Latest / Ego and Other Things / Jung: the Good and the Bad
Transcript
- William: This morning I'm trying out the the chest mount here. I'm hoping this will be a little bit more entertaining than just the the words on the screen as I do my morning walk. But it's definitely gonna be something that I'm gonna have to get used to. but yeah, hopefully the scenery will be a little bit better than just the the black screen with the captions, but I suppose we'll see. Now I have a sort of backup topic in mind about why people seek after meaning in their suffering, which is a topic I've talked about before, but I might be able to take a new angle at it. But before I go into that, I had these half-formed thoughts in my mind about Jung. I've been In an effort to clear out my my audiobook library, I've been going through The backlog and I've sort of organized things by the shortest length, I suppose, so the longest length. And a very i a very short introduction of Jung like part of that book series there, was on there and I thought that well I might listen to it. So I've been listening to it and I haven't really Ben meshed or been I haven't thought about Jung in a long time, I guess is the way to put it. And being reminded of him and in his psychology has been interesting because I feel as though I mean anybody who has any sort of psychological or even philosophical or even spiritual interests, I think at some point usually comes across Jung just because he was so influential in all these kinds of areas. I mean he tied them together. He tied psychology and speculation and mythology together in his writings and in his theorizing. that even if you don't agree with him, even if you think he kinda went off his rocker. You kinda have to admit that pretty interesting ideas. Pretty interesting ideas. And I don't have any clear formulated thoughts about it right now. And that's kind of why I wanna take this opportunity to go over what I've been reminded of, I guess, the good and the bad when it comes to to Jung's ideas and where they might go. Now, I've always had an ambivalent relationship or feeling towards Freud. Because, of course, on the one hand, Freud, father of the unconscious, right? Or at least the one who has who popularized the the notion of the unconscious and popularized the therapeutic model. And was probably the first person to ever really take mental issues seriously up until that point and not only take them seriously but try to study them in a scientific way and propose a way to actually help people who are suffering from that. A pioneer obviously in that kind of way. And you really can't talk Freud is sort of like Kant, right? You can't really talk about the mind without talking about Freud, without borrowing his language from one degree or another. And of course Jung is no up exception to this being a student of Freud's and being a partner of Freud's later on. So on the one hand, you have to admire Freud and what he did in just, in essence, creating the field of psychology at all to begin with. But on the other hand, in my own view, Freud really set back the entire profession of psychology really from the start. And what I mean by this is that he You know, in essence. He had the central problem in his hands when He wrote his work on hysteria at the beginning of his career and talked about how it was likely that these cases of of hysteria were actually linked to early childhood trauma. That Came from the parents. Oftentimes many of the hysterical patients that came in would report to him and tell him very plainly and openly that their fathers or their brothers or their uncles or somebody around them had sexually abuse them in some way. They're actually pretty direct about saying I was sexually abused as a child. I have been unable to talk about or express out to anybody. I've had to keep it inside. And that's why I think I'm having these hysterical symptoms. And again, you can read about this in Freud's own book that he wrote with Bauer, I believe it was, Studies on Hysteria. One is one of his very early books. And this really disturbed Freud when he was writing that book because he s he the way he he the way he talked about it is that he could not believe that this amount of sexual abuse and exploitation was going on among the most powerful and respected and influential class of people of his time. And I mean this is at least that's what he said as to his reason rejecting The sexual abuse as the root of hysteria. And of course later on he went on to develop the the sexual theory of Neuroses and which he reinterpreted these his patients complaints that they had been sexually abused into a theory of sexual neuroses where these women he was saying the these women actually what they wanted was an incestuous relationship with their their father and brothers and uncles and whatnot. And that this had created a fantasy that they in their minds that they sort of made up their own sexual abuse as out of a desire out of out of a desi a desire for it. And Freud thought this was more plausible than the idea that all of these men were really sexually exploiting all of these women in this kind of categorical way. And I again that was Freud's explanation for it. I think it's more likely that the people I it's more likely. that the people that he was treating, his business, so to speak. I mean it was all paid by these rich people who had all of this influence and wealth and And could have destroyed Freud's career, if Freud came out and said, actually, the reason why these women are suffering is because the you know, all the men around them are sexually abusing them. It would have caused a massive scandal in his time to have come out and just said forthrightly that you know the cause of this all of all this hysteria is the fact that these women have been sexually abused, you know, by their own family members. And so instead of standing up and saying the truth of that, Freud essentially made up some nonsense about the Oedipus complex. And that's