Latest / Beyond Mommy Dearest Podcast / The False Prophet: How Cult Leaders and Narcissists Use the Same Psychological Abuse Tactics
Transcript
- 0:00You're listening to the Beyond Mommy Dearest podcast, where we talk about growing up with narcissistic moms, how it shapes your nervous system, your relationships, and your sense of self, and how to heal without shame.
- 0:12I'm your host, Nalani Pearl-Hernandez.
- 0:15This episode is sponsored by The Happy Cannabis, body products designed to help you on your healing journey by supporting your nervous system with every application.
- 0:26Today's conversation is one I've been looking forward to for a long time.
- 0:30After watching Netflix, Trust Me, The False Prophet, I couldn't stop thinking about the striking similarities between cult leaders and narcissistic parents.
- 0:40The manipulation, the coercive control, the gaslighting, the isolation, the way victims slowly lose trust in themselves.
- 0:47Today I'm joined by Dr. Christine Marie, whose courage helped expose one of the most dangerous modern cult leaders, Samuel Beatman.
- 0:55Working alongside law enforcement, she risked her own safety to help rescue women and children trapped in psychological and spiritual abuse.
- 1:04Dr. Christine, I'm so happy that I get to speak to you, not just because I love pink so much and you make me so happy every time I see you, but because of your enormous amounts of strength and your heroism in this huge, huge story that we're going to talk about.
- 1:24So thank you for being here.
- 1:26My pleasure.
- 1:27I'm really happy to be on your podcast.
- 1:30You know, one of the things that we, so we talk about narcissism and narcissism and mothers.
- 1:38And one of the things that I found through my research is that cult leaders very much share some of the same values.
- 1:49attitude, some of the same personality that narcissistic mothers do.
- 1:54And we've had other people on like Mark Vicente when he was talking about NXIVM.
- 2:00At that same time or around then, I was watching Trust Me, False Prophets on Netflix and was blown away by...
- 2:09You're calm by everything.
- 2:13So for those who don't know, and you alluded to it a little bit, before Sam Bateman and the False Prophet, you had your own story in surviving a cult and changing the way you kind of recognize what was happening in Short Creek.
- 2:31So can you talk a little bit about that?
- 2:34Yeah, so I...
- 2:37I was a divorced single mother and I wanted to be the very best Mormon I could be.
- 2:43And I got interested in polygamy because that was one of the higher laws.
- 2:49As you know, the mainstream Mormon church broke off.
- 2:52I mean, the fundamentalists broke off on the mainstream Mormon church over polygamy.
- 2:57So I was open to it.
- 3:00And I...
- 3:02met somebody.
- 3:03I wasn't looking for it.
- 3:05I was just open to it.
- 3:07So I met somebody when I was searching for Mr.
- 3:10Right, who happened to have been a polygamist.
- 3:18And was that good English?
- 3:19Anyway, so...
- 3:24And I got lured into his story and I believed it was true.
- 3:28He had written some documents which I believed were true and I believed was a new prophet.
- 3:37And next thing you know, I'm obeying the prophet at the peril of my life.
- 3:42Wow.
- 3:46What was there or was there a moment that while you were recording this documentary, because a lot of it, my assumption is because it happens to me as I'm doing these podcasts, I get a lot of the trauma kind of rebuilds up for me.
- 4:00And so when did this stop really being a documentary and the documentary that we saw to becoming a rescue mission for all those wonderful women?
- 4:10Well, it didn't start as a documentary.
- 4:12Yeah.
- 4:14It started as a ruse to get evidence.
- 4:25We were working on a different documentary.
- 4:27Okay.
- 4:28Right?
- 4:29About the FLDS.
- 4:31And Sam saw pieces of it because Tova showed him.
- 4:35And then Sam wanted to be in that one.
- 4:37So the more...
- 4:43Sam filmed the more he wanted to film because it, you know, talk about narcissism.
- 4:48Right.
- 4:48It fed into his narcissism.
- 4:51Right.
- 4:52And in fact, I was very much against a documentary on Sam for a long time.
- 4:58And I even have it.
- 4:59I just noticed it in the past couple of weeks that I even have it in some of my,
- 5:06legal documents that I mean, things that I shared with law enforcement, because media was camping outside their house.
- 5:13And my fear was that if this story became big before we had the investigation button down, that he would move away with everybody.
- 5:25And he was gathering passports,
- 5:28And there was a budget for a plane.
- 5:31He's a pilot.
- 5:33Oh, my goodness.
- 5:34And he kept going to Mexico for some reason.
- 5:36So we were afraid that if this became big before he was arrested, that we might lose it.
- 5:44So it was not a documentary and then a rescue mission.
- 5:48It was first and foremost.
- 5:50A rescue mission.
- 5:51Yeah, absolutely.
- 5:54That's amazing.
- 5:56You know, it.
- 5:58Looking back, and for those of you who haven't watched it, you have to watch it, listen to the podcast, and then watch it again, because that's what I'm going to do, to kind of look back at what was going on.
- 6:09And was there ever a point where you thought, oh my goodness, we're going to need to walk away.
- 6:14This is just too dangerous for me and my husband.
- 6:20And it was definitely dangerous.
- 6:25Mm-hmm.
- 6:27The option of walking away is not something that we seriously entertained, but we had times where we couldn't keep going for a while.
- 6:37I had to go in therapy.
- 6:39I also used the FBI special agent as a cry on her shoulder, and I needed to get a lot of support because I just felt that complexity of knowing that they were victims when they didn't know it.
