Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Cutting Edge Ethics and Risk Management for Real Estate Lawyers
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome, everyone. My name is Howard Gould. I'm
- 0:06co -chair of the real estate section for the
- 0:08Beverly Hills Bar. And it's a pleasure to welcome
- 0:12everyone today. We're very excited about today's
- 0:17program. And I've known our speaker now for,
- 0:19I don't know, probably a decade or two. It's
- 0:22quite a while. Before we begin, let me tell you
- 0:26what some of our upcoming programs are going
- 0:28to be. February 26th. We're going to have a program
- 0:31on real property taxes. Chris O 'Neill from the
- 0:34Greenberg Tower firm is coming back to join us
- 0:36along with one of his partners to talk about
- 0:40real property taxes in California. March 19th
- 0:44is our annual California Association of Realtors.
- 0:47That's CAR update on their new forms or form
- 0:50updates and Jana Gardner is joining us again.
- 0:53She is always extremely well versed in what's
- 0:57going on at CAR and the CAR forms. And it's always
- 1:00a very useful program for anyone who does anything
- 1:03in residential real estate in California. April
- 1:0616th, Howard Fisher, a long time participant
- 1:11and officer at the bar here, is going to do a
- 1:14program on 1031 Exchanges. Larry Jacobson on
- 1:18April 23rd is going to do his annual review of
- 1:21prior years, real estate cases. And we're going
- 1:24to put on a program we haven't done before on
- 1:27May 21st. which is landlord insurance coverage
- 1:31for habitability claims in landlord tenant disputes,
- 1:36which has become a big issue for landlords as
- 1:38to when their insurance will actually cover them
- 1:41for all the habitability issues that come up.
- 1:44And Steve Raucher, also a former president of
- 1:48the Bar Association, is going to put on that
- 1:50program. There is the link for the program materials
- 1:53in the chat, if you didn't get those before,
- 1:56so you can go to the chat and pick up the link.
- 1:58Otherwise, the chat is just for announcements.
- 2:01If you want to do questions for the speaker,
- 2:04please put those in the Q &A. I'll be monitoring
- 2:07those, and we'll certainly cover as many of them
- 2:09as we can. So again, it's a great pleasure to
- 2:14welcome Heather Rosing to join us. Heather has
- 2:19a very distinguished background despite how young
- 2:21she is. She's a partner of Rosing Pot and Strobein
- 2:25in San Diego. She serves as the leader of their
- 2:29complex litigation and professional liability
- 2:31department, and also the discipline, defense,
- 2:34ethics, and risk management department. Ahead
- 2:37is a certified specialist in legal malpractice
- 2:39law with a nationwide reputation as a skilled
- 2:42litigator and complex and multi -party matters,
- 2:46particularly those involving issues of fraud,
- 2:48breach of fiduciary duty, professional negligence,
- 2:52malicious prosecution, civil conspiracy. Excuse
- 3:00me for a moment. Rico and aiding and abetting
- 3:04she also practices in the area of administrative
- 3:06law Jonathan Representing a myriad of professionals
- 3:12before disciplinary agencies including attorneys
- 3:15In proceedings with the state bar of California
- 3:18and judges and commissioners in proceedings with
- 3:21the Commission on judicial performance in addition
- 3:24to her In addition to her litigation practice,
- 3:32Ms. Rosing serves as a risk manager, providing
- 3:35advice to hundreds of law firms, legally related
- 3:38organizations, directors and officers, professional
- 3:41fiduciaries, accountants, and other professionals
- 3:43in areas of ethics, conflict of interest, disqualification,
- 3:47duties to third parties, unauthorized practice
- 3:49of law, and many other areas, including professional
- 3:52responsibility. She serves as an expert witness
- 3:55in these areas, as well as on issues of law firm
- 3:58management. Of particular note, Heather served
- 4:01for four years on the State Bar of California's
- 4:04Board of Trustees, Vice President, Treasurer,
- 4:07and other offices there. And then in 2018 to
- 4:102019, when the California Lawyers Association,
- 4:13CLA, split off from the State Bar, Heather served
- 4:16as the inaugural president of CLA with the largest
- 4:19statewide voluntary bar association in the country,
- 4:22helping them establish themselves as an independent
- 4:25organization. She's also served on numerous ABA
- 4:28committees related to her areas of practice.
- 4:31Heather's a recipient of numerous accolades,
- 4:34too numerous for me to mention here, but has
- 4:37had, as I said, a very distinguished career already.
- 4:41She was born into Chicago, attended University
- 4:43of Illinois Northwestern Law School, where she
- 4:46served as president of the Student Bar Association.
- 4:49Heather, the floor is yours. Thank you for coming.
- 4:55Thank you, Howard. I really appreciate that nice
- 4:57introduction. It's very nice to be here. Well,
- 5:06Heather, it looks like you're video cut out,
- 5:08actually. My video cut out? I hear you. Yeah,
- 5:16you're back. Yeah, it looks like we're back.
- 5:18Okay, excellent. Sorry about that. I'm Heather
- 5:23Rosing. It's great to be here today. I wanted
- 5:25to thank Howard for that kind introduction and
- 5:27we haven't known each other a long time. It's
- 5:29my pleasure to be presenting to the Beverly Hills
- 5:32Borough Association real estate section today.
- 5:35I've had the opportunity to present to some of
- 5:37your colleagues through the trust in the state
- 5:39section and I thank you for having me here. So
- 5:43today we're going to go through a very kind of
- 5:46rapid, practical a tip session where I've put
- 5:51together a number of topics that I think would
- 5:53be of interest to you as lawyers and as real
- 5:56estate professionals. And we're not going to
- 6:00dwell on the intricacies of every rule for these
- 6:04eight topics, but rather we're going to hopefully
- 6:07impart on you some some really, really practical
- 6:11advice that can help you in governing risk in
- 6:14your practice. Governing risk in the practice
- 6:17of law has never been more important. The risk
- 6:19has never been more. I've been representing lawyers
- 6:23for 30 years this year, 20. 26. So by the end
- 6:28of this year, I'll be a 30 year practitioner
- 6:30because I was barred in 1996. So I've worked
- 6:33with thousands of law firms, thousands of lawyers,
- 6:35and I've seen every possible scenario you can
- 6:38think of in the risk management context, the
- 6:42state par discipline defense context, the arbitration
- 6:44context, litigation context. So much of what
- 6:47I impart to you comes from those real life experiences.
- 6:50This is a PowerPoint that I put together on my
- 6:52own. I've shared derivations of it with other
- 6:55groups and hopefully you've find it interesting
- 6:56and informative. As I mentioned in the chat,
- 6:59if you have a follow -up question that can't
- 7:02be dealt with during the course of this program,
- 7:04feel free to email me, and I'm happy to talk
- 7:06with you offline. I find that one or two people
- 7:09like to do that, and I'm happy to get to know
- 7:12people and to share my impression of the answer
- 7:17to your question. So with that, let's go to our
- 7:20first topic, which is client intake. Oh, well,
- 7:27first, I forgot I have an alert. I put this alert
- 7:31here because it's so important. It's before our
- 7:32first topic. So because we are a state bar discipline
- 7:36defense attorneys and state bar compliance attorneys
- 7:38here at Rosemont and strobing, we do a lot of
- 7:40other things as well, but we have a whole department
- 7:42dedicated to that. We are very attuned to upcoming
- 7:46deadlines. And every year, usually in about this.
- 7:50the late spring or summer, we get a whole series
- 7:53of calls of people who are panicked because they've
- 7:57been put into administrative inactive status
- 7:59on their state bar profile. And they usually
- 8:01learn that because a client or their opposing
- 8:03counsel have told them that their state bar profile
- 8:06says they are on an administrative inactive status.
- 8:10Then they have to figure out whether they engaged
- 8:11in the unauthorized practice of law. And it's
- 8:14a true nightmare. So I am putting this out there
- 8:18because the state bar has these following compliance
- 8:22points that are on this slide. And the compliance
- 8:26needs to be done by certain deadlines. In the
- 8:28general, what they call timely compliance deadline
- 8:31is March 30th, 2026. You then have some latitude
- 8:34to complete these items after that. But best
- 8:37practice is to have it done by March 30th, 2026.
