Latest / The Thyroid (and Hormone) Fixer Podcast: Thyropause, Menopause, Metabolism and How to Fix It / 639. The Keto, GLP-1 & Fasting Mistakes Wrecking Midlife Women — with Maria Emmerich
Transcript
- 0:00There's fat fasting, there's egg fasting, there's intermittent fasting, there's extended fasting, there's protein sparing modified fasting. I would say fat fasting is the worst idea. Here's the thing, you might see it on the scale, but guess what? You're gonna see a lot of muscle loss.
- 0:20Welcome to the Thyroid and Hormone Fixer podcast. If you've been told everything is fine, but you're gaining weight despite doing all the right things, struggling with brain fog, mood swings, low libido, or feeling like a stranger in your own body, you're in the right place.
- 0:35I'm Dr. Amy, The Thyroid Fixer, and I want you to know right now, I see you, I believe you, and you don't have to figure this out alone anymore. We're going to do this together. But I'm also not here to play nice with bad medicine or empty promises. This show is meant to disrupt the entire health space. We're gonna challenge the status quo, connect all the dots other providers miss, and give you real practical science-backed tools you can use today.
- 1:04You're not going to get any more recycled biohacking advice, just truth, strategy, and hope. Let's get you back to feeling like the badass human you're meant to be.
- 1:19My guest today is someone that has been on the show before, and many of you know her, many of you love her, many of you follow her, but we're going to have a little bit more in-depth conversation today. So Maria Emmerich, she's been in this space for over 25 years. You've seen her in the keto world, the functional nutrition world. She's a bestselling author of 20 plus books, mentor to Halle Berry, and one of the most recognized voices in the world.
- 1:45in low carb living. Check out Maria Mind Body Health, maybe. She reversed her own PCOS as a teenager through food, but her new book, The Art of Metabolic Health, comes from a much more vulnerable place. She recently dropped to 83 pounds at five foot two, just like myself. She's open about losing muscle and has been publicly rebuilding herself, rethinking fat, rethinking fasting, rethinking OMAD,
- 2:14And she is a pioneer in this space for HRT, telling all you ladies how important it is and how it changes your life. That's why we're two peas in a pod.
- 2:26So Maria, welcome back on the show. I'm so excited to talk to you today. It's always a pleasure to be in your presence. Thank you so much for having me. Oh girl, you have such, such a story. So obviously we have to start there. You know, I've been doing keto for many, many years. You have been an advocate in the keto space. I mean, giving women recipes to die for, living the life. But the woman that wrote this book,
- 2:51is a little bit different from the woman that wrote the earlier one. So take us into that. What happened? What did your body teach you that all the research you've done previously never did?
- 3:02Well, I went through quite a bit of hardships, having a sick husband for about 15 years to the point where he was bedridden. And during that time, adopting two children that needed a lot of attention and we homeschool them. I also was the breadwinner. Yeah, I couldn't do what I do without Craig, but just being like, wow, we could lose it all if I lose my SHIT, right? I mean, I just was trying to hold everything together, including...
- 3:31taking care of the kids, taking care of the house. I did everything. I never even sat down to eat because there was too many things to get done. And I didn't know if Craig was ever going to get better. And thankfully he did.
- 3:45I didn't take care of myself, right? We talked a little bit about this yesterday, about how important it is to take care of ourself and how much better we are to the whole entire world if we take care of ourselves. But I wasn't taking care of myself. And yeah, I got down to 82 pounds and ended up in the hospital three times. And it was a big wake-up call. And even though I went through that, the wake-up call didn't come until about...
- 4:10Four months later, I was walking with one of my best friends and she said, are you trying to kill yourself? And I was like, whoa, because this girl is like super hippie. Like she doesn't wear makeup. She doesn't wear chem. Like she's so chemically free and she's so positive. And for her to say those words to me, I was like, wow.
- 4:32Yeah, so it was a big wake-up call, and ever since then, I've been... I think people can see it in my face. My face is puffier, my muscles are showing, and I feel better than ever. So I think it's just interesting. I got a lot of flack for this. I don't know about hate, but just people were really hard on me, and I never fasted. It's so funny because some of these people...
- 4:55These doctors in this carnivore community fast for like 30 days. I'm not telling anybody to do that. I did not do that. But I just wasn't even feeding myself enough every day. And it was partly because of control, because everything else was out of control, but partly because I didn't have time to do it.
- 5:14I mean, I had two little baby boys that were like, if you've ever adopted children, you realize how much needier they are because they never had the attention. So I'm not complaining about it. It was the best decision we ever made, but it was just a lot of hardships.
- 5:31Maria, that is, that's a lot. That is a lot. That is heavy. Thank you for being vulnerable and for sharing. And I want to unpack this because as you were speaking, I was just thinking of the women listening and, um,
- 5:46What Maria is referring to is her and I did a joint collab class yesterday, and we really kind of touched on the fact that women have this tendency to put everyone else first. We take care of everyone else, our husband, our kids, our parents, our friends, our coworkers, our employees, like literally everyone else comes first.
- 6:09before we do, before our own health, before our own body. Let's give some help to those women that are in the same position. What was it that was going on in your mind, in your world, in your life, where it's almost like you didn't see or recognize what was happening to your body? Because I think so many women, whether...
- 6:30You're like in your case, you lost weight, you lost muscle. And then in someone else's case, they might be like gaining weight and they all of a sudden look in the mirror and go, where the hell these 20 pounds come off? Like where they come from? I'm all of a sudden blown up. So it could really go either way. But the core message is the woman is not taking care of herself and putting everyone else first.
- 6:49So I think body dysmorphia can go two ways, right? So you see yourself as your small self, the way that you looked when you were in your 20s. Well, I was heavy then. So for me to look in the mirror, I still saw my heavy self. And I think some women might not see the weight coming on because they hate going on the scale. They don't want to go on the scale. But here's the thing.
