Latest / The Great Retirement Debate with Ed Slott & Jeffrey Levine / S1 Ep2: GRD002 - Trusts as a Beneficiary
Transcript
- 0:00INTRO: Hi, I'm Ed Slott and I'm Jeff Levine.
- 0:02And we're two guys who just love to talk about retirement and taxes.
- 0:06Look, our mission is simple to educate you the saver so that you can make
- 0:10better decisions because better decisions on the whole lead to better outcomes.
- 0:14And here's how we're going to do that each week.
- 0:16Jeff and I will debate the pros and the cons of a particular retirement strategy
- 0:21or topic with the goal of helping you keep more of your hard earned money.
- 0:26Yeah, but we won't know which side of the debate we're taking until we flip a.
- 0:30Winner of the coin flip gets to pick which side of the debate they want to argue.
- 0:33And both of us will have to argue in favor of our respective positions,
- 0:38whether we agree with them or not.
- 0:40At the end of each debate, there's going to be one clear winner.
- 0:43You a more informed saver who can hopefully apply the merits of
- 0:47each side of the debate to your own personal situation, to decide
- 0:50what's best for you and your family.
- 0:52So here we go.
- 0:53Welcome to the great retirement debate.
- 1:02Jeff Levine: All right.
- 1:02Welcome back to our latest episode of the retirement debate.
- 1:06Ed.
- 1:06Good to be back
- 1:07Ed Slott: The great retirement debate.
- 1:08I thought it was
- 1:09Jeff Levine: What'd I say?
- 1:10What'd I say?
- 1:11Ed Slott: You just said it was a retirement debate.
- 1:13No, it's a great one.
- 1:14Jeff Levine: That's all right.
- 1:16Maybe this week is gonna be the excellent one.
- 1:17That's a, you know, it's, it's probably a good idea.
- 1:19We're we're still relatively new to this podcasting thing, ed,
- 1:22but probably a good idea to know the name of your own show, right?
- 1:25That's a that's that's usually a good start.
- 1:27All right.
- 1:28Well, uh, ed, what's on, what's on the docket for today.
- 1:31What do we got?
- 1:32Ed Slott: Well, some questions are surround whether a person should
- 1:36name a trust as their IRA or planned beneficiary and as with everything
- 1:41there's reasons for or against.
- 1:44Jeff Levine: All right.
- 1:44All right.
- 1:44That's a good one.
- 1:45That's a good one.
- 1:46I definitely get that question a lot.
- 1:47I'm sure you do.
- 1:48Ed Slott: Oh yeah.
- 1:49Jeff Levine: Quite a bit as well.
- 1:50Alright, so your topic this week, so I get to flip the coin alright.
- 1:54I'm gonna take tails and, uh, let's see what it comes up as.
- 1:58We're flipping the coin here.
- 1:59We're actually gonna use Google coin flip for this.
- 2:01Ed Slott: I didn't even know there was such a thing.
- 2:03Can we trust it?
- 2:05Cause we're talking about trust.
- 2:06You get it?
- 2:07Jeff Levine: Ah, you got they very good.
- 2:09Oh boy.
- 2:10All right.
- 2:10This is gonna be a lot of bad jokes between the two of us.
- 2:12I can see that already.
- 2:13We're gonna get groans, audible groans coming through the speakers.
- 2:17All right.
- 2:17So good news for you, ed.
- 2:19Uh, heads is the answer.
- 2:20So you get to pick.
- 2:21Do you wanna argue this?
- 2:22Ed Slott: Don't people get to see the Google thing?
- 2:24Like how do we know?
- 2:25You're just watching that.
- 2:26Jeff Levine: Well, I told you you won.
- 2:27All right.
- 2:27Fine.
- 2:28I won.
- 2:28There you go.
- 2:29Ed Slott: All right.
- 2:30no, I thought we would see the whole coin turning thing and everything.
- 2:33Jeff Levine: All right.
- 2:33So, well, no, one's gonna see stuff, ed.
- 2:34Remember, this is a podcast.
- 2:36Ed Slott: Oh, right, right.
- 2:36It's.
- 2:37Podcast.
- 2:37Right.
- 2:37I can think.
- 2:38Yeah.
- 2:38Cuz we're on video now.
- 2:39All right.
