Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / Show #700: with Drew McCoy of Genetically Modified Skeptic
Transcript
- 0:00We understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol,
- 0:09an idea. The population of atheists in this country is going through the rule,
- 0:14rejecting faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the
- 0:19truth, it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand
- 0:23on a book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world.
- 0:29Take the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness. Truth Usian
- 0:32wisdom will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and
- 0:39start thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. This
- 0:56is a very special day as I celebrate broadcast numbers seven hundred. It's been
- 1:02what thirteen years plus. The podcast started in summer of twenty ten, and
- 1:10you know, I've done different things over these milestones. To mark the occasion
- 1:14for this, I wanted to talk to a friend, a buddy of mine
- 1:17and fellow activist. He is host of the Genetically Modified Skeptic Channel. His
- 1:23name is Drew McCoy. Thanks for coming, Drew, It's good to see
- 1:26you. Yeah, I'm honored to be here. You've been doing this thirteen
- 1:29years. I'm just over thirteen years old now. And so dude, you
- 1:34and I on camera. The YouTube link is in the description box. But
- 1:38it's like old Guard meets the next generation. Like I have some people who
- 1:44are like, oh great, it's like a father son event when they see
- 1:48us on screen together. And I'm having a moment about that. But for
- 1:52those who do not know who you are, let's get a quick introduction.
- 1:56Introduce yourself to the audience. I'm Drew, host of Genetically Modified Skeptic on
- 2:00YouTube. I've been around doing atheist type stuff since twenty seventeen and make a
- 2:07whole variety of videos on my channel about you know, debunking pseudoscience, alternative
- 2:14medicine stuff, to talking about early Christian literature. I have scholars that come
- 2:19on my channel to discuss a lot of issues related to religion and cognitive science
- 2:23of religion, that kind of thing. A whole variety, yeah, of
- 2:28things related to atheism and skepticism. Kind of like Seth, you don't just
- 2:30stick to just one thing. You've got to have a little grab bag of
- 2:35contents, so you have something that interests just about everybody. Now you bring
- 2:38something up. I had somebody on the Al Jazeera English feature that you and
- 2:43I were both part of They came to our homes and interviewed us for this
- 2:47nine minute piece on YouTube atheism, and I want to talk about that.
- 2:52But there was somebody in the comments and they were like, you know,
- 2:54once monetization became mandatory for the dissemination of YouTube video, these frontline activists,
- 3:01you know, they're all doing the same stuff. There's nothing new under the
- 3:06sun, no new arguments. Why bother. And of course I was like,
- 3:08well, hang on, So I went back. Maybe I'm just being
- 3:12defensive, but I was just looking at my recent channel, because you were
- 3:15talking about variety Christian nationalism. We did ghost hunters, purity culture, Old
- 3:21Testament, slavery, Robert Ingersoll, Islam, secular students, molecular biology,
- 3:27vaccines, interfaith alliances, suicide, the Sound of Freedom, film, the
- 3:31Gothard Cult, AI, Cognitive Liberty, Ron DeSantis, book bands, I
- 3:37Swear to God. I was, well, if you'll pardon the expression,
- 3:40I'm like, what more do you want? We're all doing our best out
- 3:45here, and it sounds like you're trying as well, that you don't just
- 3:47log on every day and say this is why the Book of Genesis has been
- 3:52debunked, which is really old hat these days, Is that correct sir?
- 3:55Oh? Yeah? I mean this is the thing atheism skept critical thinking in
- 4:00general. If that's your kind of core of your content, creation of your
- 4:05interests, there's so many things that that touches. You know. I get
- 4:10comments on videos that have nothing to do with whether or not God exists,
- 4:13saying dude, when are you going to stop just saying God isn't real?
- 4:16Over and over for years. This is getting boring. And that's when I
- 4:20know the person has not actually watched the video. They're they're commenting based on
- 4:26a stereotype, which you know some people are going to do that. You
- 4:29got to you got to break that mold with time. Well, you know,
- 4:31I've I host a scient and show called The Thinking Atheist, which is
- 4:36an icon representing the rejection of faith. I came out of a faith culture,
- 4:42so did you, and we'll talk about that. And so I was
- 4:46afraid to give myself permission to reason right, trust, not in your own
- 4:49understanding? And the Lord works in mysterious ways. Who am I to know
- 4:55the mind of the Lord? And so I was trained to distrust reason and
- 5:00not to rely on thinking. And so the Thinking Atheist was really more of
- 5:03a reminder we should all engage. And one of the apologist things I see
- 5:09is a drive by in the comments, thinking atheist, that's an oxymoron,
- 5:14and then they all take off, you know. And most of the time,
- 5:16a lot of people who were hammering all cap stuff into the channel,
- 5:19you can tell that they aren't really watching or listening. They are sort of
- 5:25forming an opinion based on what they think the channel might be. And that's
- 5:29the case for you, right. Definitely that happens. And I actually released
- 5:33a video just the other day that was talking about the idea of being a
- 5:39nice atheist. And you know, I have a brand similar to yours in
- 5:45that I'm not this kind of raging type guy. That's not my personality.
- 5:49I don't know if I have the charming gift of the gab that you have.
