Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL: Big Roy MacGregor sells Highlands port, hydrogen hullabaloo pt. 2 and NSTA shows teeth
Transcript
- 0:00Hello, and welcome to Energy Voice Out Loud.
- 0:04This is the weekly update from Energy Voice, giving you some
- 0:11insight into some of the amazing stories that we've had on the
- 0:15website this week. My name is Erica Asklan, I'm the
- 0:18News editor of Energy Voice and I'm here with colleagues Matt,
- 0:25who's got some exciting news from up in the Highlands Way,
- 0:31the sale of global engineering or the part of *** as well.
- 0:36We will then be going to our colleague Jessica Davies on an
- 0:42update on her investigation into home boiler trials in Fife.
- 0:48And then we will end up with the Nstas finally deciding to name
- 0:54and shame those rascals in the North Sea.
- 0:57Welcome, Matt. How are you this morning?
- 1:00I'm doing well. Thanks, Erica.
- 1:01It's good to be back after a few weeks off from the the podcast
- 1:05and it's been what a what an exciting week in the North Sea
- 1:08energy news it's been for to welcome me back into the chair.
- 1:12Well, you've been on a fabulous holiday in Australia and I'm
- 1:15sure you've probably seen some interesting stuff down there,
- 1:18but there was some really exciting stuff going on while we
- 1:20were away. We totally missed your insight
- 1:23and, you know, amazing writing skills on that one actually.
- 1:27Yeah. And in fact, so much going on
- 1:28that we're not even going to have a chance to talk about the
- 1:30Shells Q2 results this morning. But if you do want to get into
- 1:35all of that news, you can head to the Energy Voice website and
- 1:38see my rundown of those results this morning.
- 1:40As I think we were chatting, always started recording, Eric,
- 1:43it wasn't much particularly exciting there.
- 1:45You know, their profits were down on the the same period last
- 1:48year. But you know, it has been a very
- 1:50volatile global market at the moment.
- 1:53And I mean to to Shells credit, they didn't beat analyst
- 1:56expectations. I don't know if that just means
- 1:58that all the analysts were feeling a bit gloomy this year
- 2:01or if Shell is actually, you know, done, done better than
- 2:03expected. Gloomy analyst.
- 2:04Leave that to the readers to decide.
- 2:07I've ended that. Yeah, No, I mean, this is the
- 2:09thing about, you know, quarterly results for oil and gas
- 2:12companies. If the price of oil and gas is
- 2:13down, guess what? Their results are down, too.
- 2:15I mean, it's like as much money. Yeah, rocket science.
- 2:18It's not. But you know who is hoping to
- 2:21make some money is a Japanese firm?
- 2:24Mitsui. And they've made quite a big
- 2:26purchase this week. They've agreed a deal with long
- 2:32time partners and actually a company that they've invested in
- 2:35over the years, a global energy group, which is headquartered up
- 2:38in Inverness and steered by Ross County FC chairman Rory
- 2:43McGregor, who I believe you you've met over the years,
- 2:46Erica. But they've agreed to sell the
- 2:48Port of Nic, which is part of the Inverness and Cromartie
- 2:52Firth Green. Freeport has a lot of investment
- 2:54going up that up in that section of the Highlands, particularly
- 2:59around offshore wind and floating offshore wind in
- 3:02particular. It's not just the Port of Nick
- 3:05that Mitsui is snapped up. They've also picked up global
- 3:10energy groups, multi site fabrication and manufacturing
- 3:13business, global energy fabrication and it's scaffolding
- 3:16access division, global energy services.
- 3:18And I guess, you know, the way that it's sort of been framed is
- 3:22that, you know, this is rather than, you know, a company
- 3:24swooping in and snapping up some assets.
- 3:26This is a a long time partner with global energy group, a long
- 3:29time investor. They've they've been involved
- 3:31with global energy groups since 2012.
- 3:33I believe they had a about a 25% stake, you know, position on the
- 3:37board. So this is really just a
- 3:40strategic investment is what it was branded there from Mitsui,
- 3:43who's sort of obviously likes likes what they've got in, in
- 3:46the port of *** up in in the Highlands and they want to to be
- 3:50involved in its next phase of development, they said.
- 3:52Well, you know what I mean. For us fans of the Cromartie
- 3:56Firth, of which I'm one, it's just an amazing part of the
- 3:59country. It's huge, right?
- 4:01Ryan McGregor will just put it out there.
- 4:04Bit of a legend. I interviewed him.
