Latest / Well Bound Podcast / Ep. 77 - Creatine: The Supplement Everyone's Asking About
Transcript
- 0:09[SPEAKER_01]: episode of Wellbound, we are your host, Brooke Snyder, and be in a check.
- 0:13[SPEAKER_01]: And today's episode is all about a supplement that I feel like is constantly in the orbit and being talked about, but I just know me, like myself personally, and my practice and with like working with my athletes and clients have just,
- 0:29[SPEAKER_01]: heard a lot more questions about creatine.
- 0:33[SPEAKER_01]: And it just become my feel like buzzy again.
- 0:36[SPEAKER_01]: There's just more questions.
- 0:37[SPEAKER_01]: I just feel like it's kind of recirculating.
- 0:39[SPEAKER_01]: So we figured we would talk about creatine on the podcast today.
- 0:44[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, and I think we talked about this in our supplement episode, which I don't remember with.
- 0:52[SPEAKER_00]: You did.
- 0:53[SPEAKER_00]: It was in 2024, so it was like over two years ago at this point.
- 0:56[SPEAKER_01]: It was one of the first episodes, and we like briefly touched on it, but we didn't do a deep dive.
- 1:00[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, it wasn't like a deep deep dive, so we give like a little bit, but not.
- 1:05[SPEAKER_00]: all the things that we're going to give today.
- 1:07[SPEAKER_00]: But yeah, I think we just wanted to walk through kind of what it is and why our bodies, because our bodies make it to a certain degree, but we'll talk about some of the different reasons of why supplementation might be necessary and kind of like who supplementation can benefit.
- 1:24[SPEAKER_00]: And yeah, we'll just walk into all of it.
- 1:26[SPEAKER_00]: So
- 1:27[SPEAKER_00]: First, I guess I wanted to just talk about creatine as we know it and then we can talk about kind of like its supplement form and how we dose it and all of that.
- 1:38[SPEAKER_00]: So creatine is naturally occurring.
- 1:42[SPEAKER_00]: Your body makes creatine from amino acids, primarily in the liver and the kidneys.
- 1:47[SPEAKER_00]: You also can get it from animal foods, and this is particularly like meat and fish, but you need to eat quite a bit of it, and I looked it up because I was like, how much is the translation really, and I think it was like 2 pounds of B for something a day would get you around like the 5 gram mark, which is typically what we're supplementing up to.
- 2:09[SPEAKER_01]: All right, so the conversion I knew in my head was like one pound of meat equals like two to three grams.
- 2:15[SPEAKER_01]: So that's your translation is the same thing.
- 2:18[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 2:18[SPEAKER_00]: Yes.
- 2:19[SPEAKER_00]: So like, but if you think about that, like I'm thinking it's a lot of like a roast, right?
- 2:23[SPEAKER_00]: Like I just had a pot roast tonight.
- 2:26[SPEAKER_00]: And I got like a 2.19 pound pot roast.
- 2:30[SPEAKER_00]: That thing was huge, okay?
- 2:32[SPEAKER_00]: And
- 2:33[SPEAKER_00]: So that is just not realistic right on like a day to day basis one from the financial standpoint, but also just from like a gut integrity.
- 2:43[SPEAKER_01]: Even if you think about like if you're going to eat like a one large chicken breast per meal, like a really large chicken breast is about six ounces, and I mean there's 16 ounces in a pound.
- 2:53[SPEAKER_01]: So you'd have to eat.
- 2:55[SPEAKER_00]: like oh my gosh that's just a lot of it's a lot and it's heavy so it's like just not something we're all gonna be doing especially especially if you're training which is where a lot of this supplementation comes in like eating that weight and that amount of
- 3:12[SPEAKER_00]: me is just not going to sit well in your gut if you're trying to exercise.
- 3:15[SPEAKER_00]: So that being said, this is why supplementation is typically done.
- 3:21[SPEAKER_00]: Most of the body's creatine is stored in skeletal muscle, which is the muscle that you use in exercise.
- 3:27[SPEAKER_00]: It's the muscle that's attached to bones that you can grow with exercise essentially.
- 3:31[SPEAKER_00]: And think like your quads, your glutes, your
- 3:40[SPEAKER_00]: Yep, and so that's where we're storing it, and so when we're exercising, we're able to utilize that.
- 3:48[SPEAKER_00]: It's main job is helping to produce energy quickly.
- 3:52[SPEAKER_00]: So, creatine is stored as this phosphocreatine, and that helps regenerate ATP, which is energy.
- 4:00[SPEAKER_00]: This is particularly useful during short intense efforts, so think like lifting, sprinting, jumping, or a repeated hard effort.
- 4:10[SPEAKER_00]: And this is where
- 4:13[SPEAKER_00]: I guess why we utilize it as a supplementation form for this type of exercise, because if we don't have it ready and accessible, then we're maybe not going to have as much energy to perform those activities, if we were to had supplemented.
- 4:30[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, this is how I always explain it in my like team talks with either like my sports teams I talk to or like anywhere from youth athletes, all the way up to my professional athletes I work with.
- 4:42[SPEAKER_01]: Like I always explain, okay, how does this work?
- 4:45[SPEAKER_01]: I explain that creating supplementation essentially floods your phospho creatine stores in your muscles and so when you flood the stores which help regenerate ATP or energy like think of ATP when we say that.
