Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Think Twice Before Suing Opposing Counsel: Anti-SLAPP Risks and Litigation Strategy
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Think Twice Before Suing Opposing
- 0:06Counsel, Anti -Slap Risk and Litigation Strategy.
- 0:11I'm Lori Krip, Martin Certified Family Sp - family
- 0:14law specialist and litigator who settles most
- 0:17of her cases. I'm delighted to introduce our
- 0:19speakers today. They are Oren Betan, Effie Kogan,
- 0:23and Elaine Chen. Oren Betan is a partner in Buchalter's
- 0:27Los Angeles office, and he is co -chair of the
- 0:29Los Angeles Litigation Department, as well as
- 0:32the firm's fiduciary receivers and trustees.
- 0:36and cannabis and hemp industry groups. He is
- 0:39a trusted advisor in complex commercial litigation,
- 0:43receiverships and regulated industries, having
- 0:46first chaired numerous trials and arbitrations,
- 0:50secured multiple eight -figure results, and successfully
- 0:53argued precedent -setting cases before the California
- 0:56Court of Appeal. and the Ninth Circuit. Oren
- 0:59is widely recognized for his leadership and achievements
- 1:02by the Los Angeles Times and Los Angeles Business
- 1:06Journal, and he serves in prominent roles with
- 1:09several legal and industry organizations. Effie
- 1:12M. Cogan is of counsel at Buchalter. It is a
- 1:16certified appellate specialist by the California
- 1:19State Bar of Legal Specialization, with extensive
- 1:22experience handling appeals before a variety
- 1:25of courts and matters involving land use, real
- 1:28estate, probate, sports law, commercial disputes,
- 1:33products liability, and employment law. In addition
- 1:35to her appellate practice, She litigates complex
- 1:39cases including construction and real estate
- 1:41disputes, nuisance and easement claims, governmental
- 1:45and constitutional law matters, class actions,
- 1:49and commercial and copyright litigation, drawing
- 1:52on her experience representing both municipalities
- 1:55and developers. Len Chang is an attorney in the
- 1:59Los Angeles office of Buchalter and is a member
- 2:01of the firm's litigation practice group. She
- 2:04previously served as a summer associate and law
- 2:07clerk at the Calter and was a production editor
- 2:10and staff editor for the Loyola of Los Angeles
- 2:14International and Comparative Law Review while
- 2:19attending Loyola Law School in Los Angeles. Miss
- 2:23Chang brings a diverse professional background
- 2:25that includes intellectual property and technology
- 2:28experience at Baker McKenzie in Hong Kong, as
- 2:32well as prior experience in finance, consulting,
- 2:35and education. And now let's get started. Thank
- 2:39you, Lori. I like your necklace. What does it
- 2:42say, by the way? It says my Hebrew name, Attara.
- 2:46So if I have amnesia and can read Hebrew, I'll
- 2:49remember part of who I am. I like it very much.
- 2:53That was my grandmother's name, and mine says
- 2:55my name in Hebrew. There we go. Excellent. Well,
- 2:58I'm looking forward to hearing your presentation
- 3:00this morning. Thank you, Laurie. So, you know,
- 3:04I'm very fortunate, you all are very fortunate
- 3:07to have Elaine and Effie here. You know, I was
- 3:12thinking preparing for today's session, it's
- 3:15an interesting interplay between civility and
- 3:20the new requirements by the state bar for us
- 3:22to attest to promising to be civil, that we have
- 3:26been civil, you know, dovetailing that with suing
- 3:31your opposing counsel. I think probably the program
- 3:35title could have been, you know, think three
- 3:38times, four times, five times before suing your
- 3:40opposing counsel because most of the time it's
- 3:45going to result in an anti -slap. Certainly are
- 3:48exceptions to it. So thank you all for joining.
- 3:51If you have any questions along the way, feel
- 3:53free to chime in. You know, we can make this
- 3:56as interactive as possible. I guess the participants,
- 4:02you don't have the ability to speak or be seen,
- 4:06but feel free to interrupt along the way. We're
- 4:07happy to make it interactive. You know, and I
- 4:11think it is for those that are not very experienced
- 4:15with anti -slap motions. I wonder if we could
- 4:20do a quick poll, but it's I think worth taking
- 4:24a step back and talking about what is an anti
- 4:28-SLAP motions, SLAP meaning strategic lawsuit
- 4:32against public participation, an interesting
- 4:36creature of California law that does exist in
- 4:39other states but is really a California specific
- 4:43thing that is meant to dispose of such lawsuits
- 4:48that are meant to chill speech at an early stage
- 4:52in the proceedings. There are some interesting
- 4:57unique aspects to it including that it is effectively
- 5:02a summary judgment in reverse as some of the
- 5:05cases call it because of the manner in which
- 5:10it plays out procedurally and the fact that it
- 5:13is immediately appealable does provide sort of
- 5:19a tactic that I think is pretty often used to
- 5:22delay. adjudication of matter. So, you're the
- 5:26defendant, you get sued, you file an anti -slap,
- 5:29you lose, you then immediately appeal it, it
- 5:32stays the case. The scope of the stay is arguable
- 5:36and you can get into all those things, as I say,
- 5:38the entire matter, just that claim, just that
- 5:42pleading, whatever the case may be. In any event,
- 5:46it does slow things to a halt if you want it
- 5:51to. So we have done a number of them. It's such
- 5:58a malleable tool that can be used in so many
- 6:03different circumstances. State court, there's
- 6:09federal court nuances to the ability to do it.
