Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Accessibility Laws and Trends (2026 Update)
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to Accessibility Laws and Trends, the
- 0:062026 update. I'm Edward Weiss. It is my pleasure
- 0:11to introduce our speaker today, Matthew S. Kenefick.
- 0:15Matthew S. Kenefick of Jeffer Mangels Butler
- 0:17and Mitchell LLP is going to break down the evolving
- 0:20legal landscape of accessibility compliance with
- 0:24a focus on both physical spaces and websites.
- 0:28This program will cover key provisions of the
- 0:31ADA and related California laws, including the
- 0:35Unruh Civil Rights Act and the Disabled Persons
- 0:38Act, and explain how these laws apply to businesses
- 0:42open to the public. It will also highlight our
- 0:45legal obligations. intersect with practical considerations
- 0:54in real estate, web development, and consumer
- 0:56-facing operations, offering insight into litigation
- 0:59trends, compliance, strategies, and risk management
- 1:02techniques to help businesses avoid costly lawsuits.
- 1:06And now let's get started. Thank you, Edward.
- 1:11Hello, everybody. My name is Matt Kenafick. I'm
- 1:14a partner at Jeffer Mangels Mitchell. We've done
- 1:16this program a couple of years now, and for those
- 1:19who previously attended, I appreciate that. What
- 1:23it usually brings us here is not just the general
- 1:27landscape of accessibility laws, but the fact
- 1:31is it's a very hot area of litigation. We saw
- 1:34that trend continue in 2025. We have noted about
- 1:4110 ,000 distinct lawsuits filed in 2025 over
- 1:46accessibility. We have California, Florida, and
- 1:51New York are still the top spots for accessibility
- 1:56lawsuits. And we'll talk about that in a little
- 2:00bit and why that is. We have seen a big increase
- 2:05in Illinois. Chicago specifically. In large part,
- 2:11we believe that that's due to adverse treatment
- 2:16from the New York federal courts. The New York
- 2:19federal courts have been more and more increasingly
- 2:22skeptical of these lawsuits. They've been put
- 2:28a lot of scrutiny. They've been granting motions
- 2:29to dismiss. So we've seen a lot of the New York
- 2:32bar shift over to Illinois and almost a 10X increase
- 2:40in those lawsuits. Of those lawsuits, of those
- 2:44approximate 10 ,000, about 20 to 25 % of those
- 2:49are specifically digital accessibility, meaning
- 2:53websites or mobile apps, and we'll talk about
- 2:55that. So the litigation landscape is still going
- 2:58heavy. One of the things that's an interesting
- 3:01development is we've seen a big surge in pro
- 3:03se litigations. and estimated up to 40 % of these
- 3:10are coming pro se. A lot of people attribute
- 3:12that to the advent of artificial intelligence.
- 3:16AI allows people to very easily take a pre -existing
- 3:25lawsuit or a template lawsuit that's been filed
- 3:28many times before and reuse it for their own
- 3:32personal purposes. So we've seen that too. With
- 3:36that said, let's go ahead and I have a deck and
- 3:39we'll go through the PowerPoint slideshow here.
- 3:42So let me share my screen here. So here we are,
- 3:51just the title page. And so let's start off.
- 3:55We're going to start off with the ADA and the
- 4:01correlating state laws, just the general legal
- 4:04framework. So to give some context, and so you
- 4:08can understand all sides of the perspective here,
- 4:13the ADA is a civil rights law. ADA is the acronym
- 4:19for the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990.
- 4:23It's intended to afford individuals with disabilities
- 4:28rights similar to those Without disabilities
- 4:33and the protections are they extend all different
- 4:38contexts from public accommodations to employment
- 4:41to transportation. Even say local government
- 4:45the idea is is historically persons with disabilities
- 4:49at a hard time participating in society one way
- 4:53or the other right there's challenges to living
- 4:56with disabilities and a lot of people do. estimated
- 5:0025 % of our population has disabilities, and
- 5:04those disabilities could be cognitive, they could
- 5:06be physical, there can be a lot of different
- 5:08ways to manifest, and those disabilities can
- 5:11make it challenging for the individuals participating
- 5:13in society, and the ADA is intended to help overcome,
- 5:20make society more welcoming for persons with
- 5:24disabilities. Because it is a remedial statute
- 5:28intended to remedy prior bad acts, conduct, whatever
- 5:33you want to call it, where society has been less
- 5:39inaccessible. It's broadly construed. Remedial
- 5:43statutes are broadly construed, meaning that
- 5:47courts aren't supposed to round up in favor of
- 5:52access, so to say. The intention is to provide
- 5:57guidelines to enable the full and equal provision
- 6:02of access. The idea is if people know what to
- 6:06do, they can do it. And as we'll talk about it,
- 6:10those guidelines are not so clear on some things,
- 6:13but they are clear on others. So we have different
- 6:16sections of the ADA. Title I through Title V.
- 6:23Title I is employment. Title II is public services,
- 6:27state and local governments. Title III, public
- 6:30accommodations. Title IV, telecommunications.
- 6:33Title V is miscellaneous provisions. We're going
- 6:36to focus on Title III, public accommodations.
- 6:39So what is a public accommodation? It's pretty
- 6:42much any place that does business with the public.
- 6:46So we have examples listed here, and these are
- 6:49right out of the statute. You've got places of
- 6:52lodging like hotels. You've got restaurants,
- 6:54food service establishments, entertainment venues
- 6:58such as theater, stadiums, auditoriums, convention
- 7:02centers, bakeries, grocery stores, clothing stores,
- 7:07pretty much any retail place. That goes on to
- 7:11see the next bullet point. It gives some examples,
- 7:13whether it's a Laundromat or bank or whatever.
- 7:18We have public transportation terminals, depots,
- 7:21museums, galleries, zoos, nurseries, daycare
- 7:24centers, gyms, health spas, bowling alleys. You
- 7:30get the point. It's intended to be places that
- 7:33are generally open to the public. This can become
- 7:36an area of contention. We have seen the argument
- 7:41over website access, whether or not a pure internet
- 7:47facility is a place of public accommodation.
- 7:53We also see this with private clubs or private
- 7:56businesses that are sometimes opened to the public
- 7:59and then turned into a place of public accommodation.
- 8:04So what is required? Again, when we're looking
- 8:07at physical access. So physical access means
- 8:11something that you would think of generally as
- 8:14you know when you think of somebody who has mobility
- 8:16disabilities somebody who may use an assistant
- 8:19device such as a wheelchair walker cane for physical
- 8:24access we if you have a new construction facility
- 8:29it must comply with all new construction standards
- 8:35and that and that is important because The ADA,
- 8:43as we talked 1990, we have effective dates of
- 8:46either January 26, 1991 or 93 depending on the
- 8:50facility. And so we have pre -existing facilities
- 8:55and we'll talk about that. But for new construction,
- 8:58you need to comply with the Americans Disabilities
- 9:02Act Accessibility Guidelines or Accessibility
- 9:06standards. One is the 1991 standards. One is
- 9:09the 2010 standards. But these are very clear
- 9:12federal standards. They're memorialized in the
- 9:17Code of Federal Regulations. You can find them.
- 9:21They'll give you very specific guidance on dimensions,
- 9:25tolerances, things that you're supposed to do.
- 9:28You also see there's Title 24 of the California
- 9:31Building Code referenced here. That's important
- 9:35to note because California has its own laws,
- 9:41the UNRWA Civil Rights Act, and you have to comply
- 9:44with the California laws. And Title 24 sometimes
- 9:51is a little bit different than the Americans
- 9:56Disability Act Accessibility Guidelines or Accessibility
- 10:00Standards. you have to comply with the stricter
- 10:05of the two standards. We see this in some, like
- 10:07I said, there's some interesting things. You
- 10:10know, California uses a different type of braille.
- 10:13We have westernized braille in California. California
- 10:18transactional counter heights can be different.
- 10:21California ATM locations and scoping can be a
- 10:24little different. So this new construction standard
- 10:27also applies to alterations. And that can be
- 10:31an area of dispute as well. An alteration is
- 10:35a modification which affects usability of the
- 10:38feature. And so you could have an argument. If
- 10:44I re -slurry a parking lot, is that an alteration?
