Latest / Coffee and Crime with Mom / The Changeling | The REAL Haunting Behind the Horror Movie
Transcript
- Zalle: At exactly six o'clock every morning I started pounding on the walls, hard enough to wake the man sleeping inside me, hard enough to knock pictures to the floor. Then the faucets started turning on by themselves. Doors moved when no one was near them, and every morning the second Russell Hunter got out of bed, I went silent. For days I tried to get his attention, until finally he started searching, and inside a part of me that had been sealed away. He found the stairs. That was only the beginning, because according to Russell Hunter, this house had been trying to tell him something. Something about a child, something buried, and something that did not want to be forgotten. Russell's story would eventually help inspire one of the most unsettling haunted house movies ever made. But the story he told and the history of the house are not quite the same. Nicholle: Welcome back to Coffee and Crime with Mom. I'm Nicholle, but around here I'm Mom. Zalle: And I'm Zalle. Nicholle: If you're new here, welcome. We cover true crime, strange cases, mysteries, and at times, apparently, we also investigate houses with boundary issues. Zalle: Which is why I don't understand why people in these stories never just leave the house. I guess that's true. Before we Nicholle: Well, because then we wouldn't have an episode. Before we get into it, make sure you're following or subscribed wherever you listen. And if you're watching us on YouTube, hit the like button. The like button. Hit like, subscribe, and come talk to us in the comments. Share this one with the person who swears they will survive a haunted house. Because tonight we're talking about Russell Hunter and the alleged true haunting behind The Changling And we're going to do this in two parts. First, we're going to let Russell tell his story. Zalle: No interrupting him with the receipts yet. Nicholle: Correct. We're going to experience it the way he described it. Then we're opening the records. Russell Hunter was a playwright, composer, and television music arranger. By the late 1960s, he was living in Colorado and needed somewhere where he could live and work. And he found this enormous old brick mansion near Cheston Park, 1739 East 13th Avenue. According to Russell, the rent was around $200 a month. Zalle: month. Which sounds like a deal until you hear that apparently nobody wanted to live there. Nicholle: Exactly. And 1969 Russell said the rent was unusually cheap. Now I know what the correct response is supposed to be. Why is this giant old mansion so cheap? But I'm not gonna lie to you, I'm probably still going inside. Well, I'm gonna tour. I said tour. For the right price though, me and Casper maybe I'll work something out. Zalle: You're definitely going inside. You always think you can negotiate with the ghost. Nicholle: Hey, everybody needs boundaries. Russell apparently agreed with me because he moved in, and at first nothing happened. Then came February ninth, nineteen sixty-nine. Zalle: Russell said he woke up at six o'clock in the morning to this loud repetitive banging, not the normal noises you expect from a old house. This woke him out of his sleep. So he gets up and the second his feet hit the floor, it stops. Next morning, six o'clock, Same thing. He gets up, silence. Nicholle: And it keeps happening, same time, same unexplained banging, but then it starts spreading beyond six o'clock. Faucets turn on, doors open or close, the house vibrates hard enough that pictures reportedly fall from the walls. Zalle: And I know you're gonna say the faucet is where you draw the line. I think mine would have been the banging Nicholle: Absolutely. Now you're haunting me and increasing my water bill. We have a real problem. Zalle: Absolutely. See, I'm gone before we even get to that conversation. Is you're trying to talk to people. I'm trying to get gone. Nicholle: Russell wasn't though. He started investigating the house and while he was trying to figure out where all this was coming from, he noticed something strange about the layout. There seemed to be space above part of the house, but no way to get to it. Zalle: So Russell and an architect friend start looking around, and eventually their search leads them to a closet. Behind part of that closet, according to Russell, they find a concealed staircase. A whole staircase. had apparently been sealed behind a wall. I'm moving. Nicholle: Yeah, see that bothers me more than the banging because somebody covered those stairs. I immediately wanna know why. Zalle: But Russell wanted to know too. So naturally he went up the stairs that were behind this wall in the closet. Of course he did. Nicholle: Of course he did. Zalle: And at the top was a small room. Dusty. closed off, apparently untouched for years, and inside, Russell said they found school books, personal belongings, and a journal that appeared to have belonged to a child. Nicholle: From what Russell said he found there, he became convinced that a young boy had once been connected to the house. A boy who had been sick or disabled and apparently kept isolated, which changes the feeling of those noises. Before Russell was trying to figure out what was happening. Now he's starting to wonder who is behind it. Zalle: it. And then the house gives him something else. One day. Nicholle: One day Russell is near that staircase at the top. There's a small red rubber ball. It drops. One stair, then another, then another, bouncing down the staircase toward him. Zalle: Absolutely not. That little ball is scarier to me than almost anything else in the story. Because somebody has to move it. So who pushed the ball? Nicholle: Exactly. I can rationalize a door, a draft, pipe spanging, old plumbing, but once toys start moving on their own, I no longer require an explanation. I require a realtor. Zalle: Expedition matter of fact, meet me at the hotel. Okay. Nicholle: Yeah. Zalle: But Russell does the exact opposite. At this point, he believes whatever is happening in the house is trying to communicate with him. So he decides to