- 4:07I've interviewed him many times and it's always, always great
- 4:10value. But one of the first times I
- 4:13think I asked him, so are you related to Rob Roy McGregor?
- 4:17And of course he said yes. So, you know, I mean, that sort
- 4:23of like Highland tradition is pretty cool.
- 4:25So, I mean, but I mean, is this, is this the end for Roy?
- 4:30I mean, it's not, you know, because, you know, he's 72, he's
- 4:33not getting any younger. But that said, you know, he's
- 4:36still like such a huge presence in that community, in that
- 4:41industry. I can't believe this is, you
- 4:42know, just him ceding, you know, some of his business interests,
- 4:47right? No.
- 4:47And. I think he said announcing the
- 4:50the deal with Mitsui that he's hugely proud to be passing on
- 4:53the baton, but I don't think he's he's out of the race as,
- 4:56as, as such. So, you know, Global Energy
- 4:59Group will be still keeping a hold of some of his other supply
- 5:02chain companies. They'll still be involved at the
- 5:04port of the Nix site. You know, there will still be
- 5:06Global Energy Group staff on a on a labor hire basis working at
- 5:09that site. And Aberdeen headquarter
- 5:12engineering firm Apollo, which is part of the wider group, will
- 5:15remain part of its portfolio. So I think this is is not not so
- 5:19much a case of, you know, Rory McGregor stepping down or
- 5:22stepping out of the game. I think it's just a a pivot.
- 5:26And you know, as we know in that part of Scotland, there's a lot
- 5:29of investment going on in really Global Energy Group has steered
- 5:32the port of need quite well over the years.
- 5:34I think they advanced over £120 million in redeveloping and
- 5:38expanding the port and they've been involved in some major
- 5:42offshore wind contracts. Beatrice Murray, E Murray, W Sea
- 5:46Green, a lot of big developments going up there.
- 5:48And of course, with Scotland and INTOG on the horizon, the green
- 5:52Freeport shaping up, you know, some other big port developments
- 5:56like Artesia and you know, Juventus investing quite a lot
- 6:00of money up there. So I think it's just, you know,
- 6:03potentially with so much going on, maybe they need someone with
- 6:07the deep pockets like Mitsui to to kind of be stepping up.
- 6:10And I think that's because we've also seen in kind of looking at
- 6:13this, Japan has really had its kind of sights on the offshore
- 6:18wind sector and, and Scotland in particular quite.
- 6:20You did a really interesting insight into, you know, Japanese
- 6:25investments into UK energy development and this is, you
- 6:30know, in Inverness, it's quite a lot of them go what so they've
- 6:34got. So in addition, and this is
- 6:38Japanese investors, you know, just not, you know, kind of
- 6:42really get anything else out. But of course there's Sumitomo,
- 6:45which are making that big £350 million investment in a cable
- 6:49factory. Freeport indeed, indeed.
- 6:52You know what, actually I want to catch up at some point with
- 6:55Green Freeport because of course, clearly this is not a
- 6:59new partner for them, but you know, it's a partner going to be
- 7:02stepping up, you know, to the table of the operation of the
- 7:05green Freeport, which of course just recently achieved.
- 7:09Finally, after so much dithering and sitting in a treasury, you
- 7:13know, office in tray somewhere for years and years, you know,
- 7:17they finally got their tax status.
- 7:19So I what this means, I'm not quite sure.
- 7:22There's a lot to kind of go in there.
- 7:23But anyway, so and then what other Japanese investors were we
- 7:28looking at here? We've got.
- 7:29Japan's state owned power company TEPCO is also a
- 7:33shareholder in Flotation Energy, which is involved in the Green
- 7:36Vault and Cenos floating wind farms, as well as the White
- 7:39Cross demonstrator project down in the Celtic Sea.
- 7:42And just this morning, we've actually seen Japan strike a
- 7:44deal with Vestas to advance turbine manufacturing in Japan.
- 7:52So I think kind of when you think about it, it makes a lot
- 7:55of sense. Japan's a big energy importer
- 7:57and they don't have, compared to other countries, a lot of
- 7:59landmass say they don't have the space, such as someone like
- 8:02Australia or Canada has to roll out huge solar farms, that sort
- 8:08of thing. So I think they're really
- 8:09looking at offshore wind and they don't have a hugely
- 8:12established offshore wind at the moment.
- 8:13They've got very deep waters. And so floating wind seems as
- 8:17something that Japan is really, really interested in.
