Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Taking a Look at 2025: Transactional Entertainment Law Year-in-Review
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to the look at 2025. This is the transactional
- 0:07entertainment law year in review. My name is
- 0:10Keith Cooper. I'm the vice chair of the Beverly
- 0:12Hills Bar Association Entertainment Law section,
- 0:16and on this particular occasion, I'm also the
- 0:19moderator of this panel. So I will be doing the
- 0:23speaker introductions. as well. I wanted to mention
- 0:27at the outset that this section, the entertainment
- 0:30law section, is sponsored by Lawyers Mutual Insurance
- 0:34Company. Those of you who've heard me talk about
- 0:36them before, I will mention, again, they've been
- 0:39doing this for five decades, Lawyers Mutual Insurance
- 0:42Company. They're the only California -based company
- 0:45to continuously provide lawyers throughout the
- 0:48state with professional liability insurance coverage.
- 0:51Their experience and expertise are complemented
- 0:54by the fact that LMIC, as they go by, is directed
- 0:58by a group of dedicated lawyers. They offer special
- 1:01rates, competitive premiums for a wide range
- 1:04of areas of practice, including entertainment
- 1:07law. You could go to lawyersmutual .com. And
- 1:11actually, when we did the panel the other day,
- 1:14I took a moment to mention a cool feature that
- 1:18Lawyers Mutual actually has, and that is they
- 1:21have their own ethics hotline. So if you do secure
- 1:26insurance through Lawyers Mutual, it's very handy.
- 1:29You can call them up if you have an ethical issue
- 1:33or question or quandary, just use that word.
- 1:36They will be happy to take the time to answer
- 1:38that for you. And for most lawyers, that can
- 1:41be helpful from time to time. So I wanted to
- 1:44now proceed to introduce our speakers. We have
- 1:47Anne Clark, Jonathan Handel, Emma Smeiser, and
- 1:50David Shraga. Anne is a shareholder at Greenberg
- 1:53Trarig here in Los Angeles. She focuses on transactional
- 1:57entertainment, media, and intellectual property
- 1:59law. She represents production companies, studios,
- 2:03digital media companies, financiers, producers,
- 2:06and talent across all stages of development,
- 2:09production, distribution, and exploitation. Her
- 2:13practice includes AI -related deal structuring,
- 2:16union and guild matters, rights clearances, influencer,
- 2:20and endorsement agreements. She was also named
- 2:22to the Hollywood Reporter's Next Generation List
- 2:25and is a member of the Television Academy and
- 2:29the NAACP Image Awards Nominating Committee.
- 2:33Jonathan Handel is senior counsel at Big Finkel,
- 2:37also in Los Angeles. He represents talent, producers,
- 2:40production companies, and other industry professionals
- 2:44in transactional entertainment and technology
- 2:46matters, including union and guild issues. He
- 2:49previously served as associate counsel at the
- 2:53WGA and is special counsel to SAG -AFTRA. He's
- 2:57taught entertainment law as an adjunct professor
- 2:59at UCLA, Yale, USC, Boo, and Southwestern Law
- 3:04School, no comment. He is the author of several
- 3:07books on entertainment guilds and law, and has
- 3:10appeared over 1 ,600 times as a media commentator,
- 3:15and has been named to the Daily Journal's top
- 3:17100 lawyers in California. He is also a member
- 3:21of the Television Academy and a research fellow
- 3:24at Rutgers University. Emma is an associate in
- 3:29the interactive entertainment group at Frankfurt
- 3:32Kernet. She advises video game developers and
- 3:36publishers on IP licensing, transmedia and interactive
- 3:39entertainment, co -branding, monetization, advertising
- 3:44and data privacy. She's a certified information
- 3:47privacy professional and was named to Variety's
- 3:51Demail Viewmakers of 2023, up next list. Emma
- 3:56co -founded the legal name and gender. uh marker
- 3:59change project which is a pro bono clinic serving
- 4:02the transgender and non -binary communities in
- 4:05the greater los angeles area and serves on the
- 4:08emerging leaders board of the association of
- 4:11media and entertainment council finally david
- 4:15charaga david is a private mediator at charaga
- 4:18resolution services specializing in entertainment
- 4:21media and intellectual property disputes. He
- 4:24spent the first decade of his career as a trial
- 4:27lawyer before transitioning to a decade in -house
- 4:30counsel as studio executive serving as senior
- 4:34vice president and head of global television
- 4:37business and legal affairs at Miramax, VP of
- 4:41business and legal affairs at NBC Universal's
- 4:44International Television Studio, senior counsel
- 4:47at Universal Pictures. He serves on the executive
- 4:51committee of the entertainment law section of
- 4:55the Beverly Hills Bar Association, volunteer
- 4:57mediator for the Los Angeles Superior Court and
- 5:00California Lawyers for the Arts. He's also a
- 5:03member of the Southern California Mediation Association.
- 5:08All of these individuals are experts and all
- 5:11of them make me feel inadequate as a lawyer for
- 5:13thank you all for that. In the meantime, we're
- 5:16going to transition over to the transactional
- 5:20entertainment law year in review. This is our
- 5:23panel discussion. And by the way, we do have
- 5:28a Q &A, and I'm going to reserve some time at
- 5:30the end of this Q &A. So if you have questions,
- 5:33you can put them in the Q &A channel, and I will
- 5:36track them, but we will get them. toward the
- 5:40end of the session today. Now, we have a few
- 5:45different topics that we're discussing. The main
- 5:47focal point that we want to cover is what happened
- 5:50in 2025, or at least very recently, that is affecting
- 5:55transactional deals, agreement drafting, et cetera,
- 5:59in 2026 and beyond. There are a few significant
- 6:04cases to discuss. across a variety of areas.
- 6:09There is also going to be some discussion about
- 6:11the SAG -AFTRA agreement, excuse me, largely
- 6:14involving publicity rights, name, image, and
- 6:17likeness, and that side of stuff. But the first
- 6:19case that I wanted to mention is Cruz versus
- 6:23Tapestry. There, the California Court of Appeal
- 6:27refused to enforce an arbitration clause contained
- 6:30in a website's terms of use. And the reason is
- 6:34because the platform failed to provide what they
- 6:37characterized as reasonably conspicuous notice,
- 6:40and they did not obtain clear user assent. This
- 6:45has been an emerging issue over time, and this
- 6:47particular court has addressed it. The court
- 6:49focused not on whether the terms existed, because
- 6:52I think they did, but on whether a reasonable
- 6:55user would have understood that completing the
- 6:59transaction constituted an agreement to those
- 7:03terms, and I think specifically in the context
- 7:05of arbitration. In this decision, it makes clear
- 7:09that enforceability is tied to how a scent is
- 7:13actually obtained. And that means the specific
- 7:17circumstances under which the user presented
- 7:20with an agreed to the terms and not just the
- 7:23language of the agreement itself. Consequently,
- 7:27enforceability now depends on how assent was
- 7:30actually obtained in practice and not just the
- 7:34written terms. In other words, there's a difference
- 7:36between including the term in your end user license
- 7:41agreement, among other things, and not just that
- 7:44it's there. It has to be conspicuous and so.
- 7:48The issue was whether the user user was meaningfully
- 7:51put on notice and took an action that unambiguously
- 7:56signaled agreement. Now there again, this has
- 7:59been an issue that's been around for awhile.