- 5:00[SPEAKER_01]: you can interchange that with the word energy.
- 5:02[SPEAKER_01]: So you're essentially able to access more energy in your muscles, which helps you train at higher intensities for longer periods of time.
- 5:11[SPEAKER_01]: And so, to Peyton's point, that repeated hard efforts, think of like tennis players, volleyball players, a lot of athletes in those stop and go sports even football.
- 5:22[SPEAKER_01]: And this would be really helpful for athletes like that, as well as if you're just like an active individual who is training on your own, maybe you're training for something or you're just trying to get in shape.
- 5:36[SPEAKER_01]: it can be great for you, but yeah, to kind of expand a little bit further, the energy demand can be greater than the speed at which your ATP stores are depleted when you're exercising.
- 5:48[SPEAKER_01]: So this is essentially where creatine shines and provides that fuel contributing to your overall energy storage.
- 5:57[SPEAKER_01]: So in other words, when you supplement with creatine, you're increasing the
- 6:06[SPEAKER_01]: allowing, like I said earlier, your body to work at a higher intensity for a longer period of time.
- 6:11[SPEAKER_01]: So that's essentially why there's all this like buzz and hype around creating supplementation because it does honestly wonders and has been researched.
- 6:24[SPEAKER_01]: very well researched and well documented for like generation or generations.
- 6:29[SPEAKER_01]: I'm in say decades at this point.
- 6:32[SPEAKER_01]: That's a big question I get from a lot of clients, athletes, etc.
- 6:36[SPEAKER_01]: Is like, well, is it safe or is it well researched?
- 6:39[SPEAKER_01]: And the answer is yes.
- 6:40[SPEAKER_01]: This is one of the supplements that is extremely safe to take for a majority of individuals.
- 6:45[SPEAKER_01]: We'll go through a who here in a minute.
- 6:47[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 6:47[SPEAKER_00]: It's pretty safe, it's effective, and it's been heavily researched, so I feel confident in saying that loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud loud
- 7:12[SPEAKER_00]: The cognitive side of things because there is a lot happening there too, but yeah, I just wanted to keep talking through this a little bit with the form.
- 7:24[SPEAKER_00]: So when we talk about creating supplementation, the most extensively studied form is creating monohydrate.
- 7:34[SPEAKER_00]: And that's the form that we recommend when we're recommending a supplement.
- 7:40[SPEAKER_00]: There's currently no compelling evidence that expensive alternative forms are superior to the monohydrate, so I would just say stick to that, the creating monohydrate.
- 7:51[SPEAKER_01]: I want to kind of go through some of the other forms that are out there, because sometimes different supplement companies try to market their other forms as like the most optimal, and it's just a big play.
- 8:03[SPEAKER_01]: So I just kind of want to go through the other forms that are out there, but just know that creatine mono hydrate is the form that you should be taking if you're going to supplement.
- 8:12[SPEAKER_01]: So I'll go over what that is.
- 8:14[SPEAKER_01]: Typically creatine mono hydrate is like a white crystalline powder that is absorbed pretty quickly and transferred from your blood to your muscles to be used for energy.
- 8:26[SPEAKER_01]: And typically this is kind of like a flavorless powder that you could add to any drink
- 8:32[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I know some people who mix it in their coffee, in their electrolytes, in their water.
- 8:38[SPEAKER_01]: That's creatine model hydrate.
- 8:40[SPEAKER_01]: Then you have creatine ethyl ester, and that form has been chemically modified with an ethyl group, so it's just like, I don't know, chemistry is just like a little group of ions at the end of the molecule, in order to boost its bioavailability.
- 8:56[SPEAKER_01]: So this wallet claims to be more effective than like other forms of creatine, the evidence is mixed here and doesn't really support that.
- 9:05[SPEAKER_01]: So that is another form you'll see.
- 9:07[SPEAKER_01]: You'll also see buffered creatine out there.
- 9:11[SPEAKER_01]: This type has like had its pH adjusted, which is why they call it buffered, to be essentially like less acidic compared to other forms.
- 9:23[SPEAKER_01]: particularly, less acidic than creating mono hydrate.
- 9:27[SPEAKER_01]: So again, companies will claim that this form is more stable, better absorbed, and has like fewer potential side effects, but that's
- 9:40[SPEAKER_01]: hasn't really been researched to be the case and buffer grating can come in like capsules or in powdered form sometimes and then the last one is called creatine HCL and this was kind of like a newer form a few years ago that kind of like emerged on the scene and it's been modified to like improve solubility which is essentially just like when you mix it into something
- 10:10[SPEAKER_01]: And so the addition of so HCL stands for hydrochloric acid and so the addition of that is intended to help like boost its absorption in your digestive system but in terms of like creating HCL versus
- 10:30[SPEAKER_01]: of it's like proposed better absorption.
- 10:34[SPEAKER_01]: But again, the evidence is limited and doesn't support this.
- 10:36[SPEAKER_01]: So those are kind of like the claims and how you can find the other forms.
- 10:41[SPEAKER_01]: But at the end of the day, creatine monohydrate has been around the longest.
- 10:45[SPEAKER_01]: We have the most data on the safety effectiveness benefits of creatine monohydrate for athletic performance and for some of those like
- 10:55[SPEAKER_01]: cognitive, memory, brain health, concussion, stuff that will touch on a little bit.