- 8:19So it makes sense that you know, the, when you look at it in that
- 8:21context, these investments in flotation energy, these
- 8:24investments with Vestas port of *** it really seems as Japan,
- 8:28Japanese companies, the Japanese government is really quite
- 8:30interested in, in building out its floating wind sector as
- 8:33well. And they're looking at Scotland
- 8:34because obviously Scotland, Norway, the North Sea is really
- 8:37a a world leader, a hotbed for floating wind developed.
- 8:40And it looks as if Japan is trying to get in on the in on
- 8:44the action. Well, that kind of brings into
- 8:46focus the whole concept of energy security.
- 8:50I mean, if Japan, of course, you know, was subject to a recent
- 8:54tsunami warning, which, you know, was a real problem, you
- 8:58know, for their reliance on nuclear power.
- 9:00I think it was in 2011. Fukushima ended up, you know,
- 9:04kind of having that trouble. So flooding offshore wind
- 9:06actually sounds like a really interesting option for Japan.
- 9:09Yeah. And I think we, you know,
- 9:10getting slightly off track from the port of *** now, but with
- 9:13the. Yeah, that Fukushima incident
- 9:15really was sort of a turning point in nuclear.
- 9:18We saw a lot of countries sort of step away.
- 9:20There was this kind of real, I guess, change in public
- 9:23sentiment around nuclear energy. And we've just now we're really
- 9:26starting to see that reverse with obviously the huge rise in
- 9:29in artificial intelligence data centers.
- 9:31We're seeing companies like Amazon, Google, Microsoft, Meta,
- 9:35you know, investing in in nuclear.
- 9:37We're seeing the UK government doubling down on on nuclear and
- 9:40small modular reactors. So, you know, Japan's in there.
- 9:43But I guess bringing it back to to Rory McGregor, he's not
- 9:46outlined what's next on the cards for the Global Energy
- 9:49Group. But yeah, I.
- 9:51Don't think. This is the last we'll be
- 9:53seeing. He's he's, you know, got too
- 9:56much energy, he's got too much of an entrepreneurial spirit.
- 9:59I don't think he or the the wider McGregor clan are are
- 10:02quite done with the the Highlands just yet.
- 10:05I don't think so. You know, one of the things that
- 10:08I, I tend to speak to Roy about when I have been interviewing
- 10:13him is his real kind of like desire to want to see the
- 10:19Highlands and particularly, you know, the areas above Inverness
- 10:23and Port of Cremarty Firth succeed.
- 10:27He wants to, you know, see investments benefit the people
- 10:31of that area. He wants to make good houses,
- 10:33good jobs and, you know, just to address, you know, like he, he
- 10:38actually, you know, thinks that, you know, this sort of
- 10:41investment, you know, that he's been leading and galvanizing, as
- 10:46you know, is kind of the sort of thing that turns around, you
- 10:49know, trends that historic trends like the Highland
- 10:51clearances, like this is gives people a reason to stay there
- 10:54and work there and all that. And so he has been really
- 10:57focused on, you know, the energy transition and they've been
- 11:01doing such good work, particularly with ocean winds,
- 11:05marshalling, floating offshore wind and offshore wind, you
- 11:08know, in the Murray Firth. Like that gave them some real
- 11:11insight into, you know, what we're now seeing hopefully
- 11:16eventually being built out with Scotland and INTOG.
- 11:19They're in a prime position, albeit I think, you know, really
- 11:23when it still comes down to a global and energy group is still
- 11:25probably making about half of its money from oil and gas.
- 11:28But you know, they're really good exemplar of the sort of
- 11:32supply chain companies that are, you know, doing a little bit of
- 11:36both in this energy transition. And of course, decommissioning
- 11:40as well, which we'll be chatting about later.
- 11:42Commissioning the podcast. But first, I think we're heading
- 11:45off to to speak to our colleague, Jess.
- 11:48Are we Erica? That's it.
- 11:49No, Stay tuned for the next installment.
- 11:52We're going to be speaking to Jess with an update on her
- 11:56ongoing investigation into the trial to get hydrogen powering
- 12:02homes in Fife. Now hydrogen very flammable,
- 12:06although people are saying it's getting safer.
- 12:08But you know, would you want to have it in your house?
- 12:10Let's find out more. Welcome back.
- 12:51We are here now with Jessica Mills Davis, who's our London
- 12:55correspondent. And welcome Jessica, How are
- 12:58you? You've just had an arduous
- 13:00journey of from London to Edinburgh.
- 13:04Are everything OK? Hey, Erica, I finally got here
- 13:08following a couple of train delays, but I am in Edinburgh
- 13:11and you know what? It's warmer than London.
- 13:12It's warmer than London, which makes a change.
