Latest / 323 Bourbon Library Podcast / 06/18/26 EPISODE 004: BOTTLE BREAKDOWN: OLD CARTER PLDC4
Transcript
- 323 Bourbon Library Podcast: you All right. We are back at it again. Welcome back to the 323 Bourbon Library podcast. Our buddy James brought a bottle to the bar. So I picked this up from Silbox in December. Okay. And first old card I've ever had. I excited about it. I think it was about $225, $250. $250. Okay. And you got a bottle, $969 of $1173. So only less than 1200 bottles out there. So first one I've heard great things about old Carter and 125 proof. this for those people, this is PLDC four, whatever that means. So while he pours that up, I thought I pulled up some statistics here about the bottle. thought it be interesting to share. ⁓ I've only ever tried one other old Carter product. Never have. And ⁓ it was great. It was very good. But this is a blended batch exclusively comprised of 11 year old bourbons. ⁓ It says like all of Mark's whiskeys, it has the addition of some double barrel bourbon. And for this, it was a small amount, but impactful. This is one of five private batches of Old Carter that released this month, whenever the month was. This is like, you thought this was December of last year? ⁓ Mark has described PLDC4. as his personal favorite batch that he's released to date. Okay, that's awesome. Excited to try this. The whiskey shows great depth and balance and a rich fruit forward core vanilla and seamlessly integrated oak presence. The influence of the double barreled component lends a subtle spice box quality with nutmeg, clove, et cetera. Thank you, sir. No worries. Which is good. God, these are big pores. Jesus, we're just here having a good time. Which is the signature attribute. I didn't know we wearing our panties tonight. No, we're definitely not after these cores. ⁓ So anyway, man, sounds great. And so the proprietor, the owner of Old Carter, he says that this is his favorite batch. Look at it. Look at the color on it. Color's great. Dude, the color is like dark. You see that. Look. It's like reddish burgundy. Beautiful. It's almost like a You'd guess it was finished in like a Cabernet wine cask or something. Kind of like a reddish tint to it. What was it? It was, ⁓ was 125 proof, right? I think that's what the proof was. Yeah. 125 proof. Jesus Christ, dude. Do you even smell that? Nice. Panty dropper. we met a guy, James and I were in line at a fries event, a bourbon release fries event. I don't remember the guy's name, but he was standing right in front of us in line and he kept talking about, he's like, he's part of the old Carter society or something. There's something that they've got. And he's got all the old Carter's and he buys every one that comes out. And I was like, damn, I only ever have owned one of them before. And, ⁓ this guy's got a lock box in Chicago where he gets these old Carter's. has a plug. No, he says he's got a lot box in Louisville in Louisville. it where like, guess they're where they get these. Yeah. So ⁓ I was like, is it that good? Like, I'm about to find out. Cause this is my first one. He was, he was, I've met him before. And I think I've met him at a liquor store and I believe he was saying And he was all same thing all over it, all old car. And so, it's incredible. The fucking nose on this thing is unbelievable. It's it's sweet. It's I hate the word smooth. A lot of people hate it. I don't necessarily hate it, but it's got this like velvety texture on the nose of sweetness. I think it's like you can almost taste. Like the viscosity. Some bourbons like I just like, you know, hover above the glass. This one, can put the full beak in. Yeah. You can get into this. And you're not assaulted by it either. Just wait till you try it. This has got, this has got an absolute excellent nose. Nice vanilla sweetness. It's almost creamy. Wait till you try it. The cream is crazy on the palate. You jumped right in. were like sniffed it. He's gonna forget the nose. You're more on what it tastes like. Yeah, I'm not a big smell guy. That's fine. Listen, understand. I'm going to try it. That's taste. It drinks 125. It does. But that is tasty. It's actually... Definitely drinks 125. And I think I like, it's almost like a cigar box, cedar or something like to it. Yeah, but then try another, did you get the cream and like, there's like. It coated the palette. It coated. I got it for me. went, went really quickly to the finish where I got a lot of baking spice, nutmeg. barrel spice, almost like a little, maybe even light peppery notes on the back end of it. Definitely got that pepper in the back end. That could have been the way I took the sip in on the first. So I'm going to take a second sip and I'm going to hold it before I swallow it and see if I can pick up some of that creaminess on the front. And it's this one that needs to open up a little bit. Mm. Pepper-y. Warm spices. Definitely has those warm spices. The front does have it like that. It's almost like an aged vanilla. The vanilla to me is... It's like those Madagascar vanilla beans. If you steep them in vodka or something and just make a... What's that called, chef? ⁓ You know what I'm talking about? It's vanilla extract is what you're vanilla extract. Yeah. I smell that. Yeah. For sure. That's ⁓ it's really good. Really good. We tried a couple earlier. Couple of a couple of other, other different urban's a little bit ago and I'll let me tell you something. It's not even, it's not even Well, yeah, no, we were trying like 90, $100 