- 8:03So what I'd like to do is start with Emma and
- 8:06get her thoughts about this. For example, what
- 8:09does a legally significant asset flow actually
- 8:12look like in practice and how should companies
- 8:15if they need to redesign? their interface interfaces
- 8:20to preserve enforceability going forward. And
- 8:23a separate question that I have for you, Emma,
- 8:26I'll ask it again. But a separate question is
- 8:29what happens to all these gaming companies as
- 8:32one significant example that we deal with when
- 8:35they've got these existing ULAs in place? And
- 8:40now this case comes along. Do they have to go
- 8:42back and rewrite the ULAs and send out get new
- 8:45consents? How do you see all that unfolding?
- 8:48Sure, so hi everybody, thanks for having me.
- 8:52I guess first to kind of zoom out at the thousand
- 8:55foot level, I think with EULA's in terms of service,
- 9:00we're continuing to see a kind of move toward,
- 9:04I would say like visibility, consumer protection,
- 9:08and expectations of consumers. And so I think
- 9:10what the cruise, the tapestry case is getting
- 9:12at is, something that is sort of expected at
- 9:16this point. When a consumer is interacting with
- 9:19terms of service or EULA, do they know they're
- 9:23agreeing to these terms? And so one thing that
- 9:26I think we deal with in practice is visibility.
- 9:30And it sounds maybe silly to talk about the actual
- 9:33color or the placement of text, but it is something
- 9:37that I'm actually looking at in my practice is
- 9:39what is the actual user flow looking like from
- 9:43how the EULA or how the Terms of Service is presented
- 9:46and clicking through that. So it could be something
- 9:49like how it's presented on screen if you're scrolling
- 9:52all the way to the bottom and then you're clicking
- 9:54a checkbox. And just like, it ends up being something
- 9:58where we're really looking at the exact user
- 10:01flow. And so in this case, I think it was a really
- 10:03good example of where you have, it's like small
- 10:06text on a, it's gray text on a gray background.
- 10:11and wasn't really something designed to reasonably
- 10:13put a consumer on notice that they're agreeing
- 10:16to these terms. Also, I mean, I think this is
- 10:19like a side issue, but it is something I wanted
- 10:21to bring up in this section. There's a law in
- 10:24California, and we're seeing it across the states
- 10:25now, California, I think it's AB 2426, about
- 10:30digital transactions and giving users disclaimers
- 10:34when it comes to, you know, not that they're
- 10:36purchasing an item, but that they're getting
- 10:38a license to something. rather than having a
- 10:41continuous ownership over a digital asset. So
- 10:44I think for me and what I see in my work, whether
- 10:47it's, I think it's prevalent in video game companies,
- 10:50but really it's kind of in anything. If you have
- 10:52an app, if you have a website, if you have something
- 10:55that is triggering the agreement of terms and
- 10:57those terms contain language like a meaningful
- 11:00arbitration provision, you need to be aware of
- 11:03how you're presenting it to your users. I think
- 11:07one of the interesting questions that this raises
- 11:10as well, well, that was interesting, zoom out
- 11:12here, is whether this principle that arbitration
- 11:19agreements have to be prominent, prominently
- 11:23disclosed, is that the end of it? Or will, for
- 11:28example, limitations of liability, if there's
- 11:31an extreme limitation of liability in terms of
- 11:34service or EULA, uh does that will that will
- 11:37the courts ultimately decide that that has to
- 11:40be prominent and you know how much how do you
- 11:44start you know everyone clicks through these
- 11:46things you know without reading them you can't
- 11:48possibly read every terms of service um and and
- 11:52yet the it raises questions as to the distinction
- 11:57between what the court sees and what people do
- 12:02in practice it seems to me I think generally,
- 12:07oh sorry, go ahead. No, I was just going to jump
- 12:09in and say I work as a mediator and an arbitrator
- 12:12and I think it's an interesting issue, Jonathan,
- 12:14because arbitration provisions often get a special
- 12:17look. from the courts, right? I mean, we're talking
- 12:19about the waiver of a constitutional right to
- 12:22a jury trial. There's a strong public policy
- 12:25incentive in favor of the finality of arbitration
- 12:27agreements under the Federal Arbitration Act.
- 12:30So I think this is one of those areas where,
- 12:31as a transactional lawyer, you may want to also
- 12:33give it some heightened attention simply because
- 12:36it's such a It's such an important public policy
- 12:39issue. And in fact, we see new laws being passed
- 12:42by the courts to give folks ways to get outside
- 12:44of the scope of their arbitration agreements
- 12:46when certainly involving things like sexual harassment
- 12:49claims. These agreements, especially the arbitration
- 12:55clauses, I mean, the issue becomes it is now
- 12:58it's no longer an enforceable agreement. So when
- 13:02you're talking about redesigning uh it and i
- 13:06think i i may have maybe missed it because i
- 13:08was looking at one of the questions i apologize
- 13:09but do they need to redesign these things now
- 13:13um and re get regain people's consent i think
- 13:18it depends on how it's presented to them in the
- 13:21first place um like when when was when was this
- 13:25entered into and how and i think that's what
- 13:27the cruise case is getting at is did she really
- 13:30agree to this contract did she Do you know what
- 13:32I'm saying? Was it disclaimed to her enough?
- 13:34Was it clear enough that she had agreed to it?
- 13:36So I think for us, you're really deep in the
- 13:39facts as to when was the EULA presented or the
- 13:42terms of service? How was it presented to them?
- 13:45Is it clear enough that they're entering into
- 13:48a binding agreement? I think that becomes kind
- 13:50of a deep question of facts. So not to do the
- 13:53lawyer, like it depends thing, but I think you
- 13:56really do have to look at the facts of actually
- 13:59looking at the size of the font on the screen,
- 14:02the color of it. And that's sometimes what I'm
- 14:03doing on my end is also thinking about across
- 14:06different mediums. If it's something on a TV
- 14:09screen versus something like your phone, how
- 14:12does that appear to a user? Are they scrolling
- 14:14to the bottom? Is it a checkbox? When does it
- 14:16appear? Is it after they've already created an
- 14:18account? Is it before they've created an account?
- 14:20Is it before they complete a transaction? Is
- 14:22it after? So it's a long way of saying, I think
- 14:25it really depends on the exact facts. The end
- 14:28of that you still gave the it depends answer
- 14:31it does I know sorry, but I do I mean I do know
- 14:34which is fine, but um the You know, but what
- 14:38in another thing is like a lot of people use
- 14:41kind of this click through concept and you know,
- 14:43a lot of companies in the past and continue to
- 14:46do so, by the way, they, you know, they say by,
- 14:50especially in the gaming context or, you know,
- 14:52in a number of online context, you know, by using
- 14:56the service that we provide to you, you hereby
- 14:59consent to these terms, to this you law. Is that
- 15:02good practice or is it better to require a much
- 15:06more clear affirmative assent some way. And in
- 15:10that regard, when you're talking about that,
- 15:13is it enough? Because look, I would not give
- 15:17this legal advice to anybody, but I know I always
- 15:19just scroll straight to the bottom and hit I
- 15:22agree at the bottom of it without having actually
- 15:25read it. Is that a good practice to use or is
- 15:29there something now that you should require your
- 15:32users to do to affirmatively consent? Well, I
- 15:35think what's what's tough is that even in the
- 15:38courts they also sort of have the it depends
- 15:40Response like it really depends how you're presenting
- 15:42it to them and what what's going on in the user
- 15:44flow? And also, I think I mean there is a little
- 15:49bit of that tension between what's a good legal
- 15:51hygiene and then what's business practice and
- 15:54what's going to happen a lot of our clients want
- 15:57you know, a frictionless experience for users.