- 13:15It's lovely to be here. The streets are so beautiful in
- 13:17Edinburgh, especially Georges St., it's a pleasure.
- 13:21Well, glad to hear you made it in.
- 13:24And so you're going to be telling us now a little bit
- 13:28about this investigation you have been doing, you know about
- 13:34this hydrogen trial, which is from what I understand, it's
- 13:38about running 100% hydrogen in boilers and homes.
- 13:44So tell us a little bit about, you know, what you've found and
- 13:48what you've what you've been writing about on Energy Voice.
- 13:52Brilliant. Thank you, Erica.
- 13:54Yeah, that's right. So, so recently, actually it's
- 13:56been about six months, I've been investigating what's happening
- 14:00with hydrogen boilers in this country.
- 14:01So it seems like a a very benign matter to anyone who might just
- 14:08come off the street and and hear about hydrogen boilers.
- 14:11They don't sound particularly damaging in any way.
- 14:14They sound like they they might be quite a good thing.
- 14:16Indeed they might be. I mean, they can potentially
- 14:19reduce carbon emissions quite significantly compared to
- 14:22natural gas, which is a form of methane.
- 14:24So what I've been investigating is around the safety of hydrogen
- 14:28boilers and that's because a few companies in the UK have been
- 14:31looking to roll out trials on residents in various parts of
- 14:36the UK. The latest trial is looking to
- 14:39kick off in Fife in Scotland. Now what's interesting about
- 14:43this is that hydrogen, it's been found is 4 times more likely to
- 14:47explode than than natural gas, which leads to a massive
- 14:53potential risk in in people's homes.
- 14:56So 2 trials, similar trials were aborted in the UK in a place
- 15:01called Red Car and a place called Ellesmere Port.
- 15:04And they were aborted because local residents were up in arms.
- 15:08They were really concerned about the safety of these trials,
- 15:12about being used potentially as Guinea pigs in order to, to, for
- 15:17energy companies to, to essentially experiment on
- 15:20whether or not hydrogen boilers can be used safely and
- 15:23effectively in, in residents homes.
- 15:26Now the reality is that companies have tried to mitigate
- 15:30the safety, safety risks to some degree.
- 15:32So I was speaking to a couple of experts earlier this year who
- 15:37explained that there are some ways that companies have tried
- 15:40to get around the safety issue, For example, using an air cavity
- 15:46within the within the boilers themselves, which enables some
- 15:50of the air to get out. Now, apparently that can reduce
- 15:54the extent of the potential damage of an explosion, but it
- 15:58doesn't necessarily decrease the actual risk of that happening,
- 16:01according to experts. So the jury's out when it comes
- 16:05to how safe hydrogen boilers can actually be in the homes.
- 16:08So while they present a really, really potentially valuable way
- 16:12of cutting carbon emissions, they at the same time have these
- 16:15inherent risks due to the explosive and volatile nature of
- 16:19hydrogen gas. I mean, you know, the hydrogen
- 16:21bomb used hydrogen for a reason, because hydrogen is is is very,
- 16:25very flammable and explosive. So I actually wrote a book in
- 16:29which there was a scene around this, a book about Rosalind
- 16:32Franklin, in which in which there's a, there's a scene where
- 16:37she's contemplating whether or not the hydrogen tanks might
- 16:41explode in, in, in the, in, in the labs that she's working in
- 16:46at the time. Now that was a, a dramatisation
- 16:51of some real experiments that she was doing at the time using
- 16:54hydrogen at different, different quantities, which actually
- 16:57played incidentally a really significant role in, in, in
- 17:00discovering the structure of DNA.
- 17:02But really, you know, it, it points to the fact that, that
- 17:07it's commonly known that hydrogen as a gas is highly
- 17:10explosive, highly flammable, and companies now are looking to put
- 17:13that into people's homes and use it for electricity.
- 17:16So, you know, there are pros, which is that it could
- 17:18potentially reduce carbon emissions, but there are also
- 17:21these these real concerns. So right now as it stands, the
- 17:24latest, so we've been investigating this for about 5
- 17:27or 6 months and the latest or, or potentially longer the latest
- 17:31news that we've unearthed around this whole controversial move is
- 17:40that the Fife trial is essentially required to carry
- 17:46out safety assessments. And those assessments must be
- 17:50rigorously checked by the Health and Safety Executive in the UK,
- 17:53which is essentially the government agency for ensuring
- 17:56workplace safety. And it has a has a role in in
- 18:00overseeing these sorts of studies.
