Latest / Newcomer Pod / Taylor Swift Tickets, FTX & Twitter
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome. Hey, everybody.
- 0:13Welcome to Dead cat. It's Tom.
- 0:15I'm here with Katie and Eric, the whole family is back here
- 0:18together for Thanksgiving. So exciting.
- 0:21I feel like Katie like shows up, you know, like MTV's Daria and
- 0:24Eric's like arguing with like various cousins over like who
- 0:28can beat who in chess. I have a chessboard laid out on
- 0:32my carpet right now with a book. Yeah.
- 0:34It's like it's like the people who only go to church on
- 0:37holidays. That's me.
- 0:38I'm just showing up for the podcast on.
- 0:40Yeah, yeah. And I'm, I don't know, starting
- 0:42various contrarian arguments with different people at the
- 0:45table, all at once, but we've got an exciting episode today.
- 0:49So many scandals happening in Tech.
- 0:51So many things go unpack. So many people to blame and try
- 0:54to understand. But basically, as I see, we have
- 0:57two giant stories. Right now in one, we've got This
- 1:01cascading series of scandals in a sector that is Rife with scams
- 1:07begging, for regulatory involvement and maybe even
- 1:09criminal involvement and the other is ft x.
- 1:13So tiny, you're going to set it up that way.
- 1:16Yeah, so the first thing we've got here.
- 1:19What are things going good? Yeah, so what the fuck is going
- 1:22on with Taylor? Swift concert?
- 1:26Well, just got an alert for New York Times that the doj is
- 1:28investigating Ticketmaster, and Live Nation.
- 1:31This is something I don't really understand.
- 1:33I I actually listen to the new album because I knew that Eric
- 1:36wood and so I wanted what I wanted to have that experience
- 1:38with him. Yeah.
- 1:40What percentage of your Millennial cultural effect items
- 1:43are just like studying but anyway, yeah, I know Eric looks
- 1:47G like the millennial cultural, you know, immersion program for
- 1:51Katie without Eric. I'd still be listening to Lou
- 1:53Reed. Eric you probably were trying to
- 1:54buy tickets, right? So you've had oh my God, my
- 1:56stance is like devastated. I mean we both were working
- 2:00really. Hard to try to get tickets and
- 2:02like, yeah, I mean it's sour Enos lately on Taylor Swift,
- 2:06though she put out something on her Instagram today.
- 2:10I mean, it's it's pretty brutal. I mean it's this solution to.
- 2:14It isn't clear. I'm much more in the, you know,
- 2:17free marketer. Like oh, let these things be
- 2:19sold in the secondary for like a 10,000, Mark.
- 2:22Oh, no. Don't don't create this
- 2:24situation where they're so cheap on the, you know, from the
- 2:27primary seller that they're all these people.
- 2:30Are basically incentivized to flip them.
- 2:32I mean I think it should just be a pool of ones that are
- 2:35dedicated to fans and they need to do a much better job of
- 2:37making sure those get to fans and then a pool of tickets that
- 2:40are truly happy to Mark himself and isn't that whole issue,
- 2:46right? Right right.
- 2:47That's why I'm like when you say fans, you mean humans?
- 2:50Yeah. Yeah.
- 2:50They should hook it up to like Spotify.
- 2:53They should be like, how many fucking Taylor records have you
- 2:57bought, you know? Like, I mean, they should and
- 2:59they should only make People should only be able to get like
- 3:01one, you know, one, you know, one for each person.
- 3:05So I think they just need to do a much better job of, you know,
- 3:08human identification. Here are some sort of a quiz.
- 3:12Like in the way they do like a captcha to understand dryer, you
- 3:14may also feel like a fan captcha.
- 3:16Be like you know like which of these lines did not appear in
- 3:20ever more those or some songs is about which boyfriend.
- 3:24Well, that's good. Right.
- 3:25Oh my God. Yes, Harry Styles.
- 3:28Yeah. Match the line.
- 3:30To the boyfriend who fuck the patriarchy is.
- 3:33You know, you know, five paragraph essay on why Jake
- 3:38Gyllenhaal's like the worst of these are great ideas.
- 3:44I would say much more effective than like doj involvement.
- 3:47I think we can stop. We we already solved it right
- 3:49here. If the answers Tom Hiddleston,
- 3:52you know, it's not a real person, right?
- 3:54We had like Taylor Lautner boyfriend or not boyfriend was
- 3:58people I think I think boy, By the way, I think boyfriend.
- 4:02Yeah, thanks. Twilight era.
- 4:03Okay. I was I was getting a coffee
- 4:07with somebody who knows, Josh Kushner, and it took everything
- 4:10in my being not to be like, do you think Karlie Kloss did date
- 4:14Taylor Swift? You're aware of daylor Swift.
- 4:18This is actually something I've been supposed to ask you even
- 4:21I'm aware. I wasn't until roses like
- 4:24co-workers who is gay and was explaining at length.
- 4:27The Gaylor Swift conspiracy. Have you listen to the question?
- 4:30Like I do think she probably dated Karlie Kloss.
- 4:33Like I think that's more likely than but did she date Lena
- 4:35Dunham. I'm scared when they're
- 4:38photographed kissing each other? You know what I mean?
- 4:40Like that means. No.
- 4:41I mean yeah you heard of it was the squad Donna and but I think
- 4:46that whether or not it happened, the way that it has fueled fan
- 4:51speculation and I think, can we draw a direct line between
- 4:54something the question. The open question of whether or
- 4:57not Taylor Swift dated Karlie Kloss to this insane.
- 5:00In collapse of the Ticketmaster Ticket system.
- 5:02Maybe, I mean, it's that kind of intrigued that fuels this kind
- 5:06of fan base, right? You mean, do row her?
- 5:08Just being able to like play her fans.
- 5:10Like a fucking violin. Absolutely absolute build up
- 5:14even more intrigued. So like, oh, maybe she'll have
- 5:16is a special guest like one of her Gaylor Swift.
- 5:19You know, conspirators. That would be amazing.
- 5:21Yeah. Well the thing is I mean, I have
- 5:24no emotional attachment to her as an artist or as a human being
- 5:28but I don't think she does either really.
- 5:29She seems like A purely capitalistic marketing product
- 5:32to answer. Yes, no.
- 5:33She's connected to her fans. What are you talking?
- 5:35Well, in a way, that it benefits, or I'm not even saying
- 5:37this is a criticism. She is like a pure distillation
- 5:39of like late capitalism, you know, in like the marketing of
- 5:43a, you know, very talented artist.
- 5:44Bailey, I mean, the Pinnacle of that just to give you a little
- 5:48data is that, you know, like, she somehow got her fans, invest
- 5:51in her re-recording the album's just so she could make money or
- 5:55Masters and not so well because he understood that she was a
- 5:57victim of Scooter, Braun. And so we have We were forced,
- 6:01we were forced to band together to fight life's all about
- 6:05cheering for your favorite rich person.
- 6:06I mean that's exactly it wasn't exactly to the conversation of.
- 6:10Yeah. It wasn't like, oh, we're gonna
- 6:11get great new music from Taylor. It's like we're gonna get the
- 6:13same old music that's going to make you richer.
- 6:16Exactly. And that's my investments.
- 6:18Are we need her to be our billionaire?
- 6:20You know, in a world where that's all the matters, you
- 6:22know. Well, we're down one musician.
- 6:24Billionaire with, with ye so I feel like Taylor should more
- 6:28effectively fill that spot. But yeah.
- 6:30You know who would have thought that the Kanye Taylor fight
- 6:33would have ended here. Oh, I assume she's like, that
- 6:37was what rocket fueled her into becoming even more successful in
- 6:39the same way that like Donald Trump ran for president, because
- 6:42Obama made fun of him. And that one White House
- 6:44Correspondents Dinner. I assume Taylor was like, I'm
- 6:47going to dominate the music industry because I was
- 6:49embarrassed once at an award show, by a drunk Kanye.