- 2:41all right, so you, it should
- 2:42Jeff Levine: hold on.
- 2:42Wait, I wanna just make a note to our producer.
- 2:44Ed.
- 2:44Don't cut this part.
- 2:45Please leave this in.
- 2:47Ed Slott: All right.
- 2:47Wait, then you gotta have a noise.
- 2:49All right.
- 2:50So I'm gonna make a noise.
- 2:51Jeff Levine: All right.
- 2:51There's the coin flip noise.
- 2:53Very good.
- 2:53I don't know if that came through on audio, but ed, you win.
- 2:56Great.
- 2:56You get to argue which side you want, which, uh, which,
- 2:59which one you going with?
- 3:00Ed Slott: I would say not to name a trust.
- 3:02I would go on that side.
- 3:03Although there are arguments on both sides.
- 3:05Jeff Levine: Well, I'm gonna do that part, ed.
- 3:06Hold on.
- 3:08I'm gonna do that part.
- 3:10All right.
- 3:10So you're gonna argue in favor of not using a trust.
- 3:14Yes?
- 3:15Ed Slott: I would argue not in favor of a trust.
- 3:18You said in favor of not using a trust.
- 3:20Right?
- 3:21I would argue against.
- 3:23Jeff Levine: Okay, perfect.
- 3:24So I'm gonna argue, I'm gonna argue pro I'm gonna say you should use a trust
- 3:29in most instances to leave your IRA or other retirement vehicle to a trust.
- 3:33All right.
- 3:34You wanna, you wanna, it's your topic.
- 3:35You go first.
- 3:36Let kick us off.
- 3:36What, why, why, what what's what's what's your argument against trust?
- 3:40Ed?
- 3:40Why?
- 3:40Why?
- 3:41I mean trust?
- 3:41Ed Slott: Well, there are reasons for it, but the secure act made it a lot
- 3:45less valuable before the secure act people had stretch IRAs, they could do
- 3:50it through, what's known as a conduit trust where you could get both the
- 3:54protection of keeping the funds in the trust with just small distributions
- 3:58going out to the trust beneficiaries.
- 4:01That's not the case anymore.
- 4:04In almost all the cases.
- 4:06Non-spouse beneficiaries.
- 4:07There are exceptions of course, with everything, but most
- 4:10non-spouse beneficiaries will have to empty that account.
- 4:14Or if it's left to the trust, will have to be paid into the trust
- 4:17by the end of the 10th year after death under these new 10 year rules.
- 4:21And if you want.
- 4:22Credit or, or the credit or a trust protection or protection for the, uh,
- 4:26beneficiaries or from the beneficiaries, it would have to remain in the trust
- 4:31and get taxed in the trust at high trust tax rates, trust tax rates, not
- 4:36that they're high, but the brackets are very compressed after about 13,000.
- 4:41You're at the top, right?
- 4:42Where an individual wouldn't hit that rate till over 500,000.
- 4:46So.
- 4:46What's the cost of protection.
- 4:49It may be prohibitive.
- 4:50So I don't think most people need that kind of, uh, heavy duty
- 4:54lifting of a trust, uh, given the cost and the complexities.
- 5:01Jeff Levine: All fair points, but I, I would ask you this, what's the
- 5:05one thing we know about the future.
- 5:09Ed Slott: That we don't know
- 5:10Jeff Levine: That's exactly right.
- 5:12We don't know what the future is.
- 5:13And so if we don't know what the future is, I mean, what if there's a,
- 5:17a car accident or what if there's a, a, a divorce or what if there are any
- 5:22number of issues that we can't foresee?
- 5:24If there's one thing we know about the future, it's, it's
- 5:27unknown and you are right.
- 5:29Like things happen all the time.
- 5:30You talked about law changes, but I mean, I, I think.
- 5:33A decade ago, ed, think about all the things that have already happened since
- 5:38then, that you could have never predicted would be the case at this point in time.
- 5:42Right?
- 5:42I mean, who could have seen all the things happening over the last, I mean, in my
- 5:46own lifetime, over the last decade I got.
- 5:49Married.
- 5:50I had three kids.
- 5:51I moved halfway across the country.
- 5:52I mean, so many things happen.