- 6:56Mm-hmm.
- 6:57And knowing that they were going to suffer more when they learned that I'm the one that shed a light on their prophet's crimes to authorities.
- 7:10And he was taken away.
- 7:11The father of their children was taken away because of me.
- 7:15So I just knew the betrayal and the harm that they would feel was caused by me.
- 7:22Didn't know if any of them would ever stop hating me.
- 7:26You know, and I know that this is not a question that's on our list of things, but I, because I follow the girls, I know that you have a close relationship with many of them and they're flourishing.
- 7:42And in fact, it's one of their birthdays today.
- 7:44And it's, it's just such a lovely thing to see the growth.
- 7:48And I, I think that for a lot of people, a lot of women, a lot of men that have been
- 7:55children of narcissistic parents, that thought process of them not understanding that they're in an abusive relationship and people trying to slowly dissect them out of it is probably one of the biggest fears that the opposite parent has.
- 8:13I know for my dad, he never really talked about my mom being like that.
- 8:19And so I think that that feeling that you just said, like, is a very, like,
- 8:26it hits me really deeply because I can see that.
- 8:31You know, I always am amazed by men like Sam Bateman or other cult leaders that believe that they are the prophet or that they proclaim that.
- 8:48So do you think that he really believed the prophet, that he was a prophet?
- 8:52No.
- 8:53Okay.
- 8:54So he knew what he was doing.
- 8:56That is my belief because one of his, one of his themes was that Warren Jeffs was not in prison, that it was a mannequin there, that he actually was this immortal person now.
- 9:12Like he'd gone through this process that we believe in called translation.
- 9:18And that he was kind of immortal person who could speak to him.
- 9:23So he knew that wasn't true.
- 9:25He knew Warren Jeffs wasn't appearing, talking to him.
- 9:28He knew that if Warren Jeffs had actually died, that it would be world news.
- 9:34Every little thing is world news in this town.
- 9:37And if Warren Jeffs had died, he would, everybody would know and there would be a big funeral and he'd be in the cemetery.
- 9:45But no, I don't believe that he knew, I mean that he,
- 9:49believed that he was a prophet.
- 9:52And he just, I believe he was a natural predator from his childhood.
- 9:57He was aggressive as a child.
- 9:59And I believe that he just figured out how he could gain control over the people who believed in him.
- 10:10You know, it was interesting while I was watching the documentary when it first came out, there was this look that he had.
- 10:17There's like this specific look that...
- 10:21people who have been in narcissistic relationships or have been through this kind of cult leader, like brainwashing that he just had, he had that look.
- 10:32Or if one of the girls he believed was misbehaving, there was this look that like just sent chills down my spine because it was the same look that I would get if I was acting like a kid and I was doing something my mom didn't like.
- 10:47And it was interesting.
- 10:48I didn't expect that.
- 10:50watching something like that.
- 10:52I didn't expect it.
- 10:54Yeah, we caught it.
- 10:57So he made me nervous when there was this one time when we were in the greenhouse, which is where Sam was with all of his wives, a two-bedroom house with, you know, like 20 wives and all these children.
- 11:14And he said something, and one of his wives corrected it.
- 11:18Mm-hmm.
- 11:20Said that's not what you said before before you said something rather and I thought oh no Oh, no, she's gonna get reamed Mm-hmm, and I don't know what happened, but I did learn that when we would leave he would His word was rebuke Which means humiliate insult strike.
- 11:43Mm-hmm.
- 11:43He would
- 11:45be, you know, be picking them apart because he wanted to put on this perfect show.
- 11:49And so they would go through, you know, difficult times if they weren't perfect when they were with us.
- 11:56Gosh, that and, you know, every time I do an interview, whether male, female or with a person who survived the cult, that those things ring true when you're dealing with a narcissistic mother.
- 12:09And I think for a lot of
- 12:11people who have narcissistic parents are a narcissistic romantic relationship, are, you know, they're in a cult, to know that their community, the people they can lean on is vastly larger than that person makes it.
- 12:27There's, you know, so many people out there and, you know, when I watched him and if someone is watching him and watching him speak, there are subtle behaviors
- 12:40that would tell them to pay attention to him?
- 12:45What did you see in those behaviors?
- 12:47Like, what did he do specifically?
- 12:50For one thing, he would cut people off while they were talking and tell them what they're supposed to say.
- 12:55Right?
- 12:57You know, I mean, we caught a little bit of that, that made it on the documentary.
- 13:03Now, let me remind you, Toga and I filmed, but we were filming primarily for law enforcement.
- 13:09hoping to catch evidence.
- 13:10And we didn't filter what we filmed.
- 13:13We just gave it all.
- 13:15But in that process, he, I mean, we would sometimes catch him slipping up and we would catch that look.
- 13:26So we didn't know exactly what was going to end up in the final documentary because we just entrusted the footage to a production company and they put it all together and we didn't even see it until two weeks before it came out.
- 13:38So when I say it made it into something, made it into the documentary, it's because we're not the ones that built the story out of the footage.
- 13:47So, yeah, a couple of things did show up in there and where he's, you know, telling people, you know, what to say.
- 13:58But another thing he would do is send people over to our house or they would come on their own because they knew it would please him.
- 14:08have them talk about how much they loved him on camera.
- 14:11You know, Sam was not allowed, Sam did not allow the girls to be vain.
- 14:13They couldn't primp in the mirror for very long, like look at themselves in the mirror.
- 14:17They wouldn't let the children see pictures of themselves on the phone because they would become vain.