- 6:53I mean, they're worse, reasons? Sure.
- 6:55All right, so here's what we got on today's episode.
- 6:58It's time that we do a Recapping of where things are with FTX.
- 7:02And I've spent a lot of time in the last week reading.
- 7:05All the stories I even read the entire milky eggs, post what
- 7:10you're talking about? No, there's some blog called
- 7:13milky eggs in which there's like a 10,000 word unwinding and
- 7:17speculation on where all the money went over.
- 7:19These like things will probably not be relevant the you guys
- 7:22didn't see that. Anyway yeah, all these things
- 7:24will probably be irrelevant once, you know the full order
- 7:26of, you know, the internal mechanisms or put forward in the
- 7:30The courts. But for the time, you know,
- 7:31there's been a lot of speculation.
- 7:32Anyway, I read all of that. Yeah, it'll be good for you to
- 7:35explain because I mean, obviously, we joke on this
- 7:37podcast sometimes about not bringing people along, but I
- 7:39think even sort of the most hardcore sort of tech readers
- 7:45Among Us would benefit from a little bit of a, sort of
- 7:48summation, of, of the Scandal. So follow, this is the nation.
- 7:51This beautiful stay one, but no, okay.
- 7:54Well, basically where we are right now, is that the FTX
- 7:58unwinding since, you know, the Finance selling of the ftt
- 8:02tokens revealed that FTX was highly over leveraged, its main
- 8:06token collapsed and value. There is a huge run on the FTX
- 8:11Bank, essentially by all of its depositors.
- 8:14And that revealed that the company had basically and Sam
- 8:17bakeman freed had taken all of the assets that were in there
- 8:20and tried to cover up. All the losses, that his related
- 8:23hedge fund Alameda, had been using to cover all of their
- 8:27losses because they had been taking incredibly risky.
- 8:30A bets, not just to cover their losses but to trade, to fund the
- 8:32entire trading arm. Yeah.
- 8:34Because they had so many losses, right?
- 8:36I mean, I assumed they were only dipping into the FTX piggy bank
- 8:39because they were down so much in all of their investment.
- 8:42That was something it was unclear to me.
- 8:44Whether it was something they did out of desperation or just
- 8:46something that they did to feel that to feel the trading
- 8:49platform and success of it. Well, I think Matt Levine made
- 8:52this point. But like, what's funny looking
- 8:54back on this is that I think while Sam SBF was sort of In his
- 9:00prime and like everybody worshipped him.
- 9:02The Assumption was that he was sort of improperly using
- 9:06information from FTX to become a really good Trader at Alameda
- 9:11and that's why he was so rich. Like, he had this sort of inside
- 9:14information but in fact, he was just using customer accounts
- 9:18from ft x and he wasn't like a great trainer at all, and he was
- 9:21just siphoning all the money to blow it on Alameda on failed
- 9:25trading strategies. It's the very fine line between
- 9:27like a high-frequency Trader and A Ponzi scheme, right?
- 9:32Right, right. So that's you know, a very quick
- 9:35and dirty explanation of why FTX Unwound and then what happened
- 9:39since then is they broaden a, what's the term?
- 9:42I mean, like an interim. CEO, a ward, a cleanup guy.
- 9:47A cleanup guy in a cleanup guy. Yeah.
- 9:49They brought in like the adults in the room who basically, you
- 9:51can imagine the picture here. You know, they fly in the sky
- 9:54into the Bahamas. I imagine he's like walking up
- 9:56into like the F16 and of like the Pelican Brief.
- 9:59Yeah. Exactly.
- 10:00He walks into the office. He like takes out his briefcase.
- 10:03He tells his right-hand man like schmidty.
- 10:05You know how this goes? I need two gallons of coffee.
- 10:08I need, I need protein, I need carbs, every 45 minutes.
- 10:12Let's dig into this thing, and then he liked it and goes, holy
- 10:15shit. Yeah, he opens up the file.
- 10:17Not like a zombie. He throws up.
- 10:19I mean this guy dealt with Enron.
- 10:20This guy always the cleanup great for Enron.
- 10:23Yeah. And then Tom do you have in
- 10:25front of you, eat like a statement?
- 10:26Well, it's out of savings in the chapter 11 bankruptcy filing
- 10:29which these Things. I don't know, Katie.
- 10:31If you've read these before, when you were covering the 08
- 10:33collapse, but these are pretty dry documents typically.
- 10:35Yes, very lawyer. The, there's no color in a
- 10:38chapter 11, filing, there's no killer quotes that come out of
- 10:43it, but this was one of the lines is pointing directly from
- 10:45the chapter 11 filing in Delaware.
- 10:47Once again, Delaware is one of the most interesting states
- 10:50because of a scandal, I have over 40 years of legal and
- 10:54restructuring experience, I have been the chief restructuring
- 10:57officer or chief executive officer and several of Largest
- 11:00corporate failures in history. I have supervised situations
- 11:03involving allegations of criminal, activity, and
- 11:05malfeasance in parentheses N, Run.
- 11:08I have supervised situations involving novel.
- 11:10Financial structure is parentheses Enron and
- 11:12residential capital and cross-border acid recovery, and
- 11:15maximization, Nortel and overseas ship holding.
- 11:18I don't know those, but they were bad too.
- 11:21Really every situation in which I have been involved.
- 11:23Has been characterized by defects of some sort and
- 11:25internal controls Regulatory Compliance, human resources and
- 11:29systems. Items Integrity.
- 11:31Next paragraph, never in my career.
- 11:34Have I seen such a complete failure of corporate controls
- 11:37and such a complete absence of trustworthy, financial
- 11:39information as occurred here, from compromised systems
- 11:42integrity, and faulty regulatory oversight abroad to the
- 11:45concentration of control in the hands of a very small group of
- 11:48inexperience, unsophisticated, and potentially compromised
- 11:52individuals. This situation is unprecedented,
- 11:55he doesn't say they're all fucking each other or like,
- 11:58well, you know, that wasn't in the books.
- 12:02Vlog that now. Yeah.
- 12:04He's like also, they were kind of was no HR department, right?
- 12:07Yeah. Like also these beanbags smell
- 12:09but I'm not going to guess what? Yeah, this is basically like the
- 12:14cleanup specialist like the garbageman comes in there and
- 12:16it's like, what the fuck is that smell?
- 12:19And I mean, as I read through the bankruptcy filing, which I
- 12:22actually did read through most of it because it is pretty great
- 12:24reading. One of the biggest takeaways
- 12:26from it and I think maybe the most shocking that I saw a lot
- 12:29of, you know, analyst Reporters pick up on.
- 12:31It doesn't seem like they have any idea where the money went
- 12:35and more. So they don't even know how much
- 12:37money they had. They have no records of the
- 12:39liabilities in there. So when it gets to a point,
- 12:42where the people who had their money stored in FTX will
- 12:46reasonably ask, hey, where did my money go?
- 12:48There doesn't seem to be any accounting for that.
- 12:51No, so this is always gonna like, yes, just imagine being
- 12:55the type of person they can just be out and about with the
- 12:59knowledge that This is all gonna come crashing down someday.
- 13:03Like I there. I mean, maybe I don't want to
- 13:06jump ahead, but like I've seen speculation we all made of 5,
- 13:10right? This is where I think that that
- 13:14sort of like Bernie Madoff, feel really takes hold.
- 13:18No one has any idea. What's going on?
- 13:19Nobody knows where the money is. It's really just all been a hope
- 13:22and a prayer and like kind of preying on people who have who
- 13:28are other crypto Believers. There's just It's a lot.
- 13:31We don't slay, star codex, Scott, Alexander.
- 13:33Yeah, yeah, he had a piece basically like analyzing the
- 13:38medicine, the drugs that SPF is taking and just sort of
- 13:43wondering whether perhaps like a side effect of these drugs was
- 13:46like a gambling Iraq. These it is it's a new argument
- 13:50against Adderall. Is that like it's not Adderall?