- 5:55And if we can't foresee that, well, then the only reasonable approach
- 6:00might be to use a trust to make sure that no matter what happens in the
- 6:04future, that I have protection, you talked about taxes, but if I lose $1
- 6:10of my IRA to a creditor, I have $0.
- 6:13If I lose 40 cents of my IRA to a trust tax rate.
- 6:17Like, no, I don't want that, but at least I have 60 cents left.
- 6:23Ed Slott: Yeah.
- 6:23The only reason you would use a trust, uh, what I'm saying, I,
- 6:27it's not so much in the past.
- 6:29People used it for both tax reasons and non-tax reasons.
- 6:33I don't think there's a tax reason anymore because you don't get the long deferral.
- 6:37You don't get the stretch IRA for the most part.
- 6:39The only time I would use a trust, if you, it would be for personal non-tax reasons.
- 6:45Like some of the things you said, you have a minor.
- 6:48An unsophisticated beneficiary.
- 6:50Some of those things are divorced.
- 6:51Credit of bankruptcy, lawsuits.
- 6:53Every client I ever had, especially with young kids has told me.
- 6:59You know what I don't mind giving to my kids.
- 7:02The one, the thing that bothers me is the ones they marry.
- 7:06That's what they always say because they built up 3 million in an IRA and
- 7:10they say, but I don't want it to end up with somebody I don't even know now.
- 7:13So that may be a reason to name a trust, but I think it's overly
- 7:17cumbersome for most people.
- 7:19And you can use better vehicles.
- 7:21For example, if somebody said, I'm not sure if my kid's gonna be on drugs.
- 7:25Uh, problems or be, uh, full prey to people, uh, taking advantage
- 7:30of them with money issues.
- 7:32Then I would say if that money is earmarked for your children
- 7:35or grandchildren, maybe take it down at today's low rates and put
- 7:38it in a life insurance policy and leave that life insurance to the
- 7:42trust we have total flexibility.
- 7:44You get the post death control, you get the protection and low tax rates.
- 7:49Jeff Levine: Yeah, but what if it's not earmarked?
- 7:51What if I I'm one of the, the majority of Americans out there who say, you
- 7:55know what, I've gotta worry about my retirement first and if my kids
- 7:58get anything left, that's fantastic.
- 8:01Well, I can't spend all that money on life insurance today and go broke so
- 8:04I have no money left in my lifetime.
- 8:06I mean, that's a great problem to have don't get me wrong, where I'm
- 8:09trying to, to leave a, a giant legacy to my kids and, and God willing.
- 8:14Everyone of everyone listening today has that particular problem.
- 8:18But as we know, the, the majority issue today is I don't wanna run out
- 8:21of money before I run out of life.
- 8:23And if I spend all my money on life insurance, I'm gonna run out
- 8:26of money before I run out of life with a lot greater frequency.
- 8:29So I think we've gotta look at a, a situation where.
- 8:33You have a, a vehicle that if you end up with money and look,
- 8:38hopefully that's the case.
- 8:40If you do there's protection, but if not, you are able to spend
- 8:43those dollars freely in retirement.
- 8:45I mean, whether it's long term care needs or, I mean, we just, again, the future
- 8:49is unknown and putting those dollars into life insurance means they're probably a
- 8:53lot less likely to be used today for you.
- 8:56Ed Slott: Well, it could be used today.
- 8:57For example, life insurance could have long term care riders where you
- 9:00can pull out the cash value tax free.
- 9:03But if you're really worried about that, then you don't have as big an issue.
- 9:07I think the trust would only be for very large IRAs where more of that money.
- 9:11Will be passed to the next generation and won't be consumed during your lifetime.
- 9:16I would even put a dollar amount on it, but everybody's situation is different.
- 9:20I would say if you don't have a million dollars in an IRA, you probably, you
- 9:24know, uh, I would only consider a trust to say a million or more in an IRA.
- 9:29And every situation is different.
- 9:31Some people might say, that's not enough.
- 9:33I may need the whole million.
- 9:35So every situation is different and I agree you have to take care of yourself
- 9:39first, but if you're really worried about post death control, uh, you may want
- 9:44to lock some of it up in a trust, but I think there's better vehicles, IRAs
- 9:48were always lousy assets to leave to our trust with all the complexities and the
- 9:53hurdles and the obstacles and the tax rules and the RMDs and now the new IRS
- 9:58rules, making it even more complicated.
