Latest / Pedagogically Speaking / The Dangerous Lie About Passion in Teaching
Transcript
- Ilana: Here's the uncomfortable truth. The education system doesn't just tolerate teacher burnout. It depends on it. If you've ever stayed late, skipped lunch, answered emails at night, and told yourself, it's part of being a teacher, this is just what the job entails, well, this episode might make you a little uncomfortable. Because... if the thing that you believe makes you a great teacher is also the thing that's going to push you out of the profession. Welcome to Pedagogically Speaking. My name is Alana Huffer you for joining us here. It's so great to have you in the community ⁓ where can build trust ⁓ and those relationships with collaboration time ⁓ absolutely and funding getting ⁓ more more. ⁓ Sparse shall we say with funding cuts and no end in sight to those cuts This is the way that I decided it would be best to reach out to colleagues and reach out to teachers who are experiencing so much New teachers veteran teachers and everything in between so we can have a nice safe space together and chat. I really love reading your emails. Thank you so much for reaching out. The email is pedagogicallyspeakingpod at gmail.com. And thank you so much. I definitely use all of your questions and I put them into these podcast episodes. So please keep them coming. It is wonderful getting to know each of you so much more personally. So thank you. I have been teaching for 16 years and I'm an inclusive educator. teacher. I actually just did a workshop the other day over for a school and had a great time it was really lovely ⁓ and we were talking lot about teacher burnout ⁓ and we were also a lot about ⁓ how we see ourselves as teachers and can we change the perspective? Can we reflect a little bit and be kinder to ourselves? There was definitely a couple of teachers that needed to hear that they are amazing teachers because we are all amazing teachers. You are all amazing teachers and teaching is hard. All right, so today we are definitely talking about something that is going to sit a little heavy because it challenges what I think is one of the most deepest ingrained belief in education, is that ⁓ in order to be good teacher, you have to give everything. You have to give your You have to ⁓ give your energy. ⁓ And, you know, ⁓ a of emotional ⁓ when you have to ⁓ ⁓ co-regulate with someone. You're expected to give up your personal life, whether it's, you know, staying after school for clubs. And it's not that these things are supposed to be given up occasionally, but really it's more of a consistent kind of chipping away at yourself. But I think this is the truth that I really want to explore today, is that belief It's really just not sustainable, right? It's not something that can be done over and over again year after year. And actually that belief, it's part of the problem. It's really keeping us down, And I think it's really time to name it ⁓ and it clearly the martyrdom trap. ⁓ Okay, that quiet expectation that the best teachers go above and beyond, the most dedicated teachers always say yes, the most caring teachers sacrifice, they sacrifice their time, they sacrifice their home life. And the system, reinforces it constantly. It's not that we inherently want to do this, it's that the system, the institution of education, everything props up this belief that teachers need to be doing all of these things. They need to be giving themselves up into education, right? We're supposed to do it for the kids. Well, it's just part of the job. What did you expect being a teacher was? Or we all go the extra mile, but... You know what's rarely actually said out loud? When overwork becomes normalized, it stops being extra, and it becomes expected. I could not tell you how many times in the last, I mean, I'm just going to call it the last school year, certainly the last, like since people started like thinking about retiring at the end of this year or thinking about moving to a different school at end of this year, how many times have I heard, ⁓ well, that's just going to end when that teacher leaves because no one's going to take that up again. Well, you know what? Maybe that's for the best. How much free work can we really be doing in our jobs? We already pay for everything that's in the classroom, almost, like all of the beautiful things. When kids and families walk into the classroom, go, ⁓ wow, that's all paid for by teacher dollars. When you think about September, October, and November, we get paid the same, teachers get paid the same amount, September, October, November. And we're doing roughly the same work. Come December, when we are analyzing all of the data, scoring everything, bringing in exams, marking things, and then writing learning updates, report cards, whatever they're called, we don't get paid extra for that. That's just time that we're supposed to give. And that's also the time when winter concerts happen, winter dances, all of those things start just popping up right in that time and we're supposed to give all of that time for free it's for the kids. ⁓ well every other teacher in the school is doing it if you don't do it that's not gonna look good. Like all of these peer pressure things and that's not fair. I had a friend of mine get told well you don't have kids you should be volunteering the most. It does not nor should it matter whether you have kids plus you do not know what other people are going for like going through and how dare anybody shame you for not volunteering to do something. Some of us are able to run clubs and love it and get a whole bunch of energy from it. And that's fantastic. Those people are amazing. A lot of us cannot do that. And that's OK. A lot of us, think also, do know what our boundaries are and do not enforce them. And I think that is to all of our detriment. when we, when overwork becomes normalized, it stops being extra and it becomes expected. And ⁓ is exactly