Latest / Common Sense Rankings Podcast / CSR Podcast #24: Week 9 recap, a new CSR Top 25, auditing the first CFP Rankings, and what to look for in Week 10
Transcript
- 0:13Hello and welcome to another episode of the Common Sense Rankings podcast, where we rank the resume.
- 0:18This is episode number 24.
- 0:20I have another week of college football to go through.
- 0:23I'll go over the changes to the top 25 in the Common Sense rankings.
- 0:26There's the first CFP rankings of the year that came out Tuesday night, so we'll give them an audit.
- 0:32We'll compare some resumes to see which teams deserve to be ranked higher based on resume, and I'll end like I always do by previewing the top games of week 10.
- 0:41For the second consecutive week, 112 college football teams took the field, giving us 56 games that'll impact the Common Sense rankings.
- 0:49The remaining teams had an extra week of rest.
- 0:51There were six teams in last week's CSR Top 25 that were on bye, meaning their opportunity to improve their resumes was put on hold.
- 1:00During their bye week, those six teams lost anywhere from one to five spots in the Common Sense rankings.
- 1:06While some may think that unfair, we are looking at the totality of the resume here at the CSR, so when other teams acquire more positive data, they are potentially going to pass those who do not play.
- 1:18Just one non-conference battle took place that did not include an independent, UCLA hosted Nevada.
- 1:23The Big Ten had already stamped a winning record over the Mountain West this season, so it wouldn't impact the conference strength rankings, but it could have had a lasting impact on the CSR Top 25.
- 1:33UCLA though took care of business to maintain their top spot atop the Common Sense rankings.
- 1:41When we look at the timeline from week nine, there were games that could have big implications in both the CSR and the college football playoff this season.
- 1:49James Madison's hopes of making back-to-back college football playoffs took another hit as they lost to the Troy Trojans Thursday night.
- 1:56That dropped the Dukes to number 31 in the current CSR.
- 1:59BYU will now lose points for every loss UCF suffers the rest of the season, and the Knights suffered another L on Friday, losing handily to Baylor 41-9.
- 2:09Notre Dame battled Navy, and while the Midshipmen did manage to hold Notre Dame's offense in check, the Irish did prevail 35-13.
- 2:18And in the battle of one-loss Big 12 teams, the Texas Tech-Arizona game could end up being a CFP elimination game.
- 2:24If that's true, then the Arizona Wildcats will be on the outside looking in this season.
- 2:30The chances of the ACC being a two-bid league took a hit as one of their three ranked teams suffered a loss.
- 2:36SMU controlled their own destiny on their way to the ACC championship, but after suffering a loss to Syracuse Saturday, their chances are growing thinner.
- 2:45Wisconsin snuck into the AP top 25 last week but didn't do so again this week after being shut out by Iowa in their week nine game.
- 2:54Auburn was a team that was on the cusp of the CSR top 25 last week even with three losses.
- 2:59Their resume was being carried by their win over UGA, but another loss this time to Ole Miss in week nine will not help them raise the ranking.
- 3:08Speaking of Georgia, they moved the world's largest outdoor cocktail party indoors to Mercedes-Benz Dome in Atlanta this year.
- 3:14Georgia did well in the new confines, beating Florida twenty-seven to eight.
- 3:19BYU righted the ship before their in-state showdown in week ten.
- 3:23After losing to the UCF Knights in week eight, they took down Arizona State twenty-seven-twenty to stay afloat in the CFP race.
- 3:31Indiana may be second to Kentucky in giving its fans heart palpitations.
- 3:35Another close game resulted in a Hoosier overtime win over Minnesota.
- 3:40Just when things were starting to make sense in the Big Ten hierarchy, Oregon rose up and beat ranked Northwestern on Saturday.
- 3:46The Ducks have alternated looking great and then looking weak, but the Wildcats were the victim of their most recent good game.
- 3:53Mississippi State was near the top of the CSR for several weeks, rising all the way up to CSR number two after week four, but their offense has stalled.
- 4:01Putting up just three points against Texas was never going to get the job done as Texas rolled.
- 4:08As dusk settled on the East Coast, Miami, who was number one in the AP poll, went on the road to North Carolina to take on Belichick, who had the Tar Heels ready.
- 4:17The Hurricanes did escape, but not without a stressful four quarters.
- 4:21AP number two, Ohio State, flew out to LA to take on the USC Trojans.