- 11:02[SPEAKER_01]: So yeah, creatine monohydrate is proven to be the most effective form and the form that we would go for and it's also the most affordable.
- 11:12[SPEAKER_01]: So that's kind of also a pro.
- 11:14[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, and I think the main thing to is like, all these other versions of it talk about like, oh, improved absorption in this and that and the other, but it's like, we don't really have issues with the model hydrant itself.
- 11:30[SPEAKER_00]: So, it's like, if it's not broke, don't fix it.
- 11:33[SPEAKER_00]: Like, it's fine.
- 11:34[SPEAKER_00]: We're not having like intense issues with the model hydrate form where we would need to find something to do better.
- 11:42[SPEAKER_01]: So yeah, this isn't something that people have a hard time with like in their gut.
- 11:49[SPEAKER_01]: And yeah absorbing this to be yeah that's it's not an issue.
- 11:53[SPEAKER_01]: So again, those are just kind of claims that are being made about each of the forms and it's mostly it's mostly marketing like mumbo jumbo.
- 12:03[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
- 12:05[SPEAKER_00]: So I wanted to go into kind of like the recommendation before we jump into all the other informative pieces.
- 12:12[SPEAKER_00]: So typically what we recommend and broke I assume you'd recommend this too is the 3 to 5 grams per day.
- 12:22[SPEAKER_00]: And this
- 12:25[SPEAKER_00]: this is kind of standard across the board.
- 12:27[SPEAKER_00]: I have seen and I've kind of looked into people talking about going upwards of like 10 grams a day, especially for the cognitive benefits, but I think that's more of a unique situation.
- 12:42[SPEAKER_00]: I think we're typically still seeing the 3 to 5 grams per day.
- 12:46[SPEAKER_01]: Yep, a lot of the research that I've seen that compare like five grams versus 10 grams a day for mostly athletic performance is the research that I've looked at.
- 12:56[SPEAKER_01]: They show the same performance benefits, so it's kind of like almost pointless to take that extra five grams when the performance benefit is pretty much the same from the five gram dosage, so you're not only.
- 13:07[SPEAKER_01]: like saving money, you're saving product, you're the same effectiveness.
- 13:11[SPEAKER_01]: So I don't typically recommend going up to 10 grams a day or going through like a loading phase, for example like I don't know some like bodybuilders and or other people out there will maybe tell you to like start with 3 to 5 grams and then bump up to 10 and then 15 and then 20 and then kind of like ride that way back down and there's no need for that.
- 13:35[SPEAKER_00]: as well.
- 13:35[SPEAKER_01]: There's no greater benefit to doing that.
- 13:39[SPEAKER_01]: So again, it's just kind of like a waste of product and a waste of money at that time.
- 13:43[SPEAKER_01]: If you hear about a loading phase, the 3 to 5 grams a day will suffice and benefit, I would say, like a majority, if not all of individuals who take it for the purpose of athletic improving athletic performance.
- 14:01[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, and I would add on to that too, especially with that loading phase concept, I was just kind of listening into a couple different things and it sounds like to the idea behind that was like the research.
- 14:16[SPEAKER_00]: before would show that, you know, we didn't have enough in the system or whatever, but typically what's happening is when we're doing this consistent three to five grams per day of creating monohydrate, which I also want to say to that this has to be consistent.
- 14:32[SPEAKER_00]: You can't like take it one day and then four days later take it again and then three days later take it again or
- 14:37[SPEAKER_00]: You're only going to work out this day so that's when you do it like you have to be consistent every day for this to really make a difference.
- 14:43[SPEAKER_00]: But I wanted to say that it does take about three to four weeks for your muscle creatine stores to become saturated.
- 14:50[SPEAKER_00]: And that was like the purpose of people trying to load before was to like saturate their their creatine and their muscles super fast.
- 15:00[SPEAKER_00]: but a lot of us have the time.
- 15:02[SPEAKER_00]: So there's no reason to like load up and do all that craziness if we're just going to be taking it on a consistent schedule anyways.
- 15:09[SPEAKER_00]: So that's like why it's not really necessary to do that.
- 15:14[SPEAKER_00]: And I also think it's really important to mention because I think I don't want people to get this idea and they're had that like, oh, I'm going to start taking creating and I'm going to like build muscle and get really strong and like whatever.
- 15:28[SPEAKER_00]: Because I think to some people that's the idea behind creating is like it just helps you bulk up and like get muscles, but.
- 15:36[SPEAKER_00]: It's not it doesn't affect like the protein synthesis model.
- 15:41[SPEAKER_00]: It's like it's helping you get the energy to exercise or perform at a higher level, which then ends up resulting in said muscle growth.
- 15:49[SPEAKER_00]: Thank you for mentioning that.
- 15:50[SPEAKER_01]: I think that's really important is yeah, this is a athletic adaptation or training adaptation or enhancement to
- 16:01[SPEAKER_01]: Aiding or assisting your workouts.
- 16:03[SPEAKER_01]: So if you're just like taking this and not putting in the work of like training, string training, you know, I don't know, conditioning, et cetera, this supplement is it really gonna work in the way that you think it's going to.
- 16:21[SPEAKER_01]: It's not, it's not magic.