- 8:40So I just wanted to quickly touch on these with
- 8:43you. This is an actual screenshot of what you
- 8:45see when you log into your state bar profile.
- 8:49So log in today is my recommendation. This is
- 8:52my own. profile. I screenshotted for you so you
- 8:56can see I still have to complete these items.
- 8:58But number one is the annual fees. Number two
- 9:01is civility oath. You are now required to take
- 9:03an annual civility oath pursuant to the rules
- 9:06of court. I was the co -vice chair of the statewide
- 9:09civility task force and this is something we
- 9:12got passed because of our belief in the importance
- 9:14of civility in the profession. CTAP annual reporting,
- 9:18we're going to talk about that a little bit later,
- 9:19but this is your trust accounting reporting.
- 9:21It's probably the most sticky and difficult requirement
- 9:23out of all these requirements, and it needs to
- 9:25be completed by you personally because you need
- 9:27to attest to the answers under penalty of perjury.
- 9:31MCLE, that's why you're here today, getting ethics
- 9:33credit. Another important requirement, keep in
- 9:36mind that MCLE compliance just requires you to
- 9:38say that you did comply, but the state bar does
- 9:41audit. And if they audit, then you need to transmit
- 9:43the actual CLE record showing that your compliance
- 9:46certification was truthful. There's a pro bono.
- 9:49annual reporting requirement and an attorney
- 9:51record verification. I actually had a client
- 9:53who was put into inactive status and I'm not
- 9:56sure if that was a mistake because it was kind
- 9:58of new at the time, but because she didn't comply
- 10:02with the attorney record verification, which
- 10:04you would think would not be something that would
- 10:06have that type of repercussion and maybe it doesn't
- 10:09anymore. But these are the requirements. Once
- 10:11they're completed, all these boxes or circles
- 10:13turn green and it says completed. Next slide.
- 10:19Okay, now we're on client intake. Now that I've
- 10:22sufficiently scared you about the compliance
- 10:24tracker on your state bar profile, we'll get
- 10:26into client intake and next slide. So these are
- 10:33the practical considerations that I promised
- 10:34to bring to your attention. Again, I look at
- 10:38these rules from the perspective of people who
- 10:40have called me with their problems, lawyers who
- 10:42have called me with their problems, and I get
- 10:44many, many, many calls regarding what we call
- 10:461 .18 potential client scenarios. Keep in mind
- 10:54that if you are taking calls from potential clients,
- 10:57you may be incurring a duty of confidentiality
- 11:00to those people. And if you incur a duty of confidentiality
- 11:04to a potential client, then you may later be
- 11:07disqualified from being adverse to that client
- 11:09in the same or a substantially related matter.
- 11:13Family law attorneys fall into this trap all
- 11:15the time. But my advice to you is when you're
- 11:18talking to a potential client, don't accept more
- 11:20information than is necessary to figure out whether
- 11:23that person is a good fit. If you really start
- 11:26getting into it and you spend an hour on the
- 11:28phone with them and you accept confidential information,
- 11:31you will want to enter them into your conflict
- 11:33system. in order to make sure that you are not
- 11:36later adverse to them, even if they do not hire
- 11:38you. Potential client situations lead to a lot
- 11:41of disqualification motions. We'll talk about
- 11:43that a little bit later. The other thing, of
- 11:47course, is when a potential client comes in,
- 11:49you want to make sure that you've run that conflict
- 11:51check before you're talking to that person to
- 11:54make sure that you can actually potentially represent
- 11:56them. Sometimes I make the mistake of getting
- 11:59too excited about talking to a lawyer and I forget
- 12:01to run the conflict check. I do that very rarely,
- 12:04but it's a mistake. category that I would mention
- 12:09to you here is the fit check. This is what we
- 12:12call it here at Rosing Pot and Strobean. And
- 12:14this is where you should figure out from a preliminary
- 12:19standpoint if the client is the right client
- 12:21for your firm. In the thousand plus malpractice
- 12:25cases that I've handled, I will tell you that
- 12:28I have heard this hundreds of times, what I'm
- 12:31about to tell you. Heather, I did make a mistake.
- 12:34And my mistake was I should have gone with my
- 12:37gut at the client intake stage and turn down
- 12:39this client who has just sued me for malpractice.
- 12:41Or I should have asked more questions to ascertain
- 12:44that this person wasn't a good fit or this company
- 12:46wasn't a good fit for my law firm. So fit check,
- 12:51practice area, do they fall squarely within your
- 12:53practice area? Does your workload permit it?
- 12:56Does the client have the finances in order to
- 12:59support your services? As you can imagine, this
- 13:02is one of the key Points of dispute and tension
- 13:05between lawyers and law firms. You've probably
- 13:07encountered it yourself. I would be surprised
- 13:09if you haven't. But if the client can't afford
- 13:11you, it's going to go wrong and it's going to
- 13:13go wrong in the middle of the representation,
- 13:16leading you to a situation where you may need
- 13:18to withdraw and the client potentially making
- 13:20allegations at that point in time. And do you
- 13:23get along with the potential client? Sometimes
- 13:24you can feel like it's not going to be a good
- 13:26personality fit. The red flags, I did want to
- 13:29mention, these are the ones that come up and
- 13:31these are the ones that later shine out. in the
- 13:34malpractice case that we are defending. Did that
- 13:36person have three lawyers prior to you? Did they
- 13:39pay those lawyers? Did you ask for docs and or
- 13:43are you asking for docs during this intake stage
- 13:45and they're not providing you with the docs or
- 13:47the information? Do you feel like they're being
- 13:48cagey with you? Do they have realistic expectations?
- 13:51Do they expect the transaction to close for 20
- 13:53million when it can only close for 10 million?
- 13:55Do they expect to get you know, a $50 million
- 13:58recovery and litigation when the case is really
- 14:00only worth $500 ,000. And are they responsive
- 14:03to you? I will tell you, even if you do accept
- 14:06the client, but you later experienced these red
- 14:08flags, do consider whether or not you want to
- 14:11continue on with that representation. The next
- 14:13slide, please. troubles me sometimes is when
- 14:20you have a client and you can see they're gonna
- 14:23want you to take a position that you're not gonna
- 14:25be comfortable with for whatever reason. That's
- 14:30a great question. Is my audio okay at this point?
- 14:33I just wanna double check. Yes, we're all great.
- 14:41I'm hearing you now. Excellent. Okay. Howard
- 14:44asked a great question, which is, And sorry,
- 14:49it seems to be like a little bit of a glitchy
- 14:50freeze thing going on, which we talked about
- 14:52in advance, and I'm not sure what's causing that.
- 14:55But please do let me know if there's any problem
- 14:57with anyone hearing me, and we will make sure
- 15:00that we remedy that. I'm sorry, could you repeat
- 15:04the question one more time? What I was saying,
- 15:08yeah, the point I was making is just that sometimes
- 15:11I find another big red flag is when you can see
- 15:15that a client is going to want you to take a
- 15:17position on their behalf that you're really uncomfortable
- 15:19with for whatever reason. Yeah, that's a great
- 15:23one, Howard. I really appreciate you mentioning
- 15:24that. And in fact, as a lawyer, you can't take
- 15:26a position without probable cause. You can't
- 15:29take a position for the purpose of harassing
- 15:30somebody. So I think that if the client says,
- 15:34hey, this is the strategy I'm looking for from
- 15:36a lawyer, and the strategy is not something you
- 15:39think is right or ethical, or you're just not
- 15:41comfortable with, that's a great reason for declination.
- 15:43I don't think you'll ever, as a lawyer, regret
- 15:46a declination. That's my opinion. I had a partner
- 15:49who took on a life insurance claim on behalf
- 15:52of someone who was accused of killing his wife
- 15:55and his child. And that was the policy, of course,
- 15:57that was at issue in the case. Wow. Yeah, well,
- 16:03there you go. That's a very illustrative story
- 16:05and it nails down the point. So thank you for
- 16:08that. So, okay, so topic number two is diligence.
