Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / Energy Voice Live: Where is the green investment?
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud.
- 0:03I'm Aberdeen features lead Ryan Duff.
- 0:06But you're not going to hear too much from me this week.
- 0:09That's because we hosted the second ever Energy Voice Live
- 0:13event. The theme was, where is the
- 0:16green investment? My colleague and news editor
- 0:20Erica Askeland was joined by Nicola McDonald, general counsel
- 0:25and director of corporate affairs at D20, Doctor Valentina
- 0:31Kretchmer, vice president of consulting and energy transition
- 0:36strategy at Wood McKenzie, and finally Paul Addison, director
- 0:41of policy and external affairs at GB Energy.
- 0:45They were speaking about the vital point of the energy
- 0:48transition. Where's the cash coming from?
- 0:50So I'm going to stop flapping my gums.
- 0:52I'm going to let them get into this really insightful
- 0:55conversation that took place in Edinburgh.
- 0:58Good evening. Welcome.
- 1:00My name is Erica Asplund. I'm the news editor of Energy
- 1:04Voice, and you are here as part of the second in a series of
- 1:09live recordings of our Energy Voice Out Loud podcast.
- 1:15I have an amazing panel of people who are going to be
- 1:18talking about one of the most interesting and challenging
- 1:24problems, challenges we have all good starting well in the energy
- 1:34transition, which is finance. Where is the green money coming
- 1:40from? So we've got a very interesting
- 1:43very panel of people who are going to address this naughty
- 1:47problem. I will introduce them, then they
- 1:50will introduce themselves. Then we're going to have a
- 1:53discussion amongst ourselves. Then I'm going to open it out to
- 1:57you to ask tricky questions. And then we're going to repair
- 2:03to the bar and have a few more drinks and snacks.
- 2:06So that's, you know, us in a nutshell.
- 2:08For the next little while. There's just been one call off.
- 2:12Unfortunately, Eddie Maccavenchi from the National Wealth Fund is
- 2:16been unable to join us tonight, which is unfortunate because
- 2:20he's been having a lot of really interesting things that they've
- 2:24been doing recently, including running an investment and
- 2:30lending package into a battery factory in Sunderland.
- 2:34And then in Scotland. There was also a big funding,
- 2:381.3 billion funding package for Scottish Power into the network.
- 2:41But maybe he will come back and do that next time and tell us
- 2:44about that. In the meantime, we have Nicola
- 2:47McLeod who's general counsel and director of corporate affairs
- 2:51for D20. She'll tell you a little bit
- 2:54more about the role D20 is playing in terms of ensuring
- 2:59that industry is decarbonized and, you know, going to meet net
- 3:040 targets. Then we have Doctor Valentina
- 3:07Kretchmar, vice president of consulting for energy
- 3:10transaction strategy at Wood McKenzie.
- 3:13I often refer to the folk that we meet from Wood McKenzie as
- 3:16the big brains in the room. So any questions we could
- 3:19definitely ask Doctor Valentina? And then of course, last but not
- 3:23least, we have Paul Addison, who's the Director of Policy and
- 3:27External Affairs at Great British Energy.
- 3:30So, and we should probably say congratulations to him because
- 3:34the King just recently put his signature on a piece of paper
- 3:40that made GB Energy finally a thing.
- 3:43So we hope to be able to find out a little bit more about what
- 3:47it means for us, for the UK, for the energy industry, for the
- 3:52supply chain, because there's lots riding on that.
- 3:56No pressure. Paul.
- 3:58Good. So without much further ado,
- 4:01give us a shot. Nicola.
- 4:03Tell us a little bit about yourself at D20.
- 4:05OK, well you've introduced me, so I don't need to go.
- 4:08I don't need to tell you my name.
- 4:09I I work for a company called D20.
- 4:11We are a private equity backed company, so we're owned by SCF
- 4:16Partners and we're really a portfolio of six companies that
- 4:20are all working in different parts of the energy transition.
- 4:23So by that I mean the traditional oil and gas helping
- 4:28those companies decarbonize through emissions reduction
- 4:32through to hydrogen. We work with, we've got a neat
- 4:35little company working on fuel cell systems technology.
- 4:39We are involved in electrification and voltage
- 4:43optimization and battery storage.
- 4:45So we're really the whole gambit.
- 4:47There are a little bit of carbon capture as well.
- 4:50You're touching every corner. We are touching every corner and
- 4:53we are, we are really living and breathing the supply chain part
- 4:56of the energy transition and what what it's going to take for
- 4:59the supply chain. And that's what I hope to I can
- 5:01share with you today what it's going to take for the supply
- 5:03chain to transition along with the rest of the industry
- 5:06involved. Yeah, great.
- 5:08Thank you. Valentina, give us your
- 5:11thoughts. Well, thank you.
- 5:12Thank you, Erica. It's, it's great to be here.
- 5:16So I feel really privileged to have worked in the energy
- 5:20industry for almost 30 years and to have been part of the energy
- 5:26transition megatrend over the last decade.
- 5:29Because this has really enabled me to witness some of the
- 5:34massive changes that happened in the energy industry over this
- 5:39time, especially over the last the last decade.
- 5:42And I think what many people don't appreciate and I think the
- 5:44theme of this conference is where is green investment?
- 5:49What people don't appreciate is the amount of progress that we
- 5:53have actually made over the last 10 years.
- 5:56Just looking into the in terms of investment.
- 5:59I'm going to throw a lot of figures at you now because we
- 6:02are from Wood Mackenzie. We're good with figures.
- 6:05Numbers make all. The verified number, all
- 6:08verified numbers. So over the last decade the
- 6:12investment in green technologies have has increased from 300
- 6:17billion to 1.8 trillion, so 300 billion in 2014, 1.8 trillion,
- 6:24that's 6 * 6 fold increase in in clean technologies and
- 6:30renewables and what that means in terms of penetration so of of
- 6:35clean technologies. When we look into solar and wind
- 6:39globally, this is now talking about global primary energy
- 6:44demand. And when we say primary energy
- 6:47demand, it's not just electricity, it's also other
- 6:51areas of the economy. So you know we're talking about
- 6:54transportation, industry, etcetera.
- 6:56So solar and wind, they currently account for 3.8% of
- 7:02primary energy demand globally. Now you're probably thinking,
- 7:06wait, what, 3.8% only less than 4% and we're spending $1.8
- 7:12trillion already on this. And yes, you did hear correctly,
- 7:18it's 3.8%. And if we add nuclear, if we add
- 7:22hydro, that's 19%. So where's the rest?
- 7:26Well, ladies and gentlemen, the rest which is 81% is in fossil
- 7:31fuels. So this is oil, gas and coal
- 7:34accounts currently for 81% of primary, global primary energy
- 7:40demand. That is a lot of oil and gas and
- 7:44and coal. And we expect in Woodmac this to
- 7:48go down to around 65% by 2050, assuming that people stop using
- 7:54coal, because guess what, every time we say we have reached the
- 7:59coal, what happens? We reach actually a record
- 8:03consumption of coal. We've just had record
- 8:05consumption of coal in 24. We've had record consumption of
- 8:08coal in 23. So assuming that people stop
- 8:12using coal, we might achieve this 65% of fossil fuels by
- 8:172050. So what is the situation like in
- 8:19the UK? It's better, but only slightly.
- 8:2425% of UK's primary energy demand, this is electricity as
- 8:30well as everything else is in renewables, hydro and nuclear.
- 8:36So that means that 75% of our economy is underpinned by fossil
- 8:43fuels. And I know there's a lot of talk
- 8:46and I'm sure Paul will be talking about the carbonizing
- 8:49electricity grid that is different to what actually this
- 8:54country needs. So a 75% of our economy actually
- 8:59relies on fossil fuels. So what does that mean?
- 9:03Well, that means several things. It means that we need to
- 9:06increase investment in renewables and generation of
- 9:12clean technologies. If you want to start changing
- 9:15this mix faster, but not just into generation, we have to
- 9:20start investing huge amount of money in transmission and
- 9:25distribution networks. Now this is going to cost
- 9:29hundreds of billions and it's going to take a lot of time, a
- 9:34lot of time. So in the meantime, and This is
- 9:38why it's it's not, it's not a switch.
- 9:42This is a transition. And actually in many ways it's
- 9:45an addition rather than transition.
- 9:48So in the meantime, while we are trying to transition and to
- 9:52develop this in a sustainable way with the the funds that we
- 9:58have available, we have to ensure that we have the oil and
- 10:04gas resources that we need to support our economy.
- 10:08And I know that this is about green investments, but actually
- 10:13the point is that we can't look into renewables and separate
- 10:18them. They are inextricable, these
- 10:21two. So the old systems and the new
- 10:24systems really have to work together.
- 10:28And you know, going forward, what I would really love to see
- 10:33is, is a more reasonable debate, more reasonable approach to the
- 10:36energy transition, more balanced approach that will really
- 10:40prioritize UK security of energy supply.
- 10:45And it will ensure that actually we, we reduce our dependence on
- 10:50imports because guess what, we already import a lot.
