Latest / The Jeremy Ryan Slate Show / Britain: What Real Civilizational Collapse Actually Looks Like
Transcript
- 0:00Everywhere Rome fell, civilization transformed in
- 0:04Britain. It stopped.
- 0:06We've been told that's poetic myth, that the Barbarians
- 0:09arrived, absorbed Roman culture, and the world moved on.
- 0:14The fall of Rome as a long, slow handoff empire into kingdoms.
- 0:20That handoff happened in Gaul, in Hispania, in Italy.
- 0:24Itself. But not in Britain.
- 0:27The fault line here. Wasn't military defeat?
- 0:30It was replacement new. People arrived.
- 0:32With new gods, a new language, and no desire to inherit what
- 0:37came before. Mosaic floor under leaves.
- 0:41No one left to claim them. Latin above the doorway, no one
- 0:45left to read it. Roman towns not burned, not
- 0:49sacked. Empty Britain is what actual.
- 0:52Collapse looks like. And the condition that caused
- 0:55it. Successors who?
- 0:57Chose not to inherit. That is an ancient history.
- 1:01You're watching the replay. Welcome back to the Roman
- 1:22pattern. I'm your host, Jeremy Ryan.
- 1:24Slate, CEO of. Command your brand.
- 1:27You can check us out over at commandyourbrand.com.
- 1:31This. Episode is the comparison case
- 1:33for the whole. Series.
- 1:35If you've been with me from the start, you already know the.
- 1:38Thesis, which is that. Rome didn't really collapse so
- 1:42much as it transformed. The Empire turned into kingdoms,
- 1:47Latin turned into French and Spanish and Italian, and the
- 1:51Church ended up preserving a lot of the institution, the
- 1:54emperors. Had built.
- 1:55That's the. Standard story and honestly
- 1:58most. Of it is true, it's true just
- 2:00about. Everywhere except one place.
- 2:03In Gaul, the Franks took over Roman administration and kept it
- 2:06running, and Hispania, the Visigoths held on to Roman law.
- 2:11In Italy, the Ostrogoths kept Roman governance going.
- 2:14At least. For a generation, even in North
- 2:17Africa, where the vandals were genuinely disruptive, Roman
- 2:22urban life carried on. Britain is the exception.
- 2:26To all of it. Britain is the one.
- 2:28Place where the lights. Actually went out.
- 2:30And the reason that matters isn't only historical.
- 2:34Understanding why Britain went dark when nowhere else did tells
- 2:38you something. Real about what collapse
- 2:40actually requires. And what it requires turns out
- 2:44to be quieter than Barbarians at the gates or some dramatic
- 2:48military. Defeat it's.
- 2:49Something more subtle than that, and in a way, it's more
- 2:53dangerous. So let me start the clock around
- 2:56the year 200. By then, Britain has been a
- 2:58Roman province for something like a century and a half.
- 3:02It's not the center of the empire.
- 3:04Obviously. But it's a real, functioning
- 3:06piece of it. Londonium is an actual city.
- 3:10It's not Rome, but a genuine city with a forum and a basilica
- 3:14and a working. Port Bath has its.
- 3:17Thermal baths. York is a military base and a
- 3:20supply. Hub Colchester has a.
- 3:22Colony of veterans and roads tie.
- 3:25All of it together. And those roads aren't just
- 3:28infrastructure, they're really the nervous system of the whole
- 3:31thing. The tax collectors move on them.
- 3:34The soldiers move on them. The merchants move on them.
- 3:38Information travels along them. So if you pull out the roads or
- 3:43you pull out the people who keep the roads.
- 3:45Working everything starts to slow down and eventually.
- 3:49It stops. By the end of the 2nd century,
- 3:52Roman Britain is genuinely producing tin and silver and
- 3:57grain, even hunting dogs, and it's importing wine and oil and
- 4:01fine pottery and glass. Latin is the working language of
- 4:05government and commerce, the educated class writes in it.
- 4:09They're carving it into stone. Christianity is starting to
- 4:12arrive. But slowly it is arriving.
- 4:15The villa economy is up and running with wealthy families
- 4:18building these country. Estates that have heated.