- 18:02So a government agency has to review the safety evidence for,
- 18:08for the five trial. Now what happened is the SGM,
- 18:10the gas distributor behind this trial essentially told us that
- 18:14that it was moving ahead and is looking to, to, to start the
- 18:20trial in, in, in autumn this year.
- 18:23Now it's already set up the, the generation I believe for, for
- 18:27hydrogen to supply these homes and the network is essentially
- 18:31all in place. The, the thing that remains to
- 18:34be decided is really, you know, is the trial safe enough to go
- 18:38ahead? Now, what the HSE has told us is
- 18:42that not only will it need to look at the evidence to decide,
- 18:47but the government, the Energy Department will have to look at
- 18:49the evidence often. We'll have to review the safety
- 18:52evidence of this trial in order for it to proceed.
- 18:56Now, SGN is pretty bullish about this trial going ahead.
- 18:59And we reported earlier this year that actually by the time
- 19:02we were reporting in February, it hadn't actually submitted the
- 19:06relevant safety evidence. Since then, we've had a fairly
- 19:10consistent dialogue with the company and the Safety Executive
- 19:13and we now know that the company submitted their safety evidence.
- 19:17They submitted what they call a safety dossier, which included a
- 19:19lot of historical information about how this trial would
- 19:22proceed. As of June, that's what they
- 19:27told us they had done. And the Safety Executive, as I
- 19:30say, they are looking at this evidence.
- 19:32And while while the trial doesn't actually require strict
- 19:35approval from the HSE, the HSE has told us under, you know, in
- 19:40in unequivocal terms that the government, the Energy
- 19:44Department, Ofgem has to look consider these, these findings
- 19:48seriously in order to make a decision as to whether or not
- 19:50this project can go ahead. It's not enough for the HSE to
- 19:53look at it. It's not enough for SGM to
- 19:54decide it's safe, you know, the government authorities must,
- 19:58must actually make a decision on this.
- 20:00Where, where does the buck actually stop on this?
- 20:03So who? Who green lights this trial in
- 20:07homes in Fife going ahead? Well, it's a very good question.
- 20:11It's a very good question. So SGN, as I said, they said
- 20:14that they'd submitted the evidence and the, the HSE and to
- 20:20some extent SGN have said that they, that they don't
- 20:25necessarily believe that the, the, the evidence will, will
- 20:29require that the project will require strict approval from,
- 20:34for example, the HSE. However, what the HSE has told
- 20:37us in no uncertain terms is that actually quite to the contrary.
- 20:40You know, the, the Energy Department and Ofgem are going
- 20:43to have to review this, this trial and the safety before we
- 20:46can go ahead. Now I've got my inklings as to
- 20:48why that might be the case. And that leads us on to to the
- 20:52next big development in the whole future of hydrogen in this
- 20:57country and hydrogen boilers and hydrogen residential heating.
- 21:00Now there's been a lot of, there have been a lot of murmurings
- 21:04and statements from Hydrogen UK from the National Energy System
- 21:08operator recently about just the extent to which they believe
- 21:11that hydrogen can be rolled out in this country.
- 21:14And they've been surprisingly, surprisingly conservative in
- 21:20their their future projections of, of how the roll out might
- 21:23happen. So they're said, they have said
- 21:26recently just this month that they don't really see a future
- 21:29of hydrogen being used widely in the residential heating network.
- 21:32Now this is really important because the government desner's,
- 21:35the Energy Department has told us in response to our inquiries
- 21:39that they will in due course imminently be launching a
- 21:45residential heating trial consultation, which will look at
- 21:50the the position of and potential for hygiene roll out
- 21:55in residential heating in this country.
- 21:58So the government is about to investigate this matter more
- 22:01more broadly. So the government's already been
- 22:03looking at the safety of injecting hydrogen onto the grid
- 22:06at various percentages. So that's, that's the blending
- 22:09consultation which it recently released just this month.
- 22:12Now, they'll eventually do have to issue a response and a final
- 22:15position to that consultation once they've looked at all the
- 22:18evidence. Now, what's been happening with
- 22:19the residential heating trial is that the HSC, the Health and
- 22:23Safety Executive, has since 2023 been gathering evidence from the
- 22:26safety of hydrogen in the homes and for use in in residential
- 22:30heating. They've already done a lot of
- 22:31ground work for this consultation, which is expected
- 22:35to be to be announced very shortly.
- 22:38So it's expected to be published pretty shortly.
- 22:40Now what the shape of that consultation will look like is
- 22:43currently unknown. So that it's not beyond the
- 22:46realms of possibility that the consultation might decide to
- 22:50limit the use of 100% hydrogen boilers in homes and take it to
- 22:55industry for consultation essentially for comment.
