Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Reflecting Without Regret: Letting the Past Year Be What It Was
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.medigroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.n ETTAGROU p.org. So welcome everybody.
- 0:22This is I love you keep going. It is Thursday, December 18th,
- 0:252025. It's 7:37 PM Pacific Standard
- 0:30Time and we're getting on toward the end of the year and I and
- 0:34we're not going to meet for the next two Thursdays, Christmas
- 0:39and New Year's Day. So we'll be back.
- 0:42When is that the 7th or 8th of January?
- 0:48Is that right? Let's have a look on the 8th of
- 0:55sorry of yeah, the 8th of January.
- 0:58We'll come back. So it's a couple of weeks off.
- 1:02But I thought that maybe what I would point to in tonight's
- 1:08conversation is that the year is winding up and we we tend to
- 1:16like to do our reflections on what happened during the year
- 1:21and whether we progressed or didn't progress or whether we
- 1:25met our goals or we didn't meet our goals.
- 1:27We tend to be a goal oriented society, which I think could be
- 1:33useful in the Buddhist context. Of course the idea is to be
- 1:40goalless, but I but I find that actually we have so much trading
- 1:51in, in goal setting and goal achieving that we should employ
- 1:56that in, in terms of our practice all the way up to the
- 2:00moment where you don't need to have goals anymore.
- 2:04You become enlightened, so driven, driven, driven, then
- 2:09just letting it all go and coming into fruition.
- 2:15Of course, on a, a micro level, it's the grabbing, it's the
- 2:18resisting that is the thing that keeps you out of that.
- 2:21And so not grabbing, not resisting in each moment is the
- 2:25thing that carries you through. And then of course, there's the
- 2:31intention setting for what we're going to do next to the habit of
- 2:35the New Year's resolution. I, I jokingly say in all
- 2:40sincerity that the only resolution I've ever been able
- 2:45to keep is not to make anymore. So I actually also recommend
- 2:51that big, big recommender of giving up frequently and then
- 2:56starting again frequently. There's a meme that goes around
- 3:08quite a bit, which is the confessions of the Hospice nurse
- 3:15who claims that nobody ever says on their deathbed that they wish
- 3:19they'd spent more time at the office or they wish that they'd
- 3:23made a little bit more money. What they really say is that
- 3:29they hope that the people that they loved knew that they loved
- 3:33them and that they were good at taking care of them.
- 3:42In Myanmar, where we used to go before the coup to practice in
- 3:51English translation of what people would say to you as you
- 3:54were departing from them was I, I hope I took good enough care
- 4:00of you while we were together, which I thought was actually a
- 4:04good frame. When we talk about attachment in
- 4:14relationship to all of this and we talk about exploration, you
- 4:24know, these three endeavours, the attachment system, the
- 4:29exploration system, the collaborative relationship
- 4:32system, trying to organize those so that they work well.
- 4:37One of the things that becomes apparent is that the way that we
- 4:41know who we are comes from the reflection of other people to
- 4:46us. That as human beings, we're just
- 4:49not so capable of of really seeing ourselves clearly without
- 4:54that reflection of other people. And this, you know, starts at
- 5:00the very beginning of life when you're an infant in the arms of
- 5:03your caregiver. The whole world is their face
- 5:06and your whole understanding of who you are and comes from that
- 5:16interaction with the caregiver the whole way that you define
- 5:19yourself at the very beginning, that understanding is in the way
- 5:23that the caregiver responds to you as an infant.
- 5:29Do you have a, did you have a well resourced caregiver so that
- 5:32they they were capable of taking care of you in the way that you
- 5:37needed? And that's really the essential
- 5:39piece. Did they take care of you in the
- 5:41way that you needed to be taken care of?
- 5:43Or did they take care of you in a way that they liked to take
- 5:46care of you, which may or may not have been In Sync with who
- 5:50you were and what you needed? Even if they took care of you in
- 5:55the way that they like to take care of you, if that didn't
- 5:58match up closely enough to your needs, you would have the
- 6:01experience of not being well taken care of.