- 13:53It's some weird. You know.
- 13:54I thought that was it. It was not even that we do.
- 13:56It's like some rule is some patch, we can look it up well
- 13:59because he failed. Miss Lee s BF.
- 14:00This is was famously only sleeping like four hours a night
- 14:04because when he was not the psychopharmacology of the FTX
- 14:08crash. Yeah, yeah.
- 14:10So there was just all kinda know is that he was designer
- 14:13laterals, it's called Sela Jolene, em Sam.
- 14:18I mean I'm I don't take any stimulants, I people have come
- 14:22up to me, people come up to me and they're like, oh yeah, I
- 14:25just I take, you know, the way to do a cross-country flight is
- 14:29like taking An Ambien and then take an Adderall and their side.
- 14:32I'm like I'm not living that life.
- 14:34I'm not, I'm not living that gambian lifestyle.
- 15:00It's about you. Even if you might be like
- 15:01marginally happier, like, I don't want like, I don't know,
- 15:04well my few times taking Adderall, my experience at
- 15:07typically been that I just felt like my brain was functioning
- 15:10differently. Like I wasn't thinking in the
- 15:11same way. I was definitely awake friendly.
- 15:14Yeah, but it's like my thought processes were not like the
- 15:17train wasn't going down the track in the way that I was
- 15:20comfortable with. And I was definitely alert and
- 15:23very awake, there was no denying that but I never really thought
- 15:26like boy, if I had access to like a trading terminal, I could
- 15:29the billions right now. Write what, you know, I already
- 15:33think every idea that I have is like gold.
- 15:36So imagine on cocaine, you know, just sort of like the right.
- 15:40That's like, let's just pull it through and let's go like me.
- 15:44I have a lot to have a lot to say right now.
- 15:46Like we could barely keep you on track during the podcast.
- 15:49Be taking notes on this. It's like that Billy crudup from
- 15:53America from almost famous scene, where he screams, I'm a
- 15:55golden god, that's Eric, just unkind.
- 15:59That's just Generally. Yeah.
- 16:01That's before the Ambien. Exactly.
- 16:03I that's just me on a scoop like get a scoop.
- 16:06I'm like all right just yeah. It what were most reporters are
- 16:09like you know scoop coming Eric's is like I'm a golden god.
- 16:15Anyway, so yeah, he's not sleeping.
- 16:19Yeah, it's not sleeping when he feels guilty clearly but
- 16:22continue. Well, I want to get to that in a
- 16:24second, but yes, what. So when he's not sleeping he's,
- 16:27you know, he's on the he's on the grind and apparently he's
- 16:30really shitty at League of Legends which is my favorite of
- 16:33all the twists and all of this. Because there is this kind of
- 16:36like ongoing theme that he was like playing League of Legends
- 16:38in the background while speaking to reporters and his investors
- 16:42and shit like that. And then you know I think it was
- 16:44the Ft or something. Has revealed that his ranking on
- 16:46League of Legends is actually extremely mediocre.
- 16:48He's a bronze something or other.
- 16:50Yeah yeah. So this like the fraud goes
- 16:53incredibly deep with this guy's but apparently he had taken out
- 16:58a 1 billion dollar loan on some of the assets here.
- 17:02It's not really clear where he spent the money on, although FTX
- 17:05had bought houses for some of the people at the company.
- 17:08But what's clearly going to be happening over the next couple
- 17:11weeks is trying to answer the question of like, where the
- 17:14money went Oh, that's also interesting because in that
- 17:16report that you referred to, there's also indications that he
- 17:20was taking the money even as he knew, his firm is collapsing and
- 17:22safing it out through different entities in the Bahamas.
- 17:27So nobody knows if he was taking things on his way, out the door
- 17:31either. Yeah, right.
- 17:32I do think people, I mean, I think we're going to get into
- 17:35the interview with Vox, but there is a little bit of It's
- 17:40like, he probably took the money, you know, he's like he's
- 17:44not admitting special people, even though this guy is like
- 17:48clearly lied every, which way there's still sort of a desire
- 17:52to assume, he's telling the truth in any given interview.
- 17:55Even though it's like at this point, how can you trust a word?
- 17:58This guy says, right? And so at this point, aside from
- 18:02these apparent, tweet threads, that he's been putting together
- 18:06in which the first one was, just the spelling out of the word.
- 18:09What? And right, and then followed by
- 18:13some sort of a thread that maybe tried to give some explanation
- 18:16as to what went down. He first gives an interview to
- 18:20the New York Times, David yaffe, Bella knee, who's like the
- 18:24crypto reporter over at the Times.
- 18:26David got a lot of shit for this story because people felt that
- 18:31they were not pressing him hard enough.
- 18:32And there was kind of a quote in there, in which they were like,
- 18:35how are you sleeping? Well, these days I don't know
- 18:38how you guys feel about that story gets Katie, you know, you
- 18:40know, David so you know, I do want to put you too much on the
- 18:42spot here, but I thought the story was fine.
- 18:45I thought he came off like a psychopath with was my
- 18:48interpretation of it. It's like I don't know how much
- 18:50more the fraud and malfeasance is so evident here.
- 18:54I don't know how much browbeating right.
- 18:55Like journals begins to do like a certain type of person who is
- 18:59so mad at Maggie Haberman, because they just wanted to put
- 19:02after every line. She reports.
- 19:04And that is very bad. You know, it's sort of like
- 19:07Can't the reader read it and be like, oh, this see, I mean I do
- 19:11think the New York Times could have been a little more - and I
- 19:14think that sometimes you can get lost in like, well, we've got we
- 19:17put out a body of work. There's several different
- 19:19stories is one story, doesn't sum everything up but like
- 19:23overall I do think it's like yeah obviously, you're supposed
- 19:27to read this interview, me like this guy is like fucking yeah,
- 19:30he gave him enough rope to hang himself.
- 19:31I don't know how else to say like right, you know, it starts
- 19:34off with like, you know, Sam you just lost people.
- 19:37Nine billion dollars I'm actually sleeping better than I
- 19:40ever have before dated the lamb. Stop crying, David more
- 19:48billions, I lose the better. I sleep David like it's all
- 19:52right there, right? Like you don't need like a body
- 19:54language expert to come and analyze the person who confessed
- 19:57to a murder like, right? It's bizarre.
- 20:01I mean people just want to eat. I mean obviously you know the
- 20:04people should on the New York Times wrote like the Kraken CEO
- 20:07and the coin. A CEO who both had negative
- 20:10coverage from the times and I guess to the extent, I would
- 20:13defend them. You know, it's just like people
- 20:16get almost like more mortally Angry in some ways about, you
- 20:20know, coinbase not doing enough to include sort of minority
- 20:23employees then, you know, maybe SBF, sort of defrauding people
- 20:27of billions of dollars. And so I think it's just sort of
- 20:30the tenor and tone of different types of stories and sort of how
- 20:35Twitter can react. But obviously, So, my point is
- 20:38just, these are two CEOs who were covered negatively by the
- 20:41New York Times and they're happy to look for an excuse right to
- 20:43dunk on the New York Times. There is certainly a huge media
- 20:47aspect to the SBF story and a failing on the part of the media
- 20:51in the way that he was covered over the last couple of years.
- 20:54This is not a good example of it.
- 20:56There is a Feeding Frenzy right now on this guy, every single
- 20:59aspect of this person's life is going to be mind into content,
- 21:03right? Because it's an incredible
- 21:05story. If I don't know, they were
- 21:06scandals of our time. Crypto, people want to play it.
- 21:08Like the media is not going to willing to go after him but
- 21:12really it's like no, it's like the media is happy to go after
- 21:14one of their own if there is a case, it's right for a great
- 21:17story, it's a great story, but anyway.
