Latest / Back in the Circle / Episode 3: The third voice in the Circle
Transcript
- Joshua: All right, well welcome back to Back in the Circle. And joining me today for episode three is my good buddy Ben Miller. How's it going, Ben? Hey, hey. Ben Miller: Hey Josh. Good man. I'm glad we're finally doing this. Joshua: I know, right? Man, crazy. I flew all the way to Cape Cod to kinda launch this thing off from a start. And right at be right at the beginning we ended up having technical difficulties, which then based on our schedules didn't allow you and I to get an episode in. So but at least me, you and Brian got to all hang out, you know, see the Cape. So well you guys Ben Miller: Yep. And like if anything if anything it's good practice, you know. Obstacles. Joshua: Yeah, absolutely. Exactly. And a good test for mindfulness, you know. Like we definitely had to practice patience and you know, we both had our moments. Ben Miller: Yeah, slip fall, get back up, and here we are now. Joshua: Yep, exactly. So yeah. So all right. Well, let's start this thing off here. I know basically episode one kind of feed into my story and kind of how my my coming of of seeking knowledge and discovery started. And we kind of covered a little bit of that with Brian. So do you have any story you'd like to start off with of any anything that created any epiphanies in your life or things that led you down a path that you are currently on now? Ben Miller: It's like a there's definitely like a series. hard to think of like a first one, but as long as I can remember, my family and my dad and my grandfather always talked about faith and values and attitude, but not in a religious sense. But that was always like a general focus of kind of a North Star, what to bring yourself back to. Hey, where are you at right now? Where's your faith? Where your values? Where's your attitude at? So there was always kind of this like I think I said North Star before, but that was sort of like a grounding Joshua: Yeah. Ben Miller: thing for me at a really young age. so there was always, you know, Buddhist love lists and I ended up in like deeply entrenched in Buddhism. So I think that was my first list, like my first little snippet of what would end up being the Four Noble Truths and the Eightfold Path later on. Joshua: Right. Okay. So yeah, so I mean you and I in our older years we've definitely gotten into talking about Buddhism and whatnot. do you remember so like when you and I hung out when I lived in Cape Cod and you were a kid, I mean I met you when you were like nine between nine and ten. So y Ben Miller: Yeah, I don't remember life before Josh really. Joshua: What do you mean? Like before Josh? Before meeting me or? yeah, I see. Ben Miller: Well just you've always been in my life, yeah. Like you've been in my life since I was so young. Like I remember Joshua: Yeah. Ben Miller: we'd be at the beach and he'd be talking to about the ego and just breaking my head open and you know, planting seeds that wouldn't sprout for many years later. Joshua: Right, right. Well, yeah, that's funny. Cause I mean, when I moved to Cape Cod, I was kind of on my own self self journey, you know, ro the road less traveled, trying to find my path. And so you you met me in my like early to mid twenties, I'd say. And Ben Miller: Mm-hmm. Joshua: like back then, going back that far, I mean, that was that was the beginning of my lessons of the ego, not even understanding. the layers, you know, and like what was to even come. So yeah, I met you back in that time for for me, for my life. But like you had mentioned Buddhism Ben Miller: Mm-hmm. Joshua: a minute ago. So like you're I mean, I know your grandfather, an awesome man by the way. you know, j I remember actually he was just there on the visit to Cape Cod. So I got to hang out with him again. And I he had a nice analogy I liked where he was talking about that he he kind of sees everything as there's a fence and you're you're walking along the fence and to one side of the fence is anything that's life supporting. And to the other side of the fence is anything that doesn't support life. And we might call that good and bad, but that's just what it is. And so he says any choice you make, as long as it's support life, then it's it's gotta be a good choice. So I kinda like that analogy. But you Ben Miller: Yeah. Joshua: know, being that you were, know, being raised obviously by your father and then also your influence of your grandfather prior to your adult getting into Buddhism that I do know about, was there any specific thing when you were younger That led you on that quest of even questioning like Buddhism or any religion specifically. Ben Miller: Hmm. I have a really early memory of my other grandfather taking me birdwatching when I was really young. And he was kind of one of the first people per he was probably the first person to ever really like show me what it meant to be still and to be quiet in those moments. So it wasn't necessarily like I picked up stillness and silence, you know, from that. And I'll never forget that actually, like Just walking through the woods with him and being a little kid and being all excited and just wanting to yap, yap, yap the whole time. And him kind of pulling me aside and being like, Hey, like we got plenty of time for that, but we're we're here right now. And like experience what this is and like hear the leaves and hear the sounds of the birds and like keep your eyes open because you don't know what you're gonna see. And now here we are. I'm thirty-three now, and I was just bird watching with Libby the other day and still having those same moments all these years later. And you find the Dharma in everything once you start looking for it, you know? And I just think it's great because whether it's bird watching or music, like I could talk about music too, and how my dad's love for music, you