- 5:55People do think that I'm nice generally in person, and so that works
- 5:59well for me. I have people that say that, oh no, Drew,
- 6:02it's just a facade. You're actually very cruel because you're willing to criticize,
- 6:06you know, people promoting gay conversion therapy, which is nonsense and very
- 6:11harmful. So if you say that you're nice, but you do that,
- 6:14you're a hypocrite. Or they say, oh, you're way too nice,
- 6:16and you know, you'd never actually have any teeth to your content, you
- 6:20never criticize, which again, if you take a deeper look into what I'm
- 6:26doing, I think that's that can be shown to be pretty untrue. There's
- 6:30there's substance there, but you'll get the drive by hey comments no matter what
- 6:34you do. Honestly, I think a lot of people too they think kindness
- 6:38is weakness and I just don't buy that. Or if you're not extreme,
- 6:43then you're singing Kumbai yah with your ideological opponents. There is no middle ground,
- 6:48you know. And I see this sometimes with the punch a Nazi crowd,
- 6:51So that do you support punching Nazis in the street And I'm like,
- 6:55no, oh, well, you're empowering the Nazis. It's just one of
- 7:00those things where there's no other form of protest or resistance or a method for
- 7:04activism or even changing minds. They've just given up. The only thing to
- 7:09do is to destroy these people, and I think they must be defeated,
- 7:14or certainly the ideology. But if you're not an extreme person in that way,
- 7:16they think you're weak and that's hard. You know, I'm the mister
- 7:20rogers of the movement, right. I mean you've probably heard that kind of
- 7:24thing drew you and I are. I've literally gotten comment. Yes you have
- 7:27that comment. Yes you're an ex vangelical. How long were you a Christian?
- 7:34I left Christianity when I was about twenty two, so I beat you
- 7:41to it when it comes to age at least, Well, what flavor of
- 7:46Christianity to paint the picture? Yeah, I was in the independent Fundamental Baptist
- 7:51Church, so rather conservative. I will say though, that my family was
- 7:59considered somewhat distastefully liberal within the context of the specific church because my sister wore
- 8:03pants. I don't mean pants in church, I mean pants, just pants,
- 8:09and we were allowed to listen to secular music. So yeah, very
- 8:13very conservative. Being gay as an abomination, Young Earth six day creationism,
- 8:18that whole fun circuits, and so you know, when you leave that kind
- 8:22of high control group, it affects every relationship in your entire life. It
- 8:28affects the way that you carry yourself day to day. When people sometimes come
- 8:33in and say, well, d're you're so nice that I actually think that
- 8:37maybe you are regressing to fundamentalism, I want to say, first of all,
- 8:41if you think that being nice and fundamentalism are one and the same,
- 8:46you're in for a rude awakening. You ever get into rural Alabama. Now
- 8:50when you say IFB, though, I'm thinking about these wacky extremist guys that
- 8:54Hemmet Meta is always posting on social media, right, They're calling for the
- 8:58death, they want the execution of gay people. Am I think? Is
- 9:03this the same thing you came out of? Yeah? It's oh God all
- 9:07most I mean. So that's the new Independent Fundamental Baptist Church. And I
- 9:11was a part of the Independent Fundamental Baptist Church, so the old guard.
- 9:16The way that I differentiate the two is I say that the new IFB says
- 9:20slurs in public and the IFB says slurs in private. So we would never
- 9:26have a sermon that was up there talking about execution of anyone. But back
- 9:31in the back room, if you were to discuss something with the pastor and
- 9:35you caught him being particularly candid, then sure he might say that, well,
- 9:39being gay's in abomination, and it absolutely is bringing hurricanes and you know,
- 9:43tornadoes and other natural disasters into our country and poverty and all those things.
- 9:48So maybe the best thing to do would be to round them up.
- 9:50You know, the NEWIFBS is very brazen about that. The al jazeer At
- 9:56piece was really focused on YouTube activists and how the game has changed since the
- 10:03quote unquote New Atheists of two thousand and seven two thousand eight. I entered
- 10:09the game in two thousand nine, and my stuff was a lot harder edged
- 10:15back then. But over time I began to soften. I started to relax
- 10:20a little bit. I think some of the anger that I felt from the
- 10:24damage done by my religious culture started to wane a little bit. But I
- 10:30also realized that, you know, getting into shouting matches and freaking out of
- 10:33people on Twitter and mocking other people for believing produced no positive result. Like
- 10:39I never changed a mind with that. I don't know, Drew. Did
- 10:43you ever have a moment where you came out you were just pissed off and
- 10:46that anger sort of tempered or or fed into your work your content in a
- 10:52way. Yes. I never was the type of person who was raising my
- 10:58voice at all. I made some jokes at people's expense, for sure,
- 11:03But I think that the way that it my anger and just kind of healing
- 11:09or yet to be healed. Wounds affected my activism and my content was just
- 11:13I used to consider myself an anti theist, you know. I thought that
- 11:20kind of the ultimate goal for me was getting us closer to a world where
- 11:24religion didn't exist. And I thought that that was a realistic goal, and
- 11:28that that was, you know, the highest goal that I could attain.
- 11:33That was kind of the best good that I could I could fight for.
- 11:35And now I've realized that, yeah, religion can do a lot of harm.
- 11:43It still actively does a lot of harm. And I have no qualms
- 11:46about anybody trying to fight against religious harm, whether they are a religious person
- 11:50or they're an atheist, whatever. But I think that it was somewhat my
- 11:56latent Christianity actually that that was in ruencing me to be kind of an anti
- 12:03theist. What that meant for me was that I had figured out the best
- 12:07way to be a moral person and to influence society to be moral and productive,
- 12:13and so that meant everyone kind of needed to do what I'm doing.
