Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Getting It Right: Navigating Pregnancy Leave and Accommodations Under California
Transcript
- 0:03Good afternoon, everyone. Happy Monday. My name
- 0:07is Andy Fields. I'm a partner at the Jeannie
- 0:09Harrison Law Firm, and I am the most recent chair
- 0:12of the Beverly Hills Bar Employment Law Section.
- 0:16I am absolutely delighted to introduce our speaker
- 0:19today, Courtney McFaite. Courtney is a member
- 0:22of the firm at Epstein. Becker Green in its Portland,
- 0:26Los Angeles, and San Francisco offices. She represents
- 0:30employers in a broad range of employment matters
- 0:32from single plaintiff harassment, discrimination,
- 0:35and retaliation claims to complex wage and hour
- 0:38class actions and Paga litigation, while also
- 0:41advising clients on complex issues such as hiring,
- 0:44terminations, leaves of absence, reasonable accommodations,
- 0:48pay equity, and workforce reductions. Admitted
- 0:52to practice in Alaska, California, Oregon, and
- 0:55Washington, she brings a litigator's perspective
- 0:58to her counseling work, helping employers across
- 1:00industries like healthcare, retail, hospitality,
- 1:04and technology navigate risk before it turns
- 1:06into costly disputes. Courtney, thank you for
- 1:09being here. I'll hand it over to you. Great.
- 1:12Thank you, Andy. Thanks everyone for joining.
- 1:16Just going to share my screen here. So today
- 1:32we are going to talk about one of my favorite
- 1:34topics, which is pregnancy leave and accommodations
- 1:37under California and federal law. I'll go over
- 1:41kind of the legal landscape, but also provide
- 1:43some practical guidance on. You know, sort of
- 1:46things to look out for when you're counseling
- 1:48your clients on this issue. This is a very complex
- 1:52and ever -evolving area of employment law. And
- 1:57you'll notice on my slides that there are quite
- 1:59a few, it's quite a few slides that have a lot
- 2:01of content on them. That's really for your reference
- 2:05after the presentation. I'll be referring to
- 2:08a lot of the slides and a lot of the content,
- 2:10but won't be able to go over everything today,
- 2:13mostly because it would probably be a little
- 2:14bit too dry. So if you have questions, please
- 2:19use the Q &A function, and I'm happy to answer
- 2:21those after the presentation. So just a general
- 2:28disclaimer that this is only for informational
- 2:30purposes. I'm not providing legal advice today.
- 2:34and this is attorney advertising. Okay, so today
- 2:39we are going to talk about quite a few areas
- 2:41of touching on this topic. So I'm going to start
- 2:44with pregnancy -related discrimination. The Pregnant
- 2:48Workers Fairness Act will spend quite a lot of
- 2:52time on the PWFA. It's been a big change in the
- 2:56law in the past few years and it's an area where
- 2:59a lot of employers get tripped up. Also, I'll
- 3:02talk about accommodations under the Fair Employment
- 3:05and Housing Act, which is California state law,
- 3:09pregnancy -related leaves, state leave and disability
- 3:11benefits, retaliation based on pregnancy and
- 3:14related conditions. We'll touch a tiny bit on
- 3:17lactation accommodations. And then I'll talk
- 3:20about avoiding common employer mistakes and practical
- 3:23guidance for California practitioners who advise
- 3:28both employers and employees. So pregnancy -related
- 3:34discrimination is an area that has federal protection
- 3:40and state protection. The federal version is
- 3:44the Pregnancy Discrimination Act. That has been
- 3:47around for quite a while. So that was an amendment
- 3:49to Title VII. It was enacted in 1978. And it's
- 3:53pretty broad. It applies to employers with 15
- 3:55or more employees. So most of the employer clients
- 3:59it'll apply to. It prohibits discrimination based
- 4:03on pregnancy, childbirth, or related medical
- 4:05conditions. The related medical conditions really
- 4:09are pregnancy and childbirth adjacent. So things
- 4:14like disability related to pregnancy, miscarriage,
- 4:19things like that that will relate to pregnancy.
- 4:23The law mandates that protected employees must
- 4:25be treated the same as similarly situated non
- 4:28-pregnant employees. And it covers all aspects
- 4:31of the employment relationship. So hiring, firing,
- 4:34pay, transfer, promotion, et cetera. It does
- 4:37require equal treatment, but it doesn't require
- 4:39accommodation of pregnancy. That is required
- 4:42under a different law, which we'll get into shortly.
- 4:46This law, the PDA, is enforced by the EEOC. And
- 4:50under federal law, you have to have a right to
- 4:52sue letter before you can file civil action.
- 4:58So for California protections, we have the Fair
- 5:02Employment and Housing Act. And this is broader.
- 5:06So it applies to employers with five or more
- 5:09employees instead of 15. It's similar in terms
- 5:12of what it prohibits, although it includes breastfeeding
- 5:15and lactation. So it's, again, prohibiting that
- 5:18discrimination on the basis of pregnancy, childbirth,
- 5:21breastfeeding, lactation, or related medical
- 5:23conditions. It also is broader in that it includes
- 5:27protection for fertility and reproductive health
- 5:30decisions. This is a fairly new development in
- 5:34state law. We're seeing this development, frankly,
- 5:37across the country, but California was on the
- 5:39vanguard of including fertility and reproductive
- 5:42health in that discrimination umbrella. FIHA,
- 5:46just like the PDA, prohibits adverse actions
- 5:50relating to termination, demotion. reduction
- 5:53in compensation, failure to promote, et cetera.
- 5:57Employees can file claims through the CRD, the
- 6:00California Civil Rights Department, or they can
- 6:03go directly to court. California generally provides
- 6:07stronger remedies. So under the federal law,
- 6:11there can be a cap on compensatory and punitive
- 6:14damages. Under FEHA, no such cap. There's a three
- 6:18-year statute of limitations. and a one -year
- 6:21statute of limitations from the issuance of a
- 6:23right to sue notice by the Civil Rights Department.
- 6:28So you can kind of see that this is quite a bit
- 6:31broader than PDA. It's got a lower employee threshold.
