Latest / The Action Catalyst / Update: Get Better at Anything, with Scott H. Young (Science, Education, Learning, Self-Improvement)
Transcript
- 0:00Host: Scott Young is an author, programmer and entrepreneur
- 0:03whose book Ultralearning was an international success. We hosted
- 0:07Scott on the Action Catalyst back in 2019. But now he's back
- 0:11with a new book, Get Better at Anything. Who doesn't want to do
- 0:15that? Scott, welcome back. And before we dive into the new
- 0:18book, catch us up on what's been going on in your life since your
- 0:22last appearance.
- 0:23Scott Young: Yeah, I mean, I became a father, I have two
- 0:25kids. Now, I also spent a good chunk of the last five years
- 0:28working on this new book. So reading hundreds of books,
- 0:31hundreds of papers to make something new that I thought
- 0:33would be helpful to people.
- 0:34Host: So the new book, Get Better at Anything, is a deep
- 0:38dive into the science of mastery. To start us off, let's
- 0:41set the table and tell us exactly how you define mastery.
- 0:46Scott Young: Well, so the thing I bring this up is that you know
- 0:49why I was so interested in writing this book, is because we
- 0:53all know the experience of things that you spent a lot of
- 0:55time doing, and you're just you don't get that much better at
- 0:58it, or things that you you tried it and you failed at it, you
- 1:03weren't very good at it. And we also have experiences of like,
- 1:05Oh, we're just clicked and you just got it, and you got really
- 1:08good at it. And for me, you know, those highs and lows can
- 1:11be so extreme like the oh my god, I found a new hobby, a new
- 1:15sport, I got a new job, I'm being allotted by my peers
- 1:18versus man, I suck at this. It can be such a big extreme
- 1:21emotionally, to try to understand what are the
- 1:24ingredients? What are the reasons why sometimes it works,
- 1:26and sometimes it doesn't. So the book is not specifically about
- 1:29like how to become Tiger Woods at your golf game, or how to
- 1:33become a world concert violinist. It's to be better,
- 1:36how do we figure out wherever you are, whether you are just at
- 1:39the beginning? Or whether you are, you know, you've spent
- 1:42decades doing something? How do we get better? And what are
- 1:45those ingredients? And I think diving into the stories, the
- 1:48research the size, the kind of like systems of learning, that
- 1:51was really fun for me to try to bring that out so that these
- 1:53principles can be available to people who want to use
- 1:55Host: Is there anything that it's better to just be okay at
- 1:59rather than great?
- 2:00Scott Young: I mean, the truth is, is that most of the things
- 2:03that we do, we don't really care to get better at it. Like I
- 2:05know, if I went on YouTube right now and I looked at like videos
- 2:08on how to tie your shoes, I could find like someone doing
- 2:11some like crazy, not that I've never heard of before that like
- 2:14doesn't come on time. But like for me, I don't need to do that,
- 2:17like I'm fine tying my shoes 99.9999% of the things that you
- 2:21do in your life, it's okay to do whatever you're doing, how you
- 2:24do your laundry, how you walk to work, how you do everything. But
- 2:27the thing is, is is just because that point 00 1% of the things
- 2:30that we're doing looms so large in our life, you know, the skill
- 2:33that we do at our job that determines whether or not we get
- 2:35a promotion, like the hobby, whether or not we enjoy it
- 2:38really depends on you know, do we feel like we're good at it?
- 2:41Do we feel like we could get better at it? And so I wrote
- 2:43this book for that point. 00 1%. So you're absolutely right.
- 2:46There's tons of things where, you know, I'm not gonna worry
- 2:48about getting better at this. But what are the things where I
- 2:51want to get better at this? And you don't know how that's that's
- 2:54what I wrote the book for.
- 2:55Host: You mentioned the balance of joy and proficiency, kind of
- 2:59a chicken and the egg thing. Which do you think leads into
- 3:02the other?
