Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / The Tax Code Exposed: Stock Options
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep Dive. Today we're jumping into
- 0:02something absolutely critical if you're actively trading US
- 0:06options. That's right, we're talking
- 0:07taxes. Exactly.
- 0:09And look, our sources are really clear on this.
- 0:12For an active trader, understanding the tax side isn't
- 0:15just paperwork you do later. It's, well, it's fundamental to
- 0:18actually being profitable. It really is.
- 0:20It's an integrated part of your strategy, or at least it should
- 0:23be. We're going to focus especially
- 0:25on how the IRS looks at things when you're selling premium like
- 0:29calls and puts. Because getting this wrong can
- 0:32seriously eat into your returns, right?
- 0:34No, absolutely. Weeks, maybe months of good
- 0:38trading can be undermined if you don't grasp these nuances.
- 0:40So yeah, let's make sure that doesn't happen to you.
- 0:43OK, let's start with the basics. The foundation capital gains.
- 0:47Before options even enter the picture, we need to get this
- 0:50part straight. How does the holding period work
- 0:53and why is like one single day so important?
- 0:56It's kind of a sharp dividing line, isn't it?
- 0:58The IRS is very precise here. Your holding period starts the
- 1:01day after you acquire the asset, not the day of the day after,
- 1:05and it ends on the day you sell it.
- 1:06Now, if you hold that asset for one year or less, so 365 days or
- 1:12fewer, any gain or loss is short term.
- 1:15And short term means taxed like regular income.
- 1:19Exactly. At your ordinary income tax
- 1:21rate, you know that could be anywhere from 10% up to 37%
- 1:24depending on your tax bracket for the year.
- 1:26Pretty steep. Yeah, that's high.
- 1:28But if you managed to hold that asset for more than one year,
- 1:31meaning 366 days or more, then it becomes long term.
- 1:35And that's where the big advantage kicks in.
- 1:37That's the preferential treatment.
- 1:38Long term capital gains are taxed at much lower rates, 0
- 1:41percent, 15% or 20%, again depending on your overall income
- 1:46level. That difference between, say,
- 1:4737% and 20%, that's a massive incentive to hold on just one
- 1:52more day sometimes. Huge incentive, especially for
- 1:55people in higher income brackets.
- 1:56It can make a world of difference to your net profit.
- 1:58OK, but trading doesn't always mean profits.
- 2:00What if you net everything out for the year, all your buys and
- 2:03sells, and you actually end up with a loss?
- 2:05Yes, that brings us to a really important rule, the capital loss
- 2:10limitation. If your total capital losses are
- 2:12more than your total capital gains, you hit a ceiling on how
- 2:16much you can deduct against your other income.
- 2:18Other income like salary. Exactly like your salary, wages,
- 2:22that sort of thing. You can only deduct a maximum of
- 2:25$3000 of that net capital loss against your ordinary income in
- 2:30any single tax year. Only 3000.
- 2:32So if I have a really bad year and lose say $20,000 trading
- 2:36stocks, I can only use $3000 of that loss to reduce my taxable
- 2:41salary income that year. That's precisely right.
- 2:43The remaining $17,000 isn't lost forever, though.
- 2:46It gets carried forward. Carried.
- 2:48Forward. Yeah, you carried forward a
- 2:50future tax years indefinitely actually until you can use it to
- 2:53to offset future capital gains. But you can only use that $3000
- 2:56per year against ordinary income.
- 2:58That's a pretty tough limitation for someone just starting out or
- 3:01having a rough patch it. Is it's a structural reality you
- 3:03have to plan around? Yeah.
- 3:04And it really sets the stage for why understanding the options
- 3:08rules is so vital, especially for sellers.
- 3:10Right, this is where it gets, well, maybe a bit tricky for the
- 3:14income focus trader. Let's say I sell cash secured
- 3:18put or maybe a covered call and the option either expires
- 3:22worthless or I decide to close it out early for a profit.
- 3:26How's the IRS treat that premium I collected?
- 3:29OK. This is fundamental.
