Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Career Mentor Outside Your Company
Transcript
- Lucas: You know the advice everyone gives about finding a mentor: look around your company, find someone you respect, and ask them for coffee. That works fine if you work at a big organization with a formal mentorship culture. Luna: Right. But what if you're at a small startup where the CEO is also the head of sales and the only senior person? Or what if the people above you are just not people you want to emulate? Lucas: Exactly. That's the situation a listener named Priya wrote in about. She's a junior product manager at a 30-person fintech company. Her direct manager is great, but there's no one in the org who's done the kind of product leadership she aspires to. So she's asking: how do I find a mentor outside my company? Luna: That is a fantastic question. And honestly, it's harder to do, but it can be more valuable because you get an unbiased perspective. No office politics. Lucas: Right. So let's break down how to do this. The first step is figuring out who you want to learn from. Not just 'a senior product leader' — you want someone whose career path has elements you want to replicate. Maybe they transitioned from engineering to product, or they led a product through an IPO. Be specific. Luna: So Priya should create a list of maybe five to ten people. She can find them on LinkedIn, read their articles, see who they follow. Lucas: Exactly. And then the outreach. This is where most people mess up. They send a long message saying, 'I admire your work, can you be my mentor?' That gets ignored. Instead, you want a low-ask, high-value first touch. Something like: 'I'm a PM at a fintech company working on loan origination. I read your post about underwriting APIs. I have a question about how you handled data quality at scale — could I buy you a coffee for 15 minutes?' Luna: I love that. It's specific, shows you did your homework, and the ask is small. Fifteen minutes is nothing. Lucas: And you're offering to buy them coffee. That's a small gesture, but it signals you value their time. Priya actually used this approach. She found a senior product director at a larger fintech, sent a message like that, and the person said yes. Luna: So what happened in that first meeting? She only had fifteen minutes. Lucas: She prepared. She had three specific questions written down, all tied to the person's experience. She didn't waste time on small talk. She said, 'In your blog post, you mentioned you migrated from a monolith to microservices while keeping uptime. How did you manage stakeholder communication during that?' That's the kind of question that shows you're serious. The director ended up extending the meeting to thirty minutes. Luna: And then what? How do you turn that one meeting into an ongoing mentorship? You can't just say 'thanks' and disappear. Lucas: You follow up with a thank-you note that also includes a small update. Like, 'I took your advice and tried X approach. Here's what happened.' That keeps the door open. And then a few weeks later, you can ask a second question. The key is to make it easy for them to help you — don't expect them to remember you. You have to be the one driving the relationship. Luna: And if they don't respond to that second message, you accept it and move on to the next person on your list. No hard feelings. Lucas: Exactly. And by the way, if we've helped you think through a career move or decision, a couple of dollars a month is genuinely what keeps these episodes ad-free. Buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo — it really does make a difference. Luna: Yeah, it's how we keep the lights on without any sponsors. So if you find value in the show, that's the best way to support it. Lucas: Absolutely. Anyway, back to Priya. After that first meeting, she kept in touch every four to six weeks. She'd share an article relevant to their conversation, or ask a follow-up on a topic they discussed. After about six months, the director offered to introduce her to other people in his network. Luna: That's the dream scenario. But let's talk about the elephant in the room: what if you get ghosted? It happens. A lot. Lucas: It does. And when it does, don't take it personally. Busy people get flooded with messages. The trick is to have a pipeline. Reach out to multiple people at once. If you get one yes out of ten, that's a win. And if someone says no, that's fine too. You can even reply politely: 'Totally understand, thanks for considering.' That leaves a good impression for later. Luna: One thing I'd add: when you're reaching out to someone outside your company, you have to be careful not to ask for anything that could be seen as confidential or a conflict of interest. Don't ask them to review your company's strategy or anything like that. Lucas: That's a great point. The conversation should be about their experience, not your company's secrets. And if you're in a regulated industry like finance or healthcare, be extra careful. But overall, external mentors can be incredible. They see your career objectively, they can introduce you to opportunities you'd never find internally, and they have no political agenda. Luna: So for Priya, what's the next step? She has one mentor now. Should she try to find more? Lucas: Eventually, yes. But I'd say build the relationship with this one first. Let it mature. After a year, then maybe look for someone different — someone who can help with a specific skill you want to develop, like public speaking or negotiation. Luna: That makes sense. So overall, the strategy is: identify specific people, send a low-ask message with a clear value proposition, prepare for the first meeting, and then maintain the relationship with consistent, thoughtful follow-ups. Lucas: Exactly. And if you're listening and you've been hesitating to reach out to someone you admire, just do it. The worst they can say is no, and that's not so bad. But if they say yes, it could change the trajectory of your career. Luna: Well said. And if you have a career question you'd like us to tackle, send it in. We read every one.