- 22:58Now that is what we've been hearing from sources close to
- 23:02the matter, that there's the potential that this, this trial
- 23:05in Fife might not actually be able to go ahead as a result of
- 23:09the government consultation. For example, if the government
- 23:12decides to ban hydrogen boilers on safety grounds as part of its
- 23:16consultation, which is imminent, is likely to be released this
- 23:18year, then then obviously all trials of hydrogen boilers will
- 23:24essentially be, you know, be cancelled.
- 23:26That's what we've heard from people, people in the industry.
- 23:30That was Jessica Mills Davis reporting on her special
- 23:33investigation into hydrogen home trials.
- 23:38Stay tuned. Next up, we will be looking at
- 23:42decommissioning and also venting and flaring in the North Sea.
- 23:45And what is a regulator doing about it?
- 23:48Find out more. Welcome back.
- 24:45So we're here again with Matt. An amazing thing happened this
- 24:49week. The North Sea Transition
- 24:50Authority finally decided to get some teeth or to say, you've
- 24:55been really following this mountain.
- 24:56You kind of like Fizz sometimes with, you know, kind of like
- 24:59righteous indignation whenever, you know, the NECTA fails to
- 25:04answer your questions. Are they going to tell us more
- 25:07now? Is this what we've been hoping
- 25:08for all this time? Oh yes, finally the the North
- 25:11Sea Transition Authority, the UK is offshore regulator, has
- 25:14confirmed after a painstaking year long industry consultation
- 25:18that they will be naming and shaming the names of oil and gas
- 25:21firms that have under investigation for potential
- 25:24breaches. So this is a fairly significant
- 25:26policy shift. So previously we would only ever
- 25:29find out the names of these operators after they've been
- 25:31subject to a sanction. And what this often meant is
- 25:34that the NSTANSTA would raise concerns with operators.
- 25:37They'd go through the investigation processes and
- 25:41often companies would be able to, you know, not get a
- 25:44sanction, reduce a sanction. You know, there'll be a whole
- 25:47ongoing process, you know, things around failures to meet
- 25:50their decommissioning obligations, flairing and
- 25:53venting breaches. And so this was kind of going on
- 25:55and I guess behind behind the scenes.
- 25:57And it raised a lot of concerns, particularly in the
- 25:59decommissioning sector that obviously, you know, when
- 26:02companies don't meet their decommissioning obligations to
- 26:05plug in abandoned wells or other things like that.
- 26:07When they kind of, you know, kick the work into the next year
- 26:10or, or things like that, that really has a flow on impact on
- 26:14the supply chain. Because obviously they need
- 26:16these contracts, they need this work to pay their bills, pay
- 26:20their stuff, you know, keep their cash flow going.
- 26:22And So what what has been often happening, particularly with
- 26:25with rig operators, if they're not getting that work in the
- 26:27North Sea, they're looking further afield.
- 26:29Australia has a lot of decommissioning projects coming
- 26:32up in its offshore sector. Australia's you.
- 26:34Know they're. Paying they're, they're quite
- 26:36keen to get that going. And so, you know, we're seeing
- 26:39rigs leave the North Sea and go elsewhere and, and what that
- 26:42does is it makes it very, very difficult and much more
- 26:44expensive to bring those back when North Sea projects need.
- 26:48So this is a real effort by the NSTA to I guess, you know, keep,
- 26:53keep the the nose to the grindstone of a lot of these
- 26:56North Sea operators to make sure that they are be keeping up with
- 26:59their obligations. And I guess, you know, with this
- 27:02effort, they're promising greater transparency because as
- 27:06they're arguing that if, if companies are, you know, being
- 27:10shown that, look, they're under an investigation, they're not
- 27:12doing the right thing, that this might be a bit of a nudge to the
- 27:15companies don't want that kind of bad PR.
- 27:17They don't want that kind of publicity.
- 27:21So it might encourage them to keep going.
- 27:24But I guess, you know, it really remains to be seen because it
- 27:27often the industry has often been criticized for, you know,
- 27:30the word paltry, embarrassing has been used for the the level
- 27:34of fines that they're able to dish out.
- 27:35You know, these are obviously companies with multibillion
- 27:38dollar profits, you know, multibillion # revenues and they
- 27:43sometimes get hit with £160,000 fine for, for flaring, inventing
- 27:48breaches or things like that. So, you know, compared to what
- 27:51we see the EU dish out to social media companies that that do the
- 27:55wrong thing, it's, you know, not particularly huge fines.