- 16:22[SPEAKER_01]: You have to be willing to put in the effort behind it and then it'll assist you along the way
- 16:31[SPEAKER_01]: like we said, at higher intensities for a longer periods of time, but you kind of have to be willing to do that to then see those training adaptations and body composition changes like muscle gain, take place or muscle gain and fat loss taking place, because oftentimes if you can train at higher intensities for longer periods of time, I think a lot of people can fuse
- 17:00[SPEAKER_01]: Some people actually use this to help them lean out in the sense of like yes, they're trying to build and maintain skeletal muscle mass, but if they're able to train longer higher intensities.
- 17:10[SPEAKER_01]: And depending on what they're doing with their diet outside of that, et cetera, they can also potentially be burning fat.
- 17:15[SPEAKER_01]: That's the same time and overall improve their body composition too.
- 17:19[SPEAKER_01]: So not to get off on a tangent, but yeah.
- 17:31[SPEAKER_00]: you also have to be like adding the term is stress but like we don't want to be like stressing our brain right like that's not the purpose but you have to be actively working your brain in order to see the cognitive benefits as well so if you're just taking it and you're not really ever exercising your brain for example like you're not
- 17:52[SPEAKER_00]: you know, learning or doing something that is really working on your processing, you're also not going to see as big of a cognitive improvement as you might, if you're doing that.
- 18:06[SPEAKER_00]: And this also goes
- 18:09[SPEAKER_00]: into why it can be really beneficial, potentially, I think there's a lot more research that needs to be done here, but potentially for people with like traumatic brain injuries, or concussions, or things that have caused stress on the brain where your brain is like trying to fix something or like learn something new.
- 18:27[SPEAKER_00]: And that's where they see the supplementation paired with that work, right?
- 18:32[SPEAKER_00]: So there's always going to be an amount of work that has to be done.
- 18:36[SPEAKER_00]: That is what's going to lead to those improvements, whether it's muscle or brain muscle, if you know.
- 18:42[SPEAKER_01]: I actually, I mean, if we're going to segue into some of the concussion stuff, I actually wanted to read a couple things from an article, but I do want to caveat and say that in my work, I now utilize creatine as a part of concussion recovery protocol, along with like Omega-3 supplementation.
- 19:02[SPEAKER_01]: I've
- 19:03[SPEAKER_01]: we've added creatine to our protocol for those athletes because of some of the emerging research don't get me wrong.
- 19:11[SPEAKER_01]: I do think there's always more to be done, but I just kind of wanted to read some highlights from this a conclusion of the study.
- 19:18[SPEAKER_01]: So with creatine supplementation looking at mild traumatic brain injuries or something like a cushion,
- 19:26[SPEAKER_01]: it says that creatine supplementation can have both neuroprotective effects in both animal models.
- 19:35[SPEAKER_01]: So those type of research studies where they looked at like protecting mitochondrial function antioxidant effects and increased ATP to the brain.
- 19:45[SPEAKER_01]: So energy to the brain.
- 19:47[SPEAKER_01]: and in clinical cohorts.
- 19:48[SPEAKER_01]: So this would be like, think about people studies.
- 19:52[SPEAKER_01]: So improving recovery, reducing, and then reducing concussion symptoms.
- 19:56[SPEAKER_01]: So like headaches, dizziness, fatigue, and improved cognition.
- 20:01[SPEAKER_01]: It says creatine supplementation also improves cognition and non-clinical populations.
- 20:06[SPEAKER_01]: So outcomes in anxiety and depression related mood disorders.
- 20:11[SPEAKER_01]: and has a protective effect in situations that impair cell energy status.
- 20:16[SPEAKER_01]: So kind of interesting.
- 20:18[SPEAKER_01]: There's also some factors to consider, which is just that the efficacy of creatine supplementation is dependent on its ability to increase neural concentration.
- 20:30[SPEAKER_01]: And it says this increase may be small and slow due to limited creatine transporters at the blood-brain barrier.
- 20:37[SPEAKER_01]: So essentially accessing this energy or ATP to your brain, there's limited...
- 20:45[SPEAKER_01]: like creatine transporters that allow basically that to happen.
- 20:49[SPEAKER_01]: So that's just a factor to consider.
- 20:52[SPEAKER_01]: And then it's just as other factors that affect efficacy, our dosage regimen.
- 20:56[SPEAKER_01]: So again, trying to play around with that dosage, because we don't exactly know what the right one, like, or what they maybe like max benefit would be.
- 21:06[SPEAKER_01]: prior neural concentration, which varies across areas, maybe influenced by diet, age, and gender, and then tolerance.
- 21:13[SPEAKER_01]: So safety of his administration or your overall hydration status.
- 21:17[SPEAKER_01]: And then it says another factor to consider in a particular interest is preemptive supplementation prior to injury.
- 21:26[SPEAKER_01]: So if you were taking this prior to injury,
- 21:29[SPEAKER_01]: that may have a greater neuroprotective effect than post-industry supplementation, which I thought was interesting.
- 21:36[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 21:36[SPEAKER_01]: Um, so basically saying like if you're preemptively taking this and where to get a concussion, that could potentially help you get back to baseline quicker than if you were to add something like creatine in post concussion.
- 21:50[SPEAKER_01]: And then some conclusion and like future perspectives, sorry, this is getting kind of lengthy, but it just says that creating supplementation demonstrates potential as a neuroprotective both before and after a traumatic brain injury.