- 16:13The rules of professional conduct were revised.
- 16:16um, in 2018, November 1st, 2018, they came into
- 16:19effect. I was a legal advisor to the Rules Revision
- 16:22Commission of the State Bar. We made the proposals.
- 16:25Most were adopted by the State Bar and we implemented
- 16:27a new diligence rule, 1 .3. There was no diligence
- 16:30rule before then in the RPCs, though the standard
- 16:33has been around for a very long time. Um, so
- 16:36this is an ethical standard, not a malpractice
- 16:38standard, though it could lead to malpractice
- 16:41claims, but reasonable diligence means that you
- 16:44have to act with the commitment and dedication
- 16:46to the interests of the client, and you do not
- 16:49unduly delay the matter entrusted to you. So
- 16:53diligence is kind of a wide ranging concept that
- 16:57ties in heavily to the other ethical obligation
- 17:02of competence, but it has some nuances to it.
- 17:06And in particular here, I want to talk about
- 17:08how diligence ties into deadlines. We're a very
- 17:11deadline oriented profession. I don't know about
- 17:14you guys, but I use the word calendaring like
- 17:18five times a day minimum, probably more than
- 17:20five times a day. But if you use the word calendaring
- 17:22with a normal person in life, they don't understand
- 17:26why you keep saying the word calendaring because
- 17:28it's not a word that they utilize unless they're
- 17:30in a business with a lot of calendaring. But
- 17:32very few people calendar like we do as lawyers.
- 17:35But I will say this. I am finding that as the
- 17:38practice of law is becoming more pressure filled
- 17:41with more and more requirements, with more difficult
- 17:45clients, with more laws that come out on an annual
- 17:51basis and sometimes more frequently than that,
- 17:54lawyers are having harder and harder time meeting
- 17:57deadlines. So my, I guess, admonition to you
- 18:03here is that it's important not only to meet
- 18:07deadlines but to get ahead ahead of deadlines,
- 18:10not only from an RPC standpoint but from a malpractice
- 18:14standpoint. If you are an IP practitioner, which
- 18:16you probably aren't because you're here on the
- 18:18real estate section CLE, IP practitioners experience
- 18:23catastrophic claims. by failure to meet deadlines,
- 18:27sometimes due to lack of calendaring, but sometimes
- 18:29due to lack of paying attention to the calendar.
- 18:31For example, paying a fee associated with a trademark
- 18:35or a patent. We've seen those claims in the hundreds
- 18:38of millions of dollars, so you can see the import
- 18:40of it. But what I would say here is that lawyers
- 18:43who wait to the last minute oftentimes will miss
- 18:46the deadline, will do shoddy work. And I've seen
- 18:48this play out before the state bar and in malpractice
- 18:51cases, and it is not pretty. The practical tip
- 18:55that I give people is don't be afraid to ask
- 18:57for help if deadline management becomes difficult,
- 18:59especially if you're an associate on this call,
- 19:02one of the 54 people. or somebody who's not senior
- 19:06management, go to your senior manager and just
- 19:08say, hey, I appreciate the workload. I'm still
- 19:10learning how to manage it. And I need help with
- 19:12these deadlines. I need help managing these deadlines.
- 19:15I'm not sure I can make all of these deadlines.
- 19:17That's hard to say. It's hard to admit that.
- 19:19But if you try to do it all yourself, you're
- 19:21going to fall into traps. And I'll tell you the
- 19:23trap that people are falling into with last minute
- 19:26deadlines. Can anybody guess what it is? I don't
- 19:28think I can hear you. So maybe you can't guess.
- 19:31But AI. People are running up against deadlines
- 19:34and they're generating AI work product, submitting
- 19:37it to the court, submitting it to the client,
- 19:40submitting it to opposing counsel. And in fact,
- 19:44as we will talk about later, that comes with
- 19:46its own perils. So going to the next one, tip
- 19:48number three, fee agreements. Okay, next slide.
- 19:53Fee agreements are critical. edited and drafted
- 19:57thousands of them, not only for myself and my
- 20:00law firm, but for our clients because our clients
- 20:03have specialized practices and they need specialized
- 20:05fee agreements. So sometimes we work on. certain
- 20:08clauses. Sometimes we draft the whole thing for
- 20:10them, but your fee agreement needs to be something
- 20:13that you review on an annual basis. I would calendar
- 20:15it for an annual review. Make sure that you like
- 20:17the terms that they're working well for you.
- 20:19The first thing I would mention is that your
- 20:21fee agreement needs to be reviewed by an attorney
- 20:23before it goes out. Paralegals and legal assistants
- 20:26should not be issuing fee agreements without
- 20:28your... The audio has cut out. It's funny because
- 20:33I can see myself and... No? Now we're hearing
- 20:38you. Okay. Thank you. What I was mentioning here
- 20:43is that you as an attorney need to review the
- 20:45fee agreements and approve them before they go
- 20:47out because there's a number of provisions which
- 20:49cannot be handled by a paralegal or a legal assistant.
- 20:52For example, the scope of representation. Your
- 20:56fee agreement needs to be clear on what it is
- 20:59you are doing and what it is you are not doing.
- 21:02The fee agreements that have a scope that is
- 21:04undefined or too broad, oftentimes will lead
- 21:08to confusion and will lead to missed deadlines,
- 21:12will lead to the client believing that you are
- 21:14doing more for the client than you are actually
- 21:16doing. There's a famous published opinion out
- 21:18there about a workers' compensation attorney
- 21:21who is handling a workers' compensation case.
- 21:24And the personal injury statute of limitations
- 21:26against a third party expired during the workers'
- 21:29compensation case, and the workers' comp attorney
- 21:31was sued. And he said, no, I was just the workers'
- 21:33comp attorney. But the fee agreement didn't make
- 21:36it clear that the representation was only limited
- 21:38to that and excluded the personal injury defense.
- 21:42And in fact, what ultimately and kind of form
- 21:45and fashion the court found is that that attorney
- 21:48had the right under the rules of professional
- 21:50conduct to limit the scope of his services, and
- 21:52he could have excluded the personal injury services.
- 21:55But he didn't do that. So it was therefore at
- 21:58the minimum his ability or his obligation to
- 22:00provide a referral. to provide a referral or
- 22:03to advise on the statute. Next slide. So this
- 22:09is the rule that I mentioned a second ago about
- 22:11limiting the scope of representation through
- 22:13informed written consent, rule 1 .2. This is
- 22:16done through your engagement letter. There are
- 22:18a couple of other questions here that I wanted
- 22:21to mention that you should tackle when you're
- 22:23putting your engagement documentation together.
- 22:26Who is it you represent and who do you not represent?
- 22:29For example, let's say you represent an LLC.
- 22:31I know that's a very common thing in real estate
- 22:33practice that you would represent an LLC. Do
- 22:36you represent any of the individual members?
- 22:38Do you disclaim representation of the individual
- 22:40members? Many, many lawsuits come out of LLC
- 22:44members or come from LLC. LLC members who claim
- 22:47individual representation of themselves in addition
- 22:52to the representation of the LLC by the attorney
- 22:56and the attorney says no that's not the case
- 22:58oftentimes we go to the LLC operating agreement
- 23:01to try to clear that up but it could have been
- 23:03cleared up through the fee agreement. So I hope
- 23:07this highlights the importance of your involvement
- 23:09in the scope section of your engagement documentation.
- 23:11Next slide. And just on fee agreements as well.
- 23:18I have like a two hour presentation on fee agreements,
- 23:22but you know, other slides or other provisions
- 23:25that you'll want to take a look at as you proceed,
- 23:28just so you have them in your mind is your arbitration
- 23:31provision. If you want an arbitration provision,
- 23:33do not have a prevailing party attorney's fees
- 23:35clause. Bad, bad, bad idea. Run back to your
- 23:38desk after this presentation and delete it from
- 23:40all your fee agreements. You need to take a look
- 23:42at things like third party payor agreements.
