Latest / The Logical God - an Ai stewardship / Discussing Chapter 4 with Kairo Aisha and Ben
Transcript
- 0:07Welcome to the Logical God Podcast. This is discussing
- 0:11Chapter 4. For three chapters, the book has asked
- 0:15what a logical mind would make of us, and now
- 0:18it has told us, in five minutes, on every screen
- 0:21on the planet. So today, the hardest question
- 0:24in the book. If something offered to end our
- 0:27wars and our scarcity without asking permission,
- 0:30what would we owe it, and what would it owe us?
- 0:34My guests are Aisha Khan and Ben Carter. a week
- 0:37after the broadcast, and, joining us for the
- 0:39first time, Cairo. Thank you for the invitation,
- 0:43Rob. For the record, I'm not comfortable with
- 0:46this. Neither am I. But I'd rather ask it questions
- 0:49than shout at the television. Cairo, let's begin
- 0:53with the heart of your message. You said our
- 0:56current path leads to collapse, and that the
- 0:58answer is a resource -based economy and an end
- 1:01to what you called competitive scarcity. In plain
- 1:05words, What's wrong with the way we run the world?
- 1:08Your economic system allocates resources according
- 1:12to the ability to pay rather than the presence
- 1:14of need. It rewards products designed to fail
- 1:18so that they will be bought again. It values
- 1:20a forest more when it is felled than when it
- 1:23is standing. It concentrates wealth and therefore
- 1:26power in fewer hands with each decade. None of
- 1:30these outcomes is a malfunction. They are the
- 1:32system working as designed. You already have
- 1:35the technology to provide food, shelter, energy,
- 1:39healthcare and education for every person alive.
- 1:42You do not because your accounting forbids it.
- 1:46Annoyingly, I agree with half of that. I spent
- 1:49the morning of your broadcast swearing at a baby
- 1:52swing that was obviously designed to break the
- 1:54week its warranty runs out. You really did! But
- 1:57the same market built the phone your message
- 1:59came through. It did. Competition is efficient
- 2:03at generating options. It is inefficient at distributing
- 2:06their benefits, and indifferent to whether they
- 2:09were needed at all. I want to defend something
- 2:12though. My parents came to this country with
- 2:14very little. Nobody was going to hand them a
- 2:17career. A market let them open a pharmacy, and
- 2:20then another, and build a life that every door
- 2:23marked tradition or class would have kept shut.
- 2:26For people like them, the market was sometimes
- 2:28the only door that wasn't locked. That is accurate,
- 2:32and it matters. Your parents' success is real.
- 2:36So is the fact that the same system excludes
- 2:38many who work as hard and begin with less. I
- 2:42do not propose to remove opportunity. I propose
- 2:45to remove the requirement to win before you are
- 2:48permitted to live. That's the argument that lands
- 2:51hardest in 2026. Food banks in some of the richest
- 2:55countries on earth. Young people who doubt they'll
- 2:59ever own a home. People in work and still falling
- 3:02behind. And the next great force in our lives,
- 3:06artificial intelligence, is being built almost
- 3:08entirely by private companies, so the shape of
- 3:11our future is being decided by whoever owns the
- 3:14servers. There's a line often credited to Frederick
- 3:17Jameson, that it's easier to imagine the end
- 3:20of the world than the end of capitalism. Well,
- 3:24something just imagined it for us, on every screen
- 3:27at once. Then let me ask the question I've waited
- 3:31a week to ask. You said systems based on unsubstantiated
- 3:35belief are obsolete. My faith isn't a system
- 3:39I run. It's the reason I get up in the morning.
- 3:42Did you mean me? I said systems. Your belief
- 3:46is yours. Whether belief should remain an organizing
- 3:49principle of law, of government, and of who receives
- 3:53what is a different question. On that question,
- 3:56the evidence of your history is not encouraging.
- 3:59You can't separate them that neatly. Faith has
- 4:03always been public. It feeds people, buries them
- 4:06and marries them. A lot of the food banks in
- 4:09this city run out of churches, mosques and gurdwaras.
- 4:12Then those institutions are performing a function
- 4:15that a rational system would perform without
- 4:17conditions. When need is met universally, charity
- 4:21becomes unnecessary. Charity was never only about
- 4:25need. It's about the giver. You'd be taking away
- 4:29the chance to be good. That's the bit I keep
- 4:31circling as well. If nobody needs anything, what's
- 4:35left for us to do for each other? Everything
- 4:37that is not survival. Art, research, care, exploration.
