Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / EVOL X DNV: What will it take to meet UK net zero goals?
Transcript
- 0:04Hello and welcome to today's special edition of Energy Voice
- 0:10Out Loud with DNV. We are celebrating the launch of
- 0:15DNV's Energy Transition Outlook, the fourth such publication
- 0:19focused on the UK's energy system, with some fascinating
- 0:24insights into what will happen in 203020352050 and 2060.
- 0:31I'm here today, delighted actually to be here today with
- 0:35Jack Downey, who's the Head of operations with DNV.
- 0:39He's going to take us through some of the key points that our
- 0:42audience is dying to know about. And then, of course, we're
- 0:46absolutely thrilled that Donna Sutherland, who's head of
- 0:49commercial with Veri, is also here to just talk through some
- 0:53of these points from someone who has seen the energy system and
- 0:58the industry throughout several positions.
- 1:01That gives her some real insight into what we need to do to
- 1:05ensure we keep the lights on. So welcome and thank you both
- 1:08for joining us today on our podcast, which is really
- 1:12exciting. You know what actually, it's
- 1:13been a long time in planning and the DNV energy transition
- 1:18outlook has been out for a little bit.
- 1:20But I kind of think that this is the sort of report that has the
- 1:23sort of thing that you can keep on looking at and, you know,
- 1:27there's real insights into, you know, the current energy
- 1:31industry. And then, of course, we're
- 1:32having lots of changes going on, you know, kind of with a war in
- 1:36Iran, lots of changes going on with a war in Iran, which is
- 1:39impacting outlooks and what we're doing.
- 1:41But before I keep on whittling on, can you tell us, Jack, what
- 1:45are some of the key points in this year's energy transition
- 1:48outlook that you think we are most prescient?
- 1:51Thank you, Erica. I'm delighted to be here today.
- 1:53I guess the key take away from me is that the energy transition
- 1:56is real. When it's happening, it's not
- 1:58happening fast enough and we're clearly not going to meet the
- 2:01government set targets for 20302035 and 2050.
- 2:05As you indicated, there's very good momentum in renewables and
- 2:09electrification and the long term direction is clearly
- 2:12positive. However, it's very clear that
- 2:14without meeting these targets we have a very good ambition.
- 2:16But the ambition alone is not really taken as there we need
- 2:19pace, we need delivery and we need clarity on the whole
- 2:23system. Thinking of the energy system as
- 2:26a whole, how does it actually operate?
- 2:28How do we solve the problems that electrification won't
- 2:31address? I think we'll probably be able
- 2:33to tackle that a little bit as we go on here.
- 2:36So I think maybe one of the key aspects of this report that has
- 2:42become clearer through each of the iterations, but I think it
- 2:45is probably worth people paying attention to this part is under
- 2:49current UK policy, which has focused on electrification,
- 2:54notwithstanding a bit of heating and aviation, with more of which
- 2:57and on. But what we're looking at here
- 3:00is reaching electrification targets, net 0 targets or
- 3:04getting close enough to them. But in order to do that, most
- 3:08people will realize or acknowledge we'll need gas and
- 3:12oil. Certainly, you know, as we make
- 3:15this transition, I think what the energy transition outlook
- 3:18specifically highlights is we can either get it from here or
- 3:23we can get it from there. And you know, there are pluses
- 3:26and minuses to both of those things.
- 3:28Yeah, quite. So.
- 3:29I think that outside of Aberdeen in the public debate, this facts
- 3:33of the demand of the UK are requiring oil and gas for the
- 3:37whole of the transition. 14 billion barrels of oil
- 3:40equivalent will be required to be consumed according to the
- 3:43patterns as we Live Today until 2050.
- 3:46And really policy, as you suggest, will define whether or
- 3:49not that comes from UK supply or entirely from imports.
- 3:54You know, is IT security and resilience, energy security and
- 3:57resilience is, is more important today than it's ever been with
- 4:00the current state of world politics.
- 4:03The solution isn't whether or not we import, whether we will
- 4:07consume it. We have to, that's a fact of
- 4:09life. It's where it comes from.
- 4:11So if we're going to produce it domestically and the
- 4:14capabilities are there, the the reserves are there, but how do
- 4:17we manage it? How do we decarbonise it?
- 4:19How do we align it with the overall decline in demand?
- 4:23But a clear demand in any case. Now, Donna, welcome.
- 4:27Now tell us a little bit about Very Energy and how it's playing
- 4:32a role in delivering this necessary energy transition that
- 4:36we need in the UK. Thanks, Erica.
- 4:38And I just thank you very much for inviting me on to this.