- 6:36It's got a broader scope of protected characteristics,
- 6:39a longer limitations period, and then that potentially
- 6:41higher damages because there's no cap. We have
- 6:46seen the CRD actively investigating pregnancy
- 6:49discrimination claims recently. They do go after
- 6:55employers that violate the FIHA with respect
- 6:57to pregnancy. And so it is something we're seeing
- 7:00enforcement of. Same at the EEOC. We're seeing
- 7:03a pretty steady group of EEOC. litigation that
- 7:09pertains to the Pregnancy Discrimination Act
- 7:11and then the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, which
- 7:13we'll talk about in just a moment. So I'm going
- 7:18to spend most of my time today, like I mentioned,
- 7:20on the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act because
- 7:22it's been such a big shift for employees, employers,
- 7:28for everyone. So this law really, it was passed
- 7:31a few years ago in 2022. It is a federal law
- 7:34and The purpose of this is really to ensure that
- 7:39employees can receive accommodation for pregnancy
- 7:42-related conditions. So some in the audience
- 7:45may be familiar with the Americans with Disabilities
- 7:48Act and the accommodations required for folks
- 7:51with disabilities under that law. This is akin
- 7:54to that in some ways, and we'll talk about the
- 7:56differences. But this also is a law that separately
- 8:00from the ADA provides for accommodations, reasonable
- 8:04accommodations. Employers that are covered, and
- 8:08that's most employers, do have to provide accommodations
- 8:11for what the law terms known limitations related
- 8:15to pregnancy, childbirth, and related medical
- 8:17conditions. I'll talk about what that means in
- 8:20just a moment. But these limitations can be either
- 8:23physical or mental. And again, just like the
- 8:27PDA, the PWFA is enforced by the Equal Employment
- 8:31Opportunity Commission. So the conditions that
- 8:36are covered under that umbrella of pregnancy,
- 8:40childbirth, and related medical conditions by
- 8:43the PWFA include things like gestational diabetes,
- 8:47even carpal tunnel syndrome, migraines, all of
- 8:51the mental health conditions that could be associated
- 8:53with pregnancy, such as anxiety, depression,
- 8:57whether that's pre -partum, post -partum, breastfeeding,
- 9:00or related... issues with breastfeeding, infertility,
- 9:05termination of pregnancy, and that would include
- 9:07miscarriage, stillbirth, or abortion. The damages
- 9:13and the remedies available under the PWFA are
- 9:17the same as under Title VII and the ADA. So these
- 9:21would include injunctive relief. So, you know,
- 9:24basically reinstating or instating the accommodation
- 9:27that wasn't provided, reinstatement of the employee
- 9:30in their role. back pay for lost wages, front
- 9:35pay for front lost wages going forward, compensatory
- 9:39damages for any out of pockets, and then punitive
- 9:41damages. So the difference between federal and
- 9:45state law as far as damages, and I've alluded
- 9:47to this a little bit, is that like the ADA for...
- 9:52accommodation claims under the PWFA, money damages
- 9:56can be limited if the employer shows good faith
- 9:59efforts to identify and provide a reasonable
- 10:02accommodation. So this will cap compensatory
- 10:07and punitive damages. It will not cap back pay
- 10:10or front pay, but it will cap those compensatory
- 10:13and punitive damages. Even if those efforts to
- 10:19accommodate were unsuccessful, if there are you
- 10:22know, good faith efforts shown, then that can
- 10:25be capped. This does not apply to disparate treatment
- 10:31claims. So this just applying to the PWFA accommodation
- 10:35claims. So if the employee alleges that she was
- 10:39fired or demoted or otherwise discriminated against
- 10:43on the basis of pregnancy or childbirth, rather
- 10:46than denied accommodation, the damages cap would
- 10:48not apply. And just to note that the injunctive
- 10:52relief and the back pay and the reinstatement
- 10:56still apply. The good faith element really requires
- 11:01an actual consultation with the employee. So
- 11:04the employer has to show that it engaged in an
- 11:07interactive process with that employee, not just
- 11:10that it had a policy in place for accommodations
- 11:12and a unilateral determination by the employer
- 11:16would not satisfy the standard if there was no
- 11:20employee input. There are some differences, as
- 11:28I mentioned, between the PWFA and the Americans
- 11:31with Disabilities Act, and strictly sticking
- 11:34to the accommodations portion of the ADA. So
- 11:37the PWFA really only applies to pregnancy, childbirth,
- 11:41and related conditions, whereas under the ADA,
- 11:46you know, that applies to any qualifying disability.
- 11:49Under the PWFA, a huge difference is that the
- 11:53limitations from childbirth or pregnancy do not
- 11:57need to reach the level of disability before
- 12:00that employee would be eligible for an accommodation.
- 12:03Under the ADA, the employee has to be disabled
- 12:06or has to have a disability that substantially
- 12:08limits one or more major life activities for
- 12:11them to be eligible for those accommodations.
- 12:15Also, the difference is under the PWFA, temporary
- 12:19conditions related to pregnancy and childbirth
- 12:22could apply. So things like morning sickness,
- 12:25not something we traditionally think of as a
- 12:27disability and likely wouldn't be a disability
- 12:29under the ADA. That would be considered a limitation
- 12:33under the PWFA, entitling that employee to an
- 12:36accommodation. In addition, under the ADA, in
- 12:40order to receive a reasonable accommodation,
- 12:43you need to be able to perform the essential
- 12:46functions with or without a reasonable accommodation
- 12:49of your role. The PWFA, again, that's not a requirement.
- 12:54So I mentioned morning sickness. Other sort of
- 12:58limitations could also be things like endometriosis
- 13:01or infertility treatments. Again, it doesn't
- 13:05need to be a lifelong or even permanent disability,
- 13:09it can be a temporary disability. As far as the
- 13:12essential functions requirement, so under the
- 13:16PWFA, unlike the ADA, employees are still considered
- 13:21qualified for their role and therefore potentially
- 13:23eligible for an accommodation, even if they cannot
- 13:27perform one or more of the essential functions
- 13:29of their job, as long as the ability to do so
- 13:32or inability to do so is temporary. the essential
- 13:36function can be performed in the near future,
- 13:38so typically 40 weeks -ish, it's kind of the
- 13:42timeline that the EEOC looks at, and the inability
- 13:46to perform the essential function can be reasonably
- 13:48accommodated. So another key difference, and
- 13:56this touches on the, this is kind of the, it
- 13:59definitely touches on the definition of no limitations
- 14:02under the PWFA, and that is they per se reasonable
- 14:07accommodations under that law. So what that means
- 14:10essentially is that if an employee expresses
- 14:13a need or has a need for one of these four accommodations
- 14:17on the slide, that employee gets that accommodation.
- 14:21That is considered per se reasonable. There's
- 14:24no discussion with the employer as to whether
- 14:27it's reasonable or not. And in fact, there's
- 14:30no documentation required to prove that the accommodation
- 14:34is reasonable if it falls into one of these four
- 14:37categories. So these categories are carrying
- 14:42and drinking water as needed, additional restroom
- 14:46breaks, alternate sitting and standing, so the
- 14:49ability to sit or stand at their workstation
- 14:52or generally, and then breaks as needed to eat
- 14:56and drink. So these are pretty broad. And the
- 14:59purpose of these four per se reasonable accommodations
- 15:02is really to address the main accommodations,
- 15:06the most common accommodations that people need
- 15:09when they are pregnant. So these really are related
- 15:13to that. The breaks as needed to eat and drink
- 15:16are typically related to or can be related to
- 15:19gestational diabetes. So that's why those are
- 15:21included. There's not a really clear definition
- 15:25on the amount of break time that's permitted.