- 6:13But Effie, tell us a little kind of about. some
- 6:17of your experiences, some of the unique ways
- 6:20that anti -slap motions can be used and adjudicated.
- 6:26Great. Oren's correct. California's anti -slap
- 6:31statute, which is located at CCP 425 .16, is
- 6:37probably the most stringent anti -slap statute
- 6:42there is in any other state. I've had to address
- 6:48anti -slaps in other states and none of them
- 6:51are as defendant friendly as ours is. When the
- 6:59anti -slap statute was first enacted it was construed
- 7:03very narrowly originally by the courts. They
- 7:07thought that it was only supposed to address
- 7:11the paradigmatic. People are out picketing and
- 7:15a developer wants to stop them. Now it applies
- 7:18to all kinds of claims. You don't have to show
- 7:23that it chills speech anymore. All you have to
- 7:26show is that it qualifies under 425 .16e. Either
- 7:32it, you know, conduct occurring in an official
- 7:36proceeding, in a judicial proceeding, in a matter
- 7:40of public interest, and there's case law that
- 7:43explains what each of those things mean. And
- 7:50the beauty of an anti -slap for a defendant is
- 7:56if the plaintiff alleges that conduct is petitioning
- 8:03activity, Then it shifts the burden to the plaintiff
- 8:07to show a prima facie case, that they can make
- 8:12out a prima facie case based on actual admissible
- 8:16evidence, not based on the allegations of their
- 8:21complaint. It now applies to defamation claims
- 8:28because by definition, you sue someone for defamation
- 8:34that arises as petitioning activity, especially
- 8:38if it involves a prior lawsuit. Even though,
- 8:44for example, Civil Code Section 47 is not a bar
- 8:51to a malicious prosecution suit, the Supreme
- 8:54Court has said that if someone sues you for malicious
- 8:58prosecution, you can bring an anti -slap. They're
- 9:03going to have to prove a prima facie case at
- 9:06the inception that they can demonstrate a lack
- 9:11of probable cause. In my experience, that Supreme
- 9:15Court case is Jero versus Lamarche. myself, Harry
- 9:20Chamberlain, and Bob Dado were involved in that
- 9:23case. Since that case was decided, and it was
- 9:27decided at the Supreme Court, no one agreed with
- 9:30us till we got there, I have never seen a malicious
- 9:33prosecution case prevail against an anti -SLAP
- 9:37because plaintiffs are never prepared to address
- 9:41prong two. It applies when... A lawyer represents
- 9:50a client and gets on television and accurately
- 9:53describes the allegations of the complaint. There
- 9:58are cases where lawyers get sued for that. And
- 10:03the courts have said, no, if you're on the news
- 10:07describing the allegations of your case, you're
- 10:11good. And the other beauty of an anti -slap is
- 10:15if a plaintiff is thinking lazily about the allegations
- 10:23of their complaint. And they're not thinking
- 10:26about whether something falls within one of the
- 10:30prongs of the anti -slap. They've given you,
- 10:34as a defendant, a basis for bringing the anti
- 10:39-slap. And the consequences to them are huge.
- 10:45If you as the defendant win, you get your attorney's
- 10:50fees, all of them if you dispose of, if you entirely
- 10:57win, some of them if you partially win. If you're
- 11:02a plaintiff and you're lazy and you think that
- 11:05you can just bury protected activity in a cause
- 11:10of action where the cause of action might otherwise
- 11:14you think survive, you're still going to lose
- 11:17because the Supreme Court in Beryl versus Schnitt
- 11:20has now said an anti -slap motion goes to allegations
- 11:26in a complaint, not just to the cause of action.
- 11:31I was involved in just such a case as that. It's
- 11:35the Crossroads case, Crossroads versus Fannie
- 11:39Mae, and there was The case was a mortgage foreclosure
- 11:45case, which you wouldn't think would be subject
- 11:48to an anti -slap motion, but they alleged in
- 11:52their complaint that our wrongful conduct was
- 11:56failing to provide them with the amount it would
- 12:00be required to... What's the word I'm looking
- 12:05for, Warren? Tender. Yes, to tender in order
- 12:10to cure the deficiency, but what they left out
- 12:14was that they never asked for it, and the only
- 12:20place they asked for it was in a discovery response
- 12:24in bankruptcy proceedings. And as it turned out...
- 12:31trial court disagreed with me and the Court of
- 12:34Appeal disagreed with me and then we went up
- 12:37to the Supreme Court and the Supreme Court remanded
- 12:40at the same time that it remanded Beryl versus
- 12:43Schnitt back and then the Court of Appeal said
- 12:46yeah you're right these allegations go and it
- 12:50significantly narrowed the case. Well I think
- 12:53technically the trial court disagreed with me.
- 12:57and the court of appeal disagreed with me. And
- 13:00then Effie got involved and the Supreme Court
- 13:03agreed with us. So perhaps there's a moral of
- 13:07the story there. Always call me. I'm kidding.
- 13:12And so in that case, these things can arise not
- 13:16necessarily from a claim against a lawyer. but
- 13:20a claim against a party for the acts of a lawyer.