- 4:26With a backup QB, the Buckeyes were out of sync on offense and couldn't get enough points on the board to hang with Lincoln Riley's team.
- 4:33Give USC another Big Ten win and Ohio State a second loss this season.
- 4:38In the late-night games, Boise State was up big early, but then let Texas State score thirty-six straight points.
- 4:45The Broncos did end up buckling down late for a one-point victory and maintain their spot near the top of the Group of six.
- 4:52Lastly, Oregon State had received a few votes in the AP poll last week, which was a stretch.
- 4:57They won't be getting any this week as they lost to Fresno State thirty-eight, twenty-two.
- 5:03Okay, next let's put up some resumes next to one another.
- 5:07Let's leave the team names blank so as to not show any preferential treatment and we'll see what we get.
- 5:12Blind resume test number one.
- 5:14Team A and team B are in the same Power 4 conference.
- 5:17Team A is six and two.
- 5:19They are four and two in their conference with an additional win over a Power 4 team and another over a team from the American.
- 5:25Their losses are to two conference teams with a cumulative three losses.
- 5:29The teams they've defeated have 14 Power 4 wins and 22 FBS victories.
- 5:35Team B has the same record, six and two.
- 5:37They are three and two in the same conference with an additional Power 4 win and a win over Conference USA.
- 5:43Their losses are to teams with five cumulative losses and the teams they've beat have 10 Power 4 wins and 14 FBS wins.
- 5:51To review, team A has an additional conference win and out-of-conference wins are more impressive based on the conference of the defeated team.
- 5:59The teams that they've lost to have fewer losses and the teams they've defeated have both more Power 4 wins and more FBS dubs this season.
- 6:08Team A is Alabama who sits eighth in the CSR and fifth in the initial college football playoff rankings.
- 6:14Team B is Tennessee who sits 18th in the CSR and 13th in the CFP.
- 6:19While looking at their resumes without opponents listed, that would seem to make sense, but the discourse on social media is the Volunteers head-to-head victory over the Tide should outweigh all the other information.
- 6:30I contend if we try to strip away the brand names when claiming biases, then we should also strip away brand names when looking at resumes Blind resume test number two.
- 6:42Team A is seven and one.
- 6:44They are four and one in the Big 12.
- 6:46Their out-of-conference wins were over Conference USA and the Pac-12, and their loss is to a three-loss Big 12 school.
- 6:53Their six FBS wins are over teams with 10 Power Four wins, nine in the Big 12, and 19 total FBS victories.
- 7:01Team B is seven and one.
- 7:02They are five and one in the ACC, so they have an additional conference win.
- 7:06Out of conference, they beat a Big Ten school and a MAC team.
- 7:10Their loss is to an undefeated ACC team, and their seven wins are over teams with 14 Power Four wins, including 10 in the ACC and 17 total FBS wins.
- 7:20So Team B has one more FBS victory.
- 7:23They have two additional Power Four wins.
- 7:25Their loss is to a team that is undefeated, and the teams they've defeated have beat more Power Four teams but two less FBS schools in their other games to this point.
- 7:34At the very least, these two resumes are similar, but Team B likely has the better resume, right?
- 7:40Not to the CFP Committee.
- 7:41Team A is Texas Tech, who's number 15 in that initial CFP rankings.
- 7:45Team B is Wake Forest, the team just one spot behind them at number 16.
- 7:50In the common sense rankings, Wake is number 11 and Texas Tech is number 14.
- 7:56Let's put one more blind resume test up.
- 7:59Team A is seven and one.
- 8:00They are four and O in a Group of Six conference.
- 8:03Their only loss was to a Power Four team, a Big Ten school who now has three losses.
- 8:08The teams they've defeated have 22 total FBS victories all over Group of Six teams.
- 8:14Team B is also seven and one with a four and O Group of Six conference record.
- 8:18They lost their only matchup with a Power Four school this year, an SEC team that currently has two losses.
- 8:24Their wins are over teams with 15 FBS victories all over Group of Six.
- 8:29While Team B's wins are over less successful teams, their loss is to a team from a statistically better conference, and that team has fewer losses.
- 8:36Again, these teams are at least comparable when taking team names out of the equation.
- 8:41Team A is Boise State, who snuck into the CFP Top 25 this week at that 25th spot and are number 20 in the AP poll this week.
- 8:50Team B is UTSA, who likely didn't get a look in the committee room and got enough votes to be 28th in the AP poll.