so frustr frustrating because of course the seeds of that book, The Studies on Hysteria, were the seeds of what we call today the trauma model of of neuroses, or the trauma model of mental illness, in which Mental illness is ascribed in large part to experiences that we have which are traumatic that are repressed and unprocessed and unacknowledged in particular, either by oneself or the people around you. And most of this kind of traumatic, most of these kinds of traumatic events happen in childhood, where the the person is the most vulnerable to traumatic events because they depend so much on the people around them for love and care. But this can happen, you can have veterans who you know suffer PTSD, or as we've seen recently in the news, mothers who suffer postpartum traumatic experiences. And when those traumatic experiences happen and the person is unable to express and understand and work through and communicate and have their trauma taken seriously by the people around them, this can often lead to repression and depression. And depending on The sort of genetic, you might the sort of genetic predispositions they have to processing trauma can make this more or less difficult and more or less destructive if this becomes repressed. The trauma model of neuroses is not the only contributing factor to mental health, but it is, I would say, the significant driving factor. But because Freud repressed this, because he was afraid of the scandal that it would cause in his time, he was afraid that his own repu reputation would be destroyed. He repressed this and the father of psychology. posited the father of the unconscious, posited the sexual model of neuroses, which kept psychology back for almost a century. I mean it really wasn't until people like Alice Miller that the trauma model of neuroses was much better recognized And much better developed. You had seeds of it, you had seeds of it in the in the early period, but it wasn't really until Alice Miller that that started to turn around. And Freud's students, they all missed this too, including Jung. I mean Adler went on to talk about how to to essentially take a sociological view of neuroses and say that neuroses come about because a person lacks good strong social relations with other people or because the society itself is neurotic, which was of course partially the case. And Jung took the I mean he probably perhaps would would have said the the introverted route of neuroses and said, actually neuroses comes about because we fail to to deal developmentally with whatever stage of life that we're going through. And we haven't properly individuated, we haven't properly navigated the the golden mean, you might say, between introversion and extroversion. We haven't allowed our psychic events to come to the fore and forthrightly examine them and search them for meaning, much like we would a storybook or anything else. And Jung's criticism of Freud was that Freud was too reductionist, that everything came down to Freud's sexual model of neuroses, and Jung argued, and Adler would argue as well in a different direction, that there was much more, there was much more involved, and that it shouldn't be so reductionist, and that we can't pin down every dream and every problem to sexual neuroses. And Jung in in in particular took this to that ideal of individuation. The ideal of coming into contact with who you really were, coming into contact with your whole self, not just the good parts, but as Jung would say, the shadow, the anima and the animus, the female and male parts within oneself, regardless of gender. Essentially coming in contact with all the different parts of oneself that Are there and dealing with them in an open and conscious way and attempting to integrate them into the rest of the personality. In one sense, taking all the different parts of oneself and negotiating into a whole self as far as you can over time. This is that process of individuation. And then taking that individuated self and also trying to integrate it or or you might say reconcile it with one's society. Of course both Freud and Jung were interested in this reconciliation with society, this reconciliation with okay, what how do I need to interact? How do I need to relate myself to the world around me, to the society around me, so that that society doesn't collapse. Freud would have said that, you know, if you allow your your id, so to speak, just to to take take control and if everybody just acted on their id all the time, then this would necessarily create chaos within the society. And Jung would have said something similar, that if we ignore the needs of society, this represents some integr unintegrated part of ourself that we haven't we haven't in one sense individuated. And of course Adler would have said that society does not give the individual what it needs in order to actually be psychically whole. Of course you can almost immediately see the problem with especially y well, Jung and Freud's interpretation of this, which is that they project a kind of ideal, right? I mean they they look, they presuppose, or at least Jung presupposes, that every part of the self has some value to it that needs to be recognized and integrated. And the question is what part judges the value, right? Where is the where is the value hierarchy within that actually judges whether or not this aspect of this part here is of value or of or not. So there's a bit of a confusion there. That whole idea of individuation and reconciliation with society presupposes that the reconcil reconciliation with society is at some level desirable. Which is not always the case. I wouldn't even say not majorly the case. At the very least one has to look at society and wonder or evaluate what is of value to this and what is not. What is of value to reconcile myself to? What do I value in relationship to society and what do I not? And make that individual judgment and decide to what degree or in what way that they're going to reconcile