Corrasson. So I'm actually also a tiny bit surprised we didn't
- 48:52get one or two more stories using that space to to to celebrate it.
- 48:59So that is jargon naboo right there. We see him in aftermath, So
- 49:07yes, those are those are probably the like quote unquote surprises. But even
- 49:13with being surprised, I think one and one of the reasons why I'm actually
- 49:16very happy you asked this question is like one of the things that was always
- 49:20so important to us that we talked about at the beginning of this conversation,
- 49:22but it's worth circling back to, is that, like all of the choices
- 49:25around the characters really were driven so much by the authors. So it wasn't
- 49:30like we were sitting there and we were like, we need two we walk
- 49:34stories and we need this character. There was no checklist. Yeah yeah,
- 49:37yeah, there was not. There are I can tell you that there are
- 49:40across all three volumes in total, there are four stories where the idea for
- 49:46the story the core nugget came out of a suggestion from my team to an
- 49:52author that an author ultimately said yes to, rather than the author being like,
- 49:58I want to do this character in this is the story that I want
- 50:00to do. But even in those four cases, all of the authors said
- 50:05yes, and we're super enthusiastic about doing it, and if they had said
- 50:07no, we wouldn't have made them do it. We would get you know,
- 50:10they could picked a different story, but there are only four. So
- 50:15yeah, it's very much an author driven project and something that that was like
- 50:20super important to us. And I think one of the reasons that we got
- 50:23such you know, weird and wild and interesting and inventive stories is that we
- 50:29really put it in their hands because their authors and their creators and they have
- 50:32this this you know, they have all these skills and abilities, so allowing
- 50:37them to really kind of run wild in any direction, I think is what
- 50:42what got us the best stories. Very very cool, absolutely really really excited
- 50:51to have you here. It was a great conversation. We have been gushing
- 50:57over this book for the past three weeks now. That's like I said earlier,
- 51:01We have already recorded our review. It will be dropping for all those
- 51:06who are listening to this right now, and technical difficulties did not have us
- 51:09go live during this segment, so I do apologize, but this video will
- 51:15be going out during the time of you guys listening to this podcast as well,
- 51:20So if you want to watch the interview, you can definitely go do
- 51:22that over at the geek Verse YouTube channel as we go live on that channel
- 51:28every single week. But Tom, can you let the listeners know where everybody
- 51:36can find you. If you have any projects coming up that you can let
- 51:39us know about and want to prepare us for, go ahead and do that
- 51:44as well. Sure, so, you can find me in a couple of
- 51:46places on social media. On the place formerly known as Twitter, I'm at
- 51:52darth Internus I N T E r n o us. Also same thing on
- 51:58Blue Sky, and as you mentioned earlier, I started a sub stack newsletter
- 52:02called The Cubicle at the End of the Galaxy, which if you go to
- 52:05my former lead Twitter page or blue Sky you will see links to it.
- 52:10It's a Newslayer where I did the first couple entries. We're talking more about
- 52:15this series and sharing some fun stories and other tidbits about it, But in
- 52:19general that newsletter is going to be talking about what it's like being a book
- 52:22editor and working and publishing in a really broadway. It's going to talk about
- 52:25Star Wars sometimes, but it's going to talk about just in general what that's
- 52:29like because there's a lot of weird and fun stories that I have to share.
- 52:32As far as what's coming up that I could talk about. Obviously,
- 52:36we are full steam ahead towards more stories in the High Republic with the third
- 52:43phase coming, you know, as we round towards the Fall and into the
- 52:46Fall. The Eye of Dark by George Mann is our first novel. It's
- 52:51going to be super cool. George has done incredible work. I'm super excited
- 52:54for that. And you know, in more local news, if anyone happens
- 53:00to be going to New York Comic Con in October, me and the whole
- 53:02team will be there. We're still finalizing exactly what's going to be going on
- 53:07as far as you know, like panels and events and all sorts of stuff
- 53:09like that, but you know, keep an eye out for that. And
- 53:14if you happen to be come to New York for New York Comic Con,
- 53:15come find us at the Star Wars Books booth and say hi, hang out.
- 53:19We'll talk about fact POV, and we'll talk about whatever else I want
- 53:22to talk about related to books and Star Wars. So awesome. Well,
- 53:27thank you so much Tom for being here. I know like you were,
- 53:30I talked about it on Twitter, but you were one of the first people
- 53:32who kind of gave us a chance and helped us get our foot in Star
- 53:36Wars podcasting. I really appreciate you. You've've been like such a resource and
- 53:42we love what you do, so thank you. I appreciate that. Thank
- 53:45you for having me back. I always appreciate being asked. It's always very
- 53:47nice. So it was lovely to talk to both of you again and to
- 53:52spend a spend a Wednesday evening just kind of geeking out about Star Wars books
- 53:55because it's pretty much the best thing to do, so anytime I get to
- 54:00do it. I never said now, And we're about to jump into our
- 54:05third ad, y'all. We promise we'll be right back. We promise.
- 54:09Let's move forward with the review of episode three. I do not have the
- 54:16title of this episode. I don't know if you do, so yes,
- 54:21because I did a review last night. I'm flister listening to dot com,
- 54:24so you can go read that. And again, just continue to support both
- 54:29Star Wars Alliance and by writing endeavors so people continue to say, hey,
- 54:32yeah, Katie can get this, Sam. Just Sam. So the episode
- 54:37title for part three is time to Fly. Alright, so time to Fly.
- 54:47This was a great episode in my mind. One thing that we like
- 54:53to sound off on in our gua chats. Whenever we are finished with an
- 54:59episode all of us are watching, is I have seen and then the title
- 55:02of the show. Last night, I put I have seen Hu Yang featuring
- 55:08Ahsoka because this this episode specifically, I felt like really highlighted his humor,
- 55:19like his dry humor, the the like the relationship that he has with both
- 55:23Ahsoka and with Sabine Uh. Quite possibly going to be my favorite character of
- 55:31this series. Have you seen Doctor Who? I have seen Doctor Who.
- 55:37Yes, David Tenner is amazing. He is the best tenth and fourteenth doctor.
- 55:43I'm so excited for those episodes. I'm so excited. I just had
- 55:45to make sure because like my one of my sisters has not seen it,
- 55:49and she was like, I love Who Yang And I was like, have
- 55:52you seen Doctor Who? And she's like no. I was like, you
- 55:54need to see Doctor Who because you just get the full David. I mean,
- 56:00he had nearly the longest run of the Doctor. And then of course
- 56:07Matt Smith was like hold my beer and he took that over. But yes,
- 56:13he Yang is absolutely amazing in this Katie, where do you want to
- 56:19start off? Because there is uh of course, we we start exactly where
- 56:27we had left off here with the last episode. We know that Morgan has
- 56:35the uh this giant ring that you I believe had suggested was a hyperspace ring,
- 56:44and I was like, yeah, probably that totally makes sense. It
- 56:47has been confirmed here in this episode that it is a hyperforce ring and this
- 56:54sorry, hyper space ring, and the the implication that I believe Asoka head
- 57:01made was, oh, is this ring large enough to jump to a neighboring
- 57:09galaxy. Let's go ahead and just start from there. Yeah, go ahead.
- 57:15So that's uh shorted towards the end of the episode. I still want
- 57:19to talk about the beginning, but we'll like hit this part. So Ahsoka
- 57:23does ask that question, uh, and Yang confirmed it, and he's like,
- 57:29I don't know for sure, but it seems like it because it's that
- 57:31big. He's never really seen like a hyperspace ring that big, and obviously
- 57:38he's probably never been to another galaxy unless that's where he came from in the
- 57:43Blue Box. I'm just saying possible, Mike Chen, you you will.