- 10:53If we don't produce our own oil and gas, we're going to import a
- 10:56lot more and it's going to be 6 times more carbon intensive than
- 11:01what we can produce ourselves in the UK.
- 11:05So we really have to, we have to make sure that we have this
- 11:10balanced reasonable approach and and ensure that both all the new
- 11:15systems work together. So I know I've probably gone
- 11:18over my time. No, I'll give you 5 minutes.
- 11:22You know, I think we'll probably have to come back to
- 11:25additionality, you know, which is, you know, can you actually,
- 11:29you know, go from one system to another and entirely replace it?
- 11:35You know, there's a lot of debate around that and I'm sure
- 11:39there's some views in the audience as well that I would
- 11:42love to, you know, going to bring on board.
- 11:45But to go to Paul first, thank you ever so much for joining us.
- 11:49And tell us a little bit about how she's a bit of a hard act to
- 11:53follow, but tell us a little bit about GB Energy and what you're
- 11:56going to do with that 8.3 billion that you've got.
- 11:59Well, yeah, now I'm happy to do that.
- 12:01And you know, you quite rightly indicated when you're
- 12:03introducing us that we achieve Royal assent basically a week
- 12:08and a half ago. This is good news.
- 12:10The focus for us is going to be in three distinct areas.
- 12:13It's probably worth me just explaining exactly what Great
- 12:15British Energy will do. Great British Energy, The main
- 12:18question I get asked is like, what is it?
- 12:20What's the purpose? And, you know, getting out there
- 12:23and explaining and, you know, having these conversations is
- 12:25really important. So look, there are going to be 3
- 12:28main components, as I see it, for Great British Energy.
- 12:30Component #1 is investing in new novel technologies where we
- 12:35think we have a national comparative, national advantage
- 12:40competitively and there's a huge opportunity for the UK in that
- 12:45space. And I've spoke, you know many a
- 12:47time with many a folk about the technologies that we are
- 12:49interested in. We are interested in floating
- 12:51offshore wind and I find it remarkable.
- 12:54I was in Kincardi recently in the, the wind farm, the floating
- 12:58offshore wind farm there, which is the largest connected to the
- 13:01grid in the world. And there are basically three
- 13:05leading nations that are looking at that technology and that's
- 13:07us, Norway and it's Japan 4. Actually maybe you include South
- 13:12Korea with that as well. But for us, there is a huge
- 13:16opportunity there both in the Northeast Sea and Scotland, but
- 13:18also in the Celtic Sea too. Not just that technology or the
- 13:22technologies too. We're very interested in load
- 13:24duration, storage technologies, hydrogen, CCUS.
- 13:29Our goal is to be, and you kind of referenced it a little bit,
- 13:32you talked about additionality is to be an investor that comes
- 13:36in early, identifies the opportunity well and then helps
- 13:40investment get over the line where investors are cautious and
- 13:45we can send the right signal. That's where a large chunk of
- 13:48our focus is going to be and it's an important focus and it's
- 13:52an important focus too. The second area is about the
- 13:56local power plant and that is very, very Simply put, focus on
- 14:00using the public sector of state to invest in more established
- 14:05technologies. And there are huge opportunities
- 14:07there. You know, I speak to Scottish
- 14:11Water, I speak to Forestry England, I speak to, you know,
- 14:14Network Rail and there's major opportunity there for some low
- 14:17hanging fruit. But you know, we committed 180
- 14:20million to rooftop solar and we were on the day of Royal Ascend.
- 14:25I wasn't there. My, my, my chief executive Don
- 14:28McGrail was there. He was in whole with the
- 14:29Secretary of State speaking to a hospital trusted a trust of
- 14:33hospitals that was saving around 200,000 a month from the
- 14:37deployment of rooftop solar. This is low hanging fruit.
- 14:39And why is that important? It's important because trust is
- 14:42important. You know, the big kind of gap at
- 14:44the moment in terms of the national debate around renewable
- 14:47energy is trust. You know, whether that's at
- 14:49consumer level or whether that's at a, you know, a business
- 14:52level. And we have to show where those
- 14:54savings can be made. And working with schools and
- 14:57hospitals, in my view is a is a is a good place to start.
- 15:00The third component is the supply chain and there's a huge
- 15:03opportunity there. I mean, let's just take a step
- 15:05back, right? We're around about 23,500 SMEs
- 15:09in the green innovation, you know, ecosystem in manufacturing
- 15:14and fabricating and engineering generating about 28 billion.
- 15:18So we can have these kind of like high level, you know,
- 15:20global conversations about what's happening with the, the
- 15:23shift. But I, I go out and I meet these
- 15:25small businesses and I'm, I'm telling you the opportunity is
- 15:28huge and the growth there is huge.
- 15:29So we announced a £300 million, a £300 billion investment to be
- 15:36matched in offshore wind and, you know, supporting the supply
- 15:39chain too. And I, I, I see huge opportunity
- 15:41there for small and medium businesses that want to
- 15:43transition and, and, and take part in that.
- 15:46So they're three main components.
- 15:49And we haven't done this in a long time.
- 15:53We haven't done this in 70 years.
- 15:55You know, you have to go back to the, you know, the hydro dam
- 15:59technologies that were pursued in the 1940s and 1950s.
- 16:03We haven't done this. But what great British energy
- 16:05is, and I said this time and time and again, I said it on
- 16:07this platform before, is not that novel, right?
- 16:10Vattenfall, Olsted, Equinor, EDF, Thames Valley Authority
- 16:15Corporation in America, you know, having publicly owned
- 16:18energy generators that return value to the taxpayer is good
- 16:22because it shows that there is a public stake in energy
- 16:25transmission as a whole. So our mission is to get that
- 16:28thing up and running, established and to become a a
- 16:32nationally, an enduring national institution and company, right.
- 16:39During national institution and it's starting now.
- 16:41So thank you ever so much. Very good.
- 16:43Great. Now I was just doing some
- 16:48digging into my inbox today and so I've been down from Aberdeen.
- 16:53We managed to make it down. We had to take a bus.
- 16:54There was a bit of a delay on the train.
- 16:56It was a bit of a problem, but you know, we made it here to be
- 17:00here. Now in Aberdeen, we had a very
- 17:04similar event like this and it was about where are the green
- 17:07jobs. And we're looking at what is in
- 17:10terms going to be available in terms of employment for
- 17:13particularly people currently in the Osher Energy supply chain
- 17:18who are expecting what they've been told for the past few
- 17:22years, which is that there's going to be a just transition.
- 17:26And there's going to be opportunities for those amazing
- 17:29skills that we've got for people who are working offshore energy,
- 17:33you know, various things that they're going to be able to
- 17:35transfer over into the green energy opportunities that are
- 17:41going to be available. So the problem with that is that
- 17:45currently we're seeing a really rapid decline in the offshore
- 17:51energy workforce. It's many reasons for it.
- 17:56People will say that there's a fiscal issue.
- 17:59North Sea firms are really declining in terms of their
- 18:02investment. They're pulling out of the UK,
- 18:06I'm going to let slip. So our our friend Paul Dileo,
- 18:11who's a professor at Royal Robert Gordon University, who
- 18:14does a lot of research into these things.
- 18:16He's going to come out with some insight next week and his
- 18:20research kind of confirms that in 2024 we lost 5000 people from
- 18:25this supply chain and that this will continue as a trend for the
- 18:30foreseeable future, which is going to be at the equivalent of
- 18:34the amount of jobs lost at Grangemouth every two weeks.
- 18:38So I mean, like, that's a bit grim.
- 18:40And so that's something now in Aberdeen, jobs are really, you
- 18:44know, like a major focus, you know, just because so many
- 18:48people, you know, they have uncles, brothers, sisters,
- 18:51mothers who, you know, have worked in the supply chain for
- 18:53so long. But in Edinburgh here, we're
- 18:56talking about the money, you know, because you're all
- 18:59bankers, you're all asset managers, You know, they all
- 19:02discovered banking here and then they sold it to England.
- 19:04But that's a different story altogether.
- 19:06We'll forgive them. But what we want to talk about
- 19:10here is the money coming in. So, you know, Energy Industries
- 19:15Council does some great research into final investment decisions.
- 19:20So that's where the money goes on the table.
- 19:22Here it is. So the only trouble is, is, is
- 19:25that, you know, when it comes to financial investment decisions,
- 19:28rates now they're global, but you're getting kind of really
- 19:31good rates and oil and gas elsewhere, not here because, you
- 19:36know, people are kind of reluctant to invest here.
- 19:38But what you're getting is lower financial investment decisions
- 19:42in those key areas like carbon capture storage is like 7% and
- 19:47hydrogen 8%. Offshore wind is kind of not
- 19:53doing so great. Floating offshore wind.