- 7:12I loved going on the scale. I know how gross I looked. Like you could see the bones in my chest. You could see all my bones in my back. But I got a high off of that low number. I was like, woohoo. And it's so twisted. And so I still use the scale as data. Yeah. But I'm trying to tell women in either way, they're losing too much or gaining too much. Using the scale as data, but it's not an all, end all or be all.
- 7:39What I would do is where my scale is, I also had my favorite clothes that looked just terrible on me because they were low cut. I couldn't wear that anymore. It looks gross. Or even like a baby suit. Like we all want to look great in a bikini. Well, I look too got. Like I just didn't even look good there. So having my favorite things hanging there and being like, I want to look good in this again. So this number is still too low. You can't wear your favorite clothes.
- 8:08Yeah. So it was data, right? And it could be vice versa. You have your favorite clothes, your favorite pair of jeans that you don't fit in anymore. And the scale, like using that as data, like it's, I got to keep up, keep on working on it. And the thing is, is some people hate going on the scale, but it's a truth teller. I'd rather know that I gained 10 pounds rather than I gained 30 because it's way easier to lose 10 than it is to lose 30. So get the reins going, pull the reins in at 10 pounds rather than a month later, it's 30 pounds.
- 8:37Well, and it's interesting, too, that you also mentioned earlier that control aspect, like when everything in your world feels out of control. And there's listeners right now that might be going through a divorce and they feel totally out of control. They might have a sick husband, a sick child, a sick parent. And then you really feel just like helpless, like, oh, my gosh, there's nothing I can do to help this person. I need to control something in my world to feel safe. Right.
- 9:02and secure. We feel like if we're in control, we have some sense of safety. So for you, basically, did you feel like food was the only thing that you could really control? Yeah, my whole life was out of control. Like I couldn't control anything. Like it was just seemed like it was a tornado. And my safe, what do they call it? The eye of the tornado? My eye was my food. And I mean, I'm really good at helping people lose weight. And so I know all the tricks
- 9:32And you used them all just to have that control. I shouldn't know. Yeah. Yeah. That's incredible. So, you know, I'm thinking too about even the women that are, they're confusing under eating with discipline, you know, and you and I run into a lot of ladies like this and we're going to dive more into the specific aspects of food, protein, all of that. But just in general, without getting into the macros, I think-
- 9:57women tend to restrict and under eat. And it's almost like they're giving themselves a pat on the back. Like, okay, I only took in, you know, a thousand calories today. And we know the detriment of GLP ones are helping people basically starve themselves. So it's like, okay, I only ate a thousand calories, only 1200 calories. Yay. Me, I get a gold star for the day. I mean, do you find that with your clients as well, with the women you work with?
- 10:21Yeah. And, you know, they're just kind of shooting themselves in the foot. We have to, macros are a big deal. Like what is that thousand calories made up of? Rice cakes? I mean, come on. So it's not just about that number. I mean, I'm not saying that calories don't matter, but we want a body composition that is strong. We want hair that's beautiful. We want skin that's glowing. And that's not going to happen if you're not hitting that protein macro, right? So I think
- 10:51Yeah. Yeah. And like that one, I feel like should be the free food. You know, like when you talk about Weight Watchers, they have like the certain foods that are free foods like popcorn is one point or whatever. I mean, I don't want to get a cease and a cease again, but the free food should be protein. It really should. Because the thermic effect of food is so powerful. You eat 100 calories of protein, you really only net like 65, 70. Yeah.
- 11:18Yeah, yeah, absolutely. So yeah, let's kind of get into that now. Now let's unpack the new rules with protein, with fat, with fasting. And you talk about this in your new book as well. So you used to do, let's, well, let's start with protein. Then I want to get into, into fasting as well.
- 11:37You just said that protein can be a free food. Let's unpack that. What does that mean? Does that literally mean that women can eat protein all day long in any way, shape or form and not be concerned about counting the calories from that protein?
- 11:53I don't think anybody should be eating all day long. Giving your body a time to break and heal other parts of your cells only happens in times of fasting. And that fasting could be a six-hour window. It could be a four-hour window. But just giving your time a break, right? But when it comes to protein, so carbs and fat are your energy sources. Protein is not a good energy source. Right.
- 12:19Oh, interesting. Okay. Yeah. So protein is made up of amino acids. That's what actually peptides are made up of, amino acids. So what happens is your heart tissue is always turning over. Your liver is always turning over. Your hair, skin, and nails. Autophagy is always happening. We do not need to go through a three-day fast to get into autophagy.
- 12:39Just work out. Work out, you're going to get autophagy without the downsides of the extended fasting, okay? Okay, wait, wait, you just said a big word. You got to break that down for the listeners. What is autophagy exactly? It's purging old cells. You know, you're getting rid of old unhealthy cells. You're purging them, which is a good thing. We want to get there, but you can do that with a really good workout, strength training, and it's just happening all the time, right? Your skin is always shedding every single day. Your hair is always shedding every single day.
- 13:08So what you need to do to repair those, if you want them to look beautiful, your hair to keep growing, you want to keep living, right? This is why anorexics die is because what happens is you steal from your muscles because muscles are expensive. You break those down into amino acids so you can repair your heart. You can repair your liver. You can repair your lungs. You can repair your hair, skin, and nails.
- 13:30But eventually, you get so lean, you have no muscle to take from. And it's extensive, like an anorexic state. And then the heart tissue, you know, I don't even want to talk about that. But what people don't realize is if they do a fat fast, if they do this 80%, which producing percentages will never work. You have to count your macros. Percentages are different. But like an 80% fat diet for a ketogenic diet to have higher ketones. Higher ketones is never correlated to better weight loss.
- 13:59But if they aim for this 80% fat, 20% protein, guess what? You're going to have hair loss three months later. It's not an automatic, it's not like a really quick thing, but three months later, you're going to notice a lot of shedding. But this is people doing the carnivore diet that way with a ribeye and a stick of butter. Like what? When you are eating that much fat, it's hard to get enough protein in because you're so full, right?
