Latest / Newcomer Pod / A Long Drag on a Mango Juul Pod (w/ Lauren Etter)
Transcript
- 0:00Okay, I'm going to do my new low-voiced intro, so that your
- 0:03lower, you have a lower voice, Eric said that, my voice is too
- 0:06high on the internet. Pitches up.
- 0:08When he does the intros I pitches a I speak in Millennial
- 0:11up talk so that people can feel comfortable immediately and then
- 0:15I hit him with my podcast. Hey everybody.
- 0:29Welcome Welcome to dead cat. Tom here.
- 0:31Got the Full House Eric and Katie and very exciting episode
- 0:36for you guys. It's a two-parter.
- 0:37We haven't done one of those in a while.
- 0:39But first off, Eric is going to fill us all in on his time.
- 0:42At Collision, the u.s. branch of the web Summit conference and
- 0:47his takes on the state of venture capital investing.
- 0:51And I don't know, whatever fun panels that he contributed to,
- 0:55and then we've got an interview that Eric and I did a couple
- 0:58days earlier with Lord eddard, a Bloomberg journalist who wrote a
- 1:02book about Jewel, which is a tech company.
- 1:05We decided through the course of that interview and it is a text
- 1:08story. You were skeptical.
- 1:09I'm like if their nose becomes a text Story.
- 1:12I mean do you want? You won the Overture back.
- 1:14Yes, art up. And we get into it and yeah, you
- 1:17won me over was like yeah, it's Hardware.
- 1:19Its Hardware, I got it now. But anyway, so we talked we
- 1:22talked to Lauren in the wake of jewels the decision by the FDA
- 1:26to yank Jewel of the shells which now apparently has been
- 1:29stayed. And and so when we recorded that
- 1:31interview Jewel, I believe was not like it had just been struck
- 1:36down by the FDA but since then there's been an injunction so
- 1:39keep that in mind as you listen to her interview.
- 1:41So is that fair that's a good update on where things are with
- 1:43Jewel and the FDA? Yeah, I'm glad we get a moment
- 1:46of just the three of us hanging out.
- 1:49I feel like we always have guests on and then and there's
- 1:51someone choose if they have their own opinions.
- 1:53I know who Jerry, I love the Gary as guests talking about.
- 2:00Artificial intelligence. What I hear?
- 2:02He was a man after my own heart and that he had a lot of takes
- 2:06that he wanted to make sure he distributed to the world.
- 2:09He was like, this is a random sidebar that I want to miss my
- 2:13show down random sidebars and I want to unload on people games.
- 2:17Like, I'm going to serve up a couple takes on.
- 2:20Stoughton, exactly everything. I'm too lazy to write up for a
- 2:26newsletter. I intend to get on the air here
- 2:29so at least I'm like On the record somewhere, but this is
- 2:32all our gas. This is really muddy it up.
- 2:33This is the alternative to Twitter.
- 2:35This is what I always tell myself, it's like I had this
- 2:37take, there is no upside for me, tweeting it out, but if I can do
- 2:40it here, maybe no one will cancel known right out of you
- 2:44and there's no Barrel mechanisms, right?
- 2:49So few people get cancelled for podcast episodes in comparison
- 2:52to tweets. That's, that's not how there's
- 2:53time yet. Yeah, Eric give us the rundown
- 2:56on collision. Why don't you even explain what
- 2:58Collision is? I don't know if I did the best
- 2:59job. What is this conference in
- 3:01Toronto? This case?
- 3:03Okay. So not only is this a conference
- 3:04in Toronto it was once a conference in Spain.
- 3:06In the year of Our Lord 2016 isn't that when you were you at
- 3:10Collision then? Yeah.
- 3:11Listen is this like huge huge. Huge Tech conference.
- 3:15It is so huge. That you actually feel like you
- 3:18are in a cattle call. It doesn't make any sense.
- 3:21You'd I don't hate it. So much Eric's going to give us
- 3:23a real definition but I just know that a collision in 2016.
- 3:26Tom was there then thank you, commissioner web.
- 3:29Some it was Of summit. It's owned by the same company.
- 3:32Yeah. They're the same web Summits.
- 3:34The huge one in Lisbon, which is 100,000 people.
- 3:37Collisions big is 35,000, so it is a smaller one, a 35,000.
- 3:41They're both organized by ADI Cosgrave.
- 3:43It's a bunch of Irish people. You know, if you hear anybody
- 3:45with an Irish accent, you're like, are you you're in church?
- 3:48Are this? Yeah, that's analogous.
- 3:50Irish were in charge of collisions in Toronto, web,
- 3:53Summits and Lisbon. I think both cities pay them a
- 3:55bunch of money. I think Lisbon pays them like 11
- 3:58million dollars a year or something.
- 4:00I'm not saying it almost insane government handout I've ever
- 4:03seen in my life. We had regular dinners and like
- 4:0516th century castles. Yeah, I moderated two panels on
- 4:10sort of the Venture Capital Stage, which is smaller more
- 4:13intimate about sort of the, you know, Venture World crumbling
- 4:18and one with hey, mate, General Catalyst, who had profiled then
- 4:22I did a main stage interview which is huge, similar similar.
- 4:27Sort of is the bubble bursting themes.
- 4:30My main take honestly, is that they're the conference?
- 4:33I loved it. The conference is really good at
- 4:37giving the elites I totally different conference that
- 4:39everybody else. Like, if you're a speaker, you
- 4:42get a badge that allows you into the forum where, you know, only
- 4:47the speaker's go and they serve you lunch and dinner and
- 4:50breakfast, and there's coffee. And you can like, never have to
- 4:54go in with the riffraff. There's a similar one for media.
- 4:57That's like much worse. So I just Out in the Forum all
- 5:01day and then yeah, they invite speakers to drinks it.
- 5:05So I feel bad almost even admitting it but it is a very
- 5:08like, I mean you can see the logic to it which is you get the
- 5:13speakers to go because they're going to have this sort of more
- 5:16intimate conference experience and then you get everyone else
- 5:20to go because they're going to be able to hear from the
- 5:22speakers that they want to. So there there is a certain
- 5:25logic but it is sort of yeah. My experience was Great.
- 5:30Because it was sort of the rarefied version of the calm.
- 5:34You think it's the rarefied, I'm sure there's a version of it,
- 5:36that's even a higher level above you that you're not invited to.
- 5:39Well, you said, I don't the real cute.
- 5:41This is like, see what is it? CES and Vegas is so similar,
- 5:45right? You have this huge conference
- 5:47with far, too many people coming together to basically, look at
- 5:51an exhibition Hall, and go here speakers.
- 5:54And then there is the presenters area their experience.
- 5:57And then there are the people who go to CES and never pretend
- 6:00anything that's private dinner, right?
- 6:02They go to Rupert Murdoch. Sweet, exactly.
- 6:05Yeah. Well there, yeah, they have an
- 6:06event afterwards called Founders, which is sort of a
- 6:09small scale. I think I could have gotten into
- 6:12that. I I've been to Founders.
- 6:14We will do an episode about Founders and which I will bring
- 6:16other people that read founders with me 16, because it's a real,
- 6:19it's a real experience, it's crazy, but I did.
