Latest / StarQuest Media / The Doomsday Machine (TOS)
Transcript
- 0:00Dom Bettinelli: The Secrets of Star Trek is brought to you by the StarQuest Production Network
- 0:04Dom Bettinelli: and is made possible by our many generous patrons.
- 0:06Dom Bettinelli: If you'd like to support the podcast, please visit givestarquest.
- 0:10Dom Bettinelli: com
- 0:15Dom Bettinelli: You're listening to The Secrets of Star Trek, where we discuss the hidden layers and deeper meanings found in all the Star Trek TV series, movies, and more.
- 0:25Dom Bettinelli: And today we're discussing the original series episode, The Doomsday Machine.
- 0:31Dom Bettinelli: I'm Dom Bettinelli, and joining me today are Fr. Jason Tyler.
- 0:35Dom Bettinelli: Hey Father.
- 0:35Dom Bettinelli: Hello
- 0:36Dom Bettinelli: and Jimmy Akin.
- 0:38Dom Bettinelli: Hey Jimmy.
- 0:38Dom Bettinelli: Howdy
- 0:39Dom Bettinelli: Dom.
- 0:40Dom Bettinelli: Uh folks, be sure to stick around to the end of the episode.
- 0:42Dom Bettinelli: We'll have your listener feedback on a recent episode we've done.
- 0:45Dom Bettinelli: Uh
- 0:46Dom Bettinelli: but before we get into today's discussion, I know you're hearing this a couple
- 0:50Dom Bettinelli: weeks later than the events that the
- 0:52Dom Bettinelli: that uh have just happened, but
- 0:54Dom Bettinelli: Uh we
- 0:54Dom Bettinelli: just learned this week that we've lost two
- 0:57Dom Bettinelli: of our
- 0:58Dom Bettinelli: great lights in the Star Trek universe.
- 1:01Dom Bettinelli: Uh
- 1:01Dom Bettinelli: both Walter Koenig, who uh died first.
- 1:04Jimmy Akin: It's a Hollywood TV show.
- 1:06Jimmy Akin: You can call 'em
- 1:07Jimmy Akin: stars.
- 1:09Dom Bettinelli: I was thinking like
- 1:10Dom Bettinelli: you know with
- 1:10Dom Bettinelli: Star Trek, stars in our
- 1:13Jimmy Akin: Genesis one, God made these great lights.
- 1:15Jimmy Akin: You can say stars.
- 1:18Dom Bettinelli: All right.
- 1:19Dom Bettinelli: And uh and so we lost Walter Koenig
- 1:21Dom Bettinelli: and uh p Patrick Stewart.
- 1:23Dom Bettinelli: And uh so
- 1:24Jimmy Akin: uh
- 1:24Dom Bettinelli: we thought we'd start with uh
- 1:26Dom Bettinelli: well
- 1:26Dom Bettinelli: first
- 1:27Dom Bettinelli: uh
- 1:28Dom Bettinelli: a prayer for the the repose of their souls, uh
- 1:31Dom Bettinelli: and uh
- 1:32Dom Bettinelli: a uh
- 1:32Dom Bettinelli: that there would be um
- 1:34Dom Bettinelli: condolences for their families and their loved ones who who missed them.
- 1:39Dom Bettinelli: Um
- 1:39Dom Bettinelli: I think that's a uh our
- 1:41Dom Bettinelli: important first f
- 1:41Dom Bettinelli: thing we should do.
- 1:43Dom Bettinelli: Uh
- 1:43Dom Bettinelli: but after that we could
- 1:44Dom Bettinelli: I thought we'd maybe
- 1:45Dom Bettinelli: t uh
- 1:45Dom Bettinelli: discuss our memories of these two great
- 1:49Dom Bettinelli: contributors to Star Trek over the years.
- 1:51Dom Bettinelli: Um
- 1:52Dom Bettinelli: Walter Conney
- 1:53Dom Bettinelli: was the
- 1:53Dom Bettinelli: the first one to pass
- 1:54Dom Bettinelli: and um
- 1:56Dom Bettinelli: I was thinking
- 1:57Dom Bettinelli: We've only got two of our original series stars left, uh William Shatner and George Takei.
- 2:04Jimmy Akin: And and they're gonna fight it out in a lava pit
- 2:06Jimmy Akin: somewhere, you know.
- 2:09Dom Bettinelli: Well, and you know, Shatter's in his nineties now, so that's
- 2:13Dom Bettinelli: uh
- 2:14Dom Bettinelli: you know,
- 2:14Dom Bettinelli: he's not gonna live forever.
- 2:16Dom Bettinelli: Uh
- 2:16Dom Bettinelli: uh
- 2:17Dom Bettinelli: thoughts on uh
- 2:18Dom Bettinelli: Walter Koenig's uh contribution to Star Trek over the years?
- 2:22Dom Bettinelli: But
- 2:24Jimmy Akin: Father, you go first.
- 2:25Fr. Jason Tyler: Well, I was just going to say
- 2:26Fr. Jason Tyler: you know, in some ways it it
- 2:28Fr. Jason Tyler: it feels a little bit lighter because I don't remember any episodes focused
- 2:32Fr. Jason Tyler: specifically on Chekov
- 2:34Fr. Jason Tyler: 's backstory, his
- 2:36Fr. Jason Tyler: uh
- 2:36Fr. Jason Tyler: his family, his origin, anything of that sort.
- 2:39Fr. Jason Tyler: Uh the biggest thing, of course, he comes along in season two
- 2:42Fr. Jason Tyler: of the original series, um
- 2:44Fr. Jason Tyler: giving uh
- 2:45Fr. Jason Tyler: giving a series a a Russian on the bridge and sort of showing
- 2:49Fr. Jason Tyler: uh, you know,
- 2:51Fr. Jason Tyler: hope for humanity's ultimate
- 2:53Fr. Jason Tyler: um
- 2:54Fr. Jason Tyler: unity, I suppose, you know, since
- 2:56Fr. Jason Tyler: uh
- 2:57Fr. Jason Tyler: the
- 2:57Fr. Jason Tyler: the
- 2:57Fr. Jason Tyler: TOS was airing during the Cold War and
- 3:00Fr. Jason Tyler: and you know
- 3:01Fr. Jason Tyler: Chekov
- 3:02Fr. Jason Tyler: being Russian is
- 3:03Fr. Jason Tyler: is like a non-issue
- 3:04Fr. Jason Tyler: in many ways, except for all the times when he says things about Russian history or or you know in Russia
- 3:10Fr. Jason Tyler: the you know
- 3:11Fr. Jason Tyler: this happened in whatever way, that sort of thing
- 3:14Fr. Jason Tyler: Um
- 3:15Fr. Jason Tyler: you know
- 3:15Fr. Jason Tyler: one thing of course
- 3:16Fr. Jason Tyler: because of of Chekov's contribution, I'll never forget that the nuclear vessels are kept in Alameda.
- 3:23Dom Bettinelli: They were.
- 3:27Dom Bettinelli: Uh I
- 3:28Dom Bettinelli: I uh
- 3:28Dom Bettinelli: I was thinking that he got two Saturn Award nominations for acting.
- 3:32Dom Bettinelli: Uh
- 3:33Dom Bettinelli: at least two, but
- 3:34Dom Bettinelli: two for Star Trek
- 3:35Dom Bettinelli: One for
- 3:36Dom Bettinelli: his role in uh
- 3:37Dom Bettinelli: Wrath of
- 3:38Dom Bettinelli: Khan
- 3:39Dom Bettinelli: and uh
- 3:39Dom Bettinelli: which
- 3:40Dom Bettinelli: he was great
- 3:41Dom Bettinelli: and of course
- 3:41Dom Bettinelli: Voyage Home which you referenced uh
- 3:44Dom Bettinelli: And
- 3:44Dom Bettinelli: the nuclear wessel scene and the hospital rescue scene.
- 3:47Fr. Jason Tyler: Yes.
- 3:48Dom Bettinelli: Both of those were so
- 3:49Fr. Jason Tyler: great.
- 3:49Dom Bettinelli: Although I really love the interrogation
- 3:52Fr. Jason Tyler: uh
- 3:52Dom Bettinelli: with the FBI agent.
- 3:54Dom Bettinelli: Uh
- 3:54Dom Bettinelli: he
- 3:55Dom Bettinelli: he's a
- 3:55Dom Bettinelli: he's a rescue, but there's something wrong with him.
- 3:58Dom Bettinelli: Oh, can I go now?
- 4:01Dom Bettinelli: I just love those scenes.
- 4:02Jimmy Akin: Actually, that's one of the key questions you always want to ask law enforcement.
- 4:07Jimmy Akin: Am I detained or am I free to go?
- 4:08Fr. Jason Tyler: Right.
- 4:09Dom Bettinelli: Exactly
- 4:10Dom Bettinelli: You're through here.
- 4:11Dom Bettinelli: Oh good, I can go now.
- 4:14Fr. Jason Tyler: And you know, one of the nit things about Wrath of Khan, of course, uh, in many ways he shouldn't have been
- 4:20Fr. Jason Tyler: um
- 4:21Fr. Jason Tyler: the main guy in that in the the
- 4:23Fr. Jason Tyler: uh
- 4:23Fr. Jason Tyler: his first officer on uh
- 4:24Fr. Jason Tyler: is it the Reliant or whatever early on.
- 4:27Fr. Jason Tyler: Uh
- 4:27Fr. Jason Tyler: because they have the scene where, you know, they get captured by Khan and he says, I never forget a face
- 4:32Fr. Jason Tyler: and uh there have been all sorts of ways that that's been retconned over the years
- 4:35Fr. Jason Tyler: but
- 4:36Fr. Jason Tyler: the real world story was that was kind of an error that
- 4:39Fr. Jason Tyler: somebody put that in there.
- 4:40Fr. Jason Tyler: And
- 4:41Fr. Jason Tyler: I think the story goes that uh Walter Koenig
- 4:43Fr. Jason Tyler: noticed that
- 4:44Fr. Jason Tyler: But he kept quiet about it because he knew he would wind up with fewer lines and a a less prominent role
- 4:50Fr. Jason Tyler: that they would have put Sulu in that role instead of him and he wouldn't have had nearly as much to do in the movie, so he just
- 4:56Fr. Jason Tyler: Played it cool and and wrote uh read the lines as they were scripted and everything.
- 5:00Fr. Jason Tyler: So
- 5:01Jimmy Akin: it's easy to head canon
- 5:02Jimmy Akin: that anyway.
- 5:03Jimmy Akin: He was aboard the Enterprise earlier and con
- 5:06Jimmy Akin: met him off screen.
- 5:07Fr. Jason Tyler: Right.
- 5:07Fr. Jason Tyler: Exactly.
- 5:08Dom Bettinelli: Yeah
- 5:09Dom Bettinelli: Uh
- 5:10Dom Bettinelli: Jimmy, your
- 5:11Dom Bettinelli: and thoughts about Walter Koenig?
- 5:13Jimmy Akin: Yeah, I really like Walter Koenig.
- 5:15Jimmy Akin: Um
- 5:16Jimmy Akin: he uh
- 5:17Jimmy Akin: uh
- 5:18Jimmy Akin: of
- 5:18Jimmy Akin: of the folks who were on the bridge
- 5:21Jimmy Akin: on the regular
- 5:23Jimmy Akin: He's, I mean, other than Kirk and Spock, he's the one that
- 5:27Jimmy Akin: has
- 5:28Jimmy Akin: um
- 5:30Jimmy Akin: commented
- 5:31Jimmy Akin: the most frequently, and I I know more about him.
- 5:36Jimmy Akin: than
- 5:36Jimmy Akin: I
- 5:37Jimmy Akin: I do.
- 5:37Jimmy Akin: I mean, I know about the others and their personal lives a little bit, but Koenig
- 5:43Jimmy Akin: um
- 5:44Jimmy Akin: has
- 5:44Jimmy Akin: interacted with fandom
- 5:47Jimmy Akin: in
- 5:48Jimmy Akin: areas that I travel more than most of the others.
- 5:52Jimmy Akin: And so I have a greater sense of connection to him.
- 5:55Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 5:55Jimmy Akin: he lost a son
- 5:57Jimmy Akin: uh a few years ago in really tragic circumstances.
- 6:01Jimmy Akin: Also, as I know we're gonna mention, he played Alfred Bester
- 6:05Jimmy Akin: on Babylon Five, which was a great role for him.
- 6:09Jimmy Akin: It was
- 6:09Jimmy Akin: I uh
- 6:10Jimmy Akin: and and JMS, the Joe Michael Strazinski, the creator of Babylon V
- 6:15Jimmy Akin: He
- 6:15Jimmy Akin: um
- 6:16Jimmy Akin: he recently put up some thoughts on Walter Koenig's passing, and he
- 6:22Jimmy Akin: he revealed that Bester
- 6:24Jimmy Akin: was not
- 6:25Jimmy Akin: the part he had originally planned.
- 6:28Jimmy Akin: for uh
- 6:29Jimmy Akin: for Koenig
- 6:30Jimmy Akin: that uh
- 6:31Jimmy Akin: he originally had him
- 6:33Jimmy Akin: planned for this
- 6:34Jimmy Akin: kind of secretive government agent who
- 6:37Jimmy Akin: appears
- 6:39Jimmy Akin: in
- 6:39Jimmy Akin: um
- 6:40Jimmy Akin: um
- 6:41Jimmy Akin: in
- 6:41Jimmy Akin: the first season
- 6:42Jimmy Akin: Babylon 5 episode
- 6:44Jimmy Akin: where
- 6:45Jimmy Akin: they start exploring Sinclair the hole in Sinclair's mind.
- 6:50Jimmy Akin: And there's a head agent in that.
- 6:52Jimmy Akin: And he originally planned Koenig
- 6:54Jimmy Akin: to play that part, but then Koenig
- 6:56Jimmy Akin: had a heart attack
- 6:58Jimmy Akin: And
- 6:58Jimmy Akin: he was
- 6:59Jimmy Akin: he was gonna
- 7:00Jimmy Akin: he was gonna
- 7:01Jimmy Akin: he had this quadruple bypass surgery
- 7:04Jimmy Akin: and he was out for a couple of weeks.
- 7:07Jimmy Akin: And
- 7:08Jimmy Akin: uh
- 7:08Jimmy Akin: as a result of that, and he was just crushed that he wasn't gonna get this to play this great role
- 7:14Jimmy Akin: And JMS said, Don't worry, I have something better for you in mind now.
- 7:18Jimmy Akin: And he got the
- 7:19Jimmy Akin: the Alfred Bester
- 7:20Jimmy Akin: role, which led to multiple seasons
- 7:24Jimmy Akin: of
- 7:24Jimmy Akin: appearances and could
- 7:25Jimmy Akin: and should it was meant to lead to even more.
- 7:28Jimmy Akin: Um
- 7:30Jimmy Akin: but
- 7:30Jimmy Akin: uh
- 7:31Jimmy Akin: but he was actually playing
- 7:33Jimmy Akin: Bester
- 7:34Jimmy Akin: for the first time, like four weeks after he had quadruple bypass surgery.
- 7:39Jimmy Akin: Wow.