- 14:23So this is basically people doing keto the wrong way. Yeah. So now we're talking about, okay, here's what women think they will do to lose weight. Right. Right. And so they go, they research keto, they start doing a keto diet and they see, and I mean, I've said this all along too, there's good and bad keto. There's a variety of different ways to do it.
- 14:46So you have women basically doing dirty keto where they're eating the sticks of butter and the bacon and putting heavy whipped cream in their coffee and they're not getting in enough protein. That's exactly, yeah, tell us, break that down more because we do see the hair loss, obviously. And really we see lack of weight loss when people are doing that dirty keto with the heavy fat.
- 15:08Oh, yeah. I mean, again, this is why calories do matter. So I know people just want this easy way out where they're like, okay, I'm gonna do the carnivore diet. I'm gonna eat beef, bacon, butter, eggs, cheese, you know, all the carnivore things and the weight is just gonna fly off and guess what it doesn't.
- 15:25Because you're eating massive amount of calories and you're sitting on the couch. There's only two places for fat to go. Actually, three. A little bit goes through your stool, about 8%. If anything more than that goes through... Do you remember Olestra, the wow chip? Yes, yes. You do now. People are facking their pants, like literally. They literally, on the bag of chips, said...
- 15:48Warning causes anal leakage. Like how appetizing is that? So if anything more than 8% goes through your stool, you are going to have massive diarrhea. And this is only like three or four more percentages. This is not a big percentage that's going through your stool and causing massive diarrhea. You don't want this to happen.
- 16:04Okay. So the other two places is it's going to storage or you're going to burn it for energy, but nobody's running marathons after they're eating their sticks of butter. It's just, they're not. So mainly going to storage. And when that happens, your fat cells, most people can't grow new fat cells after adolescence. Okay. So hyperplasia, you can't really grow more fat cells.
- 16:30So people like this idea like, oh, I don't have a lot of fat cells. I'm always skinny. I can eat whatever I want. I'm always skinny. Well, guess what? You're more likely to get type 2 diabetes. This is called the Asian paradox, where they're usually very lean, but they're more likely to get type 2 diabetes because they don't have a lot of fat cells
- 16:47They're just more likely to get stuff full. And this is why liposuction is not a good idea because you just took fat cells out of your body. So if you do happen to overeat, you're more likely to get type 2 diabetes. But I want to back up to protein. Protein is where the nutrients are. If I put a plate of steak in front of you, a blueberries in front of you, a stick of butter in front of you, or kale in front of you, which one has the most nutrients? Yeah.
- 17:12The steak by far. My mom, I love her dearly, but she's like, no, I think it's the blueberries. You're wrong. It's the blueberries. I'm like, look at the science, mom. I have all of the facts right here for you. It is the steak. It has all the nutrients that you need. The butter has like CLA, a little bit of vitamin A, nothing really. So if you're starting your day with a bulletproof coffee with butter and coconut oil and heavy cream, whatever, not only is that dairy, and I think you would agree with me,
- 17:40When it comes to autoimmune issues, which everybody's dealing with Hashimoto's, we just talked to about, I don't know, 200 people yesterday with Hashimoto's. We poo-poo gluten, right? Gluten is off the table, keto and carnivore. But hello, dairy is a more common allergen than gluten is.
- 17:56But we don't want to address it because we already took all of our favorite foods away. Yeah, exactly. Exactly. And people don't want to lose one more food. Right. So when you're starting with a new client, will you allow her to eat a little bit of dairy as you're kind of transitioning her into...
- 18:16what her diet should look like, like, especially the women that are coming from dirty keto. They've been doing it for a while. Now they're coming in going, I don't feel any better and I haven't lost any weight. So what gives? I thought this keto diet was supposed to be the be all end all. And now they're realizing that like, well, maybe they're doing it wrong. So what do you say to her?
- 18:34I say, here are your meal plans. Eat these. You will lose weight, guaranteed. And there will be no dairy on it. No dairy. Okay, so we're going to write these no dairy. But by the time they come to me, you know, I'm not cheap. By the time they come to me, like...
- 18:49Well, I mean, I have free groups too, but they have gone through the ringer. They've done everything else. If they want my help, I'm like, here is your plan. Do this plan, and it's going to work. And I also tackle sleep. I tackle hormones. I tackle all that type of stuff. But here are the foods you can have in this amount, and it's dairy-free, gluten-free, you know, nut-free. That's another thing too. People overeat nuts all the time, and they don't realize how many...
- 19:17how much caloric dense that is and the oxalates and all that other stuff. But there's a lot of images where there's two hands and this one has like 500 calories worth of nuts. And this one has 250. They look exactly the same. Yeah. You know, I know. I'm not so notorious. I know. Yeah. Nuts, butter, all of that. And that, that French, that,
- 19:37That crunch you'll feel actually it's called sensory specific satiety. It's what you feel in your ear that keeps you wanting that crunch and you keep going for more and more and more nuts or pork rinds or whatever it is. Okay. So you're giving women meal plan. You're saying here, just do this. And the main shift in that is removing dairy and shifting their macros from that 80% of fat. What are you doing with their protein? Are you kind of flipping it on your head?
- 20:07Yeah. However, what your macros are is not going to be what my macros are. It's not going to be everybody's very different because we have different lean mass. And so if you want to use this, we have a free macro calculator. If you don't know your macros, you're not going to see the success that you will, if you know what your macros are. So there's a free macro calculator, ketomaria.com, use it. And it will ask you what's your lean mass. If you don't know, it's going to help you guess, figure it out, right? Most people,
- 20:34overestimate what their lean mass is because they don't want to admit how much body fat percentage they are. Right? Yeah. But we have some guidelines to help you figure that out. And it's going to tell you how much protein you need, how much fat is a maximum you want to go under. Protein is a goal. You can go over that. Fat is a maximum. Carbohydrates is a maximum. You can go underneath that. And then it's going to also give you a calorie count.
