Latest / Shades of Jade Podcast / Defending the Constitution from the States: Jen Brown on Utah's Fight Against Overreach
Transcript
- 0:10Hey everyone. My guest today is Jen Brown, a
- 0:13constitutional advocate and legal strategist who's raising
- 0:16urgent questions about Government Accountability and
- 0:19overreach. She's currently involved in the
- 0:22high profile case of Rubicon versus the Utah Attorney
- 0:25General, which challenges how far state officials can go when
- 0:28investigating and targeting private businesses and citizens.
- 0:33Jen brings a rare mix of legal insight, moral conviction, and
- 0:36on the ground experience fighting for civil liberties.
- 0:39Welcome to the show Jen. I want to thank you for being
- 0:42here today. Thank you.
- 0:44So good to be on. Could you tell the?
- 0:46Audience a little bit about yourself and the things you're
- 0:49working on. Yes.
- 0:51So my name is Jen Brown and I am the President of Utah Citizens
- 0:56for the Constitution. That is an organization that I
- 1:00started about 3 1/2 years ago and we are very involved here in
- 1:07the state of Utah. Our legislative session just
- 1:11ended. We actually have the shortest in
- 1:14the country, only seven weeks, but it is really amazing how
- 1:19much influence and how much involvement you can have on the
- 1:22state level. And so that's something that I
- 1:25like to remind people because a lot of citizens automatically
- 1:29think of Washington, DC, their federal reps where they can,
- 1:34where they should be the most involved.
- 1:37And the state level is where so many important things are
- 1:41happening. And so, and whatever we can do
- 1:45on the state level, it trickles up to the federal government.
- 1:49If we're able to have moral and scrupulous government here, it
- 1:55it affects it affects the federal too.
- 1:58So that is kind of the focus of my organization.
- 2:02Guys, what do you find are some of the biggest challenges with
- 2:06that? I think with, as with
- 2:08everything, of course, we, it's easy to get frustrated when you
- 2:14work hard on something and you know you don't get the the
- 2:17result that you wanted. So for example, here in Utah, we
- 2:23were just working really hard on HB374, which was a bill about
- 2:29voter ID because several years ago Utah changed and went to
- 2:37primarily vote by mail. Well, at the time the
- 2:42legislators just did not think of the repercussions of going
- 2:47away from voter ID and by mail the the amount of problems you
- 2:55can have if you don't have a clean voter rolls and all of
- 2:58those ballots are getting mailed.
- 3:00And then you couple that that you take, you take away voter
- 3:03ID. So we worked really hard on that
- 3:07bill. The sponsor was Representative
- 3:11Jefferson Burton and we got it through the House and then it
- 3:16did not pass the Senate committee.
- 3:18So it that was disappointing. But he and I have talked to each
- 3:23other. The sponsor, he is going to come
- 3:26right back with the next year. And in the meantime, he was able
- 3:30to pass a bill for a study to be done on voter ID, why that is
- 3:36important and the best way to implement that.
- 3:39And so it's one of those things where you just have to give
- 3:43yourself a minute with the session being over, get your,
- 3:46get yourself picked back up and say, you know what, we're going
- 3:49to, we're going to keep going, we're going to keep working on
- 3:52it. But we did have 5 good election
- 3:56integrity bills. And so you have to keep in mind
- 4:00the positive and the influence that that we that we were able
- 4:04to to have. Yeah, Yeah, it is, you know,
- 4:09kind of a little bit of like what you said, I think a lot of
- 4:12people forget that there are things that can be done on the
- 4:15state level. We don't need to rely on the
- 4:19federal government to to make these changes if if your state
- 4:24wants them that bad. So exactly, that's one of the
- 4:29main things that I try to educate other citizens on is
- 4:33that the founders and our constitution, they intended the
- 4:37state to be where the majority of decision making was taking
- 4:43place. Where where decisions that had
- 4:47to do, for example, with families, with education,
- 4:52healthcare, transportation, all those things are supposed to be
- 4:57taking place at the state level. So you can say, well, how do you
- 5:05know what the federal government is supposed to be doing?
- 5:08Because we don't, you don't hear people talk enough about the
- 5:12enumerated powers. So I just want your just to
- 5:18remind your listeners that the genius of the Constitution are
- 5:23those enumerated powers which are in Article 1, Section 8.
- 5:27And So what does that mean? Well, enumeration is kind of
- 5:32like making a list. Well, that's.
- 5:34Exactly. What the founders did, they made
- 5:37a list of what the federal government was supposed to be in
- 5:42charge of. And then very specifically in
- 5:45the 10th Amendment, they said everything else is reserved to
- 5:48the states. So have we seen the federal
- 5:52government grow too large? Absolutely.
- 5:56And So what we need to do is arm ourselves with the knowledge of
- 6:00the enumerated powers and set to work bringing those
- 6:05responsibilities back to the states.
- 6:08And, you know, teaching that, for example, the federal
- 6:12government, it does not have the authority.