know, and his like obsession with classic rock and the Grateful Dead, you know, you start paying attention to these lyrics. Everywhere you look, people are kind of sneaking Dharma into your life if you're paying attention. Whether it's your grandfather talking to you about how to be still, or it's like a Grateful Dead song or a Rush song or a Led Zeppelin song. And these guys, as like wild and crazy as they were in that time, they were all in the late sixties and seventies early seventies tapping into something that we as a culture hadn't really seen in the United States yet. And so being Joshua: Right. Ben Miller: I was that little kid running around wearing like Bob Marley T shirts and tie dyes and Grateful Dead stuff. And I went through other phases too that were like very left field and wonky. But that's it. You know, we're trying to figure out who we are until we find out, you know, what's the truth of the self, right? There is no self. So that makes Joshua: Right. Yeah, right. So for Ben Miller: all of those phases change a lot. Joshua: yeah, for sure. Exactly. How many faces do you wear? so for the for listeners that don't know what Dharma is, let's reflect on that a little bit because for you and I, that's pretty common terminology. And I know like Ben Miller: Yeah. Joshua: as I as I run the sets in Hollywood and as a foreman, I have my morning meeting all the time and I always do a read at the end of my meeting. Like we talk about work and then I always end it on a positive note with some read, you know, and Everybody seems to appreciate it. But anytime the word Dharma comes up, I always do a little touch on that just to for for guys Ben Miller: Mm. Joshua: that are with me that don't know it, just so it gives them a little bit of context. So for our listeners, why don't you give them a little bit of context to what that means to you? Ben Miller: Well, ask ten times, get ten different answers, I guess, but for me it's just kind of the nature of reality. You know, the nature of reality and especially the the path that was set forth for us by the Buddha and then has been carried on as an oral tradition over the last twenty six hundred years. And it's sort of just a roadmap on how to live your life so as to not avoid suffering, but to experience suffering in a different way. Because that's what the Buddha taught us, like from the jump, first teachings of the Buddha, you know, the four noble truths, which are I gotta like play it back. Joshua: Right. Ben Miller: In life in life there's inevitable suffering. Right? Everybody stubs their toe. Joshua: Which they which they right, which they call Duca. Ben Miller: Right, dukkha. Which like more directly Joshua: Which I think translates more Ben Miller: translated as dissatisfaction. Dissatisfaction Joshua: Yes. Ben Miller: or like a broken I heard Joseph Goldstein, who's like a great Dharma teacher, he said that the most direct translation it's a broken spoke in a wheel. So like imagine the feeling of like a flat tire that like clunk clunk, cluck clunk, clunk, like it's when you had a s have like a skip moment in your life. I stubbed my toe. my wife left me. Like these are the polarities of intensity that you're dealing with, but it's all dukkha or suffering or dissatisfaction. So that's the first Joshua: Yeah. Suffering. Okay. Right. Right. So that's number one. Ben Miller: one. You're gonna you're gonna have a bad day. That's gonna happen. Number two, so in life is inevitable suffering. there is a cause to the suffering. That's the second one. So cause and effect, these are the laws of cause and effect. there is an end to suffering. That's the third law, the third noble truth. Nothing lasts forever. This is the law of impermanence. And then the fourth is the end of suffering is contained in the Eightfold Path, which is just a longer roadmap of how to experience life in such a way so that dissatisfaction isn't so dissatisfactory and causing so much suffering. Because you you Joshua: Correct. Correct. Right. Yeah, and then Ben Miller: learn sorry, go ahead. Joshua: I was gonna say and and the Noble Eightfold Path, like I don't rem remember it so much verbatim, but you know, the Noble Eightfold Path is, you know, things like right livelihood, you know, meaning if you make a living, Ben Miller: Mm-hmm. Joshua: you you know, as long as you're aligned with integrity, then that's aligned with the Dharma. You know, like that's that's one I remember for sure without like looking at and reading it. but Ben Miller: Yeah, I know I've got it here somewhere. Joshua: You know, but also as I've you know, for my thirty year quest of looking for truth and just studying, you know, every religion, obviously not at the level of a theologian, but just studying for my own self inquiry, they all have very similar teachings to that, you know. So I think that's there's something to be said about that, you know. And then how how many texts or teachings that were only done orally before we even had written language that they were already teaching each other from from learning, you know. I mean, hunter and gatherers Ben Miller: Mm-hmm. Joshua: obviously had dukkha also, you know? Like they they had suffering. Like I'm not sure that there was ever any time in history that we were ever in total bliss, you know. Ben Miller: Yeah. I don't know I don't think that that's attainable. Total bliss. Cause then that what's Joshua: Right. Well then that's in Ben Miller: that saying? Like the ignorance is bliss thing. So it's like if Joshua: Right. Ben Miller: you are in that state, then you're just completely ignorant, which is another form of suffering. Ignorance is just another form of suffering. So that Joshua: Right. It could be, yeah. Ben Miller: bliss would be illusory. Joshua: Yeah. Yeah, I mean there's so many parables and I think we I think we tend to dismiss so many of the teachings as like a cliche thing, you know? like Ben Miller: Mm-hmm. Joshua: the ignorance is bliss, you know, and I mean there's there's not any more coming to the top of my head at the moment, but yeah, I feel like there's so many teachings. Like you mentioned music and you know, what what little tidbit is out there in a lyric, you know. I mean, do you have any specific Ben Miller: sobre. Joshua: I'm sure you do. I mean I have I have many, like, but you know, certain lyrics that Ben Miller: yeah. Yep. Joshua: catch you and just kinda resonate and become this voice that's always like, you know, when you when you fall down, it's like the it's like the lyric that's the voice that gets Ben Miller: Mm. Joshua: you back up, you know? I mean Ben Miller: Yeah. I mean the more you look for it, the more you see it everywhere. There's I've got tons of Do you wanna go down that road? 