- 6:22I got to go to a dinner. The beauty of being a one-man
- 6:26show is that I like that the top person in my, my media
- 6:29organization. So yeah, he's at a dinner with
- 6:32the what the I guess, editor-in-chief of the
- 6:34Washington Post, like president of ABC News executive producer
- 6:38of 60 Minutes, Sean Kelly from Puck Peter Kafka was there.
- 6:43So that was a cool sort of media.
- 6:46Who's, who experienced the editor of refinery29 was sitting
- 6:51across from me. It's immediate, I'm so curious.
- 6:53So, The obviously venture-backed media is struggling, so,
- 6:59bizarre, conversation about that, where people talking about
- 7:01was going on with Bice, I mean, refinery29 had its own issues,
- 7:05what's their part of speed? Exactly.
- 7:08What's going on at BuzzFeed and they sort of disaster that that
- 7:13became or did the dinner completely?
- 7:15Do you guys just ignore ignore this all together and have fun?
- 7:18No, I'm over talking about media.
- 7:19Was it off the Record? Can you what did who by the way
- 7:22is the editor-in-chief of the Washington Post.
- 7:24Isn't it Sally Busby I was just like Sally Busby.
- 7:27Yeah I wasn't seated near her. She was definitely.
- 7:30I mean a lot a lot of questions for Busby I did hear someone.
- 7:32I don't know if it was off the Record or not, so I'm gonna be
- 7:35someone definitely did. There's like I'm, you know,
- 7:37you've really handled this like Twitter thing, very well, you
- 7:41know, just like someone's like, yeah, I'm sure like she doesn't
- 7:44want to, even be brought up, but like this Twitter thing, being
- 7:48the insane implosion that happened around two reporters.
- 7:53It's everything you Imagine with like top people will sort of
- 7:56back slapping each other where they probably have only like
- 7:58consume like a tenth of what's go, you know.
- 8:00They just like it's like God there's there's definitely some
- 8:04of it where it feels like I don't know.
- 8:07Senior people and media are. I didn't talk to her at all so
- 8:10I'm not talking about her but they're not.
- 8:13As in the weeds, the senior people in media necessarily is
- 8:16all the reporters and you can get sort of feel the make much,
- 8:20much, much more money than a reporter for doing more work.
- 8:25If someone is complimenting Busby, I can say, that's gonna
- 8:28work. There was, someone is
- 8:29complimenting Busby for handling the Twitter thing.
- 8:32Well, that's kind of the point of the dinner where I maybe I
- 8:34get up and get these Twitter. Things is to handle them.
- 8:39Well, is literally to try to pretend they didn't happen
- 8:41because so I talked to somebody who is thinking about should I
- 8:44go, you know, I want to go to Washington Post, or should I go
- 8:48to the New York Times, the post's just had this issue and I
- 8:50said, what do you remember? This thing that happened at the
- 8:54New York Times that eventuated in the firing of the head of our
- 8:58op-ed section. He literally couldn't remember,
- 8:59it happened two years ago. So I think these things go James
- 9:03Bennett and are forgotten, right?
- 9:05As quickly as they like explodes, only the sickest
- 9:08external is the remember that fire, right, right?
- 9:11Yeah, that is not. So the funny thing about asking
- 9:14you this question, Eric is like what everyone would want to say,
- 9:16coming out of a conference was like, what was the temperature?
- 9:19What was the sense of it? But either you weren't really in
- 9:21like the, you know the riffraff you were just The elites, which
- 9:25I may be gives you like the high level understanding what's going
- 9:28on the mood. I mean, all the panels were
- 9:30like, is the world ending but then the, you know, the
- 9:33panelists themselves backstage, you know, want to like, have you
- 9:35ever? No, stay stay upbeat so I think.
- 9:39Yeah, I definitely sort of the market turning.
- 9:42I mean, ever, that's everybody. Everybody's talking about that
- 9:46and crypto taking a nosedive. I mean, that was definitely a
- 9:48big Conversation Piece, you know, Wesley Chan was there, he
- 9:52just started a new fun. So I mean even though the
- 9:55world's ending people are clearly willing to like start
- 9:58start new things. I mean, know those things
- 10:00probably took a long time to get going.
- 10:02It takes a long time for the world to end.
- 10:03I think that's what people forget.
- 10:05You know. Like even if you agree that
- 10:06we're on like an inexorable March towards some sort of
- 10:09dissolution, it's not going to happen overnight.
- 10:12You know these things right funds will still be raised.
- 10:14Its capital will be deployed Ryan Peterson and Flex for.
- 10:17It was definitely the best speaker.
- 10:20I mean he's just good at being history story in that he was
- 10:23doing. So some of it it's like okay
- 10:25I've heard this so many times now but he is good at he's like
- 10:29oh we think we're going to do five billion in Revenue, you
- 10:31know, he's just he drops in very specific stuff.
- 10:34He was also really Self-flagellating when it came
- 10:38to hiring Dave, Clark, from Amazon, you know, he's like,
- 10:41Ryan's just like, you know, I was looking at everything, I
- 10:44know how to do and everything he knows how to do, and he's better
- 10:47me than all of it. So I was like, oh, I guess you
- 10:49should be CEO with that but then he couldn't help using the
- 10:52euphemism of. I'm stepping up to be executive
- 10:56chairman. You know, like people love to
- 10:57get promoted out of the CEO job but overall he was very good.
- 11:03I think you re spoke I was promoted out of the top jaw.
- 11:06Job. I was that's good.
- 11:09Anyway, Ryan is great that we should have him on the show.
- 11:12I feel like there's always it's Logistics lot going on there.
- 11:17I feel like you're kind of at the Nexus of a low points in the
- 11:20international capitalistic Market.
- 11:22I just find it. So shocking that people still
- 11:24want to go to things like Collision like this.
- 11:26Pandemic was forced to make some of the worst things go away and
- 11:29conferences are like back by the fact that Davos just happened.
- 11:33I have always hated conferences. So this is my bias but I did
- 11:38think to myself. Maybe people want to do
- 11:40something else with their time. I was wrong.
- 11:44I was so wrong. Conferences are back.
- 11:46It's efficient way to see a lot of people that you would like to
- 11:49talk to. I definitely feel like I made a
- 11:51bunch of news sources. I did a hysterical small rent
- 11:55Round Table. It was like me and like four
- 11:57other people, explaining them, how to build lifelong
- 12:01relationships with media, where like, I feel like if that if
- 12:05that were Did I ever really gave all my my media dark arts to for
- 12:09random people that I'd never met the random for people who showed
- 12:20up at a round table for an hour where I just monologue to about,
- 12:23you know, media you should have charged for that.
- 12:26Are you still collecting business cards at conferences?
- 12:28No, that was your thing for a while.
- 12:29No, I don't bring mine, but now I just ask your peoples number
- 12:33right, right there. Very personal, it is funny.
- 12:36Conference, it's the sea adult. It's the last adult place.
- 12:39You can go to have Camp friends. You know, you have those people
- 12:42that you like meet up with early and then you're like, oh, we
- 12:45should hang out at all the different events together.