communicate back. to the house. Nicholle: In indeed he does. He brings in a medium, they hold the seance inside the house. And this is where Russell's haunting becomes something much darker. According to his account, the presence they contacted was a young boy, a child from a wealthy family. The boy was reportedly sickly or disabled, and at some point the child died. Zalle: Mm, that's heartbreaking, but I don't know about dead children or beginning of a war. Right. Nicholle: Always the beginning of a horror move. Zalle: but according to the story that came through during the seance, his death created a problem for the family. An inheritance problem. And Nicholle: And that's always a big problem. Always. Always. The parents supposedly feared that if people knew their son had died, it could affect where the family fortune went. So according to the story, they hit his death. Zalle: Always. Always about the money. Always. And this is where it gets crazy. Because they supposedly went to an orphanage, found another boy around the same age who resembled their son and brought that child home. Nicholle: Then raised him under the dead boy's identity. So as far as the outside world knew, their son never died. Zalle: That's insane. But so far, we got one child gone and another that just took his place. Correct. And changed them. But that still leaves the original Nicholle: Correct. A changelink. Zalle: child. Because if the family hit his death, what happened to his body? Nicholle: Well, according to the seance, He had been secretly buried on property southeast of Denver, and Russell believed the child wanted him to find it. Zalle: He It was Russell White. This was not a black man. Okay. Which means we have now gone from something keeps waking me up to Russell searching for a secret grave, a child's grave. Nicholle: That seems accurate. And according to him, he found the location. By that time, another house had been built near or over the area where the child was supposedly buried. Russell said he eventually got access to the property and they dug. Zalle: By Nicholle: you want? Zalle: And Russell claimed they found human remains. Nicholle: along with the gold medallion he believed was connected to the child. Now, if you're following Russell's version of this story, that feels like confirmation. The seance gives you a location, you go there, you dig, and supposedly there's a body. Zalle: he So you would think whatever wanted his attention would be done. Right. Nicholle: You you might think that. You might, you might, but you would be wrong. Because instead, Russell said the haunting became violent. He claimed glass doors exploded near him and cut his wrist badly enough to sever an artery. He described part of a wall collapsing near his bed. And that finally was enough. Russell left the mansion. Zalle: That was enough. It took a severed artery. I just wanted that noted. everything the bangin' doors. The child the dead child throwing balls at the man down the steps. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Yes, what we've determined is we clearly have different thresholds. He moved into another house, but Russell claimed the activity followed him Zalle: See that's the part that scares me. Because now it isn't the house. It's it it followed him. Exactly. Nicholle: Exactly. Eventually Russell said he contacted a priest. an exorcism was reportedly performed at the second home. And according to him, after that, the activity stopped. Zalle: I'm just wondering Why we didn't do that to begin with? Why did we need to go find graves? Nicholle: Well, because he he thought that he was helping the little kid spirit 'cause he was gonna go there and figure out what happened to him. You gotta follow the logic, Zalle. Zalle: but but but I'm not well versed in the world of exorcisms. Nicholle: Mm-hmm. Zalle: But ain't that what the exorcism is supposed to do to let them go on, help them move past where they going? Nicholle: Well it is, but it was the the kid he had to go find I don't know. That's what he did. Okay. Let's go on with the story. Zalle: but the original mansion was still there. Nicholle: For a while. Eventually it was demolished and Russell said he went back to watch. He later claimed that during the demolition, part of the structure came outward, and the man operating the demolition equipment was killed. And if all of that happened exactly the way Russell Hunter described it, I don't have a need explanation for it. Zalle: Neither do I. Because at that point, you're way past one weird noise in an old house. This is out there. Nicholle: exactly. Except now we're opening the records. Researchers with Denver Public Library Special Collections and Archives investigated the history behind Russell Hunter's story. And this is where things started getting messy. They looked at building permits, city directories, telephone books, census information, genealogy records, and the first issue they ran into was Russell himself. Zalle: Because the records they checked couldn't confirm that. Russell Hunter lived at seventeen thirty nine East thirteenth Avenue during the period he said he did. Nicholle: And we need to be precise about that. That does not prove he never lived there. Historical directories aren't perfect. Someone could rent a property without appearing in those records. So we can't say Russell never lived in the house. What we can say is those records did not independently confirm that he did. Zalle: The house itself though, that was real. It was very real. Nicholle: It was very real. And we know who built it. In eighteen ninety two, prominent Denver attorney Henry Treat Rogers and his wife Kate had the brick mansion constructed. And once researchers started looking into the Rogers family, Russell's story hit a much bigger problem. Zalle: Henry and Kate didn't have any children. Nicholle: No children of their own. there were younger relatives who lived in the home at different times. Their niece Frances Clark Rysteen lived there as a child, and their nephew, Henry Treat Rogers II, lived there later as a young man. But researchers did not find the murdered young son