- 13:25So it can go either way in that sense, trying
- 13:30to hold a party liable for what the attorney
- 13:33did within the context of a proceeding. And the
- 13:38overlap with civil code section 47 is very powerful
- 13:44in the context of an anti -SLAPP, the litigation
- 13:47privilege. It can be pre -litigation, it can
- 13:51be during litigation. It is broadly interpreted
- 13:54to protect acts taken within the context of a
- 13:59dispute. Yeah, now there is case law in the anti
- 14:03-SLAPP context that says, um, um, Flatley versus
- 14:10Morrow is the case that's most cited for this,
- 14:13that if conduct is unlawful, as a matter of law,
- 14:19It will not fall within prong one. In flatly
- 14:24versus morrow, it was a letter by an attorney
- 14:26that all the parties agreed was on its face extortionate.
- 14:32The court refused to provide anti -slap protection
- 14:38to that. But A, rarely is conduct considered
- 14:44illegal as a matter of law as it was in that
- 14:48case. And B, there's case law that says that
- 14:52where there's a dispute as to whether the petitioning
- 14:56activity was lawful or not, and that's the vast
- 14:59majority of cases, whether or not it was wrongful
- 15:03is not decided on prong one. You get the benefit
- 15:06of the prong one. We're not sure if it's legal,
- 15:09if it's illegal, it's petitioning activity, we're
- 15:12moving on to prong two. And then at prong two,
- 15:15the plaintiff has to determine. has to prove
- 15:19that the action was wrongful in order to be able
- 15:25to move forward. Should we talk a little bit
- 15:30about how it's different in federal court? Yes.
- 15:33Do you think federal court in in state court
- 15:38you bring an anti -slap discovery estate um on
- 15:45all claims affected by the causes of action to
- 15:50which you're bringing the anti -slap. So, essentially
- 15:56the plaintiff's case stops. When the court rules
- 16:00on the anti -slap, that's an immediately appealable
- 16:03order. In most circumstances, it's going to affect
- 16:07the stay of the entire case. In federal court,
- 16:12it's different. Federal courts don't like anti
- 16:15-slaps that much. In the Ninth Circuit, they
- 16:20recognize that an anti -slap, even though it
- 16:25is also procedural, it has substantive aspects,
- 16:29which means that it is to be applied in the federal
- 16:32courts. But there's a huge but. It does not stay
- 16:38discovery because that's entirely procedural.
- 16:42The 60 -day time limit for bringing an anti -slap
- 16:46does not apply, meaning that you can wait. You
- 16:50can allow discovery to go on and you can bring
- 16:52it as a summary judgment motion later and whether...
- 16:58It is granted or denied. It is not a separately
- 17:02appealable order. It doesn't have the same power
- 17:05in federal court as it does in state court unless
- 17:10it happens to be a what I like to call paradigmatic
- 17:16anti -slap motion. Someone sues you for issuing
- 17:21a cease and desist. letter immediately prior
- 17:25to litigation. Someone sues you for filing a
- 17:29lawsuit against them. Those even in federal court
- 17:34are easily disposed of at an early stage. The
- 17:39last thing I would say as a reminder to everyone
- 17:44and it'll tie into our discussion of the court's
- 17:49new case is plaintiffs often think that they
- 17:55can artfully plead around an anti -slap. And
- 18:01you really can't because most anti -slap motions
- 18:05are accompanied by evidence. So a plaintiff can
- 18:10try to plead around an anti -slap, but if you,
- 18:15as the defendant and the defendant's counsel,
- 18:18Know that really the basis of this is Petitioning
- 18:23activity you are entitled and you should on an
- 18:27anti -slap motion make it an evidentiary motion
- 18:31Attach declarations attach pleadings prove to
- 18:35the court that you've met prong one it's two
- 18:40-thirds of the battle and I would always suggest
- 18:44that you do that and if you don't get past prong
- 18:48one, the court doesn't even go to prong two on
- 18:51the merits. So that's sometimes an easy way for
- 18:56a court to not have to deal with all the facts
- 19:00and the evidence and just simply find that it
- 19:03doesn't arise from protected activity. Therefore,
- 19:06you don't meet prong one, you never get to prong
- 19:09two. And sometimes when cases go up and down,
- 19:13the court of appeal will send it back down. for
- 19:15the trial court to then go to find the affirmative
- 19:20on prong one, deal with prong two, and you still
- 19:22lose. So there's that interplay. The only thing
- 19:28I'd say about federal court too is there's been
- 19:30a lot of debate, right, in the federal courts.
- 19:33Is this procedural? Is this substantive? Are
- 19:36you sort of circumventing rule 56 on summary
- 19:40judgment motions? Does this really belong here?
- 19:43And to Effie's point, federal courts don't really
- 19:46like them, I think, for that reason. So let's
- 19:50turn it over to Elaine, who will tell us about
- 19:54the latest case in this area. And I guess my
- 19:58final point, this can apply to so many things.
- 20:01Effie described a case we had with discovery
- 20:04responses. I've had a case where a lawyer hired
- 20:08a PR company and issued a press release that
- 20:12had false statements in it. So it can be quite
- 20:19broad as far as the acts of your opposing counsel.
- 20:24So Elaine, tell us about the latest developments
- 20:27in the case law. So the latest case that inspired
- 20:31this article and this presentation is Ramirez
- 20:35versus McCormick. The latest entry in a growing
- 20:38line of cases that addresses a recurring phenomenon
- 20:41that both Warren and Effy's spoken about. Dissatisfied
- 20:45litigants that sue counsel for conducts that
- 20:47occur during or after an underlying case. And
- 20:51in that sense, this case, Ramirez versus McCormick,
- 20:55really isn't an outlier. But the newest reaffirmation
- 20:58of a principle in California courts have repeatedly
- 21:01emphasized that the adversarial system protects
- 21:05lawyers from liabilities for doing their job.