- 3:30There's a universal rule for closing or expiring short
- 3:33options. Yeah.
- 3:34And it's, well it's not always what people expect.
- 3:37Any gain or loss you realize from a short option when you
- 3:39wrote that you either close out by buying it back or that just
- 3:42expires worthless is always treated as a short term capital
- 3:46gain or loss. Wait, always short term?
- 3:48What if I wrote, say, a late PS call?
- 3:50You know, one that doesn't expire for two years and maybe I
- 3:52close it after 18 months for a profit.
- 3:54That's still short term. Yes, still short term.
- 3:56But why? I held the position open for
- 3:58over a year. The IRS sees it differently.
- 4:01Their rationale is that when you write an option, you're not
- 4:04really holding a capital asset in the traditional sense.
- 4:08You're taking on an obligation. An obligation to buy or sell
- 4:10stock later, right? And when that obligation is
- 4:13extinguished, either because you buy it back or it expires, the
- 4:17gainer loss is realized then. And the rule just says that
- 4:22realization is always short term.
- 4:23It doesn't matter how long the option was open.
- 4:26So that premium income gets taxed at my highest marginal
- 4:29rate. That's a significant tax drag
- 4:31for premium sellers. It's a major structural
- 4:34inefficiency from a tax perspective.
- 4:36If your goal is generating income through selling premium,
- 4:39you're constantly fighting that short term tax rate.
- 4:41Unless. Unless assignment happens.
- 4:43Exactly. That brings us to the third
- 4:45possibility assignment. And this is where the IRS logic,
- 4:49it's, let's say, counterintuitive, but actually
- 4:51helpful for the taxpayer. OK, so assignment, getting
- 4:54exercise on a short put or called away on a covered call.
- 4:57What's the core principle here? The absolute key principle is
- 5:01assignment itself is not an immediate taxable event.
- 5:04Not taxable right away. Nope, you don't calculate a gain
- 5:07or loss on the option at the moment of assignment.
- 5:10Instead, it's treated as a basis adjustment event.
- 5:12Basis adjustment meaning. Meaning the option transaction
- 5:15basically disappears and gets merged into the resulting stock
- 5:19transaction. The tax impact is deferred until
- 5:22you eventually sell the stock involved.
- 5:24OK, that sounds important, but maybe a bit abstract.
- 5:26Let's walk through the 2 main scenarios with some numbers.
- 5:29Good idea. Let's start with scenario 1.
- 5:32You sold a cash secured put and oh, the stock price drop and you
- 5:36get assigned, you're forced to buy 100 shares, right?
- 5:39OK. Remember that premium you
- 5:40collected when you first sold the put?
- 5:42Yeah, let's say I got $300.00 for it.
- 5:44Perfect. And let's say the strike price
- 5:46was $150.00, so you have to pay $15,000 for those 100 shares at
- 5:50assignment. That $300 premium you received,
- 5:53it's used to reduce your cost basis in the stock you just
- 5:57bought to your actual tax basis isn't $15,000, it's $15,000
- 6:02minus the $300 premium, So $14,700.
- 6:06That's your official starting point for calculating gain or
- 6:09loss when you eventually sell those shares.
- 6:12OK, so the premium effectively makes the stock cheaper for tax
- 6:15purposes, and the tax event only happens way later when I sell
- 6:18the stock? Precisely, and the holding
- 6:21period for that stock begins the day after assignment.
- 6:23Got it. Now scenario 2.
- 6:26I own stock. I sell a covered call against
- 6:28it. The stock price rallies and I
- 6:30get assigned. I'm forced to sell my shares.
- 6:32OK. Similar logic, but kind of in
- 6:35reverse. Let's say this strike was
- 6:37$45.00. So you're selling 100 shares for
- 6:39$45,000, and let's say you collected a $500 premium for
- 6:43selling that call, right? That $500 premium is added to
- 6:46the strike price to calculate your total sales proceeds.
- 6:49It's like you sold the stock for a bit more than just the strike.