- 7:40Jimmy Akin: Um
- 7:41Jimmy Akin: and
- 7:42Jimmy Akin: and
- 7:42Jimmy Akin: he clearly had acting range
- 7:45Jimmy Akin: You know, Bester
- 7:46Jimmy Akin: is nothing like Chekov.
- 7:47Jimmy Akin: I've also seen him in other movies
- 7:50Jimmy Akin: and things like that.
- 7:51Jimmy Akin: In fact, I've seen him act on Columbo opposite William Shatner.
- 7:56Jimmy Akin: Um
- 7:58Jimmy Akin: But
- 7:58Jimmy Akin: uh
- 7:59Jimmy Akin: uh
- 7:59Jimmy Akin: i
- 8:00Jimmy Akin: I I liked what he did
- 8:02Jimmy Akin: as Chekov.
- 8:04Jimmy Akin: Um
- 8:05Jimmy Akin: the
- 8:05Jimmy Akin: the
- 8:06Jimmy Akin: all the Russia stuff is kind of a running gag
- 8:09Jimmy Akin: You know, uh
- 8:11Jimmy Akin: and
- 8:11Jimmy Akin: I I
- 8:12Jimmy Akin: personally
- 8:13Jimmy Akin: my head canon, I'm inclined to think he's winding them all up by claiming everything was first done in Russia.
- 8:18Jimmy Akin: That
- 8:19Jimmy Akin: he's not really
- 8:19Jimmy Akin: not really serious about that.
- 8:21Dom Bettinelli: I think so.
- 8:22Jimmy Akin: Yeah.
- 8:22Jimmy Akin: Um
- 8:23Jimmy Akin: and I
- 8:24Jimmy Akin: I love in his very first aired episode, even though um
- 8:28Jimmy Akin: I don't think it was filmed first in production order, but in his very first uh aired episode there's
- 8:34Jimmy Akin: one of the other bridge officers
- 8:37Jimmy Akin: um
- 8:37Jimmy Akin: implies
- 8:39Jimmy Akin: that he's new
- 8:41Jimmy Akin: and
- 8:41Jimmy Akin: but he's clearly already competent and he has this aside in that episode where he says, I'm not that
- 8:48Jimmy Akin: green.
- 8:50Jimmy Akin: And
- 8:51Jimmy Akin: and
- 8:52Jimmy Akin: and it's like, yeah, don't underrate me, dude.
- 8:55Jimmy Akin: And uh and I like that.
- 8:58Jimmy Akin: Um, I like the symbolism of having a Russia
- 9:01Jimmy Akin: a Russian as an ally on the bridge
- 9:04Jimmy Akin: in
- 9:04Jimmy Akin: at the
- 9:05Jimmy Akin: you know, in this peak Cold War period.
- 9:08Jimmy Akin: I mean, it w
- 9:09Jimmy Akin: this was only five years after the Cuban Missile Crisis.
- 9:13Jimmy Akin: And
- 9:14Jimmy Akin: so
- 9:14Jimmy Akin: um
- 9:15Jimmy Akin: so I I like that.
- 9:17Jimmy Akin: Um
- 9:17Jimmy Akin: we do get a little glimpse into his past
- 9:20Jimmy Akin: in
- 9:21Jimmy Akin: The Way to Eden, but that's such a terrible episode, nobody remembers it.
- 9:25Fr. Jason Tyler: Right.
- 9:26Fr. Jason Tyler: Yeah, I forgot
- 9:27Fr. Jason Tyler: brotherly.
- 9:28Jimmy Akin: Yeah.
- 9:29Jimmy Akin: Um
- 9:30Jimmy Akin: But I I
- 9:31Jimmy Akin: I really value uh
- 9:33Jimmy Akin: I really value Walter Koenig
- 9:35Jimmy Akin: and um
- 9:36Jimmy Akin: and
- 9:36Jimmy Akin: what he did for Star Trek and I'm glad he was there.
- 9:39Jimmy Akin: I just wish they'd given him more.
- 9:41Fr. Jason Tyler: Yeah.
- 9:43Jimmy Akin: But that's true for everybody.
- 9:51Dom Bettinelli: So let's talk about the other big loss this week, which was Patrick Stewart
- 9:56Dom Bettinelli: and uh
- 9:56Dom Bettinelli: who
- 9:57Dom Bettinelli: as a captain
- 9:58Dom Bettinelli: h
- 9:58Dom Bettinelli: you know, he he
- 9:59Dom Bettinelli: had a much bigger impact, uh you know, to
- 10:02Dom Bettinelli: it's easy to say
- 10:03Dom Bettinelli: that than Walter Kenning
- 10:05Dom Bettinelli: and uh
- 10:06Dom Bettinelli: I have to
- 10:06Dom Bettinelli: say, I mean, it's
- 10:08Dom Bettinelli: you know, we saw him most recently in the Picard
- 10:11Dom Bettinelli: series and he was he look he was looking pretty
- 10:13Dom Bettinelli: pretty old and and frail there.
- 10:16Dom Bettinelli: Uh so it was, you know, clear he'd been
- 10:18Dom Bettinelli: uh, you know,
- 10:19Dom Bettinelli: getting getting older as we all do.
- 10:21Dom Bettinelli: Um
- 10:21Dom Bettinelli: but you know it's it's interesting.
- 10:23Dom Bettinelli: There's been a lot of talk among fans about his best performances.
- 10:27Dom Bettinelli: What were his
- 10:28Dom Bettinelli: best performances?
- 10:30Dom Bettinelli: Um
- 10:30Dom Bettinelli: w w
- 10:31Dom Bettinelli: I I
- 10:32Dom Bettinelli: I
- 10:32Dom Bettinelli: I it's kind of interesting.
- 10:33Dom Bettinelli: I don't think the ones that everyone else kind of went to first
- 10:37Dom Bettinelli: are the ones that I would go to first.
- 10:38Dom Bettinelli: But
- 10:39Dom Bettinelli: what do you all
- 10:40Dom Bettinelli: What do you all
- 10:40Dom Bettinelli: think of his
- 10:42Dom Bettinelli: best performances as Picard?
- 10:44Dom Bettinelli: Father, why don't you go first again?
- 10:45Fr. Jason Tyler: Yeah, so the first one that jumps to mind is Chain of Command, you know, where he's captured and tortured by the Cardassians.
- 10:52Fr. Jason Tyler: Um
- 10:53Fr. Jason Tyler: I thought that was a a powerful episode overall.
- 10:56Fr. Jason Tyler: Uh obviously the other big one that would jump out would be best of both worlds as being a big episode, but I'm not sure that's a big
- 11:03Fr. Jason Tyler: Patrick Stewart performance in many ways, right?
- 11:05Fr. Jason Tyler: I mean it's pivotal for so many things that happen
- 11:07Fr. Jason Tyler: afterwards, but it it doesn't
- 11:10Fr. Jason Tyler: that episode doesn't turn on his acting ability, I guess.
- 11:13Fr. Jason Tyler: Whether he's good or bad, that's that episode I think.
- 11:15Fr. Jason Tyler: is about the same.
- 11:16Fr. Jason Tyler: Um, you know, one
- 11:18Fr. Jason Tyler: one thing I read online
- 11:19Fr. Jason Tyler: that really got me thinking was uh
- 11:21Fr. Jason Tyler: and I agree with it, the defector may be one of his better performances.
- 11:25Fr. Jason Tyler: Uh
- 11:25Fr. Jason Tyler: and that was, you know, where they had the
- 11:27Fr. Jason Tyler: Um
- 11:28Fr. Jason Tyler: Admiral Gerrock, the Romulan defector uh
- 11:31Fr. Jason Tyler: that
- 11:31Fr. Jason Tyler: that comes aboard the ship.
- 11:33Fr. Jason Tyler: And
- 11:34Fr. Jason Tyler: Jerok
- 11:35Fr. Jason Tyler: only wants to give them so much information.
- 11:37Fr. Jason Tyler: Yeah, he wants to sort of stop short, and Picard
- 11:39Fr. Jason Tyler: has to
- 11:40Fr. Jason Tyler: really
- 11:40Fr. Jason Tyler: convince him.
- 11:41Fr. Jason Tyler: And he, you know, he says at one point, you've already decided you are the trader.
- 11:44Fr. Jason Tyler: You've you've crossed that bridge already.
- 11:47Fr. Jason Tyler: You know, I don't remember the exact wording, but basically, you know, really
- 11:50Fr. Jason Tyler: pushes this idea that that Jarak
- 11:53Fr. Jason Tyler: Can't take these half measures.
- 11:55Fr. Jason Tyler: He has to be sort of all in now that he's he's done this.
- 11:58Fr. Jason Tyler: And ultimately,
- 11:59Fr. Jason Tyler: yes, uh
- 12:00Fr. Jason Tyler: Jarrock gives them the information.
- 12:01Fr. Jason Tyler: As it turns out, it's all been, you know, bad information, you know, handed to him by
- 12:07Fr. Jason Tyler: uh
- 12:07Fr. Jason Tyler: by other
- 12:07Fr. Jason Tyler: Romulans to to try to trap uh
- 12:10Fr. Jason Tyler: the enterprise, I guess.
- 12:11Fr. Jason Tyler: But
- 12:12Fr. Jason Tyler: um
- 12:12Fr. Jason Tyler: I thought that was a very good uh
- 12:14Fr. Jason Tyler: Patrick Stewart performance in that that episode.
- 12:17Dom Bettinelli: Yeah, yeah, agreed.
- 12:18Dom Bettinelli: Uh
- 12:19Dom Bettinelli: Jimmy, how about you?
- 12:20Dom Bettinelli: What do you what do you think?
- 12:21Jimmy Akin: Yeah, um, I agree that Best of Both Worlds is an important
- 12:25Jimmy Akin: Picard
- 12:26Jimmy Akin: story, but it's not an important Patrick Stewart
- 12:29Jimmy Akin: acting story.
- 12:30Jimmy Akin: Yeah.
- 12:31Jimmy Akin: Um
- 12:32Jimmy Akin: The one that a lot of people cite for his acting is the inner light, which is the one where he he spends almost all the episode in in a
- 12:43Jimmy Akin: in a mental recreation of a dead civilization
- 12:46Jimmy Akin: and he learn
- 12:47Jimmy Akin: comes and you know it's like
- 12:49Jimmy Akin: I went to Vegas and all I got was learned how to play this alien flute.
- 12:55Jimmy Akin: Um
- 12:57Jimmy Akin: But
- 12:58Jimmy Akin: uh
- 12:58Jimmy Akin: but I don't like that episode.
- 13:00Jimmy Akin: I loved it the first time I saw it.
- 13:03Jimmy Akin: I thought it was really clever.
- 13:05Jimmy Akin: But on rewatching it, man, is that alien civilization just depressing
- 13:10Jimmy Akin: and nothing
- 13:11Jimmy Akin: Nothing but depressing.
- 13:13Dom Bettinelli: Yeah.
- 13:13Jimmy Akin: So
- 13:13Jimmy Akin: I'm not a fan of that one.
- 13:15Jimmy Akin: Um
- 13:16Jimmy Akin: I I agree, Chain of Command is
- 13:19Jimmy Akin: um
- 13:20Jimmy Akin: is
- 13:21Jimmy Akin: uh
- 13:21Jimmy Akin: good.
- 13:22Jimmy Akin: Um
- 13:23Jimmy Akin: one of the things that
- 13:25Jimmy Akin: th
- 13:26Jimmy Akin: that
- 13:27Jimmy Akin: they
- 13:27Jimmy Akin: often did
- 13:29Jimmy Akin: with
- 13:29Jimmy Akin: with
- 13:30Jimmy Akin: Patrick Stewart
- 13:31Jimmy Akin: was
- 13:32Jimmy Akin: um
- 13:33Jimmy Akin: they
- 13:34Jimmy Akin: would
- 13:35Jimmy Akin: uh g
- 13:36Jimmy Akin: to try to give him acting range.
- 13:39Jimmy Akin: The way they often interpreted that
- 13:41Jimmy Akin: was
- 13:42Jimmy Akin: We've got to reduce him to a screaming
- 13:44Jimmy Akin: tortured mess.
- 13:45Jimmy Akin: And it's like, okay, chain of command can fit that slot.
- 13:48Jimmy Akin: Yeah, d
- 13:49Jimmy Akin: but
- 13:49Jimmy Akin: they do it multiple times.
- 13:51Jimmy Akin: So I'm not gonna cite other
- 13:52Jimmy Akin: oh yeah, this is a Patrick Stewart
- 13:54Jimmy Akin: screaming episode again.
- 13:56Jimmy Akin: Um
- 13:57Jimmy Akin: but
- 13:58Jimmy Akin: uh
- 13:59Jimmy Akin: ones
- 13:59Jimmy Akin: that I liked
- 14:01Jimmy Akin: that
- 14:01Jimmy Akin: um
- 14:02Jimmy Akin: that
- 14:03Jimmy Akin: showed a little bit of range with him, not Captain's Holiday.
- 14:07Jimmy Akin: I don't like that one.
- 14:08Jimmy Akin: Um
- 14:09Jimmy Akin: but
- 14:09Jimmy Akin: Tapestry, which is the one where Q
- 14:13Jimmy Akin: uh
- 14:13Jimmy Akin: plays its
- 14:14Jimmy Akin: wonderful life with him.
- 14:16Fr. Jason Tyler: Yeah.
- 14:16Jimmy Akin: Also
- 14:17Jimmy Akin: Dharmac.
- 14:18Jimmy Akin: I mean, he's gotta
- 14:19Jimmy Akin: he's got to wrestle with what's going on there.
- 14:23Jimmy Akin: Um
- 14:24Jimmy Akin: and the drumhead
- 14:26Jimmy Akin: where he comes to the defense of Simon Tarsus
- 14:31Jimmy Akin: uh
- 14:31Jimmy Akin: who's being persecuted.
- 14:33Jimmy Akin: And so those are some of the Patrick Stewart episodes that I really liked.
- 14:38Jimmy Akin: Also, I've seen him in a lot of other roles.
- 14:41Jimmy Akin: Um
- 14:42Jimmy Akin: he
- 14:43Jimmy Akin: um
- 14:44Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 14:45Jimmy Akin: he
- 14:45Jimmy Akin: uh you know
- 14:46Jimmy Akin: uh
- 14:47Jimmy Akin: I
- 14:47Jimmy Akin: I
- 14:48Jimmy Akin: one of the first things I saw him in other than Star Trek
- 14:51Jimmy Akin: was he plays Sejanus, the
- 14:54Jimmy Akin: the
- 14:55Jimmy Akin: who
- 14:56Jimmy Akin: during the time of the Emperor Tiberius
- 14:59Jimmy Akin: tried
- 15:00Jimmy Akin: kind of tried a coup
- 15:02Jimmy Akin: and didn't get away with it.
- 15:03Jimmy Akin: He he was like
- 15:05Jimmy Akin: Tiberius's right hand and he was basically running the empire for him
- 15:09Jimmy Akin: and
- 15:09Jimmy Akin: he got to the point of
- 15:10Jimmy Akin: maybe I should just take over here.
- 15:12Jimmy Akin: And that's where things fell apart for him.
- 15:15Jimmy Akin: But he plays Sejanus in I
- 15:17Jimmy Akin: Claudius
- 15:18Jimmy Akin: And he's got hair.