- 3:03Scott Young: I mean, you hit the nail on the head, like, I have a
- 3:05whole chapter where I write about Albert benders theory of
- 3:08self efficacy. And this was his idea that our motivation to do
- 3:12things comes not just from like, would this be good for us, but
- 3:16also, like, am I capable of taking the actions that are
- 3:20necessary. And if you're not capable, the motivation might be
- 3:23low, even if the outcome is very valuable. And this plays into
- 3:27learning in a lot of ways. Because if we don't know that we
- 3:30can do something, if we don't think that we can achieve
- 3:32something, then our motivation to pursue it goes down
- 3:35dramatically. And in some ways this is adaptive, I don't want
- 3:37to say this is like a bug in our software, there's a million
- 3:40things you could be doing, it often makes sense to do, the
- 3:42things that come easier to you, this is just sort of natural
- 3:44hardwiring, but where it can be dis advantageous, if there's
- 3:47something you need to do, you can avoid doing it. And you
- 3:51struggle in the beginning, then getting that motivation off the
- 3:54ground can be really hard. And similarly, you can have fall
- 3:57starts where you like, you start out motivated, you're doing
- 4:00something but then you get stuck in the you get frustrated, and
- 4:02you give it up halfway. And so I think it's about recognizing
- 4:05this feedback loop of like being good at something and enjoying
- 4:09it and understanding that that makes understanding learning so
- 4:13important to understand that process. Because otherwise you
- 4:16just get into these situations where like, Well, yeah, I used
- 4:18to have these hobbies, but then I gave them up because
- 4:20unconsciously at some point you felt stuck, or at some point,
- 4:23you felt like you know what, I can't, I can't get better at
- 4:25this or I can't improve at it. So in some ways, learning how to
- 4:28learn is also about learning how to, you know, enjoy life about
- 4:31learning how to enjoy your job, enjoy, your hobbies, things like
- 4:34that.
- 4:35Host: You mentioned earlier that while some people have to really
- 4:38learn a skill for others, it just clicks. How do you account
- 4:41for that?
- 4:42Scott Young: So there's a couple factors. I mean, obviously I
- 4:44don't want to deny it. There are people who have maybe some
- 4:47intrinsic intelligence talent for particular domain. I don't
- 4:50want to make the claim that like well Tiger Woods just because of
- 4:53like something his dad did was the reason why he's like on The
- 4:57Mike Douglas Show at two years old lobbing golf balls. I mean,
- 5:00that's just that's just incredible, right? And people
- 5:02tend to fixate on talent, but I kind of don't like talent, not
- 5:05because, you know, it's inconvenient for my book, but
- 5:08just because it's sort of a residual concept. It's sort of
- 5:11just like, well, this is the stuff we can't explain. So
- 5:14therefore, it's talent, right. And one of the things that we've
- 5:17learned from psychology is, is the importance of background
- 5:20knowledge and background experience. So I know there's
- 5:23this study that I really liked, that was talking about reading
- 5:26ability, and they were looking at people reading sort of a
- 5:29description of a baseball game. And what they found is that the
- 5:32amount that people learn from this context dependent way more
- 5:35on whether they knew about baseball and whether they were
- 5:38good readers. So I think what happens is that sometimes you
- 5:41maybe have a little bit of ability, you have some extra
- 5:44ability, and you gain some proficiency in a skill. And
- 5:47maybe the environment also works out so that like, you know,
- 5:50maybe you're not doing that great at it in the beginning,
- 5:53but because let's say you're a kid, or because of the
- 5:55environment you're in, you're not getting punished, you
- 5:58develop some of this proficiency, then you move to a
- 6:01different environment. And you're stacked up against people
- 6:04who either have tons of proficiency, or who've never
- 6:06taken it before. And depending on where you're putting that
- 6:09group, you can feel like Oh, I'm actually I have a lot of
- 6:12aptitude for this. And so you keep going on and you get better
- 6:15at it. And other people don't, you know, my, my favorite, my
- 6:18favorite story about this is that a friend is a woman who got
- 6:21a master's in civil engineering. So this is like, you know, she's
- 6:25doing like, advanced calculus and this kind of stuff. And she
- 6:28told me with a straight face, you know what I did this intro
- 6:31programming class, and I was just, I wasn't smart enough to
- 6:34do it. And it was like, How could you say that? Well, the
- 6:37reason she said that is because the other kids in the class were
- 6:40populated with people who like picked up programming in high
- 6:43school. So she's going in there with zero, they're going there
- 6:46with 10. And she just feels like, oh, I can't do this. And
- 6:49so again, to me, I think like going back to principles, going
- 6:52back to what are the factors that motivate learning, they
- 6:55don't transform you as a golfer into Tiger Woods, but they give
- 6:58you a map, they give you a way to make progress and making
- 7:01progress, I think, ultimately, is what it's about.