- 21:10I'll turn first to a general background of the
- 21:13facts of the case. So Adriana Ramirez was a property
- 21:17manager at the Stockdale Villa Mobile Home Park.
- 21:21After she was terminated, she sued her employer
- 21:24Stockdale and a third party, Harvey Miller, who
- 21:27was the owner of Stockdale, on employment claims.
- 21:31Miller hired attorney Sandra McCormick, the main
- 21:35character of this case. to bring an unlawful
- 21:37detainer action against Ramirez. The parties
- 21:40eventually reached a settlement agreement that
- 21:43resolved the employment and unlawful detainer
- 21:46action. And along with some other terms, the
- 21:49agreement required the dismissal and sealing
- 21:52of the unlawful detainer action and payment of
- 21:55settlement funds to Ramirez through her attorney
- 21:59McCormick. Ramirez was unhappy with McCormick's
- 22:04representation of Miller and sued McCormick claiming
- 22:08a number of things. That McCormick had delayed
- 22:12or refused to seal the unlawful detainer action
- 22:15or records which would have impacted her ability
- 22:19as a property manager to get subsequent employment.
- 22:24That she sent settlement checks to the wrong
- 22:26address and overall interfered with the execution
- 22:30of a written settlement agreement. Unsurprisingly,
- 22:35McCormick moved to strike the complaint under
- 22:38the anti -slap statute, arguing that all of the
- 22:41alleged conduct in the complaint arose out of
- 22:44her representation of her client and the underlying
- 22:47litigation, all of which were protected for tick
- 22:51petitioning activity under the statute. Relying
- 22:54on Thayer versus Cabotect, which actually is
- 22:58a case that Buckalter. assisted with, McCormick
- 23:02invoked the well -established precedent that
- 23:04communications, negotiations, and filings by
- 23:08attorneys in the course of representing clients
- 23:10are shielded from liability and fall squarely
- 23:14in prong one of what the anti -SLAP is designed
- 23:17to protect. So Ramirez opposed McCormick's anti
- 23:22-SLAP motion and hinged her opposition on the
- 23:26idea that The Thayer v. Kapitek case didn't apply
- 23:30because McCormick's alleged conduct occurred
- 23:33after Ramirez had already dismissed her lawsuit.
- 23:38Ramirez reasoned that because her dismissal effectively
- 23:41concluded the lawsuit, McCormick's alleged conduct
- 23:45fell outside the scope of Thayer and the anti
- 23:48-SLAPP statute. The trial court agreed with Ramirez
- 23:52and effectively drew an artificial line after
- 23:56settlement. The trial court relied on two cases,
- 24:00but neither of those two cases involved lawsuits
- 24:04against opposing parties' attorneys, or any attorneys
- 24:07for that matter. So in effect, the trial court
- 24:11took the position that once a settlement agreement
- 24:14is signed, conduct is no longer protected by
- 24:19the anti -SLAPP statute. The good news for all
- 24:23of us is that the Court of Appeal disagreed.
- 24:26And in coming to that conclusion, the Court of
- 24:29Appeal walks through the Thayer case itself.
- 24:32So in Thayer, Thayer and his spouse were potential
- 24:35beneficiaries, and maybe Effie can go into a
- 24:38little bit more. Oh, no, you do it. It's good.
- 24:40Thayer and his spouse were potential beneficiaries
- 24:43of a class action that was prosecuted by the
- 24:47Cabotect law firm. Thayer had wanted more money.
- 24:50accused Capotec of mismanaging the settlement
- 24:53allocation and the firm responded by an anti
- 24:57-slap motion, arguing that the lawsuit attacked
- 25:00its litigation conduct. Court of Appeal there
- 25:03agreed with Capotec and in line with that case,
- 25:08this Court of Appeal for Ramirez versus McCormick
- 25:11found that the Ramirez complaint alleged liability
- 25:14that directly implicated petitioning activity.
- 25:18The court specifically writes that this includes
- 25:21things like directing process servers, communicating
- 25:24with other counsel, negotiating and drafting
- 25:27a settlement agreement, advising clients whether
- 25:31and when to perform according to the terms of
- 25:33the settlement, and drafting requests to dismiss
- 25:37and to seal the unlawful detainer action. So
- 25:41basically everything that McCormick was doing
- 25:44and everything that Ramirez was alleging McCormick
- 25:49was doing was done to help her client petition.
- 25:53Can I interrupt a second? It's worthwhile noting
- 25:57that all of the things that the lawyer was described
- 26:02as doing involved kind of processes of litigation.
- 26:09It's been the law in California for a really
- 26:13long time that Claims for abuse of process are
- 26:19slappable because they involve petitioning activity,
- 26:23because the anti -slap statute doesn't just protect
- 26:27conduct that occurs inside a corpora. It protects
- 26:34everything that has a logical connection or relation
- 26:38to the litigation. Certainly, settling the claim
- 26:43and taking actions necessary to affect it are
- 26:50subject to the anti -SLAP. Go ahead. The Court
- 26:53of Appeal rejected Ramirez and the trial court's
- 26:57distinction that Ramirez was only challenging
- 27:01post -settlement actions for two main reasons.