- 12:48Yeah. Yeah, they were Myself by
- 12:49Southwest bloody. Right.
- 12:50I think the reason conference is persist is that there's just
- 12:53enough to make like to appeal to the weaknesses and narcissism is
- 12:56of all the different types of person that goes to a
- 12:59conference. But no one's really willing to
- 13:01call it out for the uselessness that every other part of it is,
- 13:04you know, right. Because nobody, I mean the
- 13:06panels are sort of beside the point.
- 13:09I'm not really sure what I've ever heard.
- 13:10But execs like to be asked to speak on the panel there, like I
- 13:13get to be on a stage, right? Because I have a microphone
- 13:16enough to spell a plowed, dude, on CNBC, I need to say the same
- 13:21thing, that doesn't say anything to it.
- 13:23Even smaller group of people write, I write a truly insane,
- 13:27though. The people who just fly in just
- 13:29for their panel. I'm like, nobody loves consuming
- 13:32this, like, what what's the point?
- 13:34Because it's live, audiences you You get a here, you get to see
- 13:37on their faces, the recognition, when they in take your
- 13:39Brilliance, whereas when you're doing on CNBC you're talking
- 13:42into a piece of glass. So our Executives like just
- 13:45frustrated former theater kid. They talked down to the theater
- 13:48kids. Like they definitely bullied
- 13:49them but they also understood the core truth of what the
- 13:54theater kids wanted, which was, you know, they want to be on
- 13:56stage, they want to show. They need to fill that hole in
- 13:59their, in their heart, and their and their soul.
- 14:01So after you came out of collision, what are the, what
- 14:05are the It's of the venture-backed world that just
- 14:07don't really make sense anymore. We're not going to see as much
- 14:10of, you know, I think I feel like when obviously I don't
- 14:12cover Tech anymore but when I did it was Hardware with the
- 14:15future and like, direct-to-consumer.
- 14:19Woodstock some substance. I think, you know, a lot of
- 14:22people are turning on crypto that wouldn't have been willing
- 14:25to before or now, right. Well, you know, there are people
- 14:29who are like, who are skeptical dipping their toes in it,
- 14:32without it, who, you know, who now are seem Skeptical, trauma
- 14:37on all in was talking about uh Chris Dixon and sort of the, you
- 14:42know, Venture firms. Basically, you know, selling
- 14:45tokens along the way and getting rich quick and like that being
- 14:48sort of a big area, big question marks that super interesting, it
- 14:52was hysterical to see each machine on someone else.
- 14:55When of course, his SPAC performance has been totally
- 14:59under scrutinized. It was like a bullet point of my
- 15:01newsletter, but definitely on a permanent to-do list of hold
- 15:05Shema. Ah, accountable for taking a
- 15:08bunch of companies public that have seen their stocks, tanked
- 15:11in the beauty, of course abuse sponsor, you get a cut of the
- 15:14value, the company and it's only if you had to do the private
- 15:17round and evaluation you really got screwed.
- 15:20I think in most cases, he avoided doing that.
- 15:22He got other people told the bag.
- 15:24So I mean, the death of spax, is ongoing the death of not death,
- 15:28but a sort of sinking values of crypto.
- 15:32I mean, bird is down to like 160 160.
- 15:36Yeah in yeah I just reported that even Sequoia, you know, has
- 15:39held onto doordash and unity some two of their biggest bets.
- 15:44Those are down significantly. BuzzFeed is a spec that's
- 15:47obviously eating shit. Yeah, it'll be funny.
- 15:50I'm interested which of these high-profile spax like eats it
- 15:53first. Like if BuzzFeed is like the I
- 15:57don't know. One of the iconic companies of
- 15:59this downturn that would be really lame for media, but I
- 16:02think I think you're onto something Erica.
- 16:04I really do think that shimoff is going to Be held accountable
- 16:07and sort of be seen as, like, one of the great, you know, snow
- 16:10almost you could add. Some will say, I would not say
- 16:12this, but some could say, kind of charlatans of the spec era.
- 16:15And I think you'll see a real change, their somebody has to do
- 16:18the math. Like, how much did he make?
- 16:20And how much did other people lose?
- 16:21And, yeah, I mean, yeah, the math there.
- 16:24So, I think what's interesting is that Tech is the most visible
- 16:27part of the downturn because the stocks for, it's a lot of public
- 16:30market companies and they were doing so, so well, so it feels
- 16:34like an early indicator but I I think that we live in a world
- 16:37especially because we have the combination, very low, interest
- 16:40rates and a lot of money. When I say a lot of money, I
- 16:43made a lot of money being taken out of things like the stock
- 16:47market and put into the hands of private equity.
- 16:50And that the downturn that happens in other sectors might
- 16:54not be as visible this early on, but we could see later and have
- 16:58real impact later. It's almost like it for our
- 17:01purposes tech stocks, or the canary in the coal.
- 17:04Mine of something bigger, right? And the world is so
- 17:07interconnected and at the very sort of like riskiest part of
- 17:11the of the market. So everything from like public
- 17:14companies out to private equity and Venture Capital that it's
- 17:18hard for me to believe that this the this stops with tech stocks
- 17:22and sort of a tech industry, right?
- 17:24And then I guess the last thing is that the first the first like
- 17:28would like really Clarion call about housing bubble and the
- 17:32residential mortgage-backed security risk.
- 17:34This started happening was probably a 20 2005.
- 17:38So it took until September of 2008 for the collapsed.
- 17:44I know these things are so slow. Being in the preview, read about
- 17:47faith and it's about trust. And so, people will fall
- 17:50themselves for a really long time, until they suddenly wake
- 17:52up and say, we can't do it anymore, then they all label and
- 17:54then the books. Don't even come until after
- 17:56that. And that's when everybody
- 17:57concludes would actually happen. So it is this amazing thing
- 18:00where the reporters early on are like, oh, this is looking bad,
- 18:03it's starting to happen and then the big Stories.
- 18:06Come you know and then the final actions come and then the books
- 18:09time your let you know I mean in the movies or even later, right?
- 18:12Exactly. It's just like the movies about
- 18:14the founders came exactly as we've been processing on this
- 18:17podcast so long after you know years after and so yeah right
- 18:23The Big Short came years after the last downturn.
- 18:25So I think what's changed is we have this Twitter world where
- 18:28people not just reporters would everybody is consuming the
- 18:31narratives very quickly get the information right away but then
- 18:35the sort of Entertainment, info, industrial complex.
- 18:38Still takes a while to what I said, wonder about is like, with
- 18:42the housing bubble and the collapse.
- 18:45There was all of this interconnectedness and and
- 18:47over-leveraged companies, over-leveraged assets and I
- 18:50don't really see the same. I'm trying to find like, what is
- 18:53the over-leveraged or like, what is the leverage here with time?
- 18:56It was, the issue is that the banks were amongst the group of
- 18:59over-leveraged, lenders and over-leveraged actors.
- 19:03And the banks also had to do a lot of other functions.
- 19:05Or the economy, keeping the money flowing all around the
- 19:08world and like keeping keeping our savings accounts open.