- 16:00So having this thing that pops up all the time
- 16:01that they have to scroll to the bottom up and
- 16:03then click accept isn't always practical. And
- 16:05I think it also depends on the exact, you know,
- 16:07how restrictive are the terms that are in your
- 16:09terms of service or your EULAs. I think generally
- 16:12the kind of prevailing belief amongst companies
- 16:15today that are presenting a EULA is that you
- 16:17want something that shows them the EULA, you
- 16:19scroll to the bottom, and then it allows you
- 16:21to click accept to move forward. But again, I
- 16:24think it kind of depends on your risk exposure,
- 16:26your liability, and your kind of visibility in
- 16:30this as to like what sort of friction you present
- 16:32your users. And that also interacts with the
- 16:39the pop -ups about we use cookies here. You can,
- 16:42you know, cookie control. the business desire
- 16:46to be frictionless is really running into a lot
- 16:49of conflict from legal here, that you've got
- 16:52cookies and you've got to scroll to the bottom
- 16:53of the EULA. And by the way, another area that
- 16:58I would wonder whether there has to be, may,
- 17:00courts may decide there has to be prominent disclosure
- 17:03is, relates to AI, which is if one of the terms
- 17:07is we get to use whatever you upload as training
- 17:11material, Is that going to shock the judicial
- 17:13conscience to the extent that that too will have
- 17:18to be prominent and maybe have its own little
- 17:19checkbox along with the checkbox of arbitration,
- 17:24class action waiver, cookies? I mean, you've
- 17:26got already now three to four different things.
- 17:32I did mention at the outset that I was going
- 17:35to hold all questions to the end, but Jeffrey
- 17:39Kravitz just came up with a really good one that
- 17:42I think is timely to this discussion, and that
- 17:45is, do they have to be in English, Spanish, native
- 17:49languages? How do you address that, particularly
- 17:52on a global scale? For me personally, when we're
- 17:59dealing with game companies, it's such a global
- 18:01market. I'm probably dealing with local council
- 18:03in different jurisdictions about every week.
- 18:06I'm emailing with someone who's in like Brazil
- 18:08or Russia or in Germany. I think you want to
- 18:13make something that's understandable to the consumer.
- 18:15So is there an argument in other jurisdictions,
- 18:17certainly where if it's, you know, the prevailing
- 18:19language is one thing, but you present the terms
- 18:21in English. that they're agreeing to something
- 18:23that they don't understand, sure. And I think
- 18:26in different countries, there are laws that address
- 18:28that. So I think being aware of where your markets
- 18:31are, what you present to users, what's the language
- 18:34that you're presenting it in, I think is really
- 18:36important. On a side note, Emma, I agree to things
- 18:39I don't understand all the time, but that's just
- 18:42me. But it's just my point, though, as to practicality.
- 18:46Is anybody reading this? So if we make you scroll
- 18:48to the bottom, like, are consumers more protected
- 18:50by having this language or having to scroll to
- 18:52the bottom? In practice, I think that's tough.
- 18:55Which is a good segue to the question that I
- 18:57was going to have, because first of all, I don't
- 18:59think anybody actually reads it. And we always
- 19:01joke about... You know, putting in, I think Noah
- 19:06Downs, his firm, they actually put in a terms
- 19:08of service one time something about a zombie
- 19:11apocalypse just to see if anybody actually picked
- 19:15up on it and read it. And the answer was no,
- 19:18they did not. So which leads to. this question,
- 19:22is it better given this case to separate an arbitration
- 19:26agreement out from the regular ULA or terms of
- 19:29service or whatever the case may be so that they
- 19:31have to separately consent more affirmatively
- 19:35to the very specific arbitration provision? It's
- 19:39not something I've seen currently that there's
- 19:41like a separate consent for the arbitration provision
- 19:43or that it's why I'm raising it. Should there
- 19:45be in light of this case? I don't know. I mean,
- 19:48I think it's hard because you don't want to be
- 19:50the first person to move on something like this.
- 19:52Should there be? I don't necessarily take, from
- 19:54reading this case, I don't necessarily take it
- 19:55to say that that's what's being required. I think
- 19:58there's ways to give notice and make sure that
- 20:00you're putting the EULA properly in front of
- 20:03users enough. Does it have to require its own
- 20:05consent for arbitration? As of now from this
- 20:08case, that's not what I read it to say. say too
- 20:13here that there's, especially with respect to
- 20:15arbitration provisions, whether you're talking
- 20:17about ULA online or talking about, you know,
- 20:22in real life agreements, that, you know, we,
- 20:26as I think it was David mentioned, obviously
- 20:29arbitration provisions are given special scrutiny
- 20:32by the court because you are waiving such important
- 20:35rights. And anecdotally, we had this actually
- 20:38come up in 2025. We were representing a company
- 20:41that entered into an agreement with a minor.
- 20:45As maybe many of you know, in California, when
- 20:48a minor is working in the entertainment industry,
- 20:51you have the ability to get that contract approved
- 20:54by the court. So they can't then later disaffirm
- 20:57by reason of their minority. And we went through
- 21:00that process. and then there was a dispute. And
- 21:03one of the issues that came up or one of the
- 21:06claims made by Miners Council was that they were
- 21:09trying to argue that the arbitration provision
- 21:12should be removed. They wanted to separate it
- 21:14out from the rest of the agreement and specifically
- 21:16disaffirm it. You know, making some special arguments
- 21:19about how this was even more cumbersome on a
- 21:22minor, et cetera, and the minor wouldn't have
- 21:23had the ability to agree to it. That was never
- 21:26adjudicated by the court, but you know, it does
- 21:29really bring up that issue. And I think especially
- 21:31when you're talking about who is clicking through
- 21:33this agreement, if that is someone who's under
- 21:36the age of 18, I can potentially see that becoming
- 21:40something that someone would also try and use
- 21:43as a claim as to why it wasn't valid. But yeah,
- 21:46arbitration provisions do deserve. I think I'm
- 21:50guilty of it too. It's like we have the standard
- 21:52language in our agreements. It includes an arbitration
- 21:54provision. especially when we're having a minors
- 21:58contract where I'm representing the company,
- 22:02I make sure that in the parental inducement,
- 22:05whether or not we're going to go on and seek
- 22:06court approval, but in the parental inducement
- 22:08where they're saying they're responsible if the
- 22:10minor disaffirms, we do specifically refer to
- 22:12the arbitration provision in its own small provision
- 22:15there. So yeah, definitely something to consider.
- 22:19Yeah. And this comes up, you know, especially
- 22:22again to revert this portion of the conversation
- 22:25to the gaming community, right? I mean, there's
- 22:28a massive online community of gamers right now,
- 22:32and a large segment of them are children. Now,
- 22:35you had mentioned, you know, you get, and I've
- 22:37seen it in contracts, you get that maybe the
- 22:39parents sign it, whether it's a personal guarantee,
- 22:42some jurisdictions actually allow it, I think,
- 22:46to be enforceable, I think. California, they
- 22:49do it with a personal guarantee, but I think
- 22:51there's other jurisdictions where the parents
- 22:54can sign on behalf of the minors and it's enforceable.
- 22:57But in this context then, would you have kind
- 23:01of a separate parental consent provision or recommendation?
- 23:05I mean, how would you think to handle it? Because
- 23:07this affects an industry that's bigger than the
- 23:11music and the film industries combined. Oh, sorry,
- 23:18go ahead. Oh, no, no, go ahead. It's you. I was
- 23:20throwing that to Anne, but, Emma, go ahead. Oh,
- 23:22no, no. Please go ahead, Anne. I think this is
- 23:24really more your bailiwick when it comes to EULA
- 23:27and Clickthrough. Yeah, so I defer to Emma here.