- 10:48Well, you're changing the striping, right? Because
- 10:51the striping is going to be covered. So is that
- 10:54an alteration? It's a co -triggering alteration.
- 10:57But certainly, if you do just a slurry, are you
- 11:00going to have to change the the slope on it that
- 11:03would have come from the paving. So the scope
- 11:06of the alterations can be an area of dispute.
- 11:12The standard is you're supposed to remediate
- 11:17the entire altered element. Again, these are
- 11:21flexible, subjective terms intended to allow
- 11:24judicial discretion. You must remove access barriers
- 11:29where readily achievable. So that's the second
- 11:31standard. And this applies to pre -existing facilities.
- 11:37So these are places that were constructed prior
- 11:40to the ADA. And what that means is you don't
- 11:47have to tear down a whole building to make it
- 11:49accessible. We see this a lot. There's a lot
- 11:51of legacy buildings. Depending on the location,
- 11:55usually it's out of state where we see a lot
- 11:58of buildings that are built up on a foundation
- 12:01that's above the sidewalk, presumably for drainage
- 12:04or snow. And so you have a built -in set of stairs
- 12:10right into the sidewalk. And you may not have
- 12:14the room to put a ramp in place. So the question
- 12:18is, are you required? to tear down that whole
- 12:23facility, raise the facility and get rid of the
- 12:27raised foundation and make it street level for
- 12:31the purposes of achieving access. And the argument
- 12:35of course is that's not readily achievable. Readily
- 12:38achievable is something that can be accomplished
- 12:40without great difficulty or expense, does take
- 12:43into consideration safety and security that does
- 12:46come into play sometimes. So what would you do
- 12:50by way of example in the case of a of a legacy
- 12:55pre -existing facility that has a built -in set
- 12:59of Set of stairs You know ramp to base it a bit
- 13:05this would not a ramp assess stairs a step up
- 13:08that you're not able to overcome Without tearing
- 13:13down facility. Well, you look at either putting
- 13:15a wheelchair lift in Some places have done that.
- 13:19That's generally pretty expensive, but we have
- 13:22seen that a lot in New York. You can put a portable
- 13:24ramp. You can use a portable ramp with a sign
- 13:28that says, look, let us know. And we're either
- 13:33with a phone number or a call button that's prominently
- 13:36placed. So a person with disabilities will know
- 13:39that's the accessible route, and they can go
- 13:42there. Or alternatively, you could have an alternative
- 13:44entrance, as long as you have clear signage.
- 13:47It's not circuitous. You're not sending them
- 13:49three blocks around a building to get in. But
- 13:52something that provides equivalent facilitation.
- 13:56When it's not readily achievable, then you can
- 14:00look at what's called an equivalent facilitation.
- 14:05So we also see that another standard that we
- 14:12have in the in the ADA as policies, procedures,
- 14:18and practices. And this is kind of the catch
- 14:21-all. And this is public accommodations have
- 14:26to make reasonable modifications in their policies,
- 14:28practices, and procedures to afford equal access.
- 14:35And so when you find something that's not specifically
- 14:38enumerated in the code, We'll often see enforcement
- 14:42agencies like the Department of Justice or private
- 14:45individual enforcers or plaintiffs. We'll see
- 14:48them rely on this and say, look, you need to
- 14:52modify your policy. There's a lot of examples
- 14:55of this. There is some precedent that the modification
- 15:03not only needs to be reasonable, that the patron
- 15:06must request it. That's a Ninth Circuit precedent.
- 15:12But yeah, this is a catch -all. And you can see
- 15:15this just in about any application. So another
- 15:20area of the ADA is auxiliary aids and services.
- 15:24And basically what it is, no charge of public
- 15:29accommodation must provide auxiliary aids and
- 15:32services to achieve effective communication.
- 15:36The public accommodation gets to decide what
- 15:38those auxiliary aids and services are, but you
- 15:41need to achieve effective communication. Examples
- 15:44could be a braille statement, qualified interpreters
- 15:47at events, note takers, video displays, screen
- 15:51reader software, magnification software, et cetera.
- 15:55We usually see this come up as a backup argument
- 16:00on website access. But I've had class actions
- 16:05over all kinds of different layers like this.
- 16:09There was one that was sweeping New York for
- 16:11a while about Braille credit cards, or gift cards,
- 16:17rather. Gift cards, they wanted to have some
- 16:18type of way for persons with visual disabilities
- 16:22or who were blind to be able to. to check their
- 16:26statement balance or know who to contact for
- 16:28customer service. So this is an auxiliary aid
- 16:31and service component. We have seen this come
- 16:36up in several different contexts. So the next
- 16:41one is the California laws. I mentioned earlier,
- 16:44we have California laws. They're specific to
- 16:47access. We have the UNRWA Civil Rights Act and
- 16:49the Disabled Persons Act. Unruh Civil Rights
- 16:56Act incorporates ADA as a violation of the Unruh
- 17:00Act. However, a lot of it for those attorneys
- 17:04who immediately think when they get a lawsuit
- 17:07under 51F, which is an unruh act violation triggered
- 17:13by an ADA case. If you're in the central district,
- 17:16be cautioned about removing it. Check your judge.
- 17:21Some judges have rejected that. as being a basis
- 17:24for removing a state court case to federal. And
- 17:28that, obviously, you don't want to do a removal.
- 17:31If that particular judge is going to reject it,
- 17:35you might end up having some adverse consequences.
- 17:39Unlike the ADA, which does not provide a private
- 17:42plaintiff damages, you can get plenty of fines,
- 17:47penalties, and damages from Department of Justice.
- 17:51But the ADA, the monetary recovery, is limited
- 17:53to attorney's fees. Unlike that, the Unrested
- 17:57Civil Rights Act provides $4 ,000 minimum per
- 18:02incident statutory damages for physical access,
- 18:10not communicative access, but physical access
- 18:13cases. There is a requirement that the The plaintiff
- 18:18shows difficulty discomfort or embarrassment
- 18:20or a deterred visit that they would have went
- 18:25to the place of public accommodation, but for
- 18:30their knowledge of the barriers. That's the requisite
- 18:35threshold. to achieve these statutory damages.
- 18:39There's a couple other roadblocks they put up
- 18:41for small businesses, facilities that have been
- 18:44CASP inspected, certified access specialists
- 18:46inspected, but this is the primary standard.
- 18:49There are some cases out there that have held
- 18:53that difficulty, discomfort, or embarrassment
- 18:55is a little bit higher of standard. They have
- 19:00to show some type of physical or emotional injury.
- 19:03more than just encountering the facility. We've
- 19:08had some judges who have found that even though
- 19:12a plaintiff has encountered a barrier, they were
- 19:16still able to achieve access. And therefore,
- 19:20the requisite damages component is present. But
- 19:24again, you could imagine how these $4 ,000 per
- 19:29incident statutory damages make a very big threat
- 19:34on a class basis. I've handled and worked on
- 19:37some class actions that have had very significant
- 19:40damage claims and resolve for eight figure amounts
- 19:46based upon the presence of these statutory damages.
- 19:51And the UNRWA Civil Rights Act does require mitigation
- 19:55of damages, both specifically under the codes
- 19:59applicable to accessibility, but also in general,
- 20:03case law precedent does require that. The Disabled
- 20:09Persons Act, and I'll just make a comment about
- 20:12it. It's actually a, it's a less than politically
- 20:16correct named of a, of a, of a statute. The vernacular,
- 20:25the terminology that's preferred is persons with
- 20:29disabilities, meaning that the disability doesn't
- 20:33define the person, but that's our law. So Disabled
- 20:37Persons Act, it's $1 ,000, statutory damages
- 20:41a little bit less, very, very, very less frequently
- 20:46used because there's a California Supreme Court
- 20:49case that found that the fee shifting clause
- 20:52in it is bilateral, whereas under Civil Rights
- 20:56Act and ADA, the fee shifting clause is viewed
- 21:01as a component of damages. Disabled persons act,
- 21:05there's a case that holds that it's bilateral,
- 21:09meaning that in that case, the defendant successfully
- 21:13established that it wasn't readily achievable
- 21:16to remove the stair. that the plaintiff was suing
- 21:19over and they got defensive attorneys fees. So
- 21:25we talked about the building code and there's
- 21:28a delta between the federal and the state standards.