- 12:18After a while, when my wounds healed a bit more, I kind of
- 12:20realized, oh, that's like Christianity, you know, there's one. There's
- 12:26only on one path to God, There's only one way to do the right
- 12:30thing, and I have it and everyone else needs act like me. It
- 12:33was. It was several years into doing content until I figured out that I
- 12:39don't think that was that was me anymore. Probably beginning of twenty twenty is
- 12:43when I started thinking, no, I wouldn't call myself an anti theist,
- 12:46but just someone who's trying to fight religious harm. The Al Jazeera piece had
- 12:52a couple of things that the host said that I disagreed with. First of
- 12:56all, it called Christian nationalism a fringe movement. I'm like, holy,
- 13:00it is not fringe. Secondly, it talked about the atheist worldview, and
- 13:05I hear this sometimes from religious people, Well you have an atheist worldview,
- 13:11And I'm like, atheism is not a worldview, damn it. Humanism is,
- 13:15but atheism is not. You agree, disagree? Yeah, this is
- 13:20one of the things that I feel like gets me in trouble or people have
- 13:24a hard time with with me. I agree with with. I think the
- 13:30sentiment that you're expressing that no, atheism is a singular position. It doesn't
- 13:35entail all of these other beliefs like humanism, that said, if you call
- 13:41yourself an atheist in an American context and the context that we're in, I
- 13:46think maybe especially in the American South, you know, Tulsa or Austin,
- 13:50that people are going to think, Hey, that means that you are some
- 13:54sort of secular humanist. Either that or they think that you're a Satan worshiper.
- 14:00They don't think you're a Satan worshiper, then they think that you're a
- 14:03secular humanist, and usually they're right now. I am someone who does not
- 14:11philosophically, you know, align with what atheism has been defined as in those
- 14:16kind of rigorous intellectual terms. I don't make any sort of claim that there's
- 14:20no God. I don't even necessarily know that. I defend the lack theism
- 14:24kind of idea like, well, I'm not claiming that there is no God.
- 14:28I just am not convinced that there is. My position is that I
- 14:31just don't think that it's knowable, and I don't think it's particularly useful to
- 14:33speculate about it. But I call myself an atheist, and even an atheist
- 14:41more so than like a humanist, because when people hear the word atheist,
- 14:45they know what I'm saying more often they know I'm where I'm at, what
- 14:50I'm getting at the people that I have things in common with. So no,
- 14:56atheism isn't a worldview, but it is, and I identity at least
- 15:00where we are. And so I think that's the overlap there, you know,
- 15:03with the way that we speak, in the way that Ryan the journalist
- 15:07speaks. Well, here's where I'm coming from. The aliens told me there
- 15:11is no God. That person's an atheist, But it doesn't mean they're a
- 15:15rationalist. You know, I don't believe in God and everything sucks and I
- 15:20hate humanity, you know, you know those types of things, or I'm
- 15:24not I'm a flat I've met flat earth atheists. I've met anti vax atheists.
- 15:31I've met people who cross the political line one way or the other,
- 15:35you know, run the spectrum as atheists, and so they don't believe in
- 15:39a god. But it didn't mandate anything else about them. But I understand
- 15:43your point that it's that it's sort of the first step toward we would hope
- 15:48toward humanism. I mean, am I hearing you correctly? Like if you
- 15:52don't believe there was a god to solve our problems, then we're going to
- 15:56have to solve our own. Is that accurate? I mean, I wish
- 16:07no. I think that My main point is just that, you know,
- 16:10I think about this in sociological terms, is that when people hear atheists,
- 16:14they have a certain thing in mind, and usually that is a broad category
- 16:19or broad identity that like, I do have most things in common with I
- 16:25do have most things in common personally with the popular conception of atheists, at
- 16:29least if that conception of atheists is not entirely based on horrible stereotypes. You
- 16:33know, but I do see what you're saying. You know, there is
- 16:36definitely utility in saying, you know, I'm an atheist, But that's just
- 16:41one part. There's way way more. And I think that you and I
- 16:47actually might be coming from the same place ultimately in that, Yeah, find
- 16:52myself as an atheist because it's kind of easy. But if I'm having a
- 16:56longer conversation with someone me getting out here and being like I'm an atheist and
- 17:03really sticking by I don't care that much about that. I'd rather be the
- 17:07thinking part in the thinking atheist rather than the atheist part, right, I
- 17:11feel like that's what that's more what you're about too. You and I have
- 17:15a lot in common, and that we were sort of both mister clean in
- 17:18our youth, right. I mean I was like student leader. We weren't.
- 17:22My parents did not drink. We got in trouble for humming a beer
- 17:27jingle once, you know, where me and my sisters and I in course
- 17:30you'd play HEREM on television and we were in the car and it was like,
- 17:33you know, if you've got the time, one beer stands clear.