- 19:12I mean like there was. So part of the issue, is that
- 19:15such a central part of the economy was in such big trouble,
- 19:19and shirer and Banks, because of Dodd-Frank.
- 19:24I mean, Jesus Christ, I can't believe I'm saying this if
- 19:26nothing else that possible piece of legislation, if nothing else
- 19:30but it did is it did Force big financial institutions to hold
- 19:34cash on hand. To offset risky assets like if
- 19:38even if that's all it actually accomplish, that's good because
- 19:41it means it's less. Likely that a central player in
- 19:44the economy, could go down in flames but so Tom, you're right.
- 19:48What if it is just a lot of hedge funds that start
- 19:50imploding. It's hard for me to argue that.
- 19:54Even a very large hedge fund is so interconnected.
- 19:56And so important to the world that its collapse will really,
- 20:02really hurt Main Street. And the way that the Housing,
- 20:06collapse and attendant. Securitized Finance.
- 20:09Collapse hurt. Yeah.
- 20:11Like the most that I could see here is the contagion sort of
- 20:14spreading to quote unquote, non tech stocks because from my
- 20:19perspective, what's really happening here is just a
- 20:21revaluation of these companies. A lot of them have businesses
- 20:24that are more or less the same. You haven't seen a huge downturn
- 20:27and revenue quarterly that may happen.
- 20:29But what's happened is, you know, investors basically said,
- 20:31oh maybe they're not worth a hundred X multiples on their
- 20:34revenue, maybe they're only worth.
- 20:35Or 3x or 10x or something. And over the last couple of
- 20:39years, I just saw this covering media.
- 20:41There were a lot of companies that were looking very
- 20:43longingly. At these insane multiples, the
- 20:45tech companies had and they're like, oh, how can we pinch
- 20:47ourselves in a tech like way in a growth like way?
- 20:50So it seems like it's a, we can get the and that's what Disney
- 20:52did, right? They basically said, actually,
- 20:54we're streaming company and they one day just got valued at like,
- 20:58you know, I can't remember that the multiple difference, but,
- 21:01you know, significantly more than they were just because they
- 21:03call themselves a streaming company.
- 21:05And They're down along with, you know, the rest of the market
- 21:08about. I mean, valuation, we says been
- 21:10sort of a key key piece of this. I wanted.
- 21:12I forgot a funny thing. I didn't tell you I was looking
- 21:15at but finally my ears were figuring out the market painting
- 21:19classic fashion, you know? You know, I was in here, I went
- 21:22early for like the ventured a collision.
- 21:25And, you know, there was a guy, you know, in shorts, right,
- 21:30which of course, I think was the richest guy.
- 21:32There he is. One of the top people.
- 21:35Or if not the top people at multi coin.
- 21:39Have you even heard of this one? Either of you heard of this
- 21:42fund. I love the name, though.
- 21:44Multi coin according to their last filing which I pulled up
- 21:48while we're on this call. This was at the end end of last
- 21:51year, I think so. So they've certainly sunk
- 21:54significantly from this. But they had eight point nine
- 21:59billion dollars in assets under management.
- 22:01You never even heard of them. I mean that's how big some of
- 22:04these crypto funds have gotten this.
- 22:05Guys standing around shorts that I think there are 17 people that
- 22:09work there. So this guy got they're huge in
- 22:12Solana and they're huge in helium.
- 22:15And I mean, it seemed like they were just holding it holding on
- 22:20tight, you know. It's like we don't sell that
- 22:22sort of. That was the attitude.
- 22:24Yeah, it was he was amazed that you should follow up with that
- 22:26guy that. Yeah.
- 22:28Yeah, he may, he may lose his shorts with the last few minutes
- 22:31before we catch her interview with Lauren.
- 22:32Do you want to quickly talk about the overturn of Road?
- 22:35Wade and all the tech companies that put out statements saying
- 22:39that they will support their employees crossing state lines,
- 22:42but Duolingo, did a good job, right?
- 22:43Didn't they say he was threatening Pennsylvania?
- 22:47I don't know. Katie Katie, do you have?
- 22:49I think that there are tech companies.
- 22:51There were also like larger companies like Dick's Sporting
- 22:54Goods. I think, JP Morgan said we will
- 22:58pay if our employees need to cross their minds on that
- 23:02tangent portion. Yeah.
- 23:03And and Susan will. She keep basically came out and
- 23:04said, like, I understand? I run a company and I understand
- 23:07there are a lot of different opinions on this issue in the
- 23:09company but my personal opinion is terrible.
- 23:12So I think the two questions Beyond like the making of the
- 23:16statements, which being realistic people inside, those
- 23:19companies are going to have a variety of opinions on.
- 23:21They're not going to agree is for corporate.
- 23:25America one do States passed a legislation.
- 23:30We're doing something like providing that kind of funding
- 23:33and transport violates law. Not that the I moved from one
- 23:37state to another and cross the border, which I think have a
- 23:40knot in his separate. Decision says, he does not think
- 23:43should you know, he lets you can't go after people just for
- 23:46leaving their state to obtain an abortion, but can a company be
- 23:50attacked for aiding and abetting an illegal act.
- 23:53So I think that's like a big gray area that have to be worked
- 23:55out. The other thing is our will
- 23:58companies be eager to headquarter in states, where
- 24:01abortion is just straight-up illegal or highly restricted.
- 24:05So so that throws Texas which has been the recipient of so
- 24:09much business. So many people setting up
- 24:11companies, they're so much investment.
- 24:13What happens to Texas what happens to Florida and then what
- 24:16happened? You know.
- 24:17So there there are definitely bigger questions Beyond like the
- 24:20making of the statement which of course would make sense that
- 24:23that happens in the moment, but you were going to have to see
- 24:27those bigger questions. Worked out.
- 24:29And worked out pretty quickly. Yeah.
- 24:30No, I completely agree. I'm actually more interested in
- 24:34people Reckoning with that. That reality of so much energy
- 24:38and effort. I mean, basically boosterism for
- 24:40Texas and Florida by prominent people in The Tech Community.
- 24:44Now, having to deal with the fact that, yeah, these states
- 24:46are not politically aligned with what you claim to stand for.
- 24:49And what are you going to do? I mean, you can shit all over
- 24:51California for its anti business proposals, and statutes and
- 24:55culture. But politically you're far more
- 24:58aligned with the people that you are in those other states.
- 25:00And what you going to do, I do, there will be another, I think
- 25:03be to the story in that you Do a lot of the actual humans doing
- 25:08the work for these. Big tech companies are employed
- 25:11by outside contractors and they rarely get the benefit of tech
- 25:17protections and so they're, they're all.
- 25:19So, you know, I mean, what the poor people are more affected by
- 25:25by these abortion rules. Obviously, they're not making
- 25:27the high salaries and I think in a lot of critiques, the outside
- 25:32contractor issue has sort of been met with.
- 25:36Shrug is maybe too strong but I feel like it hasn't really hit
- 25:40these companies. But I do think on an issue like
- 25:43abortion where people, you know, really want everyone to have
- 25:47access. I I would not be surprised if
- 25:50companies like you on. Facebook got a lot more pressure
- 25:53to make sure they're contractors.