- 6:16Let's just take, for example, education.
- 6:19No place in the Constitution does the does it give the
- 6:25federal government the authority to manage the education system.
- 6:30That without a doubt. Was meant to be done by the
- 6:32states so we can see what. Has.
- 6:36Happened to our education system.
- 6:38As more and more control has gone away from the States and
- 6:43gone to government, what have been the results?
- 6:46It has not been a good thing and we we are not following our own
- 6:52document of governance, but. This is a great time to talk
- 6:57about that because President Trump, President Trump is
- 7:01seeking to close down the Department of Education.
- 7:04And Reagan actually wanted to. Reagan understood that the
- 7:09federal government did not have that authority, but he was not
- 7:12ever able to accomplish that goal.
- 7:15But it's a great discussion as we talk about the state and then
- 7:21our County School boards that all that authority and those
- 7:25decisions are supposed to be being made and the staff work
- 7:29with each other. There's no limit on that.
- 7:32It's just the federal government is not supposed to be involved
- 7:36involved in it. And so we are seeing some
- 7:38correction in that right now. Yeah, Yes, it's it.
- 7:44You know, I don't I don't really hear about in Iowa, there's very
- 7:48much stuff going on. So it is interesting to hear
- 7:52about kind of the activities of of the other states.
- 7:58And like we have, we have the trifecta, like it's it
- 8:03Republican, all three, you know, So it's so usually there's not
- 8:07that much of A battle to to pass things, but.
- 8:12It's interesting here in Utah because we actually have the
- 8:15trifecta too, but we have a lot of opposition to some of some of
- 8:22these common sense things that should be put into law.
- 8:26So that really is interesting, isn't it?
- 8:28We have, you know, and, and so it can be really the dynamic can
- 8:34be so unique in each state with what is going on.
- 8:37But we actually have our governor right now has really
- 8:41brought in policies that have made Utah a sanctuary state also
- 8:47for people here illegally, which is a tremendous tax burden on
- 8:53the citizens of Utah. And you, you wouldn't think that
- 8:57we would be dealing with some of the issues we're dealing with in
- 9:00the state of Utah. And I actually think there's a
- 9:03lot of citizens here that think everything is going OK because,
- 9:08you know, we do have the trifecta.
- 9:10But there, there are definitely in Utah a lot of, of battle
- 9:16still a lot of different ideas how to do things.
- 9:19And so it's it's really interesting.
- 9:23It's an interesting dynamic. Yeah.
- 9:26So we're talking about the trifecta and and you know that
- 9:31that's good for people on one side, it's probably not good for
- 9:34people on on the other side. But I didn't.
- 9:38So I don't know if this adds to it or not.
- 9:41But why do you think so many people feel powerless when
- 9:44dealing with the legal system? Yes.
- 9:47Well, with the legal system that can be so frustrating because,
- 9:53and I think a lot of it does have to do with judges are
- 9:58supposed to only be interpreting if a lot is being followed or
- 10:03not, but not to be legislating from the bench.
- 10:08Oh, that's a really interesting topic for us right now because
- 10:14what happened is with our redistricting map is we have in
- 10:19the Utah Constitution, it's very specific specifically states
- 10:23that that the legislature makes our congressional maps.
- 10:28So what happened is we about six or seven years ago, Prop 4 was
- 10:35passed here in the state. It narrowly passed, but it it
- 10:40gave this authority to an appointed board to make just
- 10:46suggestions. And in Prop 4, it did say just
- 10:50to make a suggestions what they feel would be a fair
- 10:54congressional map and that the legislature had the authority to
- 10:59either accept that or to disagree and make changes.
- 11:04Well, you're not going to believe what happened here is
- 11:08after the legislature decided that they were not going to use
- 11:13that exact map, they created a a different map, which they have
- 11:18the authority to do so. And we had an organization sue
- 11:24the legislature. Well, we had an activist judge
- 11:28here in the state of Utah saying that the legislature did not
- 11:33adhere to the will of the people.
- 11:36Well, that doesn't even make sense because the legislature
- 11:40has the authority anyway to make the map.
- 11:42And even if you look at the wording of Prop 4, it, it even
- 11:46said this is just a, this is a suggestion you have the, the
- 11:51legislature can accept or deny that map.
- 11:54But Can you believe that with that ruling that said, well, the
- 11:59legislature and it was actually the Utah Supreme Court said the
- 12:03legislature didn't adhere to the will of the people.
- 12:06So now what has happened is we have a congressional map that we
- 12:12have 1 judge that picked up. Her name is Judge Diana Gibson
- 12:17and this map was written by an activist group.
- 12:22She just looked at the map, the judge and said this is the map
- 12:26that I'm going to go with. So the law, this Utah
- 12:30Constitution have not been followed on so many different
- 12:34levels. And yet right now we are
- 12:38literally facing our next election using that
- 12:42congressional map that instead of us always being for
- 12:46Republican seat, they carved out an area that that is basically
- 12:51Salt Lake and created a seat that will that will give
- 12:55somebody most likely a Democratic seat.