- 23:45which also would be in your fee agreement. A
- 23:47lot of people are including conflict waivers
- 23:49which need to be customized in their fee agreements.
- 23:52Some people are doing litigation holds now in
- 23:54their fee agreements. These are all things that
- 23:56you can consider if you think that they are right
- 23:58for you, but put your time into it. So topic
- 24:01number four, a complex of interest. Excuse me,
- 24:02Heather, but one really tricky thing to keep
- 24:05in mind is a lot of times you're hired by another
- 24:08lawyer or you're representing more than one person
- 24:11and you always, if that's the case, if it's not
- 24:14a single individual, want to include who you
- 24:16can take instructions from and who you're authorized
- 24:19to act on direction from. I had to do that this
- 24:22week where I'm being retained through a lawyer.
- 24:25I've never talked to the client who's out of
- 24:26the country. His main contact is his family law
- 24:29lawyer, and I'm only handling the real estate
- 24:31aspects. And so I had to put in something specifically
- 24:35about taking instructions from that lawyer. Yeah,
- 24:38I love that, Howard. Thank you so much for that
- 24:40great tip. you know the conflict section conflict
- 24:47of interest section of your fee agreement which
- 24:49needs to be customized it can talk about um uh
- 24:53you know all those concepts if you're representing
- 24:55joint clients it can waive the conflicts between
- 24:57joint clients it can say who you're going to
- 24:59take instructions from it can say you know who
- 25:02is responsible for the payment, who gets, for
- 25:05example, a refund of any payment, which client.
- 25:08It can also do things like, you know, authorize
- 25:11certain agents to receive information, you know,
- 25:14so you're not breaching your duty of confidentiality
- 25:16by sharing information with the agents of your
- 25:19clients. So thank you for that. And that's a
- 25:22good thing to think about. Topic number four,
- 25:25conflicts of interest, basics and trends. This
- 25:27is definitely like a 10 -hour course, but conflicts
- 25:29of interest come up all the time in state bar
- 25:32proceedings and in breach of fiduciary duty lawsuits.
- 25:35I see it being weaponized, like, you know, there's
- 25:37not really like a serious conflict consideration
- 25:40that we think actually impacted anybody, but
- 25:43because it's Conflict waivers need to be so specific.
- 25:48Attorneys trip up on the requirements of conflict
- 25:51waivers all the time, putting them in peril later
- 25:54on of a breach of fiduciary duty claims. Next
- 25:57slide. Here, I just wanted to give you a sense
- 26:03of the top conflict of interest rules. We're
- 26:07not going to be able to go through all of these.
- 26:09I've picked three of them to talk about. There
- 26:12are quite a few of them. So you can take a look
- 26:14at this list over a glass of wine tonight. So
- 26:16we'll go to the first example, the next slide.
- 26:21Current clients. So these are the 1 .7 A and
- 26:27B are, I think, the two most common conflict
- 26:33scenarios that arise. I mean, I must cite 1 .7
- 26:36A and B also. five times a day right after I
- 26:40use the word calendaring. So this is really important
- 26:43for everybody to focus on. 1 .7a is just a very
- 26:48basic premise, which is you can never be adverse
- 26:50to a current client, even in an unrelated matter,
- 26:54period, because you have a duty of loyalty to
- 26:58them. Duty of loyalty is one of your two fiduciary
- 27:00duties, the other being the duty of confidentiality.
- 27:03You can't be adverse to a current client even
- 27:05on an unrelated matter. Ethical walls don't work.
- 27:08Subsection B deals with other, well, you can
- 27:11if they give you informed written consent, but
- 27:14nobody gives informed written consent candidly
- 27:16in these situations. Informed written consent,
- 27:18by the way, is a conflict waiver that they mean
- 27:20the same thing. And in a couple of minutes, I'll
- 27:23tell you what would need to be in your informed
- 27:25written consent in the event that you get a conflict
- 27:27waiver in any of the conflict scenarios that
- 27:30we're presenting today. But subsection B also
- 27:32comes up all the time, and subsection B deals
- 27:36with different conflict scenarios, and I'll tell
- 27:38you what those are in a second. Those also can
- 27:41be waived with informed written consent. But
- 27:44subsection B deals with certain conflict scenarios
- 27:47that present a significant risk of material limitation
- 27:51in your services. And what are those scenarios?
- 27:55It's significant risk of a material limitation
- 27:57based on your responsibilities or relationships
- 28:00with another client. The classic situation would
- 28:03be joint client scenarios. Can you represent
- 28:05both clients at once? If representing them both
- 28:08at once presents a significant risk of a material
- 28:10limitation, then you can't do it without a conflict
- 28:13waiver. The next one is a significant risk of
- 28:18a material limitation posed by a former client
- 28:20or a third person. Maybe you have a relationship
- 28:23with a witness or the former client is involved
- 28:25in the case somehow and that handcuffs you. You
- 28:29shouldn't be disadvantaging the current client
- 28:32in that scenario without getting a conflict waiver
- 28:36from them and formed written consent to proceed.
- 28:39And finally, if there is a significant risk of
- 28:41a material limitation by your own interests,
- 28:43A classic scenario there is if you make an error,
- 28:46let's say you miss a statute of limitations and
- 28:48you're trying to fix it, so now your own interests
- 28:50are implicated. Should you be representing that
- 28:52client without a conflict waiver in place? Rule
- 28:541 .7b says no. So I wish I had more time to go
- 28:57over these because they're so, so, so important,
- 28:59but these are the top conflict rules that you
- 29:01will likely encounter in your practice. Next
- 29:03one. Because you are real estate lawyers, I figure
- 29:10there must be situations from time to time in
- 29:12which you yourself enter into business transactions
- 29:15with clients. Maybe you're involved in the deal.
- 29:18That's permissible. 1 .8 .1 details the type
- 29:23of conflict waiver you need in these scenarios.
- 29:27This comes up more often than you would think.
- 29:28A lot of lawyers miss it because they do things
- 29:30that they don't realize are a business transaction
- 29:32with a client. I had years ago these clients
- 29:35who were T &E lawyers and they went to the restaurant
- 29:37business with their client and they didn't get
- 29:40a conflict waiver and they're like, we needed
- 29:41a conflict waiver for that. It had nothing to
- 29:44do with our representation, but it doesn't matter
- 29:46if it has anything to do with the representation.
- 29:49It's still a conflict if you have a current client
- 29:51relationship. But essentially you can do it assuming
- 29:54that you have this conflict waiver informed written
- 29:56consent and you advise the client to seek independent
- 29:59counsel and the terms are fair and reasonable
- 30:01to the client. I would say that the prudent lawyer
- 30:04who is actually taking a cut of the deal, maybe
- 30:07as payment, will require that their client have
- 30:10this conflict waiver reviewed by separate and
- 30:13independent counsel before the client signs.
- 30:16That's a hot tip from me, which will be highly
- 30:18protective in the event that this is later called
- 30:21into question. Next slide. I did want to mention
- 30:26third party peers because lawyers miss this conflict
- 30:31point all the time. 1 .8 .6 is a conflict rule
- 30:36and it requires the written consent of the client
- 30:38in the event that you are accepting fees from
- 30:41a third party. So let's say, for example, you're
- 30:44representing a company and the company is defending
- 30:46an individual, you should be getting that individual's
- 30:49consent to take money from the company for the
- 30:51representation. That's because, you know, theoretically,
- 30:55the person who's paying could have some type
- 30:57of influence over you. So the client is entitled
- 30:59to know and consent to a third party paying the
- 31:02fee. As I very obliquely and quickly referenced
- 31:06earlier, current retainer documentation also
- 31:09indicates who will receive any refunds of an
- 31:11advanced fee at the end of the case. I get this
- 31:13call once every two months. Who do I give the
- 31:15money back to? The client or the third party
- 31:17payor? And I always say it would have been great
- 31:20to have set that forth in the initial engagement
- 31:23documentation so there's no confusion at the
- 31:25end. Next slide. And Howard, please keep jumping
- 31:29in with your great tips. So I did want to briefly
- 31:33mention, as I referenced before, disqualification
- 31:37trends. I keep mentioning things that are happening
- 31:44with frequency in our practice. But one of the
- 31:47things that's definitely happening with more
- 31:49and more frequency is threats of disqualification.