- 21:33We'll see that we look at the building code which
- 21:37is title or section 11b of title 24 of the California
- 21:41building code. That's updated tri -annually.
- 21:45So, you know, unlike you know, unlike the ADAG
- 21:51or the federal standards, which are not regularly
- 21:53updated, the building code is, like I said, there
- 21:57are some distinctions between the California
- 22:01standards and the federal standards. And unlike
- 22:05the federal standards, which has the readily
- 22:10achievable requirement, the building code does
- 22:13not. You know, you've heard the term grandfathering.
- 22:17That does apply. to building codes. So if you
- 22:20have a permit that you obtained, the building
- 22:23code of time of achieving that permit is what
- 22:26applies. Again, if you alter the element, then
- 22:29you have to bring it up to current code. So the
- 22:32UNRWA Act is broader in that it applies to business
- 22:39establishments, not public accommodations. And
- 22:43business establishments is can be in the broadest
- 22:47sense possible for those real estate lawyers.
- 22:51It does apply to the sale and rental of housing.
- 22:56Similarly, the UNRRAC does have a broader definition
- 23:00of disability, whereas the federal standard for
- 23:06the ADA requires a substantial limitation on
- 23:09daily life activity. The UNRRAC does not require
- 23:13that. It's just a limitation on daily life activity.
- 23:18So I mentioned website access. So we'll talk
- 23:23about visual accessibility on websites. So many
- 23:28jurisdictions find that websites are places of
- 23:32public accommodation. Prior to the Target case,
- 23:36my recollection was 2009, most courts did not
- 23:41consider a a website to be a place of public
- 23:46accommodation. In fact, in 2001, I published
- 23:49as the editor, not as the author, a publication
- 23:56article about website access. And we didn't look
- 24:00anything at the federal standards. We looked
- 24:02at FCC regs, because it was understood back then
- 24:05that they weren't looking at the ADA. There are
- 24:11different jurisdictions that hold different things.
- 24:13Some jurisdictions hold that pure websites, internet
- 24:18only websites have no physical presence, have
- 24:21no, are not public accommodations. Some jurisdictions,
- 24:26the courts hold that pure internet websites are
- 24:29public accommodations. Some jurisdictions require
- 24:32that the website that needs to have some type
- 24:39of nexus with a physical or public accommodation
- 24:46that's in brick or mortar. It can be, by way
- 24:49of example, a store locator listed on a website.
- 24:54It could be something as simple as advertising
- 24:58the products or giving coupons. for that facility,
- 25:02but that's the nexus that some jurisdictions
- 25:05require. A lot of the state laws we're talking
- 25:10about that impose statutory damages, they are
- 25:16bootstrapped into the website access. We have
- 25:22seen the Department of Justice say that the standards
- 25:25that they like to see, achieved are the web content
- 25:30accessibility guidelines, WCAG, and there's different
- 25:33standards. 2 .2 is the current conceptual one,
- 25:392 .1 is one of the most acting ones. There's
- 25:42success criteria factors, AA, AAA, AA being the
- 25:47most lenient, AAA being the most stringent, AA
- 25:49is what most people go for. If you go to AAA,
- 25:55it reduces a lot of the functionality of the
- 25:57website. So we see a lot of website claims, I
- 26:04just mentioned at the beginning of this, 20 to
- 26:0725 % of the new filings are website claims. And
- 26:12it's an easy explanation. They're really easy
- 26:16to file. For a physical facility, you're supposed
- 26:21to go to the physical place and encounter the
- 26:24barrier. At least that's what's required to confer
- 26:27Article 3 standard standing rather for the injury,
- 26:31in fact, under Lujan versus the Defenders of
- 26:33the Wildlife. But the website, you don't have
- 26:38to leave your house. You just have to go to the
- 26:42website. For a physical facility, you can imagine
- 26:49all these measurements that people need to take,
- 26:52need to figure out what's there. They have to
- 26:55often send out some type of architect to look
- 26:58at or an expert to figure out what are some of
- 27:02the nuanced violations. But for a website, they
- 27:06can just use an automated program to test the
- 27:11facility or the website. But the interesting
- 27:13thing is the automated tests really are not the
- 27:17true standard of access. We don't have a formal
- 27:22adoption of the WCAG. We have the Ninth Circuit
- 27:27say that it can be used as compelling evidence
- 27:30of non -compliance, and also a court can compel
- 27:35a public accommodation to remediate to that standard
- 27:38under its equitable jurisdiction. than Title
- 27:45II, we don't really have a wholesale adoption
- 27:48of WCAG. And in part because WCAG is conceptual
- 27:52in some regards. So what is usually the gold
- 27:58standard on whether something is accessible is
- 28:00use case testing. Actual persons with disabilities
- 28:05using the websites, using their assistive technologies,
- 28:09screen reader technologies, et cetera, in the
- 28:11way that they ordinarily would. and use the website.
- 28:14They can use it with or without the WCAG compliance
- 28:19that tells you whether or not it's usable. There's
- 28:21some people who will say, look, you can apply
- 28:23with WCAG, but I still have problems using your
- 28:25website. There's some people who can't use a
- 28:27website or can use a website that's not WCAG
- 28:31compliant. So it's an issue. Now, one of the
- 28:34things that we do see that makes a very easy
- 28:37target is the fact that a lot of people use templates
- 28:41for their websites. They use common development
- 28:44teams. So you can imagine you have one company
- 28:47with multiple brands. All those brands probably
- 28:51have similar website development templates. They
- 28:54probably have the same developer. If it's in
- 28:55-house, probably the same back office team or
- 28:58the same outside developer. And the fact is that
- 29:04makes it a really easy target. If you know a
- 29:06company has multiple sites, you find one problem,
- 29:09probably on all their sites. And now as a plaintiff,
- 29:12you can sue all those different companies, which
- 29:15is why when I settle cases for those types of
- 29:18companies, I insist on two things. First, I insist
- 29:24on an enterprise -wide release. I want the plaintiff
- 29:30to give us an entire release. And if we're doing
- 29:33it in New York, I want it to be future claims
- 29:36too, because under New York law, you can't get
- 29:39a release of future claims. But the other thing
- 29:44is I want to notice an opportunity to cure. If
- 29:47this plaintiff believes that there's anything
- 29:48wrong with our enterprise in the future, I want
- 29:50a warning shot. Some plaintiffs will, or some
- 29:55defense attorneys rather, will request and some
- 29:57plaintiffs will give a representation from plaintiffs'
- 30:00counsel about no other pending lawsuits. That's
- 30:05up to you on your conflict level. But everybody
- 30:09knows it's a violation of professional rules
- 30:15to impair the ability of another attorney to
- 30:20represent their clients. So I have seen In the
- 30:24past, some plaintiff's attorneys would offer
- 30:26protection. They'd say, look, you just hire me
- 30:30as your consultant on a going -forward basis,
- 30:34and then I'm conflicted out and I can never sue
- 30:37you. And we've had professional responsibility
- 30:41opinions looked at this that said you can't do
- 30:44indirectly what you can't do directly. And I
- 30:46have seen and represented some people who have
- 30:51had those agreements come to light. with some
- 30:54federal judges who weren't very happy about them.
- 30:57So we talk about claims having bootstrap damage
- 31:02claims. That's an issue. One of the things that
- 31:06makes it difficult is anybody who services retail
- 31:11clients, they know that often will have code
- 31:14locked during the holiday season. Meaning that
- 31:16if you get a claim during November or December,
- 31:22maybe even October, about the website, you're
- 31:26probably not going to be able to make any repairs
- 31:29to that website until the end of the holiday
- 31:32season. They do not want people interfering with
- 31:37the ability. The retailers do not want people
- 31:39interfering, especially compliance lawyers, interfering
- 31:42with the ability for those websites to generate
- 31:45revenue. Holiday seasons can be very important.