- 4:20Floors and painted walls and geometric mosaics.
- 4:25This is what? Civilization looks like when
- 4:27it's actually working. Nobody would call it invincible,
- 4:31but it's functioning, doing all the things a working system is.
- 4:34Supposed to do. And standing there in the year
- 4:37200, there's really no reason to think any of it is going to.
- 4:41Stop which if you've. Watched any of these.
- 4:44Videos is usually exactly how it looks right before it does.
- 4:48The Roman army was really the spine of the whole province, and
- 4:53not just for defense. It handled administration supply
- 4:57chains. Legal order.
- 4:59Tax collection. The engineering and the
- 5:02maintenance. So when you remove the army,
- 5:05you're not just pulling out soldiers, you're pulling out the
- 5:08entire operating system the place runs on in four O 7, a
- 5:12general named Constantine the Third strips the British
- 5:15garrisons. He needs the men, though, not to
- 5:18defend Britain. He needs them to invade Gall and
- 5:21make his own run at the throne. And this is the pattern you've
- 5:25seen before in this series. You've got an ambitious general,
- 5:29a frontier that's been left too thin, and a gamble that ends up
- 5:33not paying off. His coup falls apart within a
- 5:36few. Years and he's captured and.
- 5:38Executed, but he took. The British garrisons with him
- 5:41when he went, and they never really come back.
- 5:44Then in 410, the Britons send an appeal to the Emperor Honorius,
- 5:49asking for help, asking for troops.
- 5:53And Honorius at the moment is dealing with a genuine
- 5:56catastrophe in Italy. Because the Visigoths.
- 5:59Have just sacked Rome. Itself.
- 6:01So he writes back to the British cities.
- 6:04And the letter is. Short.
- 6:06And the message. Is basically.
- 6:08Defend yourselves now. The whole scene, the appeal and
- 6:13the reply comes down to us from Zosimus, A Pagan historian
- 6:17writing about a century later and I should be honest that
- 6:21historians still. Argue about it.
- 6:23He drops the line right in the middle of a.
- 6:25Passage about Italy. And a few of them think the
- 6:27letter may not have been meant for Britain at all.
- 6:30But the British monk killed us tells more or less the same
- 6:34story from the other side, so the traditional reading holds
- 6:37up. And this is really the moment
- 6:40the written. Record goes dark.
- 6:42And what's striking is that the whole thing marking the end is a
- 6:45letter. There's no final battle and no
- 6:48great invasion, just a short reply telling.
- 6:50Cities to look after? Themselves, and as far as the
- 6:54record is concerned, those few words are where Roman Britain
- 6:58ends that kind of withdrawal. By the way, was.
- 7:01Happening across the Western Empire with provinces getting
- 7:05left to fend for themselves, but almost.
- 7:08Everywhere else what? Moved into that vacuum was
- 7:12Barbarian Federate Kingdom A. Successor state that stepped.
- 7:15In absorbed the Roman administration and kept the
- 7:19machine running in Britain. That just doesn't happen, not
- 7:23right away and not in any lasting way.
- 7:26And the reason it doesn't is. Exactly what makes.
- 7:28Britain. Such a strange and useful case.
- 7:31For the first few decades after 4. 10 The Britons genuinely try
- 7:35to hold things. Together, local leaders step up.
- 7:38Some calling themselves kings, some of them calling themselves
- 7:42magistrates, and they're still reaching for Roman titles and
- 7:46Roman legal frameworks and Roman administrative language.
- 7:50The church is still. Operating.
- 7:52The bishops are still. Meeting people are still writing
- 7:55in Latin. You even get a British monk
- 7:57named. Pelagius, Who's?
- 7:59Influential enough to be argued? About at the very top of the
- 8:01church. His theology is considered wrong
- 8:04by Rome's standards, but the fact that someone like Augustine
- 8:08of. Hippo is still.
- 8:10Bothering to argue against a British theologian tells you
- 8:13Britain is still plugged in. Still.
- 8:15Legible to the wider. Civilization for a while anyway,
- 8:19but that kind of connection depends on maintenance, and this
- 8:22is where it. Starts to slip.