bourbons. You this, you said, I think you said this was a $250 bottle. Yeah. It drinks like a $250 bottle. $250 bottles all day. Yeah. Like how old is this? 11 years. They're entirely 11 years. I mean, you would think it drinks even older. Like, look at that. looks older. they did say a small component is is part of the double barreled. So you may be getting some of those like more oaky tannins and not in a bad way. No, no, no, but it's good. It's lending it to maybe drink like it's maybe, so what do think of this compared to your one that you opened a couple of weeks ago? You want to try that one right now? No, I'm just curious on your let's try it now. Let's try it. But maybe you can pour it not. Here's big ones. Yeah. But my whole thing is, like we're hanging out, we're having drinks. Like this is good shit. So why not have a good pour of it? Yeah. That's kind of my. So funny. This is PLDC. Four. Four. This is PLDC five. So one after. So this is the next batch. This is only, there's only 802 bottles of this out there and it's 117.66 proof. So, yes. It's an old Carter episode here, fellas. Why not? Let's get into the good stuff. And when we do go to Louisville, I'd love to go check out, I you know, their store is great, supposedly, I don't know if y'all, I mean, know Ronnie has, but their store is great. Look at the, I mean, you can tell a color is way lighter. I'm gonna side by side these noses. James is just going for the juice. Well you know which one's gonna win though, the nose. They're quite similar. Let me look up some stats on this PLDC4. No. No. They're not, I don't think they're even. By the way, guys, they're both from Silbox. Silbox released these and in December, Ronnie was taking a little break from buying bottles. And I was like, Ronnie, I got to get my first old carter. And he goes, well, I'm taking a couple month break. And you didn't get that because we talked about it. I missed out on that one. Well, that was a lottery too. I think that you, that was a lottery. had to put it in for ⁓ And this was not a lot. I think you can actually, they just released this today. You can go back on and get these today. So this, the notes on the, one are ⁓ jammy with notes of peach, soft oak, sweet tannins with a touch of sparkle on the palate, slowly warming finish. I got to taste the sparkle because I've been cooking for 15 years. ⁓ man. It is almost like a Sprite or 7up type note on the nose. I could just drink the fucking juice. I mean, enough of the smelling. So your yours, the batch four is more richer, almost like barbecue. I would it doesn't taste like barbecue darker, but I would say it smells like a like a barbecue sauce. Very thick. You'll laugh at me, but this. The one you just pulled out is a little spritzy. Yeah, I just said Sprite. It's thin. Seven up. But try it. It's almost ephra... But it's spritzy. It's got like a spritz. Like sparkling. Like sparkling water. And effervescence. Effervescence. That's the word we're looking for. What do you think? It's lighter. It's definitely a lot lighter. It's still really good. It's really good. Both are $250. I don't think this one... Oh wait, it does say. Let's see here. If you can find a PLGC4. bottles, distilled in Indiana. This is a four barrel blend of eight year old bourbon. So we got eight year old bourbon versus 11 year old. And 11. could taste it three years. The 11 beats it. The 11. The 11's just grown man compared to, I mean, this is good. Yeah. Yeah, it's good. Crazy that they're both $250. Why wouldn't you put the eight at like 200 bucks? Cause they don't, because don't have to. Because they just came back with more. That's why. Because they fan boy from that we met in line and we got to find his name and I can look it up. you know, well you do too. Yeah. don't have his number. I don't either, but we can look him up, but he, People like that just will buy every one of them. That four. That four is good. It's really good. It is good. Delicious. It's... I'm glad you gave us big pours. Thank you very much. Yeah, I'm going to just slide this one off to the side. We're going to give it some Willett next. She just smells. You know what? just spelt it again. What are you getting? Okay. I, Oh, I see that that kind of, yeah. 15 year old above Turkey is what I get on the nose. I mean, dude, that's dark. It is dark. It's gotta be that I don't, I wonder what percentage of the blend is the double oat. I'm sure that's where they're picking up all that color from it. That's a good bottle. Why did I pour you so much? Cause you like us. Hey, listen, we got some good box. We'll pour you plenty. But I like it. I mean, I think that's really good. Did you just get one of them or did you get two? Bought one because everyone needs a just one chance to get one. Okay. Oh, you were generous. You didn't have the FOMO in the moment. Oh, does. Yeah. But my first one, I didn't know anything about it. And it's not a cheap bottle. Look, no, not at all. So like everyone ramps the raves about it, but like, I'm glad we did it. Yeah. I'm glad you bought it as well, sir. Thank you. Yeah. Honestly, thanks for bringing it over. I, I, my entire life of old Carter memories is just off of this eight year old. So seeing, um, I'm to be a little bit more cognizant of the specs of the bottle when they drop them. Yeah, but future, agree with you, but you, the specs on this one is more your palette. Right? Like this? Yeah, I like this. I like a lot. I tend to like sweeter. But I agree. doesn't have the in the notes. This