- 15:21Jimmy Akin: Um
- 15:22Jimmy Akin: and
- 15:23Jimmy Akin: uh
- 15:23Jimmy Akin: and then just
- 15:24Jimmy Akin: just this last weekend or n
- 15:27Jimmy Akin: the last couple of weeks, I w
- 15:29Jimmy Akin: there are
- 15:29Jimmy Akin: two
- 15:30Jimmy Akin: uh
- 15:31Jimmy Akin: late seventies, early eighties
- 15:33Jimmy Akin: BBC
- 15:34Jimmy Akin: series starring Alec
- 15:35Jimmy Akin: Guinness
- 15:36Jimmy Akin: ,
- 15:37Jimmy Akin: you know, Obi-Wan Kenobi.
- 15:39Jimmy Akin: as
- 15:40Jimmy Akin: uh George La
- 15:41Jimmy Akin: Care
- 15:42Jimmy Akin: 's uh
- 15:42Jimmy Akin: spymaster, George Smiley.
- 15:46Jimmy Akin: And
- 15:47Jimmy Akin: there
- 15:47Jimmy Akin: 's a trilogy of the original La
- 15:49Jimmy Akin: Care
- 15:50Jimmy Akin: novels
- 15:50Jimmy Akin: called the Carla trilogy, which all involve George Smiley going up against this Russian equivalent
- 15:58Jimmy Akin: spymaster name whose codename is Carla.
- 16:01Jimmy Akin: And Carla
- 16:03Jimmy Akin: appears in
- 16:04Jimmy Akin: two scenes.
- 16:06Jimmy Akin: He
- 16:06Jimmy Akin: in um
- 16:08Jimmy Akin: in
- 16:08Jimmy Akin: in the first
- 16:10Jimmy Akin: of
- 16:10Jimmy Akin: the uh
- 16:11Jimmy Akin: of the adaptations they did, which is Tinker
- 16:14Jimmy Akin: Taylor Soldier
- 16:15Jimmy Akin: Spy.
- 16:16Jimmy Akin: They
- 16:17Jimmy Akin: um
- 16:18Jimmy Akin: there's a flashback
- 16:20Jimmy Akin: where
- 16:21Jimmy Akin: Smiley met Carla in India.
- 16:24Jimmy Akin: And then
- 16:25Jimmy Akin: in
- 16:26Jimmy Akin: um
- 16:26Jimmy Akin: in
- 16:27Jimmy Akin: uh
- 16:28Jimmy Akin: Smiley's People, the third novel
- 16:30Jimmy Akin: and the second BBC series
- 16:32Jimmy Akin: It's all about how do we take down Carla?
- 16:36Jimmy Akin: And he appears in one scene at the very end.
- 16:40Jimmy Akin: And
- 16:41Jimmy Akin: he
- 16:41Jimmy Akin: um
- 16:43Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 16:44Jimmy Akin: in both cases, Karla is played by Patrick Stewart.
- 16:49Jimmy Akin: And in both cases
- 16:51Jimmy Akin: He doesn't get a line.
- 16:53Jimmy Akin: He just is there
- 16:54Jimmy Akin: in the flashback, and when they finally take him down in the final scene when he turns himself into
- 16:59Jimmy Akin: Western authorities, he just shows up, doesn't say a word.
- 17:03Jimmy Akin: But it's Patrick Stewart and he's this commanding
- 17:06Jimmy Akin: powerful presence that they've been building up and building.
- 17:09Jimmy Akin: I mean, they do it for three novels or and two
- 17:12Jimmy Akin: TV mini-series
- 17:14Jimmy Akin: where they're always talking about Carla and his decisions and how powerful he is and how he smokes American cigarettes that smell really weird.
- 17:23Jimmy Akin: And
- 17:23Jimmy Akin: uh
- 17:24Jimmy Akin: and
- 17:24Jimmy Akin: and
- 17:25Jimmy Akin: so we have this
- 17:26Jimmy Akin: character that's been built up extensively and we only get little glimpses of him and he doesn't even have to talk.
- 17:33Dom Bettinelli: I bet he could just couldn't do a Russian accent.
- 17:37Jimmy Akin: He he'd have to ask about the nuclear whistles, yeah.
- 17:41Dom Bettinelli: So
- 17:42Dom Bettinelli: for my part, uh
- 17:43Dom Bettinelli: I I know a lot of people like
- 17:45Dom Bettinelli: will
- 17:45Dom Bettinelli: will
- 17:45Dom Bettinelli: mention, as you said, Interlight.
- 17:47Dom Bettinelli: I think Interlight's
- 17:48Dom Bettinelli: the the
- 17:49Dom Bettinelli: the reason that stood out was more the concept, more the
- 17:51Dom Bettinelli: oh
- 17:52Dom Bettinelli: more than Stewart's acting.
- 17:53Jimmy Akin: Yeah.
- 17:54Dom Bettinelli: Uh and chain of command
- 17:55Dom Bettinelli: It
- 17:56Dom Bettinelli: is
- 17:56Dom Bettinelli: yeah, I mean
- 17:57Dom Bettinelli: it's be
- 17:58Dom Bettinelli: he's tortured and he just g
- 17:59Dom Bettinelli: he does it so well and uh that that that uh
- 18:01Dom Bettinelli: inner strength that he has there
- 18:03Dom Bettinelli: Um
- 18:03Jimmy Akin: for
- 18:04Jimmy Akin: for another example of a similar
- 18:06Jimmy Akin: i r let's reduce Patrick Stewart to a screaming
- 18:09Jimmy Akin: disheveled state, SARAC.
- 18:11Jimmy Akin: Would be an example of that.
- 18:13Dom Bettinelli: That was gonna be one of my my uh
- 18:15Dom Bettinelli: uh uh examples of his of his acting.
- 18:18Dom Bettinelli: Um
- 18:18Dom Bettinelli: I I have to
- 18:19Dom Bettinelli: side a lot of great memes in tribute
- 18:21Dom Bettinelli: uh to
- 18:22Dom Bettinelli: to Patrick Stewart.
- 18:22Dom Bettinelli: There are a lot of great me Patrick Stewart memes out there.
- 18:24Dom Bettinelli: But one I saw was
- 18:25Dom Bettinelli: I'm lighting five candles for Patrick Stewart in this
- 18:28Dom Bettinelli: one.
- 18:29Dom Bettinelli: It was awesome.
- 18:30Dom Bettinelli: Uh
- 18:31Dom Bettinelli: I I really think
- 18:32Dom Bettinelli: family
- 18:33Dom Bettinelli: is a great one.
- 18:34Dom Bettinelli: That's where he goes after he
- 18:36Dom Bettinelli: he recovers from
- 18:36Dom Bettinelli: Best of Both Worlds.
- 18:38Dom Bettinelli: He goes back to France and
- 18:39Dom Bettinelli: uh you know,
- 18:40Dom Bettinelli: has that
- 18:41Dom Bettinelli: r
- 18:41Dom Bettinelli: mud
- 18:42Dom Bettinelli: fight with his brother and the g in the you know, and he has to deal with what's
- 18:46Dom Bettinelli: and all of that stuff
- 18:47Dom Bettinelli: of
- 18:48Dom Bettinelli: Of Picard
- 18:49Dom Bettinelli: dealing with having been Locuteus, I think that
- 18:52Dom Bettinelli: really is what elevated the Picard
- 18:55Dom Bettinelli: character as is
- 18:56Dom Bettinelli: is
- 18:57Dom Bettinelli: the
- 18:57Dom Bettinelli: as being interesting.
- 18:59Dom Bettinelli: Uh
- 18:59Dom Bettinelli: from
- 18:59Dom Bettinelli: that moment on in
- 19:00Jimmy Akin: Oh yeah, and I meant to mention uh
- 19:03Jimmy Akin: with Best of Both Worlds Part One, um
- 19:06Jimmy Akin: even though it's an important Picard
- 19:08Jimmy Akin: story
- 19:09Jimmy Akin: That was written as an exit for Patrick Stewart because they didn't know if he was coming back or not.
- 19:16Jimmy Akin: There were contract negotiation issues.
- 19:18Jimmy Akin: And so
- 19:19Jimmy Akin: if
- 19:19Jimmy Akin: things had gone
- 19:20Jimmy Akin: there's another timeline out there where he just stayed aboard
- 19:24Jimmy Akin: and Riker became captain and that
- 19:27Jimmy Akin: Um
- 19:28Jimmy Akin: that f
- 19:29Jimmy Akin: female first officer became the new first
- 19:31Jimmy Akin: Shelby
- 19:32Jimmy Akin: became the new first officer.
- 19:34Dom Bettinelli: Right.
- 19:34Dom Bettinelli: Right.
- 19:35Dom Bettinelli: That would yeah, that's an interesting timeline.
- 19:37Dom Bettinelli: Uh
- 19:38Dom Bettinelli: so
- 19:38Dom Bettinelli: uh
- 19:39Dom Bettinelli: so f
- 19:39Dom Bettinelli: I think family is great
- 19:41Dom Bettinelli: and um
- 19:43Dom Bettinelli: Dharmac obviously is uh was is
- 19:45Dom Bettinelli: was one a lot of people remember, although
- 19:46Dom Bettinelli: again that
- 19:47Dom Bettinelli: may be more the writing.
- 19:49Dom Bettinelli: Um
- 19:49Dom Bettinelli: But I
- 19:50Dom Bettinelli: but even in the movies, you know, um
- 19:52Dom Bettinelli: First Contact I felt like was an a very interesting performance from him
- 19:57Dom Bettinelli: I mean, you know, the
- 19:58Dom Bettinelli: where
- 19:58Dom Bettinelli: that line that he delivers
- 20:00Jimmy Akin: your little
- 20:00Jimmy Akin: shift.
- 20:02Dom Bettinelli: And that line that he delivers, you know, like you
- 20:06Dom Bettinelli: just
- 20:07Dom Bettinelli: It's commanding.
- 20:08Dom Bettinelli: So
- 20:08Jimmy Akin: I I
- 20:08Jimmy Akin: I love
- 20:09Jimmy Akin: that
- 20:10Jimmy Akin: was already so iconic that they parodied it on Deep Space Nine with Quark.
- 20:15Fr. Jason Tyler: Yeah.
- 20:16Dom Bettinelli: Right, exactly.
- 20:18Dom Bettinelli: Um
- 20:19Dom Bettinelli: and then other roles as we mentioned, uh
- 20:21Dom Bettinelli: of course everyone remembers uh
- 20:22Dom Bettinelli: him as
- 20:23Dom Bettinelli: Professor X in the X-Men, although
- 20:27Dom Bettinelli: His role in Logan, where he's the old
- 20:30Dom Bettinelli: man
- 20:30Dom Bettinelli: with with
- 20:31Dom Bettinelli: with Wolverine, uh I
- 20:33Dom Bettinelli: I thought that was
- 20:34Dom Bettinelli: maybe the most interesting version of Professor X
- 20:37Dom Bettinelli: that we got.
- 20:38Dom Bettinelli: Uh
- 20:38Dom Bettinelli: so uh
- 20:39Dom Bettinelli: I mean Patrick's doing
- 20:41Dom Bettinelli: he's played a couple other roles where he's like a villain and a couple other things.
- 20:44Dom Bettinelli: So uh
- 20:45Dom Bettinelli: just just
- 20:45Dom Bettinelli: a
- 20:46Dom Bettinelli: a really great actor.
- 20:47Dom Bettinelli: And of course, I can't forget him in uh
- 20:50Dom Bettinelli: a Christmas Carol.
- 20:51Dom Bettinelli: The
- 20:51Dom Bettinelli: Especially when he did the one
- 20:53Dom Bettinelli: man
- 20:53Dom Bettinelli: version of it.
- 20:54Dom Bettinelli: If you ever get a chance to either see it
- 20:57Dom Bettinelli: or listen to it as an audiobook, the one
- 20:59Dom Bettinelli: man play version of a Christmas Carol.
- 21:01Dom Bettinelli: uh where he does all the voices
- 21:03Dom Bettinelli: is fantastic.
- 21:05Dom Bettinelli: So
- 21:05Dom Bettinelli: um
- 21:06Dom Bettinelli: again, you know, rest in peace to both
- 21:08Dom Bettinelli: Walter Koenig
- 21:09Dom Bettinelli: and Patrick Stewart.
- 21:11Dom Bettinelli: And uh
- 21:16Fr. Jason Tyler: And how appropriate that we're recording this on All Souls Day as we speak of
- 21:21Fr. Jason Tyler: the deceats
- 21:22Fr. Jason Tyler: who have gone before us here.
- 21:23Dom Bettinelli: Exactly, exactly.
- 21:25Dom Bettinelli: Yes, thank you.
- 21:26Dom Bettinelli: So
- 21:26Dom Bettinelli: uh
- 21:27Dom Bettinelli: moving on from that, let's talk about our main topic today that we planned, uh, which is Doomsday Machine, uh the
- 21:32Dom Bettinelli: original series.
- 21:33Dom Bettinelli: Uh and that always begins with a recap.
- 21:35Dom Bettinelli: So Jimmy, can you give us a recap?
- 21:37Jimmy Akin: This week, Kirk and the gang encounter a series of solar systems where the planets have been pulverized and destroyed.
- 21:44Jimmy Akin: They also find the USS
- 21:46Jimmy Akin: constellation and its sole surviving crew member, Commodore Decker.
- 21:50Jimmy Akin: He reveals that the destroyed planets were caused by a robotic doomsday machine that looks like a giant bugle's corn snack.
- 21:58Jimmy Akin: Which also attacked his ship.
- 22:01Jimmy Akin: Kirk Spock
- 22:02Jimmy Akin: as Kirk Scotty and a few others
- 22:04Jimmy Akin: stay on the constellation to ready it for towing, but McCoy and Decker
- 22:08Jimmy Akin: being back to the Enterprise.
- 22:10Jimmy Akin: That puts Decker
- 22:11Jimmy Akin: in position to take command of the Enterprise and start manifesting his obsession with the doomsday machine.
- 22:17Jimmy Akin: Because
- 22:18Jimmy Akin: like Captain Ahab, he tries to attack his white whale with the Enterprise to the point of irrationality.
- 22:24Jimmy Akin: And
- 22:25Jimmy Akin: oh, did I mention this is obviously inspired by Moby Dick?
- 22:29Jimmy Akin: Um
- 22:29Jimmy Akin: eventually
- 22:30Jimmy Akin: Decker
- 22:31Jimmy Akin: is relieved of command, steals a shuttle, and pilots it into the doomsday machine.
- 22:36Jimmy Akin: That hurts it, but doesn't kill it.
- 22:38Jimmy Akin: It does, however, give Kirk
- 22:43Jimmy Akin: You beam him back at the very last second.
- 22:46Jimmy Akin: The end.
- 22:48Dom Bettinelli: All right.
- 22:49Dom Bettinelli: Uh
- 22:49Dom Bettinelli: you you froze up a little bit there at the end there, Jimmy, but I think we've got to go.
- 22:54Dom Bettinelli: Yeah, but
- 22:55Dom Bettinelli: uh
- 22:55Dom Bettinelli: we have a little bit of a freeze in our recording system.