themselves. It's not a a priori it's not an a priori understanding that s society in some way is necessarily valuable. And that really gets to the heart of I think one of the major weaknesses with Jung. I mean w pause for a moment to say one of the major one one of the thing one of the things that I I prize highly when it comes to Jung's psychological insight, as against Freud, is that Jung was willing to look. Jung was willing to look at the whole self and refuse to ignore the investigation of parts of the Self just because they were uncomfortable to explore. And wasn't willing to reduce all of the whole of the Self to one one value constraint of of of the Oedipus complex. He wasn't willing to be so reductive when it came to the complexity of the mind and the unconscious, different parts of oneself that you find there. He started off by saying, let's investigate everything. Let's let the let's let us let the mind speak for itself. Let us allow and take seriously people who are experiencing some sort of mental problem or neuroses to express themselves and to take seriously what they're saying in their own language, right? We don't necessarily always have to have this skepticism, right? We don't always have to presume what's going on for the patient. And that kind of open minded inquiry, that sense in which We must be willing to confront the whole self. The whole self. That is what I would call part of, or yeah, part of this authentic instinct. The sense in which, okay, I'm willing to go investigate the phenomena of my mind and the phenomena of the minds of other people. and what they express to me. I'm willing to take what they say at face value and take that seriously, not necessarily to invest to end my investigation or more questioning there, but to take what they're saying to me seriously. And explore all parts of myself. I think that that desire to explore all parts of oneself and not simply decide things a priori, that openness, you might say, to the whole self, was a crucial, crucial step forward in psychology that Jung himself developed. That part of the individuation process that has to do with self-awareness, right? True self-awareness, open-ended self-awareness. But where does Jung stray? Jung strays in that he has no center of evaluation. He has no standard by which to judge. the value or the non-value of the expression of a part. The expression of a part. There is a sense in which Jung values a priori, every part that comes to the surface, and tries to integrate their needs and desires and values into the rest of the psyche. There's a degree to which Jung judges the a priori value of society and tries to integrate it into how we orient ourselves, how we orient our psyche in the world. And the question becomes: by what standard does Jung use to say that every part has a value? And does not this part which judges all parts to have some kind of a priori value, is not not a a part which itself is not being necessarily explored or critically examined. And I think there's this tendency in Jungian psychology that trends towards the the an assertion of the multiplicity of the self. You get into this language of these different aspects. The anima, the animus, the self, the the persona, the mask. The true self, all this kind of stuff. And there's this, I think, risk to break up the self into a million little pieces. And you kind of see the extreme of this in something like internal family systems, where every mood and every state and every emotion it it becomes its own distinct part. And there's no end to the number of parts that one has. And you end up to be able to explore the psyche, you have to, you know, write this list of characters that you have going on in your head. There's nothing which unifies them. But the self is not the self isn't this way, it's not even the way that we experience it. there has to be a unifying factor to everything. It's like the body. We might be able to identify this or that part of the body and say it does, it produces this or that faction, but my in my pinky does not have its own identity. in the sense that my pinky does not have an identity that that rests outside of me. Or I am the I am the primary of its of its function. I'm the primary of its identity. And in the same way, the different psychic parts, while being valid in their own right, are not, in my view, distinct personalities which exist within you. like a a different spirit or a different mind or something like that. Because of course, that again invites this inf infinite regress. I mean if the part of you, my persona, for example, is its own psychic energy or own psychic identity that rests within my mind, then does it not also have parts which themselves represent distinct identities or whatnot? And so you have to have more of a clinical perspective when it comes to the psyche of saying in a sense identifying the parts of the psyche in the way that you would identify the parts of the body. As this serves this function but relates back to this central value framework. And that's why you have something like in my my conception you would have the total self which is the totality of who you are, not just in the moment, but stretching back and stretching forward. And you have parts of yourself that sit in value potential, meaning that Not that every every part that comes up in your mind, or every aspect of the psyche, has a kind of inherent value to it, but it may have an inter a potential value depending on circumstances. And this is really part of Jung's case that every part had value, was that every part had come out of this collective evolution of the human race, and that we were sort of born. I mean he almost took this straight out Kant, but we were sort of born with a psyche that was able to adapt to whatever situation that we found ourselves in, and so enable or disable different parts of ourselves in relationship to our environment and relationship to our or whatever we were trying to achieve. Whatever, I guess in Jung's