Latest / Ego and Other Things / Faith and Philosophy
Transcript
- William: I don't have I don't have a lot of motivation to record today, but for the sake of the authentic exposure and just the consistency in practicing these recordings, I'm gonna be doing a video today on the next topic on my list, which is I labeled it as as faith versus reason. You might call it philosophy versus religion or faith versus philosophy. I think Faith versus philosophy is kind of how we're gonna frame it. Because As I'm sure plenty of you have noticed, I this is a channel that talks about philosophy. This is a channel that at least attempts to use reason to come to philosophical conclusions. And at the same time, I'm a Christian. I mean I wear this cross in most of my videos. I've got the cross there in the background. And Especially in my writings, I will I will reference God and and Christianity frequently enough that some of you might be wondering, how do I how do I reconcile these two? Or how do I view the relationship between reason and faith, or Christianity and philosophy? And I guess today I just want to try to do my best to to explain how I kind of view the relationship and how they either work together or conflict with one another. to be Christian, I mean to be c to be clear, when I say that that I'm a Christian, it means that my faith, I believe in the divinity of Jesus Christ, that he came to earth, lived the perfectly righteous life, was crucified in place of us sinners as a substitution for our sins, that he died and was buried and was raised from the dead three days later by God the Father and now sits at the right hand of God in heaven. And these are all things which I believe on the basis of faith. I also believe that the Holy Bible is the perfect inerrant word of God, is exclusive communication to us. Or I guess you could say the principal way that he communicates through us, because he also communicates to us through natural revelation and the Holy Spirit. And I pray to Jesus, I go to church, I try to live my my life as far as I can with the with in accordance with the commands of the Bible. And My primary vision of the world is a biblical vision. And I've touched on this before in another video, but The place that I fe that I see philosophy taking in the world is primarily one of Pointing. pointing us towards our need for Jesus, for his sacrifice in our place. By. Showing how lost, how fallen, how evil, and how corrupt we and the world around us is, and showing us that by our own strength, we are unable to in the end overcome either evil or death. That philosophy shows us our impotence at the end of the day and is At the same time, unable to overcome that impotence. Rather Reveals to us the despair of the world, which then prepares us to receive Jesus as our Lord and Savior. And I wasn't always a Christian, for much of my life until a few years ago I was I was a a strong atheist. I believed that not only did God not exist, but that he couldn't exist. He was equivalent to a square circle, that the stories of the Bible were essentially made up, or even if they were genuine, they were reflections of sort of psychological tensions. Or power games or attempts at manipulation. In particular, I sort of followed Feuerbach in thinking that the Bible often w represented examples where human beings had taken their own properties or their own struggles or their own incentives or their own value hierarchies and ascribed them to God in a semi-conscious way in order to sort of rev resolve internal conflicts. And it was it was only a couple of years ago that God revealed himself in a way to me, Jesus revealed himself in a way to me that I couldn't turn away from or couldn't deny. And I put my fa my I put my faith in Jesus and have been following that path ever since then. And yet I still consider myself f somebody who is interested in philosophy, right? Somebody who I still study philosophy, I still write about philosophy, many of the philosophical ideas. that I came to before Faith in Jesus remained with me in practically the same forms. And so how have I reconciled these kinds of things? because I can tell you that before I Christian, I th thoroughly agreed with with Kierkegaard's position on faith. Kierkegaard had thought that the accusation that faith was irrational was inaccurate. But not accurate because faith was rational, but inaccurate because the description irrational did not go go far enough. to describe what what reason was. But rather reason was was a rational. It was the complete opposite of reason. That For one to have actual faith, one needed to purposefully Suspend their reason and take a the leap of faith towards God. One had to come to the to the necessary recognition that. Reason was not enough for life. Reason was not enough for what it was trying to do. And sort of to take to suspend reason in favor of God. And as an atheist, I was in complete agreement, except that I wasn't recommending the leap of faith, right? I was saying that yes, actually faith is entirely arational. It is the enemy of reason, is the opposite of reason. Insofar as one wishes to be rational, one cannot have faith. And the degree to which one has faith is the degree to which they've suspended reason. And as a Christian, I still hold to that line. I still hold to the line that the g these two are at odds with each other. And that they are not Fundamentally compatible. There's a sense in which reason can be integrated into faith once faith has been established, but incompatible in the sense that reason can never lead you to faith. And faith, insofar as it is faith, is always arational See, reason comes out of an epistemological position. at least in my own philosophy, d loosely described, reason is the the catchphrase for the Validity of the sense