- 20:59So in a range, right? And then if your goals change, because everybody's like, well, I lost 10 pounds. Won't my macros change? Not really, because if you follow the guidelines, you lost fat, not muscle. So with any weight loss program, a certain percentage of it will be muscle loss. And we see with the GLP-1s, it could be up to 50%. And that's really causing more type 2 diabetes because muscle gives you more places for glucose to go.
- 21:25But if you're losing that muscle mass, your blood sugars are going to rise, all of these ailments are going to happen. The lowest you can get is about 2%, which is basically nothing. And that's with a protein sparing modified fast approach. So this is a tool. Instead of extended fasting, you just have high amounts of protein.
- 21:43low fat, low calories. So you keep that metabolic thermostat humming, you get all of the muscle building effects of that, but you can really tap into that body fat because there's oxidative priority. Your body has to burn first alcohol because it's completely toxic, then exogenous ketones, then carbohydrates, then protein is going to help you build muscle or lose it. Then you're going to burn fat and then you can burn body fat. So
- 22:09So if we cut out alcohol, exogenous ketones, carbohydrates, and fat, keep the protein in to build your muscle, you're going to burn a lot of body fat. Okay. So, oh my gosh, there's so much to unpack here. All right. Step by step. Step by step. All right. Okay.
- 22:25So we covered dirty keto. We know a lot of people are doing that incorrectly. The right way to do it to really see results with specifically weight loss and even the other health results that you get from it, like you mentioned autophagy, obviously that comes into just kind of cleaning house, getting rid of those dead zombie cells, whether we're talking about your skin or whether we're talking about cancer cells, right? From one end of the spectrum to the other, autophagy helps with that.
- 22:55by preserving our muscle and eating pretty much nothing but protein, even if we're doing like a protein only diet for let's say three to seven days, we're still getting the effects of fasting or autophagy, but we're still consuming food and we're getting in our amino acids. Do I have that correct so far?
- 23:17Well, I would say, especially if you're strength training, that's going to really help preserve and build muscle. I mean, you can't build muscle without some sort of stimulus. Nobody wants to hear that, but you need some sort of stimulus to build muscle. And that is also going to enhance the autophagy effect. Right.
- 23:34Yes, those two things together would help you get the autophagy benefits that you would get from extended fasting. And everybody, I don't know where this rumor started that you don't lose muscle when you do extended fasting. I mean, it shows nitrogen in the urine. That means that you're burning your fuel. You're burning your muscles. Protein is in the urine, right?
- 23:53Yes. Okay. No, this is all good news. And there's so much more I want to ask about insulin. I want to tie in GLPs, but just staying here for a moment, this is good news for me because we know, and we've heard over and over again, especially in the world that we live in, how fasting is good for cancer. And now last year I had a public about it, had uterine cancer, had a full hysterectomy, all of that. So I'm always in kind of battle mode right now, even though
- 24:23the cancer is out per se, I'm using air quotes, there still are cancer cells. You know, anytime that you've had cancer, there's going to be circulating tumor cells that are left behind. In fact, I mean, pretty much all of us have cancer cells that our body is fighting on a daily basis. Yep. So, you know, you hear about this like,
- 24:40Seven day fast, seven day fast. And I got to tell you, Maria, there is nothing in me that can do a seven day fast. So this is music to my ears. I could do protein for seven days. So I can still get those. I can do it for 14 days. I'll do it for 21 days if you told me to. So I can still get the same autophagy benefits while still consuming protein, protecting my hair, protecting my muscles, all of that.
- 25:05Well, I'm going to say if someone was in a very severe state of cancer. Right. Right. I would do extended fasting because it is going to be much more beneficial. But you've already beat it. You're going to have these benefits doing something less intense because you do want to keep your hair. You do want to keep your muscles. And with a protein sparing modified fascia, I wouldn't do it longer. You want three days a week. No more than that.
- 25:29Okay. Okay. Okay. Just because there's metabolic adaptation, right? Because it is low calorie. Okay. And so if you do three days a week, I want one overfeeding day. And this is not a pizza day. This is just your maintenance calorie day where it's not your weight loss macros. It's, you know, maybe some ribs or chicken wings or ribeye. Again, it's still dairy free, but you're going to...
- 25:55really just mess with that. You keep your thyroid guessing, right? We're going back and forth. We're like doing a ping pong thing. They don't know what's coming at them next, right? So they're ready. So that's where it's really, really powerful.
- 26:06Yes. Okay. This is fantastic. This is music to my ears and music to many people's ears. It's fantastic. Okay. So now let's connect this to insulin because I know you've been publicly open about how insulin is being vilified and it's not the villain. It's a signal. So for women who have spent like a decade demonizing carbs and being scared of insulin, that's a huge reframe. So let's unpack that.
- 26:36Oh my gosh, there's so much to unpack. So- I know, I know. When your fat cells get overstuffed, right? So we only have an infinite amount of fat cells, right? Most people, it's very rare if you can grow more, but we have fat cells, right? And small fat cells are happy, okay? That's what you want. You want these happy, small fat cells. But when they get enlarged like this, insulin is like a net holding everything in, okay? And your fasting insulin is going to keep creeping up.
- 27:03When your fat cells are really stuffed, it's like a net and it's like, I can't work anymore. Please help me. You need to shrink these fat cells. And if you don't listen, that fasting insulin is going to keep rising. This is what's a hormone, right? So insulin's a hormone secreted by our pancreas. And what's its job first? Tell the audience what's its job.