- 19:55Oh my God, Like the only thing happening is here, but it's kind
- 19:58of almost not happening. We might get, you know, One
- 20:02Financial investment decision for floating offshore wind this
- 20:05year and that would be amazing. But things are looking a little
- 20:08bit iffy now on the other side. I've I've told Valentina that
- 20:13she's the brainy one in the room, but there's another brainy
- 20:15organization called DNV. And they've put out a report and
- 20:19they've said that in order for us to reach 2050 legally
- 20:27required targets for decarbonization, net 0,
- 20:32whatever, however we approach it, that's going to take an
- 20:36extra, I don't know, they put a figure on it and it, what does
- 20:40it mean, I don't know, 50 billion per year, which is extra
- 20:43to the 28 billion per year we currently spend in the energy
- 20:46industry for its infrastructure. Now, apparently that's about,
- 20:50it'll grow at about the same rate that it has been.
- 20:53So actually, it sounds like a big number, but it's not that
- 20:54big. And they reckon that by the end
- 20:56we get there, we will have cheaper bills.
- 20:59So Ed Miliband will be proved right 20 years from now.
- 21:03So don't tell him I said that though, but all good.
- 21:07But that said, you know, there's a lot at stake here and there's
- 21:10a lot at stake right now. And, you know, a lot of people
- 21:14are kind of feeling it. We're seeing it, you know, kind
- 21:16of go through out our supply chain.
- 21:18And so I guess I'm going to take it back to my panel because you
- 21:22probably don't need to hear me say it, but can the UK afford
- 21:27net zero? I'm going to ask Nicola first.
- 21:31We'll just go around in the same, then break.
- 21:33It all up, I'm not sure it's a question whether we can afford
- 21:35it. I don't think we've got an
- 21:36option. We have to get there and we have
- 21:38to find a way where we can work as private investment with the
- 21:42government to get to a place where you know, we can we can
- 21:47reach the targets. We'll I'm sure we'll come on to
- 21:50targets, you know, later in the conversation.
- 21:53So for our companies, I mean there's a reason that SCF, our
- 21:57investors, we looked at our companies, we had a base load, a
- 22:01mainstay of traditional oil and gas work and we've been able to
- 22:05transition with those companies within that sphere to help them
- 22:08decarbonize. Emissions reduction is massive
- 22:10for us now. It's, it's a great area of work
- 22:13and we've we've scaled our workforce accordingly.
- 22:16That's allowed us to invest in more renewable energies taking a
- 22:23place like the fuel cell systems of pure energy work, but also
- 22:26within our base load companies like Hydroson now working on
- 22:31hydrogen projects as well as in the past pure, purely
- 22:34traditional oil and gas. So that, that investment has
- 22:38been critical that that base load.
- 22:39And that's what I what attracted me actually to the company.
- 22:42And I should have said in the introduction, my, I've only been
- 22:44with D20 since October last year.
- 22:47Prior to that it was 25 years in upstream EMP laterally working
- 22:51on carbon capture and storage. So in the, the challenges facing
- 22:55that. And before that it was five
- 22:56years in government. So hopefully I can give she's a
- 22:59balance. Of hats that we well, well.
- 23:01Before devolution, which shows my age.
- 23:03But. I and things have changed a lot
- 23:06since then. I but yeah, it is a real
- 23:09challenge to look at from the supply chain point of view and
- 23:13the investment point of view. We have to go where the business
- 23:15is, where the money is and where the work is.
- 23:18And in Aberdeen yesterday, the Aberdeen Grampian Chamber of
- 23:21Commerce announced it's the results of its local survey.
- 23:24And that had a worrying trend. It's been for a few years now,
- 23:28but where the, the, the companies questioned.
- 23:34So the majority of their business overseas by 20-30.
- 23:38That's a real concern for us because we have to our companies
- 23:41as well are looking a, you know, we employ 4000 people across our
- 23:45companies and we're based in 70 jurisdictions.
- 23:48So we have to go where, you know, we've got returns to make
- 23:50to our shareholders. We have to go for that.
- 23:52That art work is so any and I think to, to Vanya's point, the
- 23:57whole energy way is so interlinked that any decision
- 24:02that's made, whether it's on EPL, whether it's on investment
- 24:06coming from GB energy, whether it's on wind, so solar, whatever
- 24:10they, they interplay with each other and they have a knock on
- 24:12impact on the supply chain. And I think that's something
- 24:15that we need to get a better understanding of.
- 24:17This isn't an Aberdeen problem. There is a problem for Aberdeen
- 24:21as the the main state, but this is the UK and it's an energy
- 24:24security problem. I agree absolutely.
- 24:28Now, I mean, when I asked the question, you know, can the UK
- 24:32afford net zero? It's true.
- 24:34It's not that we can't not, but we're a bit skint actually.
- 24:39And aren't we kind of doing, you know, kind of like investment in
- 24:42in bombs, not turbines now and we're kind of changing our, you
- 24:48know, approach to investment. So Valentina, do you have the
- 24:53answer to that already? See those pots of money coming
- 24:55from? I have a lot to say on that.
- 24:58So the question is, is there any common sense in this?
- 25:06OK, so UK emissions, they are less than 1% of global
- 25:11emissions. Now I'll use China to contrast
- 25:18what you know we are doing. So China is the global
- 25:24electrostate. Global power in renewables
- 25:27accounts for 50%, around 50% of global wind, solar, offshore
- 25:34wind, storage, you name it. When it comes to supply chain,
- 25:38it accounts for over 6070% of of supply chain.
- 25:44So you you think your wind turbines are made in Denmark?
- 25:47Actually 70% of them are made in China.
- 25:51So China is absolute superpower. So what is their approach to net
- 25:59zero? They have their commitment out
- 26:01to 2070, but really not important.
- 26:06You know their, their mantra is do not knock down your old house
- 26:12before you've built a new, your new one, right?
- 26:16And and they they laugh at us because they see us knocking
- 26:20down our old house and we don't even have a a permit to build a
- 26:26new one yet. You haven't even got the tent up
- 26:29yet. Yeah.
- 26:29Yeah, that far ahead. We just need to have a
- 26:33reasonable approach to energy transition.
- 26:38And and another thing is everyone talks about net 0, but
- 26:43I bet you, you ask people what net net 0 is just like, well,
- 26:47first of all, it's not 0. A lot of people think, think
- 26:50it's 0 fossil fuels. Absolutely.
- 26:52It's not 0 fossil fuels. So even in this net zero
- 26:56scenario, we have to produce quite a lot of oil and gas and
- 27:02we will need quite a lot of oil and gas.
- 27:04In fact, even in the net zero scenario, the UK will have to
- 27:08continue even if if we produce every molecule of our oil and
- 27:12gas that we currently can't, even if we produce it, this is
- 27:17not enough even to satisfy our net zero scenario.
- 27:20OK, So even if we and it's rather unrealistic that we are
- 27:23going to hit it anyway. So and net zero, it really came
- 27:29about it post COP 21 in 2015 when countries decided that
- 27:37they're going to strive towards to limit the global warming to
- 27:402° by 2100. And then that became well, let's
- 27:46push it kind of even be more aggressive.
- 27:48Let's do 1.5, let's limit global warming to 1.5° by 2001, 2100
- 27:57compared to pre industrial levels.
- 28:01Well guess what, we have already hit 1.5.
- 28:05We don't need to wait until 2100 global warming.
- 28:09We already have that 1.5°. So as part of that concept, net
- 28:16zero was created by 2050 because we needed to net zero our
- 28:21emissions again, not 0, but you know, needed fossil fuels.
- 28:25But we are going to use carbon capture and storage.
- 28:26We're going to use a lot of, we're going to plant a lot of
- 28:29trees to offset that carbon that we are still going to use in
- 28:332050, but we need to net zero it.
- 28:36But it's too late. So, and, and actually it's a
- 28:40very uncomfortable conversation for many, many governments.
- 28:43And they are talking globally because actually some islands
- 28:47are already sinking and you can hear them different cops crying
- 28:51out for help. It's already too late.
- 28:54Physical risks of climate change are already happening, whereas
- 28:58many governments are still talking about mitigation, trying
- 29:03to achieve this net zero, right. But actually we need to talk
- 29:07about adaptation more because net 0 is not achievable anymore,
- 29:14right? We, we, we missed it in terms of
- 29:16physical risks and, you know, in terms of the, you know, the,
- 29:21the, the burden on taxpayers trying to mitigate it when
- 29:29actually in our case, in the case of the UK, it's less than
- 29:321% of the global emissions. Just doesn't seem like the most
- 29:38sensible approach to how we could be approaching this energy
- 29:43transition. OK, well, do we all go home?
- 29:49No, I think what we need to do, I think we need to kind of put
- 29:54this all on Paul now. No, no, no, because we're
- 29:58talking, you know, so, you know, Valentina is, you know, kind of
- 30:03making an argument that, you know, there's really, you know,
- 30:08we should be kind of looking at a different, taking a different
- 30:13approach. But that said what we've got and
- 30:17you know, when I was in a, a, a Glasgow recently, you know,
- 30:22there was a lot of people focusing on offshore wind,
- 30:25which, you know, is such a, for me, it's always been what I
- 30:29thought was a really exciting low carbon energy production
- 30:33opportunity and that it was a great chance to offer, you know,
- 30:39an, an industrialization of Scotland that made you feel
- 30:42great. You know, there was lots of
- 30:44opportunity there now, but that said, you know, we've got Orsted
- 30:52was one of the biggest investors in the UK energy system, which
- 30:57is an option for GB Energy as a model, which is something that
- 31:01we're kind of looking at. But, you know, they put through
- 31:07plans for a vast wind farm, but in AR-6, which is a recent
- 31:14funding round. But then they decided, sorry,
- 31:17ain't going to happen, which was a lot, you know, which was a bit
- 31:21of a kick in the butt for the industry.