- 25:56Could get out to or not to have contractors in these, in these
- 25:59states. And then, you know, yeah, we
- 26:01talked about that in the Kiki Freeman episode that it's one
- 26:04thing to kind of make make statements in favor of what your
- 26:07employees want. But when you do start Crossing
- 26:10into a world where yeah these contractors that you have are
- 26:13not eligible for the same rights and you know, if they want to be
- 26:16they choose to be unionized that is directly in contradiction to
- 26:18your business interests and they have no interest in these
- 26:21companies in furthering that at all.
- 26:24And so they're going to walk very gingerly on this line.
- 26:27Even though, you know, politically speaking, you know,
- 26:30their Pappy to make statements, you know, in support of abortion
- 26:34rights of their employees, you know, Freedom to get them, it's
- 26:37terrible. I can say that hard hard not to
- 26:39be like a legal realists. After this that it's just an
- 26:43exercise of power and not sort of argument or coherency.
- 26:48I don't know. Very, very disillusioned young
- 26:50always hard. I don't know when these National
- 26:54stories, sort of swamp. What's going on in?
- 26:58Techland can be a little bit like well I think it's actually
- 27:01just a very clear reminder When I got to think about something
- 27:07other than Venture Capital, this is sort of the opposite.
- 27:10It's like, how can you expect me to think about venture capital
- 27:13and the days where I feel a little silly, sometimes, you
- 27:16know, publishing thing. And then my cloud is so much
- 27:19lesser in these nets, right? Or and I also feel dumb, I don't
- 27:22know. I don't sometimes, it's good,
- 27:23you know, you covered Tech, you repurpose it, you know, you
- 27:26could talk about the contractor thing, but it can be a little
- 27:29ridiculous. Every Tech reporter just trying
- 27:31to recontextualize their bead into the national political
- 27:34issue of And sometimes it's like you're not really the heart of
- 27:38the story, you just happened to cover this other thing, I don't
- 27:40know. It's a, you know, it's just an
- 27:42awkward dance for. I also think it's just a good
- 27:44reminder, for Tech reporters of what power really is and where
- 27:49power really resides in this country and certainly business
- 27:51has with Cal was awkward. Yeah, exactly.
- 27:58Power resides in the Vatican, it's like, we think about like
- 28:01the Chamber of Commerce or we think about big companies being
- 28:04able to Lobby or Mark Zuckerberg.
- 28:05Having private dinners with Trump.
- 28:07But really it's about, you know, it's still about the three
- 28:11branches and our state legislators but dang
- 28:14Constitution. Well, we're going to get rid of
- 28:16that soon enough on one level. I'm like, oh, I guess I do
- 28:20believe in like I was thinking, oh, would I support?
- 28:24Jeff Bezos for president, I think I would support Jeff.
- 28:27Yes, I just had a meeting with somebody who is an executive and
- 28:31he was so interesting. He was explaining why he doesn't
- 28:33think the executives actually make Good political leaders
- 28:38present, because a CEO, your job is to figure out what works
- 28:41quote-unquote. And then do it over and over and
- 28:44over again with only enough deviation to keep up with the
- 28:48changes that are buffeting your business.
- 28:50But at the end of the day, your you have one goal truly or if
- 28:54you have multiple business line, each line has a goal but they're
- 28:57all rowing in the same direction.
- 28:59It's like if you are the mayor or you are the governor or
- 29:02you're the president, you have competing Constituents not,
- 29:07everybody is rowing in the same direction.
- 29:09You are not supposed to the same thing over and over and over
- 29:11again. Because you will fail.
- 29:13And there is no measure of success, like pnl against like
- 29:17and so people come in wanting to think it's actually very simple
- 29:20and then they realize unfortunately that it's much
- 29:23harder. I don't know.
- 29:24And that was from somebody who is a CEO Katie, you know, you
- 29:26need to go back and read him as on Unbound Brad's book on is a,
- 29:31I mean, it really there really Hard or they're taking a lot of
- 29:37time off because their knees hurt because I'm making them
- 29:39pack your boxes on the floor. So I'm going to get them knee
- 29:42pads and I thought, there you go.
- 29:43Tactical exactly what I mean. Phasers comes off as someone
- 29:47who's good at like okay, we hear all the fires burning.
- 29:49I'm gonna push you on this but you and that you know I don't
- 29:52know, fires burning around a single goal making money for the
- 29:57company. It's not like a look at sure.
- 30:01This is their fight because keep in mind that when Roe versus
- 30:04Wade happened, there was a significant portion the country
- 30:06that was very happy and felt that a goal had been realized.
- 30:10So you're managing just on one issue, completely competing
- 30:16constituencies because when you're president, even if you're
- 30:18democrat or republican, it's still all the people.
- 30:21I this tight, I can see your argument an abstract.
- 30:24But then if I actually had to compare the strengths and
- 30:29weaknesses of the, various top Democratic contenders or the
- 30:32current president, I'd say, uh, I Of these people, you know, the
- 30:37Caribbean. What, what's his name
- 30:39Transportation? True P mayor.
- 30:42Pete boot each Edge like that guy's next Consultants.
- 30:45He's not even a good X. Business-minded at least basis
- 30:48is done with the, I mean, No One's Gonna like Bezos
- 30:50obviously, so it's sort of it's a moot point, but I was just as
- 30:54a thought, exercise, if I could actually like, say, who would I
- 30:58really want? Like, if I could install
- 30:59anybody, that's the closest I come Bezos.
- 31:03I think Tim I you know I go to Tim Cook.
- 31:06I go Tim Cook because at least he's had to negotiate with
- 31:09leaders around the world. Yeah, yeah, you're right.
- 31:12He's done more of the foreign policy and he actually manages
- 31:15like a huge Workforce. Has you be good at running an
- 31:18Empire? It is sort of like
- 31:34I see that. Not one.
- 31:36Mark Zuckerberg suck forced himself to learn Mandarin.
- 31:40So he could connect with the Chinese market that never wanted
- 31:42Facebook in the first place. Whereas Tim actually operates in
- 31:45China, and probably doesn't speak a word of maybe ruined.
- 31:48So one is power. The other one is, you know,
- 31:51goals. Anyway, on that front, we should
- 31:53probably kick it on over to our interview with Lauren, editor of
- 31:56Bloomberg and are fascinating discussion about the state
- 32:00present and future of Jewel. And jewels already already
- 32:04fought the Anning. I think temporarily.
- 32:07So this is a story that some keep turning and she is the
- 32:10expert. So it was you couldn't times.
- 32:12Also keep in mind that as Eric and I were doing that interview,
- 32:14both of us were like man, that actually sounds great like Kevin
- 32:17Jewel. Like I said yeah I need more
- 32:19vices, that's whatever. Yeah, because they go long take
- 32:22a long drag on a mango Jewel pod right now.
- 32:33We've got boring editor from Bloomberg who I've interviewed
- 32:36once before about her book, The Devil's Playbook on Jule and
- 32:42now, jewel is back in the news, I was hurt.
- 32:45I was shocked to find out that the fda's thinking about or
- 32:51intends to take them off the shelves, right?