- 57:47I don't know if you listen to our podcast, but if you want to
- 57:51confirm that or not, you could definitely do that. But also one thing
- 57:57that I think Andrew in our last episode he was joining us live. Both
- 58:04Andrew and David were both conversating, and I can't remember which one I had
- 58:07said it, but one of them had suggested that it was possible that the
- 58:19way they could track the location of thro I think it was David. It
- 58:28was the idea of tracking the location of Thron was through the pergoles. And
- 58:34again, very exactly what came up. That's exactly what came up with hewing
- 58:40scan of the hyperspace ring. Yeah, because he identifies it. So he
- 58:45identifies it as a hyperspace ring, and then he brings up the information with
- 58:50the multiple galaxies that in the Jedi Archives there was records of multi galaxy travel
- 59:00based on the migration path of Purgles, which we do in fact get live
- 59:05action Purgles. They look great. I know that, Like, like in
- 59:13my mind, I was really worried, like how much were we really going
- 59:17to see? Because again in the trailer, when we actually do see a
- 59:22part of the Purgles, a part of my mind thought that, like the
- 59:27tentacles were probably the only thing that we were going to see, and it
- 59:32was supposed to be like this ominous like horrifying thing, but we actually saw
- 59:38purgls from one into the other multiple it was like a whole herd. And
- 59:44I thought this was awesome or heard school. I don't know what a what
- 59:47a pack of whales are, but it was awesome. I absolutely loved it,
- 59:55really really cool. What did you think about the size difference? So,
- 1:00:01like, are the purgles we saw in Rebels like kid purgles for instance,
- 1:00:08because like you see Ezra on top of it, but then you look
- 1:00:12at I'm assuming Asoka ship is named Fulcrum, but if you look at the
- 1:00:16Fulcrum compared to the purgles, those purgles are huge. Compared to the ones
- 1:00:23we saw in Rebels, the purgles here on this episode looked about the size
- 1:00:29of a star destroyer, if not larger. I think it's it's really really
- 1:00:40like because the way that they kind of made them seen in Rebels was that
- 1:00:51they really couldn't hit the atmosphere of a planet. Yeah, but here they
- 1:01:00were clearly in the atmosphere of a planet. Uh. That's exactly what I
- 1:01:06said to Matt last night. I was like, holy crap, they're in
- 1:01:09the middle of the atmosphere, like I was like shot because it was there
- 1:01:15in like the clouds, like everybody knows, Okay, we have like the
- 1:01:17clouds, and like planes can be above or below that part of the atmosphere,
- 1:01:22and like they're smack dab right in the middle of it. And they
- 1:01:27also are not as colorful as the Purgles and Rebels. Yes, these are
- 1:01:32are are much more gray scale, very like uh, like you said,
- 1:01:39the Purgles and Rebels, they were very blue. They had like a rainbow
- 1:01:44kind of like uh like a tone to them whenever a light shined on to
- 1:01:50them. Uh. The and again you look at the Purgles here, this
- 1:01:54is also a very dark planet. It looks like very very cloudy, not
- 1:02:00a whole lot of quote unquote sunlight. So that might be another reason why
- 1:02:05they are looking at Yeah, and none of this, none of like the
- 1:02:08differences really bug me because I also know, like, okay, like obviously
- 1:02:15I think the ending episode of Rebels is a little bit different because we don't
- 1:02:19really get like a close perspective of the Purgles other than like to the Chimera.
- 1:02:25But like I'm talking about like the episode and Rebels where like they're feeding
- 1:02:30on like the unrefined gas particles uh clause in nineteen forty seven, So I
- 1:02:37can't remember the number, but like, do you see what I'm saying?
- 1:02:40Like I'm just kind of like wondering, like if we're going to get like
- 1:02:46the higher archy of purgles. I don't know. These are the things that
- 1:02:52haunt me. I would be very interested to see if we see different variations
- 1:02:59of purgles because they're not very well known. Yeah, like Sabine specifically says
- 1:03:09in this episode, I haven't seen those creatures since the day Ezra left or
- 1:03:15the day Ezra was gone or whatever, so they're not very uh social,
- 1:03:27should I say? Yeah? But I also think that creatures of that size
- 1:03:32have probably interacted with sentient beings. And one thing that pissed me off in
- 1:03:42the middle of the purgles, they were having a firefight, and I'm like,
- 1:03:46if they shoot these purgles, I'm gonna be so pissed. And you
- 1:03:51just saw you saw blast fire and like, surprisingly none of them really hit
- 1:03:59al or like shot a pargle in the face or anything. But I was
- 1:04:02bored. I wasn't worried for a soca or as a bean. I was
- 1:04:05more worried for the Purgles. I was like, don't kill the pargles,
- 1:04:09save the whales. I was. I was like, what is wrong with
- 1:04:15you guys? Like, for real, not cool? H Marek at least
- 1:04:19is a dark sider, so he does not care. We don't know what
- 1:04:23Shin is yet. But also also it's not pronounced Merrick. In the show,
- 1:04:30they pronounced it Maroc. Oh, yeah, you're right Maroc. So
- 1:04:35I was like, oh, very very interesting. Which, by the way,
- 1:04:40uh Snell puts something in the guhat today. Uh that would be a
- 1:04:45very uh let's say, not very popular reveal of who Maroc is. Oh
- 1:04:51yeah, Cal Oh yeah, yeah that was not smell. Oh was it,
- 1:04:57Chris? I thought it was snow. Yeah. Yeah. There there's
- 1:05:00a I guess a new fan theory because there is a costume that you can
- 1:05:04wear in both uh the in both Calcustus games, you can wear a inquisitor
- 1:05:15outfit, and so they're like, oh, maybe maybe he's the inquisitor in
- 1:05:19Ahsoka. So the theory I saw today about who uh Morocc could be is
- 1:05:30the eighth brother because he remember he felt to his supposed death on Malakor.
- 1:05:36But what if he mysteriously found a world between world portal and was saved.
- 1:05:43The visor is like pretty close to what he was wearing, Like he had
- 1:05:48like more of a helmet on, but the visor looks the same. Oh
- 1:05:56that's interesting, and we do no. And this is where like the Sam
- 1:06:02Whitwer theory comes into play, because Sam Whitwer was in the credits for episodes
- 1:06:10one and two last week. I don't know if he was this week,
- 1:06:13but Paul Darnel is only playing the physical role of Maroc, So who's voicing
- 1:06:20him, I don't know, We'll have to wait and see. But going
- 1:06:30back to the beginning of the episode, like you said you wanted to,
- 1:06:33we see Sabine and Ahsoka as well as Huang doing some training. We see
- 1:06:43Sabine practicing her ready stance, her and some other different stances. I love
- 1:06:47the way that they are practicing because Huang has these like little sensors that look
- 1:06:55like life sabers themselves, but it basically tracks the right positions for each form
- 1:07:04that hu Yang is yelling out. Those are the different lightsaber forms and she
- 1:07:09is supposed to be striking in that form, and then those bars that he's
- 1:07:15using lights up to show the correct positions and which ones she missed, and
- 1:07:19I thought it was a very cool representation of how it all it all works
- 1:07:26when it comes to training with Huang, and it did remind us in the
- 1:07:31uh, you know, previously on and then it has it's a part of
- 1:07:34this discussion here that Sabine tells Thesoka. She's like, well, Huang told
- 1:07:40me that I'm the worst Jedi ever and that I could never become a Jedi
- 1:07:44if I was you know, back then. And she's like, wait,
- 1:07:47did you actually say that? And he was like, yeah, I did,
- 1:07:49because it's true. Just like, holy crap, And I love how
- 1:07:56how straightforward hu Yang is. I really do and he like he's lived twenty
- 1:08:01five thousand years at this point, like what's a man gonna do? Like
- 1:08:06he's literally seen and done it all, Like he deserves to be honest as
- 1:08:12an old man, an old droid. Excuse me, but it's just kind
- 1:08:16of funny because you look at episode two and he's like, so when you're
- 1:08:20gonna get Sabine back in the band, like it's Sabine ever coming back?
- 1:08:25She needs to and he's the bear to be like, come on, do
- 1:08:30it, do it? Do it and then she's back and he's like,
- 1:08:32you're such an idiot, Like it's very odd to read him. But I
- 1:08:39love his personality, I really really do. And if you don't believe that
- 1:08:45this is his personality, y'all please go back to season five episodes seven through
- 1:08:53ten to get Hugh Yang Hu Yang's episodes and you will see this is like,
- 1:09:00oh, this is this is with all the kids, right, yeah,
- 1:09:02yeah, yeah, great episodes. I love the training sequence. I
- 1:09:10think this is so needed, and I know people want to get into Baylin
- 1:09:15and Shin and like who they are, what they're supposed to be, and
- 1:09:21like getting to Thron. We were both wrong on win Thron was going to
- 1:09:25make an appearance in Ahsoka. Yeah, but like, I think this episode
- 1:09:31was fully needed to get Sabine and Ahsoka on the same page, but also
- 1:09:36put the confidence of the viewer that Ahsoka and Sabine relationship is actually a thing.