- 7:04Host: In the book, you list out three main steps in the roadmap
- 7:07to learning. Could you share those with us?
- 7:09Scott Young: Yeah, so the book is organized around these three
- 7:12sections, these three big ideas that influence learning. The
- 7:15first is See. This is the idea that actually most of what we
- 7:18know how to do comes from other people. So things that make it
- 7:21easier to learn from other people will accelerate our
- 7:24progress. Things that make it harder to learn from other
- 7:27people will slow our progress. And you can see this across many
- 7:30domains. Like, you know, the example I used to open the book
- 7:33is as Tetris proficiency, whereas like, the game was super
- 7:36popular, and people are obsessed with it. But actually, if you
- 7:39look at their scores and their rankings, they're not actually
- 7:42that good. The kids that like 13 year old kids who play Tetris
- 7:45today, who are like obsessed with the game are much better.
- 7:48And the reason why, because the internet created the ability to
- 7:51like, every single technique and strategy is now learnable, and
- 7:54accessible and instant, you can watch replays of the best
- 7:57players playing the game. Whereas before, it was just
- 8:00like, you know, your big brother's friend who could live
- 8:03you like, oh, yeah, you got to do this or something to get you
- 8:06to the game. And I mean, Tetris is a bit of a trivial example.
- 8:09But the principle is universal, this ability to learn from
- 8:12others. And whether or not it's easy or not, makes a huge
- 8:15difference. The second is do obviously, to get good at
- 8:18something requires a lot of practice. But there's a lot of
- 8:20nuance to this, the kind of practice matters to our brains,
- 8:23our effort saving machines, we are hardwired to try to avoid
- 8:26expending effort. And expending effort is often what's required
- 8:30for learning. And so often, what we get involved with practice is
- 8:33trying to overcome this natural tendency to not use effort. So
- 8:36an example I talked about is like Retrieval Practices, a big
- 8:39idea. This is the idea that we remember things better when we
- 8:42try to remember them than when we see them right in front of
- 8:45us. So if you already have encountered some information,
- 8:48and you try to recall it, that act of effort is going to make
- 8:51you remember it more, because it's as if the brain saying oh,
- 8:54well, the paper with the answers in front of me, so I don't
- 8:57actually need to store this in my head. And so this do
- 9:00component I also have break this down into four like Maxim's that
- 9:03are covering some of these ideas. But fine tuning the
- 9:06practice is super important. And then the last one, of course, is
- 9:09getting feedback corrections for our actions, not just a teacher
- 9:12saying do this, write this do this this way. But also just
- 9:15even just interacting with the situation we're having, like
- 9:18realistic practice is so important for gaining
- 9:21proficiency and something that's often missing when we're
- 9:23starting out learning skills.
- 9:25Host: Are those three weighted at all? Or is there a resistance
- 9:28to one over the others? I can see potential resistance to
- 9:32feedback, for example.