- 23:30I'll just say quickly on it. I think that you're
- 23:32starting to get into the kind of like the big
- 23:35topic of age verification and knowing that your
- 23:37users are under the age of 18 or wherever that
- 23:40jurisdiction is, they're under the age of 13,
- 23:42and getting proper parental consent. So I think
- 23:45it's without turning this into an entire age
- 23:48verification panel, I think it's something that's
- 23:50incredibly relevant. And we're seeing laws right
- 23:52now that are dealing with it. Equally important
- 23:57to the arbitration issue is the issue of waiving
- 24:01class action and class arbitration. And I would
- 24:08certainly suspect that the position should be
- 24:11that that would need to be prominent as well.
- 24:14Although I don't know if Emma, I don't know if
- 24:16the case dealt with that specifically. Oh, yeah.
- 24:21And I think, you know, sort of combining really
- 24:23what everyone has said so far, there really is
- 24:25a spectrum in terms of how aggressive you're
- 24:27going to be to put this in front of folks, right?
- 24:29And Emma talked about tension between what is
- 24:31good legal hygiene, which is a great term, versus
- 24:34the business interests, right? And I do sort
- 24:37of feel like And I'm sure you've had agreements
- 24:39where the arbitration provision requires specifically
- 24:42initialing those types of provisions. And I'm
- 24:44sure there's something that could translate over
- 24:46to the digital context. It's a practical matter,
- 24:49right? You're always balancing what's too much
- 24:51to put in front of someone. But at the same time,
- 24:54are they not going to ascend to the arbitration
- 24:56agreement and continue to click through? So I
- 24:58think you're probably with each gradient of business
- 25:00clients trying to strike that balance in view
- 25:02of how the law is evolving. And I think there's
- 25:05also a similar risk if you're pulling, if you're
- 25:07doing a click through and you pull out the arbitration
- 25:09provision that someone to argue, well, you know,
- 25:12if there's a dispute over another provision saying,
- 25:14well, that wasn't specifically pointed out to
- 25:16me. You know, I didn't, I saw the arbitration
- 25:18version. I didn't see that one. So it's a, I
- 25:20think you have to weigh all the factors there.
- 25:23I think also you really have to think about who
- 25:26your demographic is, who are the people clicking
- 25:28through this? I think it's just as important
- 25:29to think about what you present as it is to understand
- 25:32and practice like, who are truly, who's your
- 25:35audience here? Who's likely to be clicking through
- 25:36this? And I think you have to kind of tailor
- 25:38your approach and your risk accordingly. And
- 25:43I'm going to violate my rule for a second time,
- 25:46but there's another question here before I didn't
- 25:49want to leave the subject because I'm about to
- 25:51leave the subject, but I didn't want to do so
- 25:53without asking this question. The question from
- 25:56Jonathan Kirch in this case is, did the arbitration
- 25:58clause focus on the issue that David raised?
- 26:02That is the arbitration clause requires a higher
- 26:04standard for consent other than provisions because
- 26:09it's a waiver of constitutional rights, which
- 26:11I take it by that means the constitutional right
- 26:13to a trial by jury. Sorry, just want understanding.
- 26:18He's asking about what the actual arbitration
- 26:20provisions said in Cruz. I don't have it in front
- 26:23of me, so I don't know what exactly it said,
- 26:24but I think I think really what Cruz focused
- 26:28on. Maybe this is the point of this is not. The
- 26:31language of the arbitration provision is itself
- 26:33important and needs to be considered what the
- 26:36court was dealing with in Cruz was the Ascent
- 26:40to those terms not just the terms themselves.
- 26:42How is this presented? Did this person is sent
- 26:44to this agreement? I don't know if that's answering
- 26:46the question and probably it's not In my mind
- 26:49it does but I'll leave that to Jonathan He can
- 26:52we can revisit it at the end of the session if
- 26:55he has additional question. So I'm going to move
- 26:57on to another subject. And this pertains to artificial
- 27:02intelligence, because no one's talking about
- 27:04that these days. So I thought we should. Artificial
- 27:07intelligence, digital replicas, and contract
- 27:10restructuring. I think there's two cases that
- 27:13are relevant here, Cadre versus Meta. And this
- 27:16is still a great subject. And David, you and
- 27:19I saw a lot of this at the Entertainment Law
- 27:23Summit. point that I will mention because it's
- 27:26going to come up here in this subject, but in
- 27:28copyright versus meta, the authors, uh, challenge
- 27:32metas use of copyrighted books in this case to
- 27:35train large language models without permission.
- 27:39And this has definitely been the trend here.
- 27:41And I think there's multiple courts that have
- 27:43actually ruled in this direction, but the court
- 27:46held that the training qualifies as fair use,
- 27:49emphasizing that the training uh is general purpose
- 27:53or training a general AI purpose model is a transformative
- 27:56use did not serve as a substitute substitute
- 28:00for the original uh work product or the works
- 28:03in the marketplace and for those that aren't
- 28:06that familiar with this particular subject basically
- 28:09you know the issue here on fair use is you're
- 28:13taking an entire existing work in many instances
- 28:16and the courts have held if it's input It's not
- 28:20copyright infringement. It's fair use. You have
- 28:23to look at the output and just I'll mention it
- 28:25because this is what David and I saw at the entertainment
- 28:28law summit the other day. They showed some examples
- 28:31where they use input under the guy under actual
- 28:36fair use. But the AI, the generative AI on its
- 28:40own volition, to the extent that's an applicable
- 28:42word, re you know, created works that were literally.
- 28:47almost literally identical to the existing works.
- 28:52People were saying, give me a Star Wars type
- 28:54of theme. And my God, the artwork that it spit
- 28:58out looked like Star Wars. And they had a Superman
- 29:01character. And I think it was. Bugs Bunny, I
- 29:04think, was the other character that we looked
- 29:06at. And it was strikingly similar. And so the
- 29:10output, not necessarily intentionally, was looking
- 29:13exactly like the input in some of that way. But
- 29:16the law at this point is that you can use this
- 29:20material for training AI because it doesn't substitute
- 29:26for the original works in the marketplace, which
- 29:28is what would Keith, I want to jump in. That
- 29:31was a very preliminary decision, and there are
- 29:35court decisions to the contrary, as well as the
- 29:39anthropic book author settlement. So my take
- 29:44on the law is that it's actually unsettled that
- 29:48there is an argument that it's fair use, but
- 29:51there are arguments that it's not fair use. So
- 29:54we don't have clarity on that at this point,
- 29:57which is which complicates, I know we're gonna
- 30:00get to this in a minute, the guild negotiations
- 30:03because the guilds have concerns, but the background
- 30:06law is unsettled and that makes it harder to
- 30:09negotiate in these areas and harder for transactionalists,
- 30:14to our point, for transactionalists to know exactly
- 30:21what needs to be contractual and what can be
- 30:23handled by background law. Yeah, it's an extremely
- 30:27important point. And yeah, we will cover that
- 30:29in a moment. And we are going to take a look
- 30:32at a contrary opinion, although I don't think
- 30:36it's that contrary. I think it's a different
- 30:39context altogether. But at least in this instance,
- 30:43the court did accept that copying the entire
- 30:46work which for those of you that don't know,
- 30:49is a relevant determination as to whether it's
- 30:51fair use. The amount that you're taking for the
- 30:55purpose that you're taking it usually credit,
- 30:57I'm sorry, criticism, commentary, that news are
- 31:01typically fair use. But usually even in that
- 31:04context, you can't take the entire work. And
- 31:07it seems that this court was leaning, it was
- 31:09finding that, yeah, it doesn't matter. You could
- 31:12take the entire work for training purposes. As
- 31:15long as there's no evidence of market harm, again,
- 31:18from this buzzword, from the model's outputs.