- 8:24The roads still exist. The walls are still standing the
- 8:28mosaic. Floors are still.
- 8:29Perfectly intact. What's disappearing is the
- 8:32system that is used to keep all of it maintained.
- 8:35The aqueducts begin to fail. Because without specialist the.
- 8:39Ceramic pipes crack over the winter and nobody repairs them.
- 8:43The HIPAA costs under the floor heating systems.
- 8:46Go cold because. Running them takes a specific
- 8:48knowledge, and that knowledge is walking out the.
- 8:51Door so the villas start to feel different.
- 8:54They're not abandoned, not. Yet, but they're.
- 8:57Clearly declining rooms get. Closed off the upkeep stops.
- 9:02The mosaics are still sitting there, but nobody's
- 9:05commissioning new ones. That's really the sub.
- 9:07Roman period in a single sentence, nothing is fully
- 9:11collapsed. Yet.
- 9:12But everything is quietly declining.
- 9:15The scaffolding is all still standing, while behind it is
- 9:18already going soft. And that's about the moment that
- 9:21Anglo Saxons show up the Anglo Saxons to.
- 9:24Start with aren't really. One single.
- 9:27People you've got. Saxons coming from northern
- 9:29Germany, Angles coming from Anglin which is the stretch of
- 9:33the Danish borderland in what's now northern Germany, and the
- 9:37Jutes coming from the Danish peninsula.
- 9:39That neat three-way division actually comes down to us mostly
- 9:43from Bead, who's writing his church.
- 9:45History a solid 3. Centuries after the fact.
- 9:48So it's a tidy. Scheme that almost certainly is
- 9:51a lot messier on the ground. They start showing up around the
- 9:54middle of the 5th century and some of them are actually
- 9:57invited in. The Britons, following the old
- 10:00Roman playbook, bring in Germanic.
- 10:02Warriors as federates? Which just means paid fighters
- 10:06who defend your territory in exchange for land.
- 10:09And every frontier commander in the late empire was doing the
- 10:12same thing. Stillico did it in Italy,
- 10:15Atheists did it in Gaul. You invite the barbarian inside
- 10:18the. Walls.
- 10:19You give him land, and you hope. He stays.
- 10:22Loyal in most of the West, that. Actually worked.
- 10:25Not Florida. State, but it held the Visigoths
- 10:29took Gaul. And Hispania and kept the Roman.
- 10:31Legal code. They kept Latin, kept the
- 10:34Church. The Franks who came into Gaul
- 10:37did the same. When Clovis converts to
- 10:39Christianity in 496, he isn't giving up his Frankish identity.
- 10:44He's buying into the Roman institutional system, and that
- 10:47system survives. Precisely because he does.
- 10:50The Anglo Saxons end up going in a completely different
- 10:54direction, and it comes down to their situation in Britain being
- 10:57genuinely different from everyone else's, not to some
- 11:01deliberate choice they made and not to them being any more
- 11:04hostile than anyone else. There was no working Roman
- 11:07administration left to absorb them, no strong British.
- 11:11Successor state to. Begin with no emperor keeping an
- 11:14eye on things from. The East, the.
- 11:16Infrastructure was already failing by the time they
- 11:18arrived, so they didn't simply inherit it.
- 11:21They built their own thing on top instead.
- 11:24Wooden halls went up where stone villas had been, they spoke Old
- 11:27English instead of Latin, and their Germanic gods took the
- 11:31place of the Christian Church. This isn't the fall of Rome as
- 11:35some dramatic event. It's the fall of.
- 11:37Rome as a. Slow substitution.
- 11:40One culture gradually getting replaced by another.
- 11:43And the thing to really sit with is the Anglo Saxons didn't
- 11:46destroy Roman Britain. Roman Britain was already
- 11:49failing on its own. What they did was.
- 11:52Build something completely different on top of the ruins,
- 11:56something that had no real interest in preserving what had
- 11:59been there. So the fault line here is
- 12:01replacement, which is genuinely different from the invasion we
- 12:05usually picture. Somewhere around the year 500.
- 12:08Something happens and I want to be.
- 12:10Careful here, because we. Honestly don't know.