- 1:09:45Like they fell back into what feels like, oh okay, they're familiar
- 1:09:49with each other, they know each other's routines kind of thing. Like it
- 1:09:54just everything flowed so well. And Steph Green directed this episode and she did
- 1:10:00credible job with it. I love also that they continue to honor the Japanese
- 1:10:03elements. George Lucas pulled originally for Star Wars. The little wooden saber that
- 1:10:09Sabine is using and that Sooka ends up using as well, is actually like
- 1:10:14the name of the Bachan saber is actually a Japanese trading sword like full on.
- 1:10:20So I love that. The really cool thing about this is it brings
- 1:10:30up a conversation of uh that Sabine is very aware of. She is not
- 1:10:36forced sensitive, and it really draws back to the conversation that that Nan was
- 1:10:48having with Harra, the idea that everything, everything, anyone and everyone has
- 1:10:55the force she is and that she is blocked. You need to remember that
- 1:11:00from Rebels. Yeah, again, you don't need to remember it, but
- 1:11:04those of us who have seen Rebels have the context and it even if you've
- 1:11:11only seen the movies. Qui gon Gin in The Phantom Menace brings it up
- 1:11:15to Anakin when he does the blood test on Anakin. He's looking for Medicallorians,
- 1:11:19midic Larians resided everyone, but they're an indication of how much of a
- 1:11:25connection you can pull with the force, basically, how much talent you have
- 1:11:30in order to connect with the Force, and I really just love that that's
- 1:11:33a continuing theme because it like it puts everybody on not necessarily the same playing
- 1:11:41field, but it goes back to that I can't think the word. I
- 1:11:45can't think of the word, but it's like it just like if people are
- 1:11:51like being jealous of a Jedi, well, it's just kind of they don't
- 1:11:56have to be as disciples as you. It's like it's very much a sports
- 1:11:59metaphor. Like my sister was always way more talented with softball than I ever
- 1:12:02was. I put twice as much work in her and still was never as
- 1:12:05good, but I still had the capability to play softball. Like that kind
- 1:12:11of thing. That's not what I was intending for originally. It made it
- 1:12:15work. But also I want to double down on a counter point that you
- 1:12:25were bringing up in the earlier episodes. You had said that Sabine and of
- 1:12:31course her being Mandalorian, could possibly be the indication that, you know,
- 1:12:38she doesn't need to have the telekinesis and she could still be a Jedi.
- 1:12:43I think that if people were paying attention, lucasfilm has already shown us Sabine
- 1:12:49using the Force. Oh really, yes, and it wasn't technically showing us.
- 1:12:57They didn't show it to the entire world. The entire world got it
- 1:13:00from a leaked video from the cup. The cup, the cup, because
- 1:13:09the cup is very important to this episode, and everyone thought, everyone thought
- 1:13:15in that trailer that it was Jason. Yes, everybody thought it was Jason
- 1:13:20Yes. Which we actually see a live action Jason Cindola here in this episode.
- 1:13:28Looks a little different. I feel like in the show he looked a
- 1:13:33little bit more alien. He had the combination look, which I appreciated.
- 1:13:41Yeah, but I I think for sure because the thing is after this whole
- 1:13:46training sequence, which, by the way, like the whole thing about like
- 1:13:51try to sense me where I'm at and everything. Love that entire sequence because
- 1:13:57at some point, like Sabine was getting it and then she you know,
- 1:14:01got frustrated and was letting her anger kind of kind of guide her rather than
- 1:14:08trying to focus. I really love that scene. Yeah, and like the
- 1:14:13whole training scene. It again, it's not heartwarming, it's not There's like
- 1:14:20some funny moments, but it's not like Sabine is getting this, Like like
- 1:14:25you said, there's flashes of inspiration for Sabine where she does get but she
- 1:14:30doesn't realize she got it, and Ahsoka, Asoka's because she doesn't have the
- 1:14:34visor on, realizes Okay, Sabine is getting it. She just has to
- 1:14:39get it consistently. It's not a heartwarming scene, but it is continuing to
- 1:14:45build the relationship up. Yeah, there is a moment where at the end
- 1:14:54of the training sequence, they're sitting down at the table and you know,
- 1:14:59they have the conversation about the force, and this is where Ahsoka goes into
- 1:15:04the cockpit and Sabine is sitting there with both cups and she puts her hand
- 1:15:13up and she just focuses and focuses and focuses. And I don't know if
- 1:15:17a lot of people thought it was going to move. I thought it would
- 1:15:20be a little too easy if it like maybe jiggled a little bit. And
- 1:15:24I was like, ah, she's not ready. She's definitely not ready.
- 1:15:26I don't think it's gonna happen. But as soon as I made that thought
- 1:15:30in my head, it reminded me of the leaked footage trailer, and I
- 1:15:35was like, it's gonna be her, She's gonna do it. And you
- 1:15:41had said that there and I didn't see it in the trailer when I first
- 1:15:45saw it, so I need to go back and double check. But you
- 1:15:47had seen in either a TV spot or another trailer. There's a moment where
- 1:15:53she is fighting Shin and she puts her hand up like she's about to use
- 1:16:00the force. So I think they're teasing it, and I think it's going
- 1:16:03to happen eventually, but I don't think it's going to happen for a majority
- 1:16:09of the season. I think it would have been cool, Like I say
- 1:16:14cool, but like in Star Wars, I don't know if this would ever
- 1:16:16be a thing, But like if she walked away and then the cup just
- 1:16:20like slightly moved like hint, but like for me, I don't think it
- 1:16:30would make much sense because our focus wouldn't even be on the cup at that
- 1:16:32point, you know. Yeah, And that's where I was like, I
- 1:16:34don't know if this makes sense in Star Wars, but like I wanted it
- 1:16:38to happen, just like tease it and like, hey, you can't actually
- 1:16:44do this kind of. I think we will get more hints or or we
- 1:16:48will see her potential for it more and more for sure. But speaking of
- 1:16:55Jason Sindula Harra has a very hostile conversation with some senators and U uhn Matha,
- 1:17:08and we get the live action version of a character that we've never seen
- 1:17:12in animation before. Uh So, I don't think you phrased that quite right,
- 1:17:17because we have seen Senators, Senators Diona and animation we have yeah where
- 1:17:30uh so you have never watched this show Star Wars Resistance. Have you seen
- 1:17:36Resistance? Yes? I actually did. Oh I thought you hadn't seen Resistance.
- 1:17:42That's why I said that. No, I have not seen Resistance.
- 1:17:45I knew that he came from Resistance, but I had never seen it.
- 1:17:50But when I saw how much of a dick this dude was, I was
- 1:17:55like, is he a dick in the show, because this is like a
- 1:18:00Disney Channel show, if not like a Disney Kid show. Like so,
- 1:18:05I only ever saw Rebels once at art Resistance once. I think he makes
- 1:18:11I think he makes like three or four appearances, but they're very brief because
- 1:18:15he's the father of the main character. Okay, so in that case,
- 1:18:23like he he kind of gets involved. I don't remember him being a dick.
- 1:18:28But also you gotta think, like Resistance takes place, Resistance takes place
- 1:18:34twenty five years, twenty five, thirty years after this, so he's had
- 1:18:40time to change and like realign his thoughts. But Jordan Mason put this on
- 1:18:46Twitter today and he was like, I did not think we were going to
- 1:18:49get the new Boriks failure in Star Wars Cannon like this, oh failure,
- 1:18:58yeah, yeah, yeah, And I just I love that comparison because like
- 1:19:01you feel it, and especially with what you know what aired to the empire
- 1:19:05because like we talked about it, like Borsk failure and the Bethans didn't get
- 1:19:12involved until they saw that the rebellion could actually win. Mhm, and this
- 1:19:17is exact up. That is so true. I like I like that connection
- 1:19:24now that now that you've pointed it out. I like that comparison as long
- 1:19:32as long as if he decides to be a trader to the entire rebellion or
- 1:19:43a new Republic, whatever you want to call them, uh, I do
- 1:19:46not need them to welcome him back with open arms. He needs to be
- 1:19:51keep curb. I don't think he'll end up being a trader because he's still
- 1:19:57a senator in resistance spoil alert. So is this oh I guess this takes
- 1:20:03place before resistance? Yes, because Resistance is a sequel trilogy show. Yes
- 1:20:10it is, because I'm pretty sure BB eight is a part of that show,
- 1:20:14right is Pasma and Poe Damner room You can actually see I think it's
- 1:20:25called The Colossus and Raise of Skywalker. Oh okay, okay, okay,
- 1:20:31So yeah this. I did not like this dude whatsoever in this conversation and
- 1:20:39like Harrah, Harold, like she threw on the sass like this, Like
- 1:20:46the moment she was like, oh where were you during the war. Oh,
- 1:20:51you were just waiting to see who won to take sides? Okay,
- 1:20:57cool? Yeah, I was like a woman is great? Oh step Yeah.