'Cause if we open that box I could turn this into a whole musical podcast. Joshua: Yeah, right. No, I think that might well, I mean, let's let's go down that road with one. I mean, give me your give me your Ben Miller: Sure. Joshua: your top your top one that comes to mind. Ben Miller: Yeah. The one I think about it every day. So it's a Grateful Dead song called Eyes of the World. And the lyric is wake up to find out that you are the eyes of the world. And I've been listening to that song since I was a little kid. Like my dad's been playing Grateful Dead in the house since I was born. So that's always been present in my life. And I think that songs, the meaning of songs change as we grow, you know. Joshua: Agreed. Ben Miller: And so wake up to find out that you are the eyes of the world. is just this like the aha moment of like, consciousness. Like, what is consciousness? And the deeper that we go down that rabbit hole of, well, if I am the eyes of the world, you know, and we all are, well we are all are this one thing. And then I came to find out later on that the eyes of the world is a book that was written by a Tibetan master like however many hundreds of years ago. So like these guys were tapped into this stuff when they're writing these songs and it's just really, really cool to be you feel like an archaeologist sort of with your listening, it's just like, man, I found this new fossil of like information that I'm so excited about. Like these guys were connected to something that I'm connecting with now, sixty years Joshua: Right. Ben Miller: later. Joshua: yeah. Ben Miller: You know, and they were connecting to something from hundreds of years before that was written in Sanskrit and then translated. I mean, they're still translating that stuff. Joshua: Yeah. yeah. Yeah. Fascinating stuff. Ben Miller: So but yeah. Joshua: Yep. Yeah, I know like so for me as far as in music, there was always kind of like a listening to the music for the rhythm sake, right? Like for the music. Like if the piece got me musically, then it got me. But I hadn't quite Ben Miller: Mm-hmm. Joshua: discovered the depth of lyrics or what was really behind that, you know. I know like when Brian and I talked, we talked a little bit about a song from Incubus. I believe the song's called Drive. And you know, back in my high school years, I just thought that because like one of the lyrics in it is something like, would you I know it says, Would you choose water over wine and hold your own and drive? And I just thought that was a song about like choosing not to drink and drive, you know? When when in Ben Miller: Ha ha ha Joshua: reality it's really about like Driving your own experience, you know, like making the choices right through basically mindfulness. And through mindfulness, you can achieve less suffering because you by applying mindfulness to the thoughts that are arising, you can detach from the thoughts and realize that's not me. You know, so now, Ben Miller: Is it Joshua: and like you said, like the meaning kind of changes as the years go on, you know. So But yeah, for me, like that song represents a lot more than what it meant to a high school teenage mind, you know. But for what what Ben Miller: Yeah, totally. Joshua: what I was gonna say, because I got off track a bit, what cracked me open and and led me to actually look at lyrics, where I then went backwards and looked at lyrics of of songs I liked in the past, was specifically a tool song. From the band tool. And I remember I was I was building a set. I don't remember the set, but it was we were working on a night crew. Cause typically in Hollywood, if you have to get up a big set, you'll work like two 12 hour shifts and you'll work 6 a.m. to 6 p.m. And then the night crew will come in at 6 p.m. and they'll work till 6 a.m. And I was on the night crew. And night crew is always a little different because it's more relaxed. Like usually the bosses aren't around. And I don't know. It's just it's a different feel. It kind of goes by faster. You're like delusionally tired, and there's a lot that goes on where you're while you're getting on schedule for a night shift. Ben Miller: Mm-hmm. Joshua: but because it was a little bit more low-key, I had my own job. I had I wasn't running sets back then. I was just a prop maker as a carpenter builder. And I had my headphones on and I was listening to a tool album, and there was a song where he was talking about the ego. And he said, I have to crucify the ego before I pine away. And I guess because of hearing it on the headphones, like that lyric, like it hit me differently. You know, like like I knew the words in my head in a way, but like somehow on the headphones, like I'm like, what's he saying? You know, so then I wanted to pull up the lyrics and like try to go, like, well, what's what's this song ultimately about? You know? And I don't remember the song specifically by title, but I know it was on the album Lateralus And Ben Miller: Mm. Joshua: That was kind of the song that really woke me