Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How the Lake Wobegon Effect Warps Your Office Self-Assessment
Transcript
- Lucas: Luna, quick question — on a scale of one to ten, how good are you at your job? Luna: I mean, I'd say an eight? Maybe a nine on a good day. Why, what are you fishing for? Lucas: Just setting the trap. Because statistically, most people — and I mean well over half — would rate themselves at least a seven. And that's the Lake Wobegon Effect in action. Luna: Lake Wobegon — the Garrison Keillor town where all the children are above average. Right, I remember that from psych 101. Lucas: Exactly. And it turns out the effect is alive and well in offices everywhere. A 2023 study in the Journal of Applied Psychology found that 87 percent of mid-level managers rated their own performance in the top quartile. That's not just optimism — that's a statistical impossibility. Luna: Wait, 87 percent in the top quartile? That means only 13 percent of managers think they're below the 75th percentile. That's wild. Lucas: It gets worse. The same study found that low-performing managers were the most overconfident. The bottom 10 percent of actual performers rated themselves, on average, in the 68th percentile. So the people who need the most improvement are the least likely to see it. Luna: That's basically the Dunning-Kruger Effect, right? We talked about that in Episode 116. Lucas: It's related, but it's not exactly the same. Dunning-Kruger is about the gap between perceived and actual ability — specifically that low performers overestimate and high performers underestimate. Lake Wobegon is broader: it's the general tendency for people to see themselves as above average on any positive trait, whether it's driving skill, ethical behavior, or job performance. Luna: So Lake Wobegon is like the blanket bias, and Dunning-Kruger is one specific flavor of it? Lucas: That's a fair way to put it. And the workplace consequences are huge. Think about performance reviews. If everyone walks in thinking they're in the top quartile, a manager who rates someone as 'meets expectations' is going to get pushback. The employee feels undervalued, the manager feels frustrated, and trust erodes. Luna: I've been on both sides of that. As a manager, I'd have people argue with me over a three out of five rating. And I'd think, 'You're good, but you're not exceptional — and that's okay.' Lucas: Right, and the employee hears 'you're average,' which feels like an insult because they genuinely believe they're above average. That mismatch is a recipe for disengagement. Luna: So how do you fix it? Or at least mitigate it? Because you can't just tell people 'you're biased' — that never works. Lucas: There's a technique I like called the 'pre-mortem self-assessment.' Before a performance review, have the employee write down what they think their manager will say — the good and the bad. Then compare it to the actual review. Luna: Oh, that's smart. It forces them to step into the manager's perspective and anticipate feedback before they get defensive. Lucas: Exactly. A pre-mortem makes the bias visible without the manager having to say 'you're wrong.' The employee sees the gap themselves. And studies show it reduces the Lake Wobegon effect by about 30 percent in subsequent reviews. Luna: That's a pretty concrete number. Let me guess — it works best when the employee has a clear rubric to work from, not just vague criteria? Lucas: You nailed it. The more specific the performance dimensions, the harder it is to inflate your own rating. If you ask 'how good are you at project management?' people will say eight out of ten. But if you ask 'how often do you update the project timeline?' they'll be more honest. Luna: Because it's a behavior, not a vague trait. That's actually useful for team meetings too, not just reviews. Lucas: Absolutely. Think about a brainstorming session. Everyone thinks their idea is above average. But if you force people to rank ideas against a specific criterion — say, 'feasibility within budget' — the Lake Wobegon effect shrinks. Luna: It makes you wonder how many bad decisions are driven by this bias. Like, teams that launch mediocre products because everyone thought their idea was a winner. Lucas: That's exactly the kind of cost we don't measure. And it compounds in promotion decisions. If a manager believes they're above average, they're more likely to think they deserve a promotion — even if their actual performance is solidly average. Luna: And then they get passed over and become disgruntled, and you lose a decent employee because they felt undervalued. Lucas: Exactly. The bias doesn't just inflate self-assessments — it inflates expectations for career progression. And that's a retention risk. Luna: So what about the opposite end? High performers who underestimate themselves? Does Lake Wobegon apply to them too? Lucas: It does, but differently. High performers tend to rate themselves more accurately — sometimes even slightly below their actual performance. That's the Dunning-Kruger flip side: the best people assume everyone else is as good as they are. Luna: So they undersell themselves in negotiations and promotions. That's a different problem — but still a problem. Lucas: Right. So the same pre-mortem technique helps them too. When they anticipate what their manager will say, they often realize their manager sees them more positively than they see themselves. Luna: Okay, so the pre-mortem is a calibration tool for both ends of the spectrum. Lucas: Exactly. And it's one of those rare interventions that works for everyone, regardless of where they fall on the confidence curve. Luna: I want to try this in my next one-on-one. I think my team would actually appreciate it — it's a way to get ahead of the feedback rather than reacting to it. Lucas: That's the spirit. And if it helps someone avoid a tense performance review, that's a win. Luna: Honestly, if today's episode helps even one person dodge that awkward 'but I'm above average' argument, it's worth it. Lucas: And if you found this useful, that kind of reaction is exactly why we do this show ad-free. The way that stays sustainable is listener support — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Luna: Yeah, it's a small gesture that lets us keep digging into these biases without any sponsor pressure. Lucas: So back to the bias — one last thing I want to leave you with. The Lake Wobegon Effect is sticky because it feels good. Believing you're above average is a nice mental place to live. But the cost is that you stop growing. Luna: Because if you think you're already above average, why bother improving? Lucas: Exactly. The best antidote is to actively seek disconfirming evidence. Ask yourself: 'What would it look like if I were below average in this area? What data would prove that?' If you can't think of any, you're probably in Lake Wobegon. Luna: That's a great note to end on. Thanks, Lucas. And thanks to everyone listening — we'll be back next week with another episode of The Office Politics Podcast.