- 1:21:03She she does not like him as well, clearly. But this big
- 1:21:08moment was her telling them that she believes thron is coming back and she has
- 1:21:15seen him in action and if he at all has any sort of power,
- 1:21:23she knows that he will use it to its fullest and there will be another
- 1:21:28war, and so she is trying to prevent that war. And they're just
- 1:21:31like, well, uh, if if I don't see a duck, it's
- 1:21:36not a duck, basically is what they said, and they're not going to
- 1:21:41help her out, and this is when we start. But they also They
- 1:21:47also accuse her of specifically trying to use the New Republic for another mission to
- 1:21:55go after Ezra. And I find that super interesting and I do have to
- 1:21:59one or if maybe there will be some sort of prequel material that kind of
- 1:22:04goes over Ahsoka and Sabine's relationship, but also the little missions where Ahsoka has
- 1:22:11maybe said, oh, maybe Ezra is here, like let's go try and
- 1:22:14find well, I don't think it would be Ahsoka. I think it would
- 1:22:16be Hara. No, it would be Hara. But like Ahsoka and Sabine
- 1:22:23are specifically like oh, going out to the to the missions that would and
- 1:22:28building that like initial Padawan master relationship. Oh maybe actually yeah, yeah,
- 1:22:33yeah, that makes sense. But Harra gets defensive of that too, because
- 1:22:42the senator he's like, oh, well it seems you know you've used this
- 1:22:45kind of thing before to you know, go on your your hypothetical rescue of
- 1:22:53this Ezra Bridger and uh they were like, yeah, he's dead, and
- 1:23:00she like she barked back. You don't know that, like you have no
- 1:23:04evidence of that. So it is a very touchy subject. You need to
- 1:23:08remember they weren't just a crew, they were family. Uh so uh,
- 1:23:14and I love after this whole thing where Jason comes out and he's like,
- 1:23:19oh, so he's gonna be a Jedi, and she's like, where did
- 1:23:24you hear that from? Oh, Chopper, me, what are you talking
- 1:23:28about? Like Chopper was like, I didn't do anything. Uh. But
- 1:23:31I love Danny Chopper. I love the eagerness in Jason's voice of I want
- 1:23:38to be a Jedi too. Like it's just like I love the actor they
- 1:23:43got for him. I've seen him and he's like made like small appearances and
- 1:23:47like one of the medical dramas I watched and he was really good in that.
- 1:23:50So I think he's a super good choice. And he is actually in
- 1:23:56the main credits for the episode. He's not in the ending. Uh.
- 1:24:00Same with Genevieve O'Riley. Genevieve o'reiley was in the main credits and not as
- 1:24:08like a guest person. So very very cool. But we do get to
- 1:24:13the firefight. They when I say they, Asoka, Sabine and who Yang
- 1:24:19exit out of hyper space. They see, uh, the planet and they
- 1:24:26have a reading of what will be known of course as the hyperspace Ring that
- 1:24:32is on the other side of the planet, and so they're wanted to get
- 1:24:35closer. They uh, they sit back for a little bit. But of
- 1:24:41course this is when Shin Marock and other fighters. We got to talk about
- 1:24:47the other fighters. We gotta get side of the way. And I know,
- 1:24:50I'm sorry, I'm excited, but what if they're Chiss. So I
- 1:24:58saw how excited were on Twitter throwing this theory out there. You go ahead
- 1:25:06and throw this theory out there, because you know more about the Chiss than
- 1:25:10I do. I still haven't really read much about them any any of the
- 1:25:15legend stuff. So you go ahead and you fire off. Okay, So
- 1:25:19my theory is because we see the so Shin comes out with morok In basically
- 1:25:28a squadron of six ships and the other four fighters are piloted by an alien
- 1:25:33species. We don't get a name. They're speaking an alien language. My
- 1:25:39thought process is because Morgan has apparently worked so close with Thron is that she
- 1:25:44had Chiss connections, and so in super secret missions, she basically pulls in,
- 1:25:53especially when they're getting this close to Thron because Hu Yang tells us they're
- 1:25:57putting the final hyperspace engine into the high or Face Ring. So like if
- 1:26:02they're they're on the last legs of kind of like the before the journey portion.
- 1:26:08So on these like secret missions, I'm thinking that maybe she's able to
- 1:26:14contact the Chess ascendancy and get people to help locate Thrown and basically add bodies
- 1:26:20to her fight. And the reason I think this is because we don't see
- 1:26:26any skin on these people, and we all know how the Empire feels about
- 1:26:31alien species. Despite the fact that she's using them for bodies, they're like
- 1:26:38fully masked, Like why would you be fully masked and like gloves and everything
- 1:26:45if like you weren't trying to hide something. I like the theory, but
- 1:26:53it could easily be as simple as this is their suit. This is just
- 1:26:59now is very convenient that every single one of them is fully covered, because
- 1:27:04you could easily just say, okay, well, why doesn't shinn't have a
- 1:27:09space suit like that? You know, yeah, because even on the planet,
- 1:27:13like they're fully covered. It's not just in the fight. So like
- 1:27:17for me, I think this is potentially like something especially considering Feloni and Fabra
- 1:27:26both consulted with Timothy's on to make sure under the impression that they were trying
- 1:27:31to get thrown, right, what if they also wanted to pull in more
- 1:27:35details about the Chiss ascendency. I could see it happening. I will not
- 1:27:43be surprised if they do end up being Chiss, just because you know,
- 1:27:49you you have so much more knowledge than I do about them. I would
- 1:27:55I would really enjoy that. I think it would be like an AHA moment
- 1:27:59for a lot of people who no rebels but don't know Thron's legacy within the
- 1:28:05Legends books and all of his trilogy and everything. I think it would be
- 1:28:09like, holy crap, there's more of his people type of thing, yeah,
- 1:28:13which I think would make for a cool moment, depending on how they
- 1:28:16do the revealed you know. So I'm I'm I'm in it for the theory,
- 1:28:24but I think there has to be a little bit more build up for
- 1:28:27that as well. You know. I have to wonder, especially because Balan
- 1:28:30at the end of the episode sends like the fighters off to like go hunt
- 1:28:36for Asoka and Sabine. I have to wonder if a lightsaber strike here or
- 1:28:42there is going to reveal something. I could see that happening. Yeah,
- 1:28:48yeah, I could definitely see that happening. Actually, but in this firefight,
- 1:28:58I wonder, I wonder Katie if there is gonna be any man babies
- 1:29:08out there saying, why is Asoka deflicting battleship blast fire? Nobody can do
- 1:29:15that when just this year we read a book that had a Padawan doing the
- 1:29:25exact same thing, and like, and those man babies they're going to have
- 1:29:31seen Star Wars Clone Wars where Anakin does something very similar. The scene is
- 1:29:38not identical, but it feels so much like the Clone Wars moment right there.
- 1:29:45It's so awesome. And I love this blue suit by the way,
- 1:29:49that Asoka is wearing. Yeah, it's it looks like a New Republic space
- 1:29:56suit, so like the Uni forms that we see kind of on the ship.
- 1:30:03You can see it in the background when Harrah's talking to the New Republic
- 1:30:08Council. It looks like that. But somebody oncewater was like, I want
- 1:30:13to see how Ahsoka put that on her head so quickly because the space suit
- 1:30:18covers her leku and everything, and you're just like, how much time did
- 1:30:24you have? You know? She she it's it's one of those mechanisms where
- 1:30:29you kind of just like slip through like it's already open, Like it's it's
- 1:30:32not like she has to unfold it and everything. It's already just like hanging
- 1:30:35on hooks and she just like kind of dives into it and if you if
- 1:30:41you look at it back Leko, it completely flaps. It's not tucked into
- 1:30:46the space suit. Really. It's like, yeah, yeah, that's interesting.