- 12:58This was all done without the authority from these judges to
- 13:04be able to do this. And the legislature has said
- 13:06that they will take this to the Supreme Court.
- 13:09We feel that it will be overturned at the Supreme Court
- 13:12level. But the problem is the time.
- 13:15So we've got an election coming up this very year.
- 13:19And until that map is overturned, that is what we we
- 13:24are currently using. And so I think when you ask
- 13:27about frustration in the judicial system, the judicial
- 13:31system and the the judges, they have got to remember what their
- 13:35proper role is. And there needs to be more
- 13:38transparency and accountability within the judicial branch.
- 13:43And there has been a big movement of that because of of
- 13:47the situation that happened here in Utah this legislative
- 13:51session. There were several bills passed
- 13:54that had to do with judicial reform.
- 13:57And, and so it's, it's been really interesting.
- 14:01And Can you believe that it in this day and age where we have
- 14:06so much technology where AI obviously is coming, is here for
- 14:11us to use what to use that There's not, there was, hasn't
- 14:16even been one place where citizens can go to request a
- 14:20copy of or, you know, a video or an audio of a specific court
- 14:28hearing. And so things like that have
- 14:31been, we have passed some laws now that are going to make that
- 14:35more of a uniform process that there's going to be better
- 14:38accessed by the, by the citizens to be able to get in and get
- 14:43information from the different hearings within the court
- 14:47system. And so it's just like with
- 14:50anything, there's got to be more transparency to bring more
- 14:54accountability. So, yeah, it's it's an
- 14:58interesting topic. There is definitely a lot of
- 15:01frustration around this area. And Utah at least is doing doing
- 15:08past several bills to try to work on this and to bring a
- 15:12little more accountability to these judges because we have
- 15:15just witnessed A brazen, A brazen use of judicial activism.
- 15:20And there are very serious consequences.
- 15:23Yeah, You know, in that I keep hearing that so much more about
- 15:29the the activist judges, those judges that are ruling on things
- 15:35that they don't and shouldn't have the the authority to do so.
- 15:42And it's just holding up the courts.
- 15:45Well, and it's what it is, is their job is saying I need to
- 15:50look and to see what happened. Was the law being followed or
- 15:52was it not being followed? But they sometimes the judges
- 15:57will come up with the ruling, which essentially creates an A
- 16:01new law without it being put in statute.
- 16:03But that's what that's what judicial activism is.
- 16:06So they're, they're stepping out of their prescribed area and
- 16:10what their responsibility is. And that, you know, that has to
- 16:15really be pushed back on if we are to keep our system of
- 16:19government with the three branches and that separation
- 16:23where only the legislative branch can make laws.
- 16:27You know, the judges were not ever meant to be able to do
- 16:30that. And so it's it's good that
- 16:32there's a lot of conversations going on around this.
- 16:35And Utah definitely has some some bills that other states
- 16:41could look at with the adds to the judicial reform approach
- 16:45we've taken here. Yeah, yeah.
- 16:49You know this this ties a bit into my government overreach
- 16:53question. And you gave it an example of
- 16:57what it looks like in real life. Like I would consider that those
- 17:02judges overreaching. Absolutely.
- 17:05Yep. And yes, when we talk about
- 17:08overreach, there was a specific example of that happened here in
- 17:13the state of Utah back in 2023. It had to do with the company
- 17:19Rubicon. They are a landscaping and snow
- 17:22removal company. So this has just been been very
- 17:28so concerning to understand some of the details of what happened
- 17:32in this case. But out of the blue, their
- 17:36office was raided by people from the the Attorney generals
- 17:41office. And they they arrested some
- 17:45people back in 2023. It was the day before
- 17:48Thanksgiving. And there were actually some of
- 17:52their people from the company that spent Thanksgiving in jail.
- 17:57And, you know, so we're all hearing about this thinking, Oh
- 18:01my goodness, what what has happened?
- 18:03What did they do? And as more time has gone by and
- 18:08more and more layers of this have been unfolded, is there are
- 18:14some things that we found out that for one thing, the Utah,
- 18:20the attorney general's office was, was competing to get a
- 18:25grant for that had to do with human trafficking, being able to
- 18:31work with that area. But to give them a better chance
- 18:36to receive that federal grant, they needed to have their
- 18:39numbers higher of, you know, the numbers higher that of the
- 18:44people that they were trying to protect and that they were were
- 18:47being human, human trafficked. And so they, that's what they
- 18:54did to this company is they, they brought 96 felonies against
- 19:00this company, all saying that they were, they were being
- 19:05trafficked, their employees, human trafficking.