- 12:13Exactly what the sources? Are thin.
- 12:16The dates are disputed. The names aren't reliable, but
- 12:19something happens that later grows into legend.
- 12:23A British war leader. Pulls the resistance together
- 12:25and defeats the Anglo-Saxon force.
- 12:27At a place called. Baden Hill, our one near
- 12:30contemporary witness. For this is Gildus.
- 12:33The British monk again, writing maybe a couple generations
- 12:37later. And it's worth pointing out that
- 12:39even Gildus never gives us a name like.
- 12:41Arthur, he just records. The siege of Baden Hill.
- 12:44As a real British victory that bought a stretch of peace.
- 12:48The name Arthur doesn't get attached until centuries
- 12:51afterward, so the details are almost certainly off.
- 12:54The name may be largely legendary, and the scale of the
- 12:58wind was probably exaggerated over the time, but there's
- 13:01something real underneath. All of it.
- 13:03Some actual Romano. British war leader.
- 13:06Probably fighting on horseback. Probably trained the last of the
- 13:11Roman cavalry. Tactics.
- 13:13Probably defending what was left of sub Roman Britain against the
- 13:16next wave of Anglo-Saxon pressure, and for a generation
- 13:20maybe. Two, it actually works.
- 13:23The Eastern Lowlands are Anglo-Saxon ground by now.
- 13:26While the West Wales. And Cornwall and part of the
- 13:30North stay. British.
- 13:32And this is really where the Arthur myth comes from.
- 13:35Strip away the magic and Camelot and a sword in the stone, and
- 13:38what you're left with is a real man, or maybe a composite of
- 13:42several men trying to. Hold a civilization together.
- 13:46With cavalry and seer desperation for a generation, he
- 13:50pulls it off. And then it stops mattering.
- 13:53Because Batten is a military victory sitting inside a
- 13:56cultural collapse. The Anglo Saxons don't stop
- 13:59coming, the British institutions keep decaying, the trained
- 14:03cavalry leaders die and nobody replaces them, and the Latin
- 14:07speaking administrators keep disappearing.
- 14:10So the battle delays the collapse without ever.
- 14:12Reversing it by the year 600 the eastern. 2/3 of Britain.
- 14:16Is Anglo-Saxon territory Latin is vanished from public life the
- 14:21church in the. East has fallen apart.
- 14:23And the towns are empty. Arthur, if he ever existed at
- 14:27all, basically died for a. Civilization that couldn't be
- 14:30saved. And I think that's a big.
- 14:32Part of why the? Legend sticks.
- 14:35There's something about the last man standing that.
- 14:37Stays with us especially. When he.
- 14:40Loses so this. Brings us to the central
- 14:42question of the whole. Episode.
- 14:44Same empire, same pressures, the same barbarian migrations moving
- 14:49through the same stretch of time, and you get a completely
- 14:51different outcome in Britain than you get in.
- 14:54Gaul Why the first piece of it? Is just institutional depth.
- 14:59Gaul had been roaming for longer and more deeply, with more
- 15:03towns, more people, more administrative machinery layered
- 15:06into daily life. So when the Western Empire
- 15:09contracted, there was simply more to preserve in Gaul,
- 15:13because there had been more to begin with.
- 15:16Britain, by contrast, was always a frontier province, rich in
- 15:21places but thin. This is pretty close to the
- 15:24argument that Peter Heather makes about the fall in general.
- 15:28That how deep the. Roman institutions had actually
- 15:30sunk into a given province largely decided whether anything
- 15:34survived the contraction. Where the roots were shallow,
- 15:38the. Recovery tended to be shallow.
- 15:40Too the second piece. Is what you might.
- 15:42Call the successor problem. In Gaul, the Franks had a
- 15:46functioning successor state. They kept the Roman
- 15:49administrative machinery turning, kept Latin as the
- 15:52language of law and church and government.
- 15:55But the. Bishops kept the legal code.
- 15:58In Britain, there was no equivalent to any of that.
- 16:01The Anglo-Saxon kingdoms that grew up in the 5th and 6th
- 16:05centuries had no use for Roman administration.
- 16:09They didn't need it. Because they already.