- 27:05First, that Ramirez's complaint makes factual
- 27:08allegations rooted to times and actions before
- 27:12any settlement was even contemplated or achieved,
- 27:16and that obviously with this litigation between
- 27:20Ramirez and the opposing party's counsel, that
- 27:22the litigation between the two sides is clearly
- 27:24not over. So through the combined force of Thayer's
- 27:30precedent and the policies of the anti -SLAPP
- 27:32statute, the Court of Appeal protected a lawyer's
- 27:35ability to do what's necessary in furtherance
- 27:38of the right of petition. And based on this,
- 27:42the Court of Appeal held that McCormick successfully
- 27:45met prong one of the anti -slab statute. It is
- 27:50important to note that in this case, it echoes
- 27:56the anti -slab statute in the sense that even
- 27:58if a defendant establishes its conduct constitutes
- 28:02petitioning activity, a plaintiff could still
- 28:05make a prima facie case of Prong 2. But here,
- 28:11Ramirez simply didn't do that. Ramirez's opposition
- 28:14relied a lot on argumentative declarations from
- 28:18counsel without any admissible evidence of wrongdoing
- 28:21or a showing of damages, and expressly declined
- 28:26to brief Prong 2, stating that she would only...
- 28:30brief Prom 2 if the court ruled against her on
- 28:33Prom 1. So what does this really all mean for
- 28:38us as litigators? Ramirez confirms that attorneys
- 28:42have broad statutory protection for conduct arising
- 28:45out of their professional duties. This includes
- 28:47settlement communications, post -resolution actions,
- 28:51everything that Effie and Oren had spoken about
- 28:54earlier. The court treated drafting dismissal
- 28:57papers, coordinating sealing, everything as advocacy
- 29:03and that advocacy is protected. So secondly,
- 29:08anti -SLAP remains a powerful early defense tool.
- 29:11If you're accused of interference the way that
- 29:14McCormick was, based on litigation conduct, this
- 29:17case reinforces that you definitely should consider
- 29:21moving to strike under the anti -SLAP statute.
- 29:24And Third, and probably most importantly, if
- 29:29you're doing this on behalf of someone, don't
- 29:32skip analysis on prong two. The anti -slap analysis
- 29:35is two pronged, and if you fail to address one
- 29:38prong effectively, you waive it. Unaddressed
- 29:41issues are deemed forfeited, and requests for
- 29:45supplemental briefing won't necessarily save
- 29:48you. So that's the takeaway from Ramirez versus
- 29:52McCormick. And I think it is important You know,
- 29:56the court noted just because a claim arises from
- 30:03protected activity doesn't mean the anti -slaps
- 30:06automatically granted. You know, if you get to
- 30:09prong two and the plaintiff is able to prove
- 30:12its case, that it has a likelihood of prevailing
- 30:15on the merits, you'll survive. And so I had a
- 30:19case where a claim against you know, lawyer hiring
- 30:25a PR firm issuing a press release post trial,
- 30:29so post trial, but the allegation was the press
- 30:34release had false statements in it. And so, sure,
- 30:39the attorney's hiring of a PR company and issuing
- 30:43a press release relates to the matter, it's protected
- 30:46activity, but once you get to prong two, We were
- 30:51able to prove there are false statements there
- 30:54and we have a likelihood of prevailing so and
- 30:57I slap denied That there's a there's a gloss
- 31:01to that and I'm glad that Warren brought up that
- 31:04case because It is it is true that if a complaint
- 31:13addresses communications that are made in court
- 31:17or pre -litigation or regarding settlement as
- 31:23between parties, that's going to fall within
- 31:2747B. And while I never suggest that anyone shouldn't
- 31:32address prong two, they should, the likelihood
- 31:36is that if your prong one analysis is a 40, is
- 31:42subject, shows that you're, that you can claim
- 31:46the absolute litigation privilege, no prong to
- 31:51analysis is going to help you. In the case of,
- 31:55for example, a press release issued to the press,
- 32:01right, that's not going to be subject to 47B,
- 32:05that's going to be subject to 47D, that privilege,
- 32:11which is a qualified privilege, which means that
- 32:14it is really important. to have a prong to analysis
- 32:20because you're not fighting against an absolute
- 32:24privilege. You're fighting against a qualified
- 32:29privilege. So you want to show as Orrin successfully
- 32:32did that you fall outside the qualified privilege.
- 32:38The other thing I think that Ramirez teaches
- 32:41and I tell this to people all the time is that
- 32:48When you submit evidence on behalf of Prom 1,
- 32:52make sure it's admissible evidence. And when
- 32:55the other side submits evidence purportedly in
- 32:59support of Prom 2, or vice versa if your rules
- 33:04are reversed, make sure your evidence is admissible
- 33:09and each side should actually look at the declarations
- 33:13and make evidentiary objections. Judges, at least
- 33:18in the LA Superior Court, will rule on those
- 33:23evidentiary objections if you make them. And
- 33:27if you don't make them, and then you lose, you've
- 33:31forfeited the objection. Don't want to do that.
- 33:37No. I tell people all the time, don't do that,
- 33:40because it makes it harder on appeal. So we have
- 33:45one question. What was the site for the mortgage
- 33:48case and where can I find the handout? We don't
- 33:51have handouts, but we're happy to give you that
- 33:54site if you want to email one of us or all of
- 33:57us online. Email us and we'll send you the site.