- 31:22And what David and I saw the other day, you could
- 31:25easily make the argument these were substitutes
- 31:28for the original. But for transactional attorneys,
- 31:31the key takeaway here is AI training is not automatically
- 31:37infringing. It really depends on how the model
- 31:40is used. A contrary, somewhat contrary opinion
- 31:44came out, and that's the Thomson Reuters case
- 31:47versus Ross. Kind of reached the opposite result,
- 31:50but I think, and I'll ask the panelists what
- 31:54their thoughts on this are. But what happened
- 31:57in that case is they actually, Ross used the
- 32:00Westlaw headnotes that most of us are familiar
- 32:02with. to train an AI legal research platform.
- 32:08But in that case, that AI research platform performed
- 32:11the same exact function as Westlaw. So it was
- 32:14the substitute for the existing marketplace.
- 32:17And the court did reject the fair use doctrine
- 32:21in that particular instance. Turning to agreements,
- 32:27though, this is now becoming a real negotiating
- 32:31point, right? So many agreements do not treat
- 32:33AI training as a distinct, defined use. And after
- 32:38the meta case, which talks about that it may
- 32:41qualify as fair use, but only if transformative,
- 32:45my question for the panel is, how should transactional
- 32:48attorneys moving forward in 2026, draft provisions
- 32:53addressing AI training given that fair use is
- 32:57conditional and fact dependent. Yeah, maybe I
- 33:01could jump in. I mean, I think what you're really
- 33:04demonstrating is that there's such a diversity
- 33:06of analysis going on. These are really very fact
- 33:09specific and fact intensive cases, right? And
- 33:14You know, Jonathan mentioned the Barts versus
- 33:16Anthropic case, which, as we all know, just recently
- 33:19settled for $1 .5 billion, right? And then, of
- 33:23course, there's the Cadre versus Medicase, two
- 33:25cases in the exact same courthouse in front of
- 33:27two different judges that came out very differently.
- 33:31And as you mentioned, fair use is a multifactored
- 33:33analysis. And both of these judges found that
- 33:36that the use was sort of wildly transformative
- 33:39in terms of ingesting these books in order to
- 33:41train these models. But the real distinction
- 33:45that mattered for them because what you're describing
- 33:47concerning market harm and the effect that it
- 33:49has on the market. And I think that translates
- 33:51into two pieces that you've already touched on.
- 33:54The distinction really doing the work here is
- 33:56between the inputs and the outputs. And on the
- 33:59input side, part of the analysis touched on the
- 34:02course perception that there wasn't really a
- 34:05licensing market in place for training to take
- 34:07place. And I think what we're seeing, and to
- 34:10your question about what transactional lawyers
- 34:11are doing, we're seeing a change in that, and
- 34:13a shift in how that's working. Open AI is seeking
- 34:17out more and more partnerships across various
- 34:19forms of media, including news media. images,
- 34:24right? Shutterstock, Getty images, things like
- 34:25this, where they're entering into license agreements
- 34:28in order to license this underlying material
- 34:29for training purposes. So I think from a transactional
- 34:32perspective, lawyers are seeing more of this
- 34:34going forward. Then, of course, there's the output
- 34:36piece, which is if you've licensed your work
- 34:38for training, even if you haven't, is the output
- 34:41going to look substantially similar? And is that
- 34:43output potentially going to pollute the market?
- 34:46and compete with your works. And that was a big
- 34:48issue that the court talked about in the Kadri
- 34:50case and ultimately found that the plaintiffs
- 34:52hadn't presented any evidence of that at summary
- 34:55judgment and therefore dismissed it. So I think
- 34:57that the push -pull, again, is if you're on the
- 35:01side of the studio or someone who is licensing
- 35:04in creative works, you want to capture as broad
- 35:06rights as possible to use this work and license
- 35:09it for training. It's an asset. You bought it
- 35:13on a work -for -hire basis, potentially. we want
- 35:15to be able to use this and monetize it. On the
- 35:18talent side, I'm sure that the folks on our panel
- 35:20are doing this all the time, you're marking up
- 35:22these agreements and you're trying to put in
- 35:24as much protection as possible to limit the use
- 35:26of your client's work for training. And if they
- 35:29are going to use it for training, there's going
- 35:30to be consent and there's going to be compensation,
- 35:32which is really the hallmark of this conversation.
- 35:35And that gets us to something that's going on
- 35:38right now, which is the Writers Guild negotiations
- 35:40on their TV theatrical contract. Unusually, the
- 35:46Guild leadership last week publicly stated some
- 35:52details about what they're looking for. And I
- 35:56had predicted a week earlier, this is my victory
- 35:59lap, that the Writers Guild was going to be concerned
- 36:01about compensation for training data. Because
- 36:07all three of the above the line guilds, of course,
- 36:11get residuals when the film footage is reused.
- 36:14a movie or a TV episode, whatever it goes from
- 36:17one platform to another. But the Writers Guild
- 36:19also, under certain circumstances, gets compensation
- 36:24when the script is reused. You use the characters
- 36:28and the worldview to create a sequel, or you
- 36:31do a reboot, you merchandise a character, you
- 36:35merchandise an object like a lightsaber, whatever.
- 36:37So the Writers Guild is... is even more deeply
- 36:40concerned with reuse than the Directors Guild
- 36:44and the Send, Sag, After are. And indeed, a week
- 36:49after my prediction, the Writers Guild said,
- 36:52we are looking for compensation when our scripts
- 36:54are used as training data. Now, that's going
- 36:56to be a very heavy lift because the studio position
- 37:02is going to be, look, the background law is unsettled.
- 37:05There's some rando who doesn't own the copyright.
- 37:09to the script, unlike us, because it worked for
- 37:11hires, as was pointed out, can potentially make
- 37:16use of a script as training data. Why should
- 37:20we put ourselves, the owners of the script, in
- 37:24a worse position than some random third party
- 37:27and have to pay the writers for that use? So
- 37:31this is going to be very touch and go, frankly.
- 37:35in these negotiations, and it's going to be a
- 37:37very difficult, probably hard fought issue. Even
- 37:41as we speak right now, they're in the room. And
- 37:44Jonathan, going to the question also with the
- 37:47WGA negotiations and the question of input. input,
- 37:51output. I thought it was interesting that one
- 37:53of the other topics they brought up was because
- 37:56just as a little bit of background, as I'm sure
- 37:58people know, separated rights is such a huge
- 38:00part of what writers are entitled to if they
- 38:03are entitled to certain credits, certain higher
- 38:06level credits. And if you are working from assigned
- 38:10material, you're less likely to be entitled to
- 38:13those credits and then therefore less likely
- 38:15to be entitled to separated rights. And I know
- 38:18that W .J. is very interested in talking about
- 38:20the fact that assigned material, which is traditionally
- 38:24a book or could be an underlying script, could
- 38:27be a story, it could be a treatment. They don't
- 38:31want AI generated materials to be labeled assigned
- 38:35materials for that purpose, which I think is,
- 38:37I mean, I don't see that being too much of an
- 38:40issue because - Well, it's not an issue now because
- 38:42they got that three years ago. You're exactly
- 38:46right. AI -generated material cannot be considered
- 38:50literary material or assigned material. That
- 38:53they already got. Yeah. Yeah. And we have, in
- 38:56our agreements as well, with the writers, whether,
- 38:59you know, it depends on which side we're on because
- 39:01we represent writers and we represent, you know,
- 39:04companies that are engaging writers. But, you
- 39:06know, in our agreements, we also I'll have a
- 39:09reference to what the writer can do in terms
- 39:11of what they're using in their materials. So
- 39:16if they're going to use AI, obviously, they have
- 39:19to identify what the source was. This is at least
- 39:23what we include our agreements. What the source
- 39:24was and annotate the materials that are AI -generated
- 39:28so we can make sure we don't have issues down
- 39:32the road. Right, because AI -generated material,
- 39:36at least if it's separable, material is not subject
- 39:39to copyright. So that's a great concern for your
- 39:44studio clients, obviously, your producer clients.