- 6:07And what's interesting about attachment conditioning is that
- 6:10the care is what's central here, not whether or not you felt
- 6:14loved. One of the things that Mary
- 6:18Mayne said to me, which struck me was that you can grow up in a
- 6:27home that's loving, but where the care is poor and not develop
- 6:30secure attachment. Whereas you could grow up in a
- 6:34home where the care was good and reliable and was less, much less
- 6:38loving and still come out of that with secure attachment
- 6:43because it's the irregularity of care, the the, the sense of
- 6:49security and that the care will be provided.
- 6:52That is what shapes us. Did you have a well resourced
- 6:59caregiver who could respond to you or had interest in you and
- 7:04took the time and energy to learn your cues so they could
- 7:08understand what you were attempting to communicate to
- 7:10them? And could they then respond by
- 7:13taking care of you in the way that you needed so and do it so
- 7:18reliably that you didn't worry about it.
- 7:20And then that propelled you as you developed and came into your
- 7:27free thinking autonomy, which happens around 18 months so that
- 7:33you could begin to explore the environment to discover the
- 7:38things that matter to you. And then were you supported and
- 7:42encouraged, encouraged to develop those capacities that
- 7:47were actually important to you? And so if you you think of this
- 7:55in this space between people and in this capacity of one person
- 8:02to reflect the other to each other, is the space of that
- 8:07creative exploration that opens up.
- 8:11And in the trusting of the other person to protect you, that
- 8:16vigilance of the environment falls away and you can settle
- 8:20into that space and begin the process of collaborative
- 8:25exploration. That's really what we mean in
- 8:27the sense that you're in relationship to someone else who
- 8:32supports you so that you can relax the vigilance of the
- 8:36environment and really focus in on exploration, on playing
- 8:42really, you might say playing to becoming your authentic self.
- 8:53And if that doesn't happen, if the the sense of safety and
- 9:01security in that relational network doesn't form for you,
- 9:06you don't really ever pull out of the vigilance of the
- 9:10environment. And because you don't pull out
- 9:13of that vigilance in the environment, you that's creative
- 9:17safe space doesn't open. And what we do instead is we
- 9:23begin the process of developing a false self that we use to
- 9:29manage the environment. So as we talked about last time
- 9:38in the intention setting and I made the bold request of you to
- 9:47push into your authentic expression here, we're talking
- 9:52about the mechanics of that. One of the things that happens
- 9:59in this construction of the false office, we get pretty good
- 10:02at it. And when we begin to turn toward
- 10:08the authentic self, depending on how sequestered it is, how
- 10:14little attention we've given to developing it as a, as a mode of
- 10:19travel can be kind of awkward and klutzy and not well formed
- 10:28and embarrassing and inhibited, self-conscious, all of those
- 10:35things beautiful that will be rejected or humiliated or
- 10:42killed. And that's really what that safe
- 10:48space is where we didn't get it when we were an infant or a
- 10:52child. And we're not used to the the
- 10:56parameters of that. And if we're now attempting to
- 11:00open that space, that reflection of somebody and holding the
- 11:07space with us, we're going to have to endure all of that,
- 11:12right? You're going to have to, I mean,
- 11:16I, I think if you can drag over some of the skills that you
- 11:18developed for your false self and, and employ them as the
- 11:22authentic self, but that's a good thing to do.
- 11:26But it may be that the skill set for the false self doesn't
- 11:30overlap so much with the authentic self.
- 11:35The inauthentic self is quite skillful at managing, but the
- 11:40authentic self isn't yet, so we have to take the time to
- 11:45develop. That reminds me of that old
- 11:55Buddhist trope of the novice monk calling to the master
- 12:01across the river. And now in understanding
- 12:05Buddhist cosmology, the river always divides the ordinary mind
- 12:11from the enlightened mind. And so the the novice monk is
- 12:14standing on the side of the ordinary mine, calling across
- 12:19the river to the monk, the senior monk who's standing on
- 12:24the enlightened side. And he calls out, how do you get
- 12:30to the other side of the river? How do you become enlightened?
