Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / Criticism isn't harassment
Transcript
- 0:02Check podcasts. If you're a public figure or someone who puts themselves out there
- 0:15on the Internet, you'll probably get negative feedback, disagreement, judgment, trolling,
- 0:21abusive comments, threats, or even worse. I've experienced it from people
- 0:26disagreeing with me, to hating the sound of my voice, to calling for
- 0:29me to lose my job, to labeling me a terrorist. I can accept
- 0:34the first three of those examples as criticism, even if I think they're unfair
- 0:38or unfounded, whatever, But I hope we can agree that the last one,
- 0:43being called a terrorist is harassment. Now, my experience is nowhere close
- 0:48to that of women, especially women of color, the queer and trans community,
- 0:52and other racialized and religious groups who get it way worse. Some folks
- 0:56are harassed for simply existing. But there's there's a difference between criticism and harassment.
- 1:03Criticism might be unfair, but harassment is always wrong. You see,
- 1:07Criticism can be incisive, silly, antagonistic, any of which can be unfair,
- 1:12but it's not dehumanizing or threatening, but all harassment, whether it's objectifying
- 1:18someone's physical appearance or health, using derogatory slurs or bigoted arguments, threatening or
- 1:23wishing physical harm on someone, invoking someone's family, accusing someone of crimes without
- 1:29any evidence. All forms of harassment are wrong. I call out politicians and
- 1:34people with power all the time for their hypocrisy, ignorance, inconsistent logic,
- 1:38and incompetence, and I get criticism along those same lines, even when I
- 1:42think it's unfair. That's part of being in the public sphere. The problem
- 1:48is when someone in trying to elicit sympathy or justify an unpopular opinion, conflates
- 1:52criticism with harassment. BC politicians like Jane Thornthwaite, Sanjiv Gandhi, and Selena
- 1:59Robinson fail heavy criticism and subsequent consequences for things they said and did, even
- 2:05if you think it was unfair, I don't see anything wrong with that.
- 2:08But those same politicians were also subject to abusive comments and threats, many forms
- 2:14of harassment, which is unequivocally wrong, as much as you and I may
- 2:17have agreed or even participated in the criticism against them. And if you cannot
- 2:23separate criticism from harassment, whether as an observer, participant, or target,
- 2:29then maybe the public discourse isn't for you.