- 21:20Yeah. So so that was that was the
- 21:22first interview that he gave and then I guess the real coup de
- 21:25gras was he had an interview with Kelsey Piper who is a ruse
- 21:31herself like an effective altruist person and right
- 21:33Porter, there is so this was, he slid into her DMs. And had an
- 21:39hour-long conversation with Kelsey Piper in which and it
- 21:43seems like they were friends in some way or they had a reporter.
- 21:46I certainly had a rapport trusted her enough to have this
- 21:50totally insane back and forth. I mean yeah.
- 21:52Truly one of the most self-destructive things I've
- 21:55seen on Terry what do you mean Katie if you still billions of
- 21:59dollars? And I check in on how you're
- 22:02doing? Asked what's going on?
- 22:03You need to at least say we're off the Record.
- 22:05All right. Look, I feel like call me.
- 22:07I don't care how good of friends, we are really a billion
- 22:11dollar like I hear you. Should at least like be like,
- 22:13Eric, I just want to be clear where this is not report, you
- 22:17know, it's just like there's, there's got to be a threshold.
- 22:19I don't care how not, I wouldn't, you know, I don't
- 22:22know. There's some limit of just like,
- 22:24if you become a criminal, you know, like, I don't know how
- 22:26much really to return your call Eric, right?
- 22:29Exactly. You might be hearing from my
- 22:32lawyer and right. Yeah, I encourage readers to go
- 22:36and read the article because there was a kind of funny back
- 22:38and forth between them in, which he has like a very casual style.
- 22:42So when she's DME him being like like what was going on, I'm not
- 22:46calling her out for saying, like I'm just saying that this is the
- 22:48kind of smart as usual strategy. Yeah, it was a very yeah, I
- 22:51guess he was, she was really luring him out but he also
- 22:53seemed like he was desperate to talk, right?
- 22:56You know, the idea that he was, you know, had his confidence
- 22:58completely. You know, subverted by this
- 23:01reporter here just doesn't really align with the fact that
- 23:04this guy's desperate to this. What kind of crazy people do is
- 23:07they want their, you know, Tales of derring-do, a manipulation to
- 23:10be out there for people to admire We've lost Katie Because
- 23:14by the time this episode comes out, you will understand.
- 23:16The reason why just I guess I'm maybe pointed a special counsel
- 23:19because they're chickens but or whatever Katie thinks they have
- 23:23a good reason but she has to go report on that.
- 23:25Yeah, so we've lost K throughout the episode, Happy Thanksgiving
- 23:28Katie will. So, you know, effective altruism
- 23:31obviously, is this philosophical movement, based in
- 23:34utilitarianism, where and largely funded by Sam Bateman
- 23:38freed, that was sort of donating with an eye.
- 23:42Towards sort of the future worrying, about pandemics
- 23:45worrying about things that cause the most human suffering.
- 23:48So that's that's effective. Altruism and in this exchange,
- 23:54he's sort of plays it off like you is never a True Believer.
- 23:58And that it was all just sort of a PR stunt.
- 24:00He disappears people of the notion that he believed in any
- 24:03of the things that he had been saying.
- 24:04And I mean the one that includes his belief in regulation of
- 24:07crypto. And then also that just general
- 24:09philosophy of effective altruism both of Is he kind of says, for
- 24:13PR stunts, but yeah, on the matter of, you know, regulation
- 24:17he texts the reporter, it was all just PR, fuck Regulators,
- 24:21they make everything worse and then actually I didn't pull out
- 24:26the specifics around effective altruism but I guess his point
- 24:30was that the idea like you're saying, the argument effective
- 24:33altruism is that in a situation in which there is a good usage
- 24:37of money and a bad usage of money.
- 24:39I guess all things considered you should be spending that
- 24:42money on people who know how to spend it on good things, right.
- 24:45There's so much more to it than that.
- 24:47I mean effective. Altruism has one key component
- 24:52of it. Is that while like a lot of sort
- 24:55of charitable mindsets might say you should like you as much of
- 24:58your money as quickly as you can effective.
- 25:01Altruism can allow for the idea that you should try to make a
- 25:05lot of money so that you can then give it away.
- 25:08Anyway, I SP have sort of disavows.
- 25:12It's um, and I think they're going to be all these questions
- 25:14around and we're going to get way too in our heads about it,
- 25:18whether he's trying to protect effective altruism by sort of
- 25:23slowly distancing himself from it.
- 25:25So this doesn't become the sort of case study that ruins
- 25:29effective altruism or if he was never sincere.
- 25:33And then, I mean, there are ways to read, you know, I think we
- 25:36talked about this on, with a little bit in the episode with
- 25:39Teddy. You know, going for broke or
- 25:42like trying to get, you know, flip keep flipping coins, right?
- 25:47And gambling. Everything that there are some
- 25:49people in the EA world, who thinks you should just keep
- 25:52flipping because, you know, the world really requires huge sum
- 25:55of money to save it. So then you just like go For
- 25:59Broke and try to get as much money as you can.
- 26:01So there's a certain lens in which effective.
- 26:03Altruism itself is the motivation for sort of Gambler,
- 26:07what he did, right? Because anything below that
- 26:09level of money is Is ineffective, right?
- 26:11And you're not going to be able to achieve the results that are
- 26:14necessary to improve. You're not willing to you know,
- 26:17like we've talked about before you know these moral intuitions
- 26:20are sometimes about biting the bullet and saying like no, like
- 26:23it's not about like sort of, you know human beings want to
- 26:26minimize risk, right? It's just sort of in our
- 26:28evolutionary psychology. It's well you know, you don't
- 26:31you want to, you don't want the downside to be too bad, even if
- 26:35the upside would be revolutionary.
- 26:37And so some of effective altruism is saying, No, I look
- 26:41at the world, clearly I'm doing the calculus clearly and clearly
- 26:44the risk is worth the reward. And so I'm going to do it.
- 26:47And so there's this, there's a sort of view of the whole SPF
- 26:50Saga as him sort of. And now, the guy clearly, I
- 26:55mean, once everything fails, we start viewing him much more
- 26:59psychologically and less is a rational actor.
- 27:01And so I think now the lens is going to be much more like like
- 27:04we are referencing sort of drug use like how koujun was he blah
- 27:08blah blah rather than This is the ultimate rationalists who,
- 27:12you know, pursued sort of a great strategy.
- 27:15I mean, if he was he would have at least on his accounting
- 27:17right, you know, right at there's no excuse for that.
- 27:20You can say it's important to take big risks, because that's
- 27:23the only way to achieve the results.
- 27:25Required to make substantial agenda book should be clean and
- 27:28it should be like well on this day I like put it all upside to
- 27:31the risk of having shitty book, right, right.
- 27:34That's just careless. And I think that's kind of what,
- 27:36you know, the the new CEO and arbiter of FTL.
- 27:40Is trying to deal with here. But look, I think there's a part
- 27:44of his entire unraveling that is a pure distillation of the
- 27:49utilitarian mindset, right? It's like better for me to have
- 27:53had this money and try to funnel it towards good.
- 27:55Then the people that had this money that would have known what
- 27:57to do with it, right? I mean I don't know how cynical
- 28:00all the people that movement really are but it's within like
- 28:03the spectrum of their belief system that this type of action
- 28:06was like within the bounds right.
- 28:08I mean it's like it's And owned by a kind of utilitarian set and
- 28:13you know, they're you know, somebody who is writing to me
- 28:16and reminding me of my own old like philosophy classes.
- 28:19I mean there is you know like rule utilitarianism this sort of
- 28:23belief that you can't just abandon ethical precepts because
- 28:29fundamentally adhering to those moral rules, will create the
- 28:35best good. And that, if you totally abandon
- 28:37any sort of like, oh, you should be honest you Steal from your
- 28:41customers in, you know, chasing some great outcome that
- 28:46maximizes for utilitarianism. That is sort of the thinking of,
- 28:49you know, a fraudster where you're like right, you know, I
- 28:52alone can sort of see the great outcome and therefore I should
- 28:56break all these rules in favor of the outcoming and clearly
- 29:00human beings just aren't really equipped.