- 12:35And the enlightened monk calls back, you're already on the
- 12:39other side of the river. So in this understanding of a
- 12:47particular type of Buddhist thought.
- 12:49So in one type of Buddhist thinking, you're already there.
- 12:56All you have to do is remove the obscuration so that you can see
- 13:00that you're there. And in the other school, there's
- 13:03a lot of effort that you have to put into developing the capacity
- 13:08for enlightenment. So this is a Zen story.
- 13:17So they're the Mahayana tradition where you're already
- 13:20enlightened, you just have to see that you are.
- 13:36It's interesting because I studied for so long in in
- 13:38Theravada Buddhism. Theravada Buddhism is actually a
- 13:41subset of Hinayana Buddhism. And Hinayana is often translated
- 13:46as the lesser vehicle and Mayan is translated as the greater
- 13:54vehicle. And when I first started
- 13:59studying with Dan Brown, he said, I don't know why you keep
- 14:03up with this. The possum and stuff that you're
- 14:07doing. It's it's a lesser vehicle.
- 14:09Why would you pursue the lesser vehicle when the greater vehicle
- 14:14is available to you? And so I said I don't need to
- 14:19beam up to the spaceship and beam down on the other side of
- 14:22the street. I can just walk across the when
- 14:26the light turns green. Which he did not find as funny
- 14:31as I thought it was. In fact, I didn't think it was
- 14:36funny at all. And it's an interesting thing.
- 14:48I find the the stripped down Burmese style of interaction
- 14:55with the teachers to be easier to comprehend than the the very
- 15:00flowery I experienced. The the Tibetan descriptions of
- 15:05everything is quite flowery. And I have a, a strong version
- 15:13which I'm working on to piety. It registers mostly as hypocrisy
- 15:19to me. And so I like the, I like sort
- 15:23of the plain matter of fact version.
- 15:32But in practice, of course is you get to a place where these
- 15:36things open up and make sense. And I was just reviewing a text
- 15:40and the the claim about Hinyan and Mahayana was plainly stated
- 15:47and it didn't irk me anymore. So I think that there's a, a
- 15:51kind of transition that happens whether you think about it or
- 15:54you like it or not, just that comes from the practice you see
- 15:58in a sense. And I like the sense of
- 16:00sacredness that comes from the Mahamudra in Six Lamps
- 16:07practices. I never really had much a sense
- 16:11of that in in the Metevoposumus side.
- 16:16I like the the progress of the Metevoposum.
- 16:19I've practiced a lot that change from that extremely negative
- 16:27sense of self and the aversion to the world to a an open place
- 16:34that is, that feels quite beautiful most of the time.
- 16:40So then in reflecting back on the year that you've spent in
- 16:49practice and in in pursuing worldly goals, how well do you
- 16:54think you did? And is that clouded by that
- 16:59habit of mind in the way that you habitually think of
- 17:03yourself? Remember that that way that you
- 17:05habitually think of yourself, at the core of it is the reflection
- 17:10of you in your caregiver's eyes. I guess for most of us it would
- 17:16be a mother, but sometimes a father and how they viewed us.
- 17:21And, and can you see clearly what part of it is you and what
- 17:27part of it is the, the response of the caregiver to the demands
- 17:33of caring for a child? You know, we do tend to
- 17:42personalize it quite a bit. We tend to think that when they
- 17:47complained to us that we were difficult, that it was us who
- 17:51was difficult, that somehow our our demands as a child were
- 17:57outrageous, and that if we could just tone it down a little, if
- 18:02we could need less, it could be more invisible.