- 1:30:53I have to go back and watch that. But oh, we'll go
- 1:30:58ahead, go ahead. So the dog fight was probably my least favorite part
- 1:31:02of the episode. I just think it could have been done maybe a little
- 1:31:06cleaner. Everything looks fantastic, but I think I think the biggest thing for
- 1:31:14me is I am not digging Shin's character. I really like Balan. I
- 1:31:18think Ry Stevenson has given him a lot of character, but we're getting a
- 1:31:24lot of Shin and we have given her no personality whatsoever. I think unfortunately,
- 1:31:35I think Shin is getting the silent edge lord, like I want to
- 1:31:45be a badass, but I like also don't know how to control my emotions
- 1:31:51type of character. What a lot of people thought Anakin was in UH Clone
- 1:32:00Wars and Attack of the Clones and and of course Revenge of the Sith.
- 1:32:05There's a lot of people who hated the UH. Of course, the portrayal
- 1:32:12of Hayden Christensen with Anakin Skywalker and they're like, Oh, he's whining too
- 1:32:16much. This is blah blah blah blah blah blah blah. I think,
- 1:32:19unfortunately, Shin is kind of going to be that exact same character in a
- 1:32:28sense of like she talked to the way she talked to Morgan. Oh,
- 1:32:34look at that, you almost got them. I'll finish them off, you
- 1:32:40know, right. But I think and I think it's like where we don't
- 1:32:44know exactly the exact definition of who Balin and Shin are. They are clearly
- 1:32:48using orange lightsabers. You can see the difference in Brock's uh helicopter lightsaber versus
- 1:32:56their lightsabers, and it's just kind of like, okay, are is she
- 1:33:00going to at some point tap into rage because like there's no emotion with that,
- 1:33:08which kind of leads me more to like a Jedi philosophy with them,
- 1:33:13but also like they're clearly not Jedi. Balin physically says that in the first
- 1:33:17episode, you were right on one thing. We're not Jedi. So how
- 1:33:23were they greeting the Force? I guess once we kind of get that answer,
- 1:33:29I think I will start to understand Shin more and appreciate her as a
- 1:33:31character. I just am like, Okay, I need to see some sort
- 1:33:35of leaning. How many episodes are we getting? Eight eight? We're three
- 1:33:45episodes down. We have five more to go. I think we only have
- 1:33:51one episode, if any at all, that shows the background of Balin and
- 1:33:56Shin, and I think that's going to be the next episode. It's going
- 1:34:00to be the fight between Balin and Asoka, which kind of tells that story
- 1:34:04it's gotta be, you think so. I like, I really think so,
- 1:34:10because Asoka knows Balin was a Jedi, so she is going to try
- 1:34:15and figure out what happened, why is he partnering with Morgan and doing all
- 1:34:20of these things because she cares about people being on the right side of the
- 1:34:25force. She may not care that he's not a Jedi, but she wants
- 1:34:29people on the right side of history. So you think the Shin Sabine fight
- 1:34:36is going to be happening at the exact same time as the Baalin Asoka fight.
- 1:34:42I think so because you see we don't necessarily see the Shin Sabine fight
- 1:34:48surroundings, but it feels like like the around around Sabine. Yeah, it
- 1:34:55feels like they're in the midst of the forest. We also see Murrok and
- 1:34:58Asoka fight again, and that's in the forest, and we know for a
- 1:35:01fact a soaken balance fight is at the little altar thing at the edge of
- 1:35:06the forest. So to progress the story, it needs to happen next episode.
- 1:35:14I think I'm trying to figure out where they could put a flashback episode
- 1:35:25without it feeling like a full stop. And I don't think I'm gonna get
- 1:35:30that. I think it's going to feel like a full stop. You know.
- 1:35:35With Obi Wan Kenobi, we had the episode go back and forth with
- 1:35:44a flashback or actually no, it opened with the flashback and the rest was
- 1:35:50the was in quote unquote present time of that show, and the only thing
- 1:35:57I can think of for there to be a flashback, And I hate this,
- 1:36:01I really do hate this. But it's the Tales of the Jedi episode
- 1:36:04with the Practice makes Perfect and that's where the voiceover's coming from. I was
- 1:36:09just about to say, I think that might be the I think it's a
- 1:36:14cold open that flash vaccine. Yeah, and they did a cool open technically
- 1:36:19this episode two, so it's something that they've kind of taken use of.
- 1:36:26So I think that could definitely happen for sure. But that is basically the
- 1:36:33episode. We've kind of talked about everything. I'm trying to think of there
- 1:36:36was anything specific you think. I think the last part was kind of a
- 1:36:44Soca opening up to Saban because yeah, he Yang kind of calls her out
- 1:36:51on it and it's like, you too are not interacting like a master and
- 1:36:56apprentice, and like my Christian talked about it, but like Huyang talks about
- 1:37:03like, oh yeah, well you come from a line of very odd master
- 1:37:06and apprentice relationships and that kind of triggers Ahsoka to be like Sabine what you
- 1:37:13need because Sabine and this is the other thing about the firefight that I really
- 1:37:16didn't like, like was Sabine does not forget how to fire like in the
- 1:37:25gun like, and it felt like she was kind of off her game.
- 1:37:30I don't think that it was necessarily that she was off her game. You
- 1:37:34need to remember when you look at Rebels, you saw the entire crew going
- 1:37:45into the fight. You saw Zeb and Sabine manning the guns, or you
- 1:37:51saw Ezra and Sabine man in the guns. Well, while Zeb was working
- 1:38:00on something within the ship to help with the shields and it was all one
- 1:38:03cohesive unit, whereas Asoka was just flying the ship and Sabine was trying to
- 1:38:11get the right angle to It's a symbiotic relationship with those ships. The only
- 1:38:15way you can get a perfect angle with that gun is if the Fulcrum tilts
- 1:38:20or turns in whatever. Like, if the Fulcrum turns and Sabine is trying
- 1:38:26to shoot somebody at a particular angle, she may not get it just because
- 1:38:30Ahsoka is flying kind of crazily. So there needs to be a communication between
- 1:38:36the pilot and the gun, and I think that's what they were trying to
- 1:38:40insinuate, like, hey, we need to work together to better work out
- 1:38:45this this fight that we're having. Not necessarily that Sabine was, you know,
- 1:38:51off of her game. I think she was doing just fine, but
- 1:38:55it was for the fact that her pilot wasn't really necessarily all focused on the
- 1:39:03fight, whereas she was just trying to survive. You know. Yeah,
- 1:39:09that makes sense and that does change her perspective. So good job there it
- 1:39:12go. Uh grandfather was was air Force, so I kind of I know.
- 1:39:21But the h in that same fight, we saw Morgan have giant laser
- 1:39:33cannons attached to this uh hyperspace ring and it it nearly got me. It
- 1:39:43nearly got me because he's like scanning, scanning, scanning, come and then
- 1:39:48you just see sparks flying, and I was like, like, I didn't
- 1:39:54care about Ahsoka, I didn't care about Sabine. I was just like doing
- 1:39:58no. And then like he was out for like the majority of the later
- 1:40:02end of that fight. And I love how like Serbian's like the one time
- 1:40:09I could use your advice, like are you that you're just you're out?
- 1:40:13Uh, But he of course woke up. It was for the fact that
- 1:40:15he like in his protocol, it's like he shuts down, uh reserve power
- 1:40:21or whatever. It was. Uh yeah, it had a good I didn't
- 1:40:27really get that, like I know, it was like for like the plot
- 1:40:30and everything, and I was like, why did he power it out?