- 8:56The CSR has Boise State at 17 and UTSA just two below at number 19.
- 9:04So what is my goal in providing these blind resumes?
- 9:06It's to show you that a formulaic evaluation of a team is almost certainly better than random football knowers' judgment.
- 9:13Now let me tell you who the real top 10 resumes are in college football through week nine.
- 9:18UCLA has the best combination of wins in the country, starting eight and O against FBS competition.
- 9:24They're also five and O in the Big Ten, the second best conference in college football this year.
- 9:29That lack of loss obviously keeps the score up, but the strength of their opponents' wins is actually losing ground to the teams around them.
- 9:35Their opponent win strength went from twelfth last week to fifteenth this week, so the Bruins are relying heavily on their own wins to keep them atop the CSR Taking advantage of the Kentucky Wildcats' bye week is the Utah Utes from the Big 12.
- 9:48Similar to UCLA, it's the strength of their own wins that puts them in this spot over the strength of their opponents' wins.
- 9:54Their resume of wins sits second behind just UCLA, but their strength of opponent wins is 14th.
- 9:59That's good enough for second in the CSR this week.
- 10:03The top three in the CSR are our final three undefeateds in college football, with number three being the Miami Hurricanes.
- 10:10Their resume is the opposite of UCLA and Utah.
- 10:13Their quality of wins is 12th in the country, but opponent win strength is third, thanks in large part to their win over otherwise undefeated Wake Forest.
- 10:20Obviously, their lack of loss isn't hurting.
- 10:24Indiana is the second Big Ten team in this week's rankings, coming in at number four.
- 10:28Having already played nine games gives it a leg up, but they do have a bye coming up this week, so we can expect them to fall a few spots in next week's common sense rankings.
- 10:37Number five starts a run of five SEC schools.
- 10:40The Kentucky Wildcats fell three spots during their bye week, but maintain a resume of wins that sits tied for third with Indiana.
- 10:47Kentucky's resume will continue to improve with each SEC victory, as the SEC is the strongest conference statistically in football this season.
- 10:56Number six is the Texas Longhorns, who benefit from a schedule void of an FCS school.
- 11:01FCS wins mean nothing, so a full complement of wins over FBS competition allows them to have maximum opponent win strength.
- 11:09The Longhorns are overcoming their two SEC losses.
- 11:13The six teams they've beat this season have the strongest combination of wins of any team in the country right now, and it's not even close.
- 11:19That portion of the CSR formula is 25% higher for the Longhorns than for any other team.
- 11:25Number seven is Georgia following their win over Florida.
- 11:28At seven and one and in control of their destiny, the Dogs just need to keep winning and they'll move up steadily in the CSR.
- 11:35Alabama slid down five spots from last week, settling in at the number eight resume this week.
- 11:40A loss to Georgia hurts very little, as it's an SEC school with just one other loss.
- 11:44The Tide suffered their drop due to being on bye and will play an FCS school in a few weeks, limiting further resume-boosting games this season.
- 11:53Number nine is the fifth straight SEC team, the Ole Miss Rebels.
- 11:56Their biggest wins are over LSU, Missouri, and Auburn so far this year.
- 12:00But they're similar to Alabama.
- 12:01They have an FCS team left to face.
- 12:03They'll lose a little ground with just three FBS matchups remaining.
- 12:0710th this week is the USC Trojans.
- 12:10USC is still being propped up by nine- ninth game already played, but I'd expect them to drop in next week's top 25 as they are taking a bye this upcoming week.
- 12:20The rest of the top 25 in the CSR are number 11, Wake Forest, 12 BYU, the second Big 12 team, 13 Notre Dame appropriately one below the team that beat them.
- 12:3114 is Texas Tech.
- 12:3315 is LSU.
- 12:3516 Ohio State after the Buckeyes lost to Southern Cal.
- 12:3817 is Boise State, the top Group of 16.
- 12:4118 is Tennessee.
- 12:4319 is UTSA who only dropped one spot after their bye week.
- 12:4720 Missouri.
- 12:4821 Florida, the top three lost team.
- 12:5022 Houston.
- 12:5223 Iowa and we round out with two Group of six teams New Mexico at 24 and Memphis at 25.
- 12:58Florida is the lone three lost team in this week's rankings and their resume is being propped up immensely by their win over Texas while the losses of the teams they've lost to will limit their ceiling.
