Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Religious Abuse
Transcript
- 0:00So we have a very special guest back on the podcast today, Dan Koch.
- 0:05Welcome to the podcast. Dan, thanks for having me back. So
- 0:08we had you on the pod or I was on your podcast a few years
- 0:12ago, and then I used that audio for my podcast and I recently ran
- 0:17that episode and I titled it Progressive Christianity. And the feedback was really great,
- 0:23except for one person who on YouTube I think, commented that progressive Christianity
- 0:29is not real Christianity. What would have been your reply to that comment,
- 0:34Dan, Yeah, you're gonna get those kind of comments on YouTube. I
- 0:37think enough people watch it. My comment is that who gets to decide,
- 0:43you know, like probably that person. I'm going to make some assumptions here.
- 0:47I'm not going to cast dispersions on their character, but I'm going to
- 0:50assume that they come from some particular conservative Protestant denomination. That denomination may or
- 0:56may not consider Catholics, Eastern Orthodox, Coptic Orthodox, Ethiopian Orthodox, and
- 1:02a Baptists. Other folks like that Christians. It's their right to think that.
- 1:06But I would just say anybody who identifies as a Christian and can sort
- 1:11of give some sort of motivation for why that makes sense for them, I'm
- 1:15perfectly happy considering them a Christian, you know, I the way that I
- 1:19think of it myself as like, probably seventy percent of the world's Christians would
- 1:23not consider me a Christian, and that's their right, but I consider me
- 1:26a Christian. So I guess we're at a loggerheads there. No like,
- 1:32you know, we don't have Protestants, don't have a pope. There's nobody
- 1:34to say definitively who's in and out. And so I would just say,
- 1:40hey, we could chat about it if you want. Of course he wouldn't
- 1:44he or she would not want to chat with me about it. So yeah,
- 1:46and I'm guessing the person didn't even listen to the episode. I think
- 1:48they just saw the title, they found the keyword. Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:52And you know, the culture War, which has now you know, encompassed
- 1:56seemingly everything in American life and maybe even what during cultural life, now you
- 2:00know, it's the culture War spares no one, no topic. So there
- 2:06are plenty of people who just think that their marching orders today are to track
- 2:12down, you know, the headline version of what their enemies think and post
- 2:16about how it's wrong. And you know, I think, like with YouTube
- 2:21comments or something like I just sort of pretend everyone's a teenager or something like
- 2:27that until proven otherwise, and then that doesn't bother you. It's like,
- 2:30oh, what did your teenager say? Well they said this, Well,
- 2:32okay they're a teenager. They're not. But like if you think of it
- 2:37that way, and then occasionally you get someone who's really engaging and you go,
- 2:38oh, that's what a brilliant young guy, what a smart daughter you
- 2:43have, you know, and then you can enjoy it and engage with them
- 2:46as a peer. But that's kind of just like a format specific, like
- 2:49a medium specific thing. Yeah. So Dan Koch is currently in his doctoral
- 2:55program training as a psychologist and also currently working with clients. He is a
- 3:02fellow Pacific Northwestern and he also has a previous life as a musician like me,
- 3:10and he went way beyond with his musical career by actually becoming a paid
- 3:16songwriter for jingles. He sold out to the man. But you gotta do
- 3:23what you gotta do. Yeah, and Dan, you emailed me and said,
- 3:28hey, I am working on Is it your dissertation that you're working on?
- 3:31Well, I am still finishing it, but toward working on my dissertation.
- 3:36I got this thing published. I developed a scale that measures potentially spiritually
- 3:43abusive experiences and some of the common effects of those experiences. So it's got
- 3:49like six subscales within it, and it's currently being used by some indeterminate number
- 3:54of clinicians nobody, you know, no one has to tell me it's free
- 3:59on my website. I've got a decent amount of feedback from therapists who are
- 4:01using it with clients who they think may have experienced spiritual abuse or religious trauma.
- 4:06So, yeah, it's out there, and it's a topic that I
- 4:10come by honestly, which we may we may get to the origins of all
- 4:14that. Yeah, and it's very relevant to me now because Berto and I
- 4:19did the deep dive on IBLP. Yes, I listened to some of that,
- 4:24and I also was looking into Ruby Frankie and Jody Hildebrandt and their usage
- 4:31of the Mormon principles and more generally evangelical current evangelical Christian principles to harm children
- 4:40in that sort of world that they're in. And through the research and making
- 4:45the episodes on IBLP and otherwise, I have come to realize, you know,
- 4:50I always knew that these movements were afoot, but I did not understand
- 4:57how prominent and prevalent and common and mainstream they were. And the way that
- 5:02I think about it, it's like the cult next door for all of us.
- 5:08You think about, what's that church and where they hold signs? And
- 5:13Hillsboro Baptists. Is it Hillsboro. That's why I wanted to say something Borough
- 5:18Westboro Baptist. Yes, God has right. There's like twenty five of them,
- 5:25you knowew very small number, very vocal, very noticeable. But so
- 5:30I always knew that little groups like that existed, but I had no idea
- 5:34that like a good I don't know, thirty percent forty percent, and some
- 5:40communities and some areas like in the plains, areas like in Illinois or something,
- 5:46it could be ninety percent of a community could be absolutely characterized as being
- 5:54indoctrinated into an extremist cult that believes in some very strange things and the way
- 6:00that they parent their children from day one. You know, not all of
- 6:02them, of course, you know, it's not all evangelical. There's like
- 6:06we have with clients and like doctor like prescribers know with medication. There's also
- 6:12like the question of real adherents. So yes, you might have communities where
- 6:17a really large percentage of people would identify as the type of evangelical, possibly
- 6:24fundamentalist Protestant, maybe doing homeschool stuff, maybe they've used some of the Bill
- 6:29Gothard materials and stuff. But what you do also find is like these people
- 6:32are skeptical of institutions, so they are they are not the kind of people
- 6:38to just go whole hog on whatever Bill Gothard says. Like the fact that
- 6:42they are homeschooling and not sending their kids to public school is sort of a
- 6:45testament to that. So I think my senses, I would maybe reduce my
- 6:49alarm is reduced by about fifty percent or something. Just recognizing that not everybody
- 6:55is really doing all of that. That makes me feel better. I'll take
- 6:58your word for it. That does mean you feel better. But it still
- 7:01is alarming that anyone would use Bill Gothard's education system. I mean that thing.
- 7:08I obsessed on that for like a few days and red it's dark,
- 7:13it's it is, Yeah, it is something. And how far a field
- 7:18that you would have to be as a parent to even begin to use this
- 7:25material. I mean, it just represents just how divorced they are from reality
- 7:29and from science and from the world and from the way things work and how
- 7:34well there's a lot of science skepticism and that has been built into evangelical culture
- 7:41going way, way way back. I mean, think about the Scopes monkey
- 7:44trial. I think that's was that nineteen nineteen, nineteen twenty three, twenty
- 7:47four, something like that, So we're talking one hundred years ago or whatever.
- 7:51And basically I know cultural historian, So this is just kind of what
- 7:58I've picked up from reading and interviewing historians and sociologists and stuff, which I
- 8:03often do on you have permission, especially around evangelicalism, because that's where I
- 8:07grew up and most of my listeners kind of grew up, so we're One
- 8:11of the things I think I primarily provide is like language and concepts for people
- 8:15to help understand like where they came from and where they are now. And
- 8:18one of the things that was super enlightening for me, especially in the wake
- 8:24of the Trump election and Trump support, was the extent to which in evangelical
- 8:31America, and I think Gothard is actually part excellence. He is a perfect
- 8:35example of this of what John Ward, who's a journalist and author who's a
- 8:39political editor of politics at Yahoo News and a buddy of mine. He calls
- 8:46parallel institutions. So essentially, it got to a point in America where you
- 8:52have enough evangelical Christians, and this could be true of like conservative Catholics,
- 8:56it could be true of It's probably true of Muslims. It's got to be
- 9:00true of sort of any religious subculture, subgroup. But evangelicalism got big enough
- 9:05that it could have very robust versions of all of the cultural institutions that we
- 9:11rely on in our secular life. So you've got educational institutions, you've got
- 9:18media, your own books, movies. I remember going to my buddy's house
- 9:22in nineteen ninety three and playing Bible Nintendo games. There was like they had
- 9:28their own you got what was this game? What's there was like a Moses
- 9:31game which Jesus, Jesus have a sword and does he like kill things and
- 9:37stuff? Oh, that'd be cool, not Jesus killing. Although I don't
- 9:41know how much you read when like the Left Behind game came out a few
- 9:43years back, and there was all this hubbub because by some accounts, like
- 9:50if you if you killed non believers, like that would maybe anyway, I
- 9:54don't I'm not gonna go that's like a whole Cameron thing, is it wasn't
- 9:58he involved? Yes, I'm sure it was with Kirk Cameron. Yeah,
- 10:01it's like that new kind of Kirk Cameron era left behind. He's really he's
- 10:05really letting my name down by the way. Yeah yeah, yeah, Well
- 10:09you always got Captain Kirk or Kirk Cousins, you know, or Kirk Cousins.
- 10:13Yeah. Which another religious guy, right, isn't he religious? Maybe
- 10:16a lot of evangelical NFL players. I mean, I'm a forty nine Ers
- 10:18fan. Brock Purty very very overt about his evangelical faith, you know,
- 10:24dudes from I don't know if he's from Iowa or a state adjoining Iowa.
- 10:28You know, I do think it's like we get a pretty well, we'll
- 10:33save that for Seattle fans. That he's a Niners fan is because he grew
- 10:39up in the Bay area. I grew up in the area, So he's
- 10:41not he's not born or raised the Seattle and just some sort of crazy person
- 10:45who decides to be a Niners fan. No, don't take it as a
- 10:48don't take it as a knock on my you know, cognitive capacities or anything
- 10:52like that, or you're worth as a human my moral development. Yeah yeah,
- 10:58no, but so you get this really really bust tradition. And by
- 11:01the nineties when I was growing up in evangelicalism, even though I was very
- 11:05fortunate neither of my parents are fundamentalists, my church was not fundamentalist, but
- 11:09I was aware of this, Like the kind of the totem for someone my
- 11:13age, for a millennial who grew up in youth group, was these ubiquitous
- 11:18posters that you would have up on youth group walls that would say, if
- 11:22you like Nirvana, check out Plank Eye, If you like Rage Against the
- 11:28Machine, check out Project eighty six, And there would be these Christian alternative
- 11:33band alternatives to these secular Can I tell you so this is exactly or it
- 11:41wasn't as slick in the eighties when I was in youth group in my church,
- 11:46but it was the same. It wasn't overt, like they weren't saying
- 11:52you need to or you should listen to this music. Yeah, but the
- 11:56band that they were trying to get us to listen to was You Too before
- 12:03they became famous because they were at least coded, maybe an interviews, because
- 12:07there's I think they're devout. I mean Bono's a devout Catholic, Yeah,
- 12:11and I think he has been the whole time. But they don't say overt
- 12:15sentences about Jesus. I mean, I don't know, man, it gets
- 12:18pretty close. Yeah, streets have no name name, but but but there
- 12:22we go. For a non religious person to listen, they wouldn't hear that,
- 12:26you know what I mean? Yeah, And so because it's good art,
- 12:30yeah, is what I would say. Another band was The Alarm,
- 12:33which was a like another British Irish I don't know that one. It's kind
- 12:39of like you two, but more fun, I guess. And some gen
- 12:43xers would know The Innocence Mission that was like a little bit more in that
- 12:46kind of R E M kind of gen x alt world. There was also
- 12:50a metal band, right like, what was the the hair metal band in
- 12:56the age, Striper Striper Riper Yeah, yeah, yeah, that dude is
- 13:01now a right wing culture warrior. The singer of that band or whatever,
- 13:05the main guy is the cultural war spares nobody Kirk. It comes for us
- 13:09all. Yeah, but you somehow, you somehow evaded. How did you
- 13:13evade. Well, there's I mean, I'm part of a fairly large contingent.