- 15:29It's really as needed. So it's a very broad entitlement.
- 15:33There was a case called the EEOC versus Roundy
- 15:37Supermarkets. It's still pending. It was filed
- 15:41in March of this year in the Western District
- 15:43of Wisconsin. And essentially the employee made
- 15:49a request to keep a water bottle at her workstation
- 15:52to maintain her milk supply. So this was postpartum.
- 15:57Initially, Roundy's agreed to the request, but
- 16:01she was transferred then to a second store where
- 16:03the accommodation was denied. She made repeated
- 16:05requests for accommodation, and the company insisted
- 16:08that she sign a release authorizing it to access
- 16:10her medical records in order to provide that
- 16:13accommodation. And then, ultimately, Roundy's
- 16:16fired her rather than letting her keep the water
- 16:19bottle at her workstation. So it remains to be
- 16:22seen how this will shake out, but this was filed
- 16:25and initiated by the EEOC on the employee's behalf
- 16:28under the PWFA. So one of the common issues under
- 16:36the PWFA that comes up is whether the employee
- 16:40themselves is covered. So can an employee ask
- 16:44for pregnancy accommodation? Any employee? No,
- 16:47the PWFA only applies to the pregnant employee.
- 16:50It doesn't apply to their partner or spouse.
- 16:54So I've got a hypothetical here. So Carly has
- 16:58been employed with her company for a year and
- 17:00a half. She just told HR that her wife Liza is
- 17:03undergoing fertility treatments to have a baby.
- 17:06Carly wants to take time off for Liza's fertility
- 17:08appointments as a reasonable accommodation under
- 17:11the PWFA. Does HR have to approve Carly's request?
- 17:16The answer is no. So, again, the PWFA only applies
- 17:20to the person carrying the child or undergoing
- 17:24treatment, fertility treatments, and their respective
- 17:27employer. If, for example, Carly was undergoing
- 17:30fertility treatments, that arguably could be
- 17:33covered under the PWFA. However, just to point
- 17:37out, Carly may still be able to take paid time
- 17:39off or sick time to accompany Liza on her appointments,
- 17:44depending on whether she's got any accrued, depending
- 17:49on company policy, et cetera. She also could
- 17:53be able to take intermittent leave under the
- 17:57Family and Medical Leave Act, which could come
- 18:00into play here if Liza has a serious medical
- 18:05condition related to pregnancy. We would need
- 18:07more information to make that determination,
- 18:09but that could also be a potential entitlement.
- 18:14So under the PWFA, and a question that comes
- 18:18up a lot in my work is, can an employer require
- 18:23leave for a pregnant employee as a reasonable
- 18:25accommodation? So there are instances where an
- 18:31employer thinks, gosh, I don't know if this person
- 18:33is going to be able to perform the job, they're
- 18:35pregnant, why don't we just say that they can
- 18:37go on leave and we'll kind of leave it at that.
- 18:41So you cannot require that. So if another accommodation
- 18:44can be granted, the employer can't require that
- 18:47the employee take a leave of absence. So if the
- 18:51employer thinks the employee can't perform the
- 18:53job, but maybe some of those limitations are
- 18:56temporary, that person would fall under the PWFA
- 19:00and would not be able to force them to take a
- 19:03leave of absence. So here's another hypothetical.
- 19:08Paola is a medical assistant. She informed her
- 19:11employer a medical practice that she is pregnant.
- 19:14As recommended by her physician, she requested
- 19:16the ability to sit, take short breaks, or work
- 19:19part -time if needed. The medical practice told
- 19:22her that she would have to take unpaid leave
- 19:23instead and that they couldn't guarantee that
- 19:26they would rehire her or that she would be allowed
- 19:28to take lactation breaks after childbirth. Paola
- 19:31told the practice that she couldn't work without
- 19:33guaranteed breaks. Is this lawful? No. So this
- 19:40conduct would violate the PWFA and the ADA. Leave
- 19:44is considered an accommodation of last resort
- 19:46under both of those laws and it cannot be required
- 19:50if there's another reasonable accommodation possible.
- 19:54Also her request specifically. So she requested
- 19:57the ability to sit, take short breaks, and work
- 20:01part -time. two of those really fall under those
- 20:05predictable assessments or known limitations
- 20:07under the PWFA. And then the PUMP Act, which
- 20:11we'll talk about briefly later, requires lactation
- 20:14accommodations. So these do definitely fall under
- 20:18both laws and the ADA. This hypothetical is actually
- 20:22a fictionalization of a real case, EEOC versus
- 20:26urologic specialists of Oklahoma. Parties in
- 20:29that case ultimately settled for $90 ,000 and
- 20:33injunctive relief. And then in June 2026, the
- 20:36EEOC brought suit in EEOC versus proper ventures
- 20:40in the district court in Washington DC. That's
- 20:45still pending. The defendants in that case were
- 20:48a restaurant chain, and they repeatedly questioned
- 20:51the employee about her maternity leave and voiced
- 20:54their concern over the employee working while
- 20:56pregnant. Then they pressured her to go on leave
- 20:59earlier than she had planned, and despite the
- 21:01fact that she was still able to work. And then
- 21:03they later fired her when she requested to extend
- 21:06her maternity leave by two weeks. So again, that
- 21:09is still pending. So also under the PWFA, I mentioned
- 21:16this before, but there are limited circumstances
- 21:19under this law when an employer can request a
- 21:22documentation for an employee's accommodation
- 21:24request. The rule is that you can require documentation
- 21:29to support an accommodation request when it is
- 21:32not per se reasonable. So when it doesn't fall
- 21:35under one of those four categories and the situation
- 21:38requires it. And so the seeking seeking documentation
- 21:44really must be reasonable under the specific
- 21:46circumstances. This means things like, you know,
- 21:50you see an employee is pregnant or you know they're
- 21:53pregnant and they request a larger uniform to
- 21:56accommodate their pregnancy. That is a situation
- 21:59where you really shouldn't be asking for documentation.