- 31:50So another issue is You know, people who get
- 31:52third party content, some content's deep linked,
- 31:56some content's licensed. You could imagine a
- 31:59payment processing component. Those things, that
- 32:05can be an issue if it's not compliant. So doctor,
- 32:11you know, mentions here what public facing website
- 32:14access policies we like to have. And we'll talk
- 32:17about this a little bit. We like to have policies
- 32:19that face the public that say, look, this is
- 32:23our policy. This is what we care about. And if
- 32:25you have any problems, here's a channel of communication
- 32:29to let us know what's wrong with our website.
- 32:31The reason that's important is I've seen, I've
- 32:35reviewed just about every consent judgment that
- 32:38justice has required over the years related to
- 32:42website access. And they always want a public
- 32:44facing policy. And one of the first things I've
- 32:48seen when the Department of Justice has made
- 32:51any investigatory inquiries about website access,
- 32:56is they say, we want to know about all the complaints
- 32:58you've received over the years. What type of
- 33:02things are people complaining about with regard
- 33:05to your websites and your usability or communicative
- 33:13policies? And it's really hard for you to prove
- 33:18a negative. But if you have a dedicated communication
- 33:22channel, and you preserve all incoming complaints,
- 33:28and you have no complaints for a very small amount,
- 33:32that's how you prove the negative. You say, look,
- 33:35we have 300 million interactions per year on
- 33:39this particular website. Of those, we believe
- 33:4380%, just pick a random number. X, Y, Z percent
- 33:48are unique users. And we only have three complaints,
- 33:53something like that. That's compelling evidence
- 33:56that a lot of people are using your website,
- 33:58not having a problem. One of the things, of course,
- 34:01is you got to make sure that the points of contact
- 34:06are... are also compliant with law. We'll talk
- 34:11about that in a little bit, because you'd get
- 34:13in trouble over that. Then remedial access vendors.
- 34:17There are companies out there that will help
- 34:18you bring your website into accessibility compliance.
- 34:22A lot of developers, they have accessibility
- 34:28training. Historically, they did not. So we relied
- 34:33really heavily on these third party vendors.
- 34:35But that has changed. That has changed a lot.
- 34:38We talked about the WCAG. It comes from the World
- 34:43Wide Web Consortium. It's a voluntary standard
- 34:47at this point. But a lot of courts use this as
- 34:52a benchmark. Most plaintiffs do as well. It focuses
- 34:56on perceivability, operability, understandability,
- 35:00and robustness on the The content, again, we're
- 35:06looking at people who are using assistive technologies
- 35:09to access the website. So what would we think
- 35:13of as assistive technology? Screen readers, like
- 35:16JAWS by way of example. So imagine somebody who
- 35:19is blind navigating a website. They're not able
- 35:23to use the graphic interface. They can't use
- 35:25a mouse. So how do they navigate the website?
- 35:29Well, they use it with their keyboard. often
- 35:33using the tab function or the arrow keys. And
- 35:36they will go from heading to heading to substructure
- 35:39to substructure. They have software that will
- 35:42read to them what's on those headings, what's
- 35:46describing them. We'll talk about some of these
- 35:47features a little bit. And those types of features
- 35:52are how people interact. So what you can do yourself
- 35:57is certainly you can hire somebody to check your
- 35:59website. or just wait until somebody sues you
- 36:03and check out and get the report. But you could
- 36:06also check it yourself. Here are some free tools
- 36:10to do an automated test. These are starting points.
- 36:15It's not going to be comprehensive. There are
- 36:17some more comprehensive ones out there. But manual
- 36:22testing is always recommended. So we talked about
- 36:26some of these website features. So we said the
- 36:30heading structure, right? So heading structure
- 36:33is really important for people to navigate using
- 36:35a screen reader. Easy way for people to get lost
- 36:38or stuck is bad heading. So another one is alternative
- 36:43text. So what is that? Alt text is a descriptive
- 36:46set of invisible text for images. So by way of
- 36:52example, if I was shopping for women's shoes
- 36:56and I'm scrolling over an item and it's described
- 37:00by a heading. But then when I go to the item
- 37:03itself, it just says shoe. That's not going to
- 37:06be very descriptive. It's not going to tell me
- 37:07what's there. But you could have alternative
- 37:10text. It could say black woman's, you know, pump
- 37:15with a leather upper and sequins or whatever
- 37:19would be the three inch, whatever would be the
- 37:22meaningful text to be able to allow people to
- 37:28navigate the website. Now, certainly, if it's
- 37:31in the description of the item, the alternative
- 37:34text can be duplicative. So there is a level
- 37:43of judgment call there. But a lot of people get
- 37:47popped on alt text. And the reason being is you
- 37:51can have a lot of items. You can have a lot of
- 37:52items on your website. One of the things gets
- 37:56changed a lot, often are the images. So it's
- 38:01the updates. It may be developed and compliant,
- 38:04but it gets updated and it's not kept in compliance.
- 38:07And the alt text is one of the things gets updated
- 38:09a lot. Color contrast is something that we see
- 38:12a lot of. A high contrast would be something
- 38:19like my slide here, a dark black on a white background.
- 38:25But if you look at the watermark on the bottom
- 38:28of here, it has our firm branding and the date.
- 38:31That's low contrast. That's a gray on white.
- 38:35That's not going to be accessible. And this is
- 38:39not for somebody who uses screen reader technology.
- 38:41It's for somebody who's low vision. We see a
- 38:45lot of claim for there are blind individuals
- 38:47asserting color contrast claims. Certainly it
- 38:51doesn't apply for blind. We're not going to be
- 38:54noticing a color contrast issue. But again, that's
- 38:59just the sloppiness on the plainness bar. Again,
- 39:03we talk about navigability with the keyboard.
- 39:08The captioning is something that's really important.
- 39:11So if you have prerecorded video that has sound,
- 39:18you should have captions on that. Now live, it's
- 39:22optional. it's recommended that for live content
- 39:27that you're not going to if you don't have any
- 39:32captioning that you put a statement look there's
- 39:35no captioning but you don't have to and certainly
- 39:39again if the captioning is duplicative what's
- 39:43in the content of the website itself and it's
- 39:48easily ascertained then then there's a good argument
- 39:53that you don't need the captioning and there
- 39:54are some comments about that. These are just
- 39:57some of the common barriers we see that are addressed
- 40:02in claims. Now again, you can, if you're worried
- 40:08about website claims, what you can certainly
- 40:11do is you can hire a website consultant to help
- 40:15you check. You could do your own regular checking
- 40:17yourself. Anytime you have new content, it's
- 40:20really important to make sure that that new content
- 40:24is compliant and we obviously provide training
- 40:29for people who are involved in this culture of
- 40:36compliance. I've seen some people come up with
- 40:39development guidelines for internal development
- 40:42staff. Again, You can create whatever infrastructure
- 40:46you like to try to achieve accessibility, depending
- 40:49on the priority it is for your company or your
- 40:52client's company. One of the things that we have
- 40:56seen that is helpful is making sure there is
- 40:58one person who has ultimate ownership of accessibility.
- 41:02It looks good from an optics perspective. It
- 41:05also helps make sure that things get done. Another
- 41:11thing we like to do is we have templates. And
- 41:14you got to make sure those templates are accessible.
- 41:18Otherwise, you really got a problem. All your
- 41:24websites have the same problems because you have
- 41:28one bad template. Some of the pitfalls, software
- 41:33overlays. One of the very marketable things is,
- 41:41look, you could just pay a company to put a software
- 41:43overlay on your website, and they'll tell you
- 41:50that it'll make it accessible and screen reader
- 41:52compliant, and you'll never get sued again. The
- 41:55reality is technology is good, but it's not there
- 41:58yet. And a lot of plaintiffs target websites
- 42:02specifically that use overlays. In part because
- 42:07they want to discourage people from relying on
- 42:09the overlays because if people have a quick and
- 42:12easy cheap fix, they're not going to get sued
- 42:15as much, but also because there's a lot of criticism
- 42:18over the overlays not working. If you are using
- 42:22third -party companies for their website templates
- 42:26or for their... embedded or deep -linked content,
- 42:33you should watch out for that. That's an easy
- 42:35way of getting in trouble. Remember, we talked
- 42:39about alt text, we talked about keyboard, navigation,
- 42:44color contrast. I mentioned earlier about captioning
- 42:48for prerecorded content. This is the standard
- 42:53on that, the WCAG 1 .2 .2. Again, it just goes
- 42:58through that. You need to have some type of captioning
- 43:07for pre -recorded content, or you risk getting
- 43:10sued. There were a lot of suits over this for
- 43:14a while. We saw a lot of it over certain types
- 43:18of websites. First, one wave was they hit all
- 43:22the resorts. Resorts always have nice videos.