- 6:52So my proceeds aren't $45,000, they're $45,000 plus the $500
- 6:56premium. Exactly.
- 6:58Your adjusted sales proceeds for tax purposes are $45,500.
- 7:02That's the number you use to calculate your gain or loss
- 7:04against your original cost basis in the stock.
- 7:06And the character of that gain or loss, short term or long
- 7:09term, what determines that? Is it how long the option was
- 7:11open? No, crucially, it's not about
- 7:13the options holding period here either.
- 7:15It depends entirely on the holding period of the underlying
- 7:17stock you were forced to sell. So if I held that stock for say
- 7:20five years before selling the call and getting assigned?
- 7:23Then the resulting gain or loss on that 45,000 to $500 sale is
- 7:28long term benefiting from those lower rates.
- 7:31The option Premium essentially inherits the tax character of
- 7:34the stock transaction it gets merged into.
- 7:36That's a huge benefit assignment.
- 7:38Basically converts what would have been short term premium
- 7:41income into something deferred or potentially even long term
- 7:44gain. It's a fundamental shift in the
- 7:46tax treatment, but as we'll discuss, it's often missed if
- 7:49you're not careful. OK, so we've established that
- 7:51the always short term rule for closing or expiring options is a
- 7:55big hurdle for income traders, but assignment offers a way
- 7:58around it by merging with the stock.
- 8:00Is there any other way for really active traders to get
- 8:03relief from high short term gain taxes without relying solely on
- 8:07assignment? Yes, there is.
- 8:08And this is where things get, well, quite advantageous if you
- 8:11trade specific products. We need to talk about Section
- 8:131256 contracts. Section 1256.
- 8:16OK, what falls under that? This generally applies to
- 8:19regulated futures contracts, foreign currency contracts and
- 8:22importantly for our audience, certain options.
- 8:25Specifically options on broad based stock indexes.
- 8:28Broad based indexes like the S&P 500.
- 8:31Exactly. Options on the S&P 500 index
- 8:33itself, the SBX or the NASDAQ 100 index, NDX, or even the VIX
- 8:37index. But not options on the ETF's
- 8:40that track these indexes like SPY or QQQ.
- 8:43Hold on. So if I trade options on SPY,
- 8:45the S&P 500 ETF, that's just a regular equity option subject to
- 8:49the normal rules we discussed, correct?
- 8:51Normal rules apply, yeah. Short term if closed or expired,
- 8:54Basis adjustment on assignment. But if I trade options on SPX,
- 8:57the actual index, even though it tracks the same thing, the tax
- 9:00treatment is completely different.
- 9:01Profoundly different SPX options are Section 1256 contracts, and
- 9:06the big, big advantage is the 6040 rule. 6040 What does that
- 9:09mean? It means that regardless, and I
- 9:12mean regardless of how long you hold the position, even if it's
- 9:15just for 5 minutes in a day trade.
- 9:16Wow. Any capital gain or loss you
- 9:18realize is automatically treated as 60% long term and 40% short
- 9:23term. Automatically just like that.
- 9:24Just like that, it's a blended rate built right into the tax
- 9:27code for these specific contracts.
- 9:29It seems incredibly favorable. Why does the IRS do that?
- 9:32Well, the history goes back to futures markets and trying to
- 9:34simplify taxing these highly leveraged, often very short term
- 9:38instruments. They basically decided on this
- 9:40fixed blend as a compromise. Yeah, but for an active options
- 9:43trader today, it's a huge tax break compared to trading
- 9:46standard equity options. Let's put numbers on that same
- 9:49scenario as before. A top bracket trader, maybe 37%
- 9:52ordinary rate, 20% long term rate.
- 9:54They make $10,000 profit. Closing out an SPY option that's
- 9:58short term so tax is $3700. Right, correct $3700 tax.
- 10:02Now what if they made that exact same $10,000 profit trading an
- 10:06SPX option, closing it out just as quickly?
- 10:08OK, apply the 6040 rule. 60% of the $10,000 gain, which is $6000
- 10:13is taxed at the long term rate of 20%.