- 29:02So, I'm much more of a rule, utilitarian, just a maximizer.
- 29:05Which, by the way, is a side point to all of this is why it
- 29:08is pretty hysterical. That it's possible that Kelsey
- 29:10Piper the reporter at vaux betrayed or had like a breach of
- 29:13trust with right. BF.
- 29:14Exact, because that was a purely utilitarian, like, look,
- 29:17alright? Given this information Capital,
- 29:19right? Right.
- 29:19The best amount of good I could do with that is to disseminate
- 29:22widely because I believe that what you've done is wrong.
- 29:24So no I don't think she'd live by the sword die by clear to be
- 29:27clear that it's funny what you're saying but there's no
- 29:29allegation that Sam said it was off the Record so it's just did
- 29:33he betray a friend? So that's basically where we're
- 29:36at with SPF. There's going to be, you know,
- 29:40like I said, Feeding Frenzy of reporters examining every aspect
- 29:43of how this company was run. Saw there was a profile in
- 29:46Forbes of the CEO of Alameda who's an interesting character
- 29:50and all of this potentially his girlfriend, you know, as more
- 29:54filings come forward will finally start to learn more of
- 29:57like where all the money went which hasn't been fully
- 29:59disclosed. I really want to hear from his
- 30:01parents. I mean that's his parents are
- 30:03like legal experts. Their law professors at Stanford
- 30:07and they did help him set some of this up, right.
- 30:10Why should we care if they come up in the filings actually?
- 30:12So no, you're not too far. You're not going too far with
- 30:15that one. I know that as things began to
- 30:18unwind. He did consult his father that's
- 30:21a that's a tough call to make to tell you right, I really fucked
- 30:24up. I got nine billion in
- 30:26liabilities that I can't really account for but yeah I know his
- 30:29dad is going to be for sure called into you know, whatever,
- 30:33whatever Iram aching, the TV show.
- 30:35I mean that would be the central conflict.
- 30:37I mean on the one hand, I don't know anything about his parents
- 30:39so I can imagine them. I mean, very sort of
- 30:42establishment or I mean there's Stanford people and I am
- 30:45skeptical like it if you like Stanford is an Institutional
- 30:48like Stanford exactly. You're talking about is that the
- 30:50Peter teal Stanford is right. Exactly.
- 30:52Stanford or is a School founded by a robber barons?
- 30:56You know, it's like it, there's a reason Silicon Valley is much
- 30:59more aligned with Stanford than sort of the ivy league, which is
- 31:02more sort of institution. Maintaining state does have an
- 31:05incredible history, they have a real, you know, ghouls list of
- 31:09alumni that That I mean, SBF dropped out of Stanford, right?
- 31:12So I guess they can disown him. As far as that with us, there's
- 31:15nothing more Stamford. You could be than a Dropout.
- 31:18Yeah, especially if you're in the Peter.
- 31:19Teal mold. Oh, speaking of the Peter teal
- 31:22world. What aspect of this and this
- 31:23goes a little bit back to effective.
- 31:24Altruism is I saw that, you know, one of the people trying
- 31:27to make a real hey, out of this whole Scandal are David Sachs
- 31:32and people in his orbit and I did pull a few wants to talk
- 31:35about everything but the midterms right now, but, but the
- 31:38midterms. Yeah.
- 31:39But, but yeah, Tweet that I contacted me.
- 31:42Which was that the biggest con man, since Madoff, just
- 31:44admitted, that woke is virtue signaling game quote, where we
- 31:47say all the right shibboleths. And so Everyone likes us.
- 31:50How stupid does the New York Times feel now?
- 31:53I understand that everything through this guy's worldview of
- 31:55Saxon talking about is about woke and and it's the only, it's
- 31:59like the laziest term. But he just assumes that
- 32:01everything that is like altruistic is woke.
- 32:04I really don't refer. I wouldn't refer to effective
- 32:06altruism as being woke right there like barely.
- 32:09It's I woke. Yeah, a lot of the woke people
- 32:11hate it because they're like I let everybody now die.
- 32:13Because people's lives. You know, we have to worry about
- 32:16all lives and future lives would be saved by deferring the money
- 32:20to do it. You know, there are lots of what
- 32:22people hate it, a lot of ways also, So yeah no Wolk thing is a
- 32:24scam you know like they're barely any woke people anymore.
- 32:29I'm also like after the midterms in which like people that ran
- 32:31explicitly on the anti woke agenda just got like creamed
- 32:35right. I don't know how much I would
- 32:36like spend. I don't know yet just in that
- 32:38stuff. David Sachs is out there acting
- 32:40like the fact that the Biden in administration wants to resolve
- 32:44the Ukrainian Russia war is like some victory to him.
- 32:48Like I used, tried to set it up, I don't know.
- 32:51I don't want to go down this whole rabbit hole but Just want
- 32:53to put it on the record that I think it's absolutely absurd.
- 32:56That David Sachs thinks he should get credit for any sort
- 33:00of like, you know, like like what they were just going to
- 33:04blow rush off the map. Like obviously it's some level
- 33:07like there would be a negotiated settlement and that that might
- 33:11not include Crimea, anyway. Sorry this is this doesn't drive
- 33:15you insane. I did.
- 33:16He's so disingenuous about what he gets credit for you.
- 33:19Don't think the defense department is listening to all
- 33:21land and his fucking at his tweets.
- 33:23And like deciding, you know, with all the like Chiefs of
- 33:25Staff, try to stab whether or not liking how can you finally
- 33:28arms to Ukraine are not. So you didn't persuade them.
- 33:31So it's more, just like he's annoyed that he basically he
- 33:35wanted to voice it earlier whereas other people were a
- 33:38little more deferential to the US state department to just
- 33:42figure it out as this was a live situation, I everything now
- 33:45especially if you'd through Twitter like the people that
- 33:47respond to your Tweet is a battle between you and your
- 33:50haters right time. So I'm assuming I don't follow
- 33:52him but I'm a You mean that every time he tweets out, you
- 33:55know, that there should be like a truce negotiated between the
- 33:58Ukraine and Russia, he has like an army of people in his replies
- 34:02just like shitting on him for it.
- 34:03And certainly, I mean, the great thing about Twitter is you can
- 34:06bait, people who hate you into over, extending their own
- 34:10position by sort of articulating, a repetition that
- 34:13people want to share that, like his replies is the discourse
- 34:16like he really thinks that is the national conversation he's
- 34:19just a disingenuous, are you are an well in Fury, okay?
- 34:22So all of this This then is actually a perfect transition
- 34:25into the other thing we're going to talk about on this podcast,
- 34:27which is Twitter. Oh, yeah.
- 34:29Because everything devolves to a conversation, about your Twitter
- 34:33thinking that the people that are in your replies, is the
- 34:37world. And that is like, how business
- 34:39works. That is how politics works.
- 34:41That is how like the economy Works seems to have been the
- 34:44main miscalculation that Elon Musk had any but sweater.
- 34:48So let's just give a quick recap on where things are right now
- 34:51because it is fairly and I want to read the Fresh off the
- 34:54presses. He tweeted this 30 minutes ago
- 34:58this is Elon Musk. Okay.
- 34:59Yeah. Elon Musk.
- 35:01New Twitter policy is freedom of speech but not freedom of reach
- 35:05- hate. Tweets will be maxed he boosted
- 35:08and demonetized so no ads are other Revenue to Twitter.
- 35:12You won't find the Tweet unless you specifically seek it out
- 35:15which is no different from the rest of the internet.
- 35:17So basically he's ended up to where things already were but
- 35:20like well the ultimate question is just what our - hate tweets.
- 35:23It's and it's just but he said it's not going to be boosted,
- 35:26right? Isn't that the exact complain
- 35:28about Matt O'Bannon? He boosted.