- 22:58Dom Bettinelli: Uh
- 22:59Dom Bettinelli: so
- 22:59Dom Bettinelli: father,
- 23:00Dom Bettinelli: your thoughts on Doomsday Machine?
- 23:02Fr. Jason Tyler: I really like this one.
- 23:03Fr. Jason Tyler: You know, this is one of the uh the episodes I
- 23:05Fr. Jason Tyler: Can remember pretty well, I guess, uh
- 23:08Fr. Jason Tyler: in in rewatching it, can
- 23:10Fr. Jason Tyler: can enjoy it again.
- 23:11Fr. Jason Tyler: Um
- 23:12Fr. Jason Tyler: you know, as Jimmy said, it's got the the Moby Dick connection.
- 23:15Fr. Jason Tyler: We see the obsession there in Commodore Decker.
- 23:18Fr. Jason Tyler: Uh it's clearly also trying to connect to an issue of the time, even to the point that that Kirk calls it out.
- 23:24Fr. Jason Tyler: I mean they really
- 23:25Fr. Jason Tyler: put a lantern on it and say, Hey, this thing's like what the H bomb used to be like
- 23:29Fr. Jason Tyler: as in at the moment we're recording this.
- 23:30Fr. Jason Tyler: That's what the H bomb
- 23:31Fr. Jason Tyler: fear is, right?
- 23:33Fr. Jason Tyler: You
- 23:34James T. Kirk: ever hear of a doomsday machine?
- 23:36James T. Kirk: No, I'm a doctor, not a mechanic.
- 23:39James T. Kirk: It's a weapon
- 23:40James T. Kirk: built primarily as a bluff.
- 23:42James T. Kirk: It's never meant to be used.
- 23:43James T. Kirk: So strong it could destroy both sides in a war.
- 23:47James T. Kirk: Something like the old H
- 23:49James T. Kirk: bomb was supposed to be.
- 23:51James T. Kirk: So
- 23:51James T. Kirk: I think this is
- 23:54James T. Kirk: a doomsday machine
- 23:56James T. Kirk: that somebody used in a war uncounted years ago.
- 23:59Fr. Jason Tyler: Fear is, right?
- 24:00Fr. Jason Tyler: Yeah.
- 24:01Fr. Jason Tyler: And so, you know, Star
- 24:02Fr. Jason Tyler: Trek.
- 24:03Fr. Jason Tyler: Often will
- 24:03Fr. Jason Tyler: try to uh use
- 24:04Fr. Jason Tyler: as stories to to look at uh an issue
- 24:07Fr. Jason Tyler: or you know, concept or whatever of the day.
- 24:10Fr. Jason Tyler: Um, and as I said, this time they
- 24:12Fr. Jason Tyler: They they're a little more direct maybe in doing so, but um
- 24:16Fr. Jason Tyler: uh
- 24:16Fr. Jason Tyler: but overall, you know, uh as I said, a very, very enjoyable episode
- 24:20Dom Bettinelli: Uh how about you, Jimmy?
- 24:22Jimmy Akin: Yeah, I like this episode
- 24:24Jimmy Akin: too.
- 24:25Jimmy Akin: Um
- 24:26Jimmy Akin: it
- 24:26Jimmy Akin: um
- 24:27Jimmy Akin: I
- 24:27Jimmy Akin: I think it's well done.
- 24:30Jimmy Akin: Um
- 24:31Jimmy Akin: I
- 24:32Jimmy Akin: it it it gets
- 24:33Jimmy Akin: some of the characters, you know, doing some th
- 24:36Jimmy Akin: even though we have a
- 24:37Jimmy Akin: effectively he's a commodore, but he's effectively a badmiral.
- 24:41Jimmy Akin: And
- 24:42Jimmy Akin: um
- 24:43Jimmy Akin: and
- 24:44Jimmy Akin: it's not too heavy on the H
- 24:47Jimmy Akin: bomb
- 24:48Jimmy Akin: parallelism
- 24:50Jimmy Akin: Uh, because the doomsday weapon is not a
- 24:53Jimmy Akin: even though it p
- 24:54Jimmy Akin: f
- 24:55Jimmy Akin: would play a similar function
- 24:57Jimmy Akin: in society, the mechanics of this episode are not like defusing a nuclear bomb.
- 25:03Jimmy Akin: Right.
- 25:04Jimmy Akin: Um
- 25:05Jimmy Akin: s
- 25:06Jimmy Akin: and
- 25:06Jimmy Akin: uh and I
- 25:07Jimmy Akin: there's just a lot to like here.
- 25:09Jimmy Akin: This episode was Hugo nominated.
- 25:11Jimmy Akin: It didn't win, but it it was nominated.
- 25:14Jimmy Akin: Also, even though this is a second season episode
- 25:19Jimmy Akin: Um
- 25:19Jimmy Akin: neither Chekov nor Uhura are in it.
- 25:23Fr. Jason Tyler: Yeah.
- 25:23Jimmy Akin: And the reason for that, I
- 25:25Jimmy Akin: because I looked it up.
- 25:26Jimmy Akin: I thought, well, why is is Walter Koenig not in this if he was already in the second season?
- 25:31Jimmy Akin: And it turns out
- 25:33Jimmy Akin: that
- 25:34Jimmy Akin: with
- 25:34Jimmy Akin: uh
- 25:35Jimmy Akin: with roles
- 25:35Jimmy Akin: like Chekov and Uhura, they didn't have contracts to be in every episode.
- 25:41Jimmy Akin: They were only gonna appear in a certain number of episodes, and then to save money, they would use non-regular actors in others.
- 25:50Jimmy Akin: So
- 25:50Jimmy Akin: for
- 25:51Jimmy Akin: d
- 25:51Jimmy Akin: due to the budget driven contract structure they had, that's why we don't have Chekov
- 25:58Jimmy Akin: or Uhura in this episode and why there's another woman filling in for Uhura.
- 26:02Jimmy Akin: 'Cause she
- 26:03Jimmy Akin: got paid less than Nishelle Nichols, which I couldn't have imagined was that much for even Nichelle Nichols back then.
- 26:10Jimmy Akin: Um
- 26:12Jimmy Akin: also
- 26:13Jimmy Akin: it's been noted, even though this is never set on screen, but it was the intent, uh, is
- 26:20Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 26:20Jimmy Akin: so we have
- 26:21Jimmy Akin: Matt Decker, Commodore
- 26:24Jimmy Akin: Matt Decker
- 26:25Jimmy Akin: in this.
- 26:26Jimmy Akin: And in
- 26:27Jimmy Akin: Star Trek The Motion Picture, we have Captain
- 26:31Jimmy Akin: Will Decker
- 26:33Dom Bettinelli: Yep.
- 26:33Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 26:33Jimmy Akin: who becomes the first officer
- 26:36Jimmy Akin: and
- 26:37Jimmy Akin: he
- 26:37Jimmy Akin: and and
- 26:38Jimmy Akin: and he's meant to be Commodore Decker
- 26:41Jimmy Akin: 's son.
- 26:42Dom Bettinelli: Yeah.
- 26:43Jimmy Akin: Um
- 26:43Dom Bettinelli: the novelization makes that explicit.
- 26:46Dom Bettinelli: Yeah.
- 26:46Jimmy Akin: Right.
- 26:47Jimmy Akin: Um
- 26:48Jimmy Akin: they
- 26:48Jimmy Akin: they never say it on screen in the movie, but
- 26:51Jimmy Akin: That's the intent.
- 26:52Fr. Jason Tyler: I always wondered that, yeah.
- 26:54Fr. Jason Tyler: I
- 26:54Fr. Jason Tyler: thought I'd missed it somewhere maybe, but okay.
- 26:56Fr. Jason Tyler: It's never on screen.
- 26:57Jimmy Akin: And and
- 26:58Jimmy Akin: it's a nice bit of backstory
- 26:59Jimmy Akin: for that character.
- 27:01Jimmy Akin: Um, was a little less nice.
- 27:03Jimmy Akin: Now you notice, uh uh
- 27:05Jimmy Akin: so
- 27:05Jimmy Akin: i in the motion picture, since they're basing it on Star Trek Phase Two that never got made.
- 27:11Jimmy Akin: Um
- 27:12Jimmy Akin: you've got the
- 27:14Jimmy Akin: the action first
- 27:15Jimmy Akin: officer named Will
- 27:17Jimmy Akin: and the exotic
- 27:18Jimmy Akin: foreign
- 27:19Jimmy Akin: seeming female who's a telepath or empath.
- 27:23Jimmy Akin: Who uh, you know, Ilea
- 27:25Jimmy Akin: became Deanna Troy
- 27:27Jimmy Akin: and Will Decker
- 27:28Jimmy Akin: became Will Riker.
- 27:30Jimmy Akin: So notice they're both Will.
- 27:32Jimmy Akin: Except apparently
- 27:34Jimmy Akin: Will Decker, it's not short for William.
- 27:36Jimmy Akin: It's short for Willard.
- 27:39Jimmy Akin: Which is
- 27:39Jimmy Akin: which is not as good as William
- 27:42Jimmy Akin: for that character.
- 27:43Fr. Jason Tyler: Yeah.
- 27:45Dom Bettinelli: So
- 27:46Dom Bettinelli: speaking of Williams, uh
- 27:47Dom Bettinelli: uh
- 27:48Dom Bettinelli: the
- 27:48Dom Bettinelli: the guest star in this is uh William Windom.
- 27:51Dom Bettinelli: He plays uh
- 27:52Dom Bettinelli: plays Decker
- 27:53Dom Bettinelli: in this and
- 27:54Dom Bettinelli: uh
- 27:54Dom Bettinelli: You mentioned Jimmy
- 27:55Dom Bettinelli: Oh is
- 27:55Dom Bettinelli: obvious a parallel or allegory for uh for Moby Dick.
- 27:59Dom Bettinelli: Apparently he didn't get that when he when he when they were filming.
- 28:02Dom Bettinelli: In fact he thought it was all kind of silly and kinda played it cartoonishly, which I think is
- 28:07Dom Bettinelli: interesting
- 28:08Jimmy Akin: He he
- 28:08Jimmy Akin: he did take he he did see a parallel though
- 28:12Jimmy Akin: between this and the Kane
- 28:13Jimmy Akin: mutiny,
- 28:15Jimmy Akin: um, which has Humphrey Bogart as Captain Queeg.
- 28:19Jimmy Akin: And
- 28:19Jimmy Akin: who is similarly obsessed.
- 28:21Jimmy Akin: And
- 28:22Jimmy Akin: in in the cane
- 28:23Jimmy Akin: mutiny, Captain Queig has these little
- 28:26Jimmy Akin: I think they're marbles
- 28:27Jimmy Akin: or something, if I recall correctly.
- 28:31Dom Bettinelli: I mentioned
- 28:32Dom Bettinelli: yeah.
- 28:32Jimmy Akin: And so in this
- 28:34Jimmy Akin: um
- 28:34Jimmy Akin: uh
- 28:35Jimmy Akin: Commodore Decker
- 28:36Jimmy Akin: has these two
- 28:38Jimmy Akin: old style
- 28:39Jimmy Akin: Commodore sixty-four
- 28:41Jimmy Akin: uh
- 28:42Jimmy Akin: Floppy drive, the
- 28:44Jimmy Akin: floppy disks.
- 28:45Jimmy Akin: Yeah.
- 28:45Jimmy Akin: I mean these are the futures
- 28:47Jimmy Akin: equivalent of them.
- 28:48Jimmy Akin: But they they look
- 28:50Jimmy Akin: like
- 28:50Jimmy Akin: exactly the computer discs we all had in the nineteen nineties.
- 28:54Dom Bettinelli: Right.
- 28:54Jimmy Akin: And he's constantly fidged in with those in his hands, which he patterned off Captain Queig.
- 28:59Dom Bettinelli: Even kind of chews on him
- 29:01Dom Bettinelli: a a little bit.
- 29:02Dom Bettinelli: And
- 29:02Dom Bettinelli: and I
- 29:03Dom Bettinelli: it
- 29:03Dom Bettinelli: it is it's
- 29:04Dom Bettinelli: this sign of his mental state, you know, this this
- 29:07Dom Bettinelli: this tick that he has, which I thought was interesting.
- 29:09Dom Bettinelli: You know, as a kid,
- 29:11Dom Bettinelli: this episode made a huge impact on me.
- 29:13Dom Bettinelli: I remember this is one of the ones I really remembered, and it was so dramatic.
- 29:17Dom Bettinelli: You know, that that moment when he's
- 29:19Dom Bettinelli: Flying into
- 29:20Dom Bettinelli: the the
- 29:21Dom Bettinelli: maw of the
- 29:22Dom Bettinelli: cornucopia.
- 29:24Commodore Decker: You said it yourself, Spock.
- 29:27Commodore Decker: There is no way to blast through the hull of that machine, so
- 29:31Commodore Decker: I'm gonna take this thing right down his throat.
- 29:40Jimmy Akin: The bugle snack, yeah.
- 29:41Dom Bettinelli: Yeah.
- 29:42Dom Bettinelli: Uh
- 29:43Dom Bettinelli: and and
- 29:44Dom Bettinelli: You know, it was so drama
- 29:45Dom Bettinelli: like it
- 29:45Dom Bettinelli: it
- 29:46Dom Bettinelli: it's kind of all
- 29:46Dom Bettinelli: kind of hammy
- 29:47Dom Bettinelli: now when you see it, but but at the time it was like, Wow, you know, this
- 29:51Dom Bettinelli: this scary thing
- 29:52Dom Bettinelli: Um
- 29:52Dom Bettinelli: and they've
- 29:53Dom Bettinelli: of course
- 29:54Dom Bettinelli: again I saw this in the updated graphics that they have when they remastered these back in the
- 29:59Jimmy Akin: 90s.
- 30:03Dom Bettinelli: Yeah.
- 30:04Dom Bettinelli: Uh
- 30:04Dom Bettinelli: just uh to mention like I kind of I'm kind of nostalgic for the original
- 30:09Dom Bettinelli: graphics in this one.
- 30:10Dom Bettinelli: I usually like the newer
- 30:11Dom Bettinelli: graphics, but that older version, I don't know.
- 30:13Dom Bettinelli: There was something about that that
- 30:14Dom Bettinelli: I liked better than the newer one.
- 30:16Dom Bettinelli: But
- 30:17Dom Bettinelli: go ahead.
- 30:18Jimmy Akin: Well I was gonna say basically the same thing.
- 30:20Jimmy Akin: I watched the newer
- 30:21Jimmy Akin: graphics for this
- 30:23Jimmy Akin: and
- 30:24Jimmy Akin: because
- 30:24Jimmy Akin: in my Amazon it has both
- 30:27Jimmy Akin: versions
- 30:27Jimmy Akin: and I normally watch the newer graphics to compare it to my memories and I watch the newer graphics here
- 30:33Jimmy Akin: and I don't like
- 30:34Jimmy Akin: The newer
- 30:35Jimmy Akin: graphics that much.
- 30:36Jimmy Akin: It's the the
- 30:38Jimmy Akin: the cornycopia
- 30:40Jimmy Akin: doesn't look as real
- 30:42Jimmy Akin: as the original Doomsday machine, which is pretty simple and you could tell it's not a real Doomsday machine, but it looked better
- 30:51Jimmy Akin: And
- 30:52Jimmy Akin: and I
- 30:53Jimmy Akin: I just don't think that they did a good job with the replacement graphics for this one.