- 27:23A lot of people say it's a storage hormone, which it is, but it does a lot of other things too, right? Like I said, it's a net holding everything back. This is not the devil. The devil's in the details, okay? You want insulin. You want to hold this back. So a lot of the studies and even people in this community where they get it wrong, it's insulin in a Petri dish. It's not insulin in a human, okay? So when you add insulin to a Petri dish...
- 27:49Yes, things go to storage, but we're always producing insulin unless you're type one. And so it's such a different ballgame. And the thing is, fasting insulin is dangerous. But what I get upset about is when someone has a high protein meal. So Amy, you're going to start eating high protein. Not that you don't. Right. But you notice, okay, I was eating the 80% fat and my insulin and my blood sugars were always really low. Right.
- 28:12But now I started increasing my protein and lowering my fat. And now my blood sugars and my insulin is going like my blood sugars are like 120. Whoa, there's a spike. That's not a spike. That is helping you put protein into your muscles where you want it to be.
- 28:30So this postprandial insulin is not what we should be villainizing. We should be villainizing this fasting insulin that is way up here when it should be down here. And we want to bring it down here by eating high protein, low fat, your macros, getting some strength training on building more muscle. You're going to bring that all down sleeping. You got to sleep eight hours. You know, you're going to bring all that down.
- 28:55So all that will help lower. Where do you like to see the fasting insulin on blood work? Because I like it less than six. Yeah. Yeah. At least less than six. If they're doing their A1C then to ideally five or less, you know, five or less. Yep. Yeah. But they, there are people like Sean Baker, his, I think is 5.6 or something. And there's something to be said about eating high protein. Yeah.
- 29:21Or eating a carnivore diet, red blood cells live longer than someone who's not eating that way. Does that make sense? We could have someone that has, like Sean, has a 5.6 insulin, still really darn good, but we know that he's healthy because of the way that he eats and has red blood cells. Whereas we could take someone with an insulin of...
- 29:41let's say a three, but that's not really a true representation because I mean, I've even seen people with low insulin who are, they're low insulin because they're starving themselves and they're not eating enough. Right. Or an alcoholic. Right. Right. Because you're burning alcohol first because it's toxic. So they, alcoholics have a A1C that's always really low on it. It's not representative of their actual health. Right.
- 30:06At all. Yeah. So... We want to keep our insulin basically under a six in a healthy way. If you go too low with the insulin, you really have to examine your macros and your caloric intake. Because even though we've moved out of the calories in, calories out model, and it obviously...
- 30:22is very dependent on the type of food that you're putting in your body in the macro, there still is the starvation principle that occurs. And I mean, that's part of what tied into you dropping your weight is you were not eating enough calories. It's not like Maria just all of a sudden decided to like smoke cigarettes and eat one piece of pizza a day. You just weren't, you were still eating healthy, but you weren't consuming enough. Right.
- 30:48Yeah. And part of that, I was really completely nauseous for some reason, too. I got very, very sick. So anyway, that's I digress with that. But and I was saying how like you want the insulin low, but not too low. Right. You don't want to go into starvation mode either. You don't want to do all these things to, oh, I got to get my fasting insulin down. So I'm just not going to.
- 31:08No, that's not who I'm even talking to. I'm talking to people that are 100 and 200 pounds overweight and they're doing the carnivore diet and they're like, oh, people are telling me that I'm priming and I'm healing by gaining weight. I'm like, no, when you are already 100 pounds overweight and you are gaining weight, you are not healing. This is the opposite of healing. Even if you are eating just, you know, bacon, butter, cheese or whatever that they tell you to, you're putting yourself in a worse state and it's dangerous. It's called lipotoxicity.
- 31:37Yeah. Okay. So we don't want to vilify insulin. We need it. It's a hormone. It's a signaling hormone. We want just enough of it. And how we control that is, I'm just kind of summarizing, you know, the food, sleep, controlling for stress, all of that. Ooh, talk to me about that. Without estrogen, you become more insulin resistant, which means you're going to become more sensitive to carbohydrates, alcohol, caffeine, and fat. Yeah.
- 32:07Okay. So these menopausal ladies are not just gaining weight, especially in their midsection, because of the drop. Well, they're gaining it because of the drop of estrogen, but it's more what that drop of estrogen does to the other systems in their body. Yep. And women are known for their curves and their hips and their bosoms, right? Where men store their fat usually in their belly, but this starts to shift.
- 32:31they start to gain more of that weight in their belly area, which is, we know, the dangerous area to gain that fat. And a lot of this has to do with hormones. And I am so adamant, I know you are too, about talking to women about hormones, because it's so sad to me that only 8% of postmenopausal women are on HRT. It's insanity. I know. I know. I know. And yeah, we're going to end with that conversation because you and I have a lot to say about that.
- 32:57So hang tight, ladies. If you're not on hormones, you really need to be. You really need to be. But before we go there, I want to transition to GLPs because this ties to insulin. So here's the thing. We have all these people going on GLPs. And what I'm seeing in the blood work is elevated insulin. So,
- 33:17So here's me going like, wait a minute. We're supposed to be keeping insulin low. Insulin will, we know, drive plaque in the brain, i.e. Alzheimer's. We know that insulin is highly inflammatory and will pretty much drive any disease. We know the fastest way to, you know, if you want to wrinkle really quickly, keep your insulin high. Like you're going to look 80 when you're facing. Yeah, you're going to age quickly. So these people are taking GLPs and their insulin's going up.
- 33:47I was unaware of this. However, I do feel, and I've seen this even in the community, where people who have been carnivore, have been keto, they go on a GLP, GLP-2, GLP-3, whatever you want to call it. Yeah. And it's kind of like their freedom to eat whatever they want because they still will lose weight eating a pizza hut. And that could be why the insulin's going up then. That's kind of what I'm thinking. But here's another thing that I worry about is that food sits in your gut longer, right? Mm-hmm.
- 34:17with any GLP one, two, or three. And what people are eating are glyphosates, GMO foods. That GMO food was meant to kill the bug that was eating that plant, right? So it sits in our gut even longer. I feel that it's gonna start eating holes into our gut.