- 14:20But when it came to him, you know, you know, he was, you know, he was, you know, he was, you know, he was, you know, he was, you know, he was, you know, he was, you know, he was, you know, he was, you know, he was, you know, he was, you know, he was, you know, he was, you know, he was, you know, he was, you know, he was, you know, he was, you know, he was, you know, he was, you know, he was, you know, he was, you know, he
- 14:36he was having his hair dyed and people, you know, before the, before we filmed him one time, he was getting all primped up and, you know, but this white jacket that they told us was $15,000.
- 14:49And I'm thinking, Oh, that jacket, yeah.
- 14:55You know, and he's eating dinner like,
- 14:58at his birthday or anniversary things, he would be sitting there like a king eating while everybody else is working or singing or serving him, at least for a while.
- 15:10And, I mean, the fact that the whole world revolved around him, he was centered.
- 15:16So there was something going on that let those wives know, you center Sam or you're in trouble.
- 15:24Mm-hmm, mm-hmm.
- 15:27You know, I laugh because I'm going to try to say this as nicely as possible, but Sam is not a good looking guy.
- 15:36Like he's just, he's not.
- 15:40And, you know, I think my husband is incredibly handsome.
- 15:46So I am always shocked when someone like Sam is,
- 15:51And convince someone, and not just one person, he convinced an entire community that he was, you know, the bee's knees.
- 16:02He was like, he's the one.
- 16:05And I don't even know how you would begin to accomplish something like that.
- 16:13Like, sorry, go ahead.
- 16:16I believe it was because...
- 16:21He took over the mantle of the prophet.
- 16:26And it was really his position that they fell for, not him.
- 16:33And once they did, they wanted to see him that way.
- 16:36And, you know, they had confirmation bias.
- 16:39They would see everything that he did as if it was an appropriate thing for a prophet to do.
- 16:44They were prophets' wives or they were prophets.
- 16:47you know, men that stood up for the prophet.
- 16:51So I don't think it was his personality.
- 16:54I do think it was his deceptiveness.
- 16:57And he's confident too.
- 16:59That confidence becomes a sneeze, hang on.
- 17:03No worries.
- 17:06Oh, I think I'm not gonna sneeze.
- 17:10Sorry.
- 17:10No, it's okay.
- 17:12But his confidence,
- 17:14went a long way because as honest people, we don't expect another human being to do something as bold as pretend you are a prophet speaking to God himself.
- 17:30So when we have believed that for generations and we finally meet someone, I mean, many FLDS did say,
- 17:41You know, that's a crock of shit.
- 17:42I mean, they didn't do shit, but you know.
- 17:45Yeah.
- 17:45They were like, would have nothing to do with him.
- 17:48But for the people who opened their minds to the possibility and ended up believing in him, they would then see everything from that lens because they were hungry for certainty.
- 18:03Mm-hmm.
- 18:04Their prophet wasn't communicating with them anymore.
- 18:06Mm-hmm.
- 18:07And they're
- 18:10Sam represented this as a way you can get communications with the current prophet.
- 18:16And so they were just so hungry for that.
- 18:20That makes sense.
- 18:21You know, why...
- 18:24Why do you think that people didn't see the red flags at the same time?
- 18:29Why do you think it took like dribs and drabs for them?
- 18:32Because I saw, you could see when the girls started to kind of come out of it, come out of that haze is what we call it, that narcissistic haze.
- 18:41But some of them didn't come out right away.
- 18:44And I attributed some of it to them being young.
- 18:49But why do you think that,
- 18:52everyone didn't see the red flags at the same time.
- 18:55Well, I think it's because of groupthink.
- 18:58They were in a fishbowl where everybody was monitoring everybody else.
- 19:05And then you have some very smart and college educated women in that group that were mothers saying their testimonies, you know, declaring their beliefs and saying,
- 19:19interpreting coincidences and things that they see happen in their lives like nature.
- 19:27They're giving meaning to random events and using it as data that he's really the real thing.
- 19:34So people are trusting in the words of others.
- 19:39It's called social proof.
- 19:41When you see everybody else doing something, you think it's okay.
- 19:45And I think the fact that they were all together and all confirming the same thing
- 19:51story.
- 19:52It made it hard to say, no, they're all wrong.
- 19:56You know, was there one lie that seemed to kind of unlock that complete obedience from his followers?
- 20:03Like, what was the one thing that, if you just weren't sure, he came with the lie and then that was it?
- 20:10Remember, when he was in front of us, he put on a, you know, he put on a show.
- 20:17Yeah, yeah.
- 20:18But I do know
- 20:20that he required everybody to obey, be obedient.
- 20:26And he also had them doing affirmations, writing affirmations like it was punishment in high school.
- 20:36You know, he'd read over and over, pages and pages and pages.
- 20:40Like, I love Samuel Rappley Bateman.
- 20:43I love Samuel, he is my, I will obey, I will obey father.
- 20:47Call him father, I will obey father, I will obey father.
- 20:49We have to write that morning and night, pages and pages of the same sentence over and over and over.
- 20:57That is...
- 21:00Maddening.
- 21:00I mean, you know, when I went back way back when, since I'm turning 50 next year, way back when I was in grade school, we would get lines when we would do something, we would get in trouble or something was going on and we would say, we can't be led to class or whatever it was.
- 21:16And, you know, we sure as heck weren't late then.
- 21:20We, you know, we listened and we went.