- 17:37We were just saying it, which is what jingles do. They're supposed to
- 17:40brand into your mind. And my mother had a fit lost her mind,
- 17:44like, oh my god, don't you ever utter those words again? And
- 17:48there was this sort of culture of prohibition, right, a whole bunch of
- 17:52don'ts. Was that true for you? Oh yeah, Actually, it's funny
- 17:56that you bring that up, because when I was about seventeen, I went
- 18:00to a Rangers baseball game with one of my friends from the youth group and
- 18:03with her parents, and you know, I thought I was a good influence
- 18:08and all that kind of thing. But I did get in trouble because at
- 18:11the game there was a guy walking around, like, you know, selling
- 18:15beer, and I thought it was really fun that he would go to each
- 18:21section in the bleachers and have a little contest basically saying ice cold beer,
- 18:26you know, yelling eyes cold beer. And everyone was supposed to stand up
- 18:29and yell at and whatever section yelled at the loudest, you know, got
- 18:33bragging rights whatever. And I thought that was a fun thing. I at
- 18:37one point stood up with the rest of the crowd and yelled eyes cold beer,
- 18:41even though of course I would never drink a beer. And that was
- 18:45the moment that my friend's parents decided that I was a bad egg. So,
- 18:52yeah, it's just such a for those on the outside looking in,
- 18:56they must think, what, like, how did you not see how I
- 18:59happened? Normal? They're bizarre or controlling? This is but you know,
- 19:02when it's everywhere and everybody else is doing it, you know, we The
- 19:07Satanic panic of the eighties and nineties was also part of you know, my
- 19:12formative years late seventies, eighties and nineties, where everything was imbued with the
- 19:17devil. We thought kiss stood for nights in Satan's service. The rock band
- 19:23they, you know, Gene Simmons, was out there spitting blood with his
- 19:27big tongue and we thought, well, that's the devil's tongue, and so
- 19:30whatever it was, I mean, everything was satanic. The music was satanic,
- 19:34the cartoons were satanic, the toys were satanic. We just saw the
- 19:38devil everywhere. We were kind of a terrified culture. Did you have any
- 19:41of that in your background? Oh my god. Yeah. So I was
- 19:48a young kid when Pokemon started to get really, really popular, and my
- 19:55mom saw the little cartoons and the little characters and thought they were really cute,
- 19:59which they were. I was like a five year old boy, so
- 20:02of course I loved Pokemon. I knew a bunch of Pokemon names and things
- 20:04like that. And one day my mom wanted to sit me down and have
- 20:11a very serious conversation. And she leads me to the living room and my
- 20:15dad is sitting there, and you know, I'm only five. I was
- 20:19like, it's about to go down because Dad's dad's there. He's going to
- 20:22talk to me about this too. And that's when I first heard the term
- 20:29oriental demons, which apparently they heard from some preacher. They I think that
- 20:37they did a look into Pokemon from some of their friends and they found some
- 20:45VHS tape or DVD that had this sermon on it that was saying that Pokemon,
- 20:52because it's based somewhat in Japanese you know, Shinto beliefs and have parodies
- 20:59of different spirits and things like that, that means obviously that Pokemon is a
- 21:03ploy by Satan using the people of Japan to in script or enlist children into
- 21:12you know, yeah, Satan's service. So I was not allowed to have
- 21:15any of my little Pikachu toys anymore because Pikachu was actually in some sort of
- 21:21Japanese electricity demon. Oh yeah, And I became horrified of Pokemon for for
- 21:27a little while because of that. Is you can imagine, well, I
- 21:30think there's a Pokemon character that actually evolves in the game, and I know
- 21:34that was a point of contention for some pastors. All they're brainwashing children by
- 21:40having their creatures evolve. One of the things I heard, and it was
- 21:44one of the complaints about contemporary Christian music. You know, back when Christian
- 21:48rock started to become a thing where we would copy what was going on in
- 21:52the pop culture. We'd have a Christian version of it. But a lot
- 21:56of hardcore pastors still condemned it as satanic. They said that drums emulated the
- 22:00drums of Africa that were used in ritual to summon demons. Just see you
- 22:06nodding your head, does that? Yes? I mean you heard that one.
- 22:08Oh lord, yeah, I'd only heard that one. I was from
- 22:15not my immediate family, but my extended family. These were the guys,
- 22:18the missionaries that went to places where indigenous people lived and still celebrated, you
- 22:23know, in traditional ways, that saw that and came back to the States
- 22:29to tell all of the naive white folks in the nineteen forties and fifties that
- 22:36they're summoning demons out here. And rock and roll was invented by black people,
- 22:41and so that's you know, obviously there's a through line there, and
- 22:44so rock and roll is really just a ploy to enlist people into Satan service.
- 22:49You know, it's all connected. So it's not even it's not even
- 22:55covert racism. There's some overt racism attached to that, resolutely yeah. Crazy.
- 23:00Yeah. You posted a series of videos on your channel about the quacks.
- 23:08Define quack and tell me why you did the series. In that series,
- 23:14I just mean, a quack is someone who I guess maybe we would
- 23:17call it grifter nowadays, someone who is using pseudoscience or kind of just dishonest
- 23:23argumentation or ideas in order to shore up political or monetary or any other kind
- 23:33of support or power. And I did that series because I just thought,
- 23:37you know, in having conversations with my own family members and friends, I
- 23:45have confronted ideas like naturalness bias, you know, the idea because something's natural,
- 23:51it's automatically better. And it never really occurred to me that that was
- 23:56a particularly difficult thing to see through or debunk. But for a lot of
- 24:00people, they just hear that around them. It's very normal. They see
- 24:03these authority figures, these quacks using arguments like that to sell their nonsense miracle
- 24:08supplement, and they buy into it. So I just thought, I'm going
- 24:11to make a series. At first, it wasn't supposed to be a series,
- 24:15but I really liked making those videos where I just talk about some of
- 24:21the basics of maybe media literacy was a part of it, or just critical
- 24:26thinking skills, knowing some terminology that's very useful in seeing through some of the
- 24:33trickery, some of the grifting that people get into online, in person,
- 24:37in literature, whatever. Well, that's where I was going. There are
- 24:41specific tactics that you lay out that they use that you say we should be
- 24:48really watching for. Can you think of any specifics examples? A big one
- 24:53is that it's a huge one today. Honestly, people will make some sort
- 25:00of statement and it's very outlandish. Think of a Jordan Peterson type. And
- 25:07there's a lot of kind of like big manly men types on social media now
- 25:11that do this. They make these very outlandish, grandiose claims, and then
- 25:15when someone says, hey, I have some questions about that, you know,
- 25:19can you back that up? They kind of just retreat too, well,
- 25:23I'm just asking questions, you know, Well, what I'm saying is
- 25:26not rigorously understood, and I'm not saying that you should accept it as fact.