terminology, whatever stage of development. We had gotten to. And And in that way, I i I suppose you look at these parts and saying maybe they're p of potential value. Because there might be, I mean you could conceivably come up with a circumstance in which, you know, this this part that wants to, I guess, brutalize somebody might be of value in some circumstance. Though even so, you might have you might have a hard, a hard set, right? Like there might be a psychotic and a manipulative part within yourself that In certain survival situations, very very small number of social survival situations, for instance being put in a prison camp where you're going to die, and the only way you can get out is by manipulating, perversely manipulating the the the guards or something like that, right? And you might come up with a situation in which that was necessary, but not necessarily not necessarily a situation in which it was good. And so perhaps all the parts sit within a potential value aspect, but even that I would I would push against that because I think there are just certain aspects of human nature which, I mean, are never good. I don't know if I can mention them on YouTube without getting demonetized, but I'm sure you could think of some. The the Chris Hansen types, right? But The point is to say so you can't I pri I a priori say that this is of value, this part of me is of value innately. You have to, at the very least, refrain from judgment until the situation arises. And in fact, I think you can make some judgments in which you recognize that this part in and of itself is not of value. So the process of individuation and the way that Jung conceived it in terms of actually embodying and integrating all aspects of oneself is not, I think, psychologically healthy. because there are plenty of parts of yourself which are not good. It's not being reconciled to who you are. It's about understanding Who you really are, meaning who you want to be, in some sense. And utilizing the different parts of yourself, being open and conscious to the different parts of yourself, which is very important. I mean, there's no use in denying the reality of some part of yourself. You should confront the shadow, using Jung's terminology here, confront the shadow and be honest with yourself about here, this is a shadow part of myself. But integrate it, I don't know about that. That's where you have to make an evaluative judgment. And But he was certainly right in the sense that, you know, the the the more that we are unwilling to look at our internal lives, the more that we are unwilling or unconscious about, unwilling to look at or are unconscious about who we really are, both the good and the bad, then the more dangerous we become. because we get that projection. We get that kind of hypocrisy. Now we get hi rejection. We get projection and hypocrisy regardless. But, you know, taking this from a Christian perspective, right? If you deny the sin, the Bible says if you deny the sin in yourself, then you're worse than a f you're worse than a fool. and so if you walk about this earth like many people do, thinking I'm a good person, and not recognizing that in fact you've you've done plenty of bad in your life. and then maybe you're maybe you're a a good person in relationship to other people, all of whom are sinful and have done wrong in their life. Sort of like if I was in a high security prison with a bunch of violent criminals, and I said to myself, well I wasn't as violent as the people around me, that wouldn't necessarily make me a good person. In the same way, comparing yourself to other people and saying, well, I'm not as bad as so-and-so does not necessarily make you a good person. But denying your own sin not only makes you more dangerous because now you are unconsciously, you're not aware of the sin that you're committing, either in your heart or objectively, and you're not even focused on looking for it, but also. you project that same kind of sin and evil on other people and treat them in ways that you would never treat yourself in the g in in the same kind of circumstances because you don't identify with it. Identification is the root of empathy. If I understand that you know the person who has committed evil against me is like me, right? That the evil is not just in this person out there, but it's in me that I have the potential to be like this person, if it wasn't for the grace of God, then that identification creates empathy. And empathy is what actually creates compassion and love and the desire to help and uplift rather than the the desire to destroy. Right? If a hyena comes into your your campsite and attacks you, you don't empathize with the hyena, you just put it down. But human beings are not animals. But when we deny our own sin or we deny our own evil, we deny our own shadow. then we fail to identify with the people around us and therefore we treat them as though they are different from us, which creates a lack of compassion, a lack of love, a lack of uplifting. So that's very crucial. And that's a very, very important part of what Jung was talking about there. Is that the individual has a responsibility to understand and investigate themselves, to know themselves, the good and the bad. But again, where he goes wrong is in this sort of un I don't know if it's uncritical acceptance, because he made a stance on it, but this acceptance of the value of these parts. in some fashion and the value of reconciling the self to society. And again, I think where the reconciliation of the self to society goes wrong is of course, what if your society is is messed up? Right? This is something that Adler pointed out. What if your society is messed up? What if your society fundamentally fails you in some way? If we depend so much on the people around us for our own survival, for our own self-understanding. for the things that we need in life. If you have a society that is corrupt, broken, ignorant, destructive, pathological, then you can't expect much