- 9:33Scott Young: So it gets it depends on the feedback we're
- 9:35talking about too. Because in some ways, like if you are
- 9:38skiing down a mountain, the most important feedback is the one
- 9:41coming from the hill through your feet. Like if you didn't
- 9:44have that you couldn't learn to ski. So I take feedback in this
- 9:47kind of broader sense than just like, you know, the teacher's
- 9:50red pen. But but the thing I would say the thing I would say
- 9:53about that is that these three ingredients it's like if you're
- 9:56making a cake you need like flour, sugar and like an egg or
- 9:59something. If you're missing one is not going to taste good. And
- 10:02so I think part of the problem is recognizing when one of these
- 10:06elements is deficient, and it's going to really depend on your
- 10:09situation, you know, we were talking about Tetris, this sort
- 10:11of being able to see other players was the major
- 10:14breakthrough, players playing the game, they got tons of
- 10:16practice, when you play the game, you know, whether you win
- 10:19or lose, you get quick, immediate feedback, that wasn't
- 10:21the problem. The problem was that techniques which were
- 10:24rather subtle, which were not obvious and took a while to
- 10:27develop, someone could develop it, but then it would stay with
- 10:30that person, it wouldn't get transmitted. And this is true in
- 10:33many domains that we struggled to learn because the best
- 10:36practices, the way to do it are stuck inside the heads of
- 10:39experts, and we have difficulty getting it out. But for other
- 10:42skills is not like that. Like if you want to learn, I don't know,
- 10:45if you want to learn basic math or something like that. There
- 10:48are like 1000s of books. And like every single thing, giving
- 10:51you how to do it, the difficulty is often getting practice
- 10:54getting feedback, figuring out well, what are the concepts that
- 10:56I have that are mistaken, getting the right level of
- 10:59practice, that's the difficulty. So in my mind, you know, I kind
- 11:03of present the book, not so much of a, it's more like, you know,
- 11:07if you had a recipe, you're like, Oh, this is what's
- 11:09missing, or this is what is happening, and it's going to
- 11:11vary from person to person. But laying out all the ingredients
- 11:14is very important. I was really grateful to be able to tie in
- 11:18Joseph Henrich. He's a Harvard anthropologist and economist,
- 11:21his work on cultural evolution. And he makes the argument kind
- 11:24of somewhat provocatively that like, there is some experimental
- 11:27evidence that shows that some of the great apes, you know, like
- 11:31chimps and orangutangs, when you compare them to small children,
- 11:34and admittedly, we're not talking about adults, partly
- 11:36because just all adults are in cultured and socialized, it's
- 11:39impossible to remove that. But when you're dealing with very
- 11:41young children, they actually do better than those children at
- 11:44some kinds of raw problem solving tasks. I mean, one of my
- 11:47favorite demonstrations, as he showed this video, it's a chimp
- 11:51doing some kind of memory task, there's the numbers, one to 10
- 11:53on a grid, and they like blink on and then they disappear
- 11:56immediately. And it's like, incredible, the chimp knows to
- 11:59like, go like one in order of all these 10. And it just goes
- 12:02like, click, click, click, click, click, click, and it gets
- 12:04it right, like it's practiced. But at the same time, I mean,
- 12:06this is a chimp, this is not even a person, and he's doing it
- 12:09so well. And he uses these examples to sort of challenge
- 12:12the idea that like, what it is that makes humans so great is
- 12:15that we're just so much smarter than every other animal. And he
- 12:18argues, that's not what it is. It's that we are really good
- 12:21social learners. Chimps, despite their problems on the ability
- 12:25are really bad at learning from other people. And so I just I
- 12:28love this because it's, it's so ironic, we all we like to say
- 12:31monkey see monkey do. But it's not, it's because the monkeys
- 12:35can't see and do is because they can't do that, that that really,
- 12:39it makes a massive Gulf in our proficiency. If we didn't have
- 12:43all our accumulated culture, if we didn't have this imitative
- 12:46ability to like, learn from the examples of other people. I
- 12:49mean, people are really inept, like he gives us stories and
- 12:52just like, you know, explorers getting lost in unfamiliar
- 12:55lands, and just doing things that to the native inhabitants,
- 12:57it just seems so stupid because of this. And so I think, you
- 13:01know, this is a real human strength, and how we're able to
- 13:04tweak that makes a big difference.
- 13:06Host: And these principles don't just apply to hard skills, you
- 13:10say they work in the artistic realm as well. And were even on
- 13:13display in the Renaissance.