- 22:02In that situation, it's not reasonable because
- 22:05it's obvious that the person is going to need
- 22:07a larger uniform and they've requested it. Also,
- 22:12if the company wouldn't normally require documentation
- 22:15under existing policies, it shouldn't require
- 22:17it for a PWFA -related request. And the documentation
- 22:22really needs to be tailored to the pregnancy
- 22:25request and not you know, kind of doing a one
- 22:28-size -fits -all documentation form under the
- 22:32ADA. So there is a case, EEOC versus Wabash National
- 22:36Corporation, where the EEOC filed a lawsuit against
- 22:42the employer in part for requiring medical documentation
- 22:45for a pregnancy condition using their ADA reasonable
- 22:49accommodation request form. Obviously, you can
- 22:55request documentation if the request is not per
- 22:59se reasonable and the situation requires it,
- 23:05but it is limited. So another question that comes
- 23:16up is, are employers required to grant a request
- 23:19for remote work or other preferred accommodations
- 23:22as a reasonable accommodation? The answer is
- 23:24no. So just like the ADA, employers aren't required
- 23:28to grant a preferred accommodation if there are
- 23:31other equally effective accommodations available.
- 23:35As I mentioned, kind of up top, the employer
- 23:37is still required to engage in the interactive
- 23:39process with the employee to determine the accommodation
- 23:43that they need and that would meet those needs.
- 23:49So for lactation accommodations, often a question
- 23:53comes up as to whether remote work as an accommodation
- 23:57would be required for lactation purposes. The
- 24:00PWFA is not explicit on this, but the law does
- 24:05not require an employee or employer to make an
- 24:07accommodation for the limitations of the child.
- 24:10So if the child is having lactation issues, that
- 24:12would be considered a limitation of the child.
- 24:15It's really only the employee who is entitled
- 24:17to an accommodation that could include remote
- 24:20work. The best practice here would be to get
- 24:23detailed information From the employee about
- 24:25the basis for the request and the scope of the
- 24:27limitation. I just want to make a note here that
- 24:30local laws may have varied standards for accommodations.
- 24:33We'll talk about California law, but to the extent
- 24:35that there is. If the employee is working from
- 24:38a specific locality or your subject, the laws
- 24:40of a specific locality that could impact what
- 24:43accommodations that are entitled to. So just
- 24:47a kind of a little bit of a law nerd slide here.
- 24:50Where is the PWFA headed? So there was a challenge.
- 24:56In 2024, the federal government has challenged
- 25:00a 2024 district court order asserting that the
- 25:03PWFA cannot be enforced against the state of
- 25:06Texas. The Fifth Circuit has granted, agreed
- 25:10to hear oral arguments on the case. Those occurred
- 25:12in May at 2026 and the case is still pending.
- 25:17So we do anticipate that this case will probably
- 25:20go on to the Supreme Court. So, what are the
- 25:25best practices for compliance? The number 1,
- 25:29you know, I would say it's not it's not on this
- 25:31list, but the number 1 best practice would be
- 25:33to really. for your clients to really familiarize
- 25:37themselves with your help with the requirements
- 25:40of the PWFA because they are different than any
- 25:42other accommodation law that we've seen. The
- 25:46second step would be to prepare and revise those
- 25:49accommodation forms. Again, a one -size -fits
- 25:52-all approach using an ADA form is not going
- 25:56to cut it with the PWFA. There should be a separate
- 25:59form for those types of requests. The client
- 26:04will want to make sure that their HR and benefits
- 26:06managers are fully trained on the PWFA. I think
- 26:10that also would include frontline managers to
- 26:12the extent that they would be taking on and hearing
- 26:18accommodation requests from employees. To the
- 26:21extent that a client has a third party administrator
- 26:24administering their leave, you should never count
- 26:28on that TPA being fully compliant. So the client
- 26:32would want to make sure that that TPA is fully
- 26:34compliant with PWFA. And then, of course, taking
- 26:37a look at handbook policies or other policies,
- 26:40evaluating and updating those to make sure that
- 26:43those are accurate and meet the needs of the
- 26:46PWFA. So also impacting pregnancy accommodation
- 26:53is FIHA. So accommodations under FIHA are a separate
- 26:56entitlement, separate requirement. And so we'll
- 27:00get into those. I'm not gonna go through all
- 27:03of the details on this slide. It's fairly detailed,
- 27:06but I wanted to put all of them on one slide
- 27:08to show that there are several different overlapping
- 27:10accommodation laws under California state law.
- 27:14So we've got FIHA. We've talked about that a
- 27:16little bit. That essentially is geared towards
- 27:21accommodations and discrimination. We've also
- 27:24got the pregnancy disability leave, which I'll
- 27:26talk about in a moment. That actually provides
- 27:28four months or up to four months of job protected
- 27:31leave for pregnancy. There's no minimum employment
- 27:35length. You've got to maintain group health coverage
- 27:38and you can be required to transfer that employee
- 27:41to a less strenuous position. CFRA or the California
- 27:46Family Rights Act is another sort of layer on
- 27:48top of this. So CFRA provides essentially family
- 27:52leave. So it provides 12 additional weeks beyond
- 27:55the four months of pregnancy disability leave,
- 27:57if needed, of baby bonding leave. And if you
- 28:02stack PDL and CFRA, let's say the person has
- 28:05a disability that has them out for four months
- 28:08related to pregnancy, plus they get CFRA, that
- 28:11could be up to 12 months of total protective
- 28:13leave. CFRA applies to employers with five or
- 28:17more employees. And for childbirth purposes,
- 28:21it runs sequentially. So it would run after the
- 28:26PDL for the childbirth purposes. You would then
- 28:29get baby bonding leave. Reproductive loss leave
- 28:32also overlaps with this. So under California
- 28:36law, you're entitled to up to five days of protected
- 28:39leave for miscarriage, stillbirth, failed adoption
- 28:42or surrogacy, or unsuccessful IVF. There is no
- 28:45documentation required for this leave. And this
- 28:49applies to employers with five or more employees.
- 28:52So the bottom line here really is that while
- 28:54PWFA is very expansive, California law really
- 28:58sets the compliance floor. So it's got a lower
- 29:00employee threshold, that five employee versus
- 29:0215, a leave that is up to seven months, depending
- 29:07on whether or not the person giving birth has
- 29:10a disability or person pregnant has a disability.
- 29:14Broader predicted characteristics. there are
- 29:17unlimited damages, that's the biggest one, and
- 29:20there's stricter notice and posting requirements.
- 29:23So if you put the PWFA and FEHA side by side,
- 29:26you can kind of see that there are different
- 29:30requirements. I would say the PWFA is actually
- 29:35a little bit more broad in the type of accommodations
- 29:38that it requires. And for PDL, for pregnancy
- 29:43disability leave, the condition actually must
- 29:45rise to the level of, and under FEHA, the condition
- 29:48must actually rise to the level of disability
- 29:50for an accommodation under those two laws. But
- 29:53under the PWFA, the employee does not need to
- 29:55be disabled. It just needs to be a limitation.