- 21:24So of course, of course, I mean, especially for the girls who were younger, that would absolutely convince them to obey or whatever things that he was asking.
- 21:36Go ahead.
- 21:36Sorry.
- 21:37Well, he would humiliate them if they didn't.
- 21:42And they were all walking on eggshells because they were afraid to get hurt.
- 21:49rebuked in front of the other girls and it would be a very Devastating experience for them.
- 21:55So he had them like a scared Pack of kittens.
- 22:01Mm-hmm and whatever he said they want they wanted to do it The he pressured them to be able to predict what he wanted.
- 22:08So he didn't even have to tell them It was incredibly controlling
- 22:13Gosh, you know, and you mentioned that you're a mother and I'm a mother and I can't imagine who could convince me as a parent to surrender any of my daughters, even on the days that they have the worst attitudes.
- 22:30I wouldn't do it, right?
- 22:31And so how do you think he convinced all of those mothers and fathers to surrender those daughters to him?
- 22:40Like...
- 22:44In Mormon culture, including mainstream church, you start from childhood singing songs like Follow the Prophet, hearing talks in Sunday school and in all the general conference meetings about the importance of following the prophet.
- 23:08And the FLDS were no different.
- 23:12And...
- 23:13There is a belief that if you do not follow the prophet, you will be destroyed.
- 23:21So the key was the amount of faith that they had in him being a prophet.
- 23:30I had that same experience.
- 23:32I was a mother.
- 23:34I was educated and a little, and I believed if I did not do what,
- 23:43my prophet wanted me to do that.
- 23:47I would suffer eternal consequences and he separated me from my children for a while.
- 23:52I didn't give them away or give them up, but he wanted me to.
- 23:57And, you know, so something in me found a workaround on how I could not, how I could, how I could get away with not doing that.
- 24:08I think that because they were, the women were,
- 24:15you know, raised in a patriarchal society, that what they thought was not as important as obeying their husband.
- 24:24I know that Julia did not want any of her girls to go to Sam.
- 24:29And she expressed that, but then she...
- 24:33suffered the consequences as a result of it.
- 24:35And then he started marrying her daughters without her even knowing.
- 24:39So it's more nuanced than it looks.
- 24:42It's not like all of a sudden he said, give me your children.
- 24:45And they said, yes.
- 24:46Right.
- 24:47You know, there were battles and struggles and,
- 24:51Well, and I think that because, you know, FDLS is so, a lot of people don't know much about it.
- 25:01Like what we know about Mormonism often is that people, they're the people who come to the door and they come and do, you know, the prayers with you in your living room.
- 25:12And as people,
- 25:14They don't really know much more to it.
- 25:17And it sounds like, especially in this SEC, in this cult, in this with Sam Bateman and previous, there was really that want to control in order to benefit from that control.
- 25:31And that is really something that is common for narcissistic abuse survivors and daughters and narcissistic mothers, because we're not daughters.
- 25:45We're not, you know, children.
- 25:47We are a pawn in whatever they need next.
- 25:50Right.
- 25:51And, you know, as I watch the women...
- 25:55and with you, you and your strength to get through this and all the women who were in the documentary, I couldn't help but really see a lot of similarities.
- 26:08Did you notice any common psychological patterns among the women who eventually found that strength for them to leave?
- 26:21Well, I found...
- 26:25you know, commitment.
- 26:28Taking a quick break from our podcast to let you know about today's sponsors.
- 26:32Feeling overwhelmed by anxiety?
- 26:34Does it have you overthinking, second-guessing yourself, or constantly on edge?
- 26:39Meet iCare, a 14-day experience designed to help you understand your anxiety patterns and practice simple, evidence-based tools that fit into real life.
- 26:50Each day includes a quick exercise, practical insights, and AI-guided reflection.
- 26:56Start your free three-day trial at iCare.app to discover a different way to work with anxiety, helping you build greater calm and confidence day by day.
- 27:06If perimenopause has your muscles aching, your stress levels climbing, or your nervous system feeling like it's working overtime, check out The Happy Cannabis.
- 27:16Their THC-free, plant-powered CBD body oils, sugar scrubs, and goat milk soaps are designed to support everyday wellness and help you unwind naturally.
- 27:27Use code BMD20 to save 20% on your order and give your body a little extra love.
- 27:33And now back to our episode.
- 27:36Let's think about Gnomes.
- 27:39Gnomes was very passionate and committed.
- 27:42Mm-hmm.
- 27:43Do Sam while she believed in Sam.
- 27:46Yes.
- 27:47And we recognize that.
- 27:48And one of the people who filmed besides Toga was a young woman.
- 27:56She said, you know, if no one would just wake up, she could put all that energy and that passion into something that would really help her life.
- 28:06So we could see it.
- 28:08Yeah.
- 28:08And I think it's the same with a lot of the other young women as well.
- 28:14they, to the degree that they were committed there, they can use that energy and focus and passion on something that will help their lives now.
- 28:27You know, that was what, I'm sorry, go ahead.
- 28:30But as far as psychological patterns, I don't, the only thing is that, that they all were in a situation of coercion and,
- 28:42They were all compelled to comply.
- 28:44That's just a survival brain.
- 28:48You know, it's interesting that you say that about gnomes because when I was watching it, at first I thought she would be the last to leave.
- 28:57I totally thought that because of her, you know, her commitment to him.
- 29:05And it was just, it was very interesting just watching her.
- 29:08It made me uncomfortable because of the things she was doing, but it was very interesting.
- 29:12And then when I...