- 22:03[SPEAKER_01]: There's a gap in the literature for research into supplementation following a concussion.
- 22:10[SPEAKER_01]: So there does, to your point, Peyton need to be more
- 22:20[SPEAKER_01]: against a mild traumatic brain injury like a cushion and then a sub-concussive injury in high-risk populations such as athletes and military personnel.
- 22:30[SPEAKER_01]: So that was just this
- 22:34[SPEAKER_00]: basically like research review.
- 22:37[SPEAKER_01]: But based on a lot of the different areas of like human performance that I work with, we added that in as if you are concussion prone, you should be taking creatine.
- 22:48[SPEAKER_01]: So if you've had concussions in the past, this is something that you should be like, let's say a soccer athlete has had recurring concussions.
- 22:55[SPEAKER_01]: They should be taking creatine.
- 22:57[SPEAKER_01]: already.
- 22:58[SPEAKER_01]: And then we have still added it to the post concussion protocol, even though there needs to be like more research done in this area, but it's something that we are utilizing in practice as a potential benefit.
- 23:10[SPEAKER_00]: So yeah, no, I think that's really cool.
- 23:12[SPEAKER_00]: And I think it's it's helpful too because most of the time it's not harmful to be taking this.
- 23:20[SPEAKER_00]: I don't know
- 23:26[SPEAKER_01]: No, the other thing I just wanted to mention, I was reading this article, and I thought this was really cool.
- 23:33[SPEAKER_01]: It's kind of talking about how the brain utilizes creatine, even though I just mentioned that like some of the transporter stuff can maybe we don't know enough about, or is a little bit limited to getting that energy to the brain.
- 23:45[SPEAKER_01]: But this article said that creatine might increase, um,
- 23:49[SPEAKER_01]: the creatine stores inside our brain cells by 5 to 10 percent.
- 23:53[SPEAKER_01]: So this may provide the brain with more energy and the technical term for this energy promoted by creatine is a molecule called ATP, like we've been talking about, and
- 24:04[SPEAKER_01]: And creatine's role in increasing the fuel for the brain or energy for the brain is critical for the health and recovery, a brain function, since the brain alone consumes about 20% of the body's total energy, so that's like a massive amount related to the rest of your body.
- 24:21[SPEAKER_01]: It goes on to just kind of say that like when a person suffers a concussion, one of the effects of like,
- 24:27[SPEAKER_01]: or a result of that brain dysfunction is a sudden rapid increase in brain activity, and so this is known as like the excitatory phase of a concussion, and so like this abrupt onset of this like neuronal hyperactivity results in your concussion symptoms, like your headache or nausea, your dizziness, difficulty falling asleep lasting hours to days, so
- 24:52[SPEAKER_01]: Essentially what everyone is kind of theorizing about this whole thing is like this excitation phase of concussions burns a lot of energy.
- 25:01[SPEAKER_01]: So if you're supplementing with creatine before, you may be have more energy or ATP to access to help heal or get through that excitatory phase kind of like faster.
- 25:13[SPEAKER_01]: And then what they're still kind of looking into is like if you were to start it after directly after you get a concussion, because we know it kind of takes a while to get into your system, you know, how much of a benefit is that, but that's kind of like the idea behind concussions, so I thought that was cool.
- 25:32[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, that is super cool.
- 25:33[SPEAKER_00]: And it's worth mentioning that the effect isn't going to be identical for everybody in individual responses will vary.
- 25:42[SPEAKER_00]: So, you know, one person could have this result, another person could have another result, same thing with any supplementation, but the research is really good surrounding creating.
- 25:54[SPEAKER_01]: We'll also like, and when we are just talking about
- 26:01[SPEAKER_01]: because everyone's like brains work a little bit differently.
- 26:04[SPEAKER_01]: And so it's important to say like when we're talking about creatine specifically like when we stop talking about muscles and athletic performance and get into the whole brain stuff, that is where like Peyton and I are not experts in that area.
- 26:17[SPEAKER_01]: We're kind of like regurgitating some of the research here, although we find it very fascinating and interesting, but everyone's brain is also very different.
- 26:25[SPEAKER_01]: So it's hard to say that
- 26:29[SPEAKER_01]: this would act or react the same way in myself versus Peyton versus one of you out there listening.
- 26:37[SPEAKER_00]: So I think I want to kind of talk now about if you start supplementation what you can maybe expect to see.
- 26:44[SPEAKER_00]: And like we said, there's differences with everybody.
- 26:47[SPEAKER_00]: And
- 26:49[SPEAKER_00]: This goes for like Brooke was mentioning a little bit about the cognitive piece, but also the performance piece where you might see somebody who again, it's all based on like the effort you're putting in and kind of the the reward you're getting out, but
- 27:05[SPEAKER_00]: It's not to say that everybody's going to have those same results should they be doing the same exact thing and taking the same exact dose and whatever, but there are some things that you might see happen once you start taking creating and this is I think something that scares people a little bit, which is the initial weight gain that can happen with.
- 27:26[SPEAKER_00]: creating supplementation, and this is primarily due to water, because it increases our water retention within our muscles.
- 27:37[SPEAKER_00]: So it kind of sucks in more water into those muscles, and it's like, hey, hold on to this for a little bit.