- 25:32I'm just saying that you should buy my book where I talk about it.
- 25:36They retreat back to this position of I'm just asking questions. And so
- 25:40they're asking questions all over everyone. And this is a form of what we
- 25:45call Mott and Bailey. It's kind of like an informal fallacy. It's where
- 25:51someone puts forward a claim that is kind of easily attacked and they lead with
- 26:00that. But then when that claim is attacked, they retreat to a position
- 26:04that is actually very easy to defend and harder to attack. So it's difficult
- 26:11to point out the logical fallacy or the various purposes that the person has if
- 26:17they're just asking questions, right, But ultimately, what we have to remember
- 26:22is that if we're seeing people that are just like spewing all of these ridiculous
- 26:27claims, that they're not trying to back up, and that's what they're doing
- 26:32until and you know, they stand by it until they are asked to back
- 26:37it up, and then they retreat to I'm just asking questions. Bro,
- 26:41got to realize that, like, no, they're not just asking questions,
- 26:45and if they are asking questions, they're doing so in a way which is
- 26:48obviously, whether it's purposeful or not, obviously deceptive and spreading misinformation. So
- 26:55we should be able to call someone out on something like that. I get
- 27:00a lot of Joe bros. Who come by my channel because I go hearted
- 27:03Joe Rogan, a guy who i'd like to like, you know, I'd
- 27:08like to like Joe Rogan, but every time I turn around, he's got
- 27:12some crank in the interview chair and he gives them a platform to spew the
- 27:18worst, most batshit, crazy, destructive, just totally unsubstantiated stuff, and
- 27:25then when somebody pushes back, he does that very thing. Well, I'm
- 27:27just asking question. I'm just a guy. I mean, I'm not a
- 27:30scientist. I'm just saying, don't you want to have the discussion? Aren't
- 27:33you the least bit cure? The fact that you're not asking questions tells me
- 27:37that you're the closed minded one. And of course when he does this,
- 27:40I'm screaming. I'm screaming at the video feed. I don't know. Are
- 27:44you got any thoughts on Rogan? I don't want to, like, I'm
- 27:45not trying to increase your amount of hate mail, but what do you think?
- 27:49Yeah? I did a response video to an interview that Joe Rogan did
- 27:56recently. It was with this guy named doctor Stephen Meyer and being nice and
- 28:00using his using his his title there, Steven Meyer. But he works for
- 28:07the Discovery Institute, which is an it's an apologetics factory masquerading as some kind
- 28:14of scientific research institution, which it's not. They don't they don't actually publish
- 28:18in rigorous journals. Creationism doesn't have anything to say scientifically. It's just religious.
- 28:23But yeah, I did a response to this alongside my friend John Perry,
- 28:27who makes science kind of science education videos about biology, and sure,
- 28:33Joe Rogan pushed back a little bit, you know, said that, hey
- 28:37man, you're you're saying that you believe in Jesus because there were were sightings
- 28:42that were reported hundreds or thousands of years ago, but there were sightings of
- 28:45bigfoot, you know, so is that really particularly good evidence for that?
- 28:51And yeah, they have a bit of a back and forth, but ultimately,
- 28:55what I'm seeing is when it's not super simple, when it's not extra
- 29:00really easy for Joe Rogan to push back, kind of for the sake of
- 29:03comedy more than anything, he just sits there and lets the guests spew whatever
- 29:07they're spewing. So you have Joe Rogan being like, hey man, like,
- 29:12why don't you believe in evolution? And then Steven Meyer has a very
- 29:18long explanation about why he thinks that certain theories within genetics are not rigorous and
- 29:23they don't make sense because of this and this and this, and math gets
- 29:26involved and it gets very complicated, and so Joe Rogan sits there being like,
- 29:30whoa man fascinating because he has no idea what the guy's saying, and
- 29:34the audience doesn't know what he's saying either. He just sounds smart. And
- 29:37I think that that's kind of the danger of the just asking questions man thing,
- 29:42because when you entertain any idea because it's just fun and you think that
- 29:48that's what being open minded looks like, you're going to let in a lot
- 29:53of nonsense that you just don't have the skills to understand are different than other
- 30:02forms of information. A lot of Christians just don't have the skills or understanding
- 30:07of science to realize that someone like doctor Stephen Meyer is not a publishing accomplished
- 30:12scientist. He's a guy that writes popular apologetics books about biology. Show number
- 30:19seven hundred with Drew McCoy of Genetically Modified Skeptic continues next. Hang on,
- 30:33I am talking here with Drew McCoy is host of the channel Genetically Modified Skeptic.