- 31:25And again, they said it's too expensive.
- 31:27The money that was on the table isn't going to cut it anymore.
- 31:30So I know that this isn't, you know, kind of like something
- 31:33that, you know, it's not you can't do GB energy, can't do
- 31:39fixed bottom wind. There's some opportunity for
- 31:43floating wind, but you know, there's just such a complex
- 31:49problem and it just seems to be heading in the wrong direction.
- 31:55Wow. Listen, I'm an optimist, right?
- 32:00Optimist. That's, you know, my mindset.
- 32:03And there is a risk, I think in this whole debate and how it
- 32:13shapes over the next few years and how it's been conducted as
- 32:18of late that we talk ourselves into a particular position and
- 32:26there is no need for that. You know, I, I just point that
- 32:29to two things. I mean, statistically there was
- 32:31the recent CBI report that said that the net zero economy grew
- 32:37by on average 10% here in the UK compared to a notional 112
- 32:41percent in the rest of the economy.
- 32:44The opportunity is, I would describe a substantial, there
- 32:48are already 1/4 of a million people working in the green
- 32:52economy and it's projected to be reaching 3/4 of a million over
- 32:59the course of the, of the coming years.
- 33:01And look, you know, for me, if we keep our focus and we keep
- 33:11the mission in mind and the economic opportunity in mind,
- 33:15the potential is, is, is significant.
- 33:18No one said, I don't recall anyone saying anyway that the
- 33:21road would be, you know, smooth and perfect and, you know, it
- 33:25would all be fine. And you know, this is a major
- 33:28economic change, no doubt about it.
- 33:31We have lived through major economic changes before.
- 33:34You know, it's not the first time.
- 33:35I remember in 2014 with Siemens when I worked, actually there
- 33:42was similar skepticism about the deployment of fixed bottom wind,
- 33:45right? The scale out of that over the
- 33:47course of the last decade or more has been substantial.
- 33:51I also remember at that time, you know, we roughly, we still
- 33:56had coal, 5 power stations and we still had other technologies
- 34:01in the mix. But I distinctly remember that
- 34:04there was a view that, you know, it was obscure, it couldn't be
- 34:08done. You look at the amount of
- 34:10electricity that's generated through that technology now,
- 34:12it's substantial. And that particular factory
- 34:15making wind turbine blades in hold, you know, employing about
- 34:191200 people thereabouts is, you know, at the time it was
- 34:24considered, you know, not far fetched, but you know, a risk.
- 34:28And we're going through that same debate with things like
- 34:29floating offshore wind technologies.
- 34:32And, you know, so my, my view is, is that we keep a pragmatic
- 34:36and calm and, you know, sensible kind of conversation in this
- 34:39space and, you know, invest where we see returns, You know,
- 34:45for example, in great British energy, and I've said this
- 34:47before, you know, predominantly staffed with folks, including
- 34:50myself, that have lived their careers in the private sector.
- 34:53We're not just kind of like, you know, making this up as we go
- 34:57along. We're thinking, right, OK, there
- 34:58is some serious economic potential in this technology and
- 35:01let's work with investors. Let's collaborate with
- 35:03developers and get this stuff going and have a bit of
- 35:05positivity about it. You know, we don't need to be
- 35:08negative about this debate, I don't think.
- 35:11Thank you. Great positivity.
- 35:15Now, I think, you know, one of the things, you know, that is
- 35:19between these two is, you know, kind of where, where do we put
- 35:24those targets? And I think, you know, in
- 35:27Glasgow, you know, there was still that optimism that Paul
- 35:31has identified in the offshore wind industry.
- 35:35And, you know, investors, you know, acorn aside, we're not
- 35:38sure what's happening with CCS and Grangemouth, but you know,
- 35:41well, hopefully there's still a lot of expectation.
- 35:45But as an investor, if you know, maybe UK decided to do a bit of
- 35:54China and shift some of these goals out a little bit, would
- 35:57that change your scenario? Would that cause you to think
- 36:02differently maybe about some of the choices you've made in terms
- 36:06of your portfolio or some of the things that you know D20 has
- 36:12been doing and this is when we. Talk about 20-30.
- 36:15I think targets are targets are important to have.
- 36:17They can be I, they can, they set a goal to work towards, but
- 36:22they also have to be realistic. So whether it's 20302040, I
- 36:25don't think that's what changes the investor mindset.
- 36:29I, I think, you know, we, we, our businesses work on two to
- 36:33five year planning cycles. You know, 2, the two year ones,
- 36:36very robust. The five year ones, they also
- 36:38have to be pretty robust. They can't just be pie in the
- 36:40sky. You know, we're going to do all
- 36:41this and somehow we're going to achieve margins of X of X
- 36:45amount. So I think you 2030 is only five
- 36:47years away. You would expect that, you know,
- 36:50that plan, that integrated plan between investment.
- 36:52I think, you know, I'm an optimist as well as, but there's
- 36:56a lot to do in the time scale and it does feel, and we'll come
- 37:00on and talk about things like zonal pricing.
- 37:02It does feel like we're flailing about.
- 37:04We've got lots of really good ideas, but somehow now we need
- 37:07to get them together and tackle the real challenges.
- 37:10We've got challenges with our grid network, We've got
- 37:13challenges with planning and reforms.
- 37:15So those planning systems, it's still really complicated to do
- 37:19planning and it to get through planning and regulatory reforms
- 37:22in the UK. You know, we when you look
- 37:23overseas, you'll see systems whereby if it's in the national
- 37:27interest, it will override local planning regs here.
- 37:30It's a minefield of for, for companies trying to invest and
- 37:34investors trying to get, get through that.
- 37:36So that that then creates delays.
- 37:39Delays for my sector means that you know, we are upscaling right
- 37:44now. One of the things we're super
- 37:45proud of AD to 0 is that we have 400 apprentices this year
- 37:50working in our companies. That's a huge investment that
- 37:53companies are making in industry and technology.
- 37:57You know, in, in Hydrason, we are going to be working on the,
- 38:00the Aberdeen Hydrogen Hub. That's for a new jobs.
- 38:04But what the service sector can't do is it can't handle
- 38:07delays. It doesn't have the ability to,
- 38:11to set out for long delays on projects.
- 38:13So then you get that, that circular, you know, that we,
- 38:16that we hate, we were, you know, manning up, manning down.
- 38:19And that's, that's not good for the industry either.
- 38:23So I, yeah, it's, it's a real challenge to get to get those,
- 38:28to get those reforms made to the, the regulatory space.
- 38:32And we also need a stable fiscal regime.
- 38:36That's something that's, that's critical for us, you know, from
- 38:39in my last role in, in EMP, you know, the UK was, was being seen
- 38:44as an unstable political environment to invest in. 15
- 38:49years ago that would have been, you know, Africa.
- 38:51It wasn't, it wasn't the UK. So there's been massive changes
- 38:54in also in, in my time of, of working that that will impact
- 38:58where investment and how investment comes into the UK.
- 39:01Yeah. No, I get you.
- 39:04Polly, could you now have a word with some people in government
- 39:07to stabilize that fiscal regime and ensure that, you know, they
- 39:11balance things out a little bit? Yeah.
- 39:13Do you know, I, I, I reflect a lot on, you know, the, the
- 39:16ambition that has been set out by the end of the decade.
- 39:19And you do need a North Star, right?
- 39:22You need a North Star to kind of galvanized folks, galvanized
- 39:25industry and, and send a really, really clear signal.
- 39:29And, you know, I think the UK has had the underpinning of that
- 39:32for a long time with the climate change back in what was it 2008.
- 39:35So that, you know, there has been like a, a sense of, of
- 39:39trajectory with the UKI would argue that the 2030 trajectory
- 39:46does provide quite a lot of certainty.
- 39:48I mean, you know, what the, what the crack is and what's been
- 39:50tried to achieve. And it's pretty clear what Chris
- 39:53Stark and his Mission Control they're trying to do.
- 39:56And, you know, I, I reflect that, you know.
- 40:02Political certainty and. Investment certainty, the lack
- 40:08of it, and folks have complained about the lack of certainty, you
- 40:11know, for many, many years and the different governments and
- 40:14all the rest of it, you know, can deter investment.
- 40:17But at the moment I think I'm in that North Star's really
- 40:19important and there isn't any question about what the
- 40:25objective and what the goal is here.
- 40:28And you know, Great British Energy's role in that is to, you
- 40:32know, work and find those particular projects, invest and
- 40:37then send a really clean signal that X or Y project and
- 40:40technology will be backed. And you know, every lever that
- 40:45we can pull as Great British Energy sat where sat in the
- 40:48market, but also, you know, publicly owned company can can
- 40:51deliver good. I think North Star is great and
- 40:57I think 2050 maybe seems a little bit far away, although
- 41:01it's not that far away. 2030 is like upon us.