- 13:18I would say of you know, younger gen X, millennial and older
- 13:22gen Z who were raised evangelical. But I would say that the real determining
- 13:28factor that has separated us is that we have not shared their socio politics.
- 13:33I used to think that it was one's faith and the beliefs in you know,
- 13:39the beliefs that are a part of your religious faith, that is the
- 13:43real mover of kind of where people align themselves day to day, week after
- 13:48week, culturally, et cetera. I don't think so anymore. I think
- 13:52it's it's your socio political identity. And you know, folks like my wife
- 13:58and I and our friends, we look at, roughly speaking, our two
- 14:03choices that we have today. I'd like to problematize that and offer that there
- 14:07is actually kind of a large unexplored middle. But if we're choosing between today's
- 14:13sociocultural left and right, I mean, the right is like a that's a
- 14:18very obvious that's going to be a no for me dog, you know.
- 14:22And so if that if we're not going that way, and that's the way
- 14:24that they're all going, and all the stuff that they're consuming and all the
- 14:28things they're posting on Facebook, and you know, making Donald Trump their golden
- 14:33calf avatar. I mean, it's frankly preposterous. I mean, most of
- 14:37my friends can't imagine following whoever in their life has continued down that path.
- 14:45I flew down to California a year and a half ago to go to my
- 14:48old Bible study leader's funeral who died unvaccinated from COVID, And you know,
- 14:54I'm hanging out with ten or fifteen of my friends from growing up, and
- 14:58we're sitting there, we hung out the night before, and we're just like
- 15:01this just so unnecessary, Like we don't need to be here right now.
- 15:05It's great to see you all, But this guy didn't have to die,
- 15:07and he died because of the culture war. I mean, that's that's how
- 15:11I would frame it. And we, you know, we now can estimate
- 15:13maybe something like three or four hundred thousand Americans needlessly died because of vaccine skepticism,
- 15:20and he was one of them. And it was pretty gutting, and
- 15:24it also revealed like this shit is life and death. It can be life
- 15:28and death. I should say, it's not always I and I don't want
- 15:33to overemphasize that division as as unsustainable and untenable as a life direction that as
- 15:41that seems to me, there's still plenty of crossover. You know, I
- 15:46can hang out with adults in my life, relatives and other loved ones who
- 15:50are conservative and who vote for Trump and are excited to do it again,
- 15:54and I can still find things to talk about that talk about with them in
- 15:58ways to connect, and they can still hold my sons and you know,
- 16:00play with them, and you know, life can still happen. But there's
- 16:06just like no chance of me following them down that religious path. But how
- 16:11do you do that? Because I am fascinated by whatever series of whys on
- 16:17the road you decided to take to where you are today, because apparently it
- 16:22is very, very hard to resist. The individual that died as a youth
- 16:29pastor, I think you were saying it was he Bible study leader, Bible
- 16:33study youth pastor Jason Okay, Bible study leader. He was probably a loved
- 16:37person, a smart person, right, a wise person in some ways.
- 16:44And how what differentiates you from them? Well, I think that's a good
- 16:49question, because I would be tempted, like I think most people to locate
- 16:56myself in some morally superior camp. I don't think that that's the case.
- 17:03Man, I'm I figure there will be people who will know who I'm talking
- 17:07about, so I I want to I want to keep my comments about him
- 17:10specifically. I won't say much about him as an individual here. But the
- 17:15biggest difference, uh that I notice is like sort of living in too different
- 17:18epistemological or like knowledge or fact worlds, right, And you know my my
- 17:26sense generally, my my true personal opinion is that there is a lack of
- 17:33maturity in in a lot of ways in that world. The the biggest emotion
- 17:38I have felt about White Protestant evangelicalism since the Trump era is embarrassment. And
- 17:48that might actually say more about me and my own lack of moral formation that
- 17:52that would be my thing, not horror at people dying, but being personally
- 17:56embarrassed. Maybe that's a shortcoming, but it but it's incredibly embarrassing to me
- 18:03that I could have come from a world that has collectively made these kinds of
- 18:08choices. Well, what do you mean by maturity? Like, what was
- 18:12it that prevented them from maturing? Oh, that's a million dollar question.
- 18:18I mean, well, I'm curious what you think as a psychologist, But
- 18:22emotional maturity is not necessarily correlated with anything socio political right. I would put
- 18:29it sort of logically prior to one's socio political identity, label, identity,
- 18:34whatever right you can have. I know, I personally know many people who
- 18:41you know, are into all the correct causes, you know, they they
- 18:45sort of check all the boxes for a modern progressive, and I happen to
- 18:49know that they are quite emotionally immature, you know. So it's not it's
- 18:53not like that's no guarantee of anything, but I think that you know,
- 18:59people like Trump, they appeal to pretty you know, oftentimes pretty dark you
- 19:07know, places of pain, that people have, places of resentment, And
- 19:12it takes emotional maturity and maybe a certain amount of intellectual skill to recognize when
- 19:18someone is appealing to that darker part of you and to choose not to give
- 19:23them your attention and your loyalty. And so, just in a very basic
- 19:27sense, I think a lot of the adults in my evangelical upbringing fail have
- 19:33failed that test. It's also been interesting to see the ones who passed it
- 19:37from the beginning and then other ones who I really respect to maybe failed at
- 19:41the first time in twenty sixteen. I'm calling that a fail. I recognize
- 19:45that that's me stacking the dice or whatever. But then and then learned their
- 19:49lesson and have described to me how they voted against him in twenty twenty and
- 19:52kind of what they saw, the sort of fruit of the poison tree that
- 19:56they came to realize. And so, you know, I my hope is
- 20:00just that people would move toward maturity and away from hucksterism and away from gullibility.
- 20:06You know, I think the gullibility is what was most embarrassing for me,
- 20:08frankly, and that says something about me. Probably. I consider myself
- 20:12to be intelligent. I consider myself to be, you know, a clear
- 20:15thinker and seeing the world clearly. And I came from this world and they
- 20:18see things so unclearly. So I'm embarrassed by that. And Frankly, yeah,
- 20:23I think that's more on me than on them, probably, Yeah,
- 20:26But also it's true, that's really fascinating. Yeah. I just imagine the
- 20:32pressure, I mean, you being in Seattle, in San Francisco or the
- 20:37Bay Area, you know, the pressure would be a lot less, right,
- 20:40whereas if you were in other areas, the pressure would just be I
- 20:45imagine, overwhelming. Oh yeah, And it's not hard to imagine because it's
- 20:48the inverse of what I experience. Like I do, I think two things
- 20:53are true at the same time. Number one, I think that Donald Trump's
- 20:56vision of the world is impoverished. And number two, if I did think
- 21:00he was right, and I lived where I live, in my circles of
- 21:04friends, it would be an incredible uphill battle. It would require incredible courage,
- 21:11I guess is the word I would use. That seems kind of weird,
- 21:14but it would take some sort of courage to stand by my convictions,
- 21:17however false they might be. And people who live in Arkansas have literally the
- 21:22mere opposite. Every single person they know is on that train. And I
- 21:25think you would agree. We tend to devalue the amount of agency that are
- 21:33our groups and our circles place upon us to become the kind of people we
- 21:37are, and we overvalue our own maverickness. And I've looked at the data.
- 21:41Yeah, I say this to myself and on the podcast occasionally, that
- 21:47my political views are ninety five percent a result of the people around me and
- 21:52my culture. If I grew up in a different community, I would probably
- 21:56have vastly different opinions. It's hard for me to accept that because it makes
- 22:03it seem like I don't believe these things, or that I don't have agency.
- 22:10But you know, put me in fifteen hundreds France, and my point
- 22:15of view would be different. I do think science. I've kind of figured
- 22:22out that that's the clearest way to distinguish the type of Christian that I am
- 22:27and the type of Christianity that I am interested in. Sort of to the
- 22:33extent that I'm modeling anything, that's what I'm modeling. And I really do
- 22:38think that in today's day and age, that's a pretty good that's a pretty
- 22:44good marker, a delineating marker. And you know, I've personally come to
- 22:48a position where any theological claim that anyone might make, say about the nature
- 22:53of God or our role, you know, our role in the universe,
- 22:57or something about the Bible or any other religious text, like whatever evidence you
- 23:04can give me for that claim, whatever that claim is, is not as
- 23:08much evidence as as I can find for like the age of the universe,
- 23:14or even the fact that like CBT works, Like I'm more confident about that
- 23:19than I am about any particular thing I believe about God, you know,
- 23:25Like I hold my beliefs about God such as they are, like so pretty
- 23:30lightly because I just don't I don't have that much evidence for them. Yeah,
- 23:34what where they're closer in therapeutic language, they're closer to things like values
- 23:40than they are to things like firm core beliefs. And it's faith, you
- 23:45know, Like the leaders in religion that I always respected, when they get
- 23:49to this realm that we're talking about, would say that they believe, they
- 23:55have faith that God actually created a world in which you could not know whether
- 24:02God is real or Heaven is real, or that you know, the glory
- 24:07of God is real or not you have to go on faith. If it
- 24:11was concrete and scientific and data driven, then it wouldn't be a choice that
- 24:17you had to make. It would be just a conclusion that you naturally came
- 24:22to. And God did that on purpose, because God wants to give humans
- 24:27a chance to figure it out and to explore it themselves, you know.
- 24:33And that makes sense to me, you know, And it would help to
- 24:37have that point of view, I think, because when people start to take
- 24:42religion down the road, and it, you know, convolutes all their science
- 24:47and they start believing in the world is six thousand years old and that vaccines
- 24:52are of the devil, and you can't trust these scientists. So let's take
- 24:56a break and we get back. Let's talk about this measure that you developed.