- 19:09So then as more and more time went by, all of those charges
- 19:15were dropped. There was no, never any
- 19:19substantial evidence that was found that and in fact, the
- 19:24judge even declared that for the warrants that were obtained for
- 19:28that there was untruth. There were things said that were
- 19:33not true to be able to obtain those warrants.
- 19:36And so and then Can you believe though that shortly after that
- 19:40happened, they did get that grant from the federal
- 19:42government? It was it was several
- 19:45$1,000,000, all having to do with human trafficking.
- 19:49And but as more and more has come out of this and frankly,
- 19:53because they can't, they weren't able to prove anything.
- 19:56They were not able to 1 charge that they made, they were not
- 20:00able to prove it. This is just an egregious show
- 20:05of overreach of government. And we are just have have I
- 20:11have, I know the owner of this company.
- 20:15And what they have been through is it can't even be described
- 20:20what what they went through. And so now they've actually
- 20:24filed A lawsuit back against the Utah attorney general's office.
- 20:31I mean, think, think of the amount of stress that they went
- 20:34through. I mean, the, the authority
- 20:36government has and what it can do to people when, when there's
- 20:41overreach and there there couldn't be a better example of
- 20:45this than with the company called Rubicon that that this,
- 20:49that this all came down on in 2023 and then the counter suit
- 20:53was filed just the end of last year.
- 20:58Yeah. So what?
- 21:00What is your advice for entrepreneurs and community
- 21:04leaders navigating regulatory or legal threats like like the
- 21:08situation? Yes, do you know what with what
- 21:12I would say is just make sure you are just you are just
- 21:20documenting everything you've got your good paper trail, you
- 21:23have everything in order because then if something like this
- 21:27happens, you have a very strong case to protect yourself and
- 21:32these this company was able to protect itself.
- 21:35But the thing of just the amount in attorneys fees, you know
- 21:40what, what this cost and for people to innocently go to jail
- 21:45on Thanksgiving Day. That they were.
- 21:47Holding them in jail for that day and, you know, and then they
- 21:51got released on belt, but there were some of them that literally
- 21:54missed Thanksgiving with their families and and they didn't
- 21:57even know fully what was going on and.
- 21:59So, but yeah. When you when you go back into
- 22:02the details of it and they were applying for that grant and that
- 22:05they needed their numbers of, you know, numbers higher of.
- 22:10People that they were trying to protect, you can see how it was
- 22:14driven by money, this, this overreach.
- 22:17And so it just, we cannot be careful in this, even in
- 22:23America, it takes so many citizens being involved.
- 22:28And that's why we need more citizens involved at the state
- 22:32level because it makes it harder for the overreach of government
- 22:37with the more, the more eyes that are involved, the more
- 22:40people involved in the legislative session, the more
- 22:43people directly communicating with state elected leaders.
- 22:49That is our surest way to protect ourselves.
- 22:53And so that is the message I would give is, you know, we just
- 22:59we need more citizens. We we need more people that are
- 23:02willing to really get a little more involved with these
- 23:06legislative sessions. Yeah, yeah.
- 23:09And then the, I mean, this goes into another question about
- 23:14people feeling powerless when dealing with the legal system.
- 23:19And I I imagine the more people involved than the more support
- 23:24they have when their rights are being violated.
- 23:27Definitely. It's just less can happen when
- 23:32more eyes are on things. They just, it's just the way
- 23:35that it goes that transparency solves a lot of problems because
- 23:38they just simply can't get away with with unethical or, you
- 23:44know, immoral or just plain just breaking the law if there are
- 23:51more people aware of what is happening.
- 23:54And so that's why with our form of with our form of government,
- 23:59which is a constitutional Republic, which is the greatest
- 24:04gift that we have been given to protect our freedoms, is our
- 24:07form of government. It requires the citizens to be
- 24:12involved. It's not just, well, it's nice
- 24:15if they are, but if we're to regain our power, and that's one
- 24:20of the unique, that is one of the unique points of our
- 24:24constitutional Republic is that the people have the power, we
- 24:28have the sovereignty. That was unheard of.
- 24:32I mean, and, and you look back to Europe and, you know, as the,
- 24:38you know, when the Revolutionary War was happening, that is not
- 24:42how it was. It was always from the top down,
- 24:46you know, monarchies, dictatorships and the thought of
- 24:50the people have the power. That was literally a radical
- 24:55idea and we can't maintain the power if we are not really
- 25:02involved and just constantly helping to put checks and
- 25:06balances on our elected on our elected representatives.
- 25:11Sorry to interrupt, I just wanted to tell you about my
- 25:13sponsors real quick. Sometimes I get on a roll
- 25:18cleaning or gardening and I need a boost but don't have time for
- 25:21a meal. Big Fork Brands Pork Jerky is
- 25:24the perfect choice to keep my momentum, offering high protein
- 25:27snacks for on the It's a little salty and very
- 25:52flavorful. My discount code gives you 20%
- 25:56off your entire order and it's currently the best deal
- 25:58available. Just visit bigforkbrands.com and
- 26:02enter in my promo code JADE. That's JADE at checkout.