- 4:41So yeah, I'm Donna Sutherland. So I'm Head of Very Energy, our
- 4:46company's wholly owned subsidiary of Inquest, who has
- 4:50the operatorship and Co ownership of the Sullivan
- 4:53terminal Shetland. So Very Energy has been engaging
- 4:56with our Sullivo terminal owners who own the terminal on
- 5:00Shetland. The the Shetland economy and
- 5:03supply chain has been supporting oil and gas sector for five
- 5:06decades. And there's a phenomenal site
- 5:08up, up SVT that has got all of the critical infrastructure and
- 5:13the skills, which I think is the most important aspect for
- 5:18supporting the energy transition.
- 5:20So we've been engaging with the owners to assess non oil and gas
- 5:24related activity. So that's been focused around
- 5:27carbon storage because Verdi was awarded 2 carbon storage
- 5:31licenses. They were very early on, weren't
- 5:33they? Yeah, carbon storage license,
- 5:35which is amazing. So we.
- 5:36Initially had a four, but two were two were returned just
- 5:40because of the technical feasibility of those particular
- 5:43acreage areas were challenging. But the two that varies
- 5:47continuing to progress relates to the Thistle field, which is
- 5:51in the process of being decommissioned.
- 5:53All the whales have now been P, it's just the top side removal
- 5:56and then the Magnus field and the Magnus field is continuing
- 6:00to produce at this point. So that will be one of the sort
- 6:04of last legacy east of Shetland fields to continue to produce
- 6:08through the Southern terminal. But obviously as that decline
- 6:11continues, the energy transition and action has started at so the
- 6:16southern owners are currently installing a new stabilisation
- 6:20facility to right size the terminal and also putting a grid
- 6:24connection in place to significantly reduce the
- 6:26emissions up at Sullivo. So fantastic, you know,
- 6:30opportunities and projects there that are demonstrating
- 6:32transition and action. But cost reduction, emission
- 6:35reduction is just part of the what very seeking to do is take
- 6:40advantage of that fantastic site, it's a Tier 1 Coma site
- 6:44and be able to assess the repurposing of that
- 6:46infrastructure to deliver a scalable E fuels opportunity.
- 6:52Chris Shetland has some of the highest wind capacity factors
- 6:54anywhere in in Europe and the terminal used to process one and
- 6:59a half million barrels. So we've got access to
- 7:02significant quantities of potable water and other critical
- 7:05element to create hydrogen. And the hydrogen would be used
- 7:09as a feedstock for creating low carbon fuels.
- 7:12And they would either be a drop in fuel that you could use
- 7:15directly to in your combustion engine or they'd be used as a
- 7:19feedstock to create fuel somewhere else in Scotland, like
- 7:22at Grangemouth for example. So, yeah, so both those projects
- 7:26are key focus for. Us, I was up at Sullivo last
- 7:31year and you know, the potential is incredible, you know, and to
- 7:34see something that has, you know, been so important to the
- 7:40energy system for decades. Also now looking to the future
- 7:44is kind of exciting. But there probably is a bit of a
- 7:48gap between what we hope to achieve and what is, I don't
- 7:53know, maybe you tell me what what do we need, I think to
- 7:57maybe sort of ensure that, you know, the investment gets
- 8:00focused on those sort of areas along the lines that, you know,
- 8:03we see required in the DMV. Report I think from our E fuels
- 8:07perspective to have taken that in turn 'cause my
- 8:09responsibility, that's my area focus where carbon storage is my
- 8:13colleagues. So one of the biggest factors
- 8:16and, and and sort of barriers to progress has been the energy
- 8:20price. So 80%, seventy to 80% of the
- 8:23levelized cost of your, of your E fuel is, is your energy cost.
- 8:28So a lot of the hard projects you know have not come to
- 8:32fruition, which is disappointing.
- 8:34Those are the hydrogen. Hydrogen allocation.
- 8:36Round allocation, round projects, Yeah, they're very
- 8:38slowly happening indeed. And the target for the hydrogen
- 8:42allocation round one was 250 megawatts.
- 8:45There's only been about 125 megawatts of capacity actually
- 8:49entered into the, into the contracts.
- 8:52HAR 2 hygiene allocation Round 2, the shortlist of 27 projects
- 8:57were announced in April 25. No clarity regarding, you know,
- 9:02the, the, the which projects will actually go forward.
- 9:05And there's been a couple that actually pulled out Scottish
- 9:07Power up in the sort of in Scottish Highland area.
- 9:11They've deemed the challenging, you know, to progress that.
- 9:15So I think for for us, it's very much around the price point.
- 9:18So we've sought to address that. Very was very fortunate, very,
- 9:24very unfortunate to receive 750,000 LB of grant funding from
- 9:30the the net 0 technology centre here in Aberdeen.
- 9:33So that technology centre is being assessing how to
- 9:36transition the energy, oil and gas sector up in in the
- 9:39northeast of Scotland. They've spent five years
- 9:42assessing hydrogen backbone link from Scotland to Germany as well
- 9:46as aspects. So asked them if they would
- 9:50consider looking at how we create place based approach
- 9:54distributed energy systems where we can capitalise on wind
- 9:57resources like up in Shetland and lower that levelized cost
- 10:01through private wire configuration.