- 27:59It's kind of like a speeding or a parking ticket is what it
- 28:02sometimes feels. Like but.
- 28:04We'll we'll see if this has has an effect A.
- 28:06Little bit of a slap on the wrist.
- 28:09Because, you know, making this announcement, the NSDA Director
- 28:12of Supply Chain and Decommissioning, Pauline Innes,
- 28:15who we've spoken to a fair bit recently about sort of the
- 28:18struggles facing. Pauline, she's great.
- 28:19Yep. The decommissioning sector, but
- 28:21she sort of pointed out that, you know, last year there were
- 28:24103 wells decommissioned in the North Sea and then she spent
- 28:27about £2 billion with, you know, to to their credit, many
- 28:31licensees in the North Sea meeting their obligations.
- 28:34But you know, there needs to be over 1500 wells decommissioned
- 28:38by 2030. So that annual rate, what we're
- 28:40seeing at the moment, 102 wells that needs to double.
- 28:43And so, you know, sort of put the call out, Pauline, is to say
- 28:47that all of the industry needs to to step up because we have
- 28:50seen in in recent weeks or as recent months, sorry, concerns
- 28:55raised by a particularly, you know, industry veteran, Mark
- 28:58Patterson, He was the Co founder of of Wellsafe Solutions.
- 29:01He's no longer with Wellsafe, but he sort of expressed
- 29:04skepticism about sort of the short term opportunities.
- 29:07He's another industry legend, you know, who's kind of been
- 29:09done a little bit of everything in the North Sea supply chain.
- 29:13Yeah, for sure. And what he says, you know,
- 29:15really kind of matters, right? So.
- 29:16Yeah. And it's sort of not just, you
- 29:18know, the impact this has on the supply chain.
- 29:19Obviously at the end of the day, this has an impact on on UK
- 29:22taxpayers because of the way the decommissioning, you know, the
- 29:25financing of that is set up. So, you know, I think came out
- 29:29recently that the analyst firm Westwood said that they estimate
- 29:33that any further delay to an RC decommissioning projects could
- 29:36end up costing the UK an extra £4.25 billion.
- 29:39That's not, you know, that's a, that's a fair bit of cash.
- 29:43That's insignificant. Yeah, OK.
- 29:44And certainly we could probably use that for things like
- 29:47hospitals and schools and social care and all that sort of stuff
- 29:51rather than spend it on oil and gas companies dithering and
- 29:54waiting rather than, you know, pulling and then plugging and
- 29:57abandoning their their wells. For sure.
- 29:59You know what? Finally, I was just a few days
- 30:01ago NSDA came up with one of those fines.
- 30:05It was for Harper Energy, although it was associated with
- 30:11Chris ER, which was initially an earlier, you know, version of
- 30:14Harper, you know, in the M&A rounds.
- 30:17That is the Joyce of the North Sea.
- 30:20Now, interesting thing about it, £150,000 fine for a kind of
- 30:26venting, I guess like the wind blew out, you know, the, the,
- 30:31the flare on the Armada platform in 2022.
- 30:35But then no one really noticed. So seven months later they
- 30:38recognized that they were emitting, you know, got a far
- 30:42more methane and carbon and greenhouse gases and they'd
- 30:46actually be going. And so interesting thing was
- 30:48they said, you know, at some point the big announcement they,
- 30:53you know, they're really good. They do try to kind of like give
- 30:55you all the information, you know, that you could possibly
- 30:57want to ask for and saves you from having asked them too many
- 31:00questions. But you know, they said that,
- 31:03you know, from reports being coming in from 1st of January
- 31:082025 would then start levying fines of half £1,000,000 rather
- 31:14than, you know, kind of like these, you know, barely 3 figure
- 31:17fines like the one that harbor energy is paid.
- 31:22So I mean, I guess maybe you know, every little bit of you
- 31:26know, heft and their welly counts.
- 31:28But again, you know, kind of flaring, we want to kind of stop
- 31:32reduce that because greenhouse gases and you know, as part of
- 31:36the deal that they have to try to decarbonize and you know,
- 31:42kind of clean up the North Sea. And then as you know, Matt has
- 31:46been in a saying they also really need to start investing
- 31:52in decommissioning assets because you know, they don't
- 31:57need them anymore really. The NSTA is also looking at
- 31:59wanting to increase the fines they dish out for firms that
- 32:02don't need the decommissioning obligations.