- 29:15As I've seen her, because she's someone I follow on Instagram, and I'll put this in the show notes so people can see the growth that has happened.
- 29:25She is kicking ass.
- 29:28Excuse my language.
- 29:28She's amazing.
- 29:30I know.
- 29:31I know.
- 29:32She's doing so great.
- 29:33Yeah.
- 29:34And I love the relationship that a lot of the survivors have with you, because I think that for them, you know, you going through something similar, they look at you as, you know, a very, like a motherly figure who has helped lead them to this relationship.
- 29:51this life of still being, you know, believing in what you're believing and still like being faithful and, you know, believing in religion, but also being able to be yourself.
- 30:05And that's huge.
- 30:06I hope so there.
- 30:07Let me point out that there are plenty who still are very angry with me.
- 30:12You know, you would think that when they leave Sam, that they would,
- 30:18leave their anger and be like, I'm free.
- 30:21Oh, thank you, Christine, for going to the FBI and sticking this out.
- 30:24But they have, you know, these thought patterns that were ingrained in them while they were with Sam.
- 30:31So most of the girls are, have a good relationship with, but there are a couple that, you know, I don't either, you know, they're in other states and I don't talk to them or that they're influenced by their sisters who are still...
- 30:48part of the blue house where the followers live or hang out.
- 30:54Are they, and I know this question wasn't on there, I know that there were males that were under Sam.
- 31:00Are those males still, is that still all part of, is it still going or is it, has it kind of disbanded?
- 31:08Because I heard you refer to the blue house.
- 31:12Well, the men that were,
- 31:17shown under him in a chart in the documentary, they're in prison.
- 31:20They're in prison.
- 31:22Oh, good.
- 31:22Okay, good.
- 31:24One of them woke up, and that was Moroni, and he took accountability and went to the FBI.
- 31:33And...
- 31:34And people sometimes question whether he was sincere or not.
- 31:38Maybe he just did it because he knew he was caught.
- 31:41But he, I'm a witness, that he would not take an attorney to that FBI meeting like they were, the FBI was saying, bring an attorney.
- 31:51Wow.
- 31:51And he was saying, I don't want an attorney.
- 31:53I don't even want a deal.
- 31:55I just want to start cleaning up.
- 31:59Mm-hmm.
- 32:00you know, the damage that caused.
- 32:03So I do believe that he was sincere in his trying to be accountable for what he did.
- 32:12The other ones still believe in Sam, but there are other men still who did not commit those crimes who to this day believe in Sam.
- 32:22You know, it's, I want to just a little bit, Roni, was that his name who went to the FBI?
- 32:32Moroni.
- 32:33Moroni, right.
- 32:34Moroni, thank you.
- 32:36He is a example of it's never too late to do the right thing.
- 32:42True.
- 32:43Because, you know, I think for a lot of people,
- 32:48who are stuck in, you know, whatever, some kind of relationship are there, maybe they're a cult leader and they listen to this, whatever it is, it's never too late to do the right thing because you can change the direction of where things are going.
- 33:04I think that's a really, really important thing.
- 33:07Um, you know, one of the things that we often talk about, um, is that people don't leave these kinds of relationships, um,
- 33:20Not because they are becoming stronger.
- 33:22They leave because they finally trust themselves.
- 33:26And so was there a common like turning point when you saw that these women began trusting their own tuition, trusting their tummies, as we say, versus what they were hearing?
- 33:38Well, that would be something known by the foster families.
- 33:45Because when...
- 33:50When the search warrant was executed and there was this big raid, then the young women, I mean, the children were taken by DCFS and put in a group home.
- 34:02In the group home, nobody woke up because the whole group was still together and you had the more passionate, aggressive older girls overseeing the activities of the younger girls and they had so much influence.
- 34:16No one could wake up in that situation.
- 34:19close-knit of a group.
- 34:22It wasn't until they were all separated into foster family homes.
- 34:30So it was getting time away from the group and the pressure and working with the parents of the foster, I mean the foster parents,
- 34:46they're the ones that help them deconstruct as individuals.
- 34:51Now, so yay for them.
- 34:55Now, the older, a little bit older girls like Gnomes and Moretta, they woke up because they went to prison and they didn't have constant...
- 35:14conversations from prison with the blue house, with the people, the blue house means the sailor.
- 35:21So it took gnomes quite a while in prison before she would even speak to a therapist.
- 35:28So she hung on tight.
- 35:31And then Maretta started seeing the light, which is Julia's daughter that went to prison.
- 35:36She started waking up from her fog pretty early.
- 35:42Not immediately, but it was it was that separation.
- 35:46So as long as those people are still living over there or hanging out over there or in constant communication, then it's going to be harder for them to truly wake up.
- 35:59You know, it's, it's often what the way that you're saying it, the way that I'm saying it, the waking up from that haze is really what it is.
- 36:08You know, I know that when I'm like on Friday of last week, I did three podcasts.
- 36:15So it was back to back to back.
- 36:17And I was exhausted by the end of the day because we're talking about really, we're not talking about, you know, light heavy stuff or chisme gossip in Spanish.
- 36:28We're not talking about chisme.
- 36:29We're like, it's heavy.
- 36:31And so by the end of the day, these are really...
- 36:34they're big things.
- 36:35So the haze is there.
- 36:36And so that lifting up that haze stops my automatic reactions, stops me thinking that someone might be being critical of me when they're trying to help.
- 36:47And I think that is really, really important, knowing that you can come out of the haze.