- 16:11Had their own way of doing things.
- 16:13And the third. Piece is the cultural gap.
- 16:16Which I think is the deepest one of the three.
- 16:19The Franks were already inside the Roman orbit.
- 16:21Before they ever took over Gaul, they'd served as federates.
- 16:25They'd. Fought alongside Roman legions,
- 16:28they traded in Roman towns. They used Roman law in their
- 16:32dealings. The Anglo Saxons came from
- 16:35completely. Outside that orbit.
- 16:37From the north. Sea coast of.
- 16:39Germany and Denmark, a world that had never been Roman at.
- 16:42All they weren't. Hostile to Rome so much as they
- 16:46were simply post Roman in a different sense because they
- 16:49didn't really know what it was they were stepping into.
- 16:52So when a Frankish noble moved into a Roman villa in Gaul, he
- 16:56understood what he was looking at.
- 16:57He kept it running. He used the Roman legal system
- 17:00to lock down his ownership. He spoke Latin.
- 17:04With the local Bishop. When an Anglo-Saxon war leader
- 17:07settled near a Roman villa in Britain, he built a wooden hall
- 17:10next to it and let the villa fall down.
- 17:13And the striking thing is how little contempt is involved in
- 17:16that. What you're really?
- 17:17Seeing is indifference. The villa wasn't part of his.
- 17:20World. He had no framework for it, no
- 17:23real use. For it.
- 17:25That indifference, that basic failure to inherit.
- 17:28Is what actually produces the collapse.
- 17:31And it comes down to a gap in understanding between one
- 17:33culture and the next, rather than any single.
- 17:36Battle or policy? When your successors don't want
- 17:40what you built, it doesn't get fought.
- 17:42Over it just quietly goes. Away, and that holds well beyond
- 17:46Rome or Britain. Whenever you stop maintaining,
- 17:49you lose, and whatever your successors decline to inherit
- 17:53tends to disappear completely. It's worth stopping on what it
- 17:56actually means for a language to disappear.
- 17:58Latin in Britain just didn't stop being spoken.
- 18:02It stopped being written, it stopped being read, it stopped
- 18:05being taught to anyone new. Compare that to Gaul, where
- 18:09Latin doesn't die. It evolves.
- 18:12It slowly turns into Old French. The language Molyar was writing
- 18:16in descends directly from the Latin the Romans carried into
- 18:19Gaul with no real gap and no real break in the chain.
- 18:23You see the same continuous line in Spain and again in Italy.
- 18:27Britain is where that line snaps the language.
- 18:30That actually survives. There is Brithonic, the island's
- 18:34own Celtic tongue, the ancestor of Welsh and Cornish, something
- 18:39older than the Roman occupation itself, not a form of Latin at
- 18:43all. And it only hangs on in the
- 18:45West, in the parts of Anglo Saxons never reached.
- 18:50That's the contrast that I really want you to sit with in
- 18:53Gaul. What?
- 18:53Survived was a direct. Descendant of Latin while in
- 18:57western Britain, what survived was the native Celtic language
- 19:00before Rome ever showed. Up.
- 19:02And Latin. Itself just evaporated.
- 19:05In the east, in the lowlands and the towns, Latin disappears
- 19:10completely. And what replaces it?
- 19:12Is a totally separate. Germanic tongue, not a daughter
- 19:15language at all. Old English, the language of.
- 19:18Beowulf. Comes off a completely different
- 19:21branch of the language tree. It isn't descended from Latin,
- 19:25and it isn't even a cousin of French or Spanish.
- 19:28And that matters more than it might sound, because a language
- 19:31isn't only a way of talking to each other.
- 19:34A language. Is also how a society.
- 19:36Stores what it knows. Think about everything that was
- 19:39written down in Latin, the administrative records.
- 19:43The legal texts, The theological.
- 19:45Manuscripts, the engineering and agricultural manuals when Latin.
- 19:50Drops out access to all of that quietly drops out with it.
- 19:54Not instantly and not completely, but in a real
- 19:58functional sense. Farmers in sub Roman Britain
- 20:02around 500 who can't read Latin can't get at the Roman.
- 20:05Agricultural treatises. That might have improved.