- 25:00Cool, all right, we're back from the break. So Dan,
- 25:10tell us about this measure and how it's being used and what you've found with
- 25:15some of the results. I'm really curious. Yeah, it's probably probably good
- 25:18to define spiritual abuse first. So the way that I conceive of it is
- 25:25as a form of psychological and emotional abuse, but that is perpetrated by a
- 25:30religious leader or a group, or it takes place in a religious context,
- 25:36or there's some spiritual or religious component to it. Right, So it's like,
- 25:41if you are sexually abused by a clergy member, for instance, then
- 25:45I would consider you two have been both sexually abused and spiritually abused, and
- 25:49that those distinct processes would have you know, obviously it's different for every person,
- 25:56but we would if you have one hundred people or a thousand people that
- 25:59have that experience, you're going to find kind of all the sexual abuse symptoms
- 26:03and consequences, and you're gonna find these other ones about the way that they
- 26:07conceive of God or their faith, or the way that like problems practicing their
- 26:11faith basically problems using it as a source of hope and strength and stuff like
- 26:18that. So that's that's the very basic sort of thirty thousand foot view of
- 26:21what spiritual abuse is. Yeah, And the reason that it matters is that
- 26:27I describe religion and spirituality as like nuclear fission. You know, the research
- 26:33is pretty clear that whatever levers in US religion and spirituality are pulling, they
- 26:40are deep and powerful levers. I mean, you think about religious motivated war,
- 26:45you know, you thinking about jihad groups, think about fundamentalism. I
- 26:49mean, just like there are so many examples of when people get real into
- 26:52religion like it, those levers can move a lot within us. And nuclear
- 27:00fission, I think is a good metaphor because when nuclear fission is done well,
- 27:04we have like nuclear power plants producing the cleanest and most renewable and cheapest
- 27:11energy that we can imagine that we've ever experienced as human beings. And then
- 27:15of course when those reactors break down, it irradiates everything in a twenty mile
- 27:19radius you know, destroys all life nearby, causes untold havoc. And so
- 27:26that's why spiritual abuse matters, because when we are engaging someone at a faith
- 27:33level, we are engaging with them at a very deep and very central level.
- 27:38I'm sure you've experienced this with clients, and you know, we know
- 27:41as clinicians that when that can get engaged in a good way. You know,
- 27:47think about people who get clean in a twelve step you know program.
- 27:52Even if it's just higher power language or whatever, it's like it works because
- 27:57it's almost like by definition, because just if it's not dealing with that central
- 28:03stuff, then it's not really religion. You know, it's kind of like
- 28:06baked into the cake a little bit, and so we have to be aware
- 28:11of the possibility for harm and the consequences. M right. Yeah, that's
- 28:15good to emphasize because for I think, particularly non religious people, they might
- 28:19think of it as like a hobby or an interest totally that you just sort
- 28:23of do casually. It's not something that is deep and core to who you
- 28:30are. Yeah, I mean, like both my podcasting work, public work,
- 28:36and my work as a therapist are ultimately for me, you know,
- 28:41I think there's a lot of reasons that I like to do that work.
- 28:44But if you ask me what's the deepest reason that I do each of those
- 28:48things, it is related to my faith, because if I have any kind
- 28:52of faith, it's about my purpose. And so that's the backstop. You
- 28:57don't get any further down. Yeah, then your purpose as a person,
- 29:00and to have somebody abuse you through those levers, yes, exactly, is
- 29:06a very harmful thing for them, for those victims. Yes, So maybe
- 29:11the simplest way to talk about it is just to talk briefly about the kind
- 29:15of different types that the scale measures, and that's sort of a way in
- 29:19and I'll just leave a little space for you to ask a follow up after
- 29:22each one. So the first type I call maintaining the system. So this
- 29:27is when both leadership and group members tend to act in ways that maintain the
- 29:33status quo. So this can be victim blaming, shunning, protecting leaders from
- 29:38consequences, socially isolating those who are not fitting in, stuff like that.
- 29:42That's maintaining the system. Yeah, I'm reminded of a viral story from a
- 29:48few years ago. I think, if I have it right, where a
- 29:52minister of a church was caught and admitted to having sexually abused a teenage girl,
- 30:00maybe another person as well, and he I think gave a sermon to
- 30:08what seemed to be the congregation was on board with his thing, which was
- 30:15that he did a lot of soul searching and had had some shame and some
- 30:19pain about it, but he had come out the other end, renewed and
- 30:22having and so he had just proclaimed that everything is now okay, and let's
- 30:30all forget about it and move forward. And there can be a lot of
- 30:33pressure to maintain a system. The system is working in a lot of ways,
- 30:38and sometimes the system is working in like pretty tangibly good ways. Maybe
- 30:41this church is like doing a ton of homeless ministry, and maybe there,
- 30:45you know, like there can be even good reasons to maintain the system.
- 30:52But if it comes at the expense of victims, then it's spiritually abusive.
- 30:56It just is right. So for that victim and maybe other victims watching it,
- 31:02they would feel both harmed by the victimization, but then doubly harmed by
- 31:08the congregation who de emphasizes the victim's experience and rights and continues to kind of
- 31:18worship the leader of the church, who is the abuser and the perpetrator.
- 31:22Yeah, imagine that you're one of the military families that Trump mocked or whatever,
- 31:26the families who lost the gold Star families or whatever. And then it's
- 31:32like, okay, so let's say you're a Republican and you think, hey,
- 31:36I've been a Republican my whole life, like we're a military family,
- 31:38and then Trump uses you like thinks that you are some sort of threat to
- 31:44him, so he turns that into like a Trump issue, and then you
- 31:48get threatening letters at your address from you know, rabid Trump supporters about you
- 31:56know, how dare you endanger our republic and give the Democrats a you know
- 32:00whatever. Then like you could be like, I guess I'm not welcome in
- 32:04the GOP anymore like you you would, you would? And now I guess
- 32:08if that's where I had made friends, made business contacts, if that's where
- 32:13I felt comfortable, if those are the parties that we went to, if
- 32:15these are our friend's kids, And now that's gone because the leader did this
- 32:22and everyone else piled on and so now like that whole structure is no longer
- 32:25available to us. That's what it's like for someone who's on the other side
- 32:30of these scandals, when it's when they double down. Yeah, okay,
- 32:34so your measure gets at assessing if that was a dimension of the spiritual abuse?
- 32:39What what what kind of what kind of questions? What kind of questions?
- 32:43Yeah? So that one. Like so they're all basically, uh,
- 32:45you know, indicate the extent to which you've experienced each across your lifelong church
- 32:51or religious group experience. It's it's only really normed on Christianity. There'd be
- 32:55it'd be interesting, and there's some people working on doing this in other cultures,
- 33:00their languages and other religions. I'm excited to see where that goes.
- 33:05Being expected to consult my pastor or a leader before making non religious decisions falls.
- 33:09Oh, I'm sorry, I just skipped them around. I rather that's
- 33:14the wrong one. Okay, hold on, let me get the order correct.
- 33:19Okay. So for maintaining the status quo or maintaining the system we've got,
- 33:25being shunned or ignored by my pastor or group, being pressured to forgive
- 33:30an abuser while the abuse was ongoing, seeing the leadership or group protecting or
- 33:35elevating abusive individuals, being blamed for harm that I suffered rather than blaming those
- 33:39who harmed me and my church community abandoning me in a difficult time. Right,
- 33:45Okay, so that's very much in line with the anecdote, or the
- 33:50least the version of the story. Do you remember that that viral story that
- 33:52came out that particular a video someone had leaked or something of him giving this
- 34:01speech, and it's pretty gross from my memory, but anyway, yeah,
- 34:06okay, So when you ask people about this dimension, what sort of experiences
- 34:15do you get? What do you hear from people? There are? I
- 34:17mean, what's interesting about religious experience? It's so wide, right, so
- 34:23any version you can imagine, you know, like someone has experienced that.
- 34:28So I've definitely heard people talk a lot about yeah, like odd ways that
- 34:34they were sort of monitored, you know. And definitely a lot of people,
- 34:38a lot of pastors, I think, and I get this, but
- 34:43they come to believe that their wisdom extends beyond the spiritual realm, so to
- 34:50speak. And you know, look, if you honestly believe that God has
- 34:54called you to be a shepherd of a bunch of people, then it's not
- 35:00a big logical leap to think that you might have some things that would help
- 35:04them beyond simply how to interpret this passage in the Gospel of Matthew right,
- 35:09like you might have some real practical wisdom, and I get that, like
- 35:15us therapist actually will fall prey to this where yes, we have expertise in
- 35:20training, and it will make our heads so big that we think that we
- 35:24can provide advice on all sorts of shit, or advice in general. I
- 35:29mean, we're not trained on how to tell people what to do with their
- 35:31life, you know, and we have to. I always think about the
- 35:37triumph in Roman history that, at least from my memory, that they would
- 35:43be celebrating Julius Caesar or whatever general, and as a way to keep them
- 35:49in check, they would have a slave behind them whispering in their ear saying,
- 35:54you are not a god. You are not a god. You are
- 35:58human. You are not a god, even though you're being treated like one,
- 36:00and you might start to be tempted to think that you're a god.
- 36:05You know, we are a Roman Republican, you are not a god.
- 36:07I find to be eloquently poetic in terms of we all need that voice in
- 36:15our head that is telling us keep it in check, keep it in check,
- 36:20because especially as we're being worshiped. Right, Clients don't quote unquote worship
- 36:25us, but they could very much respect us, right, And society can
- 36:29very much respect us, particularly if you're a minister that has a lot of
- 36:35followers that are hanging on your every word. You're a celebrity. You know
- 36:38they want your autograph, they want selfies with you, and you think of
- 36:43yourself as being closer to God than It can be very tempting to take that
- 36:50and run with it totally. And I think I did sort of I misspoken
- 36:53in terms of that's actually an example from the controlling leadership part. And you
- 36:59asked me for an exile from the maintaining the system, and what I'll say
- 37:02about maintaining the system. One of the interesting ways this shows up is around
- 37:06sexuality and gender. So there's a lot of blaming young women for even what
- 37:13the church would consider the sinful desires and actions of men. Like there just
- 37:19is it is like this kind of Jezebel theme, this sort of scarlet letter
- 37:23theme in Western tradition that we just cannot seem to get away from, where
- 37:29you know, the woman has to be the temptress and has to be the
- 37:32villain and men often get a huge pass, and that can go all the
- 37:38way to like proper sexual assault and abuse, all the way down to much
- 37:45smaller things like just like a more innocuous story that I've heard so many times
- 37:50is like at a Christian youth camp, you know, the female counselors being
- 37:55docked for the length of their shorts and how much leg they're showing while the
- 38:00male counselors are going around in boy shorts, and nobody says anything about it.