- 30:58Jimmy Akin: Also, they may have introduced a problem.
- 31:01Jimmy Akin: Now I didn't go back and re-watch the original to see
- 31:04Jimmy Akin: But
- 31:05Jimmy Akin: um
- 31:06Jimmy Akin: there's a sequence.
- 31:07Jimmy Akin: It's the sequence where Decker
- 31:09Jimmy Akin: steals the shuttle
- 31:10Jimmy Akin: and we see him skulking about the hallways, and we can tell he's near the shuttle bay because there's a shuttle bay
- 31:17Jimmy Akin: door
- 31:17Jimmy Akin: sign
- 31:17Jimmy Akin: there's a
- 31:18Jimmy Akin: on
- 31:18Jimmy Akin: sign on the wall.
- 31:19Dom Bettinelli: Yeah.
- 31:20Jimmy Akin: And then we see the shuttle bay
- 31:23Jimmy Akin: lift up off its pad and the doors open and it flies out.
- 31:27Jimmy Akin: The
- 31:28Jimmy Akin: shuttle.
- 31:29Jimmy Akin: And
- 31:30Jimmy Akin: then we cut to the bridge and Sulu
- 31:32Jimmy Akin: suddenly reports that someone is opening the shuttle bay doors.
- 31:37Dom Bettinelli: Yeah.
- 31:38Jimmy Akin: And I'm going, we've already seen him fly out.
- 31:41Jimmy Akin: You know, and it's like was
- 31:43Jimmy Akin: uh they
- 31:44Jimmy Akin: they
- 31:44Jimmy Akin: may have
- 31:45Jimmy Akin: um
- 31:46Jimmy Akin: they may have
- 31:48Jimmy Akin: introduced a problem there
- 31:50Jimmy Akin: because
- 31:51Jimmy Akin: they may not have sh had the ability to show the shuttle flying out in the same way in the original.
- 31:58Jimmy Akin: And
- 31:59Jimmy Akin: the animators may have thought, oh, we can show it flying out now.
- 32:03Jimmy Akin: And they just never thought, wait, is the
- 32:06Jimmy Akin: is
- 32:06Jimmy Akin: are there any lines that are going to imply he hasn't done that?
- 32:10Dom Bettinelli: Right, right.
- 32:11Dom Bettinelli: Yeah.
- 32:11Dom Bettinelli: I th
- 32:12Dom Bettinelli: I think
- 32:13Dom Bettinelli: yeah, I
- 32:14Dom Bettinelli: I I don't
- 32:15Dom Bettinelli: I actually I don't know the uh the diff
- 32:16Dom Bettinelli: whether they they
- 32:17Dom Bettinelli: whether they had it
- 32:18Dom Bettinelli: the same way in the original either.
- 32:20Jimmy Akin: Yeah, because
- 32:21Jimmy Akin: I know they had a graphic or a shot of
- 32:23Jimmy Akin: of
- 32:24Jimmy Akin: in in some episodes
- 32:26Jimmy Akin: of the shuttle rotating on its cake
- 32:29Jimmy Akin: stand
- 32:29Jimmy Akin: and then the doors open
- 32:31Jimmy Akin: and
- 32:32Jimmy Akin: but they didn't have the ability to easily make it lift up and fly out.
- 32:37Dom Bettinelli: Right.
- 32:39Dom Bettinelli: Uh I I have to say uh
- 32:40Dom Bettinelli: for the remastering, uh I like the the what they did with the constellation itself as uh
- 32:45Jimmy Akin: Yeah, that was good.
- 32:46Fr. Jason Tyler: Yeah.
- 32:47Dom Bettinelli: Yeah, that was that was that look
- 32:49Dom Bettinelli: looked really good.
- 32:50Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 32:50Jimmy Akin: also
- 32:51Jimmy Akin: speaking of things that look good, here's something from the 60s actually that still looks good.
- 32:56Jimmy Akin: Um
- 32:56Jimmy Akin: one of the
- 32:57Jimmy Akin: one of the things they do in
- 32:59Jimmy Akin: in many
- 33:00Jimmy Akin: uh
- 33:01Jimmy Akin: uh
- 33:01Jimmy Akin: TOS
- 33:02Jimmy Akin: episodes
- 33:04Jimmy Akin: It
- 33:04Jimmy Akin: when they're repairing something, like or when they're in a Jeffries
- 33:08Jimmy Akin: tube or things like that, and they're doing some kind of work, there's this
- 33:14Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 33:14Jimmy Akin: it's both audio
- 33:15Jimmy Akin: audible
- 33:16Jimmy Akin: and visual, but
- 33:18Jimmy Akin: in
- 33:18Jimmy Akin: in
- 33:19Jimmy Akin: they will have in the audio track this intense crackling sound
- 33:24Jimmy Akin: And they'll show flashes of light.
- 33:27Jimmy Akin: Like a
- 33:28Jimmy Akin: you there
- 33:29Jimmy Akin: you don't get to see electrical sparks usually, but you have these flashes of light
- 33:34Jimmy Akin: and you can tell there's something sparking here.
- 33:37Jimmy Akin: And
- 33:38Jimmy Akin: I love that combination
- 33:41Jimmy Akin: of
- 33:41Jimmy Akin: of
- 33:42Jimmy Akin: the flashes and the the intense crackle sound.
- 33:46Jimmy Akin: And it it really gives you a sense of
- 33:49Jimmy Akin: Hey,
- 33:49Jimmy Akin: what we're doing here is dangerous.
- 33:51Jimmy Akin: This is we're doing this under emergency circumstances.
- 33:54Jimmy Akin: This is not a safe and simple repair.
- 33:58Jimmy Akin: And
- 33:58Jimmy Akin: I really like it.
- 33:59Jimmy Akin: It adds more drama and
- 34:01Jimmy Akin: and visceral.
- 34:03Jimmy Akin: feeling uh
- 34:04Jimmy Akin: because you're y
- 34:05Jimmy Akin: it uh
- 34:06Jimmy Akin: it tricks your subconscious into
- 34:07Jimmy Akin: wow, I may get shocked here.
- 34:09Dom Bettinelli: Yeah.
- 34:10Jimmy Akin: And
- 34:11Jimmy Akin: and it's a lot better than just, oh, we've got to plug in all these chips in the right sequence.
- 34:18Dom Bettinelli: Press
- 34:18Dom Bettinelli: the screens.
- 34:19Dom Bettinelli: Yeah.
- 34:19Dom Bettinelli: Lots of screen pressing.
- 34:22Dom Bettinelli: So
- 34:22Dom Bettinelli: the constellation, uh, this is the first time we've seen another a sister ship of the Enterprise, right?
- 34:28Dom Bettinelli: This is
- 34:28Dom Bettinelli: like the Enterprise
- 34:29Dom Bettinelli: Basically, um, you know, we've seen other ships, but not other like
- 34:33Dom Bettinelli: same Starfleet ships.
- 34:35Dom Bettinelli: So that was really fun.
- 34:36Dom Bettinelli: It is kind of funny
- 34:37Dom Bettinelli: the
- 34:38Dom Bettinelli: even though it's a sister ship, its number is 1017
- 34:42Dom Bettinelli: because
- 34:43Dom Bettinelli: they did
- 34:43Dom Bettinelli: they only had the
- 34:44Dom Bettinelli: those
- 34:45Dom Bettinelli: Four numbers.
- 34:46Dom Bettinelli: Basically w
- 34:46Dom Bettinelli: seventeen oh one they just re
- 34:48Dom Bettinelli: no
- 34:48Dom Bettinelli: reuse the numbers.
- 34:50Jimmy Akin: And and the reason for that is this came out the
- 34:53Jimmy Akin: the like within months of the
- 34:55Jimmy Akin: first
- 34:55Jimmy Akin: Star Trek model
- 34:57Jimmy Akin: kits
- 34:58Jimmy Akin: hidden stores.
- 34:59Jimmy Akin: And so they bought a model
- 35:01Jimmy Akin: and made it
- 35:02Jimmy Akin: made it the constellation
- 35:04Jimmy Akin: and and the well the model came with N C C
- 35:07Jimmy Akin: one
- 35:07Jimmy Akin: seven oh
- 35:08Jimmy Akin: one so they just swapped the numbers around.
- 35:10Dom Bettinelli: Why didn't they go at
- 35:11Dom Bettinelli: 1710
- 35:12Dom Bettinelli: and save all of our head cannons a lot of trouble?
- 35:15Dom Bettinelli: That's what I was
- 35:16Dom Bettinelli: assuming.
- 35:17Dom Bettinelli: Anyway, uh
- 35:18Dom Bettinelli: so that was that was fun.
- 35:20Dom Bettinelli: Um
- 35:20Dom Bettinelli: you mentioned uh
- 35:21Dom Bettinelli: No Uhura, that was we had Lieutenant Palmer, and she got quite a few lines actually uh in this one.
- 35:26Dom Bettinelli: Um
- 35:27Dom Bettinelli: Uh I like, you know, Kirk and Scotty getting a lot to do on this one, by the way.
- 35:32Dom Bettinelli: Uh they
- 35:33Dom Bettinelli: beam over.
- 35:34Dom Bettinelli: There's no crew.
- 35:36Dom Bettinelli: I
- 35:36Dom Bettinelli: I
- 35:36Dom Bettinelli: there's a very it's very creepy and it kind of
- 35:39Dom Bettinelli: reminds me a little bit of
- 35:40Dom Bettinelli: Uh
- 35:41Dom Bettinelli: the recent Strange New
- 35:42Dom Bettinelli: Worlds episode we talked about, which was the
- 35:45Dom Bettinelli: the sort of the horror movie movie episode
- 35:47Dom Bettinelli: and how differently they've pla
- 35:49Dom Bettinelli: they play that out.
- 35:50Dom Bettinelli: It's just different
- 35:51Dom Bettinelli: Storytelling styles.
- 35:53Fr. Jason Tyler: And you know, when they take the away
- 35:54Fr. Jason Tyler: team over uh to the constellation, I
- 35:57Fr. Jason Tyler: I was
- 35:57Fr. Jason Tyler: kept waiting.
- 35:58Fr. Jason Tyler: I said, Okay, we got red shirts on an away team.
- 36:00Fr. Jason Tyler: Who's getting killed over there?
- 36:02Fr. Jason Tyler: And nobody does.
- 36:02Fr. Jason Tyler: They they don't lose any red shirts in this one.
- 36:04Fr. Jason Tyler: So
- 36:04Dom Bettinelli: Nobody
- 36:05Dom Bettinelli: nobody
- 36:05Dom Bettinelli: just
- 36:06Dom Bettinelli: just
- 36:06Dom Bettinelli: The
- 36:06Dom Bettinelli: only
- 36:07Jimmy Akin: person
- 36:08Jimmy Akin: only
- 36:08Jimmy Akin: person who dies in this is Matt Decker
- 36:10Jimmy Akin: and and and he's
- 36:12Jimmy Akin: he he offs himself.
- 36:15Jimmy Akin: Um
- 36:16Jimmy Akin: one
- 36:17Jimmy Akin: one thing, so they they've gotta explain why there's no crew on the other ship.
- 36:21Jimmy Akin: And there needs to be no crew on the other ship
- 36:24Jimmy Akin: so that they can
- 36:26Jimmy Akin: So it gives our characters something to do.
- 36:29Jimmy Akin: Yeah.
- 36:30Jimmy Akin: And
- 36:30Jimmy Akin: and so they
- 36:31Jimmy Akin: they're in this solar system.
- 36:33Jimmy Akin: It is not the first solar system.
- 36:37Jimmy Akin: that
- 36:37Jimmy Akin: either
- 36:38Jimmy Akin: um
- 36:39Jimmy Akin: the enterprise or the constellation has come through.
- 36:42Jimmy Akin: There's this train of solar systems.
- 36:44Jimmy Akin: In fact, if you watch the um
- 36:47Jimmy Akin: The
- 36:47Jimmy Akin: pre-credits
- 36:48Jimmy Akin: sequence in this, they're in one solar system, and then they're in another one.
- 36:53Dom Bettinelli: Yeah
- 36:54Jimmy Akin: And so
- 36:55Jimmy Akin: so they've traveled.
- 36:56Jimmy Akin: You have to listen to the dialogue to catch it, but they're in another we've seen
- 37:00Jimmy Akin: we've seen the Enterprise in two solar systems.
- 37:02Jimmy Akin: And Decker
- 37:03Jimmy Akin: says the same thing
- 37:05Jimmy Akin: that we found this series of solar systems.
- 37:08Jimmy Akin: And then we came into this one which had four planets
- 37:11Jimmy Akin: and we s
- 37:12Jimmy Akin: we saw
- 37:13Jimmy Akin: it looked like the
- 37:15Jimmy Akin: what's going to be the doomsday weapon.
- 37:17Jimmy Akin: was
- 37:18Jimmy Akin: up by
- 37:19Jimmy Akin: um, you know, one of the inner planets
- 37:22Jimmy Akin: and it seemed to be carving it up
- 37:25Jimmy Akin: and we came up to investigate and then it attacked us
- 37:29Jimmy Akin: and I had to beam down the crew.
- 37:32Jimmy Akin: to the third planet.
- 37:33Jimmy Akin: And in my notes, it's like
- 37:35Jimmy Akin: you beam down your crew to planet three
- 37:38Jimmy Akin: despite
- 37:40Jimmy Akin: going
- 37:40Jimmy Akin: through destroyed solar systems
- 37:43Jimmy Akin: and you're seeing the fourth planet break up
- 37:47Jimmy Akin: because
- 37:48Jimmy Akin: this thing's cutting it up and then you beam down to the third planet
- 37:52Jimmy Akin: It seems even in emergency circumstances it's safer to keep the crew on the ship.
- 37:56Dom Bettinelli: Right.
- 37:57Jimmy Akin: Um
- 37:58Jimmy Akin: but
- 37:58Dom Bettinelli: lifeboats.
- 38:00Jimmy Akin: Yeah, but it gave us a great line, which was, you know, Kirk says, but there's no third planet.
- 38:07Jimmy Akin: And Decker
- 38:07Jimmy Akin: is like, don't you think I know that?
- 38:11Jimmy Akin: On the third planet.
- 38:12James T. Kirk: There is no third planet.
- 38:18James T. Kirk: Don't you think I know that?
- 38:20James T. Kirk: There was.
- 38:22James T. Kirk: But not anymore.
- 38:25Jimmy Akin: And that's a that's a great line.
- 38:27Dom Bettinelli: That scene where they come upon him and he's kind of catatonic and yeah and
- 38:31Dom Bettinelli: And overcome by what has happened.
- 38:34Dom Bettinelli: And I
- 38:34Dom Bettinelli: that's what I I think is a really effective scene.
- 38:37Dom Bettinelli: I think that's you know the
- 38:38Dom Bettinelli: this guy is
- 38:39Dom Bettinelli: Kind of lost it.
- 38:43Jimmy Akin: Well and and he he verbalizes some of that.
- 38:46Jimmy Akin: He says
- 38:47Jimmy Akin: I
- 38:47Jimmy Akin: I
- 38:47Jimmy Akin: in explaining himself to Kirk at one point, he says
- 38:50Jimmy Akin: it's
- 38:51Jimmy Akin: Just that I never lost a command to a giant bugle snack before.