- 13:14Scott Young: Part of the problem with with talking about the
- 13:17scientific research is that a lot of the cognitive psychology
- 13:20is really grounded in like math and this kind of stuff. So like
- 13:23a lot of the original research is done with this. And it's just
- 13:26like, I can't do another chapter. This has math. And so
- 13:29this was a little bit my own kind of dovetailing because you
- 13:31see a lot of the same themes in different subjects. And so one
- 13:34of the themes in mathematics research was this kind of
- 13:37tension between showing people how to do it and letting them
- 13:40solve the problems themselves. And I found John swelters work
- 13:43to be really instructive here is that he's kind of created this
- 13:46edifice of research called Cognitive Load Theory, which
- 13:49tries to explain when it's more beneficial to solve a problem
- 13:52yourself. And when it's more beneficial to see a
- 13:54demonstration. And he kind of proposes somewhat counter
- 13:57intuitively, that it is possible to solve problems without
- 14:00learning how to solve them, it's probably possible to do
- 14:02something to solve the problem and not infer like, well, this
- 14:05is the procedure for solving problems of this type. And in
- 14:08his theory, there is that part of the issue is that when you're
- 14:11solving a problem, it's very mentally demanding. And that
- 14:14mental bandwidth is devoted to solving the problem and not
- 14:17recognizing what the pattern is for solving it. And there is
- 14:20something analogous here in artistic training because during
- 14:23the Renaissance, you know, Leonardo da Vinci bought a
- 14:25jellybean guys, yo, Titian, all these, like great painters
- 14:28worked under an apprenticeship system. And this wasn't like
- 14:31some kind of design that like, Oh, this is the right way to
- 14:34teach. It was just because this was an artisanal class of people
- 14:37who were like they weren't seen as artists, they're seen as
- 14:40like, laborers, right? And Leonardo was actually one of the
- 14:43first people to sort of change this perception. But the idea
- 14:46was that you'd go to this studio, and they'd get you like,
- 14:48Okay, we're going to show you how to paint leaves and then
- 14:51you're going to paint leaves and you're going to work on that
- 14:54work on it. Now you're gonna paint this face, you're gonna
- 14:57work on this and the This idea of this like progression from
- 15:00simple elements, copying someone and then working on it. And then
- 15:03as you get better and better, you're like developing your own
- 15:06ability, and you're developing these sort of more sophisticated
- 15:09creative talents. This very much mirrors a lot of John's father's
- 15:12work with mathematics and learning. And I also think is
- 15:15very interesting that in a similar way, in artistic
- 15:17movements have kind of, you know, the pendulum swings back
- 15:20and forth. But for a long time, there was a swing away from
- 15:23this, there was this idea of like, you know, teaching kids
- 15:26how to draw perspective, teaching them these basic
- 15:28principles, getting them to go through drills, getting them to
- 15:31work with like black and white before color, all these ideas
- 15:34that were really foundational, not only to their Renaissance,
- 15:37but the whole Academy system that produced just like
- 15:40fantastic artists, was kind of seen as like this is dated, we
- 15:43want people to be creative, and use their creativity, and just
- 15:46get them to use ideas. And in some ways that really kind of
- 15:49stunted a lot of artists development, you have experts,
- 15:51you have people who had a lot of proficiency that managed to
- 15:54persevere nonetheless, but I thought that was very
- 15:57fascinating that these, these principles that you know, are in
- 16:00such wildly different domains still apply. And the other thing
- 16:03too, which creates a tension, and I just had a conversation
- 16:06with someone else about this. But as you get better in a
- 16:08skill, the problem solved becomes more important, because
- 16:11you are able to kind of decompose the skill into
- 16:14different chunks in your mind, so that he can do it with less
- 16:16bandwidth. So just to use an example, like think about the
- 16:19first time you drove a car, like how much you had to think about
- 16:22all the little things you had to do. And now I mean, you can
- 16:25listen to a podcast, maybe you're listening to this one
- 16:28right now about driving a car, and you've just missed your turn
- 16:31off or whatever, because it's so obvious to you. And this
- 16:34tendency for skills to be extremely effortful to go to
- 16:36almost automatic is universal across skills. But what it means
- 16:40is that what works best for learning is also going to change
- 16:42depending on where you're at, in the beginning, seeing examples
- 16:45are important because solving the problem is so taxing that
- 16:48you might not realize, oh, all the problems are solved this
- 16:51way. You know, because you're just kind of like, you know,
- 16:54fidgeting with things to try to figure them out. And so that's
- 16:57why the examples and instructions are so beneficial
- 17:00at that stage. But as you get later on, and you know those
- 17:02things, and you have them kind of in the back of your head,
- 17:05then the practice the problem solving works on the other end,
- 17:08like we were talking about, about this retrieval, like if
- 17:11you have the pattern in memory, and you can recall it, it
- 17:14strengthens that memory more and adapts into more of that
- 17:17situation. And so this tension often comes up because when you
- 17:20have someone teaching a class, when you have someone telling
- 17:22you well, what's the right way to learn something, they're
- 17:25usually an expert, they're usually on that end where like
- 17:28they benefit more from experimentation, from practice,
- 17:31from problem solving from like, increasing the difficulty. And
- 17:34that's not necessarily what's beneficial at the early stage.