- 39:47Only because we're going to cover the SAG -AFTRA
- 39:50material in just a moment, just a general question
- 39:54for you. you know, for the practitioners in this
- 39:58regard, what are your thoughts? I mean, do you
- 40:00believe that this should that these agreements
- 40:02should expressly permit training or prohibit
- 40:05it? You know, or what what would you recommend
- 40:09with respect to telling other practitioners should
- 40:12be the defined limitations in there? I'd like
- 40:15to get your thoughts in terms of your personal
- 40:17recommendations. That depends on leverage, of
- 40:24course. Go ahead, Emma. I was just going to say,
- 40:28on the game side of things, I think what's interesting
- 40:30is that there's, I mean, I'm sure this is true
- 40:32as well for film and TV, there's a lot of functionality
- 40:35and use of artificial intelligence that is beyond
- 40:37just generative artificial intelligence. So whether
- 40:40it's image upscaling, you're working on motion
- 40:42capture, the revision of the refinement of code,
- 40:46I think what we've been doing, at least what
- 40:48I have seen is it seems like when we are licensing
- 40:52materials, so when we are taking existing IP
- 40:54and putting it into a game, there tends to be
- 40:57a push for just a kind of blanket prohibition
- 41:00on artificial intelligence. So what we've been
- 41:02trying to do is kind of parse out generative
- 41:06AI, training in generative AI, and then the other
- 41:10uses for artificial intelligence that are outside
- 41:13of just generative AI. And that's kind of mirrored,
- 41:15I think, in what you see in the interactive media
- 41:18agreement for SAG. I'm just curious if anybody
- 41:24else has any recommendations for any of the practitioners
- 41:29that are in attendance today. As Jonathan said,
- 41:36the law is constantly evolving and changing.
- 41:38And these are some early decisions. There's something
- 41:40like over 100 copyright claims have now been
- 41:42filed against the AI companies and even more
- 41:44worldwide. And some of these decisions we're
- 41:46talking about may potentially be subject to review,
- 41:49we would expect. And so the law often it goes
- 41:55behind the pace of business. And something we
- 41:57saw recently at the end of last year, within
- 41:59the licensing landscape is the deal that was
- 42:01announced between Disney and OpenAI, right? Where
- 42:04they effectively announced a partnership to make
- 42:06some of the crown jewels of Disney's IP library
- 42:08available on the OpenAI platform for ChatGPT,
- 42:13as well as for Sora, right? And interestingly
- 42:15in that deal, Disney specifically excluded training
- 42:18from the scope of the license, okay? And not
- 42:22surprisingly given that they're having... lawsuits
- 42:24right now against other companies claiming that
- 42:27unauthorized training is copyright infringement.
- 42:29So they sort of sidestep the complicated issues
- 42:31that are involved in that. in that aspect of
- 42:34the deal. But they're really focused on the outputs.
- 42:37And so I think this is something that's going
- 42:39to happen more and more. I think deal makers
- 42:41can be very creative about how they approach
- 42:43this on both sides of the input -output divide.
- 42:47And then, of course, the issues become what are
- 42:49the guardrails? How are we going to monetize
- 42:50this? How are we going to enforce brand protection
- 42:55when potential user -generated content is being
- 42:58created based upon this underlying IP? And it's
- 43:02happening at AIC. scale on a global basis, potentially
- 43:04across platforms. So I think there's a lot of
- 43:06opportunity for lawyers to be creative around
- 43:10this and really stay up to speed with what's
- 43:13happening in the marketplace. Because I think
- 43:14that's what the clients are really trying to
- 43:16do is to take advantage. Something you touched
- 43:19upon. First thing I wanted to mention is. you
- 43:23know, people to know that the SAG -AFTRA extended
- 43:28beyond just film and television. It does go into
- 43:30gaming because there are voice actors and motion
- 43:33capture and the like. So it's kind of crossing
- 43:37platforms, in my opinion. But, you know, when
- 43:40we talk about the AI and we talk about the use
- 43:42and we talk about the publicity rights that are
- 43:45involved in there, how do you guys, when you
- 43:49negotiate these agreements, negotiate in provisions
- 43:54with respect to separate exploitation rights
- 43:57for these. Do you address these on the front
- 44:01end as to when you're granting AI rights for
- 44:05input or whatever purposes that you're doing?
- 44:08Because I know that there's the big tension.
- 44:09I think the basis of the SAG -AFTRA strike in
- 44:12large part was effectively talent losing control
- 44:16over their names, images, and likenesses as a
- 44:19result of this. On the back end of that, and
- 44:23SAG -AFTRA did address this, but how does the
- 44:27compensation model work? Is it a separate category
- 44:30of exploitation? And if it is, how do you guys
- 44:33structure the exploitation aspect of that to
- 44:36compensate the rights holder? Well, a very interesting
- 44:41example, actually, also from last year, is the
- 44:43commercials agreement, the SAG -AFTRA commercials
- 44:46agreement. has a provision that says that digital,
- 44:54that synthetic characters, synthetic avatars
- 44:58cannot be used strictly for economic reasons.
- 45:03And if they are used for non -economic reasons,
- 45:06that one and a half times the scale compensation
- 45:10that would have been paid has to be paid into
- 45:12the pension and health fund. along with a pension
- 45:15and health contribution on top of that. So that's
- 45:18an attempt to look at market harm in the labor
- 45:23market. Market harm on the broad level, not displacing
- 45:29a single individual where you have an avatar
- 45:32that resembles one individual, but in fact the
- 45:36market harm that the technology may create as
- 45:41a whole. It's difficult. To your question about
- 45:49what a transaction lawyer should do, it does
- 45:52depend in part on leverage. If you raise a sleeping
- 45:57dog as to whether something can be used for training
- 46:02or not, if your counterparty has more leverage,
- 46:05they may insist that training be allowed. When
- 46:13in fact, if you'd left it ambiguous, you might've
- 46:15been in a better place. I do have an anecdote,
- 46:17by the way, we don't talk that as much about
- 46:19trademark, but trademark is an issue here when
- 46:23it comes to characters, when it comes to logos.
- 46:26I did a kid's book where I wrote the text and
- 46:29the illustrations were done by AI. And I said,
- 46:33colorful illustration for a kid's book of a football
- 46:36player, for example. And later I looked and I
- 46:39realized, his sneakers had a Nike Swish, which
- 46:43I had not asked for, but there it was. And I'm
- 46:47like, okay, is that fair use? Is that infringing?
- 46:53I mean, this was on the output side. The input
- 46:56prompt was just exactly as neutral as what I
- 46:59told you. So you just don't know what you're
- 47:02gonna get sometimes. Seeing that this is again
- 47:07a collective question, but are you by that? I
- 47:09mean to the panel generally is there are we getting
- 47:13a two tier system between guild agreements and
- 47:16non guild because there's plenty of non union
- 47:19movies that are being created. Are we seeing
- 47:24disparate treatment? I mean, how is that in terms
- 47:27of the agreements reflected? Are non -union productions
- 47:33using these same AI restrictions and same AI
- 47:38systems or, you know, provisions in the agreement?