data combined with the categories of a logic that come from the principle of identity. And essentially and and these combine with the the principle of causality, that things are are causally related. And the principle of causality and the principle of identity are themselves both related to we might say metaphysical, a metaphysical understanding of the world. That I don't know how pertinent it is to get into that right now, but the point is to say that the methods of knowledge that I consider to be reason are themselves an outgrowth of metaphysical principles, right? An understanding of the categories of being or the categories of existence that cannot be violated without. violating those categories. Basically we say, you know, here are the categories of what is possible and what is inescapable for human beings and human existence. And from those inescapable categories, because of their the the nature of their inescapability, we're able to derive universal principles of knowledge, like like the principle identity, like the principle of causality. And these principles then get developed further into the scientific method and the discipline of logic. and also the discipline of phenomenology. And essentially the rest of my philosophy is an outgrowth of those three kinds of methods, making due Room for the insufficiency of language and certain empirical empirically and certain empirically observation certain observ modes of observ certain modes of observation that suggest that the human mind is is mistaken in some way or limited in some ways. So far this this this video is really a test of the authentic exposure because I'm I'm kinda all over the place. But that's fine. This is exactly what we want, right? I want to show the kind of floundering and the struggle to to to articulate what what it is I'm talking about. But essentially, you know, what I understand reason to be is what most people would understand reason to be. the use of of the senses. in order to experience the world around us combined with the categories of logic. and you can consider that the sense experience to both be internal and external, combine that with the categories of logic, that's reason, right? And that comes out in the discipline of logic and the scientific method, which is the essential bedrock of of all of what we consider to be modern day understanding of knowledge. And there's a certain layer in there of Of functional knowledge. So one might, for instance, know how to drive a car, but not know how to fix a car. And so one knows about the car in a functional way rather than sort of an analytic way. So there's different forms of this kind of knowledge depending on like how deep you're going and whatnot, right? All kinds of variations. But s but essentially the process of empirical sense data. combined with the categories of logic produce knowledge and it is the the stratagems of sense experience and logic that constitute reason. So reason doesn't in this understanding of reason doesn't extend to the use of feelings or emotions or intuitions or or just random thoughts or mass appeal or institutions or history, even though it might use all these as analyzable context or content, it does not these do not in and of themselves constitute reason. Rather, reason is a kind of methodology derived from metaphysical principles that allow you to explore the world around you in a categorical kind of way. And then reason applied to philosophy is you know, reason geared towards the assumptionlessness. Whereas reason in the sci in sciences is reason applied to the scientific method or extended through the scientific method, whereas in philosophy it is extended t towards assumptionlessness or total justification. And I would say a rational person is the person who's always sort of willing to examine the the underlying premises of any any any given notions. And most probably most importantly of all, the the rational person is the person willing to test their premises and ideas against counterfactuals, against arguments or information that come up to suggest that the premise is false. But a person who is operating on the basis of faith is at at one level or at some fundamental level refusing to let go of a belief based on counterfactuals or new information or what have you. And this is the faith that I that I hold towards Christianity and towards Jesus, towards the perfection of the word. I believe in those things regardless of the evidence brought against them. I believe in those things regardless of counterfactuals. I believe in a given, you know, set of of understandings here, regardless of whether I can I can't succeed in arguing for it rationally. And this is sort of what I mean by the fundamental by the fundamental conflict between reason and faith. you will never reason me out of my belief in in Jesus or in God or in the perfection of the word. And not only that, but I would say to you that by reason you will never get to belief in God and Jesus. In in a broad way, because God and Jesus are things which transcend what we have the ability to rationally analyze. And so that's one category, that's maybe the philosophical way of presenting that. The second way of presenting that is saying that according to the word itself, the only way that you actually receive no true knowledge about God is a according to what he reveals to you, according to what he sets in motion in your heart, so that you know you can reason you can reason towards towards faith in these kinds of things as much as much as you want to, but unless God has decided to give you the the grace of revelation, you simply won't arrive there either in either intellectually or or or you might say emotionally or spiritually, you'll never arrive to the conviction. You'll never arrive to the con to conviction of