- 38:57Dom Bettinelli: I like the fact that they don't
- 38:59Dom Bettinelli: That the this
- 39:00Dom Bettinelli: this thing is a mystery from beginning to end.
- 39:09Dom Bettinelli: But w
- 39:09Dom Bettinelli: who knows
- 39:10Dom Bettinelli: what
- 39:10Dom Bettinelli: what alien intelligence
- 39:12Dom Bettinelli: But it's behind it, you know, and uh and Kirk makes us
- 39:16Dom Bettinelli: kind of a a leap here a little bit
- 39:18Dom Bettinelli: with
- 39:18Dom Bettinelli: well, I think it's a doomsday weapon.
- 39:21Dom Bettinelli: And
- 39:21Dom Bettinelli: and he
- 39:22Dom Bettinelli: like you said, he relates it to the you know
- 39:24Dom Bettinelli: cold
- 39:25Dom Bettinelli: uh
- 39:25Dom Bettinelli: cold war
- 39:25Dom Bettinelli: on our planet.
- 39:26Dom Bettinelli: And it's interesting because you and I, Jimmy, talked about Doomsday Machines on Mysterious World, that the Soviets actually had
- 39:32Dom Bettinelli: An actual doomsday machine that would destroy everything
- 39:37Dom Bettinelli: uh
- 39:37Dom Bettinelli: if if
- 39:38Dom Bettinelli: i
- 39:38Dom Bettinelli: in the
- 39:39Dom Bettinelli: if they if the US
- 39:40Dom Bettinelli: somehow defeated them
- 39:42Dom Bettinelli: um
- 39:44Jimmy Akin: Yeah, the dead hand
- 39:46Jimmy Akin: system.
- 39:46Dom Bettinelli: Right, right, exactly.
- 39:48Dom Bettinelli: Yeah, that's uh
- 39:49Dom Bettinelli: back in Mysterious World episode twelve, if folks want to go check that out.
- 39:52Dom Bettinelli: Uh
- 39:53Dom Bettinelli: and uh
- 39:54Dom Bettinelli: so
- 39:54Dom Bettinelli: i
- 39:54Dom Bettinelli: it
- 39:55Dom Bettinelli: it's
- 39:56Dom Bettinelli: I I
- 39:57Dom Bettinelli: I
- 39:57Dom Bettinelli: I
- 39:58Dom Bettinelli: have
- 39:58Dom Bettinelli: a hard time trying to convey to young people
- 40:01Dom Bettinelli: what it was like living in a world where there were doomsday machines.
- 40:06Dom Bettinelli: And I think that's the element
- 40:08Dom Bettinelli: in this
- 40:08Dom Bettinelli: that
- 40:09Dom Bettinelli: of this story that kind of carries here
- 40:12Dom Bettinelli: because
- 40:13Dom Bettinelli: everyone in this
- 40:14Dom Bettinelli: who watched this move
- 40:15Dom Bettinelli: this show
- 40:16Dom Bettinelli: when it came in nineteen sixty seven
- 40:18Dom Bettinelli: They rem
- 40:19Dom Bettinelli: they still had pretty good memories of the World War, the atomic bombs in Japan, and
- 40:26Dom Bettinelli: the you know, the
- 40:27Dom Bettinelli: um
- 40:28Dom Bettinelli: Cuban
- 40:28Dom Bettinelli: Missile Crisis, this was all present to them.
- 40:30Dom Bettinelli: So the
- 40:31Dom Bettinelli: this sort of story would have carried differently.
- 40:34Jimmy Akin: And and that's incidentally why they mentioned the H-bomb
- 40:37Jimmy Akin: specifically.
- 40:38Jimmy Akin: Not the atom bomb.
- 40:41Jimmy Akin: Because the atom bomb had already been used and it didn't end the world.
- 40:45Jimmy Akin: But no one has yet ever fired an H-bomb in anger.
- 40:49Dom Bettinelli: Right.
- 40:50Jimmy Akin: And so
- 40:51Jimmy Akin: it's it
- 40:52Jimmy Akin: it had a doomsday threat in a way the A-bomb didn't at this when the episode was made.
- 40:58Dom Bettinelli: Right, exactly.
- 41:00Dom Bettinelli: So
- 41:00Jimmy Akin: By
- 41:01Jimmy Akin: by the way, a couple of technical details about the machine, they tell us its
- 41:05Jimmy Akin: hull is made of neutronium.
- 41:07Jimmy Akin: which
- 41:08Jimmy Akin: is
- 41:08Jimmy Akin: a form of degenerate matter made of neutrons.
- 41:12Jimmy Akin: It's you know, you've lost all the electrons and so forth
- 41:15Jimmy Akin: because it's so heavy and compressed.
- 41:17Jimmy Akin: And
- 41:17Jimmy Akin: which means this thing, it's not dwarf star matter
- 41:20Jimmy Akin: exactly, but it's like that.
- 41:23Jimmy Akin: And so yeah, you're never I mean it
- 41:25Jimmy Akin: it
- 41:25Jimmy Akin: all of all of Decker
- 41:27Jimmy Akin: 's lets fire on this thing.
- 41:30Jimmy Akin: you know, uh
- 41:31Jimmy Akin: is
- 41:33Jimmy Akin: really
- 41:34Jimmy Akin: not a good strategy.
- 41:36Dom Bettinelli: Right.
- 41:36Jimmy Akin: Um
- 41:37Jimmy Akin: the only way to attack it is what they eventually come up with, which is
- 41:41Jimmy Akin: attack it from the inside
- 41:43Jimmy Akin: where you don't have to get through all that neutronium.
- 41:46Jimmy Akin: They also tell us it's got a total conversion drive.
- 41:50Jimmy Akin: Which
- 41:51Jimmy Akin: the enterprise is pretty I mean the enterprise kind of has that too, given that it's driven by matter antimatter reactions.
- 41:58Jimmy Akin: Uh total
- 41:59Jimmy Akin: conversion
- 42:00Jimmy Akin: is
- 42:02Jimmy Akin: where
- 42:02Jimmy Akin: all of the matter in something gets turned into inner
- 42:05Jimmy Akin: into usable energy.
- 42:07Jimmy Akin: That's a total conversion drive.
- 42:09Dom Bettinelli: Right.
- 42:10Jimmy Akin: And matter
- 42:11Jimmy Akin: antimatter reactions would be one example
- 42:15Jimmy Akin: of
- 42:15Jimmy Akin: of
- 42:16Jimmy Akin: that.
- 42:17Jimmy Akin: Um
- 42:17Jimmy Akin: I do kind of wonder about
- 42:20Jimmy Akin: how this one works though
- 42:21Jimmy Akin: because they tell us it fires pure anti-proton
- 42:25Jimmy Akin: beams.
- 42:27Jimmy Akin: And that makes sense.
- 42:28Jimmy Akin: And that would mean it's got a ton of antimatter in there.
- 42:32Jimmy Akin: So
- 42:32Jimmy Akin: how does it refuel itself by cutting up planets made out of matter?
- 42:38Jimmy Akin: I guess uh
- 42:39Jimmy Akin: it's got some kind of polarity flipper
- 42:43Jimmy Akin: that that lets it take matter and convert it just
- 42:46Jimmy Akin: flip it into
- 42:47Jimmy Akin: be an antimatter and then it can use that.
- 42:49Dom Bettinelli: Mm-hmm.
- 42:51Dom Bettinelli: Yeah.
- 42:51Dom Bettinelli: It
- 42:51Dom Bettinelli: has to be.
- 42:53Dom Bettinelli: Um, I want to talk a little bit about
- 42:55Dom Bettinelli: Decker
- 42:56Dom Bettinelli: taking command of the Enterprise.
- 42:57Dom Bettinelli: You know, cause Kurt
- 42:58Dom Bettinelli: is stuck on the the the constellation when the the robot machine comes back.
- 43:03Dom Bettinelli: Uh
- 43:03Dom Bettinelli: and Decker
- 43:04Dom Bettinelli: relieves Spock of command
- 43:06Dom Bettinelli: Spock's in command.
- 43:07Dom Bettinelli: He relieves Spock of command in order to launch this pointless attack on the Doomsday Machine.
- 43:12Dom Bettinelli: And
- 43:13Dom Bettinelli: McCoy is kind of objects, of course, and
- 43:23Spock: States
- 43:23Dr. McCoy: to blazes with regulations.
- 43:25Dr. McCoy: You can't let him take command when you know he's wrong.
- 43:27Spock: If you can certify Commodore Decker
- 43:29Spock: medically
- 43:30Spock: or psychologically unfit for command.
- 43:32Spock: I can relieve 'em under section C.
- 43:35Dr. McCoy: I'll certify that right now.
- 43:38Dr. McCoy: You
- 43:38Spock: 'll also be asked to produce your
- 43:40Spock: medical records to prove it.
- 43:42Dom Bettinelli: And McQueen's like, okay, I'm gonna do it.
- 43:45Dom Bettinelli: But
- 43:45Dom Bettinelli: of course you'd have to present your you know uh
- 43:47Dom Bettinelli: evidence
- 43:48Dom Bettinelli: like
- 43:49Dom Bettinelli: this guy was catatonic ten minutes ago
- 43:51Dom Bettinelli: right
- 43:52Dom Bettinelli: you don't need to take him down to sick bay for a medical exam to to to determine this
- 43:57Jimmy Akin: Well, but then it's it's also gonna be his word against yours
- 44:01Jimmy Akin: about how catatonic was he and once he snapped out of it, was he fit for command and things like that.
- 44:07Jimmy Akin: I I
- 44:08Jimmy Akin: I do love
- 44:09Jimmy Akin: the way, you know, m
- 44:10Jimmy Akin: so McCoy is
- 44:11Jimmy Akin: his usual
- 44:12Jimmy Akin: self and that's great.
- 44:14Jimmy Akin: And then I love how Spock
- 44:16Jimmy Akin: is Mr.
- 44:17Jimmy Akin: Rulebook here.
- 44:18Fr. Jason Tyler: Yeah.
- 44:19Jimmy Akin: That he is
- 44:20Jimmy Akin: he is, you know, I I
- 44:22Jimmy Akin: I just love that
- 44:23Jimmy Akin: that
- 44:24Jimmy Akin: he is
- 44:26Jimmy Akin: proceeding methodically
- 44:28Jimmy Akin: and he ends up getting
- 44:30Jimmy Akin: getting Decker
- 44:31Jimmy Akin: out of the chair
- 44:32Jimmy Akin: but he does it in the correct way
- 44:35Jimmy Akin: he does it the way the rules envision
- 44:38Jimmy Akin: because
- 44:39Jimmy Akin: um
- 44:40Jimmy Akin: He uh
- 44:41Jimmy Akin: he points out to uh
- 44:43Jimmy Akin: the captain,
- 44:44Jimmy Akin: the to the commodore, that his
- 44:47Jimmy Akin: proposed course of action is suicidal.
- 44:50Jimmy Akin: And
- 44:50Jimmy Akin: that's can be understood as a sign of mental illness, and he gets him to back off
- 44:56Jimmy Akin: at that point.
- 44:58Jimmy Akin: And and then later
- 44:59Jimmy Akin: he's directly ordered by Kirk
- 45:02Jimmy Akin: over the radio, who
- 45:03Jimmy Akin: Kirk is only on the Enterprise
- 45:06Jimmy Akin: Like
- 45:06Jimmy Akin: at the very end of this, yeah.
- 45:08Jimmy Akin: Um
- 45:09Jimmy Akin: the rest of the whole episode he's on he's on the constellation.
- 45:13Jimmy Akin: But um
- 45:14Jimmy Akin: but Kirk
- 45:15Jimmy Akin: orders Spock to relieve him of command
- 45:17Jimmy Akin: and having been given a direct order
- 45:19Jimmy Akin: that gives Spock
- 45:21Jimmy Akin: the ability
- 45:22Jimmy Akin: to
- 45:23Jimmy Akin: um
- 45:24Jimmy Akin: to
- 45:24Jimmy Akin: to relieve him
- 45:25Jimmy Akin: and Decker
- 45:26Jimmy Akin: objects and Spock says, you can file a protest with Starfleet if we survive this encounter.
- 45:33Jimmy Akin: And
- 45:33Jimmy Akin: and
- 45:34Jimmy Akin: and
- 45:34Jimmy Akin: he says
- 45:35Jimmy Akin: you're bluffing
- 45:36Jimmy Akin: and he says
- 45:36Spock: Vulcans never bluff.
- 45:38Jimmy Akin: And it's like, oh
- 45:39Jimmy Akin: no, they just exaggerate.
- 45:41Fr. Jason Tyler: Right.
- 45:42Dom Bettinelli: Um
- 45:43Dom Bettinelli: I wanna point out though
- 45:44Dom Bettinelli: that
- 45:45Dom Bettinelli: When McCoy wants to
- 45:47Dom Bettinelli: bend
- 45:47Dom Bettinelli: the regulation, Spock is against it.
- 45:49Dom Bettinelli: But what's when Kirk suggests it
- 45:51Dom Bettinelli: now it's okay.
- 45:53Dom Bettinelli: And I th
- 45:53Dom Bettinelli: I find that difference very interesting and I wonder if it's intentional.
- 45:57Fr. Jason Tyler: And
- 45:57Fr. Jason Tyler: they both use the same phrase, blast
- 45:59Fr. Jason Tyler: regulations.
- 45:59James T. Kirk: Blast
- 46:00James T. Kirk: regulations.
- 46:00James T. Kirk: Mr.
- 46:01James T. Kirk: Spock, I order you to assume command on my personal authority as Captain.
- 46:07Jimmy Akin: Yeah, yeah.
- 46:08Jimmy Akin: I I think
- 46:09Jimmy Akin: One difference is that Spock 'cause I think he was willing to go along with McCoy
- 46:14Jimmy Akin: if McCoy could have documented it
- 46:17Jimmy Akin: Um
- 46:18Jimmy Akin: but uh
- 46:19Jimmy Akin: and and he had
- 46:21Jimmy Akin: Kirk had sent Decker
- 46:23Jimmy Akin: back to the enterprise to get him checked out medically.
- 46:26Jimmy Akin: It's just that didn't end up happening.
- 46:28Jimmy Akin: Right.
- 46:29Jimmy Akin: Um
- 46:30Jimmy Akin: but
- 46:30Jimmy Akin: um
- 46:31Jimmy Akin: But
- 46:32Jimmy Akin: I I
- 46:33Jimmy Akin: I
- 46:33Jimmy Akin: I
- 46:34Jimmy Akin: um
- 46:35Jimmy Akin: think that for Spock, it
- 46:37Jimmy Akin: one of the differences
- 46:39Jimmy Akin: is McCoy
- 46:40Jimmy Akin: says this the first time.
- 46:42Jimmy Akin: Decker
- 46:43Jimmy Akin: gives a sketchy command
- 46:45Jimmy Akin: and Kirk does it after
- 46:48Jimmy Akin: significant damage has been done and produce nothing.
- 46:51Dom Bettinelli: Right.
- 46:52Jimmy Akin: And so
- 46:52Jimmy Akin: it's clear
- 46:53Jimmy Akin: if we keep attacking this thing, we're just gonna get squashed.