- 1:40:33Was he like maybe like a chopper and he was like plugged in the fulcrum
- 1:40:38trying to get the scan kind of thing, because I was like, why
- 1:40:41does he need to be plugged in I to use the technology? I mean,
- 1:40:46you could easily head cannon again. Twenty five years old and seventy five
- 1:40:55percent original parts five percent original parts, but those are old parts, so
- 1:41:01you know, maybe he just needs an extra oomph of power whenever he works
- 1:41:05now and he always needs to be plugged in. Maybe maybe that does make
- 1:41:11sense. But that's that's all I got. Is there anything else that you
- 1:41:17can think of within the episode that that we haven't brought up yet? I
- 1:41:21don't think so. I think we covered everything. It's it's a packed episode,
- 1:41:26Like there is no break whatsoever in this to like breathe, Like the
- 1:41:31whole thing is stuffed basically, which is a good thing. I'm not saying
- 1:41:35it's a bad thing, but like, for thirty six minutes, the dude
- 1:41:40was packed. Yeah, I really really enjoyed that. I and for for
- 1:41:48somebody who has a very short attension span due to my ADHD, I need
- 1:41:54that. I need something to keep my attention and if it just keeps going
- 1:42:00boom boom boom boom boom, I'm going to get that. The one thing
- 1:42:02I will say, and I think I saw was it Zach on Twitter?
- 1:42:10Or was it Chris? I can't remember who it was. They're like,
- 1:42:13my only complaint is that I want more Like it ended too fast, and
- 1:42:16a lot of people on Twitter will say on that, and and for me,
- 1:42:23I did want maybe a little bit more from from Balin, but I
- 1:42:26know I'm going to get more, so I can be patient and wait for
- 1:42:30those scenes with him. Yeah, And just like as a note on like
- 1:42:35when the episode's releasing, I appreciate this episode releasing at nine pm so much
- 1:42:42because, like I'm actually interacting with people on Twitter versus waking up early on
- 1:42:46Wednesday morning at five. Again, I don't feel like getting on Twitter after
- 1:42:51that, but you know what, at nine pm on a Tuesday, I
- 1:42:56could physically interact with people on Twitter and like throwback series and stuff like I
- 1:43:00know everybody can't watch it at the same time every day, but like I
- 1:43:04have missed that because I used to watch the CW Live. Yeah, it's
- 1:43:09it's it's a great time for people to drop episodes. I remember when,
- 1:43:16like Netflix had a very sporadic upload and release schedule, and like the first
- 1:43:24season of Daredevil uploaded at like four or five AM, and I thought it
- 1:43:30was gonna be two am, so I stayed up and I just stayed up,
- 1:43:32and I stayed up and stayed up until it finally showed up after refreshing,
- 1:43:36and I was like, oh, gotta start watching it now, and
- 1:43:39it was horrible. But it's great. You know, even the guys over
- 1:43:45the Geek First podcast, they're able to do the review immediately after the episode,
- 1:43:49and they used to do that on midnight releases, but for them,
- 1:43:54uh, you know, midnight is two am my time, and then they're
- 1:43:59fin with the episode closer to one, and then they're having to stay up
- 1:44:01until two or two thirty. It's absolutely nuts for them dropping at nine finishing
- 1:44:09the episode within an hour. These guys on their coast, it's not even
- 1:44:15eight o'clock yet by the time they're starting their podcast, And I appreciate that
- 1:44:19for some people. It gets people excited for not only the content that they're
- 1:44:27watching, but the discussion afterward. It's the discussion that they're able to have
- 1:44:31with everybody else. And I think that is so important when it comes to
- 1:44:36stuff like this, because it gets the word of mouth out there. Because
- 1:44:42you're right, a lot of people if it drops at two am, a
- 1:44:46lot of people aren't like us. They're not gonna wake up, and that's
- 1:44:49the first thing they do. They have to get ready for work, they
- 1:44:54have to get their kids ready for school, they have to go to work
- 1:44:56and do all this stuff, and they might be able to watch half the
- 1:44:59episode during their lunch break and then have to finish the rest when they get
- 1:45:01home, so they can't talk about the episode throughout the day until they finish
- 1:45:06it, you know, twenty four hours after its release. Now at least
- 1:45:10they have the opportunity to watch it at the same time as everybody else,
- 1:45:15and I think that is perfect and they need to start doing that more along
- 1:45:18every platform. Yeah, and now again, I forgot to talk about this
- 1:45:25at the beginning, but I've been wanting to make sure that we include this,
- 1:45:28y'all. I know a lot of podcasts are not talking about the show
- 1:45:30right now, and that is completely a decision made for them. But ultimately
- 1:45:35we're all in support of sag Aftra and the WGA getting the correct deal they
- 1:45:42need from the AMTP AMPTP. We would not have this show without their hard
- 1:45:47work, and that's truly important to highlight. So just make sure that you're
- 1:45:53staying on top of things. Make sure if you see a news release.
- 1:45:57The WGA has been awesome about updating their website to make sure everybody's getting the
- 1:46:00correct information, so please make sure you're supporting your writers and your actors.
- 1:46:05Okay, y'all. Yes, I just saw one of the TikTok influencers that
- 1:46:14I watched that was very big into Star Wars content. He has shifted his
- 1:46:17content, uh, specifically because of the WGA and sag Aftra, and I
- 1:46:23do not blame him whatsoever. He will have his time to talk about this
- 1:46:28show, and I want to respect everybody else who makes that decision. Currently
- 1:46:33with what we have and our decisions, we want to go ahead and talk
- 1:46:38about this show because we know that we are able to do that without disrespecting
- 1:46:44those that are in the WGA and sag Aftra. We have let people know
- 1:46:49where we stand with sag Aftra and the WGA. And I know that a
- 1:46:57majority of you guys wouldn't absolute lutely love the fact that if me and Katie
- 1:47:01just talked about books every single episode, so we have to talk about something.
- 1:47:06But I do know that there is a lovely quarter of you guys that
- 1:47:11do enjoy our book reviews, so we do thank you for that for sure.
- 1:47:17But just a reminder, as I am as we are signing off here,
- 1:47:23there is an interview out there. Well, we're not signing off,
- 1:47:27yet we got to talk about book club. Oh, we do have to
- 1:47:30talk about book club. Speaking of book reviews, let's talk about From a
- 1:47:34Certain point of View Returns, Return of the Jedi, and this should be
- 1:47:41our final at break. So y'all, thanks for bearing with us. We
- 1:47:45appreciate y'all. We'll be right back. Let's go ahead and take a look
- 1:47:49at that the first story you said eleven through fifteen, So, so the
- 1:48:00first one is the Starlac Story, Yes, by Charlie Jane Anders, and
- 1:48:05this one is titled entitled My Mouth Never Closes This I said this in our
- 1:48:13review. For those of you who have not listened to our review, it
- 1:48:16is dropping the exact same day as this episode. If you are just listening
- 1:48:21to our podcast, go check out that review of From a Certain point of
- 1:48:29View Return of the Jedi. This was in one of my This was in
- 1:48:33my top five stories. When it comes to these characters and the events that
- 1:48:41happened throughout each movie, you think, okay, there are important characters and
- 1:48:46there's not so important characters, and the Starlac Pit you're just looking and you're
- 1:48:51like, okay, it's a big plot device. You know, it's a
- 1:48:57big gaping hole in the sand. It's you can't, is it. But
- 1:49:01to find out the history of this uh somewhat peaceful creature, actually UH peaceful
- 1:49:15creature is absolutely hilarious. We said this in our review that the way they
- 1:49:24interpreted UH their own sign language is really really cool and also really hilarious to
- 1:49:32think about when you when you just think that this pit is absolutely terrifying and
- 1:49:39scary looking and all he's trying to say is hello, and he's just kind
- 1:49:43of waving and whatnot. Uh, But I really dug this story, you
- 1:49:47know, learning that there was a school of uh sarlas and that the uh
- 1:49:58that tattooing was once a jungle planet, I thought was even coolerly like it's
- 1:50:04it brings a whole lot of more mythos into the universe of the Star Wars
- 1:50:11galaxy. So I thought that was really really cool. Yeah, this one
- 1:50:15took me by complete surprise, And I don't know why it did, because
- 1:50:17the creature stories from a certain point of view, and from a certain point
- 1:50:24of view, strikes back shot the ever loving crap out of me. Like
- 1:50:28I absolutely love them, and this one is a hote. Charlie and Charlie
- 1:50:33Jane Anders did an incredible job with this, just making everything kind of funny
- 1:50:43innocence, but also like sarcastic, like I was also not expecting, like
- 1:50:48the technacle weaving to be sign language, like I think that's freaking awesome,
- 1:50:55but also just the fact that vegetarian Sarlac did not expect at all, like
- 1:51:01could not have dreamed of that, and it just fits so well. I
- 1:51:05loved it. This was in my honorable mentions. Yeah, yeah, very
- 1:51:11very cool story here. The next story is Colonel's Anne Husks. I'm trying
- 1:51:24to remember this story in particular. This one is by Jason Fry and it's
- 1:51:30about sim Alou. Yes, sim Alou was an advisor to Darth Sidius.