- 36:54And
- 36:57the people who helped each of them, whether they were in prison or they were in a foster home, they're angels.
- 37:07Because it's a lot.
- 37:09It's a lot.
- 37:10And then of course, once they start deconstructing from Sam, then the family's right there.
- 37:16Because when they believe in Sam, they didn't want to be close to their family.
- 37:22They might not have even talked to many family members.
- 37:24But the minute they started deconstructing, they started reaching out and they had a lot of support from the families.
- 37:30That's, you know, I really, I'm really glad that the people who are out have gotten out.
- 37:36And my hope is that this will act as hopefully like a bridge for other people who are still in this to get out.
- 37:46I hope so too.
- 37:48Yeah, you know, it's...
- 37:51You were like a little, you and your husband were like little, like undercover detectives as I watched this.
- 37:57And I was astounded by how well you kept it all together and in, in the face of like
- 38:11I mean, the devil himself, right?
- 38:14And there were moments where, you know, I watched it.
- 38:18I don't know if you did, if when you forgot that you weren't law enforcement, that you weren't just undercover and how much pressure did you feel knowing that all of these women or all of these people who were under this control were depending on you to get this information?
- 38:38I felt tremendous pressure.
- 38:41I felt every single day that it was those girls were at risk of being abused several times a day, every single day.
- 38:53And so I didn't want any grass to grow under my feet.
- 38:58I was in a hurry.
- 38:59And I was quite...
- 39:01I was banging on the door, making the calls, trying to do what I could.
- 39:05I called the FBI long before they officially got involved, but they explained that they couldn't get involved until they had a referral from local law enforcement that showed that there was an interstate crime and that it would be within their jurisdiction.
- 39:21I mean, I was doing what I could.
- 39:24Yeah.
- 39:25And I think for a lot of people, that's what happens.
- 39:28You know, I, I think back to when I, I first understood what was going on in my house and going and trying to talk to people and people saying, that doesn't seem like it really is happening.
- 39:40And, you know, people not believing it and me just basically without screaming, screaming at the top of my lungs saying, can you please just look into it?
- 39:50Yeah.
- 39:50Um,
- 39:51Did Sam ever suspect you two?
- 39:57I don't think so.
- 39:59Well, I mean, there was a moment.
- 40:03Not a very good prophet.
- 40:04Anyway.
- 40:06No, no, he's not.
- 40:09There was a moment.
- 40:12When he brought baby over to see us and I said, oh, this baby's so cute.
- 40:20She looks just like her daddy.
- 40:22And he got offended at the word daddy because they say father.
- 40:26And something about that spooked him.
- 40:28This is early on, very early on.
- 40:32And so then they shunned us for like three months.
- 40:38That's so odd.
- 40:40I mean, that's such a like, it's a normal reaction.
- 40:46Like you just say, that's so odd.
- 40:49I know, I know.
- 40:51So then they came back, and after they came back around, then the trust was great.
- 40:57He told his followers that it was just a test, and then we were back in the swing of things.
- 41:06But when we were shunned, we didn't know the extent of what was going on.
- 41:13And to me, it makes sense that we were shunned because, you know, it might have been,
- 41:21Um, it might've been, there was one baby born that was conceived when a girl was underage.
- 41:29Maybe that was the baby.
- 41:30Maybe I thought of that, but for some reason he got spooked and it was worried.
- 41:35But after that, then he trusted us so much.
- 41:38Like he wouldn't let any men around the women, not even his own followers.
- 41:43He wouldn't let them look at men if they went out.
- 41:47I did a presentation for them one time.
- 41:50on fashion, gentile or outsider fashion, you know, and because they were going to start dressing, they call it dressing down when they went to court and such.
- 42:03I was doing the presentation.
- 42:04One of the things they asked was, are there any hairstyles for long hair?
- 42:08What kind of hairstyle should we do?
- 42:11So I went online to search long hairstyles and on my computer,
- 42:16a picture of a man popped up and Sam was like, get him off the screen.
- 42:21No, no, no.
- 42:21You know, he's all panicking because they saw a man.
- 42:25He was incredibly jealous, but in spite of all this, he said they could be around Tolga because Tolga has no lust.
- 42:35Tolga has no lust.
- 42:37That's so interesting.
- 42:39Well, he does for you, but for no one else.
- 42:43I'm like, I mean,
- 42:44we laughed about that quite a bit.
- 42:47My no less husband.
- 42:49Oh my gosh.
- 42:53That, I mean, he really believed it.
- 42:56He really believed it.
- 42:58Like that man, yuck, gross.
- 43:01Like Jess, I don't know how he pulled it, but okay, like.
- 43:05I know.
- 43:07He said, I trust Toga and Christine more than I trust myself.
- 43:12I think it was pertaining to
- 43:15footage we were taking.
- 43:16You know, and yeah, so
- 43:21He did trust us.
- 43:23And I did not feel guilty about violating his trust.
- 43:26No, I don't think you should.
- 43:28Screw him.
- 43:28I mean, seriously.
- 43:29Of course.
- 43:30Ugh.
- 43:31I mean, I actually enjoyed violating his trust.
- 43:35Good for you.
- 43:36I'm glad.
- 43:37You know, and after everything you witnessed, was there something that still, like, bothers you?
- 43:42Like, when you think back to, you know, spending the time that you did with them.
- 43:47And you're like, oh, that just, you know, it...
- 43:51For me, when I was watching it, and I know I didn't get all the footage, for me was just, and I think this is why Gnome's story, like, so makes me happy, is just that, that blind trust that she had for him, and that, and she was so young, and that blind trust, and I was just like, oh my gosh, and that was hard for me to watch.