- 35:30Yeah, so it's not even Shadow been.
- 35:31He's basically saying we're going to be shouted Banning.
- 35:33Yeah, exactly. Congratulations you right?
- 35:36You ended up is to wear Twitter was before you bought the
- 35:37company the thing, right? Forced you to buy the company is
- 35:40where you've ended up. Okay, let's see him.
- 35:44You stated Babylon be okay. His work here is done.
- 35:49Okay. So here is my understanding of
- 35:52where things are at Twitter over the last week or so.
- 35:54And this is clearly a, you know, a quickly moving story earlier
- 35:58this week, which is going to be last week by the time people
- 36:00listen to this episode, he laid off half of the company.
- 36:04So 50% or so. The a 7,000 people that worked
- 36:07at Twitter were given notice marching orders.
- 36:11And honestly, I mean, Without elon's price, still gonna lay
- 36:14off like 30%. Yeah, that's economy with meta
- 36:17and Amazon, and everyone, everyone, but Google.
- 36:20And apple laying people off. Yes, there were probably layoffs
- 36:22to come but he laid off 50%, which is pretty dramatic.
- 36:25Now when it's good, it is good to do it all once.
- 36:27I think there's good, it's good to have a sense of realism.
- 36:31Anyway, idea, I don't want to just and people are experiencing
- 36:34that people were expecting that there was a complete debacle
- 36:37with Twitter blue, which was a subscription service that he was
- 36:41going to make. I even want to go into Twitter
- 36:43blue. It's kind of old news now but
- 36:45that, that didn't work out. Well, reporters are salty,
- 36:48right? And then, and then, so, the most
- 36:50recent, at the time of recording, this podcast,
- 36:53controversy has been, he basically gave an ultimatum to
- 36:56the remaining employees saying, you're either in or out.
- 36:59He gave them like the Jerry Maguire.
- 37:00You have to you have to testify the you're willing to be
- 37:04extremely hard core otherwise we'll give you three months
- 37:07Severance and you can go on your way and turns out three months
- 37:11Severance sounds great. Like I know.
- 37:14Yeah. It's just like yeah better than
- 37:16most of the way. Alright companies doing.
- 37:19Yeah and so hundreds of people took him up in the three months
- 37:22offer it was way more than he was expecting there.
- 37:25Sounded like there were emergency desperate meetings to
- 37:27keep some of the essential, you know, top Engineers, top product
- 37:31people, I don't know, some, some marketing, people keep them on
- 37:34board. It's unclear how that played out
- 37:37there is like this cascading series of like salute emojis
- 37:40inside the Twitter slack, I love you.
- 37:42Yeah, people were signing off and this was not a guess what
- 37:45you I was expecting. I want to say, I want to have
- 37:48according to the line New York Times, right?
- 37:50Well, but I do want to say, and I said this probably still in my
- 37:54tweets somewhere when it was coming out that you, I was
- 37:56buying a company, I put out a poll and I said, what percentage
- 37:59of Twitter employees? Do you think you're going to
- 38:01quit the company? And it was like a ten percent
- 38:03when I was in for free? The lowest responding answer was
- 38:0750% plus and I guess you could debate, you know, lay off versus
- 38:11like people. Her leaving, but like there was
- 38:14a huge fucking issue with people.
- 38:16Not wanted to work at the Iran, must go and Twitter.
- 38:18And I don't see why more people weren't willing to expect that.
- 38:22I don't know. I don't, yeah, it just like it
- 38:24seems. So clearly obvious that anyone
- 38:26who is going to come in and buy this company strictly for
- 38:29ideological reasons was going to run into this problem.
- 38:32Well, there is a great tweet Storm from of recently departed
- 38:35Twitter employee. There was just like Elon didn't
- 38:40articulate sort of a Grand Vision.
- 38:42You know, it is not. Tesla and SpaceX, right?
- 38:47You know, so it's like, what are you fighting for?
- 38:50What am I going to be hardcore for, right?
- 38:52And, you know, it's there is sort of like, which political
- 38:56Vector is Elon really aligned with and like, what are the
- 38:59goals of Twitter? And like, what does it stand
- 39:02for? I mean, his this is where his,
- 39:04like, incoherency about free speech.
- 39:07And like his mind, moderation policies.
- 39:10And whether he's trying to satisfy the middle or sort of
- 39:12The Joe Rogan class or what What what exact constituency does he
- 39:17believe with believe in an aligned with, besides his own
- 39:20off-the-cuff control. It's hard to get people to Rally
- 39:24around you who want to believe in a cause, you know, and his
- 39:27inability articulate, this has actually been a major major
- 39:31problem with, with his ability, to get allies.
- 39:35Yeah, because he wasn't able to answer it.
- 39:36The central question that people had, which is why are you buying
- 39:39this company? Because there were two
- 39:40arguments, one, is that it was an underwhelming underperforming
- 39:43business. That is totally true.
- 39:46Twitter has been like an absolute mediocrity as a
- 39:49business for as long as it's been around.
- 39:51And then there's the like this is an essential part of free
- 39:53speech and it's shirking. Its duties by Shadow Banning cat
- 39:57turd, or whatever, and these two visions are potentially in
- 40:02Conflict. Like I think he and the
- 40:05billionaires and non billionaires in his, you know,
- 40:07text threads truly believe that this was an entire company made
- 40:11up of like Tucker Carlson's. And of Taylor Lorenz, right?
- 40:16He was just a bunch of like, weepy woke snowflakes just
- 40:20seeing, you know, - tweets crying about it and banning
- 40:23people. And and that was the entire
- 40:25company. It wasn't full of Engineers or
- 40:27product people or people trying to keep the business running.
- 40:30It was just, you know, woke idiots.
- 40:32And I just he he one that's not a great reason to buy a company
- 40:36anyway, but also clearly he was wrong.
- 40:38And once he realized that people didn't want to work there
- 40:41anymore, he realize that they actually did have a central
- 40:43value, right? So I mean, I will say we kind of
- 40:46touched on this a bit with the teddy episode, but I'm dying to
- 40:50know the other side of the story here because in one sense this
- 40:54is a reporter's dream, right? It's incredibly dramatic.
- 40:57We have this character and Elon Musk who reporters don't like,
- 41:00you know, just generally politically, they're not aligned
- 41:02with him. And so it's, you know, it's like
- 41:05a fucking keep using the term, like, Feeding Frenzy,
- 41:08especially, with sources that are dying to offload.
- 41:10All the bullshit that's going on, inside you two coming, but
- 41:13Elon doesn't have any PR Beretta surround him, right?
- 41:16From what I read the New York Times story.
- 41:17They do not have a comms Department right now, so there
- 41:19is no contrasting narrative to what's going on right now.
- 41:22So that's sort of the reality that's going to get out there
- 41:25because no one is able to push back on it.
- 41:28Well yeah, it's all right. It's so negative about Eli on
- 41:31Twitter right now, right? There's a mood on Twitter as if
- 41:34there's going to be sort of a fail, whale this evening and
- 41:37that's what I'm going to be the end of it.
- 41:39And so, I think empirically I am interested in How likely We is
- 41:44Twitter really to crash without sort of the Staffing.
- 41:48I think there is an argument that the left is being a little
- 41:52history Raonic on that history on it and like maybe it doesn't
- 41:56crash and it keeps operating and I mean if the worst that happens
- 42:01is Twitter is slow to, you know, improve that will be just like
- 42:07the old Twitter. You know, I was thinking back to
- 42:09Barbarians at the gate and the whole era of leveraged buyouts
- 42:13is essentially This is right. It's, you know we make it into
- 42:16something kind of mysterious and and whatever evil.
- 42:21But in fact, this is kind of a standard right in process, like
- 42:24a leveraged buyout. But during a leveraged buyout,
- 42:26the new owner of the property who let you know, lay it up with
- 42:31debt and all that stuff. They typically work with
- 42:33Management in order to kind of keep some semblance of
- 42:36transition Before ice goats, you know, start going through and
- 42:39like ripping out all the, you know, drywall and shit.