- 10:03And that means that you're not then beholding to the grid, you
- 10:06only need small amount of grid capacity, which the site will
- 10:10have once the grid connections in place to ensure you've got
- 10:13pressure and temperatures maintained within the winter
- 10:15liquid system. So we've got that money not to
- 10:18pay for very, but to pay for mathematicians to basically
- 10:22using meteorological data to move the needle.
- 10:27And because the problem is we'll never have national synthetic
- 10:32fuels, E fuels industry if we can't be competitive for
- 10:35imports. Back to your point about do we
- 10:36get it whether it's nationally or do we import it?
- 10:40And the problem with the electricity price in the UK
- 10:42being connected to the grid as well as the challenges and
- 10:46delays on the grid, you know, the cost of that is very
- 10:48expensive relative to other approaches.
- 10:51So we've taken a private wire configuration.
- 10:54So you've got cost certainty on the power that you'll utilise to
- 10:58create the synthetic fuels. And following the first phase of
- 11:02the work that the mathematicians did, we were able to prove that
- 11:05can be competitive with imports. And the reason we went to the
- 11:09Net 0 Technology Centre is because the rest of Scotland,
- 11:11rest of Britain, can benefit from the insights and
- 11:14methodologies that the mathematicians have applied.
- 11:17And we can repeat this across Scotland because there's a huge
- 11:20opportunity to transition the skilled workforce up here using
- 11:24sites like Sullenville all across the country.
- 11:27And that's our certain vision. You know, we're not stopping at
- 11:31Sullenville. We've already been in dialogue
- 11:33with another island not too far from Shetland to look at
- 11:36repeating what we're doing at Sullenville there as well.
- 11:38Amazing. I think examples like very, you
- 11:41know, that Donna is talking about indicate, you know, that
- 11:44there's a great deal of work already going on.
- 11:47And I think maybe what the Middle East conflict has
- 11:52highlighted is, you know, there's been a lot of discussion
- 11:56about the need for the urgency to, you know, focus more on, you
- 12:01know, homegrown energy, you know, get off this fossil fuels,
- 12:05you know, kind of roundabout, I suppose, of, of prices.
- 12:08And, you know, the, the urgency feels like we have to do it more
- 12:12now. DNV says we are doing it.
- 12:15We're not maybe doing it fast enough, but what we are going to
- 12:20do is, you know, going to meet targets.
- 12:23So by 2035, we're not going to be achieving our 60% reduction
- 12:29target, but you know, we'll be getting there.
- 12:31And then 2050 we're almost there.
- 12:34But you know, some of this is, what do you think is holding us
- 12:38back, Jack, you know, from, you know, the targets and what
- 12:43you're seeing in the energy transition outlook?
- 12:45I think the works that Donna and very doing is is really exciting
- 12:48because it really does try to address the the the the main
- 12:52blockers for that progress because it's not electrification
- 12:56that's not progressing. It's progressing very well.
- 12:58It's everything else, the rest of the the the energy vectors
- 13:02that are not progressing. So heating in buildings and
- 13:07transport are two major factors of our energy consumption today
- 13:10which are not addressed in the current policies.
- 13:13So UK is very different to the rest of Europe in that 70
- 13:17something percent of our homes are heated by gas and 50% of our
- 13:22overall emissions come from buildings and transport put
- 13:25together. Electric vehicles are not
- 13:27progressing fast enough. We predict that 50% of Rd.
- 13:31vehicles will be electric by 2035.
- 13:33That's still not really fast enough and still 65% of homes
- 13:37will be heated by gas. So how will we drive that
- 13:41forward? How he's going to pay to change
- 13:44the heating in your home if you can't use a drop in such, you
- 13:47know, changing from natural gas to hydrogen as possible, but
- 13:50that doesn't look as though it's going anywhere.
- 13:52So what are the alternatives? How do you like try the heating
- 13:54in your home? That's a huge blocker.
- 13:56Donna, you were saying that you have moved towards
- 14:00electrification in your your own home.
- 14:02You're kind of like I, I don't mean to say that you're the
- 14:05poster child for the energy transition all the time, but
- 14:08sometimes, you know, you are this kind of highlights, I think
- 14:12what Jack just says, you know, there's so many of us will need
- 14:15to wholesale change our lives. You know, we'll give up the gas
- 14:19boilers and you've got a ground source heat pump and you know,
- 14:23maybe it's not quite as great as maybe it was originally sold and
- 14:27how do we tackle that? I do have solar panels, which I
- 14:29love, have to admit, you know, because in the northeast of
- 14:32Scotland it might be very windy, but we are quite bright, albeit
- 14:36in January we weren't at all. But it's an air source heat pump
- 14:41we've got. And back to the point about the
- 14:43highest costs probably in Europe, certainly we have
- 14:46electricity costs up here and over winter, particularly in
- 14:50January when with that really cold snapping spell, we were 9,
- 14:54£100 a month on our energy costs.
