Latest / Braver New Worlds / Staying Informed Without Burning Out: Media Literacy and Mental Health with Ashlyn Raine
Transcript
- Nathan Young: Hello and welcome back to another episode of Braver New Worlds. My name is Nathan Young, I am your host. I think a lot of us are caught in a strange position with the news. Like we know it matters, we wanna understand what's happening, but following it can start to feel like a full time job. And like there's this slippery slope that we can go down into every time It actually like the more we do follow it, the more it sort of messes with our heads. it doesn't feel good to follow the news at all either. This terrible stuff going on and the way news is framed and the way it gets served to us, it just really serves to aggravate us a lot more than like inform us, right? And the information that we encounter, it's like just becomes harder and harder to tell what really deserves our attention, what context is missing, who we should trust. And then on top of all of that, there's this whole other layer of complicating factors too. And we live in a world of media with independent journalists and creators, and they're sharing their own content on very short-form, algorithmically driven platforms that create for each of us a very highly personalized and even addictive media environment where the ability to understand fact from feeling, news from opinion, the scale of importance and some magnitude of different news items in the context of the grander schemes of things, and all this gets scrambled into this big crazy mess of voices and clips and sound bites and no real objective understanding of the world even really being possible anymore. So yeah, that's what we're living with. that's kinda like the world we're living with. And it's just a big mess, right? So my guest today is Ashlyn Raine. She is the creator of Ask Ashlyn, a text-based news service. Like she sends you messages via text built for people who want to stay informed without feeling overwhelmed. We talk about media literacy, the incentives shaping creator journalism, how to evaluate credibility without falling into either blind trust or or blanket cynicism, and why boundaries around our attention are not a failure to care. They're actually an important part of staying informed. And I think learning how to understand this like hyper media soup we all live in and understand the nuance of what is or might be going on behind the scenes that like leads to the news that we're getting coming to our eyes and ears, it asks a lot for us as individuals. But I think for those of us that are like really want to stay informed, we see it as important. And we'd like to hope that other people out in the world are able to contextualize the news that they receive. And like I think a lot of times part of our frustration from all the different political spectrums is is yeah, we we are doubting whether people have different political stripes than us are really contextualizing their own news very well. And this makes democracy hard when we can't really all agree on any one truth, right? And so if you are the type of person that's like you're trying to stay informed of the news and you're trying to understand what's going on and you're thinking about these questions about what's going on behind the scenes with the news that gets to me and how to really understand what news to believe and what to validate and how to even like talk about it with other people that might not agree with you, I think you're gonna really appreciate this episode. And then one quick note before we jump into it, this episode was actually recorded a couple months ago, back in August of 2026. So we referenced some things that were in the news at the time. And I think it actually makes a pretty interesting backdrop to the conversation to sort of see how these things we talk about as being important at that particular moment might not even ring a bell now in this late October of the same year. And it's also being released right on the eaves of the US midterm. So it's like an interesting little fold into the conversation too. And maybe something to reflect on with the news you've been consuming over the last couple of weeks and how to put all that into context too. So I'll quit rambling about it here. We're just gonna get into the episode. So here is my interview with Ashlyn Raine. Ashlyn Raine, welcome to the podcast. Ashlyn: Thank you. Thank you for having me. Nathan Young: Alright, as I'd like to start all these off, just I'd like to have you just introduce yourself to the audience real quick so they know a little bit about who you are. Ashlyn: Yeah, absolutely. My name is Ashlyn. I am the CEO of Rain Media and the creator and host of Ask Ashlyn. It's a text message-based news service for news avoiders. My media company is largely focused on media literacy and helping to educate people in our current media ecosystem because there's a lot that people don't understand about what's happening on social and Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: with politics. And these are all skills that can be learned, but people just haven't had the opportunity to learn them. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, definitely. Okay. I wanna ask you about the media literacy. Obviously it'll be like a big point of what we'll be talking about here today, but your news service, so you a text based news service, what is that? Ashlyn: Yeah, my text message news service is called Ask Ashlyn and it's a subscription-based fee where once or twice a week, depending on the volume of news, I will send you a text, a personal one-to-one text message with an update of everything that you need to know about what happened this week, without any of the noise or what ifs or what could possibly maybe happen. It's really like a super concise, distilled way to understand what's happening in national politics. And the thing that makes my platform unique is I include mindfulness strategies and practices. Nathan Young: Mm. Ashlyn: So again, this is targeted toward news avoiders, right? So everything that I do is with the intention of helping people to not just understand the news, but also process it. Because as we know, Nathan Young: Okay. Ashlyn: for the last 10 years or so, everything that's happened in American media has been very big and chaotic and like Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: time consuming and all encompassing. And I don't think news seems to be that way. So with my updates, I always include some kind of like body scan check-in with yourself. Do you actually want to read this right now? If not, come back to it later. And at the end I'll share a meditation or a grounding strategy or some reminder to like go talk to a grandparent or go on a walk or like do something outside just to help people remember that news is not something that needs to take up as much emotional capacity as it has recently. we can change our relationship to it by the way we consume it. Nathan Young: That's crazy. No. I need to be wired. I need to be wired in all the time. Ashlyn: I promise it's possible. No, you really don't. And it's like I've even noticed, because I do social content too and all the things Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: that a business owner has to do in 2026. And Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: as everybody's gearing up for the midterms, right, I'm finding myself personally already burned out. I know this is important and I cover national politics as a journalist, but I just already feel burned out. I'm not excited by following these races. I'm not invigorated by the idea of helping people to understand what's happening with the midterms. And I think the reason for that is because there's already so much speculation about how it could go wrong or how it could be corrupted or how this experience is very different from all of our other election cycles. And so it's making me less eager to talk about it in the normal way. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: You know, like I the message I want to Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, totally. Ashlyn: share about the midterms isn't here's the candidates that are coming up that maybe could wait, it that Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: isn't as exciting to me as being real with people and being real with my audiences about like, look, I'm a journalist, I do this for a living, I'm already burned out. So if you are, that's okay. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Totally. What so I'm curious, like how do you decide, how do you curate what you share in your text messages? Ashlyn: a combination of things. So I use my background or my background in broadcast actually for kind of the way that I typically do that. So when I was a broadcast producer, we would like go through the stories of the day and kind of like create little keyword slugs for them and link them in a document and we would use that as a basis of like, okay, is this something we're gonna keep? If a bigger story got put in there, we would bump it. And that's pretty much the process that I use for my texting service throughout the week as stories come up that I think are important. So as stories come up that I think are important, I will create like a keyword slug for them. And I just have a run in Google Doc. So this week, for example, it's what's happening in Gary, Indiana. I, when I first learned that news, plugged it into my Google Doc, and when I go to write, I will. Nathan Young: I haven't heard about this yet. Ashlyn: There's like seventy-five thousand people in Gary, Indiana that have been without power and water for the last week in a predominantly black community. It's Nathan Young: wow. Okay, Ashlyn: from my perspective the first sign of an infrastructural collapse that we're maybe heading for. So, you know, Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Ashlyn: yeah, but and stories people don't know about, right? but that are important for understanding the national landscape. So that's Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Ashlyn: another piece of how I do my editorial selections is, there's a lot that comes from the White House that Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: is just noise. And traditionally Nathan Young: Yeah, totally. Yeah, yeah. And it's actually like just his propaganda. Ashlyn: Exactly. Yeah. And there are some things that come from the White House that are worthwhile, right? So Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: like if they are saying we might start doing this, that's not enough for me to Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: take it seriously. However, when they introduced ICE is gonna start wearing electric shot gloves, I'm like, that matters. That's important. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah, Ashlyn: so it's really up to my standard of Is this a what if or a maybe, or is this actually happening and going to affect you? And that's Nathan Young: Yeah. Ashlyn: how I determine what makes the cut. Nathan Young: Mm. That's interesting. And I guess is your do you feel your audience is relatively consistent in the kind of people they are and what they would be interested in and concerned by in that regard too or? Ashlyn: Yeah, typically. When people subscribe, I ask them to send me their two top issues, like the two things Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: that they're most interested in. And often that's healthcare, education, like trans rights, trans issues. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: So there's a pretty wide breadth of what people Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: are concerned about in my subscriber base, but I think the general sentiment that brings somebody to my texting service is Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: I'm overwhelmed by this and I need it to be made Nathan Young: Yeah. Ashlyn: simpler and I need somebody to do it in a way that doesn't make me feel sick. So Nathan Young: Totally, totally. Yeah, yeah. Ashlyn: I experiment with different formats and stuff. And I recently actually last week just unrolled a new format where instead of just kind of going through like top stories, I broke it down into top stories, here's what's happening in Congress, here's what's happening in the White House, here's what's happening in healthcare, Nathan Young: Mm. Mm. Ashlyn: and kind of broke it down by category, which is Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: a new thing, but people were very receptive to it. So, hopefully, yeah. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. I'm intrigued by it. It's funny. I'd had not even heard about this Gary Indiana thing. I probably listen to news way more than I should or need to. And it's interesting how just like certain things just get right by me and I come become aware of different news stories and my parents just watch Fox News all the time and they're at a completely different reality on there. There's completely different set of news stories that they're talking about on there all the time. Ashlyn: yeah. Nathan Young: And yeah. well that's so interesting. the other thing I think about too is even as somebody wants to hear about the news, there's so much stuff that comes my way that's like I don't need to know about this. maybe maybe s those and obviously are people are gonna be listening to this. It's gonna be like two months after today when people will be listening to this. But we just had like those primaries in Michigan and Wisconsin. And those were like talked over so much in the news. there was something worthwhile there, but as a person in California, I didn't need to hear as much as I heard about those primaries. Yeah. Ashlyn: Yeah, exactly. Nathan Young: cool, cool. And so when you say people that come to you they want about healthcare and education, trans rights, I mean are they coming are these the folks that are picking up your service is that a lot of it that yeah, like they they do want to sort of stay informed but they just don't want it to eat up a lot of their lives. And I'm guessing too, like if that's the case, they're not kind of consuming news for fun or even if I mean it's fun. I realize that like it's like entertainment even if it's like news and makes me upset, but it's like entertainment. but they want to know what's going on. Yes. Ashlyn: Right, because we're all addicted Yes, yes, exactly. because we're all addicted to kind of the dopamine hit, right? Of even if it's Nathan Young: Yeah. Ashlyn: bad for us, we still need to pay attention and that's the landscape we've been in for a while. But no, a lot of my subscribers are people who actively take time away from social media, who take Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: very active social media breaks. it's people who Don't necessarily trust mainstream media anymore and are more interested in the creator independent side of journalism. and people who maybe they do spend time on social media, maybe they do see a story, but they understand enough to know that a 90-second clip about something isn't giving you the full story. And Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Ashlyn: one of the key elements of the texting service is that it's a QA, it's an active QA. So Nathan Young: Hmm. okay. So they can ask you questions. wow. Ashlyn: Yes, that's why it's called Ask Ashlyn. so if I send you something that's like a breakdown of here's what's happening with the USS Abraham Lincoln and you have a question about it, you can just reply to me. I am Nathan Young: Mm. Ashlyn: a friend that you can text and ask about the news. Nathan Young: Okay. Ashlyn: And that's really how this was born, because I was doing that anyway. I was already the Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: friend that all of my people would text when they had a question about what was going on in Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Ashlyn: the news. So I just turned it into a business because it's something I enjoy doing. Nathan Young: Now I'm curious about what volume of questions do you get? Because I could see how that could be quite a thing too, right? Ashlyn: It's actually not too bad. most of my subscribers don't ask questions. Nathan Young: Mm, mm. Okay. Ashlyn: or like it'll be sporadic. It's not like every Nathan Young: Uh-huh. Ashlyn: time, because the updates I give they're concise, but they're pretty thorough. I manage to fit all of the information into Nathan Young: Mm. Ashlyn: a short little snippet of text. so if people have questions, I'll get them. But it's normally only like fifteen percent of the audience is sending me a question on any given day Nathan Young: Okay. Yeah. Ashlyn: which which is manageable. Nathan Young: Yeah. but if as you scale, I can see how that could get big. Okay. Ashlyn: Right. Then it's gonna be a different thing, but cross that bridge when we come to it. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, totally, totally. Cool. Well that's interesting. And I think it's just so interesting the way people consume news these days. And as I mentioned before we start recording, the podcast that just we're recording this the week that I rolled out the podcast with Jackie Bryant and we talked a lot about media in our world today and these shifts and the creator economy, getting the creator economy versus old school media and the more institutional media. it's just like it or not, it's fascinating that it's happening this way. And I kinda get why, but everything's a little yeah, it's just it's for every Ashlyn Ask out there, there's also Joe Rogan wannabe or something out there too, right? Like that and that's kind of Ashlyn: Right. Yep, definitely. Nathan Young: part of the problem. Yeah. Ashlyn: That's the whole problem. I don't know exactly what the latest data is, but I think from twenty twenty four the statistics were two thirds of journalism creators or news creators have zero background in journalism, Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah yeah. Ashlyn: which is a problem for so many reasons. Yeah. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, totally, totally. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Well, let's use that to segue into talking about media literacy then. Ashlyn: Okay, gladly. Nathan Young: And well Yeah, tell us about the work you do around media literacy first and what that is. Ashlyn: Yeah, so my media literacy education has been there's been a lot of different iterations of it. When I started my business, I started doing media literacy training events for different organizations. I hosted some at the library, I hosted some at different public parks and things like that just to try to generate or to try to gauge interest Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: in this type of conversation. and since then it's evolved. I have different event offerings that have shifted the idea of media literacy Into more of a wellness positioned thing. So I approach this from a lot of different angles, but specifically as it relates to events in my business, I host Doom Scroll Detox events, which are an opportunity for people to come together and talk about how media is affecting their well-being. Because I think modern media literacy is actually incredibly related to mental well-being, right? Like Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: If we stay plugged into our phones for 10 hours a day and we're scrolling every chance we get habitually without really being intentional about it, we are consuming so much more than we need to. And that affects Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: our mental health. And what is it that we're consuming? What is the quality of that information? What is it adding to your life or taking away from it? So Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: that's one of the approaches that I take to media literacy. within all of the trainings that I've done, it's Kind of the basics. How do you spot misinformation? How do you spot Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: bias? What is propaganda? And how do you learn to recognize it? how can you tell when something is AI? How can you tell Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: when something is glaringly missing context? How Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: do you read a news article and understand that the first two graphs are telling you the entire story and the entire point of view? Like there's just certain things that you learn as a journalist about Nathan Young: Yeah. Ashlyn: how to quickly spot tone and the way Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: that certain words are being used to describe something that people don't necessarily understand if they didn't Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: do that as work or as a career or receive that education. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: So, even within some of the trainings, a lot of the military reporting, there will be words like wrath or just very angry, heavy words about certain topics. And it's like, okay, how does that word in that headline affect Nathan Young: Yeah. Ashlyn: your perception of what this article is before you've even read it? Right. and I think that's so important, especially for the general masses. not just talking about adults within my age range, but like for younger kids that are growing up, like high schoolers, college kids who are growing up in this media ecosystem that has been totally rigged by chaos. It's I Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Ashlyn: think so important for them to learn this is telling you something before you've even read it. And you can spot Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: those cues once you learn to do so. another element of media literacy that's really important to me is not just as it relates to news, but as it relates to all media everywhere. So there's understanding social media context for sure, but there's also noticing the parallels in movies and TV and how that's being demonstrated to us in real life right now all the time. if you watch The West Wing or you Nathan Young: Okay. Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: watch House of Cards What does that tell you? How can you learn from those experiences, from that pop culture about how politics works? And then how can you see what's happening in the modern day being echoed in different Nathan Young: Mm. Ashlyn: media and TV? And I think, media is such a beautiful form because it's commentary. Media is always just social commentary. And the more that we can connect the dots between all of these different types of social commentary, the better informed we can be about everything that we're consuming. So it's a big landscape that Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: I work within because I think every corner of it is important. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. That's so interesting. one of the things I think about when it comes to media literacy is like, yeah, you and I have both worked in media and we're aware of it and we're think about this. And whether 'cause you listed a bunch of things that are sort of like nuanced and would be hard to really understand and get the whole picture behind unless you kind of knew how the sausage was made inside of a news media organization. And So on one hand, I have empathy with people that don't get it necessarily. And then also the people that do if you know enough to know the words media literacy, you're probably already sort of conscious of it. And if you're not conscious of it, you don't know what you're not conscious of. Is that okay? So then Ashlyn: Exactly. Yes. Yeah. You don't know what you're not conscious of. And especially on social media, which is a huge Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: part of what people social media, YouTube, all of this social video that people are consuming, right? Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: People that don't understand that a 90 second video of somebody calling themselves an expert and talking about something isn't necessarily credible, how would they know that if they didn't already know that? Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah, yeah, for sure. Well yeah. So I'm curious, what are the kind of things that come up, or the questions or the moments you notice or your certain perspectives you share that people really seem to like maybe flips a switch or gets them to to start looking at their own media differently. Ashlyn: that's a good question. I think conversations about consumption on social are usually the most eye opening for people. especially a lot of the AI stuff. these days it's getting better, but like a year ago, when I would lead trainings on like, do you think this photo is real or fake? And people would always get it wrong. That was eye opening to them. And like, here's this yeah. Like, yeah, that was AI a year ago, Nathan Young: Mm. Mm. Wow. And that's that was that was AI a year ago, too. Ashlyn: yeah. so I think, just the nuances are what is most interesting to people because again, you don't know what you don't know, right? So people that are well informed, that were college educated, that trust certain sources, not to go too heavy into hating on legacy, but like the New York Times in the journey that the New York Times has been on for the last couple of years. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Ashlyn: people that were diehard listened to the daily every week or every day, had a subscription, loved it, and then noticed or maybe didn't notice, it was pointed out to them that hey, the way that the story is framed is like kinda different from how it would have been framed a year ago. Something's shifting here. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: legacy media actively skipping certain stories. like, Nathan Young: yeah. Ashlyn: the USS Abraham Lincoln. There was kind of nothing about that in mainstream media. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Ashlyn: so the things that I've noticed is people being alarmed by where information is missing Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: and how incomplete information affects what they learn. Nathan Young: Yeah. Ashlyn: So, social media, anything, like an interview on social media Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: that's a ninety second clip of somebody talking. But the rest of that video is completely missing. You don't know what the context is. You can't really take anything from that. Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: so those types of things, people learning how to read between the lines, I guess, has been most eye-opening Nathan Young: Hmm. Yeah. Ashlyn: for them. Nathan Young: So with regards to that thought about recognizing what might not be included or talked about in the article or what might not even be covered. there's a part of me that worries with certain people when you say that their mind's gonna go straight to conspiracy thinking, like they don't want you to Ashlyn: Ha ha Nathan Young: know. and on some level, It's much less conspiratorial than that. Well that's my take at least. Ashlyn: Yes. Nathan Young: so I'm guessing like how are people processing that? Because, yeah, it's easy to be a conspiracy, but it's also be well, I don't you know, newspapers have limited resources. They can't cover everything and they have standards for a certain amount of evidence or truth or whatever that they can bring to bear to a store before they publish it. And then they're calculating who's interested in what and they have their subscription base and they have people that are on the board or people that are contributing money to it that they're trying to keep happy. So it's like, yeah, their own institution and they have their own sort of bias and inertia. And so it's not really like that's not a conspiracy. That's just they are what they are. I don't know, but do people get that and versus being like, they don't want you to know the media Ashlyn: I think I don't know that conspiracy is exactly the right word, though I Nathan Young: Mm. Ashlyn: do think conspiracy is something that we are all becoming more familiar with because Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: conspiracy, right, is a mistrust in the powers that be that are telling you things and disseminating information. And I think we are all or those who are educated and interested in media literacy are understanding every day we are developing less and less trust. In these institutions that previously we were able to trust. So is Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Ashlyn: that conspiracy or is that just awareness of how the landscape Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: is changing? but I think on the point about like, yes, it is corporate-run media has Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: a different agenda than you might as a consumer. Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: And I think that is pretty foundational to modern media literacy, because Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: as we notice the economy shifting and the way that this administration is affecting. Who's in charge, what voices are heard, what voices matter, and we're seeing a shift toward, in capitalism, the more money these corporations can make, the better off we're doing while everyone Nathan Young: Yeah. Ashlyn: else suffers. I think that's a very important element of understanding this. Because if you go to a legacy media outlet Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: not understanding that they're in this to make money, to keep their shareholders Nathan Young: Yeah. Ashlyn: happy, to stay on the good side of the administration, and you're Nathan Young: Mm. Ashlyn: reading it as if it's trustworthy and they're looking out for you. you're missing a huge piece of the context. So Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Totally, totally. Yeah. Ashlyn: I don't know that that's conspiracy as much as it's just like modern media awareness. Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. Well that's so interesting too, 'cause that's such a nuanced point to try and get across for somebody that again, like doesn't kind of come from media because yeah, I look at the New York Times and they're not lying to me. They're not necessarily withholding information, they're just coming from their own frame. And I know to take everything I read and take in from the New York Times, every headline, every word, every podcast through that lens, yeah, Ashlyn: The grain Yeah. Nathan Young: they're institutionalists, they're corporatists, that's the point of view they Have and that's gonna determine the stories that I get and I'll see stuff in the New York Times like fucking New York Times, but also I'll see stuff, but they're still Ashlyn: Yeah. Nathan Young: a legitimate news source. So yeah, again I sort of empathize with people that's a lot, that's a very nuanced position to take in for somebody that doesn't consume media the way probably you and I do, right? Ashlyn: Yes, it is nuanced, but that's not to say it can't be learned. I think that's another piece of the media literacy puzzle that is so important to me right now is as we have just a literacy crisis in general, right? Like Americans can't read. And so as that gap widens, so does the media literacy crisis, because you need literacy as a core piece of understanding what you read, understanding contexts and histories and how to put it all together to make a cohesive argument. And so the idea that certain people who are higher educated are capable of understanding nuance, or some people are capable of understanding nuance and it's harder for other people to, I don't necessarily agree with. I think it's just you don't know what you don't know, right? Nathan Young: Yeah. Ashlyn: and again with like teenagers or college kids. I've spoken to college kids in different college classes and stuff, and most of them, their media habits are still what their parents do. if their parents read the New York Times, they read the New York Times. Nathan Young: yeah, yeah. Ashlyn: if their parents listen to XYZ podcasts, that's what they listen to. I think that there is opportunity for everybody to understand nuance. It's just something that we're missing as a like foundation in literacy in general, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: but that doesn't mean it can't be taught. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, totally. And I guess my argument wouldn't necessarily be like I totally believe you learn it, but just sort our bandwidth for nuance, you know? Ashlyn: Our bandwidth for nuance is shortening every single day, it seems, especially in politics. Especially in politics. Yeah. Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah, totally. Yeah. we're talking about sort of legacy media there, New York Times and stuff, but obviously people are getting news from just random creators on Instagram and stuff like that. I mean how deep does the way you talk about media literacy go and how do you address these other formats that people are getting news from, like Substack, podcasts, Instagram creators, everything. Ashlyn: Substack kind of no comment. Nathan Young: Ha ha ha. Ashlyn: I am not on Substack and I don't plan to be on Substack. I think Nathan Young: Actually it sounds like there's something more there that I'm not aware of 'cause I think Ashlyn: Well Nathan Young: this is something that I haven't dug into yet. So I know like Heather Cox Richardson's on Substack. They must be great, right? She's great, but the Ashlyn: Yeah. Yeah. Love Heather Coxisherson. She's great. There's a lot who are great. There's a lot who were great and are not as great anymore. and I could talk about this for hours probably. But so Substack, this is not a completely formed opinion. I may I don't wanna be spreading misinformation here, but throughout the last year or two years or so, there have been Reported issues with Substack, like issues just in the way that they are running the business, like the cut that they take from writers is pretty significant. they have uplifted certain accounts that Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: a lot of people have disagreed with. And so Nathan Young: Yeah. Ashlyn: Substack within the independent journalism space, yes, a lot of people are using it, but there's also kind of a growing subset of people that are anti-Substack. and so I don't know all the details, I'm not qualified enough to completely speak on that. But Substack for me has existed as kind of a gray area. Nathan Young: less like Substack, but just this notion of these sort of like email subscription news sources. Yeah. Ashlyn: yeah, everybody's doing it. I think that's a great thing and a negative thing. So Nathan Young: Mm. Ashlyn: with the rise of creator journalism, let me dive into the social media of it specifically. Like Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah. Ashlyn: as someone who creates social content, I started at first doing news on social. I sat down and scripted out news reports based on what I had written for my text updates and then would turn them into social content, right? And I noticed that wasn't really performing. And it took me a year to figure this out. But the more that I got accustomed to news on social, the more that news on social kept growing and people kept watching the percentage of people that get their news from social media is just skyrocketing every single day. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: It started in 2020 and it keeps getting higher. And I think it's like major pros and major cons. it's a huge Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: pendulum swing in either direction. There's nothing neutral about this in my perception at all. it's Nathan Young: Mm. Ashlyn: great that all voices can be uplifted and people can connect with real people and audiences can connect with real people and have a more personal relationship with whoever is giving them news. That's fantastic. The grit, from my perspective, is that these platforms are not designed to uplift high quality information. They're designed to uplift what is aggravating, what is clickbaity, what will get the most engagement. And those two things are antithetical to each other. So Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Ashlyn: high quality information can be perceived as boring or not as interesting. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Ashlyn: And I think it's demeaning to a journalism creator to like have to be cooking or doing something crazy visually in order for their Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: information to be seen as valid by the algorithm. that's ridiculous. Nathan Young: You may have noticed that one of the recurring themes of this podcast is that the world as it is isn't the only world that's possible. And the people I talk with on here are often exploring different ways of leading, working, building community and creating change in the world here too. And you also may have noticed that we have a few problems in our world. Things aren't the way that a lot of us would like them. And many of the guests I've had on here have had on specifically for the ideas they have to share about what could make our world a better place. and this all gets back to the kind of work that I do too. This connection of leadership and social change. Very much part of the work I do. I work with leaders to help them own and share their own bold vision for a better world. Sometimes this means helping someone find the message in the heart of a talk they're giving or an overall message they're sharing about who they are and the kind of work they're doing. Sometimes it means helping an organization tell a clearer and more compelling story about the work they're doing and the change they're trying to make. And sometimes this even means helping my clients understand what it means to be courageous And applying that courage to the message they wanna share. Right now I do this primarily through coaching and consulting with leaders specifically, but also with some small organizations. I'm also developing a set of tools and training models around an idea I call narrative leadership, which is a framework for understanding how the stories we tell shape what we believe is possible and our ability to make these stories real. And I'll be sharing much more about this work here soon. So if any of this sounds interesting, it sounds like something that you could use help with for your either for yourself or for your organization, I'd love to hear from you. I'd love to see if we could work together. you can start by visiting my website which is storyculture consulting dot com or finding me on social media and all the channels. It's Nathan Cody Young on all of them. There are ways you can message me either through social media, through the website. So get in touch with me that way. And of course keep listening here. I plan to roll out some pieces of this here very soon. So as more and more of that comes together, you're all gonna be the first to hear about it. So thanks so much for listening to my little commercial here, And now let's get back to the episode. Yeah. Ashlyn: So I've noticed a lot of creators that have been at this for a while that are popular, like Mo News, Sharon says so, Jessica Yellen, that built credit you are or are not? Nathan Young: I'm not even familiar with these people. I'm not Ashlyn: well, they've been in the game for a while. All of these people kind of came up during COVID Nathan Young: Okay. Mm. Ashlyn: under the desk. Like there's just a group of Nathan Young: Mm. Mm. Ashlyn: The OG journalism creators that I've noticed in the last year or so are shifting to be more hot takes, shifting to be more Nathan Young: Mm, mm, mm. Ashlyn: and maybe it's what's more authentic to them, which is a different conversation. It's another element, it's a layer to add to this. But a lot of what is seen as credible is changing under Nathan Young: Yeah. Ashlyn: the creator journalism landscape. And Journalism ethics have not caught up to that. So Nathan Young: Mm. Ashlyn: it's like the Wild West. It's like it Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, totally. Ashlyn: in, yeah. I mean, as a creator journalist, something I struggle with every day is like, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: okay, I want to share my raw feelings about Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: this because I am educated on this topic and my raw feelings on it are well informed, right? Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: And I want to just kind of talk into the camera about whatever the issue is. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: and not be super buttoned up about exactly what I'm saying, because that's not authentic to me. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Ashlyn: So as we play with authenticity and the need for you to be seen as a real person and be engaging, it goes against the idea of journalism ethics that is like you can never share your opinion, you can never talk about, Nathan Young: Yeah. Ashlyn: you can never step outside the box. You're here to deliver straight facts. That's it. That's it. Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: And those things will go together. So creator journalists, whether they're good, trained Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: ethical journalists trying to navigate this space or not, everybody's kind of tiptoeing around what's the best way to do this. And there are a few creators Nathan Young: Yeah. Ashlyn: that I know of that are excellent at walking that line Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: and I'm so impressed with them. But for my content, the direction that I've started to go, because it's more authentic to me and easier to produce, is Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: I'd rather talk about media literacy than talk about news. Because talking about media Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Ashlyn: literacy is not it's important. It's like what I'm here to talk about. But Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: if I get something a little bit wrong when I'm riffing or doing a stream of consciousness to the camera, it's not Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: gonna affect my credibility as a journalist, right? if I get you and I Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: think that's a problem that we all are kinda navigating. I mean, there's a lot of really successful journalism creators, even smaller scale that don't have huge followings, like microcreators who are doing incredible work. But Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: I find that it's just a very high stakes environment for truth in building trust. And Nathan Young: Yeah. Ashlyn: it's hard to navigate. It's hard to navigate. Nathan Young: Yeah, definitely, definitely. And it is like I was born in seventy six. I'm like a one of those older younger Gen Xers. It came from like a part an era of time before there's any of this. And to sort of know what it used to be. And I get what for young people that like just as they're coming up and they're just realizing this is just news. This is normal for them. And to see it hear all this noise and get this and not yeah even recognizing like okay that's like an unrefined just camera phone footage of something that happened and there's a lot of convers Context that's probably missing. this is what Ashlyn: Yeah. Nathan Young: reporting is for, and yeah, recognize the difference between like editorial and news is also Ashlyn: Yeah. Nathan Young: a big thing and that was actually like institute, if you came up in the days before all this media, you sort of understood that a lot more because there'd be an editorial page and a news page in the newspaper. Whereas now Yeah, exactly. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Ashlyn: Right. Right. And the opinion section that was an entirely different thing, yeah. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. And even on old TV it would be presented that way and the opinion guy would be like, what really grinds my gears and that he was obviously the opinion guy or it was always a guy, right? Okay, okay. Ashlyn: Yeah. There was a well, I don't know. And I've seen some women, but yes, so yes. Nathan Young: But yeah, now you're just scrolling and There's no real obvious way to discern whether you're getting news or editorial or any of that. Yeah. Ashlyn: It's all mashed together. And it can be all mashed together in one video, which I'm not necessarily knocking. I don't think that's Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: impractical or irresponsible, but I do think for somebody that's not media literate, it's very hard to understand I think the line between opinion and well reported fact is tricky. And especially for people that are coming up as creator journalists, trying to navigate the landscape and build audiences, everything from the social media side says we need to see your opinion. We need to see Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: your true self, right? And everything from the journalism side is no well reported facts, people need high quality information and both can be true. But Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: both are true. And Nathan Young: Yeah. Ashlyn: so it's yeah, it's a mess. What was the question that you asked me before? Nathan Young: I was just kinda riffing on editorial versus news and opinion, and how that was Ashlyn: Yeah. Nathan Young: so obvious there and coming from, just being used to being of my age and having that the news just used to be organized that way. So as a core Ashlyn: Yeah. Nathan Young: concept, I get that. I'm not sure if there was a question. I just sort of opined and let you roll with Ashlyn: Okay. Yeah. No, the age thing is definitely interesting because the way that people consumed news Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: even twenty years ago Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: is entirely different than the way that people consume now consume news now. another big issue with the media industry for me is the twenty-four hour news cycle. I have Nathan Young: Yeah. Ashlyn: long been against the twenty-four hour news cycle, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: since I worked in broadcast. And what social media has done is made it even more intense. It's not just Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: a 24-hour news cycle anymore. Now it's like an every five minute, every time you refresh news cycle. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: And when we talk about media overwhelm, which is a huge part of the work that I do, right? it's not just you pick up the newspaper, you read it, you're done for the day, you do the same thing tomorrow morning. Now it's you can go onto your phone, pick it up habitually, and you will see Something about Trump, something about war, somebody decorating a cake, something about a new movie that's coming out, an interview with like the stars of Ted Lasso, and then Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Ashlyn: something about how we're all running out of water, and something about how all the water basins are empty. And Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: you will go through that screen, and then you'll see a picture of somebody's vacation that you can't afford, right? So it's like you Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah. Ashlyn: will go you you will go through plus fifty percent of that is ads that you don't know the people or they're just trying to sell you something. So Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. Ashlyn: In your endless scroll, you're getting news content if you're a person who subscribes to it, which I think Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: I'm sure there are some people who don't get any news on their algorithms, but Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: more power to them. it's so it's like Nathan Young: Mm. Ashlyn: the overwhelm of it all of like here's a piece of news that's really inflammatory, here's somebody cleaning a carpet, here's a cat you've never seen, here's an advertisement for a product you don't need, Nathan Young: Yeah. Ashlyn: that scroll cycle Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: is so detrimental to our mental health and to our media consumption and to our media literacy. And Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: so from my perspective, it's not just about learning how to read the news for what is worth your time and what isn't. It's also about learning how to set boundaries with yourself about how much you are consuming. Nathan Young: Mm. Yeah, yeah. Ashlyn: Because that's a piece that people are missing, right? we're so used to the 24 hour news cycle of like, okay, you watch the news from six to seven every night, or like the way that different generations did it, where it was like it was a set period of time where you would catch up. Nathan Young: Mm. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: And that's not how it is anymore. Now it's all day Nathan Young: Mm. Ashlyn: long in front of your face. And the push alerts sending you things throughout your day. I don't think that is practical anymore. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: There are very few things that are important or urgent enough that we need to Nathan Young: Yeah. Ashlyn: know about them the second they happen. And Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: Creator journalism is not doing that any favors. There are certain creators that everything is breaking news, right? There are certain creators right. And it's like, exactly. Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Guys, I got some breaking news right now. It's like that's a week old. Ashlyn: And it's like that doesn't do anything for anybody. I remember Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: even back in my broadcast days, we wanted to retire the term breaking news because like, unless it was actually something that was very urgent that was immediately affecting you, it's not breaking news. just because it's new right now doesn't mean that it's the scale of what we determine as breaking news is different than what it should be from a mental health and just public comfort level perception, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: not everything needs to be high urgency. Not everything needs your attention immediately. There's a lot of things Nathan Young: Totally, totally. Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: that can wait until tomorrow or the next day and you'll be perfectly fine. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah, definitely. Yeah. think part of where that goes back to also though, it's a business. all these creators, they are it's their job or their gig or their aspiration that whether they're making money off it or not, they're at least like Ashlyn: Right. Nathan Young: part of it is they're hoping to it someday. And Ashlyn: Yeah. Nathan Young: and I think it's funny 'cause yeah, I think of some of the earlier I don't really have names off the top of my head, but I did sort of see some early creators that I followed for news start to kind of just kinda get more more and more unhinged in one direction or another Ashlyn: Mm. Nathan Young: based of what they were sharing. I'm thinking of Glenn Greenwald Matt Taibbi or something like that I think those are I don't know. But they used to be actual journalists. Yeah. And Ashlyn: my time. Mm-hmm. Nathan Young: they just kinda went really sort of bonkers in within the context of the news they're reporting. and I don't if that was just sort of their true colors came out or if they kind of got radicalized one way or if they're like, well, you know I write about this and I get a lot more clicks and I make a lot more money. So that's what I do. Ashlyn: True. Yeah. there is absolutely on social the incentive in I'm sure in all of the subscription, on Substack on all the places, I'm sure there's an incentive for people, the more engagement you can get, the more money you'll make. That's absolutely a Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: part of this problem. But I also think, what people like Don Lemon, Terry Moran, where you get booted from traditional media and then you start your own thing. I think that does give people some more leeway to show more of their true colors and their interpretation of this news. But Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: I think also within that, it kind of all comes back to the idea of like what is a credible source, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: and credibility is determined by each individual person who is consuming the news. Like Nathan Young: Yeah. Ashlyn: what I deem as credible and Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: what somebody who really likes Joe Rogan deem as credible are different. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: so that's like all another key piece of the media literacy puzzle is teaching people what a credible source actually is. And Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: one of the issues that we have with the current administration is Nathan Young: Mm. Ashlyn: historically what the White House said, press releases from the White House were credible. They're not anymore. So Nathan Young: Mm. Mm. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Ashlyn: if you're still living in the nineties Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: in your media mindset. And you think that if the White House says it it must be true, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: you are completely understanding, misunderstanding the context. Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: And that creates a problem for journalists that are trying to operate with objectivity, the objectivity that we've come to expect of traditional journalism. Because Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Ashlyn: if one of the sources, or one branch of the government, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: one entire side of the political discourse Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: is no longer as credible. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Ashlyn: Then what is neutrality? What does that really look like? and so when you position people like Terry Marianne or Ligdon Lemon, where it's like, okay, are they speaking out of turn from their opinion, or are they addressing Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: the fact that a lot of this information that we've touted as being equivalent for the sake of Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: neutrality is no longer that way, right? Nathan Young: Yeah, totally, totally. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. Yeah, I think about that a lot too. 'Cause I'll listen to like the White House press conferences or like clips of it, and it's like, why are you fucking teeing this guy up to just like tell you lies Ashlyn: Yeah. Nathan Young: in a circumstance where like you cannot push back? Yeah. And Ashlyn: Right. Yeah. Nathan Young: then that just like well, the president said it 'cause like what the president says is news. So that gets broadcast Ashlyn: Mm. Nathan Young: out and and yeah, you're right, like they're just they'll just say whatever. Yeah. It's Yeah, it is it's maddening. Ashlyn: my god, yeah. that's why like it's so difficult. I can't imagine the people that stay tapped in all the time. I'm sure they must still exist, but I could not be one of them. I will for my business and for the texting service, I will watch the speeches, I will watch the state of the unions, I'll watch the debates. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: And it's aggravating sometimes to have to listen to what is like just Blatantly untrue or blatant propaganda or and Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Ashlyn: that's non-specific to any particular party. Like they both are infuriating. Let's get that straight. but Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah, totally. Yeah, yeah, for sure. Ashlyn: just the nature of like, okay, we really cannot trust this leadership that is supposed to be this credible source of information for how things are going. And Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: maybe that loops us back to conspiracy. And you know, all the people Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, totally. Yeah, yeah, for sure. Yeah. We're in Ashlyn: who have been saying for decades that we can't trust the government, like maybe, Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: they were just a few years ahead of the rest of us. Nathan Young: Yeah, well again, you know, like skep you the find this middle ground between trust and skepticism of like where Ashlyn: Yeah. Nathan Young: they're coming from. 'Cause I think part like part of where my mind goes too is it's not necessarily even about like the presidents or elected leaders, but also like the agencies. you kinda had some faith that the Bureau of Labor Statistics was giving valid information. Yeah, exactly. Ashlyn: Right. Or the C D C or the FCC or the FDA. Yeah. Yeah. Nathan Young: Yeah. And recognize that like these but these are also flawed organizations that can make mistakes and like I mean COVID Ashlyn: Absolutely. Nathan Young: COVID was such a perfect example. I saw people be like, Are we wearing masks or not? And it's like, I don't know, like they're trying to figure this out too. Like just Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. Anyways Ashlyn: Right. We're all trying to figure it out every single day. Yeah. Yeah. It's a you don't for anybody that's like trying to stay informed right now, it is such a difficult job. And I think that's maybe an important part of the conversation as well, because it's like Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: staying informed. There's so much information. How could it not be easy to stay informed? It's everywhere, it's all around you all the time. And I think that makes it harder. Nathan Young: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: Because you now need to discern what is good information, what is bad information. You need to be vetting Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Ashlyn: every single source, you need to be fact checking every statistic that comes from certain agencies. And that's more work than most people are gonna do. Exactly. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. We have no time for that. Yeah. Ashlyn: So how do you develop a relationship with news if Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: you awake to the idea that all of this is all over the place. You Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: can't just sit down and read the paper and trust what you read. Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah, yeah, for sure. Ashlyn: It's it's a lot to navigate. Nathan Young: So when you talk about that credibility piece there before too, what are some ways that you share for people to help determine like what sources are credible and what sources aren't and what they hear there in that regard? Ashlyn: Well, when I've done the media literacy training, I have often kind of outlined a list of like these are the news organizations that are credible that we know Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: are not bought, right? Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: unfortunately a number of the organizations on that list are now behind a paywall. W which, yes, and the paywall thing is Nathan Young: They they have been bought. Yeah, well yeah, that too. that Yeah. Ashlyn: I actually got into like kind of a heated conversation over Instagram with a friend of mine over paywalls where he was like talking about how great they were and I was ten toes down and like, no, this is horrible for the information environment. Nathan Young: Mm, mm. I know. Ashlyn: but there's a few ways to test whether something is credible. And like the way that you judge a traditional news organization is different than the way that you judge a creator. The way that you judge a traditional news organization is who are their sources. How are they describing this information? Does it seem contextualized or does it seem like any in any way hyperbolic? Does it like the AP is an organization that I keep coming back to as one that I trust? The Nathan Young: Mm. Ashlyn: Guardian, overseas media, one that I keep coming back to as trust. the BBC, prior to their paywall, was one that I always trusted. but a lot of the bigger legacy organizations like CNN tends to have a bias. Nathan Young: Mm. Ashlyn: ABC these days you can tend to have a bias. NBC sometimes will have a bias. And I have worked at all of these, like I'm not Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Ashlyn: knocking them as a, you know, but it also is up to the individual reporter. I think before this era of news and journalism and politics, people were able to give a lot more grace to Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: individual reporters writing certain stories. Right, it was you would read something, you would feel like you know what's going on, then you would put it away and not think about it for the rest of the day. Nathan Young: Mm. Ashlyn: But now, with how much is out there, we Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: are so inundated with it and we are so able to nitpick like this story from the New York Times or this story from you know, New York Times or NBC, this is good information they're sharing. But down Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: here in the third paragraph, it seems like they really editorialized that. And Nathan Young: Yeah. Ashlyn: Maybe not everybody reads for that, but I certainly do. So it's Nathan Young: Mm. Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: it's we used to be able to just not have to pay as much attention and not have to give as much weight to every single word that was written in an article, and that's not the case anymore. But Nathan Young: Mm hmm. Mm hmm. Yeah. Ashlyn: for creators and how to vet creators specifically, there's a lot of different kind of tenants that people depend on. And I do a lot of work with Trusting News. Are you familiar with that organization? Nathan Young: Mm. No, no, actually no. Ashlyn: They're cool. It's like a research nonprofit that conducts different studies to see how people develop trust in news. And I it's a Nathan Young: Hmm. interesting. Okay. Ashlyn: great team. I love them very much. and I've done a lot of work with them. I'm actually on their journalism advisory board this year. And they have released lists of like what is trustworthy in a creator. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: How can you decide to put your trust in a creator? And often it's similar, how do you cite your sources? How do you talk about the money that you're making and where you're getting it from? How transparent are you about the what you're working on and how you're working on it? how transparent are you about AI? So in Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: the way that you use AI. So I think for the creator landscape, it's a little bit of a different set of rules, but not entirely. A lot of the same Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Ashlyn: foundations are applicable to modern media and legacy media. But Ultimately what makes a trustworthy source comes down to your individual interpretation because everybody has biases. There is not a single person on this planet that does not have a bias towards something. And Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, yeah, totally. Mm hmm. Mm hmm. Yeah. Yeah. Ashlyn: so you will find the people that have similar biases to you more credible than the people who don't. Nathan Young: Mm. Mm. Yeah. Confirmation bias basically. Yeah. Yeah. We all s yeah. Ashlyn: Confirmation bias, yes. And what I would say to anybody that is like trying to figure Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: out what makes a credible source is look at how they share information. Look at the language that they use, look at the way that they source it, what they point to as their basis, who are they quoting, what kind of quotes are they using? We have a long list of these in my media literacy training that I'll just put up on the PowerPoint and be like, you should read for all of this and ask every single one of these questions to yourself about everything you're reading. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: because that's kind of the only way to do it. Like, how are you fundraising? Who are your influences? Who did you partner with? Is this an ad? Who do you advertise with? Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: what do those advertisers, what is their business? Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: how are their other partnerships demonstrating what their views might be? it's Nathan Young: Two. Ashlyn: so much deeper than just like, do I like what this guy has to say? It can be that Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah. Ashlyn: simple, but not if you want to be well informed. So Nathan Young: Yeah, totally, totally. Yeah. I always think the advertisers are sort of an interesting tell, like who's advertising on there because that Ashlyn: Yeah. Yes. Nathan Young: that sort of tells you like who's spending money to reach your ears and and who do they think you are to when Ashlyn: Yes, exactly. Right. Yes. Nathan Young: everything being advertised is like supplements and anything sort of weird, you're like, that's that's they they think you're a sucker. Ashlyn: Yeah. Or like the Axios newsletters. And I know Axios has kind of gone through different iterations of trust too, but their advertisers in their newsletters have been like Walmart and Chevron. And these Nathan Young: Mm. Ashlyn: are organizations that a lot of us don't deem necessarily as like being top tier of credibility and looking out for our interests. So Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah, toy. Ashlyn: it's an ongoing like media literacy is not a static thing that you learn once. It is something that you have to practice and apply every single day with every new thing that you learn. And Nathan Young: Mm. Totally. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: that's why it's so important. Because information you keep in your back pocket, but it's information that needs to always be applied. It's Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah. Yeah. I mean that's such a good point 'cause I mess up sometimes too, you know. Or like I get yeah, yeah. Yeah. Ashlyn: yeah, we all do. I totally do. I will like I am a there was a period of time, I'm better about it now, but I was a sucker for like I would read the first couple paragraphs of an article and be like, this is good, I should share it. And then be like, Nope, read the whole thing. You cannot share it before you read the whole thing. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Ashlyn: Or like watch the first 30 seconds of a video and then want to repost it and be like, actually, no, I have to watch this whole thing Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: before I'm willing to reshare what this person says. but people don't do that, you know? And Nathan Young: Yeah. Yeah. Ashlyn: like Misinformation is such a riveting topic for me because most people that share misinformation don't know that they're doing it. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Ashlyn: Because it's like disinformation, information that is intended to be negative or to spread bad information is Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: completely different than somebody who like misspeaks or misunderstands Nathan Young: Yeah. Ashlyn: something and then repeats it. There's Nathan Young: Toy, toy. Ashlyn: an evil approach and then there's just the Nathan Young: Yeah. Ashlyn: misinformed one. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: And it's so easy for people to not understand that they're sharing something that isn't correct. And that's like the Facebook problem. Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, for sure. And we all have the ability to just hit share. Ashlyn: Yes, and we all have the ability to hit share and spread it even wider and then those opinions or ideas or reporting, whatever it is that we share, then becomes part of our personal Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: media diet, even if it's not necessarily true. So Nathan Young: Yeah, yeah, definitely. Yeah. Ashlyn: It's it's a big world. It's a big media Nathan Young: That's a lot. Ashlyn: Yeah. Big media pie we're all eating into every day and it's just it's messy. It's it's not Nathan Young: Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Ashlyn: as clean as it once was. So Nathan Young: Yeah. Ashlyn: it's important to understand how to sift through the mess. Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Well, hopefully for the sake of the people listening, we maybe we covered a little bit here today. And there's Ashlyn: Yeah, hopefully. Nathan Young: lots more we could do, but we kinda I try and keep these podcasts under an hour and we're getting close to that. Ashlyn: Yeah, fair. Nathan Young: So let's just we'll we'll call it here. And Ashlyn: Okay, great. Nathan Young: let's see. so people that were intrigued by what they heard from you, how the can they find you? How can I sign up for your text news d yeah. Ashlyn: Yeah, absolutely. You can sign up for my texting service at joinsubtext.com forward slash askashlyn and the link I'm sure will be included here. you can Nathan Young: Yeah, put in the show notes. Ashlyn: also find me on social media at ask.ashlyn on Instagram and ask underscore ashlyn on TikTok. I'm also on YouTube and you can always just reach out to me kind of on any platform. I would love to chat with people because ultimately the point of my business is to connect Nathan Young: Mm-hmm. Ashlyn: with people about news. I'm here to be your journalist friend that can help you understand stuff. I wanna be an authentic resource for people to ask questions and to understand what's going on. And if you encounter a video that you find on social media and you're like, is this credible or not? Send it to me. I'll vet it for you, Nathan Young: Yeah. Ashlyn: so it's yeah, reach out to me whenever you Nathan Young: Mm. Ashlyn: can also shoot me an email at my website, we'll link as well. It's askashlyn.co. And yeah, I would love to chat with anybody that's interested in learning more about the work that I'm doing or media literacy in general. Nathan Young: Yeah. And yeah, and you do trainings too, so could a teacher call you to come do a thing or like Okay. Ashlyn: 100% teachers, people that run volunteer organizations or nonprofits, Nathan Young: No. Ashlyn: businesses, anybody that runs any kind of organization. I had somebody from a retirement home reach out to me to do an AI training. I was like, absolutely, yes. Like Yeah, like I would gladly, Nathan Young: That's my gosh, actually that's like great Yeah. Ashlyn: yes. so yeah, anybody that's interested in media literacy education and wanting to share it with your group or your business or your students, Please, yes, reach out to me. Nathan Young: Okay, awesome. All right. Well, Ashlyn, thanks so much for joining us on the podcast and yeah, Ashlyn: Yeah. Of course. Thanks for having me. Nathan Young: we'll talk again soon. Ashlyn: Okay, sounds good. Nathan Young: All right, thank you so much for Ashlyn Raine for joining me on the podcast. One thing I'm taking from this conversation is that media literacy isn't just about catching a fake headline or figuring out which source is good and which is bad. It's practice. It's like paying attention to framing, incentives, context, and our own habits. And this also includes the things we share and like how we talk about the news with others too, right? And there's another piece I appreciate, which is like staying informed doesn't have to mean being available to every update, every breaking news story all day long. We can take the news seriously and still have boundaries around our attention. I think the fact that some of the things we talked about in the podcast that are like completely forgettable stories by the time this podcast published a couple months later is a rather indicative of how that could go too. So if you appreciate this conversation, you can find Ashlyn through At her Ask Ashlyn platform and her social media channels. We'll include links to all those in the show notes, but you can also just find Ask Ashlyn on social media. And if this conversation gave you a new way to think about your relationship with the media and information, leave a comment, share the episode with someone else who you think might find it useful, and leave us a comment somewhere too. And with that, let's wrap this up. Thank you so much for listening to Braver New Worlds, and we will see you on the next one.