- 47:42I don't see a lot of difference between the agreements
- 47:45necessarily. And, you know, I mean, I personally
- 47:48don't. work with a lot of productions where it's
- 47:50not a sag after production, I see more often
- 47:53that there might be a non -union writer agreement.
- 47:57And again, as people have said, that all has
- 47:59to do with leverage. I think also, I believe
- 48:03it was Jonathan made an interesting point about,
- 48:05you know, or how specific do you get in an agreement,
- 48:07right? So you are opening up cans of worms sometimes
- 48:10if you get really specific and list every possible
- 48:12right that you're gonna have. Obviously, when
- 48:14you're working with someone who's a member of
- 48:17a union, there are already built -in protections
- 48:19for that talent, whether it's a SAG -AFTRA member
- 48:22or a WJ member. But I don't, you know, I think
- 48:26it's always the case that, you know, actually,
- 48:30I don't right now see when it is a non -union
- 48:33agreement, that's typically more of an independent
- 48:35producer. And I don't think they're, you know,
- 48:38even anticipating as much. They're just hoping
- 48:41at the movie made and look at those things and
- 48:43potential traditional methods. You kind of have
- 48:46to get them to focus a bit more on the AI of
- 48:48it all. But, you know, I think it's pretty similar
- 48:52that you're going to try and get as much as you
- 48:54can if you're representing the production company
- 48:57and try and restrict if you're representing the
- 48:59talent. So question for you, Anne. You do a lot
- 49:04of these WGA, writer stuff. How, if at all, does
- 49:10the Writers Guild handle it from SAG -AFTRA,
- 49:13for example? How are these reflected in the contracts?
- 49:19Are there differences? What are the similarities
- 49:21that you're seeing? You know, and how we've changed
- 49:25the contracts or the in between the two agreements.
- 49:28I mean, I was kind of asking. Yeah, I mean, well,
- 49:30both actually would be great if you could address
- 49:32that. Yeah. You know, I think. Well, there hasn't
- 49:38been too much of a change, I would say, in the
- 49:40forms that we've used, really. Speaking to, obviously,
- 49:45in a writer's agreement, we find it's very important
- 49:47in terms of the input side to make sure that
- 49:49we know that no AI is being used. If it is a
- 49:52WGA agreement or a SAG -AFTRA agreement, we always
- 49:55have that collective clause that's saying that
- 49:57the minimum terms of the agreement control. Of
- 50:02course, in the rights provisions, that's where
- 50:04I've seen it the most. And we do tend to be a
- 50:10little bit more specific, I'd say, in terms of
- 50:12referring to the fact that we can use AI, augmented
- 50:16reality, whatever we want to say in terms of
- 50:20making it very clear that we may use it for training.
- 50:23Honestly, I've never seen anyone yet use it for
- 50:25training. We talk a lot about it. I haven't,
- 50:30maybe it's going on, but I haven't, and into
- 50:33the point of like, are you seeing separate compensation
- 50:36for these things? I would say no, because I have
- 50:39not at least had it personally come up in an
- 50:41agreement where that's on the table at the moment,
- 50:44some sort of exploitation using AI, maybe others
- 50:48have. But yeah, it's not gotten that granular
- 50:52yet in my experience. Because we are running
- 50:55out of time, there's a couple things I'd like
- 50:57to cover. So I was going to talk, at least I
- 51:01mentioned, there's going to be an honorable mention
- 51:03about the music issue. And I've got some CCPA
- 51:06stuff that Emma was going to address. But one
- 51:10kind of off. Topic discussion because it's we're
- 51:14seeing a lot of this we see this definitely in
- 51:16the music business you know it used to be right
- 51:20the record labels would go out and they would
- 51:24go see bands and venues and see how they're following
- 51:26was see how they are they performed other live
- 51:30show was now in music. Certainly in the influencer
- 51:35sphere, certainly even film and television, as
- 51:38I'm understanding it, I don't do a whole lot
- 51:39of work in that area, but my understanding is
- 51:42even actors, actresses are being hired just like
- 51:48artists are being signed to labels based on their
- 51:51social media following. And I won't go into all
- 51:55the metrics that are utilized for social media
- 51:58following, but you know how... How is talent
- 52:03responding to this, because not all talent are
- 52:06social media savvy, and it's now having a significant
- 52:09impact on their career. So starting with you,
- 52:12Anne, what are you seeing as the ramifications
- 52:17of social media on talent just getting jobs as
- 52:21entertainers? Yeah, both getting jobs and then
- 52:24also just realizing the value that can come from
- 52:28having a social media presence outside of whatever
- 52:30job you're doing. I see it more actually, well,
- 52:36I shouldn't say that. Jen's ears typically are
- 52:39pretty savvy with social media, but if you have
- 52:41clients that are a bit older, have been in the
- 52:43industry a while, they're kind of looking over
- 52:45their shoulder or seeing other people or their
- 52:47peers having a big social media presence. have
- 52:52clients come to us for advice on that, or we
- 52:54actually sort of prepare them for it. For example,
- 52:58if you have talent that are about to be on a
- 52:59show that's going to really be a big break for
- 53:02them, they're going to be much more in the public
- 53:04eye. We work with also agencies that represent
- 53:11social media creators. And anyone who wants to
- 53:16monetize the value of their brand, their personality,
- 53:19we do recommend that they work with an agency
- 53:22like that. It can really help a lot. And then
- 53:24for someone who really has not had much of a
- 53:26social media presence and wishes to have one,
- 53:30it behooves them, I think, a lot to work with
- 53:34a company that is going to assist them with getting
- 53:37their social media up and running and, you know,
- 53:40kind of maybe front loading some content for
- 53:42them to use, because as we all know, you know,
- 53:45from the talent perspective, well, actually from
- 53:48both, because if you have talent in an upcoming
- 53:50motion picture and you've invested a lot of money,
- 53:53you know, one small wrong move on social media
- 53:55can be devastating as we see all too often. So
- 53:59it is definitely something to get ahead of when
- 54:00you represent talent and, you know, you don't
- 54:05want to try and force someone into it if it's
- 54:07really not. their thing. And having a social
- 54:11media presence that really is monetized and generates
- 54:14a great deal of value, you have to post very,
- 54:18very frequently. So it's not for everyone. But
- 54:21those are some of the considerations that we
- 54:24look into for our clients. Well, I want to leave
- 54:26some time here for some questions. And let me
- 54:32just look at some of these for you. And I'm sorry,
- 54:36Emma, I didn't. get to the CCPA stuff. But let
- 54:40me just run through some questions. Well, I have
- 54:43a comment from Uduak. Hello, Uduak. How are you?
- 54:47But it doesn't look like there's really a question
- 54:49here. Just a good... A good commentary here,
- 54:54but similarly we have a question here that was
- 54:59not really a question. It's a common short one,
- 55:01but I do have a question as a result of it, and
- 55:03I think it's relevant. He talks about in the
- 55:06book publishing world, authors must warrant that
- 55:08they have not used AI, and I think you're probably
- 55:12all seeing that in your practice as well. Would
- 55:16that be accurate? Yeah, I think that's true.
- 55:24Whatever it is, whatever content is being delivered
- 55:27that publishers will want to know that, you know,
- 55:30obviously companies engaging writers want to
- 55:32know that. So if content is being delivered in
- 55:33any way, we want to know that it's, you know,
- 55:36if you are, you know, it's not always prohibited,
- 55:39I would say, but if you're using it, it needs
- 55:41to be very, you know, annotated and clear what
- 55:45the source is. All right. I'm sorry. Go ahead.