- 38:07And it's like, Okay, that's a pretty obvious, like just make
- 38:09that standard the same, you know, And that's the kind of thing that
- 38:13often doesn't happen, and so then women can be made to feel like they
- 38:17are particularly to blame for the problems in this community. It's almost like a
- 38:22you know, well eveate the apple. It's almost that level of bullshit,
- 38:27you know, yeah, yeah. I mean, when you have a power
- 38:30structure for hundreds of years that is not only dominated but monopolized by men,
- 38:37then you're going to have philosophy creep that will favor men, right, And
- 38:45it's not a mystery, and we need to be pushing back. Okay,
- 38:49So what's another dimension in your measure? Yeah, I think you'll like talking
- 38:52about this one because it intersects for me in interesting ways with you know,
- 38:59peer viewed research and best practices. So I call the form of abuse here
- 39:04embracing violence. And what I say is that communities may see violence in many
- 39:10forms as a necessary part of God's plan for the world. They may lack
- 39:15concern about what's appropriate for children in terms of fear, and they may often
- 39:22employ terror and horror to motivate religious commitment or moral behavior. So you can
- 39:28think of hell houses if you've ever heard of these, like very popular in
- 39:32the South and the Midwest. Like around Halloween, a church will put on
- 39:37basically a haunted house, except it's all the things you can expect will happen
- 39:42to you if you are not saved, Oh my God, and children,
- 39:45demons and well, I mean there might be I would hope obviously the more
- 39:50responsible ones would have an age limit, you know, or something like that.
- 39:53But I mean teenagers are certainly going into these things, and probably all
- 39:57cases. Teenagers like being st They like horror movies, you know that,
- 40:01they like being shoved into the arms of each other through their shared experience of
- 40:09fear. But yeah, and this is actually kind of where where my own
- 40:15story brought me to studying spiritual abuse, because my number one source of religious
- 40:21trauma by far was being exposed to you know, what we call end Times
- 40:27teachings at way too young of an age. So I'm in sixth grade and
- 40:30someone gives me a book in April about how Jesus is going to return that
- 40:36September, and I'm eleven. And for people who don't know the version of
- 40:43the rapture that is told to people in this camp, can you tell what
- 40:50you were? I'll fill that in. So there's a view that is popular
- 40:52and fundamentalist Protestantism called it's called premillennial dispensationialism. But that's just a fancy way
- 40:59of saying saying that God deals with humanity and the world in these different periods
- 41:04of time known as dispensations. And on that view, there's certain other passages
- 41:08in the Bible that people interpret to be there will be this thing called the
- 41:13Rapture and every believer will be taken up into the sky by God in an
- 41:19instant. I mean, the Left Behind film with Nicholas Cage documents this very
- 41:24moment, very weird film. But I did watch it, and you know,
- 41:30the idea is that everybody else is left here, there's gonna be an
- 41:32Antichrist. It's gonna be seven years of all fucking hell breaking loose, and
- 41:37then at the end there's like the Battle of Armageddon and Jesus and his army
- 41:40like slay all the evil beings, including people and demons, and Satan gets
- 41:45thrown into the Lake of fire, and then we have a thousand years.
- 41:49I might be getting some of the timeline wrong here, because it's all bullshit,
- 41:52but anyway, so this view is like, there's just essentially no evidence
- 41:57for this view, but it's very popular. Of the kind of big questions
- 42:00of my public work life is like, how is that so popular given how
- 42:05little evidence there is for it? But it was. It was brought to
- 42:09my attention at age eleven, and as you might imagine an eleven year old
- 42:13who was being told by an adult, hey, probably you're going to die
- 42:16in six months, but don't worry. You'll be good. You'll be going
- 42:21to heaven with Jesus. But if you don't, unless you are in your
- 42:25heart not a good Christian, and therefore you any sin if you think a
- 42:35bad thought or you have a lustful urge, and for whatever reason God determines
- 42:42that you are one of the wicked or not pure enough, then you're not
- 42:47in. Then you will suffer in and your parents, your entire family might
- 42:53disappear in an instant in the rapture and you're going to be left alone because
- 42:57you had a lustful thought for Jennifer who sins it's in your science class across
- 43:01across the room, and that kind of pressure, you know, and just
- 43:05that constant because you know, when I was a kid, I learned about
- 43:08the rapture. We read revelation, but it wasn't emphasized, and it certainly
- 43:14wasn't told to us that it was around the corner for cran out loud.
- 43:17It was told to us like, well, you know, maybe one day
- 43:22it'll but it could be all metaphor. And also, uh, you know,
- 43:25Paul who wrote this might have actually been trying to like motivate people on
- 43:32the ground in this particular region. It might not actually be this like four
- 43:39because it's a very different book in the Bible. It's it's a very different
- 43:43tone, it has a very different message, and no other writing in the
- 43:47bi in the New Testament is along with Jesus never talks about this, for
- 43:51example, and so that was all told to me when I was young,
- 43:54and so I didn't what I did worry about a nice liberal Christian education.
- 43:59There I did worry about as a kid was the end times that were actually
- 44:05possible, which was Reagan and the USSR going head to head with total nuclear
- 44:13annihilation in the early eighties. That was a very real possibility. That did
- 44:17terrify me, you know, the day after all. But anyway, so
- 44:21that's another Yeah, this is common. I have heard a lot. In
- 44:23fact, one of my favorite podcasts, TBTL Luke Burbank talks about how this
- 44:29really hurt him. He was given this message and he even had his mom
- 44:34on the podcast recently and he asked her, like, do you think it
- 44:37was a bad idea that you exposed me to? Because I would lay awake
- 44:42at night just terrified that What did she say? It was interesting conversation because
- 44:49her I don't know, you kind of have to know their personalities, but
- 44:52she's a very fun, energetic person who might at times not really absorb what
- 44:59is happening in the moment. It kind of had that look to it,
- 45:01you know. I think she loves Luke a lot and cares. Plus you
- 45:06know, I think it's tremendously painful. I imagined for her to think about
- 45:10how she might have harmed her kids. Absolutely, and and a lot of
- 45:15us are asking this of our parents, our aunts and uncles, our grandparents,
- 45:19and you know, well, you know, my I've talked with my
- 45:23mom about that one, because we both read the Left Behind books. What
- 45:29their memory of all this stuff is different than mine in some crucial ways.
- 45:32And now I know enough about developmental stuff and memory to I know enough to
- 45:37not know whose memories are correct in that respect. You know, I think
- 45:43if you know, when my son comes to me and talks about stuff that
- 45:45happened when he was six years old, I'm probably gonna think that I have
- 45:47a better memory of it, so you know, now that I'm a parent.
- 45:52But yeah, I got more of it from school. That was really
- 45:57where the I went to Christian schools from sixth grade on and that was really
- 46:01the most damaging thing. Not so much stuff from my parents. I got
- 46:06my panic attacks from my mom, So we really, you know, we
- 46:08bond over that. But yeah, I mean, I think I think that
- 46:14maybe Luke Burbank's mom is a good example of the reality on the ground,
- 46:19which is that again, like people buy this stuff to varying degrees. One
- 46:25of the things that I have found about people who find my podcast helpful,
- 46:30and it's true of me as well, is like we were the ones who
- 46:32really believed it. Like, if you're forty today and still thinking about this
- 46:37stuff, even if you don't believe it anymore, it matters to you because
- 46:40you really did at one point. Right. Otherwise it's no big deal.
- 46:45It just goes off your back, you know. But I wasn't one of
- 46:50those people. Now, thankfully, I never thought I would go to hell.
- 46:52And I've had many clients for whom that sneaking suspicion that like they're outside
- 46:57of God's good graces. I mean that encoding goes deep and you know we
- 47:01yeah, I mean eternal damnation. I was exposed to that, but not
- 47:07not to the degree that would Did you ever think you were probably going to
- 47:10Hell? No, not at all. But I do remember it being told
- 47:16to me and believing the version of hell within this. I don't know this
- 47:22area of Christianity United States where it's eternal pain and fear and you know,
- 47:30eternal damnation just like the worst pain and the worst in you know, situation
- 47:37that you've ever been in constantly for every second for eternity. And that is
- 47:44something, you know, that's something to think about and something to expose a
- 47:47child to. I know, it really is, and and that's really that's
- 47:52why I mentioned science was like, you know, I am this is a
- 47:53good example of actually the kind of progressive Christianity or liberal Christianity that I'm I'm
- 48:00talking about, which is like, if there's a question about when to expose
- 48:05my sons to certain kinds of ideas, I don't you know, fucking C.
- 48:13S. Lewis could manifest himself on my front porch and I'm still going
- 48:17to go with whatever the developmental researchers say, you know, like there's just
- 48:21no one could give me a sufficient theological argument for what my seven year old
- 48:28needs to know based on their reading of whatever that would trump, you know
- 48:32what, like just the best, like the American Pediatric Association would tell me,
- 48:37or something like that, Like that's where I'm at and that those are
- 48:40the decisions that we will make for for our boys in terms of what they
- 48:45most Most parents who would at the same time expose their children to these ideas
- 48:52would not have them watch a rat at R movie right, right, But
- 48:57rated our movies are far from as harmful as telling because it's a fictional movie.
- 49:02It's contained a fictional story. Telling kids about these extreme ideas that are
- 49:12not held by even I don't even know the majority of Christians believe in it
- 49:16is harmful. And for these groups to overlook their parental instincts, I think
- 49:25demonstrates the power and the cultification. I think of a lot of these groups,
- 49:30you know, they they are being indoctrinated early, right, and they
- 49:37the leaders and the mindset are you know, are more important than anything else,
- 49:45you know, upholding the status quo and keeping the power structure in place.
- 49:52I think because they feel threatened by liberal America, you know, and
- 49:57so they just start digging in and putting up walls and you know, is
- 50:01chewing science and everything. And then you have this massive pressure on everybody to
- 50:07hold the line. And if you are not in our in group, you
- 50:10are definitely out group. And so then you have parents that are doing things
- 50:15that they would never have done normally. I think that that's true. I
- 50:20think I'd like to I'd like to put a little gloss on it, and
- 50:23then I would like to take a socio political risk with you, with your
- 50:28population or your your listenership here. So I think that that's true, and
- 50:32there are certainly instances where it is like leadership top down, we are protecting
- 50:37our own asses. I think there's something else going on though, that's more
- 50:40bottom up, and that for some leaders can be embarked upon in good faith,
- 50:47which is that what they've got here is a complete system that they see
- 50:53a lot of good that it does in people's lives. And we know that
- 51:00it does good in people's lives from the empirical research, and you know,
- 51:04like even the religion skeptics who are doing research like they more are asking like
- 51:08what are we missing in the research? Like no one is really even challenging
- 51:13for research and all that outcomes regarding happiness, marital marital sex satisfaction, health,
- 51:22reduced risk of vices like alcoholism or something. Absolutely absolutely yeah. So
- 51:30you're a pastor and you what you know is you've got this sort of air
- 51:35tight system, and the system as a whole is producing all these good things
- 51:38that you are aware that you're intimately aware of, and you are literally you
- 51:43know, if you're a pastor. You're also sitting with people as they die.
