Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use Buybacks to Signal Confidence
Transcript
- Lucas: If these conversations are useful for what you're building or running, there's a small but meaningful way to keep them going ad-free — I'll get to that later. First, let's talk about buybacks. Luna: You mean the wave of share repurchases we're seeing from post ipo tech companies this month? Lucas: Exactly. It's been a rough week for growth stocks — Palantir down over 10 percent in five days, Coinbase off nearly 7, Shopify down more than 5. Even the mega-caps aren't immune: Microsoft dropped 6.7 percent, Apple 4.3 percent. Luna: That's a lot of red. And in that environment, some of these companies are announcing buybacks. What's the thinking? Lucas: It's a signal. When a company repurchases its own stock, management is saying, 'We think the market has undervalued us.' It's a direct vote of confidence — and it uses real cash, not just words. Luna: But isn't that risky? If the stock keeps falling, you're essentially catching a falling knife. Lucas: Absolutely a risk. But the math works in their favor if the stock eventually recovers. The key metric is earnings per share — EPS. Fewer shares outstanding after a buyback means higher EPS, all else equal. That can support the stock price over time. Luna: So it's a tool to manage the optics of earnings during a downturn. Lucas: Partly. But it's not just optics. Look at Palantir — down 10 percent in a week. They have a massive insider lockup expiring soon. A buyback can absorb some of that selling pressure. It's a way to protect long-term shareholders. Luna: Right, because if employees and early investors are dumping shares, the stock could get crushed even more. Lucas: Precisely. And it's not just Palantir. We've seen several post ipo companies announce buyback programs in the last month — some as large as 5 percent of outstanding shares. It's becoming a pattern. Luna: What about the cost? I mean, if you're a young company still investing in R&D, is that really the best use of cash? Lucas: That's the pushback you hear from value investors. The classic argument: every dollar spent on buybacks is a dollar not spent on building the business. For a company like Palantir or Coinbase, AI and product development are still the priority. Luna: So why not just hold the cash? Lucas: Two reasons. One, cash on the balance sheet earns almost nothing. Two, a buyback signals that management believes the stock is cheap. If they're wrong, they wasted capital. If they're right, they create value for remaining shareholders. Luna: But the market doesn't always reward that signal. Sometimes buyback announcements get ignored or even punished. Lucas: True. Especially if investors think the company is trying to prop up the stock rather than focusing on fundamentals. But in this environment, with growth stocks getting hammered, I think the signal is more credible than usual. Luna: Because the selloff is broad? It's not just one company's problem? Lucas: Exactly. When the whole sector drops, a company-specific buyback says 'we're not like the rest.' And that kind of differentiation matters when you're competing for investor attention. Luna: Let's talk about the elephant in the room — OpenAI is reportedly filing for IPO. That's going to change the landscape for a lot of these companies. Lucas: Huge. If OpenAI goes public, it'll be one of the largest tech IPOs ever. And it'll force every ai focused company to justify their valuation relative to a new benchmark. Luna: Does that affect buyback decisions? I mean, if your stock is already under pressure and a giant competitor is coming to market... Lucas: It could accelerate buybacks. Companies might want to reduce share count before a big new entrant absorbs investor dollars. It's a preemptive move. Luna: So buybacks are not just about the past — they're about positioning for the future. Lucas: Right. And that's why I find this current wave so interesting. It's not panic buying. It's strategic. Luna: Speaking of strategic moves — I know we don't run ads on these conversations, and that's intentional. If you find value in the ad-free format, there's a simple way to support it. Lucas: Yeah, we keep it independent. If you want to help cover the cost of producing these episodes, you can find us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure — just an option if the content is useful to you. Luna: And it genuinely helps us keep the focus on the stories that matter, without any sponsor influence. Lucas: So back to buybacks — one more angle I want to explore. The timing. Why now, specifically? Luna: Is it just because stocks are down? Lucas: Partly. But there's also a regulatory factor. In 2025, the SEC tightened rules around insider trading blackout periods. That made it harder for executives to buy shares personally. So the company stepping in with a buyback is a workaround. Luna: Interesting. So the buyback becomes a substitute for insider purchases. Lucas: Exactly. And it's more scalable. One buyback program can absorb millions of dollars in selling pressure, whereas insider buys are typically smaller and more symbolic. Luna: What about companies that are less profitable? Can they still do buybacks? Lucas: They can, but they have to be careful. If a company is burning cash, a buyback can look reckless. Investors might question whether management is prioritizing short-term stock price over long-term health. Luna: So it's a balancing act. Use buybacks when you have the cash flow and the stock is cheap, but don't overdo it. Lucas: That's the ideal. And some of the best capital allocators — think Berkshire Hathaway, Apple — have used buybacks brilliantly over the years. But for younger tech companies, the track record is mixed. Luna: What's the worst-case scenario? Lucas: The classic example: a company borrows money to buy back stock at a high price, then the stock crashes. Now you have debt and less equity. That's destructive. Luna: But in the current environment, most of these post ipo companies are using cash, not debt. Lucas: Correct. So the risk is more about opportunity cost. Could that cash have been better spent on an acquisition or R&D project? That's a harder question to answer. Luna: And that's why investors should look at each buyback in context. Not all buybacks are created equal. Lucas: Right. The ones that get the market's respect are the ones backed by strong free cash flow and a clear strategy. The ones that feel like desperation — those get punished. Luna: So as we watch this week's selloff unfold, the buyback announcements will be a telling signal. Lucas: They already are. And with OpenAI's IPO on the horizon, the stakes are only getting higher.