- 18:06That's how I felt. If I could be more invisible, I
- 18:09would be safer. Can you see that?
- 18:16That that actually was their difficulty, not your difficulty
- 18:23as an infant. As an ordinary infant, human
- 18:27infant, how did you cook up demands that were outrageous?
- 18:38Weren't they just ordinary demands of a child for care?
- 18:42Is that what happened? Because the the conditions of
- 18:47your caregivers development weren't such that they could
- 18:51respond well enough to that they perceived you as difficult.
- 19:02So can we separate that? That would be something that I
- 19:05think would be of interest. How much progress have you made
- 19:08in the the year of practice that you've done that has opened up
- 19:12the the possibility of seeing which part of actually was you
- 19:17and which part was them? And can you push out that piece
- 19:21of them? Most of the time the way that
- 19:27that works is that the caregivers push that part out of
- 19:30themselves into you as a way of getting rid of it.
- 19:38But can you just disperse it in in the air without handing it
- 19:45off to somebody? That would be great and free
- 19:49yourself of it. The, I like to call it the
- 19:57terrible sadness, the sadness of the, the loss of everything.
- 20:02How'd you do with the terrible sadness this year?
- 20:08One of the things that happens, of course, is if in each moment
- 20:11you notice that pop of sadness that happens and you just let it
- 20:17dissipate, not grabbing on to it, not resisting and just
- 20:22letting it come and go. Each of those moments ends, and
- 20:26the pop of sadness dissipates and dissipates.
- 20:30That pop of sadness after each moment dissipates.
- 20:36Of course, If you don't, it accumulates drop by drop by drop
- 20:41until you're drowning in an ocean of sadness.
- 20:48So if you grew up in the world and didn't allow that terrible
- 20:55sadness to be part of the experience of everything, and
- 20:59you're swimming around in this ocean of sadness that you've
- 21:02dragged along with you, beginning that process of
- 21:06releasing it would be wonderful. And how much progress have you
- 21:10made in in this year? And if you haven't made so much,
- 21:13maybe make an intention to allow more and more of it to go so
- 21:19that you're not carrying it. Really, the thing about holding
- 21:25on to all of this old stuff is that it consumes a huge amount
- 21:29of energy to hold it. And so while you may think I'm,
- 21:33I'm, I'm keeping it at Bay, I'm not really dealing with it and
- 21:37makes life easier. Actually, what it does is
- 21:39consume a huge amount of the energy that you might use for
- 21:44getting on with the the exploration of this part of
- 21:48life, which would be really useful if you could get it back,
- 21:52which you can simply by allowing it these, each of these waves to
- 21:58come and go. And how are you doing on holding
- 22:11the view of lively awakened awareness as Daniel's to call to
- 22:17see in the repositive side of things, in the metaphositive
- 22:27side of things, we might say that there's there is no
- 22:32intrinsic self experience that it that arises in each moment of
- 22:38experience. In Western psychology, there's
- 22:44this idea of the core of us, the the central core of us that is
- 22:50unchanging. And this is a quite a a contrast
- 22:54to this understanding that there is not that core of a being, a
- 23:04self that can be identified and located.
- 23:07Then actually that self experience arises in every
- 23:11moment based on the conditions of the present moment on that.
- 23:15That is, we interpret the conditions of the present moment
- 23:19and we assign meaning to them and and that duality opens where
- 23:23the self is, is viewing life as it unfolds with the meanings
- 23:30that we've given to it. And that actually all of that is
- 23:341 experience, not a separate self, separate unchanging
- 23:40experience of self. When you remember something that
- 23:46you, when you remember something where you made the memory, let's
- 23:53say when you were five years old, you made the memory in the
- 23:59body that you had then and in the cognitive capacities of the
- 24:03mind of a child. And when you remember it now,
- 24:08you, you don't have a 5 year old body and your mind is your
- 24:12brain. And all of that is quite
- 24:14different than it was then. And so you don't even, you don't
- 24:17have the equipment to replay the memory to get an accurate
- 24:20perception of what actually it was.