- 34:01It's a published case. It's called Crossroads
- 34:04versus Fannie Mae. Another question. Do pro -per
- 34:12litigants get a pass? Because they are non -lawyers
- 34:17now after they're repeatedly told in writing
- 34:20to drop their suit No, I think that's a no. They
- 34:23don't get a pass You know In the old days, I
- 34:29like to joke back when dinosaurs roamed the face
- 34:32of the planet We used to that'll yeah metal we
- 34:36used to actually meet and confer Before we filed
- 34:40an anti -slap to make it look like we were reasonable
- 34:43and the other side You don't have to meet and
- 34:47confer with the other side. There is no requirement.
- 34:51You simply bring your anti -slap motion. If you
- 34:56win your anti -slap motion, you can ask for attorney's
- 35:01fees. As an aside, some people ask for their
- 35:04attorney's fees in their motion. I generally
- 35:09don't. I wait to bring a follow -on motion in
- 35:13the event. that I win number one because I can't
- 35:19calculate all of my attorney's fees till I'm
- 35:21done with the reply and with oral argument. The
- 35:29only problem you might have with a pro -per is
- 35:34that are they judgment -proof with respect to
- 35:40the attorney's fees and Sometimes anti -slaps
- 35:44can be expensive, especially if there's a lot
- 35:47of evidence involved. In which case is a judge
- 35:52really going to want to give you all of the attorney's
- 35:55fees that you're actually owed? Or do you just
- 36:00want to tell the court how much money you actually
- 36:03spent but ask for a lesser amount to seem reasonable?
- 36:09But those are questions you have with your client.
- 36:12But no, they're not excused. Yeah, they're still
- 36:15bound by all the same rules. So I don't think
- 36:18there's discretion to deny the anti -slap because
- 36:21it's appropriate, but maybe discretion to lower
- 36:24the attorney's fees. That's not really a great
- 36:28grounds either just because it's appropriate
- 36:30or some person who can't afford it. And note...
- 36:34The successful defendant on an anti -slap is
- 36:40entitled to their reasonable attorney's fees.
- 36:44The statute says shall. The court shall award.
- 36:49A successful plaintiff is not entitled to their
- 36:54attorney's fees unless the court finds that the
- 36:58anti -slap motion was essentially frivolous or
- 37:02harassing as defined by CCP 128 .7, the equivalent
- 37:09of, you know, the federal court rule 11 standard.
- 37:14The interesting question which we can answer
- 37:18on that score is... is the statute provided for
- 37:27that before there was a safe harbor provision
- 37:29to 128 .7. I don't know how, I'm not quite sure
- 37:34how under the anti -slap you as a successful
- 37:38plaintiff bring a motion for fees for a frivolous
- 37:42anti -slap when you couldn't safe harbor it.
- 37:46But that's a question for the court for another
- 37:48day. And I have, when opposing, an anti -slap
- 37:54have requested a finding by the trial court that
- 37:59it is a frivolous motion. I'm not sure any judge
- 38:04took me up on that request, but that certainly
- 38:08shortcuts the path to fee recovery for a successful
- 38:15plaintiff defeating an anti -slap. On the meet
- 38:20and confer, it's an, you know, One of our senior
- 38:24partners here, I think his practice is to send
- 38:27a letter before the anti -slap is filed. So I
- 38:33guess going back to general tenants of civility
- 38:38and giving the benefit of the doubt that perhaps
- 38:41the opposing lawyer hasn't flagged the issue
- 38:44and is willing to reasonably consider our position.
- 38:51I guess the only downside there is after you
- 38:55file an anti -slap, the pleading cannot be amended.
- 39:02It is then frozen until the anti -slap is ruled
- 39:06on. Whereas if you send a meet and confer letter,
- 39:10they can, I suppose, try to amend, hopefully
- 39:14amend to remove the offensive claim or allegation.
- 39:21Perhaps the more cynical view is trying artfully
- 39:25plead around the anti -slap somehow. So those
- 39:30are the tenants there. But yeah, once you file
- 39:34the anti -slap, they cannot amend. So even if
- 39:37it's their first, the initial complaint anti
- 39:40-slap file, there's no right to amend to get
- 39:44around it. And by the way, an anti -slap ruling
- 39:48is not like a ruling on a demur. It's not, you
- 39:52know, sustained with leave to amend. If it's
- 39:56granted, that claim or those allegations are
- 40:00gone. They're stricken from the action. Are there
- 40:06other questions? Speaking of attorney's fees,
- 40:10attorneys can't make anti -slap motions in pro
- 40:13-per. and get their attorney's fees must they
- 40:16obtain outside counsel? I don't, I don't, I seem
- 40:23to recall that there was a dispute years ago,
- 40:27there was a conflict in the courts about whether
- 40:32attorney's fees in pro per could get their attorney's
- 40:36fees and I thought but this is a while ago and
- 40:40I haven't shepardized So this is not legal advice.
- 40:43We're not providing any legal advice here. We're
- 40:45not providing legal advice. All right. We're
- 40:46getting lots of legal advice questions. Yeah.
- 40:48All right. But we're not going to be doing that.