up to lyrics. And then from that point on I started like, you know, now listening to music for lyrics. So Ben Miller: Yeah, it's Joshua: Yeah. Ben Miller: it's always that like it'll be a one phrase that hooks ya. And then Joshua: Yeah. Ben Miller: if you're curious enough, that hook pulls you to the surface and then before you know it you're gasping for Joshua: Yeah. Ben Miller: air and my god, this is so crazy. Joshua: Right, right. Yeah, and I mean Ben Miller: Yeah, I love that. Joshua: it doesn't just have to be a a song or a lyric, you know, it could be a movie or who knows. I mean, now with social media and everything these days, who knows like what it what it could be, you know? And you Ben Miller: Yeah. Joshua: might hear something today and ten years from now it's gonna mean something different. You know? Ben Miller: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Joshua: So well let's see. Let's Let's hit a little bit more on your quest into Buddhism because I know like you Ben Miller: Yeah. Joshua: and I, you and I have known each other like long enough. I mean, we've we've taken a trip to Costa Rica with your dad and surfed together. I mean, that was your first trip. We took you out of the country. And I mean, back then, you know, we were hanging out, we were we were friends, but some somewhere along the line, all of a sudden, like you found this Buddhism. You hadn't told me about it, and then somehow we reconnected. And we all of a sudden started like talking the same language. And Brian and I touched on this a little bit in episode two, because he wasn't speaking the language because I'm doing my education through reading and he's on his own path, yet they're they're still parallel. You know, like a lot of his knowledge, and and insight into mindfulness came from the Waking Up app, which we've all shared. But He didn't talk the language. So even though we were talking about Ben Miller: Yeah. Joshua: the same thing, he wouldn't he wouldn't get it as far as it being the same thing until one day I threw the word Dzogchen out and and he was like, Well, how's it spelled? And as I spelled it for him, then he knew what it was through the context of the Waking Up Ben Miller: Mm. Joshua: app. Whereas for you, I think I don't know if I introduced the Waking Up app to you or if Brian did. Like he introduced it to me, but You and I somehow started talking and realized we were talking the same language. And then we became each other's sangha, which, for those that don't know that, the sangha, along with Buddhist terminology and Dharma, the Sangha is basically the community. So you and I became each other's community to be able to talk that language and share stories, which helped lift each other up and strengthen the lessons. And I know. I was specifically on Book of Boba Fett when that kind of began because it became our habit that you were always off on Tuesdays and Wednesdays. And quite often back then, that was also in the heart of COVID, because Book of Boba Fett went Ben Miller: Mm-hmm. Joshua: on in twenty twenty and we all had to wear masks. And you and I, I would get to work early, like five AM, five thirty. And then we had at least a half hour talk on Tuesdays and sometimes Wednesday as well. Either one or the other, sometimes both. And we would talk Ben Miller: Mm-hmm. Joshua: about what we were learning and share books and insights and stuff. So so give a little bit of background to your path that led that led up to that Buddhism point in your life that allowed us to have that conversation that we considered each other each other's sangha. Ben Miller: Sure. It's kind of hard to like get an idea of when it started because the trail just keeps going all the way back to birth. But I was looking for something and I get really like intense. Whether it's like I get really intense about exercise or playing music or I'm a chef and like I got really, really intense in my twenties about just being as good as I could at that. And nothing was like really filling whatever the void was, you know, drugs, alcohol, like tried many, many different avenues to like fill this space. and I got really into stand up comedy while I was trying to like not drink anymore and get through this kind of rough patch. And I found this comedian or a couple of comedians who were involved With my t now my teacher, David Nicktern. So through like very odd avenues, like there's this comedian Duncan Trussell and another one named Pete Holmes. And Pete Holmes is very much like involved in the Ram Doss community, as is Duncan Trussell. And Duncan had now my teacher, David, on his podcast. So I was just into comedy. And I heard this guy talk and I had heard Ram Das and I had heard, you know, I'd been reading Taoism since I was in high school. So there was always kind of this little thread in my life of spirituality, but it was always just just that, you know, just a thread, just something that I dabbled in. And then upon listening to this guy talk about mindfulness meditation and feeling so lost and like willing to kind of try anything. I was like, well, I'll just do this guy's course. And you know, I had quote unquote meditated before that, but it was it had no real structure. It's just a guy sitting, you know, which full circle ends up being all you're doing anyway. Joshua: Yeah. Ben Miller: But but but I I decided I wanted to really like learn everything I could about this and realized how many different branches there were already in my life. Into this world, you know, like it turned like what are the odds that I grew up listening to The Grateful Dead, idolizing Jerry Garcia? My father followed them for years, and then my meditation teacher ends up having had been in a bluegrass band with Jerry Garcia in the 1970s. Like just all of these like really weird little things where you follow the s I'm a signs guy. I follow the signs, and I'm