- 30:40Is that a nickname for you as well or just the channel? Do
- 30:41they know you as you know GMS? I would say that more so than
- 30:48the thinking atheist, the host of Genetically Modified Skeptic is known as the genetically
- 30:52Modified Skeptic. A bit more the meaning behind that is. It's layered,
- 30:57but I think the one that's most important to me is that I am the
- 31:03first in four generations of men and my family not to be a Christian missionary,
- 31:07you know, and I mean on the mission field, living in small
- 31:11villages with the people who were still worshiping their ancestors, and you know,
- 31:15of course the demonic. And so for me, what genetically modified mean is
- 31:21it's a fun Internet speak type way of saying that. I guess that being
- 31:26a missionary is in my blood, but there was something that changed enough to
- 31:30make me not so much that I hate when people turn it around and say,
- 31:33oh, well, you're a missionary for atheism. I have to clarify
- 31:37now. I don't. I'm not trying to make converts, especially going out
- 31:41to rural villages where people don't necessarily have education, to try to make people
- 31:44atheists. I would never do that. But I do feel like there is
- 31:48enough difference from my grandparents, my father, my great grandfather that everyone there
- 31:57to say that I am I'm doing something different, but there's there's a bit
- 32:01of a through line. Obviously, I don't know. They were good preachers.
- 32:04I like to think that you're not really a missionary. I mean I
- 32:07think you and I have an activist nature. I mean, didn't you always
- 32:14I would assume by watching your work that you've always kind of wanted to be
- 32:16an agent of positive change. I want to make a difference, so I
- 32:20want to go out and engage. You find people who are passive in this
- 32:22world and people who are active, and so you know, I don't see
- 32:27you as an atheist preacher, but I see you as somebody who was engaged.
- 32:31You have an activist temperament, am I Is that a fair way to
- 32:35say it? Yeah, I mean it's a flattering way of saying at least
- 32:38I would like to think that. Yeah. But if you were not an
- 32:42atheist, you would be in the jungle right now and you would be bringing
- 32:45in probably what food and medicine and games for the kids. And you would
- 32:50be oh no, seth, oh no, no no, because that's normally
- 32:54what we did. We would go in and give them all the goodies,
- 32:58and then once we had sort of applied them with our wares, then there
- 33:00would be sermonizing. So sure, sure, but give us this day our
- 33:05daily bread. Is not referring to bread, let's just say that I would
- 33:14be very good at speaking indigenous languages and translating them, translating Bibles into their
- 33:22version of the kjav That would be my main skill set. Sure, I
- 33:27would give them my hand me downs and some food and things like that,
- 33:31but that would not be the focus. All right. Twice I did take
- 33:37an overseas mission strip and we would do that. We would go and meet
- 33:42their physical needs first, which I appreciate. You know, they needed food,
- 33:45and they needed clothing and resources, and we were raising money for a
- 33:50school, et cetera. But once we had met their physical needs, then
- 33:52we felt it was our mandate to meet their spiritual needs, which was really
- 33:58an arrogance of bringing in my own theology and saying you're wrong, you're living
- 34:02wrong, you're doing it wrong, let me fix you. I mean,
- 34:06missionary work really is pretty arrogant. Yeah, I would agree with that,
- 34:12and I do have to say that, you know, with my great grandfather
- 34:15it was very much like, no, just just preach to them. They
- 34:20don't need anything else. In fact, their poverty might even help them come
- 34:22to Christ faster. And with my grandfather it was like, all right,
- 34:28we should love people in our communities generally, and we should make sure that
- 34:32they're provided for, but we're going and preaching to them regardless of where they're
- 34:37at, and then kind of maybe after the fact, taking care of them
- 34:38just because we care about them, which is better. And then my dad
- 34:42was a lot more concerned. My dad's not a preacher, you know.
- 34:45My dad was the guy that was more like, I'm going to go work
- 34:49in a Christian run orphanage or kind of homeless shelter in a rural area and
- 34:53do that. And so I do see that there are grades to this,
- 34:59and I'd like to that it got better with every generation. You know,
- 35:02I think my dad is not really not that kind of archetype of the missionary
- 35:08who goes out and mother Teresa's all over the place. You know, your
- 35:12poverty is really a blessing, so be poor, but also love Jesus.
- 35:16So yeah, there are grades of selfishness and superiority complexes that missionaries have,
- 35:22but at the end of the day, I consider it all colonialism. Well,
- 35:29we always felt that nobody's the villain in their own story, and we
- 35:31always felt like we were doing the right thing. But you know, our
- 35:36sincerity didn't mean that we weren't really presumptuous and kind of stupid, like they
- 35:42didn't need to be fixed. How about Dad's perspective on you now? I
- 35:45mean, is he log onto your channel? Hey, that's my boy?
- 35:49You know? Is that getting sticky? I do have to say, and
- 35:53I try to keep it pretty brief when it comes to discussions of my parents,
- 35:58just out of respect. But I have to say that one of the
- 36:00reasons why I do my channel is not because, you know, like doing
- 36:06this makes my parents so happy. You know, I wouldn't say that it
- 36:09does, but my parents will still have a relationship with me and still say
- 36:15I love you unconditionally. And you know, my dad is the epitome of
- 36:21the meek that will inherit, inherit the earth, I like to say.
- 36:23And so yeah, he'll he'll watch my videos sometimes, and while it's not
- 36:28really his thing, it doesn't reflect his perspective. I think that. I
- 36:32think that as time has gone on and they've seen that the tone that I
- 36:37take is as it is, they've developed some pride in that I'm doing something,
- 36:43at least in this style that they would like. Maybe it's not the
- 36:45message they would like, but I'm not I'm not one of these guys out
- 36:50here shitting on anyone who disagrees with me or believes what they believe either.
- 36:54So I do this because there are people who are just not in that situation,
- 37:00especially coming from an IFB background. I'm lucky to have parents that,
- 37:06while it's not their favorite that I do this, they still talk to me
- 37:08and still love me. Coming out of Christianity. You did a piece about
- 37:15purity culture where you talked about conservative Christianity grooming You what do you mean.