- 27:42[SPEAKER_01]: That's why I use the term flood when I talk about it, because then I can kind of circle back to the water aspect of it all, because that is typically
- 27:54[SPEAKER_01]: Like any of my female clients or female athletes, we kind of have to sometimes have a conversation about this because it's not always the case that we're trying to like gain weight per se right like that can be sensitive topic with a lot of people.
- 28:11[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, and I think this goes back to the conversation of body composition rather than weight and why understanding that the scale isn't telling us the whole story.
- 28:22[SPEAKER_00]: Yes.
- 28:22[SPEAKER_00]: We talked about this multiple times, but just remembering like you're going to see weight change whether you're increasing muscle, you're retaining a little bit more water, you're increasing fat.
- 28:31[SPEAKER_00]: So you don't know where that weight is always coming from, but if you start experiencing a little bit like
- 28:38[SPEAKER_00]: Studies usually report roughly like two to four pounds of body weight increase over the first month in some people.
- 28:45[SPEAKER_00]: This isn't always going to be the case.
- 28:48[SPEAKER_00]: And this is when using it like alongside that strength training, but the water weight typically receives within like three-ish weeks after that.
- 28:55[SPEAKER_00]: So you might see this little increase, which
- 29:00[SPEAKER_00]: I think it's noticeable.
- 29:02[SPEAKER_00]: People talk about feeling a little bit bloated and stuff like that, too.
- 29:05[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, actually at a male hockey athlete last year, start taking Kreatyne for the first time.
- 29:11[SPEAKER_01]: And he, after one week of taking it, he pulled me aside and was like, hey, like, my weight is up.
- 29:19[SPEAKER_01]: Like, I think it was in between four and six pounds.
- 29:22[SPEAKER_01]: So like, very minimal amount for him.
- 29:25[SPEAKER_01]: He's a larger, like, a larger guy anyways.
- 29:28[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, a larger guy isn't like,
- 29:29[SPEAKER_01]: He's like six four like he's a big lucky.
- 29:32[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, yeah, he he's six four and plays division one hockey like he's a big guy and Anyways, he was like I'm like my weights up a little bit and I know you said that might happen with creatine But I've been taking it for a week and I was like hey
- 29:47[SPEAKER_01]: I was like, give it one more week, continue to be consistent and let me know, I was like, you know, when I'm here next Wednesday, we can check back in and after 14 days, his weight had returned back to normal.
- 30:01[SPEAKER_01]: So it, I typically say it takes like 14, yeah, 14, Max, like 21 days in your weight should return just because your body, again, kind of has to just like get used to this like
- 30:18[SPEAKER_00]: Right.
- 30:18[SPEAKER_00]: So yeah, with that being said, you might see a little bit of that weight shift.
- 30:23[SPEAKER_00]: And I was just going to mention to that with the.
- 30:29[SPEAKER_00]: energy that this supplies and being able to exercise a little bit more, you might not always go back to your baseline weight if you're gaining muscle at that rate too.
- 30:39[SPEAKER_00]: So, kind of keep that mine too.
- 30:40[SPEAKER_00]: I think that that's just important because your goal ultimately, if you're trying to gain more muscle or have better performance or whatever, is that you might not see a drop in the
- 30:57[SPEAKER_01]: I think, yeah, it's important, like the example that I gave, he's a highly trained, like I said, division one hockey player.
- 31:03[SPEAKER_01]: So, like his training curve or adaptation is going to be a lot smaller than somebody who's maybe starting to take creatine and also starting to like really ramp up the training for like the, maybe the first time in that life, right?
- 31:19[SPEAKER_01]: Those two things will look a lot different.
- 31:21[SPEAKER_01]: So, yeah, yeah, it's just important, obviously to understand that like all situations are nuanced.
- 31:27[SPEAKER_01]: I'm just here to try and provide like a little bit of context behind some of what we're talking about.
- 31:32[SPEAKER_00]: So yeah, and similarly, so my husband can and he takes creating like religiously, he takes it every day.
- 31:39[SPEAKER_01]: He puts it in his smoothie I think in the morning is I want to start taking it, but I just haven't with like breastfeeding, even though they say it's safe actually.
- 31:47[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 31:48[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, um, I also haven't, but I want to get into as well and same thing.
- 31:52[SPEAKER_00]: I've been like pregnant or nursing and whatever, which again, um, is there's a lot more research being done on women in this specific area, and it's deemed safe, but again, you know, it's like,
- 32:07[SPEAKER_00]: we weren't really hitting it hard until recently anyways.
- 32:09[SPEAKER_00]: So I know, though, there wasn't really a huge need to take it, but I could probably start taking it now because I have been a little bit more consistent in the gym.
- 32:18[SPEAKER_00]: So Keenan has been taking it consistently, and he exercises very consistently.
- 32:25[SPEAKER_00]: six times a week is typically his norm.
- 32:28[SPEAKER_00]: And so he's not going to see these crazy, crazy, like muscle gains in a week.
- 32:33[SPEAKER_00]: He might see them over time nice and slow and kind of like an easy role, but yeah, he's been taking it consistently for gosh, I don't know, probably a couple of years now.
- 32:42[SPEAKER_00]: So yeah, like he, everyone's in a while, he'll be like, hey, can you put creating on the list?
- 32:48[SPEAKER_00]: You're like, oh, I need to run and grab some creatine because he just takes it so consistently.
- 32:51[SPEAKER_00]: So
- 32:53[SPEAKER_00]: there's that.