- 46:56Jimmy Akin: This is suicidal and it's not doing anything.
- 46:58Jimmy Akin: And I think that may
- 47:08Fr. Jason Tyler: Yeah.
- 47:08Fr. Jason Tyler: You know when
- 47:09Fr. Jason Tyler: when Spock
- 47:10Fr. Jason Tyler: uses the line about attempted suicide which would be evidence of mental instability
- 47:14Fr. Jason Tyler: I I noted
- 47:15Fr. Jason Tyler: I noted that as well
- 47:15Fr. Jason Tyler: and said this is a the Vulcan version of a threat.
- 47:18Fr. Jason Tyler: You know, this is
- 47:20Fr. Jason Tyler: uh
- 47:21Fr. Jason Tyler: basically
- 47:21Fr. Jason Tyler: yeah, you continue on this, I'll I'll relieve you in this way.
- 47:24Fr. Jason Tyler: I also really like the
- 47:25Fr. Jason Tyler: the
- 47:25Fr. Jason Tyler: exchange too when uh
- 47:26Fr. Jason Tyler: Decker
- 47:27Fr. Jason Tyler: says uh
- 47:28Fr. Jason Tyler: Doctor, you're out of line.
- 47:29Fr. Jason Tyler: And McCoy responds, so are you, sir.
- 47:33Dom Bettinelli: There's that definite pause there.
- 47:37Dom Bettinelli: And I like that Spock
- 47:39Dom Bettinelli: When he relieves Decker
- 47:40Dom Bettinelli: says to
- 47:41Dom Bettinelli: the
- 47:41Dom Bettinelli: security guys, yeah and you know
- 47:43Dom Bettinelli: the security guys are
- 47:44Dom Bettinelli: are all on Spock side.
- 47:45Dom Bettinelli: Yeah.
- 47:46Dom Bettinelli: Uh
- 47:46Dom Bettinelli: but he says to them, Oh, by the way, escort him to Sick
- 47:49Dom Bettinelli: Bay where he can keep
- 47:50Dom Bettinelli: finally get his medical examination
- 47:52Dom Bettinelli: so they can finally just you know have the evidence needed to keep him from getting back in the chair.
- 47:57Dom Bettinelli: Which is good.
- 47:58Dom Bettinelli: Um
- 47:59Dom Bettinelli: And
- 47:59Dom Bettinelli: I I kinda like the fact that
- 48:01Dom Bettinelli: Starfleet captains of this period
- 48:03Dom Bettinelli: seem to all be like action dudes.
- 48:05Dom Bettinelli: Like,
- 48:06Dom Bettinelli: because
- 48:06Dom Bettinelli: you know Kirk would get in a fist fight with a security guard if he needed to, and Decker
- 48:10Dom Bettinelli: apparent, you know
- 48:11Dom Bettinelli: gets the best of this security guy.
- 48:14Dom Bettinelli: And the security guy, the red
- 48:16Dom Bettinelli: shirt, he kinda relishes the fight.
- 48:18Dom Bettinelli: You see
- 48:18Dom Bettinelli: do you see his attitude?
- 48:20Dom Bettinelli: Like his his expression on his face
- 48:21Dom Bettinelli: like, Oh, it's on now.
- 48:23Dom Bettinelli: Let's go.
- 48:23Dom Bettinelli: Okay.
- 48:24Dom Bettinelli: I just thought that was a a a fun little
- 48:35Dom Bettinelli: Right.
- 48:36Dom Bettinelli: Exactly.
- 48:38Dom Bettinelli: I
- 48:38Dom Bettinelli: like the fact that Decker
- 48:40Dom Bettinelli: 's death
- 48:41Dom Bettinelli: uh
- 48:42Dom Bettinelli: does give them the the
- 48:44Dom Bettinelli: the uh
- 48:45Dom Bettinelli: idea for how to destroy this machine.
- 48:47Dom Bettinelli: That
- 48:47Dom Bettinelli: Decker
- 48:48Dom Bettinelli: does contribute to the solution uh
- 48:51Dom Bettinelli: after all
- 48:52Jimmy Akin: Yeah, in hindsight, there's one big flaw that's like, okay
- 48:56Jimmy Akin: ,
- 48:57Jimmy Akin: he had the right idea here, but he was on the shuttle.
- 49:01Dom Bettinelli: Wrong ship.
- 49:03Jimmy Akin: Well, I mean
- 49:04Jimmy Akin: it
- 49:04Jimmy Akin: it
- 49:05Jimmy Akin: even
- 49:05Jimmy Akin: even
- 49:05Jimmy Akin: I can accept that
- 49:07Jimmy Akin: okay
- 49:08Jimmy Akin: they try it with shuttle first because that might work.
- 49:11Dom Bettinelli: Yeah.
- 49:11Jimmy Akin: You know.
- 49:12Jimmy Akin: And then they realize okay, we damaged it but not enough.
- 49:14Jimmy Akin: We need a bigger
- 49:15Jimmy Akin: We need a bigger torpedo that we're firing into this thing.
- 49:20Jimmy Akin: Um, so I can buy that, but he
- 49:24Jimmy Akin: flies the shuttle in there.
- 49:26Jimmy Akin: This is drone
- 49:28Jimmy Akin: work.
- 49:28Dom Bettinelli: Yeah.
- 49:29Jimmy Akin: This is you should have you
- 49:30Jimmy Akin: should have put the shuttle on autopilot
- 49:33Jimmy Akin: and and and tried that
- 49:35Jimmy Akin: ,
- 49:35Jimmy Akin: but they
- 49:36Jimmy Akin: didn't
- 49:37Jimmy Akin: They did have autopilots
- 49:39Jimmy Akin: um
- 49:40Jimmy Akin: as far back as
- 49:41Jimmy Akin: at least the nineteen forties
- 49:43Jimmy Akin: because they were using them in World War Two.
- 49:45Dom Bettinelli: Yeah.
- 49:45Dom Bettinelli: Um
- 49:46Jimmy Akin: but
- 49:47Jimmy Akin: uh
- 49:47Jimmy Akin: but TV writers
- 49:49Jimmy Akin: you know, either didn't think of it or didn't use that for dramatic reasons.
- 49:53Dom Bettinelli: I think it was on purpose, actually.
- 49:55Dom Bettinelli: I think we w
- 49:56Dom Bettinelli: they wanted to show his instability, his
- 49:58Dom Bettinelli: his
- 49:59Dom Bettinelli: um
- 50:00Dom Bettinelli: mental state in having
- 50:01Dom Bettinelli: lost his crew
- 50:02Dom Bettinelli: and that he should have gone down with his ship.
- 50:05Jimmy Akin: Right.
- 50:06Jimmy Akin: No, like I said,
- 50:07Jimmy Akin: they they
- 50:08Jimmy Akin: they
- 50:08Jimmy Akin: they may not have
- 50:10Jimmy Akin: used it.
- 50:11Jimmy Akin: purposefully.
- 50:12Dom Bettinelli: Yeah.
- 50:12Jimmy Akin: But
- 50:13Jimmy Akin: i
- 50:13Jimmy Akin: uh
- 50:13Jimmy Akin: you know, I'm trying to think
- 50:16Jimmy Akin: how
- 50:17Jimmy Akin: would I do it
- 50:17Jimmy Akin: and I would use a drone.
- 50:19Dom Bettinelli: Right, right.
- 50:20Dom Bettinelli: That would do
- 50:20Dom Bettinelli: that would do.
- 50:21Fr. Jason Tyler: Yeah.
- 50:21Fr. Jason Tyler: You know, when they get the report, you know, as you mentioned earlier about Sulu reporting
- 50:24Fr. Jason Tyler: the shuttle bay doors are open.
- 50:27Fr. Jason Tyler: And then eventually um
- 50:30Fr. Jason Tyler: they learn its
- 50:31Fr. Jason Tyler: decker
- 50:31Fr. Jason Tyler: on the shuttle and Spock looks surprised like
- 50:34Fr. Jason Tyler: Well why are you surprised?
- 50:35Fr. Jason Tyler: Like
- 50:35Fr. Jason Tyler: which
- 50:36Fr. Jason Tyler: crew member did you think was stealing a shuttle?
- 50:45Dom Bettinelli: Someone's like, I'm out of here.
- 50:47Dom Bettinelli: This
- 50:47Dom Bettinelli: I've had enough of this.
- 50:48Dom Bettinelli: I'm getting out of it.
- 50:51Dom Bettinelli: So the uh the
- 50:53Dom Bettinelli: the
- 50:53Dom Bettinelli: the
- 50:53Dom Bettinelli: they come up with the idea to
- 50:55Dom Bettinelli: blow up the constellation inside the doomsday machine and uh we get a
- 50:59Dom Bettinelli: a precise figure for what size of explosion we'd have from the impulse engines overloading because
- 51:05Dom Bettinelli: not the warp engines
- 51:06Dom Bettinelli: 97.
- 51:07Dom Bettinelli: 835 megatons, which is uh
- 51:09Dom Bettinelli: substantial.
- 51:10Dom Bettinelli: Um
- 51:11Dom Bettinelli: Scotty, can you rig
- 51:12Dom Bettinelli: it to blow?
- 51:12Dom Bettinelli: And I love Scotty's line.
- 51:14Dom Bettinelli: The shape the thing's in, it's hard to keep it from blowing
- 51:17Dom Bettinelli: The shape this thing's in, I'm working to keep her from blowing up
- 51:20Dom Bettinelli: on
- 51:21Dom Bettinelli: its
- 51:21Dom Bettinelli: own.
- 51:22Dom Bettinelli: Which which is good.
- 51:23Jimmy Akin: Scotty gets some good lines in this.
- 51:26Jimmy Akin: They also have
- 51:27Jimmy Akin: they
- 51:28Jimmy Akin: I'm glad they use
- 51:29Jimmy Akin: the term from science fiction.
- 51:32Jimmy Akin: for what this weapon is.
- 51:34Jimmy Akin: It's not
- 51:34Jimmy Akin: they sell it to the audience as a doomsday machine.
- 51:38Jimmy Akin: But what it is
- 51:39Jimmy Akin: is in science fiction terms, it's a planet killer.
- 51:42Dom Bettinelli: Yeah.
- 51:42Jimmy Akin: Um
- 51:43Jimmy Akin: it renders
- 51:44Jimmy Akin: planets uninhabitable in this case by carving them
- 51:47Jimmy Akin: up.
- 51:47Jimmy Akin: Um
- 51:48Jimmy Akin: but there are lots of planet killers
- 51:51Jimmy Akin: um
- 51:51Jimmy Akin: in science fiction and there are ways to build real planet killers
- 51:56Jimmy Akin: What what I hate about this sequence
- 51:59Jimmy Akin: is
- 51:59Jimmy Akin: they
- 52:00Jimmy Akin: you know they they have magic tech failures in this as normal with communications and transportation and stuff like that.
- 52:07Jimmy Akin: Um
- 52:08Jimmy Akin: I do like when Scotty beams back
- 52:11Jimmy Akin: to the enterprise to show us the danger with the transporter instead of just saying transporters are offline, they're showing
- 52:19Jimmy Akin: explosions
- 52:20Jimmy Akin: on the transporter pad.
- 52:22Jimmy Akin: It's like
- 52:23Jimmy Akin: Bang!
- 52:23Jimmy Akin: And you know, wow, yeah, okay, that might not be the safest technology to use at the moment.
- 52:29Dom Bettinelli: They released the magic po
- 52:30Dom Bettinelli: magic smoke from the capacitors.
- 52:35Jimmy Akin: But
- 52:35Jimmy Akin: um
- 52:36Jimmy Akin: but
- 52:36Jimmy Akin: but
- 52:37Jimmy Akin: when Spock is telling Kirk about the risks he's undertaking, we may not be able to get you back in time.
- 52:44Jimmy Akin: Kirk says
- 52:45Jimmy Akin: one of the lines that I just hate because it's such a cliche.
- 52:50Jimmy Akin: I cringe every time anyone in an old TV episode says it.
- 52:54Jimmy Akin: And you'll notice
- 52:55Jimmy Akin: nobody uses this line in modern television.
- 52:58Jimmy Akin: because
- 52:58Jimmy Akin: of what a hackneyed cliche
- 53:00Jimmy Akin: it is.
- 53:01Jimmy Akin: But Kirk says
- 53:02Jimmy Akin: a calculated risk.
- 53:06Jimmy Akin: And
- 53:06Jimmy Akin: it's never actually calculated.
- 53:09Jimmy Akin: It's just
- 53:10Jimmy Akin: You know, and but all this talk about risks and their magnitudes and things like that, it's just such hackneyed writing.
- 53:17Jimmy Akin: I hate it.
- 53:18Dom Bettinelli: Yeah.
- 53:20Dom Bettinelli: Why thirty seconds?
- 53:21James T. Kirk: Press this one, thirty seconds later, poof.
- 53:25Spock: Once it's activated, there's no way to stop it.
- 53:27Dom Bettinelli: Why did it set the delay to 30 seconds?
- 53:29Dom Bettinelli: Set it for a minute, set it for f
- 53:31Dom Bettinelli: two
- 53:31Dom Bettinelli: two minutes.
- 53:32Dom Bettinelli: Like why
- 53:33Dom Bettinelli: why did it need to like
- 53:34Dom Bettinelli: Okay, well as soon as we press this button, thirty seconds later, this thing's blown to the kingdom
- 53:38Dom Bettinelli: come.
- 53:39Dom Bettinelli: Well, maybe
- 53:39Dom Bettinelli: give yourself a little more time.
- 53:41Dom Bettinelli: I
- 53:41Dom Bettinelli: it it's
- 53:42Dom Bettinelli: I I thought it was kind of funny.
- 53:43Dom Bettinelli: We have but we have to set the delay to thirty seconds.
- 53:45Fr. Jason Tyler: Uh yeah.
- 53:46Fr. Jason Tyler: The only thing
- 53:47Fr. Jason Tyler: you know you can headcanon to say maybe they're concerned that the uh
- 53:51Fr. Jason Tyler: the planet killer
- 53:52Fr. Jason Tyler: would was going to somehow be able to expel
- 53:54Fr. Jason Tyler: the ship, you know, to burp it out or whatever, I guess.
- 53:57Fr. Jason Tyler: Um
- 53:58Fr. Jason Tyler: if it was sitting here too long.
- 53:59Jimmy Akin: And and this is a real actual problem
- 54:02Jimmy Akin: with this, if you think about it, um, because
- 54:05Jimmy Akin: this is what's sometimes called fridge logic.
- 54:08Jimmy Akin: Mm-hmm.
- 54:09Jimmy Akin: Which is where you may not notice something your first time through an episode, but you think about it later when you're going to the fridge for a snack.
- 54:15Jimmy Akin: Um
- 54:17Jimmy Akin: But
- 54:17Jimmy Akin: um, okay, if this is a
- 54:20Jimmy Akin: if this is a planet killing doomsday weapon that destroyed both sides in a war in another galaxy
- 54:27Jimmy Akin: Flying a ship into this thing and blowing it up
- 54:30Jimmy Akin: would have been tried
- 54:31Jimmy Akin: a long
- 54:32Jimmy Akin: time
- 54:32Jimmy Akin: ago.