like, well, this is my teacher. And I really quickly decided if I wanted to learn about this. Someone told me once, if you really know how to do something, you know how to teach it. And I was like, All right, well then I'm gonna take the teacher training course and then next thing you know, you know, I'm spending hours and hours and hours on the cushion and doing Zoom calls and meeting these people from all over the world and now I'm a certified meditation teacher for Dharma Moon and Tibet House. And there it is. It just kinda happened on its own. Joshua: Right. Ben Miller: Yeah. Joshua: Yeah. I know, yeah, we went we went different directions and yet in a way the same direction on meditation. So like what so the meditation that you practice, because I know we had a sit together when I came to my my visit in Cape Cod last week or so and Ben Miller: Mm-hmm. Joshua: I remember we sat outside and Like I sit eyes closed and I practice Vipassana And while we were sitting, there was like an obvious no to me, there was an obvious noise. Like it was definitely a critter or something. And I said something after we were done about like, I wonder what that was. And you were like, it was a squirrel. And I said, how how do you know that? And you said, because I I sit with my eyes open. So, like I didn't know that until until we sat together on that. So, like Talk about that a little bit 'cause your practice is a little different than mine in the sense that you do open eye meditation and I do closed eye meditation. Ben Miller: Sure. So when we talk about Vipassana, which is like original teaching stuff, you know, this is like this is how the Buddha taught in a lot of in a lot of theories. I believe so, but so tough when you're playing a game of telephone for over two thousand years. This is what the Buddha said. No, this is what the Buddha said. Like that's a tricky Joshua: That's good point. Ben Miller: one. So when I was taught mindfulness meditation. It was described to me as the combination of vipassana and shamata. And so vipassana is looked at as like deep concentration. And shamata is a calm-abiding meditation. That's how it was explained to me. So I lose I've lost students to the open eye thing because people have a very clear picture in their head of what they think meditation is because of movies and books and all of these things where somebody often sometimes people come into class and they go like this and I'm like w you don't have to do that. It's Joshua: Right. Ben Miller: I don't really I've never met anybody like anybody teaching that in particularly. But but I also could be wrong because I don't know everything. So mindfulness meditation, the combination of concentration and calm abiding. So you take your seat You place your attention on your breath, and you allow your gaze to just rest. You're not really looking at anything in particularly, but you're not shutting down any of your sense perceptors. And so what that's doing, I mean, if you're here to be completely in the moment and you're shutting down a sense perceptor, you experienced it. So upon the sound, the rustling of what ended up being a squirrel, now you're experiencing what is that? And the curiosity. Now it's not to say that you couldn't get past that curiosity and just be like, it doesn't matter what it is, I'm focusing on the breath, breath, breath, breath, breath, breath. But with my my practice, the practice that I do, the answer is right there in front of you immediately because of the senses that I have available to me. So the question arises, the question's answered. And the eyes are also a tool to help you remain focused. Because sometimes I'll sit with my eyes closed too. But I notice that when I sit with my eyes closed, it becomes much easier for me to get lost in my imagination, where like I can even like visualize things and I'm a super imaginative person. So that can be counterproductive for a meditation practice where I'm trying to sort of just focus on the breath, not sort of just focus on the breath. Joshua: Mm-hmm. Ben Miller: I think Allowing all of the sense doors to be open while you're practicing deepens your focus in a way and allows you to practice in waking life too. Does that make sense? Joshua: Yeah, I think so. Ben Miller: I kinda start rambling a little bit when I get into it, but I have so many different avenues. I've explained why I sit with my eyes open so many different times. I have a lot of reasons. Joshua: Yeah, yeah. Yeah, I mean I've known about it as being another meditation technique. That's the thing, like there are so many techniques. and you're right. I think that a lot of people that don't already meditate, they have a miss like a misconception as to what it is, And It's not about not having thoughts. Like I I like I get that some sometimes from people. They'll say, well, I I've tried Ben Miller: Totally. Joshua: meditating. I I can't do it because I can't stop thinking. Whereas the premise of it is not so much to not think as much as it is to watch your thoughts and not attach to your thoughts. You know, it's like they're your thoughts are more like passing clouds in the sky and they're just moving, but like you don't have to like grasp any one of them. And I think then what you learn in meditation, regardless of what style and form of meditation you practice, it then carries over to your waking life. And that's then it it creates a tool that allows you to make choices in your waking life to not suffer less, but change the meaning to the suffering, which inevitably reduces Ben Miller: Mm-hmm. Joshua: the hold that the suffering can have on you. You know? And like Ben Miller: Yep, absolutely. Joshua: so your your practice is different than my practice. And then coming up in an episode soon, we're gonna have a really good friend of mine, Kelly, who was a set painter that I've known for many years. She's moved