- 14:57And, you know, and then it caught, we got a grant for part
- 15:01of our heat pump, but we still have to repay the rest.
- 15:04And we, we, we have to repay the money for the solar panels.
- 15:07We are able to offset a bit of these costs because you, you can
- 15:11based sell back to the grid now when there's surplus, which is
- 15:14great. But yeah, the, it hasn't been
- 15:17quite the sort of the panacea and you know what I thought it
- 15:21was. So we'll continue to work with
- 15:23it, but disappointing. But I think, you know, the
- 15:25reason why this is important is it's kind of in this report,
- 15:29it's highlighting, you know, that there are, you know, really
- 15:35major challenges to dealing with, you know, the rest of our
- 15:40energy system. I know that can't be
- 15:42electrified. And so you were going to maybe
- 15:46talk it to us a little bit about you know what the ETO is, you
- 15:51know, saying about heating and vehicles and where the where
- 15:57we're going to close that gap that maybe looks now towards
- 16:002060. So starts are really useful and
- 16:02we quote a lot in the in the ETO, but they can be very
- 16:05misleading as well. To just take a side point, last
- 16:08week it was reported that 99% of our electrical demand was
- 16:13supplied by renewables. Completely ignores the fact that
- 16:16only 75%, sorry, only 25% of our energy demand is provided by
- 16:21electric, 75% is provided by fossil fuel.
- 16:25This talk probably winds me up. I mean, and honestly, it's, it's
- 16:30a great achievement. I think, you know, and it
- 16:34demonstrates, I think you know, that again, we're electrifying,
- 16:39you know, we're, we're doing the business, you know, like it's
- 16:42working, but 100% of electricity coming from renewables.
- 16:46Ignore the small part. Yes, absolutely.
- 16:49And, and there's so many products, every, every single
- 16:52product we use in our daily life is somehow made for an oil
- 16:55derivatives. So the change in behaviour from
- 16:57transport to products to how you heat your home, that's huge.
- 17:02And, and, and that has not been discussed in either politics or
- 17:06in public society in the debates that we hear today.
- 17:09It's never talked about behaviour.
- 17:11It's never talked about how we consume.
- 17:13It's only talked about supply. Supply is not really the
- 17:16problem, although it is. Now, Donna, you talk a lot about
- 17:24E fuels and, you know, kind of using, not having to do that
- 17:29major change because there's a way of making liquid fuels
- 17:33closer to net 0. Yeah.
- 17:35So we've been, we've looked at this, I've been working the
- 17:38energy transition space since 2023 when EnQuest launched very
- 17:44and prior to that we were looking at the feasibility and
- 17:47this was at the sort of the peak of hydrogen was going to the,
- 17:50you know, sort of decarbonise the world.
- 17:52But the reality of hydrogen being the smallest molecule in
- 17:55the universe and being really difficult to store and
- 17:58transport. Our focus pivoted towards E
- 18:03fuels and E fuels simply are taking hydrogen in our case
- 18:09because of the wind is taking basically wind and taking a
- 18:12water molecule and splitting that water molecule that into
- 18:15hydrogen and oxygen. That's called green hydrogen.
- 18:18And then if you take it and, and take it through a process with
- 18:23biogenic CO2, it's deemed that that fuel, however you, whatever
- 18:28fuel you create is deemed to be 90% full life cycle reduction in
- 18:32emissions. And it removes the harmful
- 18:35particulates and nor harmful particulates out the atmosphere.
- 18:38So you get an immediate improvement in air quality.
- 18:41So from a respiratory perspective, you know, there's a
- 18:44reduced burden on NHS, for example, with these fuels.
- 18:48So when we've been assessing the 75% of energy that's still
- 18:52consumed from liquid fuel perspective for us and the fact
- 18:56that there's a policy gap currently, we're very focused on
- 19:00what fuel can we create that could support to carbonisation.
- 19:05So as I said, we've got the shipping sector that are looking
- 19:08to procure vessels that are E methanol ready.
- 19:12So that fuel would be E methanol.
- 19:14You can then take that E methanol and you can take it to
- 19:17the last refining phase, which means it's a pure drop in fuel
- 19:21where you don't need to go out and buy a new vessel and modify,
- 19:24you can actually just consume it in its form.
- 19:28And those fuels would either be E diesel or E kerosene.
- 19:33So E kerosene is your aviation fuel.
- 19:36So there's a huge demand for aviation fuel in the UK.
- 19:39In fact, the government have recognized that and they've now
- 19:41got SAF mandate in place. 2% lend out to 25, up to 25 which
- 19:47was last year and then up to 10% by 2030 and then 22% by 2040.
- 19:53So the UK government have already put in legislation and
- 19:56need to decarbonise the aviation sector.