- 26:09Are you looking for gift for music lover or maybe some
- 26:11apparel to show off your quirky side?
- 26:14Old Glory has you covered. With over 300,000 officially
- 26:17licensed items covering music, sports, entertainment and pop
- 26:20culture, you're guaranteed to find the perfect item.
- 26:23They even have seasonal gear. My husband enjoys The Beatles
- 26:27and Led Zeppelin apparel and I love the Billy Idol apparel.
- 26:30I even found items for my fellow plant enthusiasts.
- 26:33This family owned superstore is known for their quality and
- 26:36customer service. Offers free standard shipping on
- 26:39all orders and orders are shipped the same day you
- 26:41purchase. My discount code gives you 15%
- 26:45off your entire order and it's currently the best deal
- 26:47available. Just visit oldglory.com and
- 26:50enter in my promo code JADE. That's JADE at checkout.
- 26:56Looking for a game changing way to improve your health?
- 26:59Zevo Life is the world's most nutrient dense whole plant,
- 27:02packed with over 50% plant protein, essential amino acids,
- 27:06fiber and antioxidants. Harnessing the best nature has
- 27:10to offer, Zeva Life nourishes your body while driving your
- 27:13performance, vitality and overall well-being.
- 27:16Each serving is a concentrated source of clean, well balanced
- 27:20nutrition designed to support modern lifestyles.
- 27:23And just one teaspoon a day supports your gut, boosts energy
- 27:26and promotes healthier skin and hair.
- 27:28It's no wonder that it's receiving rave 5 star reviews.
- 27:32Step into a healthier future with a 30% discount and a 30 day
- 27:36risk free guarantee by visiting Zeva Ivo dot Life and using my
- 27:41promo code to support my show and to receive 30% off your
- 27:45entire order, enter in my promo code JADE.
- 27:47That's JAVE at checkout. Where do legal systems often
- 27:52fail? The very people they're meant to
- 27:54protect. Well, one thing that I've really
- 27:57noticed is it seems like the legal system is so overburdened
- 28:02that there are more cases than the judges can can handle.
- 28:08And I think as as things just get too full, it's harder to do
- 28:16as good and as thorough of a job.
- 28:19And so that was actually another part of the judicial reform that
- 28:24Utah just underwent. We passed a bill that we added
- 28:29two judges to our Supreme Court, but we also added more district
- 28:34judges. And I, I also just was reading
- 28:37about the fact that in the immigration courts, they have
- 28:42just, the federal government has just added 42 new immigration
- 28:48judges because in the especially, yeah, if you look at
- 28:53the immigration situation, there are so many backed up cases.
- 28:58And so I think just like with anything, there's got to be
- 29:02enough, you know, enough people in the system being able to
- 29:05handle the amount of work that is given to them.
- 29:10And so it'll be interesting to see in Utah going forward as we
- 29:15have added more judges, how that dynamic, you know, how that
- 29:19effects effects our impact our dynamic here.
- 29:22And then, you know, in the immigration system, it's, it was
- 29:27interesting with these 42 new judges that were Pam Bondi just
- 29:31put them in, they are being led to different states in the
- 29:35country. But you know, we've just got to
- 29:38have enough judges that are being able to do the work.
- 29:42And so I, I think that that's one of the, the, the big
- 29:45problems that we have. Yeah, yeah, there's just not
- 29:49enough people to to give the the amount of time needed.
- 29:54Right, exactly. And the.
- 29:56Attention to detail like you said, so we agree.
- 30:01What role should. Attorneys and advocates play in
- 30:04restoring public trust in our institutions.
- 30:07So the very important thing that they can do is if they're aware
- 30:13that somebody's rights have been violated is they have got to
- 30:18talk about the details of that. They've got to go to the media,
- 30:21they've got to go to to social media, they've got to go to the
- 30:24public. So that these things are not
- 30:28just swept under the rug. And one interesting thing that
- 30:32happened with Rubicon is in this session that just ended, there
- 30:37were some changes made to the human trafficking statute in the
- 30:41state of Utah to make it harder for something like this to
- 30:45happen to a business again. And so there there were some
- 30:49good changes made in the law and, you know, hopefully saying
- 30:54that this isn't going to happen to somebody else because, you
- 30:58know, we've gone through it and these changes have been made in
- 31:01the law. And so we really do need to have
- 31:04the attitude that an in just an injustice to one person is an
- 31:08injustice to everyone because we are, we still are in a battle
- 31:13even in America, you know that we have to stay vigilant to
- 31:18protect our rights and the overreach of government.
- 31:23And I can tell you the very most important way that we can
- 31:29protect our rights is to understand our constitutional
- 31:33Republic. And as I had just said a moment
- 31:35ago, it is the gift that we have been given to have protect our
- 31:42unalienable rights. And so the reason that it is
- 31:47important that we understand what the essence of the
- 31:51Constitution is, you do not need to understand every word in the
- 31:56Constitution. You don't need to be a
- 31:58constitutional scholar and have to study it for years.