- 30:06So I'm gonna touch a little bit on pregnancy
- 30:09-related leaves as well. I've already mentioned
- 30:11CIFRA, but there's also the Family and Medical
- 30:14Leave Act. So if you compare those two, a little
- 30:19side by side. So FEMLA has been around forever.
- 30:24Many clients are familiar with FEMLA. It basically
- 30:27applies to all employers with 50 or more employees
- 30:29within a 75 mile radius. It has under CIFRA applies
- 30:34to five or more employees. That's a fairly new
- 30:37change as of 2021. For both, there's the same
- 30:41eligibility in terms of tenure. So the employee
- 30:44must have worked 12 months, and they must have
- 30:46worked at least 1 ,250 hours in those 12 months
- 30:49to be eligible. And both provide up to 12 weeks
- 30:52of unpaid leave in a 12 -month period. FEMLA
- 30:57covers a serious health condition, pregnancy
- 31:00disability, and bonding. The new child within
- 31:02one year of the birth or placement. And then
- 31:05CIFRA covers baby bonding. So new child by birth,
- 31:09adoption, or foster care. FEMLA runs concurrently
- 31:13with Pregnancy Disability Leave, that California
- 31:17entitlement for disability. Cifra does not cover
- 31:20disability. It's strictly bonding. PDL covers
- 31:23disability. So these are kind of another slide
- 31:30showing the overlapping laws. So again, we've
- 31:32got PDL. We've got CEFRA, we've got FEMLA, and
- 31:36PWFA accommodation. So this is just a little
- 31:40summary of the differences, but for one pregnant
- 31:43employee, all four of these can apply and likely
- 31:46will apply, and they're all overlapping. Just
- 31:53a little bit more about pregnancy disability
- 31:56leave, as that is specific to California and
- 31:59is not a federal entitlement. As I mentioned,
- 32:02it can cover up to four months of leave. for
- 32:06pregnancy, and really the only trigger is that
- 32:09the employee is disabled by pregnancy, childbirth,
- 32:11or related medical conditions. What that means
- 32:14is that the condition that they have makes it
- 32:17medically inadvisable to work. So it doesn't
- 32:20need to mean that they're completely disabled.
- 32:22It doesn't mean that they're permanently disabled.
- 32:25It's really just related to pregnancy and childbirth,
- 32:28and when their doctor is telling them that it's
- 32:31medically inadvisable to work. pregnancy disability
- 32:36leave can be taken intermittently. It can be
- 32:39taken on a reduced schedule when it's medically
- 32:41necessary. It is unpaid, but there is a benefit
- 32:46that I'll talk about a little bit, a paid benefit
- 32:49entitlement. But employees may and must often
- 32:53use and create accrued paid leave concurrently.
- 32:55So if they already have accrued paid time off,
- 32:58they should be using that leave along with PDL.
- 33:02The client is required to maintain health benefits
- 33:05during PDL on the same terms as if the employee
- 33:07had continued working. And the employee is entitled
- 33:10to return to the same or comparable position
- 33:12when that's done. So pregnancy disability leave
- 33:16is actually one of the most frequently litigated
- 33:19areas of pregnancy leave rights. As I mentioned,
- 33:23it runs concurrently with FEMLA. It does not
- 33:26run concurrently with CFRA. So again, that leads
- 33:29to up to 7 months of total leave time potentially.
- 33:37Certification by healthcare provider is required
- 33:40for PDL. So that is necessary for the employee
- 33:44to take PDL, but not more than necessary. So,
- 33:47you know, if they provided that certification
- 33:51once, unless the condition changes, they should
- 33:53not be required to provide it again. Some employer
- 33:57mistakes that can happen are counting PDL against
- 34:02the CIPRA entitlement. So instead of, you know,
- 34:05they do not overlap. So if you count that entitlement
- 34:08against your fare, you're going to be counting
- 34:10too short. Failing to notify the employee of
- 34:13their eligibility and then denying reinstatement
- 34:15when they return. Those are the typical errors.
- 34:20So in terms of figuring out which leave laws
- 34:24apply or which accommodation laws apply, you
- 34:26should assume that they all apply and go through.
- 34:30So step one would be to figure out is the employer
- 34:33client actually covered? Do they meet the threshold?
- 34:37Most will meet the threshold for FIHA, PDL, and
- 34:40CIFRA of five employees. If they've got 15 or
- 34:43more, PWFA also applies, and then 50 plus will
- 34:46mean that FEMWA applies. Then you want to identify
- 34:49the leave type and sequence and we'll talk about
- 34:52that in a little bit. I have a little kind of
- 34:54flow chart to show how that typically happens.
- 34:58But usually it's pregnancy disability before
- 35:00and after birth plus PWFA if they need accommodations.
- 35:05Then they have the child and that's usually PDL
- 35:09and concurrent femla. Then they have baby bonding
- 35:13after PDL ends, CIFRA, and then they've got their
- 35:18wage benefits under paid family leave, which
- 35:19I'll go into in a moment. So that's kind of the
- 35:23step two. Step three is to coordinate the pay
- 35:26and benefits. There are really specific notification
- 35:29requirements under FIHA, FEMLA, PDL, or it's
- 35:33not FIHA, excuse me. PDL, CIFRA, and FEMLA require
- 35:37pretty specific notification requirements. So
- 35:40that would be definitely something that you'd
- 35:43want to do before you even... As soon as the
- 35:48employee lets you know that they're pregnant,
- 35:49you'd want to identify what notice is required
- 35:51and provide that. Also, if there's any sort of
- 35:57a crude leave integration that the client is
- 35:59providing, that would have to be considered.
- 36:02Health coverage has got to be maintained. and
- 36:04then the reinstatement rights are going to be
- 36:08the same for those two laws. If the position
- 36:12becomes unavailable, like a client has a reduction
- 36:15in force, something like that, documenting that
- 36:18bonafide business reason is absolutely necessary.
- 36:25Okay, so this is probably the driest area that
- 36:29I'll cover, but I did want to point it out and
- 36:31provide the slide. There are two types of state
- 36:36paid state benefits that employees who are pregnant
- 36:39and give birth are entitled to. So one is the
- 36:42SDI, which is a state disability insurance. That's
- 36:45essentially a partial wage replacement or for
- 36:47some employees, a full wage replacement. For
- 36:50employees who are unable to work due to pregnancy,
- 36:52childbirth, or related medical conditions, that
- 36:55is a maximum duration of 52 weeks. So they can
- 36:58be on state disability for up to 52 weeks related
- 37:01to pregnancy. The typical pregnancy claim is
- 37:06they make a claim four weeks before the due date,
- 37:09and then they take six weeks after normal delivery,
- 37:13eight weeks after C -section of SDI. This is
- 37:16funded through a payroll deduction. The employer
- 37:19does not pay this. This is strictly paid through
- 37:21the employment development department. And the
- 37:24employment development department also takes
- 37:26in the application and determines whether the
- 37:28employee is eligible. For paid family leave,
- 37:35that is for the bonding period of the pregnancy.