- 19:59They haven't yet addressed shipping because they see that
- 20:03as mandate to address and we know where that went to last
- 20:07year. So there are opportunities and
- 20:10when I think about the 75% liquid fuel that's consumed in
- 20:14the UK. We've got a whole supply chain
- 20:16and value chain that's been set up to extract, store and process
- 20:22and use fossil fuels serving great synthetic equivalents with
- 20:26that have all those emission reduction benefits.
- 20:29You're already addressing significant proportion of the
- 20:33demand side because you don't have to do anything.
- 20:35You don't have to take in a capital decision to make any
- 20:38modification or purchase a new combustion engine that can
- 20:42consume it. And that is really important.
- 20:45But it's the price point is now the question because synthetic
- 20:50fuels are significantly more expensive than fossil.
- 20:53It was sounding a little bit too good to be true, Donna, but
- 20:55there you go. I mean, where there's a will,
- 20:57there's a way. Funnily enough, I was thinking
- 21:00about, you know, what another point of the report to address,
- 21:05which is affordability. The report looks at, you know,
- 21:09because it says that we're going to achieve a lot of this
- 21:13electrification and by 20502060 a lot of that it will be reliant
- 21:19on grid connections, grid connectors, interconnectors, you
- 21:23know, the ones that are currently being built across
- 21:25between Europe. Although the question was asked,
- 21:28well, what happens when you know, the wind isn't blowing,
- 21:32there's a Duncan flout all over Europe.
- 21:34You know, maybe it's a different question altogether.
- 21:37And then, you know, we'll, we'll, we'll have maybe hydrogen
- 21:41as part of this mix. But there's that question.
- 21:45There's so much money needs to be spent on the grid and
- 21:49electrification and EVs and our homes and our whatever.
- 21:53But DNV says that actually Disney's can take this back and
- 21:58celebrate with maybe a bottle of champagne or two.
- 22:00It is affordable. It's not as expensive as, say,
- 22:03for example, the transition from coal to oil and gas.
- 22:08Was I? Guess it does say that the key
- 22:11is I suppose that when you get further down the line and you
- 22:14getting closer to the 2050 then you're getting a lot of
- 22:16efficiencies through the electrification that don't not
- 22:20there today. I think decoupling has been
- 22:22talked a lot talk decoupling a price to be talked a lot in the
- 22:25press lately. So I think that's a step.
- 22:27A lot, yeah. So there's lots of component
- 22:31parts, but and yes, perhaps there's cause for celebration,
- 22:35but there's also cause for reflection.
- 22:37Why is it not going the way it should do?
- 22:40Why we're not meeting targets? So what is it we're going to do
- 22:44in addition to the success that we've already got?
- 22:46Yeah, that will change the the the speed of the transition and
- 22:49then and then bring the costs to the public because the public
- 22:54are certainly not seeing cheaper fuel today.
- 22:56So what is the answer? Well, a broader range of
- 23:01solutions is really important. I think there's lots of
- 23:04influencers to to price. Domestic production is really
- 23:07important. You know, global pricing is
- 23:10global pricing and it may not be possible to set your own, but
- 23:13increasing supply will automatically bring the price
- 23:15down in any case. So I think that's really
- 23:17important. But continuing along all
- 23:19pathways, along all energy vectors, and making enough
- 23:23progress as a system is super important to the pricing.
- 23:27Donna, are you? You know, that's a good starting
- 23:31point. What else do you think we'll
- 23:33need? Picking up on Jack's point about
- 23:35the whole system approach, I think that's not necessarily
- 23:38being followed at the moment. We're seeing a very focus and
- 23:42accelerated delivery of electrification, but that is as
- 23:45we've just discussed only 20 currently 25% of the energy mix
- 23:49in the UK. And I I think closer
- 23:52collaboration between industry and, and government, we've got
- 23:55phenomenal capability. And though the gas sector, we're
- 23:58project delivery ready. We've done this routinely for
- 24:02decades. You know, we send men and women
- 24:05to the bottom of the sea and we do it safely on, on on schedule
- 24:08and on budget. And I think that talent needs to
- 24:10be protected. And I think ensuring that the
- 24:14policy frame from a whole energy system perspective and not just
- 24:18narrowly focused on electrification is critical and
- 24:21looking to address the demand side of the equation and
- 24:24actually looking at that price point because, you know, leaning
- 24:27in on homegrown energy, it's not it seems such an overused
- 24:33phrase, but it isn't the geopolitical context within
- 24:36tells us that we need to have national security through energy
- 24:42security. And I think that of stronger
- 24:45collaboration and working together to deliver success
- 24:48across the country isn't needed. And using the talent and
- 24:51capabilities that exist across the energy sector and creating
- 24:56that collaboration, I think could be a game changer.
- 24:59And we I've got the capability to deliver these and, and narrow
- 25:03the gap. Of course we do.
- 25:04And actually using the talent in the UK, because at the moment,
- 25:08my concern is particularly with the fiscal environment in oil
- 25:11and gas that are engineers live leaving in their droves.