back to New York, or specifically Pennsylvania. But she practices TM meditation, which is transcendental meditation. And Ben Miller: Hmm. Yeah. Joshua: I mean, that's a whole other level, you know, and it's like, and for her, that's that's the right one, you know. So yeah, well, Ben Miller: Yeah. Joshua: I think over the course of this show, I mean, the idea is really to l through shared stories, to leave guideposts along the way for all those that are asking the existential questions, you know. I mean, maybe maybe everybody doesn't ask those questions. I I tend to make friends with people that do somehow that seems to be the story of my life. I mean, if if you've been a friend of mine throughout any of my adolescence, childhood or whatever, that was that was my topic of conversation. Like I'm I'm a questioning individual that's kind of ultimately, I'd say, looking for truth. And you know, so the idea of the show is really to get through conversation and shared stories to leave guideposts. For answers to those questions, if they're out there, you know, andor what guideposts have already been left for us that we're either not listening to or not understanding the meaning because of being translated from an ancient language into the language that we speak, or through Manipulation of the meaning and it being taken out of context, you know, because there's so many great masters along the way in our history, you know, and I think so often within any religious sect or religion itself, I I feel like there's always this. Not wanting to accept the lesson that might be valuable from somebody else's religion because you automatically disregard their religion as not being true because you believe so much in your own. But Ben Miller: Mm-hmm. Joshua: a lot of the religions were formed over, you know, centuries to thousands of years apart that. The context of the time as humanity has evolved would have been different. So people who figured it out 2,500 years before another person figured it out, again, after it was lost, it would look different, you know? But Ben Miller: Mm-hmm. Joshua: I mean, there's there's so many greats out there. And it's like if you're not willing to to listen open-mindedly, then you might miss a very valuable lesson that would essentially give you a better quality of life by reducing the level of suffering that you experience, you know? Ben Miller: Mm-hmm. And it doesn't hit until it hits. You know? Joshua: Right. Ben Miller: Like it's that old thing you can bring a horse to water. But you can't make him read a dharma book. Joshua: This is true. If a horse could even read. Ben Miller: But yeah, I mean like that's that's what's important about shows like what you're creating here. And like we're so lucky to be there's so many pros and cons to being alive in this time, but being in the information Joshua: True that. Ben Miller: age, this this information is like so much more accessible now than ever before. And to your point too, like you know, we look at different traditions and different teachers. TM might work for somebody, Vipassana might work for somebody, mindfulness meditation might work for somebody. These are all paths leading up the same mountain, you know? Joshua: I agree. Ben Miller: And I like I really like thinking about it that way because we're so because we're still just human beings, you know, we're not I don't think that we're fully cooked yet. We're not fully evolved. So we're still stuck in this tribal way of thinking. Well, these are my people, and I have to protect my people and our way of thinking, and then that spans to entire nations and huge religions and all of these things. But then You've got people like yourself and like many, many, many more, and there I think there are more every day are asking those questions. Like Ramdas, you know, like look at what Ramdas did in with Timothy Leary, and but then everything that came after that, like going from being a Harvard professor, science guy, like very, very rigid, to taking LSD and then whoa, now I'm asking the questions, and then going to India and finding his guru. You know, I'm not a Hindu and I'm not Jewish, but like he up until the day he died, like claimed both of those things. He's like, I'm a Hindu Jew and I practice Buddhist meditation and I do all of these things. And I would consider him to be probably one of my greatest teachers who died before I he died before I even got into this stuff. You know, so yeah, I mean, you gotta take the best and leave the rest and get it where you can. Joshua: Yeah, for sure. 'Cause you never know what is gonna be lying underneath the stone you turn over and what Ben Miller: Right. Joshua: what value and insight it might provide, you know. Again coming back, Ben Miller: Mm-hmm. Joshua: whether it's a that lyric, a movie, you know. And even in movies like Ben Miller: Mm-hmm. Or just a thing that you say to somebody, man. Like I remember being a kid and you talking to me about my ego and me just wrestling with what that meant for like all throughout middle school. Like I was just a kid, you know. What is my ego? What is my ego? What is my ego? Working with that. And then later on, before I knew who Ram Das was, you were talking to me about that mantra, you know, I am loving awareness. Well, what does that mean? Joshua: right. Ben Miller: Like what does that mean? What does that mean? You know? So getting these questions in my head long before I had found the tools to answer them. That was I think really important to like my not to go off track, but like my spiritual development because I had already been asking these questions for so long just to myself before ever really exploring anybody who was giving any answers. Joshua: Right. Ben Miller: You know. Joshua: yeah. Yeah. Ben Miller: So thanks. Joshua: And the the ego's a hard lesson to learn because you don't want to learn it, you know? Like