- 43:26The next one was plastic surgeons. or cosmetic
- 43:30surgeons, so there you go. Another thing to keep
- 43:36in mind is it's not just the website, it's other
- 43:39content. So if you have PDFs, by way of example,
- 43:44embedded, those should be accessible. Otherwise
- 43:48people are going and they're seeing the PDFs,
- 43:50they're not able to use their screen reader.
- 43:53We talked about policies. Policies are... are
- 43:58very important to achieve an infrastructure.
- 44:02It's also a good defensible mechanism. I think
- 44:06that if you can come up with a good policy and
- 44:09you can onboard and train off of it, keep it
- 44:12in your learning management system, you're going
- 44:14to have a higher chance of achieving access and
- 44:19then also you'll have a good defense in the event
- 44:22that something does go wrong. So we like to have
- 44:26them consistent. We like to have channels for
- 44:29customers or visitors to make accommodation requests
- 44:33for complaints. We like to have interaction etiquette
- 44:39policies so people know how to interact with
- 44:42persons with disabilities, because it's really
- 44:44easy to upset people, especially some people
- 44:49are very sensitive about. other situation. So
- 44:53we look at service and emotional support animals.
- 44:58This is a hot topic. So first, it jumps out.
- 45:02This is from last year, but it's still relevant.
- 45:05We had somebody who filed a lawsuit over a realtor
- 45:11not allowing a service animal in an open house,
- 45:14and they asserted a series of claims. So it's
- 45:17something that should be on people's radar. So
- 45:19what is a service animal? So a service animal,
- 45:22this is the federal standard, is any dog or miniature
- 45:28horse, miniature horse is federal, state assist
- 45:31dog, that is individually trained to perform
- 45:35tasks for the benefit of a person with a disability.
- 45:39The training component is a matter of controversy.
- 45:43Certainly the professional trainers all... I'll
- 45:47say, look, you can't do self -training. A lot
- 45:48of people do believe that they can do self -training,
- 45:51but I've been at these conferences. You can tell
- 45:54the difference between a professional trained
- 45:55and a self -trained service animal and the way
- 45:59they conduct themselves and the services they
- 46:01provide. So what is not a service animal? An
- 46:04emotional support animal. Now, while as a landlord,
- 46:08you may be required, following the interactive
- 46:12process, to allow somebody to take a emotional
- 46:15support animal in their individual dwelling or
- 46:20place of work. That's not for the public accommodation.
- 46:24Emotional support animal is just an animal that
- 46:27provides comfort, right, but it's not individually
- 46:30trained and doesn't perform tasks. And obviously
- 46:34that's a hyperbolic picture, a very adorable
- 46:36Yorkshire Terrier in a purse. So we talk about
- 46:42under the California law, guide dogs, signal
- 46:45dogs, service dogs, the ADA law, you know, dogs
- 46:49and miniature horses. The problem is, is you
- 46:52can't really challenge this. without getting
- 46:57it right. If you challenge somebody who has a
- 47:00service animal and say that's not a service animal
- 47:02and kick them out and you're wrong, you get in
- 47:05trouble. So what can you ask? Because you're
- 47:07not allowed to really inquire into the nature
- 47:09of the disability. So you can ask whether the
- 47:13guest needs the animal because of disability,
- 47:15but that's it. You can ask what tasks they have
- 47:18been trained to perform, but you can ask for
- 47:21proof of training or a license. They can't ask
- 47:24them to verify or explain their disability. They
- 47:27can't charge a pet fee or cleaning charge. Now,
- 47:31you may charge for actual damage, and certainly,
- 47:35a violent animal or animal that's not under the
- 47:37control of its handler can be removed. The practical
- 47:41matter is you should consider putting, if you're
- 47:47in public accommodation, some type of formal
- 47:49written statement. regarding your service animal
- 47:53policy that complies with the laws, you should
- 47:57probably discourage your employees from having
- 48:01any of this dialogue. Because either A, they're
- 48:04going to get something wrong, or B, the guest
- 48:07is going to say they got something wrong. And
- 48:09now you have a lawsuit over he said, she said.
- 48:15It's not worth it. It's a problem. I stay away
- 48:20from that. It is worth noting that it is a misdemeanor
- 48:23to represent an animal as a service animal when
- 48:27it's not one. They see this all the time. People
- 48:29go online and they get a service dog license
- 48:33or vest or whatever. There's no license. There's
- 48:37no registry. A trained service animal is a very
- 48:42special animal. The breeds are very, very well
- 48:46selected, finest stock. you know for the dogs
- 48:50to actually make it to actually the training
- 48:53it's you know some of the trainers i've talked
- 48:56to it's like 30 or 40 percent max a lot of the
- 49:00dogs they just don't have the temperament so
- 49:02you have the right temperament you have the right
- 49:04type of animal and then they have special training
- 49:08and they can be an amazing thing they really
- 49:10can and you know it's unfortunate that some people
- 49:15try to take advantage and misrepresent that their
- 49:18animal is a service dog when it's not just because
- 49:22they want to be near their pet. And I get it.
- 49:24Look, pets are wonderful. But sometimes they're
- 49:27not meant for all locations. And again, an emotional
- 49:32support animal, comfort animals not trained.
- 49:36But keep in mind, under Fair Housing Act laws,
- 49:40You may need to allow individuals with disabilities
- 49:43to have an emotional support animal. We have
- 49:47jokes about what that means, because it could
- 49:49be your emotional support chicken or snake or
- 49:52whatever. But that's a housing, not a public
- 49:56accommodation issue. And that's the FIHA or the
- 49:58Fair Housing Act. It's not an ADA issue. So what
- 50:05do lawyers do? How do you respond to claims?
- 50:08Just the same as all other claims. First, you're
- 50:10going to investigate. You'll identify all the
- 50:12barriers. I like to look at, when I get an accessibility
- 50:16claim, I do two tracks. Track one, triage, put
- 50:20out the fire. Track two, concurrently, make sure
- 50:23we don't get sued again. So we investigate the
- 50:26claims. We're going to identify all the barriers.
- 50:29We're going to see what type of protections exist.
- 50:33You know, these are small businesses I mentioned.
- 50:36If you're a small business, you get certain types
- 50:39of time from notice of the claim to remove the
- 50:43barriers. Small businesses are defined for certain
- 50:46types of numbers of employees and revenue. CAST
- 50:50Certified Access Specialist Program certified
- 50:53by the Division of State Architect. You know,
- 50:56we look at that and we look to see if you have
- 50:58a CAST certification. Again, that might be a
- 51:02reduction in damages. We look to see if it's
- 51:05new construction and permitted after January
- 51:091st, 2008. Another one of these exemptions to
- 51:12limit damages. You got to make sure your client
- 51:16knows do not retaliate with plaintiff returns.
- 51:19I've seen this happen. Plaintiff comes back and
- 51:22the individuals working at the facility or own
- 51:26the facility say, you're not welcome here. Don't
- 51:28do that. Do not do that. You got to know the
- 51:31rules. A lot of courts have special rules for
- 51:34accessibility cases. Northern District, California
- 51:37has General Order 56, by way of example, puts
- 51:40the case on stay, and then you have to jump through
- 51:42a bunch of hoops before you can actually litigate.