- 24:23You remember it now in in the capacity that you have so that
- 24:27that, that understanding of the child, you might reflect on what
- 24:31that must have been, but you won't have the capacity to
- 24:35recreate it because the gear is all different.
- 24:39It it's aged and you've had other experiences and you've
- 24:43developed the capacity to reflect in a way that's
- 24:48different. The meanings have changed all of
- 24:50that. So when you remember something
- 24:53there isn't, it isn't a reflection of the the self
- 24:58experience that was operational when you made the memory.
- 25:03And then of course, if you've remembered it before, each time
- 25:06you've remembered it, you've re remembered it with the view of
- 25:10the the self experience that was experiencing it in that moment.
- 25:15And so if you have a memory of something that happened when you
- 25:18were five that you've remembered 1000 times, you have 1000
- 25:22versions of that all compacted into the one gist that activates
- 25:28at the present moment and creates the experience of that
- 25:30that you're having now. None of that is the going to be
- 25:36at this point for me the 70 years on from childhood and even
- 25:42remotely resembling what happened.
- 25:46It's more like what must have happened.
- 25:48What must I have been feeling in in the my capacity to review it
- 25:53now That's how we engaged that. So how much grab is left in that
- 26:06right when that cycle happens, does it just grab you?
- 26:09Is there's this intense emotional experience, you just
- 26:13become aversive, you numb out when that happens?
- 26:16Or can you just allow all of that just to flow through, come
- 26:20and go without resisting, without grabbing, without
- 26:27regretting? Regret and remorse are the pair.
- 26:35Regret are the things that you don't do.
- 26:38And remorse is The thing is the, the, the sadness of what you do
- 26:44do. And it's interesting because on
- 26:51the disorganized side of things that they so much of it is the
- 26:55regret side because you withdraw from life and you don't
- 26:58participate. So you regret that more.
- 27:03The fully engaged in the maniac behavior is the the side that
- 27:09produces remorse. So I'm just saying that in that
- 27:13I have expansive experience with regret and much less with
- 27:19remorse. Mostly I default on the side of
- 27:27not doing it rather than doing it then.
- 27:33So progress on that would be doing it.
- 27:37Whereas if you are on the remorse side, maybe progress
- 27:39would be not doing so much of it.
- 27:45But it's an interesting to pay attention to that feeling of
- 27:48overexposure, of vulnerability of putting yourself at risk.
- 27:57And how did you do in that? In reflecting on the past year,
- 28:00how well have you done it, keeping yourself safe and
- 28:05keeping yourself in the care of people that really value you and
- 28:10really delight in your doing well?
- 28:16And how much time did you put yourself at risk with people
- 28:19that don't value you enough? So that might be useful in
- 28:28adjusting your intention for our next year.
- 28:38I have to say I don't, I don't tend to think of it.
- 28:43I think that way. I have, I tend to make these
- 28:57kinds of evaluations at the conclusion of things and some
- 29:01things last for years and, and some things last for days or
- 29:07weeks or months. And so the that habitual
- 29:13traditional period of reflection is has less residents for
- 29:19residents for me. And I that may also be because I
- 29:24had caregivers that had so little interest in that, that I
- 29:28never had an obligation to reflect in that way.
- 29:34So maybe that lack of preference for me is just another product
- 29:39of neglect. And that is actually part of
- 29:45that more than it's part of me. One of the things that I found
- 29:54super useful in changing was changing this obligation to
- 30:04myself to try and do my very best in everything.
- 30:09And I would say that that actually has had the most effect
- 30:14in a positive way. And that's everything in making
- 30:19a cup of coffee and keeping the kitchen clean and writing a book
- 30:24and relating to someone each moment attempting to do my very
- 30:33best. So you might reflect on the year
- 30:39that's gone and ask, in all of my activities, did I do my very
- 30:46best or did I make a decision that some activities were worth
- 30:50my best and some activities weren't?