- 32:02I can just tell you the genius of the Constitution and what
- 32:06everybody needs to remember is the fragmentation of power.
- 32:10That is what the Constitution does.
- 32:13Think of power like a window and then think of the Constitution
- 32:19like something that is thrown through the window and breaks
- 32:22it. I, I like to give this
- 32:24demonstration to this explanation so people can
- 32:28picture that in their minds. Think as the glass breaks the
- 32:32pieces of glass. Well, that is like shattering.
- 32:36That glass is what the Constitution does to power if it
- 32:40is followed. And that shattering of power is
- 32:45the number one way that we protect our individual
- 32:49liberties. History shows us over and over
- 32:53again that as power conglomerates, people's
- 32:57unalienable rights decrease. It is just a law of, of human
- 33:03nature. It is just the way it is.
- 33:07And so when we, when we go back to the enumerated powers that we
- 33:12had talked about right at the beginning, the citizens need to
- 33:16understand what the federal government is supposed to do and
- 33:20everything else belongs to the state.
- 33:23And I can just tell your listeners a few of those
- 33:28enumerated powers so that people can get an idea.
- 33:32If you understand the enumerated powers, you get you're, you're
- 33:37at 90% of the Constitution because that is that, that
- 33:41separation between the state governments and the federal
- 33:44government. And then each of those
- 33:46governments is broken into 3 branches, the executive, the
- 33:49judicial, and the legislative. But so the federal government
- 33:55has the ability to establish rules for citizenship, establish
- 34:01bankruptcy laws, coin and regulate the value of money.
- 34:06So, so think for a minute of what do all 50 states need to
- 34:11have that is uniform. It must be the same.
- 34:15So if it's if it's got to be the same, then that makes sense that
- 34:19the federal government would be given jurisdiction over that
- 34:23because so many things can be different depending on, you
- 34:27know, that state and the unique differences of all the states.
- 34:31So standardized weights and measures, counterfeiting,
- 34:36counterfeiting laws establish a postal system.
- 34:40So think if we mailed a letter and in one state as a stamp was
- 34:45a certain number of cents, and then in another state it was a
- 34:47different amount, that would just create chaos.
- 34:50So, you know, if the postal system needs to be under the
- 34:53jurisdiction of the federal government, pass copyright and
- 34:57patent laws. I think if you you invented
- 35:00something and you could get a patent in your state.
- 35:02But if you cross state lines, the patent didn't wasn't good
- 35:06anymore. That would create chaos.
- 35:08So we didn't have that established federal court
- 35:13declare war, raise and finance the armed forces.
- 35:18So obviously, if we're at war with another country, the
- 35:21federal government needs to have power and jurisdiction to be
- 35:25able to protect us as a country. We're not going to be fighting
- 35:29state, state to state. They can call up militias,
- 35:35administer federal lands and tax, spend and borrow to help
- 35:41them implement their enumerated powers.
- 35:45So if you if you really study these, it's quite limited.
- 35:49And that is what the genius of the founders was, that the
- 35:54federal government can't do too much because then it's not going
- 35:57to be different from the monarchy.
- 35:59We just had to fight. And so many people died.
- 36:04The bloodshed is indescribable. What took place the suffering
- 36:08during the Revolutionary War? Because, you know, if we allow
- 36:13the American government to just start growing again, we're going
- 36:17to end in the same place. And so I would like to see a lot
- 36:22more discussion from our from our federal congressman about
- 36:27the enumerated powers and having those discussions of wait a
- 36:31minute, do we even have the authority to be doing this?
- 36:35And, and for them to have the courage to say, you know what,
- 36:38this is for the states to decide.
- 36:40But I can tell you a really interesting point with this is
- 36:46when Roe V Wade was overturned, it wasn't that the Supreme Court
- 36:52was saying that they either agreed or disagreed with
- 36:55abortion. They turned it and said this
- 36:59goes back to the states. They were exactly right because
- 37:03the federal government doesn't have the constitutional
- 37:06authority to regulate abortion. Those kinds of issues, medical,
- 37:12moral, family issues, those all belong at the state level.
- 37:16And So what it said is we'll send it back in.
- 37:20The states can decide state by state whether they're going to
- 37:25allow abortion or not, or how much or how many weeks.
- 37:28And that was actually such a perfect example of their
- 37:34understanding of the enumerated parts, the enumerated powers,
- 37:39and that they understood the federal government doesn't have
- 37:43the authority to tell the states in general whether we're going
- 37:47to allow abortion or not. We don't have the authority.
- 37:50And they hit it right on the head with that.
- 37:53They did exactly what they should have done.
- 37:55Yeah, you know, using the the stamp price is a great example
- 38:03to compare to abortion rights. The you know, the stamp prices
- 38:09will affect people in other states.