- 32:54[SPEAKER_00]: Um, but I did want to talk to just about like timing because I know people might be like, well, when when am I supposed to be taking this and we have kind of mentioned like, oh, I said, you know, Cainan takes it in his smoothie in the morning.
- 33:08[SPEAKER_00]: He makes this again.
- 33:09[SPEAKER_00]: This guy's like religious on his basic routine has the same exact smoothie every day.
- 33:16[SPEAKER_00]: works out the same amount of time, like the same lifts or whatever, and rotates through them.
- 33:23[SPEAKER_00]: So he has his in the morning, but if he were to decide, you know, oh, I, I'm not going to have the smoothie, which he won't do, but if he decided that he wasn't going to, and he decided he was just going to take it in the afternoon with his pre-workout, it's not going to really make too much of a difference.
- 33:40[SPEAKER_00]: As long as he's being consistent with that routine every single day, yeah,
- 33:44[SPEAKER_01]: I always, I always tell athletes like consistency is greater than timing.
- 33:49[SPEAKER_01]: If you wanted to have like the gold, well, I say the gold standard, but then it kind of depends on what you're going for.
- 33:56[SPEAKER_01]: Are you going for more of the performance benefit from your training session?
- 34:02[SPEAKER_01]: If so, you'd want to take it about 60 minutes or an hour before you train.
- 34:07[SPEAKER_01]: if you were wanting to go for more of like some of that recovery benefit, which you can still provide, you could take it after and still gain plenty of benefit from like the recovery side of like the, and our maximizing energy via your muscles for kind of like that post.
- 34:26[SPEAKER_01]: exercise process.
- 34:29[SPEAKER_01]: But I am, I always default to consistency, just taking it daily over having the gold standard of timing, but only taking it two or three times a week.
- 34:39[SPEAKER_01]: That consistent person is always going to, like their benefits are always going to outweigh the person who takes it, maybe at the perfect time, two or three times a week.
- 34:49[SPEAKER_00]: right.
- 34:49[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
- 34:51[SPEAKER_00]: Yes.
- 34:52[SPEAKER_00]: And we kind of mentioned that this is really creating supplement is really good for people doing like those string training or kind of that quick motion thing.
- 35:03[SPEAKER_00]: So it's most useful for that repeated high intensity efforts.
- 35:08[SPEAKER_00]: evidence suggests that it has a little bit less of a benefit for things like distance running or cycling or swimming where the primary energy demand is sustained aerobic work.
- 35:19[SPEAKER_00]: It's not really utilizing those muscles like like we do with strength training for example.
- 35:24[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, and more so impacts your like anaerobic system versus your aerobic or endurance system if you look up.
- 35:31[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, so I would just say it's probably still okay.
- 35:35[SPEAKER_00]: It's just you're not going to get like that crazy muscle growth like if you're training, um, while you're taking it.
- 35:42[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, agreed.
- 35:45[SPEAKER_01]: I don't have like a ton more to add.
- 35:48[SPEAKER_01]: I do kind of the only last thing that I kind of want to mention.
- 35:53[SPEAKER_01]: And I don't know if you have more so feel free to add in.
- 35:55[SPEAKER_01]: But there is like some emerging research on creatine, of course, we talked about like in concussions and kind of like mild traumatic brain injuries.
- 36:03[SPEAKER_01]: But also with neurodegenerative diseases like things like Alzheimer's and Parkinson's which is really fascinating I'm not going to go into like too much detail here I just know that the Like research is kind of emerging in this area And I think it's really interesting and fascinating and A lot of people are saying that a key factor in several of those like
- 36:27[SPEAKER_01]: neurological diseases is a reduction of phosphocreatin in the brain, so they're like wondering and now researching and kind of experimenting with supplementing in cases like this.
- 36:41[SPEAKER_01]: And so they're kind of thinking since like creatine can increase these levels, it might help reduce or slow the disease progression, which I think is kind of
- 36:51[SPEAKER_01]: Um, like I said, very interesting, but it's really like the like, like, like, on the brink of new research and I don't work with those populations.
- 37:08[SPEAKER_01]: very much so I don't have really a lot of like first-hand experience in that area.
- 37:12[SPEAKER_01]: So I can't really like speak to that from a putting it into practice perspective.
- 37:18[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, but I do think it's very interesting and would love to know more and learn more.
- 37:25[SPEAKER_01]: about those things.
- 37:26[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I definitely think it would be interesting for sure.
- 37:29[SPEAKER_00]: And kind of on that note, I this is just like a personal thought, like if there's not really much backing this, but I was just thinking like there's probably people out there listening that are like, well, I'm not really working
- 37:47[SPEAKER_00]: very much right now, but like I, you know, maybe Alzheimer's runs in my family or I have something that is, you know, worrying me should I be taking it.
- 38:00[SPEAKER_00]: Anyways, um, and I, I just kind of wanted to speak out loud, but I think, again, some more research needs to be done, but based on kind of what we know, I also don't think it would be particularly harmful to supplement with it for the cognitive health piece.
- 38:21[SPEAKER_00]: I would be.
- 38:23[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, it just, again, like you need to be utilizing that muscle, right?
- 38:30[SPEAKER_00]: trying to do things to also work on your brain, which is also a piece of just like keeping your mind fresh.