- 30:54And then exploring the evaluating system that you used
- 30:59to determine that the default of trying to do your best and
- 31:07everything is easy because you don't have to make an
- 31:09evaluation. You just attempt to do as well
- 31:12as you can. And what you see in that is
- 31:16because in each moment, the conditions are different.
- 31:19Sometimes you do better than other times, but also you see in
- 31:25that, of course, that even in moments where you don't do as
- 31:29well as you might like, your value is not affected by that.
- 31:38And then in a moment where you do as the the best as you can,
- 31:41it turns out really great. Your value isn't actually
- 31:45increased in that moment that it's the, it's the variation of
- 31:51the conditions and all, all of the factors that come into your
- 31:58ability to do that, How how well you performed, how well you
- 32:04slept, how well you ate. I've spoke, I've spoken to a lot
- 32:11of people this week who have been completely sideswiped by
- 32:15the new flu that's going around all of those things, Christian.
- 32:23George, what would be the technique where you just every
- 32:26time you do something good, that you just kind of build that into
- 32:30your value, but then if you do something bad that you don't let
- 32:34that affect you at all, so you're just always going up?
- 32:37I think the western term is called narcissism is.
- 32:43There a meditation in cultivating instead.
- 32:48That would be the inflating cell, but I, I think I'd, you
- 32:52heard the instruction that you, you neither deflate or inflate,
- 32:58you just do the best that you can in that moment.
- 33:01Sure. It's, you know, it is an
- 33:09interesting thing. So what you may have noticed in
- 33:14our culture, in our society, that some people are more
- 33:17valuable than other people. And you notice that the
- 33:22resources flow to some people more than they flow to other
- 33:26people. And, and one of the things that
- 33:32happens, of course, if you're on the upper end of that, because
- 33:35it's always been like that, you assume a responsibility for
- 33:39that, that it's something about you that has allowed all of it.
- 33:44So you might even call it karma, that your karma is good.
- 33:48And so all of this flows to you. The statistic that comes to mind
- 33:55is that 50% of the Nobel Prizes are awarded to people who are
- 34:01born in the top 5% of the economic distribution, and the
- 34:08remaining 50% go to people in the next 6% of the economic
- 34:16distribution. So 100% or so of the Nobel
- 34:20Prizes go to people who are born in the top 11% of the financial
- 34:24distribution of our culture. Would would that suggest that
- 34:28nobody in the bottom 89% of the culture has anything to
- 34:32contribute? Or is it simply that no
- 34:34resources flow to them, so they have no opportunity to create?
- 34:42Steven Gould said I have less interest in the contours of
- 34:51Einstein's brain then I have in the fact that the next Einstein
- 35:00is likely parking my car because the resources are so unequally
- 35:06distributed. Paraphrased, which I find
- 35:13fascinating to think of the the the the incredible squandering
- 35:19of capacity that we we use in in our culture because of the
- 35:25unequal distribution of resources Christian.
- 35:30That's why I spend like 90% of my time trying to work on new
- 35:33kinds of dynamite. Well, yes, it is the
- 35:42whitewashing of blood money. So,
- 36:00so how have you done on that, that aspect of actually seeing
- 36:04things clearly the way things are?
- 36:20I might, as I say, see things clearly the way that they are.
- 36:24And the next thought I have is how are you doing with
- 36:27hopelessness? Yeah.
- 36:38Is it true that hopelessness is the first stage of change?
- 36:43That when you, when you think that there's nothing left to be
- 36:47done, that you've tried everything and that the old way
- 36:50cannot work, is that the moment, that moment of abject
- 36:56hopelessness, that you then decide that you'll have to do
- 36:59something else and that that is the decision, that is the
- 37:02catalyst for change? What point do we think that the
- 37:09this sort of late stage capitalism where it just
- 37:14consumes itself and consumes everything, it's too late and we
- 37:21need to move on to something else Christian?