- 51:46I mean, you are with your congregants in the worst moments of their
- 51:50lives, and you are seeing firsthand with your own eyes, feeling with your
- 51:54own hands, how this is making those moments better for people. Now,
- 51:59the problem is not that. The problem is that your denomination, the theological
- 52:05stream that you're a part of, maybe your seminary, perhaps the elder board
- 52:08at your church, whatever, that's all been done. Like the air tightness
- 52:15of the system is not backed up by evidence. So what do you do
- 52:22if someone like your first I can understand the first instinct of someone being well,
- 52:28let's hold on to our system and attack whatever is saying that it's bullshit
- 52:32because we know it's not. I think I know what you're saying, but
- 52:36I'm not sure that you could have. And I think this extends to political
- 52:40leaders as well. That you could have leaders in religion, or in politics,
- 52:45or in culture who have a more relatable point of view to you and
- 52:52me. But because of the traditions or the bottom up pressure of certain idea
- 53:00is or upholding certain practices or dogmas, the leadership the top will have to
- 53:07succumb to these movements, or else be out ousted as a leader. Absolutely,
- 53:15I mean right now, if you're not into Trump, but you are
- 53:17a pastor in a red state, your options are either get on board with
- 53:22Trump, don't talk about politics, or get fired. For so many pastors
- 53:29right now because the congregations like, we'll find someone else to tell us what
- 53:32we want to hear, and so there are There are just a lot of
- 53:36pressures from a lot of different angles, is all I'm saying. And what
- 53:39I and here's the risk I'm going to take. I'm gonna say that there
- 53:43is an analog, a psychological analog within our own circles for this. I
- 53:47think that it's clear right now, and I don't think it's even that controversial
- 53:52for people paying attention that there's a real crisis going on with boys and young
- 53:58men. But if you are on the socio political left right now, that
- 54:02is like the most inconvenient thing to be happening, because we have finally made
- 54:09some fucking progress for women and girls, and like Greta Gerwick just finally got
- 54:16to make Barbie and destroy a bunch of box office records, Like really,
- 54:22guy, you got to be focusing on the problems of the boys and stuff.
- 54:25But in my opinion, Kirk, that's what the data says. Oh
- 54:29yeah, I talk about this. I talk about this a lot. That
- 54:32the reason why you have the Andrew Tates and the reason why you have an
- 54:36increase in conservatism among young men and teenage boys is because of not that feminism
- 54:44or fairness. I mean, that's maybe a slight factor, not that these
- 54:49good things in society are actually working and they're just like sad that they're losing
- 54:54their privilege. I think that, in the likelihood, is a slight factor,
- 54:59but as a bigger factor, we are indoctrinating them into toxic masculinity in
- 55:06some very heavy handed ways. And then at the same time we're telling them
- 55:09that they're evil for having those kinds of thoughts or impulses. And we're also
- 55:15not providing what I talk about toxic masculinity. And I always will say that
- 55:22it's not saying masculinity is toxic. It means that there are toxic elements.
- 55:27There are toxic elements to femininity, and there are positive elements to masculinity,
- 55:30and they're positive elements of femininity as well. And as a man, I
- 55:37have to sift through my socialization and make decisions, and they are decisions and
- 55:42it's hard to figure it out, but it's an endeavor worth it for by
- 55:45happiness and for those around me. And I hold on to the following positive
- 55:52masculine traits that I have been indoctrinated. I can't help to have been indoctrinated
- 55:58into it. Whenever I talk about this, I always get people yelling at
- 56:04me for having positive associations with masculinity. Andre's and I'll give all sorts of
- 56:10caveats. I'll say not to say that women can't be this way. It's
- 56:15not that women can't be courageous or helpful or know how to fix things or
- 56:22reach the top shelf or open the jar of peanut butter. Women can certainly
- 56:28do that, but as a man, I was taught that that was important
- 56:31for me to do. If my grandma is trying to carry something across the
- 56:37room, a huge part of me enacting my masculinity and being able to sleep
- 56:42well at night and even feeling like I'm a good person is to jump up
- 56:45and be the first person to carry it for her. Or I'm on the
- 56:50bus and I let anybody sit who I feel is at a greater need than
- 56:55I am. And that makes me feel good as a person, and it
- 56:59makes feel good as a man. And I'll get people say, so,
- 57:01you're saying that women can't do that, You're saying that women can't can't like.
- 57:06And also they'll say, well, you know, there's a negative side
- 57:07of that, because then you have men that will deny women the opportunity to
- 57:12lift their own stuff. And I'll say, yes, I know, and
- 57:15I gave those caveats and it's a problem. You know, It's like,
- 57:21so, you know, I don't know what the answer is exactly, but
- 57:24what's done is done. You've already indoctrinated the boys into masculinity. We have
- 57:30to allow them and teach them and lead them and model for them how to
- 57:37hold on to those masculine socialized traits or behaviors so that they can have some
- 57:45path forward. Otherwise they're going to turn to edertate. I've been doing like
- 57:50a kind of an ongoing series on you know, quote unquote masculinity crisis and
- 57:55you know, new formulations of masculinity because I find it to be just a
- 58:00really rich and important topic right now, and trying to bring in a lot
- 58:04of different a lot of different voices on that male female you know, SiZ
- 58:08trans, et cetera, and looking for ideas that people have. The reason
- 58:14I brought it up was though, more just to say, like, you
- 58:17can imagine that we have like a almost like a default way of seeing the
- 58:23world and it is working for us. A person who is committed to the
- 58:29raising up of women and gender equality, like that is working for them.
- 58:35That's a good cause. And then I come in here with this, well,
- 58:38there's this problem though going on right now, and it's like you gotta
- 58:42spoil the party, man, And like that's kind of the same thing I
- 58:46think for a lot of people who see firsthand the power of religion, and
- 58:52then I want to come in and complicate the picture with facts. To be
- 58:57clear, I think the picture is complicated in reality, but I'm I understand
- 59:01where they're coming from that they're like shit, man. They wouldn't say shit,
- 59:07uh, but like they're they're bummed because it's like, no, dude,
- 59:09like you're you're ruining this thing that I'm seeing being good for other people.
- 59:15And it's not obvious to me how you keep the good while also putting
- 59:21religion up against reality and science and all, you know, it's like it's
- 59:27an open question for me and I I continue trying to do it because I
- 59:30myself am Christian and it is an important part of my life. Uh,
- 59:36but it's not like it's not obvious. You know. It would be much
- 59:38simpler to just be like, well, fuck that, and uh, I
- 59:42guess I'll figure out some other way to be spiritual. I'll go on hikes
- 59:45or something, which is great and a totally viable path to experiencing, you
- 59:50know, the beauty of the world and if God exists, God the beauty
- 59:54that God is responsible for. But but yeah, so it's it is this
- 59:59weird I find myself in this weird middle spot and I don't know how I
- 1:00:01ended up. Well, it just points to how hard it is, but
- 1:00:07how important it is that in our in groups we have to try to further
- 1:00:16the conversation, to refine the in group, to avoid extreme creep, to
- 1:00:24avoid you know, punishing discourse within your in group. You know, because
- 1:00:34to me, it is ultimately a feminist act for me to go down that
- 1:00:40road regarding positive masculinity, because if we're going to make it better for women,
- 1:00:46then we have to have a path forward for men that makes it better
- 1:00:52for women. If you say to men and boys, the only path forward
- 1:00:57is that you need to hate yourself because you're a man or a boy,
- 1:01:00or you're masculine, that is not a path forward. We see the result.
- 1:01:05You have more sexism and more toxic masculinity and misogyny because they are being
- 1:01:14rejected. They have no path forward. So it's a feminist act. I'm
- 1:01:17doing it for a lot, I'm doing it for everybody. I'm doing it
- 1:01:21for people of all genders, but ultimately, really i'm doing it for women
- 1:01:25because they're traditionally the people are who are going to suffer from this in the
- 1:01:30end. And the same goes for a religious people. When you are enjoying
- 1:01:37your religion and it means a lot to you and you want to be able
- 1:01:42to enjoy it fully and also be treated well and have a community that actually
- 1:01:46supports its members and protects them, then you have to have people in the
- 1:01:52end group say hey, great, I'm with you, I'm one of you,
- 1:01:57I'm on the same path. And if we're all going to win,
- 1:02:01we have to have these nuanced conversations about how religion can harm and how we
- 1:02:08might actually be participating in that. Because if we don't, then we might
- 1:02:14end up being harmed. And two, we know it in the back of
- 1:02:17our mind. It's always there. We know something's wrong, and wouldn't it
- 1:02:22be nice to resolve that. Yeah, and there are some people who are
- 1:02:27taking the spiritual abuse literature very seriously attempting to understand that. You know,
- 1:02:31people from religious institutions, you know, church networks, you know, parachurch
- 1:02:37organizations, educational institutions. And I'm really grateful for that. And you know,
- 1:02:44those are the conversations that I most want to have is with the people
- 1:02:47on the ground in those worlds who are wanting to make it healthier for the
- 1:02:54people involved. And then you will always have your Mark Driscals of the world
- 1:02:59if you've talked about him much on the show, or you're Bill just let's
- 1:03:02just say, Bill Gothards of the world. Who are you know, for
- 1:03:07as far as we can tell, ultimately like pretty unhealthy, narcissistic maybe certainly,
- 1:03:13yeah, culty adjacent or whatever type of type of people. And those
- 1:03:19people, you know, we we will unfortunately always have people like that amongst
- 1:03:22us. How can we develop tools for recognizing them? You know, there
- 1:03:30are interesting differences between different denominations and how much power you know, like the
- 1:03:35Ministerial Licensing Board has to like keep people from being a minister. If Mark
- 1:03:39Driscoll, who's a former Seattle Mars Hill podcast or mars Hill Church Riisenthaal of
- 1:03:45Mars Hill podcast. Guy, you know, that was the big thing a
- 1:03:47couple of years back. So like if he had been Presbyterian, he would
- 1:03:52have been kicked out of the presbytery and then he would have gone and started
- 1:03:57a non denominational church, which is ultimately what he did. So a guy
- 1:04:00like that, you're not going to keep him. He's going to go be
- 1:04:04a snake. You know, He's going to do what he can to be
- 1:04:06a snake. And the only real the only real protection against people like him
- 1:04:13are laws and individuals not getting sucked into it. But some people always will
- 1:04:17be because these people are charismatic and they don't have good intentions as far as
- 1:04:23I can tell, I don't know him personally, but yeah, and there's
- 1:04:25plenty of evidence. And when you have a system that includes the outgroup,
- 1:04:30I'll include that in the system that creates extremist points of view that they feel
- 1:04:35like they have to dig in. Like I was saying earlier, then they're
- 1:04:40a wide open door. They have a wide open door to these figures.
- 1:04:44You know, when I grew up in the seventies non denominational Protestant Ish church
- 1:04:50that I was in, there wasn't the attacking of Christians that will happen today.
- 1:04:58So we didn't need to protect ourselves by rallying around to Donald Trump.