- 1:51:41So when you this is kind of in that presentation when Darth Cidius comes off.
- 1:51:47He is one of the people following Darth Sidius onto the Death Star.
- 1:51:54Wait, this is this book five? Is this that terrifying story about the
- 1:51:59farmers yea and the corn husks and and and throwing him overboard and everything.
- 1:52:06Yep, this this is literally my worst nightmare come to life. So uh,
- 1:52:15and it's actually I've seen it happen. Of course, this isn't like
- 1:52:18really seen it happen. But they actually showed this in Smallville for an episode.
- 1:52:25Yes, I remember that episode Martha Kent gets almost crushed by corn.
- 1:52:33This this is real. Uh, people can actually be crushed by small objects
- 1:52:41in uh mounds, same thing with with sand and in all sorts of dirt.
- 1:52:46It's a real thing, people. But this reading this uh again at
- 1:52:54the god awful hour of two in the morning, and the horrified look on
- 1:53:01my face as I'm reading the events, the fact that he is, uh,
- 1:53:08this individual is like, oh, come with me. I want to
- 1:53:13show you something like oh, like I are you sure you don't want to
- 1:53:16help out with this aid and like oh, like wait, you're you're you're
- 1:53:21wanting to replace all of us with droids? Like wait, let me show
- 1:53:27you something real quick. Like this was methodical, it was evil, it
- 1:53:32was terrifying. This story was nuts. Yes, I really enjoyed how this
- 1:53:45kind of dove into the Clone Wars time and kind of still tracking everything that's
- 1:53:50going on in Return of the Jedi, that Clone Wars, treachery and the
- 1:53:55droid hate. It's just a superb story and Jason always tells an incredible story.
- 1:54:01But like the whole story is involved like this one is one of the
- 1:54:08longer ones, I think, but it was so well told. Sim Alu
- 1:54:14is a creepy person and his death on the Death Star is completely deserved.
- 1:54:24Like this provides so much characterization to him. And I was looking on Wikipedia
- 1:54:29and actually there's like a lot of details on like that he was like helping
- 1:54:34collect like sixth sixth artifacts and Cassie and Andre and K two s O actually
- 1:54:41worked to retrieve artifacts from the Alu family. So it just makes me want
- 1:54:47to read more into him. The story does so, yes, very very
- 1:54:53good. Indeed, the next story was should have been on on my Honorable
- 1:55:00mentions, uh, but it did not make the cut when I was making
- 1:55:04my list. But it's The Light that Falls. This takes place on Daguba.
- 1:55:12Another one of those random creature stories uh in these books. Uh,
- 1:55:18this actually is the creature that you see in uh the Empire strikes Back that
- 1:55:29takes down the X Wing and you know, pulls RTD two into the swamp.
- 1:55:36This is the exact same creature. He calls himself bright Eyes because Yoda
- 1:55:43at one point called him bright Eyes, which I think is really cool.
- 1:55:48Yeah. Akimi don Bowman wrote this story, and I really enjoyed this one.
- 1:55:57Getting to know Bright Eyes was great. There a draft and snake,
- 1:56:00and it's just an overall reminder that beings around us may not be sentient in
- 1:56:04like the complete way of humans, especially in the Star Wars galaxy, Like
- 1:56:09there's a lot of times oh that creatures not sentient, but like you know,
- 1:56:12they still have a brain kind of thing, and like they recognize everything
- 1:56:15that's going around. They have all these thoughts and processes to go through,
- 1:56:18and her learning about Dagoba and waiting and watching was all articulated very well,
- 1:56:24especially like there at the end. Just not one of my tops, but
- 1:56:30it's definitely like a really good story. Well, I just love the idea
- 1:56:34that like this again shows you that everything is connected to the Force. Because
- 1:56:42one of the strongest stories within day Guba was when Luke went on his like
- 1:56:48force journey vision in the cave and you know, saw Darth Vader and when
- 1:56:56he struck him down, he saw himself and that was like so a metaphor
- 1:57:00cool than like everybody like blew their minds when they saw it, but like
- 1:57:04Bright Eyes could feel that darkness, the entire planet could feel that darkness.
- 1:57:12And like the really cool thing, which is actually really really sad, is
- 1:57:17when Yoda died, there was an imbalance on the planet. Like Yoda was
- 1:57:24literally the last light on that planet, the last candle burning on that planet.
- 1:57:30And Bright Eyes says like it's like the entire planet kind of went into
- 1:57:38chaos within balance once he died. But seeing the world in her eyes,
- 1:57:45I thought was really really cool, you know, being very aware of Luke,
- 1:57:50being very aware of Yoda, and the way that like, you know,
- 1:57:56the dark side of the force kind of gets the birds on edge,
- 1:58:00and you know that means that she kind of has to skip out on dinner
- 1:58:03because if she can't reach the birds, then you know, she can't eat.
- 1:58:09So it was a very very cool kind of like ecosystem story within Dagobah
- 1:58:15for sure. Yeah. The next story is actually takes the name of from
- 1:58:24a certain point of view and just kind of works on it. But it's
- 1:58:28by Alex Jennings from a certain point of view, and it is about Obi
- 1:58:32Wan Kenobi. For me, I was jumping up and down after reading this
- 1:58:36story. I was so excited. Jennings like articulated this story so well and
- 1:58:44told the story of Obi Wan struggling with all the decisions he's ever made in
- 1:58:47his life. It's got all of the show connections, all of like the
- 1:58:54Clone Wars connections, and like even goes back to Brotherhood and like it's I
- 1:59:00literally write my notes Chef's Kiss. But my favorite part is ultimately obi Wan
- 1:59:05realizing that Anakin is not truly gone because he lives on in Luke and Laya.
- 1:59:11Those best parts of Anakin live on in his kids, and that's so
- 1:59:15important for obi Wan to actually realize, so that he can have some peace
- 1:59:20and come to terms with everything. Yes, for sure, I think that
- 1:59:26this story. I love the story because it shows, even in death,
- 1:59:32how much weight is on Obi Wan's shoulders, like you said, for every
- 1:59:39decision he has made from when we were introduced to the character until now.
- 1:59:45He has this conversation with Luke, and I said this in our review that
- 1:59:50everybody can listen to if they go search it in our feed, that there's
- 1:59:58this conversation that he immediately has. Of course, after Yoda dies and when
- 2:00:04he tells Luke that he has to fight Vader, Luke says, I can't
- 2:00:12kill my father, And this blows obi One's mind. Not because he's refusing
- 2:00:20to fight Vader because after everything Vader has done, Luke is still seeing it
- 2:00:28as his father instead of the enemy. And again it points back to the
- 2:00:34idea that goodness came from both Padme and Anakin. Anakin loved more than anybody
- 2:00:45he like that was the whole reason why he unfortunately fell to the dark side,
- 2:00:49was because of love and seeing that here, like obi one is able
- 2:00:56to say, like, oh, like it's been staring in front of me
- 2:00:59the entire time, I'm such an idiot, and I just love how much
- 2:01:04this story is a full circle moment for him, you know, when it
- 2:01:10when it comes to everything else. The only time we see or hear from
- 2:01:14Obi Wan after this movie is u obi Wan's force ghosts talking to Ray.
- 2:01:21We don't get anything else from obi Wan other than just him smiling at Luke
- 2:01:29at the end of Return of the Jedi, Like, we don't get to
- 2:01:31see a conversation between the two, well, at least on this book.
- 2:01:39Yes, until this book. I think The Air to the Jedi books him
- 2:01:49and not read Yes, okay, I have not read said book, but
- 2:01:55I think I remember people talking that their last conversation is in that book.