what the 2026 ⁓ is, right? ⁓ passion and dedication as teachers is becoming weaponized. Okay. And despite everything, everything that we know about stress and anxiety and burnout, the system has not fundamentally shifted. If anything, it's become more sophisticated in keeping us in our place and making sure that we are feeling guilt if we are not doing enough for our students. Teacher passion is still being weaponized. It's just in more subtle ways because we are hearing things like, well, we know you care about your students. So why wouldn't you stay after school to do track? Why wouldn't you drive everyone out 10 kilometers to go run a race? Right? Well, you say you're not going to do this, but This is what makes our school special, right? Or this is when, well, we're all a family here. No, we're not. No, we're not. No one has like changed my diapers here. I mean, I don't know if you work with your family, but still, you know what I mean. And you know what? Like, okay, fine. Maybe you're saying, well, those statements aren't really bad, but they really are. when you think about it because they're being used to justify unpaid labor which like no they're also being used to blur professional boundaries you know we're not family there is a hierarchy here okay it's also being used to silence pushback because we're getting these messages a lot of the time siloed It's not like there's a bunch of us, so then you think you're the only one that said no. And then you don't find out other people have said no until maybe you feel guilted into saying yes. Then you find out eight other people have and you're like, ⁓ I wish we had just known. like, and stronger together, okay? Saying no, when all of this is happening, saying no doesn't just feel like setting a boundary. It feels like you're letting your students down. It feels like now you're not being a team player ⁓ Or you don't care enough. And that's not fair. We are great teachers, but we need to stop being punished for either having boundaries and sticking to them, having families, or just not for whatever reason having the time to do all of those extra things. And I know when I grew up in the 80s and the 90s, there were things that teachers did, and honestly things that teachers did not do, that were done by, I don't know who, but there was also time for collaboration. There was time given off for collaboration and different things like that that we're just not getting anymore. So the prep time is already insufficient to actually prep for work. We're doing that before and after school already, and then we're supposed to be doing all this extra stuff. And if you really don't feel like you can or can't, or any other reason, you shouldn't be made to feel guilty about that. No should be an answer. And so... I think we should just define something that I think explains a lot. And that is this like sacrificial labor model. And when I'm talking about that, I mean like an unspoken system. where schools function because teachers give more than they're compensated for. That is something that is absolutely needed for schools to run. And the people who run schools know that. And they're banking on that free labor. And if they're not going to get it, then they're going to have to find a way to try to manipulate us to do it. Because there's gaps in funding. There's gaps in staffing. And all those resources. become filled by personal sacrifice, right? Emotional labor is expected, never acknowledged. Maybe you'll get, ⁓ yeah, it's hard. But what I hear most is it's hard for all of us. And that's from like leadership. And so what do you do with that? What do you do when you are openly saying, I'm overwhelmed? Or this is really hard. And you're getting, this is hard for all of us. Does that help? And sometimes I just really wonder what's going through people's minds when they say stuff like that to us. Because if I'm... If I'm acting vulnerable enough to tell you that I'm struggling, I actually need you to help me. I don't need you to tell me that I'm one in a million. Like, great, we're all struggling. That's actually telling me this is a systems problem and I really need you to fix it now. You know? So I think the key is that And I hate to say this because I think it's true. The system, this like institution of education, this system of student learning, it doesn't collapse because you, teachers, keep holding it up. We keep holding it up. We're the glue. We're everything that's like keeping students coming to schools, keeping communities, having safe spaces for students and their families. And that's greatly due to the fact that we are working on paid hours. And I think that's a really good thing to think about it. Because every time you stay late to prep, which we all do, every time you spend your own money, every time you take on one more responsibility, you are solving a systemic problem, temporarily. and you are reinforcing the expectation that it's manageable to do so. And what does that do to you? And what does that do to everyone around you? And what does that do to the people that we are bringing up behind us? If we keep doing all of this work for free, as it is already expected of us, as the building blocks of learning and education in our schools needs it to happen, we have got to stop upholding it. And let's face it, that's why mid-year career teachers are leaving. We are seeing record numbers of teachers leaving. Yes, not even making it to five years, but even between the five and 15 year window. And it's not because they suddenly cannot handle the job. It's because they've been handling too much for too long. No supports. No, and like, when I say acknowledgement, I say no acknowledgement. there's no admin coming being like, I have an extra hour. I know you're really busy right now. I'm going to take your class. And you can go. And I know you've got tons of prep to do. Right? Is anyone doing that for you if you're staying for a winter concert