- 10:00Most of the trusts are not even done correctly.
- 10:02The average attorney uses these garden variety, boiler plate trusts, and they
- 10:07cause more problems and they're worth.
- 10:08And generally what I find is when people do have trust, even if they're done
- 10:13perfectly after say the husband dies, the wife says, well, I don't want that.
- 10:16I wanna just do a spousal rollover and get to my money.
- 10:20So I, I think it's a personal decision, like any big financial decision, but
- 10:24I think it's overly complex and taxing to leave an IRA to a trust today.
- 10:29Jeff Levine: I, I caught that by the way, overly complex.
- 10:31And, and what Ed?
- 10:32Ed Slott: Taxing
- 10:33Jeff Levine: Ah, yes.
- 10:34That's the second dad joke for today.
- 10:36All right.
- 10:37You're on fire with those look, I, I think you make great points all around,
- 10:40but, but if I'm John or Mary Smith and I've worked my entire life and, and, and
- 10:46scrape by, and, and I've accumulated, let's say it's 500,000, as you said, I
- 10:49put, put a million dollar number on it.
- 10:51I understand that, you know, there are some cost and complexities
- 10:54that come along with trust.
- 10:55But if I have spent my entire life working to build up this half a million dollar
- 11:00retirement account, that's everything to me, it, it represents my whole lifes work
- 11:05and the last thing I want is if something happens to me, for my kids to squander
- 11:09it or for a lawsuit to occur because of maybe something outside of their control.
- 11:14I mean, we live in a litigious society today, uh, where you can't forsee...
- 11:17Ed Slott: Really?!
- 11:19I never saw a sign.
- 11:20Uh, you know, I travel around the country and I never see any signs
- 11:23for attorneys looking for lawsuits.
- 11:26Jeff Levine: You're actually going to be sued now for, for, for liable on that.
- 11:29That's an untrue statement, ed.
- 11:31And we're going to,
- 11:31Ed Slott: I don't know if you notice this, you travel around too.
- 11:34Every city, the giant signs, personal injury.
- 11:37I get your money.
- 11:38Jeff Levine: Yes.
- 11:39Yeah.
- 11:39Well every yes, everywhere.
- 11:40Yeah.
- 11:40It's uh, Yeah, that, um, well we live in a litigious society.
- 11:45All right.
- 11:45So we, we agree on something.
- 11:46We can agree on that today.
- 11:47So we agree on that.
- 11:48Ed Slott: It all comes down to how much you think you need today,
- 11:51versus how much you're going to leave over for the next generation.
- 11:54If you think a big chunk of it is going to be left over and you won't need it,
- 11:58I still don't think you need a trust.
- 12:00You're probably better off with the life insurance solution.
- 12:03It's the most flexible asset to leave to a trust cuz you don't have
- 12:06all these IRA trust complications.
- 12:09Plus no tax.
- 12:10Jeff Levine: Well, I guess, I guess in some sense you win then
- 12:15because you don't have an IRA.
- 12:17And so if you don't have an IRA, you can't leave it to a trust, but I don't know.
- 12:20That's really in the spirit of the rule, ed.
- 12:22I mean, you're, you're saying like, let's just get rid of the thing altogether.
- 12:25I mean, what, what,
- 12:26Ed Slott: No, I'm saying if, if you wanna leave your IRA to a trust because you want
- 12:30the protection, you can get the protection using other vehicles besides the IRA.
- 12:36Jeff Levine: All right.
- 12:36All right.
- 12:37I'll I'll allow it.
- 12:39all right.
- 12:40I'll allow the argument.
- 12:40Where's my, where's my gavel?
- 12:41I gotta get my gavel out.
- 12:43At the end of the day, I, I just think that the biggest issue is, uh, we, we
- 12:48have so many unknowns going forward and because of that, You can have a,
- 12:54and you talk about trust tax rates, but what if I give my trustee the authority?
- 12:59Right?
- 12:59Like trust tax rates are only an issue.
- 13:02Ed.
- 13:02If I, as you know, if I hold the assets within the trust at the end of
- 13:07the year, that they're distributed.
- 13:08Ed Slott: Right.
- 13:08But that's exactly what you're going to do.
- 13:10If you wanna protect it from those kids blowing the money.