- 37:40So it also, as with SDI, provides partial wage
- 37:43replacement for employees on family leave, and
- 37:46it covers bonding. And that can be through birth,
- 37:50adoption, or foster placement. The benefit amount
- 37:52is about the same, 60 to 70 % of wages, up to
- 37:57a weekly maximum, and there's eight weeks available
- 38:00in a 12 -month period. So it is a wage replacement
- 38:04and it runs concurrently with CFRA. It's not
- 38:06a separate leave entitlement. Both parents, not
- 38:10just the parent giving birth, can receive paid
- 38:16family leave for the same child because it is
- 38:18that bonding leave rather than a pregnancy related
- 38:20leave. There are strict anti -retaliation. provisions
- 38:26under the law for all of these leaves and all
- 38:29of these entitlements, but there is a special
- 38:32one for retaliation against an employee for taking
- 38:35a leave covered by PFL. So just to summarize,
- 38:40the way that PFLs and CFRA California Family
- 38:43Rights Act leave interact is that CFRA provides
- 38:46the leave protection, so the job protected leave,
- 38:49and then PFL essentially provides the money or
- 38:52pay during that leave through the employment
- 38:54development department. There were a couple changes
- 39:01recently, recent -ish. So in 2020, PFL expanded
- 39:05to eight weeks, six weeks. And then in January
- 39:092025, those wage replacement rates were increased
- 39:11for lower wage workers. So I mentioned I would
- 39:17talk about a typical timeline and how this kind
- 39:19of works for um, for employees and for client,
- 39:22you know, employees of clients and for employee
- 39:25clients. Um, so typically the employee, uh, you
- 39:28know, is pregnant, may need accommodations, um,
- 39:31under the PWFA or FEHA. They go on PDL for pregnancy
- 39:36disability for the birth of the child. FEMLA
- 39:39runs concurrently. The baby is born. Um, if they
- 39:43still have a disability related to pregnancy,
- 39:46then PDL continues. PDL ends, and then the employee
- 39:49can take up to 12 weeks of CFRA for baby bonding.
- 39:53So again, that total potential productive leave
- 39:55is seven months. So as I mentioned, there are
- 39:59strict anti -retaliation laws related to pregnancy
- 40:04and childbirth and related conditions, including
- 40:07lactation. I just did a summary of these so you
- 40:11can kind of see what they look like. So Essentially
- 40:16what the retaliation claim would look like is
- 40:18the employee engages in some sort of protected
- 40:20activity, the employer takes an adverse action
- 40:23against that employee, and then you've gotten
- 40:25a retaliation claim. So protected activity is
- 40:29pretty broad. So that could mean requesting a
- 40:32reasonable accommodation under PWFA or FIHA,
- 40:35taking or even requesting a pregnancy related
- 40:37leave, filing a complaint. opposing practices
- 40:42that the employee believes violate pregnancy
- 40:44discrimination laws, even if they don't, or participating
- 40:48in an investigation or lawsuit related to a pregnancy
- 40:52or childbirth issue. An adverse action by an
- 40:55employer would be any negative action, basically.
- 40:59So termination, demotion, reduction in hours,
- 41:02transfer can qualify as an adverse action, a
- 41:05negative performance review, and even an exclusion
- 41:08from things like meetings or special trainings
- 41:11or advancement opportunities. At the sort of
- 41:14the higher end of this would be like a hostile
- 41:16work environment or increased scrutiny or micromanagement.
- 41:20And then an adverse action can also be a pressure
- 41:23to resign if someone is pregnant or return from
- 41:27their parental or disability leave early. So
- 41:32the claims are pretty basic. As I mentioned,
- 41:34you've got the protected activity, you've got
- 41:36the adverse action, and then if there's a causal
- 41:38link between those two, you've got yourself a
- 41:41prima facie retaliation claim. Retaliation claims
- 41:46have several different types of remedies. So
- 41:49under FIHA and federal law, I mentioned some
- 41:52of the remedies for PWFA, but for retaliation
- 41:55specifically, there is reinstatement, front pay
- 41:58in lieu of reinstatement, back pay and loss benefits.
- 42:01So the sort of the value of the loss benefits
- 42:04can be included in that back pay calculation.
- 42:06Compensatory damages, which would include not
- 42:09only out of pocket losses, but also emotional
- 42:12distress related to the retaliation. Punitive
- 42:15damages, it's capped for larger employers under
- 42:20Title VII and the PWFA, but unlimited under FIHA.
- 42:23Attorney's fees, of course, and then injective
- 42:26relief. So that could be things like policy changes
- 42:30or training requirements. you know, from the
- 42:33EEOC or the CRD or whichever agency is, you know,
- 42:39sort of going after the employer client. So there
- 42:42have been a record number of pregnancy and retaliation
- 42:46charges filed with the EEOC in 2024 and 2025.
- 42:50And in fact, the EEOC has the largest number
- 42:53of claims that the EEOC has pursued over the
- 42:55past few years are retaliation claims. So those
- 42:59are, you know, those are the ones that they.
- 43:01do seek to litigate quite often. The California
- 43:06Civil Rights Department is actively pursuing
- 43:08pattern or practice investigations in California.
- 43:11So employers that have a pattern or practice
- 43:14of, let's say, requiring all employees to go
- 43:17on leave the moment they know they're pregnant,
- 43:19the CRD is targeting those specific violations.
- 43:23And then as you probably all are aware, we've
- 43:27got crazy jury verdicts often. So jury verdicts
- 43:29in pregnancy retaliation cases typically exceed
- 43:321 million in California. And really, that's because
- 43:35of those punitive damages and those emotional
- 43:37distress damages. So what are some best practices
- 43:41for employer clients? Typically to separate the
- 43:46decision makers. So the people that are, you
- 43:48know, determining, hiring, firing, transfer,
- 43:51advancement, all that from those who actually
- 43:54are handling the pregnancy and leave requests.
- 43:57For example, separating, you know, having the
- 43:59manager be sort of the decision maker on the
- 44:01performance side and then having a leave department
- 44:03or HR be the decision maker for pregnancy and
- 44:06leave requests for that same employee. Of course,
- 44:10documenting legitimate business reasons for any
- 44:12adverse action that's taken against an employee.
- 44:17Typically, with counsel's help so that these
- 44:21are privileged communications, not always, but
- 44:24typically those are internal memos that can document.