doesn't really. But this like drinks. mean, don't know. It drinks. It drinks. What? Fantastic. I mean, I do. I do like the eight year old. It's more a lighter peach. It's like peaches, like white peaches, like no, like light stone fruits. back. But if you're gonna, if you're gonna sit down and have a drink, it's bad. This one. Is there older expressions? I'm sure. I'm sure. And I don't, and admittedly, you know, I've got 1200 bottles of plus of bourbon. I've got three bottles of old Carter, two, and two of them I purchased within the last month. So I've got a Rye, I think it's batch two that they ever released. But I never opened it because I was like, I've never seen these. And it was my only find of it at the time. I probably had it for 10 years. Maybe one day we'll crack it open, see what a Rye old Carter is. I think, am I wrong? Did they start out with just Ryes? I honestly don't know. All I know is, didn't they? He bought out, I don't know that there was a whole deal with them and they revamped. was a, what was it? His family and he bought it all out. not a hundred percent sure. ⁓ They started in 2018. I want to say that they did a, previous brand. That's going to bug me. So I'm going look up right now. can correct us if we're wrong. The old Carter fanboys are going to be yelling at us. But it's tasty and delicious. very much. ⁓ that's what it was. Yeah, okay. I thought it was, but I'm like, wait, that's not right. So they previously helped resurrect the Kentucky Owl brand in 2017. So they worked with Dixon Dedman on starting off the Kentucky Owl brand. But historically they're wine folks, the Carters. So they were in the wine industry in California. bought out his family, right? Like in the last year or two, correct? Yeah, I don't have all the details. We're just in the infancy of this podcast. We can probably do a little background research beforehand. everyone says he's fantastic and he's doing some great Yeah, yeah. Listen, this is his product. Yes, I would agree with that. Yeah. Listen, I, I, this is a newer brand to me. It's an expensive brand. I think for the longest time I didn't dive into them because yes, I didn't. I was like, are they good? Fucking I don't want to take a shot on a 250, $300 bottle without knowing if it's good or not. If it's good or not. Right. At this point in life, I fucking buy $300 bottles all the time. But 10 years ago, eight years ago when I started, you know, was starting to get into this, I'm like, That's a lot to break off on a ball. don't know anything about. Yeah. But now I would spend the money when I see one, I'm going to buy it. Yes. 100%. And yes, by the way, there'll be a whole fucking shelf of old Carter's in the three to three bourbon library. Ronnie's has a follower that came in from Boston. Yeah. Yeah. John, ⁓ Boston, John. And he reaches out. We talk here and there and ⁓ We did a big bourbon hunt with him and we had a great time, but he's got one that is from Boston or over there that, I need to reach out to He's got one for me. He bought one like a year ago, like a month ago. He was like, Hey, cause we were talking about it. was like, dude, there's on the East coast. You see these. And so he's in John Carler. What's going on with this? He like, this is only in DC. like he does what he does. one for the state of Tennessee does one the state of all, you know, and so, um, I wonder if Arizona has any, I thought it hard and releases. Did Trevor's have one? I don't know. But anyways, I'd able to look it up. The, and so he was like, Hey, do you want this? It was 200, whatever. He was like, I'm holding it for y'all. Bring it out when I come out. But I'm like, yeah, definitely. And that's before I even tried it. So I'm, pumped that, uh, yeah. I thought bottle. Yeah, look, this Connecticut only. Like there's like club, oh, these are like a ton of club. So that's what fanboy our boy needs. Our boys signed up with Georgia exclusive Tennessee, Colorado exclusive. Arizona exclusives. All right. So maybe that was that was just in 2025. Oh, so I now that I'm. familiar with their website, I'm going to go do a little research and maybe some emailing. Old Carter's might pop up. Listen, maybe we'll do an old Carter pick. never know. So even with traveling though, now you can be like, Oh, I'm in Tennessee or I'm in Washington, G.C. or you know, it's good to know that they're regional, right? Well, yeah, it's like a no brainer until This evening, didn't know that that was how they operated. So very cool. So let us know in the comments. Have you got into Old Carter? We know it's an expensive brand. Two hundred fifty dollars a bottle. ⁓ Maybe more. But is it something that you've tried, want to try moving forward? Should try. They vary differently. We just I'm glad we pulled down both of them. Because. I would have been in my mind. I'm like, Oh, it's probably very similar to the one I already opened and then tasting it side by side. They're completely different. I mean, look at the color. I mean, there's, mean, you can see it. One's like a burnt log and the other one's like a, like a cigarette, but color, color wise. doesn't taste like that. Please. Anyway, stay tuned. We'll pop. We'll, keep popping bottles and talking about them and let us know. If there's a bottle that you're on the hunt for and that you'd like to see us pop or that you see sitting behind us on the wall, we'll pop it and talk about it. We'll see you very soon for another episode of the 323 Bourbon Library podcast. Cheers. Enjoy. ⁓ you