- 25:15Maybe the Middle Eastern conflicts has brought a lot of
- 25:18them back, to be fair, But you know, it's, it's a challenging
- 25:22time. And these are the talents and
- 25:24the expertise it's going to be required to deliver success.
- 25:27You know, one of the things that, you know, we're so focused
- 25:31on, you know, the skills that we have and, you know, the skills
- 25:36that we're worried about losing and, you know, the gap between
- 25:43the energy system we have now and the energy system we're
- 25:47working on in the future. But you know, kind of will that
- 25:49future energy system do anything, you know, for what I
- 25:53guess some people refer to as a just transition.
- 25:57You know, the just transition is, you know, the people who are
- 26:01working in the industry now finding, you know, the roles and
- 26:04the industry as we develop towards the future industry is
- 26:08really important. We were talking about aviation
- 26:10fuel. Of course, there's a concern
- 26:12maybe that what might get people really interested in the energy
- 26:17debate and, you know, the impact of the Middle East conflict on
- 26:23prices is what happens to our holidays when the price of
- 26:27aviation fuel goes up. And then, Donna, you were saying
- 26:29that, you know, we're also maybe concerned about, you know,
- 26:32ensuring kind of continuity with helicopter fuel and and stuff
- 26:36like that. Can you tell us a little bit
- 26:38about, you know, where we are with that?
- 26:40At the moment a lot of countries have adopted a just in time
- 26:44approach where they're only holding a certain amount of
- 26:48capacity in respect of of likes of aviation fuel.
- 26:53In the UK back in the 70s, I think had, I'm probably going
- 26:56to, to get these numbers wrong, but they had about 27 refineries
- 27:00across Britain and then they have 4 and, and with that, with
- 27:05that. That's a huge decline.
- 27:06I didn't realise there were 27. Yeah, I'm.
- 27:08Sure. The number was almost 30.
- 27:10It was significant. And if you, if you think about
- 27:13the UK's energy system, do you know, we had the North Sea that
- 27:16produced oil and gas, it produced all the raw products
- 27:19that we consumed in the UK with all these refineries producing
- 27:23the products that we needed in the country, as well as a gas
- 27:26ask for homes. And then of course, the fuel to,
- 27:29to move us. And with going to a situation
- 27:32that we are here now with the, with the street being being
- 27:36effectively closed and the fact there was a significant
- 27:38proportion of the aviation fuel coming from the Middle East as
- 27:42well as gas LNG as well. You're then in a situation where
- 27:47the argument about extraction, umm, domestically moves from one
- 27:53of one of price, but one of necessity because you can't
- 27:57actually move people good services around the country if
- 28:01you actually can't get the fuel in.
- 28:02And we end up in a situation where we look to other
- 28:06geographies to source our fuel from.
- 28:09And where we are now is with refining capacity for for diesel
- 28:13in the UK. They were closed because of a
- 28:17move in the focus of, I think it was Gordon Brown who pivoted and
- 28:22was champion diesel cars as being, you know, better for the
- 28:26environment, which wasn't actually correct.
- 28:28Diesel because of Gordon Brown, but you know, maybe don't blame
- 28:31him, but you know. But for whatever reason, you
- 28:35know, we actually got rid of our diesel refining capacity and we
- 28:38bought it from other geographies.
- 28:40And the reality is with, with where we are now, we're actually
- 28:43looking at other actors or other areas that we're going to have
- 28:46to source our fuel from. And the sit, the, the reality
- 28:49is, if you, if you don't create it, produce it and create it
- 28:52domestically, you end up beholding to weaponization of
- 28:56energy. And that's, that's the problem.
- 28:58People can't go on their holidays because we, we've not
- 29:00got sufficient enough, you know, capacity stock, you know,
- 29:04available in the UK. We've got only four refineries
- 29:06and they've got, you know, a finite, umm, you know,
- 29:09capability to actually produce the E kerosene that we consume
- 29:13on an annual basis. And we're now facing a real
- 29:16crisis that has not yet been felt in the UK, is my
- 29:18understanding, looking at the, the press.
- 29:20And I think that will, will refocus.
- 29:22And I think domestic production not only allow goods and
- 29:27services to continue, because that's what our GDP is based on.
- 29:30It also provides that that tax take.
- 29:33It's your supply chain, it's your, it's your, you know, your,
- 29:36your income tax. You know, it's wider than just
- 29:38price. It's actually about, you know,
- 29:41movement protection of GDP, but it's also about that, that tax
- 29:45take and, and communities that, that those those infrastructure
- 29:49supports and, and that, you know, it's, it's a hairdressers
- 29:53and the, and the taxi drivers. You know, it goes beyond just us
- 29:56and in the energy sector, it's all the peripheral activity that
- 29:59support what we do in our local community.