- 38:11What you. Right.
- 38:13One state chooses to do of the abortion rights isn't going to
- 38:17affect a different state. Exactly.
- 38:19Because, you know, obviously the mail goes through States and so
- 38:22it's got to be uniform. But you know, things like
- 38:27abortion, protecting children from pornography, medical, you
- 38:31know, medical practices, medical statutes, how how they want to,
- 38:37to do things, how we want to regulate licenses, for example,
- 38:42that that can change from state to state.
- 38:45So many things were intended to be done on the state level, and
- 38:50it is done better on the state level because when something is
- 38:54done on a closer, smaller level, it's done more efficiently, it's
- 39:00done more effectively, you know, and then you can take the States
- 39:03and go down into the cities, you know, And then you can see that
- 39:06the, the break up of power continues down to the level of
- 39:10the cities too. But the the Constitution, what
- 39:14it does is it sets up that division between the federal
- 39:18government and the state governments.
- 39:20That is called federalism. And a lot of people don't
- 39:24understand what federalism is because they think it means, was
- 39:27that making the federal government bigger or it's not,
- 39:31though that term means the balance between the state and
- 39:36federal governments as found in the Constitution.
- 39:40That is the term federalism and we have a lot happening with
- 39:45federalism here in the state. I'm actually on the Federalism
- 39:49Commission. I am a non voting member because
- 39:53I'm not a legislator, but but I'm a member of the Legislative
- 39:57Federalism Commission. And these are the exact issues
- 40:00that we're working on. And I can tell you that the
- 40:03chair, our chair just went to a meeting where there were.
- 40:08So many states there, Democratic and Republican states, and their
- 40:13whole topic was federalism. It is, it is spreading
- 40:19throughout the country. This, this basic principle of
- 40:23the Constitution. It's like there's just a new
- 40:26life and a new understanding being put into it.
- 40:30As the states are saying, wait a minute, why is the federal
- 40:33government telling us what to do on this?
- 40:35This is our jurisdiction. And I can tell you there is
- 40:39nothing that matters more as far as our individual liberty goes.
- 40:43I promise as the federal government gets bigger, our
- 40:47liberties will decrease. It has happened over and over
- 40:50again. And so.
- 40:52You know, if there's a take away for the citizens today, it is
- 40:57review Article 1, Section 8 of the Constitution, the enumerated
- 41:00powers and then get involved at the the state level.
- 41:04Even just something very small. If there's something you could
- 41:07do at the state level that helps to bring Government
- 41:13Accountability, transparency, and it also helps to push back
- 41:17against the over the overreach of the federal government and,
- 41:21you know, as the citizens do. Do our part.
- 41:24Then we're going to maintain this form of government that we
- 41:29inherited through so much sacrifice and blood loss.
- 41:32Yeah, yes, that's involvement at your local level is just so
- 41:39important. And it is, for some reason, so
- 41:42many people only care about the federal, and it's probably
- 41:45because that's what's on TV the most, and that's.
- 41:47Exactly. Yeah, you need.
- 41:50Really need. You can't.
- 41:51I mean you can. You can easily get to know, I
- 41:54mean a lot of state legislators. I mean you can you.
- 41:58Can get to know them just one-on-one your own state.
- 42:03I know my House Rep, my House senator very well.
- 42:06We text each other, I mean, at the at the state level, I just
- 42:10can't tell you how much influence the citizens can have.
- 42:13And that helps push back against the kind of natural direction
- 42:20the federal government always wants to take, which is to grow.
- 42:23And the states have to guard that, that line with jealousy.
- 42:28And they can only do it with the citizens being involved.
- 42:31Yeah, All right. This one's a little bit
- 42:35unrelated, but how do you stay grounded and focused when facing
- 42:40pressure from government entities?
- 42:43So that, that is an interesting question because, you know, even
- 42:50even on a state level, I've been working on a specific issue we
- 42:55have here in the state of Utah. And it's, it's an issue that I
- 43:00know certain legislators don't want it to be worked on because
- 43:05it it, there are some things that shouldn't be happening in
- 43:10the state of Utah that has has to do with developers and some
- 43:13of the special privileges that they've been able to put into
- 43:16the code for themselves. You know, it's, it's saying that
- 43:22even if you feel that there are people that might not want you
- 43:27to work on something that you know, is the right thing that
- 43:30needs to be changed and needs to be needs to be educate, educate
- 43:35other citizens about that. You have to have the courage to
- 43:39just to just keep going and working on it.
- 43:42And I'm kind of in that exact situation right now, working on
- 43:48this issue where we've got a very powerful lobbyist group
- 43:51plus some legislators that do not want to see any changes made
- 43:56in this area. And you know, and sometimes you
- 44:00do, I think to myself, why am I putting this much stress on
- 44:06myself? But at the end of the day, I
- 44:09just know what did our ancestors do for us.