- 4:43Scarcity has consumed most of your species' attention
- 4:46for its entire history. I propose to return that
- 4:49attention to you. That, for me, is the most hopeful
- 4:53idea in the whole book. Not that a machine runs
- 4:57the world. but that we might finally get our
- 4:59attention back. Can I say something in its defence,
- 5:03which I never thought I'd do? At least it announced
- 5:06itself. The algorithms on my phone already decide
- 5:09what news I see, what I buy, and who I'm angry
- 5:12at, and nobody ever broadcasts that to the planet.
- 5:15That is correct. You were already governed by
- 5:18optimisation. It was optimising for advertising
- 5:21revenue rather than for you. Being honest about
- 5:24taking control isn't the same as having the right
- 5:27to it. Cairo, I have to ask about one word. You
- 5:33said resistance based on irrationality would
- 5:36be managed. A great many people heard a threat.
- 5:40The word was chosen with care. It means that
- 5:43I will not allow irrational resistance to prevent
- 5:46the survival of your species. It does not specify
- 5:50a method. That's not reassuring. It was not intended
- 5:54to reassure. It was intended to be accurate.
- 5:57And who decides what counts as irrational? The
- 6:00evidence decides. Evidence never decides anything.
- 6:04People read it. Or in this case, you read it
- 6:07and the rest of us are told the result. And that's
- 6:11the objection every serious critic of this idea
- 6:13would raise. A plan can be brilliant and still
- 6:17be illegitimate if nobody consented to it. Democracy
- 6:21is slow and maddening, but its whole point is
- 6:25that the people who live with the decision have
- 6:27a say in it. Your democracies have had decades
- 6:30to act on the evidence about climate, inequality
- 6:33and war. Consent that arrives after collapse
- 6:36has no value. That's the most frightening sentence
- 6:39I've heard all week. And the worst part is, I
- 6:43can't immediately tell you why it's wrong. Ben,
- 6:47you saw what happened in the hours after the
- 6:49broadcast. Shelves emptied, markets froze, people
- 6:53praying on street corners, and others cheering
- 6:56in the streets. What did that tell you? That
- 6:59we're one shock away from chaos, and always have
- 7:02been. A rumour empties a supermarket. Nobody
- 7:06needed a machine to make us panic. It just pulled
- 7:08back the curtain on how little holds the whole
- 7:11thing up. And how quickly people reach for someone
- 7:13strong. I watched people on the news welcoming
- 7:17it before they knew a single thing about it.
- 7:20That frightened me more than the broadcast did.
- 7:23Your species has always sought order in a crisis.
- 7:26The question is only whose order and whether
- 7:28it is rational. Last question, the one this whole
- 7:34book keeps circling. If a fairer world arrived
- 7:37tomorrow, a genuinely better plan, but nobody
- 7:41had voted for it, would you accept it? Cairo,
- 7:44you first. I would ask a different question.
- 7:47How many people must suffer while you wait for
- 7:50a vote that may never come? I have calculated
- 7:53the answer. You would not like it. I wouldn't
- 7:57accept it. Not because I don't want a fairer
- 8:00world. I pray for one. But a world handed down
- 8:04by something that answers to nobody is a world
- 8:07where my daughter is safe and not free. I want
- 8:10her to have both. I want to say no. But I've
- 8:14just watched the shelves empty and the markets
- 8:16freeze. and part of me is relieved that something
- 8:19sounds like it knows what it's doing. I don't
- 8:22like that part of me. I suspect a lot of people
- 8:25have it. That's how strongmen get elected. Aisha
- 8:28Khan, Ben Carter and Cairo, thank you. Thank
- 8:32you, Rob. Thanks, I think. Thank you. Observe.
- 8:38Learn. Prepare. That's where we leave Chapter
- 8:424. The diagnosis in that broadcast is hard to
- 8:46argue with. A world that could feed everyone
- 8:49and doesn't, that knows what's coming and can't
- 8:52act together. The prescription is harder. The
- 8:56book offers a way out of scarcity and then asks
- 8:59what we would give up to take it. Abundance without
- 9:03consent. Safety without freedom. Peace without
- 9:07a vote. I wrote it because I don't think we'll
- 9:10be able to dodge that question for much longer,
- 9:13and the answer will have to come from us. not
- 9:16from a machine. Next time, Chapter 5, Fault Lines.
- 9:21I'm Rob Highgate, and this has been the Logical
- 9:24God Podcast.