- 13:13Jeff Levine: Yeah, but what if I, well, but at least I have
- 13:15choice at that point, right?
- 13:16You talk about 10 years.
- 13:17Ed Slott: No, they'll be dead.
- 13:18So the trustee will have a choice.
- 13:20Jeff Levine: That's a, well, yes, that's a good point, but all right.
- 13:22So the trustee will at least have the choice 10 years from again.
- 13:26I told you all the things that happened in my life 10 years from now, uh, that
- 13:30trustee could make the decision as to whether or not they wanna keep those
- 13:34assets in the trust or pass them out.
- 13:37And at least at that point I would, I would have 10 more years of visibility
- 13:41into, I mean, if I could predict what would happen in 10 years from now, it,
- 13:44uh, I gotta tell you, I like you, but I wouldn't be doing this podcast with you.
- 13:48Ed Slott: You don't know that for sure.
- 13:49Maybe something else you'd be beaming it to another planet or something.
- 13:52Jeff Levine: That's right.
- 13:53Yes.
- 13:53Ed Slott: But going back to the trustee thing, there's another reason I don't
- 13:56like trusts who will be the trustee.
- 13:59Most people just arbitrarily name.
- 14:02Family member as trustee not realizing they have personal liability.
- 14:06They have to know all of these rules to paying IRAs to a trust.
- 14:10Most professionals don't know that, and most trustees are going
- 14:14to be unprepared for the task.
- 14:17Jeff Levine: Well, that's true, but I would just argue, we need to
- 14:19do our research and find the right sort of professional to work with.
- 14:22And, and perhaps that that's where we have to leave it for today.
- 14:25So, so help me, help me summarize, right.
- 14:28If, if, if I'm listening here and I'm going through this debate myself, and
- 14:32I'm trying to figure out whether I should be using a trust or not, what are some
- 14:35of the key things on both sides of the issue that I need to to think about?
- 14:38Ed Slott: Well, first, if you are going.
- 14:40Feel that you're going to consume most of your IRA.
- 14:43And I just put an arbitrary number on a million or less, probably not that, not
- 14:48that much need for a trust cause between RMDs and your spending, most of that
- 14:52will be consumed during your lifetime.
- 14:54The big issue is how much of your IRA or plan 401k you're going to
- 14:59be leaving to the next generation.
- 15:02Those are the funds you're worried about.
- 15:03If it's going to be a large share, you may wanna consider a trust, or
- 15:08better vehicles like life insurance, pulling that IRA down at today's low
- 15:12rates and have a more customized plan.
- 15:15You really don't get a customized plan with an IRA trust, cuz you
- 15:18gotta go through all those tax landmines and loophole, uh, not
- 15:21loopholes , uh, tax landmines and obstacles and play by all the rules.
- 15:27The life insurance may be a better situation.
- 15:31So it comes down to two things, how much you're going to leave over to the
- 15:34next generation and how much protection and control you want from the grave,
- 15:39ruling from the grave to protect the IRA that you worked hard for.
- 15:43As you said, Jeff, that you worked hard for for 20, 30, 40 years.
- 15:47Cause if you didn't, you wouldn't have anything to worry about to
- 15:50protect it for your beneficiaries and from your beneficiaries.
- 15:55That may be a reason to use a trust.
- 15:58Jeff Levine: All right.
- 15:58At least that we can agree on.
- 16:00Look, there are two sides to every coin ed, as we know, but your life is too
- 16:04important to leave up to a coin flip.
- 16:06And that's why these types of issues have to be worked out.
- 16:09One thing we always agree on ed is that you've gotta work with a knowledgeable
- 16:12professional to help you sort through the pros and cons of any decision.
- 16:16And we encourage all of our listeners to do that.
- 16:18If you'd like to continue to discussion with ed and I make
- 16:20sure you reach out to us.
- 16:21You can contact us on social media, reach out to us on Twitter
- 16:26@TheSlottReport for Ed that's @TheSlottReport, and @CPAPlanner for
- 16:29myself, let us know what you thought.
- 16:30Let us know if you've got additional pros and cons that we missed.
- 16:33And of course, if you've got a topic for a future episode that you'd
- 16:36like Ed at night to debate, let us know until then Ed it's been fun.
- 16:40And I look forward to debating you again next week.
- 16:42Ed Slott: All right.