- 38:35[SPEAKER_00]: Like people talk about doing, you know, word puzzles and the like reading and and just doing things that really exercise your brain in ways that we're not used to want a normal day-to-day basis.
- 38:48[SPEAKER_00]: And that in itself really helps with cognitive and
- 38:54[SPEAKER_00]: I guess just like preventing cognitive decline, but I think that is also really helpful if we were to start supplementing with creating for the cognitive benefits and obviously overall health needs need to be considered and I would always recommend.
- 39:10[SPEAKER_00]: still trying to get movement in somewhere.
- 39:12[SPEAKER_00]: So it could potentially be helpful.
- 39:14[SPEAKER_00]: As a reminder, especially as we age, muscle is so important for so many, so many different things within our health.
- 39:23[SPEAKER_00]: And so strength training is literally one of the number one things that I think the older population should be doing, like actually strength training.
- 39:32[SPEAKER_00]: And yeah, there's a lot of research
- 39:40[SPEAKER_00]: We, not only do we need to be lifting, we kind of need to be lifting heavy.
- 39:44[SPEAKER_00]: Like really heavy to get some of these great, great benefits.
- 39:48[SPEAKER_01]: I know.
- 39:49[SPEAKER_01]: And I hate the fact that I have basically let that slip.
- 39:53[SPEAKER_01]: Like I gosh, like I was so strong and in shape and college.
- 39:59[SPEAKER_01]: And I just like can't believe that now.
- 40:02[SPEAKER_01]: Which is the phase of life, I'm in, but it's a home dumbbell workout and I'm like, man, I used to throw so much weight on a bar on my back and wrap it out like it was nothing and now I'm like,
- 40:16[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know, anyways, whatever, but it's so important as we age for a bones to for a bone muscles for our brain, all of it.
- 40:25[SPEAKER_01]: I think it's really important.
- 40:27[SPEAKER_00]: So as we age like the whole shift, we go through.
- 40:30[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, because having lean mask can combat a lot of, um, I guess, like issues that arise with age.
- 40:39[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, in a bunch of different health conditions and
- 40:41[SPEAKER_01]: I'll just leave it at that because that's a whole other tangent and it's yeah.
- 40:45[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, and so that's kind of just like my thought I just want to bring that up because I think there will be people who listen who are just curious and they're like, well, I'm not really in the strength training program right now where I'm not in athlete doing X, Y and Z or I'm not training for this, but I am kind of worried about like my mental health long term and like my cognitive status long term.
- 41:08[SPEAKER_00]: and so I just wanted to add that into because I think that's a good question to be answered.
- 41:13[SPEAKER_00]: But obviously, we've kind of touched on this.
- 41:16[SPEAKER_00]: It's generally considered safe for healthy adults.
- 41:20[SPEAKER_00]: Talk to your doctor if you have any concerns or any special medical issues that or you're taking a plethora of medications and you're just not sure how this supplement ties in.
- 41:30[SPEAKER_00]: We aren't just going to say like blanket.
- 41:32[SPEAKER_00]: Everybody's start taking it.
- 41:33[SPEAKER_00]: We want you to be careful.
- 41:36[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I just wanted to kind of put that caveat in there.
- 41:41[SPEAKER_00]: And then I also just wanted to say that there are some people who do experience some GI or that gastrointestinal.
- 41:48[SPEAKER_00]: I wanted to say this stress, but just like discomfort with starting it.
- 41:52[SPEAKER_00]: And so if you, you know, are starting out at five grams per day, you might have to pull back a little bit or kind of ease into it.
- 41:59[SPEAKER_00]: But just know that that's not something.
- 42:02[SPEAKER_00]: if it happens to be like, uh, this isn't supposed to be happening.
- 42:06[SPEAKER_00]: It can happen.
- 42:08[SPEAKER_00]: And also I think with the water retention to again, we start to have like a little bit of that discomfort.
- 42:13[SPEAKER_00]: So just be aware that that's also something that we might feel along with it as we're getting started, but that should level off.
- 42:21[SPEAKER_00]: And you shouldn't typically have long-term GI discomfort from this supplement.
- 42:27[SPEAKER_00]: Yes.
- 42:28[SPEAKER_00]: But yeah, I think that's all I wanted to touch on.
- 42:32[SPEAKER_00]: I think just being able to share what the current recommendations are, kind of what other people are recommending, like going up to a certain amount.
- 42:42[SPEAKER_00]: As Brooke and I mentioned, we are still on that like 3 to 5.
- 42:46[SPEAKER_00]: I feel like 5 is an appropriate dosage.
- 42:50[SPEAKER_01]: 35 grams of creating one-oh hydrate taken at daily being consistent if you are wanting to start supplementing is going to be the safest and most effective option and I kind of want to start taking this myself and just going to see like what improvements I can potentially make.
- 43:11[SPEAKER_01]: So maybe we'll report back.
- 43:13[SPEAKER_01]: Maybe we'll start taking it too and we'll report
- 43:15[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, we're going to, we're going to be in a creating pact, which is just for taking it and see what happens.
- 43:21[SPEAKER_00]: But yeah, so anyways, if you have any questions about creating feel free to message us at wellbound podcast on Instagram, Facebook, but yeah, otherwise I think we'll catch you in the next one.
- 43:37[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, that's it.
- 43:38[SPEAKER_01]: Bye.
- 43:39[UNKNOWN]: Bye.