- 54:42Jimmy Akin: believable
- 54:43Jimmy Akin: than this Death Star
- 54:45Jimmy Akin: has an exhaust port
- 54:47Jimmy Akin: that we can
- 54:47Jimmy Akin: fire something down.
- 54:49Jimmy Akin: Um
- 54:50Jimmy Akin: because
- 54:50Jimmy Akin: this has
- 54:51Jimmy Akin: gap
- 54:51Jimmy Akin: and
- 54:52Jimmy Akin: maw
- 54:52Jimmy Akin: and
- 54:53Jimmy Akin: and it's
- 54:54Jimmy Akin: it eats
- 54:55Jimmy Akin: planets and ships
- 54:56Jimmy Akin: and it's got a new tronium hull.
- 54:59Jimmy Akin: You know, attacking its mouth is the obvious thing to do.
- 55:03Dom Bettinelli: Right
- 55:04Fr. Jason Tyler: Well maybe there were once a thousand of these, and the other nine hundred and ninety-nine have all been destroyed by ships doing exactly that.
- 55:10Fr. Jason Tyler: And this is the one that happened to escape and make it to the Milky Way.
- 55:17Dom Bettinelli: So uh
- 55:18Dom Bettinelli: the other
- 55:18Dom Bettinelli: a little
- 55:19Dom Bettinelli: a little fun moment, s Scotty's racing the clock to fix the transporter for
- 55:23Dom Bettinelli: for Kirk uh to
- 55:24Dom Bettinelli: beam back.
- 55:25Dom Bettinelli: And Spock is on the bridge and he keeps saying Scotty's name over and over.
- 55:30Dom Bettinelli: Scotty
- 55:30Dom Bettinelli: Mr.
- 55:31Dom Bettinelli: Scott.
- 55:31Spock: Mr.
- 55:32Spock: Scott, twenty
- 55:33Spock: seconds to detonation.
- 55:40Spock: Mr.
- 55:41Spock: Scott.
- 55:44Spock: Mr.
- 55:45Spock: Scott.
- 55:46Spock: Try
- 55:46Spock: inverse phasing.
- 55:49Dom Bettinelli: Mr.
- 55:50Dom Bettinelli: Scott.
- 55:51Dom Bettinelli: And it's like, dude, that's not helping.
- 55:55Dom Bettinelli: Like,
- 55:55Dom Bettinelli: he knows.
- 55:56Dom Bettinelli: He knows.
- 55:57Dom Bettinelli: Poor Scotty.
- 55:58Dom Bettinelli: So that was that was good.
- 56:00Dom Bettinelli: Um
- 56:00Dom Bettinelli: we do get a little uh
- 56:02Dom Bettinelli: the final scene, a little Cold War moralizing about the uh
- 56:05Dom Bettinelli: about H
- 56:06Dom Bettinelli: bombs, you know, using an H
- 56:07Dom Bettinelli: bomb essentially, which
- 56:09Dom Bettinelli: what they turned the the
- 56:10Dom Bettinelli: uh constellation into.
- 56:12Dom Bettinelli: Um
- 56:12Dom Bettinelli: To destroy another doomsday machine
- 56:14Dom Bettinelli: and uh the the irony of that.
- 56:25Jimmy Akin: I mean
- 56:25Jimmy Akin: maybe it is, but then they give
- 56:27Jimmy Akin: us the line about it's the first probably the first time that we've used an H-bomb
- 56:31Jimmy Akin: constructively.
- 56:32Dom Bettinelli: Yeah.
- 56:33Jimmy Akin: And I understand the resonance of that line when the episode was made, but
- 56:37Jimmy Akin: again, from a realism perspective, no, I think probably people have used
- 56:42Jimmy Akin: H
- 56:43Jimmy Akin: -bomb explosions for constructive purposes by the twenty-third century already.
- 56:47Dom Bettinelli: Right, right.
- 56:48Dom Bettinelli: And uh
- 56:49Dom Bettinelli: and then we
- 56:50Dom Bettinelli: they end
- 56:51Dom Bettinelli: It
- 56:51Dom Bettinelli: it's an interesting way to end this episode, which is like they could
- 56:54Dom Bettinelli: sort of get the, you know, I wonder if there are any more of these uh
- 56:57Dom Bettinelli: devices wandering around the universe
- 56:59Dom Bettinelli: and
- 56:59Dom Bettinelli: Kirk says I hope not.
- 57:00Dom Bettinelli: I found one quite sufficient.
- 57:01Dom Bettinelli: Then we get flutes of humor and
- 57:04Spock: However I can't help wondering if there are any more of those weapons wandering around the universe.
- 57:22Dom Bettinelli: I feel like a b
- 57:23Dom Bettinelli: a more somber ending might have worked better.
- 57:26Jimmy Akin: Ye
- 57:26Jimmy Akin: yeah, but the standard was we want to go out on a light note.
- 57:30Dom Bettinelli: I guess.
- 57:31Dom Bettinelli: Yeah.
- 57:31Dom Bettinelli: I mean they
- 57:32Jimmy Akin: and and they forced it, which they often do.
- 57:35Dom Bettinelli: Yeah.
- 57:35Dom Bettinelli: They've they've made a different choice in other episodes.
- 57:38Dom Bettinelli: And
- 57:38Dom Bettinelli: and and I
- 57:39Dom Bettinelli: I don't know.
- 57:40Dom Bettinelli: I've
- 57:41Dom Bettinelli: I
- 57:41Dom Bettinelli: I would
- 57:42Dom Bettinelli: I I it's not a huge deal.
- 57:43Dom Bettinelli: I just would have I would have done a little differently.
- 57:45Dom Bettinelli: But
- 57:46Dom Bettinelli: um
- 57:46Dom Bettinelli: any other thoughts on this one, Father?
- 57:48Fr. Jason Tyler: Uh
- 57:48Fr. Jason Tyler: nope.
- 57:48Fr. Jason Tyler: We covered my notes.
- 57:49Dom Bettinelli: Jimmy, how about you?
- 57:51Jimmy Akin: Nope.
- 57:52Dom Bettinelli: All right.
- 57:52Dom Bettinelli: So let's move on to our listener feedback.
- 57:54Dom Bettinelli: And we got uh several pieces of feedback on our recent discussion of invasive procedures, which was the DS9
- 58:01Dom Bettinelli: episode we
- 58:02Dom Bettinelli: recently uh talked about.
- 58:03Dom Bettinelli: First one comes from truly awesome New Mexico Catholic who wrote on YouTube
- 58:07Dom Bettinelli: two
- 58:07Dom Bettinelli: main thoughts on this episode.
- 58:09Dom Bettinelli: One, Odo
- 58:11Dom Bettinelli: shouldn't have trapped himself because if someone threatens to unalive
- 58:14Dom Bettinelli: someone else.
- 58:15Dom Bettinelli: Uh
- 58:16Dom Bettinelli: unless you make yourself less of a threat, they'll probably unalive
- 58:19Dom Bettinelli: that person anyway.
- 58:20Dom Bettinelli: And second, I think the origin of the Trill's symbiosis would probably be legendary or mythical
- 58:27Dom Bettinelli: And that would be interesting
- 58:28Dom Bettinelli: too.
- 58:29Jimmy Akin: I agree that
- 58:31Jimmy Akin: the
- 58:31Jimmy Akin: the Trill
- 58:32Jimmy Akin: symbiosis may be legendary.
- 58:35Jimmy Akin: Maybe
- 58:36Jimmy Akin: um
- 58:37Jimmy Akin: uh
- 58:37Jimmy Akin: it would involve surgery
- 58:40Jimmy Akin: uh
- 58:40Jimmy Akin: in primitive conditions
- 58:43Jimmy Akin: uh
- 58:43Jimmy Akin: you know
- 58:44Jimmy Akin: before the invention of writing.
- 58:46Jimmy Akin: But y that's not impossible.
- 58:48Jimmy Akin: I mean, here on Earth they were doing
- 58:50Jimmy Akin: trepanation, which is where you drill a hole in somebody's head.
- 58:54Jimmy Akin: Um
- 58:54Jimmy Akin: they
- 58:55Jimmy Akin: were doing trepanation in in the Paleolithic
- 58:59Jimmy Akin: here on Earth.
- 59:00Jimmy Akin: So you can do surgery in primitive
- 59:02Jimmy Akin: you just don't have a big survival rate, but
- 59:05Jimmy Akin: you can do surgery in primitive conditions.
- 59:08Jimmy Akin: Um
- 59:09Jimmy Akin: the
- 59:09Jimmy Akin: in terms of Odo
- 59:11Jimmy Akin: agreeing to be trapped
- 59:13Jimmy Akin: ,
- 59:13Jimmy Akin: I
- 59:14Jimmy Akin: there's always that
- 59:16Jimmy Akin: um
- 59:18Jimmy Akin: risk
- 59:18Jimmy Akin: calculus.
- 59:20Jimmy Akin: And here it is a calculated risk.
- 59:26Jimmy Akin: But where you've got to decide, okay, what are the odds here?
- 59:30Jimmy Akin: What and be
- 59:31Jimmy Akin: and
- 59:31Jimmy Akin: and
- 59:32Jimmy Akin: real hostage negotiators have to make that decision.
- 59:36Jimmy Akin: And there's not an
- 59:37Jimmy Akin: obvious right
- 59:38Jimmy Akin: way to do it in real life.
- 59:40Jimmy Akin: So I can cut 'em some slack for
- 59:43Jimmy Akin: having the same tension.
- 59:45Jimmy Akin: Uh
- 59:46Jimmy Akin: in a fictional context.
- 59:47Jimmy Akin: By the way, I did have one other note.
- 59:49Jimmy Akin: I meant to mention that the Doomsday Machine was written by Norman Spinrad, who is a science fiction author.
- 59:55Jimmy Akin: So this was another episode that was a product of Gene Roddenberry going out and trying to get actual science fiction writers, not just T V writers, and teach 'em how to do science fiction.
- 1:00:06Dom Bettinelli: Right.
- 1:00:07Jimmy Akin: Uh but that's one of the reasons this may be one of the better episodes.
- 1:00:11Jimmy Akin: is you had an actual science fiction writer exploring the concept.
- 1:00:15Dom Bettinelli: Right.
- 1:00:17Dom Bettinelli: So our next feedback comes from Ravilla West
- 1:00:19Dom Bettinelli: on YouTube, who
- 1:00:20Dom Bettinelli: writes uh simply that when the news came out, uh
- 1:00:22Dom Bettinelli: rest
- 1:00:22Dom Bettinelli: in peace, Walter Kinney.
- 1:00:24Dom Bettinelli: Eternal rest
- 1:00:24Dom Bettinelli: grant
- 1:00:25Dom Bettinelli: unto him, O Lord, and may your perpetual light shine upon him.
- 1:00:29Dom Bettinelli: And then
- 1:00:29Dom Bettinelli: Georgius
- 1:00:30Dom Bettinelli: Rex on YouTube
- 1:00:31Dom Bettinelli: writes, I like to think that this Klingon
- 1:00:33Dom Bettinelli: is really Tuvok
- 1:00:35Dom Bettinelli: in deep cover.
- 1:00:36Dom Bettinelli: So though
- 1:00:37Dom Bettinelli: that's that that's a fun
- 1:00:39Dom Bettinelli: chat, Kenneth uh
- 1:00:40Dom Bettinelli: 'cause we've he's we've got uh
- 1:00:42Dom Bettinelli: basis for
- 1:00:42Dom Bettinelli: Tuvok going into
- 1:00:43Dom Bettinelli: deep cover.
- 1:00:44Dom Bettinelli: Uh
- 1:00:44Dom Bettinelli: although half of the Dax
- 1:00:46Dom Bettinelli: episodes seem to be about the worm, at least this one is an improvement over Dax
- 1:00:50Dom Bettinelli: 's legal quandaries about extraditing the worm for murder, which
- 1:00:54Dom Bettinelli: yeah,
- 1:00:55Dom Bettinelli: a bit better.
- 1:00:58Dom Bettinelli: And that's all our feedback.
- 1:00:59Dom Bettinelli: So
- 1:00:59Dom Bettinelli: thank you.
- 1:01:00Dom Bettinelli: And now let's move on to thank our
- 1:01:02Dom Bettinelli: patrons who take make it possible for us to create the Secrets of Star Trek, including
- 1:01:06Dom Bettinelli: Barbara J, Rock K, Pierre
- 1:01:09Dom Bettinelli: M, Carolyn S, and Stephanie L.
- 1:01:11Dom Bettinelli: Their generous donations at givestarquest.
- 1:01:14Dom Bettinelli: com make it possible for us to continue the Secrets of Star Trek and all the shows at StarQuest.
- 1:01:19Dom Bettinelli: And you can join them by visiting GivestarQuest.
- 1:01:22Dom Bettinelli: com.
- 1:01:23Dom Bettinelli: And be sure to share the podcast with your friends.
- 1:01:25Dom Bettinelli: Help us grow our community
- 1:01:27Dom Bettinelli: and reach more listeners.
- 1:01:28Dom Bettinelli: So that's it from us this time.
- 1:01:30Dom Bettinelli: We'd love to know what you thought of the Doomsday Machine.
- 1:01:32Dom Bettinelli: You can let us know by commenting on the show at sqpn.
- 1:01:35Dom Bettinelli: com slash trick.
- 1:01:37Dom Bettinelli: Send us an email to Trek at SQPN.
- 1:01:40Dom Bettinelli: com.
- 1:01:40Dom Bettinelli: Visit our Discord community at SQPN.
- 1:01:43Dom Bettinelli: com slash Discord, or watch the secrets of Star Trek on our YouTube
- 1:01:47Dom Bettinelli: channel at youtube.
- 1:01:49Dom Bettinelli: com slash Starkwest
- 1:01:50Dom Bettinelli: Media.
- 1:01:51Dom Bettinelli: We'll be back next time when we'll be discussing the animated series episode, Albatross.
- 1:01:57Dom Bettinelli: Until then, Jimmy
- 1:01:58Dom Bettinelli: Aiken, thank you for joining me and sharing the secrets of Star Trek.
- 1:02:02Dom Bettinelli: Don't you think I know that?
- 1:02:05Jimmy Akin: Live long and prosper.
- 1:02:07Jimmy Akin: And
- 1:02:07Dom Bettinelli: Father Jason Taylor, thank you as well.
- 1:02:09Fr. Jason Tyler: Thank you.
- 1:02:10Dom Bettinelli: And once again, I'm Dom Bettinelli.
- 1:02:12Dom Bettinelli: Thank you for listening to the Secret of
- 1:02:14Dom Bettinelli: Star Trek on StarQuest
- 1:02:15Dom Bettinelli: and remember
- 1:02:16Dom Bettinelli: Vulcans never bluff.
- 1:02:18Dom Bettinelli: Except when they do.
- 1:02:21Dom Bettinelli: Here's another show on the StarQuest Network you're sure to enjoy.
- 1:02:24Dom Bettinelli: The Secrets of Sacred Art.
- 1:02:26Dom Bettinelli: Find it wherever fine podcasts are found or at StarQuest.
- 1:02:30Dom Bettinelli: fm slash
- 1:02:31Dom Bettinelli: art