- 51:46Similarly, you know, Central District, you have
- 51:48the ability to get an early neutral evaluation
- 51:50and a stay if you elect to that. You got to pick
- 51:53your battles wisely. There is a prevalent plaintiff
- 51:57attorney's fees clause. A lot of these people
- 52:00A lot of these plaintiff's attorneys, they welcome
- 52:04a fight because you are going to just drive up
- 52:10their fees. So you have to know who you're dealing
- 52:13with. If it's one of these serial litigants who
- 52:16has a high volume model, you may want to consider
- 52:20a deterrence factor of defending the case a little
- 52:25before settling because you will disrupt their
- 52:27business model. But again, I wouldn't do that
- 52:30for the first claim. If you're dealing with the
- 52:32fifth or sixth claim from that firm, you may
- 52:34want to talk about that with your client. Obviously,
- 52:37prepare for future suits. You've been sued once.
- 52:39It's a public record. Odds are you're going to
- 52:41get in the line of fire again. One of the key
- 52:46things is these plaintiffs do circulate between
- 52:50law firms, so something to know. So make sure
- 52:55when you get the release, It protects you on
- 53:00a going -forward basis to the extent you can
- 53:02in that same plaintiff. Because even if the plaintiff's
- 53:05attorney may not sue you again, they may switch
- 53:08to a different plaintiff's attorney. Similarly,
- 53:10that same plaintiff's attorney may switch to
- 53:12a different plaintiff. We like to talk about
- 53:16creating an accessibility strategy. The accessibility
- 53:23strategy. Again, we want to identify compliance
- 53:30issues, deficiencies, any type of issues that
- 53:35we have, common conditions which cause lawsuits,
- 53:39quickly identify and prioritize action items.
- 53:45Like I said, we like the policies, practices,
- 53:47and procedures. You start with the policies.
- 53:50Then you train off of those. That creates the
- 53:53practices and you get people the procedures on
- 53:56what to do. The practices, of course, is how
- 53:58they implement those procedures. Again, I do
- 54:02like the customer -facing policy aspects. Priorization.
- 54:08Some things are going to be easy to fix. You
- 54:12can imagine at a public accommodation, signage.
- 54:18directional signage telling people how to get
- 54:20around, whereas you could see a complete structural
- 54:27change could be something that would be very
- 54:30difficult to deal with. Obviously, we want to
- 54:36do the action plan. rapid deployment of the quick
- 54:39wins, all the normal stuff. One thing to remember
- 54:42is for certain types of remedial work, you do
- 54:46have some type of tax incentive credits, tax
- 54:52credits up to a certain amount for certain types
- 54:54of businesses. So it's always good to have somebody
- 54:58look at this from a tax perspective because you
- 55:01may very well find that your client could have
- 55:05a credit, a tax credit for some of the work they're
- 55:08doing. And so that is the, that's the end of
- 55:12the slideshow, folks. And we can switch to the
- 55:15Q &A. All right, Matthew, we actually have quite
- 55:21a bit of questions. So starting us off, we have
- 55:27John Dominic, Vittier Lo. asks, where can practitioners
- 55:32find reasonable web access experts? Unlike CASP,
- 55:35there is no license associated with web access.
- 55:38And accordingly, there's no public portal for
- 55:40finding experts. Yeah, that is a big challenge
- 55:47we all face. The first thing to do, of course,
- 55:49is to start with your existing development team.
- 55:53Who's working on your websites? Who's done the
- 55:57back end? Who's done the work? Talk to them,
- 56:00find out what they have is with regard to their
- 56:04ability to do website accessibility. You'd be
- 56:09surprised. Sometimes your existing resources
- 56:11have that. You know, second of all, you know,
- 56:14certainly with key engagement, I've been involved
- 56:17with engagement on those accessibility or a lot
- 56:20of those development. people with respect to
- 56:22accessibility many times. You got to make sure
- 56:25that the scope of engagement initially does in
- 56:27fact cover access. They need to know that that's
- 56:29part of their scope of work. You can imagine
- 56:31you have a foreign developer who works in multiple
- 56:34different jurisdictions. They may not appreciate
- 56:36your needs in the states. So you got to make
- 56:40sure that they know that and then certainly contractually
- 56:42you can come up with some protections. With regard
- 56:46to the development, developers. Again, there
- 56:51are some remedial folks out there. The problem
- 56:56is the big companies like Deque, they're there,
- 57:02but they're still very expensive. And often they're
- 57:06not going to be able to be as well versed in
- 57:09the specific nature of the website you're looking
- 57:11for. So again, we talked about by way of example,
- 57:14you have there was a bunch of websites related
- 57:19to resorts that got hit. Well, there was a team
- 57:22of folks who did the resort websites. They were
- 57:26really good. And they all had a very similar
- 57:29feel to it. And you want to make sure you have
- 57:31somebody specific to that. So I would think it
- 57:34just like any expert, you're going to want to
- 57:36tailor it to the size of the client. If it's
- 57:40a smaller client, it's going to be obviously
- 57:41a smaller engagement. If it's a larger client,
- 57:45then certainly you're going to want something
- 57:46with more resources. You're going to want to
- 57:49look at somebody that has the capability to deal
- 57:51with the different types of content. Some people
- 57:54have different content than others, right? And
- 57:57then finally, of course, we're going to want
- 57:59to look at the cost budget. And obviously nobody
- 58:05wants to pay more, but sometimes there's going
- 58:07to be some cost limitations. So I wish there
- 58:11was a silver bullet answer. But unfortunately,
- 58:16I have yet to find a standard reliable web development
- 58:21resource. Usually it's. one off. I mean, I have
- 58:25a couple people who I like and you're more welcome
- 58:27to email me and I'll send that to me. I'll send
- 58:30you some contact information directly, but I
- 58:33haven't found any specific general omnibus resource
- 58:38on that. All right. And then on a similar topic,
- 58:42I'm just going to skip ahead to this question.
- 58:44What percentage of accessibility lawsuits did
- 58:46you say at the beginning of the webinar correspond
- 58:48to digital spaces? Yeah, it's It's tough to keep
- 58:53track of all of them because a lot of lawsuits
- 58:56are filed in the state court, and those are not
- 59:02tracked as well. But it's estimated 20 % to 25
- 59:06% on the data I have seen. Now, the interesting
- 59:10thing is that doesn't take into consideration
- 59:13demand letters. I can tell you. For every lawsuit
- 59:19I get from my clients, I have 10 demand letters.
- 59:22And how you deal with the demand letters depends
- 59:25on the client. Sometimes you know that these
- 59:30people are sending out mass demand letters, and
- 59:33it's a wait and see. Let them come back. Wait
- 59:35till they knock twice. Sometimes they go away.
- 59:39But really, it's a case -by -case basis. And
- 59:42that doesn't track all the demand letters. But
- 59:4620 % to 25 % is what the resources I've seen.
- 59:51I've seen statistics say more, I've seen less.
- 59:54But again, that's the general statistics I've
- 59:56seen. Thank you. And then Erica Rutan asks, do
- 1:00:01municipalities have a duty to provide city parking
- 1:00:04or could a municipality theoretically eliminate
- 1:00:06all city parking and shift the burden to provide
- 1:00:09any parking at all, including for disabled people
- 1:00:12to private entities? If there is a duty for a
- 1:00:15municipality to provide access to the cities
- 1:00:18via city parking, what is that authority? Thank
- 1:00:21you. Yeah, I apologize. I don't know. with regard
- 1:00:28to parking obligations for a municipality in
- 1:00:32general, whether or not they have to provide
- 1:00:35it or not. I suspect it would probably be something
- 1:00:38you would see in the general plan for each city,
- 1:00:40but again, I'm not a land use lawyer. I guarantee
- 1:00:44the Beverly Hills Bar Association has a tremendous
- 1:00:47list of people who are land use attorneys, some
- 1:00:49of which are at my firm. I'd be more than happy
- 1:00:52to make an introduction, but I don't know that,
- 1:00:54but I do know that there are guidelines with
- 1:00:58regard to scoping as to when parking is provided,
- 1:01:06how many accessible spots. There's a formula
- 1:01:09based upon the number of spots, the locations
- 1:01:13where they need to be. And that's one of the
- 1:01:15good things about the federal standards and also
- 1:01:18the building code standards for physical access
- 1:01:20is you do get some very specific, precise guidance.