- 1:05:04Or I mean the people we rallied around was Jimmy Carter for crying out loud.
- 1:05:08I remember him being held up as like a Christian representative of our people,
- 1:05:14you know, and he's that I didn't live through. Imagine, just
- 1:05:17just just reflect on that that, Like I know, to Christian Americans,
- 1:05:25Jimmy Carter was the guy you cannot you cannot pick someone more different than Donald
- 1:05:31Trump? And why is this christ evangelical president? And why is that?
- 1:05:34Because when you have you know, declining numbers among Christians and you have very
- 1:05:42effective ridiculing, hurtful voices that are making fun of Christians and denigrating them and
- 1:05:48calling them backward and yokels or whatever, then you get what you get,
- 1:05:54and it's everyone's fault. It's the Christian's fault, and it's the liberals fault.
- 1:06:00We all participate in provoking each other, and that whole thing just has
- 1:06:06to stop. Yeah, And I'm it's a major focus of mine, and
- 1:06:11it's going to continue to be going forward. Like I think I'm going to
- 1:06:14have to start I was telling you earlier. You know, I still have
- 1:06:15this year long internship to complete before I can get licensed as a psychologist,
- 1:06:21So I can't like start additional podcasts right now. No, no, no,
- 1:06:26I think I'm going to start it as an episode type of you have
- 1:06:29permission, and then maybe it will become its own show. But I'm working
- 1:06:32on one called Ignore the Culture War, and the idea is to like bring
- 1:06:41in focus on topics that cultural artifacts that actually can be enjoyed across the aisle
- 1:06:48and like have some fun with that and even have a little bit of like
- 1:06:53enjoy poking fun at our tribalistic tendencies. You know, it would be perfect
- 1:06:57is football, because liberals and conservatives watch football. Yep. Football is a
- 1:07:03great example. I have one planned for deer hunting, because deer hunting is
- 1:07:09like population control and disease control, and so there are these things that we
- 1:07:14can actually agree upon. None of the media, none of the major media
- 1:07:17companies right now are incentivized for us to be more unified. I think most
- 1:07:24of them have recognized that their profits increase the more polarized we are, and
- 1:07:30so we need people who are not beholden to that financially. And I'm one
- 1:07:35of those people. So I'll throw my hat in the ring and try.
- 1:07:39And you know, my first podcast before your Permission was called Depolarize. But
- 1:07:43I couldn't do I couldn't do politics all the time. It actually like freed
- 1:07:46my nervous system. So I'm gonna try again, but with bluey and football
- 1:07:53and hunting and stuff like that, and see where we get with that.
- 1:07:57But do you know where your internship's gonna because typically have to move. Yeah,
- 1:08:00I'll tell you after. Okay, So what are the other dimensions in
- 1:08:05your measure? Yeah, well I'll just go quickly. So there is discrimination
- 1:08:12on the actual screener. There's just items for gender discrimination. That's a statistical
- 1:08:16numbers thing. But there's racial discrimination and sexual discrimination. That one's fairly straightforward,
- 1:08:23meaning like if you're a part of a religious group that makes you feel
- 1:08:28lesser, like if you're lesser for being a woman or unable to serve in
- 1:08:31certain ways, Like a lot of churches will sort of appear to be like
- 1:08:35pro gay LGBTQ friendly, and they kind of are for a while, but
- 1:08:41then like you apply to be a part of the worship team and you find
- 1:08:44out that you can't because you're gay, you know, or things like that,
- 1:08:47And then and then what does that do to someone who's been worshiping in
- 1:08:50this community? And oh, like I can't sing to God for you know
- 1:08:57what I mean? Like, so there, some of these theological commitments will
- 1:09:03be obscured for a while to sort of appear more friendly, and then that
- 1:09:09can be but that can be really damaging. I mean, how likely are
- 1:09:13you to go back and find another faith community after that happens to you?
- 1:09:15Certainly less less likely yea. And then controlling leadership, which we've sort of
- 1:09:20talked about, but maybe the most interesting thing there is just this idea that
- 1:09:26you know, pastors can feel like they've got a sort of a direct line
- 1:09:30to God because they generally feel a calling, some sort of supernatural calling,
- 1:09:34spiritual calling. I don't think that all that stuff is bullshit. I would
- 1:09:40I conceive of it differently maybe than some of them do. But you know,
- 1:09:43I feel called in a sense to be a therapist. I feel called
- 1:09:45in a sense to do public work around religion and science. So I get
- 1:09:50that. But you know, you can get drunk on that and you can
- 1:09:55have too much control over people's daily lives and you can actually get you can
- 1:09:59be given really good feedback for that, and people can thank you for that,
- 1:10:02and you can think, oh, this must be a good thing that
- 1:10:04I'm providing. Or you can also be a bad actor and a narcissistant,
- 1:10:08malignant and you know there's that too. But even if you're not that,
- 1:10:11you can just the system can be set up in such a way that it
- 1:10:15rewards the wrong things. Yeah, they and the parishioners want that. Sometimes
- 1:10:18they they do will rush to the pope, and if the pope touches them,
- 1:10:23they'll they believe that they've been touched by God or a representative. You
- 1:10:29know, it's a it's a it's a magical touch that they're getting from the
- 1:10:31pope. And people want that, you know, they bring their child and
- 1:10:35say you would you please kiss my child? And even if you're a leader
- 1:10:41and you don't believe that, it'd be hard to say, hey, no,
- 1:10:45I mean I'd be happy to to bless you, I guess, but
- 1:10:50you're just as close to God as I am. I just have a calling
- 1:10:54for this. You have a calling for your thing, you know. That's
- 1:10:57how That's how I was way to do it, That's how I was.
- 1:11:00Yeah, I mean, you got a pretty damn good hand in terms of
- 1:11:05non denominational Christianity. I would say you got lucky. We were so kind
- 1:11:11of grassrootsy that I was baptized in Lake Samamish, Yeah, by my dad.
- 1:11:20And so I don't know why find you find value in that today?
- 1:11:24I'm curious or do you think of that as like a kind of a nothing
- 1:11:27burger? I think positively about it. It was very important to me.
- 1:11:31Christianity and the community was very important to me throughout my childhood and to some
- 1:11:38extent early adulthood. And my church was and I think it's common in churches
- 1:11:44today that you are asked, if you have not yet been baptized and handed
- 1:11:49yourself over to God Jesus, to volunteer and to raise your hand. There
- 1:11:57was always this call at the end of alter call. Okay, And when
- 1:12:01I was eight years old, I had gone to church my whole life up
- 1:12:05until that point and would hear that call but just didn't really feel it.
- 1:12:12But there was something about my developmental phase at eight where I suddenly had this
- 1:12:19notion of like, I make my own choices, and I make my own
- 1:12:25life. I'm given that that choice, and I actually, you know,
- 1:12:30if you wereround the clock, even just six months, I wouldn't have seen
- 1:12:33it that way. I would just be like, well, I'm seven,
- 1:12:35so I do what my parents tell me to do. But at eight,
- 1:12:39I remember thinking like, now is the beginning of me choosing things from within,
- 1:12:45like what do I want? There's a different person inside of me from
- 1:12:49my family. And I remember making that choice and it was it was very
- 1:12:55intentional, and I knew what I was volunteering for. I knew the choice
- 1:13:00I was making, and that has tremendous value to me, you know.
- 1:13:03And my family supported it. You know. No one pressured me, no
- 1:13:06one was saying, hey, Kirk, it's time. It was just left
- 1:13:12to you know, me to make that choice. And I made that choice,
- 1:13:15and that was a big deal. One of my favorite post evangelical commentators
- 1:13:19is Caitlin Beatty. She's an author. She used to be an editor at
- 1:13:23Christianity Today and now she works for Religion News Service and Brazos Press, like
- 1:13:29she works in book publishing, but she has a podcast with Roxande Stone called
- 1:13:33Saved by the City, and she's often interviewed, you know, and some
- 1:13:38of these like big pieces about you know, the post Trump evangelicals or post
- 1:13:42evangelicals after Trump. And one of the things that she says about her evangelical
- 1:13:46upbringing that I think is really spot on is she says, it taught me
- 1:13:51to take my choices really seriously at a younger age than my other friends were
- 1:13:58taught to take their choices seriously. And that's what you made me think of
- 1:14:01with like, hey, you're just old enough to make this decision, feel
- 1:14:06free to make it, feel free to take charge of your life. And
- 1:14:11you know, the it's it's funny because so much of it is evaporated with
- 1:14:15Trump. But the way that I was raised was like ethics and morality,
- 1:14:19like really fucking mattered. And I am a I am to this day like
- 1:14:25a very like sort of morally sincere person and I think it's a part of
- 1:14:29my identity. I think it's actually one of my strengths. I think it's
- 1:14:31the way that I was made or the way I showed up, or however
- 1:14:35you want to kind of whatever verb you want to use for that, And
- 1:14:42that was really nourished, and eventually I even had the tools to go back
- 1:14:45and sort of undo that harm that had been done to me through that spiritual
- 1:14:50abuse, and I was given agency. And there were other people in that
- 1:14:56world who, you know, like when I was a junior and senior in
- 1:14:59high school, who were like, why do you try this book? You
- 1:15:01know, like why did you think about studying philosophy? You know? And
- 1:15:05so I was really empowered to in that way. Yeah, that's beautiful,
- 1:15:08and I'm I'm I'm so encouraged by that, and I wish more people there's
- 1:15:13a greater percentage of people that you know, did what you did, which
- 1:15:16is to not reject your religion and your spirituality, but to actually go further
- 1:15:24into it and beyond trump and beyond the hate and beyond the dogma. You're,
- 1:15:31in my book, more closer to the religion and to the word and
- 1:15:38to the path than people that would say you've you've gone astray, you know
- 1:15:45what I mean. You know, we would say that's just a philosophy,
- 1:15:49or it's just an opinion, of course, but that's how it would feel
- 1:15:54to me. That's how it feels. And I think we talked about the
- 1:15:56sas time that for me become a therapist definitely has its original seeds as a
- 1:16:05Christian, not only that kind of the calling and the moving you know how
- 1:16:12it moves you, the compassion, the giving, the forgiving, the selflessness,
- 1:16:21also the feeling of community and giving and charity. And the sermons had
- 1:16:30a lot to do with like emotional regulation, and they wouldn't word it that
- 1:16:33way, but you know, there'd be a whole sermon about anger, and
- 1:16:36they would use scripture and they would tie it to family wisdom. That's actually
- 1:16:44the way I don't think anymore about the Bible and other Christian artifacts. I
- 1:16:50don't think of them in this sort of like either they were directly inspired by
- 1:16:55God or their man made like. I don't believe in that ecotomy anymore.