- 34:33Oh my God, Maria, I never thought of that. Like you literally, like if anybody's watching this on YouTube and you're watching my face, I was like a light bulb moment just like literally punched me between the eyes. We don't want it to sit in there. Oh my God, I never thought about that. All the times that I'm talking about people doing GLPs wrong and what they, you know, they're losing their hair and they're losing their facial fat and they're losing their muscle. I didn't think about the fact that they're making themselves more toxic. Yeah.
- 34:58By letting the food basically just sit around and release more toxins and more glyphosate and burn holes in their gut. I'm just saying, if you're going to do it, you got to do it right. And you don't want to eat any foods with GMOs or glyphosate or anything like that because it's going to sit in your gut longer. Yep.
- 35:14Yep. Excellent point. Excellent point. So, okay, in your world, and this is really kind of turned into a why people are gaining weight on keto and why people are maybe even gaining weight on GLPs or just destroying their body on it. So in your world, when you have these ladies come in and
- 35:35What do you do with them? Are you taking them off? Are you trying to transition them? Are you dropping, like advising them to maybe microdose the GLP so they're not paralyzing their gut and losing their muscle? How are you transitioning people away from that mentality of the GLPs are my crutch? And this is what has basically gotten me to my weight where I can eat whatever I want to and stay right here.
- 36:00Well, I do want to say I'm not anti. I do. I know there's a lot of anti-inflammatory benefits for SERS and all of the different gut inflammation, speaking of the gut, but this is on micro doses. Yes. And you don't want to take it ongoing. You're going to down regulate your receptors. So cycling on and off is going to be very, very important if you want it to continue to work.
- 36:24So the trick is to teach your body how to eat properly, teach your mind how to eat properly, and be able to cycle off of that without a tremendous weight gain or tremendous weight gain, fat gain, because you lost all your muscle. And muscle is so metabolically efficient, you don't want to lose any of that. So if you want to do a GLP properly, you have to strength train, you have to eat a lot of protein.
- 36:53And teach your body that junk food that you can actually get away with on a GLP-1 is exactly what you need to stay away from. But this is what I'm really concerned about is when people do higher doses where they're nauseous and not hungry, what's the last thing you want to eat? Protein. You're so right. I don't want that steak. I want comfort food. Yeah. It's so true. Like, I don't want to eat a steak, but I could eat those Doritos. Let's go. Yep.
- 37:20So making sure that the dose is not making you that nauseous. This is why I'm a big fan of the GLP-3 because it doesn't affect your appetite as much. But again, you have to be very careful about it because it is acting on glucagon, which is increasing your basal metabolic rate. So if you're not eating enough protein, guess what? It's going to steal from your muscles even faster than all the other ones.
- 37:44Right. Yeah. So they're showing even more muscle loss if you're not doing properly. I know a lot of bodybuilders are in it, but they're strength training. They're eating their protein. Yes. Yeah. And they're forcing it and they're taking, you know, all the anabolics and everything like that to protect their muscle. It's a whole nother world when we're talking about bodybuilders.
- 38:03Your average woman, and I'm with you, I am not anti-GLP. I say that over and over and over again to keep out the haters. But the reality is there's right ways and wrong ways to do them. And there are detrimental ways to do them as well that can do way, way, way more harm than good.
- 38:20But you need to cycle off of it. And if you didn't train your body how to eat, you're going to gain a whole bunch of weight when you do that. If you want it to keep working. Yep. Yes, exactly. Exactly. And the rebound weight gain is tremendous. They're saying at least 100% of the weight that people lost. And then sometimes it's like 120%. So people are rebounding and they're gaining the weight and then some.
- 38:43because their metabolisms have downshifted, downregulated to basically burn less fuel on a day-to-day basis because the body is used to, when you're on a GLP-1 and you're only taking in 900 or 1,000 calories a day, your fat burning shifts down. So you stop burning those calories for energy that you normally would, and you have a lower metabolic rate when you're coming off the GLP.
- 39:09True. Yep. Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. Okay. So GLPs to HRT. We teased this a little bit earlier. My favorite conversation.
- 39:19Oh, gee. And you're so right, Maria. I actually didn't know that it was only 8% of women in perimenopause menopause who are on VHRT. That is sad. That means that 92% of women are walking around at a huge increased risk of heart disease, osteoporosis, Alzheimer's, Parkinson's,
- 39:41cancer. And then there's just the aesthetics, like their hair falling out, they're wrinkling quickly. They're going to gain more weight in the midsection. That leads to type two diabetes. I mean, it's a shit show. Yeah. Low quality of life. Like why is that? Why?
- 39:57I think since it is kind of a slow progression, we don't even remember how good we used to feel. Do you know what I'm saying? Because I was there. I was like, I know something's wrong, but I don't know why. And it turns out my testosterone was in the tank. And people think of testosterone as just this libido hormone. No. Let me tell you, I am a very adventurous person. You will catch me on a paddleboard with the humpback whales just about every single day in February. Yeah.
- 40:26But I was to the point where I didn't even want to leave the couch. And I thought maybe it was situational, but I was like, no, I'm really adventurous. I love to travel to a third world country by myself. And I didn't want to do any. I'm very adventurous. But I was like, no, I just want to watch TV.
- 40:41And I was like, something's wrong. And I was not, I was lifting weights, but I wasn't able to build muscles. Like what is going on? And it turns out testosterone is that motivation. It's that drive. It's the thing that's going to get you to the gym or take you to having a walk or whatever. It's going to help you get to the point where you go to the doctor to get on hormones, right? You're at that point where you don't even want to do that.
- 41:06Yeah. It's like the worst feeling. And I didn't sleep. My progesterone sucked. I always had progesterone issues. People think of this as like a peri or post-menopausal thing. No, I was in my 20s and I had low progesterone. Really, really low. That can cause PCOS. That's the whole time that polycystic ovarian syndrome is low progesterone. They give me progesterone.