- 1:01:25as to what is and isn't accessible. And so that
- 1:01:29helps you comply. If you want to do the right
- 1:01:32thing, there's a lot of guidance there. And when
- 1:01:34there is some ambiguity and there is ambiguity
- 1:01:37out there, there's generally some guidance on
- 1:01:41that as well. On communicative access, digital
- 1:01:46access, it's less than clear, especially given
- 1:01:49that technology changes. You can imagine How
- 1:01:54many people now use a mobile device as their
- 1:01:58primary way to access the internet compared to
- 1:02:01five years ago, 10 years ago, and the mobile
- 1:02:04devices add a whole nother component, whether
- 1:02:06it's app or mobile content. And then you also
- 1:02:11have different assistive technologies on your
- 1:02:14mobile device. You're not using the same JAWS
- 1:02:16screen reader technology on your desktop computer
- 1:02:19as you are on your iPhone. Right? So, so it does
- 1:02:23change a lot, but again, I just don't know the
- 1:02:26circle back and close the loop. I don't know.
- 1:02:30What is the obligation of. Of a municipality
- 1:02:35to provide parking, whether they have to, or
- 1:02:38they do not. All right, and then I have a question
- 1:02:45here, the private enforcers for reasonable accommodation
- 1:02:49will file suit for it when. But when does the
- 1:02:52private enforcer become a vexatious litigant?
- 1:02:58Yeah, that is a very good question. So, I mean,
- 1:03:04certainly we have our standards for vexatious
- 1:03:08litigant, right? And we've seen that. We've seen
- 1:03:12that a lot. Anybody who's been in the court,
- 1:03:17you've either... You've either encountered one
- 1:03:20or you've seen the judges deal with one. But
- 1:03:24generally speaking, for lawsuits related to accessibility,
- 1:03:31California has standards. If you file more than
- 1:03:34a certain amount, I believe it's 10 within a
- 1:03:37certain period of time, you become what's called
- 1:03:39a high frequency litigant. And a high frequency
- 1:03:43litigant has to pay an additional filing fee.
- 1:03:47Again, this relates to physical access. You have
- 1:03:50to pay an additional filing fee. You have to
- 1:03:52register with the judicial counsel, I believe,
- 1:03:56your complaints and lawsuits. If you send a demand
- 1:04:01letter, there's some limitations on that, and
- 1:04:04you're supposed to include some materials in
- 1:04:07that. So there are some ways of dealing with
- 1:04:11that for a high -frequency litigant. I have seen,
- 1:04:14we have all heard about it. some really bad practices
- 1:04:19where we've had people where the lawyers would
- 1:04:24go out and manufacture the lawsuits, and those
- 1:04:27lawyers have been disbarred over it, where they
- 1:04:30would go to facilities either driving the person
- 1:04:33who's the plaintiff with them to these facilities
- 1:04:37solely on a trip to manufacture lawsuits. We've
- 1:04:40seen some that didn't have that. where they weren't
- 1:04:46even with the plaintiff. Certainly, when you
- 1:04:51get to a situation like that, you go into tester
- 1:04:54standing, which of course is very controversial.
- 1:04:59Most jurisdictions do not favor tester standing
- 1:05:03for Article III purposes. But there are plaintiffs,
- 1:05:07pro se litigants, who literally, and I've litigated
- 1:05:11against them, who literally will go on a road
- 1:05:14trip, and they'll hit 10, 15 different facilities
- 1:05:18on the road trip. And some of these places will
- 1:05:21be 500 miles from their home, and they come back
- 1:05:23and they sue them all. I've had one where a guy
- 1:05:25stayed at like three or four different hotels
- 1:05:28in two days. He had three or four of the same
- 1:05:32brand retailer in two days, each one 100, 200,
- 1:05:35300 miles apart from each other. It was clearly
- 1:05:38the manufacturer. It was clearly to manufacture
- 1:05:46a lawsuit. Okay, so we have another question
- 1:05:54here from Travis Chow asking, are you seeing
- 1:05:58law firm websites being targeted by these types
- 1:06:00of claims? I have, I have, and we've also seen
- 1:06:06law firms historically the subject of some Department
- 1:06:10of Justice enforcement. So one of the things
- 1:06:14that we talked about was communicative access.
- 1:06:18So about 10 years ago or so, telephone relay
- 1:06:24services was very popular, TRS. I've talked about
- 1:06:27this in our prior webinars. And what TRS is,
- 1:06:32is if I have a difficulty or disability in speaking
- 1:06:37or hearing, I'm not going to use a traditional
- 1:06:40telephonic channel to communicate, right? I'm
- 1:06:42going to either use a text message, a chat, maybe
- 1:06:45a teletype device, which is a special device
- 1:06:48that basically acts like a chat device. And that's
- 1:06:51how I'm going to communicate. And so through
- 1:06:57the FCC, through 7 -1 -1, they have of no charge
- 1:07:01to US residents. They have a program where you
- 1:07:06can call up either by text or video chat so you
- 1:07:10can sign language or teletype a communications
- 1:07:14assistant. That communications assistant will
- 1:07:17then pick up the phone and call the recipient
- 1:07:22of that. That communications assistant, they're
- 1:07:28not the client. So we had a lot of banks in trouble
- 1:07:32with this and some law firms where they would
- 1:07:35say, look, I'm not going to speak to this communications
- 1:07:37assistant. This is confidential financial information,
- 1:07:40private attorney client information. I'm not
- 1:07:42going to talk to this communications assistant.
- 1:07:44I want to talk to the actual client themselves.
- 1:07:48And that's a violation of law. And a lot of banks
- 1:07:53got hit over that. A lot of companies got hit
- 1:07:56over that and a lot of law firms got hit over
- 1:07:58that. and Department of Justice did assess penalties.
- 1:08:02I think the largest one that I saw was a $20
- 1:08:06million fund, and that was to Wells Fargo. And
- 1:08:11I did make a comment earlier about when you have
- 1:08:15a complaint channel or an accommodation channel
- 1:08:18on your website or on your company to make sure
- 1:08:22that people can actually communicate with you.
- 1:08:25I was referring to accepting teletype devices
- 1:08:30and TRS calls, because you can imagine if you
- 1:08:37tell somebody with a disability, look, you have
- 1:08:41a complaint. You can call us here. But what if
- 1:08:43that person can't hear? What if that person can't
- 1:08:48use a regular telephonic channel? Then they're
- 1:08:50limited to either using a teletype device, which
- 1:08:52you should accept the TTY calls. or a TRS call,
- 1:08:57which you should accept. Great, thank you. And
- 1:09:04let's see, so I have Lan asking, what is the
- 1:09:06accommodation for a deaf or blind person on a
- 1:09:09website? Okay, so I don't know if that is a deaf
- 1:09:13blind, a person who's deaf and blind, but person
- 1:09:15who's deaf, certainly it would be the caption
- 1:09:17for video content. And then through any telephonic
- 1:09:22communication channels, either TTY or TRS. For
- 1:09:26blind, again, we want to make it compliant with
- 1:09:32the assistive technology, the screen reader technology,
- 1:09:37which would generally be, we would aim towards
- 1:09:40a web content accessibility guidelines or WCAG
- 1:09:44standard on that. Great, thank you. And then...
- 1:09:50Robert Aronoff asks, what are the rights of a
- 1:09:53service animal over an emotional support animal?
- 1:09:56Hey, Robert. Good to hear from you. Certainly,
- 1:10:05you can take a service animal into any place
- 1:10:08of public accommodation, subject to reasonable
- 1:10:12guidelines. There are health and safety issues.
- 1:10:16There are some, we have seen some, We have seen
- 1:10:20some situations where, by way of example, it
- 1:10:24may not be safe to bring a dog into a pool or
- 1:10:29something like that. We have situations like
- 1:10:32that. But for the most part, as a service animal,
- 1:10:38you're entitled to go the same place as the person
- 1:10:41with the disability to come in. And again, a
- 1:10:46service animal has to be under control. of their
- 1:10:48handler. We say handler because, keep in mind,
- 1:10:51the person with disability may not be the person
- 1:10:53handling that service animal. They have to behave.