- 37:22Yeah, so one part of that video was really just kind of deconstructing,
- 37:28examining this term that people are throwing around, this real hot button idea and
- 37:32buzzword that we've got right now, of grooming. You know, like this
- 37:36person, that person, this whole group whoever that I don't like as a
- 37:39groomer. They are shaping children's minds through unethical means in order to prey on
- 37:46them, manipulate them, get some kind of perverted satisfaction out of them,
- 37:52something like that. And you know, I see the primary the main group
- 37:58that is really being demonized with this whole buzzword of being a groomer are just
- 38:04LGBT people, just I mean, I think especially trans people and parents of
- 38:09trans people. You know, I even have people that subscribe to my channel
- 38:15or did that think that, Yeah, if you show or expose a child
- 38:20to the fact the fact that there are people who are LGBT out there and
- 38:27that they're not harming anyone, their life is fine. They're literally just like
- 38:30anyone else that that is actually trying to shape their minds in order to make
- 38:36them gay and or trans or whatever. And there are all kinds of reasons
- 38:43why people would want to do this, which I don't I've never seen personally,
- 38:47but they tell me that this happens. But really, I think if
- 38:52you look at this whole concept of grooming, of shaping children's minds deliberately to
- 39:00make them this cookie cutter that you like and that you can control for the
- 39:06rest of their lives. Were really talking about LGBT communities. I mean,
- 39:10if we want to talk about the superlative here, we want to talk about
- 39:15the type of culture or the force or group within our American culture that does
- 39:20this the most. We're definitely talking about conservative Christians. I mean, Funny,
- 39:25when I was growing up, it was always you can grow up to
- 39:28be anything you want to be, and then they just spent the whole of
- 39:32their resources, limiting my options. We don't go to that church, don't
- 39:37date that person, don't read that book, and don't watch those movies,
- 39:42and don't have this opinion, don't vote this way. It was really restrictive,
- 39:46and it was all sort of packaged with a bow that said freedom on
- 39:51it. Right. Oh, yeah, absolutely. I mean the fact that
- 39:57I could tell a whole story that you could rely late too, about me
- 40:00not being able to play a Pokemon video game on my game boy, Like
- 40:06that shows something, you know, that there's truth to the idea that this
- 40:09is very pervasive. Yeah, I mean the way that I'll just talk about
- 40:15LGBT people in particular with the way that I was brought up. You know,
- 40:19when I was exposed to LGBT people growing up. First of all,
- 40:25it was not until my parents were very very sure that I was going to
- 40:30listen to them and that I wasn't going to be open minded about this.
- 40:34I wasn't going to question them, and that they could stoke some kind of
- 40:37fear in me. Right, So I was older, not a young child,
- 40:42and I get exposed to the fact that gay people exist. Back then,
- 40:46I was taught, you know, they choose to be gay, but
- 40:49the fact that people choose to be gay, I guess, and the way
- 40:52that gay people were painted were not as normal human beings that are diverse like
- 41:00any other group of people. But that gay culture means that you go out
- 41:05to the club a lot, you do a lot of hard drugs, you
- 41:07have a lot of extremely dangerous promiscuous sex, that you hate all religion,
- 41:14that you are purposely running away from, the truth, that you're a nihilist,
- 41:16that your mental health is horrible. And so I was really conditioned not
- 41:21just by my immediate family at all, but by my entire culture. Everyone
- 41:24in my church, in my school, extended family, all my entire culture
- 41:30all would present gay people as not just people, but as representatives of this
- 41:36entire community and group who were disgusting and unhealthy for reasons that if anybody,
- 41:43you know, really to do this, one might think, oh, that's
- 41:45you know, that's not desirable. And so when I get older and I'm
- 41:52running into not at my Christian college but out in the world, just running
- 41:57into like co workers and things that are LGBT, I'm like, why you
- 42:00seem okay? Like why do you seem fine? Why why do you have
- 42:05a steady job. Why don't you have a drug addiction? Why is your
- 42:07partner happy? Why are you happy? All of these things? And you
- 42:13just see that these narratives that you're taught from childhood are meant to condition you
- 42:20to be controlled by the group, by your parents. And that is if
- 42:24we want to use the stupid buzzword of grooming, that's grooming. All right,
- 42:30let's end with a deep thought. Let's get philosophical. Had somebody asked
- 42:36me recently, Seth, do you think things are going to improve when you
- 42:40look around, especially at this country, do you think things are eventually going
- 42:45to get better? And I wanted to say yes, Drue, I wanted
- 42:50to say something encouraging. You know, we just need to stick it out,
- 42:53the rising seculars in this country and blah blah blah. But you know,
- 42:59I'm in Oklahoma. Do you still live in Texas? Are you still
- 43:00down south of me here? I'm in the island of Austin, floating ulty
- 43:05of Texas. Yes. So you know what, So we've got Gilead going
- 43:08on in both of our states. We've got idiots getting elected and then re
- 43:13elected. We've got anti vaxxers, we've got flat earthers. Qan honors deep
- 43:17fake videos that confuse the hell out of everybody. That's going to get worse.
- 43:21You got fake headlines coming out of Gaza right, complete with doctored photographs,
- 43:27so we don't even know what the correct news is, especially on social
- 43:30media. The Epic Times, I just read that they had like increased their
- 43:36distribution by six hundred or almost seven hundred percent. This is a propaganda paper
- 43:40published by a cult. Almost two thirds of Republicans say they want Trump to
- 43:46run again in twenty twenty four. You got anti science influencers that are pitching
- 43:51everything from healing crystals to drinking your own pea. I mean, you've got
- 43:55Ai replacing human beings. Jesus Christ. I want to answer that things are
- 44:00kind of improved, dru, but I find myself sometimes really discouraged. Tell
- 44:07me your perspective, man, all right, good news and bad news here.