- 20:08His yields a local. Leader who can't read Latin
- 20:11can't reach for the Roman legal code that might have.
- 20:13Stabilized his territory. The knowledge.
- 20:15Itself was still physically there.
- 20:17Carved in stone, written on parchment.
- 20:20But there was nobody left. Who could actually read it?
- 20:24And that's the fault line showing up again.
- 20:26Because. Cultural replacement doesn't
- 20:28just change who happens to live in a place, it changes what can
- 20:32even be known there. Knowledge needs a continuous
- 20:35chain to survive, and once you break that chain, whatever isn't
- 20:39held sitting in a storage somewhere waiting to be pulled
- 20:42back out, it's simply gone. By around 500, Roman city life
- 20:48in Britain is basically finished.
- 20:50It doesn't happen everywhere at once, and there's no single
- 20:54dramatic moment that you can point to, but the direction of
- 20:57travel is unmistakable. The clearest case is probably.
- 21:01In Silchester, a fully planned Roman town in southern England.
- 21:06With. Grid streets and a forum and an
- 21:08Amphitheatre and shops and workshops.
- 21:11It gets abandoned in the 5th century.
- 21:13And here's the strange part, Nothing gets built on top of it.
- 21:17There's no medieval town, no Anglo-Saxon settlement.
- 21:21It's just left there. And it stays empty for
- 21:24centuries. That's genuinely unusual, close
- 21:27to unique in the whole Western Roman world.
- 21:31And it's really the. Core of what?
- 21:32Brian Ward Perkins argues his point is that Britain saw the
- 21:36most total material collapse anywhere in the old Western
- 21:40Empire, and not just in towns emptying out, but the
- 21:43disappearance of wheel thrown pottery, of coinage, a building
- 21:48in stone, all the way down to a standard of living that arguably
- 21:52dropped below the Iron Age. Britain is his.
- 21:55Sharpest place of. Evidence that in some places.
- 21:58The fall was really a fall. Compare that to Gaul, where the
- 22:01medieval towns grow directly on top of the Roman ones.
- 22:05Paris sits on Lutea, Leon sits on Luke Dunham and the street
- 22:09patterns of a lot of French cities.
- 22:12Still trace the. Old Roman grid in Britain.
- 22:15The pattern runs the other. Way.
- 22:17The Roman town fails, the new Anglo-Saxon settlement turns up
- 22:22nearby, but crucially not on the same site.
- 22:25And that matters for a very concrete reason.
- 22:28When a new culture builds on top of an old city, it inherits
- 22:31everything already. There the wells, the.
- 22:35Drainage. The walls, the roads.
- 22:37Running in and out the trade networks already.
- 22:41Attached to that spot. When it builds somewhere else
- 22:44instead, it inherits none of it. So Anglo-Saxon Britain didn't
- 22:49just. Fail to keep.
- 22:50Up the Roman towns, it actually chose not to use them.
- 22:54The city life, really. Depends on concentration on
- 22:57having specialists and administrators and Craftsman.
- 23:00Packed close together, the kind of.
- 23:02People who can make things other people can't.
- 23:05Your physicians and glassblowers and scribes once a town empties
- 23:10out. All of those specialists
- 23:12scatter. The glass blower moves on, the
- 23:15physician moves on the scribe moves on the specialization
- 23:19itself. Disappears, right?
- 23:20Along with them, skills that took generations.
- 23:23To build up are. Gone inside a single generation.
- 23:26You can't really rebuild an urban economy until you've
- 23:29rebuilt that urban concentration first.
- 23:32And in Britain? That whole process takes.
- 23:34Centuries. The knowledge chain breaks
- 23:36around 4:50 and it isn't genuinely repaired until the
- 23:40Norman Conquest. Which is a full. 600 years
- 23:43later. Sit with that for a second.
- 23:46Six centuries where the. Thread is just cut.
- 23:49And that's what it looks like when the power fault line.
- 23:51Collapses all the way what you're?
- 23:53Seeing is the complete failure of the administrative framework
- 23:57that made specialization possible when it goes well past
- 24:00ordinary corruption or over centralization once the system
- 24:04that organizes. Skilled labor falls apart, the
- 24:07skilled labor falls apart with it.