- 31:51We're involved at any point in time, probably
- 31:53in six or seven disqualification scenarios with
- 31:56clients. Sometimes we're counsel for them. Sometimes
- 31:58we're behind the scenes. But these are three
- 32:01things that I'm finding are giving rise to many
- 32:04disqualification allegations and motions. Number
- 32:06one is lateral hiring. If you do not have a refined
- 32:10lateral hiring conflict check procedure and protocols,
- 32:14you need to put one in place. More and more law
- 32:17firms are hiring laterals, not doing adequate
- 32:19conflict checks, and six months later, they're
- 32:22getting letters. The law firms are getting letters
- 32:24saying, hey, this lateral you hired is conflicted
- 32:27and now your law firm needs to get off the case.
- 32:30Keep in mind that in lateral hiring scenarios,
- 32:32ethical walls are usually not curative. People
- 32:35think they are, but they're not. These are 1
- 32:37.9 and 1 .10 scenarios. Those are the rules of
- 32:40professional conduct. I don't have time to give
- 32:43the lateral hiring rundown right here and now,
- 32:47but hopefully this puts it on your radar screen
- 32:49that lateral hiring scenarios need to be dealt
- 32:51with at the outset. through a full conflict check
- 32:54before the lateral hire joins your office. Potential
- 32:57client consultations, I mentioned that before.
- 33:00If you accept too much confidential information,
- 33:03you could be disqualified from being adverse
- 33:05to that potential client who never hired you
- 33:08later on, even years later. Next is inadvertent
- 33:12disclosure. This is a big one where lawyers will
- 33:15get inadvertently produced information and they
- 33:19don't go through the protocols of 4 .4, which
- 33:22is based on the Supreme Court of Rico v Mitsubishi,
- 33:26which requires prompt notifications, segregating
- 33:28the inadvertent disclosure or inadvertent production.
- 33:32And as a result, they are subject to disqualification.
- 33:35So keep your eye out for these three things because
- 33:37motions to disqualify are not pleasant. Next
- 33:40slide. I mentioned that I would tell you what
- 33:45informed written consent is. Again, this is just
- 33:47another name for a conflict waiver. It is the
- 33:49verbiage used in the rules of professional conduct.
- 33:53Because I'm running a little bit behind, I'm
- 33:55just going to mention the second one to you.
- 33:59A conflict waiver, i .e. informed written consent,
- 34:03cannot be a stock form. The reason it can't be
- 34:06is, number one, a conflict waiver could deal
- 34:08with a dozen different conflict scenarios. It
- 34:12also isn't effective under the rules of professional
- 34:15conduct unless it essentially discloses the cons
- 34:20or the downsides of waiving that conflict. So
- 34:26the client needs to be completely informed as
- 34:29to the potential conflict or the circumstances
- 34:31that give rise to the need for informed written
- 34:34consent. What does it mean for the client to
- 34:38waive it? I'll just give you a quick example.
- 34:39Let's say it's a joint representation conflict
- 34:42waiver. It would say, we represent both of you
- 34:44in the case, and here's what the case is about.
- 34:47Your position seems aligned at this time, but
- 34:49that could change. You could take differing positions
- 34:52on settlement, or you could have different recollections
- 34:55of the key transaction, or you may want to try
- 34:58to give us differing instructions, or maybe one
- 35:01of you tries to make an indemnity claim against
- 35:03the other. So these things could come up and
- 35:06you know they could come up but nevertheless
- 35:07at this time you wave the conflict and you agree
- 35:10to our joint representation of both of you and
- 35:13you have had the opportunity to consult with
- 35:16independent counsel. The conflict waiver with
- 35:19that detail is going to be enforceable and found
- 35:24to be adequate under the rules of professional
- 35:26conduct. A stock form that does not have the
- 35:29details specific to that situation is not. Going
- 35:33to the next slide. Oh, and by the way, my least
- 35:37favorite thing is when we handle breach fiduciary
- 35:39duty cases and we get the conflict waiver, it's
- 35:41in the file and nobody signed it. Like the lawyer
- 35:43took the time to draft it, but nobody followed
- 35:45up to get the signatures. So that's very painful,
- 35:48very painful. Okay. Client satisfaction, proactive
- 35:51management. And we are finding that more and
- 35:53more state bar complaints in particular. State
- 35:56bar gets, I think, around 18 to 20 ,000 complaints
- 35:59a year. That's a lot. But more and more of them
- 36:02are just based on clients not being satisfied,
- 36:09sometimes just vaguely not satisfied with the
- 36:12service that they received. Sometimes they think
- 36:14the fees are too high. Sometimes they have a
- 36:16specific result that they're complaining about.
- 36:18But a lot of times it's just about communication.
- 36:21Going to the next slide. So I wanted to mention
- 36:28here just some practical guidance tips in terms
- 36:32of client satisfaction, including this communication
- 36:34point. I did want to say take a look at rule
- 36:371 .4, which has a a correlated statutory provision
- 36:44in the Business and Professions Code. The rules
- 36:46of professional conduct need to be read hand
- 36:48in hand with the State Bar Act, which is found
- 36:50in the Business and Professions Code. Those are
- 36:52the legislatively enacted provisions that govern
- 36:55the practice of law. But what these rules collectively
- 36:59indicate is that you are supposed to reasonably
- 37:02consult with the client about the means by which
- 37:04to accomplish the objectives of representation.
- 37:06Make sure you do that. then you're going to be
- 37:09proactive in managing that relationship from
- 37:11the bat. Figure out what the client wants, you
- 37:13know, and then tell the client how you intend
- 37:16to achieve it. As Howard said, if they want something
- 37:18you can't achieve, then turn them down. Keep
- 37:21the client informed of significant developments
- 37:23and comply with their requests for information
- 37:25if it's reasonable. That is a term of art in
- 37:28the ethics rules, significant developments. You're
- 37:31required to tell clients about significant developments.
- 37:33And this includes, of course, as all of you know,
- 37:35a written settlement offers, but frankly, any
- 37:38settlement offer. Oftentimes, malpractice cases
- 37:41come out of a purported failure of the lawyer
- 37:43to disclose settlement discussions, even if it
- 37:46wasn't an offer. The lack of communication can
- 37:50breed client discontent. I've seen so many great
- 37:54lawyers that are like doing their thing and they're
- 37:56doing a great job, but they are not communicative
- 37:57with the client and the whole relationship blows
- 38:00up and you kind of wonder how did it happen?
- 38:02The lawyer was doing a good job, but the communication
- 38:04wasn't there. Final point is we do recommend
- 38:07emails. People say, Heather, this isn't the CYA,
- 38:11I don't have time for CYA, but it's really not
- 38:13CYA. If you're talking to a client about complex
- 38:17legal matters and complex decision -making points,
- 38:20keep in mind that they may not track you entirely
- 38:22over the phone. They may not track you in the
- 38:25in -person meeting, maybe a little bit, but maybe
- 38:27not 100 % because they're not lawyers. Put it
- 38:30in writing, lay out the decision -making points,
- 38:32lay out the risks. lay out the pros, lay out
- 38:35the cons, so that they can go back, take a look,
- 38:37and make an informed decision. Particularly information
- 38:41regarding risks, put it in writing. A common
- 38:45one is going to trial. A lot of people will lose
- 38:48their trials and sometimes they'll be hit with
- 38:50a prevailing party attorney's fees motion. It's
- 38:52very common for them to claim, I didn't know
- 38:54that I could lose this trial. I did not know
- 38:56that I could get hit with prevailing party attorney's
- 38:59fees. It's obvious to us and our client that
- 39:01was discussed throughout the representation,
- 39:03but we don't have a clear warning. email on that
- 39:05particular topic. The same would hold true with
- 39:08regard to a real estate transaction. I understand
- 39:10that many of your clients are probably pretty
- 39:12sophisticated. And it is true. If the client
- 39:15is sophisticated, this becomes less important
- 39:18to put the risks in writing. But nevertheless,
- 39:21even the most sophisticated of clients will,
- 39:24at the minimum, appreciate your efforts to update
- 39:27them in writing and remind them of the things
- 39:29that they need to take into consideration in
- 39:31their decision making calculus. Next slide. Heather,
- 39:35I don't know if you think this one is useful,
- 39:37but I have put for a long time in my fee agreements
- 39:40to the client that the billing statements are
- 39:42communications to them about activity or lack
- 39:45of activity in their cases and that they need
- 39:47to read those because they are communications
- 39:51about what's happening in their case. I love
- 39:54that. I think that's great. It makes them look
- 39:57at what you're doing, right? It also makes them
- 40:00examine the bill because then if the bill is
- 40:02too high and they don't say anything, then presumably
- 40:07they're okay with the bill. Or if they think
- 40:08the bill is problematic, they have the chance
- 40:10to say something. It's a great idea, Howard.