- 41:05And if we're working backwards, you know, there's a lot of
- 41:08people going to go. There's a lot that needs to be
- 41:10done kind of between now and then.
- 41:13And then there's like issues, you know, kind of where, you
- 41:17know, maybe the Department of Energy Security net zero is
- 41:22setting out ambitions for adding kind of like extra into the next
- 41:26funding round for offshore wind. But then you have Niso saying,
- 41:31oh, well, you know what, actually, we should probably
- 41:33come in with some zonal pricing and then make sure that
- 41:35everything's really cheap for everyone.
- 41:37And then they don't get any money.
- 41:39And this is what did you describe it as it was, you know,
- 41:42the Brexit of the energy industry because there's two
- 41:44sides. And sometimes they, you know,
- 41:47don't see eye to eye. And I think, you know, the IT is
- 41:51an issue for investors and you know, maybe throws a bit of a
- 41:54plank and uncertainty. Now, I don't want to put too
- 41:56much pressure on you, Paul, but Valentino, what are, you know,
- 41:59like investment trends 2030? I mean, what are you setting out
- 42:04in terms of that expectation? Well, look, I mean, there are.
- 42:08Technologies out there that have reached escape velocities and
- 42:15they can stand on their own 2 feet and they can make returns
- 42:19and onshore wind, solar, such technologies in terms.
- 42:26Of returns, they're not. Great.
- 42:27I mean, oil and gas investors will not necessarily be
- 42:31attracted to that, to that kind of investment because there's a
- 42:36huge difference in what they get from oil and gas projects.
- 42:39But then the other technologies like carbon capture and storage
- 42:44like hydrogen, these technologies, they haven't
- 42:47reached escape velocities. And offshore wind and floating
- 42:51offshore especially are included as well.
- 42:53And that means that they need massive subsidies.
- 42:57They need help from governments, from GB Energy to, to actually
- 43:05make these projects financially viable.
- 43:08So I'm all for the the UK becoming global leader in, in
- 43:16some of these technologies. But what I would like to see is
- 43:21more focused. We can't do everything.
- 43:23And I think in terms of kind of going back to your previous
- 43:26questions, are we on track? We are not on track to reach
- 43:30reach net 0 by 2030. We are absolutely not on track
- 43:34on pretty much anything in, in, in terms of the targets and, and
- 43:39I think probably for for carbon capture and storage for
- 43:42hydrogen. We need to double the
- 43:46investment, double the capacities that in order to hit
- 43:50these targets by 20-30. But we we can't do everything.
- 43:55I mean ultimately because we need this additional investment
- 44:00support needs to come from the government and that's the
- 44:03taxpayers money. I mean, it's, it's, it's, it's
- 44:07us who will be paying, you know, and we will be feeling that
- 44:11through, through our, our bills as well.
- 44:14So we just have to have a more sensible approach and more be
- 44:19more selective in in which technologies we want to invest
- 44:24and where we want to really which areas we want to be the
- 44:28best at and excel at because I don't think we can we can do
- 44:32everything now if I gave. You 8.3 billion, what would you
- 44:36put your money on just out of curiosity?
- 44:38I'm so sorry. Pretty good under pressure here,
- 44:40but you know, I think it's fair. I think we have massive wind
- 44:45resource in the UK in Scotland especially massive what?
- 44:49Sorry, wind, wind resource, you know, I think it's, it's a no
- 44:53brainer to actually just to continue developing wind.
- 44:58And but you know, as we invest in wind, we have to invest in
- 45:02transmission. We do not want to experience
- 45:04Spain and Portugal of couple of couple of weeks ago.
- 45:07So we have to invest in transmission.
- 45:09We have to invest in distribution networks.
- 45:11And I was just, you know, I'm, I'm an engineer, so I still get
- 45:15my engineering magazines and I was just reading sort of
- 45:19engineering accounts. How much?
- 45:24In terms of investment, but in terms of also just raw
- 45:28materials, you know, to to get this infrastructure into place,
- 45:33it's a huge undertaking. It's going to take not four
- 45:37years, It's good to take long time, long time.
- 45:42And and on the top of that, we just don't have skilled people
- 45:45to actually deliver the scale of of that that investment that's
- 45:49required. So yeah, we just need to be
- 45:53patient. We need to be patient.
- 45:55We have have to have sensible approach to the energy
- 45:58transition and that means unfortunately that we may need
- 46:02to just drop the ambition of reaching this net 0 because it's
- 46:06it's breaking us. We can't do it.
- 46:10It's breaking us, and no. Matter how hard we try, Nicola's
- 46:14400 apprentices are probably not going to be enough to get there.
- 46:18But that's part of the problem I suppose as well, yes.
- 46:24And So what do you, you know, you guys are placing bets, you
- 46:30know, there's hydrogen, you know, you're looking at, but
- 46:34you're also looking at decarbonizing industry, like
- 46:38even just tightening a few valves here and there is
- 46:40probably going to be transformational for some, you
- 46:44know, facilities and industries. So tell us a little bit more
- 46:48about where you're putting your money.
- 46:51Well, it's a it's a massive opportunity.
- 46:52For for companies, because we're showing that the value that we
- 46:55had, not just for their a climate, the impact they're
- 47:00having on the climate, but also in a business sense in terms of,
- 47:04you know, escape gas, gas you can't sell.
- 47:07So and, and, and the life of the field.
- 47:09So it's, it's and a really important place for, for us to
- 47:15be playing and it's mainly in our, our score energy company
- 47:18that's, that's working on that. But it's going to get more and
- 47:21more as, as Vanya talked about regulations overseas, it's, it's
- 47:25a great opportunity for us when you talk about emissions
- 47:28reduction, when you talk about putting emissions targets in
- 47:30there to encourage companies to, to see the benefit and, and just
- 47:35working at, in those, in those areas of looking at where you
- 47:39can help decarbonize and make, make that energy, I hate to say
- 47:45the word cleaner because I actually think it's an unhelpful
- 47:48debate to use terms like clean energy.
- 47:50It it kind of demonizes our main energy source right now, Tanya
- 47:56talked about. The you.
- 47:57Know the amount that we rely on. So I think for me the the North
- 48:01Sea is an enabler of the transition.
- 48:04It's a critical part of the transition.
- 48:06It's not it's not, you know, bad, good, clean, therefore
- 48:10dirty. I think those terms are, are
- 48:12unhelpful and I think our media not energy voice, because you've
- 48:16got an important, an important part to blame.
- 48:18Our media hasn't helped by that as well.
- 48:20So there's a, there's a rhetoric I think that's unhelpful and
- 48:23takes away from the fact that we're not just flipping a switch
- 48:26from one source of energy to another.
- 48:28It's much more complex than that, I think, if we.
- 48:31Could flip a switch and understand kind of how that
- 48:35works, you know, where the, you know, light comes on and how
- 48:38that if there was a greater understanding of it, we'd be a
- 48:41little bit further on in terms of being able to explain how it
- 48:45was all going to work. If you were going to say to Paul
- 48:50and GB Energy you've got this fund, 300 million aimed at the
- 48:56supply chain, is there what what converse?
- 48:59What would that conversation look like?
- 49:00What do you think? You know, where could that,
- 49:02where could it end intervention work?
- 49:04Yeah, well, we're all eagerly. Awaiting it's, it's an
- 49:07announcement. We have a sister company
- 49:08actually that's involved in the service sector for a offshore
- 49:13floating to our our particularly wind that are particularly
- 49:17interested in in what's going to come.
- 49:19I think so we can see it work. So even even smaller investments
- 49:22can work. Our fuel cell, fuel cell systems
- 49:25company we talked about earlier, they've been involved in a pilot
- 49:28with the aviation industry looking at running hydrogen to
- 49:32support all the support that's required at airports.
- 49:35So everything from your baggage handling to your refuelling to
- 49:38your catering and that's been really successful.
- 49:41So it's the, it's not, it's not hydrogen flying aeroplanes yet,
- 49:44but hydrogen flying airplanes. But it's, it's making those
- 49:48steps. And that was, that was enabled
- 49:49by CEE funding basically and, and a university pilot.
- 49:54So these, you can see that investment in new technologies,
- 49:585 GB energy I think is, is hugely positive.
- 50:01So yeah, I think there's you've got a list of projects waiting,
- 50:05waiting for waiting for the announcement.
- 50:08Are you excited about that? Well, I think, you know, way
- 50:12this points out, you know, those little examples of, you know,
- 50:16fusel technology in aviation is, you know, not just about flying
- 50:20hydrogen planes, it's about every little bit.
- 50:22There's not just one silver bullet, there's thousands of
- 50:25silver bullets that we need to be supporting, which I think is,
- 50:30you know, really interesting for the industry.
- 50:34I wonder, I'll put come back to Paul though, because I think,
- 50:38you know, there's investment here.
- 50:42It should also be the equivalent of economic growth jobs.