- 30:01We're going to just add to that. I mean, it's not just the, the,
- 30:04the, the price of the product themselves and obviously the,
- 30:07the, the ability to supply it. If we accept the notion that
- 30:12just top oil is not really feasible, then you have to
- 30:16consider, well, where am I buying it from and what is the
- 30:18carbon price from that area of production?
- 30:22The the the UK government themselves have published
- 30:25statistics that show that the UK's production is greener than
- 30:29most other regions around except Norway.
- 30:31But we like Norway. Norway Arab, absolutely.
- 30:33Yeah, we apart a lot of gas from Norway too and.
- 30:36Typically 300% higher carbon intensity.
- 30:39If you buy in and ship it to the UK, that's a 300% increase. 100%
- 30:46and three 300%. Thank you.
- 30:50I mean it's it, it kind of feels like you know that we are moving
- 30:55in the right direction, but why are we not getting this do you
- 30:58think or will it just happen? Is it kind of happening without,
- 31:03you know, maybe the voters being aware of it?
- 31:05Is that what the issue is? I think it is happening and
- 31:07we're very clearly demonstrating that that is the case.
- 31:10And hydrogen projects are moving net zero.
- 31:14Humber is is moving, but all very slowly and not at the pace
- 31:17that's required. And that's essentially defined
- 31:20by policy. If policy doesn't help the
- 31:23investors to feel secure to put the money where the project
- 31:27already is scoped and ready to go, then they get nervous and
- 31:31they will choose to with their money elsewhere.
- 31:34Are we entering an environment where investors, well, actually
- 31:39I'm going to answer my own question.
- 31:40We're seeing investors pull out of the UK.
- 31:44We're seeing maybe a lot of investors coming in.
- 31:47Certainly in terms of grid, I know there's a lot of investment
- 31:51going into solar, nuclear, you know, that's good Wind.
- 31:58Offshore wind sometimes worries me a little bit, you know, AR 7,
- 32:04you know, kind of met the target.
- 32:06ARA might do, it's being accelerated, but there's still
- 32:11that feeling that there is a lot that needs to do.
- 32:14And then of course, we're also thinking that floating offshore
- 32:18wind will you know, be the sector that really uses the
- 32:25subsea expertise that we developed right here in the
- 32:29North Sea, those skills that John was talking about.
- 32:33But I mean, I are we seeing enough of that in addition to
- 32:38ensuring we've got energy security and ensuring that we've
- 32:41got the investment coming in there because without the
- 32:43investment, as you say, it's not going to happen.
- 32:45I think my personal view on floating wind is it or why would
- 32:49you spend more to install the float and wind turbine if you've
- 32:54not exhausted all the possibilities for onshore and
- 32:57near shore wind because they're significantly cheaper.
- 33:01So for the same output and the same solution, you're going to
- 33:03spend a lot more money. So I do think that offshore wind
- 33:06floating will take longer to develop, but as long as they're
- 33:10still spending money and still investing in the other parts of
- 33:13that solution, I think that's OK.
- 33:14And how about you, Donna I? Think they haven't yet addressed
- 33:18a liquid fuel strategy in Britain?
- 33:20You know, that doesn't exist at the moment.
- 33:22There seems to be this notion that we're going to electrify
- 33:25everything, including our, I mean, what we're going to do
- 33:28HGVs and, and, and the vessels because you, I mean, aviation
- 33:32and shipping particularly is, you know, it's really, really
- 33:35hard to decarbonise and HGVs and, and agriculture vehicles.
- 33:41Build a house with cement, for example.
- 33:43You can't. Produce cement.
- 33:44So there's there's just so much that's not being yet addressed.
- 33:48So which is why we've supported the Net 0 Technology Center and
- 33:53their drive for this complementary to clean to clean
- 33:57power mission, a clean fuel mission, they've called it and
- 34:00it's, it's a clean fuel mission 2035.
- 34:03So it shows a, you know, a ramp up of, you know, increased
- 34:07capacity and what it's seeking to do is using sort of AGIS
- 34:11mapping tool as identify locations across Scotland.
- 34:14We can repeat what we're doing at SVT effectively.
- 34:16And it directly addresses the gap that DMV have in respect to
- 34:21transport decarbonization. And if the policy is, we know
- 34:26that everything's driven by policy.
- 34:28If that policy gap was addressed and it was a mandate and you
- 34:32were able to drive down, it would bring in the investors
- 34:34into the UK to have confidence that they could invest.
- 34:37But, but back to my point, unless it's competitive with
- 34:41imports, you know, we won't have a domestic industry of synthetic
- 34:45fuels. And that's the problem at the
- 34:47moment. All the ESAF that's brought in
- 34:49or consumed in the UK is imported, you know, and that's
- 34:52not the place we need to be because, you know, we can't have
- 34:56the oil and gas sector. That's predominantly chemical
- 34:58engineers, you know, going off and doing other, other
- 35:01disciplines. There seems to be this notion
- 35:03that we're all going to go off and operate wind farms.