- 44:29business decisions, also things like performance
- 44:32reviews or performance improvement plans, or
- 44:35even just notes from supervisors documenting
- 44:38why an adverse action was taken against a particular
- 44:42employee. And then, of course, training managers
- 44:45and HR. So no good deed goes unpunished is very
- 44:49true in employment law and is very true in this
- 44:51context. The most well intentioned restrictions
- 44:54like, oh, you know, you shouldn't work. You're
- 44:56pregnant. You should go home. You should go on
- 44:58leave. That can still very much be discrimination
- 45:01and or retaliation. So I did want to touch briefly
- 45:11on a lactation accommodations, even though they're
- 45:13not. No, super related to leave. They do come
- 45:17into play certainly for folks coming back from
- 45:20leave that are pregnant or that have given birth.
- 45:24There have been a couple, there's been a major
- 45:26development in federal law over the last couple
- 45:28of years, or I guess now four years, and that
- 45:30is the PUMP Act. And PUMP stands for providing
- 45:34urgent maternal protections for nursing mothers.
- 45:37So this basically extends protections under the
- 45:41Fair Labor Standards Act, which is the federal
- 45:43labor, kind of overarching federal labor law,
- 45:48extends those protections to all employees. So
- 45:51this includes exempt employees and salaried employees.
- 45:54And what the Pump Act provides is reasonable
- 45:57break time to express milk for up to one year
- 46:00after a child's birth. localities and states
- 46:03can provide for different amounts of time, but
- 46:05the Pump Act provides for one year after the
- 46:07child's birth. There's a requirement that the
- 46:11pumping location must be reasonable. It cannot
- 46:15be a bathroom. It's got to be a private space
- 46:19that's shielded from view and free from intrusion.
- 46:23Smaller employers can claim undue hardship, but
- 46:26it's rare. And this is enforced by the Department
- 46:29of Labor. And we have seen an increase during
- 46:32the current administration, an increase in Department
- 46:35of Labor audits and investigations related to
- 46:38the Pump Act. So this is something that the Department
- 46:42of Labor does go after in terms of enforcement.
- 46:47And so we are seeing that continue, and especially
- 46:50with this current administration. Under California,
- 46:53there's pretty strict California lactation protections
- 46:56that have been in place for quite some time.
- 47:00These apply to all employers, so there's no small
- 47:03employer exception. Like the federal law, there's
- 47:08lactation location required. It's got to be permanent
- 47:11or temporary. But you've also got to have an
- 47:14access to a sink and a refrigerator in close
- 47:17proximity to that lactation location room. And
- 47:21a written lactation accommodation policy is actually
- 47:23required. The policy has got to be distributed
- 47:27at hire and then when the employee returns from
- 47:30a parental leave. There is a potential denial
- 47:34of lactation accommodation penalty. It's $100
- 47:37per day plus attorney's fees. And then there's
- 47:40a separate discrimination, private right of action
- 47:43for discrimination under FIHA if the employer
- 47:46or client takes adverse action related to lactation.
- 47:52In addition to the requirements on the slide
- 47:55for lactation, there's also a requirement that
- 47:59the employee have a place to sit for lactation
- 48:03purposes and a flat surface for the pump as well
- 48:06as access to electricity. So those are also some
- 48:09requirements. So common employer mistakes and
- 48:18how we could help clients avoid them are on this
- 48:21slide. So one of the biggest mistakes, as I mentioned,
- 48:25was counting PDL against CIFRA. Remember, these
- 48:27are separate entitlements. Mistake two, I've
- 48:30talked about using those ADA kind of one size
- 48:32fits all forms for PWFA requests. Do not do that.
- 48:39Requiring leave when another accommodation is
- 48:41available. The employer cannot require leave.
- 48:44It's the accommodation of last resort, particularly
- 48:47in situations where the employee is not requesting
- 48:50leave. Leave should never be required. Or mistake
- 48:54number four, requesting unnecessary or impermissible
- 48:58or overly broad medical documentation. Mistake
- 49:02five is really failing to provide a compliant
- 49:04lactation space or written policy, which I've
- 49:07talked about. So I wanted to give just some practical
- 49:12guidance here on counseling. So I'm gonna start
- 49:17with the employer clients because that's my comfort
- 49:19zone. I mainly represent, actually only represent
- 49:21employers. So these are some immediate action
- 49:24items, really auditing those policies, creating
- 49:28a specific form for PWFA accommodation, and then
- 49:31making sure those lactation spaces meet California
- 49:34requirements at each facility where you have
- 49:36employees. When the employee discloses their
- 49:40pregnancy, the employer should really see a femalist
- 49:44triggered, provide those notices that are required,
- 49:47begin the interactive process for any accommodation
- 49:49requests, and of course document, document, document
- 49:52each step of that process, and then notify the
- 49:56employee of any sort of wage replacement benefits
- 49:59that they may be entitled to. So in counseling
- 50:03employer clients, really the goal is to help
- 50:07them see leave and accommodation for pregnancy
- 50:10as a risk management issue and not a legal burden.
- 50:13So it's something that should really be proactive
- 50:15that they're planning for as soon as they, you
- 50:18know, before they find out an employee is pregnant,
- 50:20they should already have this in place. For employer
- 50:26clients also litigation risk reduction. So, you
- 50:30know, typically this is not a hard and fast rule,
- 50:32but if there's an adverse action taken within
- 50:3412 months of pregnancy, It's always a good idea
- 50:38to have a documented business justification for
- 50:40that adverse action. And then implementing a
- 50:44dual approval for adverse actions can be really
- 50:47good if there are multiple layers of approval
- 50:49that are required from the frontline manager
- 50:52to the HR leadership. That's always a good idea.
- 50:58And then, of course, Advising clients the cost
- 51:01of proactive compliance, so the training, the
- 51:04policy updates, the programming up with the proper
- 51:06forms through council really is a fraction of
- 51:09the cost of defending a single well -documented
- 51:13FIHA case in California with those jury verdicts
- 51:16going well beyond a million in many cases. For
- 51:21employee clients, typically, there is an early
- 51:25case assessment where all the applicable laws
- 51:29are identified, and finding out whether or not
- 51:33the employer meets those thresholds. And then
- 51:36there's really the timeline, especially for retaliation
- 51:39claims, finding out when the protected activity
- 51:42took place, so in that, let's say that accommodation
- 51:44request came in, and then when the adverse action
- 51:47followed, and kind of the timeline for that.