described in Russell's story. Zalle: Which immediately makes the things he said he found upstairs more complicated. If there were really school books and a child's journal, who do they belong to? Nicholle: That's a fair question, because having young relatives in the house could potentially explain why children's belongings were there. It doesn't prove that's what Russell found, but it gives us the completely ordinary reason that children's things could have existed in their house. Zalle: So at this point Russell's story is taking some hits. Definitely. Nicholle: Definitely. and then history gives him one weird little detail back. Zalle: and The land. Nicholle: Historical research later found that Henry Treat Rogers really did own farmland southeast of Denver. And that's interesting because Russell Story had placed the alleged secret burial southeast of Denver. Zalle: That does not prove anybody was buried there. Not even. Nicholle: Not even a little bit. But it's specific enough that I don't want to pretend it means nothing either. Russell somehow included a geographical detail that lines up with something documented about the real family. What that means, I don't know. Zalle: know. And then we get to what should be the easiest part of this entire story to verify. The alleged remains. Nicholle: You would think so. If human moraines were discovered beneath or around somebody's home, you'd expect something. But the historical research we have does not independently establish that discovery the way Russell described it. And that's an important distinction. We know Russell said it happened. We do not have enough evidence to say we know it happened. Zalle: happened. And without the remains, the seance loses what sounded like its biggest confirmation. Nicholle: It does. Same thing with that dramatic demolition story. Russell said the equipment operator is killed. It's an incredible ending. But unless we can independently document it, it stays where it belongs inside Russell Hunter's account. Zalle: It sounds like the the one who sues rhyms with Nancy and fancy. Nicholle: I got to do. Zalle: I got two. Okay. So now the question becomes, was he making the whole thing up? Hmm, was he? Nicholle: Mm-hmm. That's where the story gets interesting to me. Our choices don't have to be Russell encountered a ghost or Russell Hunter was a liar. There's a whole lot of territory between those two things. Zalle: He could have genuinely experienced something he couldn't explain. I mean, it happens all of the time. It Nicholle: It does. And maybe there were strange noises. Maybe things happened in that house that frightened him. Maybe he interpreted those experiences through information he learned later. Maybe pieces were added as the story was retold. Memory changes, stories evolve, details get repeated until eventually nobody remembers which parts were documented and which parts came from the person telling the story. Zalle: And then of course Hollywood gets involved. Nicholle: And that's always when it gets fun because once Hollywood gets involved, everybody buckle up. Zalle: Mm snow telling where we're going on this ride. In nineteen eighty, the Changeling was released starring George C. Scott. The movie doesn't recreate Russell Hunter's story exactly. It moves the story to Seattle. The main character becomes John Russell. His personal tragedy is created for the film, and the mystery itself is reshaped. Nicholle: But you can still see pieces associated with Russell's story. The old mansion, the unexplained banging, the hidden room, the child, the seance, and that damn red ball. Zalle: ball. The ball. You can't make that movie and leave out the ball. You've gotta have the ball in the steps. It just adds something to it. Nicholle: Absolutely not. It just adds something to it. Zalle: Because the ball doesn't need anything else. Okay. Nicholle: No monster, no blood, no special effects demon, just a staircase. Silence and one little red ball coming down by itself. I'm finished. Zalle: Outta there. Nicholle: And that's where I land with Russell Hunter. I don't need to decide that every part of his explanation was true, to believe he may have experienced something he couldn't explain. The historical record creates real problems with the story, but it doesn't tell us what Russell experienced inside that house. Those are two separate questions. Zalle: I So you're still leaving the ghost, the little room? Nicholle: And the ball needs to keep its ass upstairs. I I I don't think there's anything wrong with that. Zalle: See. See. Reasonable. Absolutely. I don't think there's reasonable. I I don't I don't think there's I think that we should just evacuate the premises. Nicholle: And maybe that's why the story still works more than fifty years later. We can find the house. We can find the people who actually owned it. We can identify parts of Russell's story that don't match the historical record. But we can't go back into that house in nineteen sixty nine and experience whatever Russell Hunter said he experienced. The mansion is gone. The story isn't. So now we want to hear from you. Where do you land? Do you think Russell experienced something paranormal? Do you think something real happened but the story grew around it over time? or once the historical record starts falling apart, are you completely out? Zalle: And I want to know what you're doing when the red ball comes down the steps towards you. One step at a time. Hmm. After all Nicholle: Leave it. Zalle: that talk about cheap rent, we're still gonna leave. Nicholle: I I said Casper and I could establish boundaries. The ball violated the lease. If you enjoyed this episode, follow Coffee and Crime with Mom wherever you're listening. And if you're watching us on YouTube, like the video, subscribe, and come tell us what you think in the comments. Zalle: the least. Nicholle: then send this episode to the person who would absolutely go up those hidden stairs. I'm Nicholle, but around here I'm mom. Zalle: Cause it wouldn't be me. And I'm Zalle. And this is Coffee and Crying with Mom. Nicholle: And this is Coffee and Crime with Mom. Zalle: Bye! Bye.