- 44:16Was there something that, for you, that was really hard that you... Yeah, yeah.
- 44:21I was very bothered by the way he worked the older women.
- 44:28Like, they had to do physical work, carry stuff into the truck that they were using to go on their picnic and get all the food and get the babies all set up.
- 44:41And, I mean, sometimes other people would help.
- 44:45But seeing the older moms, they just...
- 44:49they were just like treated like servants and having to babysit the babies when Sam was off with the girls doing who knows what, but they were just, I felt like they were mistreated.
- 45:02I mean, of course the girls were mistreated.
- 45:05I also was bothered when different girls, he calls his wives girls, whether they're girls or not, but when different girls or young women or older women
- 45:19would be off in the corner, sad, or looking like they had just been crying.
- 45:26I was always tormented by it, like, what happened?
- 45:33That they're in a crisis right now.
- 45:38That's the empathy that he doesn't have.
- 45:41Yeah.
- 45:42That's what that is, because, you know, I...
- 45:46I was teasing before when I met Esther, your assistant, who also was in the show about how I just cried the entire time.
- 45:57And I said, it's probably perimenopause, but it wasn't.
- 46:00It was just that empathy that I had as I was watching these women, as I was thinking about what you possibly were going through, like the thought process.
- 46:11I just, it,
- 46:14it ripped me apart and I'm like a glutton for punishment when it comes to this stuff because I study cults and true crime and whatnot.
- 46:21And I know that you've spent many years studying cults.
- 46:27What do you think that people misunderstand most about brainwashing?
- 46:32That it's a serious, a series of psychological processes that are explainable.
- 46:38and that anybody can be susceptible to it.
- 46:43We have all these invisible influences and cognitive biases.
- 46:48Mm-hmm.
- 46:48That if we're not aware of them, and it's hard to be aware of all of them, but if we're completely oblivious to them, then we're not going to realize when we're being manipulated.
- 47:00Mm-hmm.
- 47:02And that brings me to my, I think the next question of, can intelligence protect against this and joining a cult or being brainwashed?
- 47:11No, I mean, studies show that cult members tend to be higher in intelligence than the average bear, you know?
- 47:21And then skepticism can help.
- 47:27Questioning can help.
- 47:30But oftentimes people are intelligent, passionate, creative idealists who are honest, looking for a good cause.
- 47:44And in a cult, it doesn't look like a cult to the outside at first.
- 47:51Sometimes, you know, it can look like a movement to do something good.
- 47:55So people are joining a good movement.
- 47:58They now have all these new friends and feeling of belonging.
- 48:02And then that gradually or quickly changes.
- 48:06Mm-hmm.
- 48:07Mm-hmm.
- 48:08You know, and I find that with, I've been watching a couple of these yoga cults because, you know, like I said, I'm a glutton for punishment.
- 48:18So I watch a lot of documentaries on cults and you're right.
- 48:23It's like, even what seems as if it's a good thing, right?
- 48:28Of course, the, what is it?
- 48:30The Manson murders, like that cult.
- 48:32Right.
- 48:33they didn't get involved in it because it was a good cult.
- 48:35But when you look at some of these other things like a yoga cult or there's a new cult, I can't remember where it is, but his followers were about saving the universe or saving the environment.
- 48:49It doesn't have to start that way.
- 48:51And, and I think that for a lot of people, um,
- 48:56and especially those who are religious.
- 48:58So like myself, and I came back to religion after leaving because I felt there was, I thought it was like control.
- 49:07Like, how do you control this person?
- 49:10And is there a difference between, I think we answered the question, between faith and control.
- 49:16And where do you think the lines get crossed for people?
- 49:21Well, in a religious group,
- 49:27you can have one family or one individual interpreted a certain way and live it a certain way.
- 49:36And the other family can be their way of living it and being controlled by it is a cult.
- 49:46So this, in this group, this family can be in a cult, and then this family isn't in the same group.
- 49:54So it's really,
- 49:57it's not just the red flags in a group to see whether it's a cult.
- 50:04It's also, it also has to be compared to your personal disposition and how easily subjugated you are and how willing you are to obey authority.
- 50:17Like most people are, you know, so yeah,
- 50:21the line is crossed when it gets coercive.
- 50:24So if you can be in a religion that it can encourage you to do good things, that's great.
- 50:31You know, it could provide the second family for you.
- 50:34That's great too.
- 50:35That's positive.
- 50:36It's psychologically healthy.
- 50:38But when it goes far into that influence continuum where there's a lot of undue influence and cult control.
- 50:49that's where the line is drawn.
- 50:51Mm-hmm, mm-hmm.
- 50:54You know, one of the things that has happened since this documentary is more recently, there was a trial that you all shared.
- 51:09And I found it really odd that...
- 51:15I found it odd, but not surprising, but also surprising that Sam acted as his own lawyer.
- 51:22I know.
- 51:23It was like, way to hand it in there, buddy.
- 51:26There's no way.
- 51:30Did you ever worry that our work, what has most surprised you about life since he's been arrested and now convicted and now in jail?
- 51:44I think
- 51:45The thing that surprised me the most is that more people haven't left, that they're still hanging on in spite of seeing his flaws and his deceptions in full living color.
- 52:01They're still hanging on.
- 52:02That's a surprising thing.
- 52:04Mm hmm.
- 52:05Mm hmm.
- 52:05Mm hmm.