- 37:27I'm like, I've been part of a church my whole life and it's
- 37:32not a great time to be a church unless you're like, I guess a
- 37:35mega church or something. And our church was really trying
- 37:40to make some very important changes the last couple years
- 37:43that needed to be done. But people have a lot of
- 37:45inertia. And I had this notion that if
- 37:50people could picture the church has already demolished as
- 37:55already like rubble, they could take the next step to move
- 37:59forward. Or like if, if, if people could
- 38:02actually picture the destruction of the world due to climate
- 38:06change, then that might free them of their fantasy that
- 38:10someone else will take care of it like that.
- 38:13Like I kind of thought of it in terms of like the charnel ground
- 38:15meditation. Yeah.
- 38:20Well, we're, we're we're ramping up climate change as a solution.
- 38:23I don't know what it is they expect to happen past the point
- 38:29that there's you can do anything about it except habit, which I
- 38:34think we're probably already there.
- 38:36So maybe they're they're just saying, well, we're going to
- 38:39have it. We can't make it worse.
- 38:42Why not cash out? But you know, I've never been in
- 38:51those hallways or part of those groups and it's hard to know the
- 39:00and media at the moment is so skewed.
- 39:03It's hard to read anything that isn't like a press release
- 39:10running up the flagpole. Let's see if this idea will fly,
- 39:14see if that ideal will fly again.
- 39:17The the that tenor of hopelessness there.
- 39:25But I also want to say that even if you're completely hopeless,
- 39:28it doesn't relieve you of the obligation to acts in the world
- 39:33in a way that is representative of the values that you have.
- 39:40And so how are you doing on your bodhisattva vow to act in the
- 39:51world in a way that's the of benefit to all beings?
- 39:56I'm going to extend that beyond human beings to all the beings
- 40:00of the earth, The bugs. The insect apocalypse, the mass
- 40:07extinction, all of that the that can cause a reflection of the
- 40:19just the powerlessness of the individual.
- 40:22But we can then group together and that group action tends to
- 40:29have more effect. But what you can do as an
- 40:34individual is authentically express the the experiences that
- 40:40you have and the concerns that you have and open perhaps a
- 40:46dialogue with somebody so that your voice is heard in that the
- 40:55polarization. It's hard to have that happen
- 40:57because it's it's very hard to to be received by people who are
- 41:13not interested in receiving. So you might even explore your
- 41:19own receptiveness to ideas and collaboration.
- 41:32And willingness to engage. I find it often quite
- 41:36frustrating, but at the same time I understand I'm not
- 41:45relieved of my obligation to participate and express because
- 41:52I'm hopeless and I find it frustrating and I'm not relieved
- 41:57of my obligation of compassion and care.
- 42:04Doesn't matter who you are and what your position is, I still
- 42:13think each of us has this obligation for responsiveness.
- 42:24So who's willing to accept the Gold Star for the year gone by
- 42:31and the efforts made and then to calculate intention for the year
- 42:45to come, making that decision to really do the very best that you
- 42:50can in every moment based on conditions, understanding so
- 42:56that you're relieved of the obligation of evaluating who
- 42:59deserves and who doesn't. What do you say we do?
- 43:07A little bit of meditation? Hard practice.
- 43:14Can we do hard practice please? OK.
- 43:18I know Christian's going to vote for something else, but.
- 43:30All right, here we go. OK, let go of the meditation.
- 43:49How's that? So good.
- 43:52Good, really great. So just a reminder that we're
- 43:59not meeting for the next two Thursdays because of Christmas
- 44:02and New Year's and so we'll resume on the 7th of January of
- 44:07next year. So wishing you a happy holiday
- 44:13season and joy and, and I so appreciate you and practicing
- 44:23this year. Thank you.
- 44:28See you soon.