- 10:15That's $1200 tax. OK, the other 40%, which is
- 10:18$4000 is taxed at the short term rate of 37%.
- 10:22That's $4480 tax, right? Add those together, $1200 + 4080
- 10:27dollars gives you a total tax of 2680.
- 10:30Dollars. So $2680 on the SPX gain versus
- 10:33$3700 on the SP Y gain. That's over $1000 saved on the
- 10:37exact same $10,000 profit just by trading the index option
- 10:40instead of the ETF option. Precisely.
- 10:42Your effective blended tax rate drops significantly, down to
- 10:46about 26.8% of this example instead of the full 37%.
- 10:50It's a massive difference if you trade frequently.
- 10:53And there's another benefit to Section 1256 too.
- 10:55Isn't there something about wash sales?
- 10:57Ah. Yes, another huge advantage
- 10:59Section. Well, 56 contracts are
- 11:01explicitly exempt from the wash sale rule.
- 11:04Which normally stops you taking a loss if you buy back the same
- 11:07thing too soon. Exactly.
- 11:08The wash sale rule usually disallows a loss deduction if
- 11:11you acquire substantially identical securities within 30
- 11:14days before or after the sale that generated the loss.
- 11:18But with 1256 contracts like SPX options, that rule just doesn't
- 11:22apply. So you can take a loss on an SPX
- 11:24position and immediately re establish a similar position
- 11:27without having that loss disallowed.
- 11:29Correct. It gives you much more
- 11:30flexibility for tax loss harvesting and risk management
- 11:32throughout the year. OK, so the rules are complex.
- 11:34We have the always short term rule, the basis adjustments on
- 11:37assignment, the 6040 rule for index options.
- 11:40When tax time comes, how much help do we get from our broker?
- 11:43Can we just trust the form 1099-B they send?
- 11:46That would be nice, wouldn't it? But unfortunately, no, you
- 11:50absolutely cannot blindly trust the 1099 mil for options,
- 11:54especially when assignments are involved.
- 11:55Really. Why not?
- 11:57They track the trades. They track the trades, yes, but
- 12:00the reporting systems often fail, I'd say usually fail to
- 12:04correctly apply the basis adjustment rules for assignments
- 12:08that we just discussed. So in that put assignment
- 12:10example where my ability should be $14,700, what will the broker
- 12:14likely report? The broker will almost certainly
- 12:17report your cost basis as just the $15,000 strike price
- 12:21payment, completely ignoring the $300 premium you received that
- 12:24should have reduced it. And if they report my cost basis
- 12:26is too high? Then, when you eventually sell
- 12:28those shares, your calculated gain will look $300 bigger than
- 12:32it really is, or your loss will look $300 smaller.
- 12:35You'll end up overpaying your taxes.
- 12:37And for the covered call assignment where my proceeds
- 12:39should be $45,500. Similarly, the broker might just
- 12:43report the $45,000 strike price proceeds and ignore the $500
- 12:48premium that should have been added.
- 12:49In that case, your reported game would look too small, which
- 12:52sounds good, but it's technically incorrect reporting.
- 12:55So the numbers on the 1099 B can be wrong in either direction
- 12:58depending on the assignment type, yes.
- 13:01And the crucial point is the IRS puts the legal responsibility
- 13:05squarely on you, the taxpayer, to report the correct numbers
- 13:10regardless of what the 1099-B says.
- 13:12OK, so if the 1099 D is likely wrong for assignments, how do I
- 13:16fix it on my tax return? You have to make manual
- 13:18adjustments using Form 8949. This is the form where you list
- 13:22out all your capital asset sales before they flow on the Schedule
- 13:25D. 48949. Yes, it has columns specifically
- 13:29for adjustments. You report the incorrect basis
- 13:31or proceeds from the 1099-B and then you use an adjustment code,
- 13:35usually code B for bases reported incorrectly, and enter
- 13:39the correction amount. So I'd manually subtract the put
- 13:42premium from the reported basis or add the call premium to the
- 13:45reported proceeds right there on Form 8949.