- 32:04You know, last year I spoke to Paul who said they're looking at
- 32:06fine potentially of up to £1,000,000 for operators that
- 32:09fails to, you know, plug plug and abandoned their wells in in
- 32:11line with their obligated timelines.
- 32:14So it seems as though the NSTA is slowly but surely trying to,
- 32:18to get out less carrot, more stick.
- 32:20Although they are also, you know, there's a few other I
- 32:24think initiatives that the NSDA is doing.
- 32:26You can read about it on energy voice, but there's either twist
- 32:30initiative, which is, you know, basically trying to get more of
- 32:33a wider view for supply chain companies to so they can see and
- 32:36plan what kind of work is, is coming up.
- 32:38So carrot and stick approach. But it seems as if the the stick
- 32:42is starting to take shape at the moment.
- 32:45So we'll see how this this ends up going because they've not
- 32:48finalized exactly how they will be publishing these names.
- 32:51They've also been mooting an annual league table people that
- 32:54will rank North Sea operators based on how well they're doing
- 32:57in in meeting their obligations. So that will be very fun.
- 33:00For us. So we love a good ranking table,
- 33:02pitting them against each other so well.
- 33:06Anyway, readers, I reckon you can probably start taking taking
- 33:09your bets. So that's who you think is going
- 33:11to be topping at the top. Who's the best behaved of all
- 33:14the North Sea operators when it comes to decommissioning?
- 33:16Or the worst? The worst?
- 33:18Yes, absolutely. That's always more exciting.
- 33:19Well, you know what, it goes back to the start of, uh, North
- 33:24Sea Transition Authority, of course, which used to be called
- 33:27the Oil and Gas authority, uh, when it started.
- 33:31And I remember, uh, because it was, um, kind of forged in the
- 33:37establishment of a, a report chaired by Sir Ian Wood, which
- 33:41was maximizing economic recovery.
- 33:43Do you remember that, Matt? I mean, it used to be that the
- 33:46North Seam is really focused on what they called maximizing
- 33:49economic recovery, which was to get every last economic drop out
- 33:53of the North Sea as they possibly could.
- 33:54And of course, times have changed.
- 33:57We're no longer operating under that policy.
- 34:00And so NSDA is also operating, you know, under different
- 34:06circumstances and different policies and of course, a
- 34:08different name. But I do remember when, you
- 34:11know, one of the key, you know, suggestions out of maximizing
- 34:16economic recovery was for the establishment of a North Sea
- 34:19regulator. And I'm like going really?
- 34:22So they actually want a regulator.
- 34:24And again, you know, I think what they wanted was a regulator
- 34:27that worked closely with the industry and was kind of more of
- 34:31a critical friend than, you know, kind of necessarily, you
- 34:36know, a big enemy that had of a bunch of like London wine
- 34:40drinkers who didn't really understand, you know, what it
- 34:42was like out there, you know, in the North Sea on those rigs.
- 34:45So, you know, that's what we got And, you know, then you know it.
- 34:50I'm just interested and I don't know if you'll end up digging up
- 34:53any of this stuff, but a year long consultation with industry
- 34:58in order to kind of get this. Why don't we actually just say
- 35:02that if you are under investigation, you will be named
- 35:06rather than have to hide behind their secrecy.
- 35:08You know, I want to. It would be interesting to look
- 35:10under the lid of that right would be who disagreed and who
- 35:12agreed. This is not a new, new power.
- 35:14The NSDA has always had the ability to to do this.
- 35:17It's always had the ability to name power, name parties subject
- 35:21to a disputes and sanctions case where they think it's in the
- 35:23public interest. They've just chosen not to quite
- 35:26most often in the past. So this is sort of a, you know,
- 35:29this is not a change in the law. This is not a change in the SDA
- 35:31powers. It's a change in their, their
- 35:33policies. So, you know, some might ask why
- 35:36it's taking them this long if, if they've known about this
- 35:38problem for such a long time, why the consultation process
- 35:41took such a long time. But you know, the change has
- 35:46been made and we will, we will certainly see if any, you know,
- 35:50poorly behaved operators get named and shamed in the months
- 35:53to come. Of course, you can find out more
- 35:58about who's been naughty and who's been nice in the North Sea
- 36:01on Energy Voice. I've been Erica Askela, news
- 36:05editor of Energy Voice, and I want to thank Matt for bringing
- 36:08all of his great insights and investigations, as well as Jess
- 36:12for telling us all about what's going on in hydrogen trials and
- 36:15Fife. Find us next week.
- 36:17We will be available next week as well.
- 36:20And we are available on your podcast platform of choice
- 36:24always. Yeah.