- 24:09Christianity had actually reached Britain back in the 3rd
- 24:12century and by the 4th. It was the official.
- 24:15Religion of the Empire, Britain very much included, showed up at
- 24:19the Council of Oral in 314 British theologians arguing at
- 24:24the top. Levels of the Church.
- 24:26So the Christianization of Britain was real and established
- 24:29thing and then in the eastern lowlands it nearly vanishes.
- 24:34The Anglo Saxons were pagans worship a Woden and Thor and
- 24:38Tieu and the days. Of our week still.
- 24:41Quietly carry those names, with Wednesday coming from Woden's
- 24:44day, Thursday from Thor's, Friday from Friggs.
- 24:48Now, across most of the Western Empire, the incoming groups
- 24:52converted. Pretty fast, the Visigoths.
- 24:54Were already Aryan Christians when they turned up the Franks
- 24:57converted within a generation of taking Gaul, the Ostrogoths in
- 25:01Italy. Kept the church structure.
- 25:02Intact. But in the Anglo-Saxon
- 25:05controlled east of Britain, the church essentially collapsed.
- 25:09Nobody persecuted it or dramatically stamped it out.
- 25:12It simply lost its congregation. Lost its clergy.
- 25:16Lost its buildings, lost its funding, and the whole
- 25:20institution died off quietly. There's a real irony in that.
- 25:24Because this. Is the same island that produced
- 25:26Pelagius, a theologian prominent enough that Augustine of Hippo
- 25:31took the trouble to condemn him, and within roughly a century a
- 25:35big chunk of it is Pagan territory again.
- 25:37Christianity does hold on in Wales, in Cornwall, over in
- 25:42Ireland where it never had been Roman in the 1st.
- 25:45Place. And it's actually the Irish who
- 25:47ended up reevangelizing the Anglo Saxons later when Pope
- 25:51Gregory the Great sends missionaries into Britain in
- 25:54597. Isn't sending them to support
- 25:56some surviving British church in the East because there isn't 1?
- 26:00Left to support. He's sending them in to start
- 26:03over from the beginning. And it's bead again.
- 26:05Who preserves that whole mission?
- 26:07Gregory dispatching Augustine of Canterbury into what was, as far
- 26:12as the church was concerned, essentially untouched Pagan
- 26:15ground. They were starting from scratch
- 26:18and that's. What collapse?
- 26:20Really means when you strip it down the chain, breaking out
- 26:23right so that somebody else has to come along and restart the
- 26:26whole thing from zero. It isn't transformation or
- 26:29adaption or gradual change into a new form.
- 26:33So step back from the timeline for a second.
- 26:35The popular picture of the fall. Of Rome comes with a very
- 26:38specific set of images. The Barbarians at the gates, the
- 26:42library's burning, the lights going out all across the ancient
- 26:46world. It's dramatic and cinematic, and
- 26:50as a description of what actually happened, it's mostly
- 26:53wrong. As an account of Gaul or Spain
- 26:56or Italy or North Africa, it just doesn't hold.
- 26:59Because in all those places, the institution survived.
- 27:02The Roman legal code, the Latin language, the Christian Church,
- 27:07the administrative structures, the urban centers, they all
- 27:11changed and adapted and passed through kingdoms that had no
- 27:14interest in calling themselves Roman.
- 27:17But they came through. Britain is what you get when
- 27:20none of those conditions are in place, when Roman administration
- 27:24pulls out completely with no gradual handover, when the
- 27:28successor culture has no interest in inheriting anything,
- 27:32when the cultural gap is wide enough that the newcomers don't
- 27:35even recognize what they're standing in front of.
- 27:37In that situation, the mosaics didn't get.
- 27:40Destroyed. They got buried.
- 27:42And time did the burying, rather than any invader across
- 27:46centuries of nobody caring enough to.
- 27:48Keep the floor above. Them intact, that's what.
- 27:51Real. Collapse.
- 27:51Looks like when you actually watch it happen and it's driven
- 27:55far more by indifference than by any kind of violence.