or anything? No. Right? So. Sure, you can acknowledge that this that we're all doing this hard thing right now. We're all staying late till 6 or 8 p.m. But there's no substance behind it, And then, you know, we have these early career teachers who are like overextending themselves to prove themselves, burning out and thinking, ⁓ I have to do this to get a job, even though you don't. We have veteran teachers who have more autonomy or boundaries. But mid-career teachers are often highly competent, highly relied upon, deeply embedded in school culture. which means they're carrying quite the heavy load. And eventually, something really does have to give. And we really need to challenge this good teacher narrative. And we need to really confront, think, reflect on this question of who benefits from the idea that good teachers sacrifice everything. Because I can tell you who doesn't benefit from that. Teachers. And long term, not even the students. because this idea that the good teacher equals a selfless teacher That discourages boundaries and it glorifies exhaustion. It also creates unsustainable expectations and it quietly shames teachers who leave at contracted time, say no to extra responsibilities, protect their personal lives, right? But here's the reframe. A sustainable teacher is a more effective teacher. A teacher who's not taking on too much, a teacher who can say no to extra things, those are teachers that are more likely to protect their time, uphold their boundaries, and not burn out. And they still might burn out because teaching is a hard profession. But at least they're giving themselves the best possible chance. Teaching, we all know. You know, it's so interesting because... Even I said it, I remember growing up and there were different activities and things like that. Some were run by teachers at my school, some weren't. teaching was also extremely different back in the 80s and early 90s. Everything about teaching was extremely different. And so you really cannot compare it at all. So if you think that a sustainable teacher is a more effective teacher, a teacher who's taken on too many things, they're more of a depleted teacher, right? And I think this is where it can get really uncomfortable because We need to start thinking of boundaries as advocacy. Setting boundaries doesn't really feel like advocacy at first. Some people can make it seem selfish. You know, it feels like you're disappointing people. You know, having boundaries and holding them can feel like you're going against the culture of teaching or the culture of your school. And it can also feel very isolating like you're standing alone. I think also... It can really, if you uphold those boundaries, you will really start to see how toxic the teaching culture can be. And that's not everywhere, of course. And that's not, you know, I'm not saying that's even most schools, but the schools that it's there, it can be really jarring to be confronted with that. Right? That isolation of like, that you're going against people. I think another thing too is that when you are able to hold your boundaries, It's advocacy because you're teaching, you know, if you have kids you're teaching kids you're teaching your students and hopefully you're teaching other teachers in your school that, you know, mental health is important and quite frankly physical health too because you will make yourself sick. And. When we can uphold our boundaries, especially when people are asking too much for us, and especially when the work demands free labor in order to go, we start to think of how we need to earn a break. Right, like, oof, well, I need this weekend, I worked so hard. We shouldn't really need to have one. to earn our breaks, but also we should not be so depleted by the weekend that we can't do anything. Hands up if you get sick by every break, right? Because your body has a chance to breathe and then your immunity, like everything has been in shock for so long that you just, get so sick. And that's, and then. Well, one, that's not healthy or great, but also, it's not a break, is it? Because you don't even get a chance to get back to baseline. You get back to where you were before you got sick, which, let's face facts, is not actually a baseline. Okay, so let's get back to this advocacy piece and how holding your boundaries is like, is an act of advocacy because the thing is, real advocacy isn't just speaking up in meetings, you know, going to your annual general meeting or going to the different meetings that maybe you have. Advocacy isn't just pushing for policy change. It's also refusing to normalize unsustainable working conditions. It is refusing to normalize working for free all of the time throughout the year to uphold systems that do not work through paid labor. When you set a boundary, you're saying, this is what a sustainable workload looks like. And that really matters, even when it's uncomfortable. And we need you to be uncomfortable. We need more people to sit in that discomfort and say, no, I will not be doing that. I cannot take on anything else. This job is too much. So if this episode made you uncomfortable, that's OK. It probably means that you're sitting right at the edge of something absolutely important. Because the goal isn't to care less. The goal isn't to become less passionate. It's to care in a way that's sustainable. And it's to make sure that people don't use our passion for teaching and for students and for learning and for inspiring. to hold us down. We need to care in a way that's sustainable and we need to advocate in a way that lasts. And we absolutely deserve to teach in a way that does not require us to disappear in the process. Thank you so much for listening. If you're listening on Apple or Spotify, please leave me a five-star review. If this is on YouTube, please give me a thumbs up and subscribe. Remember to email me at pedagogicallyspeakingpod at gmail.com and I will talk to you later. Bye.