- 44:10I think the bad news is that these kinds of delusions, paranoid delusions,
- 44:17conspiracies, bits of propaganda, these types of things have always existed,
- 44:22and I think that they am a sociology type guy like that stuff. So
- 44:28this idea that I've really taken to is something a lot of sociologists prop up
- 44:31that when there's a lot of change, especially rapid change in a society,
- 44:36whether it's technological, cultural, whatever, people kind of start grasping their reaching
- 44:42for their horoscopes and crystals, as Carl Sagan said, And I think we've
- 44:45seen a lot of especially technological change happen in I mean even just in my
- 44:52lifetime. People have always done this, and they're going to continue to do
- 44:55this. That's the bad news. I think the good news is that eventually
- 45:00people get used to something, They get used to things, you know,
- 45:05people get used to the Internet being around. People get used to America not
- 45:08being as white as it used to be or as Christian as it used to
- 45:13be, and so a lot of these paranoid delusions just don't have the same
- 45:16fuel of the kind of momentary reactionary paranoia. Of course, people will move
- 45:22on to other things. There will be conspiracies and all this nonsense in the
- 45:27future, but the ones that we have right now, you know, the
- 45:30epic times, they're going to fail someday and we can at least sit by
- 45:36and think, you know what, hopefully that's within my lifetime, and I'll
- 45:40get my popcorn ready I've been saying that about Fox News, and they are
- 45:45still right on the front, right at the top, making a shit ton
- 45:49of money. And I am waiting. I'm waiting for the time when the
- 45:52you know, the Jenga house falls, crashes to the ground. But it
- 45:57is hard to remain optimistic, especially knowing that the Internet, which is such
- 46:00an amazing resource, is also it really encourages information silos. So if I
- 46:07do have a terrible idea, I can instantly find validation. I can find
- 46:13misinformation that validates whatever I want to believe, and then a community of like
- 46:19minded people that validates me even further, and then I don't leave and I
- 46:23throw stones at everybody else. I'm not one of those guys who hates technology.
- 46:28I actually think it's amazing. But of course, when we see the
- 46:31good, we also have to acknowledge the dark side. I don't know,
- 46:36I mean, the Internet is a wonderful thing. The Internet is a terrible
- 46:38thing. That kind of thing, right, Yeah, definitely. You can
- 46:44use any tool for good or bad purposes, and every tool will be used
- 46:50for both. Every technology that's ever been invented has been used to destroy and
- 46:53to build up. I have to say that I am happy that I'm gonna
- 46:59get sappy here or Seth, you know, as someone who really values a
- 47:05certain online community of like minded people that are not in the majority, I'm
- 47:09really glad that there are some people yourself, especially included, that have been
- 47:16here for a minute doing this consistently, you know, not giving in to
- 47:22just the grift, the clickbait. I'm sure that you could blow up in
- 47:25a second if you decided to, you know, pad your pockets with some
- 47:30bullshit product or buy into some kind of alien conspiracy or something like that,
- 47:36because people like that stuff. It's sexy, but you haven't done it.
- 47:38And for me personally, as someone who started after you did, that gives
- 47:43me a lot of hope. And I hope that I can be that I
- 47:46can be somebody else's Seth and they will do a much better job than I
- 47:51I could either ever hope to do in the future. That's terrifying, you
- 47:53know, me as a role model, It's just a terrifying thing. Drew.
- 47:57I'm just saying, Yeah, I think the one thing that I'm I'm
- 48:00most proud of is that this community remains focused on the prize. You know,
- 48:09we remain focused on the work I'm going to direct everybody to go and
- 48:14subscribe genetically modified skeptic what's being worked on right now? Like, if I
- 48:19send everybody over there, what are they going to see next? Yeah,
- 48:22So, depending on when you put this out, either a video coming up
- 48:25or a video that's very recent about basically ideas that ancient Christians had about sex.
- 48:35Did you know that there were early Christian church fathers who you know the
- 48:39verse that talks about if if a piece of your body caused you to sin,
- 48:45you should cut it off. There's a certain part of the body that
- 48:50made a lot of men sin, and apparently there were some very influential Christian
- 48:54men that really possibly did cut it off. In fact, the Council of
- 48:58Nicea had to out law that practice. So I was always like, if
- 49:02I write, I offend me cut it out. But I never I wasn't
- 49:07ever thinking about that. Let's be let's be real, seth. How many
- 49:10times has your right eye made you send versus something else? Well, I
- 49:14don't know. I mean, if I'm out looking and lusting or something.
- 49:16I mean that sin can be visual, but I hadn't really thought about,
- 49:22you know, an amputation below the waist. And now I'm tremendously horrified.
- 49:25So now I'm gonna have to go watch the video when it comes out.
- 49:30I will make sure everybody has a link to your channel in the description box.
- 49:34I appreciate the conversation. It's nice to finally hang out and talk like
- 49:37real people. I'm sure we'll bump any into each other on the road out
- 49:40there, and if there's anything we can do to support your work, just
- 49:45let us know. Okay, absolutely, Thanks Seth. It's it's been a
- 49:47pleasure. Follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter for a complete archive of
- 49:52podcasts and videos, products like mugs and t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logo,
- 49:58links to Atheist page in resources, and details on upcoming free thought events
- 50:02and conventions. Log onto our website, The Thinkingatheist dot com.