- 42:42But that wasn't the case here. Right?
- 42:44He comes in day one and fires. The CEO fire is the CFO like a
- 42:48popular head of legal. All the kinds of people that you
- 42:50probably would have needed to have like an orderly transition,
- 42:53right? Our because he wanted to be, you
- 42:55know, like a new page and dramatic new ownership.
- 42:58And that that's just not how these things are typically done.
- 43:01Like there is a Playbook of leveraged buyouts, and he just
- 43:04decided to abandon it in favor of what he thought Twitter
- 43:07needed, which was like dramatic action, right?
- 43:09And it just fucking blew up. I mean, I don't know, there's no
- 43:12other way to really see it, right?
- 43:13And I think, Is an argument that elon's management style works
- 43:18for SpaceX and Tesla because people are True Believers.
- 43:22You can sell them on the mission.
- 43:24They know what it's for, you know, become sort of a kalt
- 43:28whereas, you know, Twitter, Twitter exists.
- 43:32So you need to really give people a vision of what, what
- 43:35they're building for sort of different than today.
- 43:38So, a lot of White Collar jobs, right?
- 43:40Like these people have skill sets, right?
- 43:41Pretty easily. Transferable to other companies.
- 43:44And they have more money so they're not as desperate to
- 43:46stick with the job because they don't, you know, they don't need
- 43:48it as much. And you know, I've seen the
- 43:51argument made out there that the people that are staying or
- 43:53staying because they have to pay bills, you know, like they don't
- 43:55have that much money, right? Well, in the worst case they
- 43:59have visas. And so they're sort of, I mean,
- 44:01this this speaks to some of the problems with the VISA program
- 44:05that, you know, people can't walk with their feet, which is a
- 44:08key part of capitalism. Like, you should be allowed to
- 44:11leave your job and go to another one when you don't like
- 44:13management, There's something abusive about employees who are
- 44:17on visas being trapped that a particular company and it goes
- 44:20against right? Sort of the freedom that's part
- 44:23of capitalism, right. So I guess I can closing out
- 44:26this episode and it's an impossible question to answer
- 44:30but it's really the only question asked which is like
- 44:32where does this go at this point?
- 44:35What happens because because I see like a couple of paths I
- 44:39mean one possibility is that he just unloads this thing he just,
- 44:42you know, somehow, you know who well, I don't know, some sort of
- 44:46private Equity Firm that probably should have been
- 44:48responsible for the elbow in the first movie, such a loss.
- 44:50Like I almost think the opposite that he is tanking the
- 44:54reputation he gets the debt down the like 40% or something.
- 44:59Then he buys you been more of it and he owns it and then on a on
- 45:03the cost basis of the his new ownership he could actually sort
- 45:07of I'm out. Okay sure.
- 45:09If you manage to make it a purely profitable company, I
- 45:12mean the typical way a leveraged buyout works is that you slash a
- 45:15ton of costs. You lay up with it with a ton of
- 45:17debt and then you re listed as a public company and like this new
- 45:21leaner, meaner version of the company is more profitable and
- 45:24maybe you can make it you know up all you know right Public
- 45:27Market evaluation hit has just been so bad it's such a terrible
- 45:30time. Well I suppose you're surprised
- 45:32that he paid for it but I can see like idiot logically where
- 45:35he's going here which is that he had a great plan.
- 45:38All of the woke, Twitter employees ruined it for him.
- 45:41I want to read a tweet that I think is emblematic of the, I
- 45:45don't know. Certainly the mark in but this
- 45:48guy is citing a book. Mark injuries and loves at the
- 45:50moment, so that's why I'm connecting to him.
- 45:51But Antonio Garcia Martinez, the author of chaos monkeys and I'll
- 45:56sort of a July Ally of the no dark and light Mentor.
- 46:02I don't know if you would agree with that, whatever he's on
- 46:04often on the right though. He's been aligned with the left
- 46:07on Ukraine. Anyway, it doesn't matter.
- 46:08He's one of them. He says what Elon is doing is a
- 46:12Revolt by the entrepreneurial Capital against the professional
- 46:16managerial class regime that otherwise everywhere dominates
- 46:20including an especially large tech companies and that same
- 46:24PMC, professional managerial class, which includes the media
- 46:27is treating it. As an act of last matches.
- 46:30Stay Majesty less Majesty in Burnham's formulation, this is
- 46:34James Burnham. The author of The managerial
- 46:36Revolution and Burnham's formulation New managerial class
- 46:40would supplant the former business owning Bourgeois, and
- 46:43even Capital itself. As the elite ruling class, most
- 46:46woke, labor scandals and Tech aren't entitled middle
- 46:48management class at odds with Founders.
- 46:50I think that's very true. You know, most woke, labor
- 46:54scandals and Tack are an entitled middle management class
- 46:56at odds with Founders. I mean, the media is basically
- 46:59talking to employees and parenting them now.
- 47:02Partly because Founders have decided to talk to the media
- 47:05less. But yeah, I mean this is sort of
- 47:08what's Opening or what do you make of these tweets?
- 47:10I but I would buy that argument as true but also entirely
- 47:16avoidable, because if these guys are so tapped into the mindset
- 47:20of the PMC and their woke agenda, they could have
- 47:23anticipated all of this. They could have had a honeymoon
- 47:26period coming into the company in which they, you know, yes,
- 47:29lured them into. Yeah, it wouldn't have been that
- 47:32fucking hard. Regulate them, aren't you
- 47:33supposed to be the winners? Yeah, because like, this is the
- 47:36fucking free market that you're defending here.
- 47:38It's like, if There is a great business beneath all of it than
- 47:40it should be able to withstand all of these you know, woke
- 47:43pmc's. Alright.
- 47:44If the problem that Twitter had was that there were too many
- 47:47people at the helm that were thinking about, you know, the
- 47:51emotions rather than like the cold hard facts of what a great
- 47:54business is. Then this shouldn't matter.
- 47:56You should be able to Route these people out and bring in a
- 47:58new group of, you know, based Engineers, who can bring Twitter
- 48:02to where it should have been, but you also shouldn't have even
- 48:05gotten there. You could have eased these
- 48:07people out of the company with A three-week honeymoon period that
- 48:10would have gotten rid of a lot of these or that would have done
- 48:13away with a lot of these issues. So no II totally reject that
- 48:15argument because one I just don't think it withstands any
- 48:21sort of economic test because if there's a great business model
- 48:24here, I don't see it yet and it just doesn't seem like there was
- 48:27a plan but yeah, sure, I do agree that like woke scandals or
- 48:31the results of, you know, middle-management stirring shit
- 48:34up. But like a scandal is not the
- 48:35same thing as a business problem.
- 48:37And right now he has a business Problem.
- 48:39Right? I mean like he's actively
- 48:42alienating advertisers right? Well, that sure the argument
- 48:46would be advertisers are in cahoots, cat.
- 48:49I mean, they're trying to sell their products to as many people
- 48:51as possible. I my objection to our.
- 48:53First of all, it's just setting up a case where we're supposed
- 48:56to some out route for like the capitalist class.
- 48:59You know, it's like, oh, we called him entrepreneurial
- 49:01Capital, you know, it just like Founders, whatever, you know,
- 49:05they do represent their the ultimate Elites who Trying to
- 49:09pretend like they're not, I don't know.
- 49:12We should bring him on. I'm happy to have my lunch.
- 49:14Yeah. That bgm on here.
- 49:16And argue this case, he likes directly, maybe, maybe I'm
- 49:19surprised you haven't asked him yet.
- 49:20Honestly, he he might be the one, you know, non coward among
- 49:24them. Well, I'm dying to hear more
- 49:25people defending Ilan because I certainly sympathize with any
- 49:29perspective that is like, boy. This is a very one-sided story
- 49:32right now? Yes.