- 32:54What's was were you surprised by this or do you saw this one
- 32:58coming? I definitely did not see this
- 33:00one coming. In fact I was very And I've been
- 33:03asked several times over the past year, what do you think the
- 33:06FDA is going to do? And I really would have put
- 33:08money on the FDA keeping Jewel on the market and we can talk
- 33:11about the reasons why, but I was very surprised by the decision.
- 33:15Yeah. I mean, you know, in some ways
- 33:18it seems like as in lame, not as like in a scholar of the FDA or
- 33:22something. It feels like very deserved in
- 33:25that this was a company that, you know, as you can tell from
- 33:28your book sort of flouted, the rules like Market it
- 33:32aggressively Lovely. But we can you really be
- 33:35punished for that? Sort of, I don't know when their
- 33:37product today seems like in line with other e-cigarettes or I
- 33:40don't know, what what have is this about I guess is this about
- 33:45past Acts or is this about sort of the status quo a jewel?
- 33:49Yeah, that's really interesting. I mean, going going into it, you
- 33:52know I would have thought that the FDA would have used the
- 33:54youth usage crisis as a way to sort of punished Jewel or to
- 33:59seek retribution or to hold their feet to the fire.
- 34:03But it turns out that in the decision by the FDA they didn't
- 34:07even mention, I mean in the they sort of mentioned the youth
- 34:12issue but that was not the reasoning that the FDA gave for
- 34:16pulling Jewel off. The market, the FDA essentially
- 34:20said that Jewels application that for having their product in
- 34:24the market did not provide enough evidence and in fact,
- 34:28sometimes provided conflicting data on some key health.
- 34:32Shoes, including something called genotoxicity whether or
- 34:35not the product could affect cellular change in the body of
- 34:39potentially lead to cancer. And they mentioned that they
- 34:42provided insufficient and conflicting data on the toxic
- 34:45toxicology of the product. So inside of Jewel, inside of a
- 34:49jewel pod, the little heating element that is essentially used
- 34:54to heat up the beep to heat up the liquid, and turn it into a
- 34:56vapor is made out of chromium and nickel and there's studies
- 35:02out there. That indicate that when you
- 35:04inhale the jewel Vapor, you're also inhaling some level of
- 35:10heavy metals, so the FDA didn't specifically point to that.
- 35:14They just said that they provided insufficient data on
- 35:18the genotoxicity issue and on this potentially and leaching
- 35:23issue related to the Pod. So to me it was really
- 35:27interesting because it wasn't even, they did even conclude
- 35:30that the data showed that there was a problem.
- 35:32And the FDA, in fact said we don't believe that there's an
- 35:35immediate harm associated with using this product.
- 35:38We'd we just believe or we conclude that the that the
- 35:42company didn't provide enough data or conflicting data so to
- 35:47meet which seems like a technicality with their
- 35:50application. So it's a really interesting
- 35:54finding by the FDA. It didn't find that.
- 35:57You know, this is a company that created a new generation of kid
- 36:01teen nicotine addict. And therefore were punishing
- 36:04you. So, it is actually very
- 36:06surprising and interesting decision by the, by the FDA.
- 36:10And obviously, Jewel has already filed a motion in court to try
- 36:14to seek a stay to keep their products on the market.
- 36:18And so, they're not going to go down easy.
- 36:20There's gonna be a legal fight, the FDA could get sued.
- 36:23So, it's definitely, you know, does not bode well for Jewel,
- 36:27but it also, we still have some legal maneuvering.
- 36:32In ahead of us, it seems like the story is, you know, this is
- 36:36like the latest step in this long, slow Descent of this
- 36:40company from its height, maybe four or five years ago to.
- 36:44Now, whereas once, you know, they were this hugely successful
- 36:48e-cigarette. Business that I just, as I was
- 36:51following, it story, just as a tech reporter living in San
- 36:55Francisco. Where, you know, there was a
- 36:56whole controversy about them, even being headquartered in the
- 36:58city. You know, it went from May, you
- 37:01know, the jewel pod. Cells being banned flavor,
- 37:04Jewel. Paul's being banned to just
- 37:08they're generally, there was concern around at the beginning
- 37:10of covid that vertical first, they came for our mango Jewel
- 37:13pods. Now they writing that sort of
- 37:16the red a. Yeah, it's been so interesting
- 37:18to watch its paths from being, you know, what was maybe
- 37:22arguably. One of the hottest.
- 37:23Quote-unquote tech companies, we can get into whether you know
- 37:26this is Tech or like what the tech connection is here to
- 37:29something that it seems like nobody wants any part of and the
- 37:31FDA is using Essentially technicalities to kill this
- 37:35thing. It's quite an incredible story
- 37:37over. Not that long a period of time.
- 37:40Yeah, yeah, I know certainly arise.
- 37:42Very stunning rise and fall. Remember this is a company with
- 37:46that was valued at 38 billion dollars at its peak.
- 37:49At one point it was bigger than the valuation of SpaceX.
- 37:52I mean it was a huge, it was a unicorn, this kind of huge.
- 37:57Success story investors piling in from Tiger Global to
- 38:01Fidelity. You know, I mean the growth, the
- 38:04growth potential and Prospect of Jewel on its Ascent was really
- 38:09something that was stunni and it was, it was like, you couldn't
- 38:13have a better product. In terms of customers, your
- 38:15customer becomes highly addicted to your product and we'll buy it
- 38:20first before food and anything else.
- 38:22Like so they, they describe this them as sticky customers.
- 38:27So yeah, it was a it was a very it was a very valuable tickets.
- 38:32Nicky get that, right? Yeah.
- 38:33That's between your fingers. All over your addiction is the
- 38:37greatest business model of all time.
- 38:39Yeah, Tom and I have been arguing, you see, I mean, it
- 38:43sort of fits into the there are knows ambiguity or but you see
- 38:47Jewel as a tech company or ever again, is this a text or a lord?
- 38:51Yeah, I mean, it's definitely a text story.
- 38:53You know, this is, this is a company that innovated on an old
- 38:57product and innovated on a product and brought to bear
- 39:00technology, if you want to call it that, I mean it you know is a
- 39:04little essentially a little flash drive like that's it's
- 39:06literally what they modeled their product after was a flash
- 39:09drive. So you know, it is one of those
- 39:12companies that kind of Falls in between the cracks, is that a
- 39:14tech company is that a single cigarette company?
- 39:18Is that a health company? Because there are all the really
- 39:21there are all those Blurred Lines and there are people who
- 39:24believe that this is a product that is for the benefit of the
- 39:28public health because it can potentially theoretically help
- 39:31smokers, Get off of there. They're addictive, smoking
- 39:35habit, which we know to be very deadly.
- 39:36So it is it is an interesting company that's for sure.
- 39:39Blurs lies. I think it's a tobacco company.
- 39:42At the end of the day you can't really ignore the fact that they
- 39:47are selling nicotine clean and simple that is what they're
- 39:50selling and to me that fits into the tobacco category.
- 39:54But yeah, has a tech element. You got the you got the Silicon
- 39:57Valley kind of element you. It you have the Stanford
- 40:00creators so yeah, I don't know. I do think it's kind of falls
- 40:04into two lines. Yeah, yeah.