- 55:51I thought I heard something. The concerns are
- 55:54sort of primarily twofold. I mean, one is the
- 55:56concern that whatever they're receiving from
- 55:57the author is going to be protectable, given
- 56:00the guidance from the copyright office about
- 56:02the copyright ability of works that involve AI
- 56:05and the need for human involvement. And then,
- 56:07of course, the other issue is they want to make
- 56:09sure that the things that are coming through
- 56:10are not inadvertently infringing on some of the
- 56:13underlying works that something may have been
- 56:14trained on. So this somebody raised a comment
- 56:20here in the in the comment section also So I'm
- 56:25going to because this will be the the last of
- 56:28it here And so I'm going to ask each of you in
- 56:30turn. I'm going to start with you Emma Again,
- 56:35this was more of a comment, but it's one that
- 56:37I that is really been discussed quite a bit of
- 56:41late and that is this to each of you just uh
- 56:44you know because we're just about out of time
- 56:46so i want to give each of you a couple minutes
- 56:48to both wrap up and answer this one question.
- 56:52What do you see is AI Emma starting with you?
- 56:56Do you feel AI is a threat to content creators
- 57:00at the end of the day and talent, you know, because
- 57:03of name, image and likeness rights? Or do you
- 57:06think it's going to be a useful tool? I mean,
- 57:10a lot of people are freaking out. that, oh, AI
- 57:13is going to replace us. Other people don't feel
- 57:16that way. So I'd like to get your parting shots
- 57:18here and anything else that you'd like to add,
- 57:21starting with you, Emma, as to the future of
- 57:23AI. Is it as a big, giant global threat that
- 57:26people are scared of? Or do you think it'll be
- 57:28a tool like the internet was a tool to help productivity
- 57:32and help people going forward? I think it's a
- 57:35little bit of both. And I think that's kind of
- 57:37the hard answer. It's going to be a tool that
- 57:39increasingly we use that does, I think, reduce
- 57:44the work of other people. Jonathan got this idea
- 57:46earlier about labor replacement. And that's kind
- 57:49of, I think, the core concern. I mean, not to
- 57:52say the obvious, but that AI replaces what you're
- 57:55doing. And if it's work that you normally would
- 57:57have been compensated and instead AI is taking
- 57:59that place, then yeah, I do think it does pose
- 58:02a threat and it is a concern. Do I think AIs
- 58:06is, you know, is the concern going away? No,
- 58:09I think it's how do we use AI responsibly in
- 58:11a way that makes sense, both from a legal standpoint,
- 58:13but then also from, you know, making sure that
- 58:16people are credited for their work, compensated
- 58:19fairly. How do we address those concerns? And
- 58:22I mean, I think there's the legal aspect of it,
- 58:24but then there's also the kind of very human
- 58:26issue that underlies it. But David. Yeah, look,
- 58:33I think Emma really hit it on the head. The reality
- 58:35is it's here. It's a powerful tool. It really
- 58:40comes back to responsible use, being thoughtful
- 58:42about this. And I think for transactional lawyers,
- 58:46the key is to understand what the underlying
- 58:49issues are and stay abreast of the developments
- 58:51so they can guide their clients through this
- 58:53new landscape. Jonathan. I agree with both my
- 58:59colleagues and compensation and consent are key.
- 59:05I mentioned that I did a kid's book a couple
- 59:07of years ago. It would have cost me, and it was
- 59:10a hobby project, would have cost me $16 ,000
- 59:13to do the 100 illustrations, instead it cost
- 59:15me 50 cents, eight hours of a $20 a month subscription.
- 59:21That sort of a ratio of 30 ,000 to one, even
- 59:24if it were just 30 to one, uh in cost savings
- 59:28is tells you this is a tool that as it continues
- 59:32to develop is just going to be inexorable there's
- 59:35no there's no saying no we're not going to use
- 59:38this when the cost savings are potentially that
- 59:41great so shaping that and maintaining a place
- 59:45for human creativity maintaining on ramps for
- 59:48junior for for entry level positions whether
- 59:51in law whether in entertainment whether in accounting,
- 59:55business consulting, white -collar work generally,
- 59:58is going to be a very, very difficult task. And
- 1:00:02it's something that's going to require more political
- 1:00:04will than the country so far has evinced. But
- 1:00:07it's going to require that sort of thing, I think.
- 1:00:11And how about you, Anne? You're muted. You're
- 1:00:15muted. Yeah, I agree with everything everyone
- 1:00:20said. And to build a little bit on what Jonathan
- 1:00:23said, in my world too, representing talent, I
- 1:00:26think political legislative action is probably
- 1:00:32going to be pretty important when you talk about,
- 1:00:34you know, right now you can identify something
- 1:00:36that's AI most, you know, pretty easily by certain,
- 1:00:40you know. hints that it is, but that's going
- 1:00:43to change. I mean, I'm talking now about deep
- 1:00:45fakes and things like that. And that's going
- 1:00:47to evolve. So that concerns me in terms of, you
- 1:00:50know, protecting talents rights. And yeah, it'll
- 1:00:53be interesting. We're in the infancy, infancy.
- 1:00:55So I'm, you know, we just got to do our best
- 1:00:58to stay ahead of it. Deepfakes is one thing,
- 1:01:02and I would just mention, you know, I don't do
- 1:01:05much litigation at all, but I did get sucked
- 1:01:08into one case, and it was a pro -per plaintiff,
- 1:01:11and that pro -per plaintiff turned out to be
- 1:01:13named ChatGPT. Everything they submitted to the
- 1:01:17court was unquestionably written by ChatGPT.
- 1:01:21The interesting thing about that is the plaintiff
- 1:01:24in this particular instance was really horrible
- 1:01:26at it. And we're GPT is concerned garbage in
- 1:01:30garbage out. But what I noticed through the course
- 1:01:32of this litigation, by the way, we got it dismissed
- 1:01:35because I know you're on the edges of your seat
- 1:01:37wondering. But the what I noticed of it, even
- 1:01:41she over the course of this litigation, which
- 1:01:44lasted about eight months, was getting more sophisticated,
- 1:01:47getting better with using AI. And I think people
- 1:01:51that look at this issue globally. It is not sufficient
- 1:01:55to look at this and say, oh, this is what AI
- 1:01:57is. We weren't even talking about AI during COVID.
- 1:02:01And it's all we're talking about now, three,
- 1:02:04four years later. And I think people need to
- 1:02:07start looking at this, not at what AI is, but
- 1:02:10what AI will be in 10 years from now. And that's
- 1:02:13where I think our focal point needs to be. And
- 1:02:16I know that there's a lot of active Dina LaPolt
- 1:02:18very active in trying to get deep fakes past.
- 1:02:22uh legislation to protect content creators to
- 1:02:25pretend to protect talent because these are very
- 1:02:28real issues and ai is getting more sophisticated
- 1:02:31and i did not want to focus on ai today but that'll
- 1:02:35be my final thought here um so with that i think
- 1:02:38we can wrap up we've gone a little over an hour
- 1:02:41and i want to thank you all of you sincerely
- 1:02:44uh appreciate you doing this here with me today
- 1:02:47and I really valued it and I value all you and
- 1:02:50I can't thank you enough for doing this. And
- 1:02:52I hope everybody that attended today enjoyed
- 1:02:55it and got something out of it. And thank you.
- 1:02:59And thank you for organizing. Thank you. Thank
- 1:03:01you, Keith. And thank you to the co -panelists.