- 13:47Exactly right. You have to actively correct the
- 13:50brokers figures to reflect the proper tax treatment of
- 13:53assignments. If you don't make these
- 13:55adjustments, you're filing an incorrect return and you're
- 13:57likely paying the wrong amount of tax.
- 13:59Diligence here is absolutely key.
- 14:01Wow. We've certainly covered a lot
- 14:03today from the basic holding periods, that tough $3000 loss
- 14:07limit, the always short term rule versus the non taxable
- 14:10nature of assignment and then the the big 6040 benefit for
- 14:14index options. It really drives home the need
- 14:17for careful record keeping. It really does.
- 14:19The system rewards that diligence.
- 14:21Just remember the core concepts. If you close a short option or
- 14:25it expires, that's always short term gain or loss.
- 14:28But if you get assigned, the option disappears into the stock
- 14:31transaction and the tax character short term or long
- 14:33term follows the stocks holding period.
- 14:36And if you're trading section 1256 index options, you get that
- 14:39nice 6040 split automatically. OK, for a final thought,
- 14:43something to chew on. We talked early on about that
- 14:45$3000 capital loss limitation, how restrictive it is.
- 14:48Is there an ultimate move some very serious professional
- 14:51traders might make to get around that limitation entirely?
- 14:54Yes, there is a path, but it's a significant commitment.
- 14:58They can pursue what's known as trader tax status, or TTS.
- 15:01Trader tax status? What does that involve?
- 15:03It involves meeting pretty stringent IRS tests regarding
- 15:06the frequency, regularity, and continuity of your trading
- 15:09activity. Basically you have to
- 15:10demonstrate you're running a trading business, not just
- 15:13managing investment. And if you qualify for TTS.
- 15:17You qualify. You then have the option.
- 15:19It's an election you have to make proactively to use Section
- 15:22475 mark to market accounting. Mark to market Section 475.
- 15:27That sounds serious. What does it do?
- 15:28It fundamentally changes everything about how you're
- 15:31trading gains and losses are treated.
- 15:33They stop being capital gains and losses altogether.
- 15:35So they become. They become ordinary income and
- 15:38losses just like business income.
- 15:39Ordinary losses? Wait, does that mean?
- 15:42Yes, that's the huge upside if you elect Section 475 mark to
- 15:46market. The $3000 capital loss
- 15:49limitation completely disappears for your trading activity.
- 15:52If you have a disastrous year and lose, say, $100,000 trading,
- 15:56you could deduct that full $100,000 against your other
- 15:59ordinary income, like a spouse's salary or prior business income
- 16:03in that year. Wow, unlimited loss deduction
- 16:05against ordinary income. That's powerful risk management.
- 16:08It's primarily about catastrophic risk management,
- 16:10yes, but there's a major trade off, of course.
- 16:12There always is. What's the downside?
- 16:14The cost is giving up all preferential tax rates on your
- 16:17gains. Since everything is now ordinary
- 16:20income, even if you held a position for five years, any
- 16:23profit is taxed at your highest ordinary income rate,
- 16:26potentially 37%. You lose the benefit of the zero
- 16:30percent, 15% or 20% long term capital gains rates entirely.
- 16:35So you trade lower tax rates on gains for the ability to deduct
- 16:40unlimited losses. Exactly.
- 16:41It's a strategic choice. You're prioritizing downside
- 16:44protection over optimizing. The tax rate on your winners is
- 16:47generally only considered by very active, potentially highly
- 16:50leveraged traders who see it as a cost of doing business.
- 16:53That's a really interesting high level strategic decision, a true
- 16:56trade off. OK, well, as we always say, this
- 16:59has been an educational analysis based on our sources.
- 17:01It's definitely not investment advice or specific tax advice.
- 17:04Absolutely. The rules are complex and your
- 17:06situation is unique. You should always consult with a
- 17:09qualified tax professional before making any big decisions
- 17:12or elections like Section 475. Couldn't agree more.
- 17:15Thanks for joining us on the Deep Dive.