- 44:15Why should I think that I shouldn't be able to have some
- 44:19stress and to have some discomfort from working on
- 44:22things that I know are the right things to work on?
- 44:25Why should I think it should just be easy, easy street for me
- 44:29after what people have done that have gone before us?
- 44:33And so we have to have the courage to to do what we know is
- 44:37right, even if we feel influence to to abandon that and to not
- 44:42work on it. Yeah, that's a really, really
- 44:46good way to look at it, is to look at what the people have
- 44:49done before us to benefit us today.
- 44:53Exactly. They just so many, so, so many
- 44:58amazing citizens that have come before us.
- 45:01I mean, look at think of the Revolutionary War.
- 45:04Think of, you know, World War 2 with that is, you know, think of
- 45:10the it's innumerable, the amount of suffering and the amount of
- 45:14lives that have been given for the American flag.
- 45:17And so if we're having a day where we're feeling overwhelmed
- 45:22or kind of like, why should I need to be worrying about this?
- 45:27I think if we just take a minute to think of the number of people
- 45:31that have died for the American flag, it it regroups us and it
- 45:35regenerates us and it's A and we say to ourselves, no, we are
- 45:39going to do our part. Yeah, if, OK, so if there's one
- 45:44thing you wish Americans understood about their rights,
- 45:48what would that be? I would say the the main thing I
- 45:53would want other citizens to understand is that sometimes
- 45:57that term, oh, you're violating my rights is is thrown out and
- 46:03it's not necessarily true. So the question is what is a
- 46:07right and what isn't a right? Well, I can tell you this, that
- 46:12are unalienable rights that are, you know, talked about in the
- 46:16Constitution. They don't hurt somebody else.
- 46:21So sometimes people so for example, like if you're in a
- 46:25movie theater and you shout out like fire that they a person
- 46:31could say, well, I have the right to do it, but they don't
- 46:34have the right to do that because that creates complete
- 46:37chaos and that that impinges infringes on other people's
- 46:44rights because you know, that is causing disruption disorder.
- 46:49And so sometimes people say they have a right to do something,
- 46:54but they don't have that right because it's in other people.
- 46:57And so with that is a really good rule for people to have in
- 47:02their mind is to say, now, if I am doing this, does it harm
- 47:07anybody else? And so we, we talk about that a
- 47:10lot with, with children's rights, protecting them from,
- 47:16from harmful material that, you know, what companies, people
- 47:21don't have the right to, you know, to, to push pornography,
- 47:26other material on them because it damages their brain.
- 47:30It, it stimulates their brain just like a drug does.
- 47:33And so, you know, when we hear, well, they're saying they have
- 47:36the 1st Amendment right, these pornography producers.
- 47:40No, that's not how it works. Our rights don't hurt somebody
- 47:44else. Yeah, Yeah.
- 47:46That's a really good way to think about it that way as well.
- 47:49Yes, it's it's a good rule of thumb that you know our
- 47:54unalienable rights. They're not harming other
- 47:57people, so. Yeah.
- 48:01Is there anything else that you'd like the listeners to
- 48:04know? You know what, I've just enjoyed
- 48:06being on the podcast so much today.
- 48:08And I think our, our listeners and fellow citizens, I would
- 48:15just again, reemphasize those enumerated powers, read over
- 48:20those and, and start looking through things of through the
- 48:26lens of the Constitution. And, and if you can see the
- 48:29federal government doing something, I, I challenge you to
- 48:33to think to yourself now, is that an enumerated power?
- 48:36And, and if it's not, say to your family, hey, you know what,
- 48:39the federal government shouldn't be doing that.
- 48:41That should be being done by the states.
- 48:43They don't have the authority and start teaching your family
- 48:46members because it takes every. This is the constant battle is
- 48:52to push back on the federal government's natural tendency to
- 48:56grow. And that's that's what citizens
- 48:58can really do and to talk with their with their families about
- 49:03it and say, you know, the federal government, they they
- 49:06don't have the authority to dictate that the schools have to
- 49:10allow, you know, transgender policies.
- 49:13They don't have the authority to do that.
- 49:16The schools are, you know, our bite through the Constitution,
- 49:20the schools are the state, state jurisdiction.
- 49:24So start having those conversations with your family
- 49:28members and start giving people to think about that.
- 49:31And you know, it's, it's just one we can never give up on as
- 49:35as long as we're here living, we're, we're going to fight this
- 49:40battle of keeping government from growing.
- 49:44But we can, we can work, do a lot within our own families as
- 49:48as we discuss this privilege of this form of government and the
- 49:52responsibilities that we also have to maintain it.
- 49:56Yeah. All right.
- 49:57Where can the listeners find you?
- 50:00Ok@utahconstitution.com all. Right, they can learn more
- 50:05about. About what we're doing here in
- 50:08Utah, yes. I want to thank you for being on
- 50:11today. All right, Well, have a good
- 50:13weekend. Yep.
- 50:14You too. I'll talk to you soon.