faith through reason. And then lastly, y there's just the the fact that by the standards of reason we wouldn't believe anything that the Bible teaches. We wouldn't believe in the existence of God because God is something that implies consciousness before existence, but existence must always precede consciousness. it can't existence or consciousness can't can neither be can neither precede existence nor be simultaneous to it and still be considered consciousness because consciousness is always some about something, but God is both. The conscious, omnipotent, all powerful creator and the creator of all existence. And so, by definition, God, from a rational standard, is a square circle. So, by rational standards, you wouldn't even get to the conception of God without it being contradictory in and of itself. And you can kind of see this rational failure in the history of the church fathers attempting to philosophically prove the existence of God rather than just relying on on revelation. But even just even if if God was not a square circle by rational standards, then we wouldn't believe in God based on the lack of evidence, right? Based on the fact that there seem to be better explanations, sort of like extensions of Occam's razor here, better explanations of the phenomena that are often relate related to Christianity or to God, then what is taught in the Bible and That while even if we couldn't disprove the concept of God, it would be more rational to accept alternative explanations to God than it would be to accept God as a standard. And so I think again from a rational point of view. Or from the rationalist standard, you it's really impossi I mean you can play a game where you where you try by rational standards to get as close to the concept of Christ as possible, but the truth is that the content of Christianity is fundamentally irrational. I mean, we're talking about things like miracles and people coming back from the dead and being healed instantly by the by the power of God. We're talking about an inherent contradiction. as the basis of creation. There is no rational standard by which you can arrive at the existence of God. And by the words themselves, God is not not looking for you to to to reason to him, but to have faith in him. And Insofar as you have reasoned yourself to a belief in God, I believe that if you examine that further, your reasons for belief will will inevitably come up short. They'll they'll fail the test of reason. And that's really the whole vulnerability of reason when it comes to faith, when it comes to the belief in these things. because if your belief is dependent on your on your reason, then it's changeable. It's it it's as changeable as new information comes about, right? So a good scientist, even if they have a theory that that seems to to answer most of the evidence and and and make a coherent story out of it, when counter evidence comes along. They are open to the counter evidence. And if it prove and it i if the counter evidence seems to to be more compelling than the already established theory, then they roll with the new compelling evidence. But a person and and by a rational standard, if you arrived at God, you would kind of have to ha constantly be open to the counterfactuals and to changing your mind about your belief in God. And your belief in God would change as frequently and as fluidly as as new information came up to to change it. But but true faith is unending. True faith is a gift given to you by the grace of God that you have that persists regardless of any supposed counter counterarguments, counterfactuals, rational standards, what have you. Your belief persists even when it makes no sense for it to persist. And that's faith. faith is a rational, it is entirely opposed to. To reason and to the standards of reason. It's opposed to the standards of logic and the standards of empiricism. And so it doesn't matter how how much the scientist or the philosopher argues against the particular premises of faith that have been revealed to somebody who has faith. The person continues to have faith regardless. Now it doesn't I wouldn't say that that means that once you come to faith in God or in Jesus or in in the perfection of the word, that therefore reason goes out the window. But Insofar as you're talking about religious matters, insofar as you're talking about like a a book like the Bible and you're discussing it, it's and ends up reason ends up being related to a matter of coherence within the given premises of the word, or in the sort of interpretations of the word. So one of my one of my favorite phrases is that you know that we are imperfect people trying to understand and interpret a perfect word. And so, even though this is the perfect word of God. there are, of course, you know, countless denominations, there are countless versions of this kind of faith. And this is I would say this is in relationship to exactly what the word says, which is that we are broken, sinful human beings. Every part of us, every aspect of our being is in one sense incomplete or broken or incomplete. has, you know, the seed of evil, the seed of sin within it, that bleeds out into how we how we understand things or interpret them, including God's own word. And this leads to the the broken unity in the church. This leads to all different kinds of of and again, interpretations that break out in different schools. And Not only that, but the the misuse and and and abuse of the word for the sake of individuals' agendas, right? Individuals who are you know, they want power, they want control, these kinds of things. Or they want to justify their abuse. But again, to me that that sort of reflects the truth of the word where it it tells us that, you know, everybody that nobody is righteous, not even one, that we're