- 40:05Yeah. I know and it's funny as you're
- 40:07going through the argument, I mean the theranos connection not
- 40:10you know, as in this was an out-and-out scam.
- 40:12But the fact that it was really pulling from The Playbook that
- 40:16so many tech companies want like Stanford like raising from
- 40:18Venture Capital like pitching it as a hardware, you know, like a
- 40:21hardware type product whether or not it is a, you know, in its
- 40:24Essence, a tech company or not the company Tom.
- 40:27What is also spending a lot of energy on innovating on this?
- 40:31Yeah, device And the flavors and it's easy to laugh at that from
- 40:35the outside. But there was a lot of like that
- 40:37was a big part of the come. And I want to point out that
- 40:40this was a highly successful Innovation.
- 40:43The cigarette hadn't been innovated in over a century
- 40:47literally still rolling plant matter in paper and setting it
- 40:53on fire that had not been changed.
- 40:55So they actually did bring to bear a very a genius Innovation
- 40:59part of which came from the tobacco industry's own.
- 41:02Playbook from their secret files and as you document in your
- 41:06bright and they, they did it brilliantly, their product
- 41:12really delivered. What smokers were looking for?
- 41:15Which was that, that throat hit that fairy quick spurred of
- 41:20nicotine. That goes to your brain, Braga
- 41:23surgery. Get that right.
- 41:24All right, I gotta tell ya, I mean, I need to go for it.
- 41:26So right now, the crazy crazy thing about it, their product
- 41:30was highly successful. It It was in it arguably too
- 41:34successful. They put too much nicotine in it
- 41:38and then they didn't disclose the risks.
- 41:40They didn't tell people that oh there's actually a shitload of
- 41:43nicotine in there so much that you use it once and you're
- 41:45getting it hooked right now, there are lots of copycats,
- 41:48right? I mean that's that's relevant,
- 41:50both for Jewel's business but also this sort of Crackdown,
- 41:53it's interesting. They're going after Jewel but
- 41:55not the copycats is that again one Theory would be their matted
- 41:59tool. Another would be Jules just the
- 42:01furthest along. So that, you know, there's more,
- 42:05there's more history here. So, the FDA is ready to go after
- 42:08them or that Jewels product is distinct in some way, from the
- 42:13follow-on competitors. I mean, I know this is just
- 42:15plain out but you have a theory of sort of which of those
- 42:18buckets, this FDA action, sort of fits into.
- 42:20I mean, I think there have to be a pretty big conspiracy against
- 42:23Jewel inside the FDA that I don't know if that actually took
- 42:26place. You know, you have to take them
- 42:28at their word that they evaluated their application and
- 42:31they found that their application was Is deficient,
- 42:33and that's why they denied the application.
- 42:35It is hard to imagine that there were no political kind of
- 42:40aspects to this. And it's also impossible to
- 42:43ignore the harm that Jewel inflicted on the American
- 42:46public. And so, yeah, did that color?
- 42:49The fda's decision. It's not supposed to.
- 42:52This is supposed to be purely a scientific review.
- 42:55So you got it. I at least take the FDA, the
- 42:57word that they did. The set there were that they did
- 43:00a scientific review and arrived at this at this.
- 43:02Decision. So, so, yeah, I mean, in terms
- 43:05of a copycats, it's a really interesting point in question.
- 43:09I mean, the market is being flooded with brand new nicotine
- 43:12products all the time and some of them fly under the radar.
- 43:16They're not spending a hundred fifty million dollars to ask the
- 43:20FDA for approval to sell their product.
- 43:23They're just this product that's on the market, they end up in
- 43:25vape shops. People are selling it, then
- 43:27there's a black market, you can get it on the black market and
- 43:29remember a lot of these products.
- 43:32Are really built on the back of jewels Innovation, which is very
- 43:36stinging for Jewel because some of them are literal copycats
- 43:40Black Market. But others actually just derive.
- 43:43Some of the Innovation from Jewel, for example, the the
- 43:46nicotine salts that was jewels kind of discovery that really
- 43:51made their product pop. Now, there are a million
- 43:54products that have nicotine salts in them, some of the
- 43:57products, even look like Jewel. So, you know, it is a little in
- 44:02terms of Like, is this going to solve a problem?
- 44:04Like, will taking Jewel off the market solve, some bigger
- 44:07problem about youth, nicotine addiction?
- 44:09It's just the fact is that there are so many products that are
- 44:13currently on the market that came after Julian that are.
- 44:15In fact, very similar to Jewel and the FDA doesn't really have
- 44:18the enforcement resources to go to all these deep shops to see
- 44:23what's being sold. You know, they are they actually
- 44:25are a little bit stretched in terms of the enforcement
- 44:29resources that they have. So yeah, it's a huge.
- 44:32Huge loss for Jewel. They're going to fight it
- 44:35obviously, but I will say it's a huge win for all of these other
- 44:39companies and all of the end, the two companies that are so
- 44:43Jules number one right in the market.
- 44:45Yeah, number two is Reynolds views.
- 44:48Number three is enjoy both of those products.
- 44:52Receipt, their pmta authorization, it's funny.
- 44:56By the way Lauren that you bring up Reynolds.
- 44:58As one of the winners here, I've been bugging Eric and almost
- 45:00everyone else about this recently but I I'm rereading
- 45:03Barbarians at the gate and there's a hilarious passage or
- 45:06section where they talk about their attempts to develop, you
- 45:09know, 30 years ago, the smokeless cigarette, which was a
- 45:13disaster back then, you know, it right?
- 45:15It tasted like shit. He said, right?
- 45:17Right, yeah, hilarious scene. Where the CEO of RJR Nabisco is
- 45:20like making all of his wealthy friends try.
- 45:23You know, an early prototype of the smoke was cigarette and
- 45:25they're all like, dude, this is disgusting.
- 45:27You cannot use that. And that would kind of ends up
- 45:29precipitating, but, you know, the whole drama on the story
- 45:31because they can't innovate at all.
- 45:32But It is funny to see, you know, a cigarette company, not
- 45:35able to do it a tech company, does it 30 years later?
- 45:38Now it's getting fucked by the regulatory, you know, a
- 45:41structure and big tobacco, whatever you want to call
- 45:43Reynolds these days. Somehow, emerges Victorious, all
- 45:46these years later to kind of leap off the, you know, the
- 45:49technology and product that was built by another company.
- 45:52So it seems like the establishment if you want to
- 45:55refer to it as that kind of one in the end here.
- 45:58Yeah, well yeah. And then that also the irony
- 46:01layered on top of that Is that Altria, of course, formerly
- 46:05known, as Philip Morris the maker of Marlboro, cigarettes
- 46:08had this huge investment in Jewel were twelve point eight
- 46:11billion dollars. It's now worth a fraction of
- 46:13that like 1.6, I'm sorry billion now worth about 1.6 billion
- 46:17dollars. They had their own product and
- 46:19they took their own product off the market to back Jewel.
- 46:23So not only. Yeah, not only did they have the
- 46:27worst investment make the worst investment or one of the worst
- 46:31in American history, history. But they also lost out on an
- 46:35opportunity to develop their own IP, their own product and
- 46:40basically bet on the wrong horse.