- 13:09In the CSR top 25 this week we have nine SEC schools, five Big Ten, four Big 12, two from the ACC, two from the American, then one each from the Mountain West and Pac-12 with Notre Dame rounding out those top 25 teams.
- 13:23In comparison with the initial CFP rankings we have one fewer SEC team, I mean South Carolina at 21 in the CFP.
- 13:31What are we doing?
- 13:32We have one fewer Big Ten team.
- 13:33Oregon is a reach based on their resume.
- 13:36There's also one fewer Big 12 team in the CSR as it judges Arizona as just outside the top 25.
- 13:43The three teams missing from the CFP rankings that are in the top 25 of the CSR are all Group of six, UTSA, New Mexico and Memphis.
- 13:54If the college football playoff was based on the common sense rankings UCLA, Utah, Miami and Indiana would be the teams not playing till the quarterfinals based on games through week nine.
- 14:05In the first round held on the higher seed's campus we have number five Kentucky welcoming Boise State to Lexington as the Group of six representative.
- 14:13Number six Texas taking on number 11 Wake Forest in Austin.
- 14:16Number seven Georgia welcoming Southern Cal to Athens and then number eight Alabama playing number nine Ole Miss in an all SEC battle.
- 14:25The first three teams out would be BYU, Notre Dame and Texas Tech.
- 14:29Notre Dame does get in if they're in the top 12 but they are 13th in this week's CSR Now that the calendar has flipped to November, the College Football Playoff Committee will be meeting regularly to give us college football playoff rankings every Tuesday.
- 14:45The first of those releases was just done this past week, so let's look at how they did.
- 14:50They got 22 of the top 25 resumes correct in their initial rankings and nine of the top 10, granted in a very different order, but we still need to give them their due.
- 15:00More of the good, Boise State is the top group of six team in the CSR, and they managed to get a spot in the initial CFP rankings at number 25.
- 15:09And they did put five SEC teams in the top 10, which did anger some people, but that does match up with the formulaic CSR.
- 15:16Now we have to discuss some of the bad.
- 15:19There were four teams that were under-ranked by at least five spots.
- 15:22USC was number 20 in their rankings, number 10 in the CSR.
- 15:27Boise State was under-ranked by eight positions, as they are number 17 in the CSR.
- 15:32UCLA by seven spots and Wake Forest by five spots.
- 15:36All four of those teams are allowed to be mad at the College Football Playoff Committee.
- 15:42More bads, the undefeateds are in the opposite order of the CSR.
- 15:46The committee went Miami at number one, Utah at three, and UCLA at eight, but they are the top three in the opposite order in the common sense rankings.
- 15:55Only one group of six team made this initial rankings, that is Boise State, whereas the CSR has four group of six teams as among the top 25 resumes in the sport.
- 16:07The AP poll now matters significantly less, but that doesn't mean I can't call out voters who do things well and those whose decisions leave the average college football fan quite perplexed.
- 16:16UCLA is still number one in the Common Sense rankings but haven't yet received a first-place vote.
- 16:21Bob Asmussen and Steven Means both put them number two, so a tip of the cap to both of them.
- 16:27In the CSR, Boise State is the top group of 16, but UTSA is just behind them.
- 16:32Matt McGavock was the highest on the Roadrunners, placing them at number 22 on his ballot.
- 16:38Lastly, there were three teams that made the AP top 25 that the CSR found undeserving: South Carolina, Arizona, and Oregon.
- 16:46Dave Preston, Javon Edmonds, Pete Yanity, Ryan Zuke, and Zach Klein were the five people to leave all three off their ballots.
- 16:55Next, those voters that failed in their job this week.
- 16:58Not a single vote for Memphis, so a cumulative shaming for all voters on that one.
- 17:02Louisville at five and three and Oklahoma State at five and three both got votes.
- 17:06Both are outside the top 45 in the Common Sense rankings.
- 17:10John Wilner was the overly excited voter to put Louisville on his poll, and Mike Jacques and Murray Evans included the Cowboys.
- 17:17Lastly, Cokey Riley continues to put the Kentucky Wildcats far too low on his ballot.
- 17:22Cokey put the Wildcats at number 16, while the next lowest was number 12 for the Wildcats.
- 17:30All those rankings are behind us now, so let's look ahead to week 10.
- 17:33It is quickly approaching, and it is going to be another unbelievable week on the college football field.