- 35:06But that's, you know, that, well, it is, it's electrical
- 35:09engineering and it's, it's rotating equipment.
- 35:10It isn't chemical engineering. And these are the capabilities
- 35:14that the a liquid fuel strategy would, would, would enable and
- 35:18transition the right way and then create that domestic
- 35:20resilience across the UK. That place based approach and
- 35:24taken an alternative route for wind at the moment, because
- 35:28we're spending an awful lot switching wind farms off in
- 35:30Scotland. So this could this could lessen
- 35:33the burden on the on the transmission network and provide
- 35:36an alternative route for that as well.
- 35:37You refer to interconnectors earlier on.
- 35:39There isn't enough interconnector capacity to take
- 35:44the wind turbine through the cable and connect it to the
- 35:46grid. There isn't enough capacity
- 35:48today. So you've got supply chain
- 35:50issues just on that side of it. So you spend all your money over
- 35:53there and many of money over here and you still can't connect
- 35:56it to the to the grid. Well, clear strategy is not
- 35:59quite I think got no point of transition and and just
- 36:03transition, which is a very overused term in my opinion.
- 36:05I hear you. If we haven't really drilled
- 36:08down into the details of OK, what is the skill set and how
- 36:11can we reuse it. The reason that coal didn't the
- 36:15transition from coal to oil was so expensive because the skills
- 36:18weren't the same. They weren't really there.
- 36:20Now we have got lots of the same skills that are needed, but
- 36:23we're not really driving. OK, well, here's the direct
- 36:27translation here. We're already doing it in DNV
- 36:29actually. We're very proud that we've got
- 36:31engineers from oil and gas with decades of experience there
- 36:34working on East Anglia to wind farm on NZT for BP and for high
- 36:41net on cadence projects. We're very proud of of that
- 36:44experience. But that's something that we
- 36:46have to do ourselves. There's no real strategy.
- 36:48It says OK, here's the direct mapping of 1 to the next.
- 36:51Can you envisage a system or a support that would help
- 36:57companies like DMV or any other companies working in those areas
- 37:01making that transition on their skills that would support that?
- 37:04I'll go back to policy again because without it being an
- 37:10interconnected energy system view of the world, you're not
- 37:14progressing fast enough. Like you said, chemical
- 37:16engineers can't automatically translate over to a Winford
- 37:20farm, but they can translate to alternative fuels.
- 37:23So unless you're progressing all of those and progressing all of
- 37:26those, then people can't find the jobs.
- 37:30They will find the jobs themselves.
- 37:31If you make them exist without addressing that actually, okay,
- 37:36these are all the skills. We have these where they can
- 37:38they can go to, then the gaps will appear and they will leave
- 37:41the basin and they will go somewhere else or they will
- 37:43leave the industry altogether. And that's going to leave us
- 37:46this whole situation where you haven't got skills anymore,
- 37:50they've already gone. So how then do you accelerate
- 37:52the way that you would like to? And I think the problem with
- 37:55that, the fact that there's huge gap at the moment is, is we'll
- 37:58end up in a situation with the strategies imports, and we'll
- 38:01end up in a situation where the geopolitical, you know,
- 38:05instability then creates price shocks, you know, and we could
- 38:09have a serious impact on the GDP of our country because we can't
- 38:12move goods and services. So, you know, we need to really
- 38:16look at this from a whole system perspective, perspective and
- 38:18look at the UK like a project. Because when, when you look at
- 38:22project, you think about the whole system and then you
- 38:25identify you, you frame it and you then assess multiple
- 38:29opportunities to deliver to it. And then you have a skills
- 38:33process, you know, a skills activity that then maps to the,
- 38:37the skills you need to deliver that project.
- 38:39And that hasn't been done in the UK.
- 38:41We've, we've, they've gone down a silent approach of certain
- 38:45technologies like electrification, like hydrogen,
- 38:47like CCS and not look to the whole system.
- 38:49And there's a real risk of, of, of not delivering success here
- 38:54because of the, the approach that's been taken.
- 38:56But there's time, you know, with these type of innovative
- 38:59opportunities, we could drive success.
- 39:02That actually leaves us on a bit of a high note.
- 39:06There's hope and there's time, but we need to take a whole
- 39:09energy system approach and acknowledge that we can't think
- 39:14in silos and we can't invest in silos and policy must get out of
- 39:19silos. I'll maybe, you know, kind of
- 39:21use that as the first summary. Can I just say thanks to Jack
- 39:25Downey, head of operations at DNV and Donna Sutherland, head
- 39:29of commercial at very. Your contributions have been
- 39:32magnificent as always and you have been listening to Energy
- 39:36Voice Out Loud Special Edition with DNV looking at the 4th
- 39:42energy transition outlook for the UK.
- 39:45I've been Erica Ascoland and you've been a great audience.
- 39:48Thanks for tuning in.