- 40:51No. But I think I'll suggest this. Look at a
- 40:56Supreme Court case called Trope versus Katz and
- 41:00jeopardize it. I think that an attorney might
- 41:05be able to get their their attorney's fees, but
- 41:10it depends on what the current state of the law
- 41:14is following Trope versus Katz. That's T -R -O
- 41:17-P -E versus Katz K -A -T -Z. And that was not
- 41:24a legal opinion or advice. So another quote,
- 41:28where a lawyer sends a letter containing false
- 41:31statements that's intended to and does induce
- 41:34the recipient to terminate a contract. Will a
- 41:38suit against the lawyer and or his client be
- 41:41subject to an anti -slap? The answer is it depends.
- 41:46Yeah, definitely depends. It depends on it depends
- 41:49on the It depends on the letter. It depends on
- 41:56the law and it depends on how much evidence you
- 42:01can Adduce and whether You might draw an anti
- 42:08-slap. Right. You might draw an anti -slap and
- 42:12you would have to keep in mind the fact that
- 42:16there is case law that says that it's hard to
- 42:21establish the reliance prong of a fraud claim
- 42:25when you're relying on opposing counsel's statements.
- 42:32it might not be reasonable to rely. So you might
- 42:36have, even if there's a prong issue and there's
- 42:41a prong one issue and a prong two issue. Yeah.
- 42:44Remember the interplay of prong one and two.
- 42:46So even if it arises from protected conduct doesn't
- 42:50necessarily mean they're going to win their claim.
- 42:54They're going to be able to show a probability
- 42:57of prevailing on the merits. So, you know, it's,
- 43:00it's My my personal view and I know I'm a lawyer
- 43:04and most people here are lawyers and I'm not
- 43:07saying this Just because I'm a lawyer, but it's
- 43:11generally a pretty unsafe practice to sue opposing
- 43:15counsel If you have a dispute your dispute is
- 43:20with the opposing party It's not with their counsel
- 43:31And why risk an adverse ruling in attorney's
- 43:36fees that you then have to pay the party that
- 43:39you're suing so that they have more money either
- 43:42to defend or to counter sue? Yep. Agreed. Can
- 43:49you get a multiplier for attorney's fees on a
- 43:52successful anti -slap? Technically, you might.
- 43:59I'm not sure. In my practice, I'm not sure I
- 44:05ever asked for one. And I don't recall a reported
- 44:14instance of that occurring. But if you're going
- 44:25to ask for a multiplier, you're going to have
- 44:27to, you know. Follow the rules set out in the
- 44:32is it the Ketchum case for determining whether
- 44:35a multiplier is Appropriate I've never asked
- 44:41for a multiplier Just give this second some of
- 44:55these questions are long this one's more of a
- 44:58comment Let's skip that. This is a long one.
- 45:10All right. I want to hear what you have to say
- 45:12about malicious prosecution suits after a final
- 45:15adjudication. Attorney was sued by defendant
- 45:18employer for prosecuting a claim on behalf of
- 45:21plaintiff employee. The employer's suit was slapped
- 45:24with an award of fees and costs to the plaintiff's
- 45:27attorney affirmed on appeal. Employer files BK.
- 45:31Why cannot a malicious prosecution case against
- 45:36the attorney who filed the slap suit proceed?
- 45:42I think the factual scenario has gotten me a
- 45:46little bit confused. But I will just say this
- 45:50about malicious prosecution. You should read
- 45:54Gero versus Lamarche. It's a Supreme Court case.
- 45:58I don't have the site on hand, you can bring
- 46:04a malicious prosecution action, okay, but malicious
- 46:11prosecution, the act that is causing the malicious
- 46:16prosecution lawsuit is by definition petitioning
- 46:23activity. Someone filed something in court, correct?
- 46:28They filed something in court. that satisfies
- 46:31prong one, okay? A malicious prosecution action
- 46:35does not have the benefit of civil code 47 as
- 46:41an absolute privilege, so there needs to be a
- 46:45prong two analysis. You need to demonstrate at
- 46:50the inception of the case that you can prove
- 46:53the elements of malicious prosecution, right?
- 47:00that the action was not brought in good faith,
- 47:05and that it was brought with spite, malice, or
- 47:09ill will, and the prong that will usually defeat
- 47:16a malicious prosecution action, that it was brought
- 47:22without probable cause, right? You always need
- 47:26to prove that. to prevail on malicious prosecution.
- 47:30If you can't do it at the inception, then the
- 47:33malicious prosecution action is going to be slapped.
- 47:38That's just what's gonna happen. It's what happened
- 47:41in Jarrow. These are, I mean, malicious prosecution
- 47:46actions are very difficult to prosecute, heavily
- 47:50disfavored. We have kind of a testy bunch here
- 47:56ready to sue everyone for malicious prosecution.
- 48:00Or else they're already doing it. This topic
- 48:02is counseling you to take the high road. All
- 48:07right? Don't sue your opposing counsel. This
- 48:11is the takeaway here, people. Don't overextend
- 48:19the bleeding with a malicious prosecution action.
- 48:22Yeah, you're setting yourself up for an anti
- 48:25-slap every time, I think, on a malicious prosecution,
- 48:28on an abusive process claim. It's like you're
- 48:31painting a bullseye on your forehead. And then
- 48:33you're just going to litigate that and then go
- 48:36up to the Court of Appeal and litigate there,
- 48:38and enough already. Enough. State Bar is counseling
- 48:43us to be civil. Right, Effie? Yes. You know,
- 48:49it's... We can be zealous advocates and still
- 48:54preserve the tenets of civility. Right? Yes.
- 49:00You also, you also tend not to make friends with
- 49:05the other side when you, you know, sue them.