- 52:07Yeah.
- 52:07You know, I, I akin it to, um, if we're comparing like narcissistic parents to, to Sam Bateman, I akin it to that daughter, that son who keeps going back to the narcissistic parent, like they're going to do the same thing over and over again and they're never going to change.
- 52:28And even when they get called out, some people keep going back to them and, you know,
- 52:35I think that for a lot of the people who will be listening, what I think is really important, because we've spent time on Sam, is this flip side of the survivor and the strength of the survivor.
- 52:49What is one thing that you wish every survivor of this kind of psychological, coercive abuse understood about themselves in order to get them through?
- 53:04The basic...
- 53:06is that you are not what happened to you.
- 53:10What happened to you does not define you.
- 53:15Your identity is up to you.
- 53:18You can continue to build it and craft it and make your life so that there are joys in your future.
- 53:29You can write your happy ending and
- 53:35And I think that, you know, understanding that what happened to you does not make you abnormal.
- 53:45So many people, millions of people have ultimately believed in things that they now look back on and go,
- 53:53what the heck was I thinking?
- 53:55How could I ever believe that?
- 53:57You know, once you come out of the haze, that's a normal thing.
- 54:01So to let go of that self-blame and understand, I mean, I had that too when I came out of my situation.
- 54:10I was like, how did I believe that?
- 54:12How did I fall for that?
- 54:14And I thought that nobody else on the planet Earth would have ever fallen for it.
- 54:20So I wanted to be tested for...
- 54:23mental deficiencies and disabilities because I thought this is not normal, you know?
- 54:29And then I learned that my brain did what any normal brain would do under the extreme and intense coercion and deception that I had experienced.
- 54:47My brain was manipulated and I was still a good person.
- 54:53Mm hmm.
- 54:54I did that.
- 54:56Well, and I think that one of the things like number one, of course, you're a wonderful person.
- 55:02You wouldn't have done all this work that you've done to save all these women.
- 55:05So that's the first thing I hope that, you know, and I will vocalize.
- 55:11I think the second thing is that there's hope for a better future, right?
- 55:16Like I think about myself.
- 55:18If I thought that I would have not ever had this safety, this comfort, the relationship that I had, I probably would have stayed where I was.
- 55:27You have your amazing husband.
- 55:30You have your safety, all of those things and the work that you do.
- 55:34You know, I am incredibly blessed and realize it every day that I open my eyes, not only to be waking up, but also to be where I'm at.
- 55:45So I appreciate you and all you've done.
- 55:49My last question for you is, you have seen humanity change.
- 55:55both at its darkest while doing this work for the FBI undercover and the documentary and at its bravest.
- 56:03What gives you hope today?
- 56:11I am filled with hope when I see women reclaim their power after abuse.
- 56:20Mm-hmm.
- 56:21when they find their voice and tell their story with integrity and without stigma and knowing that they can march into the future with all their own free agency.
- 56:39And I see a lot of that here in this town.
- 56:45It's a very complex town.
- 56:47It's Colorado City.
- 56:50originally known as the home of the FLDS, but now there's only about 3% FLDS.
- 56:56The rest have left the FLDS or they're outsiders.
- 57:00Oh, wow.
- 57:02Yeah, because there were all these evictions that went on and things like that.
- 57:05But a lot of people in different journeys, in different stages in their journey, and I am filled with hope when I see more and more people abandonment
- 57:17their superiority and their narcissism and, and stop judging and just start helping.
- 57:28I love that.
- 57:29What a beautiful way to end this.
- 57:31And I think also I want to end it on our love for pink because we love like, that's how I got Dr. Christine hooked.
- 57:40I said, we will just do a podcast talking about pink.
- 57:43So Dr. Christine, thank you so much for being here.
- 57:47I absolutely loved it.
- 57:49I am
- 57:51I'm filled with life and out to go be just amazing.
- 57:56So I thank you so much for being here.
- 57:59Well, thank you.
- 57:59And after, can you stop recording?
- 58:04Thank you so much for joining us for this incredibly important conversation.
- 58:09If today's episode reminded you of your own experiences, whether a narcissistic parent and abusive partner are another controlling relationship, I want you to remember this.
- 58:20You are not what happened to you.
- 58:22Your past explains your story, but it does not define your future.
- 58:27As Dr. Christine shared so beautifully, manipulation follows predictable psychological patterns.
- 58:34That means if you are manipulated, it doesn't mean you're weak.
- 58:37It means you're human.
- 58:39And just as people can be manipulated, they can also heal too.
- 58:43If this episode encouraged you, please take a moment to subscribe, leave a review, or share it with someone who may still be questioning their own reality.
- 58:52You never know whose life you could change because you shared this conversation.
- 58:57If you're ready to stop letting your narcissistic mother live rent-free in your mind, I'd love to support you.
- 59:03Join our free webinar happening at the end of August.
- 59:06Thank you for listening to the Beyond Mommy Dearest podcast.
- 59:09If this episode resonated with you, please subscribe to the podcast, leave a five-star review and share it with someone who could use a little hope today.
- 59:19To learn more about coaching, upcoming events and our growing community, visit the links in the show notes.
- 59:25Until next time, keep choosing yourself, keep healing and remember you are worthy of love, peace and a life beyond survival.
- 59:34Your skin is a part of your nervous system and taking care of it is essential to overall balance.
- 59:40Our products are specifically formulated to nourish your skin and bring it closer to homeostasis with every use.
- 59:47Start feeling better in your body today with the Happy Cannabis.