- 1:17:00I think of it as all one thing, and I think of it like
- 1:17:03early peer review, so before we I think that the peer review process is
- 1:17:10in a lot of ways and improvement right. Certainly, you can get results
- 1:17:13a lot quicker now with the modern scientific method and involving multiple voices very early
- 1:17:17on, and you know, checking all our biases and doing it in this
- 1:17:20way and making things empirical, making them testable. But before we had that,
- 1:17:27we had elders, We had people who had lived longer than other people,
- 1:17:31and they sorted through all the oral traditions and then eventually the written traditions
- 1:17:36of whatever culture they were a part of, and the shit that worked stuck
- 1:17:41around, and the shit that didn't work people stopped repeating it. And that's
- 1:17:46not a perfect like where I think conservative Christianity and conservative religion gets it wrong.
- 1:17:51It says, well, we've got this book and that's the perfect record
- 1:17:55of it, so we don't need to go anywhere beyond that. I think,
- 1:17:58no, that doesn't. I don't think the evidence spares that out.
- 1:18:00But it's not nothing. And the way that I've talked about it is uh.
- 1:18:06And if we need to wrap up all, this can be my final
- 1:18:10analogy. Like it's sort of like you get married and you are doing your
- 1:18:15registry, and now that we live in modern times, you know the guys
- 1:18:18can register for gifts too, so you might you might want to throw on
- 1:18:23like a power drill, and you know a handful of power tools and other
- 1:18:28other tools to kind of get your tool collection going. Meanwhile, you're your
- 1:18:31father in law. Your father in law to be sidles up to you and
- 1:18:33he says, hey, Kirk, I noticed that you guys were talking about
- 1:18:39this, but I did want to offer you something. As you know,
- 1:18:43your fiance's mother and I are downsizing and we're moving into a condo, and
- 1:18:48i have a whole garage full of tools. I'm not going to use them
- 1:18:53anymore. Now. I'll warn you some of them are not as safe as
- 1:18:58the modern versions. Some of them you're a little rusty. You're gonna probably
- 1:19:00have to do a little bit of upkeep, especially on the ones you're gonna
- 1:19:03use the most. Some of it you might just want to toss replace some
- 1:19:08things here and there. But tell you what, you're starting with a whole
- 1:19:11garage full of tools, and you at least have something for almost any job
- 1:19:15you're gonna need to do, at least in a pinch. And that is
- 1:19:19sort of how I imagine sticking with Christianity and raising my sons with some form
- 1:19:27of Christianity. It's not perfect, it is not a drop down from heaven.
- 1:19:31You know, I don't know Ken's dream house garage set up, but
- 1:19:38it does have every tool. I've got stuff for emotional regulation. I've got
- 1:19:42stuff for behavioral activation. I've got stuff for social support. I've got stuff
- 1:19:45for values centric action. Right, I have all those things. I've got
- 1:19:49poetry, I've got devotional stuff. I've got stuff for when I want to
- 1:19:55shut the fuck up and just like meditate on something beautiful. Right, I
- 1:19:59have like a whole system. And it's not perfect, and I have been
- 1:20:03replacing things, but I'm choosing that rather than starting from scratch. And I'm
- 1:20:10not judging people who choose to start from scratch. I think a lot of
- 1:20:13that's personality type. And I don't think that's a that's a moral question,
- 1:20:17but for me, it's a practical question, and that seems like the way
- 1:20:21to go. Uh. And the and the last thing, I'll say,
- 1:20:25that was so cool. That's been so cool about widening out from just evangelical
- 1:20:30Protestant to being able to like who are the great Catholic thinkers and writers,
- 1:20:34and who are the great Orthodox theologians? And you know what other kind of
- 1:20:39history here the Black Church in America right in our own doorstep, like maybe
- 1:20:44one of the most powerful religious movements in human history is the American Black Church.
- 1:20:48We of course totally fucking ignored it as white Protestants, But they've been
- 1:20:53there, and I can learn from them, and I can read about that,
- 1:20:56and I can engage with them. So like has also gotten massively bigger.
- 1:21:01And I've recognized that there were even I didn't know I had a fucking
- 1:21:03belt sander. Look at that, you know here. I thought I'd have
- 1:21:09to rent one, So that that is a I'm stretching the analogy now as
- 1:21:13far as it will probably hold, but that's kind of how I think about
- 1:21:16it, and and that's sort of the way I approach it. On you
- 1:21:18have permission, and then but bringing in science and helping me figure out which
- 1:21:23tools are obsolete, you know, and are not safe anymore. And I
- 1:21:28would like to think that the spiritual harm and abuse scale is one such small
- 1:21:32little tool people could use to to sort of determine which tools in their shed
- 1:21:38need need reworking and which ones are doing well. Yeah, people coming after
- 1:21:43you will be given that belt sander. That is your tool, and refine
- 1:21:49it, discard it, dive into it, use it. We stand on
- 1:21:56the shoulders of giants and one day maybe you'll be one of those giants maybe
- 1:22:01or maybe my kids will become beltsander influencers, you know. So I don't
- 1:22:05know, but yeah, well your parable works on a number of levels.
- 1:22:10It also works with the conversation we had about masculinity about discarding and you know,
- 1:22:16sifting through as well. You know, yeah, I think I think
- 1:22:19a relevant difference there might be. I think I am a bit more convinced
- 1:22:25that more of it's biological or and I don't think it's biologically binary, but
- 1:22:30biological as you would see it, like laid out on a bell curve,
- 1:22:32right, So sex puts you more likely to be in this spot of a
- 1:22:36bell curve on any number of traits and stuff, And there might be something
- 1:22:41there, Like I have been finding myself drawn to new visions of masculinity that
- 1:22:47don't don't define themselves in contradiction to the old versions, but actually trying to
- 1:22:51sort of reframe them. You know, Like there's ways of thinking about strength
- 1:22:58strong leadership, but that's not authoritarian strong leadership, but like what is actually
- 1:23:02strong leadership? Yeah, whether it's biological or or otherwise is is irrelevant.
- 1:23:08It's more that question that you just raised, which is a very important question
- 1:23:13in a number of arenas. You know, I'm socialized as a half Japanese,
- 1:23:16half white person. What are the good parts right and what are the
- 1:23:20bad parts? We have to sift through and if we tell people that there
- 1:23:28are no good parts to their identity, then you get what you get.
- 1:23:31Well. Thanks for coming on the podcast, Dan Cock Coke, And like
- 1:23:36the Koch brothers, I have to just read because don't they spell it similar
- 1:23:40to to you spell the same, pronounce the same, and I don't know
- 1:23:42them. Yeah, I'm not subsidized. Are you as rich as them?
- 1:23:46Is? Are you a chis? So we'll conclude here, but then after
- 1:23:54we wrap it up, there'll be a break, and then there's going to
- 1:23:57be a random conversation we had at the beginning of our talk today that I'm
- 1:24:01going to put at the end. And where can people find you online?
- 1:24:05Dan? Yeah, I'm on Instagram, Dan Coke, DA N C O
- 1:24:11K E. And you can watch you have permission on YouTube or listen to
- 1:24:15it on any podcast platform and we will. I'm also looking forward to in
- 1:24:21the coming months having you on to talk about the way that you have been
- 1:24:27using psychology to talk about media and characters and films and TV shows, because
- 1:24:32that's to me kind of an area I am becoming more and more interested in
- 1:24:36as like a cultural touch point for the type of psycho education that I know
- 1:24:42you and I both hope to provide in an entertaining fashion and interesting fashion for
- 1:24:46people that we also like to consume from entertaining and interesting other podcasters and folks.
- 1:24:53Well, and where can people find your measure? Oh, that's right,
- 1:24:57that one is at dancokewords dot com. That's d A n ko c
- 1:25:01H. That's my actual spelling words dot com And there is a tab that
- 1:25:05says spiritual abuse screener. Well, I'm really glad that you're out there.
- 1:25:13Dan. It gives me hope for Christianity in America that you exist. I
- 1:25:20appreciate that we are certainly the minority numerically, but you know what, who
- 1:25:30gives a shit their their project is collapsing for younger generations and it's actually truly
- 1:25:36it's truly sad and disheartening. A lot of client work around that stuff,
- 1:25:43and it's it's understood I have to do that work myself. It's it's a
- 1:25:45very tough time to come from that world. I appreciate the way that you
- 1:25:49speak about it graciously, and everyone out there please truly take care of yourself.
- 1:25:56Why should people take care of themselves? Dan? I mean, you're
- 1:25:59you are only self. You've got man later on, when appropriate, I
- 1:26:08want to talk to you about Well, I guess we can do We'll do
- 1:26:11it on you permission. But I'm I'm so interested in like how you have
- 1:26:15decided to talk about movies and TV shows and stuff because it seems like such
- 1:26:20a good avenue for psycho education, because it's fun and people like it already.
- 1:26:28You don't have to convince them to like it, you know, And
- 1:26:30I'm just like, that's gold, Like, that's that's the thing. I
- 1:26:33was just at this like a Templeton funded thing at Berkeley, and I was
- 1:26:38just like, how do we how do we get this stuff? It about
- 1:26:40intellectual humility? I was like, how do we make it less vegetables and
- 1:26:44more cheeseburgers? Yeah, you know exactly, Or how do we sneak our
- 1:26:49vegetables into the cheeseburgers? Well? Like, what sort of TV shows or
- 1:26:56movies come to mind for you and your content? Well, that's what I've
- 1:26:59been trying to figure out and like I think, you know, with a
- 1:27:01religion focus, there's kind of some built in like possible you know, thematic
- 1:27:06things there. But I'm just I'm waiting in slowly because i have my APA,
- 1:27:11my apiic internship that starts in August and I'm going to be just fucking
- 1:27:15slammed yeah for a year. Yeah, it's going to be awful. So
- 1:27:18I'm just trying some things in the meanwhile. I kind of dipping my feet
- 1:27:21in. But I think I think what we might actually do. The first
- 1:27:24thing I might do is a little mini series called We Watched the Chosen so
- 1:27:28you don't have to, okay, because all all my listeners are like constantly
- 1:27:32being recommended that, like by their evangelical family members and stuff like that.
- 1:27:36Yeah, so I thought, well that might be fun. Get I went
- 1:27:40down a Chosen rabbit hole on YouTube like a month ago and was fascinated with
- 1:27:46I guess it's like Christian YouTube that I don't normally see, Like it's a
- 1:27:50whole thing that I'm sure you know about, and I mean I don't.
- 1:27:55I don't live there either, but I'm aware that it exists. Yeah.