you well, it's 'cause the it's cause it's the ego that doesn't want to learn it, you know, like the the ego doesn't want the light to be shed on it that it's it's ultimately the thing that's creating all of your suffering, you know? And that's Ben Miller: Mm-hmm. Joshua: kind of like once you once you can transcend the ego and Which that's that's layers, right? I mean, if you think you've transcended the ego, it's more than likely the ego in disguise, just saying, Look at me, I figured it out when really that might Ben Miller: Yeah. Joshua: be at best a a better polished ego, you know. Like you think Ben Miller: Yeah. Joshua: like, Well, I'm kind to people, so like I'm not an I don't have an ego, you know? And it's like maybe true enlightenment is when you actually transcend that ego. Or like the tool song that that sprung the lyrics to my mind that made me start looking at lyrics said, I have to crucify the ego before I pine away. Ben Miller: Hmm. Joshua: You know? Ben Miller: Or the the great the great and misunderstood Chogyam Trungpa said, and I'm gonna probably mess this up, he said, enlightenment is the ego's ultimate disappointment. You know. Joshua: Right. Ben Miller: I just love that. It's like you spend all the or like the student who asked the teacher, like, if I work how long is it gonna take me to get enlightened? And the teeth the master says, I Joshua: Right. Ben Miller: don't know. I don't know, three years. And he goes, But what if I work really, really hard? He goes, I don't know, maybe six years and he goes, Well what if what if I practice all the time and I don't do anything else and I just practice and I practice harder than everyone else? And the master says, Well, for you probably never Like you know. Joshua: Ha ha ha. Ben Miller: I just love those, man. Joshua: Yeah. Yeah, there's a good there's a good version of that in there's a movie that I think Sharon introduced me to called which yeah. So I wonder if you've seen this. So did you ever see a documentary? It has a lot to do with music called One Giant Leap. Ben Miller: I know about it. I know the soundtrack. Joshua: Okay. Okay, yeah, great soundtrack. So two guys went Ben Miller: Yeah. Joshua: out and basically traveled around the world with some pieces of music and they got people all around the world thinking, well, the premise of it was that if if we enjoy music and sharing stories about consciousness and life, then other people must. So they went around the world with a camera and they would put headphones on people and play like a root music that they had recorded before they left. and people would like do what they did and felt inspired to do based on what they were hearing on the headphones, and then they would record that, and then they edited all that together and made these songs from people all around the world Ben Miller: Wow. Joshua: that never even had met each other, but while they were on that quest. They also talk to people about consciousness. And so the movie's broken up into chapters and it talks about, you know, like they'll take a topic. They'll take like love, religion, war, money, whatever, God. Like they just take different topics and then they kind of group conversations along the way into those topics to structure the movie. But there's one story coming back to your thing about the the guy who wants to know how long it's gonna take to get enlightened. And there's the story and they have like these puppets. Like I don't know what country they were in or where they created the the visual aspect of it, but there's these like puppets from my memory as they're telling the story. And there's one guy and he's like he's meditating, you know, and he's asking the question of like how long is it gonna take, you know, for him to become enlightened. And he's like You know, he's he's sitting in the sun and he's getting sunburnt, but he's just like fighting that suffering to to get enlightened. And there's like ants coming up and crawling on him and he's getting bit. He's sunburnt. And he's like, you know, how long is it going to take me to get enlightened? And you know, they they have an answer. I don't remember the years they give or or whatever. And then there's this other guy, and he's kind of like just he's dancing and he just doesn't care, kind of has that I don't give a shit attitude. And then he asks the question, like, how long is it gonna take me to get enlightened? And they, you know, the answer to him was for you, you know, ten thousand lifetimes or some some just like astronomical number, right? And the guy goes, Is that all? And then just like keeps dancing and poof, he was enlightened. Ben Miller: Yeah, yeah, totally. Joshua: And I just I I always like that story because, you know, when you get into studying enlightenment and all the teachings and stuff, they have they have sudden enlightenment and gradual enlightenment. And and gradual is most Ben Miller: Mm-hmm. Joshua: people's path, in the sense that it takes time to like plant the seeds, and then you've got to nurture the seeds and water the seeds. but you just never know what one little bit of of information will come that all of a sudden just cracks you open in such a way that It's like poof, there there you're enlightened, you know? Ben Miller: Mm-hmm. Yeah, and you never know. It might really suck. It might be a really bummer of a thing. Joshua: Maybe that's why it's the ego's biggest disappointment. Like, this isn't what I thought, you know? Like I th I th Ben Miller: Yeah, yeah, you Yeah. Getting put in front of yourself. Joshua: Yeah. I think we all think that's something that's it's it's this magical thing that like once you become enlightened, you like it's like, all the problems are gonna be gone or there won't be any more suffering, you know. Ben Miller: Definitely not that. Like even the like the Tibetans have a prayer where they like and their