- 1:10:58They have to not pose a direct threat. And if
- 1:11:02they do, then certainly then they can be asked
- 1:11:06to leave. Emotional support animal, under the
- 1:11:10ADA, it's treated as a pet. and you're subject
- 1:11:15to all the other restrictions that a pet may
- 1:11:18have. But again, under FIHA or FHA, you could
- 1:11:22get either at your workplace or your residence,
- 1:11:30you can engage in the interactive process to
- 1:11:37try to get the emotional support animal. permitted,
- 1:11:41which is you make the request, you demonstrate
- 1:11:44some type of need, you have the interactive process,
- 1:11:48you both work together collaboratively to figure
- 1:11:50out whether or not it's reasonably necessary
- 1:11:53for your access. But again, that's a housing,
- 1:11:56not a public accommodation inquiry. Great. And
- 1:12:00it looks like we just have one question from
- 1:12:02Robert Weinstock. Are you aware of any changes
- 1:12:05to laws such as providing defendants with an
- 1:12:07opportunity to cure before litigation can proceed?
- 1:12:12Well, last year there was an assembly bill 1474,
- 1:12:21something like that. There was an assembly bill
- 1:12:23that went last year that got through the State
- 1:12:26Senate and it's on the next step. Certainly,
- 1:12:30the lobbyists will know what the next step is.
- 1:12:32But there is a California bill that was passed
- 1:12:37to try to give a notice and opportunity to cure.
- 1:12:42It's in legislative purgatory right now. It hasn't
- 1:12:46been passed. And that was restricted to, I believe,
- 1:12:51small businesses to give them an opportunity.
- 1:12:54But there are some protections you can get. And,
- 1:12:58you know, I, you know, I try to cram this, this
- 1:13:02presentation into one hour and I can obviously
- 1:13:04talk about this a lot longer, but there are some
- 1:13:07things I did not talk about. And one of the,
- 1:13:09one of the things is the protections that you
- 1:13:12have a, you know, as a small business, by way
- 1:13:17of example, you do have an opportunity to cure
- 1:13:20and. If you do that, it will reduce the statutory
- 1:13:23damages, I believe, from $4 ,000 to $2 ,000.
- 1:13:27That's just my recollection. I have to look at
- 1:13:29the statute again. Then similarly, if you have
- 1:13:34a CAST -inspected facility, and it's been certified
- 1:13:37to meet all applicable standards, and nothing
- 1:13:42has changed to an element since the time of the
- 1:13:47facility being inspected, And the plaintiff is
- 1:13:51suing over the element. You likewise have a period
- 1:13:54of time to fix and remediate it after getting
- 1:13:58notice of the claim. And that, too, stands to
- 1:14:00reduce the amount of statutory damages. But otherwise,
- 1:14:06the notice and cure component has been a very
- 1:14:12controversial subject. People have been trying
- 1:14:14to get that in place for a long time. And it
- 1:14:20really just balances the whole public need versus
- 1:14:26the statutory framework. I hear it from both
- 1:14:31sides. The idea is, look, small businesses and
- 1:14:35big businesses are being exploited by cleanest
- 1:14:39firms who are making all the money. These persons
- 1:14:42with disabilities really are just being shills
- 1:14:46in this money -making scheme. That's not my words.
- 1:14:50That's the words from a case. Was it Molsky?
- 1:14:57I think that's the Molsky case. But there was
- 1:14:58a case where one of the, I think it was Judge
- 1:15:01Rafiti, described the money -making scheme of
- 1:15:05the plaintiff's attorneys using the plaintiffs
- 1:15:09as a shell. So you hear that. And being close
- 1:15:14to the world of persons with disabilities, I
- 1:15:17know you don't generally you do not want to put
- 1:15:19a lot of money into the hands of a person with
- 1:15:22legitimate disabilities, such as a big monetary
- 1:15:26reward from a lawsuit because that could compromise
- 1:15:31their ability to obtain much needed state benefits,
- 1:15:35whether it's. you know, whether it's Medi -Cal
- 1:15:38or IHSS or regional center benefits, all the
- 1:15:43different things that these people significantly
- 1:15:46rely upon. So you know the money's going to the
- 1:15:49plaintiff's attorney. So you go, well, that's
- 1:15:52really bad. We're just basically, you know, legalized
- 1:15:55extortion. But the flip side of that coin that
- 1:15:57we hear is look, you know, there's too many public
- 1:16:02accommodations out there to be enforced and patrolled.
- 1:16:06So what needs to happen is you need to have an
- 1:16:13incentive for plaintiff's attorneys to go out
- 1:16:15and do this. And the fact that they're acting
- 1:16:17as extortionists is scare tactics to bully people
- 1:16:21and to proactively do whatever they can to try
- 1:16:26to get rid of the risk of lawsuits. the juxtaposed
- 1:16:37positions. All right, Matthew, it looks like
- 1:16:43we have one last question. Do we have the time
- 1:16:45for this? Yeah, absolutely. All right. So Joseph
- 1:16:50Cole is asking, does a certificate of compliance
- 1:16:52from a web access expert provide a defense to
- 1:16:55a class action lawsuit by a blind tester? Well,
- 1:17:00it's interesting that that's a That's an interesting
- 1:17:05defense, because I've encountered this a lot
- 1:17:08over the years. And procedurally, it depends
- 1:17:11on the jurisdiction. So in my experience, certainly
- 1:17:14compliance is the standard. And if you can demonstrate
- 1:17:20compliance, then you have the benefit of getting
- 1:17:27rid of the case. So how can a plaintiff sue?
- 1:17:31if they don't have a remedial benefit, how are
- 1:17:36you going to prosecute a plaintiff's claim for
- 1:17:41federal ADA when injunctive is all available
- 1:17:45and there's no injunction available, right? And
- 1:17:49we often find that you just moot out barriers
- 1:17:52and that disposes of the case. These are from
- 1:17:56a federal component, from an injunctive class
- 1:18:01action. Keep in mind, a lot of the class actions
- 1:18:03move forward on damages alone. And so that would
- 1:18:07be, you know, when the website was not compliant,
- 1:18:11did people have damages? But so, so the issue
- 1:18:15is, is if you're going to attack that, you know,
- 1:18:20one of the ways you could attack it, you know,
- 1:18:23certainly would be, would be under a 12B1 if
- 1:18:27it's in federal court, right? Lack of subject
- 1:18:30matter jurisdiction. You can't get the claim
- 1:18:33is moot. There's nothing for the court to enjoy.
- 1:18:36There's no remedial benefit. They lose subject
- 1:18:39matter jurisdiction. The issue that you face
- 1:18:42in some jurisdictions such as the ninth is when
- 1:18:46the merits of the claim are inextricably intertwined
- 1:18:50with the with the jurisdictional facts. The court
- 1:18:56does not require the plaintiff to demonstrate
- 1:19:01that there is subject matter jurisdiction. It's
- 1:19:04a catch -22 because you're attacking the merits,
- 1:19:08but you're also attacking the jurisdictional
- 1:19:12elements. Under the Ninth Circuit, some judges
- 1:19:17will not apply that standard. Again, you can
- 1:19:22try to do it by doing a summary judgment. and
- 1:19:25hope that the other side doesn't provide competing
- 1:19:28evidence. But otherwise, you know, otherwise,
- 1:19:34you know, mootness is the defense, but it can
- 1:19:35be challenging because of that, the Ninth Circuit
- 1:19:40standard on that. That said, I've gotten a lot
- 1:19:44of 12b1s granted over the years. I've seen them
- 1:19:46granted in a lot of different jurisdictions,
- 1:19:48so. But I think that's the last of our questions.
- 1:19:52And I really do appreciate the engaged participation
- 1:19:56here. Sorry I didn't have all the answers to
- 1:19:58all the questions, but definitely some great
- 1:20:02stuff to look at. Great. Well, this concludes
- 1:20:06today's presentation. Thank you so much, Matthew,
- 1:20:08for an excellent presentation. And thank you
- 1:20:11so much to our audience. Have a great day, everybody.
- 1:20:13Take care.