- 17:37So I find this sort of framework, his way of thinking
- 17:39about it very valuable, because it's not just about what's the
- 17:42right learning technique, but it's like, when does that
- 17:45technique matter? When is it helpful for you.
- 17:48Host: So what's something that you personally have learned
- 17:50lately that you've applied these steps to yourself?
- 17:53Scott Young: Part of the reason my interest in this subject is
- 17:56because I just have such a like a laundry list of things that I
- 17:59want to learn. So very selfishly, I'm like, trying to
- 18:01learn it so that I can understand how those work. So I
- 18:04mean, something that I've been doing recently is painting, I
- 18:07really like painting, particularly I've been doing
- 18:10like watercolor painting, which if you're not involved in this
- 18:13kind of sphere, you don't know anything about it. One of the
- 18:15real challenges of it is that unlike oil painting, where you
- 18:18can kind of paint over, so if you make a mistake, you can
- 18:21paint over it. watercolors, like is transparent. So once you put
- 18:24something down, and it dries, you're kind of stuck with it.
- 18:27And so it does create challenges, because you're a
- 18:30little more technically constrained, like with oil
- 18:32paint, you can kind of almost do anything you want, if you just
- 18:35like are painstaking, whereas watercolor, you know, it's
- 18:38drying time and this kind of thing. And so these principles
- 18:41that I've been sort of looking at have definitely played a
- 18:44factor because it's been looking at like, Well, why am I getting
- 18:47stuck here? Like when I'm having difficulties and it's like,
- 18:50well, is the issue that I need more instruction? Or is the
- 18:53issue that you know, I'm trying to do practice but the practice
- 18:56is too complicated and I need to make it simpler and I don't know
- 18:59I just, to me a lot of these research and all these things
- 19:02have been feeding back into my own practice. Maybe even when I
- 19:05get a chance to finish the promotion for this book, I might
- 19:08even do a project specifically about that about applying these
- 19:11techniques to this this hobby of mine I mean the thing that you
- 19:14realize when you're doing research on this topic is like
- 19:16oh my god, this is such a big topic. There's so many things
- 19:19you could talk about like to call it down to a book, like I
- 19:22had, I have I think the bibliography has like 500
- 19:25references like to like get it down to like okay, this is
- 19:27manageable. This is understandable for person like
- 19:30that was the real challenge of this book was not like how do I
- 19:33fill another chapter but like, what do I cut and so so this
- 19:36book, I hope people will find it valuable I hope they'll enjoy
- 19:39the journey through stories that I just to me I had to write them
- 19:42because I done so fascinating when I first encountered them
- 19:45and really just you know, even if they just enjoy the ride,
- 19:48maybe it'll give them some tips for how they can improve the
- 19:51skill they care about. So I mean, the book is available
- 19:53Amazon audible wherever you get your books and they can also
- 19:56come check out my website. It's got hm.com If they want to read
- 19:59some more essays are find out more about the understanding the
- 20:02art and science of learning.
- 20:04Host: Scott thanks for joining us today.
- 20:06Scott Young: Thank you so much, it's been great being here, thanks.