- 50:47But you know, as Valentina says, you know, it's China, that's
- 50:51that's the superpower. So are you, is it the issue that
- 50:57you want to focus investment on AUK supply chain in order to
- 51:01kind of keep the works here or is that are you more agnostic
- 51:06about where it's coming from? Yeah, I mean look when I
- 51:09reflect. On 6 bottom offshore wind and
- 51:12when that was scaled up it was scaled incredibly successfully
- 51:15in the UK. World leaders, did the UK do
- 51:18enough to develop the supply chain enough?
- 51:23Probably not. So I think there's a huge
- 51:25opportunity there. And in Scotland between
- 51:28Edinburgh and Glasgow, there is a huge opportunity by way of
- 51:32engineering skills, university capacity, R&D and all the rest
- 51:35of it. So, you know, I think there is
- 51:37an opportunity to be doing something here in the UK
- 51:41focusing on the UK. And look, that's great British,
- 51:43it includes the title, right, Great British energy.
- 51:44So you know, our focus is going to be very much how we develop
- 51:47EU KS capacity. That's why we've, you know,
- 51:50announced this fund, but also there is opportunities for that
- 51:55particular fund and and and an approach to doing stuff to
- 51:59interact with other organizations too, right?
- 52:02I would love it if great British energy was a kind of a one stop
- 52:06shop front door for some of this stuff, right?
- 52:08Because you've got Snip, you've got national welfare and you've
- 52:11got the Crown Estate. They've announced a supply chain
- 52:14accelerator fund, 50 million I think it is.
- 52:16How do we work together with those folks to make sure that
- 52:20we're developing and, you know, a properly integrated approach
- 52:23to this sort of stuff and being much more strategic in how we in
- 52:26how we do it? There's been a lot of, I think
- 52:30people kind of wondering, you know, what does the landscape
- 52:33look like, you know, for the, that government, you know,
- 52:36support. And I, I think, you know, to say
- 52:39that there just needs to be 1 big one and, you know, you can
- 52:41just bring them on the phone means that, you know, you'd
- 52:44probably lose a lot of diversity of thought and maybe investment.
- 52:47So I think stick to your knitting, you know, work to
- 52:50integrate those bodies as well, which is, you know, really
- 52:55beneficial. So we're going to come out to
- 52:57you. Oh, I think.
- 52:59It's time to come out to you. Does anyone have any burning
- 53:03questions that you're really super keen to get up and out
- 53:07there? Or shall I start?
- 53:08Oh, right. Oh, there's three.
- 53:12OK, so actually the lady right there, she's the closest to the
- 53:16mic. Please tell us who you are and
- 53:19then ask your toughest question. Hi I'm.
- 53:22Kidda from CMS. Thank you to the panel, really insightful so far.
- 53:28I'm going to pick on Paul, just on that sort of thought that you
- 53:33were expressing about collaboration with SNIP and the
- 53:36National Wealth Fund. Is there scope in all those?
- 53:42Entities. Sort of.
- 53:43Combining forces almost as a syndicate on a particularly
- 53:46risky piece of tech. In order to to to reach 2030
- 53:51targets question. That's a really good question
- 53:55and I'll. Tell you why it's a good
- 53:57question is that. You know what, what Great
- 53:59British Energy needs to focus in on and do really well is the
- 54:02emerging technology piece. And implied in that is a degree
- 54:08of risk and being the first mover.
- 54:11And, you know, as we grow as an organization, will that make us
- 54:16culturally different to other organizations?
- 54:20I'm not sure. But when it comes to the supply
- 54:23chain in particular, I think that there is quite a lot we can
- 54:27do. The the, the question is making
- 54:29sure that all of those organizations have a aligned
- 54:33risk appetite. And it's not easy, right?
- 54:36But I do think that, you know, and I can say this from being on
- 54:41the other side of the fence, working in business, that
- 54:44there's nothing worse than when institutions don't work together
- 54:47and you're having multiple conversations and I can't, you
- 54:51know, I don't think GBE can resolve the intricacies and you
- 54:54know, the bureaucracy of the of all governments and all
- 54:57government institutions. But I think we've got a damn
- 54:59good chance of being a bit of a coordinating force there and
- 55:02working with other folks. But it's a very good question
- 55:05because as I say, it identifies the GBE element, which is that's
- 55:08big risk savvy and, and, and how we then work with other
- 55:13partners. Thank you very much.
- 55:17There's a question from our friend from Dragger.
- 55:23You recognize me? I'm flattered.
- 55:25She's always got the best. Questions.
- 55:27That's why I went right to her and.
- 55:30Best outfit? No, Obviously, Megan.
- 55:33Hein from Draga so. I have a question that will be
- 55:36prefaced by three statements I think.
- 55:40So I was at All Energy recently in one of the wind sessions,
- 55:45they were talking specifically about offshore wind.
- 55:48I want to take it back to the 60s and the 70s.
- 55:51You know, we have undoubtedly exported our expertise in oil
- 55:55and gas offshore drilling. You know there when we look at
- 55:59the results that you mentioned Nicola of the the report people
- 56:03saying that they are exporting more and more in the future
- 56:06their expertise overseas where they're still doing oil and gas.
- 56:11So the first statement is we we have exported our oil and gas
- 56:14over the years. The next statement is Vattenfall
- 56:17and EDF, obviously state funded or largely state owned energy
- 56:21companies that invest in the UK, EDF quite famously having
- 56:26reduced their stake recently in our nuclear investments.
- 56:29The third statement is offshore wind, very much the floating
- 56:33side, very much based on naval architecture, which takes me
- 56:35back to my first point around exporting oil and gas.
- 56:38FPS OS, you know that expertise that we've really taken.
- 56:42Is there an opportunity for GB Energy?
- 56:44I guess I'm looking at you again, Paul.
- 56:47Is there an opportunity for GB Energy to invest in UK
- 56:50infrastructure for export at the risk for offshore wind and for
- 56:56the energy transition? At the risk of suggesting we
- 56:58should run before we can walk, could.
- 57:01You just repeat the very last bit of that run before walk is
- 57:04is. There A at the risk of running
- 57:07running before we can walk, is GB Energy looking at exporting
- 57:10our expertise in other countries the way that other other
- 57:15countries invest in our energy infrastructure Also another
- 57:18good. Question.
- 57:19OK, all the good questions. I think I think there was an
- 57:27opportunity there, but I think you're, you know, the tail end
- 57:29of your question there about, you know, making sure we've got
- 57:33the right organizational capacity and great British
- 57:35energy to do that is important. You know, we've got Royal Seven
- 57:38last week. We're staffing up, we're doing
- 57:40what we need to do. I do think though you're quite
- 57:46right in, in terms of how you identify vacant file and EDF and
- 57:49others and how they effectively, you know, that are very
- 57:54commercially driven. They are operationally
- 57:57independent and they have taken their strategic decision to go
- 58:00into the markets and and return value to that company and you
- 58:05know, indirectly to taxpayers. I think in the long term it is
- 58:10absolutely possible for Great British Energy to be doing that.
- 58:14Will it happen overnight? We need to get feeling right
- 58:17first. But I, you know, could we be
- 58:19Britain's Olsted or Batten fowl or, or, or similar, if we stick
- 58:24it out and, you know, we say we're going to make this thing
- 58:27work and, you know, we're going to do what the countries have
- 58:29done very successfully. There is absolutely no reason
- 58:32why the UK can't do that. And I think it'll take a lot of
- 58:37will and determination and, and pragmatism.
- 58:39But I think it's possible and it's something we should be
- 58:42shooting for. I love this positivity.
- 58:48Bob Ruderman, you had your hand up.
- 58:49Is that something that you wanted to stick to or are you
- 58:52going to pass this opportunity to OK?
- 58:56Right. I'm trying to go into order.
- 58:57We're working forward. Thank.
- 59:01Thank you very much. Bob Roderman, Co head of energy
- 59:04at Bernas. Paul, really interesting hearing
- 59:07all the different viewpoints and I think Nicola made a point, it
- 59:11really shouldn't be either or we, we need a mix of energies
- 59:15and the geopolitics are complicated at the moment.
- 59:21And I wonder, and this is a thought then I've got a
- 59:23question, shouldn't we focus a little bit more on energy
- 59:27security and energy independence?
- 59:31And I guess it comes to you, Paul, you're Director of Policy
- 59:35and External Affairs. When we look at the way the
- 59:38world is going, the further you get into this role in GB Energy,
- 59:42the more you could inform government policy and successive
- 59:48governments in my view have failed us as a nation around
- 59:52energy with short term views, variable tax.
- 59:55Nicola made the point that we're regarded as fiscally unstable
- 59:59and I'm afraid that that is a fact.
- 1:00:02Do you have the opportunity to influence strategy at a
- 1:00:08government level and are you able to listen and think, hang
- 1:00:11on, we might have not have this quite right, we need to double
- 1:00:15down. And supporting jobs in energy,
- 1:00:19not specific areas. And my final bit before we get a
- 1:00:22chance to answer it was, you know, you made a great reference
- 1:00:24there to your rooftop solar and the investment you've made.
- 1:00:28Does anyone really look at the rooftop solar and the
- 1:00:32consequences cradle to grave of that rooftop solar panel?
- 1:00:37Where does it come from? What does it represent?