- 49:33I mean, but I, the media was desperate, like, I'm sure they
- 49:36would interview Elin. That's, that's the one thing I'm
- 49:39I get that the media would probably interview them under
- 49:42their frame but people are hungry to still to hear from
- 49:46these CEOs, and but if you listen to these people,
- 49:49especially ones that are on the all in podcast, they argued that
- 49:51talking to the media, isn't it is of itself like an act of
- 49:54treachery it's pointless to do. And so it's just not very, it's
- 49:58not fair, if you're like, well, the media is dominated by
- 50:01workers. It's like, well, if workers are
- 50:02the ones talking to Media, then, that makes sense.
- 50:06You know, this is a topic that we may be revisiting.
- 50:08In future episodes because whether it's a GM or other
- 50:11people that are in that orbit, I'd love to hear.
- 50:13I'd love to hear from them because I personally, as a
- 50:17reader of these stories, I'm not done any sort of reporting.
- 50:19I do feel like it is incredibly one-sided but unfortunate that's
- 50:22the one side that's talking right?
- 50:24And I don't know what else a reporter can do.
- 50:26And there are way more of them and an employee's believe, all
- 50:29sorts of different things. I just think reducing it's
- 50:31convenient to reduce workers to a class because then he'll on
- 50:37who is one. In is on equal footing with, you
- 50:41know, the thousands of angry employees, you know?
- 50:45And and hundreds are more of angry.
- 50:47Advertisers, you know, it is like they're your these masses
- 50:50of and then there's also the public right?
- 50:52That has its points of view and somehow given the Elan embodies
- 50:56the single class. He's supposed to count, you
- 50:59know, for so much. If he merits his placement in
- 51:02that class, you should show it by being an effective manager.
- 51:06Like if you deserve all of the The Privileges that come with
- 51:09being in the entrepreneurial class, show it, show me how
- 51:13you've managed to will navigate this controversy in a way that
- 51:18proves your point. Because right now, it doesn't
- 51:20seem like there was a fucking plan.
- 51:22Like, I'm not sure that's the same big winfried ideology that
- 51:25comes through in the DMS. It's like, people are chill with
- 51:28by Nance now because he's a winner and I'm a loser and
- 51:30ultimately people like winners and they don't like losers and
- 51:33like morality is almost like subservient to that.
- 51:36It's like you can say Shibboleth the people want but ultimately
- 51:41you know you need to, you need to win.
- 51:43Yeah. I mean I don't know that I think
- 51:45by Nance is going to continue to win.
- 51:47I think people have been a little too probe Finance lately,
- 51:50but anyways, I mean being like the last person standing in a
- 51:53crumbling field, doesn't mean you're in a great position.
- 51:56No, I look, I actually think in in so many respects, I know.
- 51:59Like as the, the Twitter you'll on Twitter thing was closing in
- 52:02on taking place, your argument had been like, let's put the
- 52:06right ideas to the test. Yes, Let them rule, let's see it
- 52:10like right, especially on Twitter where it's like, okay we
- 52:12can give that up. It's not like all of America,
- 52:14you know. I'm not saying let the right
- 52:16rule the United States but I am saying, fuck, give them Twitter
- 52:19and let's see it. Let's run it, run it, you know,
- 52:22like and so I'm actually willing to like, let's let this
- 52:25experiment run a little bit longer.
- 52:26I think people that are talking about the death of Twitter right
- 52:28now, are probably jumping the gun.
- 52:30They're seen by the enough money questions on this is the
- 52:33question for the right if Twitter dies because like the
- 52:36left abandons and everybody, Using like the managerial class
- 52:40doesn't do the work. Whose fault is it?
- 52:43Like, I feel like, they somehow believe that it's still the left
- 52:47fault, even though they're in charge of it, they had to pull
- 52:49the levers to make it work. If basically they lose because
- 52:54the left like mounts, a resistance does the right and
- 52:58Ilan sort of get off scot-free because right is going to blame
- 53:02the left. I think I'm saying that's what
- 53:04they're clearly starting to coalesce around that argument
- 53:06which is absurd right? Okay now Now, yeah, I mean,
- 53:09ultimately, you're in charge you, you're supposed to be Savvy
- 53:12enough to know the psychology of the left and manipulate it and
- 53:15get your ends. Like, you can't just whine and
- 53:17say, oh, these people are irrational like that.
- 53:20All you humans are rational, you know, you have to navigate that
- 53:23that's part of part of leadership.
- 53:26Yeah. Because the prevailing sentiment
- 53:28ality and posture that people want to take these days is the
- 53:31victim, doesn't matter what position you are in class and
- 53:34you know, in your business and your class you want to be the
- 53:37victim. It's the it's the Fault, Place,
- 53:39repeat, nobody wants to be the elite.
- 53:41You are literally running the company.
- 53:43You were signing the checks and yet you were the victim of a
- 53:46system that you have just now, declared or prior to now,
- 53:49declared as being anti Capital as an anti market.
- 53:53And I don't know what to tell you, buddy.
- 53:55You just bought the store, right?
- 53:56It's your problem. Yeah.
- 53:58Figure it out. Stop whining.
- 54:00You know, like, pull yourself up by your fucking bootstraps.
- 54:03Yeah. So let's just let this play out
- 54:06a little bit longer. You know, if Twitter Goes down,
- 54:09it would, I guess, prove someone's point, right?
- 54:11But, you know, I guess my my perspective is that Twitter will
- 54:17probably be around for another couple of weeks, you know, the
- 54:22worst of the bloodline that will pass.
- 54:24I think people's expectations for the implosion or too big.
- 54:28Especially the people who are leaving because they probably
- 54:30want to think man and masses of people around me, it's like,
- 54:33people should on the United States and then they go to Paris
- 54:35and it's like it's dirty and they only have one Cuisine, you
- 54:38know. It's like New York's great.
- 54:40Like Twitter is better than the alternative unfortunately.
- 54:43Like that's the reality in the world in which you have to
- 54:45participate in these things, right?
- 54:47Well, don't go live in fucking Macon, Georgia.
- 54:49You know, I don't even know where to leave this one other
- 54:52than. I think this topic we extend an
- 54:54open invite to anyone who wants to explain elon's managerial
- 54:58style. I know, we like to fight I you
- 55:01think the cowardice from some on on the right is z reached out to
- 55:07not a small number of people. For this episode and we'll
- 55:09continue to going forward because I do believe it is a
- 55:12one-sided story. Being told right now, I'd love
- 55:14to hear the the pro Elon side. We maybe have some guests coming
- 55:17up, that can help a little bit on that perspective, but to all
- 55:20listening out there, if you have some people that, you know, that
- 55:23can speak positively and with personal anecdote on elon's
- 55:29leadership style, and why? It's great that we're open.
- 55:32Please email us. You know, DM won't, you can DM
- 55:34Eric, you can message me dead cat.
- 55:37Show at gmail.com. We want to hear from you.
- 55:40Great. All right.
- 55:41This is fun. Thanks a bunch.
- 55:42Thanks, before we go, we do want to give credits to the people
- 55:45that make the show possible because we do not do it enough.
- 55:47But engineering, the show is our great new sound engineer, Tommy
- 55:51Heron, who is making this thing sound very professional.
- 55:54And then we've gotten can continue to get a lot of
- 55:56positive feedback on the theme song for the show.
- 55:59I agree with you. It is awesome.
- 56:00It is the work of young Chomsky who is a producer and audio
- 56:04composer. He is the producer of the
- 56:07excellent podcast. True.
- 56:08And on which I do listen to, and I don't want to get cancelled
- 56:12for that because I know they end up being controversial times.
- 56:15I think it's great. But anyway, young Chomsky has
- 56:17the awesome theme song for this and we think both he and Tommy
- 56:20for making the show. Great, goodbye.
- 56:34Goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye, goodbye.
- 56:37Goodbye, goodbye.