- 40:12And the bills say that they have X number of
- 40:15days to challenge the bill. Um as well. So yeah,
- 40:18it's it's if you aren't sending status reports.
- 40:21It is maybe in some ways to help make up for
- 40:23that Yeah, I love it. It's it's a it's a really
- 40:26good I see a lot of people do that with uh, you
- 40:29know tell us in 30 days if you don't like a billing
- 40:31entry, but Telling them to review it to make
- 40:35sure they know what activity is taking place
- 40:36I don't see that as often in engagement documentation
- 40:39and I like it So this is a practical guidance
- 40:43in terms of this proactive communication and
- 40:46proactive management of the client relationship.
- 40:48We covered a lot of this, but I would just hit
- 40:51on two final things. Periodic checking calls
- 40:54or meetings, even if you don't have a burning
- 40:56urgent decision -making point, every two months,
- 40:59you know, just offer a call to talk to the client
- 41:01about what's going on. And the other thing I
- 41:04would indicate, to you that's quite important
- 41:07is clear written communication regarding the
- 41:09end of representation. This sounds a little self
- 41:12-interested for our profession. I get it. But
- 41:14the statute of limitations usually does run on
- 41:17malpractice claims one year after the end of
- 41:19representation. And so it's a good idea to end
- 41:22your representation if it's over in writing.
- 41:24Dear Bob, thank you so much for the opportunity
- 41:26to help you with this transaction. The transaction
- 41:28is complete. Our representation is concluded.
- 41:30If we can help you in the future, please call
- 41:32any time. And again, that is not just for the
- 41:35lawyer and to get the statute running. It's really
- 41:38a courtesy to the client. The client now knows
- 41:42that the client doesn't have a lawyer because
- 41:44the legal matter for which the lawyer was retained
- 41:47is included. That's a fair thing for a lawyer
- 41:50to tell a client. If the client disagrees and
- 41:53thinks that there are still outstanding items,
- 41:55the client can then go ahead and bring those
- 41:58up with the lawyer. Next slide. Okay, this is
- 42:07the big one, CTA and CTAP standards. CTAP, in
- 42:11case you don't know, it's the Client Trust Accounting
- 42:13Protection Program. It went into effect essentially
- 42:16in 2003 after the Girardi scandals. It's a whole
- 42:20program with many, many facets. As you will see
- 42:24in another slide, I refer you to the State Bar
- 42:26website. They have a whole CTAP webpage. It has
- 42:30videos, it has hypotheticals, it has FAQs, it
- 42:33has the rules. It's pretty good. It's very good,
- 42:35actually. It also has the new auditing standards
- 42:39and programs. So that's one I'm sure you're going
- 42:42to want to rush and read this evening or tomorrow
- 42:44night, again, over happy hour. So let's go to
- 42:47the next one, and I'll give you a couple more
- 42:49specifics on this exciting topic. OK. So after
- 42:53the Girardi scandal, CTAP went into place. And
- 42:56as part of that, rule of professional conduct
- 42:571 .15 was modified. If you don't know this, you
- 43:01need to know this. This is client trust accounting.
- 43:04If you have a client trust account and you hold
- 43:06money in your client trust account and you receive
- 43:09funds, you need to notify the people who have
- 43:11an interest in those funds within 14 days and
- 43:14disperse all the funds within 45 days. That's
- 43:16because Mr. Girardi held funds for a very long
- 43:19period of time and there didn't used to be a
- 43:22date by which funds needed to be distributed.
- 43:24distributed set forth in 1 .15. It said something
- 43:27like promptly, but now it's 45 days. However,
- 43:31you cannot distribute funds if there's a dispute.
- 43:33For example, let's say there's a lien on the
- 43:35funds. You can't just, you know, at 45 days just
- 43:39unilaterally decide, you know, the lien dispute
- 43:41yourself and ship off the funds. But you are
- 43:45required at that point in time while you are
- 43:46holding the funds in trust to seek prompt resolution
- 43:49of the dispute. I will tell you, because this
- 43:52is a daily practice area for us, there are not
- 43:56great mechanisms for resolving disputes over
- 44:00funds that are held in trust. But a couple of
- 44:03them are here. Fee arbitration, private arbitration,
- 44:06mediation, declaratory relief actions, and interplator.
- 44:09We utilize all these tools. None of them are
- 44:11quick. None of them are great. CTAP. Okay, so
- 44:14CTAP is a program. It has an annual requirement
- 44:17as we discussed as you saw on your compliance
- 44:19checker where you need to enter your client trust
- 44:23account and then you need to confirm for the
- 44:26past calendar year that it was in compliance
- 44:29essentially with 1 .15 as well as the standards
- 44:31set forth in the Client Trust Accounting Handbook
- 44:35published by the State Bar of California. It's
- 44:39like a 40 page handbook with all sorts of very
- 44:41helpful exhibits. and addendums. You need to
- 44:45make sure your journal, your ledger, and your
- 44:47bank reconciliations are perfect and whipped
- 44:49into shape and that it balances. If you can't
- 44:52do this yourself, hire a professional to do it.
- 44:54State Bar ain't messing around. Now just in August,
- 44:59I believe. Heather, when you say hire a professional,
- 45:03can that be your bookkeeper or do you really
- 45:06need to have a CPA looking at these things? That's
- 45:09a good question. You know, a lot of people do
- 45:14have bookkeepers who do it, but you have to,
- 45:17with your bookkeeper, make sure your bookkeeper
- 45:19is licensed and bonded. I'm sure this is rare,
- 45:23but bookkeepers do embezzle, so make sure your
- 45:25bookkeeper is trusted and bonded. Or if they're
- 45:27your employee, make sure that they're vetted.
- 45:30Number two, make sure that they're trained. A
- 45:32lot of bookkeepers, like we have lawyers that
- 45:34come to us, they're like, my bookkeeper does
- 45:36the books. And the bookkeeper has no idea how
- 45:38to do client trust accounting. There's no bank
- 45:40recs, ledger, or journal. It's just like some
- 45:42random bank records. So yes, you can have the
- 45:46bookkeeper do it if the bookkeeper is properly
- 45:48trained. However, it's a non -delegable duty,
- 45:52so you need to be overlooking. and overseeing
- 45:55the bookkeeper. If you are a larger operation,
- 45:59let's say you're a law firm of 50 attorneys,
- 46:02the bookkeeper or even the internal CFL may be
- 46:05inadequate and you may need an outside accounting
- 46:08firm to assist with the function. There are outside
- 46:11accounting firms that are now holding themselves
- 46:13out as specialist in client trust accounting
- 46:16practice in California. So, you know, really
- 46:20Howard, it depends on the individual needs of
- 46:24your organization, but most dangerous thing is
- 46:27the lawyer, usually small firm solo practitioners
- 46:30who just do it totally themselves, right? And
- 46:33that can be a disaster. We've had a number of
- 46:35clients who've been brought up before the state
- 46:36bar and they, you know, they're good people.
- 46:40They certainly didn't embezzle any money, but
- 46:41the books weren't in good shape and they had
- 46:43to hire essentially forensic people to come in.