- 1:00:39So the real bit, can you influence strategy?
- 1:00:46It's just like a. Rehearsal of our chat
- 1:00:47beforehand. It's all on you, isn't it?
- 1:00:49I know you all have all the answers.
- 1:00:51Look, it's all good. I I.
- 1:00:52And I understand because these are really these are good
- 1:00:54questions. And the short answer is yes, you
- 1:00:58know, I do think that and I think that because we'll be, you
- 1:01:01know, EU, KS, publicly energy and publicly owned company
- 1:01:04specializing in energy development, but we will be in a
- 1:01:06position of unique kind of influence, but the ability to
- 1:01:13convene and to advise and to work with the market.
- 1:01:17And you know, bluntly, you know, our, our focus whilst commercial
- 1:01:22will be that we want to make a positive impact on the, on the,
- 1:01:28on the broader net zero debate, but also we want to return value
- 1:01:30to taxpayers. And because of that, I think it,
- 1:01:34you know, we would love to be a trusted advisor in that space.
- 1:01:37And I think that's really, really important, particularly
- 1:01:40when we can work with partners that, you know, need support in,
- 1:01:45in their projects and, and their work.
- 1:01:46And it has to be done in the right and proper way.
- 1:01:48But you know, I so yes, and I do think that's important.
- 1:01:51And I think we will be in that position.
- 1:01:55On the solar question, the short answer is, again, yes, you know,
- 1:02:00I think you're right. You need to make sure that the,
- 1:02:03the whole life cycle of the technology's looked at very,
- 1:02:06very carefully. The deployment's looked at very
- 1:02:07carefully, but I'm really interested in like potential of
- 1:02:13AI and data in this space and how you can work with trusts and
- 1:02:17schools to understand the value that this stuff is generating,
- 1:02:21but also how it can be deployed effectively.
- 1:02:27And it's important that, you know, we align closely with all
- 1:02:32of the relevant social solo schemes, the SSI scheme and all
- 1:02:34the rest of it. They're they're out in play at
- 1:02:36the moment, but it's an important part of what we've got
- 1:02:39to do. And there was a hell of a lot of
- 1:02:40scrutiny on it as the bill went through Parliament.
- 1:02:42So we are set up legally to make sure that the technology that we
- 1:02:49deploy is not only robust but ethically sourced.
- 1:03:08No, no, it might be made by. Slaves in China is the issue.
- 1:03:11Yeah, yeah. No, no, no, didn't think.
- 1:03:15About and the question about you answered the question about
- 1:03:29influencing policy with your Can you influence the politicians?
- 1:03:36Because you're going to get local feedback.
- 1:03:39Of events like this, which will have nothing, that there's a big
- 1:03:44energy picture. So my question rather directly
- 1:03:47then is will the politicians allow you to influence and have
- 1:03:55you got enough stroke to be able to stand up and say this is what
- 1:04:01we're hearing? There's a disconnect between the
- 1:04:04rhetoric and the messages, Yeah. So I do think we'll be in the
- 1:04:07position to influence, yes, you have to also philosophically
- 1:04:12balance that with our ability to be operationally independent as
- 1:04:16well. And, and I'm not saying that's
- 1:04:18really clear cut and that that we don't need to work through
- 1:04:20governance. And we do, you know, because
- 1:04:24ultimately we need to make our own commercial decisions about
- 1:04:26how we invest and what we do. And we need to be allowed to get
- 1:04:29on and run the business like a VAT and follow on Ofsted, for
- 1:04:31example. But I think it's important that
- 1:04:35we do have that Direct Line. I feel like if I'm not being
- 1:04:38direct, we talk about this afterwards, but it's really
- 1:04:40important that we do utilize that position that we have to
- 1:04:44influence in the in the right and proper way.
- 1:04:47But we do that openly, we do that transparently, and we do
- 1:04:50that in collaboration with businesses.
- 1:04:53OK, great. So I think we're getting close,
- 1:04:56but I thought we will go to Imran Meehan, is that correct?
- 1:05:00OK. And then we'll go to Finley.
- 1:05:03Maybe should we ask, get each of them to ask their questions and
- 1:05:08then we'll run to the panel and then we'll see where we are
- 1:05:11because we're getting awfully close to canopy time.
- 1:05:15But so Imran, please, what would you like to ask our panel?
- 1:05:19Thank you so much, Erica. So very good questions and
- 1:05:22really enjoy discussion. This is Imran.
- 1:05:24I'm from Aberdeen and I run my fractional CFO work.
- 1:05:28So back to the question of where's the green investment?
- 1:05:32So what would make it interesting for investor to
- 1:05:36invest in the net zero or renewal energy project because
- 1:05:42you have certain framework of supporting them, right?
- 1:05:44That could be CFD, that could be subsidies, tax rebates, some
- 1:05:50other incentives. Do you have anything laid out in
- 1:05:54terms of how would you help them or incentivize them?
- 1:05:58I'm not. I'm already grinning because I
- 1:06:00could see you looking at me and I thought.
- 1:06:03Yeah, I'm not going to. You know, usurp the chair's role
- 1:06:06here, but I think you should hear from someone that's
- 1:06:09actually in this space, and then I can come back to it as well.
- 1:06:11Yeah, yeah, yeah. What sort of incentives are you
- 1:06:14seeing that is, you know, kind of driving that what I guess are
- 1:06:21the growth in that market so in incentives in the.
- 1:06:25In the smaller scale plays, it's incentives like the one I just
- 1:06:28mentioned. So that's I think part of the
- 1:06:30the GB Energy 300 million supply chain fund.
- 1:06:33That's that's critical for where some of those companies, the
- 1:06:36smaller companies face challenges as they can't win
- 1:06:39work until they can staff up, build up, invest and they can't
- 1:06:43invest until they've got work. So they're in that classic
- 1:06:46chicken and egg of getting to the next stage.
- 1:06:48That's where I see that 300 million fund.
- 1:06:50Can we play a valuable space to bring our supply chain chain on
- 1:06:55and people that are willing to take risks in staffing up.
- 1:06:58Like I said, we're we're we're doing with our companies in the
- 1:07:01bigger place. I think there's a a challenge.
- 1:07:05I think we're getting there. So we've been running through
- 1:07:07R1. We've got R2 now in hydrogen
- 1:07:10space. We've got carbon capture track
- 1:07:12one. They they've there's been
- 1:07:14delays, but I think those are the optimist in me says those
- 1:07:17are probably not that surprising.
- 1:07:19We've got a bunch of regulators that have been working in their
- 1:07:22own space and now they have to work together.
- 1:07:24If you look at something like offshore wind, you've got the
- 1:07:26NSTA who license this government, you've got off gem a
- 1:07:31involved and you've got the Crown Estate who's got the sea
- 1:07:33bed. So all of a sudden these
- 1:07:34companies, they've had to find a way to to work together and
- 1:07:38private sector and governments have had to find a way to do new
- 1:07:41contracting models. But the optimist in me says that
- 1:07:44we do have that workforce. So I'm going to slightly
- 1:07:47challenge that. You know, the the oil and gas
- 1:07:50industry didn't sit on its ass for 50 years.
- 1:07:53If you'll look at the that fascinating story that, you
- 1:07:56know, things like horizontal drilling, that was a pipe dream
- 1:08:01when the oil and gas industry started up.
- 1:08:02We have the engineers, we have the capability, we have the
- 1:08:06desire, we've got the technology, the advancements,
- 1:08:08the thinking, and we bring AI into all of that.
- 1:08:12We've got that passion. We just need to to see it
- 1:08:15realized and to and to work with the government and investors on,
- 1:08:19on, on getting to that space before it's too late.
- 1:08:22And we'll lose that. We'll lose that supply chain and
- 1:08:26critical workforce overseas a lot of people talk about.
- 1:08:29Timing and it's coming. Valentina, do you have like a a
- 1:08:33marking system for your favorite method of, you know, kind of
- 1:08:38government industry collaboration and
- 1:08:41incentivization that you see as being particularly good?
- 1:08:46Yeah, Well, look, I mean. When, when we talk about
- 1:08:49incentivizing investment in clean technologies in the UK,
- 1:08:55and as I was mentioning earlier, you know, most of these
- 1:08:58technologies, they are, they desperately need additional help
- 1:09:03from the government either through CFDS or, or other other,
- 1:09:08other kind of subsidies. Because the mainstream investors
- 1:09:12will simply not invest in any of the projects until, you know,
- 1:09:17talking about, you know, even sort of more embryonic clean
- 1:09:21technologies. They will not invest in them
- 1:09:24until they reach the point of FID.
- 1:09:26There's a long time between the, you know, beginning of kind of
- 1:09:32growing this concept to reaching this FID and the likes of
- 1:09:37Scottish National Investment Bank and you know, in many ways
- 1:09:40GB Bank that you know, you have very similar remit.
- 1:09:43I guess you have larger funds to, to help and you know, these
- 1:09:48companies, the risk their investments.
- 1:09:51But you know what other, you know, the, the likes of SNIP
- 1:09:55have found that actually, even, you know, the investment that
- 1:09:59they put down is still sometimes not enough to actually attract,
- 1:10:04attract private investors. Private investors, they need
- 1:10:07returns, you know, they're not charity, they need returns.