- 49:09It's fair. You know, and I will tell you that
- 49:16oftentimes when a defense lawyer gets sued, by
- 49:22the other side for something that is clearly
- 49:26slappable. The first instinct is they're mad
- 49:33and they're affronted, and their second instinct
- 49:36is, oh, I'm going to get all of this money. This
- 49:40isn't going to cost me a cent. You know, there's
- 49:47just no point to suing opposing counsel. There
- 49:50really isn't. Rare is the case, take Flatley
- 49:55versus Morrow as an example, where you'll get
- 50:00away with it. And if you look at Flatley versus
- 50:02Morrow and you read the letter that the attorney
- 50:06sent, you'll understand why that's the exception
- 50:11to the rule. It requires such flagrant conduct
- 50:16that is lucidly and clearly illegal For an attorney
- 50:23to fall outside of the protection of the anti
- 50:26-slap statute extortion yes, right though the
- 50:31letter in flat in flatly was an extortion letter
- 50:35it was in effect look our clients have a dispute
- 50:40and This is what I want you to do and if you're
- 50:43not going to do it Then I'm going to go to the
- 50:45press and I'm going to tell them all kinds of
- 50:47private facts about your client's life and ruin
- 50:52them. Threatening criminal prosecution if you
- 50:58don't do A, B, and C. Correct. Flagrantly false
- 51:06statements that just have no basis in fact. Well,
- 51:10not always. Reuben versus Green. That's a squishier.
- 51:18My reference to Reuben versus green is to a California
- 51:22Supreme Court case that says that in court Lawyers
- 51:26are protected even if they commit perjury So,
- 51:30you know that's different than writing an extortionate
- 51:34demand letter, but I'm just saying Would the
- 51:40same be true in a malicious prosecution action
- 51:43for continuing to litigate after filing? where
- 51:47deposition evidence confirms there's no basis
- 51:50to continue to litigate. Yes, the same is true.
- 51:54You might have a better shot, you might, I think
- 51:58you're thinking about Zombo, so you might have
- 52:00a better shot of demonstrating the lack of probable
- 52:05cause because you have more, you have more evidence,
- 52:13but you'll... you'll still be the recipient of
- 52:18an anti -slap and malicious prosecutions are
- 52:21still disfavored in the law. Agree. Well, we
- 52:28have a few minutes left. Effies or Elaine? How
- 52:31about Elaine? Some final thoughts? Go ahead.
- 52:35Words of wisdom for the fine members of the Beverly
- 52:39Hills Bar Association. I feel like anything I
- 52:42have to say would be off the backs of the two
- 52:46of you. That's fine, that's acceptable. I mean,
- 52:49I'm pretty new to anti -slap, but from reading
- 52:52the case, I feel like I would just steer clear
- 52:58of the potential of being slapped, because I
- 53:04feel like it just doesn't lead to a good result,
- 53:09especially if you risk losing and having to pay
- 53:13for attorney's fees. You know, defendants have,
- 53:22especially lawyers who are sued as defendants,
- 53:25have a high incentive if there's a basis for
- 53:29bringing an anti -slap. In the case of a lawyer,
- 53:33there almost always is. They are highly incentivized
- 53:37to bring the anti -slap. Sometimes plaintiffs
- 53:42are so angry at the other side that they want
- 53:46to throw everything in a complaint. In my view,
- 53:51it's our job as lawyers to manage the client's
- 53:56expectations and to explain to them the risks
- 54:00because at some point a plaintiff who's suing
- 54:04on something that is slappable ends up surprised
- 54:11and upset that they've not only lost, but now
- 54:15they have to pay a lot of fees. So bringing an
- 54:25anti -slap is far less risk for a defendant and
- 54:30far more risk for a plaintiff. You should think
- 54:35about it a lot before you do it. wise advice,
- 54:40and I agree. Look, it's our job. We have angry
- 54:45clients who are passionate to tamp down, to filter
- 54:51all of that into something that's really a viable
- 54:56claim. Yeah, we can't be suing lawyers for everything
- 55:03they do. It's our job to really filter it. And
- 55:08I agree, you'll get a disgruntled client at the
- 55:10end of it, and you're not going to be happy with
- 55:13the result. And it's just going to slow down
- 55:16the process of getting to the merits on whatever
- 55:21the underlying dispute is, which is what we all
- 55:23want. So I think it's a cautionary tale here
- 55:28on claims against your opposing lawyers. One
- 55:37final question. Ah, thank you. Thank you for
- 55:42that. This is the actual heart of the matter
- 55:45and I'm grateful that you closed with this. Client
- 55:48control is our paramount duty. Amen to that.
- 55:53So thank you. Absent any final questions? Oh,
- 55:56we have one more actually. Oh, more of a comment.
- 55:59Okay. So thank you everyone out there for joining
- 56:05us. If you have any additional questions, feel
- 56:09free to email any of us. Effy's the smartest
- 56:11one. I'm happy to send you any someone asked
- 56:17about a case I worked on offline. If you want
- 56:20to shoot me an email, I'm happy to talk about
- 56:21that. But thanks so much for joining us. Thanks
- 56:24for the Beverly Hills Bar for hosting. And Elaine,
- 56:29in her debut CLE performance, didn't she do a
- 56:34great job, everybody? Co -author of an article
- 56:39in the Daily Journal and now co -presenter at
- 56:43a CLE for the first time. So thanks for keeping
- 56:48us company. Alright everybody, have a good day.