- 1:27:58Yeah, and the discourd it's the same in my world, or in like
- 1:28:03the gaming world, there's a Christian YouTube world where they seem to be very
- 1:28:09much all in conversation with each other, you know, and it has a
- 1:28:13certain vibe to it. You know. It was like I was, like,
- 1:28:16I felt like I was sneaking into like some kind of convention as an
- 1:28:21interloper and watching everyone have these conversations and the assumptions that everyone was and basically
- 1:28:30and I guess this is the algorithm, but everyone was saying that the chosen
- 1:28:34was terrible for one reason or another. Yeah, I mean real, like
- 1:28:38my sense is that real conservatives think it's like taking too many liberties. But
- 1:28:45it's hard to I mean, like people don't realize how hard it is to
- 1:28:46like make good TV. Like yeah, you know, it's it's not just
- 1:28:49you don't just put the events on screen and it's good. Yeah, And
- 1:28:54do you mind if I include this conversation and at the like maybe at the
- 1:28:58end of our a little snippet and like tune in, tune into you have
- 1:29:01permission Later on for when I interviewed doctor Honda about how he talks about characters
- 1:29:08and because the chosen for people listening to us interloping on our conversation, I
- 1:29:15guess which of course we're asking people to do. If I gathered from context
- 1:29:19for my memory, they were trying to get this series off the ground and
- 1:29:25they couldn't get funding, and so they raised funds from the crowd. And
- 1:29:30that's right, it was. It was crowdfunded. That's my memory too.
- 1:29:32And they raised millions of dollars and hired actors and directors and writers and everything,
- 1:29:38and it is it's a story of Jesus. Yeah, it's basically that's
- 1:29:44my understanding, is the story of Jesus. But that that's not so strange.
- 1:29:46Like I was just thinking about this the other day that there, you
- 1:29:50know, I was I was looking up something about some biblical passage as part
- 1:29:56of a question I was answering, and I was wanting to make sure I
- 1:29:59was getting right. And you know, what have people said about this and
- 1:30:01whatever and the amount of man hours and you know, person hours, whatever,
- 1:30:06the amount of labor paid labor of biblical scholars and professors that has been
- 1:30:15paid for, you know, like you can think of it economically. There
- 1:30:18is so much written about this set of books, you know, and the
- 1:30:24gospels about Jesus are like, I don't know if you put that into a
- 1:30:27regular book that's like eighty pages, one hundred and fifty pages. I don't
- 1:30:30know what it is. It's not that long, and the amount of other
- 1:30:33pages that have been published about it, like there, people are willing to
- 1:30:38spend money on it because it's important to them, which is actually kind of
- 1:30:42related to spiritual abuse and the power of religion and all that stuff, where
- 1:30:46it's like it creates a literal economic market that you can have whole seminaries,
- 1:30:53you know, that can make money, that can be profitable. But it's
- 1:30:57weird that Hollywood doesn't lean in to that, because well, they're they're figuring
- 1:31:01it out now, but I think that they are slow to capitalize on it.
- 1:31:08And you know, these capitalists, these marketers in Hollywood, I'm sure
- 1:31:12that they think about it, but they probably think of it as career suicide
- 1:31:15or brand suicide if they associate themselves. Sure could be. Yeah, you
- 1:31:19know, I mean, you know, Hollywood is like not not a very
- 1:31:23religious you know, the coastal like the coastal cultural centers in America are like
- 1:31:29not super religious. So I would say they're I would say they're anti religion
- 1:31:33for good and bad reasons. And it's kind of weird. Like when I
- 1:31:39like, you know, my cheeseburger is reality TV, and when I'm watching
- 1:31:44it, there are a lot of shows that I watch they don't mention religion
- 1:31:48hardly at all. If they do, it's usually like because they have to.
- 1:31:55And occasionally I'll watch a reality TV show where they actually allow that footage
- 1:32:00to be you know, put in the show, and when I see it,
- 1:32:03I'm like, I'm like kind of shocked. But then I'm like,
- 1:32:05yeah, of course, you know, most people are very real. People
- 1:32:10are doing this every Sunday. Yeah, and they you know what I mean.
- 1:32:15So it's interesting that Hollywood just washes that all out, you know.
- 1:32:20Yeah, I mean, but then like shows like Yellowstone, you know,
- 1:32:24come in and sort of disrupt everything because but that's the anomaly, you know
- 1:32:28what I mean, Well, it's the anomaly, but it's the it proves
- 1:32:30that there is a market for you know. The way I had somebody describe
- 1:32:35it to me once was people like seeing themselves displayed on film representation of their
- 1:32:42group. They like to see representation, and man like the the the population
- 1:32:48of America socio politically does not match the population of Hollywood and New York socio
- 1:32:54politically. So there is a real there's a market niche there and I'm not
- 1:32:58going to fill it, but somebody could and they probably make a lot of
- 1:33:00money. Well I feel like maybe you can in a way, you know,
- 1:33:03in the podcasting universe, and well, none of those people like my
- 1:33:09pot I mean, I'm too liberal. But that's my point is that it's
- 1:33:13a problem because when you shut it out, then the severe end of the
- 1:33:18spectrum are going to have the most the most verve to get the funds going,
- 1:33:25and then you're going to see a very I don't know one version of
- 1:33:29Christianity that is getting the voice out there. You know, I would say
- 1:33:32a lot of people in Hollywood are religious in some way. Why don't they
- 1:33:36make their version of Christianity? And then that could influence people to not become
- 1:33:43extremists, right, you do see that? Right? So, you know,
- 1:33:47you could argue that the ending of Lost is a pretty it's kind of
- 1:33:53pan spiritual, but it's also kind of liberal christian a sort of universal like
- 1:33:58this was a task. There's really loving sort of being at the center of
- 1:34:01all this. It's essentially an afterlife ending. You know. I think even
- 1:34:05the way that Mike Flanagan, is that his name. I could be getting
- 1:34:11his Irish last name wrong. Who did Vampires Midnight Mass? He the way
- 1:34:15he portrays Catholicism in that show is actually like really well done. And he
- 1:34:23in an interview who was talking about how he was he sort of his parents
- 1:34:27are really devout Catholics, and he was like checking in with them and making
- 1:34:30sure that the parts of that show that were just supposed to be a regular
- 1:34:34mass, like not the supernatural whatever kind of horror parts that they like kind
- 1:34:40of signed off on it. And I thought that that was really cool.
- 1:34:42I thought that that was like a wise and just like yeah, just a
- 1:34:46good craftsmanship. So you do find it, you do find it. But
- 1:34:51but I wonder if when people watch stuff like that, if they actually think
- 1:34:56of it as an overt religious story, you know, like when I watched
- 1:35:00the movie Constantine, which I love with Keanu Reeves, it is yeah,
- 1:35:06right down the middle, like old school Dante kat Catholicism, right right.
- 1:35:11But I don't think of it as a religious movie. I think of it
- 1:35:15as using religious fantasy elements to tell an interesting story, you know what I
- 1:35:20mean? Yeah, Well, what do you think about like when Scorsese uses
- 1:35:25Catholicism, which he does in tons of his movies, a lot of characters
- 1:35:29are well have an active faith. There's silence. There's Last Temptation of Christ.
- 1:35:31Yeah, that's silent. I'm getting chills thinking about Last Temptation of Christ.
- 1:35:35I love that movie. I think it's just amazing. And to my
- 1:35:40point, when that movie came out, conservative Christians were picketing out front the
- 1:35:45movie theater because it proposes an alternative history in which Jesus actually gives into the
- 1:35:53temptation on the cross and allows himself to come down, you know, Satan
- 1:35:58tempt I think he doesn't. No, I think that what the film says
- 1:36:01is that the temptation is like temporally long, so he's really truly tempted.
- 1:36:08He gets to kind of see it, but then he ends up not doing
- 1:36:10it. But yeah, people got all a flutter about it. But yeah,
- 1:36:13even just that, right, they were very a flutter about it.
- 1:36:15Yeah, I mean think about cartoons of Muhammed, right, people get pretty
- 1:36:20quickly about when I was younger and still kind of in this mindset, I
- 1:36:27fully indoctrinated into the Jesus world and for better for us, and watching that
- 1:36:32movie. It didn't cause me to be a flutter. It actually quite moved
- 1:36:36me and teaches lessons that I think are important to teach around this, you
- 1:36:42know. Like one lesson I think is that, look, the point of
- 1:36:45religion, the point of the story of Jesus is not for us to beat
- 1:36:50it over other people's head or to be super dogmatic and precious about our version
- 1:36:58of the story. The purpose is so that we can reflect on ourselves and
- 1:37:02society and the meaning of life and those around us and have compassion and love
- 1:37:10and understanding and forgiveness. Like, it doesn't matter what is literally written.
- 1:37:15It matters how we work with it and what we do with it, you
- 1:37:19know. And that Scorsese story has that kind of vibe to it, you
- 1:37:25know, Whereas if they don't tell those kind of stories, then the dogmatic
- 1:37:30conservatives will run the show, which I'm sure you laments every day. Right.
- 1:37:35Yeah, it's a it's an ongoing process of deep mess. So you
- 1:37:40got to get your cheeseburger out there, man, you gotta start. Well,
- 1:37:44you should watch it. You should make a reaction video to chosen.
- 1:37:46Just just watch it and make a reaction. A series of I'd watched the
- 1:37:50shit out of that. Well, we'll see. I have been integrating YouTube
- 1:37:55and video and actually having a lot of fun with that and feel a lot
- 1:37:59of creativity around it. So far, I've drawn the line at reaction videos.
- 1:38:03But but we'll see. Maybe I'll get there. So let me let
- 1:38:06me ask you about your guitars. So I see a jazz master or a
- 1:38:11Jaguar jazz master. That's it's a it's a jazz master. I have my
- 1:38:15jazz master right over there as well. And you have what looks to be
- 1:38:19an old Gibson or Martin. I think it's an old silver tone silver tone?
- 1:38:25Is that? Is it a Beatles thing that you're going for? Because
- 1:38:27I also see a Hoffner bass maybe on the lower corner. Yeah, that's
- 1:38:30a that's a fake hoffnerphone bass. I can tell. I can tell it
- 1:38:34by just the corner of the bass. That's that's eagle eyer. That's eagle
- 1:38:39eyed right there, Kurt, No, So my like I'm on my second
- 1:38:44or third career, depending on if you want to collapse the two different music
- 1:38:46careers into one. But uh, you know, I was toured in an
- 1:38:50emo pop band for a decade called Sherwood, and then I've been a commercial
- 1:38:55composer for basically a decade after that, writing music for ads, and so
- 1:38:59the these guitars are sort of the stable that helped me get different sounds for
- 1:39:03all these different genres and approaches for ad music. I'm pretty much done with
- 1:39:08that now and just you know, pursuing psychology and working with clients and all
- 1:39:13of that. But but yeah, so that's I do. Like my favorite
- 1:39:15bands, the Beach Boys and the Beatles are way up there, so that
- 1:39:19kind of you know, sixties pop thing is. So that's yeah, that's
- 1:39:23why I got those instruments. Although actually I bought the silvertone Acoustic for an
- 1:39:28AD that was supposed to sound like early Dylan, and I didn't have anything
- 1:39:31like it, and went and spent two hundred bucks on this thing, and
- 1:39:34then I actually got the ad that never happens. That was like, that's
- 1:39:39an exception. That proves the rule that you're buying gear you think to make
- 1:39:42you more money, and you never do. In that case, I actually
- 1:39:45did pay for the guitar. That's cool,