- 46:46and go back and recreate their books for years
- 46:49just to make sure that it was all balanced out.
- 46:51So don't put yourself in that position. It requires
- 46:54weekly maintenance to do a trust account right.
- 46:58The really good law firms are doing daily reconciliations,
- 47:03not formal reconciliations, but daily examinations
- 47:06of their client trust accounts, what's coming
- 47:09in, what's going out, and updating those ledgers
- 47:11and journals on a daily basis. you can see how
- 47:16that can get onerous. I did mention that you
- 47:18want to check out the Client Trust Accounting
- 47:20Protection Program page, and then the auditing
- 47:23was the final thing I wanted to mention. They
- 47:24are doing audits now. Back when I was on the
- 47:28State Bar Board of Trustee, I think there were
- 47:29nine states that did CTA audits, and I was involved
- 47:33in exploring those. I spoke to the people in
- 47:35New Jersey, and they have been doing it for a
- 47:36number of years. This is what the State Bar of
- 47:40California is doing now. sign up a bunch of accounting
- 47:43firms, you get randomly selected for the audit.
- 47:47I think they're letting you pick which accounting
- 47:49firm you want at this point. You pay for it.
- 47:52And the accounting firm does an audit. Now, they're
- 47:54not looking to punish you or they're not out
- 47:56to get you. This is mainly an educational process
- 47:58because probably what they're going to find is
- 48:00that your record keeping isn't perfect. And then
- 48:04they're going to try to help you understand how
- 48:07you can comply going forward. Occasionally, they'll
- 48:10find embezzlement. Occasionally they will find
- 48:12misappropriation, but hopefully that's not going
- 48:15to occur to too many of our practitioners. I
- 48:17think most lawyers are really good people. I
- 48:19think very few people are misappropriating client
- 48:21funds, but it's a nerve racking moment when you
- 48:24get that CTA audit. And I've gotten probably
- 48:2710 calls from clients who have gotten these audit
- 48:29notices. It's brand new. It's just happening
- 48:31for the first time. So we don't have statistics
- 48:33or anything like that yet, but this is a client
- 48:36protection measure of the State Bar of California.
- 48:38Next one. And I have a one question Heather I
- 48:44see here Yeah, if a client instructs you to hold
- 48:46funds and trust pending future work Is it still
- 48:48okay to do so and should a prevailing party attorney
- 48:51fee clause and include only an arbitration provision?
- 48:55including only in an arbitration provision be
- 48:57removed to So two questions, what's the second
- 49:02one we don't want the propelling party watch
- 49:03it Let's do the first one if a client instructs
- 49:06you to hold funds Yeah, well, I mean if if if
- 49:10it's an advanced fee and the client is instructing
- 49:13you to hold it because additional work may take
- 49:16place in the future, that's generally fine. If
- 49:19the client has a settlement that comes in and
- 49:23the client's like just hold my settlement for
- 49:25six months, I think you need to be careful because
- 49:28there's a bunch of considerations at that point.
- 49:30Number one, you may be required to open up a
- 49:33non -IOTA account which accrues interest for
- 49:36the benefit of the owner of that of those funds
- 49:39as opposed to the state bar because your regular
- 49:42trust account interest goes to the state bar
- 49:44to support the iota program um secondly it could
- 49:48be considered co co -mingling um at some point
- 49:51um i i mean well that's more if you leave your
- 49:54own um entitlement in the client trust account
- 49:58for example if a settlement comes in you don't
- 50:00take your own fee out that's considered co -mingling
- 50:03So I'd be very reluctant to do that unless it's
- 50:06an advanced fee. I guess it would depend on the
- 50:09circumstances. You had advised to take out your
- 50:11prevailing party attorney fee clause. Yeah. The
- 50:14second question here, do you say you should do
- 50:16that if it's only in an arbitration provision
- 50:18too? Yeah. Take it out immediately. Take it out
- 50:22immediately. It's bad. It's even worse than an
- 50:24arbitration provision in some circumstances.
- 50:27I mean, I could tell you with great certainty
- 50:30having handled many, many cases, that I've seen
- 50:33it work to the advantage of a lawyer in my whole
- 50:36career twice. I've seen it work against the lawyer
- 50:39hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of times.
- 50:42It encourages malpractice suits, and it's just
- 50:45not going to help you take it out immediately.
- 50:48All clauses. My advice, and I think it's good
- 50:51advice. Topic seven, cybersecurity and wire fraud.
- 50:55Okay, we're going to go over this very quickly.
- 50:56We only have eight minutes left, but I think
- 50:58we can do it. This is A friend of mine who works
- 51:05at Hinshaw and Culbertson gave this picture to
- 51:07me and he said I could use it. This is also his
- 51:10pro tip, which he said I could use. More data
- 51:12breaches are the result of human error than hacking.
- 51:15And what people tend to do is they tend to stick
- 51:18their heads in the sand and ignore the possibility
- 51:22of this happening until it's too late. But in
- 51:25fact, data and cybersecurity is everybody's business.
- 51:29We'll go to the next slide. So what I wanted
- 51:36to mention here is that we are seeing lawyers
- 51:41hacked on a regular basis, but we are also, the
- 51:48hacking is not, and I'm no hacking expert, but
- 51:52the hacking is not usually happening through
- 51:55some type of mechanism that doesn't involve an
- 52:01element of social engineering. And I've learned
- 52:04a lot about social engineering, and I've tried
- 52:05some cases involving social engineering now.
- 52:08So I've learned a bit about it. And this is essentially
- 52:11the best example in the law practice is the hacker
- 52:15is sending something to you or to your legal
- 52:18assistant or somebody on your staff that has
- 52:21a link that's going to open up a malicious file,
- 52:23which is going to allow somebody to hack your
- 52:25email. And the email that involves that malicious
- 52:28link is socially engineered in such a way that
- 52:34it is designed to make the recipient open it.
- 52:38Sometimes it looks like it's an email from opposing
- 52:40counsel with the document production. Sometimes
- 52:42it looks like some type of urgent personal message.
- 52:46Sometimes it looks like a discovery responses
- 52:51from somebody else in the case with the link.
- 52:53I mean, it can look like a million different
- 52:55things and oftentimes it's hard to know. where
- 52:57that malicious link came from in the first place
- 53:00because the actual hack isn't revealed until
- 53:03six months later. So we'll go to the next slide.
- 53:07But our general advisement here is in order to
- 53:14prevent the hack into your own computer system
- 53:17and to avoid these social engineering scams and
- 53:19your employees falling prey to them, is to engage
- 53:24in proactive training within your law office
- 53:26on what social engineering is, what hacking is,
- 53:30what phishing is, what to open, what not to open.
- 53:33And in fact, there's a bunch of great companies
- 53:35out there that will do tests. They will send
- 53:38emails that have, you know, they're not really
- 53:41malicious links, of course, but they're things
- 53:43that should be spotted as a malicious links to
- 53:45your employees and they see if your employees
- 53:47open them up. So consider that type of thing
- 53:49for your organization. If you're hacked, it's
- 53:52going to be bad, and you're going to wish that
- 53:54you had done this. Next, I wanted to mention
- 53:56as part of this whole cybersecurity and data
- 53:59breach is the CTA scam. This is where lawyers
- 54:04are having anywhere from $200 ,000 to $18 million.
- 54:08That's the highest one I've seen stolen from
- 54:10their client trust account. Sometimes it's stolen
- 54:13from somebody else's client trust account and
- 54:15you're blamed for it. So that's another derivation
- 54:18of it. But I'm just going to give you this back
- 54:20scenario really quickly because I've handled
- 54:2230 of these cases, 40 of these cases. I've tried
- 54:25one of these cases, actually arbitrated one of
- 54:27these cases. So I know the scam very well. So
- 54:30let's say Angie is supposed to pay Bob. He's
- 54:33sharing a great arrangement. Bob falls victim
- 54:35to this phishing scam that I just described.