- 27:58And Britain ends up proving something important about the
- 28:01rest of. The West, too.
- 28:02The reason Gaul made it? The reason?
- 28:05France. Exists at all?
- 28:06The reason French is a Romance language.
- 28:10The reason Paris has the street plan it has all comes down to
- 28:14the Franks genuinely wanting to inherit It wasn't that Rome
- 28:18stayed strong enough to force any of it.
- 28:20They looked at Roman administration and.
- 28:22Basically decided it was. Useful and worth keeping that
- 28:25single choice. The choice to inherit is really
- 28:29the line between transformation and collapse, and Britain's
- 28:33successors didn't make it, and so Britain went the other way.
- 28:36And this is the part that. Reaches past.
- 28:38Rome and past Britain. Entirely because.
- 28:41Every civilization eventually runs into the same succession.
- 28:44Question What comes after us and what?
- 28:47Do they decide to? Do with everything we.
- 28:49Built the usual. Assumption is that our.
- 28:52Successors will. Want to inherit?
- 28:54That they'll look at what set. Of functioning institutions we
- 28:57have. The legal systems, The schools.
- 29:00The administrative structures and that even if they change
- 29:03those things, they'll hold them to the core.
- 29:06Britain is the. Case that shows that.
- 29:08Assumption can be completely wrong.
- 29:10Successors can show up carrying an entirely different framework,
- 29:14one that doesn't happen to include.
- 29:15Literacy or urban life? Or the accumulated
- 29:19administrative knowledge of whoever came before.
- 29:23And a lot of the time it comes down to simply not recognizing
- 29:27what The thing is or not having any need for it, rather than any
- 29:32real hostility. When that happens, the
- 29:35infrastructure doesn't get. Preserved.
- 29:38It gets ignored. And ignored infrastructure fails
- 29:41on its own. Schedule the aqueducts, crack
- 29:44the heated floors go. Cold.
- 29:46The mosaics slip under the earth not a single moment.
- 29:50But across decades, slowly. And then all at once.
- 29:54So the real question was never whether your civilization will.
- 29:57Face successors because it will. The question.
- 30:00Is whether those successors will actually choose to.
- 30:03Inherit and if they don't. If they.
- 30:06Arrive with different frameworks and different languages and
- 30:10different institutions. Then everything that needed
- 30:13continuity in order to keep working simply stops the
- 30:17knowledge chain. Breaks the skills scatter.
- 30:20The infrastructure gives out. It's the same shape playing out
- 30:25in a different century. Britain in the year 500 had a
- 30:29working civilization, real legal traditions, real literacy,
- 30:33functioning infrastructure and established.
- 30:36Church. And then it met successors who
- 30:39had no framework for any of it. But inside about 5 generations
- 30:43all of it was gone. So Britain really is the one.
- 30:46Place where the Hollywood. Version of the fall of Rome
- 30:49turns out to be true, with the abandoned villas and the lost
- 30:53libraries and the language disappearing and the towns
- 30:56emptying out and the lights actually going off.
- 30:59That happened, and it happened in Britain and more or less only
- 31:04in Britain. The rest?
- 31:05Of the West transformed while Britain is the one that
- 31:09genuinely collapsed. And the difference came down to
- 31:12a choice the Anglo Saxons never even concisely made.
- 31:16They just didn't inherit, and a civilization that nobody chooses
- 31:19to inherit is a civilization that.
- 31:22Quietly disappears. It's less a story about.
- 31:25Barbarians destroying something and more A.
- 31:27Story about successors. Simply ignoring it and of.
- 31:30Those two the quiet. One is the version that actually
- 31:33tends to happen. If you want to see where this
- 31:36fits in the bigger story, the After Rome thesis.
- 31:39Itself. The whole comparison case.
- 31:42The reason? Britain is the exception that
- 31:44proves the rule. The full series.
- 31:46Is linked below. This has been the Roman pattern,
- 31:50the same pattern showing up again in a different century.
- 31:54I'm Jeremy Ryan Slate, and I'll see you on the next one.
- 31:57Do me a favor. Like this video?
- 32:00Leave. Us a comment and smash that
- 32:02subscribe button if you want more of the Roman pattern.