all sinners, we're all broken and we're trying to understand a perfect word. But we understand it in a broken way. And that brokenness again reveals to us our dependence on Jesus in order to save us. And it it sharpens our dependence on the Holy Spirit to give us, to lead us into the truth of all things, right? And it leads us into the need for prayer to be able to say, Lord, I I read a word, but I don't understand it, or it seems that my understanding is out of concordance with the church or what have you, and to pray for the the intervention of the Holy Spirit and depend on. on God's grace or really depend and accept on what God gives to you and what trials he puts you through and or what trials he allows you to go through at any rate. And to do your best to to speak the truth as far as you've understand it about about his word, but recognizing that, you know, you're a human being with flawed with a flawed heart, right? And with a flawed mind. And that you know, you should never really you should never mistake your own interpretation with Jesus and you should never mistake the church with Jesus. And you should constantly be trying to to to read and to understand what is written in the word and express that with the fellow believers. Inor, you know, they say sharpen iron sharpens iron in the in the church. And yeah, that comes in part by the communication that we have the open communication that we have about you know the varying beliefs as it as it regards the Holy Bible. But What unites us is the divinity of Jesus, his sacrifice for us on the cross, the fact that he was buried and resurrected by God, the fact that he'll come again one day in order to to save us. And all of those kinds of premises, all those things which you know are what would make you a Christian, are articles of faith. They're not are they're not articles of reason. I mean. just being bl bling blunt about it. There there's a whole tradition of Christianity that that tries to justify faith by the standards of reason, because they are trying to appeal to the world that is in one sense addicted to reason, in one sense, in one sense, a a world which needs to depend on reason because it doesn't have faith and because it hasn't been given faith by the grace of God. And so it needs grace in order to navigate or it needs reason in order to navigate the world. But of course reason is a broken tool. And so it doesn't really it doesn't end up really solving evil or death. only Jesus can solve evil and death. only Jesus can can restore us and make us complete and give us the full truth and understanding of the world. Not unfortunately, not reason. but reason itself is a gift from from God. It's been corrupted by sin and brokenness, but it is a gift from God that allows us to to navigate the world at least in a partial way. And it is it is the the tool or it is the best tool, you could say. It is the best tool that philosophy has to understand the world. and philosophy through reason is the best tool that that people have to understand rationally themselves and the world. And that use of philosophy, that use of reason will necessarily lead you into incomplete places. but it's kind of the best that that human beings have outside of faith. It's sort of like Sort of like if you have a I don't know, a giant giant gash in your stomach, you know, using some tissues, I guess, to to plug up the hole and to to slow the bleeding while you wait for the surgeon, that might be the best tool that you have. and you know, reason is kinda like the bunch of tissues, right? But the surgeon, the one who can actually heal you and fix you and restore you, I mean that's faith. That's that's really that's not even faith, it's Jesus. 'Cause your faith, your faith will ultim ultimately your faith will lead you to Jesus, if that makes sense. But Jesus is the one that actually does the work of restoration. He's the surgeon. Reason is the tissues that you stuff in the gash because you've got nothing else, right? And it's better than like ripping open your stomach or something like that, but it's really the best that you have. And again, like again, what I would really emphasize is that you know you can't reason yourself to faith. If if you you either have faith or you don't, I mean you can ask for faith, you can cry out to God. And it is true that if you ask God to reveal himself to you, if you ask Jesus to reveal himself to you in a genuine way, not in a sort of mocking way, not in a sort of like but in a really in a genuine way. If you ask God Jesus to reveal himself to you in a genuine way, he will, because God wants to see all of his children restored. But, you know, God ultimately gives people up to what they want within their hearts. And there are plenty of people out there who don't want relationship with God for one reason or another. And so he doesn't reveal himself to them. in the same way, but by the powers of reason you'll never get to faith in God. And by the power of reason you'll never ultimately overcome death or evil in the world. Reason doesn't have the power to do that. It it barely has the power to understand evil. It barely has the power to understand death, let alone overcome it. And and death and evil are the are the two things which which are man's greatest enemies. I mean man has come to a point where ever since really ever since the the ascendancy of reason and the rise of of more atheism mankind has has given up on on true immortal immortality. mankind has given up on getting to a place of that is free. from from evil and suffering and death. We many of the many of the modern strategies for around those areas are kind of just like, well, you kinda just have to deal with it, right? You kinda just have to deal with with suffering and death and evil. And here are some