- 51:49preserving all evidence related to potential
- 51:53claims. So many cases now, of course, are litigated
- 51:57on emails and text messages. So making sure that
- 52:00a preservation notice is going out immediately
- 52:03to the employer, personnel file request is immediately
- 52:06going out, and then having the employee preserve
- 52:09all of those documents on their side. There are
- 52:12some administrative prerequisites to filing lawsuits
- 52:16related to pregnancy. So under FIHA, you've got
- 52:19to file a charge with the CRD within three years,
- 52:22and then you've got to get that right to sue
- 52:24required. After you get that right to sue, you've
- 52:27got one year to file. For PWFA and Title VII
- 52:32violations, there is 300 days. So the EEOC charge
- 52:37must be brought within 300 days of that violation.
- 52:41And then FEMLA, the Family and Medical Leave
- 52:44Act, has a two -year statute of limitations and
- 52:48then three years for willful violations. For
- 52:50damages, I've talked quite a bit about the fact
- 52:53that there's an unlimited amount of damages available
- 52:56for compensatory impunities under And of course,
- 53:00attorney's fees are available for all of these
- 53:02types of violations. And then under PWFA, we've
- 53:07got damages capped at 300. There's damages caps
- 53:11on the punitive and compensatory. And most claims
- 53:17that I see come in are filed under both the EEOC
- 53:19and the CRD to preserve all options. So to preserve
- 53:23those federal claims under the PWFA and those
- 53:26state claims under FIHA. So that is it. If there
- 53:36are any questions, I can take those. And I see
- 53:39that there is a question. It says, what if an
- 53:42employer does not have a separate private room
- 53:44with a sink for lactation purposes? except in
- 53:48a communal bathroom down the hall. So the answer
- 53:53to this question is there needs to be a sink
- 53:58that is in proximity to the lactation location.
- 54:03So if you have an office, let's say an office
- 54:07is being used for that purpose, as long as the
- 54:09bathroom is not two buildings over, let's say
- 54:12it's in the same building, it's just down the
- 54:14hall like you said, that's fine. As long as the
- 54:16sink is close enough, to the lactation location,
- 54:19I think the standard is a reasonable proximity,
- 54:23then you are okay and you should be in compliance
- 54:26with the California lactation laws. I can talk
- 54:34about a little bit more employer scenarios if
- 54:37there are no other questions. Let me share my
- 54:41slides. So one of the common scenarios that I
- 54:53see have seen in my practice and in yours. Yes,
- 54:57sorry. Could you begin the screen share on zoom
- 54:59again? Oh, I'm so sorry. Yes. Just one moment.
- 55:20We pull that up again. Okay. My apologies. Okay.
- 55:45So some of the common one of the common scenarios
- 55:49that I see is that we share that there. There
- 55:54we go is when a key employee. So a really kind
- 55:58of high up employee in a company is pregnant.
- 56:03sort of instinct for that employee is to start
- 56:08asking others to take over for responsibilities
- 56:11or for the employer to step in and sort of reduce
- 56:15the workload of that employee without her request.
- 56:19And that can be really, really dangerous because
- 56:21that essentially opens up two kinds of claims.
- 56:26One is in a discrimination claim under the PDA
- 56:30or FIHA, and then second would be potentially
- 56:32a retaliation claim if she's engaged in any sort
- 56:36of protected activity before that happens. Also,
- 56:42another scenario is kind of similar to that,
- 56:45and that is leaving key employees out of meetings
- 56:49because they are pregnant with the knowledge
- 56:52that, well, we're going to shift this work over
- 56:54to a different employee while they're out. You
- 56:57don't need to attend this meeting. often that
- 57:00could also be used as support for a retaliation
- 57:03claim or a discrimination claim. Some of my clients
- 57:18have found it helpful to actually conduct a litigation
- 57:22readiness review for any adverse actions that's
- 57:25taken within 12 months of protected activity.
- 57:27So I mentioned that looking at adverse actions
- 57:32within 12 months of a pregnancy can be really
- 57:34useful. Often that is done on sort of like an
- 57:38annual basis at a certain time based on employer
- 57:43size, of course, and who has been pregnant and
- 57:46sort of figuring that out and figuring out whether
- 57:48any adverse actions have been taken against those
- 57:51folks within 12 months. As I mentioned, there
- 57:59should be a separate form for Pregnant Workers
- 58:02Fairness Act accommodations. And currently there
- 58:07is no sort of specific form like there is under
- 58:10FEMLA for accommodation requests. So that is
- 58:13something that I've assisted my employer clients
- 58:16with preparing. And there's a lot of good samples
- 58:20out there I think that you can modify. But I've
- 58:24also created a checklist for HR often when kind
- 58:28of like what to do when an employee discloses
- 58:30their pregnancy. That's often been really helpful
- 58:33for. Especially if I'm interfacing with any client
- 58:37that's an HR representative to kind of implement
- 58:40that. To see what leaves this person entitled
- 58:43to what accommodations what notifications do
- 58:46I need to provide what kind of job protection
- 58:48are the entitled to. How did the health benefits
- 58:51work how do we maintain the health benefits while
- 58:53they're out and then what's our process for following
- 58:56up with them when they're done with leave. And
- 58:59you know when they're about to come back to me.
- 59:02contact them a week out and find out whether
- 59:05they intend to return. What is our practice around
- 59:07that? And so having that checklist in place for
- 59:12HR can be really, really helpful in that instance.
- 59:18I cannot emphasize enough to document any sort
- 59:21of adverse action decisions made for employees
- 59:24who are pregnant or have related conditions or
- 59:27have just given birth or returned from parental
- 59:29leave. Employers can still terminate employees
- 59:36who are on leave related to pregnancy, but there
- 59:39needs to be a justifiable business reason that's
- 59:42very clearly documented. So I'm going to stop
- 59:48sharing and I do see some questions. have you
- 59:51ever seen successful uses of associational discrimination
- 59:55in the pregnancy context? So associational discrimination,
- 59:59in case you're unaware, would be when someone
- 1:00:03who is not pregnant is discriminated against
- 1:00:05for essentially their association with someone
- 1:00:08that is pregnant and is disabled as a result
- 1:00:10of that pregnancy. I have not seen that successfully
- 1:00:13used. And I think... You know, that's still even
- 1:00:16under the ADA and FIHA for just, you know, regular
- 1:00:19disabilities not related to pregnancy. I think
- 1:00:22that's still such an evolving area of the law.
- 1:00:24And so for purposes today, no, I have not seen
- 1:00:27that used successfully. I've also seen a question
- 1:00:31here. Are you willing to share the checklist
- 1:00:33for HR? Yes, I'm happy to share that after the
- 1:00:36presentation. If that would be helpful, I'm happy
- 1:00:38to send that over. Okay, well thank you very
- 1:00:43much. I appreciate your time today and I hope
- 1:00:45you learned something. I had a great time. Thanks
- 1:00:48again.