- 46:42Yeah. Did the original on is what I
- 46:44always wanted. Did they get away with it?
- 46:46Did did the original sort of Jewel, Founders, truel, money
- 46:50tiger, like, are there? So, I mean, they got paid out
- 46:53big by Ultra and then had some steak or who's sort of still up
- 46:58big time over this Jewel project and use who's out of the.
- 47:01Yeah, I think so. This or this coming.
- 47:03I mean the absolutely if you want to say they got away with
- 47:07it fine. Absolutely.
- 47:10The the founder, you're like your word Islanders habitual
- 47:15made out like Bandits the board of directors made out like
- 47:19Bandits on that twelve point eight billion dollar deal and
- 47:23basically you know, they're not at the company anymore or have a
- 47:27diminished role. Not really involved in the
- 47:29day-to-day Affairs and became billionaires.
- 47:32There's and then those that were already billionaires, including
- 47:35Nick pritzker are, you know, even more billionaire, ask X
- 47:40over 3 billion are rolling back. The clock a little bit to the
- 47:44are aware tool was on the rise and I remember at when I was
- 47:48working at the information at the time, we ran a couple
- 47:50stories about the dithering among Venture capitalists about
- 47:53whether or not they could even invest in Joule, because it
- 47:56would be you run afoul of their advice Clauses that they
- 47:59couldn't really be investing in a company, that was contributing
- 48:01to, You know, addiction and well Nellie's nicotine addiction,
- 48:07what is your sense of how those people might be feeling at this
- 48:10point? I mean, you know, what do you
- 48:12mean like, was the, what was going on among the VC Community
- 48:15as Jewell is on the rise. So we know that Jewel was
- 48:18brilliant at its marketing. Maybe, you know, obviously there
- 48:21early marketing was ended up going down in history as being
- 48:25maybe their original sin if you will.
- 48:27But I'm only saying that because too good, but I will say in The
- 48:32reason I bring that up is because they were also very good
- 48:34salesman on these. The two founders of the company,
- 48:38really, first of all, they believed in their product, they
- 48:41believe, like why are we still smoking?
- 48:43It's really stupid. It kills people, why can't we
- 48:45find a healthier safer way to do it?
- 48:47So they come up Jewel. So they really did believe.
- 48:51And there's actually this very big Public Health movement,
- 48:54that's been gaining Steam for the past two decades that argues
- 48:57that if smokers really want to keep smoking because they're
- 49:01addicted to nicotine. That's You continue smoking.
- 49:03If we just find a way to give them nicotine in a way that
- 49:07doesn't involve combustion, then like that would be great.
- 49:10You could save a lot of lives. You could, you could, you could
- 49:13render the cigarette moots. So they really sold that story.
- 49:19They sold the story of this being not only an innovation but
- 49:23it's an innovation that is a very promising for public health
- 49:28and the greater good. So, that's the story that they
- 49:31shopped around and I think that Really got the attention, a lot
- 49:33of a lot of venture capitalists and that made them sort of like
- 49:37set aside, this kind of like, dirty association with big
- 49:40tobacco and you know, doesn't really run afoul of the vice
- 49:43Clause because it's actually helping people.
- 49:46So that's been always kind of like the twin kind of thing with
- 49:49Jewel. It's like it's like the problem
- 49:53is that they they packaged it as it as it having this health
- 49:58promise but then they sold it like a Silicon Valley.
- 50:02Company sells widgets like a Silicon Valley company sells
- 50:06scooters, you know bird Scooters or you know, you name whatever
- 50:10product and they sold it in a way that was, very
- 50:13irresponsible, so the initial launching of it, and sort of
- 50:16like the get the Gathering of the money and finding backers,
- 50:21and Gainey earning, sympathy of them.
- 50:23Like it was kind of all wrapped up in this package and I don't
- 50:28think that it caused too many people.
- 50:30Too many of these investors a lot of Heartache.
- 50:33Honestly, because ultimately they could say, you know, this
- 50:36is. Yeah, sure might be a
- 50:37controversial product, but at the end of the day, it's going
- 50:40to help a lot of people. If this truly were embraced by
- 50:43Tech, you would have seen a lot more people out there right now,
- 50:46you know, railing against the regulatory state for stopping
- 50:49this Innovation from from, you know, continuing its March.
- 50:52And instead there's really not been that much.
- 50:55I've seen from the tech community.
- 50:56So it again, puts it in this weird nether region.
- 50:59I think, you know, a lot of people aren't really excited to
- 51:01get out and defend Will they are certainly a lot of, you know,
- 51:04the people, this Pro-V promote movement, that fair feel very
- 51:07strongly about the right to vape and you know, that, you know,
- 51:10come out in their defense but, you know, going forward.
- 51:14Yeah, there's going to be a lot of legal maneuvering if they get
- 51:16a stay that potentially means that they could keep their
- 51:18product on the shelves. So remember, 90% of jewels sales
- 51:23are in the United States. They have the res open the 90%,
- 51:27so wiping out that market potentially wipes out Jewel.
- 51:31They have some foreign It's but they're very tidy so if they
- 51:34don't win or if they don't if they are able to push back or if
- 51:38they are able to continue selling the product or screwed
- 51:41but yeah so what does that mean? For Jewel bankruptcy potentially
- 51:46likes. You know, it's it's definitely a
- 51:50potential there but I don't think jewel is going to give up
- 51:53that easily. They have an arsenal of lawyers,
- 51:57they have a lot of very smart lawyers, who have litigated in
- 52:00this space for It's and who are veterans of the Tobacco Wars and
- 52:05know exactly how the game works. So I would have write them off
- 52:10immediately, but it's definitely gonna spend it.
- 52:12They're going to spend a lot of money to keep the product on the
- 52:15shelf and it's gonna be, you know, it's going to be a cloud
- 52:17that's continuing to hang over the company for, for quite some
- 52:21time. So yeah, we shall see what
- 52:23happens in the meantime. Nicotine isn't going away
- 52:26anytime soon. If I'm, if I'm Jewel, my game
- 52:29plan here is just get this tied up in the courts for as long as
- 52:32possible. Possible until you have enough
- 52:34Millennial judges on the bench enough like activists Millennial
- 52:37vaping judges all their, we're going to be sympathetic to their
- 52:40cause and then you've got it. I mean, we've seen we've seen
- 52:43how this works the parties. Get more polarized.
- 52:45We have some. All right Baker's?
- 52:47That's that's the thing. That brings the fart.
- 52:49That's the worst shooter series is Vey together.
- 52:51Yeah, exactly. I don't belong.
- 52:53The long-term plan is actually a very solid one for them, but
- 52:56they just need to stick it through, not that I'm advocating
- 52:58for it, but I see well, I guarantee it might.
- 53:01It might drag Gone for that long.
- 53:03So you make may end up being right in the at the end of the
- 53:07aisle of the headline Jewel, drags on, there you go.
- 53:10All right, thank you very much guys.
- 53:12Hi guys, goodbye, goodbye, goodbye,
- 53:27goodbye, goodbye. Goodbye.