- 1:10:13So trying to to find what, at which point and you know, how
- 1:10:18much is needed to actually incentivize this private
- 1:10:23investment into technologies is absolutely crucial for, for that
- 1:10:29to happen because it's, it's otherwise it's not going to
- 1:10:32happen. And we have seen many, many
- 1:10:35startups actually go bankrupt because they were waiting for,
- 1:10:41you know, this private investment to happen And, and it
- 1:10:44didn't. And we're also seeing a lot of.
- 1:10:47You know, energy companies, oil and gas companies going back to
- 1:10:51their safe spaces, pulling investment out of carbon capture
- 1:10:55and storage and hydrogen and you know going to meaning that
- 1:11:00there's a lot of disappointment there.
- 1:11:04Finley, I'll go to you. Quick question and then how are
- 1:11:08we doing just in terms of time? Have you waved at me yet?
- 1:11:13OK, good. You got some time.
- 1:11:15OK, I'll try and be quick. Thank you everyone.
- 1:11:19Very much Finley Anderson, Head of Corporate and Energy at
- 1:11:21Gilson Gray. I guess back to the original
- 1:11:24question, you slightly asked it immediately before about where's
- 1:11:28the greenback coming from in a sense, what's the
- 1:11:31incentivization model that, that, that we think is going to
- 1:11:34work? I've spent probably 15 of the
- 1:11:38last 20 years in industry. I'm a lawyer, but I've spent 15
- 1:11:41in the last 20 years in an industry in large multinational
- 1:11:44companies. And I'm amazed at the the
- 1:11:46ability of industry of companies when there's a business case to
- 1:11:51move fast and to invest and to flip the chart and say, let's
- 1:11:57go, let's go for this. And, and so industry can move
- 1:12:00fast when it has the incentive and the right model, etcetera.
- 1:12:04And at the moment it feels like, it feels like our North Star
- 1:12:09has, has disappeared it, it doesn't exist and we're, we're
- 1:12:17in danger of there's a lot of flailing around.
- 1:12:19So I guess the question I have really is what would be the two
- 1:12:24big changes in the next 12 months that you would want to
- 1:12:27see that would incentivize industry to make the right
- 1:12:31investments? I think it's easy for us to get
- 1:12:34stuck in a five year plan etcetera about, you know,
- 1:12:37whatever we need to achieve over the longer term.
- 1:12:40At the moment the challenge is, is now how do we get in
- 1:12:44industry, How do we incentivize the way the Labour government
- 1:12:47talked about, what are the changes?
- 1:12:49That we need. To see in the next 12 months
- 1:12:51that will incentivize the industry to move fast through
- 1:12:542030, we're talking about next. Year What's going on, Nicola?
- 1:12:57What would it take? Planning and regulatory.
- 1:13:00Reform is one of the, the, the key ones for me to unlock.
- 1:13:04Just being able to move faster to allow the supply chain to
- 1:13:08invest, to have confidence for investors to have confidence.
- 1:13:11So that would be my my number one and #2 would be fiscal
- 1:13:17fiscal regime. Yeah, I would say clarity.
- 1:13:22On, on, on support and whether it's CFDS or, or subsidies.
- 1:13:29But I think what is really, really important is that that
- 1:13:33support is bipartisan because the problem is that if, if there
- 1:13:40is political change, you can guarantee that that's going to
- 1:13:43get scrapped. And, and the one thing that I
- 1:13:47really worried about before the Republican administration, you
- 1:13:52know, went back in, in, in now in, in November last year was
- 1:13:57that polarized debate. Because my fear was always,
- 1:14:01well, look, if the other side gets in, then all of this would
- 1:14:05go. And that ended up being pretty
- 1:14:08much the case. So when it comes to investment
- 1:14:12in clean technologies, in transformation of our energy
- 1:14:15system, that has to have partisan, bipartisan support.
- 1:14:19It cannot be just one side or the other.
- 1:14:22And, and This is why maybe scaling down the ambition
- 1:14:26slightly to to to make sure that you have that support would
- 1:14:32actually be a sensible way forward.
- 1:14:39Well, you must have some hopes for the next 12 months.
- 1:14:43What would those be? Look, I, I, I, I'm going to do 2
- 1:14:47things here because the, the, the gentleman over here asked me
- 1:14:49a question which I didn't quite answer, which is about
- 1:14:52investment as well. And I'll try to wrap it
- 1:14:53together. But you know, Great British
- 1:14:57Energy should be, as I've said before, catalytic investor that
- 1:15:01is providing value that is additional and how involvement
- 1:15:09starts something that wouldn't have happened without it, if
- 1:15:11that makes sense. And I think that's really,
- 1:15:13really important to addressing very specific market failures
- 1:15:17and that should be the framework that we should operate within.
- 1:15:19Now when it comes to the two things, you know, for next year,
- 1:15:24I think I think it is right to talk about planning and
- 1:15:27infrastructure, given that the Planning Infrastructure bill is
- 1:15:29going through Parliament to help provide clarity around certain
- 1:15:35schemes and, and, and ease of application.
- 1:15:39And I think, you know, my hope is that Great British Energy
- 1:15:43will be genuinely accessible to the private sector so that we
- 1:15:50can have very clear conversations about investment
- 1:15:54propositions. And you'll be doing that with
- 1:15:56folks that have worked with you and understand the market and
- 1:16:01understand the risks and, and is commercially savvy.
- 1:16:05And I think that's going to be that's going to be particularly
- 1:16:10important folks that we spoke to on projects where, you know, we
- 1:16:15think we can move the dial. You know, what they're looking
- 1:16:21for isn't necessarily just cash. They're not, you know, after a
- 1:16:26specific quantum per SE. What they're after is, is the
- 1:16:29sign that a great British energy project.
- 1:16:32This kind of alludes to the gentleman's question earlier the
- 1:16:37the government and great British energy gets behind the project.
- 1:16:40We can help have common sensible conversations with NISO, with
- 1:16:43grid on planning with Ofgem sensible, you know, right
- 1:16:47conversations. And we're sending a signal that
- 1:16:50we can help try and pull some levers with you.
- 1:16:53If we get that right over the course of the next 12 months or
- 1:16:58start to get that right, we'll be we'll be fairly decent shape.
- 1:17:01I hope you heard it here first. I'm afraid we're going to have
- 1:17:06to leave it there. I'm so sorry.
- 1:17:08The canapes and the drinks are calling.
- 1:17:09But I think, you know, if I I'm not worried about the well, I am
- 1:17:14worried about the next 12 months.
- 1:17:15But I think actually a couple weeks ago, I would have liked to
- 1:17:18have seen the Scottish Government give a planning
- 1:17:21consent to the Barrack Bank offshore wind farm.
- 1:17:24And I would actually really like to see a treasury ensure that
- 1:17:29the green Freeport up in Inverness and Port of Cromartie
- 1:17:33Firth actually got some of their tax incentives in, you know, the
- 1:17:37bag, because these are things that we've been waiting for for
- 1:17:40an awfully long time. And those things would give some
- 1:17:43damn pine signals to the people here.
- 1:17:45But I think what I would like to do is I'd like to thank everyone
- 1:17:49here on this panel. So Paul Addison is such a good
- 1:17:52sport. He is so unfailingly, you know,
- 1:17:56able to just like, take these questions.
- 1:17:59He always has a great answer. And I think, you know, I've
- 1:18:02never had more confidence in GB energy except for when I speak
- 1:18:05to Paul. And then, of course, I'd like to
- 1:18:07thank Valentina Kretchmar for sharing your brain, your
- 1:18:11insight. It's slightly depressing.
- 1:18:14You know, it kind of makes me think that, you know, we should
- 1:18:16all just go home. But you know what, actually, I
- 1:18:19think, you know, in this beating heart of her, you know, amazing
- 1:18:23analysis. She's also an optimist.
- 1:18:27And then I'd also like to thank Nicholas so much because she's
- 1:18:31the one who's got her money on the line.
- 1:18:34Her, you know, kind of like focus on how we're going to get
- 1:18:38there, how the supply chain is going to get there, how people
- 1:18:40are going to get there working in this industry.
- 1:18:43And you're so able to articulate what the industry needs, what it
- 1:18:47expects and you know, particularly from your point of
- 1:18:50view, you give a great insight into the sort of things that we
- 1:18:55at Energy Voice are really hoping get delivered over the
- 1:18:57next few years to 2030 to 2050 and beyond.
- 1:19:01So I'd like to say thank you very much and to thank you in
- 1:19:04the time honoured manner. What an exciting and insightful.
- 1:19:07Conversation that took place in the caves in Edinburgh.
- 1:19:11What a venue as well. I'm kind of gutted I missed
- 1:19:14that. But next week we will be
- 1:19:16returning to regularly scheduled programming.
- 1:19:19There'll be three of us discussing the weeks headlines,
- 1:19:23but myself and Erica are still on the move.
- 1:19:25We're going to be at the energy exports conference, so we'll
- 1:19:28have a stand come and say hello.