- 2:02:01Okay, well, I will definitely would like to read that because I want
- 2:02:06to see the full like closure endpoint for OBI one for sure. Hm,
- 2:02:13the I think this is the last story. Yeah, the last story we're
- 2:02:15gonna talk about today is not my favorite because my favorite is down at the
- 2:02:21bottom. But it is called No Contingency by fran Wilde and it is about
- 2:02:28mon Mathma. This story, y'all, my Matha is freaking badass. Like
- 2:02:34just to see her actually take on action and like get to do something on
- 2:02:41her own. Fran Wilde did an incredible job with this book or the short
- 2:02:46story. Now I need to go find more of her books. But like
- 2:02:51we gushed, we gushed about this story in our review, and there's a
- 2:02:57reason for it. One of the things that I had said was mon Mathma
- 2:03:03is pin and proper and political and she always wears white, she's pure,
- 2:03:11she doesn't get her hands dirty. And this throws all of that away and
- 2:03:17it says, hey, I got us into this mess, I'm gonna get
- 2:03:21us out of this mess. And I think that is so cool for somebody
- 2:03:27like Mon Matha. But because it was it's coming from somebody you would not
- 2:03:30expect that to happen. This whole idea of Okay, I sent this droid
- 2:03:39to get information, and this information had come from one of you know,
- 2:03:45our own that you know did or did not make it. But I do
- 2:03:49know that the droid it's on his way, and you know, we have
- 2:03:54to get that information because it's it is clinical for us to get this information
- 2:04:00to stop the empire. And they find out, well, there's a giant
- 2:04:06asteroid field and that droid may not make it, and it dawns on mon
- 2:04:14mathah, oh, I fucked up. I kind of you know, set
- 2:04:21this contingency plan that if nobody gets to the droid within a certain amount of
- 2:04:29time, it implodes. And if the asteroid field is going to delay that
- 2:04:35druid from getting here, he's going to implode for no freaking reason. I
- 2:04:41need to go find him, get the information so we can get one step
- 2:04:45further from stopping the empire. And everybody's no, you can't do that,
- 2:04:49you can't do that. You're mon Mapa, you can't do that. What
- 2:04:51are you doing? Why are you doing this? And she says, f
- 2:04:55all of you guys, I need to do it. I'm the only one
- 2:04:58with the codes. I'm the only one with the location. I'm gonna go
- 2:05:00do this, And I love that she steps up and do and does that.
- 2:05:05It is so so cool. Yeah, and she's she's going for the
- 2:05:12information from the Bethans that she talks about in the briefing on home one,
- 2:05:17which is just so cool and like she gets to see blood on the information
- 2:05:25and that just like kind of puts even more context into that briefing where she
- 2:05:30just kind of pauses and as like many Bethans died to get us this information,
- 2:05:35Like it just had such an impact, Like, well done, fran
- 2:05:42Wilde, well done. Yes, I absolutely love this. Uh. And
- 2:05:46when I say she gets her hands dirty, she throws down with a droid
- 2:05:50like like she stabs it right in the face, like she does badass stuff.
- 2:05:57So it's not just her flying as getting endroid And it comes to say,
- 2:06:01no, she like at one point she has a bomb in her hand.
- 2:06:04Like it is intense. So don't just let us hype up the story
- 2:06:09to like make you feel like we're letting you down. No, it does
- 2:06:13get intense, and she is a pretty big badass in this story. Yep.
- 2:06:18All right, So that brings to the closed book club, but we
- 2:06:21also forgot to talk about what we were rating Ysoka episode. Oh, this
- 2:06:30episode, like I said, it was, it was one of the highlights
- 2:06:33of the three, very big action piece. I really enjoyed it helped the
- 2:06:40characters that we are following be more connected. I would give this a solid
- 2:06:45eight out of ten. Yep, same here. That was what I gave
- 2:06:49it as well. So for me, I thought it was a pretty good
- 2:06:54episode. I do have issues with it. I'd probably give it like an
- 2:06:58eight point five now that I have kind of talked about it and I resolved
- 2:07:01some of my issues with the episode. But yeah, I really enjoyed it.
- 2:07:09And next week we'll talk about how Star Wars fans can be really fucking
- 2:07:12ungrateful. That'll be a that'll be a topic next week because it's taken Twitter
- 2:07:17by storm, and my sister even asked some questions about like rhet cons and
- 2:07:25stuff, and so I just think we need to talk about it some more,
- 2:07:30especially with like how good these episodes. So yeah, let's like tell
- 2:07:34us where they can find you. Of course, you can always find me
- 2:07:39on Twitter, blue sky threads, any and all social media at fanboy Clay
- 2:07:45go check me out there. Of course I am the host of the other
- 2:07:50show on this network called Ranger Alliance. We had a new episode this week.
- 2:07:56Go check that out with me and Joe. If you are a patron,
- 2:08:01me and Jake are planning our monthly recording for our Marvel Snap show,
- 2:08:09So go check those out and be prepared for a hefty episode at the end
- 2:08:16of this week for that. But if you don't like Power Rangers and for
- 2:08:20some reason you're listening to this, but don't like Star Wars for some odd
- 2:08:24reason, why are you listening to this? Go check out the show that's
- 2:08:28not on the network, which is Batman News Weekly, where me and my
- 2:08:31co host talk anything and everything Batman within pop culture. Okay, where can
- 2:08:35I find you? Well? And first thanks, first click, and I
- 2:08:41have to get a recording set up because we're gonna be talking about Percy Jackson
- 2:08:46and we're gonna be reviewing those books. We're gonna be going onto the movie
- 2:08:50so that we can be prepared for the show dropping in December. So keep
- 2:08:56an eye on that, because Clay and I got to talk about this.
- 2:09:00I need somebody to talk Percy Jackson with. I need to reread the book.
- 2:09:07Oh man, how long is that book? Actually it's really not that
- 2:09:11long because this young adult, it is a young adult. I think it's
- 2:09:16fairly short. It is a whopping ten hours. That's easy. Yeah,
- 2:09:22so we'll we'll figure that out. But expect that The next solo Patreon I
- 2:09:28plan on doing is talking about some things because I am going to get Patreon
- 2:09:33done. I promise, y'all. I promise. I know I keep saying
- 2:09:37that, but it's going to happen. The next thing I plan on talking
- 2:09:39about is five things that I am hoping for in mertag And, which is
- 2:09:46the next book in the air Gun series by Christopher Paulini. So that is
- 2:09:52what you can expect next from me. If y'all are interested in like a
- 2:09:56little synopsis about where mer is been at, I can also totally do that
- 2:10:03because I have all the audiobooks, so I can listen to them and then
- 2:10:07kind of rate stuff down. But I'm really excited for that book to come
- 2:10:11out. I just took off two days in November, Clay because we have
- 2:10:18the Eye of Darkness, Mertog, and Iron Flame, which is the fourth
- 2:10:22wing Uh sequel, that are all dropping on the same exact day, and
- 2:10:28I have to get all of these red like not optional, and I know
- 2:10:31we'll probably get Eye of Darkness like early, but just in case, you
- 2:10:35know, I liked I like to plan in advance. So to answer Clay's
- 2:10:41question, you can find me on most social media platforms. It's at Slice
- 2:10:45of Katie. This show you can find on Twitter. It's at Star Wars
- 2:10:48Alliance off the eight in the Wars very important. Don't forget it as always,
- 2:10:54you can email us uh Star Wars Alliance at gmail dot com. Remember
- 2:10:56there's no A in the Wars. Do not forget it. You can also
- 2:11:01shoot us a text. I know we haven't had the banner up all show,
- 2:11:05but that is eight three zero five three eight four eight to eight.
- 2:11:09Remember you can text us, leave us a voicemail voice memo on the phone,
- 2:11:16just to kind of give us reactions to Asoca. If you want to
- 2:11:20send us some thoughts on from a certain point of view returns, feel free
- 2:11:24to. We love hearing from you guys. It's super important. So yeah,
- 2:11:30I think this brings us to a close Clay. Yes, next next
- 2:11:35week we're talking Asoka episode four and then what I told you guys about how
- 2:11:39I got really fiery about ratcons and stuff and ungrateful fans. So that's what
- 2:11:46you could expect next week. If you have any questions about the show,
- 2:11:50Ahsoka, like, if you're like, what the heck is this? Like,
- 2:11:54can you go into more information on that? Just let us know again,
- 2:11:56text us email, send us a m on Twitter. We're more than
- 2:12:01happy to dive into more details. So for now, guys, I want
- 2:12:05to wish everyone a great day or night, whatever time and day you are
- 2:12:09listening or watching, and we will see you next time. May the Force
- 2:12:11to be with you.