- 17:38First, four of our top 25 are either on bye or playing an FCS school, so expect to see Indiana, Southern Cal, Wake Forest, and Memphis to fall in next week's Common Sense rankings.
- 17:50On the field, we'll see six CSR-ranked matchups this week, including several matchups between top 15 teams CSR number two will take on number 12 BYU in the latest edition of the Holy War.
- 18:03It'll be the highest cumulative ranking between the two teams in the rivalry's history, and much to the chagrin of both fan bases, it'll be played at ten AM local time Saturday on ABC.
- 18:13If Utah wins, they'll get points for each of BYU's wins too, which would potentially move it to number one in next week's CSR regardless of UCLA's result against Minnesota.
- 18:23Also at twelve noon Eastern Saturday is CSR number six's Texas matchup with number twenty Missouri on ESPN.
- 18:30Both teams sit with two losses in conference play, but with all the chaos around college football this year, a third SEC loss may not doom a team, but neither wants to test that theory this weekend in Columbia, Missouri.
- 18:41Texas didn't play an FCS program this year, so they're getting a boost from the additional FBS win, and another SEC dub would likely move them into the top five.
- 18:50Missouri, meanwhile, could launch itself into the CSR top ten with a win over Texas and getting credits for all the Longhorns wins thus far.
- 18:58CSR number eight Alabama will head westward to play number fifteen LSU at three thirty on ABC.
- 19:04Nicknamed the Saban Bowl, this will be the ninety-first meeting between the SEC rivals with Alabama having won the past three.
- 19:11Each team also has two losses, and nobody knows what will be needed to be considered as an at-large bid for the CFP.
- 19:18Alabama would likely head right back into the CSR top five with a dub, while LSU would likely be looking at number seven or eight in the CSR next week with a victory.
- 19:28CSR number five Kentucky will be on the road in a hostile environment as they head south to take on CSR number eighteen Tennessee.
- 19:35The Vols have had the Wildcats number the last several years, winning the last five in the rivalry, but Kentucky hasn't had Will Stein.
- 19:42The Wildcats will look to maintain their top five CSR rank this season, while Tennessee is looking to take UK down a peg.
- 19:50College GameDay this week is headed to South Bend for Miami's visit to Notre Dame.
- 19:54Miami is the current number three in the CSR, and Notre Dame is at number 13.
- 19:59But both teams are ranked a little higher in the CFP if those are to be believed.
- 20:03That game will be at 7:30 Eastern on NBC.
- 20:06Miami's win was crucial to the Hurricanes' inclusion in the CFP last year, as the committee chair confirmed that was the reason Miami got in over Notre Dame.
- 20:15There might be a little less pressure on both teams this year, as there are now auto bids for conference champions, and Notre Dame gets in if they're top 12, but we're still looking at potentially the game of the year.
- 20:25The last ranked matchup of the week is between CSR number seven, Georgia, and CSR number nine, Ole Miss.
- 20:31Georgia has the inside track to the conference championship, but a second SEC loss would blow that race wide open.
- 20:38This is also a rematch of last year's quarterfinal, which Ole Miss won, so Kirby and the Dogs are looking for payback.
- 20:44Ole Miss would leapfrog a lot of teams if they were to win, as a win over Georgia garners as many points as any win in the country right now.
- 20:52The only top 10 team playing this week that isn't up against another ranked opponent is UCLA.
- 20:57They visit Minnesota and take on the Golden Gopher team that just took Indiana to the brink.
- 21:02There is one non-conference matchup that could impact the Common Sense Rankings conference strength.
- 21:07That's Air Force versus Army at 7:30 on CBS.
- 21:11The American currently sports a two and one record against the Mountain West Conference, but an Air Force win would push that record to two and two, ruining the Americans' head-to-head superiority and lowering the American Conference's standing in the eyes of the CSR this season.
- 21:26I hope you enjoyed another podcast.
- 21:28I've now started speaking to college football as well as both men's and women's college basketball on the socials.
- 21:33You can follow me at CommonsenseRanking to see all those posts.
- 21:37I'll also be updating all three sports on the website each morning.
- 21:40You can find that at commonsenserankings.com.
- 21:44I've also built a blind resume tool into the website.
- 21:47You can pick the teams you want to compare or ask for a random comparison to see the resumes without team names side by side and decide for yourself who's performed better on the field or court this season.
- 21:57Thank you again for listening, and please, as you go about your day-to-day, use some common sense