strategies to make it less awful, maybe, if you have some control in it, but you're just gonna suffer and die and be a victim of evil and commit evil yourself. And you can't avoid that, right? So they rationally admit many of the premises of of the word that the world is evil, that you're going to die, that you're going to suffer, that you yourself are are evil, and that's going to to come out in in you, that you are are broken and limited. but it gives you all the problems of the world, it gives you all the Problems of brokenness, and then doesn't give you a way to overcome it, right? It kind of just leaves you with the suffering and says, Well, maybe you can mitigate it here or there, maybe you it can extend your life here or there, but you'll never overcome death, and you'll never overcome suffering, and you'll never overcome evil, whether that's the evil in yourself or the evil in other people. And I mean it's it it is a really callous and brutal kind of perspective that oftentimes you kinda people just blank out of their heads. They don't they don't think too deeply about it. But I remember that perspective as as an atheist myself and sort of coming to the realization of the brokenness of reason and and and its inability to really solve our problems. Its inability to actually save us from ourselves and Again, the only solution to actually saving yourself is is through Jesus. Reason won't get you there. so I guess in summary, that's the way that I kind of view this relationship between faith and and philosophy. I know that the ultimate answer is Jesus. I know that the ultimate overcoming of death and evil in the world is Jesus. I know that my relationship with God is the most important relationship that I have. I know that the Word, the Holy Bible, is the perfect guide, the the perfect explanation. Really, the whole Bible is about pointing you to Jesus. So the reason why it's the perfect word is because it always points you to Jesus. But that I know that the word is the ultimate truth. regardless of what my my philosophical speculation leads me into. And philosoph philosophical speculation in my life is completely constrained to the realm of reason. doesn't really extend to the biblical understanding. there is, I mean I have some controversial biblical understandings that I might get into in a different different kind of video, but My philosophical investigations, as far as they extend, extend as far as reason can extend, which is ultimately not very far in comparison to the Bible, in comparison to to Jesus. But mostly it it it points mostly I think that the use of philosophy is in pointing out what is limited and broken about the world, what is evil and and sinful in the world, what is the limitations of of us, right? It is philosophy this is the way I put it. Philosophy is capable of identifying Philosophy is capable of identifying the disease, but it's not really capable of giving you the cure, let alone administering that cure to you. The best philosophy can do is to point out the disease, point out what's wrong with the world, and then Provide some strategies for mitigating it, for you know, smoothing out the rough edges, right? in a in a very temporary way. And the that can be a lot, right? That that that's philosophy is more helpful than no philosophy at all. But it is not the answer, it's not the solution, it's not the ultimate overcoming of of evil and death, which are act the actual problems. evil and death and suffering. It can't overcome that. And so while you would rather if you're gonna if you're an atheist and atheist and you don't have faith, you would rather have philosophy than not. But But philosophy is is an incredibly poor tool, you might say. well it's a completely insufficient tool to actually overcoming evil and death. it's a completely insufficient tool to actually saving you compared to to Jesus. And so my philosophy is is very much centered around just showing you what's wrong with the world and how it's become broken, what life is maybe supposed to be like, as far as we can understand it rationally, and some strategies for you know how we might progress that way and and smooth smooth out the rough edges in the context of death, in the context of suffering, in the context of evil, and in the context of our own. limited capacity or our own internal evil. but it's not it's not capable of solving any of these things, right? philosophy is not capable of solving the problems that it raises, ultimately. It can only give you these kind of partial, insufficient insufficient answers, right? Like I said, it can identify the disease, but it can't give you the cure. And so faith is the path to the to the cure. Reason is the path to identifying the disease, but you can never get from reason to faith. You can never get from philosophy to faith. every movement from one to the other is always a suspension of philosophy and a suspension of reason in favor to what has been gracious graciously revealed to you by God. So well I was able to do the recording so I feel kinda good about that. I'm not sure how great the quality was there. I'm kinda getting I'm trying to get into that. spontaneous, just authentically leaving it all out there, leaving the the struggle of explanation out there and Well, I I I definitely hope to get better over time. So but anyway, if you like this video, please give it a like. If you think that that somebody else would get some benefit out of it, then please share it with you with them. If you have any thoughts at all about what I talked about today, then please leave it in the comments. I would love to be able to talk with you guys more about you know faith and reason. And if you would like to see more videos like this, then please subscribe. And as always, I'll talk to you guys next time.