Latest / Kentuckiana's Morning News Early Edition w/Scott Fitzgerald / Dr. Charles Pemberton on A.I. Therapy
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: Good morning. I'm Tony Cruz News Radio A forty whas
- 0:03doctor Charles Pepperton, a longtime friend of mine, and the
- 0:07show is joining us here to mentioned family therapy. Louisvilledft
- 0:11dot com. Hey Charles, how are you?
- 0:13Speaker 2: I am doing well? Good morning, Tony.
- 0:15Speaker 1: Good morning. I hope your health is mentally good.
- 0:19Speaker 2: Hey.
- 0:21Speaker 1: So this is a thing now and I just it's
- 0:24hard for me to really wrap my head around it.
- 0:27And that's artificial intelligence therapy. People are actually asking AI
- 0:34for responses and what they should do in their lives.
- 0:38Speaker 2: They are and there's actually AIS being used in multiple
- 0:42other areas within mental health. Now this is the one
- 0:46that's kind of hitting the market and hitting the news.
- 0:48And you should know that at the moment, I'm a
- 0:51little biased because I really don't think AI can do
- 0:55what a human can do, So I'm a little biased
- 0:58in that. But not only is it being utilized to
- 1:01help people, you know, you call or you text them
- 1:04and they tell you automated this AI responds to you.
- 1:09It's also being used to help therapists write notes, so
- 1:15your therapist can actually record the session and it will
- 1:20it will translate that into a note for the therapists,
- 1:23so the therapist no longer has to write notes. We
- 1:28actually have cases where clients, patients are paying AI engines
- 1:36to record their sessions and the therapist to upload it
- 1:41to improve their AI. So there's a whole lot of
- 1:45aspects of AI being used in mental health, and I'm
- 1:49a little worried as a professional about a lot of those.
- 1:53Speaker 1: Well, let's go to law first. I mean, as I
- 1:56was reading an article, it said human therapists are required
- 2:00by federal law to keep patients health information confidential. Right,
- 2:04that's that's.
- 2:05Speaker 2: What we do, is it yep?
- 2:07Speaker 1: But the checkbots and are necessarily they have no such obligation.
- 2:12And so if you're starting to say, if your therapist
- 2:14is sending you know, your stuff to AI, then that
- 2:19could be I get, I could assume stolen intel or
- 2:24information here.
- 2:25Speaker 2: Well, okay, so one your therapist is bound that if
- 2:30we utilize a service, that service needs to follow the
- 2:34same hipp of guidelines we are and if not, then
- 2:38I would be held accountable. So if you and I
- 2:40had a session and I uploaded your information to whatever
- 2:44hip whatever AI for whatever reason, if it wasn't mandated
- 2:49and guaranteed to be Hippo compliant, you as the patient
- 2:53could hold me responsible. However, if you are as a
- 2:58patient talking to an AI, could do you hold responsible?
- 3:03I mean because that AI is not mandated, because it's
- 3:09not licensed, it's not a medical professional, it's not a person,
- 3:15so it doesn't fall under those same obligations as I
- 3:20do as an individual and a human.
- 3:24Speaker 1: Well, I was reading that one person liked AI better
- 3:29than the therapist that she had because the appairly, the
- 3:33device she was using, was just giving her the facts
- 3:38you need to basically get rid of this loser in
- 3:40your life and move on.
- 3:43Speaker 2: That well, and you know, right, and some and there
- 3:47are times that these that these tools, I am sure
- 3:51can be helpful. What worries me the most is all
- 3:54the guardrails that they don't have in place yet, Protections
- 3:58for the client, for the individual, because we're talking about
- 4:02people that can be very, very vulnerable, and AI is
- 4:06not smart enough yet to know the right thing to
- 4:10say the right time to say it. And I'm not
- 4:13saying human therapist are either, But at least then there's
- 4:16some guard rails, and there's a lot of training and
- 4:19there's a natural instinct that I hope most of us
- 4:24as therapists have ais don't have.
- 4:26Speaker 1: That you mean a soul in compassion, Well, that would.
- 4:30Speaker 2: Be the yes, those would be the words absolutely.
- 4:33Speaker 1: All right. More coming up with Charles Pepperton dimension family
- 4:36therapy next, all right, look into computers now to be
- 4:40your therapist probably not a good idea, just my take,
- 4:44but Charles Pepperton's take as well. So this story from
- 4:48The Washington Post, a reporter asked chat GPT Charles if
- 4:52it could help process deeply personal thoughts, and it responded affirmatively,
- 4:58offering to help you work through your thoughts in a
- 5:01safe a way that feels safe, and to offer perspective
- 5:04without judgment. Well, you know that the computer's not necessarily
- 5:11looking at you, seeing your response and your uncomfortable positioning,
- 5:15seeing your eyes bat you know, if you're lying to
- 5:17your therapist blah blah blah blah blah, on and on
- 5:19and on. So I don't know, we've got a long
- 5:21way to go with that.