culture is so confusing to me, but they have a prayer where they're asking for adequate suffering. They're like, please, I hope that I have a I get a life that has enough suffering in it so that I can continue to learn and so that I can continue to grow in like my dharmic life and my spiritual life. Because don't waste your suffering. You know, Joshua: Right. Ben Miller: like it's it's good stuff. Like it's that's how you learn. And Joshua: Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Ben Miller: I just I just think it's so funny, like what an interesting thing. Like, please, like I don't wanna have it too easy. Like make it hard. I want it to be hard. Yeah, but be careful what you wish Joshua: Right. Yeah, there's somebody I followed Ben Miller: for. Joshua: totally. Exactly. There's somebody I follow and she like her her teacher used to say, Pray for more suffering. And she's like, Why would you pray for more suffering? you know? but yeah, you just you never know. That's the Dharma, right? The Dharma has a way of teaching. So well, I think we've we've gotten off to a really great start here for our first episode. And thank you so much for joining me on this. That was Ben Miller: Yeah, man, of course. Joshua: Super awesome. I look forward to more. I mean, as as the introduction of this three episode launch for Back in the Circle, the premise basically being that you and Brian are going to be recurring voices. So I will be the constant and be getting guests on here for more Dharma for however the language works for anybody that But whether it be the Dharma, whether it be leaving guideposts, whatever that is. But yeah, I think that you you will definitely be a recurring guest. We have got a lot more to talk about. Like we said, we could we could Ben Miller: yeah. Joshua: make a whole episode just based on music, you know, and dive down that rabbit hole. So but Ben Miller: You're easy to talk to. Joshua: yeah, right. I mean, that's how we can waste hours on the phone. So, Ben Miller: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Joshua: but yeah, do you got any before we like sign off on this thing and close this episode out, you got any final words or anything you wanna Leave behind or set a seed for a future episode? Ben Miller: Hmm. well a lesson a lesson that I'm working on constantly is something that my teacher told me, the great David Nick Turn that if anyone is interested in mindfulness meditation should go over to Dharmamoon dot com and sign up for one of their classes. They do beginner classes, they do teacher trainings, they do retreats, they do all kinds of good stuff. So I would feel really bad if I didn't put in a little plug for my teachers and the people that got me going. Check out Dart check out Dharma Joshua: Absolutely. It's all towards the same goal. Ben Miller: Moon. Yeah, check out Dharma Moon. They're really, really cool people. They have a really great podcast network. And the great David Nicktern once said, and I'm sure he says it almost every day. there are many benefits to mindfulness meditation, but there are none if you don't practice. So you gotta practice. You gotta have Joshua: Right. Agreed. Yep. Ben Miller: you gotta grow the fruit if you want the juice. Joshua: Yeah. Yeah. And that's I was kind of saying something along the lines of that with Brian saying, you know, you can read about it all day and people, you know, they they read something. I I'm specifically saying mindfulness in this case, where you read a book about it, so you think you know it, but if you don't apply that mindfulness, it doesn't do its job because it's really just a tool that we need to have so that we can have a better quality of life, be the best version of ourselves that we can be. And by being the best version of ourselves that we can be, we help lift each other up and make other people be the better versions of themselves as well. So applied mindfulness, as I kind of coined it, somebody else might have used that term, but in my own trying to understand it. And like you said earlier about being a teacher, when you know something and then you teach something, you actually instill it in yourself better. So I'm always looking for ways to to teach it and speak. about it in ways that can resonate with people. And so I I kinda came up within my own self that that term about applied mindfulness. Cause if it's not being applied, then it's not really doing its job. So yeah. So hopefully if Ben Miller: Yeah. I mean you're a carpenter, you know, like the hammer doesn't swing if it stays in the tool belt. Joshua: Right. yeah. Yeah. There's so many analogies. I'm sure that we could, you know, Ben Miller: Yeah. Joshua: like what is it? gather water, chop wood. Like that's a Brian and I say that to each other a lot. Like we'll be like, Ben Miller: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Joshua: what's it about? It's like, yeah, that's that's life, you know, gather water, chop wood. But Ben Miller: Yeah. Yeah. Joshua: if this podcast conversations with Ben, Brian, myself, and others to come help anybody out to have their own less suffering and have a better quality of life, you know, I mean, we're all at the center of our own experience. And the better tools you have, the better quality of experience it can be. So hopefully you got something out of this. If you resonated with it and you haven't done so yet, Head over to backinthecircle.com and sign up so that you can get notified when there's new episodes. all right, Ben. Well thank you for your time. I look forward to another conversation with you and hopefully our guests listening feel the same and look to see what you bring to the table again. So thank you. And again, I'm I'm Joshua. Ben Miller: Yeah man, can't wait. Can't wait to come back. I'm glad you're doing this. Joshua: Right on. Well, again, I'm Joshua and this has been back in the circle