- 41:28Yeah. They were just like that. They gave me birth control. Yeah. Oral birth control. That probably messed me up even more than anything. And that's the thing. Doctors are so quick to prescribe an oral synthetic birth control pill. But when you ask them to get on HRT, when you're on perimenopause, they're like, that's going to kill you. Right. Exactly. That's why messengers like you need to be out there screaming from the rooftops. That's why we do what we do.
- 41:56It's just, it's really frustrating. And that's why I didn't want to tell my story because it's weird. It's personal, right? But I would have eight UTIs a year. Like I was in Bali and I went to the pharmacy and you could just go to the pharmacy and buy antibiotics. I knew exactly I needed cephalexin. That's the one that worked for me. I was in Italy, had to go get cephalexin. I was all over the place and I blamed it on travel because I didn't drink enough. I hate going pee on the plane.
- 42:24No, it's because I had low estrogen down there. The day I got on vaginal estrogen was I haven't had one since. And it's been years. Very nice. Very nice. I mean, I heard that we would save $6 billion a year in health care fees if we would just prescribe vaginal estrogen. But no, we prescribe antibiotics. Women, they get sepsis. They get so sick that they die from ammonia because of like a simple UTI.
- 42:54Yeah, absolutely. Now, were hormones on board for you when your body was kind of breaking down, you're going through that very, very stressful time? Were hormones there or did you bring them in as part of kind of your rebuilding Maria protocol?
- 43:10They were already there, but I'm so glad I talked to you because you probably don't remember this, but I talked to you back then and the doctor told me I was in the normal range. Now, my estrogen, my estradiol was like 38. Like you said, ideally you want to be up to 100. Yeah.
- 43:29to have those brain protective, bone protective, heart protective benefits. And everything was still low. Progesterone was still low. I wasn't sleeping great. They gave me trazodone instead. I was like, I'm not taking this. And tea was still low. But here's the thing about tea, testosterone.
- 43:46They said that it was extremely high, but I had such a high sex hormone binding globulin, probably because of the oral birth control they put me on. My sex hormone binding globulin was pulling my testosterone down to the normal range. Now, talking to you, I realize that high testosterone I had wasn't even high.
- 44:02Right, right. Well, you have to be flagged high as a woman to even have baseline normal testosterone or optimal testosterone in our world. Yeah, you have to be flagged high. And I'm so happy that you talk about SHBG in your book as well, because that is something, sex hormone binding globulin. And we'll kind of end with this because I could talk to you for another five hours. Let's just get the people to get the book and they can get all this information
- 44:32You'll be able to piece this all together of what exactly you should be doing. Maybe you want to work with Maria as well, but definitely get the book. Thank you. SHBG, sex hormone binding globulin. I talk about this all the time. So I'll give you my take on it. And then I really want to hear your take and what you talk about in the book. The irony of sex hormone binding globulin is that the very things that we do that are good for us. Yep.
- 44:55Like hormones, like thyroid hormones, specifically T3, like eating enough protein, like restricting your processed carbohydrates, all drive up SHB gene. It's kind of like, well, what in the actual F? Because I'm doing all these things that are good.
- 45:12And now my sex hormone binding globulin, which for the listeners that haven't heard me talk about this before, I equate it to like a sticky train where your hormones jump on this sticky train and they're supposed to be delivered to the different areas and cells of your body. But yeah,
- 45:28if the train is too sticky, the hormones can't jump off at their stop to do their job. So they just ride around on the train all day long. So it's like, why is it the very things that we do that are good for us drive up this hormone that we really don't want too high?
- 45:43Right. The same thing with people with type 2 diabetes. They usually have a very low sex hormone binding globulin. It seems so counterintuitive. Right. But just being aware of what it is and knowing that you're going to need to dose probably higher so you can get those levels up there where you are actually utilizing those hormones. So it's a really important number to know and not every doctor is going to run it for you.
- 46:08Yeah, no, I'm so happy that you break that down in your book because it is a very, very important number. Most people don't run it. Most doctors don't run it. And where do you like to see it? I always like to say like between 60 and 80. Once it starts getting above an 80, it's getting too sticky. Yeah.
- 46:25It is going to be really sticky, but it's really hard to also get it down. Right. So, I mean, you're shooting yourself in the foot because the healthier you are is going to creep up there. So I think minus 86 obviously is not ideal. I did want to mention one more thing, too, is I had extremely low iron despite eating red meat every single day. And I was like, what is going on?
- 46:49And the link between low iron and low testosterone is huge. And I didn't realize that. So now my levels are completely normal. I didn't change a thing except for get on testosterone. So my energy is better. Okay. Yeah. Energy, hair, all the things are way, way, way better. So yeah, the sex hormone, to me, yeah, 60 to 80 is ideal. Mine is higher than that. But it is what it is. I can't really bring it down.
- 47:18Yeah, so you just ended up shifting your testosterone dose to override the elevated SHBG, which is what we do with patients too. Same with estradiol because that was at, like I said, 38. And she's like, oh, no, this is great. Yep, yep. It'll bind to testosterone and estradiol first before it binds to anything else. So I always tell people, like, your thyroid hormone's probably okay.
- 47:42But it is going to bind to your testosterone and your estradiol first, and then it might grab hold of your T3. We'll see what it does. Then do you do a higher dose of T3 also? Yeah, then we'll just do a little bit of higher dose. And, you know, we'll see that in the free T3. Unfortunately, we can't measure...
- 47:58free estradiol. Like we can measure free testosterone and free T3. So, you know, we can see that free testosterone drop with an elevated SHBG, but you can't really see it in the estradiol as you're looking at the total. Right. So the total for me was what, 38. So
- 48:20That's crazy. Yeah. And I mean, obviously, if you don't have enough total, you're not going to have enough free. And people ask me that all the time with testosterone, too. It's like, if you don't have enough total to start with, yeah, you can look at the free, but guess what? It's going to be low. If you have a high pretty total, let's say you have a total testosterone of a 150, which ladies, that's totally fine.