- 5:22Speaker 2: I think I would agree with you. And you know,
- 5:25it's that same idea of people that are doing telehealth
- 5:29has been very beneficial to a lot of people, and
- 5:32even on the therapist side, it's a whole lot easier
- 5:35to you know, with telehealth than to actually do in
- 5:39person therapy. But in person therapy gives the therapist so
- 5:45much more information. And when you're talking about you know,
- 5:48a chat, GPT or an AI, they're getting even less
- 5:52information because all they're processing is you know, the speed
- 5:56of your words and the words you're using. They're not
- 6:00taking an account any of those non verbals that a
- 6:04therapist should pick up on. And the other side of
- 6:08that is, as someone said in that same article, that well,
- 6:11it really improved my mental health. You know, in one
- 6:15of the basic beliefs within therapy is is that therapists
- 6:18don't improve your mental health. We point out the way
- 6:21to go, you know, the path. You're the one that
- 6:25does the work. And it really concerned me in that
- 6:27article where a patient believe the computer helped improve their
- 6:33mental health. And I know that's a fine line to walk,
- 6:36but that does concern me.
- 6:38Speaker 1: Yeah.
- 6:39Speaker 2: Sure, I will say. Another big concern that I have,
- 6:43and this is a longer term issue, is I think
- 6:46we're creating a more division in availability for services. I
- 6:52think common sense face value would say at this point,
- 6:55a real therapist doing in person work is going to
- 6:59be better than an AI, but people are moving to
- 7:02AIS because they can't afford therapist, because therapists aren't necessarily
- 7:08readily available. So we're creating another division of care because
- 7:13those that can afford it will get in. Those that
- 7:17don't have to use their insurance can pay for fee
- 7:21for service, and we have a lot of people that
- 7:24are just left on the flip.
- 7:25Speaker 1: Side of that.
- 7:26Speaker 2: AI means that, well, maybe I can't charge as much
- 7:29for my services because well, there's this computer that can
- 7:33talk to millions of people at the same time, I
- 7:36think we have to be very careful about the long
- 7:38term strategies that we're doing. Are we kind of pricing
- 7:42real therapist out of the market.
- 7:44Speaker 1: Well, I mean that's a twofold. That's not even a
- 7:47twofold questions. That's a lot of folds to be honest
- 7:50with you, because I mean, this is basically not just healthcare,
- 7:54but this is I mean mental health care, this is
- 7:56healthcare in general. There are so many people I know,
- 7:59people say, okay, there there's Obamacare. Well, a lot of
- 8:01people make too much money to get Obamacare, but it
- 8:04certainly don't make enough money if they're a private contractor
- 8:08to have their own health care situation that's anywhere near affordable.
- 8:11You know, if you've got a family of four and
- 8:13you got to pay twenty six hundred dollars a month
- 8:16because you know, you're a Stonemason or something like that,
- 8:20then it's going to be hard to make it.
- 8:23Speaker 2: You're right, And so on one hand, people need these
- 8:26services and they're going to have to get these services
- 8:29wherever they can. But if we're not careful, they may
- 8:33be getting a subpar service. So we have to be
- 8:36careful of that aspect. We can't price ourselves out of
- 8:40the market for any of these any of these healthcare products.
- 8:44But at the same time, we need to make sure
- 8:47that people are getting quality care. Because when I'm sick,
- 8:50I'm just whether it's whether I'm depressed or I'm having
- 8:54a psychotic break, or whether I'm thinking I have pneumonia,
- 8:57I'm in a very vulnerable spot and I'm just looking
- 9:00for help. We need to try to make sure that
- 9:03people get a certain level of care, at least to
- 9:06start off with.
- 9:07Speaker 1: Forgive my whining, though, you know I sound like somebody
- 9:10on the view just then I'm sorry. I apologize to
- 9:12the whole entire audience.
- 9:14Speaker 2: Well, and this would be a good thing for you
- 9:16to go talk to a chat GPT and I'm sure
- 9:19that they can help you.
- 9:20Speaker 1: Oh gosh, no, thank you hey, thank you though for
- 9:24joining us.
- 9:25Speaker 2: Thank you, Tony, you have a great rest of the day.
- 9:27Speaker 1: Are you to Charles Pemberton Divention Family Therapy