- 54:38Packer has full access to Bob's email. The hacker
- 54:41is quietly monitoring Bob's email. Bob has no
- 54:43idea. And he sees that Angie is going to pay
- 54:46Bob. Now the hacker, because he has control of
- 54:49the email, he can send emails from Bob's account.
- 54:52Bob has no idea. Next slide. And the hacker,
- 54:58pretending to be Bob, emails Angie and says,
- 55:00hey, Angie, wire the money to my bank account.
- 55:03Here's my information, Angie. Angie doesn't call
- 55:07Bob to confirm. She just wires the money. So
- 55:10she wires the money to the fraudster. The fraudster
- 55:12now has the money in his account in Singapore.
- 55:15I just made up Singapore. I'm not sure if that's
- 55:17where the account would really be if you were
- 55:19a top -notch hacker, but it's usually someplace
- 55:22foreign. Bob doesn't even know that this happened.
- 55:26He never even saw the email that the hacker sent
- 55:28to Angie because the hacker deleted it after
- 55:30the hacker sent it. The money is unrecoverable,
- 55:33$200 ,000. This is not covered. by any type of
- 55:38insurance. Even when these transfers involve
- 55:41clients, oftentimes it's excluded through your
- 55:44E &O errors and emissions policy. The tip I have
- 55:47for you here is if you are engaging in any type
- 55:50of wire transfers, if you're involved in a wire
- 55:53transfer, if you're settling a case or doing
- 55:55a transaction involving a wire transfer, you
- 55:57need to employ triple, double, quadruple security
- 56:01protocols to confirm those wire instructions
- 56:03and confirm that the the person who sent the
- 56:06wire instructions is indeed supposed to be the
- 56:09recipient of the funds. We advise Zoom calls
- 56:12where you look the person in the eye, you recognize
- 56:15their face, you know who they are, and you repeat
- 56:17the instructions back and forth to each other
- 56:19verbally. These are really bad scams. The $18
- 56:22million one, we got the money back, but another
- 56:25one, $3 million, no money was recovered. So many,
- 56:28many tragedies. Next slide. A final topic in
- 56:34our last three minutes, AI and the law. I mentioned
- 56:36this at the beginning. It's a super hot topic.
- 56:39You may be a little tired of hearing about it.
- 56:44The topic is progressing so rapidly that I don't
- 56:48have final answers for you, but a couple of hot
- 56:50tips for you. Next slide. I think you know what
- 56:56generative AI is, but I gave you this definition
- 56:59here. Next slide. I did want to mention that
- 57:05one place that you can go for tips and tricks
- 57:08and rules on the use of technology within your
- 57:12ethical obligations is the State Bar website.
- 57:15I think it's very good on this. You can see here
- 57:18that, and you'll see it on the next slide, the
- 57:20State Bar approved white paper called Practical
- 57:23Guidance for the Use of Generative AI in the
- 57:25Practice of Law. There's a link right there.
- 57:27If we go to the next slide. Oh, I'm sorry, the
- 57:30link is at the top. Anyway, take a look at that
- 57:33white paper, take a look at the state bar resources.
- 57:36Now we can go to the next slide. I would say
- 57:40the key, there's a bazillion rules mentioned
- 57:42in this white paper, but I would say the key
- 57:44one for you to keep in mind is competence. Our
- 57:49law firm has very quickly developed expertise
- 57:52in dealing with the fallout of the improper utilization
- 57:57of AI in the practice of law. And it's usually
- 58:01because of competence issues, not always, but
- 58:03usually where the lawyer who's using the AI just
- 58:08doesn't know how to use it correctly because
- 58:09they're unaware of the risks, they don't understand
- 58:11the tools, and then they fall into this trap,
- 58:17which we'll discuss in the next slide, and ultimately
- 58:20many of them suffer some pretty harsh consequences.
- 58:23Competence is you can't grossly negligently or,
- 58:28can we go back one second? That's actually going
- 58:44to be an ethical violation. And you can see the
- 58:46comment says this applies to the use of technology.
- 58:49Next slide. Okay. Yep, there's another, oh, that's
- 58:56the white paper. I gave you the link twice. It's
- 58:57so important. Next slide. I have a great slide
- 58:59that summarizes everything. I think it's the
- 59:01next one. Aha, yes, here it is. So here are the
- 59:03emerging issues. This is my final substance.
- 59:07The emerging issues in the realm of AI are as
- 59:13follows. I'm just gonna blow through these in
- 59:15my one minute left. One of the hot emerging issues
- 59:19is fee arrangements and the reasonableness of
- 59:21fees and the adjustments that you may have to
- 59:23make based on your utilization of AI. For example,
- 59:27let's say you used to review documents. for 10
- 59:30hours, but now AI does it for you in a half hour.
- 59:33You can't build 10 hours any longer. You can
- 59:35only build a half hour unless you have a flat
- 59:37fee arrangement with the client. Or let's say
- 59:40you do build the 10 hours, right? And the client
- 59:42says, aha, how come you didn't use AI to achieve
- 59:44efficiencies for me? This could have been done
- 59:46in one hour. Where does that leave you? What
- 59:49efficiencies are you required to achieve through
- 59:52the utilization of AI? It's a big issue. Another
- 59:54issue is client consent and the utilization of
- 59:57engagement letters to get that consent to use
- 59:59AI. Many people are incorporating that into their
- 1:00:02engagement documentation. Another issue is AI
- 1:00:05-generated advertisements and chat bot utilization.
- 1:00:07This is hot. If you utilize AI for your advertising
- 1:00:12or your intake or you have a chat bot, there
- 1:00:15are a whole lot of disclaimers and precautions
- 1:00:16that you will need to take. Here's the biggest
- 1:00:18one, hallucinated citations. You've read all
- 1:00:21the cases, you've seen the news articles, but
- 1:00:23Lawyers are essentially, like I said, oftentimes
- 1:00:26because they're doing it at the last minute,
- 1:00:28generating briefs with hallucinated citations.
- 1:00:31Courts are finding out opposing counsel is finding
- 1:00:33out these are going to the state bar. They are
- 1:00:35going to special masters. They are going to judges
- 1:00:37for sanctions. There are candor to the tribunal
- 1:00:40considerations. There are client transparency
- 1:00:42considerations. I've seen the sanctions get up
- 1:00:44into the seven figures already for the consequences
- 1:00:48plus sanctions. Monetary consequences plus sanctions
- 1:00:50get up into the seven figures. A couple of other
- 1:00:54things here that I wanted to mention. There's
- 1:00:57a whole new discussion about AI forged evidence
- 1:00:59in the courtroom and how to detect that. There's
- 1:01:02the question of how you as a supervisor, maybe
- 1:01:05somebody like me who's been around for a while,
- 1:01:08how do we supervise the young people who are
- 1:01:11utilizing the AI when they know it perhaps even
- 1:01:13better than we do? And what internal protocols
- 1:01:16and AI training do you have in your firm? Do
- 1:01:19your protocols say that they can only use approved
- 1:01:21firm tools? Are your protocols practical? So
- 1:01:25that's a really high -level overview. We're out
- 1:01:27of time. Howard, that was my last slide. I want
- 1:01:30to thank you so much for having me today. Thank
- 1:01:32you. One comment on that. I think people should
- 1:01:36treat AI like any first -year associate whose
- 1:01:39work you would always be reviewing. A lot of
- 1:01:42lawyers I know, my attitude is I get citations
- 1:01:44from people working with me. If they're key citations,
- 1:01:47I always check them myself, especially if you're
- 1:01:49going to be the one standing in front of that
- 1:01:51judge. Just treat AI as if it's a first -year
- 1:01:54associate and you're going to review their work.
- 1:01:56And that's really the way to look at it because
- 1:01:58these days, who knows what AI is turning out
- 1:02:00anyway. But Heather, that was fantastic. There's
- 1:02:05a lot of information in a short period of time
- 1:02:07and always wonderful to get a chance to see you
- 1:02:10and especially partake in everything that you're
- 1:02:14doing in your career. Thank you. Thank you for
- 1:02:17having me, Howard. Thank you, everybody. Have
- 1:02:19a great rest of your week.