- 48:42As long as you're not getting acne and growing a beard, you're fine. But your free could be in the toilet. So, yeah. Yeah, you have to look at the whole picture. I do not want to grow a clotinus. Just saying. Or a clotinus. I know. I say that all the time, too. Yeah, that's one of the side effects, ladies. So, no, Maria, this has been beautiful. So, we pieced together literally...
- 49:00Your journey, how people are doing keto wrong, how women are, well, we didn't touch on fasting. So let's end with that. So we did keto. We did GLPs. We did insulin. We did hormones, BHRT, tied in SHBG. Now let's just end with fasting to just tie a bow on all of this. Okay.
- 49:22Because these are, we're kind of, basically, this is becoming a what women are doing wrong in their life to their bodies and to lose weight. So talk about fasting. I mean, did you used to do OMAD? I used to. And then I realized it was miserable. I lost a lot of muscle mass doing OMAD. It's really hard, especially as a female, to eat enough protein that I needed in a day in one sitting.
- 49:46So now I make sure my first meal has enough protein, enough leucine to trigger muscle protein synthesis. And my last meal of the day also has enough protein leucine to trigger muscle protein synthesis as I'm sleeping. And I don't eat close to bedtime. I'm just saying that last meal needs to keep me going until the next morning. So I'm really...
- 50:09And that has really helped my body composition tremendously and my energy and my wounds. But so there's different types of fasting. There's fat fasting. There's egg fasting. There's intermittent fasting. There's extended fasting. There's protein sparing modified fasting. So all of those are covered in the book. I would say like fat fasting is the worst idea ever.
- 50:33Here's the thing. You might see it on the scale, but guess what? You're going to see a lot of muscle loss. Fat fasting means you're only eating fat. So we did, yes, I take it back. We did talk about the protein sparing fasting because that's what I'm going to do. Yeah. But yeah, I wanted to touch on the OMAD. And when you're saying fat fasting, the fat is just eating fat. Yes. Like sticks of butter, like cheese, only fat. Yeah.
- 50:57And people say they claim they lose weight on this. And I believe partly as you know, they're keeping the calories pretty low. They're not eating tremendous amounts of food. And when you lose muscle, it shows on the scale very quickly because you can lose it very quickly. Right. And like I said, those parts of your body that's always turning over needs amino acids. And if you're not consuming them, it's going to break down your muscle. So that's going to show on the scale. Yeah.
- 51:24And also there's a lot of water retention that happens when you're eating protein and strength training. This is what bugs me about women. They'll be like, oh, I did a really hard strength training workout and I'm up three pounds today. Like, yeah, because you just ripped your muscles apart. It's pulling all the water into your muscles. It's not fat gain. Get over it. Right.
- 51:45I love that. It's true. And I think, you know, I think all the influencers that once talked about fasting years ago have made a shift. I mean, Mindy Pell, Cynthia Thurlow, everyone has made a shift. Mindy has? Because I know Mindy was really into fasting.
- 52:00She is, but I think she's shifted away from, you know, especially for women doing these longer fasts. And I think we've all realized that 18 hours, 24 hours, even 16 is pushing it a little bit. It's so hard. Because women can't get their protein in, right? That and our cortisol. Like we have so many things going on. Like, yes, men are very resilient. They can push their bodies so much differently than a female can, but we are going to reap very,
- 52:28the detrimental things that happen with our cortisol and it's so stressful on the body and we don't have the same mechanism as a man does so it's just different but the whole thing is when you do extended fasting you are going to see nitrogen in the urine that is protein that you are burning which means you're breaking down muscle and you're peeing that right out this is not a good thing to happen yeah no all the studies even like
- 52:58The doctor, that's the big fasting doctor in Canada, his studies show that there's nitrogen in the urine. Is that Seyfried? Thomas Seyfried? Dr. Fun. Oh, Fun. Okay. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. And he's been on this circuit for a long, long time. Yeah. Long time. But I don't know. The science is out there and I'm going to follow the science. So...
- 53:20follow the science and follow what you're actually seeing in your clients. They're working. So that's the key. The Art of Metabolic Health. I love the title of this book. I love that you wrote it. Can you tell people where they can get all this juicy information? We kind of teased them with this episode, but tell them where they can find the book.
- 53:39The easiest place is to go to ketomaria.com. You're going to find the big landing page right on that page. But if you want, I have free groups. You scroll all the way to the bottom and join that. You want to join any of our retreats, they're there too. But yeah, lots of information at ketomaria.com. Ketomaria.com. We'll have the link in the show notes. We'll have all of our social links in there as well. Thank you so much.
- 54:03Oh, girl, thank you for going on the journey that you went through, for being vulnerable, for sharing it. I believe everybody is happy to see you rebuilding Maria. I'm trying. And yeah, and just coming back to health. And I wish you the utmost success. I hope your family is healthy and that Craig is healthy now and that everything is shifting for you. It is shifting. Thank you so much for having me on. It's always a pleasure talking to you. We're like kindred spirits.
- 54:29I know we totally are. I'm totally going to come to Hawaii and paddleboard with you with the whales. Cause now, now that you've thrown that out there, I'm like, can I come? Maria, February is whale month. Come then.
- 54:43Might come to Hawaii in February. All right, everyone. Thank you so much for listening. Share this episode with that woman that you know is out there right now, maybe even damaging her body, doing keto the wrong way and really struggling or doing a GLP and you see her losing muscle. Or maybe she's fasting too much because she's trying everything to lose weight and nothing is working. Yeah.
- 55:06Share this episode with her. Have her get the book because there's real help out there where you can lose the weight and be healthy the right way. Thank you so much for listening.