necessarily from yourself. And so there has to be a there has to be a social consciousness of the kind of society they were actually bringing people into and how that relates to the individual development and understanding of themselves. So it's that crucial social element. Of course just the power relationships involved there. And then the second thing that I've often found limiting in Jung which I think is something he actually pointed out himself. But, you know, the categories that he talks about, you know, introverted, extroverted, anima, animus. these kind of psychic categories that I talked about are themselves they're less reductive than Freud, but they're still reductive. And so and so often people will go into Jung and you treat it like astrological signs. They they give themselves they read into themselves parts and identities which might not have been native there and their experience because they've read Freud. sorry, because they've read Jung And you can s I mean you can see the you can see this a bit with the the Myers Briggs stuff, right? You take a thirty minute personality test and suddenly your whole your whole personality is distilled down into these random categories. And I know that Jung himself wasn't necessarily an advocate of that. He talked about the nuance there and he even talked about the the dangers in these kinds of categories and how you ought to be continually open to different aspects and not not reduce psychology down to a a a set of preconceived ideas. But recognizing that the I mean I think he literally said at one point, the individual the individual always breaks the rule. The individual always breaks the rule. And so never to funnel yourself into these categories. These categories were meant to be something which was very generalizable. But Jung in Jung's mind. In Jung's mind, the individual always came first. That was the the data that needed to be taken seriously. Jung was much more interested in the individual experience than in the The generalizable categories. And recognize that the s that that the psyche was an even more complicated place than even F even Jung understood. And the idea of the collective unconscious, I think it became sort of it was sort of made mystical by Jung himself. And I think part of that had to do with his own interest in just mythology and whatnot. but I believe that modern psychology has continued to affirm at least the neurological side of this kind of collective unconscious, and not in the sense of this. you know, I don't know, thing which sits outside of any given individual, but the idea that that human beings share share a certain hardware, right? Sir share a certain mental hardware, a certain amount of shared instincts, a certain amount of shared development that is based in our evolutionary history on how we've survived and developed cultures and and How you know people have their own individual variations of this common hardware, so to speak, that enables similar functions across a species. And that that, you know, w w when Jung talks about these archetypes, that these might be generalizable or yeah, generalizable aspects of the self that have been useful at different times in human history and so they sit in our in in potential within our minds, waiting to be, you know, quote unquote activated given a certain circumstance. But even so, I think that those archetypes, that sort of generalizable hardware, comes into conflicts with the uniqueness of any given situation. I mean this is part of the reason why we're conscious from an evolutionary perspective. is that our consciousness picks up on the details of our existence in a way that is dramatically different from our instincts or our archetypes. And that much of these archetypal patterns are interpretive. They're evaluative. The one thing that both interests and repels me about Jung's methodology too, is his active imagination amplification. Active imagination amplification. Which is why I'm really concerned about the the presupposing that every part is of value. And why I hold the kind of critical why I would say like if you are going to do this kind of amplification and act of imagination, you must be cr very critical and skeptical of what pops up, right? And I thought this even from an atheistic perspective, where it's just You know, if you if you do active imagination and you encounter these characters, these entities, you know, the old man, the the I don't know, these different kinds of archetypes that that have come out of Jungian psychology in general. I mean there's all these all these books on it, right? All these different an endless amount of archetypes that people have come up with. But if you go into this active imagination and you encounter these symbols and and archetypes and characters and entities within that act of imagination. And you assume that they have a val some sort of value to you. You assume that they're trying to tell you the truth. You assume that they have good intentions for you. You're making a big assumption. And it's not at all clear that the aspects of the self or different affect aspects of the self Are interested in truth, or interested in goodness, or interested in what would be of value to you. there are plenty parts there are plenty of parts of the self that are interested in deception, are interested in harming, are interested in in being antisocial and psychotic, because there have been plenty of instances in our history in which those things were necessary. And those parts developed alongside to, or not even necessary, but just materially beneficial to the individual in the first place. And so even from the atheistic perspective, I would say, you know, in terms of active fantasy and amplification, it's not necessarily bad, but you must treat it in the same way that you would treat real life. Where you must be skeptical and evaluate, question the intentions of of whatever comes up and evaluate it from a moral standpoint, not simply accept it as uncritically, accept it uncritically or accept it as an innate value. But even more so, I I would caution if you're a Christian doing this, I would caution you even more strongly, because we understand the reality of demonic influences. And it very well me may be that the enemy uses these forms of active imagination, if you are engaging with them uncritically, for the sake of deceiving you and turning you away from God. There is a reason why God There is a reason why God warns us against divination, you know, secret knowledge and are messing with this kind of stuff. Because even being cautious, we should even be very cautious of dreams. Because these are realms, these are suggestive realms in which the enemy can manipulate or deceive. So in the first place, if you were going if you're a Jungian trying, or sorry, if you were a Christian thinking about doing this kind of act of imagination or amplif amplification, then this would be something that I would recommend to do with a fellow Christian. This would be something I would recommend that you pray strongly on and listen to what comes back to you there. And this is something where I would invoke Jesus. I would invoke the protection of the spirit if this is something that you were going to embark on. I'm not necessarily against the exploration of the self, but this is where I don't think Jung was cautious enough. There are parts of the self which are evil. There are parts of the self which are deceptive. Not only that, but the enemy can use can the enemy can. hide itself, can present itself as yourself. The enemy can sometimes oftentimes will do this with thoughts. I mean you get this malicious thought in your mind. You get this blasphemous thought in your mind. This is oftentimes the enemy. So I would just mean I I just mean to say be careful when it comes to that kind of thing. One should be willing and open to explore, but one needs to be on guard as well. That was always the biggest danger with Jung. Again, even from the atheistic perspective, that was always the danger with Jung was that he assumed these things were of value. He assumed that they were always interested in revealing to him some sort of wisdom or truth. He viewed his unconscious as he viewed his psyche as a priori, a place of insight and wisdom that he could derive. But the truth is that the human mind is not all good. The human mind is not all valuable. The human mind is not all wise. The human heart I mean the human heart is broken and sinful. And that's reflected in the psyche. That's reflected in various parts of the self. So one must have extreme caution, caution. And if even if one is going to do that, one must do it, I believe, best, with another Christian, as in them monitoring monitoring you, in prayer, and in the power and the protection of the spirit. And even then it's it's I don't know how valuable it is. And I would take very seriously. I would take it very seriously if the spirit cautions you against that. Because I'm not really I'm not even sure how close that kind of thing is to something like divination or to entering a spiritual realm in which you God has really forbidden us to venture into at this point. So but all that being putting put aside, the exploration of the self is is of great value. And the and the willingness to confront what especially what comes up is of value. And I think Jung really pushed that in the introspective in the introspective direction that it needed to go. Though it was unfortunate that he didn't I think he didn't emphasize the role of childhood enough. which makes sense, you know, given given how he was reacting against Freud, because Freud, at least in a corrupt way. Freud, in a corrupt way, talked about the origins of childhood and how it influences people's neuroses. And Jung, rejecting Freud's sexual theory, kind of went in the opposite direction, and said, no, psychosis doesn't have necessarily to do with childhood. It has to do with problems that go wrong in any given developmental phase. And while it's true enough to say that people can suffer. neuroses at a variety of different points in their life, depending on whatever develop developmental phase they're in. It's also true that the child childhood has a greatly disproportionate impact on the rest of one's life because it sets up the expectations. I mean, look into something like epigenetics, because this essentially Certain genes get turned on and off for the rest of your life, depending on what you experience in childhood, that go on to set up how not only your mind but your body reacts in in the world going forward. Childhood represents a very significantly impactful time of somebody's psychic development that goes on often to have outsize impact later on and impact the other stages of development. And not only that, but it's also a uniquely vulnerable time. It's a uniquely vulnerable time in which a in which the power dynamics or the power gap between the parent and the child, the parent in society, the parent and their peers is so astronomically large that it has an outsized impact on the child's psychic perception. And I'm not sure that that Jung really emphasized that enough. But again, he was trying to react against against Freud. But anyway I think I'm gonna end things here. If you guys have any thoughts about this, any any thoughts of your own about Jung or Freud or really just psychology in general, I'd love to hear more about it. Jung is one of those thinkers that is so rich. To read about and to engage with that you could really just talk about his ideas endlessly if you wanted to. So I'm sure you guys have some thoughts of your own. And again, I would just love to to hear more about it. So please drop those in the comments. And if you like this video, please give it a like. If you think somebody would find this helpful